Update on EBFM governance network study by VASG and MDSG
13
Fisheries GIT Fisheries GIT Update on EBFM governance network Update on EBFM governance network study by VASG and MDSG study by VASG and MDSG Overview of network analysis Overview of network analysis Examples Examples Status of the EBFM study Status of the EBFM study Co Co - - PI: Troy W. Hartley, VASG and Jonathan Kramer, MDSG PI: Troy W. Hartley, VASG and Jonathan Kramer, MDSG August 23, 2010 August 23, 2010
Transcript of Update on EBFM governance network study by VASG and MDSG
Fisheries GITFisheries GIT
Update on EBFM governance network Update on EBFM governance network
study by VASG and MDSGstudy by VASG and MDSG
Overview of network analysisOverview of network analysis
ExamplesExamples
Status of the EBFM studyStatus of the EBFM study
CoCo--PI: Troy W. Hartley, VASG and Jonathan Kramer, MDSGPI: Troy W. Hartley, VASG and Jonathan Kramer, MDSG
August 23, 2010August 23, 2010
OverviewOverview
Network Analysis Network Analysis –– Nodes and LinksNodes and Links
�� Social Network AnalysisSocial Network Analysis
�� Communication Network AnalysisCommunication Network Analysis
�� Graph Theory algorithmsGraph Theory algorithms——spatially arranges nodes.spatially arranges nodes.
�� SoftwareSoftware——graphically maps nodes and linksgraphically maps nodes and links
�� Quantitative measures of mapQuantitative measures of map’’s structure and functions structure and function
�� DensityDensity——group cohesion, trust, consistent behaviorgroup cohesion, trust, consistent behavior
�� Path lengthPath length——disparate subdisparate sub--groups, far apartgroups, far apart
�� Centrality measuresCentrality measures——bridgers, info disseminators, bridgers, info disseminators, ““the pulsethe pulse””
Growing application in public policy and managementGrowing application in public policy and management
OverviewOverview
Governance NetworksGovernance Networks
�� Example of adaptive behaviorExample of adaptive behavior——onon--thethe--ground implementation realityground implementation reality
�� NonNon--hierarchal, emergenthierarchal, emergent
�� Varying degrees of formality Varying degrees of formality
Early research on contractorEarly research on contractor
Recent research on multiRecent research on multi--sector, multisector, multi--stakeholder, multistakeholder, multi--jurisdictional casesjurisdictional cases
ExamplesExamples
What can we do with communication network analysisWhat can we do with communication network analysis
�� Atlantic Herring FMPAtlantic Herring FMP
�� ScienceScience--toto--managementmanagement
�� Stakeholder engagement patternsStakeholder engagement patterns
�� Network resiliencyNetwork resiliency
�� NH Commercial Fishing IndustryNH Commercial Fishing Industry
�� Targeted outreachTargeted outreach
�� Watershed managementWatershed management——Fisheries managementFisheries management
�� Integrated management potentialIntegrated management potential
�� EBFM governance networkEBFM governance network
�� LocalLocal--statestate--federal linksfederal links
�� Network performanceNetwork performance
20
352
194
261
386
67
286
145
414
395
393
382
324
302
275
274
141
129
58
46
3
442
426
407
403
206
121
50283
201
455415
384
336
291
288271
210
170
122
107
78
148
99
334
265
223
14
429
408
353
279
226
221
198
197
185
153
130
113
112
110
95
422
419
367
266
256
241
230
214
184
167
163
162
149
139
126
123
106
84
81
71
49
437
346
340
235
133
363
344
338
317
315
314
304
295
289
285
284
272
236
222
190
175
108
100
92
91
82
51
34
19
440
438
433
387
378
372365
361
333
331
328
293
267
257
254
252
251 250
228
219
207
196193
186
183
171
142
137
132
41
29
24
22
21
15
12
8
1
85
76
63
62
55
WeeklyN=1461% density2.51 wght avg path length
20
352
194
261
386
67
286
145
414
395
393
382
324
302
275
274
141
129
58
46
3
442
426
407
403
206
121
50283
201
455415
384
336
291
288271
210
170
122
107
78
148
99
334
265
223
14
429
408
353
279
226
221
198
197
185
153
130
113
112
110
95
422
419
367
266
256
241
230
214
184
167
163
162
149
139
126
123
106
84
81
71
49
437
346
340
235
133
363
344
338
317
315
314
304
295
289
285
284
272
236
222
190
175
108
100
92
91
82
51
34
19
440
438
433
387
378
372365
361
333
331
328
293
267
257
254
252
251 250
228
219
207
196193
186
183
171
142
137
132
41
29
24
22
21
15
12
8
1
85
76
63
62
55
ResiliencyResiliency
5 Groups from 1 of N=146 5 Groups from 1 of N=146
Weekly Weekly –– remove hi betweenessremove hi betweeness
N=74N=74
2.04 wght avg path length2.04 wght avg path length
N=48N=48
1.21 wght avg path length1.21 wght avg path length
20
352
194
261
386
67
286
145
414
395
393
382
324
302
275
274
141
129
58
46
3
442
426
407
403
206
121
50
283
201
455
415
384
336
291
288271
210
170
122
107
78
148
99
334
265
223
14
429
408
353
279
226
221
198
197
185
153
130
113
112
110
95
422
419
367
266
256
241
230
214
184
167
163
162
149
139
126
123
106
84
81
71
49
437
346
340
235
133
363
344
338
317
315
314
304
295
289
285
284
272
236
222
190
175
108
100
92
91
82
51
34
19
440
438
433
387
378
372
365
361
333
331
328
293
267
257
254
252
251
250
228
219
207
196193
186
183
171
142
137
132
41
29
24
22
21
15
12
8
1
85
76
62
55
173
60
41
33
90
154
167
137
117
91
81
165
151
110
23
18
166
152
133
20
130
58
161
140
113
112
107
98
65
45
11
168
150
139
105
104
99
83
56
50
14
7
158
149
144
123
121
118
109
108
102
100
85
80
79
73
63
55
47
44
43
40
38
27
22
8
6
3
171
170
156
147
145
138
131
103
92
84
64
61
46
2524
13
Example: Example:
NH Commercial Fishing IndustryNH Commercial Fishing Industry
Weekly communicationWeekly communication66 members66 members
3% density3% density
2.02 average path length2.02 average path length
EBFM Gov Net StudyEBFM Gov Net Study
Socioeconomic QETSocioeconomic QET——Governance Network StudyGovernance Network Study
�� Regulatory landscapeRegulatory landscape——baselinebaseline
�� MultiMulti--jurisdictionaljurisdictional
�� LocalLocal--statestate--regionalregional--federal partiesfederal parties
�� National Sea Grant Law CenterNational Sea Grant Law Center
�� Research TeamResearch Team
�� Political scientist, Law professor, policy internsPolitical scientist, Law professor, policy interns
�� Network performance measuresNetwork performance measures
�� EBFM participantsEBFM participants
�� Two Two ““casescases””——critical places in the Baycritical places in the Bay
EBFM Gov Net StudyEBFM Gov Net Study
EBFM Governance Network StudyEBFM Governance Network Study——achievedachieved
�� Two summer internsTwo summer interns
�� Jessica EckerlinJessica Eckerlin
�� Jennifer ReichleJennifer Reichle
�� Preliminary study of the EBFM participantsPreliminary study of the EBFM participants
�� Data analysisData analysis
�� Prioritized two geographic casesPrioritized two geographic cases
�� Accomack County VAAccomack County VA——Somerset County MDSomerset County MD
�� Cecil and Kent Counties MDCecil and Kent Counties MD——New Castle County DENew Castle County DE
�� Compiling sample and site visitCompiling sample and site visit
�� Refining questionnaire and administration protocolsRefining questionnaire and administration protocols
�� Key informant interviewsKey informant interviews
EBFM Gov Net StudyEBFM Gov Net Study
EBFM Governance Network StudyEBFM Governance Network Study——achievedachieved
�� Two summer internsTwo summer interns
�� Jessica EckerlinJessica Eckerlin
�� Jennifer ReichleJennifer Reichle
�� Preliminary study of the EBFM participantsPreliminary study of the EBFM participants
�� Data analysisData analysis
�� Prioritized two geographic casesPrioritized two geographic cases
�� Accomack County VAAccomack County VA——Somerset County MDSomerset County MD
�� Cecil and Kent Counties MDCecil and Kent Counties MD——New Castle County DENew Castle County DE
�� Compiling sample and site visit in casesCompiling sample and site visit in cases
�� Refining questionnaire and administration protocolsRefining questionnaire and administration protocols
�� Key informant interviewsKey informant interviews
EBFM Gov Net StudyEBFM Gov Net Study
EBFM Governance Network StudyEBFM Governance Network Study——forthcomingforthcoming
�� InternsInterns
�� Jessica EckerlinJessica Eckerlin
�� Research Team review of instrumentResearch Team review of instrument
�� Network measuresNetwork measures
�� Performance measures Performance measures
�� Survey the five countiesSurvey the five counties
�� Data collection and analysisData collection and analysis
�� End: January 31, 2011End: January 31, 2011
EBFM Gov Net StudyEBFM Gov Net Study
EBFM Governance Network StudyEBFM Governance Network StudyZohar-UMBI
Wood-NOAA Oxford
Wilberg-UMCES
Wallmo-NOAA
Waldman-CUNY
Vogelbein-VIMS
Vaughan-NOAA Beaufort
van Montfrans-VIMS
Uphoff-MD DNR
Tuckey-VIMS
Travelstead-VMRC
Townsend-NOAA Oxford
Thomas-ASMFC
Taylor-ASMFC
Spear-ASMFC
Smith-NOAA Beaufort
Shields-VIMS
Shen-VIMS
Sharov-MD DNR
Shabman-RFF
Seitz-VIMS
Secor-UMCES
Schott-UMBI
Schaffner-VIMS
Sadzinski-MD DNR
Robertson-NCBO
Read-MDSG
Parham-MD DNR
Paolisso-UMD
Overton-ECU
Orner-NCBO
O'Reilly-VMRC
Orbach-Duke
O'Connell-MD DNR
Nesslage-ASMFC
Miller-UMCES
Messick-NOAA Oxford
Meserve-ASMFCMcTigue-NOAA
McGinty-MD DNR
McConougha-ODU
McBride-NOAA NEFSC
Martino-NOAA Oxford
Lipton-MDSG
Lipcius-VIMS
Laney-USFWS
Kritzer-EDF
Kramer-MDSG
King-DC DE
Kemp-UMCES
Kahnle-NY DEC
Kahn-DE NREC
Jones-ODU
Johnson-VMRC
Johnson-SERC
Jensen-UW
Jacobs-NOAA Oxford
Humston-Wash & Lee
Houde-UMCES
Hoenig-VIMS
Hines-SERC
Hartman-WVU
Harris-UMCES
Green-MDSG
Gephard-CT DEP
Gauthier-ODU
Fiske-UMD
Fegley-MD DNR
Fabrizio-VIMS
Culzoni-EDF
Cimino-VMRC
Carpenter-PRFC
Campfield-ASMFC
Bryer-TNC
Breitburg-SERC
Blount-consult
Beal-ASMFC
Barker-MD DNR
Armstrong-MAFMC
Appleman-U Del
Annis-Hood
Anderson-U Del
Weekly:
58N
4% Density
3.13 Wght Avg Pathlength
THANK YOU!THANK YOU!
Troy W. HartleyTroy W. Hartley
Virginia Sea Grant DirectorVirginia Sea Grant Director
Research Associate ProfessorResearch Associate Professor
(804)684(804)684--72487248
[email protected]@vims.edu
