Water Quantity & Quality Issues - Vita Plus · Innovation to Headland Stacking MSA PROFESSIONAL...

12
Vita Plus Dairy Summit 12/14/2016 MSA Professional Services, Inc. 1 MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Water Quantity & Quality Issues: An Engineer’s Perspective VITA PLUS DAIRY SUMMIT KALAMAZOO, MI DECEMBER 8, 2016 GREG GUNDERSON, PE ANDREW SKWOR, PE, CPESC MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Overview What is the state of water and Ag’s role? What is the perception of Ag? What does this all mean for your farm? What are the takeaways?

Transcript of Water Quantity & Quality Issues - Vita Plus · Innovation to Headland Stacking MSA PROFESSIONAL...

Page 1: Water Quantity & Quality Issues - Vita Plus · Innovation to Headland Stacking MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Farmstead Planning What happens when an engineer helps with planning? Vita

Vita Plus Dairy Summit 12/14/2016

MSA Professional Services, Inc. 1

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

Water Quantity & Quality Issues:An Engineer’s PerspectiveVITA PLUS DAIRY SUMMITKALAMAZOO, MIDECEMBER 8, 2016

GREG GUNDERSON, PEANDREW SKWOR, PE, CPESC

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

Overview• What is the state of water and Ag’s role?

• What is the perception of Ag?

• What does this all mean for your farm?

• What are the takeaways?

Page 2: Water Quantity & Quality Issues - Vita Plus · Innovation to Headland Stacking MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Farmstead Planning What happens when an engineer helps with planning? Vita

Vita Plus Dairy Summit 12/14/2016

MSA Professional Services, Inc. 2

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

State of Water Quality

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

State of Water Quality

Page 3: Water Quantity & Quality Issues - Vita Plus · Innovation to Headland Stacking MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Farmstead Planning What happens when an engineer helps with planning? Vita

Vita Plus Dairy Summit 12/14/2016

MSA Professional Services, Inc. 3

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

State of Water Quality

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

State of Water Quality

Page 4: Water Quantity & Quality Issues - Vita Plus · Innovation to Headland Stacking MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Farmstead Planning What happens when an engineer helps with planning? Vita

Vita Plus Dairy Summit 12/14/2016

MSA Professional Services, Inc. 4

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

State of Water Quality

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

Page 5: Water Quantity & Quality Issues - Vita Plus · Innovation to Headland Stacking MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Farmstead Planning What happens when an engineer helps with planning? Vita

Vita Plus Dairy Summit 12/14/2016

MSA Professional Services, Inc. 5

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

Page 6: Water Quantity & Quality Issues - Vita Plus · Innovation to Headland Stacking MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Farmstead Planning What happens when an engineer helps with planning? Vita

Vita Plus Dairy Summit 12/14/2016

MSA Professional Services, Inc. 6

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

What is the perception of Ag?

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

What does this all mean for my farm?

Page 7: Water Quantity & Quality Issues - Vita Plus · Innovation to Headland Stacking MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Farmstead Planning What happens when an engineer helps with planning? Vita

Vita Plus Dairy Summit 12/14/2016

MSA Professional Services, Inc. 7

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

Innovation to Headland Stacking

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

Farmstead PlanningWhat happens when an engineer helps with planning?

Page 8: Water Quantity & Quality Issues - Vita Plus · Innovation to Headland Stacking MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Farmstead Planning What happens when an engineer helps with planning? Vita

Vita Plus Dairy Summit 12/14/2016

MSA Professional Services, Inc. 8

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

2016 Freestall

Future Freestall

Future TransitionBarn

FutureSecond-Stage

Manure Storage

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

So where is the win for the farm…PROJECT COST DIFFERENCE

Freestall & Transition Barns Negligible, based on when constructed

Sand Settling Lanes $100,000

Duplex, Pumps $20,000

Pressure Pipe/Forcemain -$22,000

Gravity Piping -$15,000

Earthwork/Borrow -$60,000

Composite Manure Storage -$50,000

TOTAL SAVINGS $27,000

Environmental Risk ???

Page 9: Water Quantity & Quality Issues - Vita Plus · Innovation to Headland Stacking MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Farmstead Planning What happens when an engineer helps with planning? Vita

Vita Plus Dairy Summit 12/14/2016

MSA Professional Services, Inc. 9

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

Environmental Risk…

~30% slopeOriginal Area of Improvements

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

Manure Management = Risk Management

• Yakima Valley Implications – Compliance with NRCS standards may be insufficient.

• Fingerprinting Farms – DNA testing to determine who or what is polluting water.

• Updates to regulations and standards – emphasis on keeping pathogens out of water.

• Environmental Considerations becoming Requirements.

• WI Supreme Court – Manure in a well is considered a pollutant.

• Regulatory Agencies are emphasizing public protection.

• Limestone Karst – Increasing concerns and requiring more robust designs

Page 10: Water Quantity & Quality Issues - Vita Plus · Innovation to Headland Stacking MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Farmstead Planning What happens when an engineer helps with planning? Vita

Vita Plus Dairy Summit 12/14/2016

MSA Professional Services, Inc. 10

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

DESIGN STANDARDS & REGULATIONS

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

Pumping & Piping Seem to be ProblematicEspecially when something breaks and discharges 375,000 gal of manure . . .

Page 11: Water Quantity & Quality Issues - Vita Plus · Innovation to Headland Stacking MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Farmstead Planning What happens when an engineer helps with planning? Vita

Vita Plus Dairy Summit 12/14/2016

MSA Professional Services, Inc. 11

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

Piping and ConnectionsColors really do mean something…

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

Value of Planning with an Engineer• Understanding of Contracting, other contracting options

• Resource for Support or an Extra Set of Eyes

• Professional Liability Insurance protection

• Larger tool box

• Understanding current and future regulations

• Assurance you get what was planned for, paid for, and had bid

Page 12: Water Quantity & Quality Issues - Vita Plus · Innovation to Headland Stacking MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Farmstead Planning What happens when an engineer helps with planning? Vita

Vita Plus Dairy Summit 12/14/2016

MSA Professional Services, Inc. 12

MSA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES

What are the takeaways?

• Ag needs to lead◦ Plan for the long term◦ Be at the table◦ Be innovative◦ Develop partnerships◦ Stay of ahead of regulations

• Water Management is Risk Management

• The water you are using will be used again