Variable Rate Fertilizer at Reduced Scales
15
OSU Precision Sensing Variable Rate Fertilizer at Reduced Scales Randy Taylor Biosystems and Agricultural Engineering Oklahoma State University 2010 NUE Conference Stillwater, OK
description
Variable Rate Fertilizer at Reduced Scales. Randy Taylor Biosystems and Agricultural Engineering Oklahoma State University. 2010 NUE Conference Stillwater, OK. Field Scale Variability. Macro-variability Likely tied to soil type, landscape position, or something else Micro-variability. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Transcript of Variable Rate Fertilizer at Reduced Scales
OSU
Pre
cisi
on S
ensi
ng
Variable Rate Fertilizer at Reduced Scales
Randy TaylorBiosystems and Agricultural Engineering
Oklahoma State University
2010 NUE ConferenceStillwater, OK
OSU
Pre
cisi
on S
ensi
ng
Field Scale Variability
• Macro-variability– Likely tied to soil type, landscape position, or
something else• Micro-variability
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
App
licat
ion
Rat
e, g
pa
RX_RATERATE
OSU
Pre
cisi
on S
ensi
ng
Variability View from Equipment
• Longitudinal– Down-the-row– Response time issues
• Lateral– Across the boom– Boom divisions
A greater distance between the control and delivery points means a lower resolution and increased scale.
OSU
Pre
cisi
on S
ensi
ngSub-Meter Application System is a Proven Concept
OSU
Pre
cisi
on S
ensi
ng
Liquid Systems
• The initial sub-meter application system met market resistance
• However, sensor based VRA has found commercial success
• Section control systems have also renewed the interest in sub-boom width application
OSU
Pre
cisi
on S
ensi
ng
Accepted Resolution
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
0 20 40 60 80 100
Min
imum
Res
pons
e Tim
e, s
Application Scale, ft
5 mph10 mph15 mphLimit
OSU
Pre
cisi
on S
ensi
ng
Reduced Scale
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
0 5 10 15 20
Min
imum
Res
pons
e Tim
e, s
Application Scale, ft
5 mph10 mph15 mphLimitLimit
OSU
Pre
cisi
on S
ensi
ng
Liquid Systems
• Most commercial rate controllers can be set to about a 2 second response time.
• Multiple control sections will require multiple control valves and possibly flow meters.
• Pulse width modulation and binary valve systems have promise.
OSU
Pre
cisi
on S
ensi
ng
Granular VRT
• Granular distribution/delivery systems follow two basic designs– Gate/belt or chain/spinner– Metering wheel/air boom
• While both systems can be used for variable rate application, reducing the application scale to a partially width is really not feasible
OSU
Pre
cisi
on S
ensi
ng
Spinner Spreaders• Reducing application scales
with spinner spreaders is really not feasible.
• The material is centrally metered and distributed.
• Furthermore, VRA with spinner spreaders is a challenge.– Spread distribution patterns
are typically a function of flow rate onto the spinner
OSU
Pre
cisi
on S
ensi
ng
Air Boom Systems
• The material is centrally metered, but patterns are created locally.
• The primary challenge is lag time from the metering system to the point of application
OSU
Pre
cisi
on S
ensi
ng
Potential Solutions
• The central hopper/conveying system might be a good model to follow
OSU
Pre
cisi
on S
ensi
ng
Section Control System Speed
OSU
Pre
cisi
on S
ensi
ng
Rate Controllers and Tuning
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0NDVI
Pres
crip
tion,
GPA 1 gpa/0.05 NDVI
2.5 gpa/0.05 NDVI
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
App
licat
ion
Rat
e, G
PA
RX_RATERATE
• Prescriptions should not be developed without considering rate controller performance.
• Worry about the macro variability within the field.
• Are you capturing the general trend?
