What about riparian systems: who benefits from an early seral forest condition

43
Dr. Stan Gregory Dr. Stan Gregory Department of Fisheries Department of Fisheries & Wildlife Wildlife Oregon State University Oregon State University

description

What about riparian systems: who benefits from an early seral forest condition. Dr. Stan Gregory Department of Fisheries & Wildlife Oregon State University. Vannote et al. 1980. 24 hr NO 3 dynamics. Frady 2005. Banks 2005. Gregory et al. 1991. Large Wood Input to Streams. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of What about riparian systems: who benefits from an early seral forest condition

Page 1: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Dr. Stan GregoryDr. Stan GregoryDepartment of Fisheries & WildlifeDepartment of Fisheries & WildlifeOregon State UniversityOregon State University

Page 2: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Vannote et al. 1980

Page 3: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

15N tracer recovered (%)

Forest

Streams

Agricultural

Streams

Urban

StreamsOrganic matter 9 – 58 8 – 64 38 – >99

Gaseous N2 and N2O loss <1 1 – 15 <1 – 10Downstream loss as NO3 55 – 79 44 – 89 <1 – 53

Page 4: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Frady 2005Frady 2005

Page 5: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Banks 2005Banks 2005

Page 6: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Gregory et al. 1991

Page 7: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition
Page 8: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition
Page 9: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

OG VanSickle & Gregory 1990

CC VanSickle & Gregory 1990

OG Murphy and Koski 1989

OG McDade et al.1990

Page 10: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition
Page 11: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition
Page 12: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

HypothesisHypothesis

AquaticAquatic•SlowSlow•PhysicalPhysical•SurfaceSurface

TerrestrialTerrestrial• FastFast• BiologicalBiological• DeepDeep

Page 13: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Aquatic Placement

Page 14: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Terrestrial Placement

Page 15: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Alnus rubra Decay Progression

Aquatic

Terrestrial

Year 2 Year 6 Year 14

Page 16: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Pseudotsuga menziesii Decay Progression

Aquatic

Terrestrial

Year 2 Year 6 Year 14

Page 17: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Percent Remaining Mass

0.0

20.0

40.0

60.0

80.0

100.0

0.00 5.00 10.00 15.00

Time (years)

Pe

rce

nt

Re

ma

inin

g M

as

s

ALRU Aquatic PSME Aquatic TSHE Aquatic

ALRU Terrestrial PSME Terrestrial TSHE Terrestrial

Page 18: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition
Page 19: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Mack Creek Cutthroat Trout

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002

Num

bers

Per

100

m

Clearcut Old Growth

Page 20: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Resident trout populations (Mack Creek)Resident trout populations (Mack Creek)CV = 26%CV = 26%

Anadromous salmon populations (Coast Anadromous salmon populations (Coast Range)Range)

CV = 60%CV = 60%

Page 21: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Flynn CreekFlynn CreekBefore logging CV = 39%Before logging CV = 39%After logging CV = 42%After logging CV = 42%

Needle BranchNeedle BranchBefore logging CV = 39%Before logging CV = 39%After logging CV = 130%After logging CV = 130%

Page 22: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition
Page 23: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

1980 1982 1984 1986 1988 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998

Max

imum

Dail

y Disc

harg

e (cfs

)

Page 24: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350

Peak Flow (cfs)

Num

bers

per

100

m

Page 25: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

50 100 150 200 250 300 350

Annual Peak Flow (cfs)

Cut

thro

at D

ensi

ty (#

/m2)

Clearcut Old-growth

Page 26: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition
Page 27: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Flynn CreekFlynn Creek

Page 28: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Deer Deer CreekCreek

Page 29: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Needle Needle BranchBranch

Page 30: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition
Page 31: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition
Page 32: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition
Page 33: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

StreamStream FlynnFlynn DeerDeer NeedleNeedle1959-651959-65 2.242.24 3.013.01 2.342.341966-741966-74 1.581.58 3.733.73 3.133.131988-961988-96 1.751.75 2.202.20 3.243.24

CVCV (standard deviation/mean) (standard deviation/mean)1959-651959-65 23.723.7 17.217.2 33.533.51966-741966-74 55.055.0 39.739.7 67.667.61988-961988-96 28.628.6 39.139.1 55.755.7

Page 34: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

StreamStream FlynnFlynn DeerDeer NeedleNeedle1959-651959-65 3.653.65 2.742.74 3.343.341966-741966-74 3.423.42 2.802.80 1.711.711988-961988-96 2.162.16 2.102.10 1.791.79

CV (standard deviation/mean)CV (standard deviation/mean)1959-651959-65 47.947.9 40.340.3 16.616.61966-741966-74 14.514.5 22.722.7 45.345.31988-961988-96 35.335.3 24.824.8 66.566.5

Page 35: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition
Page 36: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Arkle and Pilliod 2010Arkle and Pilliod 2010

Page 37: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Arkle and Pilliod 2010Arkle and Pilliod 2010

Page 38: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Arkle and Pilliod 2010Arkle and Pilliod 2010

Page 39: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Increased aquatic primary productionIncreased aquatic primary productionIncreased nutrient uptake by algaeIncreased nutrient uptake by algaeIncreased quality of allochthonous Increased quality of allochthonous inputsinputsIncreased temperature can increase Increased temperature can increase growth and rates of biological growth and rates of biological processesprocesses

Page 40: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Increased temperature can decrease Increased temperature can decrease growth, increase disease, increase growth, increase disease, increase competition, and cause mortalitycompetition, and cause mortalityDecreased uptake of nutrients by Decreased uptake of nutrients by riparian plantsriparian plants

Page 41: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Decreased inputs of large wood Decreased inputs of large wood Decreased habitat complexityDecreased habitat complexityDecreased refuge during floodsDecreased refuge during floodsDecreased channel stabilityDecreased channel stabilityDecreased food and nutrient Decreased food and nutrient retentionretention

Page 42: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition
Page 43: What about riparian systems:  who benefits from an early  seral  forest condition

Proportion of landscape and river network Proportion of landscape and river network in early seral forestsin early seral forestsProportion of riparian areas in early seral Proportion of riparian areas in early seral stagesstagesNetwork patterns of environmental Network patterns of environmental factors, nutrients, and physical structurefactors, nutrients, and physical structureNetwork pattern of aquatic ecosystemsNetwork pattern of aquatic ecosystems