Water A Heritage Perspective - Development Foundation Heritage Perspective.pdf · ‘Water’ – A...
Transcript of Water A Heritage Perspective - Development Foundation Heritage Perspective.pdf · ‘Water’ – A...
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
1
‘Water’ – A Heritage Perspective1
S. Manasi2 and K.V. Raju3
Abstract
The current paper provides an historical overview of water management over time and space and also makes an attempt to understand the values that the ancient texts and scriptures laid on ‘water’ in specific, further detailing out challenges in water management in the current context and suggesting future options for improved water management. The focus is to see how ‘water’ was and is perceived and the influence it had and has on ‘water management’. There are references made in Vedas and in early scholarly manuscripts to several aspects of water management viz. technologies in water management and use, irrigation water management, water allocation and pricing, medicinal properties of water, and conservation of water for sustainable use. All this was perceived through viewing water as a ‘divine component’ where emphasis was on reverence for water, belief systems, religious practices through which they created a sense of awareness and respect towards water usage which helped conserve it as well. There are also several simple and sustainable technologies that were in practice and are found effective even to this day. Further, the paper describes the challenges encountered in water management in the current context due to competing water uses within and across sectors in view of urbanization and population explosion capturing illustrations from Karnataka. Besides providing a historical view and looking at these two contexts, efforts are made to draw some lessons from the traditional water management practices and other literature as well, for future water management.
1 This paper was presented in ISEC-DF workshop on 25-1-2012 and revised based on comments received.
We thank Prof. N.S.S. Narayana and two anonymous reviewers for their valuable suggestions and
comments. 2 Assistant Professor, Centre for Ecological Economics and Natural Resources, Institute for Social and
Economic Change, e-mail: [email protected] 3 Professor, Centre for Ecological Economics and Natural Resources, Institute for Social and Economic
Change, Currently, Economic Advisor to the Chief Minister, Government of Karnataka,
e mail:[email protected]
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
2
1.0. Background
The roots of civilizational-cultural landscape of India can be located
historically in terms of an inalienable and harmonious existence with nature over
time and space. Our ancient scriptures such as Vedas make several reverential
references to nature as an all inclusive embodiment of existence (both animate
and inanimate). Further in the Indian socio-cultural context, flora and fauna are
considered valuable entities of nature considering their relevance to the
sustainability of a healthy eco-system. Protecting the environment has been
closely related to safeguarding the earth as well. There are several examples
that indicate that cultural traditions have played a significant role in conserving
many of our water and forest resources even to this day. The ancient Indian
scriptures often emphasize the importance of a harmonious coexistence between
human beings and nature. -“Do strengthen me. May all beings regard me with
eyes of a friend. May I regard all beings with the eyes of a friend. With the eyes
of a friend do we regard one another.” YV 36.18 (Sharma, 2000).
As Shadananan Nair (2003) observes, ‘Ancient Indian literature points
towards an intuitive understanding of nature and natural processes’. However,
many of the ideas are presented philosophically, so skill and effort are needed
for tracing the meaning of many such lines. The Vedas, Upanishads, Puranas,
Epics and scholarly writings such as "Mayurchitraka" "Brihat Samhita" are vast
treasure troves of scientific and environmental knowledge. The ancient
scriptures, particularly the Vedic literature stresses maintaining the importance of
natural resources. Protection of environment is articulated through informal rules
in the form of traditions/daily rituals/prayers along with compassion towards all
forms of life with a particular emphasis on human wellbeing wherein pious
actions would result in nature’s blessings, (the earth - mother and the
atmosphere above - father would protect and provide one with a long and
peaceful life) while erroneous actions could harm nature and its functions.
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
3
The natural forces have been associated with specific names of deities -
Indra as the god of water (and heaven), Marut as god of winds while Aryaman,
Mitra, Varuna and Soma as the expediters of water, Aditi as universe, Fire (Agni)
also regarded as a god. In Vedic cosmology, the earth (Prithivi) symbolizes the
material base while the upper sky or heaven (Dyaus) symbolizes the
unmanifested immortal source also known as the ‘Universal Atman’ which
together and between them, provides the environment (paryavaran’. In Atharva
Veda also, earth is referred to as mother, while the sky or heaven (dyaus) as
father, and atmosphere between them as brother while seeking forgiveness for
any inadvertent harm that may have been caused to these ‘relatives’. The Rig
vedic hymns clearly describe the Dyava Prithivi (Heaven and Earth) as `full of
water’, `decorated with ornaments of water’, `abundantly blessed with love of
water’, `conservator of waters’, etc (Sharma, 2000).
Given this broad background, the paper makes an attempt to understand
the significance that the ancient texts and scriptures have attributed to ‘water’ in
specific, with a view to explore how ‘water’ has been perceived and the influence
it has and can have on ‘water management’. There are several references made
in Vedas and in early scholarly manuscripts to the various aspects of water
management which are not available in a compiled version. From a broader
perspective, the review would aid in a better understanding of ‘water
management practices’ as prevailing in the ancient times a part from helping us
realize its relevance to the current context of water management. Although the
contexts and the challenges are entirely different, we still hope to find some
answers and draw lessons from the past experiences for future water
management practices. The paper is divided into three sections – section 1 is a
review of ancient scriptures/historical documents on water management and
related aspects – viz. technologies in water management and use, irrigation
water management, water allocation and pricing, medicinal properties of water,
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
4
and water conservation for sustainable use and so on, while section 2 highlights
the current challenges in water management in the context of population
explosion and urbanization in addition to issues such as water scarcity due to
competing water uses, water quality, environmental flows and so on. Several
studies indicate that there is an urgent need for addressing the current water
crisis and that the situation of water management looks bleak, in spite of several
initiatives being undertaken throughout the country for its protection and
sustenance. The state’s effort in meeting the water requirements in terms of
quality and accessibility continues to remain a challenge. Section 3 proposes
certain possible future water management options.
Section 1: Traditional Water Management Approaches and
Practices
1.1. ‘Water’ in Ancient Scriptures
1.1.1. Water – As a philosophical component of life
Water, or the water element, finds cited in the Vedas, Upanishads and
other ancient literature abundantly (Box 1). In the Vedas, water occupies the
highest place amongst the five basic elements of nature4. In all the four Vedas,
water is seen as a form of god fit to be worshipped, considering its life giving
properties. Rig-Veda contains several 'shlokas' in praise of ‘Water’. Water is seen
as an embodiment of self-awareness. Besides, water is referred to as a source
of life, protector of earth and environment, nectar, honey, generator of
prosperity, cleanser of sins and so on. Water is regarded as the first important
element that gave rise to the subsequent evolution of the universe. In Yajur
4 All living and non-living bodies are made up five basic, gross elements of Nature, called
‘Panchamahabhuta’. The substance capacity later in the five basic elements (Bhutas) manifests in the
following order — Ether or Space or Firmament (Akash), Air (Vayu), Energy or Fire(Tej or Agni), Water
(Aapah) and Earth (Prithivi).
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
5
Veda, water is referred to as - ‘The Earth revolves with its mother water in its
orbit, The Earth revolves around its father, the Sun’ – (Yajur Veda 3/6). Rig
Veda says, on this planet, all life forms have evolved from apah (water); and
water is a basic need of all living creatures of this earth’. Sheetam (cold to
touch), Suchihi (clean), Shivam (replete with useful minerals and trace of useful
elements), Istham (transparent), Vimalam Lahu Shadgunam (its acid-base
balance should not exceed normal limits) - these properties symbolize water as
‘divyajal’. Further, water is seen as nectar and revered as pure, faultless, rain-
shedding, sweet essence of the earth, which the devout have first consecrated
as the beverage of Indra (RV 7.47.1). Water is also referred to as an
intermediate component between all pervasive air and localised earth. ‘Agni
Vaisvanara is the Universal God, who has entered into the heart and spirit of
water, hence considered as the life and the awareness’. Offerings are made to
waters of wells, pools, lakes, ponds, tanks, marshes, rains, streams, rivers and
ocean (Taittriya Samhita vii-4-13).
Similarly, the Taittariya Upanishad (II-i) says - `From the Self, verily,
space arose, from space air, from air fire, from fire water, from water the earth,
from the earth herbs, from herbs food, from food semen, from semen the
person’. From water earth was formed, i.e. out of water sprang forth the
embryonic state of the universe. Chhandogya Upanishad (7.10.1) says “it is the
waters which pervade everything, big or small, the earth, the atmosphere, the
heaven, the mountains, gods, men, animals, birds, grass, plants, dogs, worms,
insects, ants. All these (worldly manifestations) are waters indeed” (Sharma,
2000).
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
6
Box 1: Mythological Anecdotes
The physical and aesthetic properties of water give it a unique mythical-religious niche and, therefore, has played an important role in myths and religious rituals.
- Lord Vishnu, the God of existence, also known as "Narayan", is the one who resides in
water. The origin of life from water and the development of species explained through the ten incarnations of Lord Vishnu, constitute a Hindu theological concept of the
evolutionary of life in Vedic history. The incarnations through the ages are of various forms tortoise, boar, lion and so on till he is a perfect human being.
- The importance of rivers and water bodies is highlighted throughout "Ramayana" and "Mahabharata", epics there exist several legends about water and water bodies. The epic
"Ramayana" (Valmiki) explains a lot about the river Sarayu (Ganges) into which Lord Sri
Rama disappeared on the way to heaven. - Saints appearing in epics always lived in the vicinity of rivers, as physical purity
associated with mental purity was believed a must in realizing the eternal truth.
1.2. Benefits from Water
1.2.1. Water – Source of Happiness, Inspirer and Motivator - Water is
seen as a source of happiness and strength also represents splendor (Atharva
Veda Samhita iii – 13-5). Water is also seen as loving like mothers who care for
their children. As regards wisdom and happiness, “Since waters are the source
of happiness, grant to us to enjoy abundance, and a great and delightful
perception”. (RV 10.9.1). “I invoke for protection the divine waters of excellent
wisdom, discharging their functions – flowing by day and flowing by night” (RV).
Water is seen as an inspirer and motivator to achieve one’s goal, full of vigour
and strength besides following the right path with clarity, as in the rig veda that,
‘ceaselessly they flow from the depths, pure, never sleeping to reach the ocean,
where King Varuna resides. Waters may pour from heaven or run along channels
dug out by men; or flow clear and pure having the Ocean as their goal. ln the
midst of the Waters is moving the Lord, surveying men's truth and men's lies.
How sweet are the Waters, crystal clear and cleansing! From whom King Varuna,
Soma, and all the Deities drink exhilarating strength, into whom the Universal
Lord has entered, now may these great divine Waters quicken me’ ( RV VII, 49).
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
7
1.2.2. Water - Embodiment of Prosperity – Prayers were offered as water
was considered divine, purifier, gratifier as it provided people with food, aided to
pursue the path of the gods, offered oblation to the rivers for their incessant
flows. Water is vaporized by the sun’s rays, while Indra opens a path to bestow
upon us wealth; and cherish us with blessings." (RV 7.47.3-4). Earth, in which
lie the seas, the rivers and other waters, in which food and cornfields have come
to be, in which lives all that breathes and that moves, may she confer on us the
finesse of her yield (Atharva Veda – Hymns to the Earth – Bhumi-Sukta).
Similarly, rain plays an important role and without rain, there cannot be water
flows and even the wealth of the wide seas gets reduced. The continuance of
timely rainfall will help the world preserve its existence for bestowing fortune. In
the case of failure of rainfall, the results would be disastrous with respect to
hopes and, hunger and distress situation would prevail. The farmers will not be
able to plough their lands, resulting in the loss of lives including livestock due to
scarcity of fodder, and hence there can be no celebration of annual festivals and
daily prayers (Sharma, 2000).
1.2.3. Water as ‘Purifier’ - The position of water as a life giving and life
sustaining element is very high. Water is considered a cleanser of sins besides
being regarded as divine and a protective power. Water is seen as a means of
purification and as per "Yajur Veda" clean water has the potential to purify all
things through rain: "may waters, like mother, purify our bodies". “The waters,
with their ocean-chief, proceed from the midst of the firmament, purifying (all
things), flowing unceasingly; may the divine waters, whom the thunder-bearing
Lord Indra, showered, sent forth, protect me here (on earth)” (RV 7.49.1-2).
“May the maternal (earth’s) waters purify us, may the shedders of water purify
us with effusion; for the divine (waters) bear away all sin: I come away from
them purified” (to heaven). (RV 10.17.10). “(Waters)! the plants flourish by
means of water, by prayer is effectual through water; the essence of water is
vigorous through water; purify me with it.” (RV 10.17.14). Similarly, in the Yajur
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
8
Veda, the sages pray for purification, – “O Water, thou art the reservoir of
welfare and propriety, sustain us to become strong. We look up to thee to be
blessed by thy kind nectar on this earth. O water, we approach thee to get rid of
our sins. May the water cleanse the earth, the earth cleanse me. May the holy
waters make me devoid of sins and remove my bad deeds. The waters that keep
Agni (fire) inside them, bless us. The waters that generate all prosperity on earth
and heaven and those which dwell in different forms in the atmosphere, those
who irrigate the earth, may those waters be kind to us and bless us. O Water,
kindly touch me with thy divine self and establish strength, radiance, intellect
and wisdom in me.”
“Earth, in which the waters, common to all, moving on all sides, flow
unfailingly, day and night, may she pour on us milk in many streams, and endow
us with luster” (Atharva Veda – Hymn to the Earth – Bhumi Sukta). “Waters
bear off all defilements and cleanse people (Vajasaneya Samhita iv.2). ‘Water
cleanses humanity of the evil of pollution committed by it’ (Atharva Veda Samhita
xii-2-40) (Sharma, 2000). Similarly, the popular ‘Tirukulals’ indicate the
importance of water in a person’s life wherein he/she, without water cannot go
about the daily routine and discharge one’s duties of life.
1.2.4. Water as Procreator - Water has always been highly respected and
treated with great reverences and is prayed to grant men procreative power (RV
10.9.3). It mentions- “All creatures are born from the waters” (RV 1.23.16,
10.17.10). Waters have been considered as the producers of all that is stationary
and all that moves” (RV 6.50.1). They are also hailed as mothers of all beings
(RV 1.23.10, 6.50.6, 10.17.10). Waters as friends of man, give full protection to
his progenies (Rig Veda Samhita vi-50-7).
1.2.5. Water’s Medicinal Properties - Water’s medicinal and healing
properties are highlighted in vedas. Vedas encourage and inspire people to
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
9
explore and acquire the knowledge of nature cure. Water is seen as the reservoir
of all curative medicines. ‘Varuna’ is a cosmic ruler as well as the deity that
dwells in waters, presides over them and is, therefore, prayed to for granting
strength and virility to people’. Rigveda hails waters as the reservoir of all
curative medicines. It offers oblations to deities presiding over the flowing
waters- “O Water, which we have drunk, becomes refreshing in our body. May
you be pleasant to us by driving away diseases and pains – O divine immortal
waters” (RV 63).
Atharva Veda and other several hymns (6.23; 24 & 57) specifically
mention the medicinal value of waters and as a dispeller of diseases, as a curer
of incurable diseases. Atharvaveda and Rigveda (1.161.9) state – ‘there exists no
better element other than water - “Water is sovereign of precious treasures,
hence requested to act as a healer and remove all ill health” (RV 10.9.5).
1.3. Promoting Conservation and Protection
1.3.1. Sustainable Practices
Water conservation, use and management were given considerable
importance in ancient India (Shadananan Nair, 2003). Conservation, Protection
and Judicious use of water have been well documented in the Vedas and
Upanishads. The ancient teachers have specified the conservation of water
keeping in view the future generations. ‘Plants and water are treasures for
generations’ (Rig Veda Samhita vii.70-4). ‘Waters and herbs should have no
poison’ (Rig Veda Samhita vi – 39-5). ‘Waters are to be freed from defilement’
(Atharva Veda Samhita x-5-24’). The environmental protection was closely
related to the protection of heaven (atmosphere) and the earth. During the Vedic
times, the sages prayed for the maintainance of a required balance in the
functioning of all entities of nature - the mountains, lakes, heaven and earth, the
forests, the waters in the firmament. People were ordained to use their life
sustaining waters most judiciously and with greatest reverence. Generating
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
10
respect for water among the masses acted as a regulatory measure for curtailing
water pollution. Water in all its various forms was considered divine and blissful.
1.3.2. Water Purification Practices - It is also interesting to note that
there existed several methods for assessing and maintaining water quality and
also treatment methods as revealed by the Vedas and also books on "Ayurveda".
In Brihat-Samhita, written and compiled by Varahamihira, several methods for
obtaining potable water from contaminated sources, using plants, metals and
heat are described besides the purification process of ground water has been
dealt with at length. A powder mix extracted from herbs like Anjan,
Bhadramustha, Khas (vetiver), Amla (emblica officinalis, gooseberry) and Nirmali
(bhui amla / kataka), was in use in measured quantities for purifying water in
wells. Sushruta, the famous Indian physician provided a detailed practical
guidance for water purification. He showed that with herbs and other natural
substance muddy water could be purified, using Nirmali seeds, roots of Kamal
(lotus/water lily), rhizomes of algae and three stones, Gomed (garnet) Moti
(pearl) and Sphatik (quartz crystal). He suggested exposing contaminated water
to the sun or immersing a red hot iron rod or hot sand in it, for purification
purpose. Table 1 provides details on traditional practices in maintaining water
quality.
Table 1: Traditional Practices of safeguarding Drinking Water
Use of Alum in Water Aluminium sulfate or Alum is used as an aflocculant for removing unwanted colour and turbidity from water supplies. It has been used since ancient times for this purpose and its use together with filtration is a standard practice in conventional water treatment processes around the world.
Using cloth for filtering In Dhoti method, a thin piece of cloth is used for filtering water
Keeping Tortoises in open wells
Tortoises are known to have a much longer life span than humans. It has been a traditional practice particularly in India to keep tortoises in drinking water wells so that they feed on organisms harmful to humans while keeping water safe for drinking.
Use of Moringa Seeds Moringa tree seeds are crushed into powder and used as a water-soluble extract in suspension, resulting in an effective natural purification agent for highly turbid and untreated pathogenic surface water.
Rain water harvesting Harvesting rain water through simple filtration methods such as using cloth pieces.
Combination of local plant and filtration methods
Raw water is filtered through powdered seeds of local plant materials including Moringa oleifera and Phyllanthus emblica—natural flocculants—and through coarse sand, charcoal, and gravel, which reduce the total aerobic mesophilic bacterial, E coli, coliform, pseudomonas, and yeast counts, and turbidity, consistent with World Health Organization acceptable standards for potable water. http://hopebuilding.pbworks.com/w/page/19222829/Tamil-Nadu-group-finds-simple-way-to-purify-drinking-water
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
11
It has been scientifically proved by researches that storing drinking water
in brass vessels is good for health, a system which was also in practice in ancient
times. Microbiologists suggest that rather than using plastic containers for storing
water, it is better to use brass containers which help combat many water-borne
diseases.
“The scientific principle involved in this is the fact that any metal or alloy
tends to disrupt biological systems. The element acts by interfering with the
membranes and enzymes of cells; for bacteria, this can mean death. Pots made
of brass, (an alloy of copper and zinc), shed copper particles into the water that
they contain. But the miniscule amount that circulates into the water, while
destroying bacteria does not harm human beings”.
http://www.indiaheritage.org/science/edviron.htm
1.4. Imbibing Awareness through Belief Systems
1.4.1. Use of Water in Social and Religious Traditions
In all the cultures of the world, water is given a high prominence.
Similarly, in respect of the socio-religious-cultural tradition of India, water is
accorded a very high and unique status. This can be observed during
religious/social customs and practices, festivals and so on. Water is the most
important requirement for performing religious rituals and social ceremonies as it
is considered the basic means for purification of body and soul in Indian culture
since ancient times. On auspicious occasions like marriage and other religious
functions, metallic pitchers, symbolizing rivers, are used. Water and fire are
considered as the divine witnesses to all human deeds; hence all rituals and rites
are performed in their presence (Sharma, 2000). Several beliefs and practices
are observed (Box 2).
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
12
Box 2: Dogmas and Practices
- Associated with every Hindu temple and ashrams, are big ponds and wells. There is a popular belief that bathing in holy rivers or drinking some drops of water from these rivers
before the last breath, helps absolve oneself of all the sins committed through evil deeds
during the present lifetime and also through several lives. - There is also a popular belief that a dip in the sacred waters at Kumbha Mela ensures one
salvation or freedom from the cycle of births and deaths. - On specific occasions like the solar and lunar eclipses or specific planetary configurations a
dip in the holy rivers is an essential part of Hindu culture, as it is considered to have Cosmo- biological effect on the human body and mind.
- According to Agni Purana and Padma Purana, the Ganga descended to the earth on Ganga
Dussehra day and a bath in the holy river on this day is said to purify one of all sins. To die on the banks of the Ganga is considered most auspicious. If that is not possible, then ashes
after cremation are immersed in the river Ganga as it is believed to release one from the cycle of births and re-births.
- There is a common belief among the locals that girls who take a holy dip in the river Ganga
on Makara Sankranti day get handsome grooms and the boys beautiful brides. - On the banks of the river Ganga, Haridwar, India, there is a practice going on even to this
day, every morning and evening a daily Ganga worship with lighted lamps in the presence of thousands of devotees, and with holy music and chants of mantras is performed.
- In all religious practices, the sprinkling of divine water is an inevitable part. The water is purified with "mantras", invoking the presence of seven sacred rivers. This divine water is
used for anointing idols, which is then distributed to devotees.
- At the functions following funerals and during offerings to ancestors, bathing and dipping in holy water bodies, including the ocean, is considered of great religious and spiritual value.
- Praying with a handful of water in the mornings and the evenings is part of one’s daily life. There are several water bodies considered sacred in different States of India.
- Former generations used to give due consideration to the right of all creations for using
water. Open wells have been in use for centuries. Near the well, they used to construct small pits to be filled with water so that birds, reptiles or animals could drink.
- A certain class of Brahmins even judges the behaviour of a newly-wedded girl by asking her to water the sacred plant "tulsi" while watching to see if she leaves some water in the bucket
for other creatures. The custom is not to empty the bucket until sunset.
1.4.2. Respect to ‘Rivers’ in Scriptures and Mythological Descriptions
Rivers are considered divine in the Indian civilization and worshipped as
Goddesses as revealed in mythological descriptions. The rivers are worshipped
like goddesses, considered as holy and seen as life sustaining having medicinal
value and as a cleanser of sins. The traditional ‘chants’ invoke all the major rivers
of India to purify and absolve them of their sins. In Rigveda, river Sarasvati is
compared to the celestial cow (Kamadhenu) that nurtures people with its
nutritive milk. More references to rivers, their waters, their behaviors and the
bliss they bestow on people are to be found in the Vedas. The rivers are
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
13
considered as the daughters of the Sun and cloud and the "mantras" of the "Rig
Veda" denote that the creation started with the origin of water. The knowledge
of Geography, Geomorphology and stream flow has been well developed in the
ancient times. "Atharva Veda" mentions that rivers originate in mountains and
are perennial while during the summer river flow is maintained by the snow-
covered mountains (Nair, 2004).
1.4.3. Water Festivals of India - Several water-related festivals are organized
with millions of people participating for a holy dip in the sacred rivers, even to
this day though the celebration of these festivals varies across cities (Table 2).
During these festivals thanks giving ceremony to God for providing food, water
and shelter is also conducted. The faith behind this indicates that Lord Shiva
showers his grace in terms of providing water in times of extreme drought
conditions. Most of these legends about rivers relate to religious, cultural, and
social events in history. For instance, Pushkaram festival occurs in any particular
year with respect to one of the twelve important rivers5 which is based on the
zodiacal sign Jupiter. The first twelve days are knows as Adi Pushkaram and the
last twelve days are known as Anthya Pushkaram. There is a belief that during
these twenty four days ‘Pushkar’ the person, who is imbued with the power to
make any river holy will travel with Jupiter as Jupiter moves from one Zodiac
house to another.
5 Ganges, Narmada, Saraswati, Yamuna, Godavari, Krishna, Kaveri, Bhima, Brahmaputra, Tungabhadra,
Indus, Pranahita
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
14
Table 2: Water Festivals across States
Maharashtra Uttarkhand Madhya Pradesh
"Kumbh Mela" considered the greatest of the Indian fairs with the highest state of water symbolism, attracts the largest congregation of religious pilgrims from all over the world. Symbolically speaking, the forces of creation are collected in one vessel (Kumbh) and a celebration (mela) ensues, hence called "Kumbh Mela". Millions of piligrims take a dip in the holy rivers in order to wash away their sins. The month long festival represents a time when the river is believed to turn into purifying nectar, allowing the devotees to cleanse their souls as they bathe. It is a very important occasion that takes place every 3 years at the following four locations in India: (a) Allahabad (Prayag), at the confluence of rivers Ganga, Yamuna and mythical river, Saraswati (b) Haridwar, where the River Ganga enters the plains from the Himalayas; (c) Ujjain, on the banks of the river Shipra; (d) Nasik, on the banks of the river Godavari.
The "Ardh (half) Kumbh Mela" is held every 6 years at Allahabad and Haridwar
"Purna (complete) Kumbh Mela", the biggest and the most auspicious fair, is held every 12 years.
"Purna Kumbh Mela" is always held at Allahabad, considered exceptionally sacred because of the confluence of holy rivers. "Maha Kumbh Mela" occurs every 144 years. In addition, the "Magh Mela" or the Annual Mini Kumbh (in the month of Magh in the national calendar i.e. falls during January-February) is held every year at Allahabad, excepting the years of "Puma Kumbh Mela".
Uttarpradesh Bihar West Bengal
Ganga Dashara Sagara means the location of the ocean, and the island where the river Ganga enters the ocean. A fair is held with people coming from long distances for bathing and later they worship Goddess Ganga. The legend has it that Ganga entered the ocean at this point to wash away the bones of 60,000 sons of Sagara, in whose memory the island is named. Ganga Dussehra is celebrated on the tenth day of Jyeshtha. The river Ganga is worshipped as a mother/ Goddess, by people of Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, and Bengal where it flows. On this day, if a devotee is unable to visit and bathe in the river Ganga, then Ganga Jal (water) kept in most Hindu homes is used for purification. It is believed that bathing in the river will wash away one’s sins. People have a ceremonial bath in the river Bhagirathi before offering worship to mother Ganga and distributing alms to beggars, supposedly to earn a bonus of religious merit.
West Bengal Makara Sankranti – A dip in the ocean, where the Ganga drains into the sea is considered to be of religious significance on the Makara Sankranti day when the sun makes a transition to Capricorn from Sagittarius and becomes home to vast fairs, drawing visitors from all over the state. After they are done with the ritual obligations, they head towards the Kapilmuni Temple situated nearby, to worship the deity as a mark of respect.
Kerala
Boat festivals- Certain competitive races are held across villages of central Kerala featuring smaller churulans, oadis, and irrutukuthies by way of providing an expression to the spirit of athletics. On the backwaters of Kerala, fierce Vallom Kallies (boat races) and water carnivals are held annually that are witnessed by thousands of spectators. The water carnivals and snake boat races herald the week of the great harvest festival of Onam.
Tamil Nadu Adiperukku- This unique festival is celebrated during mid July-August, 18th day of Tamil month, Aadi, by women. The festival pays rich tributes to water’s life-sustaining properties.
Himachal Pradesh
Minjar - Celebrated during July-August at Chamba, is kind of a thanks giving ceremony to the rain god. It is also a prayer for good harvest, held for 7 days and is one of the major monsoon festivals in Himachal Pradesh.
Karnataka
Tula Sankramana - It is believed that, on this day, Goddess Cauvery provides her ‘Darshan’ to devotees in the form of an upsurge of water in a small tank. It is considered a very sacred moment with thousands of devotees visit Kodagu for receiving Goddess Cauvery's blessings. Taking a bath in the tank by devotees is the most important ritual of the day. It is said that, taking a dip in the tank purifies one’s body and soul. Devotees also take holy water to their homes.
Orissa
Kartika Purnima: The massively popular fair is held on the banks of Mahanadi river in the fort area of Cuttack from where the traders of yesteryears (sadhaba) undertook voyages along the beaten trade route in huge boats called “Boita”. To relive the glory of ancient times – the opulence associate with the thriving trade and the prosperity, the people of Cuttack as well as those of the entire state small boats in the river while recalling the by gone times .In consonance with the “bidding adieu” practice in those days when the wives prayed for the successful return of their husbands, married women and children today, wearing colorful costumes, gather near the water bodies carrying tiny boats made of paper or thermocol . They then place small lighted lamps inside them as a mark of memory of the merchants who had ventured out into the unknown in search of prosperity and launch them on the gentle waves of the water amidst the blowing of the conches, ululations and occasional bursting of fire crackers. The entire stretch of Mahanadi flowing beside the Gadgadeswar Temple in Cuttack, which was once the starting point of the trade route to the Bali island, turns into a conundrum of activity early in the morning on this day of Kartik Purnima.
Madya Pradesh
Kumbha Mela - Ujjain has the honor of holding the famous Kumbha fair once in twelve years. Ganga Dashmi- The festival falls on the tenth day of the second fortnight of Jyaistha (May-June). In Surguja region, the occasion is practiced by the Adivasis and non-Adivasis. The classes of the Hindu fold celebrate it because on this day the river Ganges had made its descent on the earth. They take a dip in any nearby river and make offerings. The tribal people go in batches with their women to the riverside for drinking and dancing. Games and local competitions are arranged.
Haryana Teej - This is celebrated on Sawan Sudi - 3 (Jul-Aug),by way of to welcoming 'Sawan' or the rainy season. After the first showers of Sawan, a small red insect called Teej in Haryana comes out from earth's soil. Swings are set up in the open courtyards and
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
15
Teej gets the first swing of the season. Girls apply henna on their hands and feet and hence are excused from household chores on this day. On Teej, girls receive new clothes from their parents and mothers send bayas or gifts. A puja is performed in the morning. The baya which consists of a variety of foodstuff, is placed on a thali at the place of worship, a decorated chowk (square) with an idol or a picture of Parvati installed. The evenings are set aside for singing and dancing. Chetar Chaudas Mela The festival is annually held in Pehowa, which has the holy Saraswati tank also called 'Saraswati Teertha' or 'Prithudak Teertha'. This ‘Teertha’ also finds mention in the ancient Hindu texts. Here at this place, the Chetar Chaudas Fair is held during the spring season. Pilgrims, both Sikhs and Hindus, flock to this place for offering 'pinds' to their ancestors. It is claimed that here in this holy spot, Yudhister had offered 'pinds' in memory of all his relatives killed in the Mahabharat war. Pilgrims take bath in the Saraswati tank during this fair. Madlia Naumi This is celebrated at the beginning of the rainy season.
Bihar
Chhath or Surya Puja is the main festival of Bihar, held after six days of Diwali; it is a festival of prayers and propitiation observed with solemnity. It is an expression of thanks and seeking blessings from the forces of nature, mainly the Sun and river. The belief is that a devotee’s desire is always fulfilled during Chhath when people worship the Sun God. On the first day, the house is cleaned, with family members going in for a holy dip and eating strict vegetarian food and sleep on the floor. All earthen vessels are reserved for this day only. The persons observing Chaath also known as Parvatis, observe dawn to dusk fast which concludes with partaking of sweets. This is followed by another fast for 36 hours till the dawn of the final day when puja starts at the river bank much before sunrise. These parvatis remain in water from late midnight until the first ray of dawn. The rivers are flooded with offerings to the sun which is followed by breakfast and distribution of sweets among those gathered. Fresh paddy, sweets and fruits are also offered by the devotees to the Sun God for a good harvest at the sun temple in Baragaon near Nalanda.
Manipur Yaoshang (Holi)- A riot of colours and water and the various chantings of devotees of Lord Krishna characterize this festival. Another feature of this premier festival is the Thabal Chongba (Dancing in the Moonlight). Boys from various places come to the site of the festival and dance with girls holding hands while moving in circles. It is celebrated for five days starting from the full moon of Phalguna (February/March).
Uttar Pradesh
Ganga Mahotsav is a five day event celebrated on the banks of the river Ganges in Varanasi. This festival is celebration of Varanasi as the cultural and spiritual capital of India and the Ganges as India’s lifeline, considered worthy of highest reverence by the Hindus. Ganga gives a sense of belonging to the people of India especially those living near its banks. http://www.festivalsofindia.in/ganga_mahotsav/
Gujarat Rishi Panchami According to is a legend Ganga came down to the earth on Rishi Panchami, the fifth day of Bhadra (September) at Tarnetar. There is a sacred tank where people congregate for a holy bath on that day.
Source: See Foot Note6
1.4.4. Local Awareness through Proverbs and Sayings
Proverbs across Indian languages related to nature, rainfall, water etc. are
treasures of wisdom simple and popular and are easily passed on through
generations. Collecting those simple connotations amounts to a huge task says
Shadananan Nair. This knowledge has been developed through keen
observations of nature and events. A review of behaviour of 165 birds and
animals is taken as an indicator of the nature of forthcoming rainfall and the
6 http://www.whereincity.com/india/west-bengal/festivals.php, http://www.indiasite.com/manipur/fairs-festivals.html
http://www.indovacations.net/english/BiharFestival.htm, http://www.haryana-online.com/culture/fairs_&_festivals.htm http://www.onlytravelguide.com/madhya-pradesh/fairs-festivals/ganga-dashmi.php, http://www.indialine.com/travel/karnataka/fairs-festivals.html, http://www.indiaatitsbest.com/kerala/festivals.html http://scraps.oriyaonline.com/blog/?tag=fairs-and-festivals-of-orissa, http://www.walkthroughindia.com/festivals/the-10-major-monsoon-festivals-in-india/, http://www.indiatraveltours.net/fair-festivals-in-india/fairs-of-madhya-pradesh.html
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
16
availability of resources. Citing examples from proverbs in Kerala, Shadananan
Nair summarizes that, "If planted in 'njattuvela' (break monsoon), even dry sticks
will grow". The break monsoon gives rain and strong sunshine alternately several
times a day, and this is considered a good time for planting small plants and
trees. "Water should be inside 'thundams' (heaps of sand) in the 'thulavarsham'
(winter monsoon)". The winter monsoon marks the end of the rainy season with
the detention of water enhancing groundwater recharge.
1.5. Technologies in Water Management
1.5.1. Awareness regarding Water Cycle and Hydrology
The Vedas have made references to hydrological cycle indicating the
conversion of water from one form to another was well understood and
documented in a scientific way during the vedic times. In Puranas, Bruhat
Samhita, Meghmala and other literature, the intake of water by plants, division of
water into minute particles by sun rays and wind, clouds of different types, their
heights, their rainfall capacities etc., with the calculation of rain-fall quantity in
advance through observation of natural phenomena are described.
The early studies on weather and water in India can be traced back to
thousands of years. The Sukla Yajur Veda Mantra is used traditionally in the
Vedas to invoke Mars (Angaraka) which has reference to water. The early
philosophical writings contain descriptions of the earth’s revolution around the
Sun, the seasons, and the processes of cloud formation and rain. The
‘Arthashastra’ and Panini’s ‘Astadhyayi’ refer to rain gauges during the 700 BC
besides the rainfall quantity in different parts of India. "Arthashastra" contains
records of scientific measurements of rainfall in various parts of India and its
application to the country's revenue and relief work.
By the time of Kautilya (4th century B.C.), instrumental devices for
measuring rainfall were developed. This raingauge was known as Varshaman.
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
17
Kautilya was acquainted with the distribution of rainfall in various areas. He
furnishes a very accurate scientific description of the same with statistics. The
quantity of rain that falls in the country of Jangala (desert countries) is 16 dronas
(4 Adak = 1 drona and one adak equals nearly 7 lb, 11 oz), half as much in
moist countries (the countries which are fit for agriculture), 13.5 dronas in the
countries of Asmakas (Maharashtra); 23 dronas in Avanti, and an immense
quantity in the western countries, the border of the Himalayas and the countries
where water channels are used in agriculture (Arth, Chapter XXIV, Book II, P.
130).
It also classifies climate and identifies the zones suitable for agriculture. It
appears that fire and flood control measures for protecting farms and villages
were also practiced in respect of rainfall and water. As Shadananan Nair points
out ‘Many of the hydrological concepts developed in the last few centuries were
known and well documented in them by 3000 BC. Only a small fraction of the
scientific knowledge contained in them has so far been studied in detail. A
valuable attempt at undertaking this work was carried out by the National
Institute of Hydrology (1990). Similarly, the "Vayu Purana" and the "Matsya
Purana" mention the rainfall potential of clouds and the formation of clouds by
cyclonic, convectional and orographic effects. The "Vishnu Purana" discusses the
glorious sun that exhales moisture from seas, rivers, the Earth and living
creatures. The great poet Kalidasa of the 7th century BC, in his work
"Meghdoot", mentions the date of onset of the monsoon over central India and
the path of the monsoon clouds (India Meteorological Department, 2003).
There was familiarity about the phenomena of infiltration, interception;
stream-flow, geomorphology, artesian wells and erosive action of water were
also well understood. According to Bruhat Samhita, the development of ground
water and quality had got sufficient attention. The management of water and
conservation, well organized water pricing system, methods of construction and
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
18
materials of dam, tanks etc., and protection measures mentioned in the ancient
books reveal the expertise in the development of water resources management
and hydrology in ancient India (Lochan, online).
1.5.2. Traditional Sustainable Practices
Societies and cultures have traditionally developed sustainable techniques
for conserving and managing nature and natural resources. India has a
fascinating and significant ancient tradition of conserving land and water and
even today, local people follow several such traditional conservation practices.
India’s diversity in respect of its climate conditions led to innovative ways of
water conservation and management which are locale specific. Technologies in
water management were practiced with regard to irrigation water management
(Box 3) and urban contexts with drinking water and sanitation given due
importance. Biodiversity-related cultural phenomena exist by different local
names in different parts of India. For example, making small heaps of sands
before the end of the winter monsoon in the central part of Kerala was, in fact, a
multi-purpose method involving water and agricultural management. Water
trapped in between the heaps infiltrates in to groundwater, so that there is no
serious water shortage in the dry months. In addition, the weeds get removed
and soil becomes loose to fit the land for agriculture. Similarly, in some parts of
Karnataka, where Arecaunut is grown, the husk is spread evenly on the earth to
contain moisture and retain groundwater. Unfortunately, because of fast
changing life styles, the rising cost of labour and the shortage of land availability
due to an ever increasing population, this sustainable and environment-friendly
method are becoming uncommon (Shadananan Nair, 2003).
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
19
Box 3: Lakes
Artificial ponds and lakes had been created in the ancient times by stopping the outlets of streams and rivers. From such water-bodies, water was lifted by counterpoised 'sweeps', or other
devices, and fed into smaller channels. These, in turn, carried the water into fields. Artificially
fabricated lakes were built across India and it has been estimated that, over time, there exist nearly 1.3 million human-made lakes and ponds. The Earliest Artificial Lake known is 'Sudarshan'
lake, Gujarat's Girnar area, (early period of Mauryan dynasty emperors). Largest Artificial lake (250 sq miles, 65,000 ha) in Bhojpur, near Bhopal, had been built during the middle of the 11th
century, by king Bhoj Parmar, of Dhar. This was built across two hills fed by 365 streams and springs. Another Artificial lake the Raj Samand in Rajasthan, built at the command of Maharana
Raj Singh of Mewar, in 1676 AD. This is a large water-body of conserved fresh-water, created,
in part, through damming the waters of a small rivulet, and augmented by the excavation of a large tract in which rain-water could be collected. Ana Sagar Lake, Ajmer, Rajasthan, 12th
century Ghadsisar reservoir-lake, Jaisalmer in 1367 AD by Bhati ruler, Rawal Ghadsi are some of the most popular old lakes known among the various lakes of Udaipur city.
Source: Hooja Rima, 2010
Agriculture was practiced on a large scale, with extensive networks of
canals for irrigation (Box 4 and 5). Irrigation systems were based on formal and
informal rules laid down by traditional societies which helped conserve and
sustain water. Traditional systems of water storage – tank systems, numerous
types of wells, low cost water harvesting techniques lay a great stress on the
need for considering the elapsed acumens gained from past knowledge. The
reservoirs built in 3000 BC at Girnar, Bhojsagar, the artificial irrigation lake at
Madhya Pradesh constructed in the 11th century, an artificial lake fed by Kaveri
river indicate finer skills associated with water management practices in the past.
Temple tanks that dot the popular south Indian temples are to be found
exceptionally in good condition. In India (western part) since fifth to the
nineteenth centuries, water was collected and stored in stone cisterns; these
glorious structures are known as step wells or stepped ponds. They are
outstanding architectural structures; few are profound as nine stories with
intricate carvings, ornamented towers, and elaborate sculptures depicting the
local culture and environment. Over the past 500 years, step wells held a center-
stage for communities as sites for drinking, washing, bathing besides colorful
festivals and sacred rituals. Distinctive, often highly decorated communal Hindu
architectural structures, with origins in the seventh century in the semiarid
regions of Gujarat and Rajasthan, step wells reached their peak from 900 to
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
20
1300 C.E. as elaborate water buildings were invested with ritual and social
meanings. These water collection systems which were designed to preserve
monsoon rains, and modified by Muslims and Mughals in the mid-19th century,
were effectively shut down by the Britishers (Agarwal and Sunita, 1997).
For several thousands of years, Indians have recognized the importance
of groundwater development and utilization, as life was and is dependent on
agriculture and because many parts of North India used to experience dry
climatic conditions. In Bhagavad-Gita, Lord Krishna discusses the importance of
sinking wells for water as great work (yagna) and emphasizes on the role of
water in the evolution (Ramakrishnan, 2000). Information on infiltration can be
found in "Taitariya Samhita" and in "Mahabharata". The Vedas mention clearly
the use of water abstracted from wells. Three chapters of "Brihat Samhita" of
Varaha Mihira, of the 5th century AD, are fully devoted to meteorology and
climatology, while one chapter is fully dedicated to groundwater exploration,
exploitation and equipment. Physiographic features, termite mounds, soils, flora,
fauna, rocks and minerals, were used for detect groundwater. It is interesting to
note that the estimation of the depth of the water table was based on the
presence of termite mounds and certain trees near them (Shadananan Nair,
2003).
.
Box 4: Tank and Canal Irrigation Practices Practices like contour-bunding and local-level lift-irrigation schemes have used available water-resources
in ways suitable to the local terrain and economy. These include the khadin-based cultivation, tankas,
nadis etc of Rajasthan, bandharas and tals of Maharashtra, the bundhis common to Madhya Pradesh and Uttar Pradesh, and Bihar's ahars and pynes. These also include the kuhls known in Himachal Pradesh
and the kuhals of Jammu & Kashmir, the ponds used in the Kandi belt of Jammu, the eris of Tamil Nadu, surangams of Kerala, and the kattas of Karnataka, which are still in use today. Sringaverapura, Allahabad, - Series of tanks, 1st century BC - The Sringaverapura tank-complex
obtained water from the nearby river Ganga during the monsoon season, when the level of the river usually rose by about 7-8 metres. As a result, excess water used to spill over from the Ganga into an
adjoining stream. From this stream, a 11m wide and 5m deep canal carried the water further into the Sringaverapura tanks.
Hathigumpha inscriptions, dating back to the 2nd century BC contain descriptions of the major irrigation works of Kalinga, Orissa. Artificial reservoirs or tanks too were built for irrigation purposes
through damming smaller streams. A complex network of irrigation and water management systems
had been established by the Gond kingdom of central India together with the necessary social and
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
21
administrative systems needed to sustain them.
Various Sultans of the Delhi Sultanate, including Iltutmish, Alauddin Khilji, Ghiyas-ud-din Tughlaq and Feroz Shah Tughlaq built and repaired various tanks, water-collection systems, and canals etc.
during the 13th to 15th centuries.
Kalhan's 12th century text, the 'Rajatarangini' (composed around 1148-1150 AD), while chronicling the history of Kashmir, refers to a well-conceived and maintained irrigation system. 'Rajatarangini' also
provides information regarding various canals, irrigation channels, embankments, aqueducts, circular dykes, barrages, wells and waterwheels, and details of numerous hydraulic works executed during the
reigns of various rulers of Kashmir. In the 8th century AD, king Lalitaditya Muktapida of the Karkota dynasty, constructed a series of
arghat or waterwheels. These waterwheels were constructed to lift waters from the river Vitasta
(Jhelum), for their distribution to villages. In the desert areas of the Thar region, now belonging to the states of Rajasthan and Gujarat, tanks,
kunds, step-wells or baolis/ baoris, vavs, wells, ponds etc., were built. Besides these, specific indigenous water-harvesting and collection methods were developed / evolved in direct response to the
local geo-physical conditions. This led to the development and maintenance of systems like johadhs,
anicuts, check-dams, khadins, tankas, adlaz, jhalara, modhera, vapi, medhbandhi the virdas of the Kutch region, etc. Water-lifting devices like draw-wells, 'rahat' and 'dhekli' systems were developed too.
Adalaj Step Well, located in Gandhinagar district, Ahmedabad, built during the reign of Queen Rudabai, a muslim ruler in 1499. It is five storey step well directly reaching out to the water table
wherein it is exposed to the fresh water that varied across the seasons and rainfall patterns. It was also used as a resting place for pilgrims for hundreds of years. The opening in the ceilings above the landing
allows the light and air to enter the octagonal well. Direct sunlight does not touch the flight of steps
except for a brief time during noon. This step well is a spectacular example of Indo-Islamic architecture and design.
The southern part of India, under several dynasties such as the Chola, Pandya, Pallava, Chera, Vakataka, Kakatiya, etc. developed a vast network of tanks and canals, famed the world over, for
irrigating crops and enhancing agrarian production. Under the Vijayanagar kingdom, a mighty reservoir
was built using the labour of 20,000 men during the reign of king Krishna Deva Raya. In northeastern areas of the Sub-Continent, including the the foothills and lower slopes of the
Himalayas different local communities had devised indigenous methods of collecting and channeling rainwater towards meeting their agricultural and drinking water requirements.
Source: Hooja Rima, 2010
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adalaj_Stepwell
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
22
Box 5: The Sanchi Dams Project - Major Buddhist hilltop, UNESCO World Heritage site Sanchi, Central India. It is a very well preserved and most studied Buddhist site in India. The establishment of
Sanchi was closely tied to the spread of the Mauryan Empire and related processes of urbanisation,
the latter well-represented by the early historic city-site of Vidisha.
According to the edicts writing of Asoka; during the later 2nd century BCE and early 1st century CE a number of building works were taken up financed by the collective patronage of the
powerful families and guilds. The contribution of land and villages recorded in the inscriptions
during the Gupta and post-Gupta periods, show that the Buddhist sangha was involved in a sustainable exchange system with local agricultural communities. To maintain water levels in the
main reservoir, two smaller tanks at Karondih and Dargawan in the shorter valleys to the west had been designed as part of an upstream irrigation system.
Throughout the Sanchi area, similar dams can be found. All have earthen cores with stone facing, on the upstream side, with heights of 1 to 6 m, and lengths of 80 to 1400 m. The volume of
early reservoir ranges between 0.03 to 4.7 m3 x 106. At Sanchi built on sloping terrains, act as inundation tanks for upstream irrigation, while for downstream irrigation dams built across deeper
valleys in the eastern part. Devrajpur shows evidence of the latter category with spillways and clean gates.
Between 1998 and 2001 during a wide archaeological survey, dams spread across 750 km2 around Sanchi, were recorded four distant Buddhist sites recognized by Alexander Cunningham in
the 19th century which included Satdhara, Sonari, Morel Khurd and Andher. The aim was to place the monuments within their archaeological landscape, with religious changes taken place during
the late centuries BCE to other key processes such as urbanization, state-formation, and
agricultural innovation. About 35 Buddhist sites, 145 settlements, 17 irrigation works and numerous sculptures were recorded.
A study of surface residue, local present-day hydrology and ancient pollen sequences, has
led to many assumptions regarding the dams' chronology and functions, usage of crops, and their
relationship to the urban at Vidisha and the history of Buddhism at Sanchi and adjacent sites. A summary of the study observations is given here:
i) Following the chronology of the primary monument at Sanchi and adjacent Buddhist sites, it is
assumed that 3rd and 2nd centuries BCE the first dam was constructed.
ii) Dams were built to provide irrigation, principally for rice cultivation in view of the increased population.
iii) Their position within a broader archaeological landscape warrants their being viewed as part of a cultural package that had accompanied the spread of Buddhism, urbanization and the
development of centralized state polities during the late centuries BC; and
iv) Like the inter-site pattern in Sri Lanka, where the monastic landlordism is found attested from c. 2nd century BC onwards, the Sanchi dams were under a similar system of exchange between
Buddhist monks and local agricultural communities.
http://www.basas.org.uk/projects/sanchi.htm
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
23
1.6. Water Use and Management in Ancient Indian
Civilizations
Urban centres were usually planned near rivers or around the coastal
areas. The great and well planned cities had excellent infrastructure facilities
with arrangements made for public and private baths,
sewerage through underground drains built bricks precisely laid, and an efficient
water management system with numerous reservoirs and wells. Under the
remarkable drainage systems, drains from houses were connected to the larger
public drains.
The Indus Valley civilization, one of the earliest civilizations and the first
major settlements of the Mohenjo-Daro and Harappa civilizations, were found
along the Indus River and its tributary, the Ravi. The Indus Valley Civilization,
which flourished on the banks of the river Indus and across parts of the western
and northern India about 5,000 years ago, had one of the most intricate urban
water supply and sewage systems in the world. The towns were well acquainted
with hygiene and sanitation as evident from the covered drains along the streets
of the ruins at both Mohenjo-Daro and Harappa. One of the best known
examples of this is the 'Great Bath' at the site of Mohenjodaro. Explorations in the
recent decades have disclosed several sites along the dry bed of a huge river.
Evidences from the excavations at the Harappan Culture site of Dholavira,
in Gujarat, also indicate the existence of a complex system for collecting and
storing rainwater within the vicinity of several reservoirs, and in part within a
partially encircling moat that might have served as a supportive mechanism.
Dholavira lies in an area that presently receives less than 160 cm of rainfall
annually with a history of prolonged droughts.
The excavations at Inamgaon – a chalcolithic site in Maharashtra/ with
three successive cultures dating back to 1600 to c.700 BC – reveal the presence
of a stone rubble and a mud embankment and a channel suggesting that during
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
24
the c.1400-1000 BC period, artificial irrigation probably facilitated agriculture at
this site (Dhavalikar 1988).
For example, during the 4th century BC, Nanda dynasty kings (c 363-321
BC), built irrigation canals for carrying water from rivers to agricultural tracts.
Their successors, the Mauryan dynasty rulers (c.321-185), built many more
irrigation works for facilitating agriculture (besides providing wells for public use
alongside roads accompanied traveller's rest-houses).
In Naneghat, about 130 km off from Pune (in Western Ghats) the oldest
water harvesting systems has been found. There existed a number of rock-cut
tanks for supplying water to tradesmen who travelled through this ancient trade
route. In the form of rock-cut cisterns, ponds, tanks and wells every fort in the
area had water harvesting and storage systems which were in use every day.
In Western Rajasthan houses were constructed with a rooftop water
harvesting system. The rainwater from these rooftops was directed into
underground tanks. Even today in all the forts, palaces and dwelling houses of
the region these systems are found in use. For the maintenance of these
structures and for the transportation of water to distant places earthen pipes and
tunnels, (placed underground) were used. In places like Burhanpur (Madhya
Pradesh), Golconda (Andhra Pradesh), Bijapur in Karnataka, and Aurangabad in
Maharashtra these systems are found still functioning.
The reviews of traditional knowledge have highlighted several aspects of
significance that are relevant to the current context as well. Perceiving water as
a divine component has always played a major role as it imbibes a sense of
respect in the mindsets of people towards the resource. The tradition and
practices had inculcated a sense of discipline and values towards the resource
that a major source of life while consciously reminding them of the need for
protecting the resource for future sustenance. Besides this, the judicious use of
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
25
the resource is obviously seen in the technological advancements made for
sustainable use. An in-depth knowledge and understanding of water resources
are visible in the varied documentations. In brief, a holistic approach towards
the management of water resources was evidently followed.
1.7. Water Management during various dynasties’ rule (Mauryans, Satavahanas, Guptas, Pallavas, Cholas and Mughals)
The Mauryan Empire’s success is also seen in terms of its extensive
development of water resources through the construction of several dams for
irrigation. Kautilya’s Arthashastra gives a good account of water management
practices in purview of levying taxes from cultivators which was based on the
type of irrigation. The tax levied varied across sources was 25 per cent of the
produce in respect of water drawn from natural resources, 20 per cent of tax for
water drawn manually and 25 per cent of tax for water drawn with the help of
bullocks and 33 per cent of tax for water diverted through channels. There were
special benefits given when cultivators intended to build or improve irrigation
facilities subject to certain specifications viz, 5 years for new tanks and bunds, 4
years for renovation of old constructions and 3 years for de-weeding. Privately
owned water bodies like reservoirs, and tanks were common with the owners
being free to sell or lease them out. They were also entitled to sell water in
exchange for produce. These water bodies were maintained by the villagers in
the absence of the owner. Violators were fined in cases like damage caused to
neighbour’s fields through water over flows, damage to gardens, parks, bunds
etc, sharing issues when high reach tank owners prevented low reach tank
owners from filling water, failure to maintain water bodies, misusing water
access, encroachment, misuse of water bodies meant for common purposes and
so on.
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
26
Brick and ring wells were introduced during 1st century BC to 2nd century
BC by the Satavahanas. Similarly, lake and well irrigation was developed during
the Pandya, Cehra and Chola dynasties (1st to 3rd century AD). During the Gupta
period a lot of water resource development took place (300-500 AD) and during
the Pallava period, (7th century AD) irrigation system was intensified and the
during Chola dynasty tank systems were developed, specifically tank cascades.
The Rajput dynasty (1000-1200 AD) largely progressed through irrigation works
in North India. During the medieval period, Mohammend bin Tughlaq (1325-
1351 AD) promoted rain water harvesting systems while Shahjahan was known
for the construction of canals.
The canals built during the Vijayanagar Empire (1336-1546 AD) are in use
even to this day and during the Bahamani kingdom, (1388-1422 AD) canal
irrigation was first introduced (see Box 6).
Box 6 : Vijayanagar System of Canals and Tanks Tungabhadra river which was the lifeline of the Vijayanagar kingdom paved the way for the construction of several canals involving colossal engineering skills. These canals fed cultivated areas within and beyond the city and had advanced features. A majority of the population depended on agriculture; plantations of coconut, areca and betel were also common. The major canals constructed by the Vijayanagar kings include the Raya Canal (King’s canal), Basavanna Canal (Nandi or Bull Canal), Turthu Canal (Fast Canal), Anegundi Canal and the Kamalapura Water Tank. Although most of the canals are old and need further maintenance, they are still in use.
Name Canal Length in kms Total area irrigated (in Ha)
Raya Canal 27.20 2,226.70
Basavanna Canal 16.00 1,240.48
Kalaghatta 7.200 237.25
Turtha 18.00 931.58
Anegundi 37.00 NA
The urban areas were provided water from private and community tanks. Large tanks such as Bukkasamudram, Vyasasamudram, Krishnarayasagara, Sadashivasagara, Maiviru Magada, Kamalapurasagara, Rayavakaluve, Basavanakaluve were constructed. The royal palaces enjoyed the most sophisticated water distribution and recirculation systems. Water pipes were sealed with brick and lime plaster. Within the royal area, a number of stone aqueducts connecting around 20 wells and ponds are to be seen indicating the engineering skills. The giant aqueduct on the north bank of Tungabhadra at Virupapur Gadde is an outstanding example. Water conservation and recirculation were given prominence.
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
27
Source: http://waterresources.kar.nic.in/irri_in_kar.htm
There were several indigenous architectural approaches to maintain natural
cooling in palaces using water, made it very comfortable (Table 3).
Table 3: Devises used in Palaces
Palaces of the Mughals, Rajputs,
and other ruling dynasties
Systems of copper pipes carrying water for cooling terrace
pavilions, channels flowing through royal chambers, fountains and water-gardens, and under-water collection tanks were
extensively designed.
Amber Fort, Jaipur, Rajasthan and other medieval fortresses of
South Asia
There are an ascending chain of water-lifting devices dating back to the 16th century. These served to lift water from a
reservoir at the base of the fort to its very peak, to the upper-most chambers of the hilltop palaces.
Deegh palace, Bharatpur Entire palace is surrounded by water for maintaining coolness
Mauryan dynasty Kautilya’s ‘Arthashastra’ makes a reference to the cooling
device that was manually operated during the 400 BC.
Source: Hooja Rima, 2010
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
28
Section 2: Current Status of Water Supply
India’s average annual surface run-off generated by rainfall and snowmelt
is estimated at 1869 billion cubic meter (BCM). It is also estimated that only 690
BCM (37%) of the surface water resources can be mobilised as around 90 per
cent of the annual flow of the Himalayan rivers transpire in a brief period of four
months and the potential to capture such resources is complex, given the limited
and suitable reservoir sites. The average annual rainfall in India amounts to
about 1170 mm with vast variation in rainfall over time and space. Most of the
rainfall occurs in the monsoon season (June to September) necessitating the
maximum possible utilisation of surface runoff. Regional variations remain
extreme ranging from a low value of 100 mm in Western Rajasthan to over
11000 mm in Meghalaya in North Eastern India (see Table 4).
Table 4: Land and Water Resources of India
Land and Water Resources Details
Geographical area 329 million ha
Flood Prone Area 40 million ha
Ultimate Irrigation Potential 140 million ha
Total Cultivable Land Area 184 million ha
Natural runoff (surface and Ground water) 1869 cubic km
Estimated utilisable surface water potential 690 cubic km
Ground water resource 432 cubic km
Available ground water resource for irrigation 361 cubic km
Net Utilisable Ground water resource for irrigation 325 cubic km Source: Water Resources India, National Institute of Hydrology website
India’s rechargeable annual ground water potential has been assessed at around
431 BCM in aggregate terms with 30 per cent of the ground water potential
being tapped for irrigation and domestic uses. The regional situation varies with
large parts of the country overexploiting the water resources beyond their
carrying capacity of their dynamic recharge. Depleting ground water tables are
more visibly prominent in Rajasthan, Gujarat and most of Western Uttar Pradesh
and all the Deccan States.
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
29
Over time, the usage of both surface and ground water resources has assumed
alarming proportions resulting in water scarcity and limited development options.
India’s situation with respect to its water resources has become increasingly
precarious in view of their over exploitation coupled with the increasing
competing water demands across and within sectors. Total annual demand for
water estimated from 552 BCM in 1997 to 1050 by 2025. The population
explosion has added immensely to the problem of water scarcity as the
difference in demand to the projections made for 2025 amounts to 30% of the
availability levels made compared to time of India’s independence. (per capita
availability over 5000 cubic meter per year for 400 million population; 200 cubic
meter per year with 1 billion population in 2000; and with 1500 cubic meter per
year by 2025).
Although the water availability index includes only surface water, ground
water is an important source of water availability which supplies 80 per cent of
water for domestic use in rural areas and about 50 per cent of water for urban
and industrial use. Ground water forms a significant percentage of water supply
for irrigation and as well. There are more than 17,000 energized wells across
the country supplying more than 50 per cent of irrigated area.
Providing safe and quality drinking water has been a challenge with a
growing demand for water due to increasing urbanization, economic
development and an improvement in living standards. The situation is more
alarming in rural areas, where half of the population does not have a ready
access to proper sanitation and water supply services. Water supply and
sanitation sectors in India have been suffering from inadequate levels of service,
increasing demand-supply gaps, deteriorating financial and technical
performance. The availability of clean water has become a scarce good. Water,
which was once considered a public good, is now considered a priced good.
There are limitations to capacities in terms of increasing water supply in relation
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
30
to the projected rise in water demand. The competing demands for water are
also continuously altering the opportunity cost of water across different sectors.
Legal rights with respect to using water (ground) are still not clear, while
dealing with related issues appears ambiguous while fresh water resources are
shrinking; the issues in management of water have become complex and
contextual to a large extent. The adverse health impacts, as a result of poor
access to clean water and poor sanitation facilities have been alarming.
Accessibility to safe drinking water is a problem that varies across regions while
causing inequity and conflicts between stakeholders. Although resource
depletion is obvious, efforts taken towards an efficient use reuse are not able to
meet the expected requirements. Technical constraints add to the problem while
the critical crisis in respect of finance has manifested.
Misuse and encroachment of natural water bodies is a area of concern.
Pollution is causing contamination problems leading to environmental and health
risks. Lack of awareness regarding the seriousness of the crisis among the
public has led to wastage and inefficient usage of water. Lack of trained
personnel for scientific planning and utilization of modern techniques have
contributed to further constraints with respect to efficient water management.
Besides, Climate change effects could add to sustainability issues as water
related disasters, with an increase in the frequency of floods and droughts, can
result in the imbalance use of water resources. It is also expected that Climate
change would further increase sea levels leading to salinity ingress in ground
water aquifers/surface waters besides causing increased floods in coastal areas.
Investments in water can be an engine for accelerating economic growth,
sustainable development, improved health and finally reduction of poverty. In
view of these facts, the Millennium Development Goal (MDG) was to "Halve, by
2015, the proportion of people without sustainable access to safe drinking water
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
31
and sanitation". In the context of India, the government has committed itself to
meeting the MDGs. Lately, the focus has been on using resources effectively
and efficiently, while making way for transparency. It has been argued that
there is a need for critical sector reforms. Since independence, the major sources
of investment have been government agencies (Central, State and local
governments), and donor agencies. Initially, more funds were provided for
urban water supply, but since 1980s, funds for rural water and sanitation are
earmarked largely because of the focus on the "International Decade for Water
Supply and Sanitation”.
Water being a state subject, the role of the Central government is limited
to special schemes, hence, there is a huge financial pressure on the State
government. The Government has been addressing this as a priority issue since
the beginning of the of first five-year plan. Although there have been constraints,
the State government still provides increasing budgetary allocations to the water
supply and sanitation sectors every year. However, the cost recovery and
revenue generation have remained inconsistent in relation to the government
expenditure and investment, while the financial returns from the sector are too
meagre to ensure sustainability.
2.1. Key Issues
The issues pertaining to water management are dealt in further depth in
this section. The first section described at length on the traditional ways of water
management in India, however this section will mainly draw from Karnataka’s
experiences as water is a state subject, besides, challenges encountered and
approaches adopted vary across states. Hence, Karnataka is taken as an
illustration to provide a better picture on the water challenges at the state level.
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
32
2.1.1. Dependency on Groundwater - Depletion Evident
In view of the failure of municipal corporations to supply adequate volume
of water, the dependency on ground water is increasing. Groundwater serves 85
per cent of the rural population’s drinking water requirements and nearly half of
the urban and industrial requirements. For instance, in Karnataka, of the 208
Urban Local Bodies (ULB), 47 are dependent on ground water sources. The
private investment on bore wells has increased tremendously with new upcoming
urban areas. For instance, the dependency on groundwater in Dharwad amounts
to 30 per cent, Hubli 51 per cent, Belgaum 37 per cent, Bangalore 45 per cent
and Kolar depends entirely on ground water (Raju K.V. et.al, 2007). With an
intense dependency on groundwater, the sources are declining very fast in the
state with 72 taluks considered critical due to over exploitation. Owing to over
exploitation of groundwater, a number of dug wells have dried up resulting in
economic losses to farmers. Even bore wells drilled up to 1000 feet have dried
up in the dry areas. On the other hand, the geologists of the Department of
Mines and Geology observe concluded that this has led to the scarcity of drinking
water, increased unit cost of wells, increased energy consumption, a drop in the
efficiency of pumps while at the same time productive lands have become fallow
(Reddy et.al, 2000).
A number of complex legal issues are involved with regard to the
integrated development and utilisation of and ground water, water rights and
people’s participation are considered. All ground water coming under private
property is fully under the control of the land owners. Inadequate regulatory
restrictions on the exercise of private property rights in respect of ground water
have resulted in excessive withdrawals in many areas.
2.1.2. Declining Traditional Sources The traditional sources of water include open dug wells, step wells, tanks,
ponds, lakes and other sources. In fact, Karnataka has been in the forefront in
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
33
respect of traditional water harvesting structures with about 40,000 such
structures existing even to this day (Agarwal and Sunita, 1997). However, these
traditional water sources have declined over the years due to a to decline in the
social values attached, inefficiency of the government in tank management,
financial crunch, poor accountability, political interference, increased access to
alternative source of water, changed user expectations from the tanks owing to a
shift in emphasis on food production, the state’s emphasis on major and minor
irrigation and so on (Raju K V et.al, 2003). The traditional sources are
significantly concentrated in the western ghats and hilly areas, while in the plain
areas, the traditional water sources have dried up due to less rainfall and an over
extraction of ground water for agriculture and industrial uses. Further, the
traditional sources, such as tanks and ponds have gradually got filled with silt,
thus affecting the storage capacity of these sources, which in turn indirectly
affects ground water levels. A ISEC study on Rural Water Supply (Raju, et.al,
2003) highlights the present status of traditional sources, in that traditional
sources have either dried up completely or have been neglected mainly because
piped water supply has taken over their place. Similarly, negligence of tanks has
led to a poor recharging of ground water.
2.1.3. Inadequate and Unreliable Water Supply
An inadequate water supply service prevails in both rural and urban areas.
Surface water supply has been poorly managed due to various inefficiencies in
terms of supply duration, quantity supplied and water demand pressure. For
instance, in Karnataka, according to the Karnataka Urban Water Supply and
Drainage Board, the municipal corporations are found unable to provide the
recommended norm of 135 LPCD as prescribed in the state water policy with
about 77 per cent of 208 ULBs (i.e. 161 ULBs) accounting for an inadequate
water supply. The per capita of water supply in Bangalore city comes to about
115 LPCD, which is less than the norm of 150 - 200 LPCD, recommended by
Central Public Health and Environmental Engineering Organization (CPHEEO).
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
34
Apart from covering habitations for supply of an adequate quantity of drinking
water, it is essential to see whether the stipulated norm of adequacy has been
compiled with or not; and also whether the water supply schemes initiated so far
are functioning properly or not. Generally, the claim of having covered the
habitations with respect to an adequate quantity of water supply appears to
relate to the potential distribution created under various water supply schemes
rather than the actual supply service provided to the villagers. The physical
distance involved in fetching the drinking water from far off sources in the rural
areas is another issue that needs a serious attention as sources situated far off
consumes a larger share of the productive time of households, resulting in a loss
of productivity, besides being a further burden on the part of women and girl
children.
2.1.4. Booming Water Markets
In view of the failure of water supply agencies in providing adequate and
safe drinking water, water markets have flourished. Packaged drinking water
produced by using high-tech water purifiers is assumed to be a pure source of
drinking water. In India, with an increasing demand for clean drinking water, the
numbers of bottled water manufacturers has increased. The bottled water
industry is estimated to be a gigantic Rs 1,000 crore business with a growth rate
of 40-50 per cent annually. The water quality standards maintained by the
packaged drinking water companies is another issue that needs further probing.
The mushrooming of illegal companies is becoming increasingly a major concern.
Similarly private water tankers supply water to consumers without adhering to
regulations regarding quality control. In Bangalore there are around 120 water
tanker companies with 3500 tankers. In addition, a large number of bore well
drillers work informally. None of the bore well drilling companies is found
accountable to the number of bore wells to be drilled, the extent of drilling, rules
or regulations to be followed in the process (Raju et.al, 2007). Based on various
parameters, a rough estimate arrived at in respect of Bagepalli taluk, Kolar
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
35
district, amounts to Rs.120.25 million per year just for drilling bore Wells (Raju,
et.al, 2005). However, ‘The Karnataka Groundwater (Regulation and Control of
Development and Management) bill 2011 brings new hope with constitution of
the Karnataka Groundwater Authority and also mandates that permission has to
be taken from the authority for drilling a borewell in private properties.
2.1.5. Inefficient use – increase in Non revenue water
Lacunae associated with operation, maintenance and poor distribution
systems limit the availability of safe drinking water. Non revenue water (NRW)
is water that is ‘lost’ before it reaches the customer. Losses can be real losses
(leaks,) or apparent losses (theft or metering inaccuracies). NRW although is
referred to as Unaccounted for water many a times, are not identical as revenue
water includes authorized unbilled consumption (for instance – firefighting, use
in religious institutions) but not included in Unaccounted for water. Although
accurate data is not available on non-revenue water, the estimates vary between
30-70 per cent in respect of most Urban Local Bodies (ULBs). The implications
of increased UFW are the reduced per capita availability of water, an increase in
supply cost, a decrease in revenue and a relatively low efficiency of service. For
instance, the UFW are estimated at 40 per cent in Hubli-Dharwad and Belgaum.
In Bangalore, a large proportion of piped water is lost in transmission, mainly
due to leakage across the network of pipes, from distribution mains, service
pipes to stand posts (EMPRI, 2008). Of the total gross supply of 1,059 Million
Liters’ per Day (MLD), sourced primarily from Cauvery, only 550 MLD is billed
while 508 MLD remains unaccounted for amounting to 48% of loss, 4th highest in
India. The unaccounted for water has increased from 16 per cent to 48 per cent
between 1990 to 2009 even though the supply has increased from 375 MLD to
1,059 MLD indicating the per capita availability for domestic use at just 75 LPCD
which is half of the (World Health Organization) WHO stipulated requirement of
150 liters per capita per day (LPCD). Like Bangalore Water Supply and
Sewerage Board, water losses in other cities throughout Karnataka range
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
36
between 35-40% indicating the gravity of the situation. With respect to
irrigation, poor water use efficiency is more visible. Distribution and conveyance
losses are huge. The violations in respect of cropping patterns also lead to an
over exploitation of ground water resource (Raju K.V, 2004).
2.1.6. Quality Degradation
Although India has perhaps the best environmental regulations pollution
thrives and environmental degradation continues. Several reasons have been
attributed to the present scenario. The principal sources of pollution include
agricultural activities, industrial effluents, urban settlements, mining activities
and over exploitation of ground water. It is a well-known fact that nearly 80
per cent of the population is dependent on agriculture for livelihoods. An
increased fertilizer and pesticide usage has resulted in high levels of water
contamination. Besides, runoffs from agricultural fields have resulted in water
logging and salinization problems affecting irrigated areas and water quality.
Industries are one of the major sources of water pollution. One of the important
indicators of water quality is the impact on fish stock and other aquatic forms of
life. Fish kills are a serious issue resulting from pollution, particularly industrial
pollution. The issue of water quality and the availability of fish have assumed
greater significance as they are directly related to the livelihoods. River quality
faces a major threat by some groups of people who illegally blast dynamite
affecting water quality and species (Raju K.V, 2007). Urban Settlements add to
pollution as Urban Local Bodies are not completely equipped with proper
infrastructure to manage underground drainage system and treatment facilities
for collecting and treating the municipal sewage. The lack of Sewage Treatment
Plants in urban areas pollutes rivers, agricultural fields, open tanks and low lying
areas. Besides, the newer forms of pollution that have evolved with practices like
immersion of idols of Ganesha and Durga during festivals have added to
contamination of water sources. Traditionally, these idols were made of clay
which was not harmful to the environment. Currently, these idols are replaced
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
37
by the materials used by Plaster of Paris and chemical dyes. The impacts on
flora, fauna and health of the people are serious. Heavy metals like lead and
chrome get assimilated in the water and affect the heart, kidneys, liver and the
central nervous system.
Ground water contamination is a matter of serious concern. The seepage
of domestic, industrial sewage, agricultural runoffs and over exploitation
contaminates ground water quality. The Department of Mines and Geology
monitor ground water quality regularly in the state. Based on the extent of
contamination, the areas are classified into four categories – most critical,
critical, less critical and non-critically affected. In most of the cities, ground
water is not tested for its quality or one time testing is practiced. There have
been no regularized processes in place for testing water quality in urban areas.
For instance, in Kolar, the ground water quality is critical with 97 per cent being
non potable while in Dharwad, 45 per cent is non-potable; similarly in Hubli 42
percent is non-potable and in Belgaum 22 per cent is non-potable (ISEC Report,
2006). The North of Bangalore indicates high levels of nitrate contamination.
2.1.7. Financial Issues
Financial issues in the form cost and time overruns have become endemic
and chronic while at the same time spill-over costs are increasing with every
plan. Financial returns are negligible because of a highly subsidized pricing of
water and substandard modernization. The returns are not sufficient to cover
costs of operation and maintenance. With an increased expenditure for
maintaining the system with worn out networks, water management remains a
problem. Water is under priced, added to that a poor collection of charges add
on. The funding pattern for the water supply schemes and also the minimum
water tariff levied are uniform throughout Karnataka, though the amount
remitted across urban local bodies – Town Municipal Council, Taluk Panchayat,
City Municipal Council and Corporations varies. The tariff charges are fixed
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
38
between Rs. 40 to Rs. 45 as a flat charge in many towns. In the Corporations,
they charge Rs. 3 per kilolitre while Rs. 2.50 in the City Municipal Corporations
(Varghese and Miglani, 2008). Resistance for increasing the tariff rates and poor
institutional arrangements in cost recovery are serious issues.
2.1.8. Technical Issues
Urban areas face a poor status of pipeline networks causing distributional
problems and equity issues. Huge investments have been made to draw surface
water from long distances though leakages lead to huge quantities of wastage.
Meters are installed but not maintained properly; hence, charging is an issue.
Rural areas also face operation and maintenance problems reducing the
efficiency of quality service. Technical interventions are introduced without
proper monitoring and appropriateness which can have negative implications.
For instance, rainwater harvesting is made compulsory in Bangalore without
studying groundwater aquifer mapping with the result that rainwater harvested
and sewage are getting mixed up in some parts of the city. Besides, violations of
the process of installing structures have accentuated the problem. In brief, it is
important not to implement a blanket policy across the issues but have to be
studied in depth and appropriate policies administered.
2.1.9. Data Inadequacies and Discrepancies
Accessing relevant State-level data regarding various components is a
major issue. Where some figures are available, they are not properly
disaggregated or classified. Adequate mechanisms for the collection and
compilation of data on a regular basis are not put in place in many states.
Moreover, information related to core functions provided by the State finance
commission and the state government concerned varies by a wide margin in
many States. Similarly, near to accurate data on irrigation potential created and
utilized is not available. Discrepancies reported are attributed to multiple
agencies collecting data with varied methodologies leading to double counting
errors as adequate checks are not carried out.
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
39
Section 3: Future Perspectives
An overview of the water management scenario indicates marked changes
in the contexts and the approaches towards water management over time and
space. The previous sections have detailed out two wide-ranging scenarios – (i)
the ways in which water has been perceived in ancient scriptures and traditional
practices in addition to water management practices prevalent in the ancient
times. The ancient scriptures and traditional practices and during the reign of
various dynasties provide a good scenario of water resources management.
(ii) Changes in water management in the current context highlighting several
issues that have evolved in due course of time with illustration from Karnataka.
One of the major causes seen is the reversal of environmental quality supply-
demand relationships in just a few years. This is mainly due to economic growth
accompanied by population increases, over-exploitation and mismanagement of
natural resources, and urbanization and its cumulative effects are resulting in
decreasing the available supply of clean water. The current scenario represents a
crisis situation which needs to be addressed on a priority basis.
In the current context, a review of the government’s efforts in
implementing various programmes, policies adopted has shown inadequate
progress in providing sufficient quantity of potable water to all persons. The
available literature indicates that various initiatives/approaches have shown signs
of improvement, but the results have not been satisfactory. As indicated earlier,
it is in this context that a historical review of ‘water resource management’ has
been taken up with a view to drawing some illustrations from the past and its
relevance for future water management options. Besides, the current options
and suggestions have also been added to this section as a way forward.
Strengthening Community Involvement and Awareness – Community
involvement in water resource management should be further strengthened for
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
40
sustainable management of water resources. Institutional mechanisms for
delegating responsibilities and powers to the various water management bodies
like the Water Users Associations, Village Water Supply and Sanitation
Committees would help a proper management of resources. Water has to be
charged for certain uses and stakeholders so as to ensure conservation and
efficiency.
Key lessons can be drawn from the traditional practices where there are
several pointers for involving people in water management. A blend of
traditional approaches with a combination of current technological means can
bring about good results. Awareness Creation through mass media
communication on a periodic basis would aid in the dissemination of water
related information. Targeted information regarding facts and figures on the
water situation and its implications could be highlighted through organizing
innovative and effective means of communication. Religious and educational
institutions could be involved in promoting awareness regarding water use and
conservation. Clues can be taken from water festivals and rituals and altered to
suit present conditions in disseminating the significance of water. Similarly, the
approaches about traditional approaches are detailed out for inclusion.
Instilling Right Behaviour Patterns – There are several indicators from the
past that focused on the behavior patterns of the society during the ancient
times. It can be observed that the admiration and veneration aided in terms of
conservation, use, and protection of water resources as these practices were
infused as behavior patterns in society. The respect for water through worship,
prayers and religious beliefs helped instill a sense of importance and value to
ensure a proper use of water. This respect for water also worked as a means
against pollution.
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
41
Capturing the psyche of people to instill change – The masses were and are ‘god
fearing’ in general. This ‘nature’ of people was used for creating a sense of
moral responsibility among the general populace to protect the environment
besides the moral standards of the society as well. For instance, there are
several hymns that point to the fact that, one should be engaged in good deeds
in order to enjoy the benefits of nature else they would face the wrath of nature
in the form of floods and droughts. An elegant hymn in the “Rudra” (from
Yajurveda) says: Namoe Rudrebhyaha yE Pruthivyaam yE antarikshe, ye Divi
Yeshaam annam vaatoe varsham ishavaha tebhyaha!) which explains thus,
There are some Gods called Rudras. Some of them exist on earth, some in skies,
and some in heavens. All of them punish sinners on earth. The arrows they use
to punish the sinners are food (deprivation of annam causes hunger), air (winds,
Vaata+Aavaranam=Vaataavaranam indicating weather), and rains (low or excess
varsham causing droughts or floods). Ishu means arrow. The verse further states
that we salute all of them in all directions (east, south etc.) with our two hands
folded for protecting us (Rajagopala Aiyar, 1985).
Creating Awareness through practice – Rituals and practices were one
important means of communicating to the people the importance of protecting
all water resources. As mentioned earlier, there are several rituals and practices
that highlight the significance of water for purification of the body and soul.
Water festivals acted as mass means of communicating and connecting to the
cosmic forces.
Educating masses through Simple and Localized Practices – Simple
sayings, Proverbs related to water served as powerful means of simple but
effective means of educating the masses. These sayings and proverbs as words
of wisdom passed on through generations acted as informal checks in protecting
water and other natural resources. Community participation in water
management was made part of the system that helped protect water resources
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
42
and associated development. Technically proven methods of water management
remain functional even to this day. Localized practices in the form of ‘shramadan’
where people contribute in terms of labour to managing natural resources was a
popular way of protecting natural resources and promoting community
participation and a sense of belonging. Local technologies were evolved in
relevance to the context, hence were tailor made to the situation. Besides these,
several other technologies, simple and effective, were shared with and passed on
to the neighbouring communities. This was widely practiced while managing
‘Tanks’ in rural areas. Similarly, the medicinal uses of water were popularized
through hymns and traditional informal practices. All these aided in the
sustainable management of water resources. Further, wisdom regarding water
management was made an integral part of their culture and community
responsibility.
Recognition and endorsing benevolence – It was a common practice
among the wealthy to construct water bodies and was seen as a benevolent act
that a man could do to society which contributed to the overall community
welfare. These are endorsed in the popular ‘Tirukurals’ that, ‘The wealth of that
man of eminent knowledge who desires to exercise the benevolence approved of
by the world, is like the full waters of a city-tank. The wealth that wise and kind
do make is like water that fills a lake’. There were several such acts which were
popularized and implemented out of good will.
All these indicate a holistic understanding and perspectives in managing
water resources which made implementation simple. Even in the current
context, water resources management need to be addressed in a holistic
perspective and implemented in an integrated way considering various and
differing socio-economic and environmental requirements. To ensure equity,
priorities have to be set with informed decision making. Given the current
challenges, besides drawing lessons from the traditional methods, there are
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
43
other approaches which are relevant to address the issue of sustainable water
management.
Integrated Water Resource Management Approach - Water
management should be based on hydrological boundaries considering river basin
as a unit and addressed in an integrated water resources management
perspective. Basin authorities have to be established for managing and
regulating water resources. Preservation and protection of all water bodies
under a basin should be carried out in a planned and holistic way.
Environmental concerns should be given a high priority including all aquatic
species. River basin authorities should also be responsible for collecting data
and information on a regular basis with respect to the basin from a social,
economic and environmental point of view. Regarding sharing and management
of waters of international rivers should be negotiated in consultative association
with riparian States while focusing on national interests besides establishing
adequate institutional arrangements at the Center for implementing national and
international agreements respectively.
Addressing Ground Water Issues - Ground water aquifers have to be
mapped which determine the status and quality of ground water besides aiding
in taking appropriate decisions on water conservation strategies at appropriate
locations. Watershed development and rain water harvesting initiatives have to
be adopted in a comprehensive way. Inter-basin transfers of flood waters aid in
recharging depleting ground waters in water stressed areas. Legal dimensions of
ground water management need further streamlining for effective
implementation.
Land and Water Use Linkages - Land utilization and water use are
interlinked; hence, appropriate measures should be taken to evolve mechanisms
to understand water demands across/within sectors and ensure sustainable
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
44
actions in land and water use management. Loss of land during erosion should
be avoided to prevent permanent loss and damage while supportive studies on
geo morphology and nutrient loss should be taken up. Besides, encroachments
should be curtailed effectively as most of the water bodies are subject to misuse.
Tackling Water Quality - Water quality in both urban and rural areas is an
issue that needs an urgent intervention. Efforts should be taken to ensure
quality through preventing pollution and using technological interventions at
various levels and types to provide quality water. Water quality is to be
protected by penalizing polluters appropriately. Strengthening of the processes
within the existing systems through accountability and transparency in place is
called for. Traditional methods of tackling the water quality issue can be
popularized as they are proven simple and effective practices that could be cost
effective and sustainable as well.
Improving Water Use Efficiency – Demand-supply management
approach is replaced by the supply driven management, but needs further
strengthening in the processes adopted to improve water use efficiency. Water
resources need to be assessed and accounted at periodic intervals for taking
appropriate decisions on usage besides coming up with innovative mechanisms
for making an efficient use of water. Contexts and issues are different in respect
of both rural and urban areas; however, efforts should be taken towards
removing disparities between the stipulations of water supply. Public–Private
partnership of water management may work out to be more feasible given the
vastness of interventions required and several success stories have proven.
Water-energy nexus needs to be addressed with appropriate measures to avoid
misuse and wasteful use of water.
Financing Water Management - Financial management should be
holistic from the view point of recovery of capital and operation and maintenance
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
45
costs to ensure proper maintenance and sustainability of projects. Monitoring
should be carried out at varied levels to avoid time and cost over-runs. Efforts
should be taken to ensure that there is no gap between the potential created
and the actual potential utilized. Water is to be priced appropriately keeping
varied needs and contexts in view. Institutional mechanisms have to be
developed for fixing water charges by involving stakeholders and ensuring that
water is not underpriced but at the same time should meet the requirements of
all.
Emphasis on appropriate Technical interventions – There is large
scope for reviving traditional practices in sustaining the simple technical
approaches that were followed. For instance, Reviving Tank Management and
involving communities has been initiated at large; similar methods can be
adopted in other sectors as well. Technical interventions for water saving and
efficient uses across sectors have to be encouraged. Unaccounted for water
should be reduced largely in rural areas and more specifically in urban areas.
Encouragement should be given for taking up innovative practices in
conservation, utilization and management of water so as to make it context
specific. Reuse and recycled water should be appropriately streamlined for users
to access and adopted extensively. Incentives and disincentives should be
provided for appropriately using water and for violations, if any respectively.
Subsidies and incentives should be provided and made feasible for adopting
reuse and recycling mechanisms.
Dealing with Climate Change - Climate change is likely to create
extreme variations affecting livelihoods, health and infrastructure. Micro level
mitigation and coping mechanisms involving community should be promoted.
Identification, resettlement and rehabilitation issues should be recognised and
beneficiaries should be given proper protection and benefits so as to help them
abide by the resettlement and rehabilitation policy.
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
46
Streamlining Data Insufficiencies and Inconsistencies - It would be
important to create a vigorous data collection mechanism that will ensure
accuracy of data. An accurate data base and information are important for
informed decision making. It is important that Hydrological Data collection and
compilation are done by a single agency with a ready access made available.
Common processes, procedures and formats for establishing a good data base
are also important.
Establishing Institutional Mechanisms – A Water Regulatory
Authority should be established at the state level to oversee all aspects of water
management – planning, monitoring, regulating and reviewing performance. A
separate wing for addressing conflicts and conflict resolution mechanisms at the
state and national levels should be established. Although Water is a state
subject, it is important to frame a policy at the National level with a legal
framework which the states adhere to. A newly formulated National Water Policy
2012 is being debated now at present throughout the country. Research and
Training need to be conducted periodically and in innovative ways for addressing
issues. Appropriate funding to respective states should be provided for
understanding the traditional ways of management and also international
approaches need to be followed for implementing the best of both the
approaches. Regular Training programmes are to be formulated and promoted
across various levels.
Concluding Remarks
It is important to understand that ‘water’ was not a scarce resource in the
ancient times as compared to the scarcity challenges that we face in the current
context. This makes it all the more relevant to use water prudently and follow a
holistic approach towards water management as stressed by the water experts
based on studies that have captured various water scenarios. Besides other
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
47
challenges, one of the crucial challenges has been the ‘implementation’, given
the conflicting interventions and situations. Best practices have strongly indicated
the role of community in its success but up scaling has remained an issue. In
this context, several lessons that are highlighted from the traditional perspectives
on water management could also be used in the current context. Similarly,
practices during the various dynasties also throw light on simple and popular
technologies besides community participation. In this context, it would be useful
to develop an overall framework for sustainable water management policies,
monitoring and progress tracking initiatives, detecting problems to suit customer
satisfaction and the user demand as well. These could be developed into various
focused frameworks in which water management issues could be perceived,
addressed and implemented in a phased manner. All through the development
of frameworks, it would be useful to understand the traditional and historical
perspectives on water management and lessons that could be drawn for its
appropriate use in the current context. Specific case studies could be taken up
which involve a thorough review of these traditional practices and lessons drawn
thereof. The response to these could be developed by involving a wide range of
stakeholders and establish demands from these various sets of stakeholders and
demonstrate the benefits in respect of an effective delivery. This would also aid
in designing pricing strategies, creating awareness and dissemination strategies,
exploring and understanding the existing processes and appropriate changes
thereof.
References Agrawal, Anil & Sunita Narain. 1997. Dying Wisdom: Rise, fall and potential of India's traditional water harvesting systems. (State of India's Environment – A Citizens' Report, No. 4), Centre for Science & Environment (CSE), New Delhi. Aiyar Rajagopla, 1985, Sri Rudram and Chamakam, Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan, Mumbai.
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
48
Dhavalikar M.K, 1988, Excavation: The Scientific Method and the Scientific Aids, Paper presented at the International Seminar on New Archeology, Indian Council of Historical Research, New Delhi, 14-16 Oct. Hooja Rima, Channelling Nature: Hydraulics, Traditional Knowledge Systems, and Water Resource Management in India – A Historical Perspective. http://www.infinityfoundation.com/hooja_book.htm Narayana NSS, 2006, ‘Issue of Sustainable Water-use and Land–use for India, Write up for the TIFAC (DST). Ministry of Water Resources, Government of India, Draft National Water Policy
2012. Nair Shadananan K, 2003, ‘Role of water in Development of Civilization in India – a review of ancient literature, traditional practices and beliefs’ ‘The Basis of Civilization – Water Science?, Proceedings of the UNI-SCO/1 AI IS/I WI IA symposium held in Rome, December 2003. Palaniswamy, K and K.W. Easter, K.W, 1983, ‘The Tanks of South India: A potential for Future Expansion in Irrigation, Economic Report, Department of Agriculture and Applied Economics, University of Minnisota. Palaniswami, K (1981), Irrigation Tank Rehabilitation’ The New Irrigation Era, Vol
XIX. Raju K.V, Hema Nagaraj, Manasi S, Deepa N, Latha N, 2007, Urban Water Supplies: Emerging Alternatives – A Case study of extent of Ground Water Use and its Implications in Hubli, Dhawad and Belgaum cities, Report, Centre for Ecological Economics and Natural Resources, ISEC, Bangalore. Raju K.V., A. Narayanamoorthy, Govind Gopakumar, H.K. Amarnath, State of the Indian Farmer, A Millennium Study, Water Resources, Vol 3., 2004, Academic Foundation. Raju K.V. 2002, ‘Participatory Irrigation Management in Andhra Pradesh: The Way Forward in Users in Water Management, eds, Rakesh Hooja, Ganesh Panagre and K.V. Raju (eds), New Delhi, Rawat Publications. Ramakrishnan M (2000), Sreemad Bhagavad Gita, Anandsramam, Kanjangad,
India
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
49
Sharma K.N, 2000, Environmental Protection and Water Reverence in Ancient Indian Culture Secretary, International Commission on Irrigation and Drainage (ICID) 48, Nyaya Marg, Chanakyapuri, New Delhi – 110 021, India as in http://www.scribd.com/doc/16813661/Environmental-Protection-and-Water-Reverence-in-Vedic-Culture-by-KN-Sharma-Secretary-ICID Sakthivadivel, R, 1982, ‘ A Pilot Study of Modernization of Tank Irrigation in Tamil Nadu’, Proceedings of a Workshop on Modernization of Tank Irrigation – Problems and Issues, Chennai, Centre for Water Resources. Sekhar Nagothu Udaya, K.V. Raju, S. Manasi, Latha N, Lenin Babu K, 2008,
Current Status and Future Possibilities to Improve the Livelihoods of Marginal Communities, STRIVER, Deviverable 9.5.
Vaidyanathan, A (ed), 2001, ‘Tanks of South India’, New Delhi: Centre for Science and Environment.
Websites referred http://www.Tamilcube.com, Thirukural, Thiru valluvar file:///C:/Documents20and20Settings/vkv/Desktop/water20in20vedas/VEDAS20III.htm http://in.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20100510061107AA2aVxr file:///C:/Documents20and20Settings/vkv/Desktop/water20in20vedas/The20Art20and20Science20of20Water20by20V.20K.20Joshi20(Bijji).htm file:///C:/Documents20and20Settings/vkv/Desktop/water20in20vedas/Blog20Action20Day20201020E2809320Water20E2809320Wisdom20from20Vedas20on20Saving20Water2020Hindu20Blog.htm file:///C:/Documents20and20Settings/vkv/Desktop/water20in20vedas/VEDAS20III.htm http://www.yousigma.com/religionandphilosophy/balakanda-chapter44.html on 24-11-11 http://in.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20100510061107AA2aVxr
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
50
file:///C:/Documents20and20Settings/vkv/Desktop/water20in20vedas/The20Art20and20Science20of20Water20by20V.20K.20Joshi20(Bijji).htm file:///C:/Documents20and20Settings/vkv/Desktop/water20in20vedas/Blog20Action20Day20201020E2809320Water20E2809320Wisdom20from20Vedas20on20Saving20Water2020Hindu20Blog.htm file:///C:/Documents20and20Settings/vkv/Desktop/water20in20vedas/VEDAS20III.htm http://www.amazon.com/Steps-Water-Ancient-Stepwells-India/dp/1568983247 http://www.culturalindia.net/indian-history/ancient-india/ancient-geography.html http://portal.worldwaterforum5.org/wwf5/enus/Discussions/Lists/Team20Discussion/DispForm.aspx?ID=15&RootFolder=2Fwwf52Fenus2FDiscussions2FLists2FTeam20Discussion2FAncient20Indian20Water20Culture Amarjiva Lochan, Landscape, Water and Religion in Ancient India, Scientific knowledge of water in ancient India as reflected in the Sanskrit literature, (Bangkok, Thailand, Sanskrit Studies Centre Silpakorn University). http://www.festivalsofindia.in/Gangasagar/ 5.11 p.m. 15-12-2011 http://portal.worldwaterforum5.org/wwf5/enus/Discussions/Lists/Team20Discussion/DispForm.aspx?ID=15&RootFolder=2Fwwf5%2Fenus2FDiscussions2FLists2FTeam20Discussion2FAncient20Indian20Water20Culture 10-12-11-7.22 pm http://indiaheritage.org/science/edviron.htm 10-12-11, 7.52 pm http://ccrtindia.gov.in/literaryarts.htm 10-12-11, 7.55 pm http://www.indology.bun.kyoto-u.ac.jp/14thWSC/programme/17/Lochan.pdf 10-12-11, 7.56 pm http://iahs.info/redbooks/a286/iahs_286_0160.pdf 10-12-11, 7.59 pm http://www.indiawaterportal.org/taxonomy/term/9622 10-12-11, 8.35 pm http://www.chillibreeze.com/articles/conserving-water.asp 10-12-11, 8.36 pm http://www.scribd.com/doc/16813661/Environmental-Protection-and-Water-Reverence-in-Vedic-Culture-by-KN-Sharma-Secretary-ICID 10-12-11, 8.39 pm
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
51
http://books.google.co.in/books?id=JI65MygMm0C&pg=PA161&lpg=PA161&dq=water+in+ancient+indian+literature&source=bl&ots=s7HsI4wNk9&sig=fyyTENKVoWGtI0p3Sk_i290t6E&hl=te&ei=TXbjTq3WO8bhrAfj9amVCA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=2&ved=0CCoQ6AEwATgK#v=onepage&q=water%20in%20ancient%20indian%20literature&f=false 10-12-11, 8.40 pm http://www.orientalthane.com/speeches/speech_5.htm 10-12-11, 8.44 pm http://www.indiawaterportal.org/taxonomy/term/413 10-12-11, 8.46 pm http://www.indiaheritage.org/science/edviron.htm http://www.hinduwisdom.info/Vimanas.htm 10-12-11, 8.48 pm http://books.google.co.in/books?id=ZKs1gBhJSWIC&pg=PA58&lpg=PA58&dq=water+in+ancient+indian+literature&source=bl&ots=KUug9SDt5N&sig=vp3GCjz79F25HUp7Vn_jlAbWphA&hl=te&ei=HfjTveaHoKqrAeyldWfCA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=6&ved=0CEwQ6AEwBTgU#v=onepage&q=water%20in%20ancient%20indian%20literature&f=false 10-12-11, 8.50 pm http://iahs.info/redbooks/a286/iahs_286_0160.pdf 10-12-11, 8.51 pm http://sarojbala.blogspot.com/ 10-12-11, 8.55 pm http://www.bellary.nic.in/HMP/REPORT%20PDFs/CHAPTER-3.pdf 6-2-12 21.42 http://hampi.in/aqueducts-and-canals 21.45 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Society_of_Vijayanagara_empire 21.55 http://megphed.gov.in/knowledge/RainwaterHarvest/Chap2.pdf http://www.climatechangecentre.net/pdf/WaterResources.pdf 20.6.12 9 pm http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pushkaram, 9-7-12 13.30 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-revenue_water http://www.funonthenet.in/forums/index.php?topic=210952.0;wap2 http://vedvikas.blogspot.in/2008/07/sukla-yajur-veda-mantra-on-mars-water.html, 17-7-12, 12.10 pm http://www.nih.ernet.in/rbis/vedic.htm, 17-7-12, 12.20 pm
Identifying the elements of Development Thinking in India-final paper
52
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adalaj_Stepwell