Relevance, relevance, relevance! A call to arms (hands, fingers and thumbs) for mobile research
.We04212009 · 2019. 8. 26. · Determine the relevance of the theory in another country Decenter...
Transcript of .We04212009 · 2019. 8. 26. · Determine the relevance of the theory in another country Decenter...
Customer Knowledge Networks
University of Missouri-Kansas City
Mark E. Parry
I. Overview
A. Thesis: The analysis of customer knowledge network maps has untapped
potential for the development of marketing and branding strategy.
B. Illustrative Application: Brand Extension Research
II. Existing Research: Aaker and Keller (1991) and Replications
A. The Importance of Fit
B. Determinants of Fit
1. Complements — “products are consumed jointly to satisfy some
particular need”
2. Substitutes— “one product can replace the other in usage and satisfy
the same needs”
3. Capability — “perceived ability of an firm operating in the first
product class to make a product in the second product class”
4. Difficult — “perceived difficulty of designing and making the
extension”
III. Fit from the Perspective of Customer Knowledge Networks
A. Customers have separate knowledge maps for products and categories.
B. Transfer depends on fit.
C. A lack of fit can lead to the transfer of negative associations.
D. Quality is only one dimension of fit.
E. High level measures of multi-dimensional attributes like quality may
obscure important differences between categories.
F. Perceived similarity is not necessarily an increasing function of
complementarity or substitutability.
G. Perception of fit is a function of customer expertise.
H. Perception of fit is a function of company expertise, (not just manufacturing
expertise).
I. Perceptions of fit may differ among those who influence decisions.
���
J. Congruence of higher level associations influence fit,.
K. Links between associations influence fit.
IV. Research Issues
A. How should knowledge network maps be constructed?
B. How should fit be measured?
C. How should we account for variations in the strength of associations within
a single customer?
D. How should we account for variation in associations across customers?
E. What subsets of associations determine fit?
F. Can we identify associations that influence fit across classes of products?
G. How do corporate associations influence the transfer of brand associations?
H. How should the desire to extend a brand influence the associations that the
firm tries to associate with the brand?
I. How should brand knowledge networks influence brand acquisitions?
���
Innovations in International Retailing: Globalisation and Networks
The University of Edinburgh
John A. Dawson
1. Innovation is the basis for retail competition
1. Competition by being different
2. A model of retail growth based on innovation
2. Internationalisation networks
1. The expansion of international retailing provide the framework for competitive
retail strategy based on innovation
2. Major international growth amongst second tier firms
3. Relatively few large Asian based retailers
3. The networks have enabled a new global dimension to retailing
1. Retailers move from internationalisation to being global
2. The increase of inter-continental retailing creates major new challenges
3. The challenges are being met by innovation in branding, ICT and SCM
4. The limits to growth of major retailers have changed
1. Globalisation and networks result in expanded limits to growth
2. Innovation has removed some former limits to growth
3. What are the new limits to growth?
���
���
Expanding Research Network in Cross-cultural Context
New York University
C. Samuel Craig
Importance of conducting research in global markets
Complexity of cross-cultural research
Key issues in conducting cross-cultural research
Developing the conceptual framework
Selecting the unit of analysis
Defining the construct
Steps in Designing International Marketing Research
Determine the relevance of the theory in another country
Decenter the research perspective/approach
Select unit of analysis
Assess the role of context
Identify possible mediators/moderators
Define and measure the constructs
Are the constructs relevant in another country?
Are the constructs expressed in the same way in another country?
Can the constructs be measured in the same way in another country?
Conclusion
���
���
���������� ���������� VS�����
������� �� �� � � � � � � �
��
� ��� �������������������� !" OEM #$�%&
��'()*�+,!"��-./�0IJV1�23456789":;<7=>?
@ABCDE�F<7=GHIDE�J59":KLMNOPNCQRSTUVW�X
��F�� ����YZ[\]^0_`1/�ab�cd(e�fgThi9"j
75kIl�jj"cdQBQ75m":n���opqr@s�tuvBrwxy
B�z{7|}~!�( �X��F�� ����T��W����� ���
���������������J��ab����'�N�vB���7����T
o�W�IJVT��9"���]^/�ab�dcQBQ7�5lW}fg:
� �[��s���7�lW�OEM� IJV�23�f� OEMj IJV����7
���T{8Z����� !"#$ %&'()*"+,-./"01��234�
Abstract
This research explores the determinants of why a leader multinational
enterprise (MNE) and follower MNE select an OEM contract as a starting point of
international strategic alliances and an international joint venture highly
evaluated as most strategic. The former alliance form is defined as a network type
and the latter as an internalization type in this article. Depending on
international product life cycle stages, how to distribute the profit accrued from
such cooperative businesses between the leader MNE and follower one is solved to
the degree of satisfaction levels for both in terms of equation models, which the
essences derived from the transaction cost theory and resource-based view are
integrated into. In this way, the distribution rule of the added value for both type
MNEs is dynamically formulated. Finally a separate distribution rule for partner
MNEs in an IJV is examined taking four independent variables such a market size,
profit ratio, volatility and innovation into consideration. Throughout the above
theoretical analysis, this research may totally conclude the determinants of
selecting OEM and IJV and moreover how to switch from OEM to IJV beyond the
transaction cost based MNE theory.
����� � ������ OEM ��-./�0IJV1� opqr@�
���
��� ���
'56789:;9<=>IPLC?International Product Life Cycle@%ABC��67
DEFG8HIJKLM�NOPQ)*��Q)*F OEM>Original Equipment
Manufacturing?RSPG8HI�3�TU@VW+XYZF[��IPLC �A\C�]
^4�O�_�PQ)*%DE`abcFdeG8HIfghic�j3k�Q)*%6
lhic�m%34nopKqr�^+stu[��v��wxTUy*>z{�|wxy
*}F~�@�j������ ����[�����%���3����� !+
�����ZF^�����#=�Fmr�_��F����_�.��� !"#$
%&'()*"+,-./"01��234�
OEM �-./�7�lWX��F�� ����(e�fg� �Z�¡¢£a
b7o¤-g¥�j7 IPLC RS¦�T5kI9"§�Z���¨B@©BYZ�ª
«��abdcQBQ7�¬9"�®T¯l*:�Z��opqr@s�
°�7±²QT|}~!"³j¤Z�´���< �$>Oxley, J.E,µ1999�p.1011
(`¶9"fgT�tuvBrwxyB0resource-based view1�·¸�9�¹º�
»¼�,!"½¾¿ÀM�Á�e�ÂN¨xÃÄÅ�Æ5ÇB@OÈÃÉT�ÊlË
¨B@©B�23ÌÍ457Î�9"§�T&Ï�(":n�ÌÐZ�������
ÑkT�9"ª«�23���T�lW�opqr@sÒÓÔ�tuvBrwxyB
��Õ-7�ÖlË�§×T��ØÙÚBÛ�ÆÜ(} !fg:�
nj��< �$Tf!³�OEM&-./�& �����ÕÝÞß�lW�=à
NÀÃ?ÁDETá9"�^âI,!W*"(>Oxley, J.E,µ1999, p.171�=àNÀÃ
?ÁD���j Sã��ÊäåE0The Market-Hierarchy Continuum of Hybrid
Forms1�*g 3æd�çZ�OEM�=��DàNÀÃ?ÁE�-./��=SãD
àNÀÃ?ÁE�lW���� !W*"0op. cit., p.281:���K� IPLC ���
��_ OEM VW^��"+ ¡�%K�OEM VW+|>?@ABCDE�wxy*+
|GHIDE0èéT�=GHITêjgëNÙE1�J5lW��lW*´:
�OEM���������������� �!�"���#$%&�'()
ìí�IPLC�î·ïT�X� Að�F� Bðj ñðÀM�ÁòóôT BðKß
L7õ~9"�*g OEM#$7ö÷wøù9":Að( BðTKL½¾7úû9"
#$&�ü,!"�9":ýïþ��lW Að�KL½¾¢£�ÀM�Á¢£�&T
��T�Ï:ÀM�Á¢£�KL½¾¢£T �9"��59"(�ÀM�Á¢£�
��(��Z�´��Ñ�KL½¾�úûFT��ÃrC7"�Z�KL½¾¢
£�Ñ(��T �9"�lfg:
Að(ñð��7�mW OEM��T�¤��Bð� AðKL½¾7��WKß
lË�îL�ñðÀM�Áòó(��T�"�9"� ������(�j��*:� � � �
���
Bð(KßlË�îL��ú�� Q��
Að�ñÀM�Á�òó¢! P�
Bð�ñÀM�Á�òó¢! P��
Bð� Aðê�KßLòó¢! P�
Bð�"#$��wú�qr@ C��
Bð�ñðÀM�Áòó � x�0�����
Að( Bðj %�o"KL½¾�ô&�7'ð�KßL0(ð�½¾7��ËK
L1ó[)�)5 �Z*"�lW�§!7+�0�������´:
Að�,Y"ab R�� 0L�-B�1
§§Z�Að�,Y½¾�ô&ab L��
Að�,YñðÀM�Áòó�¡¢£ab B��
Bð�,Y"ab R�
ýïþ���P�.P�.P�.C��
n!/� P�-P�.2P��0001�
½¾2�qr@73��45½¾2�qr@7 T���´:A ð( B ðT½¾7ú
û9",677KL��8~j �9:,� kZ;�³�½¾úû�î�þ���
T� 3�< ki
m
k
A
n
i
A LB ∑∑==
−
11
� 000=
� Að�½¾úû��T�.0Z*">¤�P�Cwqr@0sunk cost1��7?@9
"ÌÐZ&�R� L�-B�.R����!³î�9":(ð�-��ùª75kI9!
³� R� AP�Q�x-P�Q�0B<x1Cy-0P�<P�1Q�0B<x1.
R� 0P�<C�1Q�x-0P�0C�1Q�0B<x1000D
kDj ½¾�ô&�7J59!³�
+.CCB
ABCCBA
PxPP
PCPxPPP
+−
−−+−+
)(
2)2(
� 000E� �
� IPLC(îFïT~"��T� 0� ��":Að�½¾¢£���´ �l�Bð�
ÀM�Á(Ø?ÙlW´":n�Ëm�¢!GHZ P� P�
�î�(I5,!":
+ C
ABCCA
P
PCPxPP −−+− 2)(
� 000J
IPLC(KLIïT~!³�T�M0:Nð�ÀM�Á`($Ol�PQKL¢!òó
(zRì!"j �P� P� P�. � Að�½¾�ô&���+MC
BC
P
CP −
00S
AðT��"½¾úû�%Tþ�7¬9Ëm�kE7�UdlW yV 0��´:
x )2)(1(
)2()2(
CBABC
CBACBAC
PPPPP
PCPPPPP
−+−+
−++−+
� 00W
���
x�XYþ�TZgj �01+P�1.P�[P�-P�\]P�[P�-C�\]P�00^
P�-P�.P�-C�(î¤�Ï�Z�A ð(½¾�ô&GH_�Z�`��"ïY�
þ�75mË �P�M2
BA CP +
� 000a�
af¤�Að�òó�¡¢£( Bð�Kß�¡¢£f¤&)*>¤�Að�½¾�
ô&�GHZ Bðf¤&��T�Ï�{,!fg:
¢e%DE`abc£¤¥M%¦sC§�z¨%Fj��sr��
F�©��>ª�«ª�@¬>ª�«ª�@Fn�.®K�DE`abc�¢e�F�_
£¤¨¦s����¯¡K�n°n�%��^��Or��¢e%deG8HIfghi
c�±e%deG8HIfghic>ª�²³�3�´�^@+{µ�¶·�n�F�¢e
%DE`abc%£¤¥M�¸�°�¹��`abc�º¦s�n��
X»�¢e�F�_�¼nDE½¾C§+s¡�n�¿�ª�À2
BA CP +
%^�±e
Á%DE½¾+ ¡�>ª�«ª�@¬>ª�«ª�@Fn�.®KÂ�+ÃÄ[�%�3
�^���n��
z¨%34��DE½¾P)*^�% OEMÅÆ7+deG8HIfg[�5��DE
�deG8HIfg�3��6l��IPLC ���ÇÈ_�Éy*^�Ê.
Ëw���%��c�Ìu�Tr��%�/Í����Î��ÏeÁ%DE½¾+Ð
Ñ6789:;9<=%ABC^�ÒÓ�.F�_�ÔÕÖ×���Ø��TÈ��
%FÍ����Â��ÙÚF�_��K�34�
���OEM ������ ��������������� ������
� OEM�� !"!�#$%&'()*+,-.�/0�123��4��5,.
�� �������6�� ������76��8,9�� ������:
)*+,2;<2�=.5,>
���OEM������ ������
� OEM #$�fg�·ï��#$T�����/�¨B@©B^bZ*!�Nð�
&cd(e�fg�ùeTf"�j�ég7hW�*Hd(*":n§Z�-./�
T��9"§�Z�cij5'�gk�l7m��né5¼o7o¤p§g�9"Â
Br(q§¤g":ÆT�11rsI,!ËçY��t�¢!7mu"ó¤d�v*d
�wÑ�xGHTy�m7j�"�]1PÙMNzBj õ~lËHL�L{�|T
}l~�7�"��1����ê�TKLT-7Ö"��1]^KL2���Tv*
�l_57o¤��"�*�Ë�þ���Z�t��tD�-./�� OEM f¤�
!W*":�Ñ�OEM #$opj ØB�����ropT��¤�/«7� �
��'&*":
����
� n§Z�OEM}�KL��¼þ�����ú�þ�7��T|}~!W�ñð�a
�0ìË�na�1GH¢!�5ÙÚ�r(e�fg�s���2Z��"j7�� �
ÖBT� l-¹�W¬9�lfg:
� ìí�a ð(K������KL7òó9"�T�n���7%TTùgN�Ù?
@0�~t1�|}-¹�7hË�*�lfg:)Ñ��ð���KL�� Q�7%�
�ôZ��Z�"��¼o v��5t��� w7 Q�*ZcdlW�~Z�"�9":
��¼o v �qr@7�8~9"t������TUVWqr@ �6(��"§�
f¤�C(w)�5m":�ð��îL79¥W aðT OEMú�9"�lfg: ¡I
�ËmT����ô¼o�t���¼o�¢!7¸û�l�KL¢¢�Þî ¼o
�~ ��59!³�§��-�Kߢ¢ Pm��Pm C(w�)-k w�0§§Z�k�
��¼o¢! �9"1��":bð� aðT}l Pb�*g¢!��T�îL7 Q�
ú�l�að�n!7����Z Pa�*g¢!TWñðÀM�Áòó9":Að(�
"#$£~7 r �9"0r=Pa1:�
OEM�������
OEM�� ����������
�������W
���Q� ���������
����
���
�P
�������Q
1Qp
=���� �C <0, C ��
� W1
Da��AR
a
C�W1
A� �������
B� �������
����
Pm
PD��
Pb
PD�2
Pa
Q1*
Db1�t
2�
���t
2�!"
�¸1¤¥¦§(¨î
� ¢! Pb����KL��Kß[n������td0w17¸û�lË[Z�©ª
(NðT«d,!"fgT4m !"�9!³�P ��r<Pb Pb<C(w)7¬Ë9:� �
§��-�a ðZ� OEM#$7÷®¯ t1ïT�*W bðTn����5�td�
op(°ì" t2 ïj �±äopTf¤ñª²³(´����n���,7µ¶T
lW*�*:jj"��·T¡W��¼·&�¸,!¹³� �*:
����
� j¤T b ð( �ZñðÀM�ÁòólË�lW&�t2 ïTºI,!"�¼»¼�
Db1¯�*gfgT�a ð& b ð&I5lË�9!³�Pb�*g¢!��Pb.PDb1f
¤NðT½��*´¢!��"0a ð����ð( b ðT OEM �¾7jk9"��
& PDb1Z£4m9"Z*×gj 1:
�*g¹�Z�ýïþ��T��wÑ_���¦�´z":
� �§×(�b ðT��W ¿�T)¢!�57��TlËfgZ*�W&�À{[
�"¡aÁ� að([?"0að( w7YÂl�*j 1:Bð�¡aÁ0#$ÃL1
��Äb Pb<C(w)<w Å0r<C(w)Æ21Ç<w��":§��-�bð(%�aÁ7
�"T»¼��tÃL w7Èm"�lfg:9�¹º�MaxÄb0r, C(w), w17¬Ë
9 w7Èm"Ëm� 1S�þ�7ô*W�Ä’ b 0 ��´:w � r ���Z*"
j �A<C’0w1Æ2C<B 0f¤�C’0w1 <2:
/T�C’0w1 <2��"fg��tÃL w1(Èì":
b ð� OEM ú�(±ä�T´m"gºT�f¤ ´�¡aÁ7�Ë*�ÍgZ*
×g: &l��T t2 ï�ÉT�bð(ÉÃÊ©QwÀM�Áòó7��Tl�"��
!³�OEM ú��ÀË+¢(��Zé�,!Ë�-T��Ìs�¼»¼�[Ñ�O
@( Db��¦�´�q§"Z*×g:ú�� Q�7)5�9!³�PDb2�*g¢!Z�
ú�TUV"fg aðT¼Í9"Z*×g:n§Z�PDb2<Pm.Pa<PDb2��"fg
Z*!³�a ð�ÎTÏ*W]^YÂ9"�7Ïl~!�Nð(dT9"÷-aÁ7
%�IlË*��":n��-�Äab r<C(w)<w 7%�T9" w ��BS�þ
�f¤Ä’ab 0��*W�C’0w1 <17¬Ë9&���":§�Ð� w7 w2�9
!³�w1Mw2Z*"j ��J���tÃL(ÀÑ,!":að�ÒÓ�� bð��
òóÔÕ7?@9"ÌÐZ&�b ð��opÖ«7 OEM ��j -./����O
@,�"¥´�×Ò�tTØ}�":Nð�`$O7�XlW�t �75m"�
³�Nð�ñðÀM�ÁL�ÙÚ�ó[) �(n�ÛÜ��×g:
��������������� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
� ����D-./��*³��Ý���-./�0International Joint Venture;
IJV17Þ9§�( *:ß?C�B àá�Tf!³�IJV�±²QIT�âã�9
äÆ'7hÏ��7�sT|}~!"»¼��*�*g0Buckley, P.J.=Casson,
M.C.,19881:Ïì¤���J��*�ËåÕ�¼o¯�Z�´W�½¾�Ôæ�çI�
è�T�¹"¼o&-��ùªéL��T�sT|}~! !":
OEM�e� ¿lË�-�IJV�ê`�-.¨B@©B��^bT��"��Æë
�ìí�÷-T*¤�n� ´�î��÷-T�":i*TÆë�ìí7]�l-g
§�Z]^/�ÛK(�î,!":˯l�IJV 7�lW��YZn�9¥W�ìí
7»íl&]�9"�Z��´W�n�)H�}7]�l-g�-&*":¨B@©
����
B��( IJVT�ú9"ìí�gº��ÚBßQTTô���ìíT�lW�}ï'
7�":¯(�¨B@©B��(hÏt�(Ñ_ðê�'!7ü�!³�X}ï�
��l7�}¿9*:2�tu� ¥!³�ñBÂÄÅ��tu�Ñ_ðê'(
ò*:
½¾2���ÚBßQI7h´9!³�àNÄC��T�*W�ó�����YZ
��ÒÓ7Û��lË)Ê���7ùgZ*×gj �-./�9ô7, Tõ�§
�(Z�fg:ìË IJV�K���(N¨B@©BYZ��"��ö�@T�!³�
"÷e�ñBÂÄÅ��wrøQ�÷-�ÌÐ7�,�´�":�ÚBßQ�ùúZ
�ûú�ïüZ�í�Nð�ñBÂÄÅ��wrøQ��ÚBßQùúZ�Uô��
´�}ï'¯�(4,!":Z��ýËlW IJV�þå�Te�fg�þ�Z2³!
"�j:
� àá�020001Tf!³�IJV����þ���Z2�,!"�*g:
� þ�B�N�vB���(> !�ab�( ´���J�(�,*:
þ�]�N�vB���(T6Z*¤�ab����J�(T6Z*":
þ���N�vB���(��Z*¤�ab����J�(��*:
nlW�������~Ñk� ¿lW�IJV (23,!"ÂBr���;B��
�¤Z*":
;B� ���23T�9"��J���i'�N�¨C@
� � � � � � � � � � � � �i'��6
��J�� � � � *� � � � � � � )*
� ��*� � � � � -�� � � � � � � IJV
�,*� � � � � IJV� � � � � MN�����
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
�¸1Casson, M. 020001, Economics of International Business: A New Research
Agenda, Edward Elgar Publishing Limited. ��)w�� w���¦�
�����xÊ>rw�q��Cr�ç���231p:
� ���àá�(�qlË[\ 3 þ�T�lW�IJV T��9"���]^/�ab
�dcQBQ7�5lW}fg:
� !�"#$%&'()*�+,-./)01,2345)6789
2�qr@T �7�V"»¼��´���J����T���7¼9":�
����
,���J��çZab�(�,*��!³�> !Ë��¨N�çZ���Ø7�
�´o"fg�ñBÂÄÅ����(�°,!fg:ñBÂÄÅ��tu�~6(
IJV �÷-ab�dc �7%�459"Z*×g:n��-�PQT��7ÈmW
*´¯�Z�´W�ó���TT-lW*�"òó�`&��hÏ»¼(*":=�
�9ä'E(µ¹!":¨B@©BYZ�!"ý#�ÔÕ(q�T´´�$%&��
ùe('�*�Z�#$D��-.(�ì!¿9*Z*×g:
� :�"#$%&'();<=>?,-./@2345);<=>�9
IJV Z�ab()67*�9"T�Ë�W�þ� 1 �þ���çYTá9":K
L+,�Ëm� R&D (�¼°,!":¨B@©BY�]^abdcT�¹!¿9
*�͹!"éL� 1 Ï(�+,KL����~ëN�����()6T*×g:
R&D����ñBÂÄÅ��(+,L�PQ����~�-ïITe��6()l
Ëj�7.5lW¨B@©B��(n!7Ôg�2T�!³�c/"ý(�ì!W
IJV��Ë�[ê§g:
� ��"#$%&'()AB=>?,-./@2345)CD89
�tD IJV(2�,!¿9*�� !":¨B@©B^b(]^2�T�
`7�V"fg� IJV�Öî(} !":�ÚBßQ'7h�ËKL2�To¤|
}�¨B@©B��YZ�½¾01ìí�Õ-(Èm !":Nð�&ìí2�T
�VËtu�T �lW�IJV Z�Ë]^ab�dc �(5ì":��&T�Ù
Ú��òó�7ÀÑ9"�TñBÂÄÅ��01ìí�Õ-&n����"l�
R&D2ªJ�T �lW�ÚBßQ�ó[)7¼È,!"j �ñBÂÄÅ��0
1ìí�Õ-& R&D J�� �lW�¼T�":lË(�W�¨B@©B��Y
�]^/�ab�dcQBQT�R&D ()63ñBÂÄÅ��()6(�fg:
nlW R&D����ñBÂÄÅ��7)4lWÕ-lË�tD��-.(�ìl*
Z*×g:�t �&]^/�ab�dcQBQT�¹!"j �%5��abd
cÑk��\�fgT5m !�¨B@©BT��W�"¥�ab"���\�6
*�÷ýT)79¥�Z*×g:§§Z��IJV��8%ð� IJVòó8%ð(d
j!W*"�*g;�T�Ï:
0-.��9�j �"�:�<Kß"¢¢<2����¢²³c��13�
;0*í!j�¨B@©B��t �-½¾2�w7KL2�()6 �1Æ2<-
0-.��L�"ó[)<-.��9�j �"�:�<"òó9�13;0*í!
j�¨B@©B��t �-ñBÂÄÅ��()6 �1Æ2<
R&D����ñBÂÄÅ��T��"=J��9ä'E�=� �9ä'E�=Ê÷�
9ä'E()�!³�f¤ ´�÷-aÁ7��:=·�þ� 2 � ¥Wé��T�
����
¨B@©BYZ��!"ýÔÕ()R��l´�"Ëm�wÑ�&(Æë�ìí��
l>l}79"�*g?!&*":ng�"TZ�W��t �(¨B@©BY�a
bdc�74m"[Z@�B@7A9Z*×g:
¡W�ÂBr 3 Z�BC£Dqr@�BCE�qr@(%���":§! BC
qr@7e§ìZF�lW&,*j��1IJV T��W���KL���ÙÚ�ó[
)J��=��¨B@©B�gk'�DBC�����'�EBC~dQB@�gk
'�JBCE��`�n�F�dG�`�(�llW§fg:
jj"BCqr@��opqr@�Ê�BCqr@��opqr@®�Ê�BCq
r@T�s,!"�T&¾Ì7¼lfg:=��¨B@©B�gk'�����~Ñ
k� ¥W IJVZ�XÝT�¼¯:�H� �-./�T�*W�t�Æë'7�l
Ë7KL7ñð�0ô9�Z��ôIT�ôn�����MN�Z����lË�-�
¨B@©B(n���L7p�o�Wòó9"§�7l�´�!³�����ôIT
�ôZ�í�J��P�Cqr@7��,�"j Z*":§gl˨B@©B�$
%&��ùe7q§,��*ËmT��BC£D�E��dG(�¼¯(�BC��
(n��¯��BC�X}ï'(8"}��¤�BCqr@7j�W*"KTopq
r@(�( �´�":n§Z�OEM #$xÊ>r7�lWgk'7Öî9"ÙÚ
�r7�VW�gô6()´WLd�Æë���7h�ËcdZ*"�MNZ�Wj
�IJV ¨B@©BT259"Ñ(,*j&l!�*:˯l�jj"Où�ØÙÚ
BÛ7o�W*!³�%T�/�cd7PgÃrC0$%�ô���1&QRl��
!³� �*:
E��÷s
� X� �����F� ������YZG¹,!"������7 OEM ���
-./�0IJV1T�slW�;<7����T��"=>?@ABCDE�F<7=G
HIDE�lWJ5l�IPLC �iùTS�WN�~Ñk�456T�lW�s�2
7T}Ë:�����������&Ug¥� OEMj IJV��iùöàV��7
¬9¯�Z��´W�OEM T���½¾�ÀM�Á�`�l�hi75kI9"§
�Z���xÊ>r7�lW�"]^ab�dc( IPLC ��O@Tf�We�fg
T�¹�W*´�j78¬l�Ë:ìË� ����(×·9"��WXÆ'7 3 Ï
Td�W�IJV �Y39¥����2¿�°,!(º�9Ztu¼oT[*(�V�
n§Z¨B@©B��( IJVj �"¥�ab�dcÔ\&3 d�,!"�Þ]lË:
� %FT�OEM Z*! IJV Z*!�opqr@���xÊ>r�]^�¡¢£ab
�dc7�"[Z^��®°Z��*¼6Z*"�MN,!fg:éjT�BCq
r@�_l*£�(¤T`�WBC~d(f¤��Il�opqr@(�("aêT
*"��*��ZsV !Ë��¤��������î�¿´I7��9"T
����
��W�^F&opqr@s���I7b�TlW�c!�*:
;��ç)<
Buckley, P.J.=Casson, M.C.019881, “A Theory of Cooperation in International
Business” in F.J. Contractor and P. Lorange eds., Cooperative Strategies in
International Business, Lexington Books.
Casson, M.020001, Economics of International Business: A New Research Agenda,
Edward Elgar Publishing Limited. ��)w�� w���¦������
xÊ>rw�q��Cr�ç��:
Dosi, G., Teece, D.J. & Chytry, J. eds.019981, Technology, Organization, and
Competitiveness: Perspectives on Industrial and Corporate Change, Oxford
Univ. Press.
¤¥¦§020001�� ��������~ùª��ç��:
Fujisawa Takeshi020061, “Rebuilding MNE Theory from the Perspective of
Modified Transaction Cost Theory: Reviewing Traditional Rugman’s Model”,
Kwansei Gakuin University Social Sciences Review, Vol. 10.
Hart, O. & Holmstom, B.019871, “The Theory of Contracts” in Bewley, T. F. ed.,
Advances in Economic Theory, Fifth World Congress, Chapter 3.
�[dew¤¥¦§wfèg_�020071��ÚBßQxÊ>r���h7��̂ çi:
Oxley, J.E,019991, Governance of International Strategic Alliances; Technology
and Transaction Costs, Harwood Academic Publishers.
����
���������� �����������������
�������� !�"#$%&'��
ÛܸÝ� Þßàá
�
����
� â�!ã$<ä9å#$æçHF��â�!ã$<>)*äèéêä¥ëäeìÂ%Ï
%§%On��@%9å#$æçH>íî@�3�îïl%�FF�-�����Â
%5�|èéê}F�4ð�9ñ$%�òó�ô�r[r[�òó�õr�_°�F�-
����
� Â�K�QöK��â�!ã$<ä9å#$æçH%�òn÷ø%ùúKû�|èéê}
%Îó�O�_�ü�%èéêFýþ>��Û@%èéê%��+�/"���Â�_ü
��ÛèéêÅ�%��+�r-_���.¨K���ü�j3kýþ%èéê%�â�
!ã$<ä9å#$æçH%F�_%��ó�O�_��[��
������ ����������������
� ù ���'%èéê���_�7��]nm�5N�_Î�������ü�%èé
ê��ýþ%�$��$Æ�F�_�Ã��2�%�����:nèéêF�����F
�&��Â%34nü�%èéê%Î���Þß>1998�2002�2008a�2008b@�3�
F��>� !"¯s#%@$%&%&'ó�(>� !"¯s%@$%p%)���
*>� !"¯s�%@$%X+%Ì�ó�F�4,v-%�%F�_.-��.�Â�
_�Â���Î��/0+¾-�ò1F�_�2��ü�%èéê%34�5!6>j3
k7-�]@�89:;ó�]j3k<=÷>�?s��.�
�����������������������
� ¨�%ü�%èéê%@��Îó��ü�%èéê%AB%ÎóKû���ó�õ�%
�C��ôü��% 2000 DE%ü�eì�j��ü�%èéêÆ�����v%34n
Î�+F-_��F�-����Â����>)*Fèéê§%@9G�CHó%I{�
(Unsatisfaction>Ã�Kn�@%E�*JKL� èé>�OK�m�K�èé@�K
û��
�� !"#$%&'()$*+,-.�/�0��1
� z¨%MO%Î�%ÛK��|$%&%&'ó}�NèéêäO7ä;$K P%&Qn
On���|$%X+%Ì�ó}�Nèéê§P%RAnOn���|9G�CHó%I{}
�Nèéêä)*P%STó%Ìu�|JKL� èé}�NèéêäO7�)*�¥ë�
eìÂ%ÏPF�4&'nOn��+��_j��Î�ü�%èéê�j�_UV���
��WXKû��
� �QöK��ü��ÛèéêÅ�%X++�r-n���¨��O�_��[��
����
()*+,-./0�12��������34*�56�
YZ¸Ý� [� \>HUANG� LIN@
�
� ���%]���ü�^_g)*%Û'`aK%y*01�S[�yb+�c��)*
%�Ode$f=äâ�!ã$<%&'ó+���gó%û�Â�h�%â�!ã$<�
�Oid%LMóFjk+´�^�[��FKû��
�2 !"#$%���34$56& !"#$%789:;
� [>2003@K��â�!ã$<%ÎóFde$f=äâ�!ã$<u[�)*%LMó
�S�_lm%��+n/�_���
� o@â�!ã$<%Îó
(1)&'ó?(2)&p]ó?(3)�Cón��qró?(4)stó?(5)ïQó?(6)� <%
uvF�w?(7)º¦só�
� x@RyzmóF{�|É
�2 34$56& !"#$%7/<:;=>�
� de$f=}~�j�_)*%}~LM%���>1@?@AB����.de$
f=ä� !ä�$�$æ�ð?>2@���nLMó?>3@��F%Ry�aF��nÝ
��J?>4@íî�J�q¡����
�2 �CDEF:;GHIJKL;M�
(1)?@AB�NO�PQ�GHKRSTU$V�WXYZN=[89\6]$6�
(2)^_`a�bc7Nde89fg6h$"�
(3)iSjkNlm�/�4$\6IJ�no89'"$p$\q
o@`a��F���~���������`�������_�� �$I
� x@���ÕF�/æ ��
(1)�=:$=�&'n��F���n�/æ ��
� (2)��=�$!��pu�.��p F<��n�/æ ��
(3)9!$�$���| � ¡}%��°�F¢7�/%£¤
� ,@O7ÅÆFhi�/æ ���
(1)�=:$=��¥¦�F<Û�/
(2)��=�$!�de$f=§$æHdF%|�
(3)9!$�$���¨����©W¥Á%ïl�¼Ç
����
�2 :;34$56& !"#$%rs�
� Þe%Ëwªfy*%01ðe« +�¬��[�F�´nØ��û��F��^�
.���K���pu®W¥¼ÇuF��.�®+,-_�)*%â�!ã$<%&'ó
+�.��_��ò1+��.��
� o@�~¬y*01%p]ó
� x@W¥ÔÕ¬Ö×01%¦¯k
� ,@)*�J¬Û°�JFST��J>öo@
öo������)*�J%�±F�²ó�
�� � � � ¯³´¥%Û°�J� � � � ¯³§%ST��J�
��������� ��������
��������
���� ������ ��!"#$%&'
(�����
)*��� ����+,���� -.�� /012�34��-�����
56��� 7�89:;<�=>6��� ?@�� 34����A���BC����
� �µ�[>¶··¸@¹º»¶��
��¼½
[� � \>2003@¾î¿`a�~"ÀÁÂÃÄ�
Å�� ÆÇ>2007@¾_g'5uðe« ÀBÈÉ�
[� � \äÊ� ËÌ>2008@|ü�%_g)*%}~J}¾ùÍKÎâ �KÏ$À
56Ð 1Ñ�2008DÒÑ�
[� \>2009@|ü�^_g)*%Û'K%y*01}¾ÓÔ� ÌíC�û�ÕÖ>×Ú@�
ØÞÐÀÛÜÔÙe�ÚÛÜs�
����
���7������$89�:;<=�>�� ��?�@A��B
AݸÝ� Þ�ß
9H�$â�!¨K�à�á��âÏã�ä�Ged�åæå nm&'n9H�8<æç
H%a��½����H<®!8�<f�<nm�3�_èéê§â�!ã$<��A�
�_�����K�4|èéê§â�!ã$<}F��èéê�dQ��|����.�}�
|çú�n�.�}�|�H<�.�}F�-��F�3�_�A���èéê§%ST+
ö[����K��4�.èéê§â�!ã$<�è]��STó^���+Tk�
��Òé�êa[�.¡%ØùëF�_���ìHí$æçHäî$ÎïH!+�ð�.
���
uñ7%<ò�â;9!%ócosmeK�|m%34n;ó%èéê�}�|�O}�|m�
K}�|ô+}����m%34�|õ}�.^��-_�|jö���ìHf$}+÷ø
[�¦¯k�3�_ùèéê�|úFOn��_�� >̂ú%!�+����.�^@}+
ûü[��F�K����%|jö���ìHf$}÷ø%9G�3�_�$ý%±þó
®í�d8:ä�<;ó%±þó��-_�«H ®�F��.G8HI$ý�j�
�;ú�n��+.-��F�K���
��%��ìHí$æçHäî$ÎïH!%&°��|d�����ô+ �. >̂õ
�.^@}F|Ï%èéê�ô+ �.^>õ�.^@}+ha�_O7+�[���
��K�Â����-_èéê§ST+a�_G8HI$ý+Ü�.�2�eÎ�!�
í=K���.X+�G8HIÁ%õ�/0+¾-�Ì�F�_|úFST+ �_�
�^}��òKû��F�´�^�n�.�r.�����+Ç�.X+�|jö���ì
Hf$}+ÜÌ�F�_�-.�í=%�4�G8HIõÁ%Ü���õr�.�
úFST+ �_��^+�[|jö���ìHf$}%÷ø9G��èéê%$ý+�
´[�¨K�8ó®û���%34��u��°������ònE/Ì�Fn�_�
�%Kû��
O���Ü�í=^�����.������´%9H:=îH;$%/0â�!ã$<+
Í´��9H:=îH;$%�cF±:+Ç�.�����â�!ã$<���3�ù9
H:=îH;$%/0â�!ã$<+��u��ù9H:=îH;$%�B[�â�!ã
$<%3�®��F��.�lÎó+´�^��.��
�%34�èéê§â�!ã$<´%9H:=îH;$+Îs��9H:=îH;$�
úFOn��_��%^+´�^���/0â�!ã$<%3�®��+ûü[��F��
9H:=îH;$ä�$��äHd%Ò���½K���%F�-���
����
�C2?�D��E�FGH�/IJK+L
MN'OP������$E�@=��Q.M
´ ¸Ý� o!� "
�
ÚD#<ò�â+�$��äHdKêa[��F�$]��_���#Â%%Ó�nS
%oO�#&'Á%/0J�¸��èéê>9H:=îH;$@�9G+�½�#Â�
^�<ò�â�(c��)*[��F+C+[�#��,�9H:=îH;$ä�$��
äHdKû��Â%B(ó+�[L-H.$H%A/yb�û��%%#0Ý�1��+
��_ù uK��^m4^�O�_��"��^���Â�K�2K�#3êd4%�
�+5©PÇ��+�r-#v%,O%�®^��"[��
Øo�#Â�Â�9H:=îH;$ä�$��äHd��^n�67%{K��^F�
4/"�8ÚKû��èéê§%â�!ã$<�l9Kû�¿#9H:=îH;$�:;
�6�K���#Â�^�%9G)*��^n�(++T©^+�<K���Watts and
Dodds 2007 �Ç�.#×=�nâ�!ã$<¨K%æâÏ�$æçHK�#�^�#9
H:=îH;$ä�$��äHd���m(c�Kn���ó����.�Ïp#Mizuno
and Iizuka 2008 �î.n#�K%æâÏ�$æçH+Ç�_#9H:=îH;$ä�$
��äHd�B(�n�67+q¡_����>���_�#èéê§â�!ã$<%ó
�+ûü[��F�#�%8Ú�F�_��¡_�òKû��F��?����
Øx�#9H:=îH;$ä�$��äHd�/"¨B(ZF�_�#Â%.¡�WÒ
%èéê§â�!ã$<+s[��F���n%^#F�4p "�8Ú�û��â�
!ä�âÏã�änm%Î@naw+A°F#èéê§%â�!ã$<+s[��F�
:;K�n�� å$B$=ä;Hð�Hd%34np �#WÒ�ÒÓ���aw#&
°%f9C +Tk�[��ó�û���%8Ú�C�_WD%F�©¯s�nͯp
�n�F"����#8Ú%µD�O�_E6�_j°�F��òKû��
Ø,�#WÒ%èéê§â�!ã$<+qrs[��F�F¡#3�Ò5�nCðe
$ò+Ç4�FKû��9H:=îH;$%GHê+û�I�6�K�#^O=s[�â
�!ã$<�9H:=îH;$ä�$��äHd�¼�.ó�+ OF�JK��n�¿#
â�!ã$<%KL+ûü[�Mò�n�^���n��r.#ú�9H:=îH;$K
û�^+Ò5%Ç�í$�^��[�p �O�_#WD�ÇÛ%��+GN[��
9H:=îH;$ä�$��äHd�O�_�#WÒ��Òé%�4�PÇ�_���#
��ê���¯©��8Ú��&°O��_���Î�#Ö�%í$�Z�^��|�-
n�}¥�+m4P4^�#ÒéQ�����R��8ÚKû���4�.8Ú�C�_#
�$��äHd��%ù²%�0�C+��_���
����
������RS*$TQ.UVW�X9����7�YZ[9
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ����� jk�lwm[n8
��[7KL�opT�lW[N�ëB>?@Ð�T��"q�<Y�ci¨
ôTr�7�W"§�Z[f¤st��uvY��lT�9"wx7ùg&�Z*":
7KL�YôT�lW�[§!ìZ&,ìyì�(ù¹!W�W*":�³[
N�vB���op�0Rogers 20031¿½¾%�±²Q0Technology Acceptance Model1
0Davis 1989; Davis, Bagozzi and Warshaw 1989; Davis and Venkatesh 1996; Song, Parry
and Kawakami 20091T�*W[�uv¿uvY�ci�l(wx,!W�Ë:
ljl[§glË7KL�opT�9"�zõT}l[Ó,�²ÊëQ½¾¿
IT�´���&T[ù�fg�«Ï�°�77ËT�¸9"»¼(*"��Z�
�W*":
{)�[WOM0Word-of-Mouth19�¹ºåÕ��|q��}~T¡W[e-WOM
0�8��|q�1�}~7�¸9"§�Z*"0Park and Lee 20091:e-WOM�[
´�>?@q�yVÄÅ�(8 jTlW*"fgT[�5��Y�lT�
!"§�(�*Ëm[�Y�lTf�W&Ë ,!"|q�����´n�G�¿å
¹¤Ñ(��":Ë�³���020081�Z�[É�MN�q�yVÄÅ�É
OMN�q�yVÄÅZ�BC£D¿�g�*¤ÑT[*(*"§�(¬,!W*":
n�c[�[7KLopT��"q�<�ci¨ôT�lW&[�s���wx
7¼Í9"§�T�":
{«�°��[7KLop(§!ìZr�7�WW*ËõvÌê¿õv�e�Yô
RS¯�Z�´[õ~F��ô�*gùú7�¸9"§�Z*"0Shih and Venkatesh
20041:�¤¹�[>?@ABC�H'7�9"Ó,�²ÊëQKL�[àBÁ@�
Ø�õ~F&[áO@@�Ø��¡õvTf�WKL(�ô,!ä�"§�([KL
���¿MNOPNCQ, T����å���T}~9":n!/[õvìZ�
RS¯�Z�´[n!�É��ôRST&¾Û9"§�(�¼T��W*":, T
n��[7KLT��"õv��ô�RSn!�!T�*W[q�<Y�ci¨ô�
*¤Ñ&��´��"§�(I5Z�"0Shih and Venkatesh, 20041:
�[�fgT[�Z�[q�<Y�ci¨ô�lWe-WOM�WOMn!�!T
¾Ûl[jÏ7KLop�YôT�lWõvRS�}� í[�ôRSìZ��T~
!W7Ë�uv±²Q7Þm9":nlW[>?@ABC�H'7�9"7KL7}
�Tq�<j £Dl˲Bë7ô*WÀ��Twx9":n�dG7�VW[7K
Lop�7°�7�¬l[�s���Ì7�"§�(��Û�Z*":
����
\]^_`abc:,Qd^efghij�kl�m#
ÛܸÝ� S�9ù
oT�È¡��8Ú%µD
ÕÖò-â=�j�_�)*F)*�'Un��ST+XYK�� (Webster 1992)�Õ
Ö��%Asó+V�u[�.¡��Lamoreaux, Raff & Temin (2003) �n��_��
�Ðyê§%ÕÖ��%WXó���_���+ùv-%V�F�_k34 (p.407)�[
�F��%V�%YZ�[\n`a��Kû��)*�ùµ%��%��]�ÇÈ_ã
Häæç�!%��+Ç4�F�n��Â�,-�Ðyê§��^X�nOn�����
��n���%V�%_Z�[\n¯³´��Kû����K�As�n�`ST�û��
Ùa�3�_���b �����%V�%Û§���`aF¯³%cp%ó�+ �.
Û§¯³�mD[��ÕÖò-â=�j������%V�%Û%�>�^�Md���
����Â%�d%¯s�5�_9GÖeDE (ICT) �fg[(++��[�%��GN
%]�Kû�1�
�"K��ÕÖ��%Asu�/0+fg[ò1F�_�ICT+��¨h���¿�¿�
ICT%9å#$æçH�Û§ÕÖ+iA�_ò-â=�l%jku+�.�[F�4÷l
®���+�$ðHu�2��F�3�_ÕÖ��%Asó+I¡�F�4÷l+���
F�û� (Davidow & Malone 1992)�^��ICT%9å#$æçH����RS%m
n�^^���éa+o��I¡.�,-����%���¼n��RS+m[�F�K
��34�n��ÕÖ��%Asó+I¡���û� (McMillan 2002)�Îs%¦�P®
fgP�zm�n�ð8�!:�$�äKÎâ �Â%p:Kû�2��^�Â%ùpK�
)*§�r.��_ÕÖê�+(c��qÇ[��û.�_��Îs%)*�rK%kê
a��n ICT+���_�Ïe��C<« º�n�K�¼n)*§ST+�A[��F
K�ÕÖ��+Asu�.p�(c�Kû� (Å� 1994; Maruyama 2000)�Â�,-�
ICT9å#$æçH�ÕÖ��+Asu�2�^s^�O�_��DE%ó�+��[�
Mò�û��ICT%9å#$æçH�����ST+Asu�2�(+F�Â4Kn�(
+�tm�_��%Kû��Â�K�GNK��ICT�ÕÖ��Asu�fg[ 2O%(
++P�_��/"u¯F�_��Ú%îv�÷>ÔÙÝ%Q0�$]��Â��%/"
u¯%��+Ç4�
1 ����������� ������������������ Alderson (1957) ���
�� !"#$%�&'()*��+,-�.�/01��2. � !"#3��%+���4 ,-
�/015,-3���67�89):;���5�<=+Webster (1992) >?%@A)67%B5
�C��DE)�FGH�+I J!"#K�LMNOPQ #�RSTU3VWRSXY3Z%[\�
]]^5_%):;���5�
2 Hagiu (2007) `abcd)ef���5�
����
xTICT9å#$æçH%STAsu(+
� 9GÖeDE��)*§��°�)*¯³´K%ÕÖ9G%®�F��S[�DE+w
[3�ù �nDE%s>�|9Hð�!+C�!ð�!�Ìx[�¦¯k (Christensen
2000)}Kû�4�ICT%9å#$æçH��TU%kn�>�ÕÖ���j��)*§S
T�/0+fg[�ÕÖ��+Asu�2_y�nST+��Z[ì��!Fíì��!
��[K�&°%���3�_wz��_�.5�ÕÖ�j����ST%Asó��ST
ó�$��äHd%��{ë%ù¥F�_Ç��_�.6�BC�ST+X|�FK}:�
$�H �õ°n��F+#�F�OO�BC�ST%b %ò1�O�_����_�
. (Ono & Kubo 2009)��$��äHd��K�Î�ÖUÎ@ó������{ì÷>�
Ç�%9H«H�äG+�^�~v[�^�÷ÚKû�.�.Z��STó�$��äH
d�j�_��9GDE%/0�Â��m����_�n^�.���¿�ò-â=+¡
��9GDE�STó�¾-�(+�ÛN�n�%F×s��_�.%Kû�7�
ùp�ÔÕ9G"�;[��{ (1999) ��)*§K%ðe!�=%Ø���)*§K
%Î@n��ST+MòF�2��F+wz��<e$�:%DEF�_ EDI��°'
��k:%ò-â=+��$ðH:%DEF�_ VAN ��°�$ðH:ò-â=+C
Ç�2.��%�"%���û�%��)*§��%f�:��/�S��� !%!�
$I�:Kû��ù®K%æ ��%���k+���[��FK�BC�n9å#$
æçHÁ%¼Ç���Fn��F�wz��_���ò-â=���j�_����
(2008) ��ÕÖ�j�� ICT %ó���Ó��<e$�:DE^��$ðH:DEÁF
Ì��OOû��F+÷l�.8������7ÕÖ�j�_�_g*êF%�$ðHä�
ÎÏ$=%��ST%{K��+���.�g*ê��<e$�I%��ST��x�O
Oû��F+GN�_���r.��� (2008) ��ÕÖ���j�_a���� EDIÁ
%_g*ê�3��ÖF�EDI�Ö�STÎs�^F�4"®+���_�&°%;ð8
9ñ$F��[�_g*ê�m EDI������Ö��Â% EDI%STÎsó�I°n
�_���F+��_���[n���&°%;ð89ñ$F��[�_g*ê�m��
3 �� gB5 ICT�h�i+jkl�i� POS% EDI�^5 (mn 2008)�
4 opq��rs�t�^Fu���vwx� yzB{|+�� 19}~����op@A)��
= Chandler (1977) ���i:;�1��5�opq��t�#�D����^�= 19}~��<�
+���������) 1]�op�h RSTU���V�=�+�t�#�D��� �����
��� (throughput) )�#�� ���5�& ��=_%�+RSTU3��op���=��� 1
]%�1=�
5 ����%��+g���l L�¡¢£+¤¥¦*�§¨�©HW15�ª����%��+�#
«#!"¬�®%+j¯°±�²³�©HW15�
6 e´�Heide (1994))µ¶�_%�
7 ���� �·5 ICT�{|+̧ ¹ (1994) �5º»¼ °½ª��h��º»¦*�®��%
��¾¿�1��5�
8 e´�+�#Q x�� EDI£ GDS�ef�1��5�
����
�%�$ðHó+����Îs%;ð89ñ$Á%e�<9H+µ��_���F+��
�.�EDI dÓ�STAsó+�.�[ò1K�n°�)*�~�3�_ EDI �fg[
STAsó�Ìu[�%Kû��
,Tîv��ÔÙÝ%�0��q��%/"
STó�$��äHd���)*§ST+��[��û.�_F�_�.%���
�éa�í=�Eö���îv��ÔÙÝ (new institutional economics) Kû�.�S
Tó�$��äHd���j�_� ICTò1�Â��mRÅ��_��n^�.��ÚD
%îv��ÔÙÝ%Q0� ICTò1��ð[�34�n�_���������éa�í
=z����)*§%��Asu�5�_BaF�-���u¯��ð��_�����
K�Â��+����KÏ$��5!+��[��nj���K��As�ST+�q
w�Ú� �lFkn�_�"+�¡�9�
Coase (1937) +¡ÅF[���éa�í=��)*F`a%�*ST���éa�3�
_¯s���F��.�Williamson (1975, 1985) � Coase%�"+¢�u�_�`sw
/ó�{ì÷>�Ç��ºÒó% 3O%×s���_�)*§ST+���.�Â�
K£Fn�¤¥�STÎs��ÖKû��)*�Îs%��RS��^+ .n��
Ö+Ç4�FK��%��P�:;�ÅÆK�n�}~LM%×�+Ê��F�K���
�^��¦F.kSTÎs��Ö+Ç4F��%)*���P�C�_¸§�£¤J+I
¡���P^�¨$=IC�ð����F�n���%�F+/Í[�)*��©^�S
TÎs��Ö+Ç�n��Â�,-�STÎs�n�Ö+MòF[�)*��STÎs�
�Ö%I��ÇÈ_���ST+Asu�.��¦�_��Ö+´¥u��)*�þ+ª
l[�F��_�.��%�"��ÔÕ�Q% Chandler ��$]�����«�. 19
ý¬^� 20 ý¬®¿rK%TUFÕÖ+�q w�.¸)*%����:ä�![�
�%Fõ��.�
80DEz¯�Chandler�«�.�q w�í=�÷��'�j�_�RC��}~J
+j¡_�o°�*�í=�÷a�.X+�Chandler®Williamson%�´����n�
�_����q w��Ir��Â��±�_��%Asó�Ir�.�F�O�_�÷
� 3O%���ð��_�.�Ø 1����%�$íäâ$æçH{��ÔÕê%�-�
S^��eìv�%Û�²¡�r���FK�$íäâ$æçH%S�è³�OOû�F
[�è-,°S (vanishing hand) %� (Langlois 2003)�Ø 2���q w:)*�´
�_�.�$íäâ$æçH{���)*§%BC�STó (long-term relationship) �
F�_E���.F[�� (Lamoreaux et al., 2003)�Ø 3���$íäâ$æçH{�
9 e´�+>?%@A)67%B5����C��DE)Àf�=Webster (1992) +���ÁÂ%�
ÃÄlg�+ÅÆ�>?���Fi@A Ç�%ÈÉ���5�
����
��)*§K%µ¶�F�_E���.F[�� (Sabel & Zeitlin 2004)Kû��z{�
���+�����[��
3-1�è-,°S
80DE��'%6l*Kp:��TÈ.WXKû��q��%�´�5�_�Langlois
(2003) �|è-,°S}%×�+�ð�.��%×�� Smith%`a%�-·�S (visible
hand) F Chandler%ÔÕê%�-�S (visible hand) %C¸eÎ$Kû���q w:
)*F�4ÔÕê%�-�S�ÍÓ���`av�%Û��$íäâ$æçH{��²¡
�r�.X+�û.^��$íäâ$æçH{��è-_��34��-��F+«�.
�%Kû��
¹ö 1�è-,°S%×�
Langlois���p�K¦s�n*éðe« Kû��<ã�=ä�C+�9Hð�!ä
C�!ð�!�S[���Ìu^�f�:��Hd[�¦¯k�$][��¹ö 1�è-
,°S%×�+«�_���º»�`a%¼k+��_j��½»�Â��±�_)*�
MòF���f�:��Hd%y¾ó+��_���_¨��%q¿��m%I�%f�
:��Hd%y¾óKû�¿)*´�´¥u���^+�[�þ¿Kû�������'
K@���TÈ.y*v��¹Û%�|:%À¿K«^�_���è-,°S×���20
ý¬��ÔÕê�3�_�$íäâ$!��_�.f�:��Hd��`a%�-·�S
Ê´Ë5Â
Ê´5Â
Ì´Í�Â
���#K
�ÐÑ
>?�ÒÓ
ÔÕ ��=Öp×4
����
>?¼opÙÚ
op
>?
ÛÜÝLanglois (2003), p.379. Þß �Fàáâã�
����
�3�_�$íäâ$!��_�. 19 ý¬%34��`a�3�_´���34�n
�.�F+��_���
)*��¥��Ìu+f�:�$[�¦¯k��ÔÙ���ÇÈ_Â%¦¯k�`aK
û�.�¯³Kû�.�[���|:%À¿�_{���n�_�þ¿+r.�Z{ëK
TÈ_���q��%ýþ��¯³§%Ån��AòÁ��ÎÏ$=u���pu��.
9H�$:ï9 nm%`aHÂv� (market supporting institutions) �Q0[��F
K�`a�nÅn�Ç���ýþKû���%�F���q w��.ÕÖò-â=��
�pu��.9H�$:ï9 ���_ÍÓ���ÕÖ{S�`a��¯kw����
'Ã�CÇ�_����.��_�ÕÖ��%AsuF�4V�K�-¿�RÐI��`
a�Ú�¦¯kF�_/Í[��F�K�34�
3-2�BC�STó
¹ö 1 %�|:À¿������q w^��q��Á%Ìu%�´+ Langlois
(2003) F��%�®^�Äk.%�Lamoreaux et al. (2003) Kû������q��+�
ST�VW���.µ*Fkn�.�ST�VW (relational contracting) F��VW
Ã���_Å�µnm%ØÞê�VW+ÆÇ[�:�$�=nVWF��n�_���
Ðyê�jy�%Ç�%Ç�Á%C+���_ÆÇ[�9H:�$�=nVWKû�
(Baker, Gibbons & Murphy 2002)�Lamoreaux et al. (2003) ��)*§K�����Èä
;$K �ùsKû��%%�Â�+Tk�[.¡�MònSTÎs��Ö%�òó�Ì
��_j�>�STÎs��Ö+¨$=IC�ð^�ÉÊ (safeguard) [�ì�ã���
�q w^��BC�STó�Ìu�.F÷l[��[n���STÎs��Ö��.�
[�$íäâ$æçHéa%�_u+�]�_���+`aK�¯³K�n�BC�ST
óF�49H:�$�=nSTF�_F�-.���%�"��STÎs��Ö�¨$=
IC�ð%� <+�.�[�%%���÷Ó�{ì÷>�Ç��3�Ç�%˳+µ�
[�.¡��BC�ST�b ���F[��%Kû����,�ü��nBC^X�R
C����C�_���
3-3�µ¶
Ø 3��Langlois (2003) F Lamoreaux et al. (2003) ^�®®Ì�_��+��[��
K"+01�.%� Sabel & Zeitlin (2004) Kû�������q��%Í]���q
w:)*%ÛKÇ��_�.1Q{���)*§%Î�íÏ9H (co-design) ®Î�1Q
(co-development) %34�µ¶%�+F�34�n�.�F+÷l�_���Â�K«^
�_��%��)*§K£x���È®;$K %;ó�û�^È¡¯s��_j�>�
µ¶[��F�3�_�¯s���ýþKû��
����
3-4�rF¡
��rK����.îv��ÔÙÝ�;[� 3O%�����>���q����O�
_�n�.�´+Ç�_j��Â��%§K"~�Ð��.������>�����r
KÛ§¯³FÑ¿�_�. �l�O�_%KLn�9ð+�ð�_��F�-����
Â�,-�Â��+`aF¯³%|XÓ���_n/[��F�3�_���ST%A
su�O�_%�òn5!+Ê��F�K��Kû©4�Webster�n��_Â��+M
d���F¹ö 2%34�n©410�
¹ö 2�`aF¯³%|XÓ
� ¨�%34nu¯+ OF�ùÒ% ICT��U%�®^����F�K�34�Ø1��
è-,°S�CÇ[� ICT���ÎÏ$=u%�û�9H�$:ï9 %�pu�C
Ç�_���æ ��+ìHf$§KÎB[���Ó°^��Ô%ÎB�MòKû�.��
�pu��.9H�$:ï9 ���rKE9��Õ���n^�.æ ��+p�Í�
_��%Kû��Ø 2��BC�STó�CÇ[� ICT��STÎs��Ö%ó�+Ök
_���STÎs��Ö�ãHäæç�!%STK�×�w�n��Z^��Â�STó
�$��äHd%��%�$���STÎs��Ö+±�.ò-â=+b ���[�¦
¯k�$]�_�.%Kû��Ø 3��µ¶�CÇ[� ICT��Ry��â�!�n��
ØÙnã$�+%Wu��_�°�IKÒW���� ��ì9I%�%Kû���%3
4��_�Ú��� ICT ���pu��_�$ðHu���}��$Î��n��°°�
<e$�n)*§ST%ÛKÎ��nDEFn©4�
�
ÛTICTFÕÖ��
)*%}~LM�)*%�B[�´�Ö×%�ÜÝRó�Ð1[�F�4Ö×#$ /
"®¯³�J"%Na�NOn�¿���%Asó+I¡_stnÅÆ+Ç4KÎâ ä
�í=��}~LM�Þ³[��Ò5�ü�%ÕÖ�j�_}~LM+Ê_�.%��)
*§KÖUÎ@ó+õ¡û��Ry��¼u��.ST+��Z�.ò-â=Kû�.
(Å� 1994)�Â�Ka���. ICT��Ry�Î@u��. EDI+�È¡F[��ST
10 ��+Webster (1992) >?VW@A<��ä)+��+åæ��+ç»lg�+èF¼é�Â
P �ê ë�ØìÁíî8ï+ðñÀò+x��ó �@A+RSTU��& ô���5�
`a ¯³
��%As
��%
�As
è-,°S BC�STó µ¶
����
Îs�nDEKû��ÕÖ��%Asu+ß[�%Kû�.�
ùpK�ÚD%ÕÖ�j�_��È%µB�+´4Oú (merchant) F��n�àáê
%û�p�÷a�_���g�SF �S��pu��.��òHdä;$K +�½[
��FKS�b+â��ð8�!:�$�FÑ¿��àáêKû� (Hagiu 2007;
Brousseau & Penard 2007)11���òHdä;$K %k+´4ð8�!:�$��È%
µB�+´�>�S�b���_hi+Ê��F^��&°%g�SF �S+ð8�
!:�$��Ñk�©�°���ST+�$ðH^O�p�n�%F[���.��_�
ð8�!:�$�+Î����Asó%I�ÕÖ��+ã-_��%���ÎÏ$=u®
�p�9H�$:ï9 +�È¡F[��$ðH:% ICTKû�F�-���12�
� ������rK%�"���_���STF ICT%S|+n/�_j�4�#$
�n�%�Williamson (1991) K����.�¬v��í=Kû��¹ö 3%º»�ST
Îs��Ö (k) Kû��½»�Â��±�_TÈ���éaKû��_¨��%À¿�Â
�h��n���ST�CÇ[���éaÀ¿Kû��TCM�`a%��éa�TCH�Û
§¯³%��éa�TCO�¯³%��éa+w�_���STÎs��Ö�I�aw�`
a%��éa���I���STÎs��Ö�ä�[��O�_��Iéan��ST�
Û§¯³^�¯³ÁFÌ��_�°�F����_���
¹ö 3���STF ICT
��K��$ðH:% ICT9å#$æçH��TCM+{�æ:!�2�ùpK�Ï%�
�ST%��éaÀ¿��/0+fg�n�F[��[�F�¹ö 4-1����_��3
4��STÎs��Ö�&åõ°n�_���ST�As��n�`a�$%����F
�n��ùp�<e$�:% ICT9å#$æçH��TCH+{�æ:!�2�ùpK�Ï
11 =%´�`abcd£ eI J��Øõ��+i��ëö��#K�«#Q �÷�ØD���ø
E ùúB5��û1i+ü�ýþ�)�=û+èFÂ%é�Â�I�v#K ����Â��)�5
½ª��^5�
12 =��+����)2. Ø#$B5%+é�Â�,-�¸<5=�+èFÂ�� �01
5��� (2008) )µ¶�_%�
TCM TCH TCO
�� ���� ��
��
��
�
ÛÜÝWilliamson (1991)�
����
%��ST%��éaÀ¿��/0+fg�n�F[��[�F�¹ö 4-2����_�
�34��^n�§+ �.STÎs��Ö%4'KÛ§¯³�$%����Fn��
¹ö 4-1��$ðH: ICT9å#$æçH � ¹ö 4-2�<e$�: ICT9å#$æçH
æTj���
�"� ICTFÕÖ��AsuF%S|�O�_%/"u¯+���_�.�ICT�ÕÖ
���fg[(+��)*%DE$%�ÇÈ_Ìu[���"�Ç�. ICTF��Asu
+S|���/"u¯%����rZÄ"���>�1+ST+«�Z[×�+��[�
���ç�_��n��×�%�èj3kÒé���O�_��ô�%��êÚF�_O
����
��¼½
Alderson, Wroe (1957), Marketing Behavior and Executive Action: A Functionalist Approach to
Marketing Theory, Illinois: Richard D. Irwin, ëìí¬äîëùïä_ðñòäóôõù
ö (1981)�¾����$��äHdÇ�―�$��äHd%{�÷>/"―À�ÁÂ
ÃÄ�
Baker, George, Robert Gibbons, & Kevin J. Murphy (2002), “Relational Contracts and the Theory
of the Firm,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol.117, No.1 (February), pp.39-84.
Brousseau, Eric & Thierry Penard (2007), “The Economics of Digital Business Models: A
Framework for Analyzing the Economics of Platforms,” Review of Network Economics,
Vol.6, No.2 (June), pp.81-114.
Chandler, Alfred D., Jr. (1977), The Visible Hand: The Managerial Revolution in American
Business, Harvard University Press, ÷øùùúä_ûüý ö (1979)�¾ÔÕê%E��
TCM TCH TCO TCM TCH TCO TCM� TCH�
��
��
�� �� �� ���� ��
�
�
����
����
����
ËþÔÙîGe�
Christensen, Clayton M. (2000), The Innovator’s Dilemma: When New Technologies Cause Great
Firms to Fail, Boston: Harvard Business School Press, �ëà°��������ö
(2001)�¾9å#$æçH%Î�H��DEíî�¸)*+g[F�À���e�
Coase, Ronald H. (1937), “The Nature of the Firm,” Economica, Vol.4, No.16 (November),
pp.386-405, �ñùä���ä���¼ö (1992)�¾)*ä`aä ��Ø 2��Ë
þÔÙîGe�
Davidow, William H. & Michael S. Malone (1992), The Virtual Corporation: Structuring and
Revitalizing the Corporation for the 21st Century, New York: Harpercollins, �!�ö
(1993)�¾f$ò-=ä�$��$æçH―��)*Á%67 O7+Ì-��ú+Ì
-��¯³+Ì-�À��§Ã��
Hagiu, Andrei (2007), “Merchant or Two-Sided Platform?” Review of Network Economics, Vol.6,
No.2 (June), pp.115-133.
Heide, Jan B. (1994), “Interorganizational Governance in Marketing Channels,” Journal of
Marketing, Vol. 52, No. 1 (January), pp. 20-35.
��� (2004)�|¸3��g)*%�~�Ç���°ÕÖjku%��}�¾ÕÖ��À>ü
�O*Ýì@�Ø 7ÐØ 2Ñ�75-89��
'{�ú (1999)�¾�$ðHäC$L�<ò-�~―â�!ã$<E%µ¶�í=―À�
�9ñ�HIe�
S�9ù (2003)��ÕÖò-â=F��ST ―����éa�í=�3��g w%Òé
��―���ÞëOÝ������>�¸ÝOÝì��Ø 46ÐØ 2Ñ�111-132�
Lamoreaux, Naomi R., Daniel M. G. Raff, and Peter Temin (2003), “Beyond Markets and
Hierarchies: Toward a New Synthesis of American Business History,” American Historical
Review, Vol.108, No.2 (April), pp.404-433.
Langlois, Richard and Paul Robertson (1995), Firms, Markets and Economic Change: A Dynamic
Theory of Business Institutions, London: Routledge.
——— (2003), “The Vanishing Hand: The Changing Dynamics of Industrial Capitalism,”
Industrial and Corporate Change, Vol.12, No.2 (April), pp.351-385.
Macneil, Ian R. (1978), “Contracts: Adjustments of Long-Term Economic Relations Under
Classical, Neoclassical, and Relational Contract Law,” Northwestern University Law Review,
Vol.72, No.6, pp.854-906.
Maruyama, Masayoshi (2000), “Japanese Wholesale Distribution –Its Features and Future-,” in
Michael R. Czinkota and Masaaki Kotabe, eds, Japanese Distribution Strategy, Business
Press, pp.19-32.
McMillan, John (2002), Reinventing the Bazaar: A Natural History of Markets, New York: W. W.
����
Norton & Co., �!"ä#ìç�ö (2007)�¾`a+ï�―fÏ$=^�â�!�
�rKÀ�NTT�$�
��%& (2008)�¾9GuE%ÕÖ{�"À��þÃÄ�
Ono, Akinori & Tomokazu Kubo (2009), “Manufacturers’ Intention to Extend the Relationship with
Distributors,” Journal of Business and Industrial Marketing, Vol.24, No.5-6 (forthcoming).
Sable, Charles, F. & Jonathan Zeitlin (2004), “Neither Modularity nor Relational Contracting:
Inter-Firm Collaboration in the New Economy,” Enterprise & Society, Vol.5, No.3
(September), pp.388-403.
õ'(> (1994)�¾�$��äHdäò-â=¯³"À�ÁÂÃÄ�
��Æ) (2008)�|ÕÖæ ��%C$L�<ò-�xF�g*%CÇ�~*¸3�_g
]�“{�Ru”%��¯k+Û+�*}�¾,Û�$��äHdäÎ-$¸=À�Ø 108
Ñ>Ø 27ÐØ 4Ñ@�pp.21-35.
Webster, Frederick E. Jr. (1992), “The Changing Role of Marketing in the Corporation,” Journal of
Marketing, Vol.56, No.4 (October), pp.1-17.
Williamson, Oliver E. (1975), Markets and Hierarchies, Free Press, -./0ä12�ö (1980)�
¾`aF)*¯³À�ü�õ"e�
____ (1985), The Economic Institutions of Capitalism: Firms, Markets, Relational Contracting,
New York: Free Press.
____ (1991), “Comparative Economic Organization: The Analysis of Discrete Structural
Alternatives,” Administrative Science Quarterly, Vol.36, No.2 (June), pp.269-296.
Å�ÆÇ (1994)�¾�HKãîH ä !Cäæ ��%íîóÀ�ü�ÔÙî3e�
����
nopq��6GrsU�eftuvwQ.xy
z{|7w}~�v�.��z
Þ4Ý5¸Ý� � ��
�
GN]���9Gä6Õæ ����%34��g*þK����î��WX�$]��
Â��%WX�n7äm%34�Ð��_��^+�´[���u¯k+�ð[��%K
û��GNK���g)*%æ ��íî+8C�ÕÖíîF�_.-�Mò�û��F
F�̄ ³§ST�®�BaKû��F�÷l�����%Ó���v%34��A����
1.8Ú!6
1.1���%WX�$][�/9
*��CXWX�9Gä6Õæ �����*þ:;F¸3�u���$=;�$!{�
õ�u�O7)<{�Ru��={�%Ì>��g)*§%µÅnm
1.2lm���C[��KÏ$
2.Ò�ûü%.¡%yb?á
2.1¼½%´:��
*¾üÔÕÖî3>1980D*2008D@À�¾ÕÖÔÙ%S��>1976D*2007D@À
2.2´:��^��^��F
3.��u¯k%�Ú
3.1î��WXF8C�ÕÖíî
3.2¯³§ST�®�3���u¯k%ªl
4.rF¡
�
@÷n��¼½
� �� (2004)�����op�ðñl/� �������$����������,� 7�� 2 ,
pp.75-89�
� �� (2005)��èop�!�%�è��"#�[$�$%�&�&'()&��* +,-.�
� �� (2006)���g���èop�b/o01� 2´534 ]��5̦ü�èop 6B5Ô
7X8VW5��ì9:&'�&ïb&-;�� 33 ,pp.45-58�
� �� (2007)�<n��èbp���=> gB5����ì9:&'�&ï=j?@x����� 1
,pp.74-92�
����
\]i���d^��j�����
M����Wd^�����$%&'�M
A�B¸Ý� �� %&
�
� �2K��r>�CV¾9GuE%ÕÖ{�"À%X"+òW�����%5!F`
þ�O�_��[��Â%¨K�ÕÖ���j��â�!ã$<��%��ó�O�_m
��
�� ������� ��������
�� ����
� CV�Ó+D°8Ú!6��ÕÖ�j��9GuF)*§%STóF�4®�û�.�
� ÕÖ{�"%WE�!>��ÕÖ%��%Û�j�_�ÕÖ{��D£���F�4|Õ
Ö{�%EFó}����Â%8B¿¨�û��ÕÖ{��Ï%¯³�3�_EG��Kû
�F�4|ÕÖ{�%{SEGó}�òWK����^����rK%ÕÖ{�"�j�
_��ÕÖ{�%ø×�´��ÕÖ{�¢M��*����F+HI%#�F�_���
F�©��ôü%ÕÖWX�]+]��¿�6f�É® PB 67%1Q��ð:Õ*nm�
ÕÖ{�¢M�¢[��*��_��%K�n°�r.�9H�$â�!�X����9
Gu%�0�3�_ÕÖ)*�ºò�n�F�4¢[nÛJ�"K�´���öK�n��
WÒ���K�%¯³��I�%��û��23�ù%ÕÖ{��S¾�_��¶��&
°������4�.¶·+�r-�|ÕÖ{�%{SEGó}%����ªl��|ÕÖ
{�%K�{SS¾ó}F�4¤¥+���©�F�3�_�ôü%ÕÖWX+��[�
/"FWÒ%L-�ð+²¡��F+����.�
� ����ÕÖ{�"%#$ �N�.Òé��+�¡�¨K��CÇ[�¤¥®w�%
1Q�q¡����Â�K�CVK��|ÕÖ{�%K�{�S¾ó}+sª��ûü[�
.¡��|{��S¾op}n�¤¥+��[�����n7ÕÖ)*§%ø×�´�T
È�%^+�´[�.¡��|{�qÇop}F�4¤¥+��[��9GuFÔÕA+%
§��ÕÖ{�+Md����F�3�_�ÕÖ{�¢M��9Gu%/0%�é+��
��.%Kû��
� ���%Äk�3�_�ÕÖ{�"��@��c�n`þ+(M��ôü%ÕÖWX%
Òé����N-4�/"OdF�_%ø×+´4�F�K��Z©4�
�� ����
� CVK��ÔÕ9Gæ ��"%PÇ��%;$#9+ÖÈ_�ÔÕ9Gæ ��¤¥
���¥��"x�Kû�.¡�Â%(+�C�P��nõ�q¡����F�����
Â%õ�û.�_���rK%9Gu�Ö%ª�n����F3��9G�/%��n
����
��+ûüK��w��q¡����F+wz�.�
� Â�K�9Gu+öW[�¤¥F�_�9Gu�ÖÁ%��ó+�[|9Gu�Öop}
��-�)*§%9G�/æ ��%%Ó�n´:��k�©.¡��)*§Km%I�
%Ò±%ÕÖ9G�ÎB��_��%^+�[|9GÎBuop}+Qs�.�����
��¿��%��+sª��s[�%�B(ó+QR[��
z¨%/"���+ÖÈ�¹ 1 %34��9GuF)*§%STó�S[���u¯k
+���.�
����
� ������
�������
�������
�������
� ��������
��� ��
��!�"��
#$%&'�() ����() #$���()
*+,-
�� �
�� �
�� �
�� �
��
�
�
�
�
�
¹ 1� 9GuF)*§%STó�S[���u¯k
�µ���>2008@�163.$Î�
�� ������
� CV%�®K��¹ 1 %��u¯k���n���2003 D 11 S�ÒÓ�.|¸TUV
7ÕÖ%9Gu�S[��8WÅ�}�3�_v<��.í$�+a�_�Òé��+0
1�_�.����K��ÕÖ%�!K�¡_Efc%õ� POS>Point of Sales@æ �
�F EDI>Electronic Data Interchange@F�4�O%9G�/æ ���è][��
Òé��%X++�¹ 1%Û���.XÑ%2XK�:�A[��
� r>��%ST�O�_Kû��)*§ST�F���}ã$STF�4)*§%RC
�67��ÕÖ9GuFm%34�S��%^+�é�.�POS æ ��Á%�Ö��)
*§%}ã$STF�RS�n°�_g)*�F�_idó%õ�ÕÖ9Gæ ��Kû
����PF�iN�_������F��K���Ïp�EDI Á%�Ö��Ø 1 ��
_g)*�C[���P%fgzm��I�aw�����ÒÓ���F�4ST�û��
���
���
���
���
��./!��
����
�%ST��9Gu%�$ðHu��pu��0[�F�fgzm��I��m�Or��
��%û�_g)*��&��m���P���p¦'% EDIÁ%���n�Ö�w/ó
+ä[F�-�%�YÐKû©4�Ø 2 ��_g)*F��P%Ry%)*3�F9Gu
F%§�mD[�¿Z[�ST�´�^�n�.�Â���)*3��¸���¿��Ö
�J�û�\�9Gu��0[�F�4¢[n"/K�n^�.�EDI �Ö%��ó��
)*§%3�]��¸��aw3��)*3��]^[�aw%p�õ°n�_����
���E9�_`/"^��^�.STKû�����%®��9Gu��$ðHu%�
0%ÛK���rK%}ã$��°)*§ST^��Can)*�r%STÁFÌu�
_���F+�?[��
� v��(%STKû��POSæ ��® EDIÁ%9Gu�Ö%op�9GÎB%op+
õ¡�^m4^F�4®+�RS��+ÖÈ_�é�.�POS æ ���ÖF9GÎBu
op��RS����>�POS æ ���iNó%õ�9Gæ ��Kû��F�wzK
���Ïp�EDI �Ö��)*§%9GÎBFRSST�õ°��rnS���û���
��% POSæ ��F EDI%Î�����j��)*§%STóF9Gu%��X+F�
nw�Kû��
� X�_�)*§%���ha��� EDI�Ö��STÎs��Ö^s^F�4*%"®
Kû��&�%��PF��+Ç�_��_g)*�m�EDI �Ö����Kû��EDI
�Ö����n)*Kû�¿û��m�Â%ÖUÎsó�I�F�4ÒéX+����.�
�%�F��9GDE%�ë®â�!ã$<Öe%�pu�3�_�EDI ����PF%
e�<9H(++QT[�ÖU^���P$%%stó+õ¡�ÖUÁFÌ:�_�_�
�FÍbK���3�_���� !"�C��EDI %34n9Gu+STÎs��ÖF
[��p��í�q¡����
� "®c��9GÎBu�ÕÖ{�%{S�´F�_%)*§%STóFm%34�S�
�%^�O�_Kû����K��|ÕÖ{�%K�{SS¾ó}%¤¥��òFn��n
7n����_g)*�´4ÕÖ{�Á�g)*�S¾[�¶·�Or��ÕÖ{��C
�__g)*F�g)*%iN�.�O%¯³�S¾[�¶·+.-�_g)*F�g)
*%STóFÎB9GF%ST+�é[�^�Kû�����5�_��íÎ�=9G+
C¸ed9GFC��_.-��r>�ÎB9GFÕÖ{�%{S�´F%ST+�é[
��PN��C¸ed9GFíÎ�=9G%op§%ST+E�.�Â%X+�dê%
9G��RS�e°�iNSTKû��F��é��.��%X+��dê�����
��n9GKû��F+!Z�_j��9Gu��0�_��íÎ�=9G�C¸ed9
G�f����_G��F�4�F��-�°��F+!Z[��Ø 2 ��C¸edFí
Î�=%dê%9GopF��P^�_g)*%ÕÖ{�Á%S¾F%ST+�é�.F
�©�C¸ed�íÎ�=cp%9Gop�/0[�aw�Â%4�%gp�/0[�a
w�dêF�/0[�aw% 4 O��±��.�C¸ed9Gop�/0[�{�{ëK
����
��_g�h%só�n9G®¦�´ÐêFfg´ÐêF%ú��âÏã�$æçH�3
�_iÊ���9G®HI9�Â�_�9G�3�_jk���ú%ïló�q¡���
Z©4�ùp�íÎ�=9Gop�/0[�{�{ëK��üU%�.�$æçHK£x
���9GdÓ��òn!Z+ ��Â%ðe« %ÛKl����íÎ�=9G%��
��ü�%¨��nmï%)<�ð�n��F�-����
� v%o��9Gu�Ö�ÕÖ{�%qÇop%]¨+�.�[^F�48ÚKû��POS
æ ��Á%�Ö��O7�/�S��*é®pQ$%(cu���½�_���%%�
q7%r�+��¨��2�F�4���´�^�n�.�EDI �Ö�O�_��¥�
��fg{�+õ¡�pQ$%(cu��¾�_����&r�åª%pQ$�On��
F%×��st���X+Fn�.����%ÒéX+^��̧ TUV7ÕÖ�j�_��
g�)*%hi®� !uvZ�K�n°�K�%Û§ÕÖ¯³+ÖÈ_ùs%3�%Ô
Ù+ê^�.eÎ �ä< �wr��F�����
� v��{��S¾op�{�qÇop+õ¡�^F�4x%STKû��fg{��S
�� 10%w�Û 7w�K�fgS¾%(+�E��.��^��eÎ �ä< %pQ
$%(có�6Õ3�%ÔÙó%dv-�j�_��eÎ �ä< S¾%(+�EK
�n^�.�
� ��K�fgqÇop+¡��_oFx%§��¿Z[�ST�û��Â���EDI �
Öop��°�fgS¾op%ån°F�ùp�fgqÇop+õ¡_��F�4STK
û���%X+��_g%d9Ū�%õ�fg*é�j�_ EDI�B(�{���r.�
9GuZ�K�ͯK�n�¥�����P^�%ú�S¾�B(��a[��F+�?
[��
� y��ÕÖ{�%qÇop�ÔÕA+�XkO°^�O�_Kû��fgqÇop% 10
w�Û 6 w�K�zhic�O7µ�c+õ¡_���F�Õ*Ôéc�C�_��ì{
�$I%Ef%k�/0�_���F�E��.�eÎ �ä< qÇop�O�_��
6Õ3�%ÔÙó�zhic+õ¡�pQ$%(có�O7µ�c+¨h_���F��
���.�
� ����9GuFÔÕA+%Û§���ÕÖ{�+Md����F�3�_�Or�o
%X+Fy%X++a�.Þ�" �3�_�POSæ ��® EDI�gU%ÕÖ{�%w
�+á�n���Õ*Ôéc��/0�n���zhicFO7µ�c%]¨+�.�[
�F�/��.�
� x��íÎ�=9GFC¸ed9G+|�}��y��9Gu�ÖF)*§%S¾+|
�}�[�F�4�®%Ø��û��%%��>���9GuFú%ø×�´�j�_�
9Gu�ú%¦y+EGK��%^F�4ÎÖ%"®+~5�_���Â�K��íÎ�
=9G�ú��^P-n�C¸ed9G�f����_^���F�n��F�9GFú
F�¢[nEGST��n��F����.%Kû����x-�¿�mYn�9Gu�
����
�0�.F�_��ú��^K�n�¦y�M>mD[���%34nX+�Ê��./
9%ùOF�_�EDI K��P���íÎ�=9G��)*§K��¯¡.�t9�`s
���Ïp�C¸ed9Gop���ú��âÏã�$æçHK�^P�Ên�_g�h
%9G®Wa%HI9nm�&��5r�_����ó�wzK���
�� ���� !"#
� ����j��`þFêÚF�_�v% 3®��h����
� r>�/"�nêÚF�_�ÕÖ{�"�j��¤¥Fw�%1Q%8Ú�û����
��j�_�ùÕÖ{��C�_�|{��S¾op}j3k|{�qÇop}F�4¤¥
FÂ��CÇ[��s�nw�+a!��Òé��+01�_�.�ÕÖ{�%¤¥Fw
��S[�YÐó+:��[��F��ÕÖ{�"FÒé��+RA�rw[�¨K�ò
nêÚKû��
� Ø�������j��Å�+�¸TUV7_g)*+CXF�_ÒÓ�.�F�Ð1
���°O^%`só%8Ú�mD[��ùO¡��Å�CX*Ò%`só%8ÚKû��
Or��¸TUV7�j��ÕÖz�Á%��%ù u���n��¿n�n���O¡
%`só%8Ú��Å�W^�Ê���í$���Å�CXFn�._g)*FÂ%�¸
%��P%�9CIST�`s��_��®Kû������Å�CX�_g)*Kû�
�F�Ð1��_g)*;9IZ�%ÕÖ{���®�]���.���Kû�¿�ÕÖ
{��S¾[�¯³F�_�¯Ù���={S��eÎ �ä< ®fg{���6Õ*
ê®ì$�$�=s��������K�����%¯³F%ST+�X�_���Â%
!ZK��òÁ�-�nNa%��Kû��F+E¡·�+Ên��ô���q��$�
�äHdäæ ��®â�!ã$<¯³F��.3����H�< !%ÛK%���q
¡����
� ����ÕÖ9Gu%4'%8ÚKû��POSæ ��F EDIF�4Efc%õ�ÕÖ
9Gæ ���CX+��.�FK�Â��%Q0ÔKû� CRM® SCMnm�¬�î�
�æ ��+��¨h��F���n^�.��%®�ô�%�ònêÚKû��r.�
ÕÖ9G�O�_�ü��� EDIK��P���íÎ�=9G�KL���¨h��F�
K�.�%%�QF�Ö�S��34nÛBC�n!"¯s�Mòn9G®C¸ed%Õ
Ö9G+ ���%�¨�¨h��F�K�n^�.��.��_�3����®^�Õ
Ö9G+��������±:u[��F�q¡����
$� %&'()*���+�,
�� -%&'()*.!/012�345678
� â�!ã$<���H�Ï$�+On� LAN>Local Area Network@®�¯³K%ú§
ST�¯³§ST�£Ö�nm��r·rn�!K`���a�Kû��Â�Z���â
����
�!ã$<F�4a���¡_�J�Kû��â�!ã$<F�4�FZ�K��!��
��&°%�%�F+ͯ[�34n8�[��-���^��ÕÖ���j�_��â
�!ã$<F�4a��a���_�����9H:8F�_%9GÖeâ�!ã$<�
(��CXF�_%ÕÖâ�!ã$<�*p "F�_%â�!ã$<��% 3 O+Õ�
�_�-�Mò�û��
o@9H:8F�_%9GÖeâ�!ã$<
� r>�ùO¡%â�!ã$<��9H:8F�_%9GÖeâ�!ã$<Kû��9G
Öeâ�!ã$<F��LAN>Local Area Network@®9H�$â�!nm�¼�®��
nm%9G+�pe[�.¡��H�Ï$��r+�öÖeµ¿�KrX�.�%Kû��
�4�.9GÖeâ�!ã$<��POS æ ���EDI�SCM>Supply Chain
Management@�VMI>Vendor Managed Inventory@�ECR>Efficient Consumer Response@
nm�)*´�)*§%9G£x+ã-��DE+�A�_��.¡�ÕÖ9Gu�j
�_º�qKû��9GÖeâ�!ã$<��g�)*�)*§%9G�/æ ���¯
k�r��*éðe« �j��9G£x+æ$�� �|X[��F+����_���
x@��CXF�_%ÕÖâ�!ã$<
v%â�!ã$<��ÕÖâ�!ã$<Kû��ÕÖ%ø×��TUFèé%��+�
Í[��FKû��F^���ÕÖ"K�Â�Â�TU^�èé�]�_%�q�n��
��®+Ð__�.�ÕÖÔ�u�VMS>Vertical Marketing System@�SCMnm%a�
�Â%�F+Z��ö�_���������>��æ ��"�â�!ã$<"+��
�kn���ì$�$«�g«_g%�q�nÕÖâ�!ã$<+8Ú��_��%Kû
��g�ÕÖ)*´K%¥��¼�`þ+��[�ÛK�SCM�VMI�ECRnm���q
�ÕÖò-â=+ÖÈ_%�Ó�¼+�]�.��¯kF.-��F�K���
r.��$��äHd"�j�_����$æçHæ�ðä�$��äHd�÷a��
�®)*�F�_��PF%STóZ�Kn°�&°%h�STêF%STó��òKû
��F��^�_��1���$æçHæ�ðä�$��äHd��®)*^�h�STê
�]�_%��¿¶%â�!ã$<F�_.-��F�K���&°%h�STêF%S
Tó%�òó+wz�.®����$æçHæ�ðä�$��äHd%�½�û��
z¨%Ö��ÕÖ"K��ì$�$^�_g�ç��q�â�!ã$<��$��äH
d"K���®)*^���¿¶%â�!ã$<���CX+�h_�.��^��Ò5
%Å�ä��K���9CIST��-��_���F�&°�òÁ�-�n`þ+ �
_���
1 Gummesson, E.ì2002ïA B���
����
,@p "F�_%â�!ã$<��
1980DEz¯�Å�CX�r%|ST}+sª����[�S Kû�â�!ã$<�
���'+Û+�QÆ[�F���rKsó������_�.<=´%��%����
JST�}~ST�Û+ú6%Îsnm+sª��Ç4�F����n��î��Å��
��Ç���34�n�.2�â�!ã$<�����4�.eìÝ�F���Q�ä�â
Ïã�ä�!+¥�F�_Q0�_j��Ça�!������4'�fYK��3�
�H�Ï$�§���ú§%§���¯³§���Â�h�òÁ§�ô�^%ST%}
�$H�mD�_���â�!ã$<�����%34n�r·rST%}�$H+â�
!ã$<F�_F�-�Â%�l+�cä��[�p Kû�4�Or��â�!ã$<�
�%����â�!ã$<%òÁ�r%ST+�c��Â%MdÎó+��[��FKû
�5�
â�!ã$<��K��òÁ§%ST+�®>node@F�>edge@%|X%}�$H�
kW��Â%�l+��[��Ý|d8:/"}6+Ça[��F�3�_�òÁ§%ST
%Î�+�Ý��F�-�7�d8:��â�!ã$<�l+�K�%�®FÂ�+X|�
KöW����d8:/"�����%�®F�F%�l�O�_%���!Kû��â
�!ã$<��¬�_��aw���â�!ã$<+d8:KöW[��F�B(Kû�
��â�!ã$<�K�Kd8:u�R��F����Ç�öW[��F�B(�n��
â�!ã$<�Ó%�lÎó+ö�[Eö�nw���â�!ã$<%¸�����
>density@�û��r.��®%MdÎó+ö�[w����Û+ó>centrality@�<�
$<>clique@�û�8�
����®%ST�m�°��y�Kû�^+�[w�Kû��â�!ã$<�5r�
_���®%§%ST%��3�_¯r���®�r%ST��rnâ�!ã$<���
�õ°��®�r+X|��ån�â�!ã$<%���I����%õ�â�!ã$<
K���®F�®%±þó�õ°n����%I�â�!ã$<K���®%ó��&'
ó�û��F+�[�
Û+ó��Â�h�%�®�â�!ã$<%ÛKm%I�Û+�Kû�%^�m%I�
ZnmDn%^+�.¡%w�Kû��Û+ó+s[�p��¸�°��_��
®%�O�%���®§%����®%�O�áó�û��
�®�Ry�qrOn��+��_��¶��qrXwF3¿��2O%�®�y��X
kO�_��aw�Â%�®� r�_��F�4�Â%F�� r�_���%�%w
2 CDì2001bï+202C @�
3 �Eì2003ï+273-288C @�
4 CDì1997ï+2C @�
5 CDì2001aï+35C @�
6 Wilson, R. J.ì1972ïFG�÷)µ¶�_%�
7 CDì2001bï+203-204C @�
8 CDì2001aï+35-121C @ B���
����
<+�Â%�®% r�F3|�r.�qr� r�û��qrXw%STKRy�X¿
�_���®%<=+<�$<F3|�Or���_%�®%¯kw�2K��l��_
��d=$ð%�FKû��N ��ðz´K¡Æ[��®%<w+<�$<F�.�%
� N-<�$<F3¿���
�� �9:!%&'()*��
ÕÖä�$��äHdÁ%â�!ã$<��%���Ì�.��eìâ�!ã$<��
%�¢ S. Wasserman9%£ÃKû� D. Iacobucci�å$ �ï �H¸Ý�¤+Ê.�F
�3���$��äHd�!%â�!ã$<����½�.10��%�!�j��ÓÔ�K
P¥�ÓÔ�n¼½��â�!ã$<��%�$��äHdÁ%&p�Á%¼a+"È.
Network in Marketing>Iacobucci,D ed. ,1996@Kû��
ü�K����$æçHæ�ðä�$��äHd�j�_�â�!ã$<���+.[
ø×�¸�°n��F�Ü=���rZâ�!ã$<����®+q�_��Fwz��
_����â�!ã$<+���YZ��� r�_��11�
��rK%ÕÖò-â=�j����ST%��K��÷��9CI%����-��
�®+Ð_.���¸®+¦¡��CV%_g«�gST%Å�K��UV7_g)*F
Â%��P%ÛK����ª%&���P�`s�í$�+v<�.��4�.p ��
_g)*F��P%Ry%��zm��õ°�BC��¦s�_��F�467%�FK
�õ��´J+B[���^���Å�K�´�^�n�.34���$ðHu��pu
K EDI�3���P$%%:�LæK��ä�������P+�h��F�:;n¶·
K���9CIST%í$�Z�K�º �F��·�+Ên��
�'����$æçHæ�ðä�$��äHdK���PZ�Kn°&°%h�STê
��!+�h.�%%����û.�_��g�% 2 êST��-�_�r�_��®K
��¨%ÕÖò-â=��%êÚFÎÖ[�`þ+ �_���
� ����§ô%ÕÖ%�]�]+]��¿�*Ò�*�+,-_ÕÖ:;12��0�_�
����rK��)*¢M%¥��¼Z�Kn°�q�ÕÖò-â=�j��½¨|©%
ÔÙó13�ªq��_�.���%�q�nST%�Ó�¼�`þ�Ú��.�F+�?�
_���*�´}~^�*�´|É�*�§|ÉÁFo°�n���j��3�%ÔÙ�
4'%ÔÙ�æ¸Î$(+�3�o°�nÕÖíî��n��_��F�-���%34
nÕÖ%��+��%�I�v¡����*Ò®*�%§�Ry�/0�û��F�Ü=
���.¡�¢�û�*Ò+CXF�.Å�ä��K�º �Kû©4�
9 jklHI +Wasserman, S.ì1994ï�÷�^5�
10 �Eì2003ï+284C @�
11 J9Aì2002ï)µ¶�
12 <n(K�L+2009M 1N 5<OPQ�
13 RSì1994ï+123-128C @�
����
z¨%Ö����rK%ÕÖ���j��òÁ�-�n`þ�Â�_§ô%ÕÖ%��
�o°»�K�êQ�n�_�.�F+�r-�F�ÕÖ��Á%â�!ã$<��%¼
a�M«F�-��
v��ÕÖÁâ�!ã$<��+¼Ç�_�°�û.�_�¬!®���y+c���
��%Øù��F�_�â�!ã$<���3�_�g�)*��9CISTÁ%�®
u%`þ+(MK��ùpK�â�!ã$<%�þ%8Ú>boundary problem@14�O�
_��[��F��ò�n��3�_���CX+û�r��[��Fn°�m%34�
��CX%â�!ã$<+|���%^+®���-n��¿n�n��
Ø���d8:%�®j3k�%Md���O�_Kû��ÕÖä�$��äHd%â
�!ã$<��K���®��)*䯳�´���Md������F�&�ùpK�
�%Md���º´Kû�.����3�_�n�.STó®!Z�����_�.�
[��F�&^�.�Â%.¡�ùO%d8:>â�!ã$<¹@%Û��'Un!Z%
��mD�_�r4�d8:"+#$ F[�â�!ã$<��K����ô�^% ù
�.!Z+�¾[��F�q¡����
Î��ÕÖ"�j�_����9GÕ+Md����F�B(�n�F�-��9GÕ
+.-�¿�OÕ�6Õ�Ö�Õ�TA����FK���9GÕ�TA���F�-
�.¡�§r��Ï%ÕÖ:e$�.-���%Kû��ÕÖÁ%â�!ã$<��%¼
a����^n�ÕÖ9G��òn%^�O�_�±:u�q¡����
CV%Å�X+�j�_�íÎ�=9G>9GÖeâ�!ã$<@��òó+ä[ÛK
��íÎ�=9GFC¸ed9G>ú�â�!ã$<@�¢[n!�$Iä�:ST��
n�_�n^�.��%yÒ^���ÕÖ�S[�9G+�°.-�íÎ�=«C¸ed�
HI9«�t9���«ª��:e$« !�<nm%v-+�¯�_±:u[��F�
MòKû©4�
¨�%��+ÖÈ_�â�!ã$<%�lu+Ç4�F�K��¿�â�!ã$<�l
Îó�MdÎó+�[w��:;�Ê��F�K���Â��%w��3�_�)*´%
¥°§%ST�S�_Kû�¿�¥°§£x�m%I� �$��{��_��^��P
Ã�®�*{Ã�F��.A+�¾-�/0�Â�_hi�-��í=u[��FhaK
��Z©4��r.�ÕÖâ�!ã$<¯³STÁ%ÇaKû�¿���/0J�û�)
*���Û+�Md[�)*�Ï%)*F%Ry%On�����R�)*�Ï%)*F
%On���þ_�_Ï%}$!¸$Fd�x-��F%K��)*+�[�F�K��
15�
CVK"È.|ÕÖ{�%K�{SS¾ó}%ÙÚ+ªq��|{��S¾op}+´�
^��_�°.¡���â�!ã$<��%ÕÖ��Á%Ça�q¡����w�2_�
14 CDì1997ï+67-68C @�
15 Iacobucci, D.ìedï(2001)+FG 258-259C @�
����
ô+��_ÕÖíîF[�%^+�J��Â%ÕÖâ�!ã$<%íîó+õ[�.¡
���|ÕÖ{�}+»F�.ô�^%A+Ì��q¡���Z©4�ÕÖä�$��äH
d"K��â�!ã$<���rZî���%Z���%�!%&°%BC�êÚ�C�
_��rK�n�´±n²-��^�16�K��³�n���ÕÖâ�!ã$<�³©�/
>ì�ã��@���´^����F�C+����
;<=>
��%&>2008@¾9GuE%ÕÖ{�"À�þÃÄ�
�´µ>2003@¾eìâ�!ã$<��%¶eì�STÖ�"�©�_À·¸ÃÄ�
¹Þ<áä 2ºä��»¼;¾â�!ã$<ä�$��äHd"«KÎâ �í=^�
eì�í=ÁÀBÈÉ�
¦ë½>1997@¾â�!ã$<��� ô�Ǿ+¯s[�%^Àî¿e�
¦ë½>2001a@¾Ò�â�!ã$<��� ST+Í°/"FD Àî¿e�
¦ë½>2001b@|�â$Î-$%â�!ã$<��}>ëôÀÁäÂûqÃ>2001@¾¯³
Å�Ä9IG�<ÀBÈÉ�201-211.$Î�@
Å�ÆÇ>1994@¾�HKãîH ä !Cäæ ��%íîóÀü�ÔÙî3e�
Gummesson, E.>2002@, Total Relationship Marketing 2nd ed.,Butterworth Heinemann.
>ÂûÅWä�ëÆ äÇ:Èä���Ã>2007@¾��$æçHæ�ðä�$��äH
d� KÎâ %Q=+Ì-� 30%STóÀÛÜÔÙe�@
Iacobucci, D.>ed@(2001) , Kellog on Marketing, New York City: John Wiley and Sons.
>ÉìºÊaö>2001@¾�$��äHd�~"�å$ �ï �H¸Ý¸Ý5�e�dä
<$=À�9ñ�HIe�
Iacobucci, D.>ed@>1996@ , Networks in Marketing. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
Publication.
Wasserman, S. & Faust, K.>1994@,Social Network Analysis :Methods and Applications,
Cambridge University Press.
Wilson, R. J.>1996@, Introduction to Graph Theory 4th
ed., Pearson Education Limited.
England. >ËSÌÁäËSÍÃö>2001@¾d8:/"�°� �VØ 4$ÀÚE0Ýe�@
16 Iacobucci, D.ìedï(2001)+FG 259C @�
����
����
�����sU�D��6�������0@��+,���
´ Ý5¸Ý� _!Îò
�
�� ������������������������ !�"#$%&'() *$+,#-��./�012
3456789:;�<=1�>?@AB4C�DEF�GHIJK�LMN�OPQR@ST�
UV@MW�XYN�Z[�\]��)
�����^��_R�`a0����� ��bcdB4ef����gh��ij�k
l�gh���*$+,#) &') ,m#-�nPop���qr�s�tu��vFw�xyz{|}~�67�k
l�������Pbc����=s��r2bcdB4ef���s��=p�����*$+,#)
&') #���$'(#-�tu���P��rw�Or����N2���bcdB4ef�=s���0�
�P�N1P�������p�s�O� P�����P��^��nPop�GH��s���
� P^�� 0�)
����QR@���B4ef{3456789��P����� ¡¢l�r�B4ef{£
}¤8z{¥¦y§�¨©ª«) ¨#"*&�#!© ¬&'$'%) ª (&�-�®N1=�¯$"( ) $'°) ª,m���±²²³-�o´1
Lµqr2 ¨©ª ��¶·sB4efsP¸G¹�º»��¼½PB4ef{3456789��
��¾¿À�¶·�B4ef�ÁÂ1������������=s�����s�^��ÃÄ�
r��r������ÅÆÇN2���bcdB4ef�ÈÉÊN1����ËÌN���N1
��p9yÍ{£}¤8z{¥¦y§�Î °m!© ¬&'$'%)ª (&�-�ÏÐqr�Or�¾¿´2Ñ¥Òf�GH
�ÓÔÏÕ�N1�F�r����Ö×N1=�)
B4ef{3456789PØÙ��PÚÛ�=sN<<�¨©ª �®N¿���ÜrÜr�=
s�����¿Ü�gh��������P��^�P¿s ��qr�s�GH��IJK
�Ý�p�s��PÞ@¿ßTÖà�O��0��� ��áP â <Pãäáå�O´2
GHIJK�LM���¿Ü���æ�çèLéêPëìíì=�î4ïsðf6ñs���ò�ó
ôÊõöf÷3øÍPíì=�¶¦~4ùÊsëìÊs��ON1�ú���P��íì= 0�)
û�PßTÖà�N2�´1�ûüP���Ùp)
)
ýþ B4ef{£}¤8z{¥¦y§�9yÍ{£}¤8z{¥¦y§�ÏÐN¿��������<=1PR
/��Q��)
±þ ����Pî÷48�^��GHIJK�LMN�>?@¿54ff÷�7��EF1�OP
ãäáå�<=1XY��)
âþ �����=pU�@ST�^N1�3456789�� �nPop¿��ST�0À�nP
op¿��� Ô�s�Z[PST�\]��)
)
����
�¿�X��)
ä�Lusch, Robert F. and Stephen L.Vargo,eds.(2006), The Service-Dominant Logic of Marketing:
Dialog, Debate, and Directions, M.E.Sharpe.
ä����±²² -������^���<P�ß��A~4ð�8��������A�4ð�8ð
yÑ���MW��s����3456789{¦�4¤ù�ý²�������3456789�
��±²² � ý )
)
����
��������v ¡.W¢'£¤¥�xy1
NÙϸÝ� ËÐÑá
�
� ÚD�9H�$â�!>z{�â�!@�j��èéê]��ÃO��`a�¾AB+
�_�.�ÔÙU*Ò�3�F 2007D%`a3�� 5.3ÓÔ�#D� 21.7ÕäKû��
ù;9!%��Ö+��F��$=:K�×Ø`a�W 5400 ÙÔ�¢ÓK�C�ÚHÎ
-}H�W 2200ÙÔ(�s) Kû�×Ø`a�LÛKû��C�ÚHÎ-}H�j�_��
deZ�Kn°&°%_gO�����$=:�Ú��_�_���Â%��ÁÜì�W
660ÙÔ�ã�«H�W 480ÙÔF¸3�_gO� 1ÝI��KX°��â�!`a�
j�_��Ã�$=:%7Þ-6�LMFn�_�_���
� �4�.â�!`a�j��7Þ-6��ùÓm%34nÎ��û�%Z©4^�Â�
_) �>�C=@`a%7Þ-6¤¥�Ìß+2r��%n%Kû©4^��GN%8
Ú!6�����%®Kû���GNK��à�[2000]+Û+�) �n7Þ-6¤¥%
PÇ��>Alderson[1957]a@û���â�!`a�j��7Þ-6�ST[�PÇ��
>Anderson [2000], Evans & Wurster [2000], á[2006]a@+E�.¨K�Eö�n�
í=F�_×Ø`a�j��7Þ-6%9å#$æçH+@��n�®KÅ�+Ç��â
�!`a�j��7Þ-6¤¥%��+Äk��z{�Â%¤ò+�´[��
� à��|g <Û%�/}+¤¥%°F�.¨K�g�_gO%7Þ-6+=s�_�
.PÇ���C�_�<��#=F�_%_gO7Þ-6¤¥+���.�|�Ò%g +
<Û�2��F�3�_��âX%��ó�õr���ÓF�_%ÕÖéa��WK��
F[�g <Û%�/��ã§���*Ò���ùs%�a4'%ÛK%k¶��Â%�
a4'+,-�Fg %<Û�^-�_�(cFn�}(à�[2000])�èéê%mnää
�� !%.¡7Þ-6%6/�ã§%ª¸��vW�Tr���ùpâ�!ã§�j�
_�mn� !�g�S�3�O79G��n�nmåe��n�>�â�!ã§�ª¸
[��O�ä��_�°>Whinston et al. [1997]@�
� ×Ø`a�j�_����C�<P+]w�_�Ò%O7®�%ªæ�Ç��.�Â�
+����.%�&'n*Ò%_gO����®[�æ ��+1Q�.^�Kû��Â
%��×Ø`a´�j�_&'nO7+mn�®[�34���nä§$!æ ��®g
�_gO%O79GF%|É%mï�Ç���7Þ-6%â�!ã$<�Ru��.�
� yb%��+ÖÈ_%X"F�_��â�!`a�j��7Þ-6�j�_�ùs�a
4'´K%g <Û%�/�¼Ç���F�4�FKû��Z�Â%4'��) �`a
�j�_�6/�ã§%vW^�M«��TÈ_�.��â�!`a�j�_�â�!ã
§%vW^�!¹��O°��.F�4®��n��
1 µ�.T ]��+ú<�L�)µ¶�_%�
����
5;�� ���¦�E�FGH�/v ¡.
�������§�6¨�GH©�ª9JK*
Ëþ¸Ý� S�ë�á
�� �������
�������$æçHæ�ðä�$��äHd�â�!ã$<ä}$ .<�äG+
êa[�.¡%u¯kF�_�|²¡�r�.£xST%��:�$�ã$<}+��[�
�%Kû���%:�$�ã$<��|²¡�r�.£xST}F�4�®+����9
CIST>2ê§ST@+F�r°â�!ã$<�ÐÑST�C�_m%34n/0+¾-
4�^+±:���[�%Kû��&'�mD[�â�!ã$<%/0+!6�OO��
�$æçHæ�ðä�$��äHd�O�_��[��F+:;�[��%Kû��
���������$æçHæ�ðä�$��äHd�â�!ã$<�STó�²¡�k
1. ����������� ������������������ �����
�Ú%�$��äHd��+k�.[F���CX+â�!ã$<F�_F�-��$
�ä-_�.>c.f. Houston et al. 2004; Van den Bulte and Wuyts 2007@�S�ëä�ç
>2008@���%34n�®+|â�!ã$<ä}$ .<�äG}FÙè�.4-K�
Â%��+��CXFn�6y%Xw�l�Or�|m%34n^.�KXkO�_��
^}�è][��FFwz�_���
|â�!ã$<ä}$ .<�äG}Á%$]����$æçHæ�ðä�$��äH
d{ë�j�_�b�Kn��ÐÑ{ë�j��Vèn��ê��â�!ã$<�S++
]��34�n��O�>e.g. Håkansson and Snehota 1995; Håkansson and Johanson
2001@���$æçHæ�ðä�$��äHd{ë�j�_���9CI>2ê§@+,-
.ST�!6����F�&°n�_�.�
�^�n����$æçHæ�ðä�$��äHd�.>���ê����K¸�n8
Ú�q�[��F�n��â�!ã$<ä}$ .<�äG%.¡%%Ó�n��p F
�_WD÷ÕFn�OOû�%�â�!ã$<��>eìâ�!ã$<��@Kû���
���r·rn¤¥�S �w�^�A�N�_����^�Â����>���|â�!
ã$<%¶�}®|â�!ã$<%Û%Ǿê%¶�}+F�-��%Kû�����C
�_��$æçHæ�ðä�$��äHd%S+�|��$æçHæ�ð%¶�}®|�
�$æçHæ�ð%Û%Ǿê%¶�}%���û���%.¡��$æçHæ�ðä�
$��äHd�j�_�â�!ã$<��+m4êa�.�3�%^F�4��¸n8Ú
�QT[��
����
A) � ��������
�%8Ú�C[�ͯé%oO��|²¡�r�.£xST}F�4�-p%êaKû��
����û�g�SF �S%£xST>�9Cíä�<n£xST@%ó��Â��j
��Ðyê%Ç��û���ST��.�[A+F��.�%��Â%ST+��аÏ
%�ST%¯kw�2>â�!ã$<@�m4¯k�r�_��^^�/0+p��F�
4�-pKû��
�%�-p+êa[��F�3�_�â�!ã$<Â%�%K�n°�â�!ã$<�
£xST�fg[(+�O�_�"�01K��34�n��Â%X+���$æçHæ
�ð�S[��"%Û��â�!ã$<�S[��"+���©�F���Fn��
�%�F+������.%�¹ 1 Kû��Â�K��ë£xST%¶�®�Â�+�
A[�Ðyê�%¶���ìST+��аâ�!ã$<Á²¡�r�_���F^��
ím%34n(++p��^�������Â�_�ìâ�!ã$<Á²¡�r�_��
¶�+%Ó���c[�.¡��îâ�!ã$<��Ka����'Un¤¥�S �w
��a�����
nj�û�£xST�&'%â�!ã$<�²¡�r��F�4�F����rK%�
�$æçHæ�ðï�$��äHd��K��F�j�E6��_�.�>e.g. Möller and
Halinen 2000, p.42@�¹ 1%34�â�!ã$<��+��$æçHæ�ð%���êa
[�F�4]����n���Â%��¹�n/����F�n^�.�
��� ������ ���������
������
�����
��� ���
��������
����
����
�� ��!
�����
��
�������"#!
$%&'()'
*+,'-�.�
�����
/0123
����
�45
����
B) � �����������������
|²¡�r�.£xST}F�4�®��F���|²¡�k%(+}>¹ 1ðí@+Ò5
���[�.¡�øNO%�|²¡�r�.£xST%��:�$�ã$<}>ö 1j3k
¹ 2@Kû���%:�$�ã$<��2ê§Kñ��h���Ry�a�C��Â�+�
�'©â�!ã$<�fg�4�/0+±:��n/�.�%Kû���.��_Â���
��$æçHæ�ðä�$��äHd��â�!ã$<ä}$ .<�äG+�����
.¡%��u¯kFn�¿^�^�3�ù �n!ZK��9Cíä�<n£xê��C
[�â�!ã$<%/0�O�_��[�5��øNO�%Kû��
����
��� ������� ����� !"��
���� ������� ������
��� ��� ���
���������
��������� �
�������������
��� �� ! ! !
"#$%�� ! ! !
&'�� ! ! !
()�*+��
������� !���
�������
,-./�� ! !
01�� ! !
()�23�� ! !
�� ��4��
"#��������$%
&'(����������
567�8�� ! !
9:;<�� ! !
.� �� ! !
=>?��
)*�+,-.&'(�
���������
*&�� !
@A�� !
BC�� !
DEF��
/0123456��7
89��:;���
DEF�� ! ! !
�G���� �H����IJKLMN+
�O��PQRST*UJVWXYM�� �H����IJKLMN+
�Z[�PQRST*UJVWXYM�� �H����IJKLMN+
�� ��
����
�#� ������� ����� !"�� $%&'()*�
���
��
���
��
X Y
����
������
����
� ��
������
����
����
����
�������
������
� !��
����
����
����
�������
������
� !�� ������
����
� ��
|²¡�r�.£xST%��:�$�ã$<}� Granovetter�3�_�����Uzzi
�3�_01��.�²¡�k�S[���+�2ê§ST�¼a[��F�3�_A�N
�_���Â�Kv�K����%��+¤���X�_Ø 3 ��_��%:�$�ã$
<%A�N��O�_�´+[��
����
2. �������1
A) Granovetter�� !"
²¡�k>embeddness@F�4�-p��|j�òÖ%J}>j�òÖ%×�@+���
�. Granovetter�3�_�â�!ã$<��%Û�����.���|¾²¡�kÀF��
ÔÙ�nǾj3kA+��[�_%eì�nǾ®A+F�'��Ǿê�r%�9C
íä�<n>Or�CF�_%@STF�NK�%PST^��A���ËÓ�â�!ã$
<%�l^�/0+p��F�4y�O�_�f[��%}>Granovetter 1992, p.33@
F�´�_���
²¡�k��|ST�²¡�k}>relational embeddedness@F|�l�²¡�k}
>structural embeddedness@F�4{M¤¥KF�-����ST�²¡�k%v-K��
Ǿê§%XkO�>qrXw@�è]��Â%XkO�%R�®��O�_����_
�°����C�_�l�²¡�k%v-K��K�%òÖ^��A���â�!ã$<
�è]��Â%�l®�Â�j��Ǿê%Md�O�_����_�°�Or�ST�
²¡�k%v-K��²¡�k%¶�+òÖ%R�^�F�-�%�C�_��l�²¡
�k%v-K��²¡�k%¶�+â�!ã$<%��^�F�-���Kû�
>Granovetter 1992, p.34-7; Gulati 1998, p.296@�
�.��_²¡�kF�4¤¥��â�!ã$<+�A[�Ǿê§�R�XkO��
mD[��F>â�!ã$<+�A[�òÖ%R���Ó��R��F@F�â�!ã$
<´�mD[�Ǿê�r%§�qrXw�&��F>â�!ã$<%���õ��F@
+!Z�_���
B) Uzzi�� #$
Granovetter�3�_����.²¡�kF�4�-p+�Â%��̧ �°01�.%�
Uzzi>1996; 1997@Kû���%����²¡�k��%ÓpF�_õ°õ��_j��
Â�K���.9���Â%�%²¡�k��%�Fn�_���r.�%����²
¡�k:â�!ã$<%ó�®/0�O�_��¬��ó���f�_��®K�Î��
Kû��
���ãÏ$�$<`%C}�=U* >ôó]�õõI� )*@ +CX�:ä$=
Iã$<F;$#9+Ç��²¡�r�.òÖ%Î��²¡�k:â�!ã$<%Îó�
²¡�k�öT[�ðe« �²¡�k%}8I< nm�O�_´�^��.�
r>��:ä$=Iã$<�3�_�²¡�r�.òÖ%Î�F{�+´�^��.�
Â��3�F�*ê§%â�!ã$<%Û�²¡�r�.��ST��e÷>trust@��¡
%L�9G%)Æ>fine-grained information transfer@�Î��n8Úͯ%��¯¡>joint
1 U�VÓ ]��WX)Y�5 +Z[ì2003; 2006ï �5\1=õ?] �µ� �5�
����
problem-solving arrangement@F�4Î�+±�_j�����%Î���>��Â%�
�ST�j�_�òn{�++.�_�.>Uzzi 1996 p.678-9; 1997, p.41-8@�
Uzzi ������%34nÎ�+ �.òÖ�õ���Xw[��FK�Â%â�!ã
$<�Ó��§%ÔÙóF��%(có>economics of time and allocative efficiency@�
mnF w�nw!>search and integrative agreements@�� <+ø�ù����Ö
>risk taking and investment@�K�n¼ÇF}�$!mï>complex adaptation and
Pareto improvements@F�4 4 O%(+�T��F+���_��>Uzzi 1997,
p.48-57@�
�^����â�!ã$<����²¡�r���F�3�_�|²¡�k%}8I< }
�TÈ��F�wz�_���²¡�k%}8I< F��²¡�k��k[�.aw�
���â�!ã$<^�Û°�n)*�¹��_�r4F���O�.)*�R�úS+
û��(��â�!ã$<��q��w/u��¡���F�²¡�r���F�3�_
}~LM+Ê_�.)*��Â�^�Ê_�.#â:ä�!+³�_�r4��ó�û��
*-a â�!ã$<´�üî�®îýó�þ©9G�ån°n���B�n9G¿^��n
�.��*-b >é8®ç9�3�_â�!ã$<�j�)*�C[�|�Ù¯³u}[�
�FK�(+�nÔÙê���h��.��*-c F����k®��F��.�%89�
õr�d�n;9<=Á��F��.��r·rn©ó%/0�Tr�_°�F�
4�%Kû�>Uzzi 1997, p.57-9@�
3. ����� ���������������������
A) � �%&'(����)*+,-
¹ 3����rK%�"+n/��Â�%��+�-.�%Kû��
²¡�k:â�!ã$<�k��� 4O%(++$![°��[�F�Â%�>����
��^OstnÖ×ÕÖ®�Ǿê§�j���ê�%|ÉF��.WXF�hi+y�
�ä¸�2�.¡�µJ[��Û�mD�_���[�F�²¡�k:â�!ã$<��
|Ö×ÕÖFê�|É}j3k|hi�]%µJ�Û}F�4��ó��û�F�-�
���
�����ó�%4��#ê�R�òÖ�õ���Xw[��FK��Fn�{��
n��F�-��r.��ê�R�òÖ�õ���Xw[��FTÈ����n��F�
4�F�K���[n��R�òÖ�õ���Xw[��FK�Ö×+ÕÖ�2.��ê
�+|É[��F�:;�n�FF���y��hi+ä¸�2�.¡�µJ�û4�Û
�Tr��F�4��Kû��
nj�����ó�%4����^OstnÖ×ÕÖ��F���9G�Ö×�j�
_UVZF�-����n7n�9G�Ö×��e�Kû�.¡�6/�ä�éa�QT
�n�.¡F�K6�:;F�4ó�+ O.¡Kû�>!} 1974, p.21-4@�
����
r. Rowley, Behrens, and Krackhardt>2000, p.372@+���[�F�hi�]%µ
J�Û��"�®�>benevolence@��°�%F�43���â�!ã$<+�A[�
Ǿê��ÎÖ[�hi�û���â�!ã$<�Ó%hi+ªq�34F[��Û�
�°�%F�-����
��rK²¡�k:â�!ã$<%�ó�+Û+��"+Ç�_�.����C�_
���%]����9Cíä�<n£xST�C��Â�+��'©â�!ã$<�fg
�4�/0+±:��n/�.�|²¡�r�.£xST%��:�$�ã$<}%���
û���.��_¨c�.34n��ó�+ Oâ�!ã$<%ù¥�²¡�r�.�
F��û�£xST%¶�®�Â�+�A[�Ðyê�%¶���m%34n(++fg
�4�^+±:��n/[��F����%�®Fn�>¹ 3@�
�+� ���,-.�/012-.�34�
�����
���� ��
� �� ����
�� ���
� ��������
� � �!"#$
%&�'(
� )*+,-�
./�01
2
34�����
56� 789
����!:;<=>
?@�A7B6CDEFGH<=I
� JK
� E� LBMN OP
� QR�+STUV WXV�
:Y�����
56� Z89
����[AGH<=
>?@R\ �A]^6�F_BI
����
��
34 `a
bc@d `a
����
5����9
ef34
5g@�349
hijk lmn
������ o��pq
� (rst�uvwx
5yz�{|9
� }~�� ����
5a8�{|9
�����
���� �i���
B) '(�����./0
�^�n���²¡�k(+%±:�n/%.¡����rK%�"+Â%rr¼a[
�%��®®j �Kû��n7n� Uzzi>1996; 1997@�3�����C}�=U*F
�4�ù%â�!ã$<�µ;[�Ǿê�+��CXF�.�%Kû�%�C�_��
$��äHd{ëK��g�SF �SF�4Ǿê���M>���ù%â�!ã$<
�µ;�_��F�-n�.¡Kû��
.F-¿�g�SF �S��n�U*®*þ�µ;�_�.��û����ÈU*®
*þK��n����µ;�_���F�û��r.&°%�$��äHd£x��>6l
*êFèéên���_g*êFèéê%34�@ÕÖæ ���j�_�n����µ
;[�g�SF �S%§K01��_��������>���g�SF �S��n
�â�!ã$<�µ;[���ó+�?�_���
Â�Kg�SF �S+��'©â�!ã$<%��¶·�O�_��[�F�r>g
����
�SF �S���ù%â�!ã$<�µ;�_��awF��n�â�!ã$<�µ;
�_��aw��-����r.g�SF �S��n�â�!ã$<�µ;�_��a
w���n�â�!ã$<�¢ù%£xSTKX¿�_��awF�K�%£xSTKX
¿�_��aw��-����[�Fâ�!ã$<%��¶·��¹ 4 ���.34��
��ù%£xST�²¡�r�_��aw�(¢ù%£xSTKX¿�.��n�â�!
ã$<�²¡�r�_��aw�*K�%£xSTKX¿�.��n�â�!ã$<�²
¡�r�_��aw�±:uK���nj(�ÐÑST�G��ÎFn�_��®KÎ�
�Kû��G��ÎF�|â�!ã$<´% 2 ®+On��ù%Ô�Fn�34n¿}
>Granovetter 1973, �ö p.128@%�FKû��
z{K��Â�h�%��¶·+×s�n���ö 1 j3k¹ 2 ���.�²¡�k%
(++���_�°�.Z��%5�£xST+¢n�Ö×ä�Ô�K�n°�Ry�a
>e.g. ��®µ¶@%aFMd��.4-K��%Ry�a�²¡�k:â�!ã$<�
fg�4�(+�è]�_�°�
�5�������678�
��������� �����������������
�� �!"#�$%&'(
)*��������������
+,-������ �����������������
C) '(����� ��� 123456 78
�È¡����+×s�.4-K�â�!ã$<�²¡�r���F^�TÈ�(+�
O�_n/[��Ö×ÕÖFê�|ÉF�4�²¡�k:â�!ã$<%��ó�+#
�F[�F�MòF[�Ö×+��^Ost��SK��FF���d�%õ��&'%
Ǿê�)��®[°n��r.&'%Ǿê��hi�]%µÅ�Û+F�_���F
^��â�!ã$<%hi��[�34n���Ǿ�C�_��®vÅ�)�°n��
Ö×æÒ(+ ......MòF[�Ö×+��^Ost��SK��%K�ÐÑST�����
�Ö×+3�æÒ�2��F�K���
õ��/(+ ......Ïê%]+ö��.����+[�34�n��[n���d�%õ�
%�/+Äk�34�n��
��(+ .............â�!ã$<�Ó^������vÅ�����ó�û�.¡�&'%
Ǿê^���+4���
����
D) 9:+;<=>?@ 123456 78
��X����+×s[��Ðyê���ùâ�!ã$<�²¡�r�_��aw��
�%§���Ï%Ǿê��3�_�á���^.�K§r�Xw�mD[�F�-��
��[�F²¡�k:â�!ã$<%��ó�^���n�Ô�K���^OstnÖ
×ÕÖ�TÈ�FÎ��Â%Ô��mD[�Ø 3 ê^�ô�^%/0+p����ó�T
��
f9} (+ ......RS�ÐÑST����_�n�Ö×+�§r�Ô�^�iÊK���
�ó�û��
á�(+ .............cp%ÐyêFST�û�§r�Ô�¨%Ǿê^��çý�n���
�C�ná�+p����ó�û��
§r�ÇG(+...û�ST�j��d�%������RSFµÅST�û�Ï%Ǿê
�)���Â%Ǿê^�§r��ÇG+p���F�û��
E) AB '(����CDEFG 123456 78
X�_��(+×s[��ÐÑST+�A[�Ǿê���n�â�!ã$<�µ;�
_��aw�y��ÎBnÖ×®ê�+��� O��ó�û��nj^O²¡�k:â
�!ã$<� O 2O%��ó�^��Â��%/0+R°p�®[°n���%X+�
§r�Xw^�TÈ�(+%E����3O%(+�î.�QT[��
��ºù�(+...Ö×®ê�%Ø�^���n���h��34+��� O�F�
n��Ðyê§��r·rn��®|O^�w��Tr���
Hfß�(+ ......µ;[�â�!ã$<^��S�.�y��ÎB�nÖ×+�Â�h�
� ���ÐÑST���[��FK�Ðyê§%Hfó+õ¡����
}ã$(+ ..........d�%â�!ã$<^�Ê.ÎB%Ö×+�ÐÑST���2>�l-
��FK�ST�j��d�%RC�LMó+õ¡��F�K���
F) �H(IJKLEFG 123456 78
��X���(+×s[����$æçHæ�ð%Ðyê���Ö×ÕÖ�þk�Ry
µJ�Û%R�â�!ã$<%ÛKG��Î+�A�_��.¡���ånÖ×%ÕÖ+
i¦K��Na�û�FF���d��µ;[�â�!ã$<%EöF�_%ø×+´�
_����%X+��°O^%(+�TÈ��
X�(+ .............�ånÖ×%ÕÖ+i¦K��Na�û�.¡�Ðyê�rKX�+A
¡��F�3�_�3�&°%hi+iÊK���
Eö(+ .............&'^�%��®vÅ+!6�.aw�d��µ;[�â�!ã$<%
����
EöF�_�Â%â�!ã$<%hi+�¸u[�34Ç�2·�+-
n��F�û��
¢�(+ .............RS�â�!ã$<%EöF�_�d�%!���[��FK�p��
�·�+-n��F+ S�F��¢��nÇ�+F��F�K���
G) MN�����O;P��AB '(����Q<
��*+×s�.����¢Kû���%aw�Â�h�%Ðyê�%&'�â�!ã
$<�mD�_j��r.§r�Xw�mD��nj^Oµ;[�â�!ã$<��n�
_����.��_���rK�´�_�.(+%4��G��Î+�A�_���F^
�TÈ��%+A�.�9O[�_�û_�r��F�n��
H) �����RSO56�TU34VW 78
���|²¡�k%}8I< }�O�_����_k��r>|²¡�k%}8I<
}F�_���.WX��>���â�!ã$<¨�mD[��%%ÐÑST%�¥�
mD[�Ǿê®�Â%Ǿê�%XkO��j�_�>ÐÑST%@Ðyê.�%!¹®
!"F�eST�TÈ.y!��â�!ã$<�Ó�fg[�%(+F�-��
�.��_|²¡�k%}8I< }�ÐÑST^��.aw��¥ó�[n��|û
�ú%!"¯s��Â%!"¯s�^^��_��n�ú^�/0+¾-��F}>Coase
1988, �ö p.26@�3�_TÈ�(+F�4�F�K���
.Z��%�¥ó(+���âÄ�äGn�%¿^�Kn°�Î�äGn�%�û��
.F-¿Û°�Fn�Ǿê�î.���[��F�â�!ã$<�l%Ìu�±�Ö×
®{ì�ä�[��F�â�!ã$<�l�©�Kû��F^���Ìu�"®^�n
��Tmc�õr��FnmKû��
�¥ó(+��â�!ã$<%��¶·�^^��>QT�4��
4. � �
���K����$æçHæ�ðä�$��äHd�â�!ã$<ä}$ .<�äG
+�����.¡%��u¯kF�_�|²¡�r�.£xST%��:�$�ã$<}+
���.�Â��²¡�k�S[�lm��^�|²¡�k:â�!ã$<%��ó�}
+�����+�n�â�!ã$<��¶��¼a[��FK6���. 13%%Ó�(+
F�Â��+n/�. 5O%�(+^��A����%Kû�>ö 1j3k¹ 2@�
�%:�$�ã$<��9CIST>2ê§ST@+F�r°â�!ã$<�ÐÑST�
C�_m%34n/0+¾-4�^+±:���[�%Kû��&'�mD[�â�!ã
$<%/0+!6�OO���$æçHæ�ðä�$��äHd�O�_��[��F+
:;�[��%Kû��r.Â���lc%Ö��9Cíä�<n£xê��C[�â�
����
!ã$<%/0�O�_��[�5��øNO�%Kû��
.Z����%(+���>��M«�n�%Kn°³D�n�%Kû��Or���
TÈ�F�4�%K�n°�TÈ���ó�û��%Kû��3�%Ó����¹ 1 ��
�.34��²¡�k%¶��3�_�m%(+�TÈ�m%(+�TÈn�^�Ì��
_°���.��_�%��:�$�ã$<��>â�!ã$<��+êa�.s+ÖÈ
_@²¡�k%¶�+ûü�.4-K�m%34n67{�j�_�m%(+��m%I
�%R�+��_TÈ�^+´�^��_�°^.�Kêa����F�n��
!"#$
Coase, Ronald H. (1988), The Firm, The Market, and The Law. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago
Press. (�op�>?�^�(1992), �ê�_�H�� �H`ab�cd�de G`fg(K�s
h).
Granovetter, Mark (1974), “The Strength of Weak Ties,” American Journal of Sociology, 78, 1360-80.
(���ij�k���� ª"#K��x��ó �-�(2006), lbmn o�pG, qrIs, 123-58).
ttttt (1985), “Economic Action and Social Structure: The Problem of Embeddedness,” American
Journal of Sociology, 91, 481-510. (�Ou Dv (K/w%h±"#ÝU�VÓ�xy��z{Ýx�
�ó �%|w�}����(2006), MKD~��Q H`��Y G, �x��ÏIs, 239-80).
ttttt (1992), “Problems of Explanation in Economic Sociology,” in Network and Organizations:
Structure, Form, and Action, Nitin Nohria and Robert G. Eccles eds. Boston, MA: Harvard
Business School Press, 25-56.
Gulati, Ranjay (1998), “Alliances and Networks,” Strategic Management Journal. 19, 293-317.
Håkansson, Håkan and Ivan Snehota (1995), Developing Relationships in Business Networks,
London: International Thompson Business Press.
ttttt and Jan Johanson (2001), Business Network Learning, Oxford: Pergamon.
Houston, Mark B., Michael Hutt, Christine Moorman, Peter H. Reingen, Aric Rindfleisch, Vanitha
Swaminathan, and Beth Walker (2004), “A Network Perspective on Marketing Strategy
Performance,” in Assessing Marketing Strategy Performance, Christine Moorman and Donald R.
Lehmann, eds. Cambridge, MA: Marketing Science Institute, 247-68.
��D¢������ (2008),�I J!"#K�� �·5x��ó ��P �C�!"¬���QI
J!"#K@w �� 108 (� 27� 4 ), 4-20�
Macneil, Ian R. (1978), “Contracts: Adjustment of Long-Term Economic Relations under Classical,
Neoclassical, and Relational Contract Law,” Northwestern University Law Review, 72 (6),
854-905.
Möller, Kristian and Aino Halinen (2000), “Relationship Marketing Theory: Its Roots and Direction,”
Journal of Marketing Management, 16, 29-54.
l��~� (1974),�rs�(KW-�fg(K�sh�
Rowley, Tim, Dean Behrens, and Dave Krackhardt (2000), “Redundant Governance Structures: An
Analysis of Structural and Relational Embeddedness in the Steel and Semiconductor Industries,”
Strategic Management Journal, 21, 369-86.
Uzzi, Brian (1996), “The Sources and Consequences of Embeddedness for The Economic Performance
of Organizations: The Network Effect,” American Sociological Review, 61, 674-98.
ttttt (1997), “Social Stracture and Competition in Interfirm Networks: The Paradox of
Embeddedness,” Administrative Science Quarterly, 42, 35-67.
Van den Bulte, Christophe, and Stefan Wuyts (2007), Social Networks and Marketing. Cambridge,
MA: Marketing Science Institute.
Z[S� (2003), �h±x��ó �%@Aq��t�Ý�U�VÓ�}Ø� v �5Kh±&l���
�h±&�-�54(2), 159-74.
ttttt (2006), �<nop�x��ó �%t��þ���
����
��������� ����
�������������������� ��
�
¸#`N¸Ý� _û� %�
�
� ÚD�¥ëÔÙêóué%¦FOF�_�Õh¯³K$��.�~�G8HI�/S
+%a�.¥ëG8HI�~�$]��_���ù ��¥ëG8HI�~��¥ë+G
8HI%4'F[�671Qj3k`a01+Äk�|¥ë671Q:G8HI�~}F�
G8HI�~�3�_¥ëdÓ%]¨+]w[|¥ë]¨:G8HI�~}%¸
�° 2 O%�9ð�����F�K�����GNK��ê%¥ë]¨:G8HI�
~��®+û_��[��
� �%¥ë]¨:G8HI�~��ù ��¥pd Ó®ÐÑ¥ë%ÔÙ=Ónm%
&�{S�¥ëêóu+]��és[�aw�&���d�qr¥ëG8HI�~%ÒÇ
÷ÓFn��F�ån°�¥ëG8HI�~%Ò��nÒÇ÷Ó��ÐÑ¥ë%'§)*
®(µä)µnm%K�%g�÷Ó�´4�F�&��[n���¥ë]¨:G8H
I�~%Î��K�÷Ó�3�Î�ÒÇÓv�û��Â�+{��2����ùg�ÒÇ
÷Ó%d÷���[n��¥ëG8HI�~%és´:+/Í��¥ë]¨F�4Î
Ö%]�%�F�ùg�÷Ó%ÔÕ]�F|��2n��Ç4Mò�û��
� �^�n������n^n^R���F�4%��ùg�÷Ó��¥ëG8HI�~
Â%�%+ÒÇ[�%K�n°�g�÷Ó%Ç�<<�ù�Ìx�_^�ÒÇ��Â��
ÒÇ��.ê�+:�¥ëG8HI�~F�_ w[�F�4�¥ëG8HI�~Fg�
÷Óê�%Ry|S+¹�Mò�û�^�Kû��Â�K��GNK���%Ò%�âÎ
ìH!%PÇ��Kû�Å*(2007,2002)%|�$��äHdäâ�!ã$<%¥ë�í=}
+�+�n��id%�®+�-�¥ëG8HI�~%ùÒÇ÷Ó�Â%és÷ÓFû�
Ò�ÈNaKd,��¥ëG8HI�~+01��Â��%ê�+¥ëG8HI�~F�
_���kn��� }98=�n¥ëG8HI�~%01+¹�:8<�=�l:â�
!ã$<ä�âÎìH!%Baój3kÂ%S �S[�¤¥�í=%�Ú+Äk��
� �GNK�"[�¥ëG8HI�~%�âÎìH!ä�í=��gU%ÒÇê%d,�
ê��¸�°z-�.G8HI�ÚS Kû��&.��.�ê�%ËÓKû��$��
$!äG8HI®ZÁ%�`/Î�Mòn;$K äG8HI%�âÎìH!��¼a
��Kû��F^��¥ëG8HI�~%kn�>�Õh¯³+5©G8HI�~ù �
C�_�Bin�?+�.�[F"����
����
����!"#�����$%&'($)*
Ní¸Ý� 0¨µÃ
oT�ȡ�
1980DE^��$��äHd{ë�Ó�12�.STó%�]��G8HI��®G8
HIä�âÎìH!%{ë�j�_�|G8HI¶èéê}%ST+CXF�.�KmD
[��G8HI�èéê%96´�������%Kû�,-�-��STóF�4òÁ
+´~�_��F��-34��P#$ %G8HIäî<9�ä"+�è�. Keller
>2003@��G8HI96�l��°G8HI�Ú ��ð+ÓÔu�_j��Â%]
w[���3 ��ð�|G8HIF�PF%��$æçHæ�ð�A}+4-_���
�����. 4�²%G8HIäî<9�ää�8â�I�3�F�G8HI�èéê%
|h>E9@}F|+>89@}%dp�Cðe$ò�p�����_�°�FK��3�
���Ú¸H >resonance@F�4R�+/�On��FÂ���°�Î�äGnÇ
���^�����$æçHæ�ð+�Ú[��F�A/�.��,�R�G8HI��
�P^�5è+��_¦s��� ��������P�3��âÏã�ä��A��.
��G8HI%ê�����n��%�Û�����%Kû��
G8HIFèéêF%STó+.-�Eö�n¤¥F�_��1950DE�÷a�ù¸�
$�Fn�.|G8HIäe9ñ=�ä}®�&°%aw��$æçHæ�ðä�â�!
ìH!¤¥%ªlF�_Md�����|G8HIä�â�!ìH!}�û�����¤
¥��>��èéê�3�¦s�n� �¦�_�G8HI�`a´KLMn�ÎæçH
+iÊ�.��eHd«8$Fn�.�[��F+�´[�Û°�nÌ�F�-��F�
��ÚD�j�_��G8HI�C[���F�_%G8HIä�â�!ìH!¤¥�3
°a���_j��G8HIä�â�!ìH!%õI®�9ð�3�_èéê%Ç��m
%34��n�^�S+�]���_��>.F-¿ Chaudhuri 2006; Raju, Unnava,
and Montgomery 2009@��
Â�K���K��&'n!Zw�®�±�����_���¤¥+n/�.¨KÒ5
%í$�+a�_G8HIä�â�!ìH!+s��� Ç�F%ST+m�_��.
��
xTG8HIä�â�!ìH!¤¥
� �F�F|�â�!ìH!}F�4¤¥��eì+/Ý�!%CúST/"%ÛK�´
��_���%K��$��äHd{ë�j�_����a����34�n�.%��
�$æçHæ�ðä�$��äHd%¼6�j�_Kû��CúST%¼6K�|ý!}
�ûr�E¡��>�|5}�E¡���A�%ùOF�_�â�!ìH!��h��_�
����
�>.F-¿�Sternberg 1988, Bë 1990@���K�4�â�!ìH!�RSF%ST
+b �_��.��û���b �n��¿n�n�F�4¯!+w[�
��$æçHæ�ðä�$��äHd��%�!K�eì+/Ý�j���â�!ìH
!��®¯³"�j��¯³�â�!ìH!��%A++%a�_�)*§%STó®)
*FèéêF%STó%�ÚFb +�´�_�.������â�!ìH!�ST%^
X+¯s����ònòÁKû�F�4ÒéX+������±�_��â�!ìH!¤
¥���4'K�3�[°��P���34�n�_�.�
G8HIä�âÎìH!%�!K�G8HIFèéêF%STó+�][����Rr
��F°�|G8HIä��$æçHæ�ð}FH��_���G8HIä��$æçH
æ�ð+�"%CXF�.aw��â�!ìH!���%e9ñ=�䤥+EG[��
û���Hf[�¤¥F�_P����EG¤¥F[�^Hf¤¥F[�^��e9ñ=
�ä+m%34�.-�^�zm�_j��e9ñ=�ä+f��Ç�¨%¤¥>�ùG
8HI%^X�n��� Ç�+w[¤¥@F.-�aw������¤¥Kû��â�
!ìH!�Hf��a�����F�&��ùp���+5YZ¤¥F�_e9ñ=�ä
+.-.aw����â�!ìH!�e9ñ=�ä���_E���F�û�1�
7#>2004@�PÇ��+n/�.¨K�8���®[�e9ñ=�äF�â�!ìH
!%���O�_Ç��¤¥F���¤¥F%Ø��9�[Fc�_���#ê�èéê
%Ç��Îó+.-.¤¥Kû��Pc�.Ö��ùG8HI%^X�n��� +w[�
�ê�Îs%G8HI�]���.9:�n��+/�n5èKû���%G8HIä�
â�!ìH!�mD[�aw��Ç�F�_%G8HIäe9ñ=�ä%mD�Ü=��
���^�� �M>��ÆF��-n�%Kû��
,TG8HIä�â�!ìH!%±:
� �â�!ìH!%�òó�E9����O��Â%´:+ªq[����ä-_���
Or��ST+^X�234F�4Ðyê%���n!">�â�!ìH!@���^n
�×�^�TÈ_°�%^�r.Â%×�%Ø��X+F�_%Ç��m%34n/0+
fg[^�+´�^�[���Kû��
Â%34n��%Õ�%ÛK�vØ��â�!ìH!�ùv-�n¤¥K�n°×�%
Ø�+5YZ&v-�n¤¥Kû��F�wz���34�n�.2�0¨>2003@��
1 =%´� Chaudhuri (2006)+Chudhuri and Holbrook (2001)�Àf�=½ª�%�à�½ª� �
·5����!"'(ì�é����!"%�4l����!"ï)�����#�'(ì�é����
�#�%�4l�����#�ï%�´S���5�Jacoby and Chestnut (1978) �5����!"�
�Tl����+����]�¬D#_ 6B5åæ�éì/�l����!"ï%�4l����!
"�6u��0��������!" �5%�1��5�
2 @A-����+�p �@A 6B5�����#�+]<F@A�����#�)6¡%B5��
�+Allen and Mayer (1990, 1991, 1993) �5¢£¤¥�h¦%����5�§� 3£¤%+�¨
l�����#�+©rl�����#�+8Äl�����#��^5�_�Xª�õ ëö#ë�
����
��$æçHæ�ðä�â�!ìH!�S[�lm��+¤����¤¥�m%34�s
>���s��_��^+rF¡_���Â%X+�ËÊ�s��°v-F5è%3
4n89��°v-%¸�°xO�E��.�#ê�<;��â�!ìH!��ê�
89��â�!ìH!FH����F�&��
Amine>1998@���$æçHæ�ðä�$��äHd�j���â�!ìH!%�"
+����G8HIä�â�!ìH!+<;��â�!ìH!>calculative commitment@
F89��â�!ìH!>affective commitment@��±�_���89��â�!ìH
!�G8HI�C[�5è>attachment@®9��n:ä$�Hd+×�F��<;��
â�!ìH!�9�� <®}wG8HI§%9���F��.E9�nõ+×�F[
��7#>2004@�wz[�34��<;��â�!ìH!�èéê�F�_ÐÑG8H
I%��� �S|[�#â:ä�!�ÏG8HIÁ% 9�òHdä� !+¨µ�^
���j�_b ���F�-���,-��89�n�{��°�â�!ìH!%�
4�X+F�_¦s�^OWX�nG8HIä��$æçHæ�ð+�.�[FÜ=��
��Ò5�G8HIä��$æçHæ�ð+èéêFG8HIF%���n}$!¸$S
TF.-����j�_�>.F-¿� Fournier 1998, Mick, et al. 1998, Aaker and
Joachimsthaler, 2000@�G8HI�C[�gú�n<�k®5è��"%Û+�n�_�
�3�
lm%��K�=���_���F��FYmn���èéêÇ���%�!�j�_
��¨c%34nSTb �S���â�!ìH!F�=$>+��[�G8HIä�â
�!ìH!¤¥�mD�_��4�Â���èéê%� !"¯sðe« �§Ø�n°¸
�n/0J+�OS¾�Î�G8HIF�4CX�]���.|CXÎs�S¾5}F�_
Md����_���S¾���Km¡_�c[�rK�n°�°9��_��¤¥Kû
���|CX®¶·>n��êÚ@F��.�ò1�3�_êóu��.èéêgú´%]
��]�n¶�Kû��èéêgú%ÓÔ%ã�+p��ÐÑCX®¶·>n��ê
Ú@�S��9G�/®!"¯s%opj3kÂ%´:+3s[�¶�Ì�}Kû���
%S¾%s>��4F�G8HIä�â�!ìH!%�w��G8HIFèéêgú%
ÓÔF%S��%R��3�_3s���9G�/®!"¯s�/0+fg[PÇÌ�
F�-��
Ø������#��.«�i¬*�1��5�
3 =%´� Thomson, MacInnis, and Park (2005)+}Q�v�#�W- ®��¬D#_��õ
ëö#ë�Ø'( ÁúB5¬D#_Z�r�l¯�"°�± +r²+r³+]��F)©H��5�
4 àá�e´ìTraylor 1981+ µ¶ 2004ï)·�+_�� ¸�������#�'( ]��¹%
º÷»-�1�����
5 g2��6¡¼ ½·W15�6¡��lg2�%���>¾ �·5¿yÀ°)Á°%��ÂÃ�
15�>¾ì¿yï��lg2��^5쵶 2004ï�
����
ÛTG8HIä�â�!ìH!%/04'
Pc�.34���â�!ìH!�ú§%ùD�.Ç�®Ç�%^Xónm+3s[�
ò1Kû��F��^�_j��èéêÇ�%�!K�ÎsG8HI%���n� Ç�
+3�[°�´[�.¡%��Ì�F�_a����34�n�_�_���.Z���
A¤¥Kû��â�!ìH!%.-p�s%V��O�_����3�&'ó�¸��
®�$!�n��¿n�n��
G8HIä�â�!ìH!%õ�èéê�����Ç�®Î�F�_�����û��
�^X�n� %�^�ÐÑG8HI%ÏêÁ%�>Fullerton 2003; 2005,
Harrison-Walker 2002@�ÐÑG8HI%âÄ�äGn9G�C�_��Èn�?ñn�
�%� >Ahluwalia, Unnava, and Burnkrant 2000@�õ� WTP>Chaudhuri and
Holbrook 2002, Chaudhuri 2006, @o 2007@�A��¯<w;9�>Desai and Raju
2007@nm�wz��_���r.�Ú% Raju, Unnava, and Montgomery>2009@�
3���K��ÎsG8HIÁ%�â�!ìH!%õI�3�_�}wG8HI%���
C[�9G�/Ç���n��F�´�^���_���
� Ahluwalia, Unnava, and Burnkrant>2000@���â�!ìH!+�áÌ�F�_�
�Î�äGj3kâÄ�äGn}G�æ�ä�èéê%��Ì:�fg[/0+�é�_
��� �$>æÏ$�ä��B�$% NIKE+CX��NIKE�C[���ný�C
�%�#=��aKû�n����â�!ìH!%�#=��n�ûDê+<¡�}G�
æ�ä+K�EYK��4ÒD�3�_��Ì:+Å��.�NIKE�C�_�â�!ì
H!%I�èéê��âÄ�äGn}G�æ�ä�3�_�Î�äGn9G�=�.F�
3��¸�°��+Ì:>NIKEÁ%õ+I{@�2_��%�C�_��â�!ìH
!%õ�èéê�âÄ�äGn9G^��FYm/0+p�>� ��Î�äGn}G�
æ�ä�3����õ+õ¡_���F��^�.��â�!ìH!%I�èéê�9
G+P����/�_��%�C�_��â�!ìH!%õ�èéê�d�%��+b
K��34�âÄ�äG9G�C�_F^!6+ �ÉÊ�n9G�/+Ç�_��F�
-�����`aæïC%/0+iA[�.¡�`aæïC%I�MizunoK��'%Ò
D+�_����NIKEK��.X++Ru[��Fn�.�
� ¨c%34��ÚDK�G8HIä�â�!ìH!%/04'�¢n�� Ç�Z�K
�n°�9G�/%ðe« ®Â%Ï%Ç���f|�F�´�^���_�_j���
�CXF�_%É[�+ä�_���
æTG8HIä�â�!ìH!Fèéê%� Ç�
� #�KG8HIä�â�!ìH!%/0�� Ç�Z��Fmr�n��F+wz�.
��Òé¨��¸%S+y�®��ÐÑG8HI�m4[�¿� ���^���X��
^�F�4�F�û�Z©4���K��G8HIä�â�!ìH!�S[�#�rK%
����
n/+�r-.¨K�èéê%!6#$ K�n°�Ò5%� ��°í$�+a�_
G8HIä�â�!ìH!F� Ç�F%ST�O�_��+Ç4�=s[��í=�¢
[K�G8HIä�â�!ìH!%�l+Í´����w�Kû�G8HIä�â�!ì
H!�� Ç�+�´K��^m4^�é[��%Kû��
�â�!ìH!%�l��PÇ�����×��3�Ø�+�¯�.¨K�|89��
â�!ìH!}F|<;��â�!ìH!}�����R�÷��"���+�[|G8H
I¹G}+Qs�.��í=������â�!ìH!Ì���-�èéê%� Ç�Á
%/0�Ü=���ðe�$æçHÌ�����G8HIä�â�!ìH!F%ST�Ø
ÙK�"����F%&���B�$S¾>67S¾@+�´Ì�F�_���.�Â�
_�û�´Ì����èéê%f8î�ääæ$LHdÇ�FG8HI%� �c+Qs
�.�
���a�.í$���HtìeEg�Ne%µJ�3���e�IDÇ�_��Tê
ê!6Å�¾CANVASSÀ% 2008D�$Kû�6�í$�%67��B�$�æ-Hð$�
K$=�QJKäØ 3%K$=nmK���.��.F-¿æ-Hð$Kû�¿�`a�
j��÷ò 19 G8HI%4���®Dz´�ha�&^�.¨M 2 G8HI+ûDê�
$%�_����â�!ìH!>4�9H! �$=@j3k� ¶·>�c@+LM.�
�2K�N§%�w¨�æ-Hð$%X++Û+��c[��>Â%Ï%��B�$K��
ù%�í=�_�é+Ç�_��%KGN%5�?á[�ÜsKû��@
� G8HIä�â�!ìH! 3òÁ%4��G8HI¹G�S¾=$>K%�â�!ìH
!+�¯��WTP j3kG8HI�C[�9O% 2 ]Ks�.�89��â�!ì
H!�PÇ��K��°êa��_��e÷®5è% 3]�<;��â�!ìH!��
'� 9�òHdä� !%µ�nm 3]Ks�.������B�$S¾�O�_
�ÐÑ��B�$%G8HI$%�C[�de®ÏêÁ%9G�½!¹nm 3]Ks
�.�û�´Ì�Kû�f8î�ääæ$LHd���æ-Hð$%aw��� 1Dz´
���ÔD%û�G8HI%��� c��æ-Hð$� {ì+ 10 F�.aw%$
%G8HI%� �c>�� 1D§@F�.�z¨%í$�+a�_�Î�w�l��+
Ç�.X+�v%34nX+�Ê��.��í=%¼w��} T��¹���.Ö�K
û��
6 n�� Ä*�=�CANVASS 2008��ª Q+gf 30kmÅÆ+�Ç 20kmÅÆ ÈÉB5Ê 13
ËÌ69Ë�àÍÎÏ 1715Ð�FÑ�Ò�^)*��Ó;�1=i��^5�ÔÕÉ)h¦%�=Ö×Ø
£D���Q���÷ 1000ÙG�\xÚ®)ÛÜnÝÞ ß´+�àà#Ø� 6��¬D#_ÝÞ�
2áÔâ�1��5�
����
���������� �������������������
� ��%X+^��G8HI�C�_R�"���®XkO�+8È_��¹G�n�â
�!ìH!�û�Fæ-Hð$%� {ì�j��ÐÑG8HI%$%c�õ°n��
���iÏó�Rr��F��^�.�89��â�!ìH!�G8HI%$%c�C
�_ð8 %/0+fg�_���%%�G8HI¹G�m%R�K�n��89��â
�!ìH!%#$ Kû�e÷�� �j��Mò67Kû��PQk�5ènm���
�m%34n�%Kû��� ®`a��n�Fõr�_�°�%Kû�^�ZF�-�
���@o>2007@%34��#D��ÎgK� [�{ì�&^�.G8HI�O�_
vD��Å�[�FÐÑG8HIÁ%5è%õr��EK�.F�4yÒ�û��
X�_�<;��â�!ìH!F� �cF%ST+��F�I�f8î�ääæ$L
Hd�+ÖÈ.§r�n/0�û��F��^�����è��n!ZK�ÈG8HI+
`a�X��úU%mD+��_���<;��â�!ìH!�ÐÑG8HI�C[�R
�"���®5èF��.î�$æç¸=nXkO�K�n°�Ró�û���ÒU%
9�òHdä� !µ�+Eö�.Ì�Kû�.¡�ÏG8HI%��®� +|�n�
�F}�X+F�_ÎsG8HI%��� �ç�_��F�4�FKû����%G8
HIäe9ñ=�ä���j�_8Ú���.ö��ne9ñ=�äF�r���4�.
<;��â�!ìH!�3�_TÈ���� +w�_���
��B�$S¾�O�_��G8HI¹G®89��â�!ìH!FR�RSST�E
¡��.�PÇ���j�_�67��B�$�C[�S¾�G8HIä�â�!ìH!
+PÇ[�F�4×�®�dê%§�ð8 %S|ó�û�F�4×���é����F
����
�û�_�����%ST�O�_�¦s�nX+�Ê��_�n��©C��%STÍ
´���¯YZ Traylor>1981@�3�X+��67��B�$�3�_�n�F�4�
%Kû�.�ôµ�æ-Hð$��B�$K���B�$S¾FG8HIä�â�!ìH
!>G8HI¹G�89��â�!ìH!@%§�ð8 %ST�E¡��.��Ï%�
�B�$%X+�E[�Mò�û©4�r.�RSST�R�F��-�G8HIä�
â�!ìH!F��B�$S¾�û�´Ì��Â�h��n�./0+ O�F�$!�
n��¿n�n����B�$S¾��f8î�ääæ$LHdÇ��C�_ð8 %/
0+fg�_���ÐÑ67��B�$�C[�S¾�õ�èéê���3��Îs%G
8HI��â�![�F�_��Â%CX%$s�!S�Kû��F�T-��r.�%
X+�3�F���B�$S¾�õ�FÎsG8HI%� �c�I°n��Cushinh and
Douglass-Tate>1995@�67��B�$S¾%õIFG8HIä�â�!ìH!%õI
Kèéê+ 4O%}�$H��±��G8HIä�â�!ìH!�67��B�$S¾�
õ�èéê���ï+wkö���.G8HI%k+`4Î��û�Fwz�_���G
8HI�F�_���ï%$%+[�.¡%f8î�ääæ$LHdF�4ðe« +Ô
_¹G�n�â�!ìH!+��_°��èéê+�P��[��F�]w���F�
-34�
æTj���
� ���K��G8HIFèéêF%ST+�c[�¤¥F�_%G8HIä�â�!ì
H!�è]��èéê�U°G8HIä�â�!ìH!%�9ðj3kR�FÒ5%�
Ç�F%ST�O�_Í´+Äk.�èéê%Ç�%�®Z�K��G8HI+ã [�
R����mD[�%^s^+�J[��F�K�>�Ç�%¦só®?ñó+Ü[�
�F�R������%X+^��89��â�!ìH!�<;��â�!ìH!�G8
HI¹GF�4,O%G8HIä�â�!ìH!>��@��� Ç��C�_Â�h�
�n�.R�®ðe« K/0+fg�_���F�´�^�n�.�&°%lm��%
34��â�!ìH!%/0�O�_èéê%!¹�#=Ks[�%K�n°�Ò5%
� �3�í$�+a�_���.®����%¦FO%�û�F"����ô���
�â�!ìH!%�O� Ç�z�Á%/0�5¡_��[��FK�G8HI%R�®
Ç�ó+�w�F�_�â�!ìH!+êa[��F���Fn�Z©4�
r.���¢M+èéê^�gU%G8HI�#=�ªl��èéê^�Ê_���â
�!ìH!%R�FG8HI%`a�j��A+F%ST+´�^��_�°�F���
¨¸�n!>�û��Chaudhuri>2006@��ù���%ST�V©4F�.��Kû�
��èéê�U°�â�!ìH!%�9ð�3�_G8HI�`aæïC+Ê���^�
õ�RC]+Ê���^%Ø��TÈ�Fwz�_���
R�G8HI�n�.¡��>æïC+iÊ[�%^�õ�RC]+iÊ[�%^F
����
��.�9ð�5¡_@�G8HI%� êKû�èéêFm%34nSTó+�Ú[�^
�¸�n£+ü�_���STó%´Ò+¯s���G8HIä�â�!ìH!%¼|n
ûüF�âÎìH!%S +�°.¡���èéê%!"¯sðe« �Ó+�!���
.��n����MòKû©4�
�������
Ahluwalia, R., R. E. Burnkrant, and H. R. Unnava (2000), “Consumer Response to
Negative Publicity: The Moderating Role of Commitment,” Journal of Marketing
Research,37 (2), pp.203-14.
Amine, A. (1998), “Consumers’ True Brand Loyalty: The Central Role of Commitment,”
Journal of Strategic Marketing, Vol. 6, pp.305-319.
�� �2004����������������� ��!"#$%&'()�*+,-!.
/0123456�7893:;<= 23>= 4?�25-51@A
Chaudhuri, A.�2006�, Emotion and Reason in Consumer Behavior, Butterworth and
Heinemann.
Cushing, L. A. and M. Douglass-Tate (1985), “The Effect of People/Product Relationship on
Advertising Processing,” in L. F. Alwitt and A. A. Mitchell, Psychological Processes and
Advertising Effects, Erlbaum, pp.241-259.
Keller, K. L. (2003), Strategic Brand Management: Building, Measuring, and Managing
Brand Equity 2nd ed., Prentice-Hall.
Raju, S., H. R. Unnava, and N. V. Montgomery (2009), “The Effect of Brand Commitment
on the Evaluation of Nonpreferred Brands: The Disconfirmation Process,” Journal of
Consumer Research, 35(1), pp.851-863.
BC D�2007��EFG3HI�J&KLMNOPQR���� ��S�TUVW./XY
QZ<�= 455>�23-30@A
Traylor, M. B. (1981), Product Involvement and Brand Commitment, Journal of Advertising
Research, 21(6), pp.51-56.
����
IT��������� ����
ü�¸Ý� W� Xù
��
û� IT67+êa�.èéê�#z¯#±þ�.Yi+ OÏ% IT67+êa��°
°n�%Z©4 >̂�9¸â�<nEG@#êa�®[°n�%Z©4 >̂�9¸â�<n
Hf@����K�#IT 67%êaZ@í$�+a�.Òé��+Ç�#(1) ��CXF
�. IT67��9¸â�<nHf^#û���#iN%ST�û�#(2) 67êa%�9
¸â�<nST�M>��CHK�n�F�4X++Ê.�
L$ã$I�IT67#�9¸â�<nEGFHf
1. ����
WD% IT67�#{��Yi>z{#Yi@+¥���ÎB�.67�&��b-¿#
PC FÉÖ�[��>��ì$=%�peF�4Yi+ �_����'�#\ß TV F
ð8�� TV � TV �]F�4Yi+#íÎ�=�ì8F�ì8��ÉÖ�[�^Æ_/
F�4Yi+#Â�h�ÎÖ�_ �_����%34nÎÖ�.Yi+ O IT 67%
ùp+êa�.èéê�#z¯#�4ùp% IT 67+êa��°°n�%Z©4^#Â
�F�#êa�®[°n�%Z©4^�b-¿#P� PC ì$=+êa�.èéê�#É
Öì$=+êa��°°n�Z©4^#êa�®[°n�Z©4^�Â% #`�#P�
ÉÖì$=+êa�.aw��#z¯% PC ì$=%êa�~v���Z©4^#ß��
��Z©4^�
����#¨�%34nYi+¥���ÎB[� IT 67§K�#P�ùp%67+ê
a[��F�3�_#z¯#�4ùp%67%êa�~v���%^#ß����%^#
û���#/0��n�%^+��[���%34n®§�r.��.67êa%S|
ó�#�9¸â�<nEG/HfFÑ¿��>Shocker, Bayus, and Kim 2004@�¹ 1��
��_��34�#67 i%67 j�C[��9¸â�<nEGF�#® t�j��67
i%êa�® t + 1z¯%67 j%êa+~v[��FKû�#�9¸â�<nHfF�#
® t�j��67 i%êa�3�_® t + 1z¯%67 j%êa�ß�����FKû
���%�9¸â�<nEG/Hf�#�$��!äf ��!���j�_����_�
. ��ä�<nEG/Hf#`�#1®�j��67� %S|óF�Õ�����
lm��K�#<<�#=%���3�_ IT 67%Ef%S|���_�.�
Bass (1969)%�í=+�È¡F[�) �nEf�í=�#Ef�j��67§%iN+
×s�.�%Kû�.�#ÚDK�#ÐÑ67%`aê��C[�Ï%67%`aê�%
����
� 1
����/��������
/0+E¡.�í=�����#IT67%<<�#=í$��¼a��_��>e.g., Kim,
Chang, and Shocker 2000; W�äõëä¨ë 2005@��^�#���%���#<<�
#=K%67%`aê�%S|ó+���.�%Kû�#gú�#=K%67êa%S|
ó+���.�%K�n��Or�#<<�#=%��K�#û�èéê%67 j %êa
�#�/�ô�67 i+µB�_���F�3�_/0��.%^#û���#Ïê�67
i+µB�_���F�3�_/0��.%^��^�n��
Â�K���K�#�<<�#=% IT 67%êaZ@í$�+a�_Òé��+Ç�
.�Â%X+#(1) ���K��CXF�_ê�¨h. IT67%êa��>���9¸â
�<nEG%ST��n°#�9¸â�<nHf%ST�û�^#û���iNKû�#
(2) 67 i�67 j�C�_�9¸â�<nHf(++ O%�C�_#Â% #`�#6
7 j a 67 i �iNKû�F��.34�#IT 67§%�9¸â�<nST�M>��
CHK�n�F�4��X++Ê.�r.��X+^�#(3) �°O^% IT67�O�_
�#Â%êa��¥9G3��´¥9G�zm[��F��?��.�
���%/"��½% 1O�#Mick and Fournier (1998)%÷l�.ã$�æ�/ïl%
}8I< +#IT67%êaZ@í$�+a�_ÔD�����.�FKû��Mick and
Fournier (1998)�DE67%J$Ï$�C[�9H�KÏ$%X+^�#û�DE+êa
[��F�Â%DE�Ã.�4�ã$�+Ã.[F��#î.nã$�+ïl�4��
F+wz�.�����#êaZ@í$�+a�_ IT 67%êa��9¸â�<nHf
%ST�û��F+�[�F�3�_#ã$�æ�/ïl%}8I< %�¥YÐó+�é
�.��4 1O%���%/"��½�#IT67%êa��¥9G3��´¥9G�zm
[�aw�û��F+�?�.®Kû��Ef��K�#) ���âÏã�$æçH(
+��®�Ð_��_�.�>e.g., Gatignon and Robertson 1985;Rogers 2003@#ÚD#
î67êa�j��èéê96%/0+���.���bY�n�OOû�>e.g.,
�� t �� t + 1��
�� i
�� j
��� ���/�� ����� ���/��
��
����
Moreau, Lehmann, and Markman 2001; ë' 2004@����K�#IT67êa�C[
��¥9GF´¥9G%(+%dp+�¯�.��+Ç�#���+�¬�.�r.Òé
��®^��#���%X+�#IT67%ì$�$®_g�m%67%µBê�C�_m
%67+<e «=[��^F�4�?+�.�[F�-����
z{K�r>#n7�9¸â�<nEG/Hf�A�N�4�%^+�"[��v�#IT
67%êaZ@í$�+a�.Òé��+Ç4����#���%X++rF¡#`þF
ô�%��%p]ó�O�_�"[��
2. � !"#$�% IT�������� �/��&'
Yi%±þ�. IT 67§K�#�9¸â�<nEGFHf%dp�Ð��4����
K�#n7PÇ�_êa��. IT67�Ï% IT67�C�_�9¸â�<nEG(+®
Hf(++ �4�^+#èéêÇ�%�®^��_��4�
2O% IT67#67 iF67 j%Yi%�Ó�#(a) 67 iF j�ÎÖ�_ OYi#(b)
67 i �AB%Yi#(c) 67 j�AB%Yi#(d) 67 i F j +ta[��F�3�_Ê
���Yi% 4O�n/[��F�K������K�#ån°F�#(a) ÎÖYi#(b) 6
7 i%ABYi#(c) 67 j%ABYi+ O IT67%¯w2�$][���c[�Òé
���j�_��CXF�. PC ì$=FÉÖì$=#íÎ�=�ì8F�ì8��ÉÖ
�[#\ß TVFð8�� TV%¯w2�#�>�����% 3O%Yi+ �_���
� 2
4()�*+
(b)
�� i�
�����
(a)
�� i � j�
!���
(c)
�� j�
�����
�� i �� j
(d)
�� i � j�
"#��
����
P�67 i+êa�.F�#èéê�(a) ÎÖYiF(b) 67 i%ABYi+Ê���%
èéê�67 j�êa[��F�3�_Ê�ª��Yi�#(c) 67 j%ABYiF(d) t
aYiKû��ùp#67 i +êa�_�n�èéê�67 j +êa[��FKÊ�Yi
�#(a) ÎÖYiF(c) 67 j%ABYiKû��
�9¸â�<nEG�A�NO%�#67 i+êa�.�$ �j��(c’) 67 j%AB
YiF(d) taYi�C[��J��#67 i+êa�_�n��$ �j��(a) ÎÖY
iF(c) 67 j%ABYi�C[��J�3��_��awKû�>a + c > c’ + d@�Â%
%aw��#�9¸â�<nHf�A�NO>a + c < c’ + d@�b-¿#PCì$=%ê
a�#èéê�ÉÖì$=%ABYi>`ó@FtaYi>ì$=��@�C�_ô�
^%�J�+ O����#PC ì$=+êa[�z#� �_�.ÉÖì$=%ÎÖY
i>ì$=�pe@FÉÖì$=%ABYi>`ó@�C[��J�+{µ�¿#PC
ì$=%êaz¯#ÉÖì$=�êa���°°n��#¨µ�¿ÉÖì$=�êa��
®[°n��
��K#67 i%êaz¯#67 j%ABYi�C[��J��õr�4�>c < c’@��
��#±��3�67 j %Yi%/ÍF#B!�C�ðn�/�3�67 j �Ã.[î.
n]�%�A�3�_�´����67 i +êa�.èéê�#iÊ�.67 i %96�
��_#67 j%Yi+±�[��F�K��>e.g., Gregan-Paxton and Roedder John
1997; Moreau, Lehmann, Markman 2001; Moreau, Markman, and Lehmann 2001@��
�K±�F�#±þ�_���F+9-F�_#l9%CX^��9%CX+�"[��
FKû��b-¿#PÇ�_�ì8��ÉÖ�[+êa�#�ì8��ÉÖ�[%96+
iÊ�.èéê�#�%�ì8��ÉÖ�[%96+`�_#íÎ�=�ì8%ABYi
FÎÖYi>õ<�%^Æ_/@+�"[��F�K���ùp#�ì8��ÉÖ�[%
�êaê��ì8��ÉÖ�[%96+ .n�.¡#íÎ�=�ì8%Yi+±�K�
n��
67 j%Yi�/Í���F#èéê�67+Ю��.B!�C�ðn�/�3�_#
67 j%Yi�Ã.[î.n]�+�A�4�>Mick and Fournier 1998, cf. Huber and
Klein 1991; Johnson 1989@�b-¿#�ì8��ÉÖ�[+P�êa�.èéê�#±�
+ÖÈ_õ<�n^Æ_/F�4íÎ�=�ì8%Yi+/Í�.F�#�%èéê�|õ
<�n^Æ+_/[�}F�4î��]�+�A�4��|õ<�n^Æ+_/[�}F�
4]�+�A[�B!�C�ðn�/�#íÎ�=�ì8%Yi�/Í��n�`��Ð
��n���%34n±��3�67 j %Yi%/ÍF#Â��X°B!�C�ðn�/
�3�67 j%Yi�Ã.[]�%�A�Ç��.F�#67 i%êa�#67 j%ABY
i�C[��J��õr��
����
3. ,-./
01�
���K�#JMR;9îH e%}â=Å�í$�+a�_��+Ç�.��%Å��#
2002Dz¯ID 1µ>OÒÓ��_j�#���K�#2003D*2006D% 4D|Y>í
Î�=�ì8%í$�� 2004 Dz¯ 3 D|Y@+a�.�ùD%Å���'Un�8
]�5r���#��K�#IT67%µB#µÊ#�¥mn%��ó+���`a�.�
��CX67�#PC ^�%9H�$â�!rX>z{#PC rX@#ÉÖì$=#íÎ
�=�ì8#�ì8��ÉÖ�[#\ß TV#ð8�� TV#HDD��$�% 767Kû
��PCrX#\ß TV#ð8�� TV#HDD��$��O�_�#|µB�_��}F�
©�µ²�.Å�D+#ÐÑ67+êa�.CF�.>b-¿#2004DÅ�rK�|µB
�_�n�}Fµ²�#2005DÅ�z¯�|µB�_��}Fµ²�.aw#êa�.C
�(2004Å�®-2005Å�®]Kû�@�r.ÉÖì$=F�ì8��ÉÖ�[�O�_
�#ì$={�®�ì8{�%��.ÉÖ�[+µB�_�_�`a�_�n�aw�&
��F^�#|`a�_��}F�©�µ²�.Å�D+êa�.CF�.�r.ù67%
1µ]Å���´Ì�+s>[�.¡�`a�#2µ]Å�z¯+�s�a�.�
��K�#��CX67+#(1) PCrXFÉÖì$=#(2) íÎ�=�ì8F�ì8�
�ÉÖ�[#(3) \ß TV#ð8�� TV#fk HDD��$�% 3d=$ð���#d=
$ð´%�9¸â�<nST+���.�n7n�#���%d=$ð´%67�#ÎÖ
YiFù67�AB%Yi+ OF�-���.¡Kû��nj HDD ��$��#\ß
TV®ð8�� TVF%ÎÖYi+ .n��taYi+ O�F^�#���5¡.�
./23
��K�#¨�%Dv%}â=í$�+#åH}8ì!��<n�w§%�bcÏ$
I�í=>e.g., Meyer 1990; Seetharaman and Chintagunta 2003@�û_�¡.��%
�í=K�#C§(t – 1, t]>z{#tC@%�w§cÏ$I#`�#t – 1C%3��r
K�ÐÑ67�êa��n��F+67F�_#tC�ÐÑ67�êa���c�#
( ) ( )[ ]tt
xexpexp1tp β′+α−−=
F�_stu����.Z�#xt� t C%�´Ì�#<!=Kû���%t�#|X§
%#$ 89HcÏ$I+ t C% ¡%®^�3��%®%Õ§K���.�%+
exp(αt)F×s[��F�3�_������#$ 89HcÏ$I�d!%c��+×
s[��F�K���#�%aw#mYn��+×s�.^�3�_β%�s�¸�°
Ìu�_�r4���K�##$ 89HcÏ$I+åH}8ì!��<��s[��F
K#�%8Ú+µ��_���
�´Ì��#µÊ#�¥mn%��ó#fk#d=$ð´%ÐÑ67z�%µBKû��
����
µÊF�¥mn%/0%}8ì�$�s�íKû��F�C+����µB�O�_�#
b-¿#PCrX+�;Ì�F�.��K�#tC�j��ÉÖì$=%µB�â$>t – 1
CrK�ÉÖì$=+êa�_��¿ 1#Â�z�%F� 0@+�´Ì�F�_a�.�
�%µB%}8ì�$�s%eÑ�íKû�¿�9¸â�<nHf+#�Kû�¿�9
¸â�<nEG+Â�h�ö[�
./45
ö 1�cÏ$I�í=%}8ì�$αFβ+�f �3�_�s�.X+Kû��
6 1
7845
PC�� �����
α1 -3.07 *** -1.50 ***
α2 - α1
a
.00 -.35 *
α3 - α1
a
.70 *** -.39
PC��
b
.80 ***
����� .90 ***
b
.11 *** .03
�� � .26 *** .16 *
���� -354.95 -267.69
������� ���������
α1 -1.75 *** -1.29 ***
α2 - α1
a
.19 .52 ***
α3 - α1
a
b
.13
����
b
.43 ***
������� .34 *
b
.06 ** .00
�� � .04 .25 ***
���� -316.85 -743.11
�� TV ��� TV HDD!"�#
α1 -3.83 *** -6.97 *** -3.34 ***
α2 - α1
a
.59 * 1.73 1.67 ***
α3 - α1
a
1.31 *** 2.62 ** 1.92 ***
�� TV
b
.96 * .40
��� TV 1.04
b
.43
HDD!"�# .62 ** .57
b
.04 .12 * .04
�� � -.11 -.03 .17 **
���� -302.66 -107.64 -500.54
***$1%%&'()***$5%%&'()**$1%%&'()+
a: 2,-./01234*1,-56789:;<+
b$ =>?�0@ABC2+
����
r>#PCrXFÉÖì$=%X+^��_��4�PCrX%êa�C[�ÉÖì$=
%µB%(+�íKB!Kû�>β = .90, p < .01@�Â% #ÉÖì$=%êa�C[�
PCrX%µB%(+�r.íKB!Kû�>β = .80, p < .01@��%�F^�#PCrX
FÉÖì$=�#ùp+µB[��F�3�_Ïp%êa�ß����#`�#�9¸â
�<nHf(++Ry� O�F��^��
íÎ�=�ì8F�ì8��ÉÖ�[�r.#y���9¸â�<nHf(++ �_
���Or�#PÇ�_�ì8��ÉÖ�[�êa���F#z¯#íÎ�=�ì8�ê
a��®[°n��>β = .34, p <.1@#íÎ�=�ì8+êa�.èéê�#z¯#�ì8
��ÉÖ�[+êa�®[°n�>β = .43, p < .01@�
\ß TV#ð8�� TV#HDD��$��#�CHnST�û��r>\ß TV%êa
�# HDD��$�%µB�3�_ß�����>β = .62, p < .05@#ð8�� TV%µB
�3�_B!n/0+p�n�>β = 1.04, n.s.@�ð8�� TV%êa�#\ß TV%µB
�3�_ß�����>β = .96, p < .1@#HDD��$�%µB�3�_/0��n�>β
= .57, n.s.@�r.HDD��$�%êa�#\ßTV%µB�3�/0�p�n��>β = .40,
n.s.@#ð8�� TV%µB�3�_�/0��n�>β = .43, n.s.@��%X+�#ð8�
� TV 3��P� HDD ��$�®\ß TV +� �_��4�F��$��äHdgJ
+��[��Kû��F+�?�_���HDD ��$�+P�� [�F\ß TV �ê
a��®[°n�#\ß TV +P�� [�Fð8�� TV �êa��®[°n��#ð
8�� TV +P�êa�_�#z¯#\ß TV ® HDD ��$��êa��®[°n�n
�.¡Kû��
�¥mn%��ó%�s�#PCrX#ÉÖì$=#�ì8��ÉÖ�[#HDD��
$��O�_�íKB!Kû�.�#íÎ�=�ì8#\ß TV#ð8�� TV �O�_
��B!Kû�.�#c%34�#íÎ�=�ì8#\ß TV#ð8�� TV�O�_�#
Â%êa�C�_Ï% IT 67%µB�í%B!n/0+fg�_����%�F�#í
Î�=�ì8#\ß TV#ð8�� TV %êa�#�¥9G3��#´¥9G#`�#�
h´�l���.Yi%±þ�.67�O�_%96�zm[��F+�?�_���
µÊ%�s�#PCrX#íÎ�=�ì8#ð8�� TV�O�_�íKB!Kû��
ùp#ÉÖì$=#�ì8��ÉÖ�[#\ß TV#HDD��$��O�_�#eÑ�í
Kû��%%#�B!Kû�.�
4. 9��
���K�#IT67êa%�9¸â�<nEGFHf+���.�èéêÇ�%�®^
��#IT67%êa��9¸â�<nEGFHf%m���Ð��4��#}â=Å�í
$�+a�.Òé��K�#��CXF�_ê�¨h. IT 67§��>���9¸â�
����
<nEG%ST��n°#Hf%ST�û�^#û���iNKû��F#IT67§%S
T�M>��CHK�n�F�4X++Ê.�r.��X+^�#IT67%êa��¥9
G3��´¥9G�zm[�aw�û��F��?��.�
.Z�����#�9¸â�<nEG/Hf%§�±4Ìu+���_�n�F�4`
þ+ �_���67 i %êaq���67 j �êa���°°n��>�9¸â�<n
EG@#§�Ô�[��O�_67 j�êa��®[°n�>�9¸â�<nHf@F�
�.34�#67êa%�9¸â�<nST�§�±�_Ìu[��F��-����
ô�%��K�#���K����n^�.�9¸â�<nST%Ìu+��[��F�
wr������3�#ú�m%67+<e «�Hd[��^Z�K�n°#�O<e
«�Hd[��^��^�34�n��r.���Ka�.�í=�#èéê%��ó
+�¯�_�n��F�`þF�_ûh����ô�%��K�#��ó+�¯�.�í
=�3�_�9¸â�<nST+��[��F�q¡����
:;<=
Bass, Frank M. (1969), “A New Product Growth Model for Consumer Durables,”
Management Science, 15 (January), 215-27.
Gatignon, Hubert and Thomas S. Robertson (1985), “A Propositional Inventory for New
Product Diffusion Research,” Journal of Consumer Research, 11 (March),
849-67.
Gregan-Paxton, Jennifer and Deborah Roedder John (1997), “Consumer Learning by
Analogy: A Model of Internal Knowledge Transfer,” Journal of Consumer
Research, 24 (December), 266-84.
Huber, Joel and Noreen M. Klein (1991), “Adapting Cutoffs to the Choice Environment:
The Effects of Attribute Correlation and Reliability,” Journal of Consumer
Research, 18 (December), 346-57.
Kim, Namwoon, Dae Ryun Chang, and Allan D. Shocker (2000), “Modeling
Intercategory and Generational Dynamics for a Growing Information
Technology Industry,” Management Science, 46 (April), 496-512.
Meyer, Bruce. D. (1990), “Unemployment Insurance and Unemployment Spells,”
Econometrica, 58 (July), 757-782.
Mick, David Glen and Susan Fournier (1998), “Paradoxes of Technology: Consumer
Cognizance, Emotions, and Coping Strategies,” Journal of Consumer Research,
25 (September), 123-43.
Moreau, C. Page, Arthur B. Markman, and Donald R. Lehmann (2001), “What Is It?:
����
Categorization Flexibility and Consumers’ Responses to Really New Products,”
Journal of Consumer Research, 27 (March), 489-98.
__________, Donald R. Lehmann, and Arthur B. Markman (2001), “Entrenched
Knowledge Structure and Consumer Response to New Products,” Journal of
Marketing Research, 38 (February), 14-29.
Johnson, Michael D. (1989), “The Differential Processing of Product Category and
Noncomparable Choice Alternatives,” Journal of Consumer Research, 16
(December), 300-309.
Rogers, Everett M. (2003), Diffusion of Innovation, Fifth Edition, New York: Free
Press.
W�Xùäõë Ê"ä¨ë Ìi (2005)#|K�67%taF 9�ò+¯k�YZEf
�í=}#¾�$��äHdä;9îH À#14 (2)#1-20T
Seetharaman, P. B. and Pradeep K Chintagunta (2003), “The Proportional Hazard
Model for Purchase Timing: A Comparison of Alternative Specifications,”
Journal of Business & Economic Statistics, 21 (July), 368-382.
Shocker Allan D., Barry L. Bayus, and Namwoon Kim (2004), “Product Complements
and Substitutes in the Real World: The Relevance of Other Products,” Journal
of Marketing, 68 (January), 28–40.
ë' 3j (2004)#|î67%��FèéêÇ�}#"ëæÁäîÂkr;V#¾�$��ä
Hdä�B�Ï$æçH�/"FÒ�%:eH�äCÀ#BÈÉ#126-39T
��
k�ní$�+�½�_�.Z�. JMR;9îH e�¼°Êlm�¨hr[�
����
��������� ������������������
SËÝ5¸Ý¸Ý5� nÍ�Ç
��������� ���
ÚD#G8HI"%Û+�|G8HIäî<9�ä}|G8HIäC9íH�ä�ä}
+Ô_#ÔD�F�_%|G8HIäî< .�îH }ÁFÌo�OOû�>7#
1995#1999#2006@�
�%�����°O^%ò1�û�F�-��¦FO��#��rK%èéêÇ���
�� rK%ðe« +���.���&°#���%ðe« �ûr��®+Ð__�
n^�.�F>î´ 1997#p.73?p� 2001#p.120@#q.O¡�#|) ��$��äH
d�{��ÎóFYi>Feature & Benefit@%�$��äHd}>Schmitt 1999#�ö#p.37@
Kû�.�F�3�9G�/Cðe$ò+ss[�rs#,O¡�#îDE®î{��
��67è+Ì-_fg�_�°34nðe�<!>67@#$ %|�«�!:�$�
�äHd}>à0 2006@%`þKû���%34n®^�#ÔD�$��äHd®Ó
Dèé>"ë 2002@#èéÔD>à0 2006@F��.�"�ª¸�OOû�F�-��
nj#��rKG8HI"%Û+Kû�. Aaker>1996@® Keller>1998@�|�âÏ
ã�$æçH+Ö�_�P�tq�_�°>û���#Â%X+F�_9ì$ή96F
�_O�_�°��@67ä;$K Â�dÓ%>Yi@%v-Kû�.}>7# 2006#
p.31@�F^�#��%�"�Yi%u¯k+��_�n��
�%34nÔDÁF]^4�"%Õ��#Ы%�Fn��G8HIF%Îï>"
ë 2002@®G8HIä�âÎìH!>à0 2006@%�òó+õ¡_������#§ô
%��'%�h�j�_�ð89#$!äG8HI>z{ PB@�c�¾��õr�OO
û��F^�#u�v�j��¸æç¸=äG8HI>z{ NB@% .$ ��R�
°n�_�_���NB �v .$ +�[�.¡%ò7�xOû�#¦FO�#Â%
��B�$K NB + 4Z�%/9#[n��|ÐÑG8HI�#Â%;[���B�$
�j�_� [��p:�n;ó}� PB 3��J+8È��n��¿$%��n�%K
û��q.O¡�#��íä�äu�3�67%��u�ÝRKû�.¡#ÔD>Pine
and Gilmore 1999#�ö#p.59@®ÓDèé+Ã.[�F�3�#��íä�äu+É�#
Â%¥M+�[��F�MòFn�OOû��Or�#��B�$+Eö[�Û+�n
Yi+�½>î 2007@�OO#èé®ÔD#û����H�< !+ÖÈ_�PF%S
Tó®%Óó+õ¡�|G8HIä�âÎìH!}>à0 2006@%dp�q¡��_��
E�n�_�.F�4�FKû��Â�_#|ÔD+#$ F�_Ú^��9��n
w>emotional bonding@�Â�WX�nSTó�A%�Fn�}>7# 2006#p.29@�
Â%X+#|G8HI+�½[��%�Z��#�ÈG8HI+ �O���èéê%�Z
����%dê�3�_G8HI�xA��#eHd89:äG8HIFn�}>"ë 2002#
����
p.152@%Kû��Â�_|G8HIF�P®Ï% �$< ¨=�$>�P®�*{#�
�P@F%�âÏã�$æçH�3��A��.STó�G8HI+ã [�I�+3s
[�#���G8HIÁ%ã �y�����F�3�#G8HIäî<9�ä��Ú�
��}>Duncan and Moriarty 1997#�ö#P.16@�F�n��Or�#ÔD+#$
��.9��nw>e9ñ��ä@�3�_)*FèéêF��Z��>�â�!ìH!@
+ �_Îï>��$æçHæ�ð@�_�°�F�G8HIäî<9�ä�Ú�On�
�F�-_3�Kû©4�
�%34�î��G8HI%/"�nu¯k%�"��kOOû��%%#��r
K%���j�_#`aÔD®� �+~5�.��B�$#$ %G8HIs�í=
�ån�F�-�����KÔD®ÓDèé%[�_+�ó[��F�R���%%#
Â%�-p+�r-OO#��B�$%Û+�n�l�/0[�ò1��F�°z�:%
G8HIä�âÎìH!+��[��FKG8HIä��$æçHæ�ð��½[��F
+���%]�F[��%Ó�nCðe$ò�#sªCH�$!Å�+ÖÈ_Ê.í$�
+a�#�lpIt�í=�3�_ùG8HI%í$�+ð$=[��FK#��B�$
�lF�_%G8HIFe9ñ=�äF%STó+Òé�_�°�%Kû��
�������������
�.��������� !"�#$�%&'�
èéê%��B�$96�l�d�$I>�²@+ �#p:�nmD�Â%Û+�M
d�#�p:�n�%�Â%�l%���mD[��Â%Û+��#Ï%ìHf$%Îó
+��&° O�X�n|ðe!�9ð}�mD[�>e.g. Cohen and Basu 1987; Loken
et al. 2007@�r.ùpK#��B�$%Û+��#�4Fn�%Ó�nyb>G8HI@
Â%�%F�_%|îdåHð8$}�mD[�>e.g. Cohen and Basu 1987; Loken et al.
2007@�nj#ðe!�9ðFîdåHð8$%m���BJn�n%^�+/Ý%�!
�j�_�rZ´nX"�ç�_j�>#ÚD�j�_�#dê%/"�iÏ�K�n
°©�©Hf�Kû�F�-�-��OOû�>Punj and Moon 2002#Þ� Ï 2001, A
{ 2007@���rK%��B�$%Û+�n�l%èéêÇ��j�����#��B�
$ìHf$§%;ó��°±þó®p:ó�Û+Kû�#;ó®Îó�3�|Cõ�
�°9G�/Cðe$òKû�.F�-��Â%.¡#�H�< !�j��ÔD®8
�#89F��.ÓD÷>Cðe$ò>"ë 2002@%�®�q}�_�.�r.G8HI
§%RC�n}~LMó%®�����_�n^�.�F®#��B�$%Û+ó%�l
%/Í�RS��nm�~r�_j�&v-K%���Ç��_�_�n^�.®�8Ú
®F�_�h����Â�K���K�#���%p:óF%Óó%�®+~��.�í
=F[��K�v�s+Ç4�û.�m%34nò1�p:ó#%Óó�ST�_��
%^+n/[��
����
�.����� !�()*�+,*-./0%12�3456
ðe!�9ðF�_%p:ó%s��÷�#/=;ó> ideals@#&;ó�l
>multiattribute structure@#Q��±þó>family resemblance@#��B�$ìHf$F
�_%r=r�>frequency of instantiation@#<�ó>familiarity@#Eöó>typicality@#
nm�a���_�.>e.g. Barsalou 1985#Loken and Word 1990@�/=;óF���
�B�$��½[�]�F�_|=���/=�n;óKû��b-¿�9î�!:$I
%awKû�¿#|I�e�$}�/=;óFn�#Â%�B%I�+s�_��
>Barsalou 1985@�&;ó�lF����/0[�÷òn|e¥}Fn�]�%�F+
w�_j�#èéê�F�_�òne¥Z�K�A���®K|&;ó���í=}F�
�n�>Loken and Word 1990@�Q��±þóF�#�°O^%±þ�.;ó�3�_¦
FO%��B�$F�4�±��A����-pKû��ôµ��;��ÏF%±þó�
3�V�KE[��ùp#%Ó�nybKû�îdåHð8$%�A�/0[��%�
|BC�h^�%C<« �®[�}Kû��C<« �®[�%S�^�Fn�ò1F
�_#ybF�_%r�>frequency@#îÚó>recency@#UVn]�>salient goals@#
idóäx�ó>distinctiveness@��h��_��>Cohen and Basu 1987@�ybF�
_%r��#�4�nyb+y#�ÔD[��F®#yb%�Wr��Â%�%G8HI
%;ó%E6�ST[�F��.®Kû�>Ratneshwar and Shocker 1988, Barsalou
1985@#Â%X+F�_%Øù=Ю=Ðcnm+s[��FKEK��Z©4�î
Úó>recency@�#|��B�$%öX�#�Úp�.jk�&°%�k+×�Ð_�}
>Duffy and Crawford 2008@F�-��_j�#KÎÏC=F%ST�R�>Kevin et al.
2007@����K�#8����ÚG8HI+�^�.I�+E[��
78�9 ��� !�:;<=>�12�?@569
�� ����
p:ó
�����
����
�� �
�����������������
���
����� !��"#�
$%&'()*+,-./
����012)*3�
4��� �
56789&�:;<*��
:=>�?*@ABCDE*F3�
���������GH�IJ
%Óó
GH������
KL�
MN-O�
PQ�RST�
U"�VW�VX
YZ���W[L:;<\3�
]��^_`7abc�de�f�V
4��g?Whi�j?k;l7)J
UVn]��#%Ó�n�H�< !®`a¶·�j�_%ÔD�#Îs%CX®G8
HInm+=Ð�2�>Ratneshwar and Shocker 1988@�FnmKû�#m%34n�
����
H�< !®¶·KG8HI�=Ð���%^��òFn��idóäx�ó��h^�
%:T%S�^�Fn�C<« �®[�+õ¡��%K#idóäx�ó�G8HI%
Jã$<���ST�_j�#ÏF%Ø�®Î�%"��^k®[��O�_E[��
z¨%34nò1���B�$%Û+ó%�l+¯¡_j�#ôµ%�lpIt�í=�
���%ò1����A[��nja��ò1F]%ù��¹öo%Fj�Kû��
A�BCD4��EF!G
A.����� !�()*�+,*�H�I��JK
p:ó%õ�Îój3k;ó+ O�m#r./=;ó®±þó+ OmD�mp:ó
�õ°#ý!���í%ST�û�>Nedungadi and Hutchinson 1985?Barsalou,1985?
Loken and Ward 1987,1990@�r.PÇ���j�_#`a%r�Fý!��í%ST�
R��F^�#��B�$ìHf$F�_%r=r��õr��m<�ó®Eöó�õr
��>��í%ST�û�F�-����%Óó�O�_�#C<« �®[��ù �
�õr��m#�h^�=Ð��®[°n�.¡�¯<w���®[°n�#$%c�
õr��Â%.¡#Øù=Ю=ÐcFý!�®$%��í%ST�û�>Nedungadi and
Hutchinson 1985 ; Nedungadi, 1990?Aaker 1991@�r. Rosch>1978@�3�¿#��
��.yb%�/%��>reaction time@��±%��#��B�$è^�í�[¿®°
=Ð����%#=Ð���2Xnm���B�$%Eö�nmDFST[��
njp:óF%Óó�Hf�nST�û�.¡RS�û�F�-_������%�F
^�z{%� 1-a#1-b#1-c.��-����
H1-a. ����������� ����
H1-b. ���������� ����
H1-c. ���������� ����
v�e9ñ��äF��$æçHæ�ð%Õ��O�_��[��Aaker>1991#�ö#
p.58«62@�3�¿#G8HIäe9ñ=�ä�ST[�ò1�#Ç�%�>:���
c#���c#����.G8HI�nm@# 9�òHd� !#Ã��#ý!�#�â
�!ìH!��h��_���Î�G8HIäe9ñ=�ä%[�_%op%£Fn�8
Ú�Ã��Kû��F>� p.61@#ý!�®e÷ó�#89FRSST�õ�>� p.62@
�F#�â�!ìH!�|ÏêÁ%}�â}F��.�#|`a[�%���¡_YhK
×��^}nm%±×èé>� p.62@nm�e9ñ��ä�ST[��Dick and Basu>1994@
�#e9ñ��ä���/0[��%F�_#E9���F89���#�{���%,
O+�h_���E9�����#C<« �®[�#e÷ó#�ònÛ+�;ó#;ó
%´��5r�_��� 89�����89#8��¶·>feeling states@#�$I#
��rKÔD�.89>primary affect@#Ã���û�#�{����# 9�òHd�
!#;H<� !#C+[��F>expectation@�û��Â�_e9ñ��ä����
����
�$!� ®èé+ÖÈ_#¦��>patronage@F�_%��$æçHæ�ð��Ú��#
X+F�_ÏG8HI%9Gmn+�n��F>search motivation@#�"��ÊÁ%F^
>resistance to counter persuasion@#}�â>word-of-mouth@nm%�â�!ìH!Fç
����^�/ÍK���F�e9ñ��ä%���C�_#ÔD%89®Ã���
P�û�®#j3k��F�_%e9ñ��ä�Ç��±4�FK��$æçHæ�ð�
ÆA����F#Â�_�â�!F�_%����A���®Kû��nj#���%p
:óF%Óó�E9���FCÇ�_j�#89���%Ã��Fèé%±×F�489
+�í=�����FKÔDÁ%CÇ+�_�°�r.�{�����â�!ìH!
F�_5¡��nj Dick and Basu>1994@�3�¿Ã��F±×��È89�nu¯k
F�_���F^�dê�RS�û�FQs�#p:ó®%Óó��°ÓDèé%X+
F�_%89Kû�F�-.��%34n®^�z{%×� H2-a.^� H2-e.+d�.�
H2-a. ��������� �������������������� �!""#$%&'
H2-b. ������������ !"#$%&'()*������� ����
H2-c. ������������ !"#$%����+,-��.�� ����
H2-d. ������������ !"#$%+,-��.�/0123�� ����
H2-e. ������������ !"#$%()*��+�,-./0�/1 �"#$%&'
r.:� ®� r��õr�¿#yb%=Ð�®[�®��B�$F�_%PQk#
�H�< !F%ST�R°n�F�-����r.O7+`a[��FK� �ST[
�e¥F�_%96�R¡���.¡#z{%×� H3-a,3-b+Qs[��
H3-a./0123������ ����
H3-b./0123������ ����
���%×�+~5�.��u¯k�¹öxFn��
78�9 �������
$%&'
()& '
*��+, ' -��./0.'
1�23�'45 '
67 '89
H1-a
H1-b
H1-c
H2-a
H2-a
H2-b
H2-c
H2-d H2-e
H3-a,b
����
A.��LM�NOPQ�RSTP�UEUR
N�%�w¨#�hæ ��FG8HIäî<9�ä�S[�KLn�KÏ$�×5�#
��K�÷�ÒéF%ST^�#�G8HI�h%�n#(G8HIJFG8HI%
Ø�F���%Md��#%x®���_�¢�c�_j°�
r>G8HIF�h%ST�#G8HIFr=�.5#G8HIè#��B�$#C9
íH�ä:äC>eB®}��$Î#�Nnm@K�s>C9íH�ä:�9@�Ç��
�>ëÛä�� 1995#p.29@��%�F^�ôµ%�é��G8HIeB+���_Ç4�
G8HIäî<9�ä%�/�j��#G8HIJFG8HI��n��%Kû�
>7# 1995#p.12-13@����K���B�$F�4`a�j�_}wG8HI%í$�
>���èéê%CH�$!�3�G8HIõKû�.¡|G8HIJ}F[�@+ð
$=[��K�é[��F^�}~���j��ÐÑ|G8HI}+s�_���
F�n�#G8HIJF%dê+�ó�_���í=Kû�F�-��
V�WXDYZ[ �\]^_R P`^WXa
N�%ST¨#�~����[��ð�� !��Å�%$%&Q<%.¡�Ç�.�
47è�d9µ²+Û+F�.9H�$â�!Å�+ 2009D 2S 6ü^� 2S 23ürK
%C§#ôó�C�_|��a��}�O�_ÒÓ�.�|UVn]�}Fn�� �{�
Tauber>1972@+���æ$HQs�d9µ²�_µv#���%X+�����&�
�%^�2�Q8�Q<�µ²���Ó%æÕ��.n�]�5¡n^�.�n/�.
$%&%e÷ó+õ¡�.¡#�Å�%#�ÒéQÁ�C�Hd�.�÷n�C�HdP
�#�ÖÔ%üa7ì$�$�j����a����B�$%Å�ÔDê#Õ*%��B
�$ä�âÎìH!¥°%´Ðê#j3kò-â=�~%Å�´ÐnmKû��Â%�#
�Å�+ð�� !F��% Ipsos ü� <Å�Htìe%c� ¨$=I}â=>C<
« }â=@#ù eìú 20 E^� 60 E#®%ôó�#°Ao�D�%'ÛÅ�%X+
���#2009D 3S 18ü^� 3S 25üKÒÓ#µv��o��èKû�.�g��
E�.G8HI�ð�� !K=Ð��.#C�î$=#B$=I#C��<#!�ð#
G=$�9ñ#ãÏ$K$�# �9=:ä�!K#���%G8HIK��a��`a
%�×z¨+¦¡��F^���B�$�j��G8HI%�óó�O�_�8Ún�F
�-.�nj#Pc�.G8HI%�s+í�Ç�_��4.¡G8HI�O�_3°
�8�#[�_|G8HIeB�3�G8HIâ$�}F)*è+���.����#G
8HI��%2X®$%&%���[�_8H��Qs�#f9C +µ��.�
b�3456
��%#�ð$=�.í$�+a�ù1ÃFn�]+���.�CX�G8HI+9
�_�_��rK����.�F%û�ú%ð$=í$�>n=399@Kû��
����
��������� m��_`&�noJ>\pq>DIrst*upvwDI?Rvw
DxrupyzDw�7{|;Jup}~R�~up��-��up�����m@��R��F
D��up�<7)Jupde�f���.�c�*u���0p7.�����de�f|�
?u;|p1.��\r��de�f|�r-?u�����c���\����-����
0��)*\�&W ¡�-¢£¤¥&I*¦O§�"¨�0���\�¢£no©[ª«
0¬?W®©��¯°^_&I*±²®Wm³¯°^_&I*´²®�µ¶0²�\
·¸W?¹>�¢£º©»�cE�\����-./&©¼?½¾DE*�¿À|>*��
;|W·¸�Á©+&´²®�·¸0ì)*�-ÄWÅÆ�DÇ?��D���0Ç
�*���È,ÉÊcE*�¿À\��WËÌ�-*./©4�ͺIw�¼?ËÌ�0Î
��?*��DÏ,cE*��;|WÅÆ�© 0.6Ðz�pq>DIrst*up}~R�~u
p�<7)Ju�ѦO&ÒÓ�\�/�\�WÔ�W¢£¤¥0²�\·¸W¢£noÕ
�Ö×ØÙX© 71.4ÚW.�Ûº@^³��°^� αF© 0.872�Ç?��;|W��Ѧ
O0¤¥&ܬ)*�
������ ���� Barsalou@1985FWLoken et al.@1990F&���W��
�0àÓ�\��������������@E-\©�>�c&W56789-ác��
de�f0á�r|?���c:;<�);�p9.����â&:;<*u;|p1.��\rW
:;<-?uFW���@E-\&�����de�f©�ã¬�����Wá�3�:=>
�?�);WABCDEw�);�p9.���:=>�?*u;|p1.��\r:=>�?-
?uFW����� !��"#�@��de�f©E-\D���ä)*�ã¬��&á�
3�I?H���E�©�w�);�p10.���å?HcE*u;|p1.��\rWår-
?HcE*uFW����@��de�f©pq>0Irs��WyzDwDå?u�?æ,
ç0á�3�Î��?*de�fè�j?�);�p9.����rÎ�u;|p1.���é-
?uFcE*��>|���0êëá�¢£¤¥�ìí&���\·¸W¢£º©»�cE
�\DW�����������������©îï¤ð;|ñ>�?\��;|Wh&Å
Æ�DÇ?���@0.881FW����@0.771F�C¤¥&¬?*���ò��.�Ûº@^
³��°^� αF© 0.910cE*�-ÄW� ����� Sujan and Bettman(1989)0ó¿
&àÓ�\���Wzô����¦O��½¾Dõö&÷?��;|ø�¤¥ùú;|©
}ñ�\�
��������� ���� Sujan and Bettman(1989)WYoo et al.(2000)-á&��Ý�W
pû©��de�fDWá�Iæ-��;W{;��?*up4�üýde�f�Ë&E�
��W:�<oþ*up��de�f&�?�W)�&?r�;�hiDj?k;�up��
de�f©W�ä����e�4�de�f�gæ���?�0���?*u�ߦO0p7.
����æjæu;|p1.��\r�æj{-?u�����càÓ�\���ætWp4�
üýde�f�Ë&E���W:�<oþ*u�ÅÆ�D 0.458�÷;�\��;|��Í
º0}ñ�\��w�ѦO&I*Ö×ØÙX© 71.6ÚW.�Ûº@^³��°^� αF©
0.882�ÇrW�>0¤¥&ì)*�
������ ���� m��_`&��Ó�\�-*,¢&�Ý�»��ܬa
b7 ��0���W�>�>�ܬab7 ��&Ä?�Ü?\?W�?\?�jæde
�f0�º����|�\�-Ä�� ��0��Jþ*��Do�*��©��-�e
_`�:þ-D|����|�\�ø�¤¥&©W��ܬab7 ��0��E�\
º0¤¥&¬?�?*�KL�©p��de�f©á�3�:;<�);u����Wp5.
[Lõö&Ir:;<*u;|p1.[L��\r:;<-?u�����càÓ�\��;
��·¸Dîï¤ð&-��Ä|¹W���&����2 �-|-?��;|WKL�
©ø¤¥;|}ñ�\�
��������� Yoo et al. (2000) WBeaty and Kahle (1988) -á0ó¿&Wpû©��d
e�f0!?�&��?*@"#��?*Fup��de�f©ûD?t$%&&�de�f
cE*up����de�fD5&E>$W4�de�f©�{-?u�ѦO0p7.���
�æjæu;|p1.��\r�æj{-?u�����càÓ�\�-ÄWL'�de�fR
³�(��);|�*Å+@,- 2002F�. /�Í0)*13cWp³�(�(loyal)u�
?æ!20p!?�@PatronageFu���¬?\�·¸WÅÆ�©)3�õö&ÇrW86.2Ú
�ØÙXW.�Ûº@^³��°^� αF© 0.949�õö&Ç?��;|����ѦO�
�¤¥&¬?*�
��� ! � �@LikingF©WSankar@1999F���0¬?\�4������ �&
ý{þ������\��\56©WChaudhuri (1993)�7'«� 80�%èp�r�9:
����
©W��de�f0Æ;�Wá�r|?<l0=|>*�j?�);�u@����F0¬?
\�å?>]?© Price and Arnould(1999)���c[�½¾�Ç?pû©@97A9&W�
�de�f0BC@D__�F�\��DE*u0E¬W4de�f�FG0 ¡�-?�
�@search motivationF©HI-��DJ;�\��;|1K�LM·¸0ó¿&p��d
e�f0$%�\Õ�W4�de�fDN&-��W40O3\��DE*u�?�\¦O
0PÀ\��\Þ�$�ùú©WpÞ$%)*Q�W��de�f�$%0ùú)*u@�
���F��\�$���7±L�$%.R-á© IpsosS�1K��ã¬���OT·¸
0ó¿&Wîï¤ð&L?�D=|>*Iæ-§Uc&VW0�Ó�\�-ÄGH���
���&¾{*��©Wde�f�XY�V�·¸0]��)�Z�\ÕW�VX©�[d
e�f��V2J0\�Vºc}]�\^�_�`cE*�U"�V©W[`&�VJ>\
de�f&p»u�aeZ0b�W�>Ðñ©p�u��\c?�ͺcE*�
c���� !�:;*#��dNOPQe F!fgPfh[iTj�k@
Pc%¹öx%�:�$�����l+���.>¹ö,@��%�í=%¼w��#
χ2>172@#p<0.000#GFI¬0.900#AGFI¬0.866#CFI¬0.954#RMSEA¬0.066#Kû�#
;Hð=��&�awχ2�B!�n�n�aw�û��F^�>�!ä�#ä_ð2005@#
�Ó��Â�p^�I¡K�û���í=%K��+�-#GFI % 0.9 +<�C�_
�.�FK�%�í=+êa[��X+�[�_%} �j�_B!Kû�.�
78V9 ��� !�:;�=>#l%NOPQe F!fgPfh[�k@mn
����
��������
��
� ���
��
������������
�������������
��������
����
��� !"#
���
$%&'(
���
)*+,�
���
����
-./0�1���
234�56��
+78��9���
���
���
��
��� ��
/:�
���
���
;<=>
���
=>?�
���
���
���
@A,BC
�
��
���
��
���
�
DEFG9
���
���
����
��
���
���
���
������
���
���
���
HIJK����
LMN
���
������
��
���
�������
��
O$ P��
��
��
���
��
��
���
��� �����
�
��
��
���
���
��
��
��
���
��
���
��
��
�
���
���
��
���
���
o�p�q�rs
¸�n�l�jj©M×�mj�Kû�.�#±×Fý!�#Ã��%ST�j�_Â
�#×�F�n��lFn�.�Î�#èé%�I�j�_èéê�Ã��.^s^�#
vµ� +�{����òn£Fn�>î´ 1997#p.79@�F^�#èé%X+F�_%
ý!�nm3�:��+�-�5%���/0[�.¡8Ú�n�F�-.�
����
78V9 tuOv!w�x4y�mn
���������
� � ����� ���� ����
��� � �� �� ! ��"! ��#! $$$
%&� � �� ��''# ��(' ��## $$$
�� � )�* ��"' �� + ���'# $$$
)�* � ,-./01 #�� �� + ���'" $$$
)�* � 23* �� #' �� " ���( $$$
23* � 4567897 ��(+� ��'# ���' $$$
,-./01 � 4567897 ��!( ��(' ���"# $$$
4567897 � :;<=>?@ #�#!" ��"#" ��#� $$$
%&� � ABCDE� #���� �� �
:;<=>?@ � F-9GCHIJ ���"+ ��(#( ���## $$$
4567897 � =>K* #�! ��"! ��#(� $$$
��� � L�MN #���� �� #
%&� � F-9GCHIJ ���++ ��!' ���! $$$
��� � ��L� !��#� �� ( ��##! $$$
=>K* � OPQRS ��#++ ��#( ���' $$
%&� � OPQRS #�!' ��( ( ��#' $$$
��� T %&� ��"+� �� #' ���++ $$$
�UVWXTUYZ[ $$$\]^����#_$$\]^���#
V`8ab
�éX+^�c��F#|H1-a. p:óF%Óó%RSST}�ã ��.�%%#|H1-b.
p:óFý!�}|H1-c. %ÓóFý!�}%qr%ST����n^�.�|H2-a. ±×#
Ã��#p:ó#%Óó%í%RSST}�st��.�nj#|H2-b.±×#Ã���ý
!�Fí%ST}�O�_�èé�j��±×+Ô9�.ý!Á%} Fn�_�.�F
^�ù¥ã ��.�Â�_ý!^�e9ñ=�äFÃ��Á%} #Â%Â�h�^�
%�â�!Á%} ��A��_j�#|H2-e. e9ñ��ä��â�!ìH!Fí%S
T}�ã ��.�r.#|H2-d. e9ñ��ä�:� Ç�Fí%ST}��â�!ìH
!+ÖÈ.ST^�ù¥ã Fn�.�|H3-a.:� Ç��p:ó}%ST�B!Fn�
n^�.�#|H3-b.:� Ç��%ÓóFí%ST}��Ú%��C^�%Óó%�9
HIäæïC�#��r�^�UVn]��]^4} �B!Kû�.�FKù¥ã �
�.�Aaker>1991@%�4Ã��Fe9ñ��ä%qr%ST�B!Fn�n^�.�
njôµ%X+^��°O^%Q��û�.�r>©¡�#��a���j�_�%Óó
3��p:ó�R°#F���p:�n;óF�_%��B�$%ðe!�9ð�nEö
ó®/=F�_%|��+3°}F�#¦¨���¼�}F�4/=nm�R°/0[��
���PÇ��F�ù��_�.�#��%Óó�j��idóäx�ó�����ò
nmDKû�.���íä�äu�OOû��%��B�$�j�_�x�ó�E6��
_���F�Ò8K�.�r.èé�3�±×�ý!+¯¡�L$ò1Kû�#ÔD
+5¡.�í=+���.!Z����û�.F�-���%1Ã+�ô�õ¡���^
���^�%G8HI%Fn�Kû©4�Â�_e9ñ��ä��òKû��%%#
����
�â�!ìH!��Ã��%/0�R°#Â%�â�!ìH!�}�â3��:� Ç�
ÁF�·n4} �R��F�E��.���B�$Îó�¸��^���n��#�
%��B�$�j�_���FÇ��ùD�.|Æ%e9ñ��ä}>Dick and Basu 1994@
��A��_��F�-��r.�9HIäæïCF�Ú%��C%} %STnm^
�#=Ð��®[�îdåHð8$F�_%%Óó�:� �j�_�òKû��F�/
ÍK�.�nj#�%34n;9<=��F��#ùG8HI�Û+�n%|9å#
$æçH}+ñ���_��¿|Û+�n%ÛK%��uä��u}�3�#��B
�$dÓ%�J+��õ¡#EG��B�$®lm%åH�$��!²%�+ÖÈ.b
䪸���Kû�F3ê��-_���
�^�ùpK#�°O^%`þ�û��îÚó®��B�$%r=r�#<�ónm�
�í3��Kû�.�F^���^�A�2·�+Ên^�.�F#|UVn]�}�¢[
���ûh.�#èéê�3�_�H�< !%�k��n��>Kû��û_�r��
w�%í$����_��%K�í3��%Ì�FÎ�ô�#���.�������¸
�nêÚF�_%�í=%ù óKû��µ�#�%X+���íä�äO7%o��B
�$�j��G8HIä��$æçHæ�ðK�^n�®Kû��F^�#Ï%��B�
$�j�_��'�G8HIä��$æçHæ�ð%�Ú�O�_E�_�°ÜsKû
��
z{|} À÷òn�%+J\#�+�.î3�y�Ò~²
Aaker, D.A.(1991), Managing Brand Equity: Capitalizing on the Value of a Brand Name, The Free Press�D.A.��������� �������������������� !"#$%&�'!()��*�1994+,-
Barsalou, L.W.�1985,, "Ideals, Central Tendency, and Frequency of Instantiation as Determinants of Graded Structure
in Categories", Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 11(4), pp.629-654.
Cohen, J.B. and K Basu (1987), "Alternative Models of Categorization: Toward A Contingent Processing Framework",
Journal of Consumer Research, 13 (March), pp.455-472.
Dick, A.S. and K. Basu (1994),"Customer Loyalty: Toward an Integrated Conceptual Framework," Journal of the
Academy of Marketing Science, 22(2), pp.99-113
Loken, B., L.W. Barsalou and C. Joiner (2007), "Categorization Theory and Research in Consumer Psychology:
Category Representation and Category-Based Influence", in Haugtvedt, C.P., P. Herr and F. Kardes (eds.),
Handbook of Consumer Psychology, pp.133-163.
Rosch, E. (1978), "Principles of Categorization", in Rosch, E. and Lolyd, B. (eds.), Cognition and categorization,
Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, pp.27-48.
./01�1995,�2������ !"#3456789:;��<=>?@34&�2�2,�1A21BC
./01�1999,�������DEF#�G5HI&�JKC
./01�2006,�2����LM8NO5FP!�;��.�QRST�UVDW�&�9�26A35BC
XYZ[�2006,�2Q�\"#�GQRST�U5]^_;��Business Insight&�54�6-19BC
�`�abcd�1995,�2�����T)e�fg����hiT�jfk5lmn34;�<=>?@34&�2�2,�23A35BC
]opq�2007,�2rs��"te��uvw����g�"te��xy����Q�\"#�G8�"te�z{y����Q�\"#�G;��|}~4&���}��}|}34��54(4)�47A60BC
�����1997,�2�����5��;��������<=>��5��5x�}&�����C
� ���2002,������NO z&�¡¢£��C z¨
����
��������� ��������
���������
ÕÖÔÙ��µ���¸Ý¸Ý5� ��� õ
�
1. �ȡ�
ÚD� $}$�$��!+�È¡F�.��7+P4_g*K��]fß�zm[
�Í]�X�_����%34nfßê��èéê%�+]+�È¡F�.O7G8H
I�C[�õ%I{+��#O7G8HI%89:;9<=%jku+ß�_��F�
����O7G8HI+`a���[�ì$�$F�_��89:;9<=%jku��
~¡+^��eHd«8$F�_G8HI+xA[�34nfgp +��[��F�ê
ÚFn�_���
G8HI%eHd«8$u�S[���F�_�ÎsG8HI%�$ ���3�ò7
%��>à0,1995; 7#,1998@®î3�ê�3�G8HIõ+��.ò7��>¨�ä
�ë,1995@�èéê�3�67;óõ+��.ò7��>�,2002@nm��h����
�^�����%��K��G8HI�fg���aKû�_g�hK%01Ò�+�
�.ò7��%�®��¯��_�n��
���K��¨�%34n8Ú!6%{���7G8HI%_g�hK%fg01p
FeHd«8$u%ST�O�_sª��.-���7G8HI%eHd«8$u�]�
.�h01ò7+��[��F+]�F[��
2. PÇ��%�KÏ$
>1@� eHd«8$G8HIF�
eHd«8$G8HIF��¨�ä�ë(1995)�3�F�|B�C§��.�_`a
�mD��nj^Ovi+Ê_��G8HI}+w[���K%|B�C§}F�%
Ó��|5Dz¨}F.-��_���
|G8HI%R�}F�4�®K%G8HI����b-¿g¨õ®`aæïCn
m%`aA++8ÚF[��®�û���G8HI%9èc®e9ñ=�äF��.
èéê%�Ç+��[��®�ß��9ì$Î%R�®���F��.y!+8ÚF
[��®nm�&Ò&'Kû�(7#, 1998@��|m�Z�BT�äBX��_��^}
F�4�®K%.-p�M>��&°n��Î��'%��K��|BT�äBX�}
F�4�®K%����FYm���n���%��%¦FOF�_�|î67��
%5�ü�K�î��G8HIè+rF4%�&�%�C���'K��ùG8HI
è%{K%�'G-�89HªlKû�}>g°,1993@�F^���'K�îG8H
I%���&�ü�F�n��|BT�äBX�}�_��G8HI�ÖbFn�_
����ó�û��F��h����
����
>2@� eHd«8$G8HI%B(ó
��K��eHd«8$G8HI%B(ó�O�_wz[���#c%Ö��m�
Z�BT�äBX��_��^}F�4�®K%.-p�M>��&°n��.Z��
|G8HI%R�}%ì��!+wz�.��^��eHd«8$G8HI%B(ó
�O�_�°O^ÇaK���
Aaker(1991)��G8HIäî<9�ä>ÖU@%�A%ì��!F�_�|��F
ÔD�ä¸[��O�_�FÎ�R¸�n�_�°}�|�Nã%���|��.F
�_�E9op�õ°b ���Í]�û�}�F+wz�_���r.��G8H
Iäî<9�ä�A%�òòÁF�_�h_��|G8HIe9ñ=�ä}%ì��
!F�_�|�$��äHdä� !%uv}�|!�$Iä�f��Î}�|î3�P
%�1}�|}~¨%�¢�CÇ[�.¡%§��Ü}+wz�_���
���¨�ä�ë(1995)��|ÕÖ*ê%}ã$ª¸�C�_�ì$�$�ò-â=
�~¨�id%}ã$Ö×+Ru2·�+-n°n�_�_��Û�Â%ùOF�_
eHd«8$�B(n¶�+´4}F�434��eHd«8$G8HI��ÕÖ*
ê%f999Hdä}ã$%ª¸�C[�}ã$f8H %b %ø×Kû��F+
wz�_���
>3@� eHd«8$G8HI%fgÒ�
eHd«8$G8HIKû��F���'Unì��!�û��F+wz�.��
`a�01��_��G8HI%4��eHd«8$�ÑÐ[�G8HI�m%°�
�+¦¡_��%Kû©4^���(2008)K��÷òòï$H_g* 11 ��% POS
í$�+��1997D�1999D�2001D*2003D�Qg��.îQgO7%OmC
§>1D�Ã�2*4D�5Dz¨@�%O7C9����A�%�ä+��_��>¹
ö 1@���K�4|OmC§� 5Dz¨}%O7+eHd«8$G8HIF.-�F�
eHd«8$G8HI%O7C9���A���1997D�� 34ÕKû�.%��2003
D�� 9ÕFn�_���ùp�|OmC§� 1D�Ã}%O7+jÙG8HIF.-
�F�jÙG8HI%O7C9����A��1997 D�� 33ÕKû�.%��2003
D�� 45Õ�n�_������%¶·^��îO7C9��%OmC§%jku�
�Ç�_j��eHd«8$G8HIF�_`a� X[�O7C9���ån°n
�_���F��^��
����
�� 1� ������ ��������������1997��2003��
>�µ@��(2008)
>4@� eHd«8$G8HI%ò7
eHd«8$G8HIF�_`aK X[�.¡%ò7+wz�.����°O
^�h����
¨�ä�ë(1995)��î3�ê�3�G8HIõ+��|��u67%PQ�`
a��}�|67�H«ð!%´u�ºÌu�7�¦su}�|67%K�ó%iA}�
|èéê%Ìu�w�2.m¼äÌß}�|�ù�H«ð!%�FK67f�î$æç
H+O��}�|æïC%ª¸ä67%���]¨}% 6®+wz�_���
à0(1995)��ÎsG8HI%�$ ��+��|�PF%�âÏã�$æçH+
����O}�F+wz�_���7#(1998)��$ ��+��|G8HI%
ùDó}�|ªl�3�`a¼Ç}�|G8HI%íîó}�|G8HI%^Xó}+�h
_���
�(2002)��Q%�f9<�d� �¡¢£%O7��B�$+CX��,»ÙO
7�j�_èéê�õ°õ�_��67;ó+���_���Â%X+�b-¿Q
%K��|]}�|¤�}�|�¶}�d� K��|¥é}�|]}�|íÏ9H}�ò
7F�_�h��_���
���
���
���
���
���
���
���
���
���
���
���
��
��
�
�
�� ��� ��� ��� ��� ���
� �������
�������
��� �������
���� �������
���� �������
��� ���� ����
����
>5@� eHd«8$G8HI%ò7�S[���%êÚ
#K��PÇ��%�KÏ$+ÖÈ_�eHd«8$G8HI%ò7�O�_w
z�.��^�����%PÇ��K��67�H«ð!®67;óa%67�~�
K%wz�Û+Fn�_j��%Ó��m%°��%]Ö+b [�¿¼�%^�
m%ò-â=K01[�¿¼�%^�m%°��%��ä��01[�¿¼�%^
a�]�~�ò-â=�~�ðe�$æçH�~�K%ò7wz� �Kn�®�
F���G8HI�Ò5�� ���aKû�_g�hK%u�äðe�$æçH0
1%Ò�+��.ò7���Ç��_�n�®�êÚF�_�h����
ùp�_g�hK%u�äðe�$æçH01%Ò�F�_�Â��%(++wz
�.���&.��.��Â%®+n/�.��F�_�æï=:äíä ð�9%
(+(ëðä7#, 1989)��hðe�$æçH%g¨(+(¦¢ä§}, 1994)��hðe
�$æçH%èéê9G�/�K%(+(@o, 2006)a�û���^����%���
j�_��eHd«8$G8HIF�_BC§���_`a�Om[�.¡%�®K
%9�%�����_�n��
3. ��í$�%¤ò
���K��#Kwz�.êÚ%{���7G8HI%_g�hK%u�äðe�$
æçH01FeHd«8$u%ST�O�_sª��.-���7G8HI%eHd«8
$u�]�.�h01ò7+��[����K��eHd«8$F�_`a�Om[�.
¡%�89:;9<=%���F%ò7��+Ç4���S F�_�]�Ì�+ 1�O
m�0�¨©�F[� 2 eÎ �ä�<µª��+¼a��1 D]Om[�.¡%ò7�
2 D]Om[�.¡%ò7�F�434�Dv�F���+Ç��ùDv�j�_Om�
/0[�]+��[��
��;Hð=��2001 D*2003 D�Qg��.�«¬7 16 ��B�$�;[� 8,068
C9��Kû��.Z��2 D]z¯�Om�.C9��+CXF�_���_���C
9��� JAN �$Ip�n�.¡�G8HI%�ãÏ$C=�±4 JAN Ìß����
K��f$�_�n��
���¼a�.�h01òÁF�´Ì���´Ì��Aaí$�´:�¹ö 2 ��[�
�>�%w����® 2���j�� 2002D*2007D% 6D§%Ò¯í$�3��A
�_���
����
�� 2� �� !"#$%&'�('�)�*+,-
r.���%st�t(1)�n��
��� +++=
)1=(1
)1=(
lognnmmll
YERDMYδCTDMYγIDXβα
YP
YP
�
� � � � ïïïïïïï(1)
� ��K�
P(Y=1)�67�Om[�c
IDXm���w� l> l ¬1��ÖæïC, 2��Ö PI>sX@, 3��Ö PI>Îg@,
4�Îg�c>�Öp@, 5�°_�c, 6�°_u�:ï$ �, 7�ýÖ12c,
8:ýÖ´� �ÖæïC@
CTDMYn���B�$�â$Ì� m> m¬1��$Ä�Hä:��! ð��I, 2�
ò$�, 3�9H �H!��$, 4�Å/Ùk��$, 5�§$ â�< , 6�L-H
íääL-8ì=, 7�òç��$!, 8�òÏ$9HÄ�, 9�K ��!ä<�L
$, 10�!°ÎÏ$ , 11�±²:�$f$, 12��$�$I�H<, 13:ü�³ä´
³I�H<, 14: �$>I�H<, 15:K$=, 16:�LÏ$=±@
YERDMYn�QgD�â$Ì� n> n¬1�2001DQg, 2�2002DQg, 3�2003D
Qg@
α�s�, βl���w� l%}8ì$�, γm���B�$�â$Ì� m%}8ì$
�, δn�QgD�â$Ì� n%}8ì$�
������ ��� � �����
���������
�����*
��**����*
���������
�����
���� ��!"
#$%&�
#$�'(���
*�����������
**������������������� !"���#$%&'(�
��������������� !"#$%���
������&'()���*+,-�.%/01"23456���
������&'()���
�)*+
��,-.*+
'(/01*+
����
njt(1)K����B�$Îó�QgD�3�/0+A��_j��CX 16 ��B�
$% 2001D*2003DQgO7%� �Í]F�_.-��F�K���
4. ��X+
���%X+Fn��89:;9<=D�%OmÁ%/0T�+¹ö 3��[�1D]
��|� 12c}z�%]�B!Fn�_���2D]��|Îg�c>�Öp@}z
�%]�B!Fn�_���3D]��|�ÖæïC}�|sX�Ö PI}�|°_�c}�
|ýÖ12c}�|ýÖ´� �ÖæïC}�B!Fn�_���4D]�� |�ÖæïC}�
|sX�Ö PI}�|°_u�:ï$ �}�|ýÖ12c}�B!Fn�_���5D]��
|�ÖæïC}�|Îg�Ö PI}�|Îg�c}�B!Fn�_���
�� 3� .�/0�12����3456� β
5. ��
��X+�O�_�|g¨Ò¯�K%ò7}�|�hu�äðe�$æçH�K%ò7}�
|ýÖ� ê%� Ç��K%ò7}% 3®^���[��
>o@�g¨Ò¯�K%ò7
g¨Ò¯�S[�w�Fn��|��B�$�ÖæïC}�|sX�Ö PI}�|Îg
�Ö PI}�O�_��F���B�$�ÖæïC��ùD�j�_í%/0�û
��sX�Ö PI��3D]rK�í%/0�û���4D]��%/0Fn�_�
��������� ���� ��� ����� ��� ���� ��� ���� ��� ��� ���
������ � �� ��� � � ��� � � � � � � ��� � �
������ � � � ��� � � � ��� � � � � � ���
�� !"�#$% � �� ��� � � � � � � � � �
&'()! � � �� ��� � � �� ��� � � �� ��� � � � � �
&'*+,��-. ���� ��� � � // ��� � � �� � ���� ��� � � ��
0123! � �� ���� ��� � /� ��� � �� � � � /
01�45��� � �� ��� � �� ��� � �� ��� � � � � �
6789:9;<=>>9?�
@AB=>C=DC=9?�
EFGHIJ.
��� ��KL$M9���KL$M9��KL$NOP
����
/M �/ �M��� �M��� �M��� �M��
���� �� � ���� ����
�QR
�� � ���� � /� � /� ���
�QR �QR �QR �QR
����
��Îg�Ö PI��2D]rK��%/0�û��
���%Í]^��eHd«8$G8HI%ò7F�_���B�$�ÖæïC
+^X���K�_���F��òKû���^�Â%g¨�Ö��Îg%Ò
¯�zm2>�sX%Ò¯KùsI����_���F��òZF�4�?+
��F�K���
>x@��hu�äðe�$æçH�K%ò7
�hu�äðe�$æçH�S[�w�Fn��|Îg�c}�|°_�c}�|°
_u�:ï$ �}�O�_��F�Îg�c��1 D]��í%/0�û���2
D]z¯�/0�n�F�4¶·Kû��°_�c��3D]rK��%/0�û
��°_u�:ï$ ���1D]��í%/0�û���2D]z¯��%/0F
n�_���
���%Í]^��îO7F�_%Qg��K��Îg�3�� jk�¾-n
������op�~-_�°�F��òKû��r.:ï$ �+&°�_�
��+õ¡�01��òZF�4�?+Ê��F�K���
>,@�ýÖ� ê%� Ç��K%ò7
ýÖ� ê%� Ç��S[�w�Fn��|ýÖ12c}�|ýÖ´� �Öæï
C}�O�_��F�ýÖ12c� 1D]��/02>�2D]z¯��í%/0�
û�F�4¶·Kû��ýÖ´� �ÖæïC� 1 D]^� 3 D]rKí%/0�
û��
���%Í]^��îO7F�_%Qg 1 D]���� ê%µ!+�h�>1
2c%¨�@�F3���e9ñ=�ä�A>ýÖ´� �ÖæïC%¨�@��
òKû��� ê%µ!+�h�ê�� 2 D]z¯��ò�n�_°�F�4�?
+Ê��F�K���r.�%Í]��îO7Qg�����h�¶c%¨�®î
O7%Äa� c%¨��·Ð�n�F�4���%ì$�$%îO7fgp¸�
C��Â%B(ó+m¡_���_k�Mò�û�%K�n�^F�4�?�¾-
_°���
6. rF¡Fô�%êÚ
���%���3����7G8HI%eHd«8$u�]�.�h01ò7+��[
��F�K�.�Î��îO7Qg��K%ýÖ12cFýÖ´� �ÖæïC%ST��
��7ì$�$�deG8HI+xA�_�°.¡%G8HIä�âÏã�$æçH%û
�p�C��B(n�?�n��F�C+K���
����j��O��.êÚ�O�_�Ø 1�����%��K���hz�K%�â
����
Ïã�$æçHê�®G8HId4%O7Ja��¯K�_�n�®��h����Ø 2
��G8HI%�ãÏ$C=�3�89:;9<=%^Xó+�¯K�_n�®��h�
���Ø 3��èéê%89: �9=®+/¶��%/0>G8HI�C[��â�!
ìH!a@+�¯K�_�n�®��h����
��¼½
Aaker, D.A.(1991), Managing Brand Equity, Free Press.
7#¹!(1998), |eHd«8$äG8HIu%67FêÚ}, ¾�$��äHdäÎ-$
¸=À, Ø 69Ñ
à0µ¢(1995), |G8HIZ��G8HI%WÒ+�´K��} ,� ¾�$��ä
HdäÎ-$¸=À , Ø 55 Ñ
¨�ºá , �ë»(1995), |eHd«8$%"/FÂ%�~},� ¾�$��äHdä
Î-$¸=À , Ø 59 Ñ
¦¢qúä§}¼(1994), ¾«$= ïðe�$æçH―Â%/", ��S , �~―À, �
¼½.
@o¾(2006), ¾�~�èéêÇ�"À, ÁÂÃÄ.
�¿�(2002), |B»ÙO7%`aó�S[���}, ¾NÙÏÔÕÝÀ, Ø 40ÐØ 5Ñ
ëð>Êä7#¹!(1989), ¾�h��FèéêÇ���―��´� Ç���FÂ%&�
―À, "¼�î´e.
��õ(2008), |�hK%G8HIxA%�9H!}, ¾¨hj3k PB ª¸��{�j
��¸æç¸=äG8HIxA�~«â¸$À, ÕÖÔÙ��µ.
����
��������� ����
����������������� !"#�$%&'()*��
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
ÀÁݸݸÝ5� ÃÍ� ´�
"7��89:.1:��
����î�C�$��äHd�S|�.��Kû��Î�¥ë%TêÃ���j��
¥ë§�¬���3��¥ëÎó+´�^�[��F+��]���_���
��'%¥ëêóu%eìw���WDrKî''Têw�>Ä^�w�� ÅÆǬ
Å��¹È�É��ÆÊË��ÇÌÍÊ�ÎÏ�Ð�@nm�&Ò&'nw��1Q��_����^� ÅÆÇ%34
nª� <í$�Z�K�Ñ'%TêÃ����J��n�F%wz�û��¥ëÑ'Á
%Ò�Å�%Mòó�q¡��_���
���K�î''Têw�+#$ ��8+Q<���' » �`%¥ëÑ'ÁÒ�Å�
+Ç�.�Â%X+�eìw�FÒ�Å�X+�����û��r.�¥ëÎó�1Ã
��X+^���'ù,Kn°ù¥ë�3�_idó%³D1Ã���Ò�Fn��¥ë
��û��F+´�^��.�
�
;,<,=�
� eìw��î''Têw��î�C�«��äHd�¥ë§�¬�1Ã���
�
>?@ABC�
� ÚD�|¥ë}F�4�®K�eì�ÔÙ+�qÂ4F�4Õ���]u�OOû��
���%Õ�3�)*��F3�ÇÓ{S�j�_�î�C�$��äHd%���õ
r�_���ù ��î�C�«��äHd�`a%L�u+Ç��¥ëÎó®èéêÇ
���X+^�¥ë�è:%�«��äHd+01�_���Ö��¥ëÎó�èéêÇ
���&ö��_��eìw�+êa���+Ç�_����
� ùp�¥ëÎó+ûü[�¾��èéê!6�Ìu�_��ôü�lm%ª� <í«
�«Z�K� �Kn��F^�id�Å�+Ç�n��¿n�n�aw��-�����
����Ò�Å�+ÒÓ��î�C�$��äHd%ù��j��lmí«�FÒ�Å
�%ST+����¥ë§�¬+Ç4��
��'%eìw���E%ÌuFF��î''Têw��''$ýÅ�w��'Ja
�1Q��&ö��_�.�ùp�&ö��_��eìw��C�����n"��"È
��_����
�%34n�"+����"¼K�Ñ'Ã���S[�eìw�FÒ�Å�%ST+�
¬��[��nj��"¼K�&�{S�Ç�.eìÅ�+ª�í«�F�����C�
Ñ'Á%Ò�Å�+��í«�Fs>�_����
����
���K�eìw�%¸¥�+î''Têw�>ªÔÕ@�j��w�%s>+êa�
_���ªÔÕ% ÖO%Tê{ëw�+#$ ��Ñ'TêÃ���S[��8>�{ë
×Û]¬,x�8@+Q<���' » �`%Ñú>̬ØÙÚÚÛ@ÁÒ�Å�+ÒÓ�.��
���%]���eìw�>ª�í$�@FÑ'!6Å�>��í$�@F%ST+´
�^��_�°�r.�Å��`%Ñ'TêÃ��X++1Ã���3��³D�nò1
+��Ò����¥ë§�¬��+Ç4��
�
D?�EFGH$@AIJ�
KLM� EFGH�
� ��'%eìw�%Eö�nbF�_��ª� <í«�%î''Têw�FÑ'CH
�«!Å��3�''$ý�Å�a�BèKû����'�j��&%Ã��Å�� ØÛܶ
D�''$ý�Å�/{ì�ü�ú%Ã��+Qö�.F�©^� r��ØÛܶ D�|�
Ý}�S[�Ã��Å�>´É�GÞý"Å�@�ÒÓ��.�''% ßÚÕ�WD%Tê
�|Ã�}F�4X+�Qö���Ñ'Å����.|Ã��}F�_ûü��.�F
%!Z�¸����^���%''$ý�Å�� ØÛܶ D^� ¸ DI���'3�%Å�K
�àáâ�%Ã��Å�X+F�n�_�n��ùp�Ä^�w�%î''Têw�>ÅÆÇ@
��ÚÜ�àáâ��L�u��X+�&ö��_j��î�C�$��äHd+Ç4aw
���k�nª� <í«�Fn��F�&9%Fj�Kû���
�
KLK� �NOPQGH�RST��
ôµ�Ò�Å������.î''Têw�>ÅÆÇ@��ØÛÜÚD%eìw�� r��
ØÛÜÛD>î$@eìw��ØÛÖ» D''Têw��ØÛÛ¶ D�î''Têw�FQ0�_�
��î''Têw�� ØÛÖ· DE�®���'%ùú¦F�%''µÊK�ýþ%!�ð<
8 �n�ùp�|Ä^�+Ò8K�n�}F%wz�n��.�F+����ãÔÙ)<
ä� ØÛÛ¶�D*ØÛÖÖD�1Q�.w�Kû��î''Têw���Ñ©�é®[�¶°F
��.�ê�Kn°�å|�£��F��.õ�nTêê���è]���O%ê�
{ë>Ñ©�é®[�¶°�x_��æ[�å|�Ý|�£��@+Qs��W ØÚ·w�
K�A��_����Ú%w�F�_� ¶··¶ D�1Q��.ç��%mïw�>ÆèÇ@�
û���
�
KLU� �NOPQGHVW�
� &ö��.î''Têw�>ÅÆǬÄ^�w�@+ha��� �âùe� ÖO%{ëw
�%¢[°_+<;���'8HLHdF�_Gà�_�.��Â%X+��0â� ØÛÛÚ
Dz¯|XM�é�â� ÅÆÇïQ%êD>ØÛÛ¸ D@^�|X�{MFn��&°%��
fk!��ÔÙ)<äF� �â�]���.���{M%���=+ë��.é�â%9
����
y�ü�ÔÙî3Á%�ìH!K|î''Têw��ù�àáâ%Ä^�%Ò�+ö��
_��F�"-n�}F����ØÛÛÛD^�î''Têw��&ö��_�n���
� �^��3ê�î''Têw�^��'8HLHd+&ö[��F��&°%��êF
�'�ì8+ O��&�Ö��3�eìw�F�_ <í«�+Qö[��F�!>%
û��FF�-��ô��¥ëêóu®§$æ-=�$��äHd+01[�¨K�eì
w�®&� <Öb���'%�ònÇÓÖUF"�_����
�
KLX @AIJ�Y%Z[��
� ���%]��eìw�>ª�í«�@FÑ'TêÃ��%Ò�Å�X+>��í«
�@%�¬��+Ç�Å�CX�`%¥ëÎó+���¥ë§�¬+[��F�û���
î''Têw��&ö���F��r·rn��êa�¾î''Têw�%�õ�^
��Â��Ñ©Ñ'�Ã��_��F�`�n�ÀFwz���&°%����¨�_�
���^��î''Têw��C�_��W¶K�wzä���_��Z��¬r�Ò�
Å�F%ST+´��_�n���
���ú§%Ã���Ä^��O�_%!6��úÂ�h�%÷���8��n�%K
û��3�_eì��%QF�a%ª� <í«��õ�^�F��_�ùú¦F�%
��x�.���ÔDa�Ø4%Kù¤�Ã��_��F��|�n���
�.��_�v%�+��[��F�K����
� í�
×�oäääî''Têw�%õI>ª�í$�@FÑ'Ò�Å�K%Ñ'Ã��X+>�
�í$�@F�ù��n���
� � � � � � �
v���'ù¥�ÑYK��úU%TêÃ��%w���ùF��-�°��Â%��
���Ñ©¥ë%@��öG�rÃ�eì��a�3�¥ë��û��F�ù ��/Í
K���3�_�Â��Ñ©ú%Ñ'Ã��%!6>³D!6@���'ù,Kn°¥ë
I�RØ[�F�-�����.��_�v%×�+��[��F�K����
� í�
×� ¶äääTêÃ��%!6>³D1Ã@�¥ëI�idó+ ��¥ë§���û���
�
\?]^_"�
ULM ]^ ��
°A ¶· D ØØS Øü*ضS ¸·ü�
ULK ]^`abc�
����
�'^�îï�ðñ��0�¸#�òóð`% » �`+$s�.�Å��`%$s��
�'��k_Eöó+B[��F�-�ãÔÙ)<ä%îTêÃ�w�%8HLHdF�
1Ã��^�%±:u>¸�`®�̧ �`®Úô�ü�Á¥ë�&õ¥ë@̂ �$s�.��
�0`>ØM�ü�Á¥Õ@�îï`>Ø»M�&õ¥Õ@�òóð`>¶ØM�&õ¥Õ@�
ðñ`>Ú·M�¸�`®Úô@�¸#`>ÚßM�¸�`®@K�ö��e�34�$s�
_����
ULU 0de2��
B(;Hð=�� ØÙÚÚÛ ÷>¶#»··÷+��� µv¬Ø#»»Ø ÷� µvc¬ß¶Õ�e(µ
²�¬Ø·¶÷@Kû�.��
ULX f[g�
�J�� >Î-�òìH!� ;Hð�Hd@�
ULh �di,:jI�
CH�$!%�8���¥K ¸Ö ]�Â%´ö��Ñ'TêÃ���S[��8¬¸¶
]>ªÔÕ¬Ö{ë×Ú�8@F;ó�S[��8¬¸]Kû���
ULk lmnopq�
î''Têw�% ÖO%{ë´>Ñ©�é®[�¶°�x_��å|�Ý|�æ[�£
��@%w�>o{ë� ØÛ*¶Úw��Qs��_��@+�ÎÖó%û�w�+ÛO%d
=$ð�<W��Â%d=$ð�C�_�8+Q<�.�µ²pt�ºÃ�®®ºÃ�m
��F��-n��®®Ã��Ã�% »��%�>�$! +êa�.��
�
r?��]^st�
XLM� uvw_"�
¹ö Ø �µ²ê%�;ó+�[�ù�`%°_;Hð=�ø¶Û· úKû�.�ùô�
c�ùó¬»ÖºÖÕ>Ö»¶ú@�ôó¬Úغ¶Õ>»ÛÜú@Kû�.�� �úê�c��B�¬
¶ÛºØÕ>Üضú@�e��¬»·ºÛÕ>ܸÜú@Fn�.�Dû��� ¶·*»· DE� ÖÖÕF
<�_�.��
�� ����� �� ����� �� ����� �� ����� �� ����� �� �����
��� ���� ��� ���� ��� ���� ��� ��� �� ���� ��� ����� � ���� �� ���� ��� ���� �� ���� ��� ��� �� ���� �� ��� ��� ���� �� ��� �� ��� ��� ���� �� ��� � ��� ��� ��� �� ���� ��� ���� ��� ��� ��� ����
����� �� �� �� ��� � ��� � ��� � ��� �� �������� �� ��� ��� ���� � ��� �� ���� � ��� ���������� �� ��� �� ���� � �� � ���� �� ��� �� �������� �� � �� ���� �� ���� �� ���� �� �� �� ���������� ��� ���� �� ���� �� ���� �� ��� �� ���� �� �������� ��� ��� �� �� �� ��� �� �� �� �� �� ���
������ !"!�
�
���
����
��������
��� ��#$%�&���' ()��$ *!+� ,-��$ !."� /0��� !12� 34��� *51�
����
XLK� xOyz{|}]^st�~��q��
¹ö ¶�ù�`�j��TêÃ��X+>Ö{ëI%°_ �C+ö�@Kû���
îï`�TêÃ��%°_ �Cü¸º·¸K�» �`%ÛK ¸MFn�.�ªÔÕ% Öê�
{ë%ÛK�Ñ©>¸º¶»@%op���õ°�£��>¸º¶¶@�å|>¸ºØ@����v�
Kõ��ùp�x_�>¸º·¸@�¶°>¶ºÜß@%op�®®I°�é®[>¶ºÜ»@���
I°n�_����
ðñ`�TêÃ��%°_ �Cü¸º¶ÚK�» �`%ÛK��õ° ØMFn�.�Öê�
w�{ë%ÛK�Ñ©>¸ºÚ»@�æ[>¸ºÚ¶@�å|>¸º¸ß@�õ��I�w��é®[
>¶ºÛß@�¶°>¶ºÛß@Kû��Î�Ñ©�x_��å|�Ý|�£��{ë� » �`%
ÛK�õ®+��.%�Î��Kû���
�0`�TêÃ��%°_ �Cü¸º·ØK » �`%ÛK ÚMF®®I�¥ëFn�.�Ö
ê�w�%ÛKÑ©>¸º¶»@�£��>¸ºØß@�å|>¸ºØ¶@�õ��I�w��é®[
>¶ºßÛ@�¶°>¶ºÜÛ@Kû��Î�é®[�¶°{ë� » �`%ÛKùXI�w�F
n�.��
¸#`�TêÃ��%°_ �Cü¸ºØ¸K »�`%ÛK ¶MFn�.�Öê�w�%ÛK�
æ[>¸ºÚÜ@�Ñ©>¸º¸Ü@�å|>¸ºØÜ@�õ°�I�w��£��>¸º·Ø@�é®[
>¸º··@�¶°>¶ºÖ¸@Kû�.��
òóð`�TêÃ��%°_ �Cü¶ºÛßK »�`%ÛK »MF��I�¥ëFn�.�
Ö ê�w�%ÛK�é®[>¸º·Ú@�æ[>¸º·Ø@�¶°>¸º··@�õ°�I�w��Ñ
©>¶ºÛ¶@�Ý|ý¶ºÛØþ�£��ý¶ºÖÛþFn�.�Î� ßO%{ë>Ñ©�x_��æ[�
å|�Ý|�£��@� » �`%ÛKùXI�+��.��
����� ���� ��� � ��� �� ���� �������������
��� ����
������������������
���� !"#$��
%&'�()��
%&'�*+��
��� �,-./�01234���
%&'��567��
��89:;<�
��=>?@ABCDE@F<G�
%&'��H��
,IJK�?@AB��
��LMNO��
PQR��S�TU��
PV�WQX��
��YZWQ[\��
��]^[\��
��_`[\��
��abcde[\��
��fg[\��
��hijk[\��
��lm[\��
���n����
%&'CWolm�pXqrRs��
��tuv[\��
��WQ[\��
�/uw�x)qr���
�/�yz{�|r}~�����
����q���j�������
����������
�����s$���
����e[\��
���� ���� ���� ���� ���
��������� �������������������
�����
�� ��� ����
��� ���� ��� ��� ���
�� ���� ���� ����
��� ���� ����
�� � ����
�� ��� ���� ���
���� ��� ���
�� ���� ��� ���� ��� ��� ����
� � ���� ���� ����
���� ���
���� ����
���� ���� ���� �� �
���� �������������������������
!" ���� ��� ���� ���� ���� ����
����
#$
%&� ���� ���� ���
�
����
XLU� h `aPQyz{�������
¥ëÎó+ûü[�ùO%S F�_1Ã���û���%1Ã��KÂ%¥ë%³D
��û�1Ã>�ò]@+��Ò���.�¸¶]%�8]�O�_mn�1Ã��
K1Ã+���.�1Ã��%ðe« � ¸¶]+÷1à �RSÇ��ðe��<
K�£µ���1Ã�+ <�$ð�! ���Å��`%1Ã�>�¾c »·Õ�A
B¬Øº·z¨+�¯@+¯s��1ÃRSÇ��3�eRSKû��F+E�.��
v�1Ã�¶ª� ·º¸z{%�%+uA���3��f���< Kq£µ��3�
1Ã��+ÒÓ��1Ãè+��.�¹ö ¸�ù�`%TêÃ��%1Ã��X++�[��
1Ã��X+^��ù�`%Ø Ø*¸ 1Ã�¾TêhYó1ÃÀ�M>����_���
r.�v��ã���la%���nQ<�S[�¾Tê,F�1ÃÀ�¸#`+A°�
Ï%�`�R��¶ªFn�_����_����
ðñ`��0`%Ø Ø*¸ 1Ã>Tê,F���x���TêhYó@��ù1ÃFn�
.�r.¸#`�Â%Ï% Ú�`%1ÃF��¡%1Ã�l> ¦��������Tê
hYó@Fn�.��
��������� ��� �� �� � ��������� ������� ������� ������� �������
������ !"#�
�$%&�'!(#�
)*+,-
)�+,-
)�+,-./%&�'!0#�
������1'!"#�
�$%&�(2!1#�
��345�((!"#�
67%&�('!1#�
�+,�89!0#�
��345�(8!2#�
��345�11! #�
:;%&�"!0#�
:;%&�"!0#�
������'!"#�
������ !0#�
�+,�8(!0#�
��������� �����
�������
�� �
<+,�89!9#�
�+,�8=!0#�
<+,�89!=#�
>?@��ABCDE�
��345�11!0#�
������"!0#�
�
v��ù�`�j��1ÃX+�O�_c����
�
XLULM� ��a����st�
îï`%1ÃÍ� ß1ÃK�Â%y��¶ª� »ÚºÖÕKû�.�Ø Ø1Ã�|v�}|�
l}|��}a%����S[��]%Ì��5r�¾Tê,F�1ÃÀFÙè�.�
Øx1Ã��|�xÓQ}�|d«��}|�ó�x}a%ü�Tê+[�¨K%Tê�
�% ßÌ��5r�¾TêhYó1ÃÀFÙè�.��
XLULK� ��a����st�
ðñ`%1ÃÍ� Ü1ÃK�Â%y��¶ª� »ÚºÚÕKû�.�Øù1Ã�|�l}|v
�}|Q<}a%����S[�ÛÌ��5r��¾Tê,F�1ÃÀFÙè�.�Øx
1Ã�|�xé}�|��×}|d�Q}a%ü�Tê+[�¨K%�x��% ÚÌ
��5r�¾�x��1ÃÀFÙè�.��
�
����
XLULU� ��a����st�
�0`%1ÃÍ� ß1ÃKÂ%y��¶ª� »¸ºÖÕKû�.�Øù1Ã�|v�}|�
l}|Q<}|��}a%����S[�æÌ��5r�¾Tê,F�1ÃÀFÙè�.�
Øx1Ã�|�ó�xÓQ}�|¹ÃÏÓQ}|d«��}a%ü�Tê+[�¨K%�
x��%�Ì�]�5r�¾�x��1ÃÀFÙè�.��
XLULX� ��a����st�
¸#`%1ÃÍ� Ü1ÃK�Â%y��¶ª� »Úº¸ÕKû�.�Øo1Ã�|Ãx_
%Q�%µJ}|åD��}|�xÓQ}| ¦¶·}a% ¦fk¦���S[� Ì
��5r�¾ ¦ä¦�1ÃÀFÙè�.�Øx1Ã�|��ÓQ}�|á�ÓQ}a%
ü�Tê+[�¨K%�x��% ÚÌ��5r�¾����1ÃÀFÙè�.��
XLULh� ���a����st�
òóð`%1ÃÍ� Ú1ÃK�Â%y��¶ª� »ØºÖÕKû�.�Øù1Ã�| ¦}
|Q�µJ}|7Þ-}|Öe}a%Tê���S[� ضÌ�5r�¾TêhYó1ÃÀ
FÙè�.�Øx1Ã�|�l}�|��}|v�}a%����S[� Ö]�5r�
¾Tê,F�1ÃÀFÙè�.��
�
XLX ������
» �`Ëw>ÌüØÙÚÚÛ@%1Ã��X+^� ÜO%1Ã>y<�¾cü»Øº»ÛÕ@�Tê,
F��TêhYó� ¦���� ���á�����¶���d��������.��
¹ö�Ú�����.�O%1ÃÊ®%°_+�[�Ø Ø1Ã%¾Tê,F�1ÃÀ��
òóð`%1ÃÊ®�õ°�îï`��0`�I�1ÃÊ®Fn�.�Øx1Ã%¾Tê
hYó1ÃÀ���0`�ðñ`�îï`�í%Ê®Fn��¸#`Fòóð`��%Ê
®Fn�.��
�`��è][�F�òóð`�¾Tê,F�1ÃÀF¾�¶��1ÃÀ�Ï%�`�
��õ°��C�¾TêhYó1ÃÀ¾ ¦b 1ÃÀ¾� ��1ÃÀ�I��¸#`
�¾á���1ÃÀ�V�°õ�Ê®Fn�.�ðñ`� ÜO%³D1Ã�í%+��
.��
�w��%X+��O%1ÃÊ®�¥ë�>æÕB!�û�� ¹Àº·»@�k��.��
>Tê,F���>Ú#ØÚÚÚ@ü¶·º·� ¹Àº·»�TêhYó��>Ú#ØÚÚÚ@ü¶Øº»� ¹Àº·»@�
¦����>Ú#ØÚÚÚ@üضºÖ� ¹Àº·»�� ����>Ú#ØÚÚÚ@üØߺÖ� ¹Àº·»�á�
����>Ú#ØÚÚÚ@üÜÛºÚ� ¹Àº·»��¶����>Ú#ØÚÚÚ@üØغÚ� ¹Àº·»�d����
�>Ú#ØÚÚÚ@üܺß� ¹Àº·»@�
v���w��KB!��EK�.%K�¹öæ�ù¥ë§%&��c�s%X+>¥
ë��n�ü��¥ë��û�¬×@+�[�Ø Ø1þTê,F�À��îï��0�ð
ñ�¸#§�¥ë��n���Â%Ï%�O%¥ë§��¥ë��û�.>�À·º·»@�Ø
�����
x1Ã%¾TêhYóÀ�îï�ðñ�îï��0�ðñ��0�¸#�òóð§�¥ë��
n���Â%Ï%MO%¥ë§��¥ë��û�.>�À·º·»@��'�¹ö »^��Ø
¸*�1Ã��¥ë��û��F��^���
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�?� Y%��$�������
hLM� Y%���
hLMLM� Yp>��� �
¾î''Têw�%õI>ª�í«�@FÑ'Ò�Å�K%Ñ'Ã��X+>��í«
�@F�ù��n��À%�é��¹ö ß�î''Têw�>ÅÆÇ{ë@CÒ�Å�X+%
�¬+�[��O%{ë�O�_�'°_>ªÔÕ%°_¬»·�Ò�Å�%°_¬
¸ºØ@3�¨µ�]����{µ�]�×�+��_���ªÔÕFÒ�Å�%ºù�
>�F×�×F�%¥�+��@� ¶»�µKû��ºù��µ%�c� ߸Õ>¶»�Ú·�µ@
Kû�.�r.ªÔÕ�õ°Ñ'TêÃ���I�� >̀ªÔÕ²Ò�Å�@�îï`�
�0`% ¶ �`Kû�.� �ªÔÕ�I°Ñ'TêÃ���õ��`>ªÔÕÀÒ�
Å�@�ðñ`�̧ #`Kû�.�Â%Û§%ªÔÕFÑ'TêÃ����%� >̀ª
ÔÕ¬Ò�Å�@�òóð`Fn�.�z¨%X+^��ªÔÕX+FÒ�Å�X+�w
��_�n�X+����Fn�.��
¹ö Ü��ªÔÕ �C>½»@FÒ�Å� �C>º»@% �C��¹KÛO%G
e�<¢*��Å��.�`+���Hd�_����
¢Ge�<�ªÔÕÅ��Ã��Ò�Å��Ã�{ëKÑÐ�`�e��±Ge�<�
ªÔÕÅ��Ã��Ò�Å��ºÃ�{ëK�0`�îï`��d��_���³Ge�
<�ªÔÕÅ��ºÃ�Ò�Å��ºÃ{ëKòóð`��Ge�<�ªÔÕÅ��ºÃ�
Ò�Å��Ã�{ëKðñ`�¸#`��d��_���z¨%X+^�î''Têw�
>ªÔÕ@�õ�^�F��_�Ñ'�Ã��_��F�ù¤���-n���+��
���.��
��������� �
����
����
����
����
���
���
���
���
���
��
��
�
��
��
�
�
��
�
��
�
��
�
��
�
����
��
��
��
���
��
�
�
�
���
����� ���� �� ��� ��� ��� ���
�� � � � � � � �
�� � � � � � � �
�� � � � � � � �
��� � � � � � � �
�� � � � � � � �
�� � � � � � � �
��� � � � � � � �
�� � � � � � � �
��� � � � � � � �
�� ��� � � � � � � �
���������� �������������
��
��
���������� ����
� !"#$%&
'(
��������� �
����
����
����
����
���
���
���
���
���
��
��
�
��
��
�
�
��
�
��
�
��
�
��
�
����
��
��
��
���
��
�
�
�
���
����� ���� �� ��� ��� ��� ���
�� � � � � � � �
�� � � � � � � �
�� � � � � � � �
��� � � � � � � �
�� � � � � � � �
�� � � � � � � �
��� � � � � � � �
�� � � � � � � �
��� � � � � � � �
�� ��� � � � � � � �
���������� �������������
��
��
���������� ����
� !"#$%&
'(
��5 ������� ����
�����
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
hL>LK� Y%D��� �
¾TêÃ��%!6>³D1Ã@��¥ëI�idó+ ��¥ë§���û�À%�
é�O�_��Ò�Å�X+^�1Ã���Â%³D1Ã+�é[���
¹ö ¸%1Ã��X+^��ù�`%Ø Ø*¸%1Ã�è][�F�Tê,F��Têh
Yó��x��� ¦��������� ��% ßO%1Ã�����.�ðñ`F�
0`%Øo*,1Ã�l�ÎÖó�û�.��Â%Ï%�`�ÎÖó�e�³D1Ã��
���_���Î�¸#`�Ï�`%1ÃF�¡%1Ã�l> ¦��������Tê
hYó@Fn�.��
z¨%X+^��¥ëI�3�_TêÃ��%³D1Ã��ÎÖó�n�F�4���
��Ò��n�.�&���X+>»ÕB!@^�¥ë��û�.��
�
hLK� �����
z¨%��X+^�ù¥ë%Îó+rF¡_k���� �
îï`��ªÔÕK�Ã�Kû�.��Ò�Å��ºÃF�4X+��.�Î�|é
®[}�|¶°}{ë�ºÃKû�.�ùp�³D1þTê,F�À�ã��Kû��ô
�%î�C�$��äHd01F�_��¶67®�aCé��ònòÁ�n�F"��
����
ðñ`��ªÔÕK�ºÃKû�.�Ò�Å��Ã��_��X+K�|é®[}|¶
°}{ë�ºÃKû�.�îïF�'��¶67®�aCé��ònòÁF�-�����
��0`��ªÔÕK����Ã��_���`Kû�.�Ò�Å��ºÃ%X+Kû
�.�Î�|é®[}�|¶°}{ë�I�+��_����
¸#`��ªÔÕK�ºÃKû�Ò�Å�K��'°_%EÖKû�.�|¶°}�|é
®[}�|x_�}{ë�C�_%01�MòF�-����Î�|x_�}{ë�C�0
1[��F�wr���� � � � � �
����
�
�
�����
�
�
����
���
� � �
��������� �����������
�
���
� �
����
��
� �
��������
�
�
�
��� �
�
� �
� �
�
�
�
�� � ��
� ��� �
�
�
�
�� �� ���
��� � ��� � ��� � ��� ��� � ��� � ��� �
�
�
�
�
� �
�
�
�
�
�
�
� � � �
� � �
� �
� �
�
� � ��
�
� � �� � �
� � �
�
� � � � � � � �
�
� � � �
� � � �
������� ������ ����
� � � �
�
� � � �
�������
���������������
����
���
��
�
��
��
��
��
�
�
�
�
�����
�����
�����
�����
�����
���
���
���
��� �
�A�����
�������������
������
��� PLI�������� �
�����
��
�
����
�
�
�����
�
�
����
���
� � �
��������� �����������
�
���
� �
����
��
� �
��������
�
�
�
��� �
�
� �
� �
�
�
�
�� � ��
� ��� �
�
�
�
�� �� ���
��� � ��� � ��� � ��� ��� � ��� � ��� �
�
�
�
�
� �
�
�
�
�
�
�
� � � �
� � �
� �
� �
�
� � ��
�
� � �� � �
� � �
�
� � � � � � � �
�
� � � �
� � � �
������� ������ ����
� � � �
�
� � � �
�������
���������������
����
���
��
�
��
��
��
��
�
�
�
�
�����
�����
�����
�����
�����
���
���
���
��� �
�A�����
�������������
������
��� PLI�������� �
�����
��
��������
���������������
����
���
��
�
��
��
��
��
�
�
�
�
�����
�����
�����
�����
�����
���
���
���
��� �
�A�����
�������������
������
��� PLI�������� �
�����
��
�
�����
�òóð`��ªÔÕFÒ�Å�X+�ºÃKû��Î�|Ñ©}�|Ý|}�|£��}
{ë�C�_Ñ'�ºÃ+U�_��%KÑ�&�%��æÒ®¥ë9#H!1�a%�
¯�MòF"�����
�
hLU �������
O��.êÚF�_� ¶®û��o®]�ôµ » �`+$s�Ò�Å�+ÒÓ�_�.
��î�C�$��äHd+�-�FÅ��`+ª¸�ßn��¬��+[�Mò�û���
¶ ®]��ôµ%���1Ã���3� » �`%³D1Ã+��Ò��.F�©rK�¬
r�_����ß�¥ëÎó+��{h�Â%¥ë%;ó®ªÔÕw�+����î�C
�$��äHd%01+´�^��_�°Mò�û���
ù ��¥ëÎó+��[�5���ª� <í$�Kû�eìw�+�F�_��
�î�C�$��äHd+Ç�_�.��ô���Ò�Å�>��í$�@��í$
�F�_�����Mòó�û�F"�����
����ôµ%Å�K�æ�`%k%��Kû�.��^�����%�`���'�
��_Â�n�%Î�+B�.¥ëKû�F�-����^���`§�¬��^�Â�
n�%Î�+���Ê.�F��!>�û�.F�-���F3���n�¥ë%���
�+[��F�3��X+%E+¹��F�q^2n�òÁKû��F��4rK�n
���
�
���¼½�� � �
>o@�î''Têw�>ØÛÛÖ*ØÛÛÖ@�ÔÙ)<ä''Tê»�� �
>x@�''Tê$ý�Å�>¶···*¶··Ö@�´Éá��
>,@�'J>¶··Ü@��üî3e��
>Û@��ë�j>ØÛÛÖ@¾�¬�$��äHdÀ�ÁÂÃÄ��
>æ@� �ùú>¶··»@¾eìÅ�%�§À�¼!"#��
>M@�Þë� Ì$���� ù¹>¶··Ü@¾¥ëÔÙÝ�°ÀBÈÉ��
>�@�¸ç� %>¶··ß@¥ë���°� ËþÔÙîGe�
>�@�&0� Ê>¶··Ö@&� <%ÓÔF�p� ü�õ"e�
> @�¨ë� ' >¶··Ú@�$��äHd�;$ò%/"FD � ü�õ"e�
>Ø·@�Û0� 2>¶··Ü@¹Í� ÔÙÈÓí$�G�<� Ý(ÃÄ�
>ØØ@ÛðFkÃ>2005@¾Ñ'Ã��¤¥%01FÓéõÀõ2ÔÙ¸Ý� ¥ëÓé
���
>ض@�_.� Ê>>2003@¾ú�Ö��3�¥p�`%�¬>o@Àõ2ÔÙ¸Ý� ¥ë
Óé��
>ظ@)�� *�>¶··¶@¾èé%¥ëÎó�S[���À+Ó��µSG�
>ØÚ@B#� à,�ßÐ� �Á>¶··Û@¾¥ëÑ'%Tê!6F]�À�ÔÙ«â¸$��
�����
��������� ����
ÕÖ0ݸÝ� -� ./
�
ü�%Q%*þ��Ú�ü�©%¨$�:�ãæHdä !C|ã!�}�de$f=ä
�H�$IF�_%�'Û|9�C}����'´K¸:�u+èÒ��¡_��|¸0
Q%}nm%·��3�1¦uä¨M<Ûu%Í]�V�°n�_�_���Â%���
��%Q%`a+ã��_�.U¥%2Lnì$�$�Ð.�#%34�34%ù5+6
�_���
ùp�Htìeã!�%Eö�âøeB��7��. 2007D 11S 12ü���KËA
%¾�HG�C 8ÀK 50 ��ð=�v%34n�8��h^���.�Q%67+�
[�F��ô+ùX¸y�[�^F�4�8�C�_��FYm%��ð=�ã!�%
34nI]%Q%673��õ°_�ùT`-�34nQ%67%p�¼�F�4²-
��9��&^�.����ô+!Z[�%^�
��rKü�%Q%*þ+���_�.��%Q%U¥�k_���%F1:��Q%
%û�ÎsU¥G8HI�z«F�_èéê%$ý��ð�õ��ÎæçH+��_���
èéê�%Q%$kK��[��%�z«F�_õ°_B°`-��%F�4!6�R°�
�G-;ò�r<�QT�n�.¡���r��I°;ò%º¦snO7�Kû��&
åõ°_�ùT`-�Q%67+q¡�èéêã$�%mD��=>��OOû�) �
nQ%U¥�j�_Îs%U¥G8HI+xA�34F�4�ò#$æçH+õ°�_°
���
?@K%�]�nþQ%l�%A+1�.�¥ë%�$�$)*F�_?@äõÞU¥
G8HI%�Ú+B��_�.ÛÜ#«Htìe>WD%?@U*@%öT^��?@Q
%�C[�*þSTêä?@Q%�G8HIe9ñ=�ä%õ�êäÒ5�?@Q%ha
ênm�|iÎ%íÏ9H%õ7�nQ%}F�4?@äõÞU¥�Ó%G8HI9ì$
Î+Ú�¨h�rK%?@U*%G8HIxA�J+@������_k��
Â4[��F�3�_�û�Q%ì$�$%g�G8HI%xA�J�Q%U¥�Ó%
U¥G8HI9ì$ÎrKï�ûh_�°ðe« �´�^�����nj�Â%ðe«
%��^��?@U*%g�G8HI�°��J�¢n�g�)*%�$��äHdê
��Fmr�>�Q%U¥�ÓF�_%¥ëG8HI�°���½[��F�´�^��
���
�%34�Q%ÕÖä�$��äHd�j�_}~J%û�U¥G8HIÁ%$]��
Q%U¥C{8Ú+.-��û.�_î���®+�½[�Z©4�
�����
���������
NÙϸÝ� D X�
EçâBF`K� 1980 DE�®^�¸3�_g���ô�ÁF���_�°ÛK�Û
+`G¥%O�G�û� 60 z¨%ã�Qäã���+vå�2_�´¥u�_�.�Â
%°Fn�.%�Htìe�HKû��Htìe�H�Ä8 +fg[�_g*F�_ê
�[�%�Fmr�>�|r��°�ìe}F�_Û+`G¥%O*<��î3��+ß��
ã�Qäã���Á�¸H!+��[�FF��O*<�%�H«ð!+Ì-�P%�$
��äHd�Ìu+¾-_�.���I4�Htìe�H%y*�BF`%O*Óé�3
�_°F�_Md�����ã%�p�_�.�Â%X+�BF`%�´��P�%¸§
nä�����¾�.F�-���%34nHtìe�H%{���|*Ò�A����d
a%�¸H!�d��nFfk§:!y*+Ëw������Û+`G¥�j��O*
<�%ùÓu^O<<�nnF+�Õä�/[�{S}F�_ TMO(Town Management
Organization)�C+��_�.{�F�±þ[��
�GNK��Htìe�H%y*�Â%34neìó+´�.���è]�_���@
��nJl6%�m+]w�.ê�^�ìeQNrK%Ô�+c�OO�Htìe�H%
Ð×+´�^��_�°�Â�K�÷� 2®^�"È_�°�F��.��
o®]��@��nJl6%�m�j�_�&°%`'���[���F�_%òÁ�
û�.®�O�_%��Kû��WD�@��nJl6�¼uÈ�÷ø��_���r.�
`'����.���|�H��}F�Ñ¿�_����H����`�'§)*�¥ë
Ñ'(d ì) nm&°%`'+Ð��YZ���Q0�_��.�Â%���H��dÓ
%]�®!Z�Ì��_�.%Kû���Â��m%34�Htìe�H�/0+¾-_
�.%^�O�_c�_�°�
x®]��Htìe�H%QN�qr��S��_�.xO%¯³%��Kû��Щ�
Htìe�H%QNK��'§)* 8eFBF`��Ö�_�.�.Z�����%�Ö
ê�¯r�rK��&°%ͯ[��êÚ�û�.�Â��%êÚ+K�L-��.%��
xO%¯³�S��.�F�3�%Kû��Â%xO%¯³F��|n��rxo`'ì�}
F|´ç<8G}Kû���%xO%¯³�Htìe�H%QNz#^�ÒÓ�_�.y
*®Htìe�H%�Öê�A^�ìeQN%���O�_c�_�°�
X"F�_�Htìe�H��H��F�4@��nJl6+�m[�.¡%ê�^�
r��Â%��ìe%QN�j�_�xO%¯³�Û+�nø×++.�.�F+´�
^�[���-_�Htìe�H%y*p¸®/¥%����#4Fn�.¯³%ú§S
T®MRìK%"=FST�û�.�F�´�^Fn��Â%oO�ËëØN%"=%M
RìKû��r.�Â��Â�¥ë%ABó+X��_��%Kû��
�����
��������� !"#$%&'()*��� !"#$%+,-.
OP¸Ý� û5�
�
Q� �ȡ�
&°%)*�F�_�P+Ã��2��~�nÔÕ�º�q�n�_�.��PÃ�%
]¨���®)*]�%ùOFn���Pb %�~�S�F�_qr)*hi�XkO
°�%F�_E6����Â�_)*��4�.�PÃ����Pb �m4S��%^
+´�^�[�.¡%gJ+R�rn���Pb ��®+Ð_�%��î3�P%iÊ
�^^�� !�lm�P%b � !3�S^�&�F�-���^�Kû��
>Reichheld 1996@�
ÚD%�����PÃ��FÈé�A+��í%ST�û��F+�?�_���F�
���Anderson, Fornell, & Rust>1997@�� �ï$íH%�PÃ��w�>Swedish
Customer Satisfaction Index@%í$�+����õ��PÃ��+iÊ[�)*��Ô
Ù���$H+Tp[��F+´�^��.��^�n����PÃ���)*vió�
¾-�/0%¦¯k%Í´���Z`s���>Szymanski & Henard 2001@�
��%&°���PÃ��F�Pe9ñ��ä®}�â(+�è][��Or���P
e9ñ��äF}�â(++�áÌ�F��PÃ��F%ST+´�^��.¨K�õ�
�Pe9ñ��ä®Us�n}�â(+�vió%]¨+�.�[F[��nj�Mittal &
Kamakura>2001@���PÃ��F:� Ç�F%�Î�äGnST+´�^��_�
����PÃ��F:� Ç�F%S|ó+´�^�[��F�:;K�n��/"��
��P���:� ��/0[�F�-������%ST+O*�n��j�_
�[��F�R���n7n��Ã��Å��µJ�.�P�:� Ç�+Ð�[rK
��§�L-�ð�TÈ�:� Ç��S[�í$�%�S�V¸n� !+±4^�
Kû��
�Pe9ñ��äF}�ânm%�áÌ�+a���PÃ��Fvió+XkO���
��&��%%��PÃ���67®;$K �C[�� �Ö�qr/0[�%^�O
�_�z«ì8�O��r.�NSèéÈ%� F�n�¬b7�üa7nm%�NSè
éÈ%� K�^X�� ��Kû�.¡��PÃ��F� �Ö%ST��®+Ð_
��F�:;Kû��
�.��_���K���NSèéÈ>��7@�O�_%�PÃ��F� �ÖF%
ST��®+Ð_�{�% 3O%8Ú+´�^��_�°�
Ø 1 ���PÃ��F� �ÖF%ST�O�_�é[��PÇ��K�vió%Ì�
�����
F�_ãWX:�Ö>Willingness To Pay?WTP@®:� Ç�1nm+��¨h��PÃ
��F%ST+´�^��_������K����rK%��K�vióÌ�F�_�
�¨h����F%ån^�.� �Ö�è]��Ò��n9�+�-�FF���PÃ
��Fvió�O�_%Òé���+Äk��
Ø 2 ���PÃ��F� �Ö%§�áD[��P;ó�O�_��[���P��
�ç�Ã��%Y>jk�Ç�MòF����_`%jk@�#=��P%;ó�3
�_�n��F�=s����� �ÖÁ%/0�Ã��opZ�K� ��.-��F
�K�>�Ã��op��ÈKû�_��P;ó%Ø��3�_�n�� �Ö+�[�
�ó�û���P;ó%Ø��3�Y�#=%6��K��¿�3�(c�n�P�/
�C+K�34�
Ø 3 ��ha*��3�Ã��j3k� �Ö%���O�_��[��ÚD�¬7_
g*þK����:%y*01^�â�!K%$¼+p���d�rKZ�_°��â�
! $}$�y*�!+ª¸��g¨I[+(M�34F[�Äk�êQu�_���â
�! $}$%01��9G9H:8%nFnmª�%� !�MòFn���.�_�
�Fâ�!+ta[�y*01��)*%vió]¨�m%34n/0+¾-�%Z©4
^�r.���:F���PÃ��®� �Ö�Ø��û�%^�F�4"®�O�_�
�[�Mò�û©4��
\� ��%u¯k
����j�_�PÃ��F� �Ö%ST+´�^�[�¨K�a��¤¥�O�_
´��_j°�
Ã��F��èé�n��`a�%õ%X+Kû��E9�>cognitive@^O89�
>affective@òÁ+5©�%Kû�>Oliver 1997@�Oliver>1980@%C+ºù�
>expectancy-disconfirmation@/"�3�F��P�� #%C+F`a�%67®;
$K %9�7�+�¬[��FKÃ��+�J������C+�C�_ù���°�
ºù�+E9�_�°ðe« %ÛKTÈ�89>Us�n��ss�@�Ã�>ºÃ@
+¾-�F[��
r.�PÇ��K��Ã��+��Îs�>transaction-specific@Ã��Fy��
>cumulative@Ã��% 2 O�Õ��_���#ê���P%ÔD��°õ®û�6
7%���î�§$I�;$K äîH��H�$�C[��Ç+>Olsen & Johnson 2003@�
�ê��67®;$K %�½ê�C[��P%Ëw�nõ+�[>Johnson, Anderson,
& Fornell 1995@�
���K%Ã����� #%C+7��C[�èé�%9�7�%õ%I�Kû�
1 WTP��������� Homburg, Koschate, & Hoyer�2005������������ Mittal
& Kamakura�2001��������
�����
>Anderson 1994; Oliver 1980@�y����F�_Md����
PÇ��Ka���_��]¤¥��ÔÙÝK�4¬�]>reservation price@®ã
WX:]>willingness To Pay@2nm�&������K��Ò5%� �Ö+a���
1� � ��C[��P��%/0
�PÃ��F� �ÖF%ST+/"����[��û.�eì�£x�j�� Adams
>1965@%`°/">equity theory@+êa[����K%£x���P��ùs�#=
%Ã��+Tp[�E���fgê�Á%ãW���![��F+!Z[�>Lind & Tyler
1988@�
`°/"�3�F�ú�d�%¦yª®��>input@��w4G]®A+>outcome@
+Ê.�F^4��%��FA+%���Ïê%Â�Fa��aw+&°>equity)�a�
°n�aw+º&°>inequity@F3k�º&°%I��¸���m�ú�3�º±Fn��
Â%ÍèÁF�{������Bolton & Lemon>1999@��)*�]®;$K 7�n
m�Ìu+�.��.aw��P�67®;$K %`a%a�+Ì-��FK�§+
^�ãW%&°ó>payment equity@+b �34F[��F+´�^��.�
[n���ÔD+�M��FKÃ��%op�õ°n�F��P�£x%A+�õ�F
9���Ã��%I��P3�ãW�Ö�õ°n���������w4A++�{��
��%Kû��ãW%&°ó+b �34F[�Ç�F�_�´K�34��'��Ã�
�%op�I�F�&°n£x��º �Kû�F9��ãW�Ö�I°n���.��
_�Ã���õ�aw3�I�aw%� �Ö�I°n��
"® 1��P%� �Ö���PÃ��%opFF��ä�[��
2� �P;ó�3�Ã��F� �Ö%ST
Ã��F� �ÖF%ST+��[�5��PÃ��%Y3��n�FÂ%� �Ö�
r�r�Fn��.F-Ã��op��ÈKû�_�Y%I��Pn�Y%õ��P
3�ãWX:�Ö�&°n���ó�õ��Â�_�� �Ö�/0+�.�[Y%Ø
���P;ó^�Ek���F�K�34�.F-¿�D�%�P�G8HI�O�_%
9G�l���_��.¡�G8HIÁ%e9ñ��ä�õ��� �ÂD%�P��r
ZG8HI�C[�9G+l��_��5¨K�D�%�P3�î.n9G�Æ8��Ç
�G8HIä 9�òHd�r<�Ç���>Mittal & Kamakura 2001@�r.��xo
2 � !"�#$� Monroe�1990�%�&'()!"�#$� Cameron & James�1987�� Krishna
�1991�%*�$�
3 +,� �-.�/012�3�45�6789:;�<64�=>�?@,�A�B��
�0C ���DE�FGH>�+,�IJ,�K�L��M��N 9O�PQR�%��DE
�ST�LUVWX���+,�YZ��[0��$�
�����
p%I��P%G8HIä 9�òr��I�F"�����Â��îG8HI%9Gm
n�^��� !������$H�ån�F8È�^�Kû�>Mittal & Kamakura
2001@��4�.Y�#=%����Dû��xopnm%�P;ó�%��K´�^�
K���
.F- 2 ú%�P^��op%Ã���Ê��.F�_��Ã���C[�Y%I�
�P%� �Ö%p�õ���ó�û����Ã��%Y%��� ���¯��n�
aw�� �Ö�º_`n/0+¾-_�r4��ó�û��
"® 2��P;ó�3�_Ã���� �Ö�¾-�/0��n��
3� ha*��3�Ã��F� �Ö%ST
÷�¬7+��P4_g*þK��2001DËç®9!$�$��+_|���2008D9
�H®�9î$nm%¸S%���3�|â�! $}$}%}~�ku�_���þr
ÔÙ� 2009D 3S 10ü�Qö�.¬7*þ%��`a%Å��3�F�2008D%`a3
�� 2Ó 1177ÙÔK�2009D��#D� 1.9%ä% 2Ó 1588ÙÔ�n���kKû��
Â%ÛK�9H�$â�!+êa�.$¼;$K +�½[�â�! $}$�j�_�
2008D%`a3�� 227ÙÔK�2009D�� 25.1%ä% 284ÙÔ�ª¸[�FÜ=�_
���
÷�T�¬7®üa7nm%$¼+9H�$â�!Kp����d��Z�_°��â
�! $}$�����+�¿>�Ù©hYó�û�®���b�¨K2��qr]K
^¡n��76+$���F�K�n�nmâÄ�äGn���ån°n���%34��
÷�¬7+��P4_g*�j�_��:%*���-���:%e��*��y*+ª
¸[��F%B(ó+�é[��F�/"���Ò�����ònêÚKû��ôµ��
¨h�A�Tµ���*�F��:%e��*�+w�2 ��ùha*��3�Ã��
j3k� �Ö+�¬[�¨K]ý%CXKû��
"® 3�ha*��3�_Ã��F� �Ö��n��
`� Å�%¤ò
1� �CXFp
�Å��PN�_ 2008D 3S 9ü� 10è%¯w{+CX�d=$ð9H�KÏ$�3
�y#Å�+ÒÓ�.¨K�Å�W%Q<+Ç�.�
v���Å���Å�CXê�Å�W++���������[�d�t+�Å� K
ÒÓ�.�A�Tµ%¯w{+a<=F��2008D 2S 1ü^� 4S 30ürK% 3bS
§� 1 µz¨%ha%û�. 300,554è%Û^� 1%�RÐ[� 3000ú+e�¾���3
�����
�Å�CX+$s�.�Å�W 30007+ 2008D 6S 12ü�Q���6S 25ü+�c%
â|üF�.�Â%4� 17Ö�ѵº´K��K�>��3���Q�� 29837�C�
11707�µv��..¡�µvc� 39.2%Kû��
2� �8]FsV�
� Ã��Å�%Å�]%Û^����K�ËwÃ���� �Ö�4O%µ²ê;ó>ó
��Dû��dQ���ýÖDv@+a���
r>�Ã����|A�Tµ�Ëw��Ã��_��}F�4�8�C�_ 5®V�>5=
Ã��4=®®Ã��3=EÖ�2=®®ºÃ�1=ºÃ@Ks�_�����%� �Ö�|�
��ùe§�ôµI�ha��r[^}F�4�8� 4®V�>4=4µz¨�3=3µI��
2=2 µI��1=1 µz{@Kµ²+Ê_��4�e��%� �Ö�|Î�� r.�gú
��K%ha�Ö�ù�S°_m%I�K[^}F�8� 6 ®V�>6=5 /Ôz¨�5=4
/*5/Ô�4=3/*4/Ô�3=2/*3/Ô�2=1/*2/Ô�1=1/Ô�Ã@Ks�
.�µ²ê;ó%ýÖDv�O�_� 4 ®V�>4=1200 /Ôz¨�3=800*1200 /Ô�
2=400*800/Ô�1=400/Ô�Ã@KE�_���
f� X+
1� � ��C[��P��%/0
� �PÃ��F� �ÖF%ST+�s[�.¡�� �Ö+�;Ì��Ã��j3k�
P;ó+iNÌ�F�_µª��+Ç�.��s%X++ö 1��[�
� 1� ������� ��
�� �������� ����� �������� �� �� �� ���� ��� ����� ��������������� ������� ����� ���� ������� ������� ��� ���� ����� ���� !� ���� �� ����� ���� ���� �"#�$ ������ ���� ���� ����� ��%&�'()*���'(+,��� ������� � ���� ������ ����� ��-%&�'()*���'(+,��� � � ���� ����� ������ ����� ��./0 ������ ����� ��
12345� �����
��6���//���6���
789� : ;0 �
Ã��%µªT�+k�F� <��B!ní%+��_��>g=.119, pÀº01@�
����PÃ��F� �ÖF%§%�Î�äGnST+ö��Ã��%õ��P�67
®;$K �ãW4�Ö�õ��F�EK���
4 \]^_�PQ �`a�b�c;d�e`a�fg��hU ijkl��b�c;d�mn�op
�q;c;d� 3#�rstu%-�`ac;d�vw�c;x>�yz{U|���}!�1872~�
���������DE�����$�
�����
2� �P;ó%/0
ö 1 %µª��%X+^�� �Ö��P;ó�3�_�n��F��^��ó��S
[�]+A�¿�DûFýÖDv� 1%opK�dQ��� 5%opK <��B!nX
+Fn�.��.��_� �Ö��Dû�ýÖDv��dQ��%ä�FF��õ°n
�Í]�û�F�-��
v���P;ó�3�Y%Ø�+�s[�.¡�;ó5�F��t �s��°�ù-�
d%�w��+Ç�.�ùd=$ð%Ã��j3k� �Ö%°_�ö 2%Ö�Kû��
Ã��%°_� 30h�Ã3� 30h*59h%p�õ°>3.95F 3.57�pÀº05@���%
khaê3�e��%kj3ktahaê%p�õ�>ùU3.49F 3.65F 3.69�pÀº01@
Í]�û��r.�� �Ö%°_��ùó3�ôó%p�õ°>20,609ÔF 25,588Ô�
pÀº01@�ýÖDv®�dQ���I°n�FF��ä�[�Í]�û�>�>�� p
Àº01@�Dû�O�_� 30h*59h%°_���õ��
��KÃ��F� �Ö%°_+�¬[��FK��P;ó�3��n�Y+Ek
���F�K���Ã��op��ÈKû�_��Y�#=�I�F� �Ö�õ°n
�� �Y�#=�õ�F� �Ö�I°n���ó�û��Íb+ß[.¡��¹ 1
��P;ó��Ã��F� �Ö%ST+d8:u[��¹ 1% A ���í$���°
X++�B«F��Â�h�%;ó�%�¬%X++ö�_���
� 2� �������������������
� ��� �� � � ��� �� � �� �
�� � �� ��� �� ���� ����� ����� �� ����� ������ ����� �� ����� ������� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ����� ����� ����� ���� � � ���� ���� ���� �����
���� !" �� ��� �� ���� ����� ����� � �� ����� ����� ����� �� ������ ������� #�� ��� ���� ��� ���� ��� ����� ����� ����� ���� $% ��� ���� ��� ���� ��� ����� ����� ����� ���� �� � ���� ���� ���� �����
&'�(���)*!" ��� ���� ��� ���� ����� ����� ��� ����� ����� ����� �� ����� ����� �����#���)* ��� ���� ��� ���� ��� ����� ����� ����� �����#����)* ��� ���� ��� ���� ��� ����� ����� ����� �����)*$% �� ��� �� ���� �� ����� ����� ������� ��� � ���� ���� ���� �����
+,-.�#�/ ��� ���� ��� ���� ����� ����� ��� ����� ����� ����� �� ����� ����� ���#�/ ��� ���� ��� ���� ��� ����� ����� ����� ���/$% ��� ���� ��� ���� ��� ����� ����� ������� �� � ���� ���� ���� �����
��0���11���0���
� 2"34 5678 "3495678
5 �� �Mittal & Kamakura�2001���$�g�����#$� �u�������K��� 3�
�t����U�
�����
� 1� ������������
A� ��
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�� ���� �� ���� ��
�
�
�
��
�
�
�
�
��
B� ��
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�� ���� �� ���� ��
�
�
�
��
�
�
�
�
� �
C� ��
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�� ���� �� ���� ��
�
�
�
��
�
�
�
�
����� ������� ����
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�� ���� �� ���� ��
�
�
�
��
�
�
�
�������� ����������
����������� ��������
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�� ���� �� ���� ��
�
�
�
��
�
�
�
�
���� ���� ����
F� !"#
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
��
�� ���� �� ���� ��
�
�
�
��
�
�
�
�
�� ��� ��
D� $%�&
E� '()*+
�����
Ã��%°_� <��B!n��E��n^�.�%%�ùó%p�õ����
�Ö%°_�ôó%p�õ�����ùó3�ôó%p%Y�I��F+ö�_�
�>¹ 1% B@�[n����op%Ã��Kû�_�ôó%� �Ö�ùó%Â�3�R
C��õ��F+!Z�_��.¡�ó�+Õ��n�Fôó%� �Ö%4'+�_õ
[�ø��û��Y�O�_%�'%RØ��Dû�j�_�����>¹ 1 % C@�
Ã��%°_� 30h*59h���I��� �Ö���õ°�30h�î 60hz¨F
���FÃ��%Y�#=�I�� ��30 h�Ã�Ã��%°_���õ���
�Ö��{MKY�#=�õ��jÂ�° 30h*59h%�P� 30h�Ã%�P���
G8HIä 9�òHd%Í]�I°��op%Ã��Kû�_�� �Ö�õ�F�-
��������ýÖDv>¹ 1 % D@F�dQ��>¹ 1 % E@�O�_�Ã��%°
_%�����n���� �Ö%°_�Dv®Q���&��mõ°n��Or��
�op%Ã��Kû�_�ýÖDv®�dQ���&��mY�#=�I°n��õD
v®¸Q�%�P�IDv®_Q����¦s�.iýKû�.¡� �Ö�õ�F"�
���
4� ha*��3�Ã��F� �Ö%��
ha*��3�Ã��F� �Ö%ST+�é[�.¡��w��+Ç��Â%X++
ö 3��[�F��¹ 1% F� 3O%ha*�%Ã���%� �Ö+d8:Kö�_�
����%k�e��%k�ta%Ã��F� �Ö%�>�%°_�j�_� <�
�B!n��EK�.>F=5.938~196.979�pÀº01@�
� 3� !"#���������������
� ��� � ��� � ��� �� � �� � ���� ��� ���� ��� ���� ��� ���� ����� ����� �� ����� � ����� ����� ����� ��� ����� ��� ����� ��� ����� ������� ����� �� ����� � ����� � ����� ����������������
!"�# $ !"# %&"# ��'(� )*+,"-./011-.2#�
����ù]�%°_%��&��¬KE[��F�K���Ã���O�_��
e��Fta%§+A�.��Fe���taF��%§%°_%��EK�.�r
.�� ��O�_����Fe���e��Fta�taF��%�>��j�_�
°_%��E¡��.�Ã��%°_���>3.49@���I°�e��>3.65@Ft
a>3.69@��I�Kû��r.�� �Ö�O�_�ta>36,892 Ô@���õ°�e
��>23,014 Ô@���>17,632 Ô@%2�n�_���Or����haê3�e��
haê%Ã��F� �ÖF��õ°n�_j��e��%01��P%� �Ö+õ¡
�¨KB(Kû��F��_����
�����
j� j���
����j��Ø 1 %êÚ���PÃ��F� �ÖF%ST+��[�F�©�û�
.���%X+�`°/"^������.Ö��Ã��F� �Ö%�Î�äGnST
�´�^�n�.��%X+��&°ó+b �34F[��P%Ç�+� �Ö^�.
-�Bolton & Lemon>1999@��è�.ãW%&°ó>payment equity@%YÐó+�
é�.®�r.�Homburg, Koschate, & Hoyer>2005@�vióÌ�F�_è]�.ãW
X:�Ö>WTP@+Ò5%ãW�Ö�3�_�éK�.®�ÝE�n!>�û�F�-3
4�
Ø 2 %êÚ���P;ó�3�_Ã���� �Ö�¾-�/0��n�^m4^Kû
���P;ó��n�aw�ùU%�P%� �Ö�C[�Ã��%Y��n��F�
´�^�n�.�[n���ôó®õv��¸Q�nmY%I��P��Ã��op�
�ÈKû�_�ùó®Iv��_Q�%�P3�� �Ö�õ°n��î3�P%iÊ+
]w[)*�F�_T��n¦só>intrinsic retainability@+B��e9ñ��ä%õ�
�P+6�[��F�kòKû���4�.�P%b ���î67%� !`aF�
_��)*%ù�I[%f�:�$F�_%ø×++.��^X�^OlÒn)*%
v�×Fn�>Mittal & Kamakura 2001, p. 140@��P;ó�3�_T��n¦só+B
�e9ñ��ä%õ��P+6�[��F��)*%`��.Ö×+B(�êa[�¨K�
Bin9�+¾-��F�K�34�
Ø 3 %êÚ��ha*��3�_Ã��F� �Ö��n�^�O�_Kû��Ã��
�j�_���%k%ha�P3�e��%kû���taha�P%p�õ°�� �
Ö�taha�P���õ°�v�e��%k%�P�X����%k%�P���I�
X+Fn�.�Â%/9F�_�� �6%.¡��·�·����Mò%n�e��%
hYó��P%Ã��+õ¡�õ�Ã���� �Ö�/0+¾-_��F�-����
nj�e��Fta�P%§%� �Ö�j������K�%��P+B[��F�Ð
1[�F�-����¬7_g*þ�j����:%e��*�Á%y*ª¸���P%
Ã��+õ¡g¨+]¨�2�B(nS��n�Ê��
�������%`þ�O�_c���Ã��FA+>:� Ç��WTPnm@%ST
+��[�PÇ�����2Ì�%ST��¿�+=s��Ã��op�I�F���m:
+�Ã��op�õ�F���n:+�Â�_ÛopK�RC��°on�+«° S:�
��°� S:%À¿+�[�%�&Uû�>Rust & Oliver 2000; Homburg, Koschate, &
Hoyer 2005@����%��K��4�.X++���[�F�K�n^�.��ô��
�PÃ��%�¼op+6�[�.¡%�í=�Ú�q¡����
�����
��¼½
Adams, Stacy J. (1965),pInequity in Social Exchange,qin Advances in Experimental
Social Psychology, Vol. 2, Leonard Berkowitz, ed. New York: Academic Press, pp.
267-299.
Anderson, Eugene W. (1994),pCross-Category Variation in Customer Satisfaction and
Retention,qMarketing Letters, 5(1), pp. 19-30.
Anderson, Eugene W., Claes Fornell, and Ronald T. Rust (1997),pCustomer Satisfaction,
Productivity, and Profitability: Differences Between Goods and Services,qMarketing
Science, 16(2), pp. 129-145.
Bolton, Ruth N. and Katherine N. Lemon (1999),pA Dynamic Model of Customerrs
Usage of Services: Usage as an Antecedent and Consequence of Satisfaction,q
Journal of Marketing Research, 36(May), pp. 171-186.
Cameron, Trudy A. and Michelle D. James (1987),pEstimating Willingness to Pay from
Survey Data: An Alternative Pre-Test-Market Evaluation Procedure,qJournal of
Marketing Research, 24(November), pp. 389-395.
Homburg, Christian, Nicole Koschate, and Wayne D. Hoyer (2005),pDo Satisfied
Customer Really Pay More? A Study of the Relationship Between Customer
Satisfaction and Willingness to Pay,qJournal of Marketing, 69(April), pp. 84-96.
Johnson, Michael D., Eugene W. Anderson, and Claes Fornell (1995),pRational and
Adaptive Performance Expectations in a Customer Satisfaction Framework,qJournal
of Customer Research, 21(March), pp. 128-140.
Krishna, Aradhna (1991),pEffect of Dealing Patterns on Customer Perceptions of Deal
Frequency and Willingness to Pay,qJournal of Marketing Research, 28(November),
pp. 441-451.
Lind, Edgar A. and Tom R. Tyler (1988), The Social Psychology of Procedural Justice.
New York: Plenum.
Mittal, Vikas and Wagner A. Kamakura (2001),pSatisfaction, Repurchase Intent, and
Repurchase Behavior: Investigating the Moderating Effect of Customer
Characteristics,qJournal of Marketing Research, 38(February), pp. 131-142.
Monroe, Kent B. (1990), Pricing: Making Profitable Decisions. Boston: McGraw-Hill.
Oliver, Richard L. (1980),pA Cognitive Model of the Antecedents and Consequences of
Satisfaction Decisions,qJournal of Marketing Research, 17(September), pp. 460-469.
Oliver, Richard L. (1997), Satisfaction: A Behavioral Perspective on the Customer.
Boston: McGraw-Hill.
Olsen, Line Lervik and Michael D. Johnson (2003),pService Equity, Satisfaction, and
Loyalty: From Transaction-Specific to Cumulative Evaluations,qJournal of Service
Research, 5(3), pp. 184-197.
Reichheld, Fredrick (1996), The Loyalty Effect: The Hidden Force Behind Growth,
Profits, and Lasting Value. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
Rust, Roland T., and Richard L. Oliver (2000),pShould We Delight the Customer?,q
Journal of the Academy Marketing Science, 28(1), pp. 86-94.
Szymanski, David M. and David H. Henard (2001),p Customer Satisfaction: A
Meta-Analysis of the Empirical Evidence,qJournal of the Academy Marketing
Science, 29(1), pp. 16-35.
�����
����������� ������������1
ÕÖ0ݸÝ� ºÞW/änÞÍ�
oT�ȡ�
� �GN%]���ËCÎC�'%O*�j��y*^s%Ò��S[�'5�¬Å�%
X++GN[��FKû���Å�%y#pFF�_Ç��.só�nÅ�^��t�®
�;�_��ËCÎC�'�j�_��O�ÔÕê%kn�>�Â%�úêj3kQ��
Og��r�^^��_��F�4�F��^�_����^����Q��Og�^
^��F�4®K�±þó������%%�y*^s�S�_��Â%Ò��^n��
n�_�Â4ZF�4�F��^�_�.�Â�K��8WÅ�+Ç4�F��.�
xTÅ�¤ò
� Å���uö%8Ú®;Hð=;9�FÂ%f9C %8Ú�����Å�dÓ%ÒW
��óF��.'5�¬Å��ÎÖ%8Ú+®���¯�.¨K�2007D�Ç��.�Å
�¥��¸#`>ü�@�§�=`ävÞ`>w'@�xy`>Û'@�ñÀ`>ñz@K�
C}�=S|%O*ê+÷nCXF�_ÒÓ�.2�z{K�y*^s�S[� 4]>�
O�ÔÕê%ý{¶·�(PE%¤*�*y*^s%¶·�c=s�_��y*^sê@
�O�_rF¡_�°�
,T<<X+
� r>��O�ÔÕê%ý{¶·Z��ü�K�©E�ån°�w'ïÛ'ïñzK�&°
�©EKû�F�4Í]����.�(PE%¤*�O�_��O�ÔÕê>Or�PE
�O*ê@F�4²-�&^�.%�ü�FñzK� ��w'FÛ'K�ån^�.�
*y*^s%¶·�O�_��|[K�^s�_��}j3k|�>�^s[�}F�4µ
²���&^�.%�ü�Kû�.��Û'ïñzF�Â��m¸�n��n^�.�|^
s�n�}���F�&^�.%�w'K�|�^�n�}���F�&^�.%�Û'K
û�.�cy*^s%CXê�O�_�3�ü�ïÛ'ïñzK�|d�%Bù}+��F�
&°$YK��ùp�w'K�|Bùz�%Q�}+��F�&°$YK���
ÛTòWFêÚ
� Å�^��^�.�F��ü�%O*�j�_���Èt�®�û�ËCÎC�'3�
õ�×wKQ�´K%�¶:TU�Ç��_�.�F�Â%ùpK�WD%ü�%O�Ô
Õê%y*^s%×w�Ï%ËCÎC�'���_UV�õ���K�n��F�4�F
Kû��ô�%êÚ��3�KLn<<j3k��+Ç4�FKû��
1 ��������� �������������(2009)������ !"#$%&'()*+,-./012
3�4567 57389�:;
2 <=>?@�ABCBD� E 357F>GH 43.7%IDJ(E 394FK 50.1%IDL(E 388FK 77.6%IAM�NO
E 200FK 66.7%IPQR�;
3 S!TU�D��P�VWM� �'���� XBVW��'Y>?M�#�!Z�[\� �;
�����
���������� !"
#$!%&'(%)�*�!#"
�
ü�¸Ý� |0%}�
ò~�
67%'5`aÁ%01�¢n��e�3�ÃìeÁ%����Kû�_�n�n��
Â���xO%/9�û��Øù%/9�'5�$��äHd�pu«¼Çu�ÆA"
Kû��'5�$��äHd��K���rK��^n�67{�j�_ýþ��pu6
7>û���W¥¼Çu67@%$%�¼�_��%^F�4�H�äHÎïHæ$8Ú
�O�_Òé���é�_�.��^�de$f=w/u���¡Æ�.&'()*��
67%ýþ��puFW¥`a¼Çu%cp%hiiÊ+ªq[�¯³�J+MòF�_
���Ø�%/9��wu[�Ãìe%ÔÕÖ×+�e�uv� w���/[�.¡%
¯³�í=�v�û����J%1Q�&'()*Áò���_���F�Ð1[���
.��_�û�DE9å#$æçHn���íî�67�ýþ%÷òn'F¥ë`aÁE
f�12��de$f=67u[�Â%�s��ÐÑ67%ÎóF��«dìH!%±þ
ó��-_��e«Ãìe§%ÅnÇ���òn�½++.�_��F3ê��-_���� �
Â�K�GNK�� wâ�!ã$<¯³Kû�&'()*�3�de$f=67uð
e« ��®+û_�de$f=��wu>�u@[��$��äHd¥°§%ÅnFÔ
ÕA+%ST+ÔD�í$������[����K�4de$f=67uðe« F
��K�%òÁDE�67F�_`aÁ����12[�ðe« � +w[�[n��
67%`a��j3k���%m¼�Ö[�DE1Q¥°�6l¥°�DE;�$!¥°�
�$��äHd¥°�Õ*�fg¥°ºJ�nê�+��CXF�_����GNK��
Ç���/"ÙÚ�×�+�Ú[�.¡%¤bF�_�$ �íä+p "F�_$%
����ní$�%l�FÂ�%Íb+Ç4���¢M�� !ï9�!�y*�j��Ñ
ç �$î�F�',��e%STF[��;Hð=$s%ðe« �í$�v<p �Í
bp �O�_�GN´K�f[���
iÊ��.í$���� !ï9�!�67%de$f=67u���$��äHd¥°
÷��3��eFÃìe§%ÅnÇ��¸�°�½�_���F+��_���F°�ü
�`a�j�_�id%6789Hªl�3�67+W¥¼Çu�_����^��e�
3�%ÔÙó+Ën�n�34ùs%p+Q�_�Ãìe^�%¼Çu�ð+s��s
t[�F�4Ån%�°k+�Ú�_����
���GN� wâ�!ã$<¯³Kû�&'()*%ÔÕêÚ+�Q®F�_����
��KP4��¢M��eFÎs%Ãìe§%�9CISTKû���9CIST%Ëw
�â�!ã$<AB%8ÚF��n�F�4®+E6�OO���GNK�¦Fr>ÔD
�í$�%l�+LP[���
�����
+�,���-./0��123
�456��789:;�����<=>
ù͸Ý� &0� ¼
����
� �"¼%]���ü�U�HÄ%`a�Cì���j�_Q0�.@��nÔ�+ûü
[��F�û���HÄ�Cì��%�â�< >��,�|Cì�â}@F�&°%®K
�n��b-¿��HÄ�j3 17×11«Hò%¸��Kû��Ö� 200.$Îz¨û�
%�C�_�) �nCì�â�j3 23×15 «HòF¸�°Ö� 32 .$Î^�n��
��ÃKû��r.�HÄ�_�ÈKû�%�C�_Cì�â�Y�ÈKû���8$%
Cì�â�C�_-�%�HÄF�4Ø��û�����L�nCì�â%�!���<
�YK�.Cì��%úU�F�_�]��%34��°¸�°����FYmn�F�
�.ü�U�HÄ%L-8<�$%«�p――|�HÄä �9=}FH���――��
��iÎn�%�����4�.Ø���^^��>�2002D��>^ 6000/I=Kû�
.ÀCì��%�HÄ%`a3���2007D��xÙ 1,000/I=�rK¾AB�.�
� n7¼u�idó�õ��HÄ%34n�'U%¼u�67��%'%`a�j�_ú
ö+Ê[%^�Cì�â%�FYm� $}$�$e$�%Kû�.¡�Cì��K��
â�<F�[n��ù%Ã%.¡%îH�$�9ìH!Kû�F�4RAn9ì$Î�O
�rF�_�. (Lopes 2006)��4�. ����9ð��S��>�Cì��%�HÄ�
$e��^��_åD%kn�>åô�HÄ`a+1'[��F�K�.%Z©4^�
� �"¼�Î��®+w�2�%���'%¼u�67%|�$!L$}$}>°X@F�
_%W¥�HÄ�$e%ø×Kû� (Hirsch 1972)��"¼K��Cì��K�$��.�
HÄ+�ó�.í$�#$ +a�_�m%34n�HÄ��� 20Dz¨���_uö�
���$���ÕÖ��_�.%^+´�^�[� (Thompson 2007)��%*þ%@��Ô
��O�_��*þú (Schodt 1983; Schodt 1996; Thompson 2007; Thompson and Okura 2007;
�æC and �Þ 2006; î� 2006)�:�H (Patten 2004)�¹ÃÏ{ (Brenner 2007)�Î
-$¸� ! (Kelts 2006)��3�_´�^���_�.��^��"¼��$í$�+a
�_Cì��%�HÄ`a+���.©¡_%ÝE��Kû��
� �A�v%Ö�Kû��r>/"���Fp "�O�_��[��v�Cì��%�
HÄ`a%~���c����Â%¨KK�F!�Lç���ð%}wðe« ����
������X"F�_��uÇ�%Ô�zmóF �äd��/>stigma management@
%x®^�`aAB%/9�������
�����
����� �
� �HÄ��Hirsch (1972) �wz[�F�©%p:�n|¼u�67}>cultural product@�
[n��´nS��n{�3���5���°�öW�n�%F�_½���ù èé
ê]�%�6�ÈKû���HÄ�$e�r.p:�n|¼u�¯³}>cultural organizations@�
[n���'��ÕÖ�2�¼u�67+TU�_hi+Ê34F[�)*Kû���.
��_�"¼��¼u%X��òÁ�ïl���ÕÖ���õ����m���ðe«
�S++U�_�.¼u%eìÝ>sociology of culture@�F���¼uTU"%Cðe$
ò+êa[� (Peterson 1976; Peterson 1994; Peterson and Anand 2004; Peterson and Berger
1975) ��"¼��û�`aKïl��.¼u�67+�n�'%`aK��[��$e%
�$!L$}$F�_%Ç���®+w�2��
� �"¼��de$f=n�$��äHdWX%��+ÖÈ_�¼u%eìÝ�C�_,
O%�½+n[�F�C+��_���Øo��¼uTU"®¸T�×%eìÝ�j�_
�òn�$�Kû�}~ðe« ���"¼��®+w�2_�� (Dowd 2003; Peterson
and Berger 1975) �����}~ðe« +Kw��yb�c�34F�4ÚD%ü�%�
$��äHd��%��FÑÇ[� (à0 2007) �Øx��Á�%¼u67+�n�'%
`a����34FÄk��$!L$}$%ø×��®+w�2_�� (Griswold 1992;
Griswold 2004) �de$f=n¼u�67%Efðe« �O�_��%xO%�®^�%
���ån�%�W¶Kû��Ø,���"¼K��â�< ���CXF�_$¿�_
��.¡�¼u�67� �äd�u+�^��_����F�K��%^F�48Ú�
C�_î.n��+�½[��F�C+���� �äd�F��Îs%ú6®¼u�ö
Xnm�C�_�¾��.ss�n9ì$ÎKû���4�.�����®iA+Tk�
[�F�û� (Goffman 1963; Lopes 2006) �
� �HÄ�$e%Ç�+Å�[�.¡���"¼K��Îï9§Hä!Hð§H��A�
.~��n�HÄäí$�#$ +a�_�$}�$H+��[���%¾Manga: The
Complete GuideÀ>z{�MTCG@��$®>2007D�È¡@K�S��nÑöü�U�
HÄ%Ã�9G+[�_v¡_û��MTCG í$�#$ >z{�MTCGDB@���$e�
�$D�Ð��Î-H=�Dû�$�äHd�ó®�JöWnm�kn´:>objectionable
content@F��.'Un;ó�O�_�c��_����"¼K��¢n�c�n��%k
�a�����%%��%í$�#$ +a�_��HÄ`a%Q0F}~ðe« +s
ª��öW[��F����n����C§� 1980 D^� 2006 D�;Hð=ä;9��
1,058�7Kû��
�����
���������������
� ÀCì��%�HÄ`a����æD§K 6000/I=^�xÙoÁ/I=rKAB�.�
�HÄ%�$�7�����ÇÈ_ä��X�_�.�MTCGDB�3�¿�1996D��>
^ 21 �7�^�$��n^�.�%%�2006 D�� 226 �7��$��_���2006 D
rK�¨MxeKû�K�F!�Lç���ð�Â�h� 220�7�229�7ÛÇ�_�.�
���X°%� 59�9!=+ÛÇ�_���$<¨$ >Dark Horse@Kû����e%
úö�7+�$[�í=�9>Del Rey@� 2006D®K��>^ 26�7�^ÛÇ�_�
n��%%fgÖK�Ø,MKû��
��������
� 1980*82 D��Cì��©%�HÄäCH§eÎ$��$��_���%%��]�n
�HÄ�$y*� r�.%� 1987D%�FKû�.�î�@ �_ÝÏ%ÃìeK��
â�< >Viz Comics@+ 1986D�QN��êD3��HÄ+�$� ¡.%Kû��y
*+ ¡��û.�_î���Ñ�®�j�_©Fn��HÄ%�°Ã¾Manga! Manga!:
The World of Japanese ComicsÀ(Schodt 1983) +Æ3�.:�I��<äæç�!�R�+�
.�æç�!���HÄ+ü�t��$�_�Cì��ú�p�����n�F�-..
¡�Cì�â%�:�Ì-_Cì��ú�Ek®[���Ì-��F+î��CIf9
�. (î� 2006: 45) ��%34�K��q��.�¸%êÚ�m%I�|�HÄä �9
=}+b �_�m%I�Cì��úEê%iý�û�2�%^F�4W¥u%8ÚKû
�. (Levitt 1983; Ryans, Griffith, and White 2003)�
� W¥u�S�_���òZ�.%��|����}>flipping r.� flopping@Kû�.�
¨c%34��_^�YÁFEk�¡��HÄ%Ekp�´�^�Cì��%Eê��P
Qk%n��%Kû�.�Â�KCì�â%34�Y^�_ÁFEk�¡���34��
K���+o°p]�1���_��+�.%Kû���^�8Ú��ån^�ù�%�
HÄQ�d�%�7�����+X�R�F�-_�.�FKû�. (î� 2006: 66-67) �
L-8<�$%�hnm��$e�ü�_��Cì�â*þF��n���HÄQ�d�
%�7%V��+ån°F�¥�����B�_���Â%.¡����+�©�HÄQ
��L�.�7%$�+Ê�¨K¸�n��Fn�.����K��Ð�$�.�HÄ
��32 .$Î%}H:��!;9�F�4Cì�â%�:�þ2.�%Kû�.�Cì�
â%÷ònÕÖò-â=Kû�.�â�< �°�>specialty comic store@K�4�.Ñö
�HÄ+fg[�.¡Kû��
�����
� �4¦FO%8Ú�uöKû���HÄ���&°%�å�!.®iÎnBL-G8�
$® 8Hd�a���_���Â%.¡K��ü�¼uFCì�â%cp�ÖÈ.uö
ê+MòF�.���+ÒW[�.¡�K�ò$�K%uöÓv+n-_�.�r>î�
FF��K�+ï*�.�0�¸r^�uö��v�:�$8H %uöê��89!+
�_������ÉRS%Cì�â�$e�î<�ð %;<ê��í[��F�4¦¯
kKû���%ò$�ã$<��¿�¿¼u���+Tk��.��0��î<�ð %
úU��HÄ�j�_�9¸â�<n��+öW[�¨K�å�!.��^��òn%^
+�Ê[�%�¸Ì�� �.F�4 (Schodt 1996: 316) �Cì�âK��4�.���÷
aú6%ñ¡K�´������%Kû� (î� 2006: 67-69) �
� �8$u�r.¸�n8ÚKû�.�¢Q%£/®¤¢+a�.-�%�HÄä �9
=���8$<�Ы%Cì��%�â�<`aK�ºhZF�-��_�.%Kû��
Ò5��°O^%�7�¡+����_�$��.�%%��HÄ%¢QöW%¼�+ñ
e���_�r4.¡�o�xDK-�%rrK�$[�34�n�. (Schodt 1996:
316-317) �
� ü�K��¬�¥:�p�����_���HÄ%�J®ó�öW��Cì��K��
OK�[¦n8ÚKû�.�b-¿K���Û.$Î����9ðäæ$H�5r�.¾�
�9�)ÀØÛÐØo[+uA�_Øx[^� �$!2·�+Ên^�.�Ð�K�
�î<�ð F_ÝÏ%á§kKû�.�î<�ð %;<B�BD:ïâã !���
S��_�.ôóKû���4�.öW���¡_���Kû�.�ùp�<ìe%_Ý
Ï���°�öW��kKû�.F�_���7%´:+Ì-�nm�HÄQFÂ%�7
�C[�¨©K�^n�F�-_�. (î� 2006: 72-74) ��'%/9^��¾�ÀØoÐ
%ª%�«æ$H�r.uA��_�� (Thompson 2007: 477-478) ��4�.uA®�í
��rZ�ù �Kû���köW+�å�!.®*���K¬[34n���ò+�H
ÄQ�z÷[��F��°n^�.�uA�í+���.¡��K�� 2000D�id%
Dû�$�äHdäæ ��+O°�.�
� 1990DE�K�F�$<ä¨$ �x¸�HÄ�$eKû�.�MTCGDB�3�¿��
% 10D§%4��Â�h� 61�7F 26�7+�$�_���1990DE%�HÄ��â�
< �j�_��9¸$n��B�$���n^�.�÷Õ%Cì�â��u[��FK�
�â�< �°�+®��lm%Cì�âEê+�$��!F�_�.�Â%.¡Ð�
$��.�HÄ%&°�åD�HÄF7D�HÄKû�.�Â�h� 43 �7F 23 �7Û
Ç��.�ùp�åô�HÄ� 12�7�ôó�HÄ�ç�_�o�7�^ÛÇ��_�n
��
�����
� �� �����������
� �4�.ùó]��HÄ�ã��n¶·�Ìu%Ó���- ¡.��^���Cãì
¾«$8$�$HÀ>Sailor Moon@� 1990 DE®¿���KK����.�FKû�.�
1997D�â�< äîH�$�9ìH!>Mixx Entertainment@���â�<+E�Ern
�²+¯�.�HÄCH§eÎ$��¾MixxzineÀ�¾«$8$�$HÀ%�HÄ+à��
¡.��%��%ïÛÑ��â�< �rF��O° �äd�+���.¡��HÄ
%�F�â�< F���>|motion-less picture entertainment}FH�_�. (Thompson
2007: xviii) �^O_%�HÄEêF��n��¾«$8$�$HÀ% 70Õ%Eê� 13h%
åôKû�. (Harris 1998) �êD�$��.¾«$8$�$HÀ%¢Ç���Cì��K
©¡_��!�.åô�HÄFn�.�¾MixxzineÀ� 2000D�3Û�.�%%��e�Â
%�!�Lç���ðFeè+Ìß��åô�HÄ`a%�$�$)*Fn�_���
� Â%��^�� 2002D��������_j�>ü�t�_^�YÁFE©�F�K�
�|�6�HÄ}>Authentic Manga@%�$+ ¡.�F�û�.�����e��å�!
.+uö2>�ü�Kg��_���HÄ�Ú�3�_�n�:+êa�.��%X+�
���Hd%� !�kv�.�����å�!.uöF�4��%p K�o.$Îû
.� 18*36I=Kû�.%�C�_���2>�å�!.+uö�n�aw�MI=�^
^^�n^�.%Kû� (Thompson 2008)��%I� !+���|�6�HÄ}� 9.99
I=F�4I]Kfg��.�Á�`aK�È67+�½[��4�.|�pu}�~
��L�.�7+iÊ[�¨K��½�.��HÄQ%|�7}+���2��F���
rZ�$�iÊ%¨K%¸�n��Fn�_�.^�Kû��
� �4�.ò-�HÎ-$)*�3��$��äHdgJ�3�_��e%`aæïC�
2003D� 70Õ�rKÆ�.��e%÷ò�P��^O_�HÄ®Cì�â+Ern^�.
åôKû�.�°&ñ%¾8G¦nÀ>Love Hina@® CLAMP%¾�±k�>À>Chobits@
F��.úö�7+�½[��FK�!�Lç���ð��åD�HÄ`a+��-_�
.K��1'�_�n^�.åô�HÄ`a+¯�.%Kû��Â%X+�2002D^� 2003
D�^�_�HÄ`a� 6,000/I=^�oÙI=�rK¾AB�. (Griepp 2007) �ùp�
K�%`aæïC� 20ÕrKkv���$<ä¨$ %�+ª4,M)*Fn�. (î�
2006: 189) �
� oM%�+��²[.¡��K��F��F�K���ù%p ��!�Lç���ð
F�'�ü�t%�HÄ+¦°�½[��FKû�. (î� 2006: 189-192) ��FYm%
�7� 9.95 I=rK{h��.�r.<Ñe%åD�HÄ��e%!]�û��>^
7.75 I=Kg��.�{h�3��$ÎH%I{�fgª+ä®[�FKR³��.�
K��uöb+®v��2001 D� �7�^�$�_�n^�.F�©ê 2002 DF 2003
�����
D��Â�h� 22 �7��$�.�6�æ ��%mí�Ò+Xk�K�� 2004 D��
`aæïC+ 70ÕrK�µ��2.��%`aª¸���n�î3��+ß�.��HÄ
�$e%���2003D^� 2004D�^�_ 12e^� 23eÁF´ä�.�
����� !�"#$�%&$'()
� z¨%Cì��%�HÄ`a%~�^�´�^n%��}~�`aAB+�.��.F
�4�FKû��K�%`a%1'êF�_%gJ��%AB+�´[�¨Kº�qKû
©4��!�Lç���ð% 2002Dz¯%|�6�HÄ}%��Fåô�HÄ%��+�
�^�� r�.de%k��}~�`a%¾AB+�.��.F"�����%�K�
2000 DE�j�_x¸�$e%y����uä��u�n��m%34n}~+ñ��h
_�.%^+ MTCGDB +a�_�´[�����}~ðe« �$]�.yb�c��
^n�n� (à0 2007) ���K�Eê²%ó�FDû�$��äHd�è][��
� MTCGDB �3�¿��HÄ�Eê²�ÇÈ_åD�HÄ�åô�HÄ�7D�HÄ�ô
ó�HÄ%ÛO��±���>.Z����%��B�$�5r�n��7�ån^�>
û�@��%;ó�ù�$e�m%ó�«dìH!+¯�_��%^+�?�_���r.
÷òn�HÄ�$e�id%Dû�$�äHdäæ ��+ �_���MTCGDB K��
��+|All Ages}�|Over 13}�|Over 16}�|Over 18}%ÛO���_����%;ó�ù
�$e�m%Dû²+¯�_��%^+�?�_���
� r>ó��O�_k�F�K��åD�HÄ`aK�!�Lç���ð�åô�HÄ`
aKÂ�h�RAn�ÎæçH+B�_���F��^��¹ 1 �!�Lç���ð��
��. 1997D^�%åD�HÄFåô�HÄ%D�ÛÇ�%�¬Kû����+��Fx
e%��uj3k��uÇ����Z2��2003D^� 2005DrKdê�åD�HÄ3�
åô�HÄ+3�&°�$�_�.��%þ.�$Ç��dê�}wST�û��F+�
�_����^� 2006D�n�F�e���uÇ�+F�.�K��3�&°%åD�H
Ä+�!�Lç���ð�3�&°%åô�HÄ+�$�.�
� Dû�$��äHdK��n�!�HI+��_��>¹ 2@�2002D��d�$ê%÷
ònEê²� 13hz¨>Over 13@Kû�.��^� 2003D^� 2005D�^�_K�%�
7%&°� 16 hz¨>Over 16@+EêF�.�%Kû�.�2006 D�Â%Í]�Ì��
n��%%�dê�ëk��_��%��^��K � 13 hz¨]�+3�&°�$��
!�Lç���ð� 16hz¨+3�&°�$�_���
� z¨%34�K�F!�Lç���ð� 2002 Dz¯��n��ÎæçH+F�_���
K��åD�HÄ`a+ã��_��ùpK�*þ�$�$)*F�_åô�HÄj3k
7D�HÄ`aK��7+���_:=89HÓé+F�_���ùp�K�%`a��
% 10 D�����.!�Lç���ð� ã�ò`aKû�.åô�HÄ`aK3�Â�
�����
²+�$��!F�.�2003D� 100ÙI=Z�.`a3���2006D�� 200ÙI=r
KAB�.��4�.y�%Ç�%Ekw�+ÖÈ.�$��äHdÇ�%��uä��
u�`a%AB+ß�_����ó�û��
�µ: MTCG í$�#$
¹ 1: ó��F%�$�7�%Dv�ä>K�F!�Lç���ð@
�����
�µ: MTCG í$�#$
¹ 2: Dû�$�äHd�$�7�%Dv�ä>K�F!�Lç���ð@
*�
� �%yb��^�´�^�n�.%�v%x®Kû��
� Øo��÷ò�HÄ�$e%`a��u�����Ô�zmóKû��K���Cì�
â���<�YK����m��HÄ+�.�Fn�úU+��O��.¡���HÄ+
|W¥u}�.�2002 Dz¯�!�Lç���ð�|�pu}�.�HÄ+I]K�½
��`a%¾AB+ÒW�2.��%Ô�zmóF�4Q�yÒ��?[�%��1980*
90DE�j��K�%1'êF�_%W¥ugJn���2000DE%!�Lç���ð%
�����
�pu�~�ôü�ç�rK%`a%¾AB+ÒW�n^�.©4��Â%ùpK�!�
Lç���ð%�pu�~�n��¿K�%W¥ugJ�`a%¾ª¸F�4A++�.
��n^�.Kû©4�F�4�FKû�����#�%���3�¿����xe�}
~�ku�. 2003 D^� 2005 D�^�_ó�«dìH!K���u�OO��Dû«d
ìH!K��u�.�ùp�2006 D�� �ó�«dìH!K���u��Dû«dìH
!K���u�.��4�.Ç�%Ìu�`a%AB+µ�2>�deæïC+õ¡�.
¡��}wÏe%Ç�FÂ%!¹+EkCÇ[�F�4Ryðe« %X+Kû�F"�
�� (à0 2007)�
� Øx���HÄ% �äd�u+��_ñ�nîH�$�9ìH!F�_%í ó+
N[�°W¥�$e���¯YZ �äd�%�/Kû���HÄ�$e��Cì�â�
B�°O�rF�_�. �äd���HÄ��sè�n�34L+%$!+W�_�.�
¨c%34�Cì�â�B�° $}$�$e$¿^�Kû��|ù%Ã]�}F��.
�äd�+B�_�.��%�â�< ù �C[�As�¥�CÇ[�.¡��Â%.
¡©C%�HÄ�$e��$[���7+$![°$%����´:+�í2·�+Ê
n^�.�r.����í+�_`�~-�.¡�Dû�$�äHdäæ ��+�Ú2
·�+Ên^�.��%�/�n��¿`aAB�ÒW�n^�.F�-����
� Ô�zmóF �äd��/�`aAB+�.�[ò1Fn�.F�4�"��rZ×
�%��Kû���%×�%YÐó�O�_�ô�3�[°��[�ÜsKû��
�����
�
Brenner, Robin E. 2007. Understanding Manga and Anime. Westport, Conn.: Libraries Unlimited.
Dowd, Timothy J. 2003. "Concentration and Diversity Revisited: Production Logics and the US
Mainstream Recording Market, 1940-1990." Social Forces 82:1411.
Goffman, Erving. 1963. Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.:
Prentice-Hall.
Griepp, Milton. 2007. "ICv2 White Paper: Anime and Manga." in ICv2 Conference on Anime and Manga:
"Inside the Otaku Generation". New York Anime Festival, New York, NY.
Griswold, Wendy. 1992. "The Writing on the Mud Wall: Nigerian Novels and the Imaginary Village."
American Sociological Review 57:709-724.
—. 2004. Cultures and Societies in a Changing World. Thousand Oaks, CA: Pine Forge Press.
Harris, Sara. 1998. "Japanese-style Manga Beckon U.S. Readers." Japan Times 38:10.
Hirsch, Paul M. 1972. "Processing Fads and Fashions: An Organization-Set Analysis of Cultural Industry
Systems." American Journal of Sociology 77:639-659.
,-./. 2006. 012�3456789:;<=�>?MANGA@ABCD�EFG=H. I
�����
J: KL BPM.
NOPQ. 2007. RSTUVWXYZ[\]^_�`a]bc�de7STZ[\]fghijf
k>?l��m. 0noLpqrH 24:1-24.
Kelts, Roland. 2006. Japanamerica : How Japanese Pop Culture Has Invaded the U.S. New York:
Palgrave Macmillan.
Levitt, Theodore. 1983. "The Globalization of Markets." Harvard Business Review 61:92-102.
Lopes, Paul. 2006. "Culture and Stigma: Popular Culture and the Case of Comic Books." Sociological
Forum 21:387-414.
st3], uv5wxyz{|}~��y�|�{. 2006. 0��x|ij|USA7����� Anime
���H. IJ: ����.
Patten, Fred. 2004. Watching Anime, Reading Manga : 25 Years of Essays and Reviews. Berkeley, Calif.:
Stone Bridge Press.
Peterson, Richard A. 1976. "The Production of Culture: A Prolegomenon." American Behavioral Scientist
19:669.
—. 1994. "The Production Perspective." Pp. 163-189 in The Sociology of Culture : Emerging Theoretical
Perspectives, edited by D. Crane. Oxford [England] ; Cambridge, Mass.: Blackwell.
Peterson, Richard A. and N. Anand. 2004. "The Production of Culture Perspective." Annual Review of
Sociology 30:311-334.
Peterson, Richard A. and David G. Berger. 1975. "Cycles in Symbol Production: The Case of Popular
Music." American Sociological Review 40:158-173.
Ryans, Jr., John K. , David Griffith, and D. Steven White. 2003. "Standardized/Adaptation of
International Marketing Strategy: Necessary Conditions for the Advancement of Knowledge."
International Marketing Review 20:588.
Schodt, Frederik L. 1983. Manga! Manga! : The World of Japanese Comics. Tokyo: Kodansha
International.
—. 1996. Dreamland Japan : Writings on Modern Manga. Berkeley, Calif.: Stone Bridge Press.
Thompson, Jason. 2007. Manga: The Complete Guide. New York: Ballantine Books/Del Rey.
—. 2008. "History of Manga: The Introduction (Presentation Material)."
Thompson, Jason and Atsuhisa Okura. 2007. "How Manga Conquered the US: A Graphic Guide to
Japan's Coolest Export." Wired 15:223-233.
�����
?@A�B�C!D!EFGH
¼AÝ5¸Ý� îë��Ã
�
� �ö%¾�n�¹�±��gúèé%¡-�k�r[r[)�°n�_���èéê�
ºòº¾% 6+¶-.�FK�Ëw $}$®·¸�nm¸S_g*% 2008D¨®C%
Û§¯;����%viFn�.�F����¹b7%fgº��[¦Kû��'´%¹
b7`a��[K��$<% 7×%op�}��YKj���'%·¸�K%g¨õ� 10
SrK 16bS|X� $}$K� 34bS|X%#D��X�_���
� ·¸�+f�%Û°�Md���¸SC}�=��èéê%I]�]%õr�K�Ûä
õ]G8HI%gÇ��°�2009D� 3SC�� 2007D�rKýÅ+b �_�.
�Hã$I�ã$=IÎ� 2C|X%viFn���kZ�
� ùp�I]Ö%¹b7+fg[�Ëw $}$�èéê%¹b7���[¦K�b-
¿�9�HK� 2008D 8SC�¹b7fg%�c� 18.1ÕF 2D#^� 2�9H!I{
�_j��zhi%õ�¹b7%×w�vå[��FKhi�l�Ó�/0+fg�_�
�1�
� ¹b7�BCº����_��/9F�_��Hã$I%o!eB��Û'^�%¦�
O7%¸ªÕ�nmK�h�þÖ�.O7�ºk�½¨��%¶��û��FFQ»K�
`�n�¹b7��H �ûq��M+��[�LP2M�I��F+�h_��2��'
��Þ(Oì¼ßeB��gúèé%¡-�kKM+��[�ǾÂ%�%%LP2M�
{��_j���H D£�õopKû�Fc�_��3�
� �^��Â�Z���1Kû©4^�¨c�.34��¹b7`a�½�[�n^�|J
ã<e}+01[�:�$ !��9�Hd% 2008D 8SC¯;��g¨õ�Õ*hiF
��#D%���ä+�ø�_j��Â%±Å|��r�����_����9S 13ü�
¾��1��.g¨õKýþ 3M%¹b7�°� H&M>¿â äCHIä����>?�
e �ï$íH@��©ü� 8000ú+L-�ú�������[�%� 4§^^�.�
mK���ê�� 1e§K 5/ú+�À�.4�r.��Ⱦ�� 9S 21ü��ýþ 2M
%¹b�°� ZARA>9Híä��< e?�e .9H@% 35��]Fn����1�
������2Å��ä�_���
���%)*�ÎÖ[�%���>��O7%)<^�fgrKùD�_S��� SPA
>6l_g*@Kû��FZ��Jã<e��Û'�µJ«a+��_��$�¸G=K
õ7�%#$æ�<nO7+I]K�½[��F+�����ùp�ZARA® H&M��
1 2008 � 10 � 22 ������ MJ��
2 2008 � 12 � 14 ����������
3 ��
4 2008 � 9 � 29 ������ MJ
�����
õ�O7)<JF�¡L^�õ�n;ð89òï$HKÕÇ�Æ8nO7+õµ�Kfg
[�F�4ÎB+ �_���
�����¹b7º�%ÛK�èéê%� !S+¥�N_�*¯+¨h_�� SPA�
�®+û_�Â%KÎâ æ ���O�_"È��%Kû��Â%5�xO%C+�n
ybF�_�Jã<e(:�$ !��9�Hd)F .9H% ZARA>9Híä��< e@
% 2e+��¨h��
�����
IJKL�MNOPQRST=>UVW
¸#áN¸Ý� à�Á�
ÕÖÔÙ¸Ý� _�ÂÃ
� �GN��ÔÕ0ÝÔ��¥ì|wµ�ì÷�%í$�Í��H.�äæçH�j��
��CXí$�Kû�Q»´%¬y�C[�èé9G�ûDê�C[��9G�!6Å
�X++`a��1 D§+Ö�.Q»´%¬yèé%Í]®Q»%¬y�C[�!6�¬
Fm%34�S|[�^+��[��
� èéê>ùýÖ%¬y+d���ú@��Ä�%f8H �F�.¬y+�-�K��
¿j§KÅ/+�.��×��¬y��.�F�-��Ïp�ì$�$äTUêäÕÖ
*ê��de>d�@%g¨n�k�hi+Å¿�.��îO7+1Q�.��èéê�
F�_%3�¼�7Þ-+�.�F�-_���Ö�����%]����ÆA���
�F�ÆKû��K�%Ðyê�Win-Win%ST�n��F����R���
� �GN%]���3�ån�ìãÏ$K¬¤�Äþ�`a����r·rn¬¤F%¯
kw�2���nìãÏ$%��FÂ%f�î$æçH%��ó�O�_"È����%
CX�ý%��÷Ç 148úF��1D§%Ȭ%ìãÏ$�O�_��[��
r>�¬¤%Û^�ÅZb��æ±�o�j³nm+uA��ìãÏ$�j��¬¤`
a�+;�[��v�ìãÏ$�Wr��`a[�¬¤%°_µ�nm+ha�_ìãÏ
$�r%±þ�+öW�.ìãÏ$��ð+�A[��
�r·rnìãÏ$��ð^�Ê���9G+�F��ÉìãÏ$+�ð��;Hð=
í$�%èéê9G+�F��ÉìãÏ$%��n���ó��"[��
�����
�����
XYUZ[8\]^�_`abc�
ËÀ¸Ý� +0Åá
�N%ø×+G8HI%(a�qr/0+¾-�|�Ê�ø×}>qr(+@FG8HI
%�¯<w�A�/0+¾-�|9G�½�ø×}>§r(+@% ¶O%ø×+¾-�Â�
h�%ø×%G8HI$%�í=KYÐó+���.�#ê���%æHd=§$ í$
�+a�.èéêG8HI$%Ç�+��%�í�HdKÇ4%�C�_��ê%ø×�
�K����GNKî��G8HI$%�í=+�ð�.�ùG8HI%��µ���
°�N !�<�û�op+,-�F�¯<wÁ�����+,-n�aw��¯<w�
��n�F[��í=Kû������C§+ÖÈ_ùsF�_����_�.(aS
�+s>[�G8HI���G8HI%�N !�<op�ÇÈ_ICÌu[�G8HI
$%�í=Kû���sK���²#9�ðeK�!�í=+¼a[��F�3���N
%ñL(+}8ì$�j3k`a�Ç}8ì$��Q<�F��s[�C=B���+¾
-.��í=%¤òj3k¤~¹�{�%Ö�Kû���
�
( ) ( )Prht jht
j C g S∈ =
�������
htC ��� h� t����� �
jhtS ��� h� t������� j ����������
if ht jht h
j C S r∈ ≥
hr ��� h�������� !
������� [ S1 : �� ��������� ]
( ) { }Pr Pr for all such that ( ) 1jht kht kht h
ht
j u u k I S r= > ≥ =
�������������
* * *
,
jht jht h jhtu M β ε= +
������������ !"#$%&
1,2,..., ,j K= ( )K N≤
( ) ( )Prht jht
j C g S∈ =
�������
htC ��� h� t����� �
jhtS ��� h� t������� j ����������
if ht jht h
j C S r∈ ≥
hr ��� h�������� !
������� [ S1 : �� ��������� ]
( ) { }Pr Pr for all such that ( ) 1jht kht kht h
ht
j u u k I S r= > ≥ =
�������������
* * *
,
jht jht h jhtu M β ε= +
������������ !"#$%&
1,2,..., ,j K= ( )K N≤
������
Nhtu
h
β
1htu
2ht
u
���
1ht
M
���
3htu
*
Kht
u
*
1htu
*
2htu
h
r
���
≥
<
���
NhtS
h
r≥3ht
S
h
r≥1htS
h
r2ht
S
�������
�������[S1] �� �
2htM
3ht
M
NhtM
������
Nhtu
h
β
1htu
2ht
u
���
1ht
M
���
3htu
*
Kht
u
*
1htu
*
2htu
h
r
���
≥
<
���
NhtS
h
r≥3ht
S
h
r≥1htS
h
r2ht
S
�������
�������[S1] �� �
2htM
3ht
M
NhtM
�
�������� ������������������� !"#��
$"#�%&'($"#�)��*+,-./'012�34��567� )��
8797:1;<=�>�?@ABC��� DE#�FGH$3IJ��5KH�D
ELM3NOPQ�RS'T DEUVWX3YZ�[1\]+^_G_UVWX3`
a7?[ bc-defSgh-GC1 ijH$kR�l3IJ� #�3`mn
�LMo3pq'_1H$3IJ��5
�����
��������� �������������������
rstju� vwxy
z{|}ju� ~����
�
���( �y�������$����3���� �2�kR�y�����
�+�,�?��-3FQ��18�[���30������� ?��3¡¢
��[15c� 2����3;£�¤� ¥¦§<��¨©ª'01�y��
«¬C'?�����«¬87T����[15®¯���(�y������
�IJ3°±�²³� �:73!" �%&����´(?� µ¶·¸+j_�¹
º��[1» 2�����3��2�(¼½�dZ�5
¾¿(À���3Á6?[!"Â^3�y����Q�[1���� Ã,Ä°Â^3
������Q�[1�y��[n:8�ÅÆÇ1�3�����È��<ÉÊË'
�Q�5��(j_�Ìb��C��Q�[15Íb( ����ÎÏ3ÐV^_�
�ÑÒÓ Ð¦Ô���ÑÒÓ ÐÕÖ¥×ØÊÔÈ>�Ù��ÑÒÓÚ¹Û���ÜZ
����ݳ½Þ��� 2:7Ú¹Û$�� Íß ?���� kR�y
�����àbÎÏ3Â-Ëm ����ÎÏ�:á:gaâ��3�Q�5
T�Íb( Íß ?����ÎÏ�ã¬3/� �:���äå�Ø����
�,1æ[å�:�kR�y Â^ç���è Â^çg½éê�y��(Â^ç8
7½éë ���ìíîïÎÏ���3ð��� �ñ�� �ò³Ù�,Q��
���5
���� ó���'(�y�������+����34ÇÚb¹Û�b[
� ô¶Ç1ݳ½Þ3dZ�[1£�+õ��ö?[C'?� ݳ½Þ÷ø
ù*�b[�úÎÏ+?6:�[1û´TüL6:�5�:(�y��������
ýþ�Ã[� .�¬å�¾ *�3üLÇ2�+��'?[ÎÏ�y��+��Ç1
2�3@A��[15c������b[�Ú¹Û+�:á:è �?12�(
��6:��Ã-'0Q�+ �»'ÐV^_��ÑÒÓ+ ª ?��ÎÏ�ï@
?�ð�3TQ�Ã7n ®¯��4�Ç1,���cc����34Ç��
¹Û����[12��(��+018T�:?[�[����?Q�5
�b���'(����ÎÏ+�O78�õ��(�Q�([?[2� ��
$�(%& ��'������+�¨6:�[12� ����ÎÏ(���äå
�Ø�����,Q�?12� ����ÎÏ+kR�y Â^ç���è
Â^çg½é ���ìíîï÷ø3�C1T�:7÷ø(���j_[T
'(?[2�?�+�78�?Q�5
�����
d!"
vw¥~�(2008)ÐkR�y������+µ¶�ÃC1�����#Z1÷ø��Ó
$z{%&��'( 29)(Ú* pp. 15-27+
~�¥vw(2008)Ð�y��������Ç1ÎÏ������y����Ç1ÎÏ
%&��� ,����ÎÏ3»-���,Ó$z{|./01u��'( 13)(
Ú* pp. 1-15+
�����
�� !"#$%&'()*+�� !"#$%,-#./0
1234�56789:��;�<=��
}2ju� ï345�
67 (8���
�íE'( 9:;<=>?@�,1ABCDEF4GHj_?IJ?[;£�¤� ¥KÉ
L�MN3 O�?PQRST�U� VWXòY�Z�[��ÃC1PQRST
�dZ*��Ç1¾¿���UB_��Ç15�
�
\7�;£�¤� ¥KÉL���]^�_��
`a=bcd¥¥¥Ð;£�¤� ¥KÉL�Ó�[��e3f��g�5�
hc=baa=d¥¥¥%iu "j�,-i�k�lL3ÕX15�
man<=b 9:;<=>?@ `=<ddcd¥¥¥·¸�RS3oS �F45�
pa>qc= rascqa:tÙ¥¥¥9:;<=>?@ABCDE>��=5�
�
u7�vwx ;£�¤� ¥KÉL�y���¬�
RSz{ ¥|$ }�+©µ �~ ������Ç1@�+��5�
�¬ k� �ç��?�3@����Nº�½è5�
�
B7�PQRST�OJ��
PQRS�¬¥¥¥Ð�Ø����ÊÓ�
PQRS�ç��¥¥¥��¥�ä ���?�½Þ87ݳ5�
Ð;£�¤� ¥KÉL�Ó87Ð;£�¤� ¥������<=tc>�d���qcdb�Óg5�
�©ª}R�,1�ç�� k�%�3@�5�
�
�+Z�[�'PQRS��Ç1¾¿�����¥¥¥/Z��'íE�
©½ d!"�
���������� ������������������� !"#$%&'()
*+,-./0)12)32)45678)9:;.)<+/<.=>)+?)>;.)@A,B.>C/D)@CE0F)���������� ����������������0)==2�GH2)
*,A//./0)I2)32)456HJ8)�������������������������������������0)K,./>C<.G3ALL0)M/<2)
3+NA,-0)O2)P2456QH8���������������������������������������0)RC<;A,-)S2)M,NC/)M/<2)
T+>L.,0)K2456J8)[email protected],B.>C/D0F)��� ������������� �� 0)4@A,2GP=,28==255HG5�72)
V+W.L+<B0)X)Y)I,CD;>0)V24566J8)������!������� �������������������������")K,./>C<.)3ALL0)M/<2)
@<XA,>;Z0)[2)O2456�8)��������������#������������!!�����0)M,NC/2)
\.,-++,/0)K2)O2)456Q89@A,B.>C/D)?,+U):;.)K,+-]<.,^_)K+C/>)+?)\C.N0F$�������������������%)
OA/]A,Z0)��4`80)==2��5G�`Q2)
�����
��>?�@AB�CD
� ju� ¡¢£Í¤
�
ÐkR¥�êmarket orientationëÓ( ;£�¤� �ÃC1»- ?¦§'0-
¨�[�%&�§�(Щª»-ÓÐê6c��ÓЩª(Í©«Ó�[Q�kR¥
�3¬Ç1®¯+z°'[15
1990±� Kohli and Jaworskiå Naver and Slater+ kR¥�3²³²³?¦§��
�F4��G´ ¨���+µ¶6:�_�[152�·©½?���;( 2 b
015Íb(kR¥�³«Ã,IJ³¸¹�º T�Íb(kR¥��»����
'015kR¥��»�����'( kR¥�+¼[[�½�kR»�å¾Æ»�
+¼[2�+46:�[15c� kR¥�( È¿À�Á�åÂ�Ã��Ç1»�ê´
ZÄ Â�Ã�KÉÊÅ�Êë�T�c�[÷ø3#Z1�[���T97:�[15
2,�� kR¥�+[8�¼½'01834Ç��(¨[+ WÆkR¥�3[
8�¼�18�b[���6:�T(Ç[½8ö?[5[�b8���Ã[� k
R¥�ç�½ÞÈÉÃ,Äò�+��:�_�[1+ µ¶(Ê��(®Z?[5
���'( WÆkR¥�3¼�1��Ë�Ì���ÍìÎÏ�СÇ15ÐÍ
ì(©ª87Ñ-ÒÓ�®�:1,�� ©ª87T�76:1Íìå�[S��(
O�Ø�ºÓ�Ê3#Z��:15©ªÔ�3ÕfÇ1��¼½?ìíÖ'015
c� �:�Íì�×( ©ªØÙ3ÚZ ±�(ÛÈÜ�©ª3ÝÞ2�T015
Plymireê1991ë+ Щª¥�!ºgß8?à( Íì3áåÇ2�'015Ó�âã
�[1,�� Íì�×3¼«Ç12�( WÆkR¥��ö?87n÷ø3#Z�[
1�dZ7:15
���'( (Í� ÊÉ�;<=Å�Ê�,1Í켫�WÆkR¥����
3¾¿��5ÊÉ�;<=Å�ʽÞ( 2:c'�TkR¥�ç�½Þ���¢ä6
:�[1+ 22'(ÊÉ�;<=Å�Ê+Íì3¼«��[18�[�¬�b[�ã¬
30��5¾¿*å���( 2004±��æ6:�Z�ËR[�û�wÊÉ�;<
=Å�Ê 343çgè�龿��3ê���5
���(�� ÊÉ�;<=Å�Ê�,1Í켫+ �,�?Å�Ô�ë'WÆ
kR¥��÷ø3#Z�[183ÈÉ��5����( �Ý쩪ðíîïWÆ�
��5È��ðñåòó3¶�� ©ªðíîïWÆkR¥�3¼�1��� ÊÉ
�;<=Å�ÊÍ켫ôõ+ öª ��,�?æ÷3¶8��ø6:�[1
83�ù� �Å�Ô�ë�b[�ùú��5
�����
EFGH���GIJ#K��;�LM
�5jujuû� üý�Îþ
�
���[�$�ÃC1��(�º��Ã- Å��µ¶[�¦§<���;<=
Å�ÊÎÏ+¼cQ�[15�¦§<���;<=Å�Ê+�P��³Ç1���(
�,�?�� ?Â-WX+�½�6:1��85¦§<�¥Å�$�ÃC1
�¾ ��3FÇ1���¼½�?Q��1+¦§<�¥�KñÔ£�Á�'015
Mohr and Nevinê1990ë ¼�(1994ë�,:Ä ¦§<�¥�KñÔ£�Á�PQ(Å
�+��ê�3f» �T�Ç1�� µ¶[��© ?@Ç ³%�+��?
1f� T����Å���å¢4+ö?[�� µ¶[��© ?@Ç ³
%�+¼�?1�� T������6:�[15
2:������( f� T������ T���3�SÇ1�S T���ï
#è3F�Ç152�S T����,- Å�(µ¶[��© ?@Ç ³3
�¼��Å���æ÷�¾}3�P�������?ð�$�KñÔ£�Á�
R3ê�Ç12��?15�:�Z Å�(2,�?�� ��è�,1Å�É
Ê3µ¶[��$'ôï'_1T�dZ15
���'( Å���ê��ÃC1�|Ê����0/êTMSë��¤Ô
�� ?��è3dóÇ1�� �|¼����kR�Ã[���Ì3¼��_��L
��û´��3òYÇ15
c� �L ���¥!"ê��ÃC1�KñÔ£�Á�T� ©ªìíôïº
å#$%»?��Ã[� TMS�L �û�w�,1�¤Ô!"å�¤Ô[
�\&'3º(���� ?Â-WX+ �L �û�w��¤Ô$�ÃC1)H*
G ?+,��3-»6�1÷ø½Þ�?1�[�û�ºü�UB[���� ?WÆ
$���b[�dóÇ15
�íE'( �-�C >Å���ÃC1�L ����».�/#�� TMS�L
�û�w��¤Ô$¦§<���;<=Å�Ê�b[��L �û�w�,1!
"Ù3»-�òYÇ15c� �¤Ô�,1�©ª��;<=Å�ÊÂ-WX�X
7:10�ÎÏ�СÇ15
Í* Z�'cH16:���»�+Ë+Q�[?[�L ��|2&��w��
�3¦§<���;<=Å�Ê�b[��78�Ç12��,- �wf� T�+
��3�,1©ª ?©ª���?��è3�4��[1'(?[8�[�_�3ò
YÇ12��,- Å�����0/��¤Ô$¦§<���;<=Å�Ê
�ÃC1i�?0-*3����[_�[5
�
�����
,N'(%O)P��QR34�ST34��U
56×7¼Ù89u:� ;¼<=
�������
� 1�Ø' 1±$� 10>��GË�Ë3?@OA3�ÛÉL¥���®[ 2,
�?�ÛÉL¥��+�A[��ÃC1����ÖB'01��ù6:�[1���5
c� �A[�C/(2,�?�ÛÉL¥��3���ºÇ1��� OA��
�º�¨D���ºE�3�Q�[151990±�G´�FºÇ1�A[�°GSHT
2,�?¨D���ºE�3ßîÇ1��T'01�®�:15�8� Í*'
( ¨D���ºE�3ÑÒ'_?['0�� ÈIÀ�¦§êJTü7:15
� �2'���'( OA���Û����º�Û��è KLM87 �ÛÉ
L¥����[���º[�+�ØÇ1N��012�3ò���[�5
( 2 O'( ���Û��(�������¤P�¤êQRë�S�Ç1�� ¨D
���ºE�3�½��?[+ �º�Û��(�A[�WÆê��S�Ç1��
¨D���ºE�3�½�Ç1�[� ��Û��è KLM34Ç5( 3 O'
( �]��87 2,�?è KLM3ò��Z ��Û��+�ØÇ1N�
�012�3�78�Ç15( 4 O'( û´��87 �ÛÉL¥����[�
��º[�+�ØÇ1N��012�3ò�Ç15( 5 O'( Z��A[�3���
��û´��87 Z��A[����ºÇ1�ÛÉL¥���Ã[�T TU
��[���º[�+�ØÇ1²³è+¼[2�34Ç5
��� ���������������������
� �O'( OA���Û����º�Û��¦½3V��Z ��Û��è
KLM+j_[2�34��[�5
� OA���Û���( OݺSÒêNCEWNew Chemical Entityë3ÈÉÇ1�Û
��'0152�Û��( ��ºSÒX�87 ��ºSÒYZ¥i�º3
%� �º[\Ø ³�]1�Û��'015ÂQ� NCEå^AØ�_K`+���
Û��»��?152���Û��(���a"@bå1u Î��,Q�Ò�:
1�� ¨D���ºE�3�½��n ����¤P�¤�S�Ç1�®�:15
�:���� OA�º�Û���( NCE 3OAg��غÇ1�Û��'015
2�Û��( cdêin vitroëå�Ò3���Ç1�efÕg #$3���Ç1ef
Õg3%� hi¥º�U�y��U¾¿êPMSWPost Marketing Studyë�]1�Û
��'0152�º�Û��( �A[�WÆê��,Q�Ò�: K�#$3��
�Ç1efÕg� PMS�Ã[� ¨D���ºE�+�½'01�®�:15c� h
�����
i¥º�U PMS�Ã[� j è�ï#è+ßi'_?C:Ä �OAhi(Â-
�6:15ÂQ� hi6:�[1OA+�º�Û��»��ü?6:15hi6:�
[1OA»'T �A[�����ÖB(�ÛÉL¥��'015
Z��Ak��0( 2��Û��».ß�����ºE��b[� K,��
íE��[15cn ».ß�( ���Û��+ 0.05l'0- �º�Û��+ 20l'
015c� ���ºE� 20m25%+���Û����[7: n- 75m80%+�º
�Û����[7:1���5oZ� p��,:Ä ���Û����ù ©ª(���
�[�q#'01+ �º�Û����ù ©ª(�A[��[�Wƪ'01���5Â
Q� ���Û����º�Û��( ���º� 1 b�c��1�( �è KL
M+j_[2�+46:�5
����� �!"#$�
�O'( �]��87 ���Û��(¨D���ºE�3�½��?[+ �º
�Û��(¨D���ºE�3�½�Ç1�[� ��Û��è KLM3ò�
�Z ��Û��+�ØÇ1N��012�3�78�Ç15
� ���Û��*r���º�Û��*r�( K¶-'015���Û��»
�(^AØ�_K`Û' �º�Û��»�(�ÛÉL¥��Û'st��[15
� � �����*r�� W� log PATi,t-1 = u0 + uR log RDi,t-1
� � �º�Û��*r�� W� BBi,t = v0 + vP log PATi,t-1 + vR log RDi,t
� � � PATW^AØ�_K`ÛwBBW�ÛÉL¥��ÛwRDW���ºE�Dw
� ���Û���ÛuR( ���ºE�D+K`Û�#Z1#�3xÌè'yø��³
Û'015uRz1RS ���Û��gE�3 2{���±� H16:1K`Û+
2{GË�?12�3@A� 2:(Ý|%i�}Ä:1èè'015Í* uR<1'0
:Ä ���ºE�Ý|~%i+ü7:12��?15
�º�Û���ÛvR( ���ºE�D+�ÛÉL¥��Û�#Z1#�3xÌ
è'yø��³Û'015vRz1 RS �º�Û���Ã[�Ý|%i+ü7:12
��?15c� �ÛvP( K`Û+�ÛÉL¥��Û�#Z1#�3xÌè'yø
��T'015
���Û����º�Û��°±*r�)���]����( K,�?T
'01êyÚ,� �ë���5
���ºE�D+�ÛÉL¥��Û���Ç#�3xÌè'4dzÛvR�³V(
0.903'0- ¬X�M( 0.184'0152:7ÛV(���ºE�D�½�%´���
ÛÉL¥��Û+áoÇ12�3@AÇ15�:���� ���ºE�D+K`Û
�����
���Ç#�3xÌè'4dzÛuR�³V( 0.667 '0- ¬X�M( 0.119 '015
��� ���Û���(�ß����ºE�Ý|~%i+ü7:12��?15
Í* ³ÛvP�³V( 0.361'0- 2:(K`Û 1%áo+T�7Ç�ÛÉL¥
��Ûáo( 0.361%'012�3@AÇ152o(�78�vR,-�6� �
º�Û��»�� ���Û��»�+T�7ÇÛoË#�(j_�?[�®Z15
2:( ���Û����º�Û��3Ò/Ç1[�+�ØÇ1N��012�34�Ç
1��'015
ÂQ� �O�]����87 ���ºE�D+K`Û�#Z1#���ÛÉL¥
��Û�#Z1#�+j_�?12�+ò�6: 8b K`Û+�ÛÉL¥�
�Û�#Z1#�+�³6:�[12�+�78�?Q�52�]����( ( 2
O'4����Û��è KLM3�� �!FÇ1T'015
yÚ,�� �]����
abcd ef ghi jklm
u0 -1.119 0.888
noabcd
uR 0.667 0.119
v0 -7.591 1.283
vP 0.361 0.123 pqabcd
vR 0.903 0.184
rfst -343.7
uvwMiyashige, T., Fujii, A. and Kimura, K., “Are Research and Development Processes Independent
in the Pharmaceutical R&D?,” International Congress on Modelling and Simulation 2007
Proceedings, 2007, p.1038.xyz{(
%�&'� �!"#$�
�O'( û´��87 �ÛÉL¥����[���º[�+�ØÇ1N��
012�3ò�Ç15
� 1990m2003 ±c'C±ê1997 ±3��ë�Ã[� hi6:�[1�ÛÉL¥�
���[���º[�3¾¿Ç1� Ã,� 20m30l�ÛÉL¥���Ã[�
��[���º[�+�Ø��[12�+46:1êyà,� �ë5
� c� ��[���º[�+�Ø��[1�ÛÉL¥��öª û´3ü�X1
� Paxil Fosamax Allegra Zithromax ?� CA#�·3�yÇ1,�?�ÛÉ
L¥���Ã[�T ��[���º[�+�Ø��[12�+46:1êyà,Ì
���5
�����
yà,�� ��[���º[��Ø��[1�ÛÉL¥��ÏS
| }�b~���d� f ��no���pq�������f ������
1990 5 2 40.0
1991 8 2 25.0
1992 13 1 7.7
1993 22 5 22.7
1994 16 3 18.8
1995 21 5 23.8
1996 24 4 16.7
1998 14 3 21.4
1999 34 7 20.6
2000 43 6 14.0
2001 50 9 18.0
2002 56 16 28.6
2003 72 20 27.8
uvw������������nopq{�����nopq�����no�noabcd�pqa
bcd����� ¡¢££�"¤¥¦§¨§¨©ª«¬¨no¬®¬¨¯°±²³´¤2008¤
p.51µxyz{(
yà,Ì� ��[���º[�+�ØÇ1�ÛÉL¥��©?û´
2003|�¶·¸¹ º»¼ no���½¾ pq��
7 Paxil Ferrosan (Denmark) GlaxoSmithKline
14 Fosamax Gentili (Italia) Merck
23 Mabthera IDEC (USA) Roche
24 Allegra Sepracor (USA) Sanofi-Aventis
25 Lovenox Pharmuka (France) Sanofi-Aventis
26 Zithromax Sour Pliva (Croatia) Pfizer
67 Combivir BioChem Pharma (Canada) GlaxoSmithKline
69 Eloxatin Debiopharm (Switzerland) Sanofi-Aventis
uvw������������nopq{�����nopq�����no�noabcd�pqa
bcd����� ¡¢££�"¤¥¦§¨§¨©ª«¬¨no¬®¬¨¯°±²³´¤2008¤
p.52µxyz{(
� ÂQ� ( 3 O�]����'�78�6:�,�� û´����87T �
ÛÉL¥����[���º[�+�ØÇ1N��012�+ò�6:�5
�����
(�)*�+�,-�./�01�
� ( 3 O�( 4 O�Ã[� ���Û����º�Û��è KLM87 �ÛÉ
L¥����[���º[�+�ØÇ1N��012�+46:�5
� �2'�O'( Z�ðÉ 4�®�:1�tAØk� >��Ô��A (Í�ô
��ÈjR�A[� 4 /û´87 Z�jR�A[����ºÇ1�ÛÉL¥
���Ã[�T TU ��[���º[�+�ØÇ1²³è+¼[2�34Ç5
ê�ë�tAØk�
� �tAØk�( 1980m1990 ±�� ó}�+°5�AÐ�ñ���Ó �ºè��
5�AÐ�£�Û�Ó ¼���5�AÐ�Û���Ó ���5�AÐ>LÊ�Ó?�
�ÛÉL¥��3���Z�º��_�5ÂQ� �t���º���ÛÉL¥
��( ��[���º[�+�Ø��[?8Q�'015
�8� TU �t���ºÇ1�ÛÉL¥��( ��[���º[�+�Ø
Ç1²³è+¼[5
�t�t��0)�)����/)( �ÛÉL¥��3j³ �ÝXLÇ��
�( NCE lhT�½'0- �/��'Ø�Z3\[_:?[ NCE ( [��w
87¶õ �lhÇ1�âã�[1��5ÂQ� �t( ���ºE�Ý|~%i+
ü7:1���Û��3 ÈIÀ�¦§?���wº�,����[1'015
y�,�� �tAØk��,1��»�êNCEëlhê2007m2008±ë
¿À Á�Â���ÃÄ ÅÆÇÈÉÊ»Ë
2007| 3Ì ÍÎ��d�ÏÐ �Ñ�ÒÓ�}ÔÕÖ�pq×�ضסÙÚ
2007| 3Ì ÛÜÝÞßàá�âÝãÜäåæçèé¡ê� ëìíîïðÖ�ñòno{��pqסÙÚ
2007| 5Ì óôqõ�ÏÐ öÆ÷Ó�z{øù�úûסÙÚ
2007| 6Ì üý�þ~�d�ÏÐ NCE�pq×�ضסÙÚ
2008| 2Ì ü��������¡ê� NCE13»Ë�pq×�ضסÙÚ
2008| 4Ì cý���d�ÏÐ ���Ñ ����}ÔÕÖ�pq×�ضסÙÚ
2008| 4Ì ����á���å��äåæç���ß¡ê� $����Ñ�ÒÓ� NCE�pq×�ضסÙÚ
2008| 5Ì ���àÝá���å��äåæç���ß¡ê� ñòno{��pq×�ضסÙÚ
uvw���� !xyz{(
� �. �t( 2007m2008 ± 2 ±$�Ã[�T ÈIÀ�¦§?�[��w8
7��»�êNCEë3lhÇ1�4 01[( lhÇ1�Õ3 8 �T�æ��[1êy
�,� �ë5
�����
2,��jR�A[�'01�t( ���ºE��½�%´��»�97:1�
º�Û��(Ò/Ç1+ ���ºE�Ý|~%i+ü7:1���Û��(ÈI
À�¦§?���wºÇ1,��?Q�_�'015��� TU(�t���
ºÇ1�ÛÉL¥���Ã[�T ��[���º[�+�ØÇ1²³è+¼['
015
êÌë>��Ô��A
� >��Ô��A( 1980m1990±�� �ó [�6¡2�A+�ºè��5�A
Т��Óå£�¤¥¦§AШ�©�Ó?��ÛÉL¥��3 °8�ó
[�ª«AØk�+¬Ú�AÐ�Û Ô®Ó?��ÛÉL¥��3���Z
�º��_�5ÂQ� >��Ô����º���ÛÉL¥��( ó [�±
�3��� ��[���º[�+�Ø��[?8Q�'015
�8� TU >��Ô����ºÇ1�ÛÉL¥��( ��[���º[�
+�ØÇ1²³è+¼[5
� >��Ô�¯ý°±ô°0)( ÈIÀ�¦§�_²3³�12�'���º
oSÌ3¼��[_�[�� OA´êNCEë3ÈÇ��� µ¶3·Q���3I
�1ÈIÀ�¦§�С��[1�âã�[1��5oZ� [�»)3FÇ1�(
OA+¸8�n jR�A[�(OAXA¹ºåï»? NCE3FbÈIÀ�¦§
�Õ3GC�[�2��?1���Tâã�[1���5ÂQ� >��Ô�( ���º
E�Ý|~%i+ü7:1���Û��3 ÈIÀ�¦§?���wº�,��
��[1'015
y�,Ì� >��Ô��A�,1��»�êNCEëlhê2007m2008±ë
¿À Á�Â���ÃÄ ÅÆÇÈÉÊ»Ë
2007| 1Ì Í"�# ý�ÏÐ NCE�ÔÕÖ�ñòpqסÙÚ
2007| 11Ì ü���d¡ê� NCE11»Ë�pq×�ضסÙÚ
2008| 2Ì $%&nov�ÏÐ "'���ÒÓ�pq×�ضסÙÚ
2008| 4Ì ()���d�ÏÐ ��*Ûà�å��ÒÓ�}ÔÕÖ�pq×�ضסÙÚ
2008| 9Ì �Í����ÏÐ $%+,ÓÈ-�}ÔÕÖ�pq×�ضסÙÚ
uvw���� !xyz{(
� �. >��Ô�( 2007m2008 ± 2 ±$�Ã[�T ÈIÀ�¦§?�[�
�w87��»�êNCEë3lhÇ1�4 01[( lhÇ1�Õ3 5 �T�æ��[
1êy�,Ì �ë5
� 2,��jR�A[�'01>��Ô�( ���ºE��½�%´��»�97
�����
:1�º�Û��(Ò/Ç1+ ���ºE�Ý|~%i+ü7:1���Û��(
ÈIÀ�¦§?���wºÇ1,��?Q�_�'015��� TU(>��
Ô����ºÇ1�ÛÉL¥���Ã[�T ��[���º[�+�ØÇ1²³
è+¼['015
êÚë(Í�ô
� (Í�ô( 1980m1990±�� �ó [��ô+¼¼��5�AÐÅÛ¦�Ó
?��ÛÉL¥��3 °8�ó [�(Í�A+½¾AÐ��ðÉÊÓ?�
�ÛÉL¥��3���Z�º��_�5ÂQ� (Í�ô���º���ÛÉ
L¥��( ó [�±�3��� ��[���º[�+�Ø��[?8Q�
'015
�8� TU (Í�ô���ºÇ1�ÛÉL¥��( ��[���º[�+
�ØÇ1²³è+¼[5
� (Í�ô¿tÀ/)( ÁO ?OA3ÝXL���A[����».3Õ�1��
� �/��-?[¹º([��w87lh� RS�,Q�( NCET[��w87Â9
�� 2015±�(ÃÄÊÉ�LÔ�OA3��Z1�A0/�?12�3¡¢��[1
�âã�[1���5ÂQ� (Í�ô( ���ºE�Ý|~%i+ü7:1���Û
��3 ÈIÀ�¦§?���wº�,����[1'015
� �. (Í�ô( 2007m2008 ± 2 ±$�Ã[�T ÈIÀ�¦§?�[��
w87��»�êNCEë3lhÇ1�4 01[( lhÇ1�Õ3 4 �T�æ��[1
êy�,Ú �ë5
y�,Ú� (Í�ô�,1��»�êNCEëlhê2007m2008±ë
¿À Á�Â���ÃÄ ÅÆÇÈÉÊ»Ë
2007| 7Ì ü�����ÏÐ ./01�ÒÓÈ-�½ÃÖ�pq×�ضסÙÚ
2008| 5Ì 2 d" 34 �¡ê� �Ñ�ÒÓ�pq×�ضסÙÚ
2008| 7Ì ��5�6�ß78æçé��ÏÐ öÆ÷Ó��9¡:;�øù¡ÙÚ
2008| 11Ì ü Í< ý�ÏÐ �Ñ�ÒÓ�pq×�ضסÙÚ
uvw���� !xyz{(
� 2,��jR�A[�'01(Í�ô( ���ºE��½�%´��»�97:
1�º�Û��(Ò/Ç1+ ���ºE�Ý|~%i+ü7:1���Û��(
ÈIÀ�¦§?���wºÇ1,��?Q�_�'015��� TU((Í�ô
���ºÇ1�ÛÉL¥���Ã[�T ��[���º[�+�ØÇ1²³è+
¼['015
�����
êàë��È
� ��È( 1980m1990 ±�� �ºè��5�AÐ���ÉÊÓ >�ŨÈ;�
5�AÐ>���ÊÓ?��ÛÉL¥��3���Z�º��_�5ÂQ� �
�È���º���ÛÉL¥��( ��[���º[�+�Ø��[?8Q�
'015
�8� TU ��È���ºÇ1�ÛÉL¥��( ��[���º[�+
�ØÇ1²³è+¼[5
��È2ªÆ±/)( NCE3Â9Ç1���4å�Õ�Ã[� ÇD��Ç1
~j(ö?� ½+°�?�TU»)Ç1µ¶�ï»?OAå NCE3FQ�[1ÈIÀ
�¦§3È��7j¹�[�~j*+j_[5��� 2,�?ÈIÀ�¦
§3?°���'TÂ9��[�âã�[1�10
�5ÂQ� ��È( ���ºE�
Ý|~%i+ü7:1���Û��3 ÈIÀ�¦§?���wº�,����[
1'015
� �. ��È( 2007m2008 ± 2 ±$�Ã[�T ÈIÀ�¦§?�[��
w87��»�êNCEë3lhÇ1�4 01[( lhÇ1�Õ3 6 �T�æ��[1
êy�,à �ë5
y�,à� ��È�,1��»�êNCEëlhê2007m2008±ë
¿À Á�Â���ÃÄ ÅÆÇÈÉÊ»Ë
2007| 3Ì =ý3>�~�¡ê� NCE7»Ë�pq×�ضסÙÚ
2007| 7Ì ?@A���ÏÐ ö�ÑB 4»Ë�ضסÙÚ
2007| 12Ì MGI34 �¡ê� NCE�pq×�ضסÙÚ
2008| 8Ì ��@CºÓ�ÏÐ "�DE�ÒÓ�ñòpqסÙÚ
2008| 8Ì F½��Ñnov�ÏÐ öÆ÷Ó�noøù¡ÙÚ
2008| 9Ì G�HI@G�d�ÏÐ �J�È-� NCE�pq�ض�KÂLMסÙÚ
uvw���� !xyz{(
� 2,��jR�A[�'01��È( ���ºE��½�%´��»�97:
1�º�Û��(Ò/Ç1+ ���ºE�Ý|~%i+ü7:1���Û��(
ÈIÀ�¦§?���wºÇ1,��?Q�_�'015��� TU(��È
���ºÇ1�ÛÉL¥���Ã[�T ��[���º[�+�ØÇ1²³è+
¼['015
�����
ê�ë��
� Z�ðÉ 4 �®�:1�t >��Ô� (Í�ô ��ÈjR�A[� 4 /
( [n:T ���ºE��½�%´��»�97:1�º�Û��(Ò/Ç1+
���ºE�Ý|~%i+ü7:1���Û��(ÈIÀ�¦§?���wºÇ
1,��?Q�_�5��� TU(Z�jR�A[����ºÇ1�ÛÉL¥
���Ã[�T ��[���º[�+�ØÇ1²³è+¼[2�+46:�5
2�345��
� ���'( OA���Û����º�Û��è KLM87 �ÛÉL¥
����[���º[�+�ØÇ1N��012�3ò���_�5
( 2 O'( ���Û��(�������¤P�¤êQRë�S�Ç1�� ¨D
���ºE�3�½��?[+ �º�Û��(�A[�WÆê��S�Ç1��
¨D���ºE�3�½�Ç1�[� ��Û��è KLM34��5( 3 O
'( �]��87 2,�?è KLM3ò��Z ��Û��+�ØÇ1N
��012�3�78���5( 4 O'( û´��87 �ÛÉL¥����[
���º[�+�ØÇ1N��012�3ò���5( 5 O'( Z��A[�3��
���û´��87 Z��A[����ºÇ1�ÛÉL¥���Ã[�T T
U ��[���º[�+�ØÇ1²³è+¼[2�34��5
� ��� �ÛÉL¥����[���º[�+�ØÇ1N��012�+ò�
6:�'015
6�
ê�ë;¼<=$^AØ[�%&PQ,[�É��,1[�»)�jÊSH�,1[�
»),'wË!/w2005wpp.44-52+�
êÌëZ��Ak��0Ì$DATA BOOK 2006'wZ��Ak��0w2006wpp.36-44+
êÚëp�£Í$~ß�è;<=Å�Ê,OAXL R&DÐùÓ'wZ% BP/w2006w
pp.19-22+�
êàëMiyashige, T., Fujii, A. and Kimura, K., “Are Research and Development Processes
Independent in the Pharmaceutical R&D?,” International Congress on Modelling
and Simulation 2007 Proceedings, 2007,pp.1035-1039.�
ê�ë;¼<=$ÕÍ�a"Ç1���º»����Ç���ºE�#���Î���
Û����º�Û���Ø�ã¬30��Î'wÇ«jujuû�Ï1u��1ÝÐ
1u8ÑÒGN!w2008wpp.17-20+�
êÓëMiyashige, T., “Scale Expansion and the Change of Research and Development
Activities -Case of Takeda Pharmaceutical Company-,” Far Eastern Studies, 6,
�����
2007, pp.51-63.
êÔëZ�%iOÕÖ× 2008± 4Ø 9ZÙwp.11+�
êÚëZ�%iOÕÖ× 2008± 1Ø 10ZÙwp.11+�
êÛëZ�%iOÕÖ× 2007± 11Ø 29ZÙwp.6A+�
ê10ëZ�%iOÕÖ× 2008± 6Ø 27ZÙwp.17+
�
789:�
Cockburn, I. M. and Henderson, R. M., “Scale and scope in drug development:
unpacking the advantages of size in pharmaceutical research,” Journal of Health
Economics, 20, 2001, pp.1033-1057.
Gambardella, A., “Competitive advantages from in-house scientific research: the US
pharmaceutical industry in the 1980s,” Research Policy, 2, 1992, pp.391-407.
Gassmann, O., Reepmeyer, G. and Zedtwitz, M., Leading Pharmaceutical Innovation:
Trends and Drivers for Growth in the Pharmaceutical Industry, Springer, 2008.
Graves, S. B. and Langowitz, N., “Innovative productivity and returns to scale in the
pharmaceutical industry,” Strategic Management Journal, 14, 1993, pp.593-605.
p�£Í¥¼Üݱ$WÆ�@Ç ³'wÖÞß3w2001+
àwáâÌ$^AØã�WÆN'wäåjuLæ0w2002+
�·§ÝÐ�ç�É���èòYÎ��Èé�0/>�ŨÈ;ÊiÎ�5
�AÐ>���ÊÓÈÉ��¦ëû´��ÎÓ$Z�%&u0ê'( 19*w2007wpp.3-14+
Schwartzman, D., Innovation in the Pharmaceutical Industry, Johns Hopkins
University Press, 1976.
�����
VWX#YZK%[\]�^_#�ST�`STabcd
jëju� ìtíî
�
ï+����ðBC�
���( �Ø����ÊXº3�;�����Í·��� FGÊÈ¿À�
Á��;?=�D>cdDcd�<db�ñ<@dc=�\òòu�FG½Þ3È12��015FG½Þ�b[�(ç
����Ã[� ¹º+ïÇ1KèêñaDcd�c=��6óôõë K³¹º3ö÷Ç1�ÔçÈë
�øaD�6óù\� �ñ¥<ÉÊ�Lê;?=�D>cdDcd6óóôë»�+46:�[15���
(�:7»�3T�� Iç�ú��Ø�º3û´��� �º��º���
�� FG½Þ+�,������[183ßiÇ15���FG½Þ3O�?JVK
û3XºÇ12�g�4�X?� JVKûXºR+8-�b[�dóÇ15�
ü+¾¿¦½�
¾¿����� ÊÔÈ>�Û� ¨��¤ý§É�3Fb©ª�CIç�ú�3
�-0m15û´�Ã[�СÇ1( þLÔ�L��[���Ì3®Û�Ê�>��
�Ç1wØ'015LÔ�L(ÂH �o �¹�bKû��Ç1FGÊÈ¿À�
Á�3*G� �º+I�7:�_�5�
Iç�ú�©ª(oã���S'_n �ú�3�78��'g[2?�?[5
���Iç�ú�( Í#Í#©ª³Ì3º('_1�Ø3 �ºÇ1¡ 3
FQ�[15°Í�º��,1 u ç?1©ª�C�ºû´87 G`¬3ßi�
�5(��LÔ�L)6�[�Kû�b[�( �Ä ��³6:�� �$�ê6õ�
K�m6ô�K�� \7�K�Pɦ$�ë87ö÷��[15(Ì�LÔ�L)ö÷(
)01[(�`)�×8� �º�+%g ��Q�[15�
�+dó�
2:7ø�( �º�+��2�?�+8���Ç1þ�ºóF�êìt�\òòòë��Ä
b�5Í#Í#©ª³Ì3 ij�º(Ç12�+é�7:1Iç�Ø�º'
( �º�+þ�ºóF��¡3�C1RS+��Ç152ø�3 oã�Ø+@�
v@� ��³��[1þ¬X©ª�� �287�:1þ�¬X©ª�¦§�,Q�V�
Ç1522�( JVKûXº3¥�Ç1�º3��RS� þ�¬X©ª�3���
�Â-�Þ2�+'_1Iç�Ø�º3ê�Ç12�' �ø²³è3¼�12�
�b?+15�
�+�N�
����N( (�� �ºóF3!Z1þ¬X©ª� (Ì� þ�¬X©ª��,1
�ºóFi�#� (Ú� þ�¬X©ª�3��ºÇ1þîï�#�'015�
�����
ICT�Te�f���X&gh �^_#%G'K��(�ij�
,k#.lmno%ip����q
��«�jujuû� ����
� ;£�¤� ���Ã[��Ô��N( �-�C 1908±�G´ ¼½?��µ¶�
ü?6:1,��?Q�_�[15�,�?�Ô��N»�Ã[� j�Ç:Ä 2 b
���µ3��Ç12�+'_15Ç?�O ( 1 ( �����87 �Ô��
��ÇÎÏ3K³º��[1©ªÀ�¥�Ô��¥�LÈ�¤N'0- �* ( 2(
[�;£�¤� ê��ã¬3S��� �Ô���¨�b[�®�Ç1�Ô��¥
>È���¤�¤N'0152:7 2 b�� ( ð���_�0[?+7 °��
Ø+Eh6:�kR�Ã[� �Ô��JV�¨3�78���_�[1T �*
' [��,1?1;£�¤� ê�3óF���Ã- �:�Z [��,1;
£�¤� ê��b[�T°�'01�[��³(?6:�[?[�[��Ä3!Z�[
1�¢ä6:,�5
� �2' "Nê2009ë( [��,1;£�¤� ê�Ã,Ä�Ø+°�'012�
3óF� ���$�KñÔ£�Á�+�Ô��JV3�»Ç1�©#��5��
2��( ���$�KñÔ£�Á��ã¬3S���[?+7 �:+Ý�Ç1�
��$<ÉÊ�L�b[�( $#�$�X<ÉÊ�L+%»6:�[1�[
���K�¤�?&'3�³��[�5�8�?+7 ø� ICT ºJ�(Q� ��
�°G+�KñÔ£�Á�Ç12�'_1<ÉÊ�L(¹º��_�[15�2'
ICT ºJ�(����$�KñÔ£�Á��b[�¹º3de�h:� �Ô��
JVÝ»¥¹�3MNÇ1�½+Ý815
� �íE�Ã[�( ICTºJ�(Q�¹ºÇ1���$�KñÔ£�Á��b[�
( 1 � �:+Ý�Ç1<ÉÊ�L�y�)¡Ç15bc- ���(����1q#
$�KñÔ£�Á�¥<ÉÊ�LC'?� *+�Ëï�K ÈÊå,-.4
/?�,�� !"03S��12�?[ðR��KñÔ£�Á�¥<ÉÊ�
L3Tï��[1�dZ7:15�-�C U����� �£�¥®�¥<ÉÊ�
L�}Ä�1�y+¢ä6:�[15�* ( 2 � �ÃÄ�KñÔ£�Á��*
+�Ë'�KñÔ£�Á��$�KñÔ£�Á�è M�ã¬3S��15
�ÃÄ'�KñÔ£�Á�( ð������1q#$�Ã[�Ý�� ú� *+
�Ë'�KñÔ£�Á�(ð��q#3���Z?[&''Ý�Ç1�dZ1?7Ä
�:7�KñÔ£�Á��(è ?M+��Ç1�dZ7:158��� ICT
ºJ�(Q�¹ºÇ1���$�KñÔ£�Á���Ç1�:7 2 bKL3de�h
:��¨6:��Ô��JVÝ»¥¹���Ç1�Kñ��Á�¥)����)�
��g��+46:15
�����
rstuvwx����`y4z{c��;�<=��
126ju� 345�
µ¶1uju� 6ð7
�ºy_�( Ð\�@�Ó��Ç1|.%&��3��2��,Q� Z�×��
y3ÝXLǽÞ�b'01\��[�¦§+Z��K8?T'0183òYÇ1
2�'0152_��9�?Q�( 2004±���:�û�*hÃ,Ä\�@���
Ç1ÈÉ ?Z:¾¿'0152¾¿'(�;?��+��:�+ K� ×3�\<
�=+-�63²1��¢¬'01Ð\�@�Ó��Ç1¼½?4�3�Þ��+
97:�5>;(/° \�@��b[�(Z�×#½�+:|×#,-T¼['
0�� 872�Z�×#½�+û�*h3��N�+01 �dZ�[�5
¾¿���8Q�2�( Ð\�@�Ó�b[�(Z:�|$'�??M(ü7:?[�
[�2�'0Q�52��(���¼½'01�dZ7:�5�[�( >;+/°
�³��[�Ð\�@�+¼[�û�*h@�T¼�?1Ó�[Q�Í_@V3lL�
�Û=ÉL�(ð�:?[87'015
2��3�C� A��ê2007ë(Ð×��\<�=+-ÓB¦§���Ð\�Ó
�С� ¦§ ?èòY3�Q�5öª �( Ð\�Ó3�»Ç1C¦§3}�� j
_�( 2b¦§���ÜZ7:12�3¢ä��5D�b( Ð\�;E�Ó���
\�¦§' T�D�b(ÐÍ\Ý]��E�Ó���\�¦§' ó�3ÐÃ
FÊ\�Ó U�3ÐÝ�Ê\�Ó�çBC�5Ð\�Ó3Ìb¦§�P-�C�dZ1
� ÃFÊ\�(!" �\<*h@��÷ø3#Z1+ Ý�Ê\�(!" �û�*
h@��÷ø3#Z?[ �[�Û=ÉL+�³'_15��Ç1� ç�Z:¾¿'(
ÐÝ�Ê\�Ó@�+Ð\�@�Ó���ÜZ7:�[�²³è+0- ��� û
�*h3��N�+01Z�×#� û�*h3��?[N�+01:|×#Ð\
�@�Ó�M+?8Q�2�3}S �ÜZ12�+'_1,��?15
�ºy'( 2007±��:�¾¿�UB[� A��ê2007ë'òY6:�Ð\�Ó3
�»Ç1C¦§��Ç1����3�Q�5���(bG 2¬�½4'_15( 1�
H¼?ùú3�½�Ç1T \��ã ��ê×� ~�ãë�b[�( Z�,
-:|×#½�+¼«��[1N�+ßi6:�5( 2 � ¹º ��ê��¹³¥
q#¹³ë�b[�( :|,-Z�×#½�+¼«Ç1N�+ßi6:�5K�
Z�'(I¶�KñÔ�¤å©ª Â^ç����[Q�2���Ç1¹³3¼«Ç1
N�+ü7:�5
�_N!
A�J ¥¼KL�¥345¥z6M�ê2007ëÐ��×��ÃC1\�*h¦§èòY
ÎZ:%&��3»-���,Ó$|N%iOê'( 195)( 3* 17,31P5
�����
G'K�|�}~������;� �����4����������
�5uûju� Q6�Ò
�
��;<�=>
j± RSy4û�Fº?�~/y4��+áo��[1522�(T�Â^UÃ
0VØy4åæWX�ÛáoN�87T�78'015c�×ØøÒ3ßi'_n
y4YDE3,-��Z13Z?[<Éʶ�[��,- ~/y4��Ç1\«ê�å
Ý��½è(¼cQ�[15�8�]^�,1Ý�(û�ê��4�[���T0-
Ý����ªå�WX¥ä�(./?8 û��([8?1�×3Çã_8+��
�?15
�2'�M( ~/y4��Ç1å�¹�R�¥_�0-*� û���© ÂW
X0-*�b[� <Éʶ�~/y43»-�c��1T'015
�?@ABCD�EF
G�HIAJ�EF
VØy4åê��ç`(~/VØ��Ä~/y4abåë( T�8b��?��3ß
îÇ1ò¬87�����?ö÷3cm1®j?VØ�Fd�e�~/?y4�e3
Ý���[152�O~/VØ�Ý�( ÐÂ^�Ùf��Óêå 2g 1hëFd6:
1®i?VØ3Ý�Ç1T'0- T�Â^UÃ0ºÇ1E4+ jk�,1VØ�
oÙVØ�b[� �i¼DåoD3Â^JD 10�Ì?��öª ÛV3TQ
�lc�³��[115
c�~/y4Ý�( ÐØè Ý��2�Óê[��1���i å 4g 1h 1*ë
åÐJ��Â^g�Óê[��1ï��i å 4 g 1 h 2 *ë+ û��ðæ��
?����'01�Íß�������4Çy43Ý���[15�:7�z°'ÐÍß
�����i6:1Ã�:+01y4Ó�O'ÐT�Â^UÃ0+¢³Ç1TÓêå 4
g 1 h 3 *ë�b[�TÝ���[1252:7 3 �Ê~/y4�O���i�b[
�( y4mÙC�?1S� ?no���b[�}�pq+ T�Â^UÃ0'
(?�/ry43�Q�û����_�7:1�[���pqúsݳ+�C7:�Ã
-êå 4 g 2 hë S� no3TQ���'_?[DE3~/y4�X?Çݳ�?Q
�[15
?ÃVØy4å~/y4Ý�( ���?1×Ø¥ ð�3��n��6:152
1 NO�P£QRS�C a�TUVWÙX�YZ[NÈQ�Öò��\,r]ÖVÈQ(
2 ÅÆÇ�V#^�_�`abcde�f��gh#i»�jk½�f��lmÈgh#nopqû�r
�oû�f��lmÈgh#lsk�t�uvw�f��gh#t�uvw�f��gh#�cx�y
��f��lmÈgh#�zJ�{h|}£Q�(
�����
½8�K³×Ø X3���Ç1y4Ý����Aûåå JASå ÖØtÝå?�
+0- K³Â^%ä3���Ç1y4Ý����K³×Â^å+01+ 2:7VØ
y4åG�y4Ý��b[�®�(�M'(ÏuÇ135
GHIKABJ�LMNO3!P��
VØy4å(0vwbåK�å�[��ðBC'0- µ¶]÷U� ?VWX3
��]÷ xy]÷ ¾}]÷���Ç1ò¬87( 2:7åz(��]÷����
ðBC7:15
0vwbåT ~/y4�b[�(~T�?Â^*å�OÐGc° ©ª{^Óêå 2
g 9h 3*Ã,ÄÍߢ³ 8hë�,Q� ~/VØ�b[�(~T�?Â^*å�O
Ð~/?�Í�,1©ª{^Óêå 2g 9h 3*Ã,ÄÍߢ³ 9hë�,Q�Ý���
[152:7�OVØy4å(��� ~/VØ�b[�(óâ�Ã-Â^�Ùf�
�Fd6:1TX3���� ~/y4�b[�(Íß�����Ç1TX3�
����[145~/VØ�~/y4Ý��ÃC1�åz�|¬( æWåæWÃ�:
01�e����T�Â^UÃ0+£�Ð}ê0vwbåRS(£�~ðÐ}ë �E
!ßc�(ï��,1Ð@3ºÇ1¬'015c�2:7X��O £�Ð}��E
�b[�(Ty6:1¬'T�|Ç15
Í*'�åzðæ¬���VØy4åX��C7:�[1ݳÍb+ T�Â^
UÃ0�oZ��à^�ÎûT~/?ê�3�Q�û������ Ty3(�¢4 !
ßc�(ï��,1Ð@�[Q�X�3��2�+'_1¬'01êå 7 gë5c�û�
�+VØ y4ê��b[��©Ý�3��T���Ý4�¹+�C7:�[1¬'0
1êå 12gë5T�Â^UÃ0+C�Ä�,Q��© �³�7:�T���Ý43i³
Ç12�' /rÝ4�UB[�û���e�(£�Ð}+?6:?[�[�Í�Ã
�Ù_+#Z7:15
G�HJDQ3!PRSTUVW�3O"XY�Z[
VØy4å(3�å��3�[�Ô���+¨Ûû���,Q���6:�[�2�
87 1962 ±��³6:�+ y4Ý�(j±å¦��,-�º6:1N��015Ç?
�O 2003±¦�'óâ~/y4�O���i��Ç1}�pqúsݳ+�C7
: �± 2008 ±¦�'( 2�o�j�+����4å�UB[�i³������
ª����~/y4Mb��é�+Ù#6:�52:(�]X�+��'01VØy4
å�Ã[�Nû�é3O��i�12�'����¥�ñab3¡ ���[15c�
3 O�~���iÙXV�hiÙX�·��qض��m���Öò��gh\,�r]�Èu#�»g
h����Ç��û|}�(
4 ��O;#O�~�3?@�Î@�d���t������§È�������������V#�
»gh�ÖVÈ���Ç���X�N£����� ¡�¢£�È�(
�����
°± i� �å¦�(ü�7:�+ ~/y43�Q�û�����×Ø¥ ð�
�ËDÚl_LÇ�Ù3Ð81_LÇ�¹O�+|0'�M6:�55?ÃVØÝ
�( å¦�(��:�[?[TE4�,- oÙVØ�¹D+^_Ëm7:1?
��1N��015
å�¹�º�H�� å�UB[�_�¥R�T�º6:�[15`y(VØy4å
��Ç1T�Â^UÃ0��à^��,1X��Û��'01652:3X1� ~/V
Ø�%&��~/y4X��Û+�� �¨[2� X��Û�OTy3(�¼[X
�'01£�Ð}¥�E¥�à^�Îû�,1¢4+áoN��012�+�815
yWVØy4å��Ç1X��Û
������ ������ ������ ����� �����
�� � ���� � �� �� �� �
�� �� � ���� ��� �� ��� �� ��������� !� �� �� �� ��
������ �� " " � �� �
��#$ ���� � � � � �
�� � � � � ��� �� � � �� �������� !� � � � � ������� �� " " � �� ����������� ������������������������ !"#$%
c�T�Â^UÃ0(Íß���4 1,100ç87?1���)Ô��¹½8 2005
±¹,-4 200ç87?1���Â^��ºUÃ�¹3�C�0vwbåÃ,ÄVØy4
åæW��Ç1\«ê�åìíÕf3�Q�[15�à^�'T°�ê�+��: �
�ZÄäå�( 2002±¹,-��Ý꾿Ã�¹3�f� ø�(4 200ç+VØy4
åæW��Ç1\«ê�3�Q�[15
��\]^_`�ab"?@AB�cdeZ
G�HEF
¶+��(���Â^'0-×ØøÒ3ßiÇ12�+'_?[5���� �h
��h@Ç ³(���y4¥DE�¨�S�Ç12��?15�-�Cj±kR+
�j��[1<Éʶ�( %& ���Ê'û��f+��'012�87¨Ûû
�� h¥�L+F�'0- ìí�*�è?�KL87IL�Á�å>®¤�
�ÈÊ�[Q�¨�?��%ä+Ýc:�[15����~/y4\«ê�3�ºÇ
1�½è+¼[5
�8� VØy4å(�� Ý�'01�� å�¹Ë(��%äå��Ø¡�,Q�
5 ¤¥¥,tV�����Ö¦§¨|}£tu#©ª¦�»gh�Ö�«�¬|}�®¯°�:Q(
6 2004|t±Ö�²³´µ�¶�·¸¹fVº»gÖ¢�(
�����
Ý�2��M(?[5TQ�T <Éʶ�����(T�Â^UÃ0+ 2000 ±�È
��<ÉÊËy4TVØy4åË~/y4�r/��12�3E4�,Q��ß�
��0� 2002±�Ð����C,-×Â^�ÃC1y4�b[�VØy4åË��
¬��@ûhÓ�[�¢È�ÔÈ�3Ty��[175c�û���©Ý�'01T��
�Ý4(�Ä�����Ç1' �� ���Ø¡�,Q�?1Ý�+Ý8�15
_�¥R��'( <Éʶ���Ç1£�Ð}å�E�[Q�Ty3(��]X�(
ö?[+ <Éʶ��ÃC1\«ê�(�º6:�[15T�Â^UÃ0( 2000 ±G
´ >Å��_�Â^UÃ0?�C�|��]÷����T�È��<ÉÊ ®�
ÈåÈ��©�Á©�¥È��<ÉÊ�È��[�:1 *+� ÈÊ ¡�,
1~/y4ÍM¬òê�3�Q�[15c� 2002 ±,-Íß���3Wƺ��,-
×Â^¾¿Ã�¹3�C ø�(4 80 ç+È��<ÉÊË~/y4\«ê�3�
Q�Ã- æW�?1Ã�:+01�Ç�:1y4�b[� T�Â^UÃ0+/r È
ÊT������VØy4墣3¤ºÇ1Å�3�+� �© ?y4¦§3
¥��[15
GHfgh�!"cdeZ&'
äå�( 2006±¹� 2007±¹�¦Ûju�_²��È��<ÉÊËVØy4å
��Ç1~/y4¾¿3�Q�52006±¹(�ju4 40çuݾ¿Ã+<ÉÊI
L�Á��Oû��+LØ��?1y4�b[� 2007±¹(�ju4 60çuÝ
¾¿Ã+<Éʶ�y4�b[�¾¿3�[ ��(�±¹'�ÖØ�·¾¿3Ò/
��§¨ju¢l2Ã���¾¿�²�Q�5äå�+�Q�[1��Ýêþ¿�%
&���¾¿KL( 3©��'(?�<Éʶ�'01 ÂH¾¿Ã®�3v�
1»¼±ªè'(?�juÝ�,1¾¿ê�'01 �[�2�'015
2�O 2007±¹¾¿'( uݾ¿Ã+ 263û�� 519�3~/y4�[0-
�¢ä� i� �(�O 26û������äå�+!ßc�(ï�'Ð@3�Q�5
2¾¿�O��+Ò/���ÖØ�·'¢ä6:�y4�??KL(G`Ú¬'
015
(Í(��*+� ÈÊ���� jRÌ/3»-�Ç1<ÉÊ�ÁÉP� )�%
�'«×Ø+¨8Q�52:( K³<ÉÊ�ÁÉP� )�'«×Ø�~
/y4%�+KS�¼[�[�2�'(?� ×Ø3òÉÇ1.� È��<ÉÊ
ª3���Ç1òÉ��=�3�[1,-T «×ØÛ+¨[�Ç�:1jR<ÉÊ
�ÁÉP� )�2'×ØòÉ*+#� '01��� ¾¿Ã¨�+2:7
)�2'Õf¾¿3�ç ��Q�2�+©?��'01�dZ7:15
7 A@�?@�V¢�±Ö¦»¼ÙX½¾¿�{ÀÖ¢�xy�Á�VÂÈuÃÄ¿�ÃÄv¡ÅÆ�
�¦�ÖVÈQ�#��Çs�r��ÈÉ·�ÊË9V§ÌQ(
�����
(�(×Ø�·���� ¬ ¥çÈ�ÉÊ �� £��_Ç1×ØDEy4û
´+¨8Q�52�����( T�T�¾¿Ã¨�+/r×Ø�·�~/y4+¨
['0���@V3TQ��ç �Õf¾¿3�Q�2��oZ ���+~jå��
��ÉL�3ïÇ12�¨[×Ø�·'01��� ~/y4'018®8�b[�
x¯Ì+°12� ®[sZ1���û����Q�(×Ø�h�]7�12�+��?
×Ø '012�+dZ7:15
(�(DEy42�Ã,Äyø*å'015cnDEy42�����( ���
å����Ù�±+01�y4å /r×Ø���²�+y46:�[1T+¨
8Q�5c�DEy4yø*å����( г³kgqoÓ ÐÃÄijÓгq�³Ó
,�?öª 8b´j?y4å ж�J³µ,-¶lV^_Ó�[Q�no+���[
�¼Jy4+¨[½8 j_?®·�ÊåиÓйÓ;L ÐmÇ1C'Ó�[Q
��¾y4T¨8Q�52:7�����( TaºL6:�û´×Ø(jR��3
+���?[,�?T+¨�×Ø�ªÎç¹å+,è+¼�?[��� (���,
1�»ÙCåL¦�K�,-×Ø+,è�Ë3@¼��[12� °�×Ø3¦Û
û��+È��<ÉÊË'LØ¥����[1�����Ë ¡}��1�½+012
�+dZ7:15
%�IKABJCD�ij�klm�n5o
G�HCDpq�r@s
VØy4å��Ç1y4Ý�( óâ��,��}�pqúsݳ ����ª�,
1Mb��é�¹O��[Q�å�¹�'T £�Ð}Ù�Ûáoå\«ê�ê
ºº�[Q�_�¥R��'T�º6:1N��015�8�j± VØy4å��7
n���î½å�}¾å���¿O�MN+IÞ»' 2���Ý��º+À�~'
01[(���ÔÈ>��~'3Á_8Â?[�[�wx+Ý8�1� VØy4å»
'TVØÝ�(�1N��012�87 �T�Ty4Ý��º+./'018+��
�?15
�8�y4Ý��º( [�$T�?��¥I������?x¯Ì3ßîÇ
12�3ÃÄ���[152Ý��º(VØÝ��1�ðWÇ1,�'01+ VØ
Ý��1([�$��¥I�����Í�j3ÃÄ���[1'0187 �T
�VØy4å¡ êå�gë�SÅ��Ã-S� '015��8�y4Ý�(ûóÝ
�'0-[�ê���Q��4½Þ�?1+ ¬`�,�? h3Ý�Ç1T�(
?-ͳ�e3Ý�Ç1T'0187 �4r¹(ð� �ö?[5Þ��~/y
4+£�6:����y43��Æèû��+ÇÈ6:12�( y4¥DEg���
+,3¼�12��,Q�kR»)�/#� �� �(��û���Í�Tb?
+15��+Q�y4Ý��º(./'01�dZ15
�����
GHCD�tus[v�wFs
K� y4Ý�WXåä��b[�(./�[Z18+���?15��ZÄ°�
~/y43��RS'T������˼j_?[�C+£�Ð}3�C12�+0
1+ 2:(TÉ3¸�'(?[85
2¬ VØy4å(0vwbåK�å'0187 y4+æå�6:1���(
T�?��3Ê¥Ç1Ã�:+012�+½��?15��+Q�kR�÷ø3#Z�1
�˼Ë�[�C+æå���:12�( å_�¥R�Ë(~TÉ�®�2�('
_?[5�8�X�3�C1�87ªò ?UX3¸��wx(¬:+�[5T�Â
^UÃ0+û�Ë( ~/y4��Ç1£�Ð}å�E3TyÇ12�'ÍËÌÍ�T[
�ã_#�3@¼��[1GË æå�Ç1UX3,-�ß�Çã_'015°��[�
+T�Â^UÃ0������ûóðí'(Î�[UX+aÏ6:1+ ø���UX
3`a1~/?y4+?6:�RS �:+��X����?1�C'(?[52,
�?�¼UX+û�Ë��Ç12�(./�(®Z?[5c�~/y4X�+áoN
��01Í*'~/VØX�(_���ö?[+ 2:(Ý��1���[�,-T
UX+¢È�ÔÈ��,Q�ªò ��ß?'æWû´+ö?[��'01�dZ7:
152:72�87 y4Ý��b[�ªò UX+Ð�[2�(��'0- ¢È�Ô
È�èo3¦§�Ý�UX3�ߺÇ12�+�½'01�dZ15��ZÄ,-×Â^
��Ç1Ð����C,-×Â^�ÃC1y4�b[�VØy4åË��¬��@û
hÓ( 2002 ±�Ty6:�cc'0- <Éʶ��ÃC1Â^%äåDERå¨�
º�Ñ��¦³+é�7:15
c�����CÂ^'Ý81~/y4(©�[�$Â^'Ý810vwbåæW�%&
��¨o�ºÝÇ1²³è+¼[' �à^�Îû�TÝ���+012�(./'0
15�8��ê�(TyX�Û3ü1�- T�Â^UÃ0ê��%&��êº�(
®[+�[52�Þ���( �à^��ÃC1Ò/wÒ;���~�å���ð
í3�CÙC1��Ýê����_²~� �~~���+01�dZ7:1'
¦§+é�7:15
67�<Éʶ���Ç1~/y4\«ê�����( �#è3ÍÓ¼�1ÔI+¨
[5��ž¿Ã�,1\«ê�(q;#Ìo�ÕÖ6:åÇ� ê�o�4Tj
_[' ¾¿Ã��Ç1���2%���#�åû����Ç1>©*��#�(�
�Ç:Ä y4¥DE+0×:1<Éʶ�kR��Ç1\«ê��#è(õ���³
'015?Ã<Éʶ�~/y4����Ty6:�X�û´+ö?[( �Ý|
?<Éʶ�[�+¨�T���Ê¥è�[�¬' X����?-��[2�+ÍÞ
'01�dZ15�8� <Éʶ�DE'(¦Û����+°Í×Ø�b[�½�
°�y43�Q�[1RS+ö?�?� 2:(�Ý|?����¨�+�y��
�����
DE3ê���[187'0152���RS�(¨Ûû���,1öD�Ë3Ø]
Ç1��� �kR�#Z1÷ø+�[RST0-�152���2�87È��<É
ÊËìí�=��è3ê��� <ÉÊË~/y4�b[�(òÉ��=�3��
�����ë ?�L�Ô� +é�7:15
G�H&-x�!"ij�klm�o[s
û��(å�ÂQ��e3�4Ç1½8 ���ÔÈ>��å[�/0 pq �
�§�;£�¤� �[Q� û��+å½é3ÙZ��7¶õ ?ê�3Ç12�
+01+ y4���b[�Tû��+2,�?�©Ý�3Ç12�(./�[Z185
û��+å½é3ÙZ��©Ý�3Ç12�( &�3¡ �Ç1û�ê��ÚÛÇ1
'(?[8+���?15
�©Ý�( ��8�û�ê��4�?-�15�8��©Ý�3÷³�2:3¢£
Ç12�(Â^��'Ý81ÊÔ��3aÜÇ1C'?� )H �(å+®¹?Ý�
3O�Ç12�3a@2�+'_1²³è+015��?[�ê���Ç1]^Ý�+
kRÝÞ3\ßÇ1T'01���T 881Ý�(]^ÝÞ�[�O�?�#�
3ÝÞÃ�:+015��+Q� �/[�ê��&¶Ç1+�Z�]^,-T89è
3ïÇ1û��+�© Â-WX3Ç12�(#� '01²³è+¼[5
c�û���,1���î½ ?�©Ý�(�/�M�º�,-����ß}�/
#Ç1�dZ15���<ÉÊ�L#�+�����kR'�àáÞ+�ß�?-å
Ç[<Éʶ��Ã[�( ��ZÄ<ÉÊ�ÁÉP� )�jRû��+y4¥D
E��Ç1�©Ý�3÷³� 2:3L3û���¢£6�12�(�)����
�3ÍÓ�â?T�Ç12�+'_1�dZ15
y4Ý�����(VØy4å+�!'�©Ý����T���Ý4�¹3i��Ã
- û��(T���Ý4�ÂQ�y43Ç12�'æW���:?[#�3ïÇ152
¬87 ø&'(T���Ý4(×Ø�·��������C7:�[1+ ��%ä
�� ��'TO���T,['(?[��85
(�y��
~/y4���b[� VØy4å(Ý��ºN��01+ 2:([�$��'
T�?��3ßî� ����Í3ßîÇ1�[�0vwbååVØy4å¡ �SÅ
Ç1T'0- ./'015
�8��Ý�UXåä��b[�(¦§�½è+0- Ý��#è3¼�1�
½+015�:((Í� y4Ý���Ç1¢È�ÔÈ�èoã��,1 UXö
ªº¥�ߺ'015(�� �à^�X�ê�꺺'015���(��<ÉÊ
¶�~/y4\«ê��ÃC1#äPº'(?�òÉ��=�?�3ê������ë
�����
\«'015
c�û��(y4��Ç1�©Ý�UX3÷³¥¢£Ç12�( ®¹?åÝ�aÜ
å ���M�º�,1����ß}�/#Ç1�dZ15öª �(<Éʶ�k
R�j_?÷øÌ3Fb�Ç�:1jR<ÉÊ�ÁÉP� )��©Ý�UX÷³
å <Éʶ��ä��Ç1T���Ý4÷³+ï#'0��5
����
A��](2000)Ð×�]÷�yÓA��] åæçÍ èª§+$×�u(Oæ)'éÕ
ïê�
Ë�ëâ(1999)$;£�¤� PQ'ïê�
��ìí I�éî�(2007)$Q&A VØy4åê¦ï(�æë'¯ðßû
ñîòÀó tô«Ò �õ(1982)$µ¶]÷'»ö%i/
T�Â^UÃ0ÐVØy4åR�&'�Ä���Â^��ºgÂWêC±æëÓ
~A÷¥(2006)$0vwbå'ïê�
äå�Ýê!ºø(2007)$É» 18±¹ ju�_²�,1~/y4¥DEÕf¾¿�
�íEß'
äå�Ýê!º�ùÅø¥úûî£ø(2008)$É» 19±¹ ju�_²�,1~/y
4¥DEÕf¾¿��íEß'
Q6�Ò(2007)$È��<Éʶ+������]÷'ü!ì
Q6�Ò(2008)Ð>®¤��ÈÊ��ÛÉ��ÉP� Ó¨ý�Í� þ���Ì$ìí
<ÉÊ�Låz�Æ'éÕ (ÍåÝ
����(2007)$µ¶]÷h9(( 2æ)'»ö%i/
�����
x4�����J�h��0���x��������d
�
��juI¶��é� Ç��
�������
���¡ ( �ÏºÝ ?×�f¶û´��3¶8� ×�f¶+F6:1Å
�Ô�ë3�78�Ç12��015��������� ������������
���������� !"#$%&û´��87 ×�f¶+*GÇ1���( ×
�f¶3Â-)���·¸¹º�×8�f¶2w+èÌ6:1�½+012�+46:
�5c� ×�f¶2wèÌ(OÝ h3PQC�(8c- f¶2w'����
�������è�,Q�¥I6:12�+46:�5�
� �¥T�kR |.¶- É1¶-Ù$"��¨�¶-�,Q��»6:1 �k×
3�( PU$T?�%»6:��3�yÇ1×3�����Q�5�8� Ð��,��
�:1±�Ó3%��âUê6óô\ ±ë jÊ3IL��T���+I°5Iûª3j
Ê3��7:1Í*' ��gòîª(FG �áo� j±'( 6 ±'Ã,� õòò�
#òîª+�:�[15×�f¶3Â-)���·¸¹º�×8� �k×3�(
�Ø�Z3Iûª�C87òîª�C�ãØg�j��ús��5ø�'( |.¶
-3(8��¥T�kR É1¶-�]1c'�ãØ3�Z13©'����6:bb0
15�
� �k×3�û´( ×�f¶+*GÇ1���( ��·¸¹º�×8�f¶2
wèÌ+�½�?12�34Ç5/×3��Ã[�( OÝ h3PQC�èÌ+(
8c- ��×��$��T�' ��?ìíµ:�,1O�?&�PQ��+
I°2�' f¶2wèÌ+¥I6:�5�ÏºÝ ?×�f¶Å�(�z
?@Ç ³+²³?��Ç[PQ�&�PQús+²³Q�2�3dZ1� ×3�
( ͹F46:�».)��+������ ª����Íè3L�1�[�¬'
j_?�X3Tb�dZ7:15�
�M'( \òòù± ô Ø87 6ò Ø�8C��æ�� �k×3�®¤���L8
7 ×�f¶FÅ�Ô�ë3�8Ç��Îü39�[5G` KOê\ Oë'(ç
���3òY� u O'( �k×3�%»�¹��Û��3¦òÇ15iU BY�
O'(û´��8797:�Îü3T��×�f¶FÅ�Ô�ë�b[�dó� �
���,1È���£�Á�3âã15�
�
��� ����
� PUI°���äjʺ %&j�º�,Q� �:c'I¶�nÙ_Iûª
�½3����[�CI×3�(¨j?N 3�C�5×3�( �ÏºÝ �%»6
:�×�f¶'0- A�ê6óù�ë[�,�� è?Å�+fc1é!ÊWÆ
�����
'01�� "8T�T�'»c�[×3�#3�øÇ12�($�[5jʺ�j
�º�����ä+joùh�,1�J�%�?�ÁÉP� æ�3�&�I¶×3�
87©ª3'Q�[�Í*' |×3�(�����½3(-)�n�[1+�ì
'01 5�
� ×3�,�?�ÏºÝ ?×�f¶'( q;Å�+�z ?@Ç ³T�
'×�3&Þ5+ �:á:KLÛ?�À�'ðæÇ1�¥T�'��Ç1���
ª���c����� 01¡¬��C�#e �×�f¶3¹Z�[�2�($�[5
%»°H(���Ô��SÅ��&�PQ'�(��[�×3�+ ��·¸¹º�
×8�¹º'_n�[1(2���,152,�?» )^�×3�~x��3
ÐcOB�-Ó»'ù �,��Ç1�_+ 6óóò±�G´êºº��êA�¥A�ê6óó\ë
A�¥oªÌê\òò�ë A�ê\òòõë *·¥+ò¥j·Ìê\òòùëÙë5×3�èÝ��
3 ×��T��1'(?�I¶ ª�����dZ�[2��Ç1�_'015�
� ���3I¶/0»��ðBC1ÐcOB�-Ó�Ã[�( ×3�ÎÏ+èi�
6: ×���,Q�,Zn¹ºÇ1×Ø+-{6:12��,Q�O�?��3�_
#$+Á�Ç12��,Q�#;×:0[�ýµ3b�-Ç5c� 3©($"3©
�_ÒÇ12��,Q��zX3b�-� �:7+ ª���0K�k|$3.L
Ç12�3¡¢ÇêA�¥oªê\òò�ë /76Bë52:7Â-WX( ×��T��
³��Â-WX'?� »�3ÝXLÇc'�)±$3½Ç1�� �ï#è3�ß�
IJ���[¬T®�?[5×��H�³3èdÇ1�½è+¢ä6:1éG'015�
×3�ê×��ë�KñÔ�¤�³+¼½'0- ×��+��[�@A'I¶a"
3��� ´ZÄ�;?I¶�)ÈÀ�Ê�,Q�0N3f�����T �0N3
×3�ª�¹Z12�+'_?C:Ä I¶×����»-}Q�[1�([Z?[5
×3�I¶a"(×�G��Ô�u'(?� �H�Ò�³3¶8�������
��%è¼[�Ò·¸3FdÇ12��ª�012�+èßi6:bb01'01
êA�¥oª�\òò�� /7\u�ë5�
2���&'' oª( 1�23)�+�_f��×3�ø� ?êèº÷��
� ¹ºgÐPQCÓ3#Z �U('_1C·¸�ð���å���Ì3ê
��bb ×3�Ð�4WƺÓ�H1�?+7èÝ6�1Rå3F���[155ý
�){åú6®�Lù£ÉÊ ç67j8×3�( 3©O-�93PQC
�|_3©��3ù �Ø�Z3¹:��´'01êoªê\òòuë //76õó;6ôòë5�
�:'( Ë<´'(?= O-�93PQC�×3�è+j_�¹º��j
23)��Wú����8�52:( OÝ h3PQC��4º6:��:�&
�PQ)��+f¶2'��� ×3� ª���èÌ+I°��'01�dZ7:
15f¶2�(�;?ìíý§�>+��Ç1�� @b3TbÅ�'0:Ä û�
��½?ìí3���Ê'912�+'_15�
�����
f¶'97:1ìí�b[�6`ê2000ë( f¶�[�R�Ã[� ìíý§�>
ôï+Ã2-}Sè�:�ìíùú��+Â96:1���5´ZÄ >¯��[
�×�f¶�( Ò� ?|$�Ã8:�õ��¨�?ìíý§�>+��Ç153+c
Zå3��¤���È 3kð �R�» ?/ �@ <I� 3à #AX
BC 3��-{6:�×Ø '015f¶3�:����Tìíý§�>�?152
:7ìíý§�>87 f¶�[�ͳÒ� |$»'D�:�ìíùú��
3¶�� ��?ìí3EXÂ12�+'_135
c� jtFã�f¶3����Dtê1998ë( ÐRÓ�( #;+ o� @�
�01[(v@��O�ð��òó3� �KñÔ£�Á�3Ã2?[ ô¶ª
g3Ç1»' �#;0['KïTü*åG H,�?T+%»6:
�2� 3Ã�#;���÷ø3#Z1��?+7 f¶�( JG��T¼½?ý
§�>ÎÐRÓ3�»Ç1�;?TÎ+��Ç1���45ÐRÓ( �|$3�»Ç
1#;0Iåyì �ð6:�[1�Jå&ö w7�È>*ÊÂ-* ���
16å w7K¹ �Jå#ê�+b�-ÇC?� ��6cZc?T87�»
6:�Ã- ÐRÓ3ôïÇ12��,Q�òó6:12,�?6cZc?ÐRÓ�»
Ò( 6cZc?ìí3L� �º+��[1ìíý§�>'01���'0155
6`ê2000ë�Dtê1998ëMN( f¶�(M5?ìíÖ+��Ç1' f¶
»'û�3�T�Ç1Å�$'D�:�Tü*�,Q� @Ç ³��½?ì
í3Â9'_12�3@AÇ15�-�C ×�f¶�[�R( ×��$��[��
��+��R'015��� �����(��>��©3#- �¾?�:�_3
X�1&�PQ�(�-+fc15��-3ü�1C'(?� NHè+01�ÇZ
ÄÇ[PQ�OfÇ15Ç?�O ×3���78PQC+0:Ä f¶2w'97
:1���ÊìíÎ&�PQús�¸8�?[¼½?ìíÎ3ê���Of+G��5
2�_+ضÇ1��T�×�f¶2wèÌ+IX [b$�8 ª���j_?
¹P3»�Qm15"8+T���[1�C'(?[+ ×�f¶�fc1q;Å�
+��� �3��Q�i§�Ç�:1��3�Q������¹º'01+�Z�
2,�?�Û��(�ÏºÝ ?×�f¶�Ã[�H16:1ø�'015
� G`'( Ë<'òY��ÐPQCÓ�Ðf¶Å�Ô�ëÓ�С�?+7 �
k×3�û´3ü�[�5/×3�¹��Û��87 2wèÌPQC(�Q
�8 c� �PQC+[8[���f¶ ª3¹º6��[Q�83òó�
�ÏºÝ ?×�f¶+F6:1Å�Ô�ë�b[�dóÇ15�
�
������������
�
�¥T�kR |.¶- É1¶-Ù$"��¨�¶-�,Q��»6:1 �k×
�����
3�( PU$T?�%»6:��3�yÇ1×3�����Q��5�8� �âUê6óô\
±ë jÊ3L3+IÞ»'Iûª�½+�q��5Í*' ��gòîª(FG �
áo� j±'( 6 ±'Ã,� õòò�#òîª+�:�[15×�f¶3Â-)���
·¸¹º�×8� �k×3�(�Ø�Z3Iûª�C87òîª�C�ãØg
�j��ús��5ø�'( |.¶-3(8��¥T�kR É1¶-�]1c'�ã
Ø3�Z13©'����6:bb015�
� �k×3�( PU%»87ø�c'Ã,� õò±)[R�3Tb�ÏºÝ ?×
�f¶'015�âUjÊ3IL��T���·¸+j_�¹ºÇ1»' ×3�Ø
�Zå ð�Ù&�PQ3j_�ús�?+7*G��[1×�f¶'015�
�O'( PU%»6:� �k×3�¹��Û��3¦ò� �ÏºÝ ?×�f
¶+F6:1Å�Ô�ë�b[�Îü3915û´����®¤���L(
\òòù± ô Ø87 6ò Ø�8C��æ��56K¥\K��3Õf� ç���3òY��5
È��ðñ¾¿( �]¥SCT� \ ç ×3�WS� � ç q�×�� ùç 6� ç��
�� o 6õa�æ��5G`'( 2:7��3T�� �k×3�¹��Û�
���½Þ�b[�ü15�
�
���� �� ����������
G�H�z1�
�
�k×3�( PU�¥ U7ùV�,-�àÙj�[Or�%»6:�Wk3L
º¬���[15k+T�Ç1����àWk+�¥( 6T�kR��6:1?8 $
"�à uó*XY[�(|.¶-+Z��%»6:Ð[\ 6;È�Ó�}Ä:�5|.
¶-à��( kR¶- É1¶- ¢��»ö×3�Ù$"��¨�¶-+%»
6: 6ó�ò±��(Ç'���3�yÇ1×�f¶3%»���5�
� %»/°87�âóUc' �k×3�( j_� ubè3TbkR+ô�Ç1
%'»-}Q�[�5ÖØåZ�Ø'Iûª�û�½3��Çj$ÊT�kR� ¬
]Øå¼�?�a-Ø ^RÙ'O�?ÔÈ®��È�3F���� ¶87fªÇ1D
¶Ê|.¶- �»$�À��½3��ÇIFÊÉ1¶-'01 �52:7¶
-3»-���%»6:� �k×3�( Ð��,���:1Ó�[�Y®�½±�+
G�»'I¶×3���� ��3�yÇ1×3�����(� Iû#;Ýê�
¸8�?[R�?Q�[� 5�
�
GH�{|1�
�
�����
6óô\ ±�âU �k×3�( �Ä7���3�yÇ1×�f¶���I�3£
Q�[�5�8��U O�?���ä+L33o�º��[Q�5( 6 �Ã,Ä( \
�jÝ|��3©Û' �k�}IÇ13©ÏST¼[ �5�
� jʺ��O�ä(��® ð�*�3lh� joùh�,1JýþÌ3�gÇ
12�'�J3�ø'_1567� jÝ|?_�Rå�%è¼[×��¾3Tb�
� ×3��}IÇ1q#%&3©�%ã(18���Ì3Tb5/Ï `�×3�g
Iûª(jÊ3�µ: �k×3�TªØ:a��b��5�âU�Ä7�(c
�k×3�3(8�Iûq#3©'©��Ò��[� �kN+ 6óóò±��(�Ò
Ré3j��¹ZjÊ3'�ÒÇ1,��?Q� �5jʺ��O�ä+áoÇ1�b:
�k×3�gª�+ß��q- `�cc����+a��!���2�3@AÇ
15�
2,�?��·¸¹º�×8� �k×3�'( 6óóò±�G´G`,�?¹º
+�2Q�5�
�
G�H�}~~� Y����
�
� �â3PQC�jÊ3L3+IÞ»' �k×3�3(8�I¶×3�g�½
(ß��qQ�[Q�5Í*' PU��gòîªÛ�òîÕh(FG �áo��[
�ê¼ 6ë5òîª�,1�ãØg!LTj_[ �52:7·¸¹º�!��� �k
×3��( ×��OÝ h3¥ÇG`,�?¹º+�_�[� �5�
�
¼ 6� ��gh¶òîªÛÃ,ÄòîÕh���
��������� ������
��
���������
���������
���������
���������
���������
���������
���������
����
����
����
����
���
����
����
����
����
���
����
����
����
����
�
��
��
��
��
��
��
�
��
�������
��������
��������
��������
��������
��������
��������
��������
��������
�
��
���
��
��
��'
��������� ��������������������� !"#�$�%�
� � � &�&''' ()*�+ ,-.�/01���23,456789%�
� � � � �:&''' (;<��=>?��� !@A>BC��� !"#DEFG������DH�G10�%�
� � � � &:H�I3,JKLM��NOP ()* &''� (QM,�����R�+ DS@TUG9%�
VWXYZ[�\]^�_`ab�cd� &''P (ef�&''O (g�hij%'
�����
� ( 6� ��gd�%ä+ �ªd�åòîÙ_�ÉLd�87®��Ô�Ê�É
Ld� q#d�g�¹º��2�'01 �52d�%乺�,Q� òîª+
�k×3�3���aeÇ1�0+áZ�5�
� ( \� PU%»±87×�3&°'_�×��+3©fg���ú8�2�'0
15�âU 6óùò ±� óò ±��8C�o�º��jÊ3L3��:�,1IûªØ:
+IÞ»' `���å&�*�'(×�3üL�n O�?%&�ThXP:?8Q
�×��ö÷'015�
� GË \b¹º( �U �k×3�gO�?×�� h� �:�,1Ø�
Z¹º�j_�÷ø���dZ7:15�
� ( 6 d�%乺��T?[ �k×3�gòîª+áo��2�( �:c
'òîçé'�ãØ3����[�o¬����� /×3�g hÇ1È����¤�
3#Z��dZ7:152:7����(�:c'DQ�_��ãØ«��½?¹
ºå%&¿*¨*3ê��?+7 /×3�gILUTòîª�C�ã3���&�
3J���5�
� ( \ `�×��+3©fg��g�ú8�2�( /×3�g�2�87
OÝ×�� h3¥�� �5��gòî�ë�×�3üL��×�� h'015
2:7OÝ×�� h�,Q� �:c'Iûª'»-}Q�[�×3�è+j_
�¹�Q��dZ7:1'015�
� ø�'( �k×3�( �ã3¦+�J�+IX |.¶-3(8� kR¶
- É1¶- ¢��»ö×3�c' òîª3�iÉÊ����ãØ3«�3©
'����6:bb01 �52,�?¹º+»c�[8��8����(j®�N+0
1��, T'(/r×��+òîªqö3j§Ç1½� /×3�(òîª3ÅÈ�
�iÉÊ���×�f¶g�j_�¹º��5�
�
���� ��������� !�"��
� GË'âã� �k×3�¹��Û���Ã[� q;3©+�,��&�PQ
3ús��83 q�3©´'ü,�5�
� \òk��33&ÞkR�¶- p3©( 6óõò±�l#m'��� \òò6 ± ��
3�ãØg�j��ús��5n�Ø3«Q�[�o(Iûª+ÅÈ�Q�+ ø�'
(òîª+ óóp3v�1�[�5�
� p3©+ \òò6 ± Iûª�Cn�Ø87òîª�C�ãØg���ús���(
��+015/±Ç'� kR¶-3¶1ªÓ óÏ(òîªQ�5q1&äQ�n
�Ø33�ÞIûª�C3©+K;��ã3gús��[�5p3©/)( \òòò±ó
U kR�¶-'�4 ��ã3º��3©(4 u Ï ÍwC'T�ãØ3�Z1,�
�����
�?Q�3©c'S��1� Ã,� ùÏ3©+�ãØ3«Q�[��i�Ç15Hª
+ÝÄrÞ�3�%ã �ã3gªµ:(U3,�?[52°?sV3¡ó� �
ã3g��ús3 ¯��5�ã3(n�Ø,-aú�T¼� �tT¼[5�
� ùûS$� �ã33Ã�Oí3ý��?+7�:u×Øìí3ÈQ�5�8[
��ã3�( ÍZ'�aT�Ø+015j��à������Ø��(/ç�,
Iv*+ß8:�[15ùû3�Z�×3�w$'ÍxÇ1±$( �yÞC'(
?[5[�°?ìí3^_LÇ0I3ùC15T×3�'�°?3©+zC�[18
�+�:�[18'I((-Ë+15Ø \ ua(|.¶-å|{�'8C ª�_3
òó� �:u×ØKLå�y��_|ç3ßiÇ152:7Z� ?ìíÕf�
,Q� p 3©(��Ê30c-8Cn��ã3g���úsÇ12�+'_�5Zo
ìíÈÉ+²³Q��� ��ús�88Q�±$( }���¬`Â9��å��
B~ØQ��[�5�
� Ç?�O p 3©( ��ús �R�?1ùhçìíåØ�Zìí3 ×3�2w
'���Ê'912�+'_��� �����3¹Z12�+'_�5f¶���Ç1
M5?ìíý§�>� �:3EXÂ���Ç1×���Ì+0Q����&�PQ
ús+²³Q�5p 3©,�?Of_��,Q� �½3 ß�ÜZ�&�PQ
��+���IX �k×3�2wèÌ+I�7:��dZ7:1'015�
G`'( �k×3�èÌPQC�?Q�OÝ h@A� èÌ3¥Çf¶
Å�Ô�ë�b[�dó�,�5�
�
��������� !"#$�%&'�()�
�
� GË'ü�,�� ×�f¶F���( ��·¸¹º�×8�f¶2wè
Ì+�½�?15�M'( �k×3�' ��·¸¹º�×8�Ø�Z3j��ú
sÇ1�[�%'èÌ+I°�Û��3¦ò��5�èÌPQC�?Q�(O
Ý h'0- f¶'�����������è�,Q�èÌ+¥I6:�5�
� �j23)��_�,Q�%»6:�×�f¶([n: 1�23)���hÇ
15%»/°(���Ô��SÅ��[�Ø�Zå ð�+-�ºÇ1��'015
×�f¶+Ý_n-*GÇ1���( �-¹�Q����Ô���×'_1O�?Ø
�Zå ð�+�½�?15f¶2wèÌ+�½�6:15�8� 2,�?2w
èÌ([8����21��852���b[� �k×3�û´87dó�
,�5�
� ×�f¶2wèÌPQC( f¶gOÝ h'01�dZ7:15`�×�
�(`�&�PQ�:��°'[1C'?� Z;×��O�:O�?&�PQ
3�ºÇ1ÔÌ3T�?[87'01522� O�?���Ô�3b8°OÝ h
�����
�+ø:15`�&�PQ'(×�f¶+����[1�C87 OÝ h�»8
7O�?�½3�§��1&�PQ+üL6:1²³è+¼[5OÝ h)��»87
».´+òó6:1� 2:+`�×�����3#Z15�
� ��3�C�`�×��(Ç[PQ�&�PQús3 ¯Ç15�8� Of��[
�[�HFOC'( &�PQús(?�Z?[5f¶'( 2Of3���Ê'
²³�Ç1Å�Ô�ë+��5M5?ìíý§�>+��Ç187'015!"òó'_
1ìí È�®·;�?ýµ8797:1ìí'015�/���'ÑC��?[�
[�@b3TO ����'_1ìí3È1×����Q�( f¶�[�R( ���
ï#?ìí+���µ:1R'015c� »�Ý|×��+fc1f¶'01+�Z
� �3&�PQ( jÊ3�:�(æQ� !O��3���'_1 j?ìí'
015�:�&�PQ+f¶2'�����Ç1( 2,�?���,15�
� GË3 ×�f¶FÅ�Ô�ë���c��1� ¼ \,��?15%»/°(
�j23)�T�'�(��[�×�f¶+ �;?��·¸¹º��×'_n1
�23)���hÇ15�2� O�?���Ô��×�3T���OÝ×��+
hÇ15OÝ h�»87�:�&�PQ+�ËÇ1� �����01`�×��
Of+ðK@5O�?&�PQ+��Ç1�Û��' ×�f¶g�½Táo�ú8
èÄ�j23)���hÇ15×�f¶( 2,�?Å�Ô�ë'F6:�[��
dZ7:1'015�
�
( )' �*+�,-�./012'
' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' '
���klmno p�qrmno p,st�uv�&''w��x810�%�
VWXyz{|%�
�
� �
�����
*�+,-��
�
� �M'( �k×3�û´��3¶8� ×�f¶+F6:1Å�Ô�ë�b[
�dó��5×�f¶F���( f¶2wèÌ+�½'012�+46:�5
c� �èÌ(OÝ h3PQC�(8c- f¶'�����������è
�,Q�¥I6:12�+46:�5�
� �8� �k×3�û´( ø� |'��Ç1Û¨�×3��%ã1� òî
ªáo�[�O[s���:�K8?£��dZ12�T'_15Iûª�½'(1
�23)���h��+ òîª�½'(�j23)�Q���Ý_n-ÔI+
0Q��ü12�T'_152,�� q;×3�+!�Ç1·¸(�:á:?Q
�[1T �k×3�û´87 1�23)��01×3�gÈ���£
�Á�+�83òYÇ12�(¼½'01�dZ7:15�
��Ç1×3���¬( `��½+qöÇ1Í*' O�?�½3b8�?[�
2��01�[Z15O�?�½+�4 �46:1×�f¶'(OÝ hT�¾�IÞ
��5��+Q� 1�23)��01¨�×3�'( OÝ h01[( Tc
'�?[&�PQ)��3¶õ �Eh�L� ?�½3È12��ÐÌÇ1�½+01
�dZ7:15×3� �] kN+_²Ç1»' »c�[&�PQ)��3�ºÇ1
�½+015�
� ø�ÝÄr°'[1×3�(�ÏºÝ ?×�f¶'015jÊ��3å�ÁÉP�
����%ã��Ì+?[�Ç�:+O+ é!Ê×�f¶�(�:?-�X+0
15fcQ�[1�3"8+��'_?[W� q;��@�+���z �&
�PQ3 �����Ç2�+'_152:( ×�f¶g�½3ÈÉÇ12�+'_
:Ä �:�&�PQ+f¶2'��� ×�f¶ ª���èÌ+���IÞ²³è
+012�3@AÇ15¨�×3�( �O78�[ZÄ èÌPQC�?1L�
?�½ÈÉ�Í�°'[1�[Z1��5�
� OÝ h��:�&�PQ+�ÏºÝ ?×�f¶2'��Ç1�Û���b[�(
,-KLÛ?�À�'®¤���L+�½'0150��� OÝ h{l÷�
b[�T�78�Ç1�½+0152:7�b[�(Ka_����[5"8+T�Ç
1�C'(?� q;@Ç ³T�'����[1872�f¶¹º+¥I6:1
Å�Ô�ë+����[1'0:Ä ���rÞ¨�×3��TèÝÔI(01�
dZ7:15�
�
�
�
�
�����
.(/0�
A��]ê6óù�ë л���×Wƺ,�@«�WÆ%äÓ $»�[��í'B
//76;ù5�
A��]ê\òòòë $×�WÆ2wÌ»' �Þß�5�
A��]ê\òòõë $����wè�cOB�-' ïê�5�
A��]¥A�J ê6óó\ë $�B�-;£�¤� ' Z�%iOÕ/5�
A��]¥oª�Ìê\òò�ë $×�¥cOB�-<ÉÊ�L' K<���ß�5�
A��]¥����Ìê\òòBë $Z�µ¶ 6òò±' ïê�5�
���¡ê6óóùë Ðã�f¶@«�N�Ó ���¡¥þô�¥���¤Ì$ã�f
¶�è'ïê� éÕ5�
*·�¤ê6óóùë $ø��kµ¶çÈ©K�ë' »ö%i/5�
*·�¤¥+ò�Í¥j·��Ìê\òòùë $I¶èݵ¶��' »ö%i/5�
����ê6óóùë $È��>»�[�,0X�¨�è<ÉÊ�L' Z���x
y05�
���òî×kwòî[�_ $ò� C±æ'5�
�����×�!"���ê6óóôë $j3åÝ��1�(�»���×��便
íEß'5�
oª�ê\òòuë $µ¶�N�«Ì' �Þß�5�
�»÷�¥Ü���Ìê6óóôë $Z�Êã�f¶�H#' Z�%iOÕ/5�
Ç�ê\òòóë þ����µ¶���ë� $I¶��'�êj×�³ë5�
Ç�ê\òò�ë Ðf¶�ÃC1|�¥I,f¶Å�$Â^��3»-�Ó $Í
ÜN�'6uB��� //7óò\;ó\B5�
Ç�ê\òòõë Ðã�f¶�ÃC1Â^�|�,äj9>���kRû´��Ó Í
Üjujuû×u��1ÒGu�N!5�
Ç õê6óóôë Ð �k×�%»®r, �k|.¶-3»-�Ó $×%Nf'\B
ê6ë //76�;BB5�
Ç õê\òòBë Т��¦Y�×3�%»®r,¢��»ö×3�3»-�Ó
$ã�oS��'6\ //7\�;Bõ5�
¼��¡ê6óóùë Ðã�f¶�;£ÉÊÓ���¡¥þô�¥���¤Ì$ã�f¶
�è'ïê� éÕ5�
tò�¢ê\òò6ë $µ¶��' �Þß�5�
tò�¢ê6óùõë $Z�ʵ¶���ë' �Þß�5�
�k×k0Méê6óóBë $�Ò£¤� �k»-×3�¢È�;É�'5�
�koÆw¥ßDí_ $ �kõ½¡� 6óóB ±æ'5�
Dt¦§ê6óóùë Ðã�f¶�ÃC1��¨©6Ó ���¡¥þô�¥���¤Ì
$ã�f¶�è'ïê� éÕ5�
ª««ê\òò\ë þD¶Ê×3��ÃC1jÊ3©�»���×ô�ô¬,Ð>ÅzÓ×
3�û´��� $µ¶��'��6� //76;\õ5�
ª««ê\òòõë Ð×3�WÆ�ÃC1È�®·;�?¾}Å�Ô�ë�WÆê�,�¯
k»-k�I×3�%&��Ó $µ¶��'ó�6� //7ùô;6òù5�
C�a=c�9�:?<cq�®7�<db�;?<=qcD�¯7�°<�qcê6óùBë������������ ������������Scn�
±a=t²�̀ <D�:�̀ aatDê6¡2³¥´�µÍ¥At0bX¶ê6óóuë $(�ã��W
·' ¸¹ß�ë5�
ú�@ê6óóõë ÐZ�S»ºã�WÆ$uÓ $ð=<��ðñ'BB»\¼ //7ôó;óu5�
6`L-ê6óóuë þkR�ÃC1R�³,>¯�J%»�Û��� $WÆ1u'
\ô�6�w�//7ô�;ùõ5�
6`L-ê\òò6ë þ×�f¶çÈ©K�ë,>¯�87dZ1� $ÍÜð=<��ðñ
�����
'Bó�\� //7ôB;óB5�
6���ê2002ë Ð��� �k�ÃC1»-×3��³¹º,|.¶-RSÓ
$½�ju2%uw¢½� �Ï1u'5
����ͶÎ�ÏÐ�Ѩ�JQ£VÒj�Óz����7�ÔNQ()�)�ÕÖ�×ØÙ��¶uiÚ�Û§N#�ÕÃ�Ü�ªÝ�Þß��ëÖà�È�áâ{�»ã~�ä
x�)åæ���ç�èéÖ¢u#rê��ëì�N£#íÍîï= ��¢���ð����`()�)ñò�����#==25`7G5`J()�)k��Õ�V#ó��ëÍ����ÕN¯ô¨�õ�¨NOøù¡����ö÷ÇøQùúÖ¢�(k
��Õ�tQ£¦#ó��ëÍͶ��ûy}Oi»Ùüøù¡¦����á��N£�±�i��Õ
Öç�Þß�ýþ�)åæ���VOyQ£tu#k��ÕÃ�Öç�j����V#i��ÕÖ�y
}��]������J��~y}�()�)���566J#=2H`()�)¥����Q#���V#�½�§ôüD�ý�¡��N#�Õ)�� ú� ����º»pq�t
Q£�Õ}Æ�N£���°¡�uN#Î����ÈüD�ýº»�×Ø¡�uN£Q���¡hN
O()�)��i��V#½��u#��»«�#�ô�u#��u#A ��ë�i��# !��"Ñ
�u##$�u# !í%j�u�¶P£&{|}����i'¿v�5667#�ê&())��
ë*i��A@��~a"()�)uvw¥����6())��+É�,&v-¤�5667#���.Ø/"()�)W012[#Wvð2[#W342[i���ëì�fN£V#�ð����`¡56NO�==25J())uvw���J | H Ì 55���î�78�i'9:¤ÈV��Ç°¨;<j;=#t¶>#��½�
�ui��9:?�@�¿¯É�AB��78ó¿AÉè=öCDÖ�@��#< EF()�)GHµÍ¶i�IJc�� ��c�¶��#5667 |�KGH�L 5á§\ Ͷ� 7����� 5`
������3N#L �á§\ Ͷ�ÖV}Æ 5�6���� ``������3���GHµÍ
¶i�IJc�� �566H#�§���\,Mô�N�ëÍͶi�ÈOEF-w&"#==255G57()�)§2�Ö�PêV#56J5 |� ��Qxy 566J |�V Q �§Ö�Ù�NO�uvwGHµi'Rç�î
S¥r¤#�GHµê&säEF-w& 56J� |T#5666 |T"()�)78� 5�mOu�IuÃU¡���#VWo�X�§ÌQ��Yko��Z[QÖ¢��uvwG
Hµ78i'�78�\¤�78Ø/)��� |T"()�)uvw���J | H Ì 5J���½��ui��9:?�@�¿öC¯É�AÖ�@��#< EF()�)��¶�È]äV ���� |^_¦`Q£tu#3" a?�2D~��a�b��GHb�cO��;
����#���� |� 76�xy ��� |ÖV H`2`�Ö�Ù�N£Q�(±O#GHd¢ef¦#fe�
���� | 7J27�xy ��� | `527�Ö�ghN£tu#78��ªÝÈei¿ú�Ù�N£Q���¡
�x�Rj��uvwGHµ78i'�78�\¤�78Ø/) k|T"()�)���J |�K#½��u��;�µlumi�p�önVÐ �QoÖ¢��uvw���J | H Ì 5J���
½��ui��9:?�@�¿öC¯É�AÖ�@��#< EF()�)�p�"�qr3s"¡��NO¥t�566H#ñ������V#56J� |u#6� |u�x�£#½�
�u��;�Yk�����§v�·wNO��¡hN£Q�())uvw���J | 5� Ì 5H�t¶> 5� Ì �7�#�����u T�Üx=Ö�@��#< EF()
�
�����
�����