waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

50
IS-16-1861 Page 1 of 6 Mayor and Councillors COUNCIL 21 APRIL 2016 Meeting Status: Public Purpose of Report: For Decision WAIKANAE DUPLICATE RISING MAIN CONSTRUCTION ADVANCEMENT PURPOSE OF REPORT 1 This report seeks approval to sign the Memorandum of Understanding with the NZ Transport Agency (NZTA) to accelerate the construction of Waikanae Duplicate Rising Main (WDRM). DELEGATION 2 Council has the authority to consider this matter. BACKGROUND 3 The Waikanae terminal wastewater pumping station 009 transfers all wastewater effluent generated by Waikanae to the Paraparaumu Wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) for treatment. 4 The wastewater is pumped along a single 5km long “rising main” pipe to the treatment plant and there is no redundancy for the pipe. 5 The capacity of the existing pumping station is limited by firstly the power supply to the station and the pressure rating and size of the existing rising main. The existing pumping station has a pumping capacity of 137 litres per second (‘l/s’). 6 A three stage approach to upgrading the pumping station was developed with the first two stages now completed. 7 Stage one included the construction of 200m3 of emergency storage at the pumping station to provide buffering of flows during wet weather or pump station outage. 8 Stage two included the construction of a second wet well with new pumps, refurbishment of the existing wet well and associated pipework and odour control for the station. The redundancy and additional capacity provide by the second stage can’t be fully utilised until all upgrades are complete. 9 Stage three includes the installation of a duplicate rising main along the MacKays to Peka Peka (M2PP) Expressway designation, connection to the pumping station along Te Moana Road, connection to the Wastewater treatment Plant at Paraparaumu and upgrading of the power supply at the station. These complete the proposed upgrades to the pumping station providing additional capacity for future growth in Waikanae to 2061. In the 2012 Long Term Plan (LTP) this work was originally proposed to commence in 2016/2017.

Transcript of waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Page 1: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

IS-16-1861

Page 1 of 6

Mayor and Councillors COUNCIL

21 APRIL 2016

Meeting Status: Public

Purpose of Report: For Decision

WAIKANAE DUPLICATE RISING MAIN CONSTRUCTION ADVANCEMENT

PURPOSE OF REPORT

1 This report seeks approval to sign the Memorandum of Understanding with the NZ Transport Agency (NZTA) to accelerate the construction of Waikanae Duplicate Rising Main (WDRM).

DELEGATION

2 Council has the authority to consider this matter.

BACKGROUND

3 The Waikanae terminal wastewater pumping station 009 transfers all wastewater effluent generated by Waikanae to the Paraparaumu Wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) for treatment.

4 The wastewater is pumped along a single 5km long “rising main” pipe to the treatment plant and there is no redundancy for the pipe.

5 The capacity of the existing pumping station is limited by firstly the power supply to the station and the pressure rating and size of the existing rising main. The existing pumping station has a pumping capacity of 137 litres per second (‘l/s’).

6 A three stage approach to upgrading the pumping station was developed with the first two stages now completed.

7 Stage one included the construction of 200m3 of emergency storage at the pumping station to provide buffering of flows during wet weather or pump station outage.

8 Stage two included the construction of a second wet well with new pumps, refurbishment of the existing wet well and associated pipework and odour control for the station. The redundancy and additional capacity provide by the second stage can’t be fully utilised until all upgrades are complete.

9 Stage three includes the installation of a duplicate rising main along the MacKays to Peka Peka (M2PP) Expressway designation, connection to the pumping station along Te Moana Road, connection to the Wastewater treatment Plant at Paraparaumu and upgrading of the power supply at the station. These complete the proposed upgrades to the pumping station providing additional capacity for future growth in Waikanae to 2061. In the 2012 Long Term Plan (LTP) this work was originally proposed to commence in 2016/2017.

Page 2: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

IS-16-1861

Page 2 of 6

10 With the development of the M2PP Alliance (a formed entity between NZTA, The Fletcher Construction Company Limited, Higgins Contractors Limited and Beca Limited) Council identified potential construction synergies/savings and advanced early stages of the rising main construction in the 2015 LTP with the programme information available at the time.

11 Working closely with the M2PP Alliance significant benefits were identified in advancing further sections of the duplicate rising main while the Expressway is under construction before the road is open to traffic. These include crossing the Waikanae Bridge and the section along the Cycleway Walkway and Bridleway (CWB) north of the Waikanae Bridge adjacent to the 510 Retaining Wall.

12 In November 2015 the Corporate Business Committee considered report IS-15-1748 (copy in appendix 1) and resolved to advance construction of these sections of the WDRM in 2015/2016 in conjunction with the construction of the M2PP Expressway. Funding was achieved within the existing annual 2015 Long Term Plan (LTP) Wastewater capital budgets through reprioritisation of three existing wastewater capital projects. The existing $4.05m was redistributed across years 2015-19 as follows: $1.75m, $200k, $100k, $2.0m.

13 Any further advancement of stage three upgrades would require increases in funding in early years in excess of that provided in the 2015 LTP. Discussions with the M2PP Alliance and NZTA have identified a mechanism to provide the required funding to complete the balance of the duplicate rising main in the expressway designation by the end of 2016/17 rather than returning at a later date to complete the sections along the CWB and local roads.

14 The DRAFT Memorandum of Understanding – Wastewater Pump Station WSP009 Rising Main (MoU) attached in appendix 2 has been prepared and allows the M2PP alliance to deliver the rising main installation and provides a funding mechanism to complete the rising main within the expressway designation without further movement of the 2015 LTP budget timings. Final legal reviews are required before it is signed.

15 The sections of rising main outside of the designation, along Te Moana Road to the pumping station and to the WWTP at Paraparaumu and the power supply upgrade are not covered under the MoU and can be delivered within the current four year LTP programme in 2017-19 to complete stage three of the upgrade. Construction of the WDRM along Te Moana Road would occur after the completion of the interchange reducing total disruption in this area and the connection to the WWTP can be made from the duct already in the expressway without impacting CWB users.

ISSUES AND OPTIONS

Issues

Project Funding and Scheduling

16 The re-prioritisation of wastewater budgets in November last year has allowed the Waikanae Bridge crossing and the section along the CWB north of the Waikanae Bridge adjacent to the 510 Retaining Wall to be included in the 2015/16 capital works with significant benefits.

17 The Council has continued to work with M2PP to refine the design, construction budgets and timing to identify further synergies and savings in the construction

Page 3: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

IS-16-1861

Page 3 of 6

of the WDRM. To improve the accuracy of costings and work estimates the M2PP Alliance recently tendered all the remaining WDRM sections needed to be completed along the expressway designation. This has resulted in a revised project cost estimate of $4.0 million if undertaken in conjunction with the construction of the expressway.

18 NZTA and M2PP Alliance have prepared a MoU that allows the construction of works within the expressway designation to be undertaken by the M2PP Alliance. Funding would be provided in the short term by NZTA, through an increase of $2.1m to the forecast NZTA subsidy. This funding would be recovered by NZTA in 2018/19 through reduced NZTA roading subsidies.

Procurement and resourcing

19 The construction of the rising main is a substantial project requiring contract management and administrative support processes and resources. The original staging of the construction also allowed the commitment required from the Council to be managed within the existing contract delivery processes and resources related to the M2PP project.

20 Advancing the works increases the resource commitment required by Council in the short term. This can be mitigated by working with the M2PP design and procurement teams to take advantage of the Alliances resourcing, while maintaining value for money by procurement through competitive tendering. This also brings the benefit of improved coordination of individual works areas with the M2PP programme and mitigates contractual claims from delays or coordination costs.

21 This model where Alliance teams manage the procurement and construction of Council infrastructure, under Council guidance, has worked successfully on other works. The Council then reimburse the Alliance for the costs to complete the works.

Memorandum of Understanding – Wastewater Pump Station WSP009 Rising Main (MoU)

22 The DRAFT MoU between NZTA and Council and provides for the M2PP alliance to deliver the construction of the WDRM along the expressway designation in conjunction with the current construction programme and eliminate future disruption for CWB users and road users at Te Moana interchange.

23 The MoU works have been separated into two parts separable portion A and B. These portions reflect the works that have already been agreed for advancing in portion A and the balance of works to complete the WDRM along the expressway designation in portion B. The scope of the WDRM M2PP advanced works is shown in the plans in appendix 3.

24 The MoU sets out the desired outcome to accelerate the design and installation of the WDRM within the expressway designation to avoid unnecessary costs or disruption to both parties. It sets out the respective responsibilities, risks, joint control group governance model and commercial approach and funding to meeting the outcome.

Page 4: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

IS-16-1861

Page 4 of 6

Options

Option one – Continue with current scope of advanced works

25 This option maintains the existing advanced works programme and project re-prioritisation approval by the CBC in November last year. This takes advantage of the construction efficiencies at the Waikanae Bridge and 510 Retaining Wall sections where retrospective installation would attract additional costs to manage traffic and alternative construction techniques.

26 It also eliminates the need to excavate the local road surfaces at Otaihanga and completes the crossing of the Te Moana Interchange.

27 The completion of the rising main along the balance of the cycle, walk and bridle pathway adjacent to the Expressway and along Te Moana Road to the pumping station would still need to be completed at a later date. This would require the disruption of the use of these locations.

28 The current budget schedule is set out below:

Year 2015/16 2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 Total

Budget (,000)

1,750 200 100 2,000 4,050

Option two – Accelerate the completion of the WDRM

29 This option accelerates the completion of the WDRM along the expressway designation and eliminates the need to disturb these sections again to complete the stage three upgrades.

30 It provides a funding option through utilising increased subsidy funding from NZTA for roading in 2016/17 to offset the increased costs of the WDRM installation with no impact to the LTP budgets.

31 Competitive pricing is achieved through the use of tendering through the M2PP Alliance procurement model.

32 This leaves the rising main sections outside of the designation, along Te Moana Road to the pumping station and to the (WWTP) at Paraparaumu and the power supply upgrade remaining to complete stage three in 2017-19. These could be completed within the current four year LTP programme

33 The revised budget funding is set out in the table below

Year 2015/16 2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 Total

Current Budget (,000) 1,750 200 100 2,000 4,050

Revised schedule (,000)

1,750 2,300

4,050

Increase/ (decrease) in funding required

2,100 -100 -2,000 -

Page 5: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

IS-16-1861

Page 5 of 6

Preferred Option

34 Option two is the preferred option where the WDRM completion is accelerated along the expressway designation through the signing of the MoU.

CONSIDERATIONS

Policy considerations

SIGNIFICANCE & ENGAGEMENT POLICY

35 The signing of the MoU on behalf of Council was reviewed against the significance policy and considered to have a low level of significance.

Legal considerations

36 There are no statutory requirements related to this proposal.

Financial considerations

37 The preferred option is considered to be prudent management of capital investment funding that:

Minimises the cost of the project by coordinating works with the construction of the M2PP Expressway at critical sections along the alignment and staging completion of the balance of the rising main over four years;

Manages the advancement within the 2015 Long Term Plan wastewater capital budgets by using advanced funding through the NZTA roading subsidy to fund advance works;

Delivers the required upgrade to meet the projected growth.

Tāngata whenua considerations

38 There are no known issues for consideration relating to Iwi with the signing of the MoU to accelerate the construction of the project.

Consultation already undertaken

39 No formal consultation has been undertaken to date.

Engagement planning

40 The staging of the construction of the WDRM was set out in the 2015 LTP and was consulted on prior to adoption.

41 The acceleration of the WDRM through the MoU does not impact on the level of service to the community and it is considered an engagement plan is not needed to implement this decision. A media release to advise the community of the results achieved by working with the Alliance to deliver this project may assist in “informing the community” about progress on the long term plan.

Publicity

42 The approach to managing the staging of the construction of the WDRM was publicised in the 2015 LTP.

Page 6: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

IS-16-1861

Page 6 of 6

RECOMMENDATIONS

43 That Council approves progressing the construction of separable portions A and B of the Waikanae Duplicate Rising Main as set out in the Memorandum of Understanding with the NZ Transport Agency in appendix 3.

44 That the Chief Executive is authorised to finalise and sign the Memorandum of Understanding with NZ Transport Agency in appendix 3 on behalf of Council.

Report prepared by Approved for submission Approved for submission

Martyn Cole

Wayne Maxwell

Sean Mallon

Water and Wastewater Asset Manager

Group Manager Corporate Services

Group Manager Infrastructure Services

ATTACHMENTS

APPENDIX 1: IS-15-1748 WAIKANAE DUPLICATE RISING MAIN CONSTRUCTION

ADVANCEMENT

APPENDIX 2: MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING – WASTEWATER PUMP STATION

WSP009 RISING MAIN

APPENDIX 3: SCOPE OF WAIKANAE DUPLICATE RISING MAIN M2PP ADVANCED WORKS

PLANS

Page 7: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

IS-15-1748

N617011 Page 1 of 11

Chairperson and Committee Members CORPORATE BUSINESS COMMITTEE

19 NOVEMBER 2015

Meeting Status: Public

Purpose of Report: For Decision

WAIKANAE DUPLICATE RISING MAIN CONSTRUCTION ADVANCEMENT

PURPOSE OF REPORT

1 To seek approval for the reprioritisation of the 2015-2018 wastewater capital budgets to advance the construction of Waikanae Duplicate Rising Main (‘WDRM’).

DELEGATION

2 The Corporate Business Committee has delegated authority to consider this report under the following delegation in the Governance Structure:

Section B.3.7 Annual Planning

7.2 Authority to re-allocate funding already approved by the Council as part of the Annual Budget process provided that the re-allocation of funds does not increase the overall monies committed in the budget and is consistent with the existing LTP strategic and policy framework.

BACKGROUND

3 The Rauparaha wastewater pumping station transfers all wastewater effluent generated by Waikanae to the Paraparaumu Wastewater treatment plant for treatment.

4 The wastewater is pumped along a single 5km long “rising main” pipe to the

treatment plant and there is no redundancy for the pipe. 5 The capacity of the existing pumping station is limited by firstly the power supply

to the station and the pressure rating and size of the existing rising main. The existing pumping station has a pumping capacity of 137 litres per second (‘l/s’).

6 A three stage approach to upgrading the pumping station was developed with

the first two stages now completed. 7 Stage one included the construction of 200m3 of emergency storage at the

pumping station to provide buffering of flows during wet weather or pump station outage.

8 Stage two included the construction of a second wet well with new pumps,

refurbishment of the existing wet well and associated pipework and odour control for the station. This upgrade provides redundancy for the existing pumps and additional pumping capacity in preparation for the installation of the duplicate rising main in stage three. The additional capacity provide by the second stage

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 8: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

IS-15-1748

N617011 Page 2 of 11

of the Rauparaha pumping station upgrades can not be fully utilised until the duplicate rising main is constructed.

9 Stage three includes the installation of a duplicate rising main and upgrading of

the power supply to the station that allows the additional capacity in stage 2 to be fully utilised. Stage three was designed to provide additional capacity for future growth in Waikanae to 2061 and was originally planned for commencing in 2016/2017 in the 2012 Long Term Plan.

10 With the development of the Mackays to Peka Peka (‘M2PP’) Expressway

programme, the opportunity to coordinate with construction activities to take advantage of potential synergies/savings was identified. The rising main installation was advanced in the 2015 Long Term Plan with the programme information available at the time.

11 This was split into two stages with stage one providing limited advanced works at

existing roads crossings at Otaihanga Road and the Te Moana Interchange in years one and two of the 2015 Long Term Plan. This sought to minimise future traffic disruption with the completion of intermediate lengths along the services corridor and Cycleways/Walkways/Bridleways (‘CWB’) adjacent to the Expressway planned for years three and four.

12 Limited early works were undertaken in 2014/2015 using surplus funds from

Te Roto Wastewater Pumping Station upgrade project. This allowed a duct to be constructed under the Expressway at the wastewater treatment plant with the main Expressway earthworks in preparation for the installation of the duplicate rising main.

ISSUES AND OPTIONS

Issues

13 The Council have been working closely with M2PP Expressway Alliance as they have refined their construction programme. It has become evident following the adoption of the 2015 Long Term Plan that significant benefits exist for advancing further sections of the duplicate rising main while the Expressway is under construction before the road is open to traffic. These include crossing the Waikanae Bridge and the section along the CWB north of the Waikanae Bridge adjacent to the 510 Retaining Wall.

14 Discussions are also underway with New Zealand Transport Agency (‘NZTA’) to

assist with funding to complete the balance of the duplicate rising main as a matter of urgency rather than returning at a later date to complete the sections along the CWB and local roads. To date, no formal offer to provide advanced funding has been made.

Existing Project Funding

15 The current budget for the duplication of the rising main is $4,082,000 and is spread out over four years as shown below:

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 9: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

IS-15-1748

N617011 Page 3 of 11

Long Term Plan Year 2015/16

$000

2016/17

$000

2017/18

$000

2018/19

$000

Total

$000

WDRM 250 717 736 2,378 4,082

16 This budget provided for limited advanced works in years one and two followed by the completion of the remaining length of the rising main in years three and four. The advanced works included the road crossings at Otaihanga Road and through the Te Moana Expressway interchange.

17 Any further advancement of works would require additional budget to be

allocated / sourced in early years to meet the costs of such works. 18 The Council has been working with M2PP to further detail the scoping and

construction budgets using detailed estimates and recent tender prices. The result of this work has highlighted that the construction rates for completing the rising main in the current market have increased as indicated in the priority works section below with the cost to complete the project now in excess of $4.5 million. These prices remain estimates of the costs and would need to be confirmed at the time of contract award.

19 Further work is being done to review these budgets and consider options to

mitigate cost increases to delivering the project. This may include reallocating planned pipe renewal budgets to this project to complete the work or deferral of the completion of the project to a later time when the construction market prices are more favourable after the demand for construction resources has eased afterM2PP is complete, although this has not been determined at this time.

Priorities for advancement of remaining works

20 The table below sets out the priorities for remaining works based on the benefits of each type of area the construction is occurring in. The priorities for advancement were set, based on cost and disruption minimisation while balancing the impact on rates and borrowings:

Priority Type Benefit of advancing Locations Estimate $000

1 Existing road crossings

Eliminate the need to excavate recently constructed road surfaces Minimise future traffic disruption. Installed with main M2PP construction.

Otaihanga Road crossing

350

2 Expressway crossings

Minimise costs to install at a later date. Installed with main M2PP construction.

Ducting at treatment plant (completed 2014/2015) Te Moana Interchange

350

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 10: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

IS-15-1748

N617011 Page 4 of 11

3 Challenging construction locations

Minimise cost of installation. Installed with main M2PP construction.

Waikanae bridge and approaches. 510 Retaining Wall section

1,050

4 Existing local roads

Single period of disruption. Completion with M2PP. Minimise disruption to traffic

Te Moana Road to Rauparaha pumping station

470

5 Cycleways/ Walkways/ Bridleways

Single period of disruption. Completion with M2PP. Minimise disruption to CWBs

Treatment plant to Otaihanga Road. Otaihanga Road to Waikanae Bridge. Waikanae Bridge to Te Moana interchange

2,350

Estimated total cost to complete the rising main 2015-2017 4,570

21 To advance priorities three to five would require additional funding this year. This

could be achieved through either increasing the capital expenditure in the relevant years and/or deferring works in the early years and completing them in later years.

Sources of funding

22 The total wastewater capital works budget for 2015/2016 is $3.221 million which is made up of renewals and upgrades both reactive and planned across all asset types such as pipe networks, pumping stations, treatment plants and consents.

23 An examination of the 2015/2016 capital works budgets has identified the following planned projects that could be deferred with minimal risk to provide additional funding in 2015/2016 to undertake further advanced works.

Project Primary deferral risk Risk

Level

Value

$000

Dissolved Air flotation

(DAF) renewal to year two

Exceed current capacity or

failure

Low-

Medium

700

Annual pipe renewals Delayed improvement in

performance of wastewater

network.

Medium-

low

500

Wastewater network

reconfiguration

Delayed operational

performance improvements

Low 300

Total 1,500

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 11: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

IS-15-1748

N617011 Page 5 of 11

24 These would provide an additional $1.5 million of funding in year one giving a total budget for the advanced works of $1.75 million which represent around 54 percent of 2015/2016 wastewater capital works budget. $1.75 million would meet the estimate of costs to complete the Waikanae Bridge approach and crossing and 510 Retaining Wall section. The budgets for the first four years of the Long Term Plan for these projects are shown in the table below:

25 The deferred works could be re programmed for completion in the following years as set out in the table below that was provided at the Council briefing on 22 October 2015.

26 This includes the following funding reprioritisations:

$700k for the Dissolved Air flotation (DAF) renewal in 2015/2016 transferred to 2016/2017 and increased for CPI to $717k

$1.13 million of annual pipe renewals from years 2015-2017 transferred into years 2017/18 and 2018/19 to give a yearly budgets of $1.26m and $818k respectively.

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 12: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

IS-15-1748

N617011 Page 6 of 11

$300k of wastewater network reconfigurations in 2015/2016 transferred to 2016/2017 and increased for CPI to $313k

The $4.08m funding for the Duplicate rising main redistributed in years 2015-19 as follows: $1.75m, $200k, $0, $2.1m

27 This leaves a balance of the wastewater capital works budget of $1.47 million. The remaining works are generally related to reactive pipe renewals, on-going wastewater pumping station and treatment plant renewals and upgrades and consenting works which carry a high risk should they be deferred.

28 A further $2.8 million would be required to progress priorities 4 and 5. This exceeds the remaining balance of the wastewater capital works budget of $1.47 million. To advance this work in 2015/2016, additional funding would need to be raised. Discussions with NZTA are underway to assist with funding to complete the balance of the duplicate rising main as a matter of urgency, rather than returning at a later date to complete the sections along the CWB and local roads.

Procurement and resourcing

29 The construction of the rising main is a substantial project requiring contract management and administrative support processes and resources. The original staging of the construction also allowed the commitment required from the Council to be managed within the existing contract delivery processes and resources related to the M2PP project.

30 Advancing the works increases the resource commitment required by Council in the short term. This can be mitigated by working with the M2PP design and procurement teams to take advantage of the Alliances larger resourcing, while maintaining value for money by procurement through competitive tendering. This also brings the benefit of improved coordination of individual works areas with the M2PP programme and mitigates contractual claims from delays or coordination costs.

31 This model where Alliance teams manage the procurement and construction of Council infrastructure, under Council guidance, has worked successfully on other works. The Council then reimburse the Alliance for the costs to complete the works.

Pumping station and rising main capacity

32 The requirement to duplicate the rising main is driven by the need to transfer additional flows from growth in Waikanae to the Paraparaumu Wastewater Treatment Plant. Failure to provide additional pumping capacity will compromise the ability of the Waikanae wastewater network to cope with wet weather flows and increase the likelihood and frequency of wet weather overflows from the system.

33 The growth projected in the earlier studies has not eventuated as rapidly as projected. In the 2006 census the population of Waikanae was 10,488 and it was projected to reach 13,933 by 2016 and ultimately 18,486 by 2061 which was the 50 year design horizon for the upgrade.

34 Based on previous flow modelling the Rauparaha pumping station would require a peak pumping capacity of 158 l/s to meet the 2 year annual recurrence interval

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 13: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

IS-15-1748

N617011 Page 7 of 11

(ARI) storm event without overflowing for the population recorded in the 2006 census.

35 The current 2015 estimate for population served by the Waikanae wastewater network is now around 11,283 and peak wet weather flows are estimated at 170 l/s which exceeds the current pumping capacity of the station.

36 Emergency storage was also constructed at the pumping station during the recent upgrades and along with storage in the network provides some buffering of the peak wet weather flows at the station of just over four hours at current expected flows.

37 An upgrade of the power supply at the Rauparaha pumping station would provide the capacity to run more than one of the four pumps at a time. Running two pumps together would increase flows to around 160 l/s while running three would give 175 l/s. This does however increase the pressure in the rising main significantly, bringing it closer to its maximum rated operating pressure. Running the pumping station in this manner would increase the risk of a failure in the main.

38 Further emergency storage exists at the Waikanae ponds pumping station upstream of the Rauparaha pumping station and is used currently when the Rauparaha station reaches high levels.

39 Future growth will continue to reduce the effectiveness of the emergency storage and the network to buffer wet weather flows and prevent overflowing from the network in the 2 year ARI storm event.

40 The duplication of the rising main and upgrading of the power supply will allow multiple pumps to be used concurrently to increase the flows from the pumping station to the 50 year design population without increasing the pressure in or risk of failure of the existing rising main.

41 Further modelling is currently underway to assess the current performance of the Waikanae wastewater network and the Rauparaha pumping station at its current stage of upgrade and the results are expected by the end of the year.

Procurement and resourcing

Option 1 - Maintain existing programme

42 The existing programme would see the completion of Otaihanga Road crossing and Te Moana Interchange in the current year with the installation of other sections of the rising main being undertaken in the future. This would remove the need to excavate recently constructed local road surfaces and the associated traffic disruption.

43 Challenging construction issues would need to be resolved to complete the Waikanae Bridge Crossing across in a live Expressway. The installation of the pipe through the 510 Retaining Wall section north of the Waikanae Bridge would be difficult post Expressway construction because of the constraints in this area. Issues such as significant traffic management, the need for alternative construction methods and the potential for additional consenting would introduce further increases in the procurement, installation methodology and construction costs.

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 14: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

IS-15-1748

N617011 Page 8 of 11

44 The completion of the rising main along the balance of the CWB adjacent to the Expressway and along Te Moana Road to Rauparaha pumping station would still need to be completed at a later date. This would require the disruption at these locations.

45 While there are no changes to current proposed Long Term Plan programme a contingency for additional costs to complete the project within the proposed four year timeframe should be held in reserve until contract prices are confirmed and construction complete. This could be achieved by reallocating deferred pipe renewal budgets to this project or deferral of the completion of the project at a later time when the construction market prices may be more favourable.

Option 2 - Advance the Waikanae Bridge Crossing and the 510 Retaining Wall sections

46 It has become evident that significant benefits exist for advancing the Waikanae Bridge Crossing and the 510 Retaining Wall Sections of the duplicate rising main while the Expressway is under construction and before the road is open to traffic.

47 This advanced programme would see the completion of the Otaihanga Road and

Waikanae crossings, 510 Retaining Wall section and the Te Moana Interchange in the current year with the installation of other sections of the rising main being undertaken in the future.

48 This would take advantage of the construction efficiencies from installing the rising main with the Expressway works. This is particularly relevant at the Waikanae Bridge and 510 Retaining Wall sections where retrospective installation would attract addition costs to manage traffic and alternative construction techniques.

49 Furthermore, it would eliminate the need to excavate recently constructed local road surfaces at Otaihanga and complete the crossing of the Te Moana Interchange.

50 The completion of the rising main along the balance of the CWB adjacent to the Expressway and along Te Moana Road to Rauparaha pumping station would still need to be completed at a later date. This would require the disruption of the use of these locations.

51 This requires the deferral of $1.5 million of existing projects proposed in year one of the Long Term Plan.

52 A contingency for additional costs to complete the project within the proposed 4 year timeframe should be held in reserve until contract prices are confirmed. This could be achieved by reallocating deferred pipe renewal budgets to this project or deferral of the completion of the project at a later time when the construction market prices are more favourable.

Option 3 Defer the installation of the rising main

53 Deferral of the completion of the rising main either in whole or in part will reduce the ability of the wastewater network in Waikanae to cope with wet weather flows increasing the likelihood and frequency of wet weather overflows as the population grows.

Preferred option

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 15: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

IS-15-1748

N617011 Page 9 of 11

The preferred option is option two

54 The advancement of the construction of the Waikanae Bridge Crossing and the 510 Retaining Wall sections of the WDRM in 2015/2016 in conjunction with the construction of the M2PP Expressway.

55 Funding for option two is from the re-prioritisation of three existing wastewater capital projects:

$700k for the Dissolved Air flotation (DAF) renewal in 2015/2016 to 2016/2017

$1.13 million of annual pipe renewals from years 2015-2017 and spread over 2017-2019

$300k of wastewater network reconfigurations in 2015/2016 to 2016/2017

56 The results of the tendering process are expected by the end of the year and will confirm the projected costs to complete the rising main within the four year programme against the original budget.

57 A contingency for additional costs to complete the project within the proposed four year timeframe should be held reserve until contract prices are confirmed. This could be achieved by holding the deferred pipe renewal budgets or deferral of the completion of the project at a later time when the construction market prices are more favourable.

58 The results of the wastewater modelling will further inform the decision to proceed with the completion of the project in the four year time frame or provide updated evidence to support further deferral of the completion of the project to a later date when potentially construction rates are more favourable.

CONSIDERATIONS

Policy considerations

SIGNIFICANCE & ENGAGEMENT POLICY 2014

59 The re-prioritisation of wastewater capital spending to use $1.5 million of existing budget in 2015/2016 and deferral $1.5 million of existing projects was reviewed against the significance policy and considered to have a low level of significance.

Legal considerations

60 There are no statutory requirements related to this proposal.

Financial considerations

61 The preferred option is considered to be prudent management of capital investment funding that:

Minimises the cost of the project by coordinating works with the construction of the M2PP Expressway at critical sections along the alignment and staging completion of the balance of the rising main over four years;

Manages the advancement within the 2015 Long Term Plan wastewater capital budgets;

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 16: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

IS-15-1748

N617011 Page 10 of 11

Delivers the required upgrade to meet the projected growth.

Tāngata whenua considerations

62 There are no known issues for consideration relating to Iwi with the re-prioritisation of these projects.

Consultation already undertaken

No formal consultation has been undertaken to date.

Engagement planning

63 The staging of the construction of the WDRM and projects now proposed for deferral were set out in the 2015 Long Term Plan which was consulted on prior to adoption.

64 The re-prioritisation of the wastewater capital budgets in year one of the plan and deferral of projects to later years does not impact of the level of service to the community and it is considered an engagement plan is not needed to implement this decision. A media release to advise of the community of the results achieved by working with the Alliance to deliver the advanced works may assist in “informing the community” about progress on the long term plan.

Publicity

65 The approach to managing the staging of the construction of the WDRM was publicised in the 2015 Long Term Plan.

RECOMMENDATIONS

66 That the Corporate Business Committee accept the recommendation to proceed with option two.

67 Approve the re-prioritisation of wastewater capital projects funding as follows:

$700k for the Dissolved Air flotation (DAF) renewal in 2015/2016 transferred to 2016/2017 and increased for CPI to $717k

$1.13 million of annual pipe renewals from years 2015-2017 transferred into years 2017/18 and 2018/19 to give yearly budgets of $1.26m and $818k respectively.

$300k of wastewater network reconfigurations in 2015/2016 transferred to 2016/2017 and increased for CPI to $313k

The $4.08m funding for the Duplicate rising main redistributed across years 2015-19 as follows: $1.75m, $200k, $100k, $2.0m

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 17: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

IS-15-1748

N617011 Page 11 of 11

Report prepared by Approved for submission Approved for submission

Martyn Cole

Kevin Currie

Sean Mallon

Water and Wastewater Asset Manager

Group Manager Regulatory Services

Group Manager Infrastructure Services

ATTACHMENT

APPENDIX 1: COUNCIL BRIEFING PRESENTATION 22 OCTOBER 2015

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 18: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Waikanae Duplicate Rising Main

Construction Advancement

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 19: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Current Situation

• Conveys all wastewater from Waikanae to

the Paraparaumu treatment plant.

• Single 5km long rising main

• No redundancy for this critical main.

• Existing rising main nearing its rated

design capacity.

• Further capacity needed to meet future

grow.

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 20: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Current Rising Main

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 21: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Duplicate Rising Main

• Provides capacity for future growth

• Utilises additional Rauparaha pumping

station upgrade capacity

• Additional operational redundancy and

flexibility.

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 22: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Duplicate Rising Main

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 23: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Duplicate Rising Main

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 24: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Early works 2014/15

• The construction of a rising main duct completed during

M2PP construction at the Expressway crossing at the

WWTP

• Completed with surplus funds from Te Roto Wastewater

Pumping Station upgrade Project

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 25: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Early works 2014/15

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 26: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

LTP Staging

• Current programme stages

• Stage one – advanced works

– Limited advanced works to take advantage of any cost savings

from construction in conjunction of the M2PP expressway.

– Priority existing roads crossings at Otaihanga and Te Moana

Interchange

– Minimisation of future traffic disruption

– Years 1 to 2 of LTP

• Stage two – Completion

– Focused on completion of intermediate lengths along the

services corridor and CWB adjacent to the expressway

– Years 2-4 of LTP PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 27: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Stage One

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 28: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Stage Two

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 29: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Advanced Construction

• Stage one

– Extended advanced works

– Focused on completion of the rising main across Waikanae

Expressway Bridge, Patricia Grace Wall to and across Te Moana

Road interchange.

– Provide cost savings and minimisation of future disruption to

traffic and CWB.

– Completes critical links

• Stage two

– Focused on completion of rising main from the Waikanae bridge

south along the CWB services corridor.

– Discussions underway with NZTA

to complete with stage one

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 30: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Stage One

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 31: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Stage Two

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 32: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

LTP Funding

Project /

programme

2015/16

$000

2016/17

$000

2017/18

$000

2018/19

$000

Total

$000 Priority

Dissolved Air flotation (DAF)

renewal 700 - - - 700 Should / Must

Wastewater pipe renewals 500 513 526 541 2,079 Must

Paraparaumu Wastewater

network reconfiguration 300 - - - 300 Must

Waikanae duplicate rising

main 250 717 736 2,378 4,082 Must

Total 1,750 1,230 1,262 2,919 7,161

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 33: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Proposed Funding

Project /

programme

2015/16

$000

2016/17

$000

2017/18

$000

2018/19

$000

Total

$000

Provision

al priority

Dissolved Air flotation (DAF)

renewal 717 717

Defer to year

2

Wastewater pipe renewals 1,262 818 2080 Defer to years

3-4

Paraparaumu Wastewater

network reconfiguration 313 313

Defer to year

2

Waikanae duplicate rising

main 1750 200 2,101 4051

Advance

years 2-3 to

year 1

Total 1,750 1,230 1,262 2,919 7,161

Not net

change to

LTP

PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 34: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Risks

Issue Primary Risk /

Opportunity

Risk Level Value

$000

Defer Dissolved Air

flotation (DAF) renewal to

year two

Exceed current capacity

or failure Low-Medium 700

Defer year 1 and 2 pipe

renewals and spread over

years 3 and 4

Delayed improvement in

performance of

wastewater network. Medium-low 1,000

Defer Wastewater

network reconfiguration to

year two

Delayed operational

performance

improvements

Low 300 PREVIO

US R

EPORT

Page 35: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Draft NZTA– KCDC MOU Version 01, April 06 2016

Page 1 of 13

APPENDIX 2

Memorandum of Understanding Wastewater Pump Station WSP009 Rising Main

between the

New Zealand Transport Agency (NZTA) and the

Kapiti Coast District Council (KCDC)

(“the Parties”)

1. Purpose

The purpose of this Memorandum of Understanding (“MOU”) is to record the guidelines for collaboration between the Parties for the delivery and resourcing necessary to achieve the shared, common goal of the design and installation of the Wastewater Pump Station WSP009 Rising Main (“the Project”).

2. Background

The Mackays to Peka Peka (M2PP) Alliance is a formed entity between New Zealand Transport Agency, The Fletcher Construction Company Limited, Higgins Contractors Limited and Beca Limited. The M2PP Alliance is responsible for the design and construction of NZTA’s SH1 Mackays to Peka Peka Expressway.

KCDC is a local district council within the meaning of the Local Government Act 2002 (“LGA02”). KCDC is responsible for implementing and managing the Council’s 20 year Long Term Plan

Kapiti Coast District Council have allowed in their Long Term Council Community Plan (LTCCP) for the incremental construction of approximately 3.5km length of sewer rising main over the next 3 years. The new rising main will be provided from the Wastewater Pump Station WSP009 at Te Moana Road to the Paraparaumu Wastewater Treatment Plant (south of Otaihanga Landfill).

The preferred alignment of the Wastewater Pump Station WSP009 Rising Main has been confirmed as along the new Mackays to Peka Peka Expressway alignment, predominately within the Cycleway, Walkway and Bridleway path.

The CWB is approximately 18km long and formed to a width of 3m with a 1m grassed verge for equestrians. In rural parts of the district the CWB is constructed from an unbound “Kapiti Blue” rock.

As well as providing for non-motorised road users, the CWB acts as a utility corridor and provides for maintenance access to landscaping and stormwater assets.

Page 36: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Draft NZTA– KCDC MOU Version 01, April 06 2016

Page 2 of 13

3. WSP009 Sewer Rising Main - Separable Portion A

Separable Portion A includes sections of the sewer rising main that is committed to be installed i.e. below local roads, below expressway, Waikanae River Bridge and 510 retaining wall. KCDC currently have $1.75m budget that has been brought forward from future financial years.

M2PP will deliver the scheme design (including consents) and the installation of four sections of Wastewater Pump Station WSP009 Rising Main during the construction of the Mackays to Peka Peka Expressway.

These sections coincide with the following areas in conjunction with utility diversions and expressway construction:

Delivery of scheme design, drawings & consents

M2PP Preliminary and General including but not limited to tender processing, KCDC liaison, design input & project management/site supervision

Sector 440 - Chainage 700 to 818 - Otaihanga Road crossing. (Completed)

Sectors 460/470/480 - Chainage 1960 to 2680 – Construction of Waikanae River Bridge crossing to minimise cost and disruption post bridge completion. Includes wastewater rising main to be sleeved from bridge abutments to cycleways.

Sectors 480/510 - Chainage 2925 to 3025 - The Sector 510 retaining wall – which is a particularly constrained section of the alignment with sensitive stakeholder relationships.

Sector 510 - Chainage 3310 to 3588 Te Moana Road – Section of wastewater rising main crossing under on and off ramps and bridge.

4. WSP009 Sewer Rising Main - Separable Portion B

Subject to funding from NZTA, M2PP will deliver the remaining sections of Wastewater Pump Station WSP009 Rising Main during the construction of the Mackays to Peka Peka Expressway.

Future sections out with the expressway designation i.e. Connection to WWTP and Pump Station will be designed and delivered at a later stage by KCDC.

Sector 430 - Chainage 0 to 700 – Installation from existing sleeve to Otaihanga Road.

Sectors 460 - Chainage 818 to 1960 – Connecting Otaihanga Road to Waikanae River Bridge (South abutment)

Sectors 480/510 - Chainage 2680 to 2925) – Connecting Waikanae River Bridge (North abutment) to 510 retaining wall

Sector 510 - Chainage 3025 to 3310 – Connecting 510 retaining wall to Ta Moana Rd section.

The Parties have decided to formalise their working relationship by entering into this MOU.

Page 37: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Draft NZTA– KCDC MOU Version 01, April 06 2016

Page 3 of 13

5. Statutory Framework

The parties acknowledge that they each have statutory responsibilities, powers and duties, including under the Government Roading Powers Act 1989, the Resource Management Act 1991, the LTMA and the LGA02. While the parties have committed to work together constructively in relation to the matters addressed by this MOU, it is recognised and agreed that this MOU in no way fetters the parties in relation to those statutory responsibilities, powers and duties.

When any approvals or consents are required under this MOU a party will not be acting unreasonably or arbitrarily if it declines its consent or approval, or imposes conditions on any such consent or approval, on the grounds of its statutory responsibilities, powers and duties, provided such grounds are specified in writing at the time.

The parties will not claim from each other any compensation, loss or damage under this agreement if, as a result of the other party having exercised in good faith, its statutory duties, a party is affected in anyway whatsoever.

6. Desired Outcomes

The Parties seek to accelerate the design and installation of the Wastewater Pump Station WSP009 Rising Main within sections of the Mackays to Peka Peka Expressway alignment, avoiding unnecessary costs or disruption to either party. The parties understand that the delivery will be staged in conjunction with the expressway construction.

7. Understanding

The Parties agree to work constructively and collaboratively in relation to the implementation of this MOU and the Project.

KCDC will be responsible for:

Reviewing the detailed designs with input from Aurecon for the Wastewater Pump Station WSP009 Rising Main within the expressway alignment;

Completion of the wastewater rising main hydraulic analysis from Aurecon and confirmation of the air and scour valve locations;

Approving final design drawings to be issued for construction by January 2016;

In conjunction with M2PP Alliance, securing the necessary resource consents, licences and other approvals necessary to enable construction of the wastewater rising main by March 2016;

Leading the collaborative development of project communications messaging with the the Mackays to Peka Peka (“M2PP”) Alliance (“M2PP ALLIANCE”);

M2PP Alliance will be responsible for:

Design and delivery of drawings, details and sections for the Wastewater Pump Station WSP009 Rising Main within the expressway designation. Excluding from a) the Paraparaumu WWTP to the expressway designation and b) from the Wastewater Pump Station WSP009 to the expressway designation;

Preparation and execution of tender documents for the entire scheme for separable portions A & B but excluding WWTP and Pump Station connections..

Preparation and submissions of all consents and permits required on behalf of KCDC for Osbournes Drain

Page 38: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Draft NZTA– KCDC MOU Version 01, April 06 2016

Page 4 of 13

Any consents/permits required during the physical works for the remainder of the sewer rising main will come under the existing M2PP consents/permits for the expressway project;

Procurement of the 400mm & 630mm PE100 SDR17 pipe including all associated fittings and components;

Management, delivery, and commissioning of physical works associated with the installation of the sewer rising main for separable portions A & B;

Delivery of quality documentation and red-line as-built drawings as identified in the design specifications;

Capturing quality assurance documentation.

Initiating and fronting communication with the media.

The Parties agree that M2PP Alliance is an appropriate mechanism to use for delivery of the physical works on behalf of KCDC. The key risks and opportunities

faster initiation by using the existing contract for mobilisation planning in parallel with seeking sub-contractor prices;

faster procurement of the physical works resulting from use of existing preferred supplier arrangements;

greater flexibility within an Alliance to respond to unforeseen changes associated with consenting delays or archaeological finds during construction; and

availability of established community and Iwi engagement team to respond to day to day queries related to construction activities.

8. Key Risks & Opportunities

Risks

KCDC intend to complete the rising main by the end of the 2017/18 financial year (i.e. July 18) at least 18 months after the CWB is opened. It is expected that construction of the rising main would involve temporary closure of sections of the CWB for several months at a time. There is a risk that path users and the community are critical that this work was not undertaken at the same time as the expressway works. The community are unlikely to distinguish between the Transport Agency, KCDC or the M2PP Alliance and in effect the participants of M2PP Alliance share this reputational risk.

Construction of the rising main after the CWB is opened will be more costly (approx. $500k) for KCDC than if completed beforehand. The additional cost associated with later works would be associated with re-instatement of the CWB and associated landscaping. Traffic management would also be required if the rising main were constructed after opening.

Opportunities

Constructing the rising main during or before the CWB is delivered will avoid the need to reinstate landscaping, reinstate environmental controls (sector 480/510), CWB pavement and surfacing resulting in a cost saving opportunity for the Kapiti Coast District Council and mitigating the above reputational risk.

Procurement of PE pipes by M2PP prior to 10% cost increase early in 2016.

Page 39: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Draft NZTA– KCDC MOU Version 01, April 06 2016

Page 5 of 13

9. Scope for Physical Works

The Parties agree to the scope for physical works associated with the delivery of the wastewater rising main as below. Attachment 1 provides the detailed design and layout for the entire KCDC wastewater rising main indicating the areas of pipeline to be installed as part of this MOU.

The scope of works below relates to the delivery of separable portions A & B of the Wastewater Pump Station WSP009 Rising Main as a combination of M2PP Alliance self-delivery and sub-contractor and shall include:

site clearance / preparation;

pot-holing for existing services;

supply & installation of environmental controls;

supply & installation of all dewatering equipment including well pointing;

supply & installation of the 630mm OD PE100 SDR17 sleeves at the Waikanae River Bridge;

supply & installation of the 400mm OD PE100 SDR17 sewer main including butt-fusion welding and pressure testing;

reinstatement of CWB;

temporary pavement works at Otaihanga Road;

temporary traffic management;

supply & installation of temporary scaffolding system to be suspended between the Waikanae River Bridges;

supply and installation of 426mm OD steel pipe across the Waikanae River Bridge complete with all support brackets and ancillaries;

supply & installation of scour and air valves;

The Principal’s Requirements in relation to the physical works will be developed collaboratively by M2PP Alliance and KCDC in parallel with the detailed designs.

The following sections will be delivered using a combination of M2PP self-delivery team and open market tenders:

M2PP Chainage M2PP Sector # Separable Portion

Status as of 11.04.16 Proposed Construction Start

0 to 700 430 B Tender Recommendation April/May 16

700 to 818 440 - Otaihanga Rd

A Contract awarded to Action Civil

Complete

818 to 1960 460 B Tender Recommendation April/May 16

1960 to 2185 460/470 A Sleeve and sewer installed by Goodmans Contractors

Complete

2185 to 2370 470 A Tender Preparation for Bridge Crossing

End October 16

2370 to 2680 470/480 A Sleeve and sewer to be installed by Goodmans

May 16

2680 to 2900 480/510 B Tender Recommendation April/May 16

2900 to 3032 (Retaining Wall)

510 A Tender Recommendation July/August 16 (after wall completion)

3032 to 3310 510 B Tender Recommendation April/May 16

3310 to 3588 510 A Contract awarded to Action Civil

June 16

Page 40: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Draft NZTA– KCDC MOU Version 01, April 06 2016

Page 6 of 13

10. Governance The Parties agree that delivery of the Wastewater Pump Station WSP009 Rising Main will be co-ordinated by a Control Group comprising:

Sean Mallon representing KCDC Group Manager Infrastructure Services

Martyn Cole KCDC Water & Wastewater Asset Manager;

Chris Appleby KCDC Utilities Infrastructure Manager;

Craig Pitchford M2PP Owner Interface Manager

David Rubery, M2PP Alliance Civil Construction Manager

Craig Hiddleston, M2PP Alliance Drainage Manager

The Control Group will manage the delivery of the physical works.

The role of the Control Group in relation to the Project is to manage delivery of the physical works, approve commercial and scope matters, and resolve disputes.

Any physical works contract disputes that cannot be resolved by the Control Group will first be elevated to Neil Walker from the NZ Transport Agency and Patrick Dougherty from Kapiti Coast District Council.

11. Delivery M2PP Alliance are responsible for delivering a fit for purpose detailed design. M2PP Alliance designers will be available to respond to requests for information from the construction team and to provide designer review input to the construction process so that the designer can certify the works as being in general accordance with the design.

12. Key Contacts Key staff and primary points of contact are:

Representing e-mail Phone

KCDC Group Manager Infrastructure Services

[email protected] 027 5555 690

KCDC Water & Wastewater Asset Manager

[email protected] 027 5554 751

KCDC Utilities Infrastructure Manager

[email protected] 027 5555 721

M2PP Owner Interface Manager

[email protected] 027 224 5086

M2PP Civil Construction Manager

[email protected] 027 271 2961

M2PP Drainage Manager [email protected] 027 839 6405

M2PP Communications Manager

[email protected] 027 807 5144

KCDC Communications manager

tbc tbc

13. Commercial Approach This MOU provides the basis of the agreement between KCDC and NZ Transport Agency for delivery of the Wastewater Pump Station WSP009 Rising Main. The M2PP Alliance delivery vehicle is contracted directly to the NZ Transport Agency and will deliver the Wastewater Pump Station WSP009 Rising Main on behalf of KCDC.

Page 41: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Draft NZTA– KCDC MOU Version 01, April 06 2016

Page 7 of 13

The Parties acknowledge that the M2PP Alliance will invoice KCDC directly on a monthly basis for works associated with the Wastewater Pump Station WSP009 Rising Main in accordance with the overall commercial approach outlined below.

The basis of the commercial arrangement is outlined as follows and will be finalised via an exchange of letters as part of the scope, risk register, risk allocation and cost finalisation:

a) A Measure & Value approach will be adopted with M2PP Alliance Project

Management and On-costs applied. The basis comprises:

Measure and Value Contract for sub-contract suppliers.

Competitively secured rates from established Alliance sub-contractor suppliers.

Rates developed for any Alliance self-perform scope, e.g. if pavement surfacing, PE welding or trenching is completed via Higgins (on an open book basis)

Preliminary & General costs will be quantified, priced and recoverable for direct project management & site supervision.

A Risk Register will be developed, for agreement by the Control Group that will identify the owner of each risk and will be used to produce a KCDC Contingency sum that will be managed by the Control Group.

An agreed M2PP Alliance Construction margin of 10% is to be applied on the material supply and installation items.

An agreed M2PP Alliance Design margin of 36% is to be applied to all design and consenting items.

A defects liability period of 12 months.

b) The Parties acknowledge that additional cost, or time relating to design, consenting, expressway construction delays or archaeological finds remain the risk of KCDC.

c) The Parties acknowledge that commercial consideration is required around the risks of quality control, defect management, final handover to KCDC and contractor liabilities/insurances

14. Funding

As Part of the LTCCP, KCDC have a staged budget of $4,100,000.

KCDC budget also includes allowance at either end of the pipeline for connecting to the wastewater treatment plant and pump station. These works are outside the designation and away from local roads.

2015/16 2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 Total

$250,000 $717,500 $ 736,155 $2,378,411 $4,082,066

KCDC have requested to defer a number of projects to free up cash flow to approximately $1.75m (including existing rising main budgets) in 2016/17 to take advantage of the immediate opportunity with M2PP Alliance.

Page 42: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Draft NZTA– KCDC MOU Version 01, April 06 2016

Page 8 of 13

The table shows a rough order of cost of $1.85M to deliver the design, consenting and separable portion A of the physical works including Alliance margins which is to be reimbursed by KCDC.

SEPARABLE PORTION A

SECTION BUDGET COST

TOTAL 1.0 - M2PP ALLIANCE DESIGN & CONSENTS $ 97,277.53

TOTAL 2.0 - M2PP ALLIANCE P & G $ 75,828.16

TOTAL 3.0 - OTAIHANGA ROAD CHAINAGE 670 TO 810 $ 198,529.20

TOTAL 4.0 WAIKANAE RIVER BRIDGE CHAINAGE 1960 TO 2680 $ 914,372.19

TOTAL 5.0 SECTOR 480 CHAINAGE 2680 TO 3310 $ 190,434.72

TOTAL 6.0 TE MOANA ROAD $ 225,172.86

PROJECT SUB-TOTAL $ 1,703,614.66

LESS M2PP PROPORTION (4.1 & 4.4) $ 49,332.00

SUB-TOTAL $ 1,654,282.66

M2PP (HIGGINS/FLETCHERS) OVERHEADS & MARGIN (10%) $ 160,433.71

M2PP (BECA) OVERHEADS & MARGIN ON DESIGN/CONSENTS (36%)

$ 35,739.91

TOTAL CONTRACT COST(Excluding GST): $ 1,850,456.28

Funding would be provided in the short term for Separable Portion B by NZTA, through an increase of $2.1m to the forecast NZTA subsidy. This funding would be recovered by NZTA in 2018/19 through reduced NZTA roading subsidies.

SEPARABLE PORTION B

SECTION BUDGET COST

TOTAL 1.0 - M2PP ALLIANCE P & G $ 64,517.76

TOTAL 2.0 – TENDER P & G $ 120,000.00

TOTAL 3.0 - SECTOR 430 $ 534,805.99

TOTAL 4.0 - SECTOR 460 $ 821,557.07

TOTAL 5.0 – SECTOR 480/510 $ 372,426.33

PROJECT SUB-TOTAL $ 1,703,614.66

M2PP (HIGGINS/FLETCHERS) OVERHEADS & MARGIN (10%) $ 191,330.71

TOTAL CONTRACT COST(Excluding GST): $ 2,104,637.86

Page 43: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Draft NZTA– KCDC MOU Version 01, April 06 2016

Page 9 of 13

The rough order of costs is based on design completion, supplier quotations and from historical market rates from previous M2PP tenders. If construction costs exceed or are expected to exceed the funding allocation KCDC and NZ Transport Agency will together consider how the scope will be changed or additional funding secured.

15. Confidentiality No party will comment on any matters which relate directly or indirectly to the policies, practices or procedures of the other parties. Any other information received relating to matters outside each organisation’s own particular duties shall be subject to the provisions and principles of the Privacy Act 1993 and the parties’ respective obligations to disclose information in accordance with legal or regulatory requirements, including without limitation, the Official Information Act 1982.

16. Disputes The Parties agree to attempt resolution of any disputes in good faith, using this MOU as a benchmark against which each Party can set its approach. If any matter relating to the delivery of the physical works remains unresolved within 10 working days, either party can refer the matter to the Control Group for resolution. If there is failure to reach resolution of any works dispute at the Control Group, or the dispute relates to matters other than the delivery of the physical works, the Parties agree to refer the matter to their respective Chief Executives for resolution. Failing a result in a reasonable time period the parties agree to resolve disputes by mediation or an agreed alternative form of dispute resolution.

For the avoidance of doubt, while any disagreement remains unresolved, the Parties will continue to perform their obligations under this MOU to the extent practicable, but without prejudice to their respective rights and remedies.

17. Amendment This MOU may be amended at any time but only by written agreement of the Parties. Additional funding from NZTA may become available to enable KCDC to complete the remaining portions of the project within the expressway designation.

18. Delegations

The following persons are authorised to make decisions on behalf of their organisations in respect of this MOU: [Sean Mallon (KCDC), and Craig Pitchford (NZTA)]

19. General

This MOU will commence on the date it has been signed by both Parties. This MOU will remain in effect for a nominal period of 2 years or until the joint objectives are achieved, whichever comes first.

The Parties may terminate this MOU at any time by agreement between them.

The Parties may not assign any of their rights and obligations under this MOU without the prior written consent of the other Party.

The Control Group shall develop a handover plan for practical completion and transfer to KCDC.

From the time of each site possession the M2PP Alliance will be responsible for managing site H&S during construction.

20. Costs

Each party will bear its own costs associated with the preparation of this MOU.

Page 44: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Draft NZTA– KCDC MOU Version 01, April 06 2016

Page 10 of 13

21. Signatures

SIGNED for and on behalf of KAPITI COAST DISTRICT COUNCIL by:

Signature: Name: Position: (Under delegated authority) Date:

SIGNED for and on behalf of the NZ Transport Agency by:

Signature: Name: Position: (Under delegated authority) Date

Page 45: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Draft NZTA– KCDC MOU Version 01, April 06 2016

Page 11 of 13

Attachment 1

Sewer Main Location Plans

Rough Order of Costs Breakdown

Page 46: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Draft NZTA– KCDC MOU Version 01, April 06 2016

Page 12 of 13

NOTES:

1. The sewer rising main shown in red is part of this MOU with KCDC secure funding. 2. The sewer rising main shown in yellow are future sections upon KCDC obtaining

additional funding from NZTA.

Chainage 0 to 1960

Page 47: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

Draft NZTA– KCDC MOU Version 01, April 06 2016

Page 13 of 13

Chainage 1960 to 3588

Page 48: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

T

E

M

O

A

N

A

R

D

MACKAYS

Existing SH1

Existing SH1

WAIKANAE

Waterfall RdWaterfall Rd

P

E

K

A

P

E

K

A

R

D

PARAPARAUMU

K

A

P

IT

I R

D

RAUMATI

P

O

P

L

A

R

A

V

E

RAUMATI

SOUTH

M

A

Z

E

N

G

A

R

B

R

D

O

T

A

I

H

A

N

G

A

R

D

PARAPARAUMU

BEACH

WAIKANAE

BEACH

PEKA PEKA

SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SSSS SS SS

SSSS SS

SSSS

SS SSSS SS

SS SSSS SS

SS SSSS

SSSS SS SS

SS SS SS SS SSSS

SS

SS

SSSS

SS SSSS

SSSS SS

SSSS

SSSS

SSSS

SSSS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SSSS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SSSS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SSSS

SS

SS

SSSS

SSSS

SSSS SS SS SS SS SS SS SS SS SS SS SS SS SS SS SS SS SS SS SS SS SS

SSSS SS

SSSS

SS

SS

SSSS SS

SSSS

SSSS

SS SSSS

SS

SHEET No. DESCRIPTION

WAIKANAE RIVER BRIDGE

M2PP-47E-D-DWG-3260 WAIKANAE RIVER BRIDGE WSP009 RISING MAINPLAN AND ELEVATION

M2PP-47E-D-DWG-3261 WAIKANAE RIVER BRIDGE WSP009 RISING MAINLONG SECTION SHEET 1

M2PP-47E-D-DWG-3262 WAIKANAE RIVER BRIDGE WSP009 RISING MAINLONG SECTION SHEET 2

M2PP-47E-D-DWG-3263 WAIKANAE RIVER BRIDGE WSP009 RISING MAINCONNECTION TYPES A AND B DETAILS

M2PP-47E-D-DWG-3264 WAIKANAE RIVER BRIDGE WSP009 RISING MAINRESTRAINT SUPPORT

M2PP-47E-D-DWG-3265 WAIKANAE RIVER BRIDGE WSP009 RISING MAINSUPPORT TYPE C DETAILS

510 RETAINING WALL

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1536 WSP009 RISING MAINRETAINING WALL LAYOUT AND SECTION

N

EXPRESSWAY ALIGNMENT

EXISTING STATE HIGHWAY 1EXISTING STATE HIGHWAY 1

ORIGINAL DRAWING

IN COLOUR

No. AppdRevision Chk.V Date

DO NOT SCALE

* Refer to Revision 1 for Original Signature

Scale (A1)

Scale (A3)Reduced

Dwg Check

Dsg Verifier

Drawn

Original Design

Date

Approved For Project:

IF IN DOUBT ASK.

Title: Drawing No:

Docu

ment

No.

Rev.

Drawing Plotted: 26 Jan 2016 01:04 p.m.

M2PP

-26C

-D-D

WG-

1521

.DW

G

SH1 MACKAYS TO PEKA PEKA

RP 1012/0.00 TO 1023/5.00Document created for NZTA by M2PP Alliance, 43 Ihakara Street, PO Box 723, Paraparaumu 5254.

Construction*

By Chk

EXPRESSWAY

0mm

30

10

20

40

A3 R

EPRO

DUCT

ION

SCAL

E

50

60

20

40

80

100

0mm

A1 R

EPRO

DUCT

ION

SCAL

E

SECTOR 560

DATUM NOTESCOORDINATE DATUM: NZ TRANSVERSE MERCATOR 2000 (NZTM2000)HEIGHT DATUM: WELLINGTON VERTICAL DATUM 1953

1. PROJECT SET OUT USING ELECTRONIC INFORMATION FROMMODELS PROVIDED, UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED.

2. INFORMATION ON DRAWINGS TAKES PRECEDENCE.

3. ANY DISCREPANCIES SHALL BE BROUGHT TO THE ATTENTIONOF THE DESIGNER.

LOCATION PLANN.T.S.

SECTORS 430 TO 510WSP009 WASTEWATER RISING MAIN

CIVIL DRAWINGS

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1521 AWSP009 RISING MAIN

COVER SHEET, LOCATION PLANAND DRAWING LIST

NTS

NTS

K.RIYAZ 26.01.16K.RIYAZ 26.01.16

NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION

DETAILED DESIGN

SHEET No. DESCRIPTION

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1521 WSP009 RISING MAINCOVER SHEET, LOCATION PLAN AND DRAWING LIST

UTILITIES

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1522 WSP009 RISING MAINOVERALL ALIGNMENT SHEET 1

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1523 WSP009 RISING MAINOVERALL ALIGNMENT SHEET 2

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1524 WSP009 RISING MAINCH 0m TO CH 110m PLAN AND LONG SECTION

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1525 WSP009 RISING MAINCH 100m TO CH 400m PLAN AND LONG SECTION

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1526 WSP009 RISING MAINCH 400m TO CH 730m PLAN AND LONG SECTION

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1527 WSP009 RISING MAINCH 710m TO CH 1040m PLAN AND LONG SECTION

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1528 WSP009 RISING MAINCH 1050m TO CH 1385m PLAN AND LONG SECTION

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1529 WSP009 RISING MAINCH 1390m TO CH 1730m PLAN AND LONG SECTION

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1530 WSP009 RISING MAINCH 1730m TO CH 2060m PLAN AND LONG SECTION

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1531 WSP009 RISING MAINCH 2060m TO CH 2390m PLAN AND LONG SECTION

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1532 WSP009 RISING MAINCH 2390m TO CH 2730m PLAN AND LONG SECTION

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1533 WSP009 RISING MAINCH 2730m TO CH 3060m PLAN AND LONG SECTION

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1534 WSP009 RISING MAINCH 3070m TO CH 3320m PLAN AND LONG SECTION

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1535 WSP009 RISING MAINWAIKANAE RIVER BRIDGE DETAILS

SECTORS 430 TO 510

A FOR DETAILED DESIGN KRR

Page 49: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

C

V

C

V

C

V

C

V

C

V

C

V

10100

10000

9900

9800

9700

9600

9500

94009300

9200

9100

9000

8900

8800

8700

8600

8500

8400

8300

8200

<<

<<

<<

<<

<<

<<

<<

<

<

<<

<<

<

<<

<<

<

<<

<<

<<

<<

<<

<<

<<

<<

<<<

SS

SSSS

SS

SS

SSSS

SSSS

SSSS

SSSS SS

SS

SS SS SS SSSS

SSSS

SS

SSSS

SSSS

SSSS

SSSS

SSSS

SS

SS

SS

SSSS

SSSSSSSS

SSSS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS SSSS

SSSS

SS

SS

SSSS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SSSS

SSSS

SSSS

SSSS

SSSS

SSSS

SSSS

SS

SSSS

SSSS

SS

SS

SSSS

SSSSSS

SSSS

SS

SS

SS

SSSSSS

SS

SS

SSSS

SSSS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SSSSSS

SSSS

SSSS

SSSSSS

SS

SS

SS

SS

ORIGINAL DRAWING

IN COLOUR

No. AppdRevision Chk.V Date

DO NOT SCALE

* Refer to Revision 1 for Original Signature

Scale (A1)

Scale (A3)Reduced

Dwg Check

Dsg Verifier

Drawn

Original Design

Date

Approved For Project:

IF IN DOUBT ASK.

Title: Drawing No:

Docu

ment

No.

Rev.

Drawing Plotted: 22 Jan 2016 03:27 p.m.

M2PP

-26C

-D-D

WG-

1522

.DW

G

SH1 MACKAYS TO PEKA PEKA

RP 1012/0.00 TO 1023/5.00Document created for NZTA by M2PP Alliance, 43 Ihakara Street, PO Box 723, Paraparaumu 5254.

Construction*

By Chk

EXPRESSWAY

0mm

30

10

20

40

A3 R

EPRO

DUCT

ION

SCAL

E

50

60

20

40

80

100

0mm

A1 R

EPRO

DUCT

ION

SCAL

E

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1522 AWSP009 RISING MAINOVERALL ALIGNMENT

SHEET 11:2500

1:5000

A McLAUGHLIN 21.01.16

N

NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION

DETAILED DESIGN

A FOR DETAILED DESIGN AMcL

AV01

AV02SV03

AV04

AV03

FUTURE SECTION

SV01

CH40

00

RISING MAIN TO PASSTHROUGH EXISTING600Ø RCRRJ PIPE DUCT

WASTEWATERTREATMENT PLANT

AV00PROVISIONAL

M2PP DWG26C-1524CH0-100

M2PP DWG26C-1525CH100-400

SEPARABLE PORTION B

LOCATIONBY OTHERS

CH30

00

EXISTINGSEWER

SEPARABLE PORTION B

WASTEWATERRISING MAINSS

LEGEND

M2PP DWG26C-1526CH400-730

MATC

HLIN

E - R

EFER

DW

GM2

PP-2

6C-D

-DW

G-15

23

M2PP DWG26C-1527CH710-1040

M2PP DWG26C-1528CH1050-1385

M2PP DWG26C-1529CH1390-1730

Page 50: waikanae duplicate rising main construction advancement

// //

////

////

// // // //

C

V

C

V

C

V

5

1

H

S

D

-2

6

5

1

H

W

1

-2

6

11900

11800

11700

11600

11500

11400

11300

11200

11100

11000

10900

10800

10700

10600

10500

10400

10300

10200

10100

<

<

<

<

<

< <

<

<<

<

<

< <

// //

(Noise Fence)

0.125FENCE

NOTE: THIS REQUIRES MANUAL ADJUSTMENT UNTIL MX ADVISE OF NEW STRING

NOTE: LTSCALE = 1.0

(Noise Fence)

NOTE: LTSCALE = 1.0

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

IL10.0m

IL9.9m

SSSS

SSSS

SSSS

SS

SSSS

SSSS

SSSS SS SS SS

SS SS SS SS SSSS

SS SSSS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

TC 2924.6

R -35.0

CT 2942.7

TC 2949.4

R 35.0

CT 2969.6

TC 2973.8

R 125.0

CT 3014.1 TC 3020.9 R -100.0

CT 3042.4

TC 3047.8

3000

CREST, CH 2988.7

SWSW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SWSW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SW

SWSW

SS

SSSS

SSSS

SSSS

SS

SS

SSSS

SSSS

SS

SSSS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SSSS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SSSS

SS

SSSSSS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SSSS

SS

SS

SS

SSSS

SSSS

SS

SS

SS

SSSS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SSSS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SS

SSSS

SSSS

SS

SS

SS SS SS SS SS SS

ORIGINAL DRAWING

IN COLOUR

No. AppdRevision Chk.V Date

DO NOT SCALE

* Refer to Revision 1 for Original Signature

Scale (A1)

Scale (A3)Reduced

Dwg Check

Dsg Verifier

Drawn

Original Design

Date

Approved For Project:

IF IN DOUBT ASK.

Title: Drawing No:

Docu

ment

No.

Rev.

Drawing Plotted: 22 Jan 2016 03:27 p.m.

M2PP

-26C

-D-D

WG-

1523

.DW

G

SH1 MACKAYS TO PEKA PEKA

RP 1012/0.00 TO 1023/5.00Document created for NZTA by M2PP Alliance, 43 Ihakara Street, PO Box 723, Paraparaumu 5254.

Construction*

By Chk

EXPRESSWAY

0mm

30

10

20

40

A3 R

EPRO

DUCT

ION

SCAL

E

50

60

20

40

80

100

0mm

A1 R

EPRO

DUCT

ION

SCAL

E

M2PP-26C-D-DWG-1523 AWSP009 RISING MAINOVERALL ALIGNMENT

SHEET 21:2500

1:5000

A McLAUGHLIN 21.01.16

N

NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION

DETAILED DESIGN

A FOR DETAILED DESIGN AMcL

MATC

HLIN

E - R

EFER

DW

GM2

PP-2

6C-D

-DW

G-15

22

EXISTING SEWER

SEPARABLE PORTION AEXISTING SEWER

SEPARABLE PORTION B

SEPARABLE PORTION B

SV04

M2PP DWG26C-1530CH1730-2060

SV05

AV05

WAIKANAEBRIDGE

SEPARABLE PORTION B

M2PP DWG26C-1531CH2060-2390

M2PP DWG26C-1532CH2390-2730

M2PP DWG26C-1533CH2730-3060

M2PP DWG26C-1534CH2730-3320

AV07

AV06

SV06

FUTU

RE S

ECTI

ON

AV00

(SUBJECT TO KCDC APPROVAL)

TE MOANAINTERCHANGE

WASTEWATERRISING MAINSS

LEGEND

EXISITNG SEWERSEPARABLE PORTION A(510 RETAINING WALL)