7/31/2019 When Were the Hadith First Written

1/4

Ybdo Ydxd Ebeldd|b Cjx}| Yxj||do1

Hz ek'Beecjlb Jho Ne|bddx yj|b Maggdo|exz hz ]beznb Ebgel Gtbeggel

]beenjx

\xeo}ke|dl hz Geep Utxd}bj

Ek Beecjlb Jho Ne|bddx }ejl0 ^5W

Jolddl j| j} gdo|jaodl jo ]ebddb Gt}kjg cxag Ehdd ]e)ddl ek'Nbtlxdd jo gexcaa)^8W caxg+

)Ybadsdx yxj|d} cxag gd }agd|bjoi a|bdx |beo |bd Utxfeeo+ |bdo kd| bjg dxe}d j|/)

Jhot} ]ekeeb }ejl+ )Eol cxag ybe| be} hddo oexxe|dl |a t} ehat| j| j} |be| j| ye} lj}kjndl hz0)Tgex+ eol Jho Ge})aal+ eol Pezl Jho \beehj|+ eol Eht Gaa}ee+ eol Eht ]e)ddl jo e ixatv ac

ke|d magdx} cxag |bd Magveojao}+ eol |bd cakkayjoi idodxe|jao/)

Bd ek}a }ejl+ )Eol cxag ybe| be} hddo xdvax|dl |a t} xdiexljoi |bd vdxgj}}jhjkj|z ac |be| ax lajoij|0 )Ekdd+ eol bj} }ao ek'Be}eo+ eol Eoe}+ eol )Ehltkkeeb Jho )Tgex Jhotk )Ee} jo e ixatv cxagegaoi}| |bd Magveojao} eol |bd cakkayjoi idodxe|jao/)

J }ez+ |be| j| be} hddo d}|ehkj}bdl jo |bd |ya ]ebddb} |be| |bd Gd}}doidx ac Ekkeeb "}ekkekkeebt

)ekezbj ye }ekkeg* }ejl+ )Yxj|d cax Ehdd ]beeb/) Eol jolddl yd mkexjcjdl |bj} |avjm jo |bd

jo|xaltm|jao} ac atx cjx}| haan}/ Eol cax Ekkeeb j} |bd vxej}d/

Ek Hezbeudd eol Jhot} ]ekeeb eol gaxd |beo aod a|bdx |beo |bdg besd }ejl0 Vdxbev} |bd

vxabjhj|jao ac |be| ye} cax ybdo j| ye} cdexdl |be| j| yatkl id| gjrdl jo yj|b |bd Utxfeeo+ eol

|bdo ec|dxyexl} j| ye} }dmtxdl cxag |be|/ Eol Ekkeeb noay} hd}|/

Jolddl j| ye} xdke|dl cxag |bd }mbakex} ac ke|dx |jgd} |be| |bdz eixddl tvao |bd vdxgj}}jhjkj|z ac

yxj|joi |bd beldd|b}+ eol |bj} ge||dx j} drbet}|jsd+ yjld}vxdel+ eol ydkk noayo+ yj|bat|lj}evvxasek/

]beznb Ebgel ]beenjx }ejl0

\bd akldx Magveojao} ljccdxdl ehat| |bd yxj|joi acbeldd|b}/ ]agd ac |bdg lj}kjndl j| hdmet}d

ac |bd beldd|b ac Ehdd ]e)ddl ek'Nbtlxdd+ |be| |bd Gd}}doidx ac Ekkeeb }ejl+ (La oa| yxj|d cxag

gd eoz|bjoi drmdv| |bd Utxfeeo+ eol ybadsdx yxj|d} cxag gd }agd|bjoi a|bdx |beo |bdUtxfeeo+ |bdo kd| bjg dxe}d j|/( Xdke|dl hz Gt}kjg jo bj} ]ebddb+ eol hz Jho ]e)el "3!3=* cxag

)Thezleb e}']ekgeeodd cxag |bd akldx |eehj)ddo+^=W eol sdxjkz |bd |jgd} ac jioaxeomd ydxd

xdekjpdl ec|dx hdjoi yxj||do eol dxe}dl/ Ga}| ac |bd Magveojao} ydxd tvao vdxgj||joi |bdyxj|joi+ eol |bj} j} |bd maxxdm| }|e|dgdo|/ Eol jolddl |bd }mbakex} besd eo}ydxdl |bd beldd|b ac

Ehdd ]e)ddl yj|b geoz eo}ydx}/ ]a }agd ac |bdg }|e|d |be| |bd beldd|b j} geyuaac

7/31/2019 When Were the Hadith First Written

2/4

ac vevdx+ cdexjoi |be| |bd |ya yatkl id| gjrdl tv hz aod yba ye} oa| noaykdlidehkd ehat| |bd

hdijoojoi ac J}keeg/

Eol a|bdx ke|d magdx} eo}ydxdl |be| |bd vxabjhj|jao cxag |be| ye} vex|jmtkex |a |bd aod yba ye}

xdkjehkd jo gdgaxjpjoi j|/ J| ye} cdexdl |be| bd yatkl xdkz ao |bd yxj|joi+ ht| jc aod j} oa| xdkjehkd

jo gdgaxjpe|jao+ |bdo bd }batkl yxj|d/ Jolddl oaod ac |bd}d eo}ydx} exd ldmj}jsd/

\bd Maxxdm| Eo}ydx0

\bd vxabjhj|jao ye} ehxaie|dl hz a|bdx beldd|b} }bayjoi j|)} vdxgj}}jhjkj|z/

]a jolddl Htnbeexdd+ eol Gt}kjg xdke|d |be| mjxmtg}|eomd} xdutjxdl Ehdd ]beeb |a besd

}agd|bjoi yxj||do cxag |bd Gd}}doidx ac Ekkeeb "}ekkekkeebt )ekezbj ye }ekkeg*+ ybjmb bd bdexl

jo bj} }dxgao/ \bj} ye} jo |bd zdex ac |bd sjm|axz asdx Genneb/ ]a bd "}ekkekkeebt )ekezbj ye

}ekkeg* }ejl+ (Yxj|d cax Ehdd ]beeb/(

Eht Leeyaal+ eol ek'Beenjg eol a|bdx |beo |bd}d |ya xdke|d cxag )Ehltkkeeb Jho )Tgex Jhotk)Ee} yba }ejl+ (J }ejl+ )A Gd}}doidx ac Ekkeeb "}ekkekkeebt )ekezbj ye }ekkeg*+ sdxjkz J bdexl

}agd|bjoi cxag zat+ }a meo J yxj|d j|1) Bd }ejl+ )Zd}/) J }ejl+ )Jo bevvjod}} eol eoidx1) Bd }ejl+

)Zd}+ cax sdxjkz J la oa| }vden jo |bd}d |ya drmdv| |xt|b/)(

Htnbeexdd xdke|dl cxag Ehdd Btxezxeb |be| bd }ejl+ (Oa aod cxag egaoi |bd Magveojao} ac |bd

Gd}}doidx ac Ekkeeb Ekkeeb "}ekkekkeebt )ekezbj ye }ekkeg* bel gaxd beldd|b} |beo gd+ drmdv|cax )Ehltkkeeb Jho )Tgex/ Sdxjkz bd t}dl |a yxj|d+ eol J ljl oa| yxj|d/(

\jxgjl|bdd xdke|dl cxag Ehdd Btxezxeb |be| bd }ejl+ (E geo cxag |bdEo}eexye} }j||joi yj|b|bd Gd}}doidx ac Ekkeeb "}ekkekkeebt )ekezbj ye }ekkeg*/ ]a bd bdexl e beldd|b cxag bjg+ eol j|

egepdl bjg+ ht| bd matkl oa| gdgaxjpd j|/ ]a bd magvkejodl |a |bd Gd}}doidx ac Ekkeeb

"}ekkekkeebt )ekezbj ye }ekkeg*/ ]a bd "}ekkekkeebt )ekezbj ye }ekkeg* }ejl+ )T}d zatx xjib| beol/)Eol bd }jioekdl yj|b bj} beol |a yxj|joi/(

\bd}d beldd|b}+ ekaoi yj|b |bd eccjxge|jao ac |bj} em|jao hz |bd ge`axj|z ac |bd Magveojao}+ eol|bd }dmaol idodxe|jao+ |bdo |bd eixddgdo| ac |bd Tggeb ec|dx |be| tvao j|)} vdxgj}}jhjkj|z ' ekk ac

|bj} vxasd} |be| |bd beldd|b ac Ehdd ]e)ddl j} ehxaie|dl+ eol |be| ye} |bd hdijoojoi ac |bd ge||dx

ybdo j| ye} cdexdl |be| j| yatkl lj}|xem| |bdg cxag |bd Utxfeeo+ eol ybdo j| ye} cdexdl |be|

a|bdx |beo |bd Utxfeeo yatkl hdmagd gjrdl tv yj|b |bd Utxfeeo/ Eol jo |bdGt}oel"oa/

9893* eol jo |bd \eheuee|ac Jho ]e)el "4!86:* j} ybe| vxasd} |be| e beldd|b ye} yxj||do cax ekegd geo hz |bdg+ eol bd xdel cxag j|/

Eol |bd beldd|b ac Ehdd ]beeb megd jo |bd ke}| }|eid} ac |bd kjcd ac |bd Vxavbd| "}ekkekkeebt)ekezbj ye }ekkeg*+ eol kjnd |be| ydxd |bd oexxe|jao} ac Ehdd Btxezxeb/ Eol j| ye} jo J}keeg)}

ke|dx }|eid} |be| )Ehltkkeeb Jho )Tgex t}dl |a yxj|d+ eol bd "Eht Btxezxeb* ljl oa| yxj|d+vxasjoi |be| )Ehltkkeeb Jho )Tgex t}dl |a yxj|d ec|dx Ehdd Btxezxeb megd |a J}keeg/ Jc |bdbeldd|b ac Ehdd ]e)ddl ac vxabjhj|jao ye} ec|dx |bd}d beldd|b} ac vdxgj}}jao eol vdxgj}}jhjkj|z+

7/31/2019 When Were the Hadith First Written

3/4

|bdo |be| yatkl besd hddo noayo hz |bd Magveojao} yj|b toeltk|dxe|dl cej|b/ Jo}|del+ |bdxd

megd |bd ldmj}jsd eixddgdo| ac |bd ybakd Tggeb ec|dx |bd maomkt}jsd vxaac |be| |bd vdxgj}}jaoac |bd ge||dx ye} jo ke|dx |jgd}/ J| j} eo eixddgdo| eccjxgdl hz geoz xdmtxxdo| em|jao} cxag

dsdxz ixatv cxag egaoi}| |bd Tggeb ec|dx |bd cjx}| vdxjal/ Gez Ekkeeb besd gdxmz tvao |bdg

ekk/

Jolddl Jhot} ]ekeeb }ejl0 (\bdo ekk |be| ljccdxjoi mde}dl+ eol ekk |bd Gt}kjg} eixddl tvao

yxj|joi |be| hdjoi vdxgj}}jhkd+ eol ydxd j| oa| cax yxj|joi |bdg jo |bd haan} cax |bd kd}}ao}///(Eol jolddl bd }vand |bd |xt|b/ Gez Ekkeeb besd gdxmz tvao bjg/

Eol cxag ybe| vxasd} |be| |bd yxj|joi acbeldd|b} be} vxdmdldl cxag |bd akldx |jgd} ac |bdMagveojao} j} ybe| j} catol jo \eblbddh "5!

lad} oa| }|e|d |be| bd bdexl |bd oexxe|jao cxag |bd Vxavbd| "}ekkekkeebt )ekezbj ye }ekkeg*+ e} j}

|bd me}d bdxd/

^=W (|eehj)ddo( \bj} magd} cxag |bd Exehjm xaa| yaxl+ )|ehe)e) ybjmb gdeo} )|a cakkay/) \bd

}joitkex sdx}jao ac|eehj)ddo j} |eehj)dd+ ybjmb j} e vdx}ao cxag |bd }dmaol idodxe|jao ac

Gt}kjg}/

^

7/31/2019 When Were the Hadith First Written

4/4

b||v0!!yyy/beljdkj}keg/mag!do!joldrvkejo/vbv1vi7vxjo|#jl7=2:

Xdmaggdoldl Xdeljoi0b||v0!!yyy/mekk'|a'

gaoa|bdj}g/mag!xdct|joiQ|bdQexitgdo|QcxagQbelj|bQjoQybjmbQ|bdQvxavbd|Q}ez}QQlaQoa|Qyxj|dQlayoQeoz|bjoiQcxagQgdQdrmdv|QutxQeoQQ

http://www.hadielislam.com/en/indexplain.php?pg=print&id=389http://www.hadielislam.com/en/indexplain.php?pg=print&id=389http://www.call-to-monotheism.com/refuting_the_argument_from_hadith_in_which_the_prophet_says__do_not_write_down_anything_from_me_except_qur_an__http://www.call-to-monotheism.com/refuting_the_argument_from_hadith_in_which_the_prophet_says__do_not_write_down_anything_from_me_except_qur_an__http://www.call-to-monotheism.com/refuting_the_argument_from_hadith_in_which_the_prophet_says__do_not_write_down_anything_from_me_except_qur_an__http://www.call-to-monotheism.com/refuting_the_argument_from_hadith_in_which_the_prophet_says__do_not_write_down_anything_from_me_except_qur_an__http://www.call-to-monotheism.com/refuting_the_argument_from_hadith_in_which_the_prophet_says__do_not_write_down_anything_from_me_except_qur_an__http://www.call-to-monotheism.com/refuting_the_argument_from_hadith_in_which_the_prophet_says__do_not_write_down_anything_from_me_except_qur_an__http://www.call-to-monotheism.com/refuting_the_argument_from_hadith_in_which_the_prophet_says__do_not_write_down_anything_from_me_except_qur_an__http://www.call-to-monotheism.com/refuting_the_argument_from_hadith_in_which_the_prophet_says__do_not_write_down_anything_from_me_except_qur_an__http://www.hadielislam.com/en/indexplain.php?pg=print&id=389