Upper Limit on an Equatorial Ridge from a Tidally-disrupted Paleo...

1
(a) The orbit of Phobos, the larger moon of Mars, is gradually spiraling inwards toward Mars (b) With dal stresses strengthening, in less than 70 Myr, the moon will be torn apart (c) Development of a ring system (Black & Mial, 2015) Future forma on of an equatorial ridge from moon debris (d) Ongoing satellite-ring cycle? (Hesselbrock & Minton, 2017) Did this happen in the past? Upper Limit on an Equatorial Ridge from a Tidally-disrupted Paleo-moon of Mars Bowen Fan 1 ([email protected]) and Edwin S. Kite 2 1. School of Yuanpei, Peking University, China; 2. Department of the Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, USA Motivation Preprocessing the Topography Data Searching for All Possible Paleo-equators for the Ruins of a Past Moon Sensitivity Limit for Destroyed Paleo-moons No ridge was found from the Maran topography Adding an equatorial ridge to the real Mars. 2 cases considered I . Iapetus-like (the ridge only covers a part of the equator) . Ridge without longitudinal variaon "Mars + N*Iapetus ridge" for both cases with 10 randomly combined topography. As N decreases from a very large number (the ridge is very clear on the map), h 0 corresponding to the best fit decreases linearly while κt keeps a constant. As N drops under a crical value Nc (~0.2), h 0 begins to decrease nonlinearly and κt rapidly grows to a high value meaning the ng gradually transforms to a straight line and the ridge is too small to find (our detecon limit). 1. For Iapetus-like ridge, the more ridge lies in geological young units, the greater the limit will be, and the harder we are able to find it. For longitudinally uniform case, the ridge can never be hidden, and the upper limit value is relavely stable. 2. The degree of detrending (averaged disk size) can aect the limit. An appropriate radius should be 1° - ~10° .A too big disk is ineffecve for detrending, while a disk with radius less than 1° can erase the ridge even for real Iapetus. 3. N= N , the ridge ≈ 300m in height and 6° latitudes o True Polar Wander may have occurred, so we took all possibilies of paleo-equators by mulplying the topography matrix by rotaonal matrixes (parameters: rotated latude, rotated longitude) For each potenal topography, we used masses of inial heights (h 0 ) and shapes (κt) of the ridge, and calculated the goodness of fing between the topography and every hypothecal ridge Finally, we ploed goodness of t ( ω) on a map. Each point on the map corresponds to a potenal topography, and the value of ω derives from the best- ng hypothecal ridge of the topography. The higher ω, the more possibility ridge lies on the paleo-equator. (This gure shows a case with an arficially imposed ridge lying at rotated latude ~40° & rotated longitude ~ 4° ) - as expected, the ridge is recovered. Data: Mars Orbiter Laser Almeter (MEGDRs) Fing the zonal mean height from 20 ° N to 20° S to a diusion equaon (a hypothecal ridge) Some geological units masked out (Amazonian, early Hesperian, volcanoes and Valles Marineris) because we are searching for a >3.5 Ga ridge Detrending the 2D topography by subtr acng a matrix derived from averaging data in radius ~2.5° range h = h 0 0 ( erf + 0 4 κt - erf - 0 4 κt ) σ ( )- ( ) ω (Real ridge + good ng = huge, narrow ridge and ny error!) Discussion (Credit to Minzhi Gui) Acknowledgement. The summer stay of B. Fan at U.Chicago was funded by Peking University. height At N = N c , the ridge ≈300m in height and 6� in width. The corresponding upper limit on destroyed paleo-moon radius is <65 km, which is 6 mes greater than Phobos.

Transcript of Upper Limit on an Equatorial Ridge from a Tidally-disrupted Paleo...

Page 1: Upper Limit on an Equatorial Ridge from a Tidally-disrupted Paleo …geosci.uchicago.edu/~kite/doc/Fan_and_Kite_LPSC_2018.pdf · 2018. 3. 11. · ridge can never be hidden, and the

(a) The orbit of Phobos, the larger moon of Mars, is gradually spiraling inwards toward Mars(b) With tidal stresses strengthening, in less than 70 Myr,the moon will be torn apart(c) Development of a ring system (Black & Mittal, 2015)� Future formation of an equatorial ridge from moondebris(d) Ongoing satellite-ring cycle?

(Hesselbrock & Minton, 2017)

� Did this happen in the past?

Upper Limit on an Equatorial Ridge from a Tidally-disrupted Paleo-moon of Mars

Bowen Fan1 ([email protected]) and Edwin S. Kite2

1. School of Yuanpei, Peking University, China; 2. Department of the Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, USA

Motivation

Preprocessing the Topography Data

Searching for All Possible Paleo-equatorsfor the Ruins of a Past Moon

Sensitivity Limit for Destroyed Paleo-moons • No ridge was found from the Martian topography• Adding an equatorial ridge to the real Mars.• 2 cases considered

I . Iapetus-like (the ridge only covers a part of the equator)

II . Ridge without longitudinal variation • "Mars + N*Iapetus ridge" for both cases with 10

randomly combined topography. • As N decreases from a very large number (the ridge is

very clear on the map), h0 corresponding to the best fit decreases linearly while κt keeps a constant.

• As N drops under a critical value Nc (~0.2), h0 begins to decrease nonlinearly and κt rapidly grows to a high value meaning the fitting gradually transforms to a straight line and the ridge is too small to find (our detection limit).

1. For Iapetus-like ridge, the more ridge lies in geologicalyoung units, the greater the limit will be, and the harderwe are able to find it. For longitudinally uniform case, theridge can never be hidden, and the upper limit value isrelatively stable.

2. The degree of detrending (averaged disk size) can affectthe limit. An appropriate radius should be 1° - ~10° . Atoo big disk is ineffective for detrending, while a diskwith radius less than 1° can erase the ridge even forreal Iapetus.

3. N = Nc, the ridge ≈ 300m in height and 6° latitudeswide. The corresponding upper limit on destroyedmoonradiusshould be no more than 65km, which is 6 times greaterthan Phobos.

• True Polar Wander may have occurred, so we took all possibilities of paleo-equators by multiplying the topography matrix by rotational matrixes (parameters: rotated latitude, rotated longitude)

• For each potential topography, we used masses of initial heights (h0) and shapes (κt) of the ridge, and calculated the goodness of fitting between thetopography and every hypothetical ridge

• Finally, we plotted goodness of fit (ω) on a map. Each point on the map corresponds to a potential topography, and the value of ω derives from the best-fitting hypothetical ridge of the topography. The higher ω, the more possibility ridge lies on the paleo-equator. (This figure shows a case with an artificially imposed ridge lying at rotated latitude ~40 ° & rotated longitude ~ 4° ) - as expected, the ridge is recovered.

• Data: Mars Orbiter Laser Altimeter (MEGDRs)• Fitting the zonal mean height from 20° N to 20° S to a

diffusion equation (a hypothetical ridge)

• Some geological units masked out (Amazonian, early Hesperian, volcanoes and Valles Marineris) because we are searching for a >3.5 Ga ridge

• Detrending the 2D topography by subtracting a matrix derived from averaging data in radius ~2.5° range

h =h0

0( erf

+ 0

4κt− erf

− 0

4κt)

σ ( ) − � �

( )

ω

(Real ridge + good fitting = huge, narrow ridge and tiny error!)

Discussion

(Credit to Minzhi Gui)

Acknowledgement. The summer stay of B. Fan at U.Chicago was funded by Peking University.

height

At N = Nc, the ridge ≈300m in height and 6� in width. Thecorresponding upper limit on destroyed paleo-moon radiusis <65 km, which is 6 times greater than Phobos.