Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence...

37
A CITIES UNITED REPORT By Arnold Chandler, Forward Change Consulting Safe, healthy and hopeful Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Transcript of Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence...

Page 1: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

A CITIES UNITED REPORT

By Arnold Chandler,

Forward Change Consulting Safe, healthy and hopeful

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for

Black Males in America:

A Call to Action

Page 2: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Victimization Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Explaining and Predicting Violence Perpetration Among Young Black Males in America

Interventions for Reducing Violence and its

Consequences for Young Black Males in America

About this Report Series

Page 3: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

About Cities United

Page 4: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Message from the Executive Director

Page 5: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Table of Contents

Introduction

Violence Trends and Patterns for Black Males in the U.S.

The Costs and Consequences of

Violence and Victimization

References

The Vicious Cycle of Violence: Neighborhood

Violence is a Central Contributor to the Cycle of Urban Disadvantage

I

II

III

IV

V

Page 6: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Introduction

I

Page 7: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

A note about this report

Page 8: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends and Patterns for

Black Males in the U.S.

II

Page 9: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Section Overview

Defining “Community Violence”

Page 10: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Violence Victimization

Witnessing Violence

Hearing about violence

Rates of fatal offending and victimization show stark disparities for young black males, although gaps have

narrowed significantly since rates peaked in the early 1990s

The Varied Meanings of “Violence Exposure”

Page 11: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

SOURCE: Cooper and Smith (2011)3

SOURCE: Cooper and Smith (2011)4

100

90

80

70

60

50

40

30

20

10

0

31.4

4.5

91.1

11.7

38.4

5

Black Males Ages 14-17

White Males Ages 14-17

Black Males Ages 18-24

White Males Ages 18-24

Black Males Ages 25+

White Males Ages 25+

200

180

160

140

120

100

80

60

40

20

0

175.8

20.4

37.8

5.5

Black Males Ages 14-17

White Males Ages 14-17

Black Males Ages 18-24

White Males Ages 18-24

Black Males Ages 25+

White Males Ages 25+

64.8

8

Page 12: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

SOURCE: Fox and Zawitz (2008)6 and Cooper and Smith (2011)7

400

350

300

250

150

100

50

0

200

19

76

1

97

7

19

78

1

97

9

19

80

1

98

1

19

82

1

98

3

19

84

1

98

5

19

86

1

98

7

19

88

1

98

9

19

90

1

99

1

19

92

1

99

3

19

94

1

99

5

19

96

1

99

7

19

98

1

99

9

20

00

2

00

1

20

02

2

00

3

20

04

2

00

5

20

08

Black Male Offending Rate (18-24) Black Male Offending Rate (14-17)

Black Male Offending Rate (25+)

52.8

60.7 64.8

37.8

175.8

253.1

362.5

130.1

71.5

Page 13: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

SOURCE: Fox and Zawitz (2008)8 and Cooper and Smith (2011)9

SOURCE: FBI Supplementary Homicide Reports 1980-201310

200

180

160

140

100

80

60

0

120

40

20

19

76

1

97

7

19

78

1

97

9

19

80

1

98

1

19

82

1

98

3

19

84

1

98

5

19

86

1

98

7

19

88

1

98

9

19

90

1

99

1

19

92

1

99

3

19

94

1

99

5

19

96

1

99

7

19

98

1

99

9

20

00

2

00

1

20

02

2

00

3

20

04

2

00

5

20

08

Black Male Offending Rate (18-24) Black Male Offending Rate (14-17)

Black Male Offending Rate (25+)

183.5

91.1

38.4

31.4

76.4 68.0

64.6

18.4

68.3

90%

80%

70%

50%

40%

30%

0%

60%

20%

10%

100%

1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2013

76% 73%

87% 91% 90% 91% 91% 92%

Page 14: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Black males are significantly more likely than other males to be non-fatally violently victimized and the likelihood is most

pronounced for young black males

SOURCE: Adapted from Lauritsen and Heimer (2010)13

1973

19

74

1975

19

76

1977

19

78

1979

19

80

1981

19

82

1983

19

84

1985

19

86

1987

19

88

1989

19

90

1991

19

92

1993

19

94

1995

19

96

1997

19

98

1999

20

00

2001

20

02

2003

20

04

2005

5000

4000

3000

0

2000

1000

6000

Latino Non-Latino Black Non-Latino White

Page 15: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

SOURCE: White and Lauritsen (2012)15 and Truman and Planty (2012)16

2,500

2,000

1,500

-

1,000

500

3,000

1,170

580

2,540

1,240 1,130

670

White Black Hispanic

Youth (ages 12-17) Total Pop. (ages 12 and over)

Page 16: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Rates of fatal and nonfatal violent victimization are far higher for

young black males living in neighborhoods of high disadvantage

When violently victimized, black males are substantially more

likely to be assaulted with a firearm or other weapon

Page 17: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Black youth are substantially more likely to witness serious violence compared to their white counterparts, and household

income does not appear to buffer against the risk of exposure

Risk of violent victimization among black males is highly

concentrated and transmitted through high-risk social networks

Page 18: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Page 19: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

The Costs and Consequences of Violence

and Victimization

III

Page 20: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Section Overview

Economic Costs of Violent Crime

Violent Crime Economic Cost

Page 21: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Aggression and Violence: Violence Begets Violence

Page 22: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Page 23: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Page 24: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Violence Exposure and Educational Outcomes

Page 25: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Page 26: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Page 27: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Violence Exposure and Mental and Behavioral Health

Page 28: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Page 29: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

The Vicious Cycle of Violence: Neighborhood Violence is a

Central Contributor to the

Cycle of Urban Disadvantage

IV

Page 30: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Page 31: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

References

V

Page 33: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Page 35: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Page 36: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action

Page 37: Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black …...II III IV V Introduction I Violence Trends, Patterns and Consequences for Black Males in America: A Call to Action A note

Safe, healthy and hopeful