Vedder CPCN and Rate Application€¦ · •Vedder project in the public interest •Supporting the...

23
- 1 - Vedder CPCN and Rate Application Streamlined Review Process FortisBC Energy Inc. September 27, 2012 B-7

Transcript of Vedder CPCN and Rate Application€¦ · •Vedder project in the public interest •Supporting the...

  • - 1 -

    Vedder CPCN and Rate Application Streamlined Review Process

    FortisBC Energy Inc. September 27, 2012

    B-7

    markhudsFORTISBC ENERGY VEDDER TRANSPORT

  • - 2 -

    Agenda

    Approvals sought

    FEI NGT business

    model

    Vedder project

    description

    Vedder CPCN

    approval

    GT&Cs 12B & Vedder rate

    proposal Questions

    and Answers Submissions by FEI and Interveners

  • - 3 -

    Approvals Sought

    • Approval of a CPCN for the construction and operation of a LNG refueling station • Project is in the public interest

    • Approval of rate design and rate on an interim basis

    • Interim approval is based on potential rate impact of Overhead and Marketing charge cost methodology from other regulatory proceedings (i.e. AES Inquiry and BFI Reconsideration)

    • Rate design is based on GT&Cs Section 12B

    Reference: Exhibit B-1 at Page 1, Exhibit B-2

  • - 4 -

    Natural Gas Transportation (“NGT”) Business Model • End-to-end service offering for CNG and LNG

    Gas Supply Compression & Fueling

    (1) Natural Gas Supply (2) Compression & Fueling (3) Vehicles Operating on CNG

    FEI CNG Service Offering Customer

    (1) LNG Production & Storage

    (2) LNG Delivery (3) Fuel Storage & Fueling

    (4) Vehicles Operating on LNG

    FEI LNG Service Offering

    LNG Supply LNG Delivery and Fueling Station

    Customer

  • - 5 -

    Chronology of Events Related to Vedder

    • Regulatory review establishes FEI’s NGT fueling station offering (GT&Cs 12B)

    Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Result or Decision

    CNG/LNG Application CNG/LNG fueling stations GT&Cs, Waste Mngt

    Tractors ordered

    Vedder Contract Temporary Agreement May 12, 2011

    Suspended from August 2011 - August 2012G-128-11 CNG/LNG Service Application DecisionG-144-11 Interim approval for tanker charge & temp station

    Station Installation Temporary station installed and commissioned

    Test fueling in Sept-Oct 2011G-1-12 AES - Zero dollar CPCN threshold establishedG-14-12 CNG/LNG - Approval of GT&Cs 12BVedder Contract Permanent Refueling Agreement March 2, 2012

    G-44-12 RRA - Temporary station removed from rate baseC-6-12 BFI Decision - OH&M charge methodology

    Permanent Refueling StationFiled July 13, 2012

    Legend:

    BCUC DecisionsFEI Applications to BCUC

    2010 2011 2012

    Negotiations with Vedder

    Tractor deliveriesTemporary Station / Tanker Charge Application

    Vedder fueling tractors

    Station InstallationCPCN Application

    Construction

    FEI - Vedder activities

  • - 6 -

    Approved Section 12B of GT&Cs – Key Provisions • FEI owning, installing, and maintaining CNG/LNG fueling

    station • Charging a ‘take-or-pay’ rate (minimum contract volume) • Actual capital investment in the fueling station • Depreciation and net negative salvage rates and

    expense related to the capital assets • All O&M expenses, escalated annually by BC CPI • Allowance for overhead and marketing relating to

    developing NGT fueling station agreements • Contract renewal or customer paying unrecovered

    capital costs (including positive or negative salvage value)

    Reference: Commission Order No. G-14-12

  • - 7 -

    Vedder Transport

    • Headquartered in Abbotsford, B.C. • Liquid-edible, dry-edible, liquid rail car transport • 300 tractors, 800 semi trailers • 54 years of operating experience

    Reference: Exhibit B-1 at Page 11

  • - 8 -

    Vedder 50 LNG Tractors

    • Currently 50 LNG tractors to reduce fuel costs and achieve ‘greener’ operations

  • - 9 -

    Vedder Site Overview

    Temporary station

    Permanent station

  • - 10 -

    Temporary Fueling Station (IMC-6000)

  • - 11 -

    Permanent Fueling Station

  • - 12 -

    Permanent Station Design

    Reference: Exhibit B-1, Appendix A, Schedule B

  • - 13 -

    Permanent Fueling Station

    • Storage capacity three times greater than IMC-6000 • LNG tanker deliveries every two to three days • Refueling time of 2 to 3 minutes • Ability to serve up to 100 vehicles • 50 LNG tractors currently in operation • Target completion – December 2012

    Reference: Exhibit B-6, IR 1.5.1 and 1.5.2

  • - 14 -

    CPCN Approval – legal standards

    • Zero dollar threshold for NGT projects established in AES Inquiry (Order No. G-1-12)

    • Vedder project in the public interest • Supporting the applicable British Columbia energy objectives • Meeting the most recent long-term resources plan filed by FEI • Accruing benefits to all FEI customers, including NGT customers • Minimizing risks to core customers by complying with approved

    GT&Cs section 12B • Recovering capital expenditures, O&M, Overhead & Marketing

    costs directly from Vedder through fueling charges

    Reference: Exhibit B-1 at Page 8

  • - 15 -

    Project Benefits

    • Net Rate Schedule 16 delivery margin estimate of $284,000 per year

    • GHG emission reductions of 3,826 tCO2e per year

    • Economic benefits to the Province

    • Fuel cost savings of 35-50% to Vedder • Potential benefits may flow to Vedder’s customers

    Reference: Exhibit B-1 at Pages 13 - 17

  • - 16 -

    Forecast Net Delivery Margin Benefit (Year)

    • Incremental benefit estimated at 50% of Rate Schedule 16 delivery rate

    • Consistent with benefit calculations presented in NGT Application

    Annual NG Volume (GJ) 140,000

    Rate 16 Delivery Rate (2012) 4.05$

    Total Delivery Revenue 567,000$

    Less: Fully Allocated O&M Cost (est. 50% of delivery) -50%

    Total Incremental Margin 283,500$

    Reference: Exhibit B-1 at page 17

  • - 17 -

    GHG Emission Reductions Benefits

    • GHG emission reductions of 3,826 tCO2e per year or 26.8% from diesel

    GHGenius v3.20 X Average Annual = Emissions Per X Number of = Emissions Per Emissions Kms Traveled Tractor (tCO2e) Tractors Fleet (tCO2e)

    Diesel (t/km) 0.0015002 190,000 285.0 50 14,251.9 LNG (t/km) 0.0010975 190,000 208.5 50 10,426.3

    Emissions Reduction (tCO2e): 76.5 3,825.7

    Reference: Exhibit B-4, IR 1.2.1

  • - 18 -

    Vedder Conforms to GT&Cs 12B

    Section 12B

    Term or Condition Appendix A (Contract)

    12B.1 LNG Service definition 4.3 12B.2 owned by FEI 5.1 12B.3 take-or-pay volume 8.4 12B.4 (a) actual capital 8.3 12B.4 (b) depreciation / net negative salvage 8.2 (a) 12B.4 (c) O&M, no adj. for capitalized OH, escl. by CPI 8.2 (b) 12B.4 (d) overhead & marketing charge 8.2 (b) 12B.5 Contract renewal or buyout provision 15

    Reference: Exhibit B-1, Appendix B

  • - 19 -

    Approval of Rate Design as Just and Reasonable • Seeking interim rate approval (subject to resolution of

    AES Inquiry and BFI Reconsideration) • Related to the Overhead and Marketing charge cost methodology

    • Proposed rates in Table 5 of Exhibit B-1 • Proposed rates are designed on GT&Cs 12B and

    adjusted based on directions from the BFI Decision • BFI Decision directed FEI to include branding costs, insurance

    premium costs and application cost

    Reference: Exhibit B-1 at Page 24, Exhibit B-2

  • - 20 -

    Proposed Fueling Station Charge Component Fueling Charge

    Proposed (Table 5, Exhibit B-1)

    Excess Rate Proposed

    Capital $1.780 per GJ $0.890 per GJ

    Operations & Maintenance

    $0.584 per GJ $0.584 per GJ

    Overhead & Marketing

    $0.286 per GJ

    Fueling Service Rate

    $2.650 per GJ $1.474 per GJ

    Reference: Exhibit B-1 at Page 24

  • - 21 -

    Rate Assumptions

    Input Assumption Initial contract term 10 years Take or Pay Volume 140,000 GJ per year Capital investment $2,394,080 Branding costs (capital) $3,000 Fueling station O&M $80,000 per year Insurance premium (O&M) $1,800 per year Application costs $35,000

    Reference: Exhibit B-1 at Pages 24 - 25

  • - 22 -

    Conclusion

    • CPCN should be granted because project is in the public interest • Benefits to all FEI’s customers, including NGT customers • Benefits to the public in general • Risks to natural gas customers mitigated • Costs recovered from Vedder

    • Rate Design and Rates are just and reasonable • Consistent with GT&Cs section 12B • Cost inputs incorporated directives from BFI Decision

  • - 23 -

    Questions and answers Vedder CPCN and Rate Application