Voltolini 2013_The Content of a Seeing-As Experience

8/13/2019 Voltolini 2013_The Content of a Seeing-As Experience

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/voltolini-2013the-content-of-a-seeing-as-experience 1/23

"#$#%&' ()*+#), -,+ .,/#)'"#( 0,"/'),)&, -# 1%&,&#2'

'))( 345 )6/,"( 7

8'9: ;7<

= >#",)?, @)#$,"%#&A 0",%% B C#%&D,%#% B 7E;F7G B HHH:I68",%%:2(/E'#%&D,%#% B 4..J ;FG<*KLMM

ND, O()&,)& (I ' .,,#)9*C% 1P8,"#,)2,

C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#

7: !"#$%&'(#)%"

@)-(6Q&,-+A5 ') '/Q#96(6% I#96", 8"(/8&% ' 8D,)(/,)'+ -#II,",)2, #) (),R% ,P8,"#*

,)2, (I #& #)%(I'" '% &D, I#96", 6)-,"9(,% ' S,%&'+& %H#&2D5 #:,:5 #& #% %,,) )(H (), H'A5

6)-," ' 2,"&'#) '%8,2&5 )(H ')(&D," H'A5 6)-," ')(&D," '%8,2&: >(" %6",5 /(",($,"5

&D#% 8D,)(/,)'+ -#II,",)2, #% /'&2D,- QA ' -#II,",)& -,%2"#8&#() (I %62D ,P8,"#,)2,%T

H, %'A &D'& &D, I#96", #% )(H %,,) '% * (,$#*)" #-)".5 )(H %,,) '% *"%#-,$ #-)".: J(H

&D, U6,%&#() #%5 -(,% &D#% 8D,)(/,)'+ -#II,",)2, ",'++A 2("",%8()- &( ') )"#,"#)%"*/ -#I*

I,",)2,5 #) &D, %,)%, &D'& &D,", ",'++A #% ' -#II,",)2, #) #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& I(" &D, -#I*

I,",)& %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% #)$(+$,- #) '+&,")'&#$,+A 9"'%8#)9 (), ')- &D, %'/, '/Q#9*

6(6% I#96",5 #) ' )6&%D,++T '", %62D ,P8,"#,)2,% -#II,",)& ,P8,"#,)2,% %0 V

.(*2'++,- *"#)1)"#,"#)%"*/)2#2 ),9'&#$,+A ')%H," &D#% U6,%&#()T '& +,'%& #) %(/, 2'%,%5

)( #)&,)&#()'+ -#II,",)2, /'&2D &D, 8D,)(/,)(+(9#2'+ -#II,",)2, '& %&'W, X2I: 0,'2(2W,

Y7ZKG[\ ]'28D,"%() Y;FFM[\ J#2W,+ Y;FF^[_: `) &D, (&D," D')-5 )"#,"#)%"*/)2#2 9#$, ' 8(%*

#&#$, ')%H," &( &D'& U6,%&#(): 3,*4 #)&,)&#()'+#%&% +#/#& &D,/%,+$,% &( %'A &D'& &D,",

a6%& #% ' 2("",%8()-,)2,5 ' /,", 2(*$'"#'&#()5 Q,&H,,) &D, 8D,)(/,)(+(9A ')- &D, #)*

&,)&#()'+#&A (I ' %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,T )( -#II,",)2, #) &D, 8D,)(/,)(+(9A H#&D(6& '

-#II,",)2, #) &D, #)&,)&#()'+#&A (I %62D ') ,P8,"#,)2,: 5#$%". #)&,)&#()'+#%&% "'&D," %'A&D'& %62D ' 2("",%8()-,)2, #% ') #-,)&#&AT &D, -#II,",)2, #) 8D,)(/,)'+ 2D'"'2&," Q,*

&H,,) &H( %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% (I &D, %'/, I#96", #% 6&&,"+A 2'8&6",- QA &D,#" D'$#)9 '

-#II,",)& #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&7: b,& #)-,8,)-,)&+A (I &D, -#%&#)2&#() Q,&H,,) H,'W ')-

%&"()9 #)&,)&#()'+#%/5 &D, #)&,)&#()'+#%& '88"('2D D'% Q,,) /(-6+'&,- #) &H( I6"&D,"

7 >(" &D#% -#II,",)2,5 2I: O"'), X;FF7_T KG*K<:



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;7M


H'A%: C22("-#)9 &( (%"(,;#'*/ #)&,)&#()'+#%&%5 &D, #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& (I ' %,,#)9*'% ,P*

8,"#,)2, #% 2()2,8&6'+T -#II,",)& 2()2,8&% 2()%&#&6&, &D, -#II,",)& #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&%

/(Q#+#?,- QA -#II,",)& %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% (I ') '/Q#96(6% I#96",;: <%"1(%"(,;#'*/

#)&,)&#()'+#%&% "'&D," &D#)W &D'& &D, 2()&,)& (I ' %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, HD(%, 8D,)(/,*

)'+ 2D'"'2&," ,#&D," %68,"$,),% () (" #% #-,)&#2'+ H#&D #& #% )()*2()2,8&6'+5 #& #% )(&

/'-, (I 2()2,8&% X2I: c'9)(H Y;F77[\ `"+')-# Y;F77[\ 0,'2(2W, Y7ZZ;[\ d'I&(8(6+(%

Y;FFZ\ ;F77[\ NA, Y7ZZ<[_G:

b,& #)&,)&#()'+#%&% /'A -,$,+(8 ' I6"&D," &D,(",&#2'+ 8(%%#Q#+#&A &D'& 2(/Q#),% &D,

'Q($, &H( (),%: .(/, %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% D'$, ' 8D,)(/,)'+ 2D'"'2&," &D'& #% /,",*

+A /'&2D,- QA ' )()*2()2,8&6'+ #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&5 HD#+, %(/, (&D," %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#*

,)2,% D'$, ' 8D,)(/,)'+ 2D'"'2&," &D'& #% '+%( /'&2D,- QA ' 2()2,8&6'+ #)&,)&#()'+2()&,)&: 4) HD'& I(++(H%5 4 H#++ 8(%#&#$,+A ,P8+(", &D#% 8(%%#Q#+#&A5 QA '&&,/8&#)9 &( %D(H

&D'& #& #% 9"(6)-,- #) &D, I'2& &D'&5 6)+#W, &D, I("/," %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,%5 &D, +'&&,"

%,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% '", ;)(#%$)*/ ,P8,"#,)2,%: 4) (&D," &,"/%5 &D, ,P8,"#,)2,% &D'&

2()2,") ') '/Q#96(6% I#96", #) &D, +'&&," 2'%, '", (I &D, %'/, W#)- '% &D, ,P8,"#,)2,%

H, ,)&,"&'#) HD,) H, 8,"2,#$, 8#2&6",%5 Q(&D %#/8+, 8#2&("#'+ ",8",%,)&'&#()% +#W, ("-#*

)'"A %)'8%D(&% ')- 2D#+-#%D %W,&2D,% ')- 2(/8+,P 8#2&("#'+ ",8",%,)&'&#()% +#W, -"'H#)9

')- 8'#)&#)9%\ H#&D ",%8,2& &( &D, #)$(+$,- I#96",5 H, %#/8+A ",-(6Q+, &D, ,P8,"#,)2,

&D'& #) 8#2&("#'+ 2'%,% )("/'++A5 Q6& )(& '+H'A%5 #% a6%& ' %#)9+, (),: ](", 8",2#%,+A5 #) '

)("/'+ 8#2&("#'+ ,P8,"#,)2,5 #) %,,#)9 &D, /'&,"#'+ (Qa,2& %D, I'2,%5 &D, 8,"2,#$," '+%(

D'% ') ,P8,"#,)2, (I ')(&D," %(/,&D#)9 &D'& #% )(& &D,",: eD,",'% #) %62D %,,#)9*'% ,P*

8,"#,)2,%5 #) '9'#) %,,#)9 &D, /'&,"#'+ (Qa,2& %D, I'2,%5 &D, 8,"2,#$," '+%( D'% -#II,",)&

,P8,"#,)2,% (I %(/, -#II,",)& %(/,&D#)9% &D'& '", )(& &D,",: 4) &D#% ",%8,2&5 HD,) H,

%,, ') '/Q#96(6% I#96", %62D '% &D, I'/(6% c'%&"(HR% -62W*"'QQ#& I#96",5 H, '", #) &D,

$,"A %'/, 8",-#2'/,)& '% HD,) H, %,, ') '/Q#96(6% 8'#)&#)95 +#W, ,:9: ') C"2#/Q(+-(R%

; N"'-#&#()'++A5 2()2,8&6'+ #)&,)&#()'+#%/ #% '%2"#Q,- &( e#&&9,)%&,#) X;FFZ

L_: 4) 8(#)& (I I'2&5

/')A U6(&'&#()% QA e#&&9,)%&,#) '% ",9'"-% &D, 8,"2,8&#() (I '/Q#96(6% I#96",% 9( #) &D#% -#",2*&#()T ,:9:5 f.( H, #)&,"8",& #&5 ')- 2,, #& '% H, )"#,$;$,# #&g XY;FFZ

L[T h 77M_5 f&D, +#9D&#)9 68 (I ')

'%8,2& %,,/% D'+I $#%6'+ ,P8,"#,)2,5 D'+I &D(69D&g XY;FFZL[T h 7LF_: b,& '% H, H#++ %,, +'&,"5 e#&&*

9,)%&,#)R% '2&6'+ 8(%#&#() #% /(", '"&#26+'&,- ')- 2+(%," &( &D, 8(%#&#() 4 H#++ D,", -,I,)-: O()*

2,8&6'+ #)&,)&#()'+#%/5 /(",($,"5 #% -,I,)-,- QA &D(%, HD( ,%8(6%, ' &D,("A*+'-,) 2()2,8&#()

(I 8,"2,8&#() ("5 HD#2D '2&6'++A '/(6)&% &( &D, %'/, &D#)95 Q,+#,$, #) 2#$%". 2(9)#&#$, 8,),&"'*

Q#+#&A H#&D ",%8,2& &( 8,"2,8&#() #) 9,),"'+5 &D, #-,' &D'& 8,"2,8&#() D'% ' 2()2,8&6'+ 2()&,)&:

>(" ' ",2,)& -,I,)%, (I &D#% #-,'5 2I: OD6"2D+')- X7ZKZ_:G C+&D(69D J')'A X;F7F\ ;F77_ -(,% )(& ,P8+#2#&+A +'Q,+ D#% 8(%#&#() '% )()*2()2,8&6'+#%&5 #& )'&6*

"'++A I'++% 6)-," )()*2()2,8&6'+#%/:



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;7^


8'#)&#)95 #) HD#2D H, ",-68+#2'&, &D, W#)- (I ,P8,"#,)2, H, ,)&,"&'#) HD,) H, ,)a(A

i,()'"-(R% =%"* >)2* (" 3,+'?U6,%R >*2 =,")"*2\ &D'& #%5 H, D'$, &H( 8#2&("#'+ ,P8,"#*

,)2,% (I (), ')- &D, %'/, I#96",: ND6%5 H, %,, &D, c'%&"(H I#96", ,#&D," '% ' -62W (" '%

' "'QQ#& 8",&&A /62D #) &D, %'/, %,)%, '% H, %,, ') C"2#/Q(+-(R% 8'#)&#)9 ,#&D," '% '

D6/') Q,#)9 (" ' %,& (I I"6#&% ')- $,9,&'Q+,%: i,& /, &D,",I(", 2()%#-," &D, %,2()-

W#)- (I %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% '% ,P8,"#,)2,% (I '/Q#96(6% ;)(#'$,2:

ND, '"2D#&,2&6", (I &D#% 8'8," H#++ Q, &D, I(++(H#)9: >#"%&+A X%,2&#() ;_5 4 H#++ D(+- &D'&

&D,", '", 2%?, %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% &D'& /,",+A D'$, ' )()*2()2,8&6'+ #)&,)&#()'+

2()&,)&\ )'/,+A5 &D(%, ,P8,"#,)2,% #)$(+$#)9 /,",+A &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ '/Q#96(6% I#9*

6",%T ,P8,"#,)2,% (I %$.*")@*#)%"*/ %,,#)9*'%: .,2()-+A X%,2&#() G_5 4 H#++ I(26% () %#-,$

%,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% (I &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ '/Q#96(6% I#96",% &D'& D(H,$," '+%( 8"(/8&') ,P8,"#,)&#'+ 9"'%8#)9 (I &D, &D#"- -#/,)%#(): 4 H#++ &",'& &D(%, ,P8,"#,)2,% '% 8#2&("#'+

,P8,"#,)2,% (I '/Q#96(6% 8#2&("#'+ ",8",%,)&'&#()%: C% &( 8#2&("#'+ ,P8,"#,)2,% #) 9,)*

,"'+5 4 H#++ %D'", e(++D,#/R% X7ZKF;_ #-,' &D'& %62D ,P8,"#,)2,% D'$, ' 2(/8+,P 8D,)(/*

,)(+(9A (I ' 2') .,",$)2 &H(I(+- ,P8,"#,)2, &D'& #% /'&2D,- QA ' &H(*&#,",- #)&,)&#()'+

2()&,)&: b,& 4 H#++ I6"&D," ')'+A?, HD'& &D, I(+-% (I %62D ') ,P8,"#,)2, '", #) &,"/% (I '

I(+- (I ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*'% ')- ' I(+- (I 4"%A)"./B )//'2%$B 2,,)".1*25 QA '+%( '%2"#Q*

#)9 &D,/ ' )()*2()2,8&6'+ ')- ' 2()2,8&6'+ 2()&,)& ",%8,2&#$,+A: ND#% H#++ ,)'Q+, /, &(

&",'& &D(%, (&D," %C,$*// %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% '% 8#2&("#'+ ,P8,"#,)2,% (I '/Q#96(6%

8#2&("#'+ ",8",%,)&'&#()% &D'& '", ,)-(H,- H#&D &D, 'Q($, -#II,",)& &H(*&#,",- #)&,)*

&#()'+ 2()&,)&%: >6"&D,"/(",5 4 H#++ Q"#,I+A #)$,%&#9'&, &D, 2()%,U6,)2,% (I %62D ' 8(%#*

&#() '% &( &D, -,Q'&, () &D, %(*2'++,- 2(9)#&#$, 8,),&"'Q#+#&A (I 8,"2,8&#() X%,2&#() L_:

CI&," D'$#)9 2()%#-,",- ') (Qa,2&#() &( &D#% &",'&/,)& (I %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% (I '/*

Q#96(6% 8#2&6",% X%,2&#() <_5 4 H#++ I#)'++A &"A &( %D(H X%,2&#() M_ D(H &D#% ($,"'++ &",'&*

/,)& (I %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% D'% Q,,) ')&#2#8'&,- #) &D, +'&," i6-H#9 e#&&9,)%&,#)R%

",I+,2&#()% () &D#% #%%6,:

j,I(", %&'"&#)95 ' 2'$,'&: jA -,I,)-#)9 &D, #)&,)&#()'+#%& #-,' &D'& %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#*

,)2,% D'$, ') #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&5 ,#&D," 2()2,8&6'+ (" )()*2()2,8&6'+5 /'&2D#)9 &D,#"

8D,)(/,)(+(9A5 4 -( )(& H')& &( -,I,)- #)&,)&#()'+#%/ #) 9,),"'+: .( #) &D, ,)- 4 '/

),#&D," ' %&"()9 )(" ' H,'W #)&,)&#()'+#%&: 4 #)-,,- Q,+#,$, &D'& '% ' 9,),"'+ &D,%#% ()

U6'+#&'&#$, %&'&,% #)&,)&#()'+#%/ I'#+%5 I(" &D,", '", U6'+#&'&#$, %&'&,% k )(&'Q+A5 #)&,"(*

(" 8"(8"#(*2,8&#$, %,)%'&#()% ')- /((-% k HD(%, U6'+#&'&#$, 8"(8,"&#,% '", )(&

/'&2D,- '& '++ QA #)&,)&#()'+ (),% X2I: 3(+&(+#)# Y;F7G[_:



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;7K


;: D$.*")@*#)%"*/ 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,2

i,& /, %&'"& QA 2()%#-,"#)9 -#II,",)& %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% (I ') '/Q#96(6% /,",+A &H(*

-#/,)%#()'+ I#96",5 &D'& #%5 ' I#96", &D'& /,",+A #)$(+$,% -#II,",)& &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ 8,"*

2,8&6'+ #)&,"8",&'&#()%: ND, 8"(&(&A8, (I %62D ,P8,"#,)2,% #% &D, (), 2()2,")#)9 &D, %(*

2'++,- ]'2D I#96",5 )'/,+A &D, I#96", &D'& 2') Q, %,,) ,#&D," '% ' -#'/()- (" '% ' &#+&,-

%U6'",:

N( /A /#)-5 &D,", #% )( -(6Q& &D'& &D, &H( ,P8,"#,)2,% D,", #)$(+$,- D'$, ' -#II,"*

,)& 8D,)(/,)(+(9A: X.(/, '-/#& &D'&5 '& +,'%& #) %(/, 2'%,%5 &D#% #% U6,%&#()'Q+,L: ND#%

%(6)-% "'&D," #)2",-#Q+, &( /, k 4 2+,'"+A ,)&,"&'#) ' 8D,)(/,)'+ %H#&2D #) 9"'%8#)9 &D,

-#II,",)& '%8,2&% (I &D, I#96",: b,& ,$,) #I &D#% H,", ",'++A &D, 2'%,5 #& H(6+- /,",+A #)*

$(+$, ' 8"(Q+,/ H#&D &D, ,P'/8+, k a6%& 2D')9, &D, ,P'/8+, ')- 2()%#-," ' 2'%, #)

HD#2D (), ')- &D, %'/, '""'A (I -(&% 2') Q, %,,) ,#&D," 2()I("/#)9 &( ' $,"&#2'+ (" ' &(

' D("#?()&'+ ("9')#?'&#()_<

:

J(H5 '% /')A D'$, /'#)&'#),-5 &D#% -#II,",)& 8D,)(/,)(+(9A #% /'&2D,- QA ' -#I*I,",)2, #) &D,#" #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&: O"#&#2#%/% &( &D#% 2+'#/ X2I: 0,'2(2W, Y7ZKG[\ ]'2*

8D,"%() Y;FFM[\ J#2W,+ Y;FF^[_ /,",+A H("W '% 2"#&#2#%/% &( #/8"(8," I("/6+'&#()% (I

HD'& %62D ' 2()&,)& ",'++A '/(6)&% &(: N( /A /#)-5 &D,", #)-,,- #% ' 8"(8(%'+ '% &(

L C% Q(&D c'9)(H XY;F77[T GGG_ ')- d'I&(8(6+(% XY;F77[T <F^5 <77_ %,,/ &( '++(H:

< `) Q,D'+I (I &D, ')&#*#)&,)&#()'+#%&5 (), %62D I6"&D," ,P'/8+, #% 86& I("H'"- QA 0,'2(2W,

X7ZKG_T ;<*;M:



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;7Z


HD'& &D#% #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& 2()%#%&% #) &D'& ",%#%&% '++ %62D 2"#&#2#%/%T %62D ,P8,"#,)2,%

/(Q#+#?, #) &D,#" 2()&,)& -#II,",)& .$%';)". ;$%;,$#),2 (I &D, #)$(+$,- I#96",: ND,%,

8"(8,"&#,% '", &D, -#II,",)& H'A% I(" &D, I#96",R% ,+,/,)&% (I Q,#)9 '""')9,- '22("-#)9

&( -#II,",)& ("#,)&'&#()%M: i,& /, &D,",I(", %'A &D'& &D, &H( -#II,",)& %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#*

,)2,% &D'& 2()2,") ' /,",+A &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ I#96", '", -#II,",)& ,P8,"#,)2,% (I %$.*")1

@*#)%"*/ 2,,)".1*2: 4) &D, ]'2D I#96",5 (), 2') 9"(68 #&% '""'A #) ' 2,"&'#) H'A5 '+()9 '

2,"&'#) ("#,)&'&#()'+ 'P#% k &D, (), '2&6'++A I(++(H#)9 &D, ')9+,%R Q#%,2&#() k %( &D'& &D,

("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9 (I &D, I#96", '% ' -#'/()- '"#%,%: b,& (), 2') 9"(68 #&% '""'A '+%(

#) ')(&D," H'A5 '+()9 ')(&D," ("#,)&'&#()'+ 'P#% k &D, (), '2&6'++A I(++(H#)9 &D, %#-,%R

Q#%,2&#() k %( &D'& &D, ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9 (I &D, I#96", '% ' %U6'", '"#%,%^:

C)&#*#)&,)&#()'+#%&% H(6+- #//,-#'&,+A H()-," HD#2D W#)- (I 8"(8,"&#,% &D,%, 9"(68*#)9 8"(8,"&#,% '", X2I: J#2W,+ Y;FF^[T ;KM_: e,++5 &D, -#II,",)& H'A% (I 9"(68#)9 (), ')-

&D, %'/, 8,"2,#$,- I#96", '", -#II,",)& %EF,(#)C, 8"(8,"&#,%5 #:,:5 -#II,",)& 8"(8,"&#,% (I

%62D ' I#96",: b,& &D,A '", %$),"#*#)%"1&,;,"&,"# 8"(8,"&#,%: OD')9, &D, ,P&,")'+ I"'/,

(I ",I,",)2, &D'& '++(H% ' 2,"&'#) ("#,)&'&#() (I &D, I#96",R% ,+,/,)&%5 ')- A(6 H#++

2D')9, &D, H'A (I 9"(68#)9 &D, I#96",: ND#% -,8,)-,)2, /'W,% #& &D, 2'%, &D'&5 '+&*

D(69D &D,A '", 2(/8'&#Q+, 8"(8,"&#,% k &D, I#96", 8(%%,%%,% '++ %62D H'A% I(" #&% ,+,*

/,)&% &( Q, '""')9,- k )( ,P8,"#,)2, /(Q#+#?,% Q(&D 8"(8,"&#,% '& (), ')- &D, %'/,

&#/,K: N( Q, %6",5 (), /#9D& %688(%, &D'& ("#,)&'&#()*-,8,)-,)2, /'W,% 9"(68#)9

8"(8,"&#,% %6Qa,2&#$, 8"(8,"&#,%5 #:,:5 8"(8,"&#,% (I &D, ,P8,"#,)2, "'&D," &D') (I HD'& #%

,P8,"#,)2,-: b,& ("#,)&'&#()*-,8,)-,)2, (226"% #) ' .,%?,#$)(*/ 5 )(& #) ') ,.%/%.)(*/

%8'2,5 2D'"'2&,"#?,- QA %6Qa,2&#$, 8,"%8,2&#$,% &( Q, -,%2"#Q,- #) ' +')96'9, 6%#)9 8,"*

%8,2&#$'+ +(26&#()% Xl() &D, +,I& (I E () &D, "#9D& (Im5 l() &D, &(8 (I E () &D, Q(&&(/ (Im

M 4) &D, &"'-#&#() I(++(H#)9 $() 1D",)I,+% X7ZKK_5 &D,%, 8"(8,"&#,% '", +'Q,++,- G,2#*/# H'*/)#),2:

^ jA %62D ("#,)&'&#()'+ 'P,% 4 -()R& /,') %A//,&"A 'P,%: C% ]'28D,"%() XY;FFM[T 7FG*7F<_ "#9D&*

+A )(&#2,%5 Q(&D I(26%#)9 () ' 2,"&'#) %A//,&"A 'P#% "'&D," &D') () ')(&D," (), 8"(/8&% )( 8D,*

)(/,)'+ %H#&2D ')- 8D,)(/,)'+ %H#&2D,% '+%( (226" '% &( )()*%A//,&"#2 I#96",% +#W, &D, -#%*&("&,- %U6'", k W#&, I#96", 4 H#++ #//,-#'&,+A &'+W 'Q(6& Q,+(H:K ND#% 8(#)& I'2,% ')(&D," 2"#&#2#%/ QA ]'28D,"%() XY;FFM[T 7FG_ '9'#)%& '%2"#Q#)9 %62D %,,#)9*'%

,P8,"#,)2,% #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&% ",%8,2&#$,+A /'-, (I 2(/8'&#Q+, 8"(8,"&#,% 6)-,"%&((- #)

&,"/% (I %A//,&"A 'P,%: >(" ' %#/#+'" 8(#)& '9'#)%& ]'28D,"%()5 %,, d'I&(8(6+(% X;F77_T <FK:

](",($,"5 %#)2, %62D 9"(68#)9 8"(8,"&#,% '", 2(/8'&#Q+, 8"(8,"&#,%5 &D,A '", 2(*#)%&')&#'&,- QA

') '/Q#96(6% I#96", #) '++ 8(%%#Q+, H("+-% #) HD#2D &D,A '", #)%&')&#'&,- X8"($#-,- &D, I#96", ",*

&'#)% #&% %D'8, #-,)&#&A_: b,& '% J#2W,+ XY;FF^[T ;K<_ '2W)(H+,-9,%5 QA #&%,+I &D#% #% )(& ' 8"(Q+,/

I(" #)&,)&#()'+#%/ #)%(I'" '% #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& 2') H,++ Q, /(", I#),*9"'#),- &D') 8"(8(%#&#()%

H'* %,&% (I 8(%%#Q+, H("+-%:



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;;F


n_: .(5 ,$,) &D(69D &D,A '", -,8,)-,)2,*#)$(+$#)9 8"(8,"&#,% '% /62D '% %6Qa,2&#$,

8"(8,"&#,% '",5 9"(68#)9 8"(8,"&#,% '", )(& %6Qa,2&#$, 8"(8,"&#,%Z:

4) ("-," &( 9"'%8 &D#% -#II,",)2,5 %688(%, I(" #)%&')2, &( -"'H ') '/Q#96(6% I#96",

%62D '% &D, -#%&("&,- %U6'", k W#&, I#96", () ' &"')%8'",)& $,D#2+, %62D '% ' H#)-(H

8'), ')- #/'9#), &( %,, #& I"(/ Q(&D %#-,%5 #:,:5 Q(&D I"(/ ' I"()& ')- I"(/ ' Q'2W %#-,:

J(H5 #I &D, -#II,",)& H'A% (I %,,#)9 &D, I#96",5 &D, lW#&#%Dm ')- &D, l%U6'"#%Dm (),%5 (2*

26"",- Q'%#2'++A QA 9"(68#)9 #&% -(&% ,#&D," #) ' 68+,I&*&(*-(H)"#9D& %,)%, (" #) '

-(H)+,I&*&(*68"#9D& %,)%, HD,) (), I"()&'++A %,,% &D, I#96",5 (), H(6+- D'$, &( %'A

&D'& HD,) (), %'H &D, I#96", I"(/ &D, (&D," %#-,5 I6"&D," -#II,",)& H'A% H(6+- ,/,"9,

QA 9"(68#)9 &D, I#96",R% -(&% #) ' -(H)"#9D&*&(*68+,I& %,)%, ')- #) ' -(H)"#9D&*&(*68+,I&

%,)%, HD,) (), %'H &D, I#96", I"(/ &D, (&D," %#-,: b,& #) 8(#)& (I I'2& I"(/ Q(&D %#-,%&D,", %#/8+A '", #A% 2*?, A*B2 (I 9"(68#)9 &D, I#96",5 -#",2&#()'++A '""')9,- '+()9 '

2'"-#)'+ I"'/, (I ",I,",)2, X%'A5 ') ,'%&*&(*H,%& H'A "'&D," &D') ' H,%&*&(*,'%& H'A_

"'&D," &D') ') ,9(+(9#2'+ I"'/, (I ",I,",)2,: ND, -#II,",)& 8,"%8,2&#$'+ 2D'"'2&,"#?'*

&#()% %#/8+A '", -#II,",)& '88"(P#/'&, -,%2"#8&#()% (I (), ')- &D, %'/, 2'"-#)'+ H'A (I

9"(68#)9 &D, I#96",: .(5 &D, -#II,",)& 8,"%8,2&#$,% )(&H#&D%&')-#)95 &D,", '", a6%& &H(

H'A% (I 9"(68#)9 &D, I#96", 8"(/8&#)9 ,P'2&+A &D, $,"A %'/, -#II,",)& %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#*

,)2,%: i#W,H#%,5 '+&D(69D &D,A -,8,)- () -#II,",)& 2'"-#)'+ ("#,)&'&#()%5 &D, -#II,",)&

9"(68#)9 8"(8,"&#,% (I &D, ]'2D I#96", -( )(& -,8,)- () 8,"%8,2&#$'+ 9"'%8#)9% (I &D,

I#96",:

Z >(" ' %#/#+'" -#II,",)2, Q,&H,,) -,8,)-,)2,*#)$(+$#)9 8"(8,"&#,%5 %,, J,H'++ X;F77_T M^: J#2W,+

XY;FF^[T ;ZK_ 2"#&#2#?,% ') #)&,)&#()'+#%& ",2(6"%, &( %6Qa,2&#$, 8"(8,"&#,% I(" #& '++(H% ()+A ' "%"*

",-62&#$, #)&,)&#()'+#%& '22(6)&5 &D'& #%5 ') '22(6)& &D'& &"'2,% Q'2W 8D,)(/,)'+ 8"(8,"&#,% &(

') #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& &D'& %&#++ '88,'+% &( 8D,)(/,)'+ 8"(8,"&#,%: N( Q, %6",5 %(/, 8,(8+, X,:9:

OD'+/,"% Y;FFL[\ .#,H,"& Y;FFL[_ D'$, )( U6'+/% H#&D )()*",-62&#$, #)&,)&#()'+#%/: J,$,"&D,*

+,%%5 %#)2, 9"(68#)9 8"(8,"&#,% '", )(& %6Qa,2&#$, 8"(8,"&#,%5 &D#% 2"#&#2#%/ -(,% )(& '88+A &(

&D,/:



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;;7


4) &D#% ",%8,2&5 #& #% 2("",2& &( ",/'"W &D'& '% &( &D, ]'2D I#96",5 HD'& 8"(/8&% &D,

8D,)(/,)'+ %H#&2D I"(/ %,,#)9 &D, I#96", '% ' -#'/()- &( %,,#)9 #& '% ' %U6'", #& #% )(&

8'%%#)9 &( %,, &D, I#96", '% &#+&,-5 #:,:5 '% 8,"%8,2&#$,+A ("#,)&,- #) ' 2,"&'#) H'A H#&D ",*

%8,2& &( &D, 8,"2,#$,"7F

:

4I 9"(68#)9 8"(8,"&#,% /6%& Q, (Qa,2&#$,5 D(H,$,"5 (), /#9D& H()-," HD,&D," &D,A

D'$, &( -,8,)- () ,P&,")'+ I"'/,% (I ",I,",)2,5 '% 4 D'$, a6%& /'#)&'#),-5 (" "'&D," ()

(Qa,2&*2,)&,",- I"'/,%5 2(#)2#-#)9 H#&D %(/, #)&"#)%#2 'P,% (" (&D," (I &D, I#96",

Xc'9)(H Y;F77[T GGM*GGK_: b,& 4 Q,+#,$, &D'& (Qa,2&*",I,",)2, I"'/,% /6%& A#,+- H'A &(

,P&,")'+ I"'/,%:

`) Q,D'+I (I &D, (Qa,2&6'+#%&5 (), /#9D& ",/'"W &D'&5 #I #)%&,'- (I &'W#)9 &D, ]'2D

I#96",5 HD#2D H, %,, ,#&D," '% ' -#'/()- (" '% ' &#+&,- %U6'",5 H, &((W ' )("/'+ %U6'",5HD#2D H, 2') D(H,$," H,++ %,, )(& ()+A '% ' %U6'", Q6& '+%( '% ' &#+&,- -#'/()-5 &D,

$,"A %'/, 2'"-#)'+ ("#,)&'&#() X%'A5 ' )("&D*&(*%(6&D ("#,)&'&#()_ H(6+- 8"(/8& &)00,$1

,"# %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% (I &D, &H( I#96",% ",%8,2&#$,+A X%'A5 ' l-#'/()-#%Dm ,P8,"#*

,)2, #) &D, 2'%, (I &D, ]'2D I#96", ')- ' l%U6'"#%Dm ,P8,"#,)2, #) &D, 2'%, (I ' )("/'+

%U6'",_: .(5 '22("-#)9 &( &D#% ",/'"W5 ,P&,")'+ I"'/,% (I ",I,",)2, 2'))(& '22(6)& I("

&D, -#II,",)2, #) 8D,)(/,)'+ 2D'"'2&," '/()9 %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% X#Q#-:_:

N"6+A ,)(69D5 #) %62D ' 8",-#2'/,)& (), ')- &D, %'/, 2'"-#)'+ ("-," H(6+- 2("*

"#%8()-5 %'A5 Q(&D &( &D, l-#'/()-#%Dm ,P8,"#,)2, (I &D, ]'2D I#96", ')- &( &D, l%U6'"*

#%Dm ,P8,"#,)2, (I &D, )("/'+ %U6'",: b,& (), /6%& ",2'++ &D'& 9"(68#)9 (8,"'&#()% '+*

H'A% (226" 'I&," &D'& (), D'% 9"'%8,- /(", Q'%#2 $#%6'+ I,'&6",% (I ' I#96",: ND,%, '",

&D, I,'&6",% (I ' I#96", &D'& ",/'#) 2()%&')& #) ' %,,#)9*'% %H#&2D &D'& 2()2,")% #&T

)'/,+A5 #&% 2(+(6"% ')- %D'8,%: 4) (6" 2'%,5 &D,", #% ' -#II,",)2, #) %62D /(", Q'%#2 $#%6*

'+ I,'&6",% (I &D, &H( I#96",% #)$(+$,- &D'& /'W,% #& &D, 2'%, &D'& &D,", #% ' 8D,)(/,)(*

+(9#2'+ -#II,",)2, Q,&H,,) %62D I#96",% HD#2D #% 8",+#/#)'"A &( &D,#" '+%( Q,#)9 9"(68,-

#) 2,"&'#) H'A%: ND#% 8D,)(/,)(+(9#2'+ -#II,",)2, #)-,,- -,8,)-% () &D, I'2& &D'& Q,*

I(", &D,#" Q,#)9 %(/,D(H 9"(68,-5 &D, ]'2D I#96", ')- &D, )("/'+ %U6'", '", -#II,"*

,)&+A %D'8,-5 %( &D'& &D,A -#II,",)&+A 8'"%, &D, ",%8,2&#$, ",9#() (I %8'2,: 4) (&D,"

7F C% ]'28D,"%() XY;FFM[T Z75 7F^*7FK_ '+%( %'A%5 #)%(I'" '% %6Qa,2&#$, 8,"%8,2&#$,% 2') '+H'A%

Q, #/8(%,- () ')A I#96",5 #& #% )(& 2+,'" HDA %(/, I#96",% +#W, &D, ]'2D I#96", 8"(/8& -#II,",)&

%,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,%5 ",%8,2&#$,+A &D'& (I ') 6)&#+&,- -#'/()- ')- &D'& (I ' &#+&,- %U6'",5 HD#+,

%(/, (&D," I#96",% +#W, &D'& (I ' &#+&,- C 8"(/8& )( %62D -#II,",)2,: >(" (&D," 2"#&#2#%/% &( &D,

#-,' (I #)&,"8",&#)9 &D, -#II,",)2,% #) )()*2()2,8&6'+ #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& (I %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2*

,% #) &,"/% (I $#,H8(#)&*2,)&,",- ",I,",)2, I"'/,% I /* d'I&(8(6+(% X;FFZ\ ;F77_5 %,, c'9)(H

X;F77_T GGM*GG^:



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;;;


&,"/%5 HD'& /'W,% &D,%, I#96",% 8D,)(/,)(+(9#2'++A -#II,",)& '", &D,#" ",%8,2&#$, I,'*

&6",% &D'& ",/'#) 8,"2,8&6'++A 2()%&')& #) &D, ",%8,2&#$, 8D,)(/,)'+ %H#&2D,% &D'&

2()2,") %62D I#96",%5 )'/,+A &D,#" -#II,",)& %D'8,%: j,2'6%, (I &D#% 8"#(" 8D,)(/,)'+

-#II,",)2, Q,&H,,) &D, &H( I#96",%5 H, /'A %&#++ D'$, &D'& HD'& '22(6)&% I(" &D, %,,#)9*

'% -#II,",)2,% &D'& 'II,2& &D, ]'2D I#96", '", ' (,$#*)" 2'"-#)'+ ("#,)&'&#() (I #&% %D'8,%5

8"(/8&#)9 ' l-#'/()-#%Dm %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, (I #&5 ')- *"%#-,$ 2'"-#)'+ ("#,)&'&#()

(I #&% %D'8,%5 8"(/8&#)9 ' l%U6'"#%Dm ,P8,"#,)2, (I #&5 HD,",'% HD'& '22(6)&% I(" &D,

%,,#)9*'% -#II,",)2,% &D'& 'II,2& &D, %,2()- I#96",5 &D, )("/'+ %U6'",5 '", &D, 0%$?,$

2'"-#)'+ ("#,)&'&#() (I #&% %D'8,%5 A,& 8"(/8&#)9 &D#% &#/, ' l%U6'"#%Dm %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#*

,)2, (I #&5 ')- &D, /*##,$ 2'"-#)'+ ("#,)&'&#() (I #&% %D'8,%5 A,& 8"(/8&#)9 &D#% &#/, ' l-#*

'/()-#%Dm %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, (I #&: `" %( 4 2+'#/

77

:](",($,"5 2+,'"+A ,)(69D 9"'%8#)9 9"(68#)9 8"(8,"&#,% #% ' /'&&," (I '&&,)&#()5 '%

/')A %'A7;

: C% &( &D, ]'2D I#96",5 I(26%#)9 () #&% $,"&#2,% I'$("% 9"'%8#)9 &D, l-#'*

/()-m* '%8,2&5 HD#+, I(26%#)9 () #&% %#-,% I'$("% 9"'%8#)9 &D, l%U6'",m* '%8,2&: b,& #&

H(6+- Q, H"()9 &( %'A &D'& %62D ' I(26%#)9 #% ' I("/ (I %8'&#'+ '&&,)&#() %8(&&#)9 +#9D&

() %(/, 8(#)&% (I &D, I#96", X2I: d'I&(8(6+(% Y;FFZ[\ Y;F77[T LZK*<F^_: 1$,) &D(69D (),

I#P,% ' 8(#)& #) &D'& I#96",5 '&&,)&#()'+ I(26%#)9 '/(6)&% &( ' 2,"&'#) %C,$*// 9"'%8#)9 (I

&D, I#96",7G

: O()%#-," ') '/Q#96(6% I#96", &D'& H, %&#++ &'W, '% ' /,",+A &H(*

-#/,)%#()'+ I#96", #) HD#2D )(H ' 2,"&'#) 2()&(6"5 )(H ')(&D," 2()&(6" '88,'"% $#%6'+*

+A ",+,$')&5 '% #) &D, l&#+,%m* 2'%, Q,+(H #) HD#2D ,#&D," &D, l2"(%%*("9')#?,-m ;5 L5 M5 K

&#+,% (" &D, lo*("9')#?,-m 75 G5 <5 ^5 Z &#+,% $#%6'++A ,/,"9,%: .#)2, %62D 2()&(6"% ($,"+'85

77 4)2#-,)&'++A5 &D#% %D(H% &D'& &D, ",'%() '% &( HDA &D, -#II,",)& #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&% (I ' ]'2D

I#96", -( )(& '/(6)& &( -#II,",)& 8,"%8,2&#$'+ ("#,)&'&#()% #% )(& &D'& %,,#)9 ') 6)&#+&,- I#96",

')- %,,#)9 ' &#+&,- I#96",5 %'A ') C ')- ' &#+&,- C5 D'$, )( 8D,)(/,)'+ -#II,",)2, I(" &D, 8,"2,#$*

,": Xd'I&(8(6+(% YX;F77_T LZM[ 2"#&#2'++A 86&% #) &D#% H'A ]'28D,"%()R% X;FFM_ 2"#&#2#%/ ",8("&,- #)

I((&)(&, 7L:_ 4) &D#% +'&&," 2'%, &D, &H( I#96",% '& %&'W, '", #)-,,- -#II,",)&+A ,P8,"#,)2,-5 I("

($," ')- 'Q($, &D,#" 8(%%#Q+A Q,#)9 %(/,D(H 9"(68,-5 &D,A '", -#II,",)&+A %D'8,- I#96",%T ')

CR% %D'8, (2268#,% %8'2, #) ' 2,"&'#) &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ H'A5 HD#+, ' &#+&,- CR% %D'8, (2268#,%%8'2, #) ')(&D," &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ H'A: .( ,$,) #I &D,", '", -#II,",)2,% #) #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& I("

&D, ,P8,"#,)2,% (I %62D &)2#)"(# I#96",%5 &D,A '", #"",+,$')& &( '22(6)& I(" &D, -#II,",)2, #) 2()*

&,)& (I &D, -#II,",)& %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% (I %", *"& #-, 2*?, '/Q#96(6% I#96", D'$#)9 (), ')-

&D, %'/, %D'8,5 '% #) &D, ]'2D 2'%,:7;

>"(/ OD#%D(+/ X7ZZG_5 HD( #)&,"8",&% e#&&9,)%&,#) #) &D#% ",%8,2&5 '++ &D, H'A -(H) &( J')'A

X;F7F\ ;F77_5 `"+')-# XY;F77[T G7^_ ')- d'I&(8(6+(% XY;FFZ[\ Y;F77[T LZK*<F^_:7G

]')A '&&,)&#()'+ 8D,)(/,)' #)$(+$#)9 9"(68#)9 H("W #) &D#% H'A5 '% 8(#)&,- (6& QA j+(2W

XY;F7F[T G7*G^_ #) ' 8'8," '2&6'++A -,I,)-#)9 ' H,'W #)&,)&#()'+#%& 8(%#&#() () &D, ",+'&#()%D#8

Q,&H,,) 8D,)(/,)'+ ')- #)&,)&#()'+ 8"(8,"&#,%:



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;;G


&D, %H#&2D Q,&H,,) &D,/ 2'))(& ",I," &( &D, I'2& &D'& ' 2,"&'#) '",' (I &D, I#96", "'&D,"

&D') ')(&D," (), #% %8(&&,-7L

: d'&D,"5 I(26%#)9 () 2,"&'#) 8(#)&% (I &D, I#96", #//,-#*

'&,+A I'$("% ' 2,"&'#) -%/)2#)( 9"'%8#)9 (I #&5 HD#+, I(26%#)9 () (&D," 8(#)&% (I &D, I#96",

I'$("% ')(&D," D(+#%&#2 9"'%8#)9 (I #&7<

: i#W,H#%,5 ()2, A(6 I#P ' $,"&,P (I &D, ]'2D I#96",5

&D, HD(+, I#96", #&%,+I H#++ #//,-#'&,+A '88,'" #) #&% l-#'/()-m* '%8,2&: eD,",'% ()2,

A(6 I#P (), (I #&% %#-,%5 &D, HD(+, I#96", #&%,+I H#++ #//,-#'&,+A '88,'" #) #&% l%U6'",m*

'%8,2&:

i,& 6% %&#2W &( &D, ]'2D I#96",: C% &( #&5 #& #% 2("",2& &( %'A &D'& (), -(,% )(& ),,- &(

/'%&," &D, 2()2,8&% (I E,)". * 2H'*$, ')- E,)". * &)*?%"& 5 (" ')A (&D," 2()2,8& '& '++5

&( 8,"I("/ &D, ",+,$')& 8D,)(/,)'+ %H#&2D: ND,", #% )( 8"#)2#8+,- ",'%() '% &( HDA )(

%62D %H#&2D %D(6+- (226" I(" ' 8,"2,#$," #I %D, -#- )(& 8(%%,%% %62D 2()2,8&%: ND#% #% 8'"*

&#26+'"+A ,$#-,)& #) &D, 'I(",/,)&#(),- l-(&%m*I#96",\ &D, -#II,",)& $,"&#2'+ ')- D("#?()*

&'+ 8,"2,8&6'+ '""')9,/,)&% 2("",%8()-#)9 &( &D, 8D,)(/,)'+ %H#&2D (226""#)9 &D,",

2') Q, 9"'%8,- ')- ,$,) -,%2"#Q,- H#&D(6& ",I,""#)9 &( ')A 2()2,8& '& '++: p,)2,5 (),

/'A H,++ %'A &D'& &D, #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& (I &D, &H( ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2*

,% (I (), ')- &D, %'/, '/Q#96(6% I#96", #% 6&&,"+A "%"1(%"(,;#'*/ :

7L 4 D,", '%%6/, &D'& &D, l&#+,%m* I#96", 2') Q, &'W,) '% ' /,",+A &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ I#96",: 4) 8(#)&

(I I'2&5 %#)2, &D, 8D,)(/,)'+ %H#&2D #& 8"(/8&% #% )'&6"'++A -,%2"#Q,- '% #)$(+$#)9 -#II,",)& I#9*

6",*9"(6)- %,9/,)&'&#()%5 #& #% /(", )'&6"'+ &( "')W &D#% I#96", H#&D &D, 2'%,% (I '/Q#96(6% I#9*

6",% #)$(+$#)9 -#II,",)& &D",,*-#/,)%#()'+ #)&,"8",&'&#()%5 #:,: '/Q#96(6% 8#2&6",%5 4 H#++ -#%26%%

Q,+(H:7<

OI: c'9)(H X;F77_T GL;5 HD( 8(+,/#?,% '9'#)%& ') #)&,"8",&'&#() I /* d'I&(8(6+(% X;FFZ\ ;F77_

(I J')'AR% X;F7F_ 8(%#&#() () &D#% /'&&," k 2I: '9'#) X;F77_T GGK*LF k &D'& J')'A D#/%,+I X;F77_

D(H,$," ",a,2&%:

7 ; G

L < M

^ K Z



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;;L


ND#% #% -,I#)#&,+A )(& ' ),H #-,'T '++ &D, #)&,)&#()'+#%&% D#&D,"&( U6(&,- D'$, 8",2#%,+A

/'#)&'#),- &D#% 8(%#&#(): eD'& #% 8(%%#Q+A ),H #% %#/8+A &D'& &D, ",+,$')& ,+,/,)& #) &D#%

)()*2()2,8&6'+ #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& #% /'-, QA 9"(68#)9 8"(8,"&#,%5 8"(8,"&#,% -,8,)-*

,)& () ' 2'"-#)'++A*I"'/,- ("#,)&'&#(): `)2, A(6 9"'%8 -#II,",)& %62D 8"(8,"&#,%5 ' -#I*

I,",)& ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, (I (), ')- &D, %'/, I#96", '"#%,%:

G: DC,$*// 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,2

b,& ,P8,"#,)2,% &D'& 2()2,") '/Q#96(6% I#96",% +#W, &D, ]'2D I#96", '", )(& &D, ()+A

%,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% (I '/Q#96(6% I#96",% &D'& &D,", '",: >(" %62D ,P8,"#,)2,% #)$(+$,

()+A #A%1&)?,"2)%"*/ 9"(68#)9%T &D, &D#"- -#/,)%#()5 -,8&D5 #% )(& #)$(+$,-: q,8&D2(/,% #) HD,),$," #) &D, ",+,$')& ,P8,"#,)&#'+ 9"(68#)9% (I ') '/Q#96(6% I#96", ' 0).1

'$,1.$%'"& 2,.?,"#*#)%" ,/,"9,%5 HD#2D #% )(& &D, 2'%, '% ",9'"-% I#96",% +#W, &D,

]'2D I#96",: 4) &D,%, ),H 2'%,%5 HD#+, 2()&,/8+'&#)9 ') '/Q#96(6% I#96", HD#2D #) #&*

%,+I #% a6%& ' &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ #&,/5 #&% 8,"2,#$," -#II,",)&+A 9"(68% #&% ,+,/,)&% )(& ()+A

'+()9 D,#9D& ')- +,)9&D5 Q6& '+%( #) %62D ' H'A &D'& %(/, ,+,/,)&% '", /(", -#%&')&

&D') (&D,"%: ND#% 8"(&(&A8#2'++A D'88,)% #) &D, 2'%, (I &D, ld6Q#)R% $'%,m*I#96",5 #)

HD#2D5 -,8,)-#)9 () &D, H'A% #) HD#2D #&% ,+,/,)&% '", '+%( &D",,*-#/,)%#()'++A

9"(68,-5 (), %,,% &D, I#96", ,#&D," '% &H( -'"W I'2,% () ' +#9D& Q'2W9"(6)- (" '% ' +#9D&

$'%, () ' -'"W Q'2W9"(6)-: b,& #& '+%( D'88,)%5 &D(69D 8,"D'8% +,%% ,$#-,)&+A5 #) &D,

2'%, (I &D, I'/(6% l-62W*"'QQ#&m*c'%&"(HR% I#96",5 #) HD#2D (), %,,% &D, I#96", ,#&D," '%

' -62W X() ' Q'2W9"(6)-_ (" '% ' "'QQ#& X() ' Q'2W9"(6)-_:

`)2, /(",5 &D,", #% )( -(6Q& &D'& ' 8D,)(/,)'+ %H#&2D '+%( (226"% #) &D,%, 2'%,%\ #&

#% (), &D#)9 &( %,, &D, c'%&"(H I#96", '% ' -62W5 U6#&, ')(&D," &D#)9 &( %,, #& '% ' "'QQ#&:

`), %D(6+- )(& Q, +,- '%&"'A QA &D, I'2& &D'&5 Q,I(", ')- 'I&," &D, %H#&2D5 %(/,&D#)9



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;;<


",/'#)% 2()%&')& #) &D, ,P8,"#,)2, (I &D, I#96",5 )'/,+A #&% 2(+("% ')- %D'8,%7M

: >(" &D,

%H#&2D #% 8D,)(/,)'+ #)%(I'" '% &D, 9"(68#)9% (I &D, I#96",R% ,+,/,)&% 2D')9,: 4) &D, c'*

%&"(H I#96",5 (), Q'%#2'++A 8'%%,% I"(/ ' 2,"&'#) l2'"-#)'+m 9"(68#)9 &D'& #/8+#2#&+A #)*

$(+$,% -,8&D '% H,++ XD,)2, '88"(P#/'&,+A5 Q6& Q'%#2'++A #/8"(8,"+A5 -,%2"#Q,- '% ' 8,"*

%8,2&#$'+ l+,I&*&(*"#9D&m 9"(68#)9_ ')- ,)'Q+,% (), &( 9"'%8 &D, l"'QQ#&m*'%8,2& (I &D,

I#96", &( ')(&D," l2'"-#)'+m 9"(68#)9 &D'& '9'#) #/8+#2#&+A #)$(+$,% -,8&D XD,)2, '88"(P*

#/'&,+A5 Q6& Q'%#2'++A #/8"(8,"+A5 -,%2"#Q,- '% ' 8,"%8,2&#$'+ l"#9D&*&(*+,I&m 9"(68#)9_

')- ,)'Q+,% (), &( 9"'%8 &D, I#96",R% l-62Wm*'%8,2&:

`) Q,D'+I (I &D, #)&,)&#()'+#%&5 (), /#9D& &D#)W &D'& &D,%, &D",,*-#/,)%#()'++A

9"'%8,- '/Q#96(6% I#96",% '", a6%& (&D," 2'%,% (I &D, %'/, 8",-#2'/,)& '% &D, (), -#%*

8+'A,- QA I#96",% +#W, &D, ]'2D (),T &D, -#II,",)& %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% &"'2, Q'2W &(&H( -#II,",)& )()*2()2,8&6'+ #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&%5 2'8&6",- #) &,"/% (I X'-/#&&,-+A

/(", 2(/8+,P_ -#II,",)& 9"(68#)9 8"(8,"&#,% X%,, ,:9: c'9)(H Y;F77[\ `"+')-# Y;F77[\

d'I&(8(6+(% Y;FFZ\ ;F77[_7^

: b,& &D#% H'A (I 86&&#)9 &D#)9% ),9+,2&% &D, I'2& &D'& &D, ,P*

8,"#,)2,% #)$(+$,- D,", '", -,I#)#&,+A /(", 2(/8+,P &D') &D(%, #)$(+$,- #) &D, 8",$#(6%

2'%,%:

ND#% 2+,'"+A &"')%8#",% #I (), )(&#2,% &D, I'2& &D'&5 6)+#W, I#96",% +#W, &D, ]'2D (),5

I#96",% +#W, &D, c'%&"(H I#96", '", '/Q#96(6% ;)(#'$,25 #:,:5 &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ I#96",% &D'&

'+%( #)$(+$, -#II,",)& &D",,*-#/,)%#()'+ #)&,"8",&'&#()% #)%(I'" '% &D,A 8#2&("#'++A ",8",*

%,)& -#II,",)& #&,/% k ' -62W ')- ' "'QQ#&5 #) &D#% 2'%,: C22("-#)9+A5 ,P8,"#,)2,% (I &D,%,

I#96",% '", ;)(#%$)*/ ,P8,"#,)2,%5 /(", 8",2#%,+A ?'#);/),& 8#2&("#'+ ,P8,"#,)2,% #)%(I'"

'% &D,A 2()2,") '/Q#96(6% 8#2&6",%T &D,A ",8+#2'&, #) &,"/% (I -#II,",)& 8#2&("#'+ ,P8,"#*

,)2,% HD'& #) &D, 2'%, (I )("/'+ 8#2&6",% #% a6%& ' %#)9+, 8#2&("#'+ ,P8,"#,)2,7K

: ND, c'*

%&"(H I#96", #% Q(&D ' 8#2&6", (I ' -62W ')- ' 8#2&6", (I ' "'QQ#&5 %( &D'& &D, ($,"'++ ,P8,*

"#,)2, (I #& #% Q(&D ' %,,#)9 (I #& '% ' 8#2&6", (I ' -62W ')- ' %,,#)9 (I #& '% ' 8#2&6", (I '

7M C% 0,'2(2W, %'A%5 HD#+, '--#)9 &D'& #) %62D ' 2'%,5 6)+#W, &D, 2'%, (I &D, %(*2'++,- J,2W," 26*

Q,5 &D, 8D,)(/,)(+(9#2'+ 2()%&')2A #% /'&2D,- QA ') #)&,)&#()'+ 2()%&')2A (I &D, ",+,$')& ,P*8,"#,)2,: OI: 0,'2(2W, X7ZKG_T 7M*7^: N( /A /#)-5 &D, &H( 2'%,% '", #)%&,'- U6#&, %#/#+'": 4) Q(&D

2'%,% &D,", #% ' 8D,)(/,)'+ -#II,",)2, k %,,#)9 &D, c'%&"(H I#96", '% ' -62W5 %,,#)9 #& '% ' "'QQ#&\

%,,#)9 &D, J,2W," 26Q, '% ' 26Q, H#&D ' 2,"&'#) I"()& I'2, ')- ')(&D," Q'2W I'2,5 %,,#)9 #& '% '

26Q, H#&D ')(&D," I"()& I'2, ')- %&#++ ')(&D," Q'2W I'2, k HD#2D #% /'&2D,- QA ') #)&,)&#()'+5

8'"&#'++A 2()2,8&6'+5 -#II,",)2,:7^

C+%( ]'28D,"%() XY;FFM[T Z^*ZK_ #% -#%8(%,- &( 8"($#-, %62D ') #)&,)&#()'+#%& )()*2()2,8&6'+

",'-#)9 I(" &D,%, 2'%,%:7K

C& +,'%& %68,"I#2#'++A\ '% S(/Q"#2D XY7ZMF[T ;LZ_ /'#)&'#),-5 '++ 8#2&6",% '", #)D,",)&+A '/Q#96*

(6%:



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;;M


"'QQ#&: J(H5 '+&D(69D /')A 8,(8+, &'W#)9 8'"& #) &D#% -,Q'&, D'$, )(&#2,- &D#% I'2& X2I:

,:9: 0,'2(2W, Y7ZKG[T 7^\ ]'28D,"%() Y;FFM[T Z^*ZK_5 #&% 2()%,U6,)2,% D'$, "'&D,"

9(), 6))(&#2,-: .( +,& /, ,P8')- () #&:

C% ')A(), W)(H%5 8#2&("#'+ ,P8,"#,)2,% '", 2(/8+,P ,P8,"#,)2,%5 I(" #) ), %62D ,P8,*

"#,)2, '& (), ')- &D, %'/, &#/, ' 8,"2,#$," ,P8,"#,)2,% &D, &A8#2'++A /'&,"#'+ (Qa,2&

%D, I'2,% k &D, 8#2&6",R% C,-)(/, k ')- HD'& %62D ') (Qa,2& -,8#2&%5 HD#2D 6)+#W, &D, $,*

D#2+, #% )(& &D,", k &D, 8#2&6",R% 2'EF,(# : d#2D'"- e(++D,#/ D'% &"#,- &( 2'8&6", &D#%

2(/8+,P#&A QA D(+-#)9 &D'& 8#2&("#'+ ,P8,"#,)2,% '", 2') .,",$)2 ,P8,"#,)2,%5 ,P8,"#,)2,%

(I %,,#)9 ' %6Qa,2& )" ' $,D#2+,5 D'$#)9 ' %8,2#I#2 8D,)(/,)(+(9A &D'& #% ,P8",%%,- #) &D,

,P8,"#,)2,%R &H(I(+-),%%: >(" D#/5 ' 2,,)".1)" ,P8,"#,)2, #)-,,- D'% &H( -#%&#)2& A,&

6)%,8'"'Q+, I(+-%5 &D, (%"0).'$*#)%"*/ I(+-5 #) HD#2D (), 9"'%8% &D, 8#2&6",R% $,D#2+,5')- &D, $,(%.")#)%"*/ I(+-5 #) HD#2D (), 9"'%8% &D, 8#2&6",R% %6Qa,2& X2I: e(++D,#/

Y7ZKF;\ 7ZK^\ 7ZZK[_:

]')A 8,(8+, D'$, I(6)- &D,/%,+$,% -#%%'&#%I#,- H#&D &D#% 8"(8(%'+ '% #& %&')-%5 I(" #&

#% )(& 2+,'" HD'& &D(%, I(+-% ",'++A '/(6)& &( ')- D(H &D,A 2') /#P &(9,&D," #I &D,A '",

'Q(6& %62D -#II,",)& ,)&#&#,% ')- A,& &D, %,,#)9*#) ,P8,"#,)2, D'% ' 6)#&'"A 8D,)(/,)'+

2D'"'2&," X2I: ",%8,2&#$,+A i(8,% Y7ZZM[T <F\ p(8W#)% Y;F7F[T 7M^*7^7_: J(H5 &D, 2'%,% (I

'/Q#96(6% 8#2&6",% /'A 8",2#%,+A D,+8 (), &( 9#$, ') ')%H," &( Q(&D 8,"8+,P#&#,%: >("

&D, -#II,",)& %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% (I ') '/Q#96(6% 8#2&6", '", 8",2#%,+A &H( -#II,",)&

%,,#)9*#) ,P8,"#,)2,%5 &( Q, &",'&,- '% %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% /(", 2(/8+,P &D') &D,

8",$#(6%+A 2()%#-,",- (),%7Z

:

C% e(++D,#/ D#/%,+I ",2(9)#?,%5 &D,", H(6+- Q, )( %,,#)9*#) ,P8,"#,)2, (I %(/,*

&D#)9 #I &D,", H,", )( %,,#)9 (I &D'& $,"A %(/,&D#)9 *2 ' 8#2&6", X2I: e(++D,#/ Y7ZKF;[T

;;M_: i,& /, &D,",I(", 2()%#-," ' %,,#)9*#) ,P8,"#,)2, &D, %'/, '% &D, %C,$*// ,P8,"#*

,)2, (I %(/,&D#)9 '% ' 8#2&6",: .#)2, #) &D, 2'%, (I '/Q#96(6% 8#2&6",% H, D'$, &H(

%,,#)9*#) ,P8,"#,)2,% H#&D ",%8,2& &( (), ')- &D, %'/, I#96",5 %,,#)9 ' I#96", '% ' 8#2*

&6", D,", %8+#&% #&%,+I #)&( &H( -#II,",)& %62D %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,%5 &( Q, I6"&D," 6)*

8'2W,- '% H, H#++ )(H %,,:

`) &D, (), D')-5 ' 2,"&'#) ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, (I ') '/Q#96(6% 8#2&6", #%

%#/#+'" &( ' %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, (I ') '/Q#96(6% /,",+A &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ I#96",T #& #%

&D, 9"'%8#)9 (I ' 2,"&'#) 9"(68#)9 (I &D, 8#2&("#'+ $,D#2+,R% ,+,/,)&% &D'& '+%( #)$(+$,%

&D, &D#"- -#/,)%#(): .(5 %62D ') ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, #%5 '& +,'%& #) 8'"&5 ') ,P8,*

"#,)2, (I ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*'% &D'& D'% ' 2,"&'#) )()*2()2,8&6'+ #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&5

7Z ̀ ) &D, 2(/8'&#Q#+#&A Q,&H,,) %,,#)9*#) ')- %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,%5 2I: 3(+&(+#)# X;F7;'\ ;F7;Q_:



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;;^


'-/#&&,-+A /(", 2(/8+,P &D'& &D, (), (I ' %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, (I ') '/Q#96(6% I#96",

I(" #& '+%( #)$(+$,% '""')9#)9 &D, $,D#2+,R% ,+,/,)&% '+()9 -,8&D: C -#II,",)& ($,"'++ %,,*

#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, (I &D, %'/, 8#2&6", H#++ &D6% /(Q#+#?, ' -#II,",)& ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,*

#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,5 D,)2, ' 9"'%8#)9 (I ' -#II,",)& 9"(68#)9 (I &D, $,D#2+,R% ,+,/,)&% %&#++

#)$(+$#)9 -,8&D5 D,)2, ' -#II,",)& )()*#)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&: O()%#-," '9'#) &D, c'%&"(H

I#96",: `), /'A %,, &D, I#96", #) ' 2,"&'#) H'A5 QA 9"'%8#)9 #&% ,+,/,)&% #) ' l"'QQ#&#%Dm

H'A5 A,& (), /'A '+%( %,, &D, I#96", #) ')(&D," H'A5 QA 9"'%8#)9 #&% ,+,/,)&% #) ' l-62W*

#%Dm H'A: ND,%, -#II,",)& H'A% '", &H( 9"(68#)9 8"(8,"&#,% (I &D, I#96", /(Q#+#?,- #) &D,

",%8,2&#$, )()*2()2,8&6'+ 2()&,)&% (I %62D ,P8,"#,)2,%:

b,& () &D, (&D," D')-5 8",2#%,+A &D, I'2& &D'& %62D 9"'%8#)9% #)$(+$, &D, &D#"- -#/,)*

%#() D'% ') #/8("& &D'& 8D,)(/,)'+ %H#&2D,% 2()2,")#)9 /,",+A &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ I#9*6",% +'2W: >(" %62D 9"'%8#)9 -#%8+'A #) &D, ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% *"%#-,$ ,P8,"#*

,)&#'+ +,$,+5 &D, (), #) HD#2D (), %,,% &D, '/Q#96(6% 8#2&6", '% ' 2,"&'#) #-)". "'&D,"

&D') '% ')(&D," (),: C& &D#% +,$,+5 H#&D#) &D, ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% (I ') '/Q#9*

6(6% 8#2&6",5 ($," ')- 'Q($, &D, 'I(",/,)&#(),- -#II,",)& ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*'% ,P*

8,"#,)2,%5 (), D'% I6"&D," -#II,",)& %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% HD(%, 8D,)(/,)'+ -#II,"*

,)2, #% '+%( /'&2D,- QA ') #)&,)&#()'+ -#II,",)2,: 4) &D, I#"%& (I &D,%, I6"&D," ,P8,"#,)2*

,%5 (), %,,% &D, I#96", *2 * (,$#*)" 2%?,#-)". X'% ' "'QQ#&5 #) (6" ,P'/8+,_5 HD#+, #) &D,

%,2()- (I &D,%, I6"&D," ,P8,"#,)2,%5 (), %,,% &D, I#96", *2 *"%#-,$ 2%?,#-)". X'% '

-62W5 #) (6" ,P'/8+,_: J(H5 &D, -#II,",)& %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% &D'& '", /(Q#+#?,- '&

&D#% +,$,+ '", '+%( -#II,",)& #) W#)- I"(/ &D, -#II,",)& ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2*

,% &D'& '", /(Q#+#?,- '& &D, 8",$#(6% +,$,+: ND,%, I6"&D," ,P8,"#,)2,% -( )(& #)-,,-

/(Q#+#?, 9"(68#)9 8"(8,"&#,%: d'&D,"5 &D,A '", ,P8,"#,)2,% #) HD#2D 6&&,"+A W)(H#)9+A5

&D, 8#2&6",R% $,D#2+, #% &'W,) ,#&D," '% ' 2,"&'#) &D#)9 (" '% ')(&D," (),: 4) &D, c'%&"(H

I#96",5 I(" ,P'/8+,5 (), H,++ W)(H% &D'& &D, 8#2&6", #% ),#&D," ' "'QQ#& )(" ' -62W: b,&5

(), #% 8,"2,8&6'++A I("2,- &( &'W, #& ,#&D," '% ' "'QQ#& (" '% ' -62W: 4) &D#% ",%8,2&5 &D,%,

I6"&D," %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% '", +#W, (8&#2'+ #++6%#()% ",2(9)#?,- '% %62D5 '% HD,) (),

9(,% () %,,#)9 ') ('" '% 2"((W,- ,$,) #I (), H,++ W)(H% &D'& &D, ('" #% )(& %( 2"((W,-:

i,& /, I#)- ' ),H +'Q,+ I(" &D,%, I6"&D," %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,%T ,P8,"#,)2,% (I 4"%A)".1

/B )//'2%$B 2,,)".1*2:

4 2') )(H %'A &D'& #& #% %(/,D(H #/8"(8," #) &D, 8#2&("#'+ 2'%, &( &'W, &D,%, &H( %,,*

#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% (I ' -#II,",)& W#)-5 &D, ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% ')- &D,

W)(H#)9+A #++6%("A %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,%5 '% ,P8,"#,)2,% ;,$ 2,5 #)%(I'" '% &D,A 2()&"#Q*

6&, &( 2()%&#&6&, (), ')- &D, %'/, ,P8,"#,)2,: ND#% I6"&D," ,P8,"#,)2, #% HD'& 4 D'$,

+'Q,+,- &D, ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, (I %(/,&D#)9 '% ' 8#2&6", &D'& e(++D,#/R% %,,*



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;;K


#)9*#) ,P8,"#,)2, '2&6'++A '/(6)&% &( ')- &D'& 2(/,% -(6Q+,- #) ,P8,"#,)2#)9 ') '/*

Q#96(6% 8#2&6",: 4) 8(#)& (I I'2&5 ') ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, ')- ' W)(H#)9+A

#++6%("A %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, 8",2#%,+A '", )(&D#)9 Q6& &D, -#II,",)& '%8,2&% (I (), ')-

&D, %'/, ,P8,"#,)2,5 2'++ #& #)-#II,",)&+A ') ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, (" ' %,,#)9*#)

,P8,"#,)2,5 ,)2(/8'%%#)9 &D,/: ND,A #)-,,- '", HD'& e(++D,#/ +'Q,+%5 '% H, D'$,

%,,)5 &D, 2()I#96"'&#()'+ ')- &D, ",2(9)#&#()'+ I(+- (I ' &H(I(+- %,,#)9*#) ,P8,"#,)2,

X%,, '9'#) 3(+&(+#)# Y;F7;'\ ;F7;Q[_;F

:

06& '+&,")'&#$,+A5 H, D'$, I(6)- HD'& &D(%, I(+-% '/(6)& &(T &D, I#"%& (), #% ') ,P8,*

"#,)2, (I ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*'% #) HD#2D (), %,,% ') #&,/5 &A8#2'++A ' 8#2&6",R% $,D#2+,5

'% '""')9,- #) ' 2,"&'#) H'A5 HD#+, &D, %,2()- (), #% ') ,P8,"#,)2, (I W)(H#)9+A #++6%("A

%,,#)9*'% #) HD#2D (), %,,% &D'& $,"A #&,/ '% ' 2,"&'#) %(/,&D#)9: C% ' ",%6+&5 HD,) ')'/Q#96(6% 8#2&6", #% '& %&'W,5 H, D'$, &H( -#II,",)& %,,#)9*#) ,P8,"#,)2,%5 (" ($,"'++

%,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,%5 #) HD#2D &H( -#II,",)& I(+-%5 &D, 2()I#96"'&#()'+ I(+- (" &D, '%*

8,2& (I ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*'% ')- &D, ",2(9)#&#()'+ I(+- (" &D, '%8,2& (I W)(H#)9+A #+*

+6%("A %,,#)9*'%5 '", ",%8,2&#$,+A #)$(+$,-: eD,) H, %,, ' 2,"&'#) %(/,&D#)9 X%'A5 '

"'QQ#&_ #) ') '/Q#96(6% 8#2&6",5 (" H, %,, &D'& 8#2&6", '% ' 8#2&6", (I &D'& $,"A %(/,*

&D#)95 H, Q(&D %,, &D, 8#2&("#'+ $,D#2+,R% ,+,/,)&% '% 9"(68,- #) ' 2,"&'#) Xl"'QQ#&#%Dm_

H'A ')- H, %,, &D'& $,D#2+, '% &D'& $,"A %(/,&D#)95 HD#+, HD,) H, %,, ')(&D," %(/,*

&D#)9 X%'A5 ' -62W_ #) &D'& 8#2&6",5 (" H, %,, &D'& 8#2&6", '% ' 8#2&6", (I &D#% (&D," %(/,*

&D#)95 H, Q(&D %,, &D, 8#2&("#'+ $,D#2+,R% ,+,/,)&% '% 9"(68,- #) ')(&D," Xl-62W#%Dm_

H'A ')- H, %,, &D'& $,D#2+, '% &D#% (&D," %(/,&D#)9:

](",($,"5 #& #% )(H 2+,'" HDA &D, &H( I(+-% (I ' %,,#)9*#) ,P8,"#,)2, '", #)%,8'"'Q+,5

'% e(++D,#/ 2+'#/%: >(" &D, I#"%& I(+- D'% ') #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& () HD#2D &D, 2()&,)& (I

&D, %,2()- I(+- #% 9"(6)-,-: N'W, '9'#) &D, c'%&"(H I#96",: 4& #% Q,2'6%, (), %,,% &D,

8#2&6",R% $,D#2+, #) ' l"'QQ#&#%Dm H'A5 QA 8"(8,"+A 9"(68#)9 #&% ,+,/,)&% &D",,*-#/,)*

%#()'++A5 &D'& (), '+%( %,,% #& '% ' "'QQ#&\ +#W,H#%,5 #& #% Q,2'6%, (), %,,% &D, 8#2&6",R%

$,D#2+, #) ' l-62W#%Dm H'A5 QA 8"(8,"+A ",*9"(68#)9 #&% ,+,/,)&% &D",,*-#/,)%#()'++A5

&D'& (), '+%( %,,% #& '% ' -62W: .(5 &'W,) '% ') ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, (I %(/,&D#)9

'% ' 8#2&6",5 ' %,,#)9*#) ,P8,"#,)2, #)-,,- #% 8D,)(/,)(+(9#2'++A 6)#&'"A: >(" #&% ($,"'++

8D,)(/,)'+ 2()&,)& %68,"$,),% () #&% ($,"'++ #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&5 HD#2D #% /'-, QA &D,

&H( -#%&#)2& A,& #)&,"&H#),- 2()&,)&% (I #&% I(+-%5 &D, ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#*

,)2, (I &D, 8#2&6",R% $,D#2+, ')- &D, W)(H#)9+A #++6%("A %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, (I &D'& $,*

;F ND, #-,' (I &",'&#)9 &D, ",2(9)#&#()'+ I(+- #) &,"/% (I HD'& 4 D,", 2'++ ' W)(H#)9+A #++6%("A %,,*

#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, ("#9#)'++A 2(/,% I"(/ i,$#)%() X7ZZK_:



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;;Z


D#2+,: p,)2, HD,),$," ') '/Q#96(6% 8#2&6", #% '& %&'W,5 (), %#/8+A D'% &H( %,,#)9*#)

,P8,"#,)2,%5 (" ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,%5 &D'& ",%8,2&#$,+A %68,"$,), () &D, -#%*

&#)2& ($,"'++ #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&% (I %62D ,P8,"#,)2,%5 HD#2D '9'#) '", ",%8,2&#$,+A /'-,

QA &D, &H( ",%8,2&#$, -#%&#)2& A,& #)&,"&H#),- 2()&,)&% (I &D(%, ,P8,"#,)2,%R I(+-%:

ND#% '22(6)& (I '/Q#96(6% 8#2&6",% &D6% %D(H% &D'& #)&,)&#()'+#%/ #% %'$,- )(& ()+A

H#&D ",%8,2& &( /,",+A &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ I#96",%5 Q6& '+%( H#&D ",%8,2& &( &H(*

-#/,)%#()'+ 8#2&6",% +,'-#)9 &( &D",,*-#/,)%#()'+ ,P8,"#,)2,%: C% H, D'$, #)-,,- a6%&

%,,)5 &D, &H( ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% (I (), ')- &D, %'/, '/Q#96(6% 8#2&6", -#I*

I," #)%(I'" '% &D,A D'$, -#II,",)& #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&% &D'& 2(/, (6& (I &D, #)&,"'2&#()

Q,&H,,) &D, #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&% (I &D,#" ",%8,2&#$, 2()I#96"'&#()'+ I(+-% X&D,#" ",%8,2*

&#$, ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,%_ ')- &D, #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&% (I &D,#" ",%8,2*&#$, ",2(9)#&#()'+ I(+-% X&D,#" ",%8,2&#$, W)(H#)9+A #++6%("A %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,%_:

j6& HD#2D W#)- (I 2()&,)& #% &D, (), &D'& I#96",% #) &D, ",2(9)#&#()'+ I(+- 8'"&#'++A

2()%&#&6&#)9 ') ($,"'++ 8#2&("#'+ ,P8,"#,)2,V 4)%(I'" '% &D'& I(+- #% ' W)(H#)9+A #++6%("A

%,,#)9*'%5 #& #)$(+$,% &D, %(*2'++,- $,;%$# *A*$,",225 &D, W#)- (I 'H'",),%% ),,-,-

HD,) (), D'% &( ",2(9)#?, &D'& (), ')- &D, %'/, (Qa,2& #% 9#$,) &H#2, &( D,": eD,)

%62D ') 'H'",),%% #% '& 8+'A5 &D, 2()&,)& (I ') ,P8,"#,)2, 'II,2&,- QA #& 2') ()+A Q,

(%"(,;#'*/ ;7

: .(5 &D, -#II,",)& #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&% (I &H( ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,%

(I (), ')- &D, %'/, '/Q#96(6% 8#2&6", '", 8'"&#'++A 2()2,8&6'+: >("5 HD#+, &D, 2()&,)&%

(I &D,#" 2()I#96"'&#()'+ I(+-% '", %&#++ )()*2()2,8&6'+5 &D, 2()&,)&% (I &D,#" ",2(9)#&#()'+

I(+-% '", #)%&,'- 2()2,8&6'+:

L: 8 5-%$# J,#%'$ %" 7%.")#)C, K,",#$*E)/)#B

4I HD'& 4 D'$, a6%& %'#- #% 2("",2&5 #& D'% %(/, Q,'"#)9% '% &( &D, #%%6, (I HD,&D," ,P8,"#*

,)2,% '", 2(9)#&#$,+A 8,),&"'Q+,: O(9)#&#$, 8,),&"'Q#+#&A 2') Q, /,')& #) &H( %,)%,%5 '

H,'W," ')- ' %&"()9," (),: `) &D, (), D')-5 A,*4 2(9)#&#$, 8,),&"'Q#+#&A #% &D, &D,%#%

'22("-#)9 &( HD#2D ,)#-,$ &D, 8D,)(/,)'+ 2D'"'2&," %$ &D, #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& (I ') ,P*

8,"#,)2, '", 8,"/,'Q+, QA %&'&,% (I &D,#" %6Qa,2&%R 2(9)#&#$, %A%&,/%5 D,)2, QA &D, 2()*

2,8&% &D'& 2()%&#&6&, &D, #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& (I %62D %&'&,% X2I: ]'28D,"%() Y;F7;[_:

.,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% (I &D, I("/," W#)-5 &D, /,", ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,%

#)$(+$#)9 /,",+A &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ I#96",%5 '", 2(9)#&#$,+A 8,),&"'Q+, #) &D#% H,'W %,)%,:

;7 C% d'I&(8(6+(% XY;FFZ[T 7LK5 7<M_ '2W)(H+,-9,%:



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;GF


C% 4 D'$, %'#-5 &D, #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& (I %62D ,P8,"#,)2,% #% )()*2()2,8&6'+: 4) %62D

2'%,%5 (), 2') #)-,,- ,)&,"&'#) ' 8D,)(/,)'+ %H#&2D ,$,) #I (), D'% )( /'%&,"A (I &D,

",+,$')& 2()2,8&%: J,$,"&D,+,%%5 2()2,8&% /'A H,++ 'II,2& &D, 8D,)(/,)'+ 2D'"'2&,"% (I

%62D ,P8,"#,)2,%5 #)%(I'" '% &D,A /'A H,++ '2&#$'&, '&&,)&#() #) 8,"I("/#)9 &D, 9"(68#)9

a(Q &D'& 8"(/8&% &D, -#II,",)& ,P8,"#,)2,% #)$(+$,-;;

: `) &D, (&D," D')-5 2#$%". 2(9)#*

&#$, 8,),&"'Q#+#&A #% &D, &D,%#% '22("-#)9 &( HD#2D &D, #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& (I ') ,P8,"#*

,)2, #% 8,"/,'Q+, QA %&'&,% (I &D,#" %6Qa,2&%R 2(9)#&#$, %A%&,/%5 D,)2, QA &D, 2()2,8&%

&D'& 2()%&#&6&, &D, #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& (I %62D %&'&,%: .,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% (I &D, %,*

2()- W#)-5 ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% #)$(+$#)9 '/Q#96(6% 8#2&6",%5 '", 2(9)#&#$,+A

8,),&"'Q+, #) &D#% %&"()9 %,)%,: >("5 '% H, D'$, %,,)5 &D,A #)$(+$, ' +'A," (I 2()&,)&

HD#2D #% 2()2,8&6'+5 &D, (), 2("",%8()-#)9 &( &D,#" ",2(9)#&#()'+ I(+-:0,(8+, HD( -,)A &D'& 8,"2,8&#() (I ("-#)'"A (Qa,2&% #% 2()2,8&6'+ %&')-'"-+A -#%&#)*

96#%D Q,&H,,) ,*$/B C)2)%"5 HD#2D ,)'Q+,% ' 8,"2,#$," &( )"&)C)&'*#, ') (Qa,2& #) D," %6"*

"(6)-#)9%5 ')- /*#, C)2)%"5 HD#2D ,)'Q+,% &D, 8,"2,#$," &( $,)&,"#)0B &D, (Qa,2& '% (),

')- &D, %'/, ,)&#&A '& -#II,",)& &#/,%: 4)%(I'" '% &D#% #% &D, 2'%,5 &D,A %'A5 ,'"+A $#%#() #%

)()*2()2,8&6'+ HD#+, +'&, $#%#() #% 2()2,8&6'+: p(H,$,"5 &D,A I6"&D," 2+'#/5 ()+A &D,

I("/," W#)- (I $#%#() #% 9,)6#),+A 8,"2,8&6'+5 #% ' H'A (I 8,"2,8&6'++A 9"'%8#)9 &D, (Q*

a,2&% (6& &D,",\ &D, +'&&," #% a6%& ' /'&&," (I #)&,"8",&'&#() (I &D, 8,"2,8&6'+ -'&': ND#% #%

HDA5 &D,A 2(//,)&5 8,"2,8&#() #% 2(9)#&#$,+A #/8,),&"'Q+, X2I: ,:9: 0A+A%DA) Y;FFG[\

d'I&(8(6+(% Y;FFZ[_:

b,& #I ' 8#2&("#'+ ,P8,"#,)2, H("W% #) &,"/% (I ') ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, '% 4

D'$, D,", /'#)&'#),-5 &D#% H'A (I 86&&#)9 &D#)9% 2'))(& D(+- (I #&: >(" #) ' 8#2&("#'+ ,P*

8,"#,)2, %( 2()2,#$,-5 ,'"+A $#%#() #% 2(/8+,&,+A ,PD'6%&,- QA &D, ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*

'% I(+- (I &D'& ,P8,"#,)2,5 HD#2D '-/#&&,-+A #% )()*2()2,8&6'+ #) #&% #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&:

4I ,'"+A $#%#() 2') Q, 6)8'2W,- #) &,"/% (I ' 8"#/'"A %W,&2D5 #) HD#2D Q'%#2'++A &D, 8,"*

2,#$,- (Qa,2&%R 2()&(6"% '", 9"'%8,-5 ')- (I ' ;rq %W,&2D5 #) HD#2D -,8&D D,)2, -#%*

&')2, ",+'&#()% '/()9 &D, 8,"2,#$,- (Qa,2&% '", 9"'%8,-;G

5 &D,) %62D ') 6)8'2W#)9 #%

8",2#%,+A HD'& &'W,% 8+'2, #) &D, ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*'% I(+- (I ' 8#2&("#'+ ,P8,"#,)2,

2()2,#$,- '% ') ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,: 4) %62D ' I(+- '++ %62D I,'&6",% (I &D, 8#2*

&6",R% $,D#2+,5 HD#2D '% %62D #% a6%& ') (Qa,2& '/()9 /')A (&D," (Qa,2&%5 '", 9"'%8,-

H'* #&% 9"(68#)9 8"(8,"&#,%: b,& #I &D'& 8#2&("#'+ ,P8,"#,)2, %( 2()2,#$,- #% ",'++A ' 8,"*

2,8&#() '+&D(69D ' 2') .,",$)2 (), '% e(++D,#/ 2+'#/% QA &",'&#)9 #& '% ' &H(I(+- %,,#)9*

;; 4 D'$, -,I,)-,- &D#% &D,%#% #) 3(+&(+#)# X;F77_:

;G C% d'I&(8(6+(% XY;FFZ[T ;^;*;^L_ 2+'#/% () Q,D'+I (I ]'"" X7ZKF_:



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;G7


#) ,P8,"#,)2,5 #&% 8,"2,8&6'+ 2D'"'2&," #% )(& 'Q%("Q,- QA #&% ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*'%

I(+-\ #&% W)(H#)9+A #++6%("A %,,#)9*'% I(+- #% 9,)6#),+A 8,"2,8&6'+ '% H,++;L

: b,&5 '% H,

D'$, %,,)5 &D#% +'&&," I(+- #% 2()2,8&6'+ #) #&% #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&: jA Q,#)9 2()2,8&6'+5

&D#% I(+- #% ' 2'%, (I +'&, $#%#(): b,& %#)2, #& 2()&"#Q6&,% &( &D, 8,"2,8&6'+ 2D'"'2&," (I &D,

8#2&("#'+ ,P8,"#,)2, %( 2()2,#$,-5 '& +,'%& #) %62D ' 2'%, +'&, $#%#() 6&&,"+A 2()&"#Q6&,% &(

8,"2,8&#()\ D,)2,5 8,"2,8&#() #) &D, 2'%, (I ' 8#2&("#'+ ,P8,"#,)2, %( 2()2,#$,- #% 2(9)#*

&#$,+A 8,),&"'Q+, #) &D, %&"()9 %,)%,5 &D'& #%5 2()2,8&% I#96", #) &D, ($,"'++ #)&,)&#()'+

2()&,)& (I %62D ' %&'&,:

<: 8" DEF,(#)%" *"& * L,;/B

`), /#9D& %&#++ H()-," HD,&D," ') ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, /'-, QA &H( &A8(+(9#*

2'++A -#%&#)2& %,,#)9*'% I(+-%5 '% &( /A /#)- ' 8#2&("#'+ ,P8,"#,)2, (I %,,#)9*#) '/(6)&%

&(5 D'% &( D'$, ') #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& &D'& #% '& +,'%& 8'"&#'++A 2()2,8&6'+: C% ",9'"-%

'/Q#96(6% /,",+A &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ I#96",%5 4 D'$, '-/#&&,- Q,I(", &D'& (), HD( /'%*

&,"% ,:9: ),#&D," &D, 2()2,8& (I E,)". * &)*?%"& )(" &D, 2()2,8& (I E,)". * 2H'*$, 2')

,)&,"&'#) &D, ",+,$')& 8D,)(/,)'+ %H#&2D 2()2,")#)9 &D, '/Q#96(6% ]'2D I#96",: 4)

I'2&5 4 D'$, %'#-5 &D, #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& (I &D, ",+,$')& ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#*

,)2,% &D,", #% )()*2()2,8&6'+: b,&5 (), /#9D& H()-,"5 #% #& )(& &D, %'/, #) &D, 2'%, (I

'/Q#96(6% 8#2&6",%T '% &( ,:9: &D, c'%&"(H I#96",5 2'))(& (), HD( /'%&,"% ),#&D," &D,

2()2,8& (I E,)". * &'(4 )(" &D, 2()2,8& (I E,)". * $*EE)# ,)&,"&'#) &D, ",+,$')& 8D,*

)(/,)'+ %H#&2DV C)- #I &D#% #% &D, 2'%,5 -(,% )(& &D#% %D(H &D'& &D, 2()&,)& (I ,#&D,"

%,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, #% 6&&,"+A )()*2()2,8&6'+5 #& #% '& /(%& -,%2"#Q,- (" #)&,"8",&,- '%

2()2,8&6'+V XOI: '9'#) d'I&(8(6+(% Y;FFZ\ ;F77[ ')- ]'28D,"%() D,"%,+I Y;FFM[T Z<_:

>#"%& (I '++5 (), /#9D& ",&("& &D'& ,/8#"#2'+ ,$#-,)2, 9(,% '9'#)%& &D#% DA8(&D,%#%T

2D#+-",) +,%% &D') I(6"*A,'"%*(+- HD( -( )(& 8(%%,%% &D, ",+,$')& 2()2,8&% '", ,)'Q+, &(

,)&,"&'#) &D, %H#&2D,% 2()2,")#)9 ') '/Q#96(6% I#96", X2I: S(8)#W5 d(%'&# Y;FF7[\ %,, '+*

%( i,(8(+-5 i(9(&D,&#% Y7ZZZ[_;<

: b,& ,$,) #I 2()&"'"A &( %62D ') ,$#-,)2, #& &6"),- (6&

;L C% ,$,) )()*2()2,8&6'+#%&% H(6+- '-/#& #I &D, W)(H#)9+A #++6%("A %,,#)9*'% H,", )(& ' I(+- (I

') ($,"'++ ,P8,"#,)2, Q6& #& 2(/8+,&,+A 2D'"'2&,"#?,- ') ,P8,"#,)2,5 '% #) &D, 2'%, (I (8&#2'+ #++6*

%#()%: `8&#2'+ #++6%#()% '", '2&6'++A &D, ,P'/8+,% >(-(" X7ZKG_ #)$(W,% #) ("-," &( 8"($, &D, /(-*

6+'" 2D'"'2&," (I ("-#)'"A 8,"2,8&#():;<

N( Q, %6",5 &D, )()*2()2,8&6'+ #)&,)&#()'+#%& /'A ",8+A &( &D#% &D'& ,$,) #I 8(%%,%%#() (I %62D

2()2,8&% #% ",U6#",- &( ,)&,"&'#) &D, 8D,)(/,)'+ %H#&2D5 #& #% )(& %6II#2#,)& #) ("-," I(" &D, #)*

&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& (I &D, ",+,$')& %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% &( Q, 2()2,8&6'+: C+&D(69D 2()2,8&%



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;G;


&D'& #)-#$#-6'+% H#&D(6& %62D ' /'%&,"A '", 'Q+, &( 8,"I("/ &D, ",+,$')& 8D,)(/,)'+

%H#&2D;M

5 &D#% H(6+- ()+A 8"($, &D'& &D, 2()2,8&6'+ 2()&,)& ') ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#*

,)2, #% /,22 I#),*9"'#),- &D') H, ,P8,2&,-T #& D'% &( Q, '22(6)&,- I(" #) &,"/% (I ' 2,"*

&'#) 2()2,8&6'+ -#%a6)2&#() "'&D," &D') #) &,"/% (I ' %#)9+, 2()2,8&:

4) &D#% ",%8,2&5 #& #% #)&,",%&#)9 &( )(&, &D'& '% ",9'"-% ') '/Q#96(6% 8#2&6",5 a6%&

%(/, 2()2,8& 8"(/8&% &D, ",+,$')& 8D,)(/,)'+ %H#&2D: O()%#-," ()2, '9'#) &D, c'*

%&"(H I#96", ')- %688(%, A(6 %,, #& '% ' -62W: 4I A(6 %'H #& '% ' .%%2,5 A(6 H(6+- %&#++

D'$, &D, %'/, ,P8,"#,)2,: b(6 D'$, &( %,, #& ,:9: '% ' $*EE)# &( ,)&,"&'#) &D, ",+,$')&

8D,)(/,)'+ %H#&2D: `) &D, (&D," D')-5 %688(%, A(6 %,, &D, I#96", 8",2#%,+A '% ' "'QQ#&5

QA &D,",I(", D'$#)9 ')(&D," %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, 2()2,")#)9 #&: 4I A(6 %'H #& '% ' -*$,5

A(6 H(6+- %&#++ D'$, &D, %'/, ,P8,"#,)2,: b(6 D'$, &( %,, #& ,:9: '% ' &'(4 &( ,)&,"&'#)&D, ",+,$')& 8D,)(/,)'+ %H#&2D:

C )()*2()2,8&6'+#%& /'A %'A &D'& &D#% I'2& %D(H% &D'& ' 2,"&'#) ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P*

8,"#,)2, D'% )( 2()2,8&6'+ #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& I(" #& #% ') ,P8,"#,)2, &D'& #& #% /,",+A

2()2,8&6'++A #)&,"8",&,- #) ' 2,"&'#) H'A;^

: j6& &D#% #% )(& HD'& &D#% I'2& %D(H%: d'&D,"5

#& %#/8+A %D(H% &D'& &D,", '", +#/#&% &( &D, #)&,"8",&'&#()T #) (), H'A (I %,,#)9 &D, '/*

Q#96(6% 8#2&6",5 (), 2') '88"(8"#'&,+A #)&,"8",& &D, 8#2&6", '22("-#)9 &( -#II,",)& 2()*

2,8&%5 A,& '++ &D,%, 2()2,8&% D'$, &( Q, 2(/8'&#Q+, H#&D ' 2,"&'#) 8D,)(/,)'+ 2D'"'2&,"

(I &D, 8#2&6",R% ,P8,"#,)2,: `&D," 2()2,8&% '88,'" &( Q, '88"(8"#'&, ()+A ()2, &D, ,P*

8,"#,)2, D'% ' -#II,",)& 8D,)(/,)'+ 2D'"'2&,"5 #& Q,2(/,% ') 6&&,"+A -#II,",)& ($,"'++

%,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,: J(H5 &D#% 8",-#2'/,)& 2') Q, '22(6)&,- I(" QA %'A#)9 &D'& #) #&%

W)(H#)9+A #++6%("A %,,#)9*'% I(+-5 ' 2,"&'#) ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, D'% ' 2()2,8&6'+

#)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& HD(%, ,P&,)%#() #% Q"('-," &D') HD'& (), ("#9#)'++A %688(%,-\

)'/,+A5 ') ,P&,)%#() &D'& 2(#)2#-,% H#&D &D'& (I &D, -#%a6)2&#() (I &D, 2()2,8&% &D'& '",

/(Q#+#?,- #) &D, '88"(8"#'&, #)&,"8",&'&#()%:

8"(/8& &D, %H#&2D5 &D,A -( )(& I#96", '% 2()%&#&6,)&% (I &D, 2()&,)&% (I %62D ,P8,"#,)2,%5 HD#2D

",/'#) )()*2()2,8&6'+ X#) &D, &,"/% (I &D, 8",$#(6% .,2&#()5 '/Q#96(6% 8#2&6",% '% H,++ '% '/*

Q#96(6% I#96",% H(6+- &D6% %688("& '& /(%& H,'W5 Q6& )(& %&"()95 2(9)#&#$, 8,),&"'Q#+#&A_: OI: NA,

X7ZZ<_T 7LF: 4 D(H,$," &D#)W &D'& &D#% ",8+A #% "6+,- (6& QA HD'& 4 8",$#(6%+A %'#-T 8#2&("#'+ ,P8,"#*

,)2,% '", 6)+#W, ,P8,"#,)2,% (I /,",+A &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ I#96",% #) &D'& &D,A D'$, ",2(9)#&#()'+

I(+-%5 D,)2, #I &D,A /(Q#+#?, 2()2,8&% &D,%, I#96", H#&D#) &D, #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&% (I %62D I(+-%:

>(" (&D," 2"#&#2#%/% &( NA,R% 8(#)& (I $#,H5 2I: ̀ "+')-# X;F77_T G7;:;M

0,"D'8% %62D ') ,$#-,)2, #% )(& %( -,2#%#$,5 '% ]'28D,"%() XY;FFM[T Z<5 )(&, G<_ 2+'#/%:;^

C% '9'#) d'I&(8(6+(% X;FFZ\ ;F77_ 2+'#/% '/()9 (&D,"%:



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;GG


.(5 H, %D(6+- )(& 8"(8,"+A %'A &D'& ' 2,"&'#) ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, (I ,:9: &D,

c'%&"(H I#96", 8D,)(/,)'++A #% &D, ,P8,"#,)2, #& #% #)-,8,)-,)&+A (I HD,&D," #& #% #)&,"*

8",&,- ,#&D," '% &D, %,,#)9 (I &D, I#96", '% ' -62W (" '% &D, %,,#)9 (I &D, I#96", '% '

9((%,: d'&D,"5 H, %D(6+- %'A &D'& %62D ' %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, 8D,)(/,)'++A #% &D, 8D,*

)(/,)'+ ,P8,"#,)2, #& #% #)%(I'" '% #) #&% W)(H#)9+A #++6%("A I(+-5 #& #% &D, ,P8,"#,)2, (I

%,,#)9 &D, I#96", '% ') ')'&#- X#:,:5 ,#&D," '% ' -62W (" '% ' 9((%,_: i#W,H#%,5 H, %D(6+-

)(& 8"(8,"+A %'A &D'& ')(&D," ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, (I &D, %'/, I#96", 8D,)(/,*

)'++A #% &D, ,P8,"#,)2, #& #% #)-,8,)-,)&+A (I HD,&D," #& #% #)&,"8",&,- ,#&D," '% &D, %,,*

#)9 (I &D, I#96", '% ' "'QQ#& (" '% &D, %,,#)9 (I &D, I#96", '% ' D'",: d'&D,"5 H, %D(6+-

%'A &D'& %62D ' %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, 8D,)(/,)'++A #% &D, 8D,)(/,)'+ ,P8,"#,)2, #& #%

#)%(I'" '% #) #&% W)(H#)9+A #++6%("A I(+-5 #& #% &D, ,P8,"#,)2, (I %,,#)9 &D, I#96", '% ' +,8(*"#- X#:,:5 ,#&D," '% ' "'QQ#& (" '% ' D'",_:

`), /6%& D,", )(& Q, +,- '%&"'A QA &D, I'2& &D'& &D, #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& (I &D, 8#2*

&6", k #) (), (I #&% #)&,"8",&'&#()%5 #I #& #% ') '/Q#96(6% 8#2&6", k D'% ' )'""(H," ,P&,)*

%#() &D') &D, 2()2,8&6'+ #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& (I &D, W)(H#)9+A #++6%("A I(+- (I &D, ",+,*

$')& ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, &D'& 2()2,")% %62D ' 8#2&6",: >(" %62D ' 2()&,)& #%

HD'& &6")% (6& (I ' ),9(&#'&#() &D'& I#P,% HD'&5 '/()9 '++ &D#)9% &D'& (), 2') %,, &D,

8#2&6", '%5 #% #-, 2()&,)& (I &D'& 8#2&6",5 HD'& &D'& 8#2&6", #% %0 k '9'#)5 #I #& #% ') '/Q#9*

6(6% 8#2&6",5 #) (), (I #&% #)&,"8",&'&#()%:

>(" #)%&')2,5 H#&D ",%8,2& &( %", #)&,"8",&'&#() (I &D, I(++(H#)9 '/Q#96(6% 8#2&6",5

#) &D, W)(H#)9+A #++6%("A I(+- (I ' (,$#*)" ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, 2()2,")#)9 #& (),

2') %,, #& ,#&D," '% i,)#) (" '% S,)9#% sD') (" '% /')A (&D," /(6%&'2D,- D6/') /'+,%5

#)%(I'" '% (), 2') 9,),"#2'++A %,, #& '% ' /(6%&'2D,- D6/') /'+,: b,& #) &D#% #)&,"8",&'*

&#() #& #% ()+A ' 8#2&6", (I i,)#)5 I(" &D#% #% %", H'A &D, 8#2&6", D'% Q,,) (II#2#'++A /,')&:

eD#+, H#&D ",%8,2& &( *"%#-,$ #)&,"8",&'&#() (I &D'& 8#2*

&6",5 #) &D, W)(H#)9+A #++6%("A I(+- (I *"%#-,$ ($,"'++ %,,*

#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, 2()2,")#)9 #& (), 2') %,, #& 8",&&A /62D

#) &D, %'/, H'A '% #I %D, +((W,- '& #& I"(/ %&')-#)9 'Q($,

#&\ &D'& #%5 ,#&D," '% OD, S6,$'"' (" '% &D, 4&'+#') ,P*

2(/,-#') j,88, S"#++( (" '% /')A (&D," Q,'"-,- D6/')

/'+,%5 #)%(I'" '% (), 2') 9,),"#2'++A %,, #& '% ' Q,'"-,-

D6/') /'+,: b,& #) &D#% #)&,"8",&'&#() #& #% ()+A ' 8#2&6",

(I OD,5 I(" &D#% #% *"%#-,$ H'A &D, 8#2&6", D'% Q,,) (II#2#'+*

+A /,')& X%,, 3(+&(+#)# Y;F7;'[T 7KG*7KM_:



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;GL


M: 3)##.,"2#,)" *2 * K$,('$2%$ %0 #-, K$,2,"# !&,*2

C++ #) '++5 &D,",I(",5 H, D'$, &H( -#II,",)& W#)-% (I %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,%5 ' /,", ,P8,*

"#,)2, (I ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*'% &D'& 'II,2&% /,",+A &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ I#96",% HD(%, #)*

&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& #% )()*2()2,8&6'+ ')- ') ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, &D'& 'II,2&% 8#2*

&6",%5 #:,:5 &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ I#96",% ,)-(H,- H#&D ' &D",,*-#/,)%#()'+ #)&,"8",&'&#()5

#:,:5 ') ,P8,"#,)2, (I %,,#)9 ' I#96", '% ' 8#2&6", (I %(/,&D#)9: 4) #&% &6")5 &D#% ($,"'++

%,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2, #% e(++D,#/R% ')'+A?,- %,,#)9*#) ,P8,"#,)2,: 4& #% #)-,,- /'-, (I

&H( #)&,"&H#),- A,& &A8(+(9#2'++A -#II,",)& ,P8,"#,)&#'+ I(+-%5 ' I(+- '9'#) (I ("9')#?'*

&#()'+ %,,#)9*'% HD(%, #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& #% '9'#) )()*2()2,8&6'+ ')- ')(&D," I(+-

9"(6)-,- () &D, 8",$#(6% (),5 ' I(+- (I W)(H#)9+A #++6%("A %,,#)9*'%5 HD(%, #)&,)&#()'+

2()&,)& D(H,$," #% 2()2,8&6'+:

J(H5 '+&D(69D e#&&9,)%&,#) #% 9,),"'++A #)&,"8",&,- '% &D, /'#) -,I,)-," (I &D,

2()2,8&6'+#%& #)&,)&#()'+#%& 8(%#&#()5 D#% #-,'% () %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% '", /(", '"&#26*

+'&,-: 4) 8(#)& (I I'2&5 D, %(/,D(H 2'8&6",- &D, 'Q($, -#%&#)2&#() Q,&H,,) -#II,",)&

&A8,% (I %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% HD,) D, -",H ') ')'+(9(6% -#%&#)2&#() Q,&H,,) %;#)(*/

')- (%"(,;#'*/ '%8,2&%;K

: >(" e#&&9,)%&,#)5 I#"%& (I '++5 (8&#2'+ '%8,2&% '", 2D'"'2&,"#?,-

QA &D, I'2& &D'& &D, 8D,)(/,)'+ %H#&2D &D,A /(Q#+#?, Q,&H,,) -#II,",)& %,,#)9*'% ,P8,*

"#,)2,% (I (), ')- &D, %'/, I#96", (226"% '6&(/'&#2'++A\ HD#+, '% ",9'"-% 2()2,8&6'+

'%8,2&%5 (), %62D %H#&2D #% %6Qa,2& &( (),R% H#++: ](",($,"5 ') (8&#2'+ '%8,2& #% /(Q#+#?,-8",2#%,+A HD,) (), /,",+A %,,% ' &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ I#96", #) ' 2,"&'#) H'A X"'&D," &D') #)

')(&D," (),_5 HD#+, ' 2()2,8&6'+ '%8,2& #% /(Q#+#?,- HD,)5 #) $#"&6, (I %,,#)9 ' &H(*

-#/,)%#()'+ I#96",5 (), %,,% #& '% ' &D",,*-#/,)%#()'+ #&,/ X(" '% ')(&D," (),_ X2I: e#&&*

9,)%&,#) Y7ZKF[T 45 hh Z^F5 7F7^_: 4& #% ()+A #) &D, %,2()- 2'%, &D'& &D, ",+,$')& %,,#)9*'%

,P8,"#,)2, D'% ' 2()2,8&6'+ #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&\ #)

&D, I#"%& 2'%,5 H, 2') 2()a,2&6", X'+&D(69D e#&&9,)*

%&,#) -(,% )(& 86& #& #) &D,%, &,"/%_ &D'& #&% #)&,)*

&#()'+ 2()&,)& #% /,",+A )()*2()2,8&6'+: >#)'++A5 (),

')- &D, %'/, I#96", 2') Q, &D, (Qa,2& (I Q(&D W#)-%

(I ,P8,"#,)2,%: ND#% #% &D, 2'%, (I &D, %(*2'++,- l-(6*

Q+, 2"(%%m*I#96",:

`), /'A H,++ 8'%% I"(/ %,,#)9 &D, 'Q($, I#96", '%

' HD#&, 2"(%% () ' Q+'2W Q'2W9"(6)- &( %,,#)9 &D'&

;K C% 0,'2(2W, XY7ZKG[T ;<5 )(&, ;^_ ("#9#)'++A 6)-,"+#),-:



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;G<


I#96", '% ' Q+'2W 2"(%% () ' HD#&, Q'2W9"(6)-: b,& (), /'A '+%( 8'%% I"(/ /,",+A %,,#)9

' &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ Q+'2W I#96", X2'++ #& ' &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ Q+'2W 2"(%% #I A(6 +#W,_ I+')W,-

'% #& H,", QA ' HD#&, &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ '""'A (I &"#')9+,% &( /,",+A %,,#)9 ' &H(*

-#/,)%#()'+ HD#&, I#96", X2'++ #& ' &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ HD#&, 2"(%% #I A(6 +#W,_ I+')W,- '% #&

H,", QA ' Q+'2W &H(*-#/,)%#()'+ '""'A (I &"#')9+,%: 4) &D#% l&H(*-#/,)%#()'+m %&')2, &(

&D, I#96",5 H, D'$, ' %H#&2D Q,&H,,) -#II,",)& ("9')#?'&#()'+ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,%

XHD(%, #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)& #%5 H, /'A '--5 )()*2()2,8&6'+_: N( Q, %6",5 e#&&9,)%&,#)

-(,% )(& ,$,) %'A &D'& #) &D, 8",$#(6% l&D",,*-#/,)%#()'+m %&')2, &( &D, I#96",5 (), D'%

-#%&#)2& ($,"'++ %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#,)2,% /'-, QA &H( I(+-% HD(%, 2()&,)& #% ",%8,2&#$,+A

)()*2()2,8&6'+ ')- 2()2,8&6'+: b,& D, 2+,'"+A /,')% &D'& &D'& ()+A #) %62D ' %&')2,

2()2,8&% '", #)$(+$,- #) &D, #)&,)&#()'+ 2()&,)&% (I &D, &H( ",+,$')& %,,#)9*'% ,P8,"#*,)2,%: C% D, 86&% #&T

ND(%, &H( '%8,2&% (I &D, -(6Q+, 2"(%% X4 %D'++ 2'++ &D,/ C '%8,2&%_ /#9D& Q, ",8("&,- %#/8+A

QA 8(#)&#)9 '+&,")'&,+A &( ' I",,*%&')-#)9 HD#&, ')- ' I",,*%&')-#)9 Q+'2W 2"(%%:

4)-,,-5 (), 2(6+- #/'9#), &D#% '% ' 8"#/#&#$, ",'2&#() #) ' 2D#+-5 ,$,) Q,I(", D, 2(6+- &'+W:

Yn[:

ND, C '%8,2&% '", )(& ,%%,)&#'++A &D",,*-#/,)%#()'+\ ' Q+'2W 2"(%% () ' HD#&, 9"(6)- #% )(&

,%%,)&#'++A ' 2"(%% H#&D ' HD#&, %6"I'2, #) &D, Q'2W9"(6)-: `), 2(6+- &,'2D %(/,(), &D,

#-,' (I &D, Q+'2W 2"(%% () ' 9"(6)- (I -#II,",)& 2(+(6" H#&D(6& %D(H#)9 D#/ ')A&D#)9 (&D,"

&D') 2"(%%,% 8'#)&,- () %D,,&% (I 8'8,": p,", &D, lQ'2W9"(6)-m #% %#/8+A &D, %6""(6)-#)9 (I

&D, 2"(%%: Xe#&&9,)%&,#) Y;FFZL

[T 44 P#5 hh ;7<5 ;7K_:

j#Q+#(9"'8DA

j+(2W5 J:5 ;F7F5 8##,"#)%" *"& =,"#*/ K*)"# 5 l0D#+(%(8D#2'+ 4%%6,%m5 ;F5 88: ;G*MG:

OD'+/,"%5 q:5 ;FFL5 6-, L,;$,2,"#*#)%"*/ 7-*$*(#,$ %0 9:;,$),"(,5 #) j: i,#&," X,-:_5 6-,

M'#'$, %0 K-)/%2%;-B 5 `PI("- @)#$,"%#&A 0",%%5 `PI("-5 88: 7<G*K7:

OD#%D(+/5 d:5 7ZZG5 8(#N 7%"#,"# *"& #-, J'(41L*EE)# 5 #) c:e: O')I#,+-5 .:S: .D')W,"

X,-%:_5 3)##.,"2#,)"O2 !"#,"#)%"25 S'"+')-5 J,H b("W5 88: ZL*Z<:

OD6"2D+')-5 0:5 7ZKZ5 K,$(,;#'*/ K/*2#)()#B *"& 6-,%$,#)(*/ <,'#$*/)#BP 8 L,;/B #% Q,$$B

M%&%$ 5 #) 8 <,'$%(%?;'#*#)%"*/ K,$2;,(#)C,5 ND, ]4N 0",%%5 O'/Q"#-9, ]C:

O"'),5 N:5 ;FF7 N 9/,?,"#2 %0 =)"& 5 `PI("- @)#$,"%#&A 0",%%5 `PI("-:

>(-("5 c:5 7ZKG5 6-, =%&'/*$)#B %0 #-, =)"& 5 ND, ]4N 0",%%5 O'/Q"#-9, ]C:

S(/Q"#2D5 1:5 7ZMF5 8$# *"& !//'2)%"5 0D'#-()5 i()-():

S(8)#W5 C:5 d(%'&#5 C:5 ;FF75 J'(4 %$ L*EE)#R L,C,$2)". 8?E).'%'2 M).'$,2 *"& S"&,$1

2#*"&)". 8?E).'%'2 L,;$,2,"#*#)%"25 lq,$,+(8/,)&'+ .2#,)2,m5 L5 88: 7^<*7KG:



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;GM


p(8W#)%5 d:5 ;F7F5 !"0/,(#,& K)(#%$)*/ 9:;,$),"(,P )#2 6$,*#?,"# *"& 5).")0)(*"(,5 #) O:

CQ,++5 s: j')&#)'W# X,-%:_5 K-)/%2%;-)(*/ K,$2;,(#)C,2 %" J,;)(#)%"5 `PI("- @:0:5 `PI("-5

88: 7<7*7KF:

c'9)(H5 d:5 ;F775 8?E).'%'2 M).'$,2 *"& #-, 5;*#)*/ 7%"#,"#2 %0 K,$(,;#'*/ 9:;,$),"(,P

8 J,0,"2, 0 L,;$,2,"#*#)%"*/)2?5 l0D,)(/,)(+(9A ')- &D, O(9)#&#$, .2#,)2,%m5 7F5 88:

G;<*GLM:

i,(8(+-5 q:C:5 i(9(&D,&#%5 J:s:5 7ZZZ5 ='/#)2#*E/, K-,"%?,"*P 7-*".)". T),A2 )" K,$1

(,;#)%"5 lN",)-% #) O(9)#&#$, .2#,)2,%m5 G5 88: ;<L*;ML:

i,$#)%()5 c:5 7ZZK5 3%//-,)? %" K)(#%$)*/ L,;$,2,"#*#)%"5 lND, c(6")'+ (I C,%&D,&#2% ')-

C"& O"#&#2#%/m5 <M5 88: ;;^*;GG:

i(8,%5 q:5 7ZZM5 S"&,$2#*"&)". K)(#'$,25 `PI("- @:0:5 `PI("-:

]'28D,"%()5 >:5 ;FFM5 8?E).'%'2 M).'$,2 *"& #-, 7%"#,"# %0 9:;,$),"(,5 lJ(6%m5 LF5 88:K;*77^:

]'28D,"%()5 >:5 ;F7;5 7%.")#)C, K,",#$*#)%" %0 7%/%'$ 9:;,$),"(,P L,#-)"4)". #-, !22',

)" >).-# %0 *" !"&)$,(# =,(-*")2?5 l0D#+(%(8DA ')- 0D,)(/,)(+(9#2'+ d,%,'"2Dm5 KL5

88: ;L*M;:

]'""5 q:5 7ZK;5 T)2)%"5 >",,/')5 .') >"')2#%2(:

J')'A5 j:5 ;F7F5 8##,"#)%" *"& K,$(,;#'*/ 7%"#,"# 5 l 8"*/B2)2m5 ^F5 88: ;MG*;F:

J')'A5 j:5 ;F775 8?E).'%'2 M).'$,2N 8##,"#)%"N *"& K,$(,;#'*/ 7%"#,"#P L,;/B #%

Q*."%A 5 l0D,)(/,)(+(9A ')- &D, O(9)#&#$, .2#,)2,%m5 7F5 88: <<^*<M7:

J,H'++5 ]:5 ;F775 3-*# )2 * K)(#'$,R 5 j'%#)9%&(W,5 0'+9"'$,:J#2W,+5 j:5 ;FF^5 8.*)"2# !"#,"#)%"*/)2?5 l0D#+(%(8D#2'+ .&6-#,%m5 7GM5 88: ;^Z*GFL:

`"+')-#5 J:5 ;F775 8?E).'%'2 M).'$,2 *"& L,;$,2,"#*#)%"*/)2?5 l0D,)(/,)(+(9A ')-

&D, O(9)#&#$, .2#,)2,%m5 7F5 88: GF^*G;G:

0,'2(2W,5 O:5 7ZKG5 5,"2, *"& 7%"#,"# 5 O+'",)-() 0",%%5 `PI("-:

0,'2(2W,5 O:5 7ZZ;5 8 5#'&B %0 7%"(,;#25 ND, ]4N 0",%%5 O'/Q"#-9, ]C:

0A+A%DA)5 t:5 ;FFG5 5,,)". *"& T)2'*/)@)".5 ND, ]4N 0",%%5 O'/Q"#-9, ]C:

d'I&(8(6+(%5 C:5 ;FFZ5 7%.")#)%" *"& K,$(,;#)%"5 ND, ]4N 0",%%5 O'/Q"#-9, ]C:

d'I&(8(6+(%5 C:5 ;F775 8?E).'%'2 M).'$,2 *"& L,;$,2,"#*#)%"*/)2?5 l.A)&D,%,m5 7K75 88:

LKZ*<7L:.#,H,"&5 O:5 ;FFL5 !2 9:;,$),"(, 6$*"2;*$,"#R 5 l0D#+(%(8D#2'+ .&6-#,%m5 Z^5 88: 7<*L7:

NA,5 ]:5 7ZZ<5 6," K$%E/,?2 %0 7%"2()%'2",225 ND, ]4N 0",%%5 O'/Q"#-9, ]C:

3(+&(+#)#5 C:5 ;F775 U%A K)(#'$, K,$(,;#)%" J,0),2 7%.")#)C, !?;,",#$*E)/)#B 5 #) C: d,Q(6+

X,-:_5 K-)/%2%;-)(*/ K*;,$2 J,&)(*#,& #% V,C)" ='//).*"5 >'26+&u -,% i,&&",%5 @)#$,"%#&u

-, S,)v$,5 S,),$'5 D&&8TEEHHH:8D#+(%(8D#,:2DEW,$#)EI,%&%2D"#I&E:



C+Q,"&( 3(+&(+#)#5 6-, 7%"#,"# %0 * 5,,)".182 9:;,$),"(,

8'9: ;G^


3(+&(+#)#5 C:5 ;F7;'5 U%A #% L,(%"()/, 5,,)".182 A)#- 5,,)".1!" WA)#- =)?,#)( K'$;%2,2 )"

=)"&X5 #) S: O6""#,5 0: s(&R'&W(5 ]: 0(W(")A X,-%:_5 =)?,2)2P =,#*;-B2)(2N 7%.")#)%"N

K$*.?*#)(25 O(++,9, 06Q+#2'&#()%5 i()-()5 88: GKG*LF^:

3(+&(+#)#5 C:5 ;F7;Q5 6%A*$& * 5B"($,#)2#)( 6-,%$B %0 J,;)(#)%"5 #) O: O'+'Q# X,-:_5 K,$(,;1

#'*/ !//'2)%"2Y K-)/%2%;-)(*/ *"& K2B(-%/%.)(*/ 922*B25 0'+9"'$,5 j'%#)9%&(W,5 88: 7ML*

7Z7:

3(+&(+#)#5 C:5 ;F7G5 6-, =*$4 %0 #-, =,"#*/ 5 l0D,)(/,)(+(9A ')- ]#)-m5 L5 XI("&D2(/*

#)9_:

3() 1D",)I,+%5 O:5 7ZKK5 D" G,2#*/#1Z'*/)#),25 #) j: ./#&D X,-:_5 M%'"&*#)%"2 %0 G,2#*/#

6-,%$B 5 0D#+(%(8D#'5 ]6)#2D ')- 3#,))'5 88: K;*77^:

e#&&9,)%&,#)5 i:5 7ZKF5 L,?*$42 %" #-, K-)/%2%;-B %0 K2B(-%/%.B 5 4*445 j+'2WH,++5 `PI("-:

e#&&9,)%&,#)5 i:5 ;FFZL5 K-)/%2%;-)(*/ !"C,2#).*#)%"25 j+'2WH,++5 `PI("-:

e(++D,#/5 d:5 7ZKF;5 5,,)".1*2N 5,,)".1)"N *"& K)(#%$)*/ L,;$,2,"#*#)%"5 #) 8$# *"& )#2 DE1

F,(#25 O'/Q"#-9, @:0:5 O'/Q"#-9,5 88: ;F<*;;M:

e(++D,#/5 d:5 7ZK^5 K*)"#)". *2 *" 8$# 5 0"#)2,&() @:0:5 0"#)2,&():

e(++D,#/5 d:5 7ZZK5 D" K)(#%$)*/ L,;$,2,"#*#)%"5 lND, c(6")'+ (I C,%&D,&#2% ')- C"& O"#&#*

2#%/m5 <M5 88: ;7^*;;M:

Voltolini 2013_The Content of a Seeing-As Experience

Documents

Transcript of Voltolini 2013_The Content of a Seeing-As Experience