Who Is Mr. Colin

8/10/2019 Who Is Mr. Colin

1/45

West Australia versusWest Java Juvenile

13thJanuary 2015

Kutoarjo Juvenile


2/45

Who am I? My backroun! is a""# $0 years in %il & 'as

(#"loration) I have live! *bet+een, Australia an! In!onesia -or

some t+enty .25/ years an! my +i-e is a very "atientan! un!erstan!in la!y -rom asik)

Justice of the Peace (JP) in Western Australia Hon. Secretary of the Western Australia

Australia Indonesia Business Council (AIBC)

Director of Social & Politics for he Indonesian

Institute rior to my involvement as an I & J I have ha! no

"rior involvement +ith social an!4or "oliticala!vocacy -or anyone or anythin) I have no "olitical

orientation or "re-erence


3/45

Justice o- the eace .J/

In city run ra6c7 8estrainin %r!er an!rison courts) In country 2 9 J :Maistrate

A""rove ; Prosecution !otices e#ce"t -or olice

Search Warrants

"ree#in$ %rders Bail & Surety

Certify Docuents ' Adaits '

Statutory Declarations etc.


4/45

In!e"en!ent rison isitor

In!e"en!ent rison isitor .I/ +orkin +ith heIns"ector o- eil Moran)

+++)oics)+a)ov)au

he Ins"ector is the Inde*endentoverseer o- all WA"risons etc)) 8e"orts to arliament not the Minister)


5/45


6/45

anksia Bill Cetention


7/45

%ver a thir! o- !etainees inclu!in some veryyoun chil!ren come -rom 8eional WA an! are!isconnecte! -rom their -amily an! culture)

$0F o- juveniles are hel! on reman! !ouble theA!ult reman! Hure)

-/0 of Children in WA detention areunder the care of the De*t. of ChildProtection)

(st 0FG o- 'irls an! E0FG o- boys have been"hysically an!4or se#ually abuse!

Many crimes are !ru relate!metham"hetamine "etrol lue +ith "ermanent!amae to the chil!ren)

Many chil!ren born !amae! -oetal;alcohol4!ru

syn!rome)


8/45

anksia Bills Cetention


9/45


10/45

Accommo!ation lock


11/45

ee!a 8esi!ential nit


12/45


13/45

o"ulation


14/45


15/45


16/45

8eci!ivism 8ate v Ae


17/45

8eci!ivism 2


18/45

West Java versus WA

WA "o"ulation a""ro#) 2)5 million +ith220 chil!ren in !etention ratio .11"er 1000

West Java a""ro#) $5 million +ith $00chil!ren in !etention ratio .11"er1000)

A tenth o- WA

8eci!ivism in WA E0FG in West Javamarinal) WB?


19/45

WB 1?

In!onesians believe; Every child comeswith the message that God is not yetdiscouraged of man8abin!ranath aore)Westerners believe; Children should be

seen, not heard. In Australia as >orthern erritory


20/45

Why 2?

In In!onesia !isci"line an! security is en-orce! but there is aclear un!erstan!in that the nee!s o- the chil! nee! to bei!entiHe! a!!resse! an! reme!ie! an! that by si*lyloc+in$ a youn$ster a2ay 2ill not achiee the desiredoutcoes)

he em"hasis in In!onesia is to return the chil! to his -amilyan! community an! truly rehabilitate by a!!ressin the

core nee!s o- the chil! an! his +i!er social s"here)

In!onesia unlike Australia has a culture that embraces a

sense o- belonin .to a -amily or community/ that chil!rencrave a nee! as they !evelo")

Australia embraces a "olicy o- retribution an! revene+here society as a +hole is "re;eminent the rihts o- thechil! are very secon!ary)

=a-ety An! =ecurity .=A=/ motto no rehabilitation)


21/45

8eal 8estorative Justice

"oral De3nition *restorative justice,can be !eeme! as a -orm o- lealsettlement throuh .re/harmoniLin or

resolvin the relationshi" bet+een thevictim the "er"etrator an! society)

I "re-er to !eHne "ractical 8estorativeJustice as 45estorin$6 the child to hisfaily and'or counity)

Without e#ternal carin su""ort there isnothin to anchor the chil! an! -or sure he

+ill continue to re;oen!)


22/45

I clearly remember one chil! sayin a-ter Iconratulate! him o- oin home in t+o !ays

I asked, !here will you stay"

#$%ll stay with my &unt for a few days !hy so short"

#'oo much grog in the house

!hat will you do then" Go to orest Place.inner city sho""in centre/ and get myselfreturned here, i)e) someone +ill be hurt or"ro"erty !amae! so the chil! coul! Hn! sa-eaccommo!ation)

Another returne! to anksia bein to et in) Bismother ha! slice! his arm an! the +oun! ha!

become in-ecte! he ha! no "lace else to turn


23/45

While your sons slee" soun!ly in their home another similar ae! chil! +ill slee" on a soli! concrete base +ith only a thin blanketto "rovi!e +armth an! com-ort) he only other -urnishin +ill be a stainless steel toilet) Be +ill s"en! his 0thniht in this room

+ith no television no human inter-ace e#ce"t Nuick visits to "rovi!e "o+er-ul "sycho;narcotic !rus an! basic -oo!) >othin)


24/45


25/45

8iot Missiles


26/45


27/45

nit Camae


28/45


29/45


30/45

>ot %"timal Acce"table

O2013P WA=< 15E =8(M( A=8ARIA

he current arranements at Bakea +ith res"ect toe!ucation recreation reme!ial "rorammes an! visits areackno+le!e! by all to be less than o*tial) ersistent

sta shortaes result in a !aily sche!ule in +hich!etainees are locke! !o+nS-or 23 hours each !ay

e#tensive use o- *hysical restraints .Te#ible han!cus/an!

stri* searchin$ that is -our times in the s"ace o- +hatmay be a short visit to anksia Bill) In a!!ition !etaineesare stri" searche! be-ore leavin a !etention centre to oto court an! aain +hen returnin a-ter court) Qurther-ollo+in the riot at Bakea it +as the "ractice to stri"search !etainees both be-ore an! a-ter each social visit)


31/45

It seems clear that there +ere !i6culties +ith both the7uality and the 7uantity of the food "rovi!e! to!etainees in the "erio! -ollo+in their trans-er to Bakea)he -oo! +as "rovi!e! in in!ivi!ual serves -rom a centralcaterin !e"artment) y the time it +as !elivere! to the!etainees in nits 11 an! 12 it +as una""etisin)Cetainees also com"laine! that the Nuantity o- -oo!"rovi!e! +as insu6cient

the o""ortunities -or recreation 2ere irtually non8e9istent)

no o**ortunity for the *roision of education to!etainees at Bakea)

no facilities available -or the !elivery o- reme!ial"rorammes

liited *sycholo$ical resourcesavailable has meantthat the "sycholoical counsellin services such as-orensic counsellin "reviously "rovi!e! to !etainees have

not been available

I i ll bli h ! h h i i -


32/45

It is +ell establishe! that the "rovisions o- aninternational treaty to +hich Australia is a "arty do notfor *art of Australian la2 unless those "rovisionshave been vali!ly incor"orate! into our munici"al la+ bystatute)

Accor!inly i- a leislature chooses to leislate in terms+hich are inconsistent +ith AustraliaUs internationalobliations as a matter o- !omestic la+ it is -ree to !o so

nite! >ations =tan!ar! Minimum 8ules -or theA!ministration o- Juvenile Justice 1D5/ the nite!>ation 8ules -or the rotection o- Juveniles Ce"rive! o-heir Riberty 1DD0/ an! the nite! >ations 'ui!elines

-or the revention o- Juvenile CelinNuency 1DD0) heinternational instruments do not for *art of the la2of Western Australia an! can only be o- assistance i-an! to the e#tent that they assist in the resolution o- anambiuity in the la+ o- Western Australia)


33/45

In y o*inion: loc+do2ns of this a$nitudea$ainst children: and *articularly ery youn$children: is inhuane.


34/45

Bakea rison


35/45


36/45

Bakea Bealth


37/45

=mokin =he!


38/45

Ben Qarm

> it < ll


39/45

>e+ nit


40/45

>e+ nit

> it Ci i


41/45

>e+ nit Cinin


42/45

rison rans"ort

1Dyo Hrst;time male "risoner ra"e! in Bakea rison


43/45

Dyo s e a e " so e a"e! a ea soin erth +hile on reman!

A 19-year-old first-time male prisoner has been raped by two male inmates at maximum security Hakea

Prison in Perth.

The AB understands the !ictim was on remand and it was the first time he had been to prison" he had onlybeen in Hakea for about two weeks when the incident occurred.

The #epartment of orrecti!e $er!ices today confirmed it had referred the matter to police for in!esti%ation.

The AB understands the !ictim is still in Hakea but has been mo!ed into a special protection unit.

After the incident" staff from &A's emer%ency rape crisis centre" known as $A( )$exual Assault (esource

entre*" went into the prison to respond.

orrecti!e $er!ices +inister ,oe rancis said sexual assault was unacceptable and the !ery serious matter

had been referred to &A Police./pposition correcti!e ser!ices spokesman Paul Papalia said he was horrified by the case.

This is a shockin% incident and it's confirmation that our prisons are massi!ely o!ercrowded under the

Barnett 0o!ernment" he said.

/!ercrowded prisons are dan%erous for prison officers and other staff" they are compromised and less likely

to chan%e the beha!iour of prisoners and they are !ery dan%erous for !ulnerable prisoners who may not be

serious offenders at all.

n a statement the #epartment of orrecti!e $er!ices said the incident at Hakea" as with any report of sexual

assault at one of its facilities" would be treated seriously and sensiti!ely.

The prisoner concerned was seen by prison medical staff and pro!ided with counsellin% and support" it

said.

There is no direct relationship between prisoner numbers and incidents of physical assault.

The statement said the security and safety of all prisoners was a priority and the department employed a

ran%e of procedures to miti%ate !iolence.


44/45

"aily fury at *risoners death

he -amily o- a man +ho !ie! in 8oyal erth

Bos"ital last +eek +hile un!er Ce"artment o-


45/45

Prisoner loses $ood *ortion of hand after =ail treatent

A WA "risoner +ho lost a "ortion o- his han! a-ter receivin incorrectme!ical treatment in jail Vcoul! have been a !eath in custo!yV accor!into his la+yer)

%n Mon!ay =tanley Malcolm Coulas Qarmer a""eare! in erthMaistrates

Who Is Mr. Colin

Documents

Transcript of Who Is Mr. Colin