VKT-v-VWS-Hawaii-Part 2

8/12/2019 VKT-v-VWS-Hawaii-Part 2

1/13

case 1:14-cv-00298

Document

1

Filed

0612711,4

page

t4

of L5

pagelD

#: t4

Plaintiff

is

currently

unable

to

ascertain the

full

extent

of

the

profits

Defendant

has

realized

by its

violations

of

L7

U.S.C.

S

1202.

4I.

Plaintiff

is entitled to

elect

to

recover

from

Defendant statutory

damages

for

each

of

its

violations

of

17

U.S.C.

g

1202.

42.

Plaintiff

is

further entitled

to

costs

and reasonable

attorneys'

fees.

PRAYER

FOR

RELIEF

WHEREFORE,

Plaintiff

VINCENT KHOURY

TYLOR

prays:

A.

That this

Court

enter an

injunction preliminarily

and

permanently

enjoining

and

restraining

Defendant

and

its directors,

officers,

agents,

servants,

employees,

attorneys,

and all

persons

in

active concert

or

participation

with

Defendant

from infringing Plaintiff's

copyrighted photographic

work

and

from

further violating

17

U.S.C.

g

1202;

B.

That the

Court

order

any

original

infringing

photographs,

prints,

separations,

publications,

copies,

products,

or materials

bearing

the

images,

digital data in

any form and/or

likenesses

impounded and/or destroyed

or

disposed

of in other reasonable

fashion;

C. That Defendant

be

required to

pay

such damages

as

Plaintiff

has sustained and any

profits

Defendant has

gained

in

consequence

of

Defendant's

t4


2/13

Case

1:14-cv-00298

Document

1

Filed

Odl27lt4

Page 15

of

15

PagelD #:

tS

unlawful and

willful

acts or,

in

the

alternative, to

pay

statutory

damages

pursuant

to

77

U.S.C.

$

50a(c)

and 77

U.S.C.

$

1203(c);

D.

That Defendant

be

required to

pay costs,

including

reasonable

attorneys'

fees, to

Plaintiff

pursuant

to 17

U.S.C.

$

505 and L7

U.S.C.

$

1203(b);

and,

E. That Plaintiff

be

granted

such other and further relief

as

the

Court

may

deem

just

and

proper.

DATED:

Honolulu, Hawaii,

June

27,2Ot4.

isl J. Stephen Street

J.

STEPI{EN

STREET

DANE ANDERSON

Attorneys

for

Plaintiff

VINCENT

KHOURY TYLOR

15


3/13

Case

1:14-cv-00298

Document 1-1

Filed

OGl27lL4

Page

1

of

6

PagelD

#:

LG

trIllilhm[

Sadifieah

{l

7

lrLC.

7mt

Certifi

cate

of Registration

This Certificate issued under

the

seal of the Cop,vright

Office

in

accordance

with

title

ry,United

States Code,

attests

that registration

has

been nrade

for the

work

identified

below.'l'he information

on

this

certificate

has

been

made

a

part

of the

Copyright

Office records.

Registration

Number

'o

?a*;ADu.*

Register

of

Copyrights,

United

States of

America

vA

l-696-s55

Effectivc dete

of

rtgfuredon:

Decembcr 17,2W

Title

TfthofWork

Hawaii2000

Com

plet

i

on/

Publ

icat

ion

YearofCompletion:

2000

Date

of

lstPublication: January l, 2000

Nation

of lst Publicdion:

United

Satc

Author

I

Author:

Author

Created:

Workmade

for

hire:

Cittuen

of:

YcerBom:

Mncent

Khoury

Tylor,

&a

Hawaiian kodlv{a*

Images

photogaph(s)

No

United States

t962

Domicitd lr:

United

States

Copyright claimant

CopyrightClrinant

VhcentlftouryTylor

P.O. Box 510164,I(ealia,

HI,96751,

United Sures

Rights

and Permissions

Orgrnlzafion

Name:

l[arm:

Emeil:

Addrcs:

Hawaiian

LandMuk

Images

Michele

Lynn

Tylor

[email protected]

P.O.Box 510154

Kealia, HI 96751 United

Stat6

Telephonc:

80&8211263

Certification

Name:

Michele

L. Tllor

Ihtc:

Docsmber

17,2W

EXHIBIT

A

Page

I

of

2


4/13

Case

1:14-cv-00298

Document

1-1 Filed O1l27lt4

Page

2

ot

6

PagelD #:

t7

lflffinal Ccrdillmte

(rI

ffi.c.

rffil

Reglstradon#:

vA0001696555

&rriccRcquest#:

l-2%9942t1

Ilawaiian

Landlr,lo&. Imoges

Michele Lynn

Tylor

P.O.Box 510164

Kcaliq

HI9675l

Unitod

States


5/13

Case 1:14-cv-00298

Document 1-1 Filed

AGl27lL4

Page 3

of

6

PagelD

#:

18

FormC,A

oryrlght Ofrco

bes are

sublcct to cha:rge.

For cununt

bcr, checl tfie Copyrlght

Off,co

wcblte

* *uutqylglttgw,u,rl'a

tho

ecp/.

right

Otfrce,

or

call

(202)

7G7i1000.

lrrtrlltanaf

arDa-

ul

l-&-711

I4ldoc

Nrnbrrot

6r lrdc frj[a[o

V

vA 1{0655

NddctAdert}V

l/horil

Ktruy

Tylor,

dbe ilaralen L.ndilrd(

lm.fr

Vrrro(ldcl4lfidoV

apo

Nan{d

of Copy{lt Cbtrrd0

Y

\rlnontl0rotryTyla

.,

t.

lrc.dr

tf

l{dlrr

dEcrrcr

llfuidm

h

blc

lAlldo

V

L&r l{utr-

Lb

llrdhr

a

Orrietat

lroarcr

lrloorlh

r

lt

Apgo b

ldc

fChrtioo

V

.t'

,

i. ,.

.lj,

i

m

JUN

2 0

20il

E'T IL Y'

MIqUNI| A OUEn{t

Lf,E

IFYOU

ErciI ?ACE,

UIIA

[email protected]

fIET.

II[.ct

Wo.tY

Heurl

ADO

Erpladolof Caacdo?

i

'

I

t'

:"

La

:rbd{r

arf

N.b*

o[

ldetLrf&o

h

ldc

f4ltth

b

Dr

Arglfnl

V

3 r'

IjENuob.t

:

tlilH.dlc-g..cdpdar

Tilarconbrils

Tila

AnptCod

laloodor. a

Bphdo el btae

V

AOI ltrtmoct NElrl,

Wcb{G.bg

A{13 llod( Scd

dqnecfi

WEB.LG.tse

AO{ }laralao

Sc

Turt

lruoblc.hg

AfillutcGtEcmELG.lpg

AO7

Sulbo

at

DUC(

Wcb.Lc.fpg

A.08 Prtm SunrdllYob.LG.lgg

...

A"1

I

Hdrelan Srnrd Wcb.tOni,

A,-l3Rubrwfiod(LG.he

&15

Scclnlcd

Falh WcbLG.Jpg

A'-17 il.Prl SLn$t ffi WcbLG.Fg

A"20 Surtr.t Tfitrt.WllLcJpg

A-238

BCI

Hd.Srrtsd WcbLG.hg

A,27 Slouh P.dllc

rrnrt

WEb{{.he

A'3O

A-Dry

lt

th. Dcacfi

WcbtGJpg

B4_1d

R.[5ow

Frhr wclLG.he

-.

mA

8le

WrvlWcllG.fpe

A{Xl

}bdr

Scl.bodr WrD-tc.tsg

A{r5 Mod( S.d

rlllh

n.?

WcbLG.hg

Atr

ildf,

Gu.

Wcbfc.he

.

Afi

@ltHaurd

WobtG.De

A.1 0 lrhxl

Sunrt

l,YEbLG.Fg

A-12

Lgll0ttf

d wbbtG.fpg

4"14

Troptcat

t

goon

WS{G.hg

A"lE l{dus

hn }lawtl WcbLG.pg

AF19

Snq*tl

lbtrlfl W.ELG.Fg

A'21 B[.r

Ery

Sm .t

WS{-G.hg

Arza

TroCc.l D.y

W.tsLG.he

A.28

E

ncdd

ulbtt

tf,blc.hg

AA5

Codd

ColqlWcbLG.Fg

- B{r1

Rrlrtor

Fe VUbb{G.tsg

',,i.r..-i.i

1.r.

r.-t.ll.

lr.

r '..''GhW

tlr

|1J

l"r'

'

'tt'

.

''

IOiAOl. UUlf

>"

.colllt

Dblr-pqr

lldr.t.,rEr

a-(|rSlnrrr

.lrtaaEralaart

DStrrttr

tor-

t

-

I


6/13

Case 1:14-cv-00298 Document

1-1 Filed

OGl27l1,4

Page 4

of

6

PagelD

#: 19

FOilCARECE]N'ED

uxcA

F(n

coPvRolr

GFEE

IJSE

q{LY

tt20rut

FI4IOSRECEilED

OAIE

JUN

2

0

20il

EXANTEDB'

@RRESFOTOSEEO

00

rorffil AlouEll{E

Lre.

vol,

xlE

ru

rAca

l[

A

ttPAtA?to0rn[r,Atpx

]EtL

Crlllnrdo

rG

O Prt E

orEl

Put C

B{il Rnrlur

E

d( Srtd Baclt WrbLG.hg B{r3 W.blo Vdcy

Wcbtc.bg

B{BT

W.hlo

Vdcy

Tnc WcbLG.bg

B{t

Anactunll Bay

Smcd Wcb.LcJpg

B{5

Foldo

Smtuc W.bLG.tse

B{0

M.glc

Sgtdr

Bxdt

Wcb.LGJpg

B{TAlrhrF.lttbrwcbtc.lpe

B,{7-VAlcldcF&wr&drUebtG.tsg

B{n Hlgna

Badr

Souh

WebtGJpg

B{e.l,l }bprrn Boch

t{orih

WcbLc.lpg

$10

Scclldorl Corr.

WcbLc.lpg

&t2lGm Co.C

W.btc.irg

$lE

Grtm

Bccdr

WcbLGJpg

Bl&BGorn

Brch

IV.bLG.rpe

&19

Folol,

Vdlty

IIb

ItEB{G.hg

&20

Fololu

Oen

vlow

Wbb.Lc.hg

F{l

Ycttr

Hlbhan

WcbLGJp0

F{n

B[d o, Pr.dlo W-F

lqrd

WebtG.Fg

F-024BEofPredrcWcbLG.be

F-{BR.d}lblurWcbLc.lpe

F-{E

tlfi

OrdJdr dd mbLG.Irg

F{17

Phmrrh W6LG.lpg

K{n Spou0trg }bn

Stnrctwelc.lpe

K{X-B Klauca Llgrttotncw.ELc.lpe

K{a-VKlruc.LhoulovutWGLGJpg

K.05UY*maStlnlltoldweb{G.lpg

K.(&AW &I

FrhrrstcalWcb-LG.h0

K{f,WillFrilrRehbowWcbLc.h0

K.s.G

Uhlln

Falr*lcryy

Rrfrt t{eb{-G.pg

K{r7l(d.|ru Vallry

RlderfVlblG.he

Corrr?crd.la:

Ghrc nau

urd

rddrcr o

whldr

coorrpcdaa

rboot

d&

A?Ucrrbn

loold

b.

ctr.

GLn

Cfiu

llaxdmArtt{eudt

1888|(SueAw

$.

C3l2

T

rtonrt

dlSrStf$t6llll3

tr

sodffi

rxr

078)30$3319

DqcllAmclf

6rngldmie bbb.drqdbrDrportAmunlchDlldrdhttrCq6lhtO6cr,gvrnrocmdruorberof

Aorl*.

Nrur

Aountl,lua$rr

C;tffi

l,

thurdd{n

d, lil{Oy

crtlt

lt .tl.D

th

(Chcdmlym)

fudrr Elorruofcrardwrlrht(r)

-

Elorr-9yxj6cldrilrt

Earry-m*.r

13aia,,

\rhFnt,l0pt{v

Tvtor,

dd:rrcrtHrotlHkr rd dut

tnrusUr

or&by tD la tb

rypucrtbn

tr

coarr b

dr.b.r oa

T[

llrr

@yrlehtSsnloo

lnffind

IrffifC

lE88 lCaleur Avr.

9r.

CXlt2

{onoluhr,

Hl90815

.t,

uEtaFI

A,'

grrlltdtgt{5

rt

rS

ar#r

.Iiblr,tt,Er rrtao.

tshL#rtlttll,t|Il..rFolEEtEt

tE,

rhrrtr-.ilisEr

Grilora

rIb

ml.lh

*lllr

rtttao0i

blll

aaira

frtac^iftI tr.@ll8a hfrOd--.@ Fl|IauHlF

utffiitfr*,D*b,-


7/13

Case

1:14-cv-00298

Document

1-1

Filed

06127lL4

Page

5

of 6

PagelD

#:20

C,ontinuation

Sheet

Form

/4

zox

urmD

ilrm GortEtll otnct

ul

t-{u-7at

orApplication

Forms

a

o

a

a

a

ilN Corfubr $.a

f

rd

h

codr*n

St

Brllr

Cf,

PA

8E 8A

D(

.rd V

odt

hdc.lf,tn

*

bm

nt

]tonllrff

h

o.?Dh tr.

rmj

ltfanrtdErr.

Tryb

tlll

htsIln

bo

c5

tr hb

lrTE

grorllt

l

ottt

*

hll\

lt

rou

(b

rU

h.[

rElleh

?E

qr

lh.

b*

tnn.

ur

hb

Cmlrl&a Atd.

d rfil

l{rlli *tmr

It

you

rlllll

[a oontueo $d.

clp

(b

] l IF. a

is.]

r

b

h.

bt*

bm

fil, 5

tll.

tE 5gdl,

D.blt rarntll3 hrtr

Fo.A

ori5.lll

b

hIU

b

lmt, $. no rerrtr.

}lo

I 5.

drldrt d

p

2

ot

0r

*

ffi.

rrc. I

bncQfcd.5lrql F n

Srca

C

(st

lhr |UUD diL

ol

u.

dt-)

5

tr

lhr

ciltndlt c

$.o..

tt

+

a

a

qr

lla

fb.ptlc&r

ator0rcalti-o

o?

tp.c.

I

ot

ry

Clll

llr

.lcttrl[tAlI'aUA

oo

xoT

urTl AtovE

illl

lJrL Fm

oFvnort *rct uac

cY

JUN

2

(}

TOII

,-

3

r'l

,*

EFFESIIVE

OATE

OF

REOATRANOiI

A

ffit

d

Apilofct

Dt}{fltrcArloif Ol

COItl'DalrAllON $lEBIl

1llb

irrr b

r

q{nrdLr

oC

ttr rgptcrdo tr opftC}t

qEUo

qr

th: brJc

furr

ruDndtd

fu lh blbutg

uoil:

r IlTl&

Gvr

trr

tlttc

rstvtrurtdll

i:h-Urg'IId. oatd.

Waf' h

aral

of

O:bdcfrtu"

Ilmli2000

o ttAMB(S)AltlDADOnES6(88)[email protected]:GtvrCr:rremd.ddltlo,trLroopydCl*ddau*

r

gtva

h

Trc

a

of lh. b.dc

fm

c

4e

2

ol

rny of lhr

Shott

hmt PA

DC

c

VA.

P.O. Eq

510t64,

KcrlL,

HI,96?51

Udbd

SEE

NAllEOTAUTHOEV

Vhccd Khilry

l),ls, dh

Hrmib

lrodltlut

lrrtpr

DATESOSUTTflAIIDDEA1IT

YcrrlotV

tw2

YrrDirdV

Wottdrqru&ruanbdr.

AUfIIOI'SNAmnlAtJrfOnD(XlCllI

wqtr'rortar&forhif?

b.cerr:,

O Yrr

trno

d

B

Conthutat

CQr.,

*tffis';

UniEdStrE

rYA6

tlll3 autuont

Goxrllxrmc{

TOfitUrOnX

Anoonsrr?

Et

Yr

gNo

1P:1-l:f

P.rjmpu,.r Ovc

Eu.

ffi

t*r

l{AllrtSCAUIllOMIIt

Brtdyd.rc6.n

hllof

thrm*slrldbytbruthclnwhlchqd$tb*htcd.V

ItcofmhyofHrmii

NA}IEOFAL'r|IOEY

DAI?E

()P

EIIf,I{

AIID I'8AIII

YerrEomY YrrrDhdV

e

f

OYa

O tlo

WrthbqrtsDudo.rbdr

AUIH(INATKTNAIITAOIHTCII.E

WASTHUIAI]rBOBltCOilTilIJtUtl

rrotr'rrortan&brl&d? rr.chnr,

TOTHIfI

OIX

*tffif,;

-

=---- =::-

ch*.

huhylw? UYr Ut{o

lr'l--

tE

enf,lynot.t

I

v.

9

ib

1 := *'

NAn nEO?AtlTIIOf,$IIP

Eddyd.rcrD.ndurcdthrauHddDylhrruthoalnwhldropyrlghtbddnrd"V

NAI|EOtAUflI(,nV

DATSOTilXTIIA}IDDBAIE

YcrrBcnY

YrrrDhdtT

WrtldraudhrUdrb0r.

wqtr'wqlnr&ftsldn?

Bvr

O trto

AUTHON

ilATIOD{ALITT ON

HrcllI

r5rca,r ,

wAa

fiE Nmlo,nt cot.Illnms{

rcTIlEYrOnX

trnqororrt

El

Yll El t5

1E3=g:.

hcudryurar?

cvr

Elm

=F-

*tffi,:'"

NAftIBOFAtlTttOlSHt?

Srlrfiydrrcr&e

r*gro(lbalrddqrcdbythrutlurlnlrlddtoo,pydgfttbdrlnr{9

tlr

0r lwl

rd& of

ffi

b

$

yott

d mt

ry

la

anldlltdr&r

ol

p

l,

r,

t 6 ol

tb fr

ln

c

ln

tb

orl&ltffi

$

Spoc

7

u

oq

of

tlc

Slft

E'I/r| Pt\ Tl$ o

v

A


8/13


9/13

Case

1:14-cv-00298

Document

1-2

Frled

OOl27lt4

Page

1

of

1

PagelD

#:22

Vincent

Khoury

Tvlor

:

"0-06

Hanauma

Bav

Wide

EXHIBIT

B


10/13

Case

1,:1,4-cv-00298 Document 1-3 Filed

06127l1-4 Page 1

of

1 PagelD #:23

Screen Ca

tures of

Defendant's

Use on

A

:

'.r

. r.r

(

\emont

narricafteo

i,ne

F

i.

a

x

fi

vermonlw-oodsstudros

Npepad

com

J

.'rs

ii.e

33reri

TrackBack

turLJ

*'3,\

Otu booknatr

Our

handcrafted

yg[ 0ltrlg4lg-j.UqiElg

is

making

its

way

around the rcrtd,

wi6|

the

latest

overseas

delivery arriving

safe,

in Hawaii.

runy

tEnks

to

Patsy

6.

and her

famity

for

sending

his

pictrre

of thlr

new

sotid

drerry

Cabri,oie

diniog

table and

Ele8ut

Ladder

Back

chairs.

"Doug,las

ask8d

hw

we

hke

our

new

dinrng

table

and

charrs

We ars

very

pleased

sth

them

The

wood

is

beautrful

the

workmanship is top

nolch.

end

they

were deltrsrod

much

qurcker

thaf,

estimated

Thark

you

for a

quatuty

Eoduct

Aloha

Patsy.

'

we

ship our handcra{ted

vermont

made

furniture

throuShout most areas

of the

continentat United States

for free. Alaska, Hawaii ed

intrmtional

deliveries incur additional

drarges

du

to

crating,

shlppiog and

duties

atthough

many

tirnes

our

furnlture

is stitt cost-competitive

particuterv

fot

targe

ordsrs.

Give us a

citl

for detaits

regardiflg

liggllJI8ilufglhhllogj 4jelryeiy.

.

P0rullnh

B

sh.r.rhi

ire

shiooiM

iurnitur.

tuHil

h.n&r.rt d furnitur.

ht..Btisrl

r$oole

*i@tu futnitu.t

TrackBa*

URL

for

this entry

EtF,r

//w-t)rpd.cffilirft6lnrl&kl6.Sol4ttlt26t

20tl{t:0ldf3t7 (

Listed

bbw

are

tinks to w.bbgs

that

refsffie

vemt

Hapdraftpd Flre Furniture

Arrivs

Sa(ety

ln

Hawali

Datet:05-14-11

i

Safari

File Edit

Vrew

Hrstory

Bookmarks

Develop

Wrndow

Help

Q.

O


11/13


12/13

Case

1:14-cv-00298-RLP-NONE

Document

6

Filed

06/30/14

Page

t

ot

2

PagelD

#:32

IN THE

UNITED

STATES

DISTRICT COURT

FOR

THE DISTRICT

OF

HAWAII

VINCENT

KHOURY

TYLOR, )

CNIL

NO.

cv14-00298

RLP

)

(Copyrightlnfringement)

Plaintiff,

)

)

vs.

)

SUMMONS

)

VERMONT WOODS STUDIOS,

LLC,

)

dba VERMONT WOODS

STUDIOS;

)

JOHN

DOES 1-10;

JANE

DOES

1-10;

)

DOE

CORPORATIONS

1-10; DOE

)

PARTNERSHIPS

1-10; and

DOE

)

ASSOCIATIONS

1-10,

)

)

Defendants.

)

)

SUMMONS

To

the

above-named

Defendant:

VERMONT

WOODS STUDIOS,

LLC,

dba

VERMONT

WOODS

STUDIOS:

YOU

ARE,

HEREBY

SUMMONED

and

required

to

serve

upon

Plaintiff's attorney

J.

STEPHEN STREET, Attorney

at

Law,

whose

address

is 734

Maono

Place,

Honolulu, Hawaii

96821, an answer

to

the

Complaint

which

is

herewith

served upon

you,

within

21 days

after

service of

this

Summons

upon

you,

exclusive

of

the day

of

service.

If

you

fail

to do

so,

judgment

by default

will

be

taken

against

you

for

the

relief

demanded in the

Complaint.

This

Summons shall not

be personally

delivered between

10:00

p.m.

and

6:00

a.m. on

premises

not

open

to

the

general public,

unless

a

judge

of

the


13/13

Case

1:14-cv-00298-RLP-NONE

Document

6

Filed OOl3Ol1,4 Page

2 of

2

PagelD

#: 33

above-entitled

court

permits,

in

writing

on

this Summons,

personal

delivery

during

those

hours.

A

failure

to

obey

this

Summons may

result

in

an

entry

of

default

and

default

judgment

against the

disobeying

person

or

party.

DATED:

Honolulu, Hawaii,

June

30

2014

SUE

BEITIA

Clerk

of

the

Court

/s/

AFC

Deputy

Clerk

of the

Court

cv

l4-00298-RLP

2

VKT-v-VWS-Hawaii-Part 2

Documents

Transcript of VKT-v-VWS-Hawaii-Part 2