World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
Transcript of World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
1/45
Reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL No. 895 OF 2014(Arising out of S.L.P. (C) No. 49!8 of 2010)
World Sport Group (Mauritiu! Ltd" # App$lla%t
Versus
MSM Sat$llit$ (Si%&apor$! Pt$" Ltd" #R$po%d$%t
" # $ % & E N '
A. . PA'NAI ".
L$a'$ &ra%t$d"
" T)i i a% app$al a&ai%t t)$ ord$r dat$d *+",-",*,
o. t)$ Di'iio% /$%0) o. t)$ /o12a3 Hi&) Court i%
App$al (Lod&i%&! No"456 o. ,*,"
F*+ts7
5" T)$ .a0t '$r3 2ri$.l3 ar$ t)at o% 5,"**",,+ t)$
/oard o. Co%trol .or Cri08$t i% I%dia (.or )ort 9/CCI:!
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
2/45
i%'it$d t$%d$r .or IPL (I%dia% Pr$1i$r L$a&u$! M$dia
Ri&)t .or a p$riod o. t$% 3$ar .ro1 ,,; to ,*+ o%
a 2id
arra%&$1$%t= )o
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
3/45
a&r$$1$%t dat$d *",*",,; to a%3 t)ird part3"
Purua%t to t)$ %$&otiatio% 2$t
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
4/45
D$$d:!
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
5/45
ot)$r 1a%%$r a t)$ ar2itrator d$t$r1i%$ ir$Buir$d i% ord$r .or t)i ar2itratio% pro'iio%to 2$ $%.or0$a2l$ u%d$r appli0a2l$ la
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
6/45
app$lla%t r$0i%di%& t)$ Fa0ilitatio% D$$d o% t)$ &rou%d
t)at it
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
7/45
t$1porar3 i%u%0tio% o. t)$ r$po%d$%t a3i%& t)at it
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
8/45
D$$d
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
9/45
2$i%& p$r.or1$d= t)$ Court
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
10/45
all$&$d to 2$ %ull a%d 'oid or %o%>$it$%t 2$0au$ t)$
ar2itratio% 0lau$ i a% i%d$p$%d$%t a%d diti%0t
a&r$$1$%t" H$ u21itt$d t)at t)i pri%0ipl$ o.
Kompetenz Kompetenz)a 2$$% r$0o&%i$d i% S$0tio% *@
o. t)$ A0t u%d$r
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
11/45
Chec* Cashin"+ Inc. v. ,ohn Carde"naet alK46@ US 66,
(,,@! a%d t)$ d$0iio% o. t)i Court i% !ranch (ana"er=
(a"ma Leasin" and )inance Ltd. & -nr. v. Potluri
(adhavilata & -nr.K(,,-! *, SCC *,5"
*," Mr" V$%u&opal u21itt$d t)at t)$ Di'iio% /$%0) o.
t)$ Hi&) Court r$li$d o% t)$ d$0iio% i% . %adha*rishnan
v. (aestro n"ineers & Ors.K(,*,! * SCC + to )old t)at
$riou all$&atio% o. .raud 0a% o%l3 2$ $%Buir$d 23 a
Court a%d %ot 23 a% ar2itrator= 2ut t)$ Di'iio% /$%0)
.ail$d to appr$0iat$ t)at i% . %adha*rishnan v. (aestro
n"ineers & Ors.(upra! t)i Court r$li$d o%-$dul Kadir
Shamsuddin !u$ere v. (adhav Pra$ha*ar Oa*KAIR *-@
SC 6,@ i%
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
12/45
app$lla%t" H$ .urt)$r u21itt$d t)at i% a%3 0a$ t)$
ud&1$%t o. t)i Court i% . %adha*rishnan v. (aestro
n"ineers & Ors.(upra!
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
13/45
app$ar to )a'$ )$ld t)at Clau$ - i oppo$d to pu2li0
poli03 a%d= i% parti0ular= S$0tio% 5 a%d ; o. t)$ I%dia%
Co%tra0t A0t= *;+" H$ u21itt$d t)at i% a%3 0a$ t)$
ar2itratio% a&r$$1$%t 0o%tai%$d i% Clau$ - o. t)$
Fa0ilitatio% D$$d 0a%%ot 2$ )$ld to 2$ oppo$d to pu2li0
poli03 a%d 'oid u%d$r S$0tio% 5 a%d ; o. t)$ I%dia%
Co%tra0t A0t= *;+" T)i
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
14/45
0o%%$0tio% i%>r$pl3 .il$d 2$.or$ t)$
1
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
15/45
/o12a3 Hi&) Court a%d t)at t)$r$
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
16/45
parti$ to t)$ ar2itratio% u%l$ it .i%d t)at t)$ ar2itratio%
a&r$$1$%t i 9%ull a%d 'oid:" H$ ar&u$d t)at a%
a&r$$1$%t
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
17/45
to ar2itratio% i. t)$ ar2itratio% a&r$$1$%t i %ull a%d
'oid= i%op$rati'$ or i%0apa2l$ o. 2$i%& p$r.or1$d a%d
a t)$ r$po%d$%t )a ta8$% t)$ pl$a t)at t)$
Fa0ilitatio% D$$d=
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
18/45
$0$pt uit
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
19/45
d$t$r1i%$ t)$ 'alidit3 o. t)$ a&r$$1$%t at t)$
t)r$)old it$l. 2$0au$ t)i i a% iu$
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
20/45
to t)$ d$0iio% o. t)i Court i% -$dul Kadir
Shamsuddin !u$ere v. (adhav Pra$ha*ar Oa* (upra!=
5ar#ana Telecom Ltd. v. Sterlite Industries 3India4 Ltd"
K(*---! 4 SCC @;; a%d . %adha*rishnan v. (aestro
n"ineers & Ors.(upra!" I% r$pl3 to t)$ u21iio% o.
Mr" V$%u&opal t)at it
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
21/45
t)$ Di'iio% /$%0) o. t)$ /o12a3 Hi&) Court )a=
t)$r$.or$= ri&)tl3 ta8$% t)$ 'i$< t)at t)$ diput$ i%
t)i 0a$ 0a%%ot 2$ 8$pt outid$ t)$ pur'i$< o. t)$
I%dia% Court a%d i. ar2itratio% i allo
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
22/45
)a'$ 2$$% rai$d 23 Mr" V$%u&opal= l$ar%$d 0ou%$l .or
t)$ app$lla%t= i% upport o. t)$ 0a$ o. t)$ app$lla%t t)at
t)$ Di'iio% /$%0) o. t)$ /o12a3 Hi&) Court 0ould %ot
)a'$ pa$d t)$ ord$r o. i%u%0tio% r$trai%i%& t)$
ar2itratio% at Si%&apor$=
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
23/45
Judi0ial 0o1it3" T)$ pri%0ipl$ i% a00orda%0$
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
24/45
Clau$ - o. t)$ Fa0ilitatio% D$$d pro'idi%& t)at 0ourt i%
Si%&apor$ or a%3 ot)$r 0ourt )a'i%& uridi0tio% o'$r t)$
parti$ 0a% 2$ approa0)$d .or $Buita2l$ r$li$. 0ould %ot
out t)$ uridi0tio% o. t)$ appropriat$ 0i'il 0ourt
0o%.$rr$d 23 S$0tio% - o. t)$ CPC" W$ .i%d t)at i% para @6
o. t)$ plai%t i% Suit No"*;; o. ,*, .il$d 2$.or$ t)$
/o12a3 Hi&) Court 23 t)$ r$po%d$%t= it i tat$d t)at t)$
Fa0ilitatio% D$$d i%
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
25/45
S$0tio% 66 a%d 64 i% C)apt$r I o. Part II o. t)$ A0t=
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
26/45
a&r$$1$%t i %ull a%d 'oid= i%op$rati'$ ori%0apa2l$ o. 2$i%& p$r.or1$d"
T)$ la%&ua&$ o. S$0tio% 64 o. t)$ A0t Buot$d a2o'$
1a8$ it 0l$ar t)at %ot
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
27/45
ar2itratio%= 2ut S$0tio% 64 o. t)$ A0t do$ %ot r$.$r to a%3
appli0atio% a u0)" I%t$ad= it r$.$r to t)$ r$Bu$t o.
o%$ o. t)$ parti$ or a%3 p$ro% 0lai1i%& t)rou&) or u%d$r
)i1 to r$.$r t)$ parti$ to ar2itratio%" I% t)i 0a$= t)$
app$lla%t 1a3 %ot )a'$ 1ad$ a% appli0atio% to r$.$r t)$
parti$ to ar2itratio% at Si%&apor$ 2ut )a .il$d a% a..ida'it
i% r$pl3 to t)$ %oti0$ o. 1otio% a%d )a tat$d i%
para&rap) 5= 6 a%d 4 o. t)i a..ida'it t)at t)$ d$.$%da%t
)ad alr$ad3 i%'o8$d t)$ ar2itratio% a&r$$1$%t i% t)$
Fa0ilitatio% D$$d a%d t)$ ar2itratio% pro0$$di%& )a'$
0o11$%0$d a%d t)at t)$ uit
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
28/45
o. S$0tio% 66 o. t)$ A0t r$.$r to an a"reement in /ritin"
for ar$itration to /hich the Convention set forth in the
)irst Schedule applies. T)$ Firt S0)$dul$ o. t)$ A0t $t
out t)$ di..$r$%t Arti0l$ o. t)$ N$< or8 Co%'$%tio% o%
t)$ R$0o&%itio% a%d E%.or0$1$%t o. For$i&% Ar2itral
A
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
29/45
It
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
30/45
p$r.or1a%0$ o. t)$ 0o%tra0t" It i a i. t
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
31/45
t)$ do0u1$%t i .ou%d to 2$ dul3 ta1p$d 2ut %ot
r$&it$r$d t)ou&) r$Buir$d to 2$ 0o1puloril3 r$&it$r$d=
t)$ 0ourt 0a% a0t upo% t)$ ar2itratio% a&r$$1$%t
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
32/45
t)$ &rou%d upo%
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
33/45
4" Appl3i%& t)$ pri%0ipl$ o. $para2ilit3 to t)$ .a0t o.
t)i 0a$= t)$ r$po%d$%t r$0i%d$d t)$ Fa0ilitatio% D$$d
23 %oti0$ dat$d 4",@",*, to t)$ app$lla%t o% t)$
.ollo
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
34/45
" /CCI )a r$0$%tl3 2rou&)t to t)$ att$%tio%o. our 0li$%t t)at t)$ Glo2al M$dia Ri&)ta&r$$1$%t 2$t
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
35/45
u20o%ti%$%t 1$dia ri&)t .or t)$ IPL .ro1 /CCI a%d %o
.a0ilitatio% $r'i0$ 0ould )a'$ 2$$% pro'id$d 23 t)$
app$lla%t a%d t)$r$.or$ t)$ r$pr$$%tatio% 23 t)$
app$lla%t t)at t)$ app$lla%t r$li%Bui)$d it I%dia%
u20o%ti%$%t 1$dia ri&)t .or t)$ IPL i% .a'our o. t)$
r$po%d$%t .or
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
36/45
2$ $%Buir$d i%to 23 t)$ 0ourt a%d %ot 23 t)$ ar2itrator"
T)$ aut)oriti$ o% t)$ 1$a%i%& o. t)$
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
37/45
+" Al2$rt Ja% Va% D$% /$r& i% a% arti0l$ titl$d T)$
N$< or8 Co%'$%tio%= *-4; A% O'$r'i$$Bual .oru1 $l$0tio%0lau$" E'$% i% t)$$ 0a$= t)$ 0ourti%t$rpr$t t)$ 0o%tra0t pro'iio% i% .a'ouro. ar2itratio%"
3
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
38/45
;" T)$ 2oo8 %eco"nition and Conferment of )orei"n
-r$itral -/ards; - 'lo$al Commentar# on the e/
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
39/45
Fi%all3= $'$ral aut)oriti$ )a'$ )$ld t)att)$ ar2itratio% a&r$$1$%t 0$a$ to )a'$$..$0t i. t)$ parti$
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
40/45
0o'$r$d 23 t)$ ar2itratio% a&r$$1$%t o%l3 i. it 0o1$ to
t)$ 0o%0luio% t)at t)$ ar2itratio% a&r$$1$%t i %ull a%d
'oid= i%op$rati'$ or i%0apa2l$ o. 2$i%& p$r.or1$d= a%d %ot
o% t)$ &rou%d t)at all$&atio% o. .raud or
1ir$pr$$%tatio% )a'$ to 2$ i%Buir$d i%to
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
41/45
r$.$r t)$ parti$ to ar2itratio% u%l$ t)$ ar2itratio%
a&r$$1$%t i %ull a%d 'oid= i%op$rati'$ or i%0apa2l$ o.
2$i%& p$r.or1$d" I% 'i$< o. t)$ pro'iio% o. S$0tio% 64
o. t)$ A0t= t)$ Di'iio% /$%0) o. t)$ Hi&) Court
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
42/45
r$%d$r ill$&al a 0o%tra0t= 23
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
43/45
t)$ 0ourt
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
44/45
56" W$ 1a8$ it 0l$ar t)at
-
8/13/2019 World Sport Group v. MSM Singapore
45/45
54" For t)$ a.or$aid r$ao%=