Volunteering and National Parks in...

17
A paper reviewing how more National Parks in Scotland could generate an increase in volunteering – therefore benefiting the local economy, the environment and health and wellbeing of volunteers. REPORT 04 / MARCH 2016 Volunteering and National Parks in Scotland The potential value and benefits of more National Parks in Scotland Author : Graham C. Barrow BA(Hons) MSc MPhil for the Scottish Campaign for National Parks (SCNP) and the Association for the Protection of Rural Scotland (APRS). APRS

Transcript of Volunteering and National Parks in...

Page 1: Volunteering and National Parks in Scotlandaprs.scot/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Volunteering-and-National-Par… · FUTURE NATIONAL PARKS IN SCOTLAND VOLUNTEERING. 2.1 Volunteers

A paper reviewing how more National Parks in Scotland could generate an increase in volunteering – therefore benefiting the local economy, the environment and health and wellbeing of volunteers.

REPORT 04 / MARCH 2016

Volunteering andNational Parks in Scotland The potential value and benefits of more National Parks in Scotland

Author : Graham C. Barrow BA(Hons) MSc MPhil for the Scottish Campaign for National Parks (SCNP) and the Association for the Protection of Rural Scotland (APRS).

APRS

Page 2: Volunteering and National Parks in Scotlandaprs.scot/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Volunteering-and-National-Par… · FUTURE NATIONAL PARKS IN SCOTLAND VOLUNTEERING. 2.1 Volunteers

1.1 Thisisthe4thNationalParkresearchpaperproducedbytheScottishCampaignforNationalParks(SCNP)andtheAssociationfortheProtectionofRuralScotland(APRS).ItfollowsonfromUnfinishedBusiness–aNationalParksStrategyforScotlandpublishedin2013bySCNP/APRSandsubsequentpapersonthesocio-economicbenefitsofNationalParks,parkgovernanceoptionsandthebenefitsofmoreNationalParksforthetouristindustryinScotland.Thispaper,draftedbySCNPBoardmemberGrahamBarrow,presentsthecasethatthedesignationofmoreNationalParksinScotlandwouldgenerateavaluableincreaseinvolunteeractivity,benefittingtheparkenvironment,thelocaleconomyandthehealthandwellbeingoftheindividualsinvolved.

1.2 VolunteeringisbigbusinessandVolunteerScotlandhascalculatedthattheworkcarriedoutbyallvolunteersinScotlandispossiblyworthsome£2.6billionperannum(2014figures).Thisfigureisarrivedatthroughasimplecalculationusingthetimevolunteershavegiventoorganisationsorgroupsmultipliedbytheaverage(median)wage.Butthispurelyfinancialcalculationdoesnotincludetheinvaluablepersonal,social,health,communityandenvironmentalbenefits,whicharelesstangibleanddifficulttomeasureinmonetaryterms.

1.3 NationalParkshave,sincetheircreationinNorthAmericaandtheirarrivalintheUKinthe1950s,stimulatedvolunteeringinarangeofactivities.TheprotectionandmanagementoftheUK’sfinestlandscapesandhabitatscertainlygeneratesastrongsenseofcommitmentinmanypeopleofallagesandtheNationalParkAuthoritiesandassociatedparksupportorganisationspotentiallyhavetheskillsandwherewithaltostimulateandmanagevolunteers.Organisinganddirectingvolunteershaveacost,butthebenefitsoutweighthismanyfold,asthispaperdemonstrates.

1.4 ThispaperseekstoquantifythevalueofadditionalvolunteeringthatafullydevelopedNationalParksysteminScotlandcouldstimulate.Thisisconservativelyestimatedatabout£500,000perannum(seeChapters7and8).ButthisfigurerepresentsonlythevolunteeringthatwouldbemanageddirectlybytheNationalParkAuthoritiesandthereislikelytobeothervolunteeringstimulatedineachnewNationalParkbutmanagedbyothervoluntarybodieswhosupportparkpurposes.

1.Introduction

THESCOTTISHCAMPAIGNFORNATIONALPARKSANDTHEASSOCIATIONFORTHEPROTECTIONOFRURALSCOTLAND

01

FUTURENATIONALPARKSINSCOTLANDVOLUNTEERING

Page 3: Volunteering and National Parks in Scotlandaprs.scot/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Volunteering-and-National-Par… · FUTURE NATIONAL PARKS IN SCOTLAND VOLUNTEERING. 2.1 Volunteers

2.1 VolunteersconductarangeofdifferentactivitiesinNationalParksaroundtheworldandthemaintypesareinoneofsixcategories:

• physicalconstructionandmaintenancetasks

• interpretationandeducationservices

• scientificresearchandmonitoring

• mountainsafetyandrescue

• fundraising,and

• marketingandadministration.

2.2 Physical construction and maintenance tasksarefrequentlycarriedoutbyvolunteersandNationalParkscanoftenhavealoyallocalgrouportheyorganisespecificvolunteerprojects,particularlyinthesummermonths.Commontasksperformedbyvolunteergroupsinclude:

• Footpathconstructionandrepair

• Wallandfencerepair

• Hedgeplantingandlaying

• Treeplanting

• Viewpointconstruction

• Erectionofsignsandway-marks

• Litterclearance

• Pondandrivercourseclearance

• Woodlandmanagementandundergrowthclearance

• Removalofunwantedtreesandbushesfromwetlands.

2.TheworkcarriedoutbyvolunteersinNationalParks

FUTURENATIONALPARKSINSCOTLANDVOLUNTEERING

2.3 MostofthesetasksareorganisedandoverseenbyeithertheNationalPark’sownrangerserviceorbyacompetentorganisationworkingwiththeNationalParkAuthority,suchasTheConservationVolunteers.

2.4 TheLochLomondandtheTrossachsNationalParkhasaVolunteerManagerandhascreatedarangeofvolunteeropportunitiesandthesehavebecomesopopularthatvacanciesarepresentlyfull.TheFriendsofLochLomondandtheTrossachsalsooffervolunteerrolesintheparkareaandthereareahostofotherorganisationswhichofferconservationvolunteeringsuchastheNationalTrustforScotlandatBenLomondandtheRoyalSocietyfortheProtectionofBirdsatWard’sFarm.ItisdifficulttoascertainhowfarnumbersattractedtovolunteerintheseplacespartlydosobecausetheyareinaNationalPark.

2.5 Interpretation and Education servicesarealsoregularlyprovidedbyvolunteersinmanyNationalParks.ForexampleguidedwalksareorganisedbyvolunteerrangersinthePeakDistrictNationalParkinEnglandandeveningtalks,bothwithintheparkandatnearbyclubsandsocieties,areregularlyprovided.

2.6 IntheNorthAmericanNationalParksitiscommontoseetheinformationdeskinthemainvisitorcentrestaffedbyavolunteerfromtheCooperatingAssociation(friend’sorganisation)oftheNationalParkandevents,talksanddemonstrationsareregularlyprovidedbythesevolunteers.

2.7 Scientific Research and Monitoring activityisalsoacommonvolunteertaskwithsurveysofbirdsandotherwildlifeortherecordingofflora,watersampling,trappingofsmallmammalsandmeteorologicalmonitoring.

2.8 ForexampletheOlympicNationalParkinWashingtonState,USAhasrecruitedvolunteerstocarryoutasurveyofthedistributionandactivitiesofmarmots,whilstonDeesideintheCairngormsNationalParkyoungpeoplefromtheBrathayExplorationGrouphaveinrecentyearsbeenmonitoringthewatervolepopulation,withguidancefromlocalstaffoftheNationalTrustforScotland.

THESCOTTISHCAMPAIGNFORNATIONALPARKSANDTHEASSOCIATIONFORTHEPROTECTIONOFRURALSCOTLAND

02

Volunteers working on a pathHelvellyn – Lake District National Park

Page 4: Volunteering and National Parks in Scotlandaprs.scot/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Volunteering-and-National-Par… · FUTURE NATIONAL PARKS IN SCOTLAND VOLUNTEERING. 2.1 Volunteers

2.9 Mountain safety and rescue teamsareoftenstaffedbyvolunteersandmanyoperateserviceswithinthemountainousNationalParksaroundtheworld,suchasthelargevolunteerteambasedinEdaleinthePeakDistrict.

2.10 FundraisingisanotherregularvolunteertaskforNationalParks.TheFriendsofNationalParksorganisationsthataresoactiveinmanyoftheUKNationalParksraisemanythousandsofpoundsperannumforconservationandeducationprojects.

2.11 ArecentexampleinScotlandisthefundraisingthattookplacetoerecttheTomWeirstatueatBalmaha,LochLomond.Thiswasco-ordinatedbyavolunteergroupandraisedover£50,000.

2.12 Marketing and Administrationisanothervolunteeractivitythatoftensuitsoldermembersofthecommunityorthosewithparticularofficeskills.TheofficesoftheCooperatingAssociationsofmanyoftheUSNationalParksarefullofvolunteerswhoarepromotingmemberships,organisingeventsandproducingpromotionalliterature.

FUTURENATIONALPARKSINSCOTLANDVOLUNTEERING

2.13 ThevolunteersformanyofthesetaskscanlivemanymilesfromtheNationalParksthemselvesandwhilstregularvolunteersmaybedrawnfromthelocalpopulation,manyotherscombinethevoluntarytaskswithweekendandlongerleisurebreaks.

2.14 SomeNationalParks,especiallyincountries

withlimitedpopulations,attractinternationalvolunteers,suchastheworkingpartiesthatcarryoutfootpathmaintenanceeverysummerontheThorsmorkareainsouthernIceland(seecasestudybelow).Thesevolunteerscontributetothelocaleconomyandareatypeofworkingholidaytourist.Scotland’sinternationallyrenownedlandscapesandwildlifehavethepotentialtoattractmanyofthesetypesofvolunteers–bringingskills,commitmentandmoneytoScotlandandintotheseruralareas.

Imageslefttoright/clockwise.

VolunteerInformationAssistantsatCanyonRim VisitorCentre,USA.

TheEdaleMountainRescueteaminthePeakDistrict NationalPark,England.

DonorswiththeTomWeirstatue,Balmaha,LochLomond.

Volunteersurveyorsatanarchaeologicalsiteinthe LakeDistrictNationalPark.

THESCOTTISHCAMPAIGNFORNATIONALPARKSANDTHEASSOCIATIONFORTHEPROTECTIONOFRURALSCOTLAND

03

Page 5: Volunteering and National Parks in Scotlandaprs.scot/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Volunteering-and-National-Par… · FUTURE NATIONAL PARKS IN SCOTLAND VOLUNTEERING. 2.1 Volunteers

3.1 RangerserviceshaveanestablishedroleinNationalParksandalltheUKNationalParkshavethem–someboostedbyanactivepoolofvolunteerrangers.RangersarethelinkbetweenthevisitingandlocalpublicandtheNationalParkAuthority.Rangershavelocalknowledgeaboutwhattosee,wheretogoandthewildlifeandhistoryoftheNationalPark.Answeringquestionsfromthepublicanddealingwithlocalcommunitiesareanimportantpartofaranger’sjob.NationalParkrangerslookoutforpotentialproblems,likestilesorsignpoststhatneedattentionandthenworkwithstaffandvolunteerstorepairthem.Theyalsoworktoreduceanyproblematicalissuesbetweenvisitorsandlocalpeopleandfarmersorlandowners.ManyrangerstakeschoolgroupsoutintotheNationalParkandworkwithvolunteerstoruneventsforthepublic.

3.2 Arangerserviceisoftenthefocusforthecreation,managementandpromotionofvolunteeringinaNationalPark.Thecostsofprovidingarangerservicecanbeoffsetmany-foldbythevalueofthevolunteerworkthatiscarriedout.Thevolunteercoordinatorroleisoneofthemostrewardingjobsthatrangerservicesprovide.

3.3 Full-timerangerservicescanalsobeaugmentedbyvolunteerswhocanthemselvescoordinatefurthervolunteersasappropriate.InthePeakDistrictNationalParkinEngland,forexample,thereisanactivevolunteerrangerforce.TheparkrangerserviceinthePeakDistrictprovidesacomprehensivetrainingcoursethatisopentopeoplefromtheageof18whowouldliketobecomevolunteerrangers.Volunteerrangersattendaseriesoftrainingcoursesandthenhavetosignuptoatleast20patrolsorsessionsofactivityperannum–manydomorethanthis.

3.Theimportanceof RangerServices forvolunteers

FUTURENATIONALPARKSINSCOTLANDVOLUNTEERING

THESCOTTISHCAMPAIGNFORNATIONALPARKSANDTHEASSOCIATIONFORTHEPROTECTIONOFRURALSCOTLAND

04Schoolchildren enjoy learning with rangers and volunteers

Page 6: Volunteering and National Parks in Scotlandaprs.scot/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Volunteering-and-National-Par… · FUTURE NATIONAL PARKS IN SCOTLAND VOLUNTEERING. 2.1 Volunteers

4.1 EarlyinthehistoryoftheNationalParkmovementintheUSAandCanadatheconceptoftheCooperatingAssociationemerged.AfterthefoundingoftheUSNationalParksServicein1916severalnot-for-profitorganisationswereformedtosupporteducationalandinterpretativeprogramsandprojectsthatwerenotcoveredbygovernmentfunding,thefirstbeingtheYosemiteAssociationformedin1923.Thesenot-for-profitorganisationsbecameknownas“CooperatingAssociations”by1936,andwereformallyrecognisedbyCongressin1946andgiventaxexemptions.

4.2 HavingavoluntaryorganisationthatsupportstheworkofaNationalParkAuthorityhasnotbeenexactlycopiedintheUKtodate,withmanyofour“Friendsof”NationalParkSocietieshavingtheirrootsinthelobbyingforandprotectionoftheareathatthenbecamedesignatedasaNationalPark.TheirrelationshipwiththeParkAuthorityisthereforeattimesmoredetachedthanbeingadirectsupporteroftheworkoftheAuthority.NeverthelesstheycanencourageasignificantmembershipandpotentiallycarryoutarangeofworkthatsupportsNationalParkpurposes.

4.CooperatingAssociationsandFriendsGroups

THESCOTTISHCAMPAIGNFORNATIONALPARKSANDTHEASSOCIATIONFORTHEPROTECTIONOFRURALSCOTLAND

05

4.3 InScotlandthemostsuccessfulNationalParkfriendsgroupisthatfortheLochLomondandtheTrossachsNationalParkwhichhasagrowingmembershipandanannualturnoverofover£100,000.RecentorcurrentprojectssupportedbytheFriendsofLochLomondandtheTrossachs,manyofwhichinvolvedtheuseofvolunteers,include:

• AcomprehensiveParkGuide

• AbookletwiththeresultsofthefirsteverarchaeologicalsurveyofLochLomond‘sislands

• VideosandDVDsonlocalclansandthespecialqualitiesofthePark

• ARedSquirrelProjectwiththeCowalRedSquirrelGroup

• ImprovementsandsigningontheThreeLochsWay

• FootpathsandinterpretationatBracklinnFalls,Callander

• Way-markingandinformationforwalkersontheRobRoyWay

• HelpingsecurethefutureoftheArdroyOutdoorEducationCentre

• TheproductionofaneducationalinformationpackforthepaddlesteamerMaidoftheLoch.

4.4 FriendsGroupshavethepotentialtoattractfundingfromarangeofsourcesandincreasinglyfromlegacies,sometimesofsignificantsize.ThisisanotherexampleofhowvolunteeractivityinNationalParkscanbenefitthelocaleconomybyattractingfinanceintoalocalruralarea.

FUTURENATIONALPARKSINSCOTLANDVOLUNTEERING

Page 7: Volunteering and National Parks in Scotlandaprs.scot/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Volunteering-and-National-Par… · FUTURE NATIONAL PARKS IN SCOTLAND VOLUNTEERING. 2.1 Volunteers

THESCOTTISHCAMPAIGNFORNATIONALPARKSANDTHEASSOCIATIONFORTHEPROTECTIONOFRURALSCOTLAND

06

5.1 Manyvolunteers,particularlythoseatthestartoftheircareers,arelookingforexperienceandqualificationstohelpthemobtainpaidemployment.VolunteeringwithaNationalParkprojectisanidealwayforsometogetthis

stepup.

5.2 ForexampleTheConservationVolunteers(TCV,formerlyBTCV)carryoutsignificantvolunteerworkintheUKNationalParksinpartnershipwiththeNationalParkAuthoritiesortheNationalTrusts.Theyprovidevolunteerswiththechancetogainskillsandgetrecognitionfortheirwork.

5.3 TCVrunawiderangeofshortcourseseveryyearwithexperiencedinstructorsteachingpracticalskills,suchasbuildingadrystonewall,creatingapondorwoodlandmanagementtasks.TCVofferscoursestoprogressayoungperson’scareer,aspartofseekingacareerchangeintotheenvironmentalsector,aspriorlearningaspartofalargerqualification,orjustforenjoyment.EveryonecompletinganyofthetrainingreceivesanAchievementCertificate,oranAttendanceCertificatefromTheConservationVolunteers.

5.4 TCVScotlandcanofferasuiteofaccreditedlearningopportunities,predominantlyforyoungpeople.TheyarearegisteredcentrewiththeScottishQualificationsAuthority(SQA),NorthernCollegeforFurtherEducation(NCFE)andwithYouthScotland,enablingTCVtodelivertheYouthAchievementandDynamicYouthAwards.TheycanalsoofferLANTRA(landbasedandenvironmentalindustries)accreditedtrainingtoyoungpeoplethroughtheirtrainingprogramme.

5.Training,qualificationsandcareerenhancement

FUTURENATIONALPARKSINSCOTLANDVOLUNTEERING

5.5 Ithasbeensuggestedbysomeinthepastthatvolunteerscantakeworkawayfrompaidemployees,butitisgenerallyacceptedthatthetypesofworkthatvolunteerscarryoutinNationalParkswouldnotbedonewithouttheirvoluntaryeffort.Thereissomeindicationthatintimesofpublicbudgetrestraintthereispressuretogetsometaskscarriedoutbyvolunteersthatwerepreviouslytheroleofpaidstaff.

Page 8: Volunteering and National Parks in Scotlandaprs.scot/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Volunteering-and-National-Par… · FUTURE NATIONAL PARKS IN SCOTLAND VOLUNTEERING. 2.1 Volunteers

6.1 Volunteeringisgoodforpeopleaswellasfortheenvironmentandallseriousevaluativestudieshavecometothisconclusion.Forexamplein2008astudyfortheForestryCommissionandScottishForestryTrustconcluded:

“…volunteersarenotonlymotivatedforenvironmentalreasonsbutalsobythepersonalbenefitstheygainfromtheoutdooropportunitiesandthesocialnatureofenvironmentalactivities.Volunteerslearnnewskillsandmeetotherswhileimprovingtheirhealth,well-beingandqualityoflife.Environmentalvolunteeringoffersarangeofopportunitiestosuitpeoplewithdiverseinterestsandabilities.Theenvironmentprovidesacommonlanguageforallandasharedpurposeindependentofgender,ethnicbackground,age,physicalability,mentalfunctioning,socio-economicstatusorknowledgeofenvironmentalmanagement”

6.2 Theresearch,basedonforestryvolunteersinScotland,concludedthatthehealthbenefitscouldbeclassifiedasfollows:

• BeingOutdoors–freshairandcontactwithnature

• Physical–stamina,strength,fitnessandweightmanagement

• Mental–restoration,calmingandreflective

• Social–meetingpeople,networksandfeelingpartofacommunity

• Spiritual–awe,beautyandwonder.

6.Healthbenefits

FUTURENATIONALPARKSINSCOTLANDVOLUNTEERING

6.3 FocussingonrecentresearchonenvironmentalvolunteeringinCornwall–HarrisonandM.andC.Leyshon(2012)–haveshownthepositivementalandphysicalbenefitsofthistypeofoutdoorvolunteering.Oneoftheirkeyconclusionsis:

“Participationinenvironmentalvolunteerismprovidesaframeworktoproduceextensiveshiftsinpsychologicalandfunctionalstates.Thecontextofenvironmentalvolunteeringisparamounttothisprocess.Throughbeingclosertonaturewithinconstructivesocialinteractionsandactions,participationunitestheduelbenefitsofwellbeingandenvironmentalchangeinasingleaction.Thishasextensiveimplicationsforcommunities,places,peopleandpolitics.Ourstudydemonstratesthatenvironmentalvolunteeringisvitallycapableofimprovinglivesandlivelihoods.”

6.4 Itisnoteasytoputafinancialvalueonthehealthbenefitsofcountrysidevolunteeringbutitclearlyhasasignificantroletoplayinpreventingsomephysicalandmentalillnessesandhelpingotherstorecover.Theriseofobesityisoneobviousareawherethephysicalworkofconservationvolunteeringhasrelevance.

6.5 ArecentNHSReport(2012)hasestimatedthatforjustfiveconditions(Post-menopausalbreastcancer,lowergastro-intestinalcancer,cerebro-vasculardisease,cardio-vasculardiseaseandtype2diabetes).inoneyearalone,theburdenofphysicalinactivityintheUKcausedover35,000deaths,3.1%ofmorbidityandmortalityintheUKandaddedover£1.06billiontothedirecthealthcostburdenontheNHS.

6.6 MoreNationalParksinScotlandcouldprovidetheadministrativeframeworkandstimulusforagrowthintheopportunitiesforcountrysidevolunteeringandmakeapositivecontributiontothephysicalandmentalwellbeingoftheScottishpopulation.

THESCOTTISHCAMPAIGNFORNATIONALPARKSANDTHEASSOCIATIONFORTHEPROTECTIONOFRURALSCOTLAND

07

Page 9: Volunteering and National Parks in Scotlandaprs.scot/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Volunteering-and-National-Par… · FUTURE NATIONAL PARKS IN SCOTLAND VOLUNTEERING. 2.1 Volunteers

FUTURENATIONALPARKSINSCOTLANDVOLUNTEERING

7.1 ThispaperhasalreadyshownthatthevalueofvolunteeringactivitiesinNationalParkscannotbesimplydescribedinfinancialterms,asthereareclearbenefitstotheenvironmentandtoindividuals,whichcannoteasilybequantified.Neverthelessitispossibletomakesomeestimationsofthevalueofthevolunteeractivityintermsofthecostofprovidingtheservicesiftheyhadhadtohavebeenpurchased.

7.2 DEFRA(2012)carriedoutanassessmentofthebenefitsoftheNationalParksinEnglandandwithinthatstudylookedatthevalueofvolunteertime.Table1quotesthreeexampleswithdatafrom2008/9.

7.3 ThereisacostinprovidingthevolunteeropportunitiesandinthePeakDistrictthiswasestimatedat£228,450meaningthatthepostivecost-benefitratiowasabout3to1.

7.Thevalueofwork

7.4 TheLakeDistrictNationalParkAuthorityrecorded4,669volunteerdaysin2013/14whichcouldbevaluedatleast£212,440–applyingtheminimumwageof£6.50perhour.TheseareonlythevolunteersworkingdirectlytotheNationalParkAuthorityanddonotincludethevolunteertimeofthoseworkingonprojectsintheNationalParkfortheNationalTrust,WildlifeTrustsandothercountrysideorganisations,whichareextensive.

7.5 Inadditiontothedirectvalueoftheworkthereisalsothelesseasytoquantifyvaluetoboththeenvironmentandtotheindividualshealthandwell-being.EncouragingactiveparticipationincountrysidevolunteeringactivitywillhaveapositiveeffectonreducingcoststotheScottishhealthservices.

THESCOTTISHCAMPAIGNFORNATIONALPARKSANDTHEASSOCIATIONFORTHEPROTECTIONOFRURALSCOTLAND

08

Table1

Dartmoor PeakDistrict Northumberland NumberofVolunteerdaysin2008/9 2,140 10,116 1,250

Numberofvolunteerhours 14,980 70,812 8,750(assuming 7 hour days)

Valueofvolunteersusing £165,229 £781,056 £96,518UKhourlypayrates

Valueofvolunteersusing £88,831 £419,915 £51,888minimumwagerates

Source:DEFRA(2012)

Page 10: Volunteering and National Parks in Scotlandaprs.scot/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Volunteering-and-National-Par… · FUTURE NATIONAL PARKS IN SCOTLAND VOLUNTEERING. 2.1 Volunteers

8.1 ItisreasonabletosurmisethatthecreationofeachnewNationalParkinScotlandwouldcreateanincreaseinvolunteeringopportunitiesandparticipation.Notallofthisvolunteeractivitywouldbenewvolunteering,assomemaybedisplacedfromothervolunteeractivitiesinthisfieldorinthesamegeographicalarea.ButtheexperienceofboththeLochLomondandtheTrossachsandtheCairngormNationalParksindicatesthatanewNationalParkAuthoritywillencourageanincreaseinvolunteeractivity.

8.2 TherewouldbeadvantagesinthisincreasedvolunteeringbothforScottishpeopleandforthelocalenvironment.TheattractionofvolunteersfromoutwithScotlandwouldalsobeofvalue–particularlyintheremoterruralareas–asthiswouldbringabenefittotheeconomythroughatypeofworkingholidaytourism.

8.3 Table2estimatestheamountandvalueoftheextravolunteeringthatcouldbegeneratedbyeachoftheproposednewNationalParkssuggestedintheSCNP/APRSNationalParks

8.HowmoreNationalParks inScotlandcould stimulatevolunteering

THESCOTTISHCAMPAIGNFORNATIONALPARKSANDTHEASSOCIATIONFORTHEPROTECTIONOFRURALSCOTLAND

09

StrategyforScotlandreport(2013).Thefiguresareconservativeestimatestotakeintoaccountsomedisplacedvolunteeractivity.TheyarebasedontheamountofvolunteeractivitygeneratedbyotherNationalParkAuthoritiesintheUK,withaconsiderationofthegeographicalremotenessandsizeofthelocaldaytrippopulationfortheproposedNationalParksinScotland.

8.4 TheseestimatesindicatethattheoverallvalueofthevolunteeringcreatedbythefulldevelopmentofthesevennewNationalParksinScotlandproposedbySCNP/APRScouldbeintheregionof£500,000p.a.SomeoftheorganisationofthisvolunteeringcouldbetackledcentrallyshouldaScottishNationalParksServicebecreated,althoughtherewouldalmostinevitablybetheneedforlocalsupervisionandorganisationineachparkarea.

8.5 Theaboveestimatesdonotincludethesignificantvalueoftheworktothevolunteersthemselvesandtotheenvironment,bothofwhichareverydifficulttoquantifybutcouldincreasethetruevalueofthevolunteeractivitybytwoorthreefold.

FUTURENATIONALPARKSINSCOTLANDVOLUNTEERING

(1)Overnightstaysofvolunteersvaluedat£50aday/nighttolocaleconomy(2)Grossvaluecalculatedat£70perday(£10perhour)forvolunteertime(3)Costsestimatedat30%ofoverallgrossvalue(stafftimeandoverheads)(4)Valueofworkpluslocaleconomicvalueofovernightstaysminuscostsofprovision.

Table2:ThePotentialValueofVolunteeringintheproposedNationalParksinScotland

Proposed Annualdays %of Numberof Valueof Grossvalue Costof TotalvalueNational ofvoluntary volunteering days nightstays ofvolunteer voluntary ofvolunteeringPark activity involving overnight tolocal work.p.a. provision tothearea nightstays stays economyp.a.(1) p.a.(2) p.a.(3) p.a.(4)

Galloway 2000 20 400 £20,000 £140,000 £42,000 £118,000

Cheviots 750 20 150 £7,500 £52,500 £15,750 £44,250

Nevis 1500 40 600 £30,000 £105,000 £31,500 £103,500GlenCoeBlackMount

Coastal 1000 50 500 £25,000 £70,000 £21,000 £74,000Marine

GlenAffric 750 30 225 £11,250 £52,500 £15,750 £48,000

WesterRoss 750 40 300 £15,000 £52,500 £15,750 £51,750

Harris 500 60 300 £15,000 £35,000 £10,500 £39,500

TOTALS 7250 2475 £123,750 £507,500 £152,250 £479,000

Page 11: Volunteering and National Parks in Scotlandaprs.scot/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Volunteering-and-National-Par… · FUTURE NATIONAL PARKS IN SCOTLAND VOLUNTEERING. 2.1 Volunteers

9.1 NationalParksgeneratevolunteeringopportunitiesthroughthestimulusandorganisationalframeworkoftheNationalParkAuthorities.ThecreationofmoreNationalParksinScotlandwouldcreateagrowthinvolunteeringintheseareas.

9.2 EncouragingmorevolunteeringintheNationalParkareaswouldbeofbenefittotheenvironment,totheindividualswhovolunteerandtosomeextenttothelocaleconomy.

9.3 Volunteeropportunitiesinremoteruralareasattractsatypeofworkingtourist,bringingwiththemtheeconomicbenefitsoftheirspending,especiallyiftheystayovernightforsomedays.

9.4 ThispaperhasestimatedthatthevalueoftheworkthatcouldbestimulatedbydevelopingallsevenofthenewNationalParksrecommendedintheUnfinishedBusiness–AParksStrategyforScotlandreportcouldbewortharound

£0.5millionperannumplusthehealthbenefitstothosetakingpartandanassociatedreductionincoststotheHealthServices.AdditionalvolunteeringwouldalsobestimulatedbutorganisedbyvoluntarybodiesintheNationalParkareas.

FUTURENATIONALPARKSINSCOTLANDVOLUNTEERING

9.Conclusions

THESCOTTISHCAMPAIGNFORNATIONALPARKSANDTHEASSOCIATIONFORTHEPROTECTIONOFRURALSCOTLAND

10Glen Nevis

Page 12: Volunteering and National Parks in Scotlandaprs.scot/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Volunteering-and-National-Par… · FUTURE NATIONAL PARKS IN SCOTLAND VOLUNTEERING. 2.1 Volunteers

TheLakeDistrictNationalParkAuthorityhasaround500registeredvolunteersfromallwalksoflife.Theygivetheirtime,skillsandenergytohelplookafterthelandscape,enablevisitorstoenjoyitsspecialqualitiesandsupportthewiderworkoftheNationalParkAuthority.In2013/14itwasestimatedthatthesevolunteersgave4,669volunteerdays.Thecostsoforganisingthevolunteersresultedinover3timesthatfigureinthecalculatedvalueoftheirwork.

Volunteershavetobeaged16orover,andthereisnoupperagelimit.TheNationalParkAuthorityalsorunaYoungRangerprogrammeforyoungpeopleaged14to18whoarekeentogetinvolvedwithveryhandsonpracticalvolunteering.

Volunteersarerecruitedintomanydifferentroleswithvaryingtimecontributions–rangingfromonedayforoneoffactivitiessuchasmarshallingevents,to20daysayearforsomeofthemorespecialistroleslikeLakeRangers.

Park Management VolunteersarerecruitedwhentheParkAuthorityhavetasksforthemtodo,andintorolesthatmatchvolunteers’skills,knowledge,experienceandmotivation.Volunteer Events and Guided Walk LeadersarealsousedbytheParkAuthority.Archaeology Volunteershavealsobeenrecruitedwhentherearespecificprojectsandarchaeologicalevents.

APPENDIX

SomeexperiencefromelsewhereLAKEDISTRICTNATIONALPARK,ENGLAND

APPENDIX1

The Lake District Young Rangersprogrammefor14to19yearoldsishelpingtotransformthelivesoffuturegenerationsandhelpingthemcarefortheLakeDistrictlandscape.WorkingalongsideNationalParkstaff,volunteersandpartners,theydevelopamonthlyprogrammeofactivitiessuchaspracticalconservationtasksandrecreationalactivities.

TheBrockholeCentreandCountryParkmanagedbytheNPAalsohasarangeofvolunteerprogrammes.Theseare:

• Anew Family Ranger programme helpsfamiliesdiscover,exploreandconservethecountryparkarea.ThevolunteersarethemainpointofcontactforallFamilyRangeractivities,fromlakeshorelitterpickstopracticalconservationtasks,liaisingwiththeleadersandcoordinatingattendance.Thevolunteersmaybeaskedtoleadactivitiessuchasponddippingorsimpleguidedtrails.

• Wayfinder volunteersarebasedatWaterheadandBownessBaypiers,onedayamonth,greetingvisitorswhoaretravellingonWindermereLakeCruisesboatsandencouragingthemtovisitBrockhole.

• Brockhole Ambassadorshelpoutonweekends

andduringschoolholidaystoensurethatvisitorstoBrockhole,VisitorCentrehaveaworldclassvisitorexperience.TheywelcomvisitorsandgivethemtheinformationtomakethemostoftheirvisitalongwithothertaskssuchasdrivingtheBrockmobileandhelpingwithcrazygolfhire.Thevolunteersalsogetinvolvedwithmanyofthespecialeventstakingplacethroughouttheseason.

• Garden and Ground Maintenance VolunteersplayakeypartinmaintainingthegardensandgroundsatBrockholebycompletingtaskssuchasplanting,paintingandwallrepairs.

Formoreinformationsee: www.lakedistrict.gov.uk/caringfor/volunteering

THESCOTTISHCAMPAIGNFORNATIONALPARKSANDTHEASSOCIATIONFORTHEPROTECTIONOFRURALSCOTLAND

11

Page 13: Volunteering and National Parks in Scotlandaprs.scot/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Volunteering-and-National-Par… · FUTURE NATIONAL PARKS IN SCOTLAND VOLUNTEERING. 2.1 Volunteers

Project Tongariro(TongariroNaturalHistorySocietyInc)wasestablishedin1984topromoteawiderunderstandingofthenaturalprocessesandhumanhistoryofTongariroNationalPark.TheSocietywasendowedwithasubstantialMemorialFundinmemoryofseveralparkstaffwhodiedinahelicopteraccidenton9December1982.

ProjectTongariroisdevotedtoimplementingawidevarietyofprojectsandactivitieswhichhelppeopletounderstandandappreciatethespecialplaceTongariroNationalPark,adualworldheritagepark,hasintheworld.

WorkinginpartnershipwiththeDepartmentofConservation(DOC),ProjectTongariro’svisionistopromoteawiderknowledgeandunderstandingoftheflora,fauna,geology,climateandthenaturalandhumanhistoryofTongariroNationalParkinparticularandtoconservationingeneral.AdeeprespectforNewZealand’swildplacesandrecognitionoftheintangiblespiritualvaluesassociatedwiththemunderliesthisvision.

Theirworkfocusesonfourkeyprojectareas:biodiversity,history,educationandrecreation.ProjectsintheParkhaverangedfromongoingpestcontrolwork,therestorationoftheHapuawhenuaViaduct,initiatingtheTussockTraverseevent,totheproductionoftheTongariroAlpineCrossingPocketRangerApp.

ThepublicareencouragedtoasupporttheProjectbybecomingamember,adoptingahectareatLakeRotopounamuormakingadonation.Theyofferopportunitiesforpeopletogethandsonwithconservationasvolunteers,goonmembers’fieldtripstolittle-knownpartsoftheParkorsupportprojectsbymakingafinancialcontribution.In2013/14theprojecthadthreefulltimestaffwith279voluntarymembersand808supporters.Thevolunteerscarriedoutanestimated625persondaysofworkwhichwasvaluedat$93,750.Theorganisationhadanincomeof$210,000whichincludedagrantfromtheDOC.

ThisvolunteerbodyhasmanyofthecharacteristicsofaCooperatingAssociationaspioneeredbytheUSANationalParks.

Formoreinformationsee:www.tongariro,org.nz

SomeexperiencefromelsewhereTONGARIRONATIONALPARK,NEWZEALAND

APPENDIX1

THESCOTTISHCAMPAIGNFORNATIONALPARKSANDTHEASSOCIATIONFORTHEPROTECTIONOFRURALSCOTLAND

12

Page 14: Volunteering and National Parks in Scotlandaprs.scot/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Volunteering-and-National-Par… · FUTURE NATIONAL PARKS IN SCOTLAND VOLUNTEERING. 2.1 Volunteers

APPENDIX1

The Thórsmörk trail volunteer programmewasestablishedbyIceland’sForestServicein2012.ItsmainroleistoassistwiththemaintenanceofthehikingtrailsinThórsmörkandGoðaland.Theprogrammewasestablishedinresponsetothegrowingneedforpracticalmaintenanceworkinthearea.Threevolunteerteamsareactivethroughoutthesummermonths.Aswellasongoingmaintenancetasks,animportantpartoftheirworkisthedevelopmentofnewtechniquesfortrailconstructionanderosioncontrol.

Althoughtheprogrammeisyoung,themanagementteamhasover15yearsexperienceofmaintaininghikingtrailswithvolunteerteamsonsitesthroughoutIceland.VolunteersworkalongsidestaffandtrainersfromtheForestService.Theworkisinthreeareas–trailmaintenance,trailmappinganderosioncontrol.

Theycurrentlyhostabout50internationalvolunteerseachseason.Volunteersareselecteddirectlyfromapplicationsandnonotpayaparticipationfee.Theyarecommittedto“freevolunteering”butareprovidedwithfoodandcampingbarntypeaccommodation.

ThemajorityofthevolunteerscometoIcelandfromEuropeandNorthAmerica.TheyareonaformofworkingholidayandmakeacontributiontothelocaleconomyofIceland.SomecombinetheirvolunteeringwithalongerholidayinIceland.

Formoreinformationsee:www.trailteam.is

THORSMORKTRAILVOLUNTEERS,ICELAND

A typical group of Thorsmork Trail volunteers

Volunteers being briefed at Thorsmork before a days work

Someexperiencefromelsewhere

THESCOTTISHCAMPAIGNFORNATIONALPARKSANDTHEASSOCIATIONFORTHEPROTECTIONOFRURALSCOTLAND

13

Page 15: Volunteering and National Parks in Scotlandaprs.scot/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Volunteering-and-National-Par… · FUTURE NATIONAL PARKS IN SCOTLAND VOLUNTEERING. 2.1 Volunteers

Unfinished Business – A National Parks Strategy for Scotland.

ScottishCampaignforNationalParksandAssociationfortheProtectionofRuralScotland(2013).

Volunteer Management in European Parks

ResearchonimpactofvolunteeringinEuropeanprotectedareas.

JohnThomson,EuroparcConsulting(2013).

Environmental volunteering: motivations, barriers and benefits.

ReporttotheScottishForestryTrustandForestryCommission.

LizO’Brien,MardieTownsendandMatthewEbden,(July2008).

Environmental Volunteering

FosteringWellbeingforPeople,PlacesandCommunities.

R.Harrison,M.LeyshonandC.Leyshon(2012).

National Parks.

Assessmentofbenefits–workingpaper.

DEFRA(2011).

Let’s Get Moving – A physical activity care pathway.

NHS(2012).

REFERENCES

FUTURENATIONALPARKSINSCOTLANDVOLUNTEERING

THESCOTTISHCAMPAIGNFORNATIONALPARKSANDTHEASSOCIATIONFORTHEPROTECTIONOFRURALSCOTLAND

14

Page 16: Volunteering and National Parks in Scotlandaprs.scot/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Volunteering-and-National-Par… · FUTURE NATIONAL PARKS IN SCOTLAND VOLUNTEERING. 2.1 Volunteers

National Parks recommended by SCNP and APRS 2013

MapreproducedbypermissionofOrdnanceSurvey,licencenumber100053751.*ForlayoutpurposestheShetlandIslandsarenotshowninthecorrectgeographicalposition.

Page 17: Volunteering and National Parks in Scotlandaprs.scot/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Volunteering-and-National-Par… · FUTURE NATIONAL PARKS IN SCOTLAND VOLUNTEERING. 2.1 Volunteers

If you would like further information on the activities of the Scottish Campaign for National Parksplease contact :John Thomson – Secretaryemail [email protected] visit the website www.scnp.org.uk

GOT A QUESTION? – GET IN TOUCH

For information on the activities of theAssociation for the Protection of Rural Scotlandplease contact :John Mayhew – Directoremail [email protected] visit the website www.aprs.scot

design / Stone Circle / e: [email protected] – Glen Nevis ©SNH