We received 875 emails from a “Do Gooder” campaign in ... · irrecoverably altered”. It will...

" We received 875 emails from a “Do-Gooder” campaign in response to the GML heritage

report prior to comments closing on 27 June 2019. The Do-Gooder campaign standard email

text is extracted below. Emails with significant variation from the standard email text are

available below”.

Dear Independent Planning Commission members,

Please accept this submission on the recent expert heritage report from GML on the Bylong coal project. The report is very clear that the heritage damage from the proposed Bylong coal project will be severe and irrevocable.

It states that the project will “irrecoverably alter the landscape’s scenic picturesque views and visual relationships”.

The Bylong valley has already been listed as a Landscape Conservation Area by the National Trust and assessed as meeting criteria for listing on the State Heritage Register. Furthermore, the Tarwyn Park property itself has been nominated for the State Heritage Register for its value as the crucible of Natural Sequence Farming.

Even though the most recent mine plan will not dig up Tarwyn Park, there will be mining all around it and GML says this will cause “a material impact on the water and soil values of the wider landscape which underpins [natural sequence farming] and the property’s ability to demonstrate the technique” .

Therefore, it is very clear from this report that KEPCO’s proposed mine will do irreparable damage to the heritage values of the Tarwyn Park property and the heritage landscape surrounding it.

I also note that the Commission does not seem to have received further advice about the Wiradjuri cultural heritage of the Bylong Valley, but these values will also be lost and degraded by the coal mine and need protection.

When these heritage impacts are added to the destruction of some of the best soils in NSW, major impacts on groundwater, and the climate change consequences of a large new thermal coal mine, it’s clear that the project must not proceed.

New South Wales has plenty of coal mines, but it only has one Bylong Valley, which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish.

Yours sincerely,

___________________________

From: Greg NashTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Blyong Environment and Heritage v KEPCO Bylong coal projectDate: Friday, 21 June 2019 2:35:31 PM


Please accept this submission on the recent expert heritage report from GML on KEPCO's Bylong coal project.The Bylong valley the gateway that connects the western side of the World Heritage Area with its northern side in the Hunter Valley.This report is very clear that the heritage damage from the proposed Bylong coal project will be severe and irrevocable.

The report states of the Bylong coal project:"The direct impacts to the Bylong Landscape Conservation Area are permanent and irreversible" and "areas of the valley's natural and cultural landforms and patterns that contribute to its distinctive qualities will be irrecoverably altered”. It will “irrecoverably alter the landscape’s scenic picturesque views and visual relationships”.

National Trust, Landscape Conservation Area:The Bylong valley has already been listed as a Landscape Conservation Area by the National Trust and assessed as meeting criteria for listing on the State Heritage Register.

State Heritage Register:The Tarwyn Park property itself has been nominated for the State Heritage Register for its value as the crucible of Natural Sequence Farming.

Even though the most recent mine plan will not dig up Tarwyn Park, there will be mining all around it and GML states this will cause “a material impact on the water and soil values of the wider landscape which it underpins [natural sequence farming], and the property’s ability to demonstrate the technique” .


I also note that the Commission does not seem to have acknowledged receipt of any further advice about the Wiradjuri cultural heritage of the Bylong Valley. These values will also be lost and degraded by the coal mine and need protection.

When these heritage impacts are added to the destruction of some of the best soils in NSW, major impacts on groundwater, and the climate change consequences of a large new thermal coal mine, it’s clear that the project must not proceed under any circumstance.

New South Wales has many coal mines already, but it only has one 'Bylong Valley', which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish.

Yours sincerely,Greg Nash

___________________________

To learn more about web protocol FC 3834 visit: www rfc-base.org/rfc-3834.html

From: Alison ZinsliTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong ...for how much longer?Date: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 9:30:25 PM

Dear All Independent Planning Commission members,

Please accept this sincere submission on the recent expert heritage report from GML on the Bylong coal project. The report is very clear that the heritage damage from the proposed Bylong coal project will be severe and irrevocable. Coal mines are a 'dying breed', soon to be confined to history books.

It states that the project will “irrecoverably alter the landscape’s scenic picturesque views and visual relationships”. This is visual pollution.

The Bylong valley has already been listed as a Landscape Conservation Area by the National Trust and assessed as meeting criteria for listing on the State Heritage Register. Furthermore, the Tarwyn Park property itself has been nominated for the State Heritage Register for its value as the crucible of Natural Sequence Farming. It is a living example of how the environment can be saved. It represents decades of effort. Dont throw this away.


Therefore, it is very clear from this report that KEPCO’s proposed mine will do irreparable damage to the heritage values of the Tarwyn Park property and the heritage landscape surrounding it. This amounts to much lost potential to save our world if Tarwyn Park is damaged.

I also note that the Commission does not seem to have received further advice about the Wiradjuri cultural heritage of the Bylong Valley, but these values will also be lost and degraded by the coal mine and need protection. The world's oldest surviving race deserves more respect than that.

When these heritage impacts are added to the destruction of some of the best soils in NSW, major impacts on groundwater, and the climate change consequences of a large new thermal coal mine, it’s clear that the project must not proceed in any way shape or form.

New South Wales has plenty of coal mines, but it only has one Bylong ValleyThis is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish and bloom. Please leave it alone.

Thank you for the opportunity to contact you.

Yours sincerely,Alison Zinsli

___________________________

From: Alex MateerTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal project - please consider!Date: Thursday, 20 June 2019 9:08:26 AM


I have lived most of my life in this district, and have been shocked and saddened to see the changes in Bylong over the past few years. I suppose that this is the core of the findings of the heritage report - a beautiful, vibrant, agricultural community is being decimated by mining. And the benefits from this project will be short term at best. Where as our future as a country that can export clean green food is much more secure. And then add the amazing contribution of Tarwyn Park to our agricultural knowledge base and the value of this valley is increased ten fold....









Yours sincerely,Alex Mateer

___________________________

From: Michaela SammanTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal project - PLEASE DON"T DIG UP BYLONGDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 4:03:23 PM










This country is crazy if it does not rehabilitate, value, preserve and protect our arable, productive agricultural lands. Peter Andrews, at "Tarwyn Park", Bylong, has proven we can drought proof our farms.

WE SHOULD BE CELEBRATING, EMULATING AND PRESERVING "NATURAL SEQUENCE FARMING" METHODS EVERYWHERE, NOT VANDALIZING THEM.

PLEASE DON'T DIG UP BYLONG !!!

Yours very sincerely,Michaela Samman

___________________________

From: Larry VincentTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 26 June 2019 1:25:02 PM

Dear Independent Planning Commission Members,

The new heritage report commissioned by the Independent Planning Commission shows the proposed Bylong coal mine will irrevocably damage the rich heritage of the Valley and Tarwyn Park. Please heed the report, honour the extraordinary heritage values of the valley, and refuse the coal mine.

The new expert heritage report found that even with a revised layout, the proposed Bylong coal mine “will permanently change the natural and historic cultural landscape, its agricultural uses and its significant scenic qualities and character that has been shaped by natural and cultural [forces] over millennia”.

Tarwyn Park is the jewel of the valley, but heritage experts say the landscape as a whole, its history, connections and relationships need to remain intact if its heritage values are to be conserved.

The consultants have informed the Commission what they need to know about the damage this mine project will inflict on Tarwyn Park and the Bylong Valley landscape.

I urge the Commission to take that advice and reject the coal mine.

Yours sincerely,Larry Vincent

___________________________

From: Meredith StantonTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 25 June 2019 9:31:59 PM


Please accept this submission to confirm my agreement with the points made by the recent expert heritage report from GML on the Bylong coal project. The report is very clear that the heritage damage from the proposed Bylong coal project will be severe and irrevocable.

The Bylong Valley community can have a prosperous future without a dirty coal mine destroying the beauty, history and culture that exists now and will support a healthy community willing to share the fruits of their labours with visitors to enjoy. A coal mine will destroy all that!

NSW ought to have "NO GO ZONES" for mining development, so that mine proponents and local communities don't waste time and money jumping through hoops that really should never have been on offer.

The heritage report states that the project will “irrecoverably alter the landscape’s scenic picturesque views and visual relationships”. In other words, a coal mine will destroy the values that currently exist and that make it a worthy investment for the community who live there.

In my book those social, historical and cultural values are too precious to ignore and must be considered a deal breaker for the coal project (but surely all the other negatives are enough to stop the Bylong coal mine proposal? i.e, loss of community cohesion, indigenous cultural heritage, food farming futures and increased climate emissions, risks to water, polluting coal burning power stations phased out by 2030 etc).






New South Wales has plenty of coal mines, but it only has one Bylong Valley, which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish.Please put the community ahead of Kepco's Bylong coal mine.

Yours sincerely,Meredith Stanton

___________________________

Please reply to Meredith Stanton at [email protected].

To learn more about Do Gooder visit www.dogooder.coTo learn more about web protocol FC 3834 visit: www rfc-base.org/rfc-3834.html

From: Noel RathTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 25 June 2019 6:44:57 PM


Please do not approve the Bylong coal project. This neighbours a sensitive area of geological significant formations in a State Forest. I ask you whether when your grandchildren ask about coal projects such as this that you will say you did your best to stop it and that you did.

Thank you for considering our environmental, geological and cultural heritage.

___________________________

From: Berenice TorstenssonTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 25 June 2019 9:36:21 AM








When these heritage impacts are added to the destruction of some of the best soils in NSW, major impacts on groundwater, and the climate change consequences of a large new thermal coal mine, it’s clear that the project must not proceed.I am a avid bush walker who walks regularly in the area ,....an area which is rich in cultural and historical heritage and am horrified to learn that the opening of a coal mine in the area will devastate not only the flora and animal life in the area but will cause so much geological destruction and contamination to the ground water that I’m vehemently opposing the application for the coal mine to be approved.We don’t need coal mines for energy we should be developing renewable natural resources like solar and wind energy. Foreign companies might be paying huge amounts to be able to work the coal seams but at what loss and pollution and devastation to the natural environment ? As a representative of our people you need to stop this and think of the future of our children and the legacy we leave ! Our natural heritage will be forsaken for what? ......... The short term greed and power of politicians or you could make a difference by preserving the natural environment and look at other ways of producing renewable energy for the long term benefits of both environment and land .New South Wales has plenty of coal mines, but it only has one Bylong Valley, which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish.

Yours sincerely,Berenice Tirstensson

___________________________

From: Debbie ReidTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 25 June 2019 8:08:50 AM


I live in Kandos, i relocated to the area over 14 years ago from Sydney. I moved here as it was a great place to raise my three children. There were jobs available at the time.

Since the closure of Kandos Cement works and Big Rim coal mine the town has been crippled. There were netball, football ad many other sporting opportunities now there is only Little Athletics.

Kamdos Rylstone needs this mine to go ahead we need the employment and we need the families to move back to town.

Please help our towns to be revived and not killed off for good.

Regards Debbie Reid

Yours sincerely,Debbie Reid

___________________________

From: Stuart RidgwayTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Saturday, 22 June 2019 1:58:53 PM









New South Wales has plenty of coal mines, but it only has one Bylong Valley, which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish.THE WORLD DOES NOT NEED ANY MORE COAL MINES!

Yours sincerely,Stuart Ridgway

___________________________

From: John BoyleTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Friday, 21 June 2019 10:40:41 PM


Thank you for the opportunity to make this submission regarding the GML expert heritage reporting on the Bylong coal project.

The report confirms my long-held opinion that the heritage damage caused by the proposed Bylong coal project will be harsh and irreversible.

The report states that the coal project will “irrecoverably alter the landscape’s scenic picturesque views and visual relationships”.

Moreover, the Bylong valley has already been listed as a Landscape Conservation Area by the National Trust and assessed as meeting criteria for listing on the State Heritage Register. Furthermore, the Tarwyn Park property itself has been nominated for the State Heritage Register for its value as the crucible of studies and work by Peter Andrews in Natural Sequence Farming..

Given that the immediate intention is not dig up Tarwyn Park, tit will be surrounded by coal mines and GML says this will cause “a material impact on the water and soil values of the wider landscape which underpins [natural sequence farming] and the property’s ability to demonstrate the technique” .

Furthermore, it becomes obvious, from reading the report that South Korean’s KEPCO’s proposed mine is likely to do irreparable damage to the heritage values of the heritage Tarwyn Park property and its heritage landscape curtilage.

It further appears hat the Commission has not received updated advice , as expected,about the Wiradjuri cultural heritage of the Bylong Valley, and as a consequence it would be tragic should these cultural values also be lost or destroyed, by the coal mine, instead of being preserved and protected for posterity.

Additionally, when these heritage impacts are tallied together with the destruction of some of the best soils in NSW, major impacts on groundwater, and the impacts on climate change by yet another large new thermal coal mine, it becomes obvious that the proposed coal mine must not proceed.

This state has sufficient coal mines, and it only has one uniquee, beautiful and irreplaceable Bylong Valley, which is and must remain as farming land, forever.

Yours sincerely,John Boyle

___________________________

From: Anne HodgsonTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Friday, 21 June 2019 7:43:20 PM


I am incredibly concerned about the proposed Bylong Mine, This area is stunningly beautiful and this would be destroyed by this mine. It is also a highly productive agricultural area which also would be destroyed.However the most worrying outcome from this mine, it would exacerbate global climate change which is already devastating communities around the planet, including farming communities and marginalised demographics in NSW. Climate change is an existential threat to human civilisation and is hastening the sixth mass species extinction.

We cannot divorce the impacts of one new coal mine from the total greenhouse gas contribution that is causing this crisis; to do so is to deny any future for our species and diverse life on this planet. Science dictates that all new fossil fuel project applications must be rejected. The recent rejection of the Rocky Hill mine is testament to the judiciary recognising this threat and acknowledging responsibility to control these impacts.

I am a grandmother. I am incredibly concerned for my children and grandchildren as the planets climate is already displaying worrying impacts of climate change. Please, for the sake of my grandchildren and yours and all future generations, the world's vulnerable and all other species on this earth - please, please, please do NOT approve this mine

Yours sincerely,Anne Hodgson

___________________________

From: Anne BowmanTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Friday, 21 June 2019 2:14:57 PM









New South Wales has plenty of coal mines, but it only has one Bylong Valley, which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish. Furthermore, with the decrease in costs of sustainable energy . and the massive coal mining afoot in the Galilee Basin, which will make the amount of thermal coal on the market rise so significantly, and prices plummet, it seems that the profitability of other coal mining operations like this would be inversely proportional to the damage inflicted to the surroundings.

From: Ian HodgsonTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Thursday, 20 June 2019 9:56:02 PM


I started up my PC today and found several depressing posts some of which were from my daughter, what were they about, the looming death of her home, why should you care, well, if you have family, you also have the same problem, their home is dying too, just more alarmist rhetoric from someone who doesn't understand the science, one of the last bastions of hope for our climate's future was that the vast reserves of methane remained locked under the permafrost its now tragically being released into the atmosphere 70 yrs earlier. “Thawing permafrost is one of the tipping points for climate breakdown and it’s happening before our very eyes,” said Jennifer Morgan, Executive Director of Greenpeace International. “This premature thawing is another clear signal that we must decarbonize our economies, and immediately.”link https://www.sbs.com.au/news/scientists-amazed-as-permafrost-thaws-70-years-early-in-canada?fbclid=IwAR1-15OUHwaUOfz3maA-gJpfsmjbzU1P1ygCE69JAXWfgjlT16ONK AJByZM

Yours sincerely,Ian Hodgson

___________________________

From: Birgit GraefnerTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Thursday, 20 June 2019 4:05:17 PM









New South Wales has plenty of coal mines, but it only has one Bylong Valley, which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish.The new expert heritage report found that even with a revised layout, the proposed Bylong coal mine “will permanently change the natural and historic cultural landscape, its agricultural uses and its significant scenic qualities and character that has been shaped by natural and cultural [forces] over millennia”.

Tarwyn Park is the jewel of the valley, but heritage experts say the landscape as a whole, its history, connections and relationships need to remain intact if its heritage values are to be conserved.

Yours sincerely,Birgit Graefner

___________________________

From: Climate Action Newcastle C/- John L HayesTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Thursday, 20 June 2019 2:34:25 PM

LETTER OF OBJECTION - Bylong Coal ProjectWe request The Independent Planning Commission accept the expert heritage report from GML on the Bylong coal project, and reject the KEPCO Application for a Coal mine in the Bylong Valley.Climate Action Newcastle was established in Newcastle about 20 years ago and has been active in advocating for the protection of The Environment, and on Climate Change issues since that time.We know that:1. A new heritage report commissioned by the Independent Planning Commission shows the proposed Bylong coal mine will irrevocably damage the rich heritage of the Bylong Valley, and Tarwyn Park.2. The new expert heritage report found that even with a revised layout, the proposed Bylong coal mine “will permanently change the natural and historic cultural landscape, its agricultural uses and its significant scenic qualities and character that has been shaped by natural and cultural [forces] over millennia”.3 Tarwyn Park is the jewel of the valley, but heritage experts say the landscape as a whole, its history, connections and relationships need to remain intact if its heritage values are to be conserved.4. The KEPCO coal mine proposal will lead toa. unacceptable impacts on the Earth’s climate;b. The emissions from combusting coal from this project would be an unacceptable addition to the burden of greenhouse pollution already in the atmosphere, and at odds with attempts to protect the stability of Earth’s climate;c. Earth is past 400 parts per million CO2 equivalent. 360 parts per million CO2 equivalent is the benchmark for the stability of Earth’s climate that has been recorded for millennia. The time to act on climate protection is running out.d. According to an ongoing temperature analysis conducted by scientists at NASA’s Goddard Institute for Space Studies (GISS) the average global temperature on Earth has increased by about 0.8 Celsius since pre-industrial times. At this increase we are already witnessing devastating sea level rise, and a breakdown to the climate relied upon for the survival of life on Earth.e. The current emissions trajectory is leading to an untenable warming of 6C degrees. We cannot afford to keep adding to the accumulated carbon in the atmosphere by digging and mining more coal.f. Short-term jobs and mining royalties can in no way justify the immediate and escalating impacts of devastating climate change.g. "Just this week we learned the terrifying news that permafrost is now thawing in Canada many decades sooner than predicted; releasing methane emissions approximately thirty times more potent as a greenhouse gas than carbon. The ensuing 'feedback loop' of intensified warming, melting, and methane release is very frightening as scientists have warned this may push Earth's climate beyond the 'tipping point' to runaway climate change.We simply can not afford to be mining and releasing more fossil fuels - including the proposed ."

We submit that:1. The Bylong Valley should be left intact and allowed to heal and recover from the damage KEPCO’s proposed coal mine has already inflicted;2. The consultants have already told the Independent Planning Commission what they need to know about the damage this mine project will inflict on Tarwyn Park and the Bylong Valley landscape;We now urge the Independent Planning Commission take that advice, and reject the coal mine.This is an incredible moment for Bylong, and the Independent Planning Commission has the power to stop this mine together.

From: Robyn DayTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Thursday, 20 June 2019 1:48:04 PM









New South Wales has plenty of coal mines, but it only has one Bylong Valley, which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish. I do not live here, but I visit often and hope to move here one day

Yours sincerely,Robyn Day

___________________________

From: Jim MorrisTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Thursday, 20 June 2019 12:21:07 PM


I support GML's heritage report on the Bylong coal project. That losses to the district's natural assets, cultural values and productive capacities will be irreversible, and for purposes that would have transient benefit, convinces me the coal project must not be approved.

I also think of the disgusting legacy typical of open cut mines: a void that creates a permanent detour, ground water pollution and safety hazard. Completely the opposite to everything we treasure in our natural landscapes. A terrible affront to what we have in the Bylong district.

There must be a threshold beyond which a coal mine cannot be allowed to exist and I believe the GML report states the Bylong Valley is in that area of exclusion from mining.

Yours sincerely,Jim Morris

From: Margaret NowlanTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Thursday, 20 June 2019 11:09:51 AM


I do not live in the local area, however I know it is a unique and beautiful place, the heritage of this valley is obvious and vital. I am 64 years old and I am saddened that the Coal Industry is having such a large impact on the environment generally including a scar on the landscape in this beautiful valley, the impact on agriculture in the surrounding area, the potential pollution of both water and air.

Then there is the impact of the quality of life and the unique heritage of the Bylong Valley. I have been following this issue and have seen the local people make it clear that a coal mine is not wanted and not welcome. The impact would be devastating and a permanent scar. This is my personal plea and what follows are some more factual issues. We are relying on your assistance to reject this mine.









Yours sincerely,Margaret Nowlan

___________________________

From: Carol RayTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Thursday, 20 June 2019 8:48:49 AM


Please accept this submission,New South Wales has plenty of coal mines, but it only has one Bylong Valley, which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish.

I feel so strongly against another coal mine and agree with the recent expert heritage report from GML on the Bylong coal project. The report is very clear that the heritage damage from the proposed Bylong coal project will be severe and irrevocable. Have you driven The Bylong Valley? Researched the histories of the various first land owners ?


The Bylong valley has already been listed as a Landscape Conservation Area by the National Trust and assessed as meeting criteria for listing on the State Heritage Register. Furthermore, the Tarwyn Park property itself has been nominated for the State Heritage Register for its value as the crucible of Natural Sequence Farming.Therefore,it is very clear from this report that KEPCO’s proposed mine will do irreparable damage to the heritage values of the Tarwyn Park property and the heritage landscape surrounding it.



When these heritage impacts are added to the destruction of some of the best soils in NSW, major impacts on groundwater, and the climate change consequences of a large new thermal coal mine, it’s clear that the project must not proceed. Bylong Valley is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish. New South Wales has plenty of coal mines, but it only has one BYLONG VALLEY !

Yours sincerely,Carol Ray

___________________________

From: Jane StevensonTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Thursday, 20 June 2019 6:54:39 AM


I LIVED IN GLOUCESTER UNTIL THE UTTER MISERY OF THE TOWN DROVE ME AWAY ....... I COULD NOT LIVE WITH THE DISTRESS OF THE PEOPLE, AND MYSELF, ANYMORE.

CLIMATE CHANGE NOW MUST BE ACKNOWLEDGED AS A FACTOR.

PLEASE TAKE HEED OF WHAT THE EXPERTS ARE TELLING YOU AND DO NOT DESTROY YET ANOTHER PART OF OUR LANDSCAPE AND HERITAGE.









Yours sincerely,Jane Stevenson

___________________________This email was sent by Jane Stevenson via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Marianne JohnsonTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 10:58:43 PM










The negative impacts and contribution of coal extraction to climate change were clearly recognised as part of the case for stopping the proposed coal mine at Gloucester NSW. I urge you to consider this as well as the irreversible damage that will occur to the Bylong Valley if this proposal continues.

Yours sincerely,Marianne Johnson

___________________________This email was sent by Marianne Johnson via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Elisabeth DarkTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 10:03:20 PM



I prefer to write my own submission but the text I have been sent from Lock the Gate states my views so clearly and comprehensively that I will only depart from it to state that I have stayed in, and driven through, the Bylong Valley several times. I have experienced its beauty and character.

The Bylong valley is listed as a Landscape Conservation Area by the National Trust and has been assessed as meeting criteria for listing on the State Heritage Register. Furthermore, the Tarwyn Park property itself has been nominated for the State Heritage Register for its value as the crucible of Natural Sequence Farming.


Therefore, it is very clear from this report that KEPCO’s proposed mine will do irreparable damage to the heritage values of the Tarwyn Park property and the heritage landscape surrounding it. In the words of the heritage report, the project will “irrecoverably alter the landscape’s scenic picturesque views and visual relationships”.



We have only one Bylong Valley, which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact.

Yours sincerely,Elisabeth Dark

___________________________This email was sent by Elisabeth Dark via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding issues they consider important. In accordance with web protocol FC 3834 we have set the FROM field of this

From: Deborah MurrellTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 9:25:20 PM









New South Wales has plenty of coal mines, but it only has one Bylong Valley, which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish. Please ensure we protect this beautiful valley.

Yours sincerely,Deborah Murrell

___________________________This email was sent by Deborah Murrell via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Ifeanna ToothTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 9:13:40 PM


Please accept this submission on the recent expert heritage report from GML on the Bylong coal project. The report is very clear that the heritage damage from the proposed Bylong coal project will be severe and irrevocable. I am concerned about the damage this proposal cause, as outlined by the experts. Damage not just to this proposal area, but the whole valley and the surrounding valleys, waterways and all they contain and support, including human communities.



Even though the most recent mine plan will not dig up Tarwyn Park, there will be mining all around it and GML says this will cause “a material impact on the water and soil values of the wider landscape which underpins [natural sequence farming] and the property’s ability to demonstrate the technique” . It has been proven that fragmentation is the death knell to these types of landscapes.




New South Wales has plenty of coal mines, but it only has one Bylong Valley, which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish. To be appreciated by generations into the future.

Yours sincerely,Ifeanna Tooth

___________________________This email was sent by Ifeanna Tooth via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Cher SchoenfelderTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 5:52:16 PM










My family has lived near the Bylong Valley for over 30 years. Our family property is near the neighbouring village of Wollar, where extensive open cut mining has already, and continues to, transform the landscape beyond recognition.

It is heartbreaking to witness these changes to a familiar landscape and devastating to think this might happen to the beautiful Bylong Valley.

Yours sincerely,Cher Schoenfelder

___________________________This email was sent by Cher Schoenfelder via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Helen HutchinsonTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 5:02:11 PM


The world does not need ANY new coal mines, Australia does not need any new coal mines and I certainly don't want any new coal mines!

What we do need is people in positions like yours to think about the future and not the past. We need people like you to think about the environment and not short term gains, and long term despoilation of the country.









Yours sincerely,Helen Hutchinson

___________________________This email was sent by Helen Hutchinson via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Rosemary BlemingsTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 4:53:11 PM





The consultants have already told the Commission what they need to know about the damage this mine project will inflict on Tarwyn Park and the Bylong Valley landscape.THE BYWONG VALLEY IS THE BACKDROP TO Natural Sequence Farming WHICH HAS GIVEN HUNDREDS OF LANDHOLDERS HOPE AND PRACTICAL GUIDANCE IN THE RESTORATION AND REHYDRATING OF THEIR LAND..land and soil destroyed by 2 centuries of inappropriate farming practices.






NO COMMUNITY CAN AFFORD TO HAVE THEIR SOILS AND GROUNDWATER WRECKED BY THE EXTRACTION INDUSTRIES.COAL, GAS AND OIL MUST REMAIN IN THE GROUND IF THE PLANET'S CLIMATE IS TO CONTINUE TO SUPPORT ALL SPECIES including humans.

Yours sincerely,Rosemary Blemings

___________________________This email was sent by Rosemary Blemings via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you

From: Lyn MewsTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 3:23:55 PM










It is a travesty to have even considered the sale of this Bylong Valley ,- to give it over to the destructive, ugly coal mining industry. The valley, the most beautiful place to behold, it is fertile, it should be cherished. The Natural Sequencing farming method which Peter Andrews perfected here at Tarwyn Park should be left intact for lessons to be learned for the future.Nothing is exempt from this filthyCOAL Industry and I doubt those of you in high places won't be happy until you have squandered all and any of the fertile lands in this country which contain the coal. About time you thought outside "the box" and say NO to this for once!

Yours sincerely,Lyn Mews

___________________________This email was sent by Lyn Mews via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding issues

From: Megan BensonTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 3:21:12 PM


I urge you to refuse the Bylong Coal Mine.

The social, cultural and environmental impacts as reflected in the advice from the expert heritage report cannot be mitigated.


I would like to draw your attention to legal advice/comments from Corrs Chambers Westgarth who state (14 May 2019 'Lessons from Ricky Hill: why proponents of major projects need to consider the link between climate change and human rights'): "The Gloucester decision recognises a notion of 'communal well being' that is not necessarily intertwined with the pursuit of economic gain. This shift away from abstractions like economic growth, and towards metrics better reflecting the tangible enrichment of human life, has long been stressed in development studies".

As you are aware, the Bylong valley is listed as a Landscape Conservation Area by the National Trust and assessed as meeting criteria for listing on the State Heritage Register. Furthermore, the Tarwyn Park property itself has been nominated for the State Heritage Register for its value as the crucible of Natural Sequence Farming.

KEPCO’s proposed mine will do irreparable damage to the heritage values of the Tarwyn Park property and the heritage landscape surrounding it.

As well, the Wiradjuri cultural heritage of the Bylong Valleywill also be lost and degraded by the proposed coal mine.

When these heritage impacts are added to the destruction of some of the best soils in NSW, major impacts on groundwater, and the climate change consequences of a large new thermal coal mine, it’s clear that the project directly threatens the social fabric, historical significance and environmental integrity of the region.

Yours sincerely,Megan Benson

___________________________This email was sent by Megan Benson via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: David HarveyTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 3:00:56 PM


I’m writing this to ensure the voice of the heritage and environment is heard, and point out it is crucial that you heed the recommendations about not allowing this recklessness.








New South Wales has a lot of coal mines, but it only has one Bylong Valley, which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish. Please protect its continued existence, and our future.

Yours sincerely,David Harvey

___________________________This email was sent by David Harvey via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Ian RalphTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 2:59:43 PM


I frequently pass through the Bylong valley and appreciate its unrivaled beauty.

In a world that will soon be awash with more coal than it needs, please reject this proposal as it is clearly unnecessary in terms of meeting demand for coal.

Also we get few chances to keep the what's left of our naturally beautiful places for our children and their children. As custodians we have a duty to stop the unnecessary destruction of our environment.

It's now up to you! What will you tell your grandchildren you did?

Yours sincerely,Ian Ralph

___________________________This email was sent by Ian Ralph via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding issues

From: Robert GarnseyTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 2:46:56 PM


Further to the recent expert heritage report by GML which concludes the Bylon Coal Project will “irrecoverably alter the landscape’s scenic picturesque views and visual relationships”, please accept this submission.

Picturesque Bylong Valley is a site of Aboriginal and early European settlement and agriculture. Within the valley Tarwyn Park is notable for the role it has played in the adaptation of European farming practices in the world's driest continent. Tarwyn Park is listed as a Landscape Conservation Area by the National Trust and has been nominated for the State Heritage Register.

Heritage conservation is both a statement and a demonstration of the community's respect for those who came before - and those who come after.

It says: "we, your ancestors, cared about the state of the natural and built environment we left behind and we tried to preserve it for your sustenance and enjoyment to the best of our abilities".

Tarwyn Park is part of that legacy. The community recognises it ought to be a place where present and future generations can visit, not only for inspiration, but to see and learn about the natural sequence farming approach to sustainable agriculture. Tarwyn Park represents the "lightbulb moment" for land use in Australia, 200 years after Europeans took responsibility from the Wiradjuri custodians who previously looked after and preserved the land for 50,000 years.

KEPCO has bought Tarwyn Park and promised it will not be dug up, so there is still a chance it could end up preserved as a symbol of Australians' passion, determination, ingenuity, innovation and practical guardianship of natural resources.

But if part of the deal is that the beautiful, historic, fertile Bylong valley around Tarwyn Park is dug up and destroyed for fleeting profit by an industry that we know without doubt is the major cause of an unfolding global climate catastrophe, Tarwyn Park will stand for something else altogether. And in that case, history's verdict on us, the custodians of the land responsible for that choice, will be damning.

The scale of the picture that is involved in your decision on this matter cannot be overstated. Please weigh all the consequences of the possible outcomes with great care.

Yours sincerely,Robert Garnsey

___________________________This email was sent by Robert Garnsey via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Jacqueline MarlowTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 2:31:33 PM




I also want to add that we should not be building or enlarging any further coalmines in Australia.

We know that we need to be drastically reducing our greenhouse gas emissions by 15% per year starting from 2018.

As Greta Thunberg said, "if the emissions have to stop then the emissions must stop" .

I object to my family, especially my children and grandchildren being endangered by climate change. All coalmines generate unacceptable levels of CO2 emission.

Therefore I respectfully request that you reject this coalmine.

Yours sincerely,Jacqueline Marlow

___________________________This email was sent by Jacqueline Marlow via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you

From: David PalmerTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 2:10:28 PM


I urge you to act on the expert heritage report’s finding that the proposed Bylong coal mine will permanently damage the natural and cultural landscape of this valley and refuse this proposed coal mine.

We have already destroyed an unacceptable amount of rural land in New South Wales and somewhere, hopefully in the Bylong valley, it has to stop.

Please take account of the report and the rich heritage values of this valley and refuse the proposed coal mine.

Yours sincerely,David Palmer

___________________________This email was sent by David Palmer via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Vanessa BibleTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 1:31:08 PM










As we see the increasingly irreversible impacts of anthropogenic climate change, it makes absolutely no sense that we would continue to invest in fossil fuels and the destruction of our vitally important natural resources. Simply put, placing short-term economic gain before the long-term viability of our childrens' future is recklessly irresponsible, and unconscionable.

Yours sincerely,Dr Vanessa Bible

___________________________This email was sent by Vanessa Bible via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding issues they consider important. In accordance with web protocol FC 3834 we have set the FROM field of this

From: Naomi HodgsonTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 1:13:39 PM


This mine would destroy the stunning local landscape and precious food producing values and exacerbate global climate change which is already devastating communities around the planet, including farming communities and marginalised demographics in NSW. Climate change is an existential threat to human civilisation and is hastening the sixth mass species extinction.

We cannot divorce the impacts of one new coal mine from the total greenhouse gas contribution that is causing this crisis; to do so is to deny any future for our species and diverse life on this planet. Science dictates that all new fossil fuel project applications must be rejected.

For the youth and children of today, coming generations, the world's vulnerable and all other species on this earth,

Naomi Hodgson

___________________________This email was sent by Naomi Hodgson via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding issues they consider important. In accordance with web protocol FC 3834 we have set the FROM field of this

From: Karen O"BrienTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 12:19:13 PM










I have visited the Bylong valley many times camping at Dunns swamp near Rylstone, please don't mine this area, what is NSW the worlds pit! Cant we leave some of it pristine so we can enjoy our landscape??Karen O'Brien

___________________________This email was sent by Karen O'Brien via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Greg RobertsTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 11:51:23 AM


Re Bylong Valley Coal Project

My wife and I are so relieved to know that the report is very clear that the heritage damage from the proposed Bylong coal project will be severe and irrevocable.

We absolutely agree that the project will “irrecoverably alter the landscape’s scenic picturesque views and visual relationships”.

It will also potentially destroy agricultural land and the water table/s.

I have written to both Premier Berejiklian and Minister Rob Stokes in the recent past under the subject of 'Land and Water Destruction' to say that we are appalled that we should even contemplate any negative impact on our agricultural soils and the water tables.

We have already destroyed country in NSW, which can never be restored to its prior quality, and which we are handing on to our children, their children and future generations to try to sort out - totally unfair.

WE HAVE NO RIGHT TO DO THIS. IT IS SELFISH AND GREEDY AND WILL AFFECT THEIR LIVES SERIOUSLY INTO THE FUTURE.

Any damage that causes, or potentially causes a threat to our agricultural production and our environment is an act of stupidity and irresponsibility - utter madness!

How long will this drought last? - no one knows, and frankly the Government must close off any actions that can potentially destroy our country (my message to the Premier and Minister Stokes).

Thank goodness that the Gloucester coal project was rejected. At last, the environment is being regarded as important for our well being - possibly survival.

I am aware that the IPC is acting independent of Government, but I shall copy the Premier and Minister Stokes as a follow up to my correspondence on this matter.

I shall appreciate your wisdom on this critically important subject.

Yours sincerely,Greg Roberts

___________________________This email was sent by Greg Roberts via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Susan BrownTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 11:41:45 AM


Please accept this submission on the recent expert heritage report from GML on the Bylong coal project. This report makes it obvious that the damage to the heritage area from the proposed Bylong coal project will be severe and irrevocable.

The report refers to the landscape's 'scenic picturesque views and visual relationships', warning that the project will “irrecoverably alter the landscape’s scenic picturesque views and visual relationships”.


Even though the most recent mine plan will not dig up Tarwyn Park itself, there will be mining all around it. I am sure you can imagine the effect of such a beautiful place surrounded by the ugliness of a coal mine, which would also change the quality of the water and soil on which the natural sequence farming relies. GML says this will cause “a material impact on the water and soil values of the wider landscape which underpins [natural sequence farming] and the property’s ability to demonstrate the technique” .

Considering these factors it is very clear from this report that KEPCO’s proposed mine will do irreparable damage to the heritage values of the Tarwyn Park property and the heritage landscape surrounding it.

It also seems that the Wiradjuri cultural heritage of the Bylong Valley has not been taken into account. These heritage values will also be lost and degraded by the coal mine and need protection.

In addition the project would destroy some of the best soils in NSW, and have major impacts on groundwater, which in the future will impact Australia's ability to feed itself.

When these heritage impacts are added to the destruction the farming activities and the climate change consequences of a large new thermal coal mine, it’s clear that the project must not proceed.


Yours sincerely,Susan Brown

___________________________This email was sent by Susan Brown via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Georgina San RoqueTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 9:40:22 AM


The Bylong Valley is an important place to me as I have visited there many times and I cannot bear to think it will be so permanently damaged.


The Bylong valley is listed as a Landscape Conservation Area by the National Trust and assessed as meeting criteria for listing on the State Heritage Register. The Tarwyn Park property itself has been nominated for the State Heritage Register for its value as the crucible of Natural Sequence Farming.

What I want to make clear to you is that damaging one part of this important landscape has a degrading impact on all the surrounds. If we are going to save our natural and cultural heritage, then it is vital to view the area as a WHOLE, and not in bits.

Please do accept the findings of the heritage report and do not degrade this unique valley.

Yours sincerely,Georgina San Roque

___________________________This email was sent by Georgina San Roque via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding issues they consider important. In accordance with web protocol FC 3834 we have set the FROM

From: Gilbert GraceTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 9:17:12 AM










In addition I have worked with Stuart Andrews as an artist and farmer interaction at his Marloo property in Mt Marsden. I take a keen interest in the land restoration program he and his father Peter have implimented. The heritage value alone of the Tarwyn Park property is significant and should be preserved for posterity. It serves as an example of the diminishing returns available to extractive economies that do not value add and do not value the social and environmental capital that exists.

Yours sincerely,Gilbert Grace

___________________________This email was sent by Gilbert Grace via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Danielle ParkerTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Wednesday, 19 June 2019 8:34:31 AM










In addition to the above, there is no economic or environmental justification for opening up new coal in the light of predictions by the recent IPCC report. In a post coal world, which is coming, this mine will be abandoned but not before it has destroyed the natural life sustaining, historical and inherent value of this beautiful area. There is more economic benefit and jobs in renewable energy and we need to switch now.

Yours sincerely,Danielle Parker

___________________________This email was sent by Danielle Parker via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: karen WagnerTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 9:50:41 PM









New South Wales has plenty of coal mines, but it only has one Bylong Valley, which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish. At a time of cataclysmic changes in climate caused by carbon pollution from burning coal it is insane to approve another coal mine. We need all the good agricultural land we can get and it must be protected. You have a responsibility to your children and grandchildren to protect Bylong.

Yours sincerely,karen Wagner

___________________________This email was sent by karen Wagner via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Georgina HuxtableTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 8:35:43 PM






When these impacts on Tarwyn park are added to the destruction of some of the best soils in NSW, major impacts on groundwater, and the climate change consequences of a large new thermal coal mine, it’s clear that the project must not proceed.

New South Wales has plenty of coal mines- which contribute massive carbon dioxide loads into the atmosphere - a fact in itself requiring urgent transition out of, for the sake of the global climate. We do not need more coal mines anywhere in Australia, let alone in the Bylong Valley, which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact for future generations to enjoy.

Yours sincerely,Georgina Huxtable

___________________________This email was sent by Georgina Huxtable via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you

From: Fiona BakerTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 7:49:23 PM


I am writing to stress the importance of giving due consideration to stopping the Bylong coal project from progressing for 2 main reasons:

1. There are a reducing number of areas in Australia where such a plethora of native birds and animals and unique plants thrive and the planned coal mine will be deliver an enormous permanent loss to all Australians, who will be cheated of this asset in the future

2. It is unethical for one company to come in and profit whilst destroying the existing livelihoods of those farmers who are relying on the natural water and resources of the area. The profits of one company should not be judged more important than the homes, businesses and future leisure enjoyment of everyone else who is a stakeholder in the future of this area.









Yours sincerely,Fiona Baker

___________________________This email was sent by Fiona Baker via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding issues

From: Deborah BushellTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 7:11:34 PM










My other concerns are:

- The mine will irreparably damage heritage values of the entire area, and also have broader heritage impacts because it adjoins the Greater Blue Mountains World Heritage Area. - This mine will directly open cut strategic agricultural land which cannot be replaced. All such land should be off-limits to coal mining. - The mine will destroy areas that have been mapped as part of the Critical Industry Cluster for the equine industry. - This mine will devastate the Bylong River and its alluvial aquifer. Government experts warned internally the river could “run dry” if the mine goes ahead. - The IPCC has released new warnings that global warming needs to be limited to 1.5 degrees and fossil fuels should be phased out quickly to avoid catastrophic change.

- we must continue to fight for the protection of prime food producing land, The Bylong Valley being one of these areas. It is irrelevant how much electricity we have to cook our food if there is no food to cook or it is too expensive to buy,- this mining lease has been shown to be predicated on serious corruption. People have been imprisoned over the granting of these leases and sale of land in the area. To acquiesce to the approval of the lease would be to agree to these immoral dealings. At some point we have to stop the ethical erosion of our society. Rewarding people involved in such activities sends the wrong message to the community and undermines democracy and the democratic process.- coal is no longer the fuel of the future. A travesty of destruction is about occur FOR NO REASON. Instead of

going ahead with the project, renewable energy, storage options must be immediately put into play.

JUST STOP DESTROYING NSW, for God's sake, all in the name of greed, cronyism, and desire for power (please excuse the pun). COAL IS NOT IN THE BEST INTERESTS OF THE CITIZENS OF NSW, ONLY IN THE INTERESTS OF A SMALL MINORITY OF CORRUPT INDIVIDUALS BOTH IN THE PRIVATE AND PUBLIC SECTORS. STOP 'UNDERMINING' DEMOCRACY. Sincerely, Deborah Bushell

Yours sincerely,Deborah Bushell

___________________________This email was sent by Deborah Bushell via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Ruth SkilbeckTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 6:47:20 PM










It would be a tragedy were the beautiful Bylong Valley to be destroyed by a coal mine. It would not only be the physical environment that would be destroyed but also the thriving cultural landscape of creative arts brought by the recent arrivals of numbers of artists and creative arts workers to the area, and the creative cultural events including an arts festival which has been founded by this new influx of artists, a new arts and cultural movement which is attracting increasing international coverage and interest, and has great potential to build a sustainable cultural arts economy in the region. All this would be destroyed by a high-risk, no-return coal mine, which would be an atrocious business move as there is no future in coal; whereas the arts, artists and creative cultures and community offer a way of creating an economy of the future; and in the protected surroundings of the Bylong Valley can only continue to attract increasing local, national and international visit ors and interest. Again, if a coal mine goes ahead, this will deter cultural arts visitors, and will destroy a vital and vibrant arts community that is successfully establishing itself in the area.

For the sake of the future of the Bylong Valley, and its cultural landscape, I implore you to not approve this proposed mine.

Ruth Skilbeck, Author, editor, publisher, Arts Features International

___________________________This email was sent by Ruth Skilbeck via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Sabine PinonTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 6:09:25 PM


Although we do not live there, we love the Bylong Valley and try and go there every year for our Xmas holidays... hoping to retire there one day! When we heard of the planned coal mine it really broke our hearts as we sincerely believe, not only that coal is better left in the ground at this stage, but that the area has much more potential in developing its tourism than its industry! New South Wales has plenty of coal mines, but it only has one Bylong Valley, which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish.

Yours sincerely,Sabine Pinon

___________________________This email was sent by Sabine Pinon via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Marilyn PerkinsTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 5:26:44 PM


Please accept this submission on the recent expert heritage report from GML on the Bylong coal project.

With the Bylong Valley already listed by the National Trust as a Landscape Conservation Area, and the Tarwyn Park property itself being nominated for the State Heritage Register, it is up to decision makers like the Independent Planning Commission to protect the cultural, historic and natural heritage, as well as the social and community values, of the whole area.

Any activities that interrupt and impact the intrinsic water and soil properties, and the current landscape, must be halted.

Having studied the reports of experts in a number of areas, Commission members will be aware of the potential irreparable damage KEPCO's mining operation will do.

Across Australia, so many recent mining project approvals perplex ordinary Australians . In this instance, your Commission has evidence to warrant refusal.

Please preserve the unique landscape and the social fabric of the Bylong Valley by refusing to give approval to this mining project.

Yours sincerely,Marilyn Perkins

___________________________This email was sent by Marilyn Perkins via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Richard MadiganTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 4:27:49 PM


The Bylong valley is listed as a Landscape Conservation Area by the National Trust and has been assessed as meeting criteria for listing on the State Heritage Register. Furthermore, the Tarwyn Park property itself has been nominated for the State Heritage Register for its value as the crucible of Natural Sequence Farming.

I have, for the past decade, visited the Bylong Valley annually and have, for even longer, been a follower of Peter Andrews and his work at Tarwyn Park..

I was deeply shocked when I learnt of the proposed coal mine in the Bylong valley and cannot fathom how this could even get past stage 1 as a proposal. The new heritage report has just confirmed how right I was to be shocked.Surely now with the points raised by this report, the mine will be stopped in it's tracks.Any alternative action would surely be unjust and immoral in light of what we , the Australian people, would stand to lose in terms of Peter Andrews amazing work and the productivity of the valley as a food bowl, and for it's natural beauty.

Thank you for readingRichard Madigana VERY concerned citizen

___________________________This email was sent by Richard Madigan via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Mak ElisTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 4:13:36 PM




Why are you looking at destroying this natural wonder when we are in a climate emergency, and the issue of fossil fuel use impacting humanities fate has been made clear..by even the Pope of the Catholic church has highlighted the issue to stostop using fossil fuels.

I would like to highlight that the report is very clear that the heritage damage from the proposed Bylong coal project will be severe and irrevocable.


And we have heard of the cost to rehabilitate mines that never happens.






I ask you to think of the long term future, not the short term profit for a company..Please reject this proposal.

Yours sincerely,Mark Elis

___________________________This email was sent by Mak Elis via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding issues

From: Amala BoumansTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 3:43:14 PM


I am writing to you today to urge you not to approve the Bylong coal mine. Many countries in the world are moving towards sustainable clean energy and yet Australia is not taking responsibility and keeps going toward coal mining and gas fracking. It breaks my heart. What about the future for our children? What about those billions of people who will be most effected by climate change? What about our beautiful wildlife and nature? I haven't been to the Bylong Valley but understand it is pretty special. I beg you to do the right thing for our planet and all that live on it.

Yours sincerely,Amala Boumans

___________________________This email was sent by Amala Boumans via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Gillian LordTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 3:16:09 PM









New South Wales has plenty of coal mines, but it only has one Bylong Valley, which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish.I AGREE TOTALLY WITH THIS SUBMISSION AND HAVE SUPPORTED SAVING THE BYLONG VALLEY AND TARWYN PARK FROM MINING FOR MANY YEARS. I URGE YOU TO RESPECT OUR ENVIRONMENT FOR FUTURE GENERATIONS. WE HAVE LOST SO MUCH ALREADY AND THE FUTURE IS LOOKING BLEAK. I FEAR FOR THE FUTURE OF OUR GRANDCHILDREN AND THEIR DESCENDANTS.

Yours sincerely,Gillian Lord

___________________________This email was sent by Gillian Lord via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding issues they consider important. In accordance with web protocol FC 3834 we have set the FROM field of this email to

From: Allen BarryTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 1:58:22 PM


The Bylong Valley is not the place for a coal mine. The Upper Hunter has been all but destroyed by expansion over the value of amenity for locals and the environment.

The Bylong Valley is one of the most beautiful locations in the State. To drive through there leaves you with a sense of bewilderment that the area could be destroyed by coal mining. In 2019, it simply makes no sense whatsoever.

We do not need any more mines. For example, if no new mines were approved in the Upper Hunter, there is enough coal resource to last for over 60 years. This would apply to areas further north and west of Bylong Valley.

This whole process has to stop. We cannot destroy the Bylong Valley at the cost to future generations. It is true, we have only one Bylong Valley.

Allen Barry

___________________________This email was sent by Allen Barry via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding issues

From: Vania ChanTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 1:06:03 PM


The recent expert heritage report from GML shows very clearly that the heritage damage from the proposed Bylong coal project will be severe and irrevocable.

Mining around Tarwyn Park will cause “a material impact on the water and soil values of the wider landscape which underpins [natural sequence farming] and the property’s ability to demonstrate the technique”, which will do irreparable damage to the heritage value of the Tarwyn Park property and the heritage landscape surrounding it.

The project must not proceed.

Yours sincerely,Vania Chan

___________________________This email was sent by Vania Chan via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding issues

From: Paul PaytenTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 12:30:15 PM


It would apear that the IPC is not concerned with representing the community or the environment if there is even a question about whether the Bylong coal projectvis to ho ahead or

The recent expert heritage report from GML on the Bylong coal project is very clear that the heritage damage from the proposed Bylong coal project will be severe and irrevocable. May I submit that this is suffiecient to deny approval and no further submission be required.




Therefore, it is very clear from this report that KEPCO’s proposed mine will do irreparable damage to the heritage values of the Tarwyn Park property and the heritage landscape surrounding it. What more evidence is required to say no?


Who does the IPC represent if not the citizens of the rlevant stakeholder groups and the nearby community?


New South Wales has plenty of coal mines, however, it only has one Bylong Valley, which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish.

If the IPC is not really acting independent of commercial interests, or not a genuine source of support for the public and eNGO views, what oart does it play in such descion making?

Sincerely,

Paul

___________________________This email was sent by Paul Payten via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding issues

From: Rob RoweTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 12:16:21 PM


We do not live in an economy, we live in a society!Society is a community of people gathered together for the benefit and well being of the individuals in it.Food, water, shelter, safety, family, culture and enjoyment.All of these tenents are threatened for the immediate and broader society if the Bylong valley is to be given over to coal mining.

It is very clear that the heritage damage from the proposed Bylong coal project will be severe and irrevocable.

The Bylong valley is listed as a Landscape Conservation Area by the National Trust and assessed as meeting criteria for listing on the State Heritage Register.Tarwyn Park property has been nominated for the State Heritage Register for its value as the crucible of Natural Sequence Farming.


It is critical that the Wiradjuri cultural heritage of the Bylong Valley,is not lost and degraded by the coal mine.

We cannot afford to proceed with the destruction of some of the best soils in NSW, and the associated impacts on groundwater.

The climate change consequences of a large new thermal coal mine are significant and at this time in history cannot be tolerated..

The Bylong Valley is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish.

Yours sincerely,Rob Rowe

___________________________This email was sent by Rob Rowe via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding issues

From: Garry BarbutoTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 12:05:01 PM










I have visited this area a number of times and have spoken to locals about the impact of this proposed mine. I have heard how the mining company has devastated the community by such tactics as targeted buying out of the properties of families with young children so that when the families left, the school closed due to low numbers.

Their tactics are to " divide and conquer". I am an Engineer and Teacher and I have taught Renewable Energy, Climate Change and Sustainability for many years. Coal is dying but just wont lie down.

The future is not in polluting our ground water, soil and air for short term gains that leave long term degradation of the environment that we can never recover.

I implore you on behalf of future generations to preserve this pristine area. History will judge us for our actions and inaction's. I want to be remembered as some that give a dam about our planet. I want my 11 month old Grand daughter to be proud of her Poppy who stood up for her future.

Yours sincerely,Garry Barbuto

___________________________This email was sent by Garry Barbuto via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding issues they consider important. In accordance with web protocol FC 3834 we have set the FROM field of this .

From: Kathryn TeagleTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 11:52:36 AM



Over 2 decades ago I lived and worked on Tarwyn Park. I was brought there by Peter Andrews to help him document his system of land and water management, Natural Sequence Farming. His work was visionary and was the culmination of many decades of watching the cause and effect of plantings, stock, water movement and earth works. Mr Andrews was able to try his theories on the then very degraded site Tarwyn Park. By using systems provided by nature and intervening only to speed the natural processes he was able to regenerate the land on the property and sustain a considerable head of horses. That he was able to raise the condition of the land whilst supporting significant numbers of very destructive beasts is a tribute to the efficacy of his then controversial regenerative practices. Mr Andrews chose the site because of it's position at the top of a water system, which provided a 'control' of sorts for the practice of his theories.

Tarwyn Park represents a massive amount of learning and proof of a method of regenerative farming practice. In this world where food production and carbon sequestering are integral to the survival of ours and most other species, we can't afford to lose this. Our world is quickly dissolving in terms of eco-systems, sufficient food production capacity and carbon sequestering ability, this is an asset we would be completely crazy to destroy, especially to produce more of the very product that is a main cause of the dire situation we find ourselves in. With fossil fuel production and agriculture both major contributors to the climate emergency, if we surrender healthy, live soil such as that that is the Bylong Valley; reportedly the best soil in the country, which has the capacity to sequester carbon from the atmosphere as all soil should, to the production of coal, we double our damage.

Beyond this, from my time on Tarwyn Park, I know the Bylong Valley to be an important cultural area to The Wiradjuri People.There are so many reasons to preserve this area. Not the least of which is the fact that it is at the top of a water system. What happens there effects everything downstream. The Bylong Valley is one of the most scenic and beautiful areas in Australia. In a world of despair, we must preserve beauty. It would be a massive disgrace to lose the land on which such an important regenerative agriculture system as Natural sequence Farming was tried and tested over decades. However, at least we can replicate Mr Andrew's system. We can not replicate a pristine water source, or tens of thousands of years of cultural heritage, or the breathtaking beauty of the landscape and certainly, we should not forsake such massive assets for an industry that necessarily needs to be reduced and replaced, not extended.

Below, is the argument set out by the very knowledgeable on the issues of coal mining such a jewel. I have maintained these arguments in my letter to support my above attestations with the facts of the matter. I beg you to please reconsider destroying such an important site, for both our future, and our past.

The expert heritage report is very clear that the heritage damage from the proposed Bylong coal project will be severe and irrevocable.








Yours sincerely,Kathryn Teagle

___________________________This email was sent by Kathryn Teagle via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Philip JamesTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 11:46:59 AM


Bylong Valley is a hidden Gem, It should be quarantined from mining. The long term damage done to other parts of the Hunter Valley demonstrate why this proposal shouldn't proceed. Those areas will never be rehabilitated. (Mining company's are not going to spend decades filling in holes they have taken decades to dig).


Yours sincerely,Philip James

___________________________

From: Sonia BennettTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 11:35:26 AM









New South Wales has plenty of coal mines, but it only has one Bylong Valley, which is unique and irreplaceable and must remain intact to flourish.Coal is on the nose, we should concentrate on alternatives. We got climatic changes happening. We have got a bad drought. We should really be concentrating on saving our water. This is the driest continent on earth. Think about it.

Yours sincerely,Sonia Bennett

___________________________This email was sent by Sonia Bennett via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding issues they consider important. In accordance with web protocol FC 3834 we have set the FROM field of this

From: Lorraine McDonaldTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 10:54:51 AM










It is obvious that this Valley could never be restored. Removing the base of what regulates and maintains the shape of the land, and the water flows across this region seems to be an utterly careless regard for what nature itself has provided. Why decimate such a valuable area of real estate for a temporary profit that will never retain value. Once the coal is removed and sold, it is gone. It is not a sustainable commodity, and will only garnish a small amount of funds for a short period. Unlike the Valley itself which will retain value over generations to come, thus ensuring benefits to both the landholders and the State (in the shape of taxes) for centuries. In the world of economics it just doesn't add up. Look to your investments and calculate the value over a century. Retaining the land is the best option for value.Regards,L McDonald.

___________________________This email was sent by Lorraine McDonald via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you

From: Beryn JewsonTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 10:50:57 AM


This submission follows the recent expert heritage report from GML on the Bylong coal project, and is against the proposed Bylong coal project.

The Bylong valley is listed as a Landscape Conservation Area by the National Trust and assessed as meeting criteria for listing on the State Heritage Register. This is one reason to disallow the project.

Of greatest concern to the writer are the destruction of some of the best soils in NSW, major impacts on groundwater, and the climate change consequences of a large new thermal coal mine.

In the absence of a genuine commitment by politicians to address climate change, the communities of Bylong and beyond require your decision which takes climate science and the consequences of inadequate action to mitigate global heating into account.

Yours sincerely,Beryn Jewson

___________________________This email was sent by Beryn Jewson via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Sascha EttingerTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 10:29:09 AM


I was pleased to hear about the results of the recent expert heritage report from GML on the Bylong coal project.

Now that it is very clear there will be too much damage from this mine, I sincerely hope you can heed this warning and reject the proposal.

As well as heritage impact, we must not allow for the destruction of some of the best soils in NSW, the pollution of groundwater, and the climate change consequences of a large new thermal coal mine.

We must honour and sustainably manage our natural assets into the future. The Bylong Valley is the wrong place for a coal mine and it is in your hands to honour this historic and fertile site.

Yours faithfully,

Sascha Ettinger

___________________________This email was sent by Sascha Ettinger via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Ben StillTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal projectDate: Thursday, 27 June 2019 2:04:04 PM



New South Wales has enough coal mines. We only have one Bylong Valley. It was the start of Natural Sequence Farming, and the work to hydrate that valley will be irreparably damaged by digging a massive hole in the ground.

We're in the middle of the worst drought in living memory. Our water table has dropped lower than it ever has. There are numerous examples of mines in the Hunter Valley, as well as other states such as QLD, creating permanent damage to the water table, from which the local area may never recover.

Yours sincerely,Ben Still

___________________________This email was sent by Ben Still via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding issues

From: Lyndal BreenTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong coal project: Tarwyn ParkDate: Sunday, 23 June 2019 11:18:27 PM



For me, the astounding thing is the threat to the property named Tarwyn Park, which was formerly owned and then managed by Peter Andrews. Mr Andrews developed the theory and practice of Natural Sequence Farming on this land. Natural Sequence Farming is an important way of managing water in Australian landscapes, and a significant adjunct to agricultural practices. While I hear that the miner plans to protect the home, its locality and landscape values, I believe that the program of Natural Sequence Farming there is essentially a work in progress. The potential for the processes of Natural Sequence Farming to be worked out and studied over the long term is important. It is not enough to preserve the immediate locality either, as the wider landscape of the Bylong Valley serves as a benchmark for comparison.

The process of Natural Sequence Farming is likely to revolutionise farming in water hungry landscapes all around the globe. Potentially many practitioners, students and agricultural scientists will benefit from being able to see the place where the practice was first developed, and having a massive open-cut mine affecting the ground water and the clean atmosphere is likely to undermine the opportunity to learn. To me, an open cut monster mine near this significant agricultural heritage is simply vandalism.

Furthermore, the report states that the project will “irrecoverably alter the landscape’s scenic picturesque views and visual relationships”.







___________________________This email was sent by Lyndal Breen via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Bruce DerkenneTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Bylong Valley coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 12:27:04 PM




As we know, many individuals and families have already been impacted by the shear weight of anxiety hanging over them by this proposal.

It’s the family and individual’s heritage and life stories that are interwoven with the Bylong Valley.

This valley is so unique. I travel to the area regularly for bushwalking, rafting and camping activities. Every time I bring someone new to the Bylong Valley they are bewildered, as I first was, by its beauty and find it incomprehensible that it could be ruined by mining.


Yours sincerely,Bruce Derkenne

___________________________This email was sent by Bruce Derkenne via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Hal EpsteinTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: KEPCO project in Bylong ValleyDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 1:47:31 PM

To the members of the Independent Planning Commission,

I am sending this submission regarding the recent expert heritage report from GML on the Bylong coal project.

The report shows quite strongly that - on heritage grounds at least - this project should not be approved.

As a volunteer of the National Trust, I know that the Bylong Valley has already been listed as a Landscape Conservation Area by the National Trust and assessed as meeting criteria for listing on the State Heritage Register. Tarwyn Park is also under consideration, I understand.

All heritage considerations aside, this prime agricultural land should be used to ensure food production not be dug up for low quality coal.

Areas with such fertile soil and solid water supply are rare and should be protected. As such this site is not appropriate for coal mining.

Since your body has itself commissioned this report, I strongly urge you to consider its contents - and the other factors of climate change and food security for our nation - and reject the KEPCO project in its entirety.

Yours faithfully for our grandchildren,

Hal Epstein

___________________________This email was sent by Hal Epstein via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding issues

From: Steph MillerTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: No new coalDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 7:47:23 PM


I am extremely concerned about the impact the Bylong coal project will have on the valley. This area has been listed as a Landscape Conservation Area by the National Trust and assessed as meeting criteria for listing on the State Heritage Register.

This valley offers vital land that is used for natural sequence farming, and plays a most important role in the lives of the traditional caretakers of the land.

Our planet cannot sustain another coal mine. Please play a part in transition to green energy for the sake of our earth.

Yours sincerely,Steph Miller

___________________________This email was sent by Steph Miller via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding

From: Maureen FlowersTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Please listen to the experts.....Date: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 4:40:48 PM

.... and accept the advice from heritage experts about the terrible consequences of allowing KEPCO’s proposed mine, which will do irreparable damage to the heritage values of the Tarwyn Park property and the unique landscape surrounding it, which is the envy of the world!

Even with a revised layout, the proposed Bylong coal mine “will permanently change the natural and historic cultural landscape, its agricultural uses and its significant scenic qualities and character that has been shaped by natural and cultural [forces] over millennia”.

The Bylong valley has already been listed as a Landscape Conservation Area by the National Trust.. Furthermore, the property itself has been nominated for the State Heritage Register for its value as the crucible of Natural Sequence Farming.


Please stand up for our land, water and unique heritage against the greed and self serving interests of a foreign company.

Yours sincerely,Maureen Flowers

___________________________This email was sent by Maureen Flowers via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you regarding issues they consider important. In accordance with web protocol FC 3834 we have set the FROM field of this

From: Piers Ettinger EpsteinTo: IPCN Enquiries MailboxSubject: Please reject the Bylong coal projectDate: Tuesday, 18 June 2019 1:40:43 PM

To whom it may concern at the Independent Planning Commission,

I am sending this submission regarding the recent expert heritage report from GML on the Bylong coal project.

I felt the report overwhelmingly showed this project should not be approved due to the heritage damage it will inevitably do to this beautiful site.

I am aware that the Bylong Valley has already been listed as a Landscape Conservation Area by the National Trust and assessed as meeting criteria for listing on the State Heritage Register.Tarwyn Park is also significant and while the mine will no longer dig it up, the soil and water will obviously be affected negatively.

This site has fertile soil and excellent water supply. It is a prime place for food security for our citizens future, which is what government should be protecting first and foremost. A coal mine in this area is highly inappropriate.

All this amounts to the fact that KEPCO's project should definitely not go ahead. We must cherish and protect the state's invaluable natural assets.

Yours sincerely,Piers Ettinger Epstein

___________________________This email was sent by Piers Ettinger Epstein via Do Gooder, a website that allows people to contact you

We received 875 emails from a “Do Gooder” campaign in ... · irrecoverably altered”. It will...

Documents

Transcript of We received 875 emails from a “Do Gooder” campaign in ... · irrecoverably altered”. It will...