WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P...

41
WARNING Benny and Ruben aren’t responsible for the effects of the information overload during their presentation such as sleeplessness, increased energy level, trouble falling asleep. It may change your point of view and will wake you up frequently during the night (or day). The information is based on personal and business experiences, copyright BlaBla here, if you have feedback or suggestions to make it better please let us know. If it is great already let Jensen Huang know

Transcript of WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P...

Page 1: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

WARNINGBenny and Ruben aren’t responsible for the effects of the information overload during their presentation such as

sleeplessness, increased energy level, trouble falling asleep. It may change your point of view and will wake you up frequently during the night (or day). The information is based on personal and business experiences, copyright

BlaBla here, if you have feedback or suggestions to make it better please let us know.

If it is great already let Jensen Huang know

Page 2: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Ruben Spruijt

CTO @ Frame

@rspruijt

[email protected]

Benny Tritsch

Principal Consultant @ DrTritsch.com

@drtritsch

[email protected]

Hard Facts - Benchmarking NVIDIA Virtual GPU Accelerated Remote Desktop User

Experience

Page 3: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Communities

Community

Advisor

REXAnalytics

VDI DesignBenchmarking

Workspace Analytics

Advisory Board Investor

Page 4: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Communities

Community

Advisor2008-2017

Executive, CTOTechnologist

Workspace, CloudCommunity

Dad, Christian, kids 17,15,11

Page 5: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

www.teamRGE.com

Page 6: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

“Sharing your knowledge doesn't put your job at risk. It empowers you to

perform at a higher level”

Page 7: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID
Page 8: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Session topics

1. Windows, session remoting and GPUs

2. Preview: EUC state of the union 2018

3. Benchmarking: tooling and lab setup

4. Benchmarking results

Page 9: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

.

Is Windows remoting still relevant?

Page 10: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID
Page 11: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID
Page 12: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Cloud Adoption Rate and the “Long Tail”

100%

50%

15%

#Win

do

ws

Ap

ps

Time

Acceptance of Web / mobile Platforms

“Long Tail”

Page 13: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

.

Page 14: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

EUC - State of the Union survey

VDILIKEAPRO PREVIEW

MARCH 2018N= 520

44.00%

2.00%

30.00%

9.00%

3.00% 2.00% 3.00% 2.00% 1.00%3.00%

1.00% 0.00%0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%

45%

50%

Windows10 x64

Windows10 x86

Windows7 x64

Windows7 x86

WindowsServer

2008(R2)

WindowsServer

2012(R2)

WindowsServer2016

WindowsXP

Windows8.x (x86and x64)

Linux Not sure Other(pleasespecify)

What operating systems are used for desktop VMs?

Page 15: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Virtual Client Computing upstart in Cloud and Mobile 1st world

Page 16: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Popular (Graphics) Applications

Page 17: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

How much video frame buffer (memory)

is required for OS and applications?

Why is this important?

Page 18: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

GPU usage for normal user - Ruben

Page 19: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

GPU Options

Page 20: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Virtual DesktopsBare Metal

Windows OS Hypervisor Hypervisor Hyper visor

VM VM VM VM VM VM VM VM VM

Hyper visor

VM VM VM

Direct Map Software GraphicsShared GPU

(API Intercept)GPU Pass-thru

GPUVirtualization

GPU graphics driver VDI vendor’s shared graphics framework GPU virtualization component

GPU GPU GPU GPUGPU

GPU GPUs

User Session

CPU(Emulating GPU)

GPU-Accelerated Remoting – Options

Page 21: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

EUC - State of the Union survey – 2018

AMD Firepro1%

AMD MxGPU1%

NVIDIA TESLA - KEPLAR12%

NVIDIA TESLA -MAXWELL

16%

NVIDIA TESLA -PASCAL

6%

NVIDIA QUADRO3%

Teradici PCoIP Server offload card

1%

None, No GPUs or offloading technology is

being used47%

Not sure13%

CHART TITLE

VDILIKEAPRO PREVIEW

MARCH 2018

N= 520

Which GPUs do you use for your on-premises VDI/SBC solution

Page 22: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

“Iron sharpens Iron, more competition between

AMD, Intel and NVIDIA is a very good thing!”

Ruben Spruijt,  Frame CTO

Page 23: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID
Page 24: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

EUC - State of the Union survey

N= 520

VDILIKEAPRO PREVIEW

MARCH 2018

Page 25: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

EUC - State of the Union survey

VDILIKEAPRO PREVIEW

MARCH 2018N= 520

Page 26: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

EUC - State of the Union survey

VDILIKEAPRO PREVIEW

MARCH 2018N= 520

Page 27: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

EUC - State of the Union survey

VDILIKEAPRO PREVIEW

MARCH 2018N= 520

Page 28: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

PLEASE SUPPORTVDILIKEAPRO.COM/SURVEY

Page 29: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Benchmarking: tooling and lab setup

Page 30: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Our mission is to "de-suckify" remote end-user experience…

…or at least to know when and why it sucks so you can make better choices! ;-)

[email protected]

Page 31: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Typical Customer Questions (in GPU context)

Perceived performance of a specific application with GPU and without?

Performance impact of the cloud and varying network conditions?

Performance impact of a predefined number of noisy neighbors?

Perceived end-user experience when migrating an existing remoting product?

How do existing and future remoting solutions and protocols compare when looking at different use cases and personas?

Page 32: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Benchmarking Workflow

Build Track Analyze

REX Workloads

• Creates set of scripted user

actions within an application

• Simulates individual users

and noisy neighbors

(personas)

REX Tracker

• Triggers/syncs test runs

• Triggers primary user

screen recording

• Collects telemetry data

REX Analyzer

• Combines and displays visual

and metric test results

• Compares load sequences

• Analyzes user experience

Page 33: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

REX Analytics

Endpoint Device Host + Guest VMs

Network

WanEmu

REX Workloads

Build Track Analyze

REX TrackerREX Analyzer

REX Connector

Page 34: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Comparison – REX Analyzer

Page 35: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Benchmarking Results

Page 36: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Notes from the field: observations & findings

NVIDIA GPU solution = Hardware + Software.

Make sure QvDWS is licensed correctly, to have maximum performance.

Bug(s) in Azure NV6. GPU connect, GPU performance counters, GPU licensing.

Bug(s) in NVIDIA on-premises licensing platform.

Using WMI – NVIDIA component heavily, CPU impact is high (15-20%)

Page 37: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Test Scenarios “On-Premises”

1. HyperV2016-DDA-vs-XD7.15-LAN-DX9-Rollercoaster

2. HyperV2016-DDA-vs-XD7.15-2mb-200ms-1%-DX9-Rollercoaster

3. XD7.15-LAN-IE-vs-Chrome-PhotoGallery (Ken Burns Effect)

4. HyperV2016-DDA-LAN-vs-WAN-OpenGL-LegoDD

5. HyperV2016-DDA-vs-XD7.15-2mb-200ms-1%-OpenGL-Cinebench

Page 38: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Test Scenarios “Public Cloud”

1. NV6-FrameHTML5-vs-RDP10-”LAN”-IE-CarVisualizer

2. NV6-FrameHTML5-vs-RDP10-8mb-200ms-1%-IE-CarVisualizer

3. NV6-FrameMac-vs-RDP10-LAN-Superposition-FullHD

4. NV6-Frame-vs-XD7.15-LAN-Superposition_FullHD

Page 39: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

SUMMARY

Page 40: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Session topics

1. Windows, session remoting and GPUs

2. Preview: EUC state of the union 2018

3. Benchmarking: tooling and lab setup

4. Benchmarking results

Page 41: WARNING · 2020. 3. 4. · EUC - State of the Union survey –2018 A M D F irepro 1% A M D M x G P U 1% N V ID IA TESL A - K EP L A R 12% N V ID IA TESL A - M A XW EL L 16 % N V ID

Ruben Spruijt

CTO @ Frame

@rspruijt

[email protected]

Benny Tritsch

Principal Consultant @ DrTritsch.com

@drtritsch

[email protected]

Thanks!