Vimarsha on ‘Transition in America and China: Implications for India’
-
Upload
vivekananda-international-foundation -
Category
Documents
-
view
222 -
download
0
Transcript of Vimarsha on ‘Transition in America and China: Implications for India’
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
1/44
Transition in the American and
ChinaImplications for India
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
2/44
1.Political Transition in the USAnalysis
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
3/44
I.US 2012 Elections Turn-out
Voters Turnout DROPPED from62.3% of the eligible voters in 2008elections to 57.5% in 2012(estimated). (Bipartisan PolicyCenter, 2012).
Despite an increase of 8 millionperson in the eligible voters fromthe 2008 elections, the turnoutdeclined from 131 million voters in2008 to an estimated 126 million in2012.
Figure: The Dip at the end of theVotes line indicate the fall in
Turnout. Some analysts are attributing the
lower turnout to the failure of theRepublican ticket to energize theirbase, and hence the reason fortheir loss.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
4/44
II. Demography: 1.GenderAt the national level, as estimated in the exit
polls: Of all the Voters, 47% were male and
53% were female. Of all the male Voters, 45% voted for
Obama, while 52% voted for Romney
Of all the female Voters, 55% voted forObama, while 44% voted for Romney By estimated figures, based on Sex,
Obama got an extra 3 million votes fromWomen. Abortion was the main issue thistime, and the Democratic position on thishas traditionally been more appealing for
women. Remarks about legitimaterapemade by two Republicans, Todd Akinand Richard Mourdock, in the US Senateraces, further spoilt the appeal of theRepublicans.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
5/44
II. Demography: 2.Age
Clearly, Obama won by alarge margin over theRepublican Candidate,Romney, among the youth(18-39 years).
Romney won over Obamaamong the elders (40 andabove), but with a narrowmargin.
However, the youth (18-39
years) accounted for 36%(11+8+17) of the total votescast, while the elders (40years and above) for 64%.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
6/44
II. Demography: 3.Race Of all the Voters: 72% were White,
13% were Black, 10% wereHispanic/Latino, and 5% were Asianand Others.
Of the White Voters, 59% voted forRomney, while 39% Voted for Obama.
However, all other ethnic groups seemto have voted strongly in the favour ofObama. Immigration was important forHispanic voters and 71% Hispanicsvoted for Obama; African-Americansgave Obama over 90% of their vote.
Two major facts 1) Percentage of
White voters in the US elections hasdropped from 77% in 2004 to 75% in2008 to 72% in 2012. 2) In 2011,percentage of white new-borns out ofthe total new births went below 50%for the first time. Indicates the probablefuture trends for the US elections.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
7/44
II. Demography: 4.Income
Predictably, 60% of thepeople earning below $50,000 per annum voted forObama
Meanwhile, those earning$50,000 above preferredRomney by a narrowmargin
The positions on taxes ofthe two Parties played arole in this.
Polls repeatedly showedthat more people trustedRomney on the economy,but this did not translate intovotes, though it did in 2010.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
8/44
III. The Electoral College
The Electoral College is made up of chosen persons sent by eachState and DC to participate in the vote for the President and Vice-President. It meets in mid-December and competes the formality ofvoting for the two posts in accordance with the votes cast in theNovember election. The number of electoral college votes for a stateequals the number of Representatives and Senators. DC has three
electors. Thus, with 435 Representatives, 100 Senators and 3 electors from
the District of Columbia (under the 23rd Amendment of theConstitution), a total of 538 Electors. Thus one gets the total numberof votes in the Electoral College at 538, and the halfway mark at270.
Electors are generally chosen by the Presidential CandidatesPolitical Party, but state laws vary on how the Electors are selectedand what their responsibilities are.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
9/44
III. The Electoral College [contd.]
In most of the States, winner-takes-all system, i.e. all Electors of astate are awarded to the Presidential Candidate who wins a majorityin that state.
Only Maine and Nebraska use the congressional district method,selecting one Elector within each congressional district by popularvote and the other two Electors by a statewide popular vote.
After the Elections, the Governor of each state prepare CertificateofAscertainment. He/she lists all Candidates who ran for theelections along with their respective Electors and declares thewinning Candidates and the Electors from the state.
The winning Electors from each state meet in December of theElection Year and cast their votes for the President and the Vice-President in separate Ballots.
Electors prepare a Certificate ofVote from all states and send it tothe Congress. Votes are counted in a joint session of Congress on6th January in the year following the Presidential Elections and theresults formally announced.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
10/44
IV. Election Campaign Contributors
Barack Obama Mitt Romney
University ofCalifornia
$1,092,906
MicrosoftCorp
$ 761,343
Google Inc $ 737,055
US
Government
$ 627,628
HarvardUniversity
$ 602,992
GoldmanSachs
$ 994,139
Bank ofAmerica
$ 921,839
MorganStanley
$ 827,255
JP MorganChase & Co
$ 792,147
Credit SuisseGroup
$ 618,941
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
11/44
IV. Election Campaign Analysis:Investment Banks
Goldman Sachs, which was the largest contributor toRomneys campaign was the 2nd highest contributor toObama Campaign during the 2008 Elections.
Most of the major Investment Banks supported Romney,even though the Obama Administration did a lot to helpthe banks through the TARP programme, launchedunder Bush but continued and enhanced by Geithner.
Attitude of the investment banks is a consequence of theDodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and ConsumerProtection Act introduced on July 2010.
Dodd-Frank Act and the Volcker Rule: RestrictsInvestments banks, whose deposits are federallyinsured, from Proprietary Trade. Strongly opposed by theMajor Wall Street banks.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
12/44
IV. Election Campaign: TheSoftware Edge
President Obama received support fromthe Software Major companies: MicrosoftCorp. and Google Inc. They had supported
him in 2008 too.
The US election system runs on IOUs,and we may expect that these companies
will moderate some of the anti-outsourcingstances among the Democrats.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
13/44
IV. Election Campaign Analysisand Observations
Obama, while receiving the maximumsupport from Software firms, has beenhammering these firms for having outsourced
jobs to India. Romney, who received most of his campaignfunds from investment banks, has beenhammering these too big to fail banks and
Obamas special treatment for them. Hypocrisy is not the monopoly of Indian
politicians.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
14/44
V. Second Terms of the US Presidents
Name Year; ElectoralVotes won for the1st Term
Year; ElectoralVotes won for the2nd Term
Dwight D.Eisenhower
1952; 442 Votes 1956; 457 Votes
Richard M. Nixon 1968; 301 Votes 1972; 520 Votes
Ronald Reagan 1980; 489 Votes 1984; 525 Votes
William J. Clinton 1992; 370 Votes 1996; 379 Votes
George W. Bush 2000; 271 Votes 2004; 286 Votes
Barrack H. Obama 2008; 365 Votes 2012; 332 Votes
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
15/44
V. Second Terms of the US Presidents[contd.]
Since the end of the World War II, the 2012 USPresidential Election is the first time that aPresident has been re-elected with lowerElectoral Votes than in his first election.
President Obama had won 365 electoral votes inthe 2008 elections, while in the 2012 electionscould only manage 332 votes.
President Obama is also the few Presidentssince Franklin D. Roosevelt (during the 1930s)to have been re-elected with high unemploymentrates over 7%.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
16/44
SENATE 2008 Elections 2010 Mid-TermElections
2012Elections
Democrats 57+2*=59
*Independent
51+2*=53
*Independent
53+2*=55
*Independent
Republicans 41 47 45
HOUSE OF
REPRESENTATIVES
2008 Elections 2010 Mid-
TermElections
2012
Elections
Democrats 255 193 201
Republicans 175 242 234
VI. Senate and House ofRepresentatives: A Comparison
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
17/44
VII. First Hindu in the US Congress
Democrat Tulsi Gabbard became the first Hindu-American to enter the US House of Representativesafter defeating the Republican Kawika Crowly inHawaiis 2nd Congressional District.
The 31 year old, Iraq war veteran, raised by aChristian father and a Hindu mother, will be takingher oath on the Bhagavad Gita.
A certain positive for the Hindus in America.Meanwhile, the Republican Crowly asserted thatTulsis religion is not compatible with the USConstitution.
How deep is secularism in the US? Cases of BobbyJindal and Nikki Haley.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
18/44
VIII. Is Obama stronger?
The short answer is yes. But there are caveats. The margin of victory is unconvincing, specially in
that his own victory margin is lower than in 2008.Also, compared to 2010, the Democrats have
improved their position slightly, but they have notundone what Obama himself called theshellacking of 2010.
He is stronger in that he can allow the fiscal cliff toraise taxes automatically, but there is also thematter of the debt ceiling. It is US$ 16.4 tr and willbe hit in early 2013. He needs the Republicans toraise this further.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
19/44
2. Transition in China
Analysis
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
20/44
I. Communist Party of China: TheNumbers
2270 Delegates at the 18th National Congress ofthe CPC.
They selected/elected 205 full and 170 alternate
members of the Central Committee. Central Committee elects/selects 25 members of
the Politburo.
And 7 members of the Politburo StandingCommittee [PBSC].
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
21/44
II. Standing Committee Members
1st
Rank: Xi JinpingParty Positions:
General Secretary of the CPC.
Chairman of the CPC Central MilitaryCommission
Pointers: June 2012, Bloomberg, revealed Xi Jinping
family amassing disproportionate andunexplained wealth.
18 years in Fujian insight into both militaryand economic aspects of China Policies.
Worked three years [1979 1982] in theCMC as aide to Geng Biao, Minister ofDefence and Sec-Gen of CMC.
Worked briefly as Party Chief in Shanghai,links with Jiang Zemin.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
22/44
II. Standing Committee Members
2nd
Rank: Li KeqiangParty Position: Deputy Party Secretary of the State
Council of the PRCState Position: First-Ranked Vice-Premier of the State
Council of the PRC; will becomePremier, barring the unforeseen.
Pointer(s): Protg of Hu Jintao, links going back to
Communist Youth League. Ranks higher than outgoing Premier,
who was third-ranked in the StandingCommittee.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
23/44
II. Standing Committee Members
3rd
Rank: Zhang DejiangParty Position:
Party Chief in Chongqing, succeeded BoXilai, who was sacked and now facescorruption and moral turpitude charges.
State Position: Third-Ranked Vice Premier of the PRC
Pointer(s):
Holds Hilal-e-Pakistan award. Likely to be appointed Chairman of the
National Peoples Congress, given rank inthe PBSC.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
24/44
II. Standing Committee Members
4th
Rank: Yu ZhengshengParty Rank: Chairman of the Chinese Peoples Political
Consultative ConferenceState Rank: [To be determined] Likely to be
appointed to head the CPPCC, given his
rank in PBSC
5th Rank: Liu YunshanParty Rank: Top-ranked Secretary of the Central
Secretariat of the CPC; head ofpropaganda department; worked for 20years in Inner Mongolia
State Rank: [To be determined]
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
25/44
II. Standing Committee Members6th Rank: Wang Quishan
Party Position: Secretary of the Central Commission for
Discipline Inspection
State Position:
Fourth-ranked Vice Premier of the PRC
7th Rank: Zhang Gaoli
Party Position: [To be determined]
State Position: [To be determined]
All five lower-ranked members due to retire in
2017, replacements of the 5th and 7th ranked
members of the PBSC likely to be anointed
successors as General Secretary and Premier.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
26/44
III. Hu Jintao: Setbacks andAttempts at Retaining Control
Hu Jintao had to vacate the post of head of the Party CentralMilitary Commission. Reshuffled the top military staff beforeleaving the position. Placed close colleagues from the PLA inthe CMC in last months of his time.
Closest Aide Ling Jihua removed as the head of the generaldepartment of the CPC aftersons death in Ferrari Car Crash.Allegations that one of the SOEs paid money to the families offemale companions to buy silence being probed. Ling madehead of the United Front Work Department. Deals with the DalaiLama, among other issues.
Among other strong commitments, Hu holds firm views onTibet, where he made his reputation declaring martial law in1989. Hu Jintao selected Hu Chunhua, youngest Politburomember at 49 years. Speaks Tibetan. Groomed by Hu Jintao tomaintain, inter alia, hard line on Tibet and possible succession
to top job in 2022.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
27/44
IV. Hu Jintaos Work Report
Corruption Remarks: Ifwe fail to handle this issuewell, it could prove fatal to the Party, and evencause the collapse of the Party and the fall of thestate.
Need to restructure the economy current model
unbalanced, uncoordinated and unsustainable.China must find an alternative model, moredependent on domestic demand, speciallyconsumer demand.
Need to be able to Win a Local War in anInformation Age. Probable reference is to Taiwan.
Important reference to consultative democracy, firstsuch reference in such a major document. Theexperiment took place in Zhejiang Province when XiJinping was Party chief there.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
28/44
V. To Sum Up
Core Interests are non-negotiable issues for theCPC.
Include: Taiwan; Tibet; South China Sea And recently they have added the domestic
political system. Suggests there is little room forchange, though reference to onsultativedemocracy is noteworthy.
Despite the above points, there are seriouseconomic challenges as given in the Work Report;the social situation is precarious, with 180,000incidents of major unrest in 2011. Change isineluctable necessity.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
29/44
3. Implication for IndiaThe Changing Nature of the US-
India-China Relations
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
30/44
I. International Economics in theGlobalised Age
there is a risk that the international diffusion ofthe U.S. recovery will not take place according tousual patterns, which might in due course hurt theU.S. economy itself, even if it is less dependent
than other industrialized countries on exportdevelopments. Traditionally a U.S. recovery hasfueled exports of developing countries, increasingtheir orders of equipment goods from countriessuch as Japan, Germany and France, and the
interdependence between European countries hasled to a diffusion in Europe of these expansionaryforces, thereby sustaining the world recovery.[Giscard dEstaing, Foreign Affairs, Fall 1983]
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
31/44
II: Economic Dynamics: Foreign Direct Investment,Total Net (US $ million):
Source: Asian Development Bank
1990 1995 1997 1998 2003 2005 2007
Peoples
Republic ofChina
2,657.0 33,849.0 41,673.7 41,118.1 47,229.0 67,821.0 121,418.3
Republic ofKorea
-263.1 -1,776.2 -1,605.2 672.8 100.0 2,010.4 -13,696.7
India 96.0 2,143.0 3,562.0 2,480.0 2,388.0 3,034.0 15,545.0
Malaysia 2,332.0 6,642.0 6,787.7 2,708.0 1,103.7 995.8 -2,561.7
Thailand 2,402.0 1,183.0 3,298.0 7,360.0 4,614.0 7,545.0 7,819.4
Japan -48,968.9 -22,591.0 -22,767.8 -20,960.2 -22,477.6 -43,004.8 -50,999.5
Viet Nam 120.0 1,780.0 2,220.0 1,671.0 1,450.0 1,889.0 6,550.0
II Economic D namics Di ti f T d
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
32/44
II: Economic Dynamics:Direction of Trade:Merchandise Exports (percent of total merchandise
exports)Source: Asian Development Bank
To Asia Europe North andCentral America
From 1990 2007 1990 2007 1990 2007
China, PeoplesRep. 67.7 40.8 14.7 23.5 10.0 22.9
Korea, Rep. of 34.0 51.4 15.5 16.1 33.4 17.5
India 21.0 32.6 47.2 23.4 16.3 17.6
Malaysia 58.0 57.0 16.6 13.5 18.1 17.3
Thailand 37.8 54.1 25.3 15.5 25.3 14.5
Japan 26.1 42.8 23.0 16.8 36.3 24.9
Viet Nam 39.1 36.8 48.1 23.1 0.6 25.0
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
33/44
III. US-China Relations in theGlobal Economy
Dichotomy: While the Security aspects between the US andChina seem to be putting relations under strain, theireconomic equations have strengthened over the last twodecades.
The common notion that the US is dependent on China
economically must be questioned. In 2011, Chinese investment in US Treasurys was $1.3trillion. It has now dropped to $1.1 trillion. Meanwhile, theshare of investment by Japan, the UK, the Persian Gulf oilexporters and India, has increased.
$1.1 trillion investment is a big number, but for a US$ 16
trillion economy, it comes to just 6.85% of the US GDP, andthe same for its national debt. The US is not dependent onChinese money, and the trend of Chinese holdings isdeclining.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
34/44
III. US-China Relations [contd.]Foreign Holdings of US National Debt (US $ billion)
Source: US TreasuryCountry Jan 2011 July 2011 Jan 2012 Aug 2012
PR China 1154 1314 1161 1153
Japan 886 885 1082 1153
Persian Gulfoil exporters
215 244 267 263
India 40 40 42 52
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
35/44
IV. Priorities: for America
The top priority is obviously the Economy. The fiscal cliffis an expressive term but there may be less to it thanmeets the eye. A reversion to Clinton-era tax levels andacross-the-board spending cuts may cause a short-termrecession, but would right the fundamentals. Even
Greenspan has said something similar recently.
The foreign policy concerns are China & the APR,Afghanistan-Pakistan, and the Middle East.
The strategies proposed by the Obama Administrationfor all three are likely to be reinforced after his re-election. The pivot to Asia emphasizes the criticalimportance of India as a strategic partner.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
36/44
V. Priorities: for China
Economy: the main point has been quoted from theWork Report; the model has been dependent on highinvestment, including FDI, high and rising exports, andcheap labour. All three are now giving diminishingreturns.
Corruption has also been mentioned. That, and Partydiscipline are real threats to the system.
Foreign policy: bleak outcomes after five years ofmuscular assertiveness India, Japan, Philippines,Vietnam, even Myanmar and North Korea looking
worrisome. Increasing focus on Af-Pak as one region of promise;
hence increasing attention as US draw-down nears.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
37/44
VI. Indian Priorities & Perspectives
Economy: betterstructurals than almost any other majoreconomy in the world. Principal requirement is to getfiscal deficit under control. Early steps offer hope.
External: India is called upon by the US and the Asia-Pacific allies to show greater participation in the SouthChina Sea and South-East Asian affairs.
However, the US and the Asia-Pacific allies need take aclear stand over the border security threats that Indiafaces from China [and Pakistan]. Political changes inChina are likely to increase these threats and thereforeIndia is justified in expecting the US and Asian partnersto address this issue.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
38/44
VII.Afghanistan: the next hotspot
On the one hand, China strictly opposes Al-Qaeda andits activities in Xinjiang. It has strongly pressurizedPakistan to control the terrorist groups from entering andinterfering in Xinjiang.
On the other hand, China has cooperated with the
Taliban from 1996 to 2001. Today, their attitude is similarto that of the Americans in the 1980s, who felt theycould use the jihadis against the USSR, and would beable to contain their hostility towards themselves, whichwas in evidence then too.
China is also confident that it can control Pakistan andits state support for the jihadis, and therefore feelsconfident enough to use the same forces against
America.
f
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
39/44
VII. Afghanistan: the nexthotspot [contd.]
China signed Treaties of Friendship with Afghanistanand Pakistan in the period 2005-6, and Zhou Yongkangvisited Kabul shortly before stepping down from PBSC.
Extract from US-Afghanistan SPA: the parties shall
hold consultations on an urgent basis to develop andimplement an appropriate response, including, as maybe mutually determined, political, diplomatic, economicor military measures, in accordance with their respective
constitutional procedures. All of this suggests that there will be a determined
struggle over the future of Afghanistan. India is not well-positioned physically or mentally to play its due role.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
40/44
VIII. Indian Foreign Policy Choices
What we are seeing then is a distancing betweenUSA and China, both in the traditional securitysense, and in the economic engagement. Still earlyto form a definite opinion, but trend bears watching.
America has been open about the growing weight ofIndia in its strategic calculus, as brought out in the2012 Strategic Guidance and subsequentcomments by senior officials.
For China, India is important in one major negativesense: Tibet. That would be about the only thingthey need from us constant reassurance that weshall not be party to any unrest in Tibet.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
41/44
VIII. Indias Foreign Policy Choices
[contd.] However, of late, India is also important in the
economic sense. As Chinas trade surplus hasshrunk from $300b in 2008 to $155b in 2011, itssurplus with India has grown, and is now, at
$40b, about 25% of its total surplus on tradeaccount. As consumer spending slows down inEurope and in the US, India is one of the mostimportant growing markets.
Walmart buys $30b from China, compared toIndia which buys $50b.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
42/44
VIII. Indias Foreign Policy Choices
[contd.] Is nonalignment the answer? On the one hand,
America, with which we have just one real conflict ofinterest Pakistan.
On the other hand, China, with which we have a
serious border dispute. China is not even making aneffort to resolve this. Can we be nonaligned in this strategic setting? That
would be tantamount to being nonaligned with ourmost basic national interest.
Unless China moves seriously to settle the borderquestion, nonalignment would be the wrongresponse.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
43/44
VIII. Indias Foreign Policy Choices
[contd.] In the current setting, it is also essential for India also to
maintain close ties & understanding with other countries,the most important of which are Russia, France andIsrael. Iran is also vital for us, specially in the context of
Afghanistan.
On gaps in power: Chinas GDP is three times ours. Wenever stop to note that our GDP is nearly ten times thatof Pakistan; or that Chinas GDP is less than half that ofthe US.
Parallel facts regarding defence spending, or size ofmilitary.
No, the reason is not inherent weakness, but lack ofpolitical will.
-
7/30/2019 Vimarsha on Transition in America and China: Implications for India
44/44
VIII. Indias Foreign Policy Choices
[contd.] We need urgently to see if we can agree on a
new platform for future relations with America.They have their exceptionalism, we have ours.Can the two be made compatible?
On the table: Pakistan, and Indias core interestsvis--vis China and Pakistan which Americamust agree to respect, publicly and with action;
American issues on the economy, civil nuclearcooperation, and the framework for deeperdefence cooperation.