“We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support...

62
“We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project Conducted in Partnership with: Department of Health & Human Services, Administration for Community Living, Health Resources and Services Administration, and Department of Housing and Urban Development Lori Simon-Rusinowitz, MPH, PhD 2014-15 Health and Aging Policy Fellow University of Maryland School of Public Health September 10, 2015 h, Housing, and Social Support Services 1

Transcript of “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support...

Page 1: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

“We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing,

and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages

 Fellowship Project Conducted in Partnership with:

Department of Health & Human Services, Administration for Community Living,

Health Resources and Services Administration, and Department of Housing and Urban Development

Lori Simon-Rusinowitz, MPH, PhD2014-15 Health and Aging Policy Fellow

University of Maryland School of Public HealthSeptember 10, 2015

 Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 1

Page 2: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Project Mentors and Planning Team Members:

• HHS Administration for Community Living: Bob Hornyak, Elena Fazio, Lan Marshall

• HHS Health Resources and Services Administration:Suma Nair, Jacqueline Rodrigue, Kent Forde, Shafa Al-Showk

• Department of Housing and Urban Development Jennifer Ho, Ron Ashford, Leigh van Rij

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 2

Page 3: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Agenda

• Background Information• Project Goals and Approach• Webinar Description• Comprehensive Agenda to Encourage more Successful 

Partnerships• References

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 3

Page 4: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Why Increased Interest in “Livable Communities” Now?

• U.S. Trends in Aging Demographic and economic imperatives.

Increased recognition about the importance of and demands on family caregivers, the backbone of our long-term services and supports (LTSS) system.

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 4

Page 5: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

U.S. Trends in Aging• In 2013 there were 44.7 million Americans age 65 and older 

representing 14.1% of the U.S. population. By 2040, the number of older Americans is expected to grow to 82.3 million or about 21.7% of the U.S. population (Administration on Aging, 2014). 

• An estimated 70% of people who turn 65 will require long-term services and supports (LTSS) in their lives (e.g., personal care, medication management, care coordination, household tasks, transportation, etc.) (DHHS 2015).

• Source: www.census.gov/population/www/projections/summarytables.html• Source: http://longtermcare.gov/the-basics/who-needs-care/ 

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 5

Page 6: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

U.S. Trends in Aging• In 2013, about 40 million family caregivers in the U.S. provided an 

estimated 37 billion hours of care to an adult with limitations in daily activities. The estimated economic value of their unpaid contributions was approximately $470 billion in 2013, up from an estimated $450 billion in 2009 (Reinhard et al. 2015).

• Older adults prefer to receive LTSS in their own home and community, as opposed to institutional settings (e.g., nursing homes).– 88% prefer to remain in their current residence for as long as possible 

(Keenan 2010)– 92% prefer to remain in their local community for as long as possible 

(Keenan 2010)

• Source: http://assets.aarp.org/rgcenter/general/home-community-services-10.pdf• Source: http://www.aarp.org/content/dam/aarp/ppi/2015/valuing-the-invaluable-2015-update-new.pdf

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 6

Page 7: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

What is a “Livable Community”?

• Multiple terms:  Housing Plus Services, Livable Community, Livable Communities for All Ages, Communities for a Lifetime, Age-Friendly Community, Dementia Friendly Community  

World Health Organization (WHO, 2007) framework for a broad set of services that supports people aging in their own community rather than an institutional setting.

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 7

Page 8: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

World Health Organization Framework (WHO, 2007)

World Health Organization (Ed.). (2007). Global age-friendly cities: A guide. World Health Organization.  Retrieved from http://whqlibdoc.who.int/publications/2007/9789241547307_eng.pdf?ua=1

Age-friendly city

Outdoor Spaces & Buildings

Community Support &

Health Services

Social Participation

Housing

Transportation

Communication & Information

Civic Participation &

Employment

Respect & Social Inclusion

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 8

Page 9: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Why Increased Interest in “Livable Communities” Now? Health Care Reform is Changing the Policy Landscape

• Affordable Care Act policies and incentives (i.e. value-based payment and population health) are changing health care providers’ priorities and behavior. 

• To achieve the “triple aim” of better care for individuals, better care for populations, and lower per capita costs, providers need to keep people healthy and out of hospitals (IHI, 2015).

• Health care providers can benefit from partnerships with affordable housing and social support programs to help meet these goals (LeadingAge, 2014). 

• Institute for Healthcare Improvement (IHI). IHI Triple Aim Initiative. http://www.ihi.org/engage/initiatives/tripleaim/pages/default.aspx . Accessed August 29, 2015. • LeadingAge Center for Housing Plus Services (2014) Housing and Health Care : Partners in Healthy Aging. http://www.leadingage.org/housinghealth/ Accessed August 29, 2015.

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 9

Page 10: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Benefits of Affordable Housing, Social Support, and Health Care Partnerships• Health care and affordable housing partnerships can offer residents:

– easy access to health care services and programs (important for high service users),

– health education programs and follow up care in a cost-effective setting,

– health care providers who have an improved understanding of social factors effecting health conditions,

– a service coordinator who knows residents and can follow up when needed.

• LeadingAge Center for Housing Plus Services (2014) Housing and Health Care : Partners in Healthy Aging. http://www.leadingage.org/housinghealth/ Accessed August 29, 2015.

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 10

Page 11: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services Can Increase Access to Health Care

• Housing Plus Services can help address the following health care challenges:- avoid unnecessary hospital re-admissions,- address medication complications,- manage chronic health,- conduct patient education and encourage patient engagement,- address social determinants of health,- address “super utilizers,” and- link older residents to social support services via local Aging & Disability 

Resource Centers and Area Agencies on Aging             (e.g., case management, personal care, transportation, homemaker services).

LeadingAge Center for Housing Plus Services (2014) Housing and Health Care : Partners in Healthy Aging. http://www.leadingage.org/housinghealth/                 Accessed August 29, 2015.

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 11

Page 12: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Health and Housing Partnership: Public Housing Primary Care Program

• HRSA operates Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHC), the primary care, safety net health system for low income, vulnerable populations.

• These health centers offer comprehensive primary care for all ages.

• HRSA funds approximately 80 Public Housing Primary Care Centers that are either located in a public housing building or within one mile.

• This program serves about 22 million patients; however, only 7% are over 65 years old (about 1.5 million patients).  

• FQHC Opportunity: Health centers can expand their capacity to serve the growing elderly population. 

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 12

• US HHS Heath Resources and Services Administration, Bureau of Primary Care, Public Housing and Primary Care Health Centers.  http://bphc.hrsa.gov/qualityimprovement/supportnetworks/specialpopulations/.   Accessed August 29, 2015.

Page 13: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Social Service Community Partnerships: “No Wrong Door” Approach to Services• ACL Goal:  A LTSS system that is consumer-driven and      cost-effective.

• Steps:– Outreach and coordination with referral community services– Person-centered counseling (focus on the person’s goals)– Streamline eligibility to public programs– State agency support: must include governor, Medicaid 

agency, consumers, key stakeholders in service design and oversight

• Administration for Community Living (2015), Center for Integrated Programs, Office of Consumer Access and Self-Determination, Aging  & Disability Resources Centers, Program, No Wrong Door System, http://www.acl.gov/Programs/CIP/OCASD/ADRC/index.aspx. Accessed  August 29, 2015.Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 13

Page 14: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services14

“No Wrong Door” System Organizations

14

Page 15: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Why Focus on Interagency Partnerships?• A Government Accountability Office Report (May 2015), entitled, Older Adults. Federal 

Strategy Needed to Help Ensure Efficient and Effective Delivery of Home and Community-Based Services (HCBS), calls for the Administration for Community Living to lead collaborations between:

– Departments of Housing and Urban Development, – Transportation, – and Agriculture, – as well as the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, 

to meet the growing needs of elders for social support services.

• With limited resources and growing needs, partnerships can leverage existing programs to better serve this population.

• This report focused on non-medical services; it did not address primary care offered by FQHCs. However, social support services are essential to the successful outcomes of primary health services.

• Federal interagency partnerships require time and attention.  Each agency has its own priorities, and culture. Successful partnerships bridge these differences.

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 15

Page 16: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Agenda

• Background Information• Project Goals and Approach• Webinar Description• Comprehensive Agenda to Encourage More Successful 

Partnerships• References

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 16

Page 17: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Project Goals: Obtain Maximum Program Benefits for Consumers via Interagency Partnerships, Encourage More Partnerships

Social Support Services 

Health Services

Housing Services

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 17

Page 18: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Project Approach

• Identify existing health, housing, and social support partnerships, and program characteristics that make them successful or create barriers to success.

• Highlight exemplary programs in a webinar designed to teach us about successful partnerships. Invite policymakers, providers, researchers, and others. 

• Identify ways to share lessons from the “early innovators” with the wider health, housing, and social support communities.

• Develop a comprehensive agenda to encourage more successful partnerships.

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 18

Page 19: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Key Project Steps

• Propose project to leaders in each agency, and obtain their support.

• Agency leaders identify interagency team members. • Review literature and conduct background discussions 

with health, housing, and social support stakeholders to inform the webinar.

• Identify successful partnerships to highlight.• Identify appropriate webinar audience members.• Conduct webinar with audience polling questions.• Develop a comprehensive agenda with recommendations.

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 19

Page 20: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

National Initiatives Indicate Growing Interest in Livable Communities

• AARP Livability Index (2015)• National Association of Area Agencies on Aging 

(2015). “Making Your Community Livable for All Ages”

• Grantmakers in Aging: Improving America for All Ages (2013)

• AARP’s network of age-friendly communities (2012)• LeadingAge “Housing Plus Services” Center, Learning 

Collaborative (2012)

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 20

Page 21: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

National Initiatives Indicate Growing Interest in Livable Communities• National Center for Health in Public Housing: 2015 national symposium 

includes a plenary session and workshops on healthy aging in public housing.

• Association of State and Territorial Health Officers, 2015 Annual Meeting showcases effective healthy aging programs, Association has a position statement on healthy aging in community settings.

• Altarum Institute (2015) “MediCaring Communities,” financing model for community support services.

• US HHS Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation (2014a), evaluation of Support And Services at Home (SASH), a Vermont statewide housing, health, and social support program.

 Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 21

Page 22: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Current Literature Indicates Growing Interest in Livable Communities

• Public Policy and Aging Report (2015). Making a home in the city:        The age-friendly community movement.

• The Gerontologist (2015): Toward the 2015 White House Conference on Aging: Creating an aging policy vision for the decade ahead, addresses “age-friendly communities.” 

•    LeadingAge (2014): Combined HUD and Medicare database documents            higher health costs among HUD-assisted elders.

• Generations (2013-14): issue on “age-friendly communities.”

• Journal of Aging and Social Policy (2014), two-volume issue on      “age-friendly communities.”

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 22

Page 23: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Agenda

• Background Information• Project Goals and Approach• Webinar Description• Comprehensive Agenda to Encourage More Successful 

Partnerships• References

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 23

Page 24: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Webinar Description

• Webinar Overview and Introductions• We Need to Learn From You:  Audience Polling Question• What Does Research Tell Us About “Housing Plus Services”?• Learning from Partnerships in Vermont, California, and 

Hawaii• We Need to Learn From You:  Audience Polling Questions• Audience Discussion

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 24

Page 25: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Webinar Audience Members

• Planning team members invited key stakeholders from their own health, housing, and social service networks. 

• We aimed for 50 key stakeholders.• Over 100 people registered for the seminar, and 

included people from:- eight federal agencies or offices, - national associations/technical assistance providers. - direct service providers, - foundations, and - researchers.

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 25

Page 26: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services

Bob HornyakDirector, Office of Performance and Evaluation

and Lori Gerhard

Director, Office of Integrated ProgramsHHS ACL

26

Page 27: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services

Suma NairDirector of the Office of Quality ImprovementHealth Resources and Services Administration’s 

Bureau of Primary Health Care

27

Page 28: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

28Health, Housing, and Social Support Services

Jennifer HoSenior Advisor on Housing and Services

U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development

Page 29: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

29Health, Housing, and Social Support Services

Robyn StoneExecutive Director, Center for Applied Research, 

LeadingAge

Page 30: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Building the Evidence Base for Affordable Senior Housing + Services

Robyn I. Stone, DrPHExecutive Director, Center for Applied Research, LeadingAgeJuly 29, 2015

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 30

Page 31: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

“A Picture of Housing & Health”

Researchers compared Medicare and Medicaid cost and utilization for HUD-assisted Medicare beneficiaries and unassisted beneficiaries in the community.

They found that HUD residents:  – included a much larger percentage of people who are dually 

eligible for Medicare and Medicaid than people who do not receive HUD assistance, and 

– have more serious health conditions, use more Medicare and Medicaid services, and have greater health care costs than those outside of HUD assisted programs.

Stone, R., (2015). Building the evidence base for affordable senior housing + services. Presented during the webinar, entitled Partnerships for Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages, July 29. 

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 31

Page 32: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

How Housing and Services Matter

Two data sources help illustrate outcomes:– Researchers surveyed 2,017 HUD properties in the HUD/Medicare-Medicaid data set, and reviewed services available and health outcomes.

– They also studied three “housing plus services” programs: 

• Vermont: Support And Services at Home (SASH)• Pittsburgh, PA: Staying at Home Program• Harrisburg, PA: Presbyterian Senior Living & PinnacleHealth Partnership

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 32

Page 33: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

How Housing and Services Matter

Sample Findings Indicate Positive Outcomes: HUD/CMS Survey: The availability of HUD building services were 

associated with several positive resident health outcomes.  Support And Services at Home (SASH): Early findings over two years 

indicated that growth in annual total Medicare expenditures was $1,756 - $2,197 lower for SASH participants in well-established panels than for two comparison groups.

Staying at Home: Participants were less likely to visit the ER, have unscheduled hospital stays, report negative health conditions, and move to a nursing home.

Presbyterian Senior Living & PinnacleHealth: Over a two-year period, partnership participants had fewer ER visits and inpatient visits.

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 33

Page 34: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services

Molly DuganDirector

Support And Services at Home (SASH), Vermont

34

Page 35: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

The Intersection of Health & Housing

“Housing is a point of natural aggregation of high risk individuals” at 128 locations across Vermont!

• SASH – Statewide, part of Vermont’s Health Care Reform Initiative 

• Housing as a platform for health care

• 65 partner agencies part of SASH Collaboratives

• Available in all types of HUD housing

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 35

Page 36: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

The SASH Model Focuses onThree Components of Care Management

• Coordinates with discharge staff, family and neighbors• Personal visit to review discharge instructions• Helps ensure a safe home transition

Care Coordination

• Develops healthy living plan• Coaches SASH Participants• Provides reminders and in person check ins• Organizes presentations and evidence based programs

Self Management

• Conducts wellness assessment• Convenes SASH team• Understands participants needs and preferences• Coordinates  individual/community healthy living plans

Transitional Care

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 36

Page 37: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Primary Challenges

• Sustainable funding source• Lack of administrative funding• Keeping housing at the “table.”• Information sharing – IT systems, HIPAA• Capacity for mental/behavioral health services• Multiple funding sources=multiple applications, reports, outcomes, etc.

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 37

Page 38: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Success Drivers• Housing sector included in statewide health care reform discussions/initiative

• Population-based approach with focus on social determinants of health

• Medicare Demonstration funds allow flexible spending to match need – capitated model

• SASH designed with participants not for them

• Real-time data and ability to regularly share outcomes

• Statewide platform to build upon

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services  38

Page 39: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

39Health, Housing, and Social Support Services

Marty LynchCEOand

Brenda GoldsteinPsychosocial Services Director

LifeLong Medical Care, California

Page 40: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Services located in Oakland, Berkeley, West Contra Costa County

48,000 patients served annually

12 Primary Care Clinics, Urgent Care, Adult Day Health, Supportive Housing, School-Based Clinics, Dental

Special history with elders and care for complex adult populations including disabled and homelessHealth, Housing, and Social Support Services 40

Page 41: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Partnerships and FundingCity/County Government

Behavioral Health Housing Departments Public Health

HospitalsManaged Care PlansCenter for Independent LivingHealth Care for the HomelessHousing DevelopersCommunity Based Organizations

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 41

Page 42: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Structural Drivers

California has decentralized health care delivery systems – delegated from state to local managed care plans

Housing availability and cost

Fee for service billing and unaligned financial incentives

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 42

Page 43: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Financing Challenges

Funding case management by non-licensed providers

Fragmented & diagnosis driven funding

Blended funding = multiple reporting/documentation requirements

Productivity concerns – longer appointments needed for

complex populations which include family members, support teams etc.

Need to demonstrate cost savingsHealth, Housing, and Social Support Services 43

Page 44: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Service Delivery Challenges

Unlinked, multiple IT systems creates challenges

Identifying target populations

Tracking patient utilization

Assessing outcomes across the system of care

Staff recruitment/retention

Aging homeless population – needs exceed access to in home services or appropriate institutional based careHealth, Housing, and Social Support Services 44

Page 45: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Opportunities

Medicaid eligibility expansion

Improved coverage of mental health services

Integration of primary/behavioral health care

Managed care plans focus on high cost members

Recognition of impact of social determinants of health (especially housing)

Increased need for medical respite care given focus on reducing hospitalizations

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 45

Page 46: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

46Health, Housing, and Social Support Services

Merlita ComptonDirector, Elder Services

AndLaura TaylorGrant Writer

Kokua Kalihi Valley, Hawaii

Page 47: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

July 29, 2015Merlita Compton

Laura Taylor

Addressing the social determinants of health among the multi-ethnic elders of Kalihi.

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 47

Page 48: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Patient Demographics, 2014

91%

8% 1% 0-100% of poverty level

101-200% of poverty level

18%

60%

17%5%

Uninsured

Medicaid/Quest

Private In-surance

Medicare

Micr

ones

ian

Filip

ino

Sam

oan

Asian

Hawai

ian

Other

Pac

ific Isla

nder

Other

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

30% of KKV’s patients live in public housing

10.5% of KKV’s patients are 65 or older

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 48

Page 49: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Elder Care Program History

1999 2001 2002 2003 2005 2007 2011 2013 20140

200

400

600

800

12 24 45 80 120226

539 571

734

# of clients

Elder Services Established with

Case Managemen

t

Health Maintenan

ce,Senior

Volunteers

Caregiver Support &

Transportation

MD, BH, nutrition

ed, eligibility services

Dental &

CDSMP

MD clinicexpan

ds

Personal Care,

Gardening

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 49

Page 50: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Dept of Public Health… eval

Key Partnerships

Public Housing communities

University of Hawai‘i

Law School

School of Medicine

School of Nursing

Office of Public Health Studies

Hawaii Department of Health, Executive Office on Aging

Honolulu C&C, Elderly Affairs Division (Area Agency on Aging)

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 50

Page 51: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

KKV Elder Care GoalsAssist Kalihi’s kupuna to maintain:

Highest level of physical/mental abilities

Highest quality of life

Save medical costs

Prevent or delay institutionalization

Reduce premature death

Improve quality of life

Reduce the risk of falling

Improve health

Promote mental well-being

Delay onset of disability

Empower elders to live independently and remain in their community

Nana Perpetua Amian, 101 years old

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 51

Page 52: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Funding partnerships, challenges in a changing landscape

66%

12%

22% City

Private

KKV

Elder Care Funding Sources

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 52

Page 53: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Agenda

• Background Information• Project Goals and Approach• Webinar Description• Comprehensive Agenda to Encourage More Successful 

Partnerships• References

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 53

Page 54: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Comprehensive Agenda: Process  • Establish an ongoing interagency workgroup that leaders from each 

agency can support with adequate time and resources.

• Include Department of Transportation and CMS team members as transportation and financing are key components of livable communities for all ages.

• Develop intentional steps to create an interagency workgroup.  Each agency needs to understand each others’ mission, priorities, and culture.

• Build on existing knowledge – research, evidence-based interventions, best practices, and discussions with key stakeholders. 

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 54

Page 55: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Comprehensive Agenda: Content • Address workforce issues, including shortages among direct care 

workers, geriatricians, and other providers.   

• Work with the newly funded HRSA Geriatrics Workforce Enhancement Program (GWEP) to address workforce issues (e.g., develop guidelines to expand FQHCs’ capacity to serve elders and adults with disabilities). 

• Develop guidelines to address issues such as:– hiring and retaining geriatricians and other geriatric providers, – training for primary care providers who see elders and adults with 

disabilities, – developing approaches to address multiple chronic conditions, and – providing adequate time for complex consumers. 

 Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 55

Page 56: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Comprehensive Agenda: Content (continued) • Address the need for oral health services, physical therapy, occupational 

therapy, and other services that support the chronic care needs of elders and adults with disabilities.

• Incorporate technology that can help support consumers, direct care workers, and family caregivers. Technology would need to include financing and training. 

• Build on quality indicators/benchmarks for each service area (health, housing, social support services), and benchmarks for integrated services (e.g., continuity of services, communication among providers, level of consumer-direction infused into services).

• Facilitate states’ efforts to offer individual budget community-based service programs if they choose to do so. This evidence-based consumer-directed option offers maximum flexibility to consumers and their families in purchasing services and hiring direct care workers. 

 Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 56

Page 57: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Comprehensive Agenda: Research• Develop an ongoing literature review from health, housing, and social 

support partnerships (including seminal work informing current literature). Update the literature review regularly to include evolving literature.

• Identify gaps in knowledge related to a low-income, diverse older populations and adults with disabilities.

• Develop a research agenda, including suggested questions to address in a demonstration and evaluation of evidence-based “housing plus services” programs (e.g., implementation with diverse populations and in diverse geographic areas).  

• Develop and test messages designed to encourage partnerships among health, housing, and social support services (e.g., we can do better by working together; the outcome is worth the effort). 

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 57

Page 58: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

Comprehensive Agenda: Policy and Implementation Challenges

• Lack of targeted, sustainable funding for health, housing, and social support partnerships (e.g., funding for administrative functions). 

• Need for streamlined funding sources to address duplication from multiple funders (e.g., multiple applications and reports).

• Data sharing barriers due to privacy concerns/HIPAA and information technology incompatibilities.

• Barriers to funding diverse types of case managers, including those who may be competent but unlicensed.

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 58

Page 59: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

References• AARP (2015) Livability Index. http://livabilityindex.aarp.org/ Accessed August 29, 2015. • AARP (2012). AARP’s network of age-friendly communities. Washington, DC. Retrieved on August 20, 2012 from 

http://www.aarpinternational.org/File%20Library/Resources/AARPNetworkofAgeFriendlyCommunitiesBooklet.pdf  • Administration for Community Living (2015), Center for Integrated Programs, Office of Consumer Access and Self-Determination, 

Aging  & Disability Resources Centers, Program, No Wrong Door System, http://www.acl.gov/Programs/CIP/OCASD/ADRC/index.aspx. Accessed August 29, 2015.

• Administration on Aging (2014). A Profile of Older Americans. http://www.aoa.acl.gov/Aging_Statistics/Profile/index.aspx           Accessed August 29, 2015.

• Castle, N., & Resnick, N. (2014). Service-enriched housing: The staying at home program. Journal of Applied Gerontology, 0733464814540049.

• Altarum Institute (2015) Center for Elder Care and Advanced Illness.  MediCaring communities. A call to action:  Making it safe to grow old. http://altarum.org/sites/default/files/uploaded-related-files/MedicaringCommunities_042815.pdf

          Accessed August 29, 2015.  • Association of State and Territorial Health Officers, Health aging and public health position statement. 

http://www.astho.org/Policy-and-Position-Statements/Healthy-Aging-and-Public-Health-Position-Statement/  • Ellenbecker, C. H., Byrne, K., O’Brien, E., and Rogosta, C. (2002). Nursing Clinics in Elder Housing: Providing Access and Improving 

Health Care Outcomes. Journal of Community Health Nursing, 19: 7–15.• Generations, Vol. 37, No. 4. Winter 2013–2014. Aging in Community. • Golant, S. M., Pynoos, J., Cicero, C., Lawler, K., Berger, C., & Blechman, A. D. (2012). Livable and Sustainable Communities.           Public Policy and Aging Report, 19(1).• Golant, S. M., Parsons, P., & Boling, P. A. (2010). Assessing the quality of care found in affordable clustered housing-care 

arrangements: Key to informing public policy. Cityscape, 5-28.• Grantmakers in Aging (2013). Age-friendly communities. The movement to create great places to grow up and grow old in America. 

Retrieved on April 12, 2014 from http://www.giaging.org/documents/130402_GIA_AFC_Primer.pdf • Institute for Healthcare Improvement (IHI). IHI Triple Aim Initiative. 

http://www.ihi.org/engage/initiatives/tripleaim/pages/default.aspx . Accessed August 29, 2015.• Journal of Aging & Social Policy (2014). Special Issue: Age-friendly cities and communities around the world. Vol. 26, Issue 1-2. 

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 59

Page 60: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

References• Keenan, T. A. Home and community preferences of the 45+ population. (Washington, D.C.: AARP, 2010), 4. Available at: 

http://assets.aarp.org/rgcenter/general/home-community-services-10.pdf • LeadingAge Center for Housing Plus Services (2014). Study documents higher health costs among HUD-assisted seniors. 

http://www.leadingage.org/Study_Documents_Higher_Health_Costs_Among_HUD_Assisted_Seniors.aspx            Accessed August 29, 2015. • LeadingAge Center for Housing Plus Services (2014) Housing and Health Care : Partners in Healthy Aging. 

http://www.leadingage.org/housinghealth/.  Accessed August 29, 2015.• LeadingAge Center for Housing Plus Services (2012). Why housing plus services. Retrieved on March 23, 2014 from 

http://www.leadingage.org/Housing_Plus_Services_Rationale.aspx• Mollica, R., and Morris, M. 2005. Massachusetts Supportive Housing Program. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers Center for State 

Health Policy.• National Association of Area Agencies on Aging, “Making your community livable for all ages: What’s working!” (2015). 

http://www.n4a.org/files/n4aMakingYourCommunityLivable1.pdf • National Center for Health in Public Housing (2015), Health Center and Public Housing National Symposium, 

http://www.nchph.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/2015-Health-Center-and-Public-Housing-Plenary-Descriptions.pdf• Public Policy and Aging Report (2015). Making a home in the city:  The age-friendly community movement.  Vol. 25 (1) Winter. • Rabins, P. V., Black, B.S., Roca, R., German, P.S., McGuire, M., Robbins, B., Rye, R., and Brant, L. (2000). Effectiveness of a nurse-

based outreach program for identifying and treating psychiatric Illness in the elderly. Journal of the American Medical Association, 283: 2802–2809. 

• Reinhard, S., Feinberg, L. F., Choula, R., and Houser, A. (2015).  Valuing the invaluable: 2015 update. AARP Public Policy Institute, Washington, D.C. Source: http://www.aarp.org/content/dam/aarp/ppi/2015/valuing-the-invaluable-2015-update-new.pdf

• Robbins, B., Rye, R., German, P.S., Tlasek-Wolfson, M., Penrod, J., Rabins, P. V., Black, B.S.. (2000). The Psychogeriatric Assessment and Treatment in City Housing (PATCH) Program for elders with mental illness in public housing: Getting through the crack in the door. Archives of Psychiatric Nursing, 14: 163–172.

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 60

Page 61: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

References• Siu, C. (2009). Impacts of nutrition and human services interventions on the health of elderly and disabled persons in public 

housing. Washington, DC: Congressional Hunger Center.• The Gerontologist (2015). Toward the 2015 White House Conference on Aging: Creating an aging policy vision for the decade 

ahead. Vol. 55(2), 179-182.• U.S. Census Bureau. (2010). U.S. Population Projections. Available at: 

www.census.gov/population/www/projections/summarytables.html• U.S. Census Bureau. (2013).  American Community Survey.  Retrieved from http://www.census.gov/acs/www/• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (2014). Picture of housing and health: Medicare and Medicaid use among older 

adults in HUD-assisted housing. Available at: http://aspe.hhs.gov/basic-report/picture-housing-and-health-medicare-and-medicaid-use-among-older-adults-hud-assisted-housing

• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (2014a). Support And Services at Home (SASH) evaluation: first annual report. Retrieved from http://aspe.hhs.gov/daltcp/reports/2014/sash1.pdf

• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2015). Who needs care?           Available at: http://longtermcare.gov/the-basics/who-needs-care/• US Department of Health and Human Services, Heath Resources and Services Administration, Bureau of Primary Care, Public 

Housing and Primary Care Health Centers. http://bphc.hrsa.gov/qualityimprovement/supportnetworks/specialpopulations/          Accessed August 29, 2015.• U.S. Government Accountability Office. (2015). Older adults: Federal strategy needed to help ensure efficient and effective 

delivery of home and community-based services and supports. Available at: http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-15-190 • World Health Organization (WHO) (2007). Global age-friendly cities: A guide. Geneva, Switzerland. Retrieved August 16, 2012 

from  http://whqlibdoc.who.int/publications/2007/9789241547307_eng.pdf

Health, Housing, and Social Support Services 61

Page 62: “We Can Do Better Together” Partnerships for Low-Income Health, Housing, and Social Support Services: Livable Communities for All Ages Fellowship Project.

For additional information about today’s webinar, please contact:

Lori Simon-Rusinowitzemail: [email protected]

62Health, Housing, and Social Support Services