VAT in the GCC - Flanders Investment and Trade
Transcript of VAT in the GCC - Flanders Investment and Trade
VAT in the GCCBrussels, 8 June 2017
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 2
VAT in the GCC
Chapter Content
Customs in the GCC • How Customs ties into VAT
• How the GCC differs from the EU customs union
Overview of VAT in the GCC
• VAT updates and timing hypothesis
• VAT fundamentals
• GCC VAT vs. the EU VAT directive
Deloitte approach toimplementation
• Our 5 phases approach
IT Systems implementation
• Lesson learnt from other implementations
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 3
Customs in the GCC
How it ties into VAT and differences with the EU customs union
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 4
Introduction to customs duty in the GCC
Customs Union
Formation & Common Customs Law – formed in 1981 and Common Customs Law implemented in 2002
Common framework and economic integration – coordination, interconnection and strengthening relations among member nations in all fields
Customs related memberships – WTO & WCO membership, OECD
Customs union – fully integrated single market for ease of movement of goods and services between members based on GCC Common Customs law
Background of GCC Customs Union
Oman
KSA
Qatar
Kuwait
UAE
Bahrain
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 5
Introduction to customs duty in the GCC
Customs Union
Common rates - 0%, 5%, except KSA
Single point of entry – no internal (non-)tariff trade barriers
GCC originating products – free movement within GCC
Common exemptions/prohibitions, although some specific countries may differ in some areas/products (e.g. KSA)
Common FTAs – GCC, GAFTA, EFTA, Singapore although individual Member State FTAs also apply
Practical inconsistencies – the application of the law may differ between GCC States
Key features of GCC Customs
Union
Common Customs Law of the GCC States
Rules of Implementation to the Common Customs Law of the GCC States
Explanatory Notes to the Common Customs Law of the GCC States
National / local policies and notices
International treaties
Basic legislation framework
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 6
Customs Exemptions
GCC Common Customs Law
• Industrial Exemptions (raw materials for manufacturing, machinery, etc.)
− Subject to certain conditions i.e. availability of the specific raw material in the local market, quantity, quality etc..
− The exemption shall be granted subject to approval from the relevant authority/ministry, in addition to other approvals which may be required
• Personal effects and household items
• Imports of the Philanthropic Societies “Charities”
• Passengers goods
• Returned Goods
− Returned goods of national origin
− Returned foreign goods
− For temporarily exported goods
• Diplomatic exemptions: Imports of the diplomatic corps, consulates, international organizations and the members of the diplomatic and consular corps
• Military exemptions: Imports for all sectors of the military forces and internal security forces
• Other types of exemptions
Goods exempted from customs duties
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 7
Free Trade Agreements (“FTAs”)
GCC FTAs
• GAFTA: Greater Arab Free Trade Area
• GCC-Singapore FTA (Called GSFTA) entered into force on 2015
• EFTA - Free Trade Agreement between the GCC States and the European Free Trade Association (which comprises Switzerland, Norway, Iceland and Liechtenstein) entered into force on 1 July 2014.
• Other FTAs: Some GCC countries have signed bilateral free trade agreements (“FTA”) with other countries, such as the FTA between Bahrain and the US.
Note: To benefit from the preferential rates under those treaties, importers/exporters would need to satisfy the conditions and requirements set out in the relevant agreement
• Negotiations: Potential FTAs negotiated include Australia, China, India, EU, etc.
GCC overview
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 8
GCC Import and VAT
Customs duty typically applies to the movement of goods from a country outside of the GCC to a country within
• Paid at the country of first import
• Free circulation of goods between GCC countries once entered for home consumption within the union (although note some variances in practice)
Import VAT typically applies to the movement of goods between countries; no ‘supply’ is required to be made
Expectation that an EU style model will be adopted in the GCC
• Import from third countries into the GCC
• Once goods are within the union, movements between may be out of scope for customs purposes (although there may be statistical reporting requirements)
What is a taxable importation
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 9
GCC Import and VAT
Mechanics of customs duty
Classification
Global system for classification “Harmonised System”
Applied by all World Customs Organization members (and others)
Applied throughout the entire ME
Up to 8 digit level
Determines Import duty rate to be applied
Link with VAT-rate?
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 10
GCC Import and VAT
Mechanics of customs duty determination
Valuation
Customs valuation is the value that is to be determined for the purpose of imposing import duties
Taxable basis for customs duties
NON-GCC country
1st border ME country (GCC)
Customer
Part of customs value
Not part of customs value
CIF first border
Meaning… this value must include all costs to the point of import, including commissions and brokerage, cost of containers, cost of packing, royalties and license fees, cost of international transport, cost of international insurance, etc.
But… is to be a value excluding certain other elements such as domestic transport
=> Not necessarily equal to the invoice value as such!!!
Customs value currently of limited / no relevance if a 0% import duty rate applies
=> Impact on / of import VAT?
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 11
GCC Import and VAT
Mechanics of customs duty determination
• Non-preferential origin
• Preferential origin
− trading blocks
− bilateral agreements
• GCC status
=> Origin / GCC status impacts VAT treatment?
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 12
GCC Import and VAT
It is typically the ‘importer of record’ who is required to pay any customs duty and import VAT
• Incoterms set out the rights and obligations between the parties on international goods movements
• Where a supplier sells on DDP incoterms it is liable for customs duty payable (in practice challenging for foreign suppliers)
GCC countries have licensing requirements and usually other legal requirements that must be met in order to import commercial shipments into the GCC
• Import activities should be reviewed to ensure that the importer of record is entitled to recover the import VAT charged (e.g. meets the business use test)
Who is required to pay….and receive any credit?
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 13
GCC Import and VAT
Who is required to pay….and receive any credit?
BA
Commercial invoice
C
Commercial invoice
Physical flow of goods / “Pro-forma” invoice
Border
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 14
GCC Import and VAT
Who is required to pay….and receive any credit?
BA
Commercial invoice
C
Physical flow of goods
Border
“Pro-forma” invoice / customs clearance
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 15
GCC Import and VAT
Who is required to pay….and receive any credit?
BA
Commercial invoice
Physical flow of goods
A instructs and pays customs broker to import in the name of B and pays customs duties
Border
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 16
GCC Import and VAT
Customs duty is payable to the local customs authorities prior to entering the goods for home consumption
Import VAT is typically due at the same time as customs duty payable
However, relief is commonly available in most VAT jurisdictions for VAT registered businesses, such as:
• Import deferral account (amount due is paid / recovered via entries on the VAT return so no cash flow impact)
• Import VAT is payable at the end of the month of import (cash flow impact limited to between payment and recovery via VAT return)
When is the payment due?
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 17
GCC Export and VAT
An export for customs purposes typically applies to the movement of goods from a country within the GCC to a country outside the GCC
• Incoterm EXW (ex-works) – considerations for Customs and VAT purposes
What is an export?
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 18
GCC Export and VAT
Customs: the entity that enters the goods for export
• Refer to Incoterms for responsibilities
For VAT purposes the position is less clear
• Likely the entity that arranges for the transportation
• May face challenges in meeting documentation requirements where flash title or back to back transactions occur before the goods are removed (e.g. back to back FOB transactions)
• May face challenges on indirect exports (supplier not responsible for transport across border)
Who makes the export?
B
A
Commercial invoice –with or without VAT?
Physical flow of goods
C
Commercial invoice –with or without VAT?
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 19
GCC Export and VAT
Customs duty is not paid on export
As VAT is a tax on consumption, VAT would not typically be charged on supplies where the supplier is responsible for export…..however…
Documentation must be retained to evidence the removal of goods from the GCC
• Typically supplies default to taxable where no evidence to support exemption is retained
Penalties/Risks of non being compliant
• Risk of no proof of export – for VAT purposes may be perceived as taxable/local supply and therefore penalties could arise
• Globally and regionally customs authorities move towards data analytics – more likely in future such sources of information to trigger audits and higher risks
How much VAT and customs duty would be payable?
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 20
GCC Law Duty Suspensions and Drawback
GCC Suspension Regimes and Free Zones
Goods in Transit Goods in transit are subject to the suspension of the customs duties and taxes applicable to all other kinds of transit transport, subject to conditions.
WarehousesGoods may be deposited within customs/bonded warehouses inside or outside the customs office without payment of customs duties and taxes, subject to conditions.
Free Zones & Duty free shopsForeign goods brought into the free zones and duty-free shops , and taken out from them to outside the country or to other free zone and duty-free shops, will not be subject to customs duties.
Temporary AdmissionGoods entering the GCC can be allowed to be placed under temporary admission for six renewable months with the suspension of the levied customs duties, subject to conditions
Re-exportation & Drawback Foreign goods imported into the GCC countries with a view to be re-exported shall be totally or partially refunded at re-exportation.
GCC Law and Implementation
Procedures
Warehouses
Free Zones &
Duty free
shops
Temporary Admission
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 21
Overview of VAT in the GCC
VAT updates & timing hypothesis
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 22
Introduction to tax reforms in the Middle East
Drivers for reform
Demographics
Planning for an education-hungry, older, future-state with long term illness a feature of longer lives
Growing need to fund healthcareobligations across age groups
Growing spending obligations
Limited existing capacity to generate revenues internally in the face of declining oil prices and uncertain demand
Existing fiscal challenges offer a ready mandate for change
Evolving realities
Hydrocarbon markets posing an ongoing revenue stability challenge
Accurate budgeting requires certainty over revenues and the ability to generate what is needed when it is needed
The current cash-funded balanced budget is not a long-term solution
Revenue stability
General trending towards convergence in the global tax environment
BEPS, CRS and transparency initiatives
Growing sense of moral obligation of MNC’s to embrace local tax obligations
International pressure
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 23
No VAT, but other indirect taxes
GCC and VAT
OmanCustoms duties
Excise duties
Hotel /
restaurant taxes
UAE
Customs duties
Excise duties
Hotel/restaurant
taxesKSA
Customs duties
(with a number of
higher rates)
Excise duties
Hotel / restaurant
taxes
Qatar
Customs duties
Excise duties
Hotel /
restaurant taxes
Kuwait
Customs duties
Excise duties
Hotel/restaurant
taxes
BahrainCustoms duties
Excise duties
Hotel/restaurant
taxes
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 24
Timing hypothesis
All countries to implement by 2019
All 6 countries
implement by
2019?
Planning is
ongoing
behind the
scenes
Remaining
GCC
countries
examine
impacts
Treaty
amended
domestic
leg. in prep
UAE, KSA
and Oman
implement
Kuwait,
Bahrain,
and Qatar
implement
Increasing
number of
statement
s of intent
issued
2016 ‘16 ‘18 ‘19
Remaining
countries
examine
current
need and
confirm
decisions
Although it is not clear when VAT will be implemented in all Gulf states, we can expect for
progress to be fast
We expect a staggered implementation
Where are we today?
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 25
Relation between the Treaty and domestic legislation
The GCC and VAT
The GCC Treaty
• UAE
• Saudi Arabia
• Qatar
• Kuwait
• Bahrain
• Oman
• The GCC Treaty is now publicly available
• Sets the main VAT principles to be adopted within the GCC
• The VAT envisaged by the Treaty is relatively similar to EU’s VAT system
• It operates within the GCC Customs Union
Domestic Legislation
• Each individual country is now developing its own domestic legislation to implement the Treaty
• Within the leeway provided in the GCC VAT Treaty, the Member States may make a differentiation in designing their national VAT legislation
• A relatively short implementation period is expected across the GCC countries following the signing of the treaty.
• Returns, compliance, formalities etc. not harmonized
• Certain sectors likely to be granted preferred treatment (e.g. healthcare and transport)
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 26
Four core features of VAT system :
• Broad-based tax on final household consumption – the burden of tax should not rest on business.
• Collected under a multi-staged process – VAT will be collected on “value added” at each stage throughout the supply chain
• Operated according to the “destination principle” – VAT should be levied at the location where the final household consumer is located.
• Tax neutrality – VAT should seek to be neutral and equitable to businesses. VAT should not hinder the formation of a business decision.
Based on the International VAT/GST Guidelines published by OECD
Design of VAT in the GCC
Design principles
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 27
• UAE, Oman and KSA target 1 January 2018
• Bahrain expected to implement in mid 2018
• Qatar and Kuwait lag further behind
• KSA has published its draft VAT law on 29 May 2017 for consultation and comments.
• Federal VAT law and the VAT Executive Regulations in the UAE are expected to bepublished in Q3 2017 setting out the application of VAT within the UAE.
• Federal Tax Procedures Law in the UAE will govern the general rules and proceduresrelating to VAT and other taxes within the UAE – expected to be published in the comingweeks
• VAT registration in the UAE will be opened during Q3 2017 on a voluntary basis and Q42017 on a compulsory basis
VAT Updates
Announcements to date
Much still needs to be defined but time is short !
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 28
Overview of VAT in the GCC
VAT fundamentals
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 29
VAT works in the GCC like in most jurisdictions
VAT Mechanics
Outputs
• A business makes ‘supplies’ of goods and servicesto a recipient
• Output tax normally due on these supplies (unlessexempt, zero-rated or “outside the scope”)
• Business charges VAT on the supplies (usuallyadds it to the price) and accounts for the VAT bypaying it to the authorities
Inputs
• VAT charged to a business on purchases andimports of goods and services
• Paid to the supplier as part of the purchase price(price includes VAT)
• VAT incurred for business purposes is input tax andis recoverable if it has been incurred in the courseof making taxable supplies
• Evidence is required to claim input tax
VAT recoverable
from customers
Payable to the Tax
Authority
VAT payable on business purchases
Net VAT
Output tax > Input tax
Less
Refundable by the Tax Authority
Output tax < Input tax
Equals
Output tax
collected
Input tax credits
(ITCs) for VAT paid
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 30
RegistrationWho must register
Every taxable person (a company, natural person, or other) resident of a Member State
Annual supplies in the Member State exceeds or is expected to exceed the mandatory registration threshold
This taxable person is conducting an economic activity independently in a permanent manner.
• Supplies made in the current month and previous 11 months; or
• Projected supplies of the current month and the subsequent 11 months
• Excluding exempt supplies
Calculation of the value of annual supplies
187,500
375,000
Voluntary registration
threshold (SAR)
Mandatory registration
threshold (SAR)
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 31
RegistrationWho must register (cont’d)
• Supplies made in the current month and previous 11 months; or
• Projected supplies of the current month and the subsequent 11 months
• Excluding exempt supplies
Calculation of the value of annual supplies
No threshold applies to non established taxable persons – they may be required to register
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 32
• Transaction not a supply of goods = supply of services.
• Income which does not qualify is out of scope of VAT (e.g. dividends)
• Output transactions = transactions made by the taxable person = Output VAT on supplies of goods and services
• Input transactions = transactions made to the taxable person = Input VAT on purchases of goods and services, as well as imports
There are only 3 types of transactions potentially subject to VAT: supplies of goods, services and imports
What transactions will be subject to VAT in the GCC
Taxable supplies of goods or services made by a taxable person
Supply of goods / services
1. Made for consideration
2. In a GCC member country
3. A taxable supply (i.e. 5% or 0%)
4. Made by a taxable person
Importation
Import of goods by any person into the GCC from outside the GCC
Supplies of goods & services
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 33
Place of supplyWhere the supply is taxed
• Is the supply taxable in the GCC?
• Which GCC Member State can tax?
• Determines the Member State in which the supply will be taxed and VAT payable
• If place of supply outside GCC Member State supply not subject to GCC VAT (but perhaps subject to local VAT)
• Taxable persons (also the ones merely making exempt supplies) need to pay VAT on goods and services received
?
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 34
Place of supplyWhere will the supply be taxed – General rules
Goods
Gas,oil, water and electricity
Services
• Taxable supply = supply of goods or services
• Supply is not supply of goods = a service
Goods Services
No delivery where goods are placed at customer’s disposal
Delivery to GCC B2B customer
Member State of final destination
Other deliveries
Member State of dispatch
B2B services Location of the customer
B2C services Location of the supplier
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 35
Place of supplySpecial rules for services
Transportation lease servicesLocation where transportation means were placed at customer’s disposal [Article 17; GCC VAT Agreement]
02
01Telecommunication and electronically supplied services Location where services are used or enjoyed [Article 20; GCC VAT Agreement]
04
03
05Real estate related services location of the real estate property [Article 18; GCC VAT Agreement]
Restaurants, hotel and events related services Location where services are performed [Article 21; GCC VAT Agreement]
Passenger transportation servicesLocation where transportation begins [Article 19; GCC VAT Agreement]
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 36
Place of supplySpecial rules goods
Goods
Gas,
Note: special rules for cross-border B2C supplies, water and electricity
Services
• Supply of gas, oil, water and electricity from one member state to
• a taxable trader in another member state
taxed at the location of the customer
• other recipients in another member state the location of consumption
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 37
Supplies within scope of VATZero-rated or exempt?
Medicine and medical equipment
Cross-border goods and passenger transportation services
Goods exported outside GCC territory
Certain cross-border supplies of services for non GCC recipients
Certain transactions in gold, silver and platinum
Certain food items
Supply of means of transportation for commercial purposes
Oil, oil derivatives and gas sector
Education sector
Healthcare sector
Real estate sector
Local transport sector
Financial services (with some flexibility to tax)
Importation, if the goods are
• exempted or zero-rated in the country of importation
• exempted from customs
Must zero-rate01 May zero-rate02 May either exempt or zero-rate
03 Must exempt04
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 38
Types of supply and rates applicable
Supplies of goods & services
• VAT will be charged at a standard rate of 5% unless the goods or services are
• Exempt
• Zero-rated
Difference in Input Tax treatment
• Specific goods or services can be zero-rated (exemption with right to deduct input VAT) or exempted
• Specific goods or services are compulsory exempt or zero-rated
Exempt
Zero-rated
5%
• Zero-rated goods or services: allows input VAT recovery in relation to purchases
• Exempt goods or services: input VAT recovery in relation to purchases notallowed
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 39
Date of removal of goodssupply with transportation
Date goods made available to customer supply without transportation
Performance of service complete
Override if before that :– Tax invoice is issued– Payment is received
Time of supplyWhen to account for output VAT on supplies
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 40
VAT liabilityWho pays VAT to the State? - Imports
• Import: Importer of record
• VAT paid by filing the import declaration
• Import declaration allows the input VAT recovery
• Special license to defer payment of import VAT: Potential option not to pay import VAT in the import declaration but in the periodical VAT return
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 41
VAT liabilityWho pays VAT to the State? Other supplies
• Who needs to pay a receivable!
• Supplier is liable for the payment of VAT to the State
− Exception: Reverse charge customers pays the VAT
− Supplier is not resident
− Customer is a business
− Shift in liability – customer pays the VAT in tax return instead of the supplier
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 42
VAT liabilityWho pays VAT to the State?
• Who needs to pay a receivable!
• By default the supplier is liable for the payment of VAT to the UAE on all supplies of goods and services which take place in the UAE
Exception: Reverse charge Customers pays the VAT
− Supplier is not resident
− Customer is a business
− Shift in liability – customer pays the VAT in tax return instead of the supplier
− Advantageous from a cash flow perspective
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 43
Free zones: Treatment of supplies made to and from free-zones
• Especially important for the UAE
• No comment on VAT treatment of supplies between free-zones and other areas
• It is possible that a difference will be made between fenced and non-fenced (i.e. financial such as the DIFC) free-zones, with the latter not being treated as a free-zone for VAT purposes
• However, whether or not this will be the case is still to be confirmed by the local VAT legislations
• Potential distinction for the non fenced free-zones between the types of supply
• As the current free-zone agreements indicate that the areas are fully exempt from taxes and will remain as such at least for a certain number of years, it is likely that the agreements must be revisited in terms of the applicable VAT treatment
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 44
VAT fundamentals
Other issues
• VAT returns submitted periodically together with payment
‒ Usually three months or monthly (quarterly in UAE)
• VAT return submission and payment determined country by country
• Electronic VAT return submission and payment possible (or even compulsory - UAE) in most countries
• Additional reporting requirements could arise for intra-GCC trade and trading between Emirates
• Incorrect, incomplete or missing VAT returns = Tax authority estimation
• Penalties for errors or failure to file and/or pay likely, and likely to be significant
Errors and penalties
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 45
GCC VAT vs. the EU VAT
directive
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 46
GCC VAT
Comparing transactions to the EU directive
• Business sells goods to another business
• Customer is established in other GCC MS
• Goods are transported from one MS to another
Supplies of goods from one MS to
another
• Intra-community supply exempt in MS of dispatch if all conditions are met
− Proof of transport and capacity customer
− VAT return
− ESL
• Taxed intra-community acquisition in MS of arrival
• Supply taxed in the MS of arrival
− Proof of transport and capacity customer
− VAT return
− No ESL but ESS (still to be set up!)
• Reverse charged by the customer
• Certain customs formalities (statistical declaration) / additional duty payment
EU GCC
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 47
GCC VAT
Comparing transactions to the EU directive (cont’d)
• Business provides general services to another business
• Customer is established in other GCC MS
Supplies of services from one
MS to another
• B2B supply of services
− Capacity customer
− VAT return
− ESL
• Located in MS customer
• Reverse charged by customer
• B2B supply of services
− Capacity customer
− VAT return
− No ESL but ESS (still to be set up!)
• Located in MS customer
• Reverse charged by the customer
EU GCC
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 48
GCC VAT
Comparing transactions to the EU directive (cont’d)
• Business makes a supply of goods or services
• To a customer registered for VAT
• The customer is established in the MS where the supply takes place
Reverse charge
• Domestic supply
− VAT return
• Option in article 194 VAT directive to R/C
− When customer has VAT number (FR)
− When customer has VAT number AND is registered (NL and partly BE)
− No R/C (DE for certain supplies)
• Reverse charged by customer
• Domestic supply
− VAT return
• Obligation to apply a reverse charge when customer has VAT number AND is registered
• Reverse charged by customer
EU GCC
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 49
Deloitte approach to
implementation
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 50
5 phased approach
Deloitte approach to implementation
1.5 Response strategy
1.6 Roadmap
1.4 VAT impact summary report
Our
delivera
ble
s
1.2 Impact Workshops
1.3 Transaction mapping
1.1 Kick-off meeting
Key o
bje
ctive
2.4 BusinessRequirements
2.5 Fit-gap analysis
2.6 IT Solution design
3.5 Communication
3.6 Migration
3.4 VAT Processes
3.2 IT Configuration
3.3 Document templates
3.1 IT Technical design
4.3 Training
4.4 VAT governance
4.1 Testing
2.2 VAT technical guide
2.3 Approach authorities
5.3 Overall VAT assessment
5.1 Post go-live IT support
5.2 Review first VAT return
PMO
4.2 VAT technical support
• Snapshot of the business and current VAT state
• Identify the impact of VAT on the business
• Develop a Roadmap
4.5 Go-live support
• Determine to-be state
• Gather legal and regulatory requirements
• Determine fit-gap to meet VAT day 1 compliance
• Building of the solution design for IT
• Development of processes and templates
• Migrate Master Data
• Training and Knowledge transfer to the end-users
• Testing of implemented changes and processes
• Communicate changes
• Finalize implementation design
• Review after first VAT return
• IT support during transition phase
1. Assessment &Roadmap
2. Design 3. Implement 4. Test & Train 5. Post go-live
3.7 VAT registration
2.1 Project Plan
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 51
Deloitte Survey
The Malaysian experience in hindsight
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 52
Deloitte Survey
The Malaysian experience in hindsight (cont’d)
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 53
IT systems
Lessons learnt from other systems implementations
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 54
Learn the 5 W’s
Tax and technology
The ‘W’ VAT expert VAT calculation engine
Who? • Who is the supplier, and who is the customer?• Are either party, or both parties registered?• Is the supplier or customer overseas?• Is it in the course or furtherance of a
business?
• Customer master data (e.g. VAT#)
• Supplier master data (e.g. VAT#)
What? • Is this a supply of goods or services?• Is this one supply, or multiple supplies?
• Item master data
Where? • The place where the supply is deemed to take place determines which jurisdiction’s VAT laws apply and the VAT liability applicable (e.g. standard, reduced or exempt)
• Customer master data - locations• Supplier master data – locations• Logistics data – ship to/ship from
When? • When do I need to account for the VAT and/or recover the VAT as the case may be?
• In either case, what documentation do I need to satisfy the authorities?
• System information dates such as invoice date, service date, payment date, delivery date
(W)howmuch?
• The value question – VAT is determined by reference to the value of the supply, the nature of the supply and the rate applicable to it
• Invoice amount/transaction value
1
3
4
5
2
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 55
Tax and Technology
• Globalization, Regulation and Business Complexity increases force on tax departments
• Automated tax disclosures and audits.
• Gap between company ERP data and governments is closing. Tax departments require technology adoption much more today then before.
• Become a stronger Partner to the broader business and IT.
• ERP Challenges: Master Data, Process excellence and IT infrastructure.
This document has been prepared by Deloitte LLP for the sole purpose of providing a proposal to the parties to whom it is
addressed in order that they may evaluate the capabilities of Deloitte LLP to supply the proposed services.
The information contained in this document has been compiled by Deloitte LLP and includes material which may have been
obtained from information provided by various sources and discussions with your management which has not been verified
or audited. This document also contains material proprietary to Deloitte LLP. Except in the general context of evaluating our
capabilities, no reliance may be placed for any purposes whatsoever on the contents of this document or on its
completeness. No representation or warranty, express or implied, is given and no responsibility or liability is or will be
accepted by or on behalf of Deloitte LLP or by any of its partners, members, employees, agents or any other person as to
the accuracy, completeness or correctness of the information contained in this document or any other oral information
made available and any such liability is expressly disclaimed.
Other than as stated below, this document and its contents are confidential and prepared solely for your information, and
may not be reproduced, redistributed or passed on, directly or indirectly, to any other person in whole or in part. Therefore
you should not refer to or use our name or this document for any other purpose, disclose them or refer to them in any
prospectus or other document, or make them available or communicate them to any other party. If this document contains
details of an arrangement that could result in a tax or National Insurance saving, no such conditions of confidentiality apply
to details of that arrangement (for example, for the purpose of discussion with tax authorities). In any event, no other party
is entitled to rely on our documentation for any purpose whatsoever and thus we accept no liability to any other party who
is shown or gains access to this document.
This document is not an offer and is not intended to be contractually binding. Should this proposal be acceptable to you,
and following the conclusion of our internal acceptance procedures, we would be pleased to discuss terms and conditions
with you prior to our appointment.
Deloitte refers to one or more of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited, a UK private company limited by guarantee (“DTTL”),
its network of member firms, and their related entities. DTTL and each of its member firms are legally separate and
independent entities. DTTL (also referred to as “Deloitte Global”) does not provide services to clients. Please see
www.deloitte.com/about for a more detailed description of DTTL and its member firms.
Deloitte & Touche (M.E.) is a member firm of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited (DTTL) and is a leading professional
services firm established in the Middle East region with uninterrupted presence since 1926.
© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved.
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 57
Annex:
Our strengths, capabilities and credentials
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 58
Your VAT implementation team at Deloitte ME
Our strengths and capabilities
Subject Matter Experts
• VAT implementation experts with recent implementation experience in Malaysia and other countries (Singapore, South Africa, Australia etc.).
Industry focused
• Our team includes a range of industry experts and can assist JC in identifying industry specific impacts
Bespoke Project Design
• We recognize that no two businesses are the same and we are adaptive to your specific demands, ready to respond to any unforeseen challenges that may arise
Cross-service line delivery
• Large scale VAT implementation projects involve a number of disciplines requiring specialists in Technology, Human Capital and Project Management, in addition to VAT and our team understands well how each discipline should interact for your benefit.
Underpinned by enablers
Deloitte has developed a number of unique tools, “enablers”, that are especially desirable for large businesses providing time & resource efficiencies and allowing for benchmarking
OUR TEAM
APPROACH
Our value proposition
Our team
Our approach
Policy Makers
• Our VAT policy team has been at the forefront of VAT in the region since the beginning of the decade.
• We are advising two of the GCC Member States in drafting their national VAT laws.
Deloitte Indirect Tax in the GCC
• Over 50 VAT specialists (including VAT implementation specialists)
• Headquartered in Dubai
• Covering the 6 GCC Member States
Knowledge Transfer
• We deliver a project designed to ensure you will be compliant at the introduction of VAT & afterwards.
• We ensure that our clients build their VAT understanding and develop VAT controls and processes as appropriate.
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 59
Johan Van Der Paal – VAT Partner
Johan Van Der Paal is an indirect tax partner with Deloitte Belgium, based in Brussels. Johan has more than 20 years of experience as an advisor in indirect taxes, with a focus on VAT. He developed a focus on tax matters affecting the financial services and energy & utilities industries.
Johan has been assisting many larger insurance and banking clients in Belgium setting up and operating cost sharing or VAT grouping arrangements. He also leads Deloitte’s international team on VAT studies for the European Commission.
Johan is Professor at the Ghent University, teaching VAT, since 2015. He is a regular speaker at internal and external seminars. He is regularly consulted in his expertise domain by professional federations in Belgium on legislative initiatives and is member of the VAT Expert Group set up by the European Commission.
Johan Van Der PaalPartnerDeloitte [email protected]+32 475 90 56 69
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 60
Thomas Vanhee – VAT Senior Manager
Thomas is a Senior Manager in the Middle East Indirect TaxPractice of Deloitte and has specialized in indirect tax foraround ten years.
Thomas works for a large variety of businesses, private clientsand institutions. He has experience in very high profile M&Adeals and has succesfully assisted the financial and non-profitsector in improving their VAT recovery.
Thomas was also exposed to French VAT during the time heworked in Paris, and is involved with VAT policy work with theEuropean institutions and GCC governments.
He is also a member of IFA and lectures at Solvay BusinessSchool. He speaks English, Dutch, French, Portuguese andSpanish.
Thomas VanheeSenior ManagerDeloitte [email protected]+971 58 263 3018
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 61
Fernand Rutten – Customs and Global Trade Leader
Fernand Rutten is the Deloitte Global Customs and Global Trade Leader and Managing Partner of the Customs and Global Trade service line of Deloitte Belgium.
Fernand has over 20 years of experience in indirect tax, with a strong focus on customs, excises and global trade matters. Before becoming a consultant, he worked as a customs official with the Dutch customs authorities dealing with several customs and global trade matters, issuing rulings on customs valuation and customs economic procedures.
Some 17 years ago, Fernand became a customs and global trade consultant. He further specialized in a variety of customs and global trade matters and built out a specialized of experts serving clients in both the public and private sectors in business model optimization, automation, compliance, export controls, excises, litigation, valuation, origin, classification, and data analytics. In leading the Belgian customs and global trade service line, Fernand has advised clients on customs and global trade matters in many domains.
Fernand RuttenPartner Deloitte [email protected] +32 (0) 496 57 49 66
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 62
Daan De Vlieger – Customs and Global Trade Senior Manager
Daan is member of the Deloitte EMEA Customs & Global TradeCentre of Excellence since 2008.
Currently holding the position of Senior Manager, he servesvarious clients in the customs, trade compliance and excisedomain across the globe. Countries and regions of activitycover a.o. the Middle East region, the European Union,Switzerland, the United states, etc.
Current and past client include both public and private sectorbodies and entities.
Content-wise, focus areas are a.o. customs classification, originand valuation; customs import and export procedures, exciseprocedures, excise categorization, excise exemptions andmovement regimes, customs and excise management, customsand trade compliance, Free Trade Agreements, WTO traderegulations, Incoterms, etc.
Daan De VliegerSenior Manager Deloitte [email protected]+32 (0)478 90 87 51
Johnson Controls ME – VAT Workshop© 2017 Deloitte & Touche (M.E.). All rights reserved. 63
Frederik Drappier – Senior Manager Indirect Tax Technology
Frederik Drappier is a Senior Manager within Deloitte Tax inBelgium where he applies his technology integration skills to alltax and regulatory topics.
He has been involved since 2002 in numerous large businesstransformation and integration projects specialized inoptimizing and streamlining transaction flows, improvingindirect tax and statistical reporting as well as pan-Europeancompliance of global organizations.
Frederik has extensive experience in different industriesincluding Financial Services, Public Sector, Communications,Industrial Manufacturing and Life sciences and Healthcare.
Frederik DrappierSenior Manager Deloitte [email protected]+32 (0)496 926 16 64