Vaccine Study

8/6/2019 Vaccine Study

1/66

Pace Environmental Law Review

Volume 28Issue 2 Winter 2011

Article 6

5-10-2011

Unanswered Questions from the Vaccine InjuryCompensation Program: A Review of

Compensated Cases of Vaccine-Induced BrainInjuryMary HollandNYU School of Law, [email protected]

Louis Conte

Robert Krakow

Lisa Colin

This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the School of Law at DigitalCommons@Pace. It has been accepted for inclusion in Pace

Environmental Law Review by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@Pace. For more information, please contact [email protected].

Recommended CitationMary Holland, Louis Conte, Robert Krakow, and Lisa Colin, Unanswered Questions from the VaccineInjury Compensation Program: A Review of Compensated Cases of Vaccine-Induced Brain Injury, 28Pace Envtl. L. Rev. 480 (2011)

Available at: http://digitalcommons.pace.edu/pelr/vol28/iss2/6
http://digitalcommons.pace.edu/pelrhttp://digitalcommons.pace.edu/pelr/vol28http://digitalcommons.pace.edu/pelr/vol28/iss2http://digitalcommons.pace.edu/pelr/vol28/iss2http://digitalcommons.pace.edu/pelr/vol28/iss2/6mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://digitalcommons.pace.edu/pelr/vol28/iss2/6http://digitalcommons.pace.edu/pelr/vol28/iss2http://digitalcommons.pace.edu/pelr/vol28http://digitalcommons.pace.edu/pelr


2/66

NDC 30

4

RTILE

UNNSWERED QUESTIONS ROM THE

VINE INJURY OMPENSTIONPRORM

Review of ompensated ases of VaccineInduced rain Injury

YNDUIS CNTT W ND ISCIN

INTRODUTION

Is the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program VICP ofthe US Court of Federal Claims a fair forum? This is not a

trivial question as it is the only forum in which parents may

bring claims for vaccine injury to their children Under the 196

National Childhood Vaccine Injury ct 196 aw Congress

created an administrative forum that it meant to ensure simple

justice for children it gave the VICP original jurisdiction for all

vaccine injury claims1 ecause almost all US children must

ary olland esearch Scholar and Director of the raduate egal SkillsProgram NYU School of aw ouis Conte independent investigator andobert rakow and isa Colin attorneys in private practice Pace aw Schoolprovided significant research support for this study The authors thank formernvironmental aw Dean lexandra Dunn and law students Jillian Petrerayle Caffrey Sohad Jamal lison aplan eorgine ells Jonne onquilloisa atem llison azi and drienne Fortin The authors also thankvolunteers who worked under the direction of ouis Conte For purposes ofdisclosure obert rakow and isa Colin represent clients and have claims onbehalf of family members in the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program

1 National Childhood Vaccine Injury ct of 196 42 USC aa-112 26 ll individuals injured by a vaccine administered after thedate of enactment of the legislation are required to go through the compensationprogram P N 99-9 at 196 reprinted in 196 USCCN644 644 fter filing in the program petitioners may reject program

judgments or opt out of it to bring claims in state or federal court but initialclaims over 1 in damages must be made in the VICP Id at 12


3/66

$+((*).+ ,)

8 (!!&*%$(&'"!&

K>BO>O:MH:MM>G==:R:G=L %, A:L A:= : BQ>= ABLMHKR BG MA> >R>L H MA>

:BEB>LHMA>O:=

BMBLH MHLM BHKM:G MA:M MABL MKB;G:E KHOB=>L >BM:;E>MK>:M>GMMK:GL:K>GGAHA:O>

MA>@K:O>BLHKMG>MH;>BGK>=;RMA>O>KRO:G=>=MH>>MA>A>:EMAR

3ABE>LH>:K>GMLHO:=GLHKM>=MA>(:HO>KMB>:GRMH

OB>BMBMA;BMM>K=BL:HBGM>GMXEK>:=R;RMA>B=ZL$$/ A:= K>== MA> @KHG=L HK K>LMBO> KR HK O:KO>KLHG= MKH;EBG@

0A:M G@> ;>@:G BG A>G G>:KER BO> MAHL:G=

:BEB>LBE>=>MBMBHGLBMAMA>%,KHEH@BK = :MBLX

M MA> %,ZL @K>:M>LM G@> R>M E:R:A>:=

&// &>+>/ %/;?3= *0%+*( *!03+.' "+. %))*%0%+*AMMBGB:MBHGBGHHK@O:K>BK>>GML E:LM OBLBM>= ">; KHOB=BG@ : L>:K EBLMH O:BK>>GMLHK G;RLM:M>

/M:KMBG@ BG MA> E:M> ZL MA> K>>GL

&// /1 KB> HK MA> *:MBHG:E :GM>K >M :E :LB /HKMBG@ ,>MBMBHG>KL K>L>BM O 3R>MA /M *H +@+36+,6/ +> AMM:>KBOB>;EB=K>OB>;KB>L=L,>MBMBHG>K*%:G=+K@L:MAM>LMBHGRH:K;:K:(H>"BLA>K;>HK>HG@K>LLBG 0A>K> BL ;BMM>K =BL:HBGM>GM :G= >KO:LBO> GA:BG>LL :HG@:K>GMLBMAMA>GMLMK:G=:=BGBLMK:MBHGHMA>O:HO>= MA> K>LMBHG H K>KR KH K>LB=:E L>BK>=BLHK=>KX BG ):K MA> K>L>BM :BER BG


4/66

$+((*).+ ,)

#!)%"!!'*%)* 7HE

;>@:GMHLRKHM %G:GGK>=>GM>=KH>=BG@MA>%,:M>= :G= +GB;L MBL ,KH>=BG@=A>:KBG@L>:GMMH;KBG@LMBMHMA>L>

%, =BLBLL>= :EE MA> M>LM X :ELHKMA>">=>K:EBKE=:EEMA>=>OB>

>LBM> ::K>GM =B=>:BGK>MA>LH:MBLX

MA:MMA>%,K>>=BGMA>+GB;L MBL,KH>=BG@K>:EER=B>K>GMKHMA>LH>GA:EH:MARX:G=K>LB=:EL>BK>=BLHK=>KXMA:MMA>%,A:LGL:M>=;>HK>:G=LBG %LBMHLLB;E>MA>%, K>>=LH:MBLX;>H MA>AHM;MMHG E:;>E :G= GHM ;> H K>:E =B>K>GL BG BGKB>L HK>OB=>G

0ABL K>EBBG:KR LM=R L@@>LML MA:M MA> %, A:L ;>>GGL:MBG@ L H O:GA:EH:MAR :G=

K>LB=:E L>BK> =BLHK=>K :LLH= BMA :MBL LBG MA>BGMBHG H MA> KH@K: 0AKH@A MABLK>EBBG:KR LM=R MA>:MAHKL A:O> HG= >B@AMRMAK>> L H :MBL :HG@ MAHL>GL:M>= HK O:

0ABL :LL>LL>GM H GL:M>= L LAHBG@ :G:LLHM>>G O:L GHMKHKM MH ;> LG %G GH :R =H>L BM >QE:BG LGMBBG G>LL:KBER G=>KBG> MA> K>:LHGBG@ H MA>

=> +GB;L MBL ,KH>=BG@ ;:L>= HG MA>LGMBBHKB>L :G= >=BOB=>G ;>HK> MA> %, *HK=H>L MABL :KMB A:O> :GRMABG@ MH L:R :;HM LM:M> LBG@>G>K:E

0ABL BG=BG@K:BL>L G=:>GM:E>LMBHGL:;HM MA>BGM>@KBMR MK:GL:K>GLLHMABLHK

3A:M MABL :KMB =H>L HBGM MH :K> G:GL>K>= >LMBHGL:;HM O: MA:M :>


5/66

$+((*).+ ,)

8 (!!&*%$(&'"!&

:KHQB:M>ER HG> BGHG>AG=K>=:G= M>GG+GMABLHBGM MABL LM=R LMKHG@ER L@@>LML MA> G>>= HK KMA>KHG@K>LLBHG:E :G= LGMBBLMB@:MBHG MH >QEHK> MA>

:LLHM>>GO: BGM>@KBMR H MABL >=>K:EER:=BGBLM>K>= GL:MBHGKH@K:

%G,:KM%>K>OB>MA>(:MA:M:M>=MA>%,:G=MA> +GB;L ;:

>:KM>GMH$>:EMA:G=$:G/>KOBLZ$$/X#96381:G=:MM>MLMH@>MBGHK:MBHG:;HM:MBLKH GL:M>= L H O:M:BEL MA>;EBLA>= L BG MA> %, MA:M GHM> :MBL HK :MBLEB>LRMHL :G= BGHK:MBHG :;HM L>MME>= L :GB>LMBG@:MBLMA:M:K>GM:E@BO>KLA:O>=%M=BLLMA>

L :G= BGL K>K>L>GM:MBO>>LMBHGG:BK> K>LHGL>L KH:K>GML :G= @BO>KL ,:KM %%% AB@AEB@AML G:GL>K>=>LMBHGL :>L K>G=:MBHGL :G= =K:L QKMLKH : "K>>=H H %GHK:MBHG .>>LM : EBLM H K>OBHLER;EBLA>=:KMBL>O:E:MBG@GL:M>=LKHMA>%,

:G=::K>GMLMK=BGM>KOB>HK

&///+>??.C8@/=>K:EE:BLHBGMERHO>KL>>MA>%,.

http://digitalcommons.pace.edu/pelr/vol28/iss2/6


6/66

$+((*).+ ,)

#!)%"!!'*%)* 7HE

(*"")&-#!$"'(#"$&!*$"(#!")')('!$"

(52*$.;1A52".A6 %, :L :KM H MA> *:MBHG:EABE=AHH=:=MABLE>@BLE:MBHG MH :O> L>O>K:E H;>L MH :M> MA>

BGK:LMK HK : G:MBHG:E BGB:MBHG KH@K: MHBGLE:M>BG=LMKR:G= MA>>=BLLBHGKHEB:;BEBMRMH >LM:;EBLA : KH@K: MH GL:M> MA> BGK>= :G= MHKHHM>L:>KO: (: HMEBG>= :G :;BMBHL :@>G=: HK O:L>:K= MA> %, MHGL:M>O:E:M>= BGKR HK =>:MAX %G BML E>@BLE:MBO> ABLMHKR

HG@K>LL :LL>KM>= MA:M MA> KHL> H MA> KH@K: :L MH>LM:;EBLA:>=>K:EGH:EM KH@K:G=>KAB MH O:= >KLHGL B:LBER :G= BMA

KM:BGMR :G= @>G>KHLBMRX HG@K>LL >G:= MA> LM:MM> MHGL:M> G AH A:= ;>>G BGK>= ABE> L>KOBG@ MA>;EBKH@K:K>BK>L:K>GMLHO:=GMHBE> BKLM BG MA> %, ;>HK> :GR HMA>K HKM H

">=>K:E E:BL BG 3:LABG@MHG HO>KL>>L MA> KH@K: *:MBHG:EABE=AHH=:


7/66

$+((*).+ ,)

8 (!!&*%$(&'"!&

M>KBEBG@BGMA>%,AH>O>K>MBMBHG>KLK>M:BGMA>KB@AMMH@H MH = >KBH= H MB> HKK>>LLBGM>G=>=MH:M>:E:K@>ER

:=BGBLMK:MBO> KH@K: :L :G :EM>KG:MBO> MH MA> 0A>KHL>HMA>%,:LMH>LM:;EBLA:>=>K:EGH:EMX GL:MBHG KH@K: 0A> HG@K>LLBHG:E HBMM>>

.>HKMGHM>=MA:MMA>LRLM>BLBGM>G=>=MH;>>Q>=BMBHL:G=:BKX :G= MH GL:M> K>= O:L BMAHMK>BKBG@MA>=BBM>KBG:MBHGL H KHL> H MA> LM:MM> :L MH HO>K MA>BG:=>:L H MA> >QBLMBG@ MHKM LRLM> HK O:=G7"8HKMA>K>E:MBO>ER>AH:K>BGK>=;RO:BKHGMA>HHKMGBMB>LHKK>=K>LL:G=K>LMBMMBHG :K> EBBM>= MB>Q>GLBO> :G= HM>GG:GL>K>= 5>M MK>LA:O> ;>>G=>LMKHR>=:G=HGMBG@>Q>GL>LLM;>>MX

3A>G HG@K>LL :LL>= MA> (: MA>K> >K> L>O>K:EK>= O:L BGGA:EH:MAR:K:ERMB=BLHK=>K :G= =>:MA

EE MA> BGKB>L HG MA> :>K>MHA:O>H0:;E>=>L=>O>GMLMA:MLMH=:RL H : BOBG@ : O:MBMBHG>KL>MMA>>Q:BK>>GMLH MA>L>=BGKB>LMA>G MA>R HE= GHM ;> K>BK>= MH EBMB@:M> :G= HE= K>BO>GL:MBHG MAKH@A :G :=BGBLMK:MBO> GH:EMX KHLL

.::

$..!,*+:M0A>HBMM>>7HG!G>K@R:G=H>K8:GMBL MA:MMA> L>>= H MA>GL:MBHG KH@K: MA>EH MK:GL:MA>GH:EMG:MK>HMA>K>BK>=BG=BG@L:G=MA>K>E:MBO>KM:BGMR:G=@>G>KHLBMRHMA>LRLM>ZL::K=LBEE=BO>KM:LB@GBBKHHM>GMB:EE:BGMBLKHEBMB@:MBHGX

.:M

.:M

&// ,( /M:M = :L :>G=>= :M / :: +@+36+,6/ +> AMMAKL:@HOO:@BLE:MBHG=

. ,:K:ERMB>KBH=H =:RLHLM BGKB>L>K> MHA:O>H


8/66

$+((*).+ ,)

#!)%"!!'*%)* 7HE

"HK BGKB>L MA:M >K> GHM EBLM>= HG MA> 0:;E> AH>O>K>MBMBHG>KL HE= A:O> MH KHO> MA>L> BGKB>L ;:L>= HG :K>HG=>K:G H MA> >OB=>G : HK> EB>ER MA:G GHMX

LM:G=:K=

0A>%,BGLE:M>LO:BK>LMA:M>MBMBHG>KL;KBG@MA>BK>MBMBHGLLHE>ER:@:BGLM$$/0A>R :R GHM L> :G:KL HKA>:EMA K:KL

0A>K:MBHG:E>HKMABLBG=LMKR:G=KH>LLBHG:EKHM>GLK> : LM:;E> KBL:HK=:;E> 0A>%, ::K=L GL:MBHG HM H : :=>K:EE:BL!B@AM/>KL:LHE>BG=>KLH:%,BL>:GMMH;>BGHK:EBMAHM K>EB:G HG MA> >=>K:E KE>L H >OB=>G :G=

*:MBHG:E ABE=AHH= :G=>= MABL BGHK:EBMR MH ;>G>BM MA>

.:::=//+6=9$..!,*+:M;BEEK>BK>LMA:M:>KLHGBMA:GBGKRK>LEMBG@ KH : O:K>= :M>K MA> >G:GM H MABLE>@BLE:MBHG BE> : GL:MBHG >MBMBHG :G= @H MAKH@A MA> GL:MBHGKH@K: ;>HK> KH>=BG@ BMA +8C EBMB@:MBHG :@:BGLM : :G:KX>A:LBL:==>=

&///1/M>O>,:E:G=KBEEH)+83=2381)+--38+>398=*2C90)+--38+>381'2/3


9/66

$+((*).+ ,)

8 (!!&*%$(&'"!&

>MBMBHG>KL ;R :BG@ MA> HK LBE>K :G= E>LL />KL =H GHM L>KO> :L K>=>GM BGL;L>>GMKH>=BG@LBGLM:M>HK>=>K:EMBMBHG>KL:RK>BO>BG MA> >O>GMH:O:E:M>==>:MA:G=::QB:HGMHHK:BG:G=L>KBG@

0A>L>GHM=LBG0A>(: :ELHKHOB=>L HK K>:LHG:;E>:MMHKG>RZL >>L:G= MBMBHGLHMA:M>MBMBHG>KL=HGHMA:O>MH:RE:R>KL

HMHHMHKHMHMA>KH>=LH: =@>GM:LMA>RHE=A:O>MH=HBG:KK:G@>>GM

0A>(:K>BK>LMA:M>MBMBHGL;>BE>=7GHHK>MA:G8HGMAL:M>KMA>=:M>HMA>HBKLMLRMHHK:GB>LM:MBHGHHGL>MHKH MA> LB@GBB :=BGBLMK:MBHG H MA> O:>R>:K LM:MM> H EBBM:MBHGL BL LAHKM>K MA:G :GR LM:M> MHKMLM:MM>L:G==H>LGHMKHOB=>HKMHEEBG@A>GE:BGMBL=B=GHM

HKBGKRBMABGMA>MAK>>R>:KLM:MM>HEBBM:MBHGL

%G>KA:LMA>HLMLB@GBBLM:MM>MA>(:K>LMKB BKLM BGMA> %,

$..>*H:M0A>KHL>HMA>LM:MM>BLMH>LM:;EBLA:">=>K:E GH:EMZ GL:MBHGKH@K: G=>K AB MHO:=>KLHGLB:LBER:G=BMAKM:BGMR:G=@>G>KHLBMRX

/ ::ABLMA:MBGHK:MBHGL;BMM>=

MH : L>K HK MA> =BG@ HG : >MBMBHG :R GHM ;>=BL=MH:>KLHGAHBLGHM::KMRMHMA>KH>=BG@BMAHMMA>>QK>LLKBMM>GGMHMA>>KLHGAHL;BMM>=MA>BGHK:MBHGX%GHMA>KHK=L:EEK>L>:E>=:G==HGHM;>:KMHMA>>GMG=>=:M/::: +@+36+,6/ +> AMMAKL:@HOO:@BLE:MBHG=

&///::>

.::

EH>KO/>:EMA$:G/>KOL">=E">=E HG>BM:;E> MHEEBG@:G==BLKR H BGKR BGO:HK> MA>HKM H>:EL HK MA> ">=>K:E BK:KBG@MH;>A>:K=BG&//EH>KO/>:EMA$:G/>KOL*H3(">=BK+


10/66

$+((*).+ ,)

#!)%"!!'*%)* 7HE

/M:KMBG@ BG GH O: HK :O:E:M>= BGKR HK =>:MA KH HG> H MA> K>G=>=O: BGKR HK =>:MA K>LEM>= KH LB=> >>K>G:OHB=:;E>>O>GMAH@AMA>O:KERK>:K>=:G=:L:K=BK>LM>LKHMA>/>LM:M>>GMH0HKML0A>/

/K>> HKM =>=


11/66

$+((*).+ ,)

8 (!!&*%$(&'"!&

:>=BHKR>

O::LHGHKMA>BGKR:G=:LAHBG@H:KHQB:M>M>HK:EK>E:MBHGLAB;>M>>G

O:K>:LHGHKMABLEH>K;K=>GMA:GMA:MG>LL:KRBGK>MHM>:G==BK>MBMBHG>KL:K>GHMK>BK>=MHLAHMA>K>>>K>ERK>BK>=MHLAHMA:MMA>O:LMBHG = MA>BK BGKR X

(52*.006;2BA6@:=BGMA>+GB;L:LBM=H>LBG:EE%,L

: ;>>G KLB:E LBG !=:K= &>GG>KBGBMB:M>=MA>BKB=>LK>:=L>BG!G@E:G=BGMA>L/H>:K@> MA:M MA> HK:KR / HO>>GM HK O:MR:G= @:G BMA (>:0AHLHGZL M>E>OBLBHG L>G/BEE>RO/>:EMA $:G/>KOL">=E">=E

"HK ABLMHKR H KLR :;HM O:> .H;>KM &HAGLMHG98>/7:9398 9@/7/8>= 38 3=>9KM&HAGLMHG>=

&//#')+--38/%9?6/>>/*M>E>OBLBHG;KH:=K>BG:M>K!(5$+%!/8



12/66

$+((*).+ ,)

#!)%"!!'*%)* 7HE

MA> E>:=BG@/ O:MR HK@:GB:MBHG 0AKH@AHM MA>E:M> ZL :G= >:KER ZL *% ;EBKB@AM MH BGHK>= GM HK O:

KBLLHO:K:G=:K;:K:(H>"BLA>KZL;HH /$+0 %*0$!.':;HM:=O>KL>K>:,0O:LMBHG>= MA> MR

0A> / O: BG MA> E:M> ZL %G

HG@K>LL:G "K:G ,:EEHG> H *> &>KL>R :MM:= :G:>G=>GM MH : "HH= :G= K@ =BGBLMK:MBHG "XK>:MAHKB:MBHG;BEEK>BKBG@MA>"MH:EBLMH=K@L:G= HH=L MA:M GMBHG:EER BGMKH== >K :G= :EBM:MBO>:G:ERLBLHMA>>K;BEEE:M>K

>OHEO>=BGMHMA>")H=>KGB:MBHG>LML ;R KHOB=BG@ =>M:BE>= BGHK:MBHG :;HM MA>BK>K MAB>KHL:E

0AB>KHL:EA:=;>>GL>=:L:K>L>KO:MBO>BGO:L;>HBMLLMKHG@:GMB;:KB:EKH>KMB>L0A>L>HMAB>KHL:E :EEH>= O:O: :ER;R:BGEMBL>OB:EL

*0Z(%*! %*"+ 0. AMMGOB= &:G

/>O>K:EHMA>O:KHMBG>

&//1/8/KGB:MBHG


13/66

$+((*).+ ,)

8 (!!&*%$(&'"!&

=MAB>KHL:EBG=BAMA>KB:M>M:GL>KMLLBLKOB,$/XH$$/:G= MA>

>KB=B:MKB=:HBGMLM:M>>GMHGMAB>KHL:EBGO:=

,$/:G=,MHK>G=MA:M:EEGLAHE=;>

BGB>= :@:BGLM MA> =BL>:L>L BG=B= BG MA> K>G=>=

BGB:MBHGL=E>#BO>GMA:MMA>KBLLHGHMO: GGHG :G= K KBL B

:GRH>QHLK>MHMAB>KHL:EBKLM

HGMAL H EB> >G= MH

BGB> :EE BG:GML >O>G B MA> K MA> HBGM LM:M>>GM :K>GML H :MBLMBKK>= MA> HLLB;BEBMR MA:M >KO>EH>GM:E K>@K>LLBHGMAKH@A : GB> HKH>KO>K:E:MAHKL ;EBLA>= :G :KMB BG)!%( $5,+0$!/!/ >GMBME>=

?>3=7 + 89@/6 09LEMH>K@:GMHBE>E:LBML:KHG=MA>,0O:KHL:E)).GHM:;ER=H>LGHM KHL:E ;> BM OBKL>L MA:M MA> MAB>KHL:EB@AM HMA>KBL> BEE "HK : EBLM H KHL:EGML>>3.:M0:;E>

/BG MA> E:M>

ZL MA> O:;:M> A:L = BMA G>

,;$>:EMA/>KO/>ZMH$>:EMA$:G/>KOL'237/ &>+>/7/8> 90 >2/ 7/2/

#?,63- /+6>2 &/ 90)+--38/9?)(.!



14/66

$+((*).+ ,)

#!)%"!!'*%)* 7HE

=>O>EH>GMLBG>=B:G=LG:G=BMA:MAHKLM:BG@HLBMBHGL;HMAHK:G=:@:BGLM:HLLB;E>O:MBO>ERLBE>>LMBHGBL:MMA>

A>:KMHMABLKH;E>0H=:R:MBLMBKXBLK>=:LR3-+8.&>+>3=>3-+6+8?+690/8>+6 3=9>K>G HK MA>GML BG LHK:GML BG O>K;:E :G= GHGO>K;:E HMRBLMKB= HK K>>MBMBO> :MM>KGL H ;>A:OBHK :G=BGM>K>LML 0A>K>:K>GHGBO>KL:EER:=;BH:K>KLL>

=H:BGLH =B:@GHLMBL> :EHLM GH LHK:O>K> ;>A:OBHK:E KH;E>L MH >QMK>>ER AB@AGGL> BGM>K>LML :G= BKR>KLHG:EBMB>L 0A> K:G@> H :MBLMBKL BG MA> /)%HK:EER BGL :MBL .>MMZL BLHK=>K ABE=AHH=

BLBGM>@K:MBO> BLHK=>K L>K@>KZL /RG=KH> :G= ,>KO:LBO>>O>EH>GMBLHK=>K*HM+MA>KBL>/>=,*+/X

"HK : K>OB> H LGMBBL LHKMBG@ : HLLB;E> EBG ;>M>>GO:3:>B>E=8(+66 09=

.:M &//3.:M


15/66

$+((*).+ ,)

8 (!!&*%$(&'"!&

>:MBLMBKBL=>BG>=HGER;R:G:@@K>@:MBHGHLRMHLMA>K>BLGH>:GBG@E=BLMBGM>>GMA>M>KL:MBLX :G= :MBLEB> LRMHLX 0ABL :KMB :>L MA>

=BLMBGM>KLMA:MMA>HKMH">=>K:EE:BL@BO>KL:G=HMA>KLL>%MBLGHM:=BLMBG


16/66

$+((*).+ ,)

#!)%"!!'*%)* 7HE

EMAH@A MA>K> A:O> ;>>G BLHE:M>= ABLMHKBKGA>GH>GHG:LBKLM=>L=;R

3=7 /HKB@BG:E

G BG ':GG>KZL L>KB>L

':GG>K BKLM GHM>=:GRHMA>LRG=KH>B:BK>= E:G@:@> LH>MBMBO> ;>A:OBHKL M

ABL E L>KB>L :G:ERLBL :BE>= MH :L LB@GBBE:M>= LRMHL BG>=BG@ :MM>KGL:G= @:LMKHBGM>LMBG:EKH;E>L BG MA> G :G= A> :BE>= MHEHH :MHLLB;E> >GOBKHG>GM:E >QHLK>L MA:M B@AM A:O> ;>>G B=>GMBB>=G BGMA> L>KB>L A:= >Q>KB>G= GHGHKE:LB;E>>QHLK>L MH >MARE >KG G>ER:M>= LRGMA>MBBG;HMAO: L>KB>LA:=:K>GML>BMA>KBGMA>>=BLLBHGHKBG@HGO:GMLBG:@KBLBG@G@BL 3ABE>MA>>KK> :K> :GR LHKLBG +ELM>=E:QBEE ;HH MA:M @BO> MA> ARHMA>LBL

E:LB;BEBMR

,BK?>3=>3-3=>?3@/98>+->*!.+/$%( +@+36+,6/ +> AMM:>=B:BM>=.@K:=LKMBL=L':GG>K+KB@,:>K=

&// * +()/0! ).' (%(( 0$! #! +"0%/) )!..5)!%%*!*)*)!!,%!)%

.:M

&//3.:M

&//3.

+MA>K K>GM LM=B>L MA:M GHM> E:MBHGL ;>M>>G >KK>GOBKHG>GM:E MHQBGL:G=:MBLBG):KR:MA>KBG> >/HMH .H;>KM0$BME:G&9381"?>>2/&:38838190?>3=7/+@C/>+6=+8.>2/$?/=>398908-3./8-/ 0 *!.+%+(+#%! !,!.%)!*0(%/ ):KR:MA>KBG> >/HMH "-52+7G=%+D93=7 '2/+=/ 09+6!/?9B38= 98>381 >9 + 3=/+=/ 90 !/? *!.+0+%+(+#5 .:RHG= " ,:E>K >M :E#C >9 #938>&9?


17/66

$+((*).+ ,)

8 (!!&*%$(&'"!&

+G> LM GHM> MA:M MA> /)% =>BGBMBHG H :MBLMBKX BL LBBE:K HG BML : MH MA> %,ZL =>BGBMBHGL H>GA:EH:MARL>BK>L:G=L>>E:X

>:L>=HK:;L>GMK>LHGL>MH>GOBKHG>GMK>LHG=LB:M

:EEHGERMHEH=OHBHK:BGELMBEB

0A>%,ZL=>LGA:EH:MARHKG>B@AM>>GHGMALH:@>:G=HE=>K BG=E>O>EH /)%ZL KB: HK HGL>M ;>HK> :@> MAK>> H :MBLMBKX0A>=B>GLBHGLH:MBLMBK:K> %,ZL =>M:BE>= =>L:L>= E>O>E H:L>=HK:;L>GM>R>HG:BER

>;>KLHKHMA>KBG=BOB=:ELHK

%GGMHK:;L>GMK>LHGL>LMH>QM>KG:ELMBEB=H>LGHM

K>:BEB:K>HE>HKMABG@L

%G HMA>K HK=L E:R> @:> B:BK>= LHE:MBHGL:G=GHGK>LHGLBO>G>LLMH>QM>KG:ELMBEB:K>GHM>=BG

;HMA MA> /)% :MBL :G= %, >GA:EH:MAR /)% %, =>LL GHM LGA:EH:MAR L>BK>L :G= L>>E: %G=>>= LGMBBK>LMBG@MA:M':GG>KABL>EGHM>=MA:M:;BHEH@BMBHEH@R H:MBL B@AM A:O>;>>G HO>KEHH>= %G MA> HK>HK= MH!.*. .%)(* %*"*0%(!/0%) /5*.+)! * %0/ %),(%0%+*/ "+. *!.(0$!+.5+"!$%+.':GG>KKHM>

0A>:KERBG:GMBE>:MBLZ%MM>KG:>:L=BEM>=;R LH>MH=>KBO> BMH BMLL>K:LL>= :L:L>=H=B:@GHLMB;:L>M HK : O:KB>MR H GK>E:M>= = ;R LH> :L MA> HGER O:EB=>QE:G:MBHGLHMA:MKMA>K=HK>O>GL=

.:MO

&//380G=BL%:G=%% 97:+2380G=BQ%%



18/66

$+((*).+ ,)

#!)%"!!'*%)* 7HE

EBM>K:MK> :=@>L MA:M MA> G QBLM

(52#:;6/B@BA6@:$?L> =>LG M LB=> ;R LB=> LAH LB@GBBL

":BEB>L :EE>@BG@ O:= E:LBML:@:BGLMO::G=>=>K:E HKM H ">=>K:EE:BL /ER >G=>= LMA>E>LL BO> MAHL:G= >MBMBHG>KL BE>= %, H O:KHL:E :G= )).HKB>L0A>%,=>=BMHE=AHE=A>:KBG@LHGMA>L>MHM>LMMA>HKB>LBMAMAK>>M>LMLXHK>:HKRMH

=> @>G>K:E =KHBEBG@ ;> MA> LMKB>R>:K LM:MM> H EBBM:MBHGL A:=>QBK>=%G:==BMBHGLH>>MBMBHG>KLBE>=BGMA>%,:G=MA>GHO>= MA>BK L MHLM:M>:G=>=>K:EK MA>K>BK>=

:BMBG@>KBH= MH;KBG@ E:LBML:@:BGLMO:MA>HKRHO:LB@G=>>KHK>MA>R:GM>=MHEBMB@:M>BGK>@E:K MA>R HE= >GHR KB@AML MH =BLKRHM>GMB:EERAB@AGL:MHKR:G=GBMBO>=::@>L:G=KB>L

*HG>HMAHL>=B>GLBHGL:K>:O:BE:;E>BGMA>%,

&///1/!KRLHG>M:E#3=77981.96/=-/8>=A3>28>/66/->?+63=+,363>3/=*&,/5$%0.5.03=7(*!0*!.+(+#5

&//(>KHRO/>>ZMH$>:EMA$:G/>KOL*H 3( ">= E +AMMLL:MBL(>KHR=

&///1$H>,KH=LHKO">KK:KB /!=#:


19/66

$+((*).+ ,)

8 (!!&*%$(&'"!&

+G">;K:KR/>KLHMA>">=>K:EHKMH E:BL K>E>:L>= EHG@::BM>= => BKLM+GB;LMBL,KH>=BG@M>LML0A>/>KLKE>=MA:M

MA>K> :L GH E:LB;E> EBG ;>M>>G MA> )). O: MAK>> M>LM X >MBMBHG>KL HK MABLHKR)BEE> >=BEEH HEM>G /GR=>K :G= 5:M>L

$:E>AKLM=>L>KO>=GHGL:MBHG0A>/>KL=B=GHMLBERLG=BL:OHK>=>MBMBHG>KL0A>RBLL>=L>=:G==>>:G>=>MBMBHG>KLZLGMBBHKB>L>Q>KMBMG>LL>L:G=MK>:MBG@ARLBK $:LMBG@L KH= MA:M MA> >=BEEH :L HG>LB=>=X MA:M MA> =H=)BEE> >=BEEH>K> @/ KHM>MA:M MA>ARLBM>>G)BEE>ZLL>O>K>:E:=B>L

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

.:M

/GR=>K O />:EMA $:G />KOL *H 3( :M ">= E ">; +@+36+,6/ +>AMMLLO:LH>EE/GR=>K= &///.36693(:M



20/66

$+((*).+ ,)

#!)%"!!'*%)* 7HE

:MBL:@:BGBG=BG@GH;:LBL HKGL:MBHG 0A>L>MAK>>M>LM>MBMBHG>KL>E>=GHMMH:>:EMA>BK=>:K@BG@)).BG==:MBLBGMA>BKLML>MHM>LML

;HMA>=BEEH:G=$:E>AKLMEHLMHG:>:E :G=/GR=>K=B=GHM:>:E

0A>HKMH>:ELHKMA>">=>K:EBK+D6/2? @ & HK:E :K@>GM MA> =@>L :GM>= MH GH

A:M HE= A:>G B E:M>K LG MAB>KHL:E:MBLMA>HKR

3A:MBEEA:>GMHMA>GZL=@>:GL>K>=ABLHG>LMBHGL:RBG@MA:MHG@K>LLKHL:EBG==:MBLMHMA>0:;E>H%GKB>L:G=LM:M>MA:MMAHL>AHA:=K>OBHLER;>>G =>GB>=GL:MBHGHE= LMBEE;>>EB@B;E>

/BBE:KER MA> :G>E H :>EE:M> =@>L BG /.3669 @ &

:L>=MA>>:KM>GMH&LMB+&XMH@A>LMBHGL

0A>:>EE:M>LL>>>=GHMMHBG=MA>

O:HKR:LBE:LB;E>:LA:=MA>/>KL

&// )>:= O />:EMA $:G />KOL *H 3(">=E@'BG@O/>:EMA$:G/>KOL*H3(">=E):KR>KO/>:EMA

$:G />KOL*H 3( ">= E ):K EEMAK>> L :K> :O:BE:;E> HGEBG> &// ?>3=7 /-3=398= +8. +-51>=@>L>K>:KERMKH;E>=MA:M+&A:=BGMKH==:G >Q>KM K>HKM MH K>;M >R >MBMBHG>K ;BHEH@BOB=>GBMAHM BGMKH= G=>KERBG@ E:; K>LEML HK ;HHLLH>MABG@ MA:M :EE :KMB>L :@K>>= HE= A:O> ;>>G BHLLB;E>

>=BEEHO/>:EMA$:G/>KOL"=">=BK +@+36+,6/ +> AMMLL=BEEH>=AKLMO/>:EMA$:G/>KOL "= ">= BK +@+36+,6/ +>AMMLL$:E>AKLMBK:G=

&//&8C./AKLMO/>:EMA $:G/>KOL "= ">= BK +@+36+,6/ +>AMM:EMA$:G/>KOL*H 3( ">= E ">; +@+36+,6/ +>AMM


21/66

$+((*).+ ,)

8 (!!&*%$(&'"!&

G=>K MA> ">=>K:E .E>L H BOBE ,KH=K> 0A>R KH;>=A>MA>K+&A:=:L>=HKMA>E:;;HHLMA>RA:=GZMHKAH+&LK>MA:MMA>>Q>KMK>HKM:LK>EB:;E>A>G+&

=B=GZMA:O> MA>G=>KERBG@=:M: A>G MA>+& E:R>K:LLK>=MA> =@> MA:M MA> =:M: HE= A:O> K>BGHK= MA> >Q>KMZL E:@A>= :L =B= H;L>KO>KL BG MA>

=@>L >K> LBBE:KER MKH;E>= MA:M +&:BE>= MH GHMBR >MBMBHG>KL MA:M MA>R >K> L>>BG@ MA> >Q>KMK>HKM BG MA> BKLME: :L LK>ER +& LAHE= A:O> ;>>G >EE::K>MA:MLKKBL>:L:G>GMBK>ERBG:KHKB:M>M::GM MH;>>MBMBHG>KKB>G=ER :G=GHG:=O>KL:KB:E 3ABE> MA> :>EE:M> =@>L BG ;HMA +D6/2?

:G=/.3669=>=BG:OHKH$$/:G=:@:BGLM>MBMBHG>KLMA>R=B=LH:M>K GMBHLHK:E :K@>GM :G=MA>=@>LGHM>= BG/.3669@&MA:M+&ZL

M>KMA>BG:E+GB;L:>:EL>K>=>=BGMA>L>KH;R:EE:>:K:GLMA>O:%,:L =0A>HKM H">=>K:E E:BLL>GMHM E>MM>KLMH:EE>MBMBHG>KLM>EEBG@MA>BGLH:GRHK=LMA:MGE>LLMA>R@> =B>K>GM MA>HKB>L :G= KHOB=> EEBG@ >Q>KML :G=>OB=>GMA>BKLHE=;>=BLBLL>=BMAHMA>:KBG@HGMA>;:LBLHMA>+GB;L@>G>K:ELML

.

.

.

.

>=BEEHO/>:EMA$:G/>KOL"=">=BK +@+36+,6/ +> AMMLL=BEEH>=AKLMO/>:EMA$:G/>KOL "= ">= BK +@+36+,6/ +> AMMLL$:E>AKLMBK:G= 3> :@K>> BMA >MBMBHG>KL MA:MMA> @HO>KG>GML :BEK> MH KH= HK >O>G MH K>>LM MA> =HGM:MBHGG=>KERBG@ K LMBGL K>HKML BL MKH;EBG@ ;M > MABG MA:M BG MA>LGHMLMBRK>O>KL:EX

&//MBL=:M>/>M>;>K8LEMBG@ BG MBL />K HK : /BBE:K *>KH=>O>EH>GM:EBLHK=>K 3( ">= E &ER +@+36+,6/ +>AMMLL:MBL:MBL=:M>= +.0 +" "! (%)/ #%*! 0+,!0%0%+*!./ +* $+3 0+ !%0 0$!%*! ,.+#.) +@+36+,6/ +>AMMLL:MBL!%0%*##%*!0+,.+/!/=



22/66

$+((*).+ ,)

#!)%"!!'*%)* 7HE

(52$L>MHM>LMLBGMA>

+GB;L MA:M HE= K A>MA>K MAB>KHL:EGM HHMA>LE:M>=M>LML%G:K>HKMK>BK>=;R HKM .E> :>= MH MA> K>LL $$/ = MA:MO:K>= $:GG:A ,HEBG@ZL>GA:EH:MAR :G= L;L>>GM =>O>EH>GM:E K>@K>LLBHG$$/ZL =>L >G :MBLEB> LRMHLX :G= :MBLX :EMAH@A MA>K>:LGH:;B@BMRMA:M$:GG:A,HEBG@BG:M

MA> LM:MMHKR KB: HK =>HGLMK:MBG@ MA:M MA> O:= HG &ER LB@GBB= :G

G=>KERBG@ BMHK AB=BLHL>= A>K MH=>BG>K@R >M:;HEBL :G= :GB>LM>= :L :K>@K>LLBO> >GA:EH:MAR BMA >:MK>L H :MBL L>KX0ABL=MHLH>BGM>K>LMBGMA>K>LLHG

MA> O: KHE> H BMH @/= MA:M $$/ :B= HO>K

&HG / ,HEBG@ >M :E /@/69:7/8>+6 %/19-298.39838+236.*3>2?>3=7&+"$%(*!.+(+#5

&//'BK;R=?:;KB>>QKMKHMABLHKMBL:ELH:O:BE:;E>:M,HEBG@O/>:EMA$:G/>KOL *H3(">=EK%MBLGHM:;E>MA:MMABLBGBMB:EHKM >K>ER >GMBHGLMA> )). O:GL:=BGBLM>K>= MH$:GG:A ,HEBG@ BG HG> HB OBLBM A>K>:L MA> BG:E GL:MBHG =>= ;>EH BG MA> ,;EBLA>= :L> A:KM :L :L> L>L )). :L MA>KBGKBGKR

&// #BG@>K 0:REHK '2/ %96/ 90 9@/ +8. /.3+ 38 %*!!,%!)%$+3+.,+.0!#.!!%/!/%!*!*+!.%!#+!.*)!*00$.!0!* +. $)* .%#$0/ +. $!(0$ * +. $%(.!* (HBL>'H$:;:L):KR$HEE:G=>=L


23/66

$+((*).+ ,)

8 (!!&*%$(&'"!&

BEEBHG BG =::@>L 0A> K>E>O:GM %, >;LBM> GHM>LEER AH>O>K MA:M ABE> HG> K>BO>= GL:MBHGKH MA>+GB;L$$/A:LG>O>K HMA>K BO> MAHL:G= >=A:M:=>MA>:MM>K:KMBEB>= HG MA> O>KR

L:>>=BQ>KM:BG@MA>O>KRL:>>=B MA>#96381 :G= MH=BLBLL HG> HMA> M>LMLBMAHMMA:M>Q>KM>O>K;>BG@Q:BG>=HKM>LMBRBG@BG>KLHG BGMA> +GB;L:;HM MABL ::K>GM


24/66

$+((*).+ ,)

#!)%"!!'*%)* 7HE

GL:M>= HK O:R>EBG:MBG@>GA:EHR>EBMBL !)X E>:=BG@ MH ,>KO:LBO>>O>EH>GMBLHK=>K*HM+MA>KBL>/>=:G:MBLMBK

'BK;R

:ELH;EBLA>=:K>LHGL>A>K>BO>=KH$$/:;HM:MBL:L: >:MK> H %,GL:M>= L $> >GMBME>= BMHGBLHKL :G= />KOBL

=BGBLMK:MBHGH$$/ MA:M BMH>L GHM0K:

"KHH:G:OB=$./7:BEMHH:GAKL:@HO8

/>GM"KB=:R">;K:KR,)

0H=BK;RGRGM

:OB=

%GK>LHGL>MHRHKHLMK>GMBGBKR$./A:LMA>HEEHBG@

LM:M>>GM

0A>@HO>KG>GMA:LG>O>KGL:M>=GHKA:LBM>O>K;>>G

HK=>K>=MHGL:M>:GR;:L>=HG:=>M>KBG:MBHGMA:M

:MBL:L:GL:M>=

LBGABQAB;BM>=:G>GA:EH:MARHK@>G>K:E

;K:BG=BL>:L>!GA:EH:MAR:R;>:=BLLBHGH:G:KK:RHLRMHLBGBK>L

&97/-236./.099

-97:/8=+>/937+>/6C/8.?:A3>2+?>3=793=>3-

=C7:>97=,?>A/.989>>23=,+=3=

.>@:K=L

&// 1/8/KM " '>GG>=R &K :OB= 'BK;R )+--38/ 9??>3=7 /,+>/ 98>38?/= $""%*#0+* ,+/0 ">; +@+36+,6/ +>AMMABG@MHGHLMKM>GG>=RK:G==:OB=BK;RO::EMA $:G />KOL*H/E:BL(!%/">=E&ER+@+36+,6/+> AMMLL ;>EE*'/==//+6=9380=:L>A:KM


25/66

$+((*).+ ,)

8 (!!&*%$(&'"!&

:OB=H:G

+BHHGB:EMA.>LHKL:G=/>KOBL=BGBLMK:MBHG

0A>:MAHKL>KE>Q>=;R$$/ZL::K>GM=BLBGM>K>LMBG:G

:LLH MA>BLL>KMA>KH:MAHK.H;>KM'K:H:==K>LL>=:"K>>=HH%GHK:MBHG %&('38

?>3=7 !*0.!/ %* 0%/) (+# />M ,)AMM:=O>GMK>LBG:MBL;EH@LHMA:LBL:==>="HK:G>QKMHMA>>:BEL>>:ELH'>GG>=R'BK;R=?:

3ABE>K>

E>@:ELM:G=:K=HL:>:LLGMBB;EBLA>=:KMBLHG O:= HG K>OB> H GL:M>= KMLLBLHEBH>:LE>LK;>EE::G=)).O:L0A>

&//380G=BQ%%%

&//380G=BQ%AB@HO>KG>GM:E:G=L H MA> %,GL:M>= L :L : LHK H O:E:;E> BGHK:MBHG HGO:


26/66

$+((*).+ ,)

#!)%"!!'*%)* 7HE

:MAHKL A:O> BG= LGMBLML :M MA> MA> %GLMBMM> H)>=B:G=MA>%,

. *$$B/96@521.@2@


27/66

$+((*).+ ,)

8 (!!&*%$(&'"!&

-(&37

&$?:0'

&"-5)

6."/&374

"5

-56-:

*4.&/5"-%&7&-01.&/5)"4#&&/"33&45&%&%0&4/?541&","/%8*--

/&7&3

$0..6/*$"5&7&3#"--:

&%0&4/?53&410/%507&3#"-$0..6/*$"5*0/

&*4/05

50*-&553"*/&%&*44&-'%&4536$5*7&"/%7&3:%*''*$6-550."/"(&

&/&&%4

$0/45"/50/&0/0/&$"3&501305&$5)*.'

30.*/+63*/()*.4&-'"/%05)&34=

03&/4&/7

&$?:0'&"-5)

6."/&374

"5

-5&$


28/66

$+((*).+ ,)

#!)%"!!'*%)* 7HE

"4BB=4AE

(42MH

>540;C7

D280;5D=2C8>

=8=68B4GCA4?A80C4

B748B

14;;864A4=C0=3B>505

40;C7

DC0;;H34?4=34=C>=>C74AB5>A74A20A40=3=443B

2>=BC0=

CBD?4AE8B8>=0=30BB8BC0=24

(748B=>=E4A10;1DCB86=BB4E4A0

;

F>A3BK

*=34AF>>3E

(42MH>540;C7

D=

A4B?>=34=C=>C43C70C)A0E8BMA3B8=3820C4C70C7

4BD5

54A435A>=B022>A38=6C>

A4B?>=

34=C0A

4=>CA4;0C43C>C74A4B83D0;B48ID

A438B>A34AK

(70A?=02:E

(42MH>540;C7

DFBC70C"460=4G7818CBB>A0;?A>1;4=0=3B>2

80;039DBCAF78278=

2;D34B7

40310=68=6

?D;;8=674A>F=708A

0=3B2A0C278=60CC78=6B=

BC0=C;HA438A42C43

4A38BAD?C8E40=3=>

=2>

Vaccine Study

Documents

Transcript of Vaccine Study