Well-being and cerebral oxygen saturation during acute heart failure in humans
Transcript of Well-being and cerebral oxygen saturation during acute heart failure in humans
Well-being and cerebral oxygen saturation during acuteheart failure in humans
P. L. Madsen, H. B. Nielsen and P. Christiansen
Department of Internal Medicine, Nñstved Community Hospital, Denmark
Received 16 August 1999; accepted 16 November 1999
Correspondence: Dr Per Lav Madsen, Department of Infectious Diseases, Rigshospitalet M 7721, Tagensvej 20, DK-2200 Copenhagen N, Denmark
............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Summary
Cerebral symptoms and near-infrared spectrophoto-metry-determined cerebral oxygen saturation (ScO2)
were followed in patients treated for normotensive
acute congestive heart failure. The reproducibilityand normal range for ScO2 were established from 39
resting subjects without cardio-respiratory disease:
the ScO2 ranged from 55 to 78% with a coef®cient ofvariation for triple determination of 6%. Patients
rated cerebral symptoms on a scale with end-points of
0 (best) and 10 (worst). In eight patients with acuteheart failure, arterial oxygen tension increased during
decongestive treatment, from 9á1 (4á9±10) to 10á4 kPa
(7á3±17); median with range, as did arterial oxygensaturation, from 94 (48±97) to 97% (87±99) (P<0á02),
whereas the mean arterial pressure, heart rate andarterial carbon dioxide tension remained unchanged.
The cerebral symptom score improved from 8 (3±10)
to 1 (1±9) and the ScO2 increased from 34 (20±58) to50% (19±91) (P<0á02). A ninth patient presented with
a silent but massive myocardial infarction: she was
cerebrally obtunded with a ScO2 of 18% and soondied. In patients with normotensive acute heart failure
and cerebral symptoms, cerebral oxygen saturation is
low, and during successful treatment ScO2 increaseswith the well-being of the patient.
Keywords: cardiac failure, cerebral circulation,
cerebral oxygenation, near-infrared, spectroscopy.
Introduction
During acute heart failure, hypotension, a low
cardiac output and arterial gas tensions may affect
cerebral oxygenation and the well-being of the
patient. Cerebral hypoxia is evident in the hypo-
tensive and cerebrally obtunded patient, whereas asymptomatic patient is less readily suspected of
cerebral hypoxia if blood pressure is not affected.
However, during acute heart failure, adequateoxygenation of the brain cannot be safely assumed
despite near-normal arterial pressure and blood gas
variables. Pulmonary congestion may cause arterialhypoxaemia, and the patient may hyperventilate and
thereby lower cerebral blood ¯ow (Kety & Schmidt,
1948). If pulmonary oedema progresses, hypoxaemiaworsens and eventually metabolic acidosis shifts the
haemoglobin oxygen saturation curve to the right.
Hypercapnia1 is a late ®nding, and the cerebrovas-cular vasodilatatory response to hypercapnia is
abolished by hypoxaemia (Paulson & Waldemar,
1990). With such complex pathophysiology, bedsidemonitoring of cerebral oxygenation is likely to be of
help in management of the critically ill cardiac
patient.Cerebral haemoglobin oxygen saturation (ScO2)
may be non-invasively assessed by dual-wavelength
near-infrared spectrophotometry (NIRS), a tech-nique equivalent to pulse oximetry for arterial
oxygen saturation (Madsen & Secher, 1999). In the
present study, cerebral symptoms and ScO2 of thefrontal cerebral lobes were investigated in norm-
otensive patients admitted to hospital with acute
congestive heart failure. It was hypothesized thatScO2 would be low when symptoms of cerebral
discomfort were prevalent, and that ScO2 would
improve if treatment was successful and symptomsvanished.
............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
158 Clinical Physiology 20, 2, 158±164 · Ó 2000 Blackwell Science Ltd
Methods
Nine patients (®ve men, 73 years old (range 53±90))met the criteria for inclusion in the study (Table 1).
The patients presented with acute congestive heart
failure as indicated by dyspnoea, rales2 and a history ofheart disease (Braunwald et al., 1997), but they were
not in shock as their systolic (SAP) and mean (MAP)arterial pressures were higher than 100 and
70 mmHg, respectively. Criteria for exclusion from
this study were angina pectoris and the administrationof morphine, due to concern that such circumstances
would affect the mental state of the patients. Also,
patients were eligible for inclusion only when cerebraland muscle oxygen saturation could be measured
before treatment. All patients were treated as consid-
ered appropriate and were followed until they wereclinically stable. Patients were seated and given
oxygen via a nasal catheter (5±10 l min±1) and furose-
mide (n � 9; 60 mg (range 40±120) supplementedwith nitroglycerine intravenously (n � 3; 1 mg h±1).
Healthy subjects and patients with predominantly
rheumatism and skin diseases recruited from a generalpractitioner's of®ce served as controls (Table 2).
Reproducibility of ScO2 determination was assessed
during three separate measurements within 2 min.Since patients with heart failure were seated upright,
the ScO2 response to short-term orthostasis was
determined in eight healthy subjects in response totwo 10 min periods of passive 50° head-up tilts
separated by 30 min of recovery. Informed consent
was obtained from each patient and subject, and the
study was approved by the local ethics committee(98-1/23).
Systolic (SAP) and diastolic blood pressures (DAP)
were measured by sphygmomanometry, and heartrate (HR) was derived from a three-lead electrocar-
diogram. Mean arterial pressure (MAP) was DAP plus
1/3 of the pulse pressure. Arterial blood samples wereobtained anaerobically in heparinized syringes and
immediately analysed for arterial oxygen saturation
(SaO2) and tension (PaO2), carbon dioxide tension(PaCO2) and pH (OSM-3 and ABL-4, Radiometer,
Copenhagen, Denmark). Patients rated cerebral
symptoms (dizziness, drowsiness, tiredness, faintnessor light-headedness) on a scale with end-points of 0
(best) and 10 (worst). The patients were requested to
separate such symptoms from dyspnoea, anxiety andany chest discomfort. Patients were given values of `9'
and `10', respectively, if they were too weak to answer
adequately or if they were cerebrally obtunded.
Table 1 Demographic data for patients with acute heart failure.
Sex/age NYHA EF (%) Chronic diseases Previous medication Cause of acute heart failure
M/84 II ± CHF, IHD, COPD, atrial ®brillation Diuretics, digoxin, calcium antagonist Atrial ®brilliation
M/78 III ± CHF, aortic stenosis, pacemaker Diuretics, digoxin Aortic stenosis
F/89 III 40 CHF, IHD, MI, aortic stenosis Diuretics, digoxin Aortic stenosis
M/69 III 30 CHF, IHD, CABG facta10 , COPD Diuretics, ACE inhibitor, b1-blockade,
statin
Newly instituted b1-blockade
of ventricular tachycardia
F/76 II 55 IHD, hypertension, uraemia Diuretics, amlodipine Uncontrolled hypertension
M/62 III 30 CHF, IHD, COPD, atrial ®brillation Diuretics, digoxin, ACE inhibitor Lack of drug compliance
M/53 II 49 CHF, IHD, MI antea11 , CABG facta Diuretics, b1-blockade, statin Lack of drug compliance
F/81 III ± IHD, NIDDM, breast cancer Diuretics, digoxin, steroid Pneumonia
F/92 III 45 CHF, IHD, MI antea Diuretics, ACE inhibitor Silent anterior acute MI
New York Heart Association functional group (NYHA) before present incident; left ventricular ejection fraction (EF); chronic diseases, previous
medication, and cause of acute decompensation in nine patients. CABG, coronary artery by-pass grafting; CHF, chronic heart failure; COPD,
chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; IHD, ischaemic heart disease; MI, myocardial infarction.
Table 2 Demographic data for control subjects.
Ambulatory patients Normal subjects12
Total number/men 22/14 17/16
Age (range) (years) 51 (18±74) 25 (20±30)
SAP(mmHg) 133 (110±170) 115 (105±135)
DAP (mmHg) 70 (60±95) 70 (60±85)
Ambulatory patients were recruited from a general practitioner's of®ce
and suffered predominantly from rheumatism or diseases of the skin.
DAP, diastolic arterial pressure; SAP, systolic arterial pressure.
P. L. Madsen et al. � Cerebral oxygenation during heart failure............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Ó 2000 Blackwell Science Ltd · Clinical Physiology 20, 2, 158±164 159
The ScO2 was measured by dual-wavelength NIRS
(INVOS 3100 Cerebral Oximeter, Somanetics,4 Troy,
MI, USA) with the light source and the sensor placedon the forehead immediately below the hairline. With
NIRS using continuous light, the absolute chromo-
phore content cannot be determined since the pathlength of the light in the tissue is not known. Using
dual-wavelength NIRS, an ScO2 proportional to the
`true' value is derived from the ratio of relativeabsorbencies of two near-infrared wavelengths
re¯ecting deoxygenated (732á50 nm) and the sum of
deoxygenated and oxygenated haemoglobin(808á75 nm). Contributions from extra-cranial tissues
are suppressed by measuring the ratios of twodetectors located 3á0 and 4á0 cm from the light
source. In ®ve heart failure patients, NIRS-deter-
mined muscle oxygen saturation (SmO2) was meas-ured over the right biceps muscle at the level of the
heart.
Variability of ScO2 determinations is reported asthe coef®cient of variation. Changes were evaluated
by the Wilcoxon rank sign test for matched pairs.
Co-variation was evaluated with Spearman's rankcorrelation coef®cient. Results are reported as medi-
ans with range unless otherwise stated, and a P value
£0á05 was considered signi®cant.
Results
Eight of nine heart failure patients had two determin-
ations of ScO2 made. Their PaO2 increased (from 9á1(4á9±10) to 10á4 (7á3±17) (kPa)) and SaO2 (from 94(48±97) to 97% (87±99)) (P<0á02; Fig. 1). Their
cerebral symptom score improved from 8 (3±10) to
1 (1±9), and their ScO2 increased from 34 (19±58) to50% (19±74) (P<0á02), with a tendency for co-varia-
tion of changes (Spearman's r � )0á58; P � 0á10;
Fig. 2). The SAP (130 mmHg, range 100±170),DAP (74 mmHg (60±95)), HR, PaCO2, pH and
SmO2 remained unchanged. The ninth patient, a 92-
year-old woman, presented with a silent but massiveleft ventricular anterior infarction and pulmonary
oedema (SaO2 56%, PaCO2 8á3 kPa, pH 7á02, blood
pressure 147/68 mmHg, ScO2 18% and was evalua-ted to have a cerebral score of `10'), and she soon died.
In the 22 control patients without cardiovascular
diseases, the ScO2 and SmO2 were 65% (range 55±78)
(mean � SD 66 � 8%; P<0á05 compared with the
heart failure patients) and 65% (45±90) (68 � 14%;
P<0á05 compared with the heart failure patients),respectively. During three separate measurements,
ScO2 and SmO2 varied maximally by 4% (2±6)
(coef®cient of variation 6%) and 7% (0±12) (coef®-cient of variation 10%), respectively. In the 17 normal
subjects, ScO2 was 75% (59±91) (P<0á05 versus the
control patients). In eight healthy subjects, the ScO2,MAP and HR were unchanged by repeated head-up
tilts, and in 48 patients and controls the cerebral
symptom score and the ScO2 co-varied (Spearman'sr � )0á72; P<0á002; Fig. 3).
Discussion
Cerebral oxygen saturation (ScO2) was 34% inpatients presenting with normotensive acute conges-
tive heart failure and cerebral symptoms. In addition
to improvements in the scores for the patients'cerebral symptoms, ScO2 recovered to 50% during
treatment and hence approached the ScO2 of the
control patients (65%) and normal subjects (75%).Patients with acute pulmonary congestion may be
unresponsive or agitated, and cerebral symptoms may
be misinterpreted as fatigue or anxiety. In this study,symptoms and signs of cerebral hypoperfusion (diz-
ziness, drowsiness, tiredness, faintness or light-head-
edness, somnolence and coma) were separated fromanxiety, dyspnoea, fatigue and chest pain, and co-
variation with ScO2 was demonstrated. Descriptions
of acute heart failure relate impaired cerebraloxygenation to arterial hypotension or severe hypo-
xaemia, but in these normotensive and only moder-
ately hypoxaemic patients, ScO2 was reduced to lessthan half of the normal value and cerebral symptoms
were prevalent.
In seven of nine patients, pulmonary congestionwas an exacerbation of a chronic condition associated
with impaired control of the cerebral perfusion. In
chronic heart failure patients, resting cerebral blood¯ow and the lower limit of its auto-regulation are
reduced even during treatment with diuretics, digoxin
and ACE inhibitors (Paulson & Waldemar, 1990;Kamishirado et al., 1997). In patients treated with
ACE inhibitors, regulation of cerebral perfusion
is also abnormal during dynamic exercise: as
Cerebral oxygenation during heart failure � P. L. Madsen et al.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
160 Clinical Physiology 20, 2, 158±164 · Ó 2000 Blackwell Science Ltd
Figure 1 Cerebral, circulatory and blood gas variables before and after decongestive treatment in eight patients withacute left heart failure. Each patient is represented by a line in the horizontal plane, and vertical bars indicate the medianwith range. A cerebral symptom score of 10 designates worst possible symptoms. Filled symbols indicate a signi®cantdifference (P£0á05) compared with the pre-treatment value.
P. L. Madsen et al. � Cerebral oxygenation during heart failure............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Ó 2000 Blackwell Science Ltd · Clinical Physiology 20, 2, 158±164 161
demonstrated by transcranial Doppler, an insigni®-cant elevation in the middle cerebral artery mean
blood velocity of ~8% during one-legged exercise wasconverted into an ~9% decrease with both legs
involved, although MAP and PaCO2 were similar
(HellstroÈm et al., 1997). In patients with chronic atrial®brillation and a limited capability to increase cardiac
output during exercise, middle cerebral artery mean
blood velocity increases less during cycling (~10%)than in age-matched healthy subjects (~20%; Ide
et al., 1999). Also, cerebral perfusion is lowered
during paroxysms of atrial ®brillation (Totaro et al.,1993) and during tachycardia in patients with coro-nary artery disease (Hagendorff et al., 1994), and both
cerebral blood ¯ow and cognitive function increase
following pacemaker implantation in patients withbradycardia (Koide et al., 1994). Arterial hyperten-
sion, diabetes (Kastrup et al., 1990) and familial
hypercholesterolaemia (Rodriguez et al., 1994) in¯u-ence regulation of cerebral blood ¯ow, and cerebral
auto-regulation is impaired in patients resuscitated
after cardiac arrest (Nishizawa & Kudoh, 1996). Inthe heart failure patient with cerebral symptoms,
cerebral hypoxia can be expected even in the face ofnear normal blood pressure and blood gas variables,
and in this study, some patients presented with a
critically lowered ScO2 despite near-normal MAP,SaO2 and PaCO2. We suspect that these patients have
impaired capacity for cerebral vasodilation in
response to a low cardiac output.The NIRS technique has been evaluated by exper-
imentally altering cerebral perfusion. During head-up
tilt-induced hypotension and near-fainting (ortho-static hypotension), ScO2 mirrors changes in the
transcranial Doppler-determined middle cerebral
artery blood velocity, and conforms to cerebral auto-regulation of blood ¯ow (Madsen et al., 1995, 1998;
Colier et al., 1997). Also, ScO2 re¯ects cerebral
perfusion and oxygenation during ventilatorymanoeuvres changing arterial oxygen and carbon
dioxide tensions (Madsen et al., 1995; Smielewski
et al., 1995; Pollard et al., 1996). As determined byNIRS and invasively by arterial (~�6 of the ScO2 signal)
and internal jugular vein blood sampling (~3/4), ScO2
is correlated in subjects breathing different hypoxic gasmixtures (Pollard et al., 1996). As determined by
NIRS, cerebral oxygenation integrates cerebral blood
¯ow and arterial oxygen content (Madsen et al., 1995).With transcutaneous NIRS, part of the signal
re¯ects oxygenation of skin and subcutis, and the
proportion varies with the inter-optode distance. Tore¯ect cerebral oxygenation, the inter-optode distance
needs to be at least 2á5 cm (van der Zee et al., 1992),
and with the applied device using two receivingoptodes with distances to the emitter of 3á0 and
4á0 cm, respectively, the signal is weighted towards the
cerebrum although an in¯uence of scalp ischaemia bytourniquet is noted (Owen-Reece et al., 1996). In this
Figure 2 Changes during decongestive treatment in cere-bral oxygen saturation and cerebral symptom score for eightpatients with acute heart failure. A decrease in the cerebralsymptom score indicates improved cerebral symptoms.
Figure 3 Cerebral oxygen saturation and cerebral symptomscore (10 designates worst possible cerebral symptoms) innine patients with acute congestive heart failure (d) and in22 ambulatory patients (s) and 17 normal subjects ( � ).
Cerebral oxygenation during heart failure � P. L. Madsen et al.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
162 Clinical Physiology 20, 2, 158±164 · Ó 2000 Blackwell Science Ltd
study, contribution from extra-cranial tissue to the
ScO2 signal was small: thus, the ScO2 was stable during
repeated normotensive head-up tilts that do not affectcerebral perfusion but lower skin and subcutaneous
blood ¯ow (Larsen et al., 1996). In line with a more
stable cerebral perfusion than muscle perfusion, thecoef®cient of variation for ScO2 was smaller than that
for SmO2. Also, the SmO2 was low in the heart failure
patients when compared with the value obtained in thecontrols. In contrast to ScO2, SmO2 was unaffected by
treatment of acute heart failure, substantiating the fact
that NIRS re¯ects mainly deeper tissues than the skinand subcutis since ScO2 and SmO2 would otherwise
expect to change in parallel. The discrepancy betweenthe increase in ScO2 and the stable SmO2 suggests that
muscle blood ¯ow is low during acute heart failure and
that the applied decongestive medication did not affectmuscle blood ¯ow. Between control patients and
volunteers the difference in ScO2 was ~10%. Poten-
tially, this difference relates to age, skin blood ¯ow andarterial gas tension.
NIRS has been used to determine cerebral haemo-
globin oxygenation during cardiac surgery withpatients on extra-corporal circulation (Nollert et al.,1995a,b). In these patients, cerebral haemoglobin
oxygenation was in¯uenced mainly by PaCO2 andfound to detect patients with post-operative neuro-
psychological dysfunction due to peri-surgical cere-
bral hypoxia. Also, NIRS re¯ected the lack of cerebralperfusion in one patient with cardiac arrest (Pilkington
et al., 1995) and in patients during threshold setting of
an implantable cardioverter7 -de®brillator (de Vries,1997). A >5% change in ScO2 indicates a change in
cerebral oxygenation (Madsen & Secher, 1999).
In patients with acute heart failure, cerebral oxygensaturation was critically lowered and cerebral
symptoms were prevalent; both recovered during
decongestive treatment. With near-infrared spectro-photometry, the cardiorespiratory system can be
assessed with respect to its ability to oxygenate the
brain, in addition to the limited and possibly inade-quate goal of maintaining blood pressure and arterial
gas variables.
Acknowledgements
Erling Veje is thanked for the determination of
wavelengths employed by the INVOS-3100 device.
The study was supported by the Danish Heart
Foundation (97-2-4-53-22541) and the Laerdal
Foundation for Acute Medicine.
References
BRAUNWALD E., COLUCCI W. S. & GROSSMAN W. (1997)Clinical aspects of heart failure: high-output heart failure;pulmonary edema. In: Heart Disease, a Textbook ofCardiovascular Medicine, 5th edn (Ed. BRAUNWALD E.),pp. 445±471. WB Saunders, Philadelphia.
COLIER8 W. N., BINKHORST R. A., HOPMAN M. T. &OESEBURG B. (1997) Cerebral and circulatory haemody-namics before vasovagal syncope induced by orthostaticstress. Clin Physiol, 17, 83±94.
HAGENDORFF A., DETTMERS C., BLOCK A., PIZZULLI L.,OMRAN H., HARTMANN A., MANZ M. & LUDERITZ B.(1994) Reduction of cerebral blood ¯ow with inducedtachycardia in rats and in patients with coronary arterydisease and premature ventricular contractions. Eur HeartJ, 15, 1477±1481.
HELLSTROÈ M G., MAGNUSSON G., GORDON A., SYLVEÂ N C.,WAHLGREN N. G. & SALTIN B. (1997) Physical exercisemay impair cerebral perfusion in patients with chronicheart failure. Cardiol Elderly, 4, 191±194.
IDE K., GULLéV A. L., POTT F., VAN LIESHOUT J. J.,KOEFOED B. G., PETERSEN P. & SECHER N. H. (1999)Middle cerebral artery blood velocity during exercise inpatients with atrial ®brillation. Clin Physiol, 19, 284±289.
KAMISHIRADO H., INOUE T., FUJITO T., KASE M., SHIMIZU
M., SAKAI Y., TAKAYANAGI K., MOROOKA S. & NATSUI S.(1997) Effect of enalapril maleate on cerebral blood ¯owin patients with chronic heart failure. Angiology, 48,707±713.
KASTRUP J., PETERSEN P. & DEJGARD A. (1990) Intravenouslidocaine and cerebral blood ¯ow: impaired microvascularreactivity in diabetic patients. J Clin Pharmacol, 30,318±323.
KETY S. S. & SCHMIDT C. F. (1948) The effect of alteredarterial tensions of carbon dioxide and oxygen on cerebralblood ¯ow and cerebral oxygen consumption of normalyoung men. J Clin Invest, 27, 484±492.
KOIDE H., KOBAYASHI S., KITANI M., TSUNEMATSU T. &NAKAZAWA Y. (1994) Improvement of cerebral blood ¯owand cognitive function following pacemaker implantationin patients with bradycardia. Gerontology, 40, 279±285.
LARSEN P. N., MOESGAARD F., MADSEN P., PEDERSEN M. &SECHER N. H. (1996) Subcutaneous oxygen and carbondioxide tensions during head-up tilt-induced centralhypovolaemia in humans. Scand J Clin Lab Invest, 56,17±24.
MADSEN P. L. & SECHER N. H. (1999) Near-infraredoximetry of the brain. Prog Neurobiol, 58, 541±560.
P. L. Madsen et al. � Cerebral oxygenation during heart failure............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Ó 2000 Blackwell Science Ltd · Clinical Physiology 20, 2, 158±164 163
MADSEN P., LYCK F., PEDERSEN M., OLESEN H. L.,NIELSEN H. & SECHER N. H. (1995) Brain and muscleoxygen saturation during head-up tilt-induced centralhypovolaemia in humans. Clin Physiol, 15, 523±533.
MADSEN P., POTT F., OLSEN S. B., NIELSEN H. B., BURCEV
I. & SECHER N. H. (1998) Near-infrared spectrophoto-metry determined brain oxygenation during fainting. ActaPhysiol Scand, 162, 501±507.
NISHIZAWA H. & KUDOH I. (1996) Cerebral autoregulationis impaired in patients resuscitated after cardiac arrest.Acta Anaesthesiol Scand, 40, 1149±1153.
NOLLERT G., MOHNLE P., TASSANI-PRELL P. & REICHART
B. (1995a) Determinants of cerebral oxygenation duringcardiac surgery. Circulation, 92, II327±II333.
NOLLERT G., MOHNLE P., TASSANI-PRELL P., UTTNER I.,BORASIO G. D., SCHMOECKEL M. & REICHART B. (1995b)Postoperative neuropsychological dysfunction and cere-bral oxygenation during cardiac surgery. Thorac CardiovascSurg, 43, 260±264.
OWEN-REECE H., ELWELL C. E., WYATT J. S. & DELPY
D. T. (1996) The effect of scalp ischaemia on measure-ment of cerebral blood volume by near-infrared spec-troscopy. Physiol Meas, 17, 279±286.
PAULSON O. B. & WALDEMAR G. (1990) ACE inhibitors andcerebral blood ¯ow. J Hum Hypertens, 4, 69±72.
PILKINGTON S. N., HETT D. A., PIERCE J. M. & SMITH
D. C. (1995) Auditory evoked responses and near infraredspectroscopy during cardiac arrest. Br J Anaesth, 74,717±719.
POLLARD V., PROUGH D. S., DEMELO A. E., DEYO D. J.,UCHIDA T. & STODDART H. F. (1996) Validation involunteers of a near infrared spectroscope for moni-toring brain oxygenation in vivo. Anesth Analg, 82,269±277.
RODRIGUEZ G., BERTOLINI S., NOBILI F., ARRIGO A., MAS-
TURZO P., ELICIO N., GAMBARO M. & ROSADINI G. (1994)Regional cerebral blood ¯ow in familial hype-rcholesterolemia. Stroke, 25, 831±836.
SMIELEWSKI P., KIRKPATRICK P., MINHAS P., PICKARD J. D.& CZOSNYKA M. (1995) Can cerebrovascular reactivity bemeasured by near-infrared spectroscopy? Stroke, 26,2285±2292.
TOTARO R., CORRIDONI C., MARINI C., MARSILI R. &PRENCIPE M. (1993) Transcranial Doppler evaluation ofcerebral blood ¯ow in patients with paroxysmal atrial®brillation. Ital J Neurol Sci, 14, 451±454.
DE VRIES J. W. (1997) Neuromonitoring in de®brillationthreshold testing. A comparison between EEG, near-infrared spectroscopy and jugular bulb oximetry. J ClinMonit,9 13, 303±307.
VAN DER ZEE P., COPE M., ARRIDGE S. R., ESSENPRIES
M., POTTER L. A., EDWARDS A. D., WYATT J. S.,MCCORMICK D. C., ROTH S. C., REYNOLDS E. O. R.& DELPY D. T. (1992) Experimentally measuredoptical pathlengths for the adult head, calf and fore-arm and the head of the newborn infant as a functionof interoptode spacing. Adv Exp Med Biol, 316, 143±153.
Cerebral oxygenation during heart failure � P. L. Madsen et al.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
164 Clinical Physiology 20, 2, 158±164 · Ó 2000 Blackwell Science Ltd