WORKSHOP “MAKING SMART CITIES SUSTAINABLE"

Summary of Workshop Sessions

http://www.etsi.org/smart-cities

SESSION 1 SUMMARY Moving from trial projects to large scale deployment

Moderator: David Boswarthick, ETSI

Session Purpose:

Examine possible methods to enable the rapid replication of smart city services in order to move beyond the trials and pilot projects to a more largescale and economically sustainable connected City deployment model.

Give examples of best practice and methods for cities to make the most of the experience gained by other cities.

EU Position on H2020 and Large Scale DeploymentSvetoslav Mihaylov, European Commission, DG CONNECT

Replication Package & Strategy / EurocitiesBernadette Degrendele, Eurocities

Delivering Public Value in City Operations. Shift from pilots to large scale deploymentsNicola Villa, IBM

City of Milan vision, Sharing Cities Coordinator for MilanPiero Pelizzaro, City of Milan

SESSION 1: Moving from trial projects to large scale deploymentHighlights and recommendations

Svetoslav Mihaylov, European Commission, DG CONNECT

Bernadette Degrendele, Eurocities

Citizens are at the hearth of the smarter city process

Technologies are key enablers

Rethinking governance: co-design, co-creation of innovative solutions

Data is the backbone of smarter cities

Standards and interoperability are crucial

City-led approach

SESSION 1: Moving from trial projects to large scale deploymentHighlights and recommendations

Nicola Villa, IBM

SESSION 1: Moving from trial projects to large scale deploymentHighlights and recommendations

Piero Pelizzaro, City of Milan

SESSION 1: Moving from trial projects to large scale deploymentHighlights and recommendations

• Use solutions based on globally applicable open standards

• Replicability and interoperability of city solutions is key

• Sharing of experience between Cities will accelerate the process

• Success is more about the CITIZEN than about the technology

• Focus on the user and generating new business models

• Shift focus from Infrastructure to Data and Services for the users

Share, educate, replicate, accelerateTogether !

SESSION 1: Moving from trial projects to large scale deploymentA summary and takeaways

SESSION 2 SUMMARY

Urban Data PlatformsModerator: Antony Page, UrbanDNA

• EIP SCC (Smart Cities & Communities) for an Urban Platform ProjectKarl-Filip Coenegrachts, City of Ghent

• Eclipse sensiNact platform for smarter urban environments, deployments in European and Japanese citiesDr Levent Gurgen, CEA Tech

• Urban Data Platform Study, Bordeaux MetropoleKasia Lewicka & Gabriel Dos Santos, Bordeaux Metropole

• Open Source Urban Platforms Development, MetapolisFabien Cauchi, Metapolis

HIGHLIGHTS FROM THE PRESENTATIONS:

• Platforms are bridges between things and cities - and exist to create measurement, comparison, insight & change of outcomes for citizens (residents, businesses and visitors).

• Smart citizens are the key to smart cities and in Ghent the cities strategic plan is co-created with citizens who are informed by open data, enabled by open process for the delivery of open services.

• There is a wide breadth of studies of platforms across domains across the EU and Japan. Key challenges for platforms include interoperability, scalability, dynamism, dependability, security & privacy.

• Bordeaux Metropole is not ready to benefit from all the different data collected and held (this is not an unusual position for many cities) and is investing in infrastructure and projects to address this. The main challenge is not technology but governance.

• An open urban platform is made up of; open data, open API, open standards AND open algorithm.

ISSUES RAISED

the focus of a urban platform must be the citizen and change of outcome rather than the potential of technology

the role of open standards to support interoperability and sharing needs to be better understood and the plethora of available standards ought to be rationalised

demonstration projects need to be rapidly moved to industrial and sustainable application BUT that depends upon education and investment

will the success of a platform depend upon smart citizens?

POSSIBLE WAY FORWARD

Cities engaged in creating urban sharing platforms agree that open standards are desirable and necessary but will need to continue to work with what exists and what are available

Supply side for platforms and their eco-system of tools and IoT devices will need to be aware of the need to educate demand side and the citizen in order to support move from pilot to industrial and sustainable application

Cities need to understand the specific requirement for a citizen (resident, business, visitor) to be smart. This can be achieved through developing use cases to appreciate the spectrum of requirement of the citizen to use and benefit from urban platforms for example bus info at the depot only requires literacy whereas energy supply choice based on district demand & lifestyle change depends on access, IT literacy, smart home sensors etc.

SESSION 3 SUMMARY

IoT Large Scale Deployments Moderator: Keith Dickerson, Climate Associates

Setting the Scene

Keith Dickerson, Climate Associates

oneM2M

Nicolas Damour, Sierra Wireless / Chairman of oneM2M WG on ARC

ISG CIM

Lindsay Frost, NEC / Chairman ETSI ISG CIM

ATTM SDMC

Christophe Colinet, Bordeaux Metropole / chairman ETSI ATTM SDMC

HIGHLIGHTS FROM THE PRESENTATIONS:

• Overview of techniques for Replicability and Scaling Up of Smart City solutions

• Overview of oneM2M and its applicability to providing a reusable horizontal communications platform

• Techniques for Context Information Management (CIM)

• Overview of participation of Bordeaux Metropole in replication and scaling up techniques

ISSUES RAISED

1. Who owns patents in oneM2M?

2. Why isn’t the role of oneM2M shown in Synchronicity slides?

3. What is the replicability strategy for H2020 Lighthouse Projects?

4. Why can’t you re-use an existing API for CIM?

5. How is the objective of the ISG CDP different from the specification activity in EIP SCC (for example on smart lampposts)?

6. What is the role of FIWARE vs. oneM2M in Smart Cities?

POSSIBLE WAY FORWARD

1. All IP contained in oneM2M standards is licensable under FRAND terms.

2. OneM2M is indirectly referenced by Synchronicity.

3. Sharing Cities will identify the replicable features from the leading cities (Greenwich, Milan and Lisbon) and try to replicate these in the follower cities (Bordeaux, Warsaw and Burgas).

4. ISG CIM can use an API for general use but nothing has been invented yet for use in specific domains (e.g. energy monitoring).

5. The specification work being done in EIP SCC needs to be taken into a standardisation environment to push it forward.

6. OneM2M is good at providing a lower layer communications platform and FIWARE is good at creating higher-layer software that can be delivered to end users.

SESSION 4 SUMMARY

Large and Sustainable ICT Deployments Pierre Mangin, eG4UConcrete measures are taken to protect environment and to make progress in energy savings. Smart Cities are concerned, as well as the IT / ICT domain , and the electrical ‘Smart grids’.

The regulation makes it clear that the life cycle management of equipments has also become a key issue. Objects, equipments & systems have a predictable end of life.

4 speakers:

Sustainable Smart Cities, by Alistair Wright, GSM Association

ICT Waste Management, by Gilles Dretsch, Orange / ETSI STF516 member

Global KPI for ICT sites, by Jean Marc Alberola, Airbus, Energy strategy group leader

Optimizing self-consumption in smart grids - REXAUTO project, by Jaime Diaz Pineda, CATIE.

HIGHLIGHTS FROM THE PRESENTATIONS:

Sustainable Smart Cities,

by Alistair Wright, GSM Association

GSM Association, 400 employees in 12 offices worldwide, created in 1987, represents 800 mobile operators worldwide.It provides frameworks & standards in commercial, operational and technical matters.

Among many sustainability projects, a special focus on Internet Of Things

To find out more visit: www.gsma.com/IoT

To contact us email: IoT@gsma.com

Available for download:

http://www.gsma.com/better

future/2016SDGImpactReport/

GSMA and Sustainable Development Goals

NO POVERTY

ZERO HUNGER

GOOD HEALTH AND WELL BEING

QUALITY EDUCATION

GENDEREQUALITY

CLEAN WATER & SANITATION

AFFORDABLE & CLEAN ENERGY

DECENT WORK & ECONOMIC GROWTH

INDUSTRY, INNOVATION &

INFRASTRUCTURE

REDUCED INEQUALITIES

SUSTAINABLE CITIES & COMMUNITIES

RESPONSIBLE CONSUMPTION & PRODUCTION

CLIMATEACTION

LIFE BELOWWATER

LIFE ONLAND

PEACE, JUSTICE & STRONG INSTITUTIONS

PARTNERSHIPS FOR THE GOALS

Global KPI for ICT sites

“Making Smart Cities Sustainable” Bordeaux 7 & 8

June 2017 Jean-Marc Alberola

Group Energy Strategy leader

Vice Chairman of ETSI ISG OEU

ISSUES RAISED

Regulatory framework

Technical, objective and Global KPI

Global KPI DCEM

Implementation at Airbus

POSSIBLE WAY FORWARD

ICT Waste Management:

Gilles Dretsch, Orange / ETSI STF516 member

presented a vast programme

showing on a new circular economy aroung retreatment of mobile, and ICT & network equipments , with value added possibilities of a new market.

HIGHLIGHTS FROM THE PRESENTATIONS:

Optimizing self-consumption in smart grids - REXAUTO project

By Jaime DIAZ Pineda, CATIE

A not profit association, specialized in smart grids

The REXAUTO project is joining initiatives around Genedis,

REXAUTO PROJECT

23237-8 June 2017ETSI workshop “Making Smart Cities Sustainable” from large scale pilots to real-life

deployment”

Consortium

Industrial partners:

Research institutions

REXAUTO PROJECT

24247-8 June 2017ETSI workshop “Making Smart Cities Sustainable” from large scale pilots to real-life

deployment”

Objectives:

To validate the concept of self-consumption within photovoltaics.

• Network dimension

• Impact of the user in consumption

• Benefits of intelligent energy management and storage

To measure the impact of these installations on the overall network:

• Transients

• Overloads

• Harmonics and flickers

• Malfunction of protective systems

SESSION 5 SUMMARY

Smart Home, Smart Buildings, Smart CityAlain Kergoat, Urban Practices

HIGHLIGHTS FROM THE PRESENTATIONS:

Smart Infrastructures (pipes, networks, roads, …) are key enablers for the smart homes & smart buildings in the smart city

Smart Home / Smart Building New regulation in France makes FTTH/B mandatory (since august 2016)

EU vision Gigabit Society by 2025, “Plan Fibre” in France to have 100% of homes & buildings covered by FTTH by 2022 (possibly earlier)

POF technology is a mature technology – cost & ease of deployment in home are main advantages – POF complements the incumbent Copper & GOF technologies

New standards for VHBB are available: 802.3xx, ETSI POF/GOF, CENELEC,…

Smart Roads How to increase the potential of road infrastructures to allow creation of new services: solar road, new

eco systems for promoting new mobile usages

The challenge : territorial integration of complex inter-related solutions

Smart Water Capabilities of advanced water management system

Smart Energy Linky the 1st block for smart grid & smart city applications – enabling new services for users & cities

Smart Networks IA to enhance the management of complex networks