War & the Noble Savage

W A R & T H E N O B L E S A V A G E

Gyrus ~ The October Gallery ~ 27th October 2009

Charles Darwin

(1809-1882)

[In pre-state societies] there is no place for industry, because the fruit thereof is uncertain: and consequently no culture of the earth; no navigation, nor use of the commodities that may be imported by sea; no commodious building; no instruments of moving and removing such things as require much force; no knowledge of the face of the earth; no account of time; no arts; no letters; no society; and which is worst of all, continual fear, and danger of violent death; and the life of man, solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short.

— Thomas Hobbes, The Leviathan, 1651

“The Noble Savage” ?

— Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712-1778)



I am as free as Nature first made man,'Ere the base Laws of Servitude began,When wild in woods the noble Savage ran.

— John Dryden,The Conquest of Granada,

1672

John Crawfurd(1783-1868)


Charles Darwin


Charles Darwin

Natives of Tierra del Fuego(from J.G. Wood’s Uncivilized Races of

Men, 1871)

“The 3 Modern Dogmas”

• The Blank Slate (the mind has no innate traits)

• The Noble Savage (people are born good and corrupted by society)

• The Ghost in the Machine (each of us has a soul that makes choices free from biology)

Based on Lawrence Keeley, War Before Civilization, 1996

Keeley’s evidence for prehistoric violence

• Jebel Sahaba, northeast Africa, 11,000 BCE



• Oneota Indians, Illinois, 1300 CE




• Prince Rupert Harbour Indians, British Columbia, 1500 BCE to 500 CE





• Crow Creek, early 14th century






• Vedbæk, Denmark, 4100 BCE






• Vedbæk, Denmark, 4100 BCE

• Téviec, Brittany, 6000 BCE


The “nightmare past” that Hobbes envisioned in which individuals lived in continual fear of violent death clearly never existed. On the other hand, an effort to locate ethnographic instances of societies in which conflict is absent and utopia concretely exemplified invites disappointment.

— Raymond C. Kelly

The seeming peacefulness of such small hunter-gatherer groups may therefore be more a consequence of the tiny size of their social units and the large scale implied by our normal definition of warfare than of any real pacifism on their part.

— Lawrence Keeley, War Before Civilization

The seeming peacefulness of such small hunter-gatherer groups may therefore be more a consequence of the tiny size of their social units and the large scale implied by our normal definition of warfare than of any real pacifism on their part.

— Lawrence Keeley, War Before CivilizationAs hunting reduces the numbers of some species, the foragers shift their aim toward other more common animals because the cost, in time, of getting the rare ones is too high. But this is not conservationist behavior. It is behavior that is focused on the short term. Deciding to stop hunting a species that has become rare differs from consciously hunting that animal so lightly that it does not become rare. The true conservationist will not kill a rare species, even when it is easy to do so.

— Steven LeBlanc, Constant Battles

It is no surprise that revisionist assaults on “noble savages” and “wilderness” come at the historical moment when the global culture’s unsustainable cultural imperative of perpetual capital accumulation is reducing the earth’s stocks of water, soil, forests, and fisheries to dangerously low levels and disrupting ecosystems and natural cycles on an unprecedented scale.

— John H. Bodley

http://dreamflesh.com

War & the Noble Savage

Education

Transcript of War & the Noble Savage