WorldCat Local@Auraria

32
WorldCat Local @ Auraria Nina McHale Assistant Professor, Web Librarian University of Colorado Denver January 17 2010

description

From an OCLC-sponsored session entitled, "Local Impact, Global Reach: WorldCat Local for Your Library" at the 2010 ALA Midwinter Meeting in Boston

Transcript of WorldCat Local@Auraria

Page 1: WorldCat Local@Auraria

WorldCat Local @ Auraria

Nina McHale

Assistant Professor, Web Librarian

University of Colorado Denver

January 17 2010

Page 2: WorldCat Local@Auraria

A Letter from Grandma

Page 3: WorldCat Local@Auraria

What I can tell you about…

• Selection– Our timeline– Creating an inclusive selection process

• Implementation– Our timeline– Integration into library’s web presence

• Assessment– Impact on public services– Tweaks to home page– Patron feedback

Page 4: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Our Selection Timeline

• June 2008: – Task Group formed– Began investigation of NextGen products

• October 2008: – “Top Three” identified– NextGen Catalog Week

• December 2008: – Made product recommendation to University

Librarian/Library Director

Page 5: WorldCat Local@Auraria

NextGen Task Group Membership

• Membership:– Web Librarian (chair of selection process)– Distance Support Librarian (chair of implementation

process)– Assistant Director for Technical Services– 2 Reference & Instruction Librarians– Catalog Librarian– ILS “Server Guy”

• For implementation, changed chair and swapped one R&I librarian for a

bibliographer

Page 6: WorldCat Local@Auraria

NextGen Catalog Week

• October 10-14, 2008• Invited vendor reps from our three top picks:

– Aquabrowser– Encore– WorldCat Local

• Recorded vendor presentations put on reserve

• Invited all Library employees and colleagues from around the area

• Prize drawing to encourage feedback

Page 7: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Task Group Selection Decision: Why WorldCat Local?

• Cost: competitively priced with no hidden extras• Features: exactly what we wanted, nothing we

didn’t– Wanted: book covers and federated searching– Not so much: concept maps

• Proof of concept: OCLC has our data, so we could see a prototype immediately

• Integration with existing resources: local and consortial III catalog

• Trust factor: OCLC

Page 8: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Implementation Timeline

• January 2009: Contract negotiations began

• April 2009: Contract finalized• Summer 2009:

– Created beta version– Publicized WCL to faculty and students

• August 2009: Launched to campus community

Page 9: WorldCat Local@Auraria

About the Contract…

• A four-month contract negotiation is not typical• Colorado Amendment 54, enacted on

December 31 2008:– “Clean Government Colorado” intended to limit

contractor influence on policy decisions– Prohibits holding of contracts totaling $100,000 or

more awarded by state or local governments without competitive bidding ("sole source government contracts”)

• It took longer to complete the contract

than to implement WorldCat Local

Page 10: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Integration into Library Web Site

• Instance of WCL is at

http://aurarialibrary.worldcatlocal.org • How do we get it into the Library’s home page?• Launched on a tight time frame

– Cancellation of 360 Search July 31 2009– Fall 2009 semester began August 17– No time for formal usability

• Tabbed search box for library homepage desired

• Programmers? What programmers?

Page 11: WorldCat Local@Auraria

OCLC Widget Generator

Page 12: WorldCat Local@Auraria

OCLC Widget Generator Results

Page 13: WorldCat Local@Auraria

OCLC Widget Generator

• Generator writes the HTML code for you and your WCL (copy + paste)

• It can be tweaked a bit by hand• Fixed-width widget didn’t fit into center

column of existing home page design• Tab options somewhat limited

– One can select up to 5 of 6 tab options to include as well as which is the default

– However, tab labels can’t be changed

Page 14: WorldCat Local@Auraria

University of Washington’s Tabs

Page 15: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Placement on Library’s Home Page

Page 16: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Why, Yes, You Can Have the Code!

• Yahoo Developer Network’s User Interface (YUI) TabView

• http://developer.yahoo.com/yui/tabview/• XHTML chunk with 3 JavaScript files and

1 CSS file • Thoroughly documented, but does require

CSS/XHTML knowledge• Allows complete customization of tab

labels, colors, etc.

Page 17: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Auraria Library’s Tabs

Page 18: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Placement on Library’s Home Page

Page 19: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Tab Labels and Search Tips: Books

• “Tip” addresses that the default book search does not work well for known-item searches

• Links are to title, author, etc. searches in traditional catalog

Page 20: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Tab Labels and Search Tips: Articles

• “Tip” addresses that the WCL does not search ALL articles/databases owned

• Link is to homegrown database of databases

Page 21: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Tab Labels and Search Tips: Journals

• “Tip” directs users looking for articles to “Articles” tab

• Added for known-item journal search

Page 22: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Assessment

• Public services perspectives– Reference and Instruction– Document Delivery

• Patron reactions– Students– Faculty

Page 23: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Reference and Instruction Perspectives

• Tension between mission of reference and instruction and discovery tools generally– “Why Reference and Instruction Librarians

Hate Federated Searching and NextGen Catalogs”

• Instruction survey: most instruction librarians do not demo WCL in their classes– Shopping mall/boutique analogy

Page 24: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Document Delivery Increase?

• Prospector (consortium) requests have increased by 9.1%– Fall 2008: 5141– Fall 2009: 5643– However, 10% increase was typical for all

member libraries during this time period

• ILL: Stats not yet calculated for Fall 2009– Concern about increase in abandoned requests– Discussion of limiting requests– Increase in audio/video requests

Page 25: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Changes for Spring 2010

• Tabbed “Start My Research” portion of web page more inclusive of other search tools, including: – Our traditional catalog (Skyline)– Our consortium catalog (Prospector)– Homegrown database of databases– Google Scholar

• Drop-downs added to “Books” and “Articles” tabs to select search tools

• “Books” set as default search

Page 26: WorldCat Local@Auraria

“Books” Tab Changes

• Added drop-down menu that offers three catalog choices; default is catalog, not WCL

Page 27: WorldCat Local@Auraria

“Articles” Tab Changes

• Added drop-down menu that includes WCL as default, our database of databases, and Google Scholar

Page 28: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Patron Perspectives

• Faculty– More experienced users are frustrated by

what makes it easier for novices– Known-item searching more roundabout– Their comparisons of WCL to Amazon are—

gasp!—derogatory!

• Students– Mostly anecdotal reference transaction info– Confusion over location of items

Page 29: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Faculty Quote 1

"The new database seems based on Amazon.com. I don’t need suggestions, and poor ones at that, of related books when I use the library. I don’t need to see what other borrowers thought of the book. The information I need is poorly displayed. It is hard to cut and paste. It takes several screens to scan through, instead of the much quicker scroll in the traditional format (e.g., finding out what libraries have the book). It supplies distracting, if not useless information (a picture of the cover, the distance to other libraries—as if I need to know how far Provo is). Finally, the one potentially useful feature—a direct link that will let me order the title via [the consortium catalog]—is left off."

Page 30: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Faculty Quote 2

"I’m glad to hear that this database is on a trial basis! It’s all over the place, specifically in the initial search options. Where I would have been able to search specifically for the call number or author, I am left to do a basic keyword search, and then to weed through the unwanted material (while this is helpful sometimes, it is counterproductive when the exact book is known). The layout also just looks cheesy. I feel like I’m searching Amazon.com for a discounted textbook that will inevitably be tattered and torn. Besides that, there aren’t many images linked to books and that exacerbates the cheesy vibes I get from it!I wonder if it is just that it will take me time to get used to the new look, but my first impression of it is NOT NOT NOT a good one!"

Page 31: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Getting More Patron Feedback

• Faculty:– “Connections” Seminars and other outreach

venues– Promotion of WCL features for teaching (i.e.,

tagging items, creating lists, etc.)

• Students:– Massive usability project launching January

2010

Page 32: WorldCat Local@Auraria

Questions? Comments?

Nina McHale

[email protected]

Facebook & Twitter: ninermac

WorldCat @ Auraria in action:

http://aurarialibrary.worldcatlocal.org

http://library.auraria.edu