Untitled

18
China Property Watch: Sales And Prices Are Likely To Moderate This Year With Tighter Financing Primary Credit Analyst: Matthew Kong, Hong Kong (852) 2533-3595; [email protected] Secondary Contacts: Bei Fu, Hong Kong (852) 2533-3512; [email protected] Christopher Lee, Hong Kong (852) 2533-3562; [email protected] Laura C Li, CFA, Beijing (86) 10-6569-2930; [email protected] Dennis Lee, Hong Kong (852)2533-3563; [email protected] Table Of Contents Contracted Sales Update And Outlook Tighter Financing Conditions Likely Aggressive Land Acquisitions Policy Fine-Tuning Expected To Remain Appendix WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 1 1268209 | 301447691

Transcript of Untitled

  • China Property Watch: Sales AndPrices Are Likely To Moderate ThisYear With Tighter Financing

    Primary Credit Analyst:

    Matthew Kong, Hong Kong (852) 2533-3595; [email protected]

    Secondary Contacts:

    Bei Fu, Hong Kong (852) 2533-3512; [email protected]

    Christopher Lee, Hong Kong (852) 2533-3562; [email protected]

    Laura C Li, CFA, Beijing (86) 10-6569-2930; [email protected]

    Dennis Lee, Hong Kong (852)2533-3563; [email protected]

    Table Of Contents

    Contracted Sales Update And Outlook

    Tighter Financing Conditions Likely

    Aggressive Land Acquisitions

    Policy Fine-Tuning Expected To Remain

    Appendix

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 1

    1268209 | 301447691

  • China Property Watch: Sales And Prices AreLikely To Moderate This Year With TighterFinancing(Editor's Note: This is the first of a quarterly series on Chinese property developers.)

    Chinese property developers struck while the iron was hot and reaped rewards. Most of the Chinese developers

    Standard & Poor's Ratings Services rate posted record-high contracted sales in 2013, benefiting from a largely stable

    regulatory environment and robust demand, especially in tier-1 and tier-2 cities. The companies also took advantage of

    favorable financing conditions to issue bonds; many were new bond issuers. With the proceeds, the Chinese

    developers refinanced loans and bought a large amount of land for replenishment and expansion.

    However, we expect sales and property prices to grow more moderately this year due to uncertainties in financing

    conditions and economic prospects. Developers took advantage of the market opportunities in January and February

    to secure funding. On the other hand, we believe leverage will rise in the next 12 months for some developers, as a

    result of this round of aggressive land acquisitions. We also expect large construction outlays to help the developers

    meet ambitious annual sales targets. Standard & Poor's ratings on these developers may face downward pressure as

    their debt increases may have outpaced property sales growth. Nonetheless, we believe the ratings in the sector will

    largely remain stable.

    Contracted Sales Update And Outlook

    After a strong 2013 for Chinese developers, with record-high contracted sales, we expect sales to ease this year. We

    are uncertain if the developers will meet their sales targets this year because onshore financing conditions may

    change. If financing conditions tighten sharply, mortgage and developers' funding could be severely affected.

    In 2013, new home sales in China rose 27% to Chinese renminbi (RMB) 6.8 trillion, driven by an 18% increase in

    volume and 8% growth in average selling price (ASP), according to the National Bureau of Statistics. Contracted

    sales in our rated companies on aggregate rose 33%, higher than the nationwide sales growth.

    Most of the companies we rate exceeded their 2013 sales targets. Sales for Country Garden Holdings Co. Ltd.,

    China Aoyuan Property Group Ltd., Yuzhou Properties Co. Ltd., China SCE Property Holdings Ltd., Sunac China

    Holdings Ltd., CIFI Holdings (Group) Co. Ltd., and Greenland Holding Group Co. Ltd. all increased more than 50%.

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 2

    1268209 | 301447691

  • Chart 1

    ASP in the top 100 cities rose 11.5% in 2013. Average price growth in top-tier cities was higher than that for the

    overall market (see chart 2). Prices in the tier-1 cities of Beijing, Guangzhou, and Shenzhen soared more than 24% in

    2013.

    Home prices continued rising in January 2014 although there were signs of easing because of new measures

    implemented on financing and purchase restrictions in some markets since the fourth quarter of 2013 and the

    traditional slowdown before Chinese New Year for China's property market.

    The property price index for the top 100 cities rose 0.63% month on month in January 2014, 7 basis points (bps)

    slower than in December 2013. This represents the 20th month of consecutive property price increases in China.

    Also, the year-on-year price increase for the top 100 cities was 11.1% in January, 41 bps slower than in December.

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 3

    1268209 | 301447691

    China Property Watch: Sales And Prices Are Likely To Moderate This Year With Tighter Financing

  • Chart 2

    Our base-case scenario for 2014 is 5% growth in ASP and 10% rise in sales volume for Chinese developers.

    Demand--stemming from urbanization and rising disposable income--should continue to support volumes and

    modest price growth. However, we expect increasing volatility in the Chinese property market into 2014. The

    growth in sales and pricing will be constrained because of easing economic growth prospects, tightened

    local-government regulations, and an uncertain financing environment in 2014. Any adverse news could weaken the

    property market sentiment.

    Tighter Financing Conditions Likely

    Listed Chinese developers may face a contraction in funding channels and higher funding cost.

    The new Chinese leadership has shown signs that it will be more restrained in pumping liquidity into the banking

    system.

    Commercial banks may slow down domestic mortgage lending or request higher premium on project loans as China

    curbs credit growth and shadow banking.

    We expect average domestic funding cost in 2014 to be higher than in 2013 amid rising bank deposit rates.

    Furthermore, the strong financing needs of a few weak industries may cause a shortage of funds or raise interest

    rates.

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 4

    1268209 | 301447691

    China Property Watch: Sales And Prices Are Likely To Moderate This Year With Tighter Financing

  • Chart 3

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 5

    1268209 | 301447691

    China Property Watch: Sales And Prices Are Likely To Moderate This Year With Tighter Financing

  • Chart 4

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 6

    1268209 | 301447691

    China Property Watch: Sales And Prices Are Likely To Moderate This Year With Tighter Financing

  • Chart 5

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 7

    1268209 | 301447691

    China Property Watch: Sales And Prices Are Likely To Moderate This Year With Tighter Financing

  • Chart 6

    Many property developers have raised funds for refinancing and working capital. In January and February 2014,

    developers issued US$7.15 billion and RMB6.8 billion, respectively, in offshore bonds to bolster their liquidity and

    funding buffer. This follows a record year for new bond issuance in 2013.

    The market may hold uncertainties because of the U.S. Federal Reserve's reduction in its bond buyback program,

    often called tapering. Chinese developers are issuing bonds in anticipation of the market turning volatile if the Fed's

    tapering is more aggressive than expected.

    Bond issues in 2014 are showing a mixed trend in their coupon rates. The coupon rates of most bonds in the 'B'

    category declined (except KWG Property Holding Ltd.'s), mainly owing to stabilized credit profiles and improving

    track record.

    In the 'BB' category or above, the coupon rates for many bonds spiked, e.g., Dalian Wanda Commercial Properties

    Co. Ltd., Greenland, and Shimao Property Holdings Ltd. This reflects a lower risk appetite in the China debt capital

    market as the U.S. Fed's tapering caused capital outflows to increase from high-yield bond markets.

    Comparing the tenors for bond issues in 2014 with those in 2013, the companies selling bonds with shorter tenors

    (seven issues) this year outnumber those with longer tenors (four issues). For this comparison, we view the first call

    date of perpetual securities as the effective maturity date. Convertible bonds are excluded from this comparison.

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 8

    1268209 | 301447691

    China Property Watch: Sales And Prices Are Likely To Moderate This Year With Tighter Financing

  • Table 1

    Coupon Rates Of Bond Issues In 2014 Versus Previous Issuance

    2014 issuance Previous issuance

    Company Amount (mil.) Tenor Coupon rate (%) Amount (mil.) Tenor Coupon rate (%)

    Agile US$500 5 8.375 US$700 Perpetual 8.25

    RMB2,000 3 6.5

    Aoyuan US$300 5 11.25 US$100 4 13.875

    Beijing Capital Land RMB2,000 3 5.75 USD400 Perpetual 8.375

    RMB250 5 6.875

    CIFI US$200 5 8.875 US$225 5 12.25

    COGO US$400 5 5.125 HK$2,200* 5 2

    CR Land US$400 5 4.375 US$750 5 4.625

    US$700 10 6

    CSC US$400 5 8.25 HK$975 5 6.5

    Fantasia US$300 5 10.625 US$250 7 10.75

    Gemdale RMB1,050 3 6.5 RMB2,000 5 5.625

    Greenland HK RMB1,500 4 5.5 US$700 3 4.75

    Greentown US$500 Perpetual 9 US$300 6 8

    Kaisa US$250 4 8.875 RMB1,800 3 6.875

    KWG US$600 5 8.975 US$300 7 8.625

    R&F US$1,000 5 8.5 US$400 7 8.75

    Shimao US$600 7 8.125 US$800 7 6.625

    Wanda US$600 10 7.25 US$600 5 4.875

    Wuzhou US$100 4 13.75 US$100 6 13.75

    Yuzhou US$300 5 8.625 US$300 5 8.75

    RMB--Chinese renminbi. HK$--Hong Kong dollar. *Convertible bond. Coupon rate before step-up. Source: Standard & Poor's.

    The financing conditions for developers may vary. With the country's strengthening regulations on shadow banking

    and tightening credit in banking system, developers with maturing trust loans will find it harder to refinance using

    the same method. Large developers generally have more financial flexibility than smaller ones.

    We believe refinancing risk should be manageable for bonds due 2014. Among outstanding bonds, Powerlong Real

    Estate Holdings Ltd. and Country Garden should be able to either refinance or use their cash to pay off their debts,

    given their healthy sales and balance sheets. We expect the parent company of Shanghai Industrial Urban

    Development Group Ltd. (SIUD) to step in as a last resort if it exhausts other refinancing channels. The refinancing

    of China Properties Group Ltd.'s (CPG) US$103 million in outstanding bonds faces slightly higher uncertainty,

    however, given the company's poor sales; but we believe its good quality assets and the controlling shareholder's

    track record in providing support alleviate the risk somewhat.

    Table 2

    List Of Credits With Bond Maturities Within 12 Months

    Issuer Amount (mil.) Coupon rate (%) Maturity month Bond type

    Evergrande* RMB5,550 7.5 Jan Synthetics

    Road King* RMB1,272 6 Feb Offshore renminbi bonds (CNH)

    Powerlong RMB750 11.5 Mar Synthetics

    R&F* RMB2,612 7 Apr Offshore renminbi bonds (CNH)

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 9

    1268209 | 301447691

    China Property Watch: Sales And Prices Are Likely To Moderate This Year With Tighter Financing

  • Table 2

    List Of Credits With Bond Maturities Within 12 Months (cont.)

    Lai Fung* US$185 9.125 Apr Senior unsecured

    Agile* US$500 4 Apr Convertible

    CPG US$103 9.125 May Senior unsecured

    SOHO HK$2,357 3.75 Jul Convertible

    SIUD US$400 9.75 Jul Senior unsecured

    Country Garden US$375 11.75 Sep Senior unsecured

    *Refinanced. --Redeemed early. RMB--Chinese renminbi. HK$--Hong Kong dollar. Source: Standard & Poor's.

    Aggressive Land Acquisitions

    We believe competition for land will remain fierce. In our view, the Chinese land market in tier-1 cities overheated.

    Many land parcels were sold at record prices. Land sales in 300 cities rose 50% to RMB3.1 trillion in 2013,

    according to China Real Estate Index System (CREIS) data. Land cost on average rose 24% in 2013, according to

    CREIS. Construction cost has also been increasing.

    Table 3

    Top 5 Land Acquisitions By Total Price And Average Price In 2013

    Company City District Project type

    Total cost

    (RMB million)

    Average cost

    (RMB/sqm)

    Premium over

    base price

    Top 5 by total cost

    Sun Hung Kai Properties Shanghai Xujiahui Commercial 21,770 37,264 24%

    CR Land Shenzhen Qianhai Commercial 10,900 13,360 62%

    Sunac Tianjin Nankai Residential,

    Commercial

    10,320 10,109 12%

    Yuexiu Property Wuhan Jianghan Residential,

    Commercial

    9,010 12,617 29%

    Excellence Group Shenzhen Qianhai Commercial 7,810 20,300 50%

    Top 5 by average cost

    Sunac/Henderson Beijing Chaoyang Residential 2,100 73,099 16%

    Evergrande Beijing Chaoyang Residential 5,135 55,000 30%

    Jiangsu Wuzhong Economic and

    Technological Development

    Corporation

    Suzhou Wuzhong Commercial 555 51,046 410%

    Wing Tai Holdings Shanghai Huangpu Commercial 1,104 42,821 48%

    K.Wah International Shanghai Pudong Residential 568 40,106 63%

    sqm--square meter. Source: Soufun.

    Most of the companies we rate have devoted a larger proportion of cash proceeds from contracted sales to land

    acquisitions in 2013. Developers acquired land more aggressively in 2013 than we had expected to increase their

    scale. Some aggressive developers, such as Evergrande and Sunac, are vulnerable to a sudden decline in the

    property market due to their large commitments for land acquisitions and high land cost on certain projects.

    Because of rising land costs and competition, profitability will likely be compressed in the next 18-24 months. Most

    developers' margins in contracted sales rebounded in 2013 owing to better pricing and historically low land costs,

    but we believe further improvement may be limited because of (1) a shift toward the mass-market segment, where

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 10

    1268209 | 301447691

    China Property Watch: Sales And Prices Are Likely To Moderate This Year With Tighter Financing

  • margins are thinner; (2) continued aggressive pricing to generate cash flow; and (3) increasing land and construction

    costs.

    Chart 7

    Policy Fine-Tuning Expected To Remain

    We expect China's housing policy to remain relatively unchanged in 2014. The central government is likely to

    continue experimenting with market-based measures such as property tax and increasing the housing supply to

    control overheating in selective markets.

    However, the government is unlikely to roll out severe measures to suppress demand. Some cities have restricted

    the purchase of a second home and reduced mortgage financing. We expect these measures to remain; the

    government may take further steps to cool the market if prices continue to rise sharply across the country.

    We believe the government's adoption of market-oriented policies will bear fruit in the long term. Increased land

    supply and development of public housing would reduce demand pressure due to increasing urbanization.

    Some local Chinese governments have increased supply of housing to cool soaring property prices. For instance,

    the Beijing government announced in January 2014 that 30% of new land supply in 2014 will be normal

    "commodity housing" (private housing at market price) and 70% will be for social housing (subsidized housing for

    low-income families) and "self-use" commodity housing.

    In our view, such measures are unlikely to control prices in the short term but will accommodate popular demand

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 11

    1268209 | 301447691

    China Property Watch: Sales And Prices Are Likely To Moderate This Year With Tighter Financing

  • for improved and better housing for low-income families.

    Table 4

    Key Property Policy Updates

    Issuing authorities Policies Details Coverage

    Central governments National "Five Rules"

    and long-term property

    market regulations

    Property price control; property tax pilot

    expansion; national network of personal housing

    information and completing uniform property

    registration system

    Nationwide

    Central governments 3rd plenum policy Allow collectively owned rural land designated for

    construction to be put on sale. Such land will have

    the same rights and prices as state-owned land.

    This will increase land supply.

    Nationwide

    Local governments/banks Tightened mortgage

    availability

    Downpayments for second home raised further;

    mostly to 70% from 60%. Some cities stopped

    offering mortgage loans for purchasinge a third

    home or above.

    A number of tier 1-2 cities,

    including Shanghai, Shenzhen,

    Guangzhou, Wuhan, Hangzhou,

    and Xiamen

    Local governments Home purchase

    restrictions

    Purchase restrictions further tightened for

    non-local households; non-local buyers need to

    provide longer records of individual income tax or

    social security payments to qualify for home

    purchases.

    A number of tier 1-2 cities

    including Shanghai, Guangzhou,

    Zhengzhou, Wuhan, Shenyang,

    Nanchang, Fuzhou, and Taiyuan

    Beijing On self-use commodity

    homes

    70,000 units of self-use commodity homes to be

    rolled out in two years with ASP 30% below

    market rate; resale not allowed in the first five

    years

    Beijing

    Source: Standard & Poor's.

    Appendix

    Table 5

    Bond Issues In 2013 For Companies Rated By Standard & Poor's

    Issuer Currency

    Sale/Original Amount

    (million)

    Coupon

    (%)

    Final Maturity

    Date

    Issue

    Rating

    Central China Real Estate Ltd. USD 200 8 1/28/2020 BB-

    Central China Real Estate Ltd. USD 400 6.5 6/4/2018 BB-

    China Overseas Land & Investment Ltd. USD 500 3.375 10/29/2018 BBB+

    China Overseas Land & Investment Ltd. USD 500 5.375 10/29/2023 BBB+

    China Overseas Land & Investment Ltd. USD 500 6.375 10/29/2043 BBB+

    China Properties Group Ltd. USD 250 13.5 10/16/2018 B-

    CIFI Holdings (Group) Co. Ltd. USD 500 12.25 4/15/2018 B

    Country Garden Holdings Co. Ltd. USD 750 7.5 1/10/2023 BB-

    Country Garden Holdings Co. Ltd. USD 750 7.25 4/4/2021 BB-

    Evergrande Real Estate Group Ltd. USD 1,500 8.75 10/30/2018 BB-

    Famous Commercial Ltd. (Gemdale)* RMB 2,000 5.625 3/21/2018 BB-

    Fantasia Holdings Group Co. Ltd. USD 250 10.75 1/22/2020 B+

    Fantasia Holdings Group Co. Ltd. RMB 1,000 7.875 5/27/2016 B+

    Franshion Properties (China) Ltd. USD 300 5.375 10/17/2018 BBB-

    Future Land Development Holdings Ltd. USD 200 10.25 1/31/2018 B+

    Future Land Development Holdings Ltd. RMB 1,500 9.75 4/25/2016 B+

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 12

    1268209 | 301447691

    China Property Watch: Sales And Prices Are Likely To Moderate This Year With Tighter Financing

  • Table 5

    Bond Issues In 2013 For Companies Rated By Standard & Poor's (cont.)

    Glorious Property Holdings Ltd. USD 400 13.25 3/4/2018 CCC+

    Golden Wheel Tiandi Holdings Co. Ltd. RMB 600 11.25 4/25/2016 B

    Greenland Hong Kong Holdings Ltd.

    (Greenland Group)*

    USD 700 4.75 10/18/2016 BB+

    Greentown China Holdings Ltd. USD 700 8.5 2/4/2018 B+

    Greentown China Holdings Ltd. RMB 2,500 5.625 5/13/2016 B+

    Greentown China Holdings Ltd. USD 300 8 3/24/2019 B+

    Hengli (Hong Kong) Real Estate Ltd. (Poly Real

    Estate)*

    USD 500 4.5 8/6/2018 BBB-

    Hopson Development Holdings Ltd. USD 300 9.875 1/16/2018 CCC+

    Kaisa Group Holdings Ltd. USD 500 10.25 1/8/2020 B+

    Kaisa Group Holdings Ltd. USD 800 8.875 3/19/2018 B+

    Kaisa Group Holdings Ltd. RMB 1,800 6.875 4/22/2016 B+

    KWG Property Holding Ltd. USD 300 8.625 2/5/2020 B+

    Lai Fung Holdings Ltd. RMB 1,800 6.875 4/25/2018 B+

    Longfor Properties Co. Ltd. USD 500 6.75 1/29/2023 BB

    Mingfa Group (International) Co. Ltd. USD 100 13.25 2/1/2018 B-

    Powerlong Real Estate Holdings Ltd. USD 250 11.25 1/25/2018 B-

    Powerlong Real Estate Holdings Ltd. RMB 800 9.5 5/27/2016 B-

    R&F Properties (HK) Co. Ltd. (Guangzhou

    R&F)*

    USD 600 8.75 1/24/2020 BB-

    Road King Infrastructure Ltd. RMB 2,200 6 12/3/2016 BB-

    Shimao Property Holdings Ltd. USD 800 6.625 1/14/2020 BB-

    Sunac China Holdings Ltd. USD 500 9.375 4/5/2018 B+

    Vanke Real Estate (Hong Kong) Co. Ltd. (China

    Vanke)*

    USD 800 2.625 3/13/2018 BBB

    Vanke Real Estate (Hong Kong) Co. Ltd. (China

    Vanke)*

    RMB 1,000 4.5 12/4/2018 BBB

    Vanke Real Estate (Hong Kong) Co. Ltd. (China

    Vanke)*

    RMB 1,000 4.05 12/16/2016 BBB

    Wanda Commercial Properties (Hong Kong)

    Co. Ltd. (Dalian Wanda)*

    USD 600 4.875 11/21/2018 BBB-

    Xinyuan Real Estate Co. Ltd. USD 200 13.25 5/3/2018 B+

    Xinyuan Real Estate Co. Ltd. USD 200 13 6/6/2019 B+

    Yanlord Land Group Ltd. RMB 2,000 5.375 5/23/2016 BB-

    Yuexiu Real Estate Investment Trust USD 350 3.1 4/3/2018 BBB

    Yuzhou Properties Co. Ltd. USD 300 8.75 10/4/2018 B

    *The companies in brackets refer to their parents.

    Table 6

    2014 Year-To-Date Bond Issues For Companies Rated By Standard & Poor's

    Issuer Currency

    Sale/Original Amount

    (million) Coupon (%)

    Final Maturity

    Date

    Issue

    Rating

    Agile Property Holdings Ltd. USD 500 8.375 2/18/2019 BB-

    Agile Property Holdings Ltd. RMB 2,000 6.5 2/28/2017 BB-

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 13

    1268209 | 301447691

    China Property Watch: Sales And Prices Are Likely To Moderate This Year With Tighter Financing

  • Table 6

    2014 Year-To-Date Bond Issues For Companies Rated By Standard & Poor's (cont.)

    China Aoyuan Property Group Ltd. USD 300 11.25 1/17/2019 B-

    China Overseas Grand Oceans Group Ltd. USD 400 5.125 1/23/2019 BBB-

    China South City Holdings Ltd. USD 400 8.25 1/29/2019 B

    CIFI Holdings (Group) Co. Ltd. USD 200 8.875 1/27/2019 B

    Famous Commercial Ltd. (Gemdale)* RMB 1,050 6.5 3/4/2017 BB-

    Fantasia Holdings Group Co. Ltd. USD 300 10.625 1/23/2019 B+

    KWG Property Holding Ltd. USD 600 8.975 1/14/2019 B+

    R&F Properties (HK) Co. Ltd. (Guangzhou

    R&F)*

    USD 1,000 8.5 10/1/2019 BB-

    Shimao Property Holdings Ltd. USD 600 8.125 1/22/2021 BB-

    Wanda Commercial Properties (Hong Kong)

    Co. Ltd. (Dalian Wanda)*

    USD 600 7.25 1/29/2024 BBB-

    Yuzhou Properties Co. Ltd. USD 300 8.625 1/24/2019 B

    *The companies in brackets refer to their parents.

    Table 7

    Rating List

    Issuer Name Issuer Credit Rating (as of March 3, 2014) CreditWatch/Outlook

    Agile Property Holdings Ltd. BB Stable

    Central China Real Estate Ltd. BB- Stable

    China Aoyuan Property Group Ltd. B Stable

    China Overseas Grand Oceans Group Ltd. BBB- Stable

    China Overseas Land & Investment Ltd. BBB+ Stable

    China Properties Group Ltd. B- Stable

    China Resources Land Ltd. BBB Stable

    China SCE Property Holdings Ltd. B Stable

    China South City Holdings Ltd. B+ Positive

    China Vanke Co. Ltd. BBB+ Stable

    CIFI Holdings (Group) Co. Ltd. B+ Stable

    Coastal Greenland Ltd. B- Negative

    Country Garden Holdings Co. Ltd. BB Positive

    Dalian Wanda Commercial Properties Co. Ltd. BBB+ Stable

    Evergrande Real Estate Group Ltd. BB Watch Neg

    Famous Commercial Ltd. BB Stable

    Fantasia Holdings Group Co. Ltd. BB- Stable

    Franshion Properties (China) Ltd. BBB- Stable

    Future Land Development Holdings Ltd. BB- Stable

    Gemdale Corp. BB+ Stable

    Glorious Property Holdings Ltd. B- Negative

    Golden Wheel Tiandi Holdings Co. Ltd. B Stable

    Greenland Holding Group Co. Ltd. BBB Stable

    Greenland Hong Kong Holdings Ltd. BBB- Stable

    Greentown China Holdings Ltd. BB- Stable

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 14

    1268209 | 301447691

    China Property Watch: Sales And Prices Are Likely To Moderate This Year With Tighter Financing

  • Table 7

    Rating List (cont.)

    Guangzhou R&F Properties Co. Ltd. BB Stable

    Hengli (Hong Kong) Real Estate Ltd. BBB Stable

    Hopson Development Holdings Ltd. B- Stable

    Kaisa Group Holdings Ltd. B+ Stable

    KWG Property Holding Ltd. BB- Negative

    Lai Fung Holdings Ltd. B+ Stable

    Longfor Properties Co. Ltd. BB+ Stable

    Mingfa Group (International) Co. Ltd. B Stable

    Poly Real Estate Group Co. Ltd. BBB+ Stable

    Powerlong Real Estate Holdings Ltd. B Stable

    R&F Properties (HK) Co. Ltd. BB Stable

    Renhe Commercial Holdings Co. Ltd. CCC Negative

    Road King Infrastructure Ltd. BB- Stable

    Shanghai Industrial Urban Development Group Ltd. BB Stable

    Shimao Property Holdings Ltd. BB Stable

    SOHO China Ltd. BB+ Stable

    Sunac China Holdings Ltd. BB- Stable

    Vanke Real Estate (Hong Kong) Co. Ltd. BBB+ Stable

    Wanda Commercial Properties (Hong Kong) Co. Ltd. BBB Stable

    Xinyuan Real Estate Co. Ltd. B+ Stable

    Yanlord Land Group Ltd. BB- Stable

    Yuexiu Real Estate Investment Trust BBB Stable

    Yuzhou Properties Co. Ltd. B+ Stable

    Zhong An Real Estate Ltd. B Negative

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 15

    1268209 | 301447691

    China Property Watch: Sales And Prices Are Likely To Moderate This Year With Tighter Financing

  • Chart 8

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 16

    1268209 | 301447691

    China Property Watch: Sales And Prices Are Likely To Moderate This Year With Tighter Financing

  • Chart 9

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 17

    1268209 | 301447691

    China Property Watch: Sales And Prices Are Likely To Moderate This Year With Tighter Financing

  • S&P may receive compensation for its ratings and certain analyses, normally from issuers or underwriters of securities or from obligors. S&P

    reserves the right to disseminate its opinions and analyses. S&P's public ratings and analyses are made available on its Web sites,

    www.standardandpoors.com (free of charge), and www.ratingsdirect.com and www.globalcreditportal.com (subscription) and www.spcapitaliq.com

    (subscription) and may be distributed through other means, including via S&P publications and third-party redistributors. Additional information

    about our ratings fees is available at www.standardandpoors.com/usratingsfees.

    S&P keeps certain activities of its business units separate from each other in order to preserve the independence and objectivity of their respective

    activities. As a result, certain business units of S&P may have information that is not available to other S&P business units. S&P has established

    policies and procedures to maintain the confidentiality of certain nonpublic information received in connection with each analytical process.

    To the extent that regulatory authorities allow a rating agency to acknowledge in one jurisdiction a rating issued in another jurisdiction for certain

    regulatory purposes, S&P reserves the right to assign, withdraw, or suspend such acknowledgement at any time and in its sole discretion. S&P

    Parties disclaim any duty whatsoever arising out of the assignment, withdrawal, or suspension of an acknowledgment as well as any liability for any

    damage alleged to have been suffered on account thereof.

    Credit-related and other analyses, including ratings, and statements in the Content are statements of opinion as of the date they are expressed and

    not statements of fact. S&P's opinions, analyses, and rating acknowledgment decisions (described below) are not recommendations to purchase,

    hold, or sell any securities or to make any investment decisions, and do not address the suitability of any security. S&P assumes no obligation to

    update the Content following publication in any form or format. The Content should not be relied on and is not a substitute for the skill, judgment

    and experience of the user, its management, employees, advisors and/or clients when making investment and other business decisions. S&P does

    not act as a fiduciary or an investment advisor except where registered as such. While S&P has obtained information from sources it believes to be

    reliable, S&P does not perform an audit and undertakes no duty of due diligence or independent verification of any information it receives.

    No content (including ratings, credit-related analyses and data, valuations, model, software or other application or output therefrom) or any part

    thereof (Content) may be modified, reverse engineered, reproduced or distributed in any form by any means, or stored in a database or retrieval

    system, without the prior written permission of Standard & Poor's Financial Services LLC or its affiliates (collectively, S&P). The Content shall not be

    used for any unlawful or unauthorized purposes. S&P and any third-party providers, as well as their directors, officers, shareholders, employees or

    agents (collectively S&P Parties) do not guarantee the accuracy, completeness, timeliness or availability of the Content. S&P Parties are not

    responsible for any errors or omissions (negligent or otherwise), regardless of the cause, for the results obtained from the use of the Content, or for

    the security or maintenance of any data input by the user. The Content is provided on an "as is" basis. S&P PARTIES DISCLAIM ANY AND ALL

    EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, ANY WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR

    A PARTICULAR PURPOSE OR USE, FREEDOM FROM BUGS, SOFTWARE ERRORS OR DEFECTS, THAT THE CONTENT'S FUNCTIONING

    WILL BE UNINTERRUPTED, OR THAT THE CONTENT WILL OPERATE WITH ANY SOFTWARE OR HARDWARE CONFIGURATION. In no

    event shall S&P Parties be liable to any party for any direct, indirect, incidental, exemplary, compensatory, punitive, special or consequential

    damages, costs, expenses, legal fees, or losses (including, without limitation, lost income or lost profits and opportunity costs or losses caused by

    negligence) in connection with any use of the Content even if advised of the possibility of such damages.

    Copyright 2014 Standard & Poor's Financial Services LLC, a part of McGraw Hill Financial. All rights reserved.

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT MARCH 4, 2014 18

    1268209 | 301447691

    Research:Contracted Sales Update And OutlookTighter Financing Conditions LikelyAggressive Land AcquisitionsPolicy Fine-Tuning Expected To RemainAppendix