University of Hawaii · .. JOHNWAIHEE ~OF_ REF:WRM-KO Q STATE OF HAWAII DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND...

.. JOHNWAIHEE ~OF_

REF:WRM-KO

Q

STATE OF HAWAII DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES

COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

JUL 15 1994

Honorable Yukio Kitagawa, Chairperson Board of Agriculture

Dear Mr. Kitagawa:

Transfer of Water Use Permit Pump 5 (Well Nos. 4158-01 to 11)

Koolauloa Ground Water Management Area. Oahu

KEITH W. AHUE CHAIN'E"-

DR. PETER SYBINSKY ROBERT S. NAKATA

J. DOUGLAS lNG, ESQ. ROBERT G. GIRALD

DAVID NOBRIGA

RAE M. LOUI, P.E. DEI'UTY

The application for future use of the abandoned Pump 5 station (Well Nos. 4158-01 to 11) was denied without prejudice on October 13, 1994, because existing uses in the Koolauloa Aquifer System were still being established. At present, there is no permit to use this source. ·

Should you have an immediate, justifiable need for water, please complete and return the attached application fonn. If you have any questions~ 'please contact Lenore Nakama at

Attach.

c: Donna Goth, Campbell Estate Mike Warren, Campbell Estate Paul T. Matsuo

Very truly yours,

Agricultural Resource Management Div.

~~ IRRA:1747 o \y Y JOHN WAIHEE Governor

State otHawaij. , -? 6' DEPARTMENT OF A~RjCOl TURE •• ,,,

T .9 .- >-

" ,~ '.

June 15, 1994'

TO: Mr. Keith Ahue, Chairperson Commission on Water Resource Management :-.

YUKIO KITAGAWA Chairperson, Board of Agriculture

LETITIA N. UYEHARA

Deputy to the Chairperson

FAX: (

Mailing Address:

~.'

SUBJECT: Transfer of Water Use Permit

I'

The Department of Agriculture respectfully reqlI'ests the transfer of the following water use permit:

Owner: Location: Water Management Area: Tax Map Key: Well Name & No.: Aquifer System:

Campbell Estate Kahuku, Oahu Koolauloa 5-6-5:07 Pump 5 (4158-01 through 11) Koolauloa

The permit was approved on October 13, 1993 by the Commission.

The Department had initiated an eminent domain litiga~~on to condemn the Kahuku Agricultural Park parcel. The First Circuit Court issued the stipulated judgement and order effective May 9, 1994. The water use will be the same as originally submitted.

If there are any questions, please call Mr. Paul T. Matsuo, Administrator of the Agricultural Resource Management Division, at .

~~i~ Chairperson, Board of Agriculture

c: Campbell Estate

p a c I

~ ,t.'

c

<0

i , ' 'b

~ \. Well No. 4158-01 to 11

"J."

....

01

,r,1

'J " In I

J!)

I: I

','

; I

. . _ ., __ ~_·_· __ I_---,-_,......:1.~~.J...,,-*...l.::--"-,-~'---'-1 \. . . !

, !

I

! ;

,}

I (

!

.I I

,I

I.r '_.

\ ::, " .,. r-

.- -. _ ----'--...)....--I-'>,,-..... :;-,I-·)!>-I: --::~-\:::k-'-'-f~-..::;;:...I "

\JI5t~. IV \A 1\I\tI)('V" '3

ISLAND OF OAHU HYDROLOGI:: UNITS

-!---'::"'....,....KOOlAULOA J!l wet

~ PROJECT AREA

----+---,1- WAHIAWA :!3 wet

NANAKUlI 1 ueD

WAIAN4E J wc;o

IroIAKAHA" ",ce

K£EAU " IoIC:l - .... J I 20 MGD EW,t,-KUNIA J

l1g WCD W,AIPAHU-W,MAWA

Exhibit 1

--L.-. WA'ALA[

Kahuku

,-'

lCj I

b'l~ &,IO~ ;'" (.Il

D Q State of Hawaii

DEPAR1MENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MLANAGEMENT

Honolulu, Hawaii

SEP -2 1993 MEMORANDUM

TO:

FROM:

SUBJECT:

Aquatic Resources Forestry and Wildlife Historic Preservation Land Management Natural Area Reserve System Office of Conservation and Environmental Affairs State Parks Water and Land Development Other Interested Parties

Rae M. Loui, Deputy Director ~

Request for Comments \ 0 Water Use Permit Application Koolauloa Ground Water Management Area. Oahu

Transmitted for your review and comment is a copy of a water use permit application for Campbell Estate for Well Nos. 4158-01 through -11. Public notice of this application will be published in the Honolulu Star Bulletin issues of September 8, 1993 and September 15, 1993.

We would appreciate your review of the attached application and please return. this form by September 29. 1923.

If you have any questions regarding this application, please contact Roy Hardy at

LN:ko Attachment(s)

Response: Contact person:

':"r' (:1' (~ We have no comments

( ) We have no objections ( ) Comments attached

, .... j'

( ) Additional information requested ( ) Extended review period requested

Signed: __________________________________________ __

",'" ';',1

Date:

-.. -.....

: ..... ,'. • . .. .:, .'

j .•

t

1608.77 11 10 o JOHN WAIHEE

GOVERNOR STATE OF HAWAII

HOALIKU L. DRAKE CHAIRMAN

HAWAIIAN HOMES COMMISSION

STATE OF HAWAII DEPARTMENT OF HAWAIIAN HOME LANDS

October 14, 1993

The Honorable Keith W. Ahue Chairperson Commission on water Resource Management Department of Land and Natural Resources

Dear Mr. Ahue: Withdrawal of Objections

1...,-' .. '

.,;'

<..~j (. ... , .,)',

'c' ) ~.-~ -dJ

.. ,..1 . c.,,:»

.~';\ c:ri The Department of Hawaiian Home Lands has been in a position to raise objections to various applications for water use permits, particularly in Windward O'ahu, on the basis that water reservations were yet required to meet statutory obligations to Hawaiian home lands.

Please be advised that as the proposed water reservations in O'ahu and Moloka'i water management areas are finalized, our objections for this reason are thereby withdrawn.

HLD:BH:ci/1608L.77

Wf?:tll~~o a

H~ Drake, Hawaiian Homes Co sion

'1' ", ~

\ \

ROLL CALL:

o o

MINUTES

FOR TIlE MEETING OF TIlE COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

DAlE: TIME: PLACE:

October 13, 1993 9:00 a.m. Board Room Kalanimoku Building

Chairperson Ahue called the meeting of the Commission on Water Resource Management to order at 9:09 a.m.

The following were in attendance:

MEMBERS: Mr. Keith Ahue Mr. Richard Cox Dr. John L Lewin Mr. Robert Nakata Mr. J. Douglas Ing

EXCUSED: Mr. Guy Fujimura

STAFF: Ms. Rae Loui Mr. Edwin Sakoda Mr. Roy Hardy Mr. Eric Hirano Ms. Lenore Nakama Ms. Sharon Kokubun

COUNSEL: Mr. William Tam

01llERS:

Winifred Miller Guy Nakamoto Creighton Mattoon Warren Iwasa Conrad Shiroma Dave Martin Wright Hiatt George Young Kent Smith Garrett Goo Chester Lao Norman Quon Edsel Yamada Reynolds Burkland Mr. Iida

Kahalaomapuana Wasson Jim Anthony Karen Piltz Barry Ching Elizabeth Martin Wayne Akana Keith Krueger Laverne Higa Ruby & Gene Montogomery Laura Thielen Ken Ishizaki Peter Lenhart David Taogoshi Keith Haugen

All written testimonies submitted at the meeting are filed in the Commission office and are available for review by interested parties. Some items were taken out of sequence to accommodate requests by applicants or interested parties.

AGENDA 1

ITEM 1 MINUTES OF THE SEPTEMBER IS. 1993 MEETING

Unanimously approved (Cox/Nakata).

ITEM 1

- . ... /

o o Chairperson and Members Commission on Water Resource Management November 17, 1993

ITEM 4

ITEMS

Staff recommended deletion of Recommendation lb. regarding DHHL reservation. The applicant's representative asked to submit yearly water use reports.

Unanimously approved as amended to eliminate recommendation 16 and require yearly reporting in Standard Condition 11 (Lewin/Cox).

WATER USE PERMIT APPLICATIONS, CAMPBELL ESTATE, KUlLIMA RESORT CO. &E. WHITE, WARREN SOH, KOOUULQA GROUND WATER MANAGEMENT AREA. OAHU

Staff recommended deletion of Recommendations 3b. and 4d. regarding reservation for DHHL

Mr. Burkland, representing the applicant R.E. White, objected to the low water use figure recommended by staff. Mr. Hardy stated that the water use recommended allocation was based on water use reports submitted by Mr. White. He explained that this is an interim water use permit, subject to the five-year review and that one of the standard conditions is that a water meter be installed to verify what was reported.

Unanimously approved as amended with the deletion of Recommendations 3b and 4d (Nakata/Cox). .

WATER USE PERMIT APPUCATIONS, POAMOUO A WELL <WELL NO. 32QS-(2). NHAC WELL <WELL NO. 3407-Q2l,WAlALUA GROUND WATER MANAGEMENT AREA. OAHU

Mr. Cox recommended that the following amendment be made for Recommendation 2 - NHAC Well:

" ... for the reasonable and beneficial airlcu1ture and aquaculture use of 200,000 gallons ... "

Ms. Laura Thielen, representing Poamoho Ventures, described how they arrived at the amount of water requested for the Poamoho A Well and how the water would be used. Ms. Thielen also presented their agricultural plan.

Mr. Martin presented written and oral testimony on the NHAC Well (see Commission file) requesting that:

1) The well be named Lopez Well (after the landowner) rather than NHACWell

2) Approval of the .75 mgd for 4.5 acres requested by NHAC rather than the .2 mgd as recommended by staff

3) Review Waialua Sugar's water use versus its allocated water use and revising their allocations and the water availability for the Waialua aquifer system

Additionally, NHAC questioned the validity of the flow measurements taken by the Honolulu Board of Water Supply in 1983. Although NHAC supports Poamoho Ventures water use request, Mr. Martin felt it unfair that they are granted 100% of its requested allocation (.6 mgd for 150 acres) and NHAC would be granted only 27% of its requested allocation (.2 mgd for 4.5 acres).

7

o o State of Hawaii

COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT Department of Land and Natural Resources

Honolulu, Hawaii

October 13, 1993

Chairperson and Members Commission on Water Resource Management State of Hawaii Honolulu, Hawaii

Gentlemen:

Water Use Permit Applications Koolauloa Ground Water Management Area. Qahu

Applicant:

(Various Well, See Exhibit 4). Campbell Estate

(Well No. 4158-14) Kuilima Resort Co.

(Well No. 3855-05) R.E. White Jr.

(Well No. 3654-05) Warren Soh

Background

Landowner:

Same

Same

Same

Same

Applications for water use permits in the Koolauloa Ground Water Management Area submitted to the Commission to date are shown in Exhibit 1. Exhibit 2 lists those completed applications scheduled for action on Qctober 13, 1993. Specific information regarding the source, use, notification, objections, and field investigation(s) are described in Attachment A and the attached exhibits.

Analysis & Issues

i>;verall Koolauloa Ground Water Management Area Conditions

The major issue in the Koolauloa Ground Water Management Area is the potential overallocation situation Jiven the number of water use permit applications for existing uses (Exhibit 1). The sustainable yield of the Koolauloa Aquifer System is 35 million gallons per day (mgd) but as of October 5, 1993 Exhibit 1 shows a total demand of 98.106 mgd. Of this total, only about 9.011 mgd is a more reasonable estimate of the existing demands on the aquifer and is calculated according to Table 1 as follows:

ITEM 4 AGENDA 3

o o Chairperson and- Member Commission on Water Resource Management October 13, 1993

TABLE 1. Calculation for Reasonable Estimate of Existing Uses

.•• ···.·.······Q~i6tit,. .. . .•.. (mgd)<il>tscliptiQn. •.

9S.106 Total from Exhibit 1.

-1.000 Future use for BWS Kaipapau Well No. 3655-03.

-0.002 CWRM approval of existing use for Well No. 3654-02 on 9/1193

-0.052 Returned applications for more information (doubtful use).

-0.061 Applications withdrawn due to non-usc.

-34.900 Applications field investigated verified with no existing usc.

-53.0S0 Applications for salt water wells (limited cffect on aquifcr).

9.011 Reasonablc estimate of existing aquifcr uses from applications.

This perspective shows a much more moderate view of the potential for overpumpage as only approximately twenty-six percent (26%) of sustainable yield is directly impacted from present application information. Additionally, the 1992 draft of the Oahu Water Management Plan estimated 1990 actual use to be 13.6 mgd which would be well within the system's sustainable yield which probably incorporates some salt water use. Finally, staff estimates the 12 month movina averap, as of __ 1993, is 24.289 mgd based on water use reports submitted to the Commission which includes significant salt water pumpage. Therefore, short of a complete field verification and analysis of the potential existing uses and of their reasonable and beneficial use, there does not appear to be an existing overpumpage situation.

Given this status, and the complexity of the salt aDd fresh water aquaculture uses, staff needs more time to analyze the existing uses from Campbell Estate applications to make reasonable recommendations, but sees no reason to delay action on other smaller users in the management area.

•

1. Campbell Estate Non-Existinl PompaB - From the various field investigations listed in Exhibit 4 the following wells scheduled for action and found not to be in use or a recent discontinued use are: 3957-01 to 06, 4100-02, 4157-11, 4158-01 to 11, 4258-04, and 4258-09. Since these wells have not been pumped and in many cases later identified by the applicant for future uses they do not qualify as existing uses and should be denied at this time until all existing uses are accounted.

2. Kuilima Resort Co. - The applicant requests an allocation of 800,000 gpd of nonpotable water from the Kuilima 1 Well (Well No. 4158-14) for irrigation of a new 1OO-acre golf course called the -Links at Kuilima-, The source and use described in this permit application were registered and declared in May 1989. A field investigation on March 25, 1992 verified the existence of this declared water use and the source.

The requested- allocation of 800,000 IPd seems high. Using guidelines developed by the County, irrigation of a 160-acre golf course may require up to 640,000 gpd. The water needs are also supplemented with treated effluent from tii", resort's private treatment plant. Also, based on monthly water use data reported by the applicant, the ac:tuall1-lDOIIdlmoYilll avenae witbdrawal from mis source is 302,000 IPd II of July Iml Finally, the -Turtle Bay Golf Course" located next to this new golf course irrigates 188 acres of turf and their 12-month moving average is 226,000 gpd although only about one-half of the acreage is irrigated intensely since only 9 holes are open for play.

No specific objections have been filed but general objections by Native Hawaiian Advisory Council are found in Attachment C.

3. R.E. White. Jr. - The applicant requests an allocation of 87,140 gpd of fresh water from the White Well (Well No. 3855-05) for irrigation of nine (9) acres of bananas and the domestic needs of three (3) residences. The source and use

2

o o Chairperson and Member Commission on Water Resource Management October 13, 1993

described in this permit application were registered and declared in May of 1989. A field investigation on September 1, 1993 verified the existence of the irrigation water use and also six (6) cottages serviced by the well were located. Of the six cottages, only two (2) are occupied on a regular basis.

The requested allocation of 87 ,140 gpd for irrigation of nine (9) acres of bananas seems excessive in light of the actual averaae withdrawal from this source, which is about 13,000 gpd (based on monthly data provided by the applicant for January 1988 through April 1992). Using the Oahu Water Requirements Forecast for Selected Crops, developed by the Department of Agriculture for the Oahu Water Management Plan, the irrigation requirement for nine (9) acres of bananas is estimated to be about 27,200 gpd.

This source is situated less than 2,000 feet inland from the shoreline near Laie Bay. No wells are located downgradient, but there are two other active wells located within one-eighth of a mile from this source. However, these uses have co-existed for a number of years, and the quantity of water required to continue this existing use is relatively small; therefore, these wells should not experience any impacts from continued withdrawals by the applicant. Refer to Attachment A for further discussion of other nearby wells.

Authorization to continue this reasonable and beneficial use of water should not result in unacceptable adverse impacts to other local wells, streams, and the Koolauloa Aquifer System. No specific objections to this application have been tiled.

No specific objections have been tiled but general objections by Native Hawaiian Advisory Council are found in Attachment C.

4. Warren Soh - This request is for an allocation of 500,000 gallons per day (gpd) from the Soh Well (Well No. 3654-05) for irrigation of one acre of mango, taro, and bananas, which seems excessive. A spring source was registered and use of water for irrigation of one acre of bananas and flowers was declared in May 1989. No wells were registered by the applicant. A field investigation on October 4,1993 verified that the well has not been in use ro. some time; also, no agricultural activity was observed on the "SPiny. Therefore, it is assumed that this request is for a future, rather than existing, use of water. Because existing uses are still in the process of being established, this request for a permit for a future water use should not be granted at this time.

No specific objections have been tiled but general objections by Native Hawaiian Advisory Council are found in Attachment C.

RECOMMENDATION

Staff recommends:

1. Campbell Estate Fresh and Salt Waler Uses - The Commission defer action on Campbell Estate actual existing use applications listed in Exhibit 2 and not covered under Recommendation 2 to afford staff more time to make a comprehensive evaluation of the aquacultural needs of the individual operators.

2.

3.

Campbell Estate Non-Existina Pumpau - That the Commission deny without prejudice the issuance of a water use permits to Campbell Estate for Well Nos. 3957-01 to 06, 4100-02, 4157-11, 4158-01 to 11, 4258-04, and 4258-09 and their requested amounts shown in Exhibit 2 since these uses are for future use. The applicant may submit new permit applications once existing uses in the Koolauloa Aquifer ~ystem have been established.

Kuilima Resort Co. - The Commission approve the issuance of an interim water use permit to Kuilima Resort Co. for the reasonable and beneficial use of 302,000 gallons per day of non-potable water for use from the Kuilima 1 Well (Well No. 4158-14) for the irrigation of 160 acres of golf course, subject to the standard water use permit conditions listed in Attachment B and the following special conditions:

3

, < \


Attach.

a. The applicant may continue this existing use of ground water within the limits approved by the Commission, and the actual issuance of the interim permit shall not be a reason to interrupt this existing use.

I b.

L The issuance of the permit shall be withheld until the reservation of water'l for the Dept. of Hawaiian Home Lands is set by rule. Until the !

reservation issue is resolved, the applicant may continue this existing use ' of water within the limits approved by the Commission. _

4. R.E. White. Jr. - The Commission approve the issuance of an interim water use permit to R.E. White, Jr. for the reasonable and beneficial use of 13,000 gallons per day of fresh water for use from the White Well (Well No. 385S-05) for agricultural irrigation of 9 acres, subject to the standard water use permit conditions listed in Attachment B and the following special conditions:

5.

a. The applicant may continue this existing use of ground water within the limits approved by the Commission, and the actual issuance of the interim permit shall not be a reason to interrupt this existing use.

b. The applicant may submit monthly measurements on a yearly basis.

c. If a single meter at the well is used, the Commission shall allow an additional 1,000 gallons per day to the water use permit allocation amount for the domestic needs of two residences, although a permit for individual domestic consumption is not required. Otherwise, the applicant must provide a meter to separately measure the irrigation consumption.

•

The issuance of the pe~mit shall be witJU:leld until the rese~ation of wate;;.:, \ c:} _

for the Dept. of Hawallan Home Lands IS set by rule. UntIl the ( ,'-'- "'-

l----,--reservation. is~ue is r~s~lved, the applicant may c~nt!nue this existing use ,:::", < ~ 1" ~ of water wlthlO the llmlts approved by the CommIssIon. ~,-

Warren Sob - The Commission deny without prejudice the issuance of a water use permit to Warren Soh to use 500,000 gallons per day of fresh water for future use from the Soh Well (Well No. 3654-05). The applicant may submit a new permit application once existing uses in the Koolauloa Aquifer System have been established.

Respectfully submitted,

~~ bAE M. LOUI Deputy Director

APPROVED FOR SUBMITTAL:

"I.

ML--.~ KEITH W. AHUE, Chairperson

4


WATER USE PERMIT DETAILED INFORMATION

1.

2.

3.

Source Information

AQUIFER: Sustainable Yield: Existing Water Use Permits: Available Allocation: Total of other pending allocations:

Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu 35 mgd

0.002 mgd 35 mgd

98.109 mgd

WELL: Location: Year Drilled: Casing Diameter:

Elevations (msl= 0 ft.) Water Level: Ground: Bottom of Solid Casing: Bottom of Perforated: Bottom of Open Hole:

Total Depth: Grouted Annulus Depth:


Elevations (msl= 0 ft.) Water Level: Ground: Bottom of Solid Casing: Bottom of Perforated: Bottom of Open Hole:



Eleyations (msl= 0 ft.) Water Level: Ground: Bottom of Solid Casing: Bottom of Perforated: Bottom of Open Hole:


Kuilima 1 Well (Well No. 4158-14) Kahuku, Oahu, TMK:5-6-3:44

1990 in.

1.0 ft. 10 ft.

-69 ftt NA ft.

-125 ft.

135 ft. NA ft.

White Well (Well No. 3855-05) 55-202 Kam Hwy, Laie, Oahu, TMK:5-5-1:21

NA 12 in.

NA ft. 18 ft.

NA ft. NA ft. NA ft.

NA ft. NA ft.

Soh Well (Well No. 3654-05) 53-120 Halai St. Hauula, Oahu, TMK:5-3-15: 18

NA NA in.

A IT ACHMENT A

NA ft. NA ft. NA ft. NA ft. NA ft.

NA ft. NA ft.

o o Chairperson and Member Commission on Water Resource Management

r-.-~

, outedmQ

1<;7 OIl II .. 01 .. tml

Tot~ Depth

Iv. I I

t. sold CGSi1g

I I I ... t. perf. casilg

- .-

Iv.I • open hole

Use Information

Current 12-Month Moving Average Withdrawal:

See Exhibit 3 for individual applications use descriptions.

Nearby Surroundin& Wells and Other Re&istered Ground Water Use

October 13, 1993

24.289 gpd (69% of Sy)

Information from the registration program indicates there are possibly 84 existing wells in the Koolauloa Aquifer System. Several of these wells have been initially field checked but many of the declarants, including the larger users, have not been completely field verified. Several are not in use or are rights claims. However, the Oahu Water Management Plan estimated that the existing withdrawals from the Koolauloa Aquifer System is 13.6 mgd as of 1990.

Specific well sites:

1. KUILIMA 1 Well- There are twenty-three (23) other wells within a mile of the well (see Exhibit SA). Eighteen (18) of these wells are downgradient. Of these downgradient wells twelve (12) are in use but all are salt water wells which should not experience adverse affects.

2. SOH Well- There are twelve (12) other wells within a mile of the well (see Exhibit 5B). Seven (7) of these wells are currently in use. No wells are located downgradient.

3. WHITE Well - There are twenty-three (23) other wells within a mile of the well (see Exhibit 5C). Eighteen (18) of these wells are currently in use. No wells are located downgradient.

jvblic Notice

In accordance with HAR §13-171-17, a public notice was published in the StarBulletin according to Exhibit 2. Copic~ oi!.he notice. Wti", sent to the Mayor's office and the Board of Water Supply. Additional notice copies were sent to the County Council and Department of Water Supply. Copies of the completed application were sent to the Department of Health, Department of Hawaiian Home Lands, Office of Hawaiian Affairs, Aquatic Resources & Historic Preservation Divisions of the Department of Land and Natural Resources, and other interested parties for comments. Written comments and objections to the proposed permit were to be submitted according to Exhibit 2.

A 'IT ACHMENT A


Objections

The public notice specifies that an objector meet the following requirements: (1) state property or other interest in the matter; (2) set forth questions of procedure, fact, law, or policy, to which objections are taken; (3) state all grounds for objections to the proposed permits, (4) provide a copy of the objection letter(s) to the applicant, and (5) submit objections meeting the previous requirements to the Commission according to Exhibit 2.

To the best of staffs knowledge there are no objectors who have property interest within the Koolauloa Aquifer System or who will be directly and immediately affected by the applications in this submittal. All objections and/or comments to the application are summarized as follows:

Objector

NHAC

DHHL

DAR

Field Investintion

Objection

General process of water use permit applications. No specific objections to this application. See Attachment • C.

Comparison of actual existing uses to requested amounts should be made.

For Well No. 3654-05 & 3855-05 there are the Maakua, Kaipapau, and Kaluanui streams which have native species. Any reduction in streamflow would be environmentally damaging to these species. However, existing uses should have already made their impact.

Applications were investigated according to Exhibit 4.

A IT ACHMENT A


STANDARD WATER USE PERMIT CONDITIONS

1. The ground water described in the water use permit may only be taken from the location described, used for the reasonable-beneficial use described, and at the location described above and in the attachments. Reasonable-beneficial use means "the use of water in such a quantity as is necessary for economic and efficient utilization, for a purpose, and in a manner which is not wasteful and is both reasonable and consistent with the state and county land use plans and the public interest." (HAR §13-171-2).

2. The right to use ground water is a shared use right.

3. The water use must at all times meet the requirements set forth in HAR §13-171-13 which means that it:

a. Can be accommodated with the available water source; b. Is a reasonable-beneficial use as defined in section §13-171-2; c. Will not interfere with any existing legal use of water; d. Is consistent with the public interest; e. Is consistent with state and county general plans and land use designations; f. Is consistent with county land use plans and policies; and g. Will not interfere with the rights of the Department of Hawaiian Home Lands as

provided in section 221 of the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act and 174C-100(a), HRS.

4. The ground water use approved must not interfere with surface or ground water rights or reservations.

5. The ground water use approved must not interfere with interim or permanent instream flow standards. If it does, then:

a. A separate water use permit for surface water must be obtained in the case an area is also designated as a surface water management area;

b. The interim or permanent instream flow standard, as applicable, must be amended.

6. The water use permit is subject to the requirements of the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act, as amended, if applicable.

7. The water use permit application and staff submittal approved by the Commission at its October 13, 1993 meeting are incorporated into the permit by reference.

8. Any modification of the permit terms, conditions, or uses can only be made with the express written consent of the Commission on Water Resource Management.

9. The water use permit may be modified by the Commission and the amount of water initially granted to the permittee may be reduced if the Commission determines it is necessary to:

... a. b. c. d. e.

f. g.

Protect water sources in quantity, quality, or both; Meet other legal obligations including other correlative rights; Insure adequate conservation measures; Require efficiency of water uses; Reserve water for future uses, provided that all legal c:.(isting uses 01 wlil.cc as of June 1987, shall be protected; . Meet legal obligations to the Department of Hawaiian Homes, if applicable; or Carry out such other necessary and proper exercise of the State's and the Commissions's police powers under law as may be required.

Prior to any reduction, the Commission shaH give notice of its proposed action to the permittee and provide the permittee an opportunity to be heard.

A IT ACHMENT B


10. If the ground water source does not presently exist, the new well shall be completed, i.e. able to withdraw water for the proposed use on a regular basis, within twenty-four (24) months from the date the water use permit is approved.

11. An approved flowmeter(s) must be installed to measure withdrawals and a monthly record of withdrawals, water-levels, salinity, and temperature must be kept and reported to the Commission on a monthly basis in accordance the Commission's September 16, 1992 action on reporting requirements;

12. The water use permit shall be subject to the Commission's periodic review of the applicable aquifer's sustainable yield. The amount of ground water use authorized by the permit may be reduced by the Commission if the sustainable yield of the KOOLAULOA Aquifer System, or relevant modified aquifer, is reduced;

13. The water use permit may not be transferred or the use rights granted by this permit sold or in any other way alienated. Pursuant to HAR §13-171-25 and the requirements of Chapter 174C, the Commission has the authority to allow the transfer of the permit and the use rights granted by the permit in a manner consistent with HAR §13-171-25. Any such transfer shall only occur with the Commission's prior express written approval. An)' sale, assignment, lease, alienation, or other transfer of any interest in this permit shall be void.

14. The use(s) authorized by law and by the water use permit do not constitute ownership rights.

15. The permittee shall request modification of the permit when necessary to comply with all applicable laws, rules, and ordinances which will affect the permittee's water use.

16. The permittee shall prepare and submit a water shortage plan within 30 days of issuance of the permit to assist the Commission in fulfilling HAR §13-171-42(c). The permittee's water shortage plan shall identify what the permittee is willing to do should the Commission declare a water shortage in the Koolauloa Ground Water Management Area.

17. The water use permit granted shall be an interim water use permit, pursuant to HAR §13-171-21. The final determination of the water use quantity shall be made within five years of the filing of the application to continue the existing use.

18. The water use permit shall be issued only after AG review.

ATTACHMENT B

o

1993 September 29

.0.

NATIVE HAWAIIAN ADVISORY COUNCIL A NoNPAoFrr CofI:aoMllON

State of Hawaii Commission on water

Resource Management ~\\~(~', ,.. -.'-.... '\'.;. '..

OBJECTIONS AND COHHENTSON Public Notice dated August Send written objections by

-0 ~

APPLICATIONS FOR WATER OSE PERMITS ." ' ..

30, 1993 ,',', :~" september 29, 1993 -',"" .. "

NHAC represents water source registrants, water use declarants, water use permit applicants, and others with property interest in land within the hydrologic unit of the source of water supply, as well as persons with non-property interests, all of who would be directly and immediately affected by the proposed water use.

GENERAL OBJECTIONS

We reiterate our general obj ections to current COWRM' water use permit application processing and decisionmaking practices as previously submitted on numerous occasions (10/12/92, 10/21/92, 12/1/92, 6/22/93, & 7/8/93).

Campbell Estate proposes to continue a total of 23.225 mgd of existing uses, 7.0 of which involve seawater. This leaves 16.225 mgd of use from the basal aquifer, yet the May 1992 review draft of the Oahu Water Management Plan (p. 14) reports 1990 groundwater use of only 13.6 mgd. The 16.225 mgd of proposed use is about 46% of the 1992 revised sustainable yield of 35 mgd for the Koolauloa aquifer. without better knowledge of existing, foreseeable, and potential competing applications for this yield, it is difficult to assess the propriety of allocating almost 50% of aquifer yield to a single applicant • .... Many of the applications are for combined domestic and agricultural use. Quantification of the breakdown between thes~uses is essential at this stage of the permit review process so ti.at existing acreage under cultivation, existing agricultural water use, crop water requirements, and future water allocations can be coherently analyzed.

Attachment C

" ' .. ~.~ ..

, ii \

'''\ .,pO.-

o o

SPECiFiC OBJECTiONS

Well 4057-01

The well site appears to be upgradient from and close to an unnamed spring. Potential restrictions on the proposed water use not identified in the application include possible effects on interim instream flow standards for the spring, existing legal uses of the spring, and inchoate legal uses of the spring as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition.

The proposed use of potable water for pasture irrigation should be questioned until applicant shows evidence of the infeasibility of using alternative non-potable water sources. •

Well 4057-01

While the public notice only lists Well 4057-01 as the well source, the application identifies 4 other wells that serve as sources for the Pump 1 battery. In order to preserve due process of all parties, the public notice for this application should be revised and re-published with a new deadline for written objections to clearly indicate that Wells 4057-02, -08, -13, and -14 are also part of the application.

The well site appears to be upgradient from and close to the Ki'i National wildlife Refuge. Potential restrictions on the proposed water use not identified in the application include possible effects on interim instream flow standards for any springs within the refuge, existing legal uses of all refuge waters, and inchoate legal uses of these waters as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition.

The proposed use of potable water for agricultural irrigation should be questioned until applicant shows evidence of the infeasibility of using alternative non-potable water sources.

Well 4057-04

While the public notice only lists Well 4057-04 as the well source, the application identifies 3 other wells that serve as sources for the Sugar Mill Pump battery. In order to preserve due process of all parties, the public notice for this application should be revised and re-published with a new deadline for written objections to clearly indicate tha~ Wells 4057-09, -11, and -12 are also part ~l the application.

The well site appears to be upgradient from and close to the Ki'i National wildlife Refuge. Potential restrictions on the proposed water use not identified in the application incJ ude possible effects on interim instream flow standards for any springs within the refuge, existing legal uses of all refuge waters, and inchoate legal uses of these waters as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition.

o o

The proposed use of potable water for agricultural irrigation should be questioned until applicant shows evidence of the infeasability of using alternative non-potable water sources.

Well 4057-06

While the public notice lists domestic service as an existing water use, the application shows that only water of non-potable quality is being requested for irrigation and other uses only, not for domestic uses. Which is correct?

Well 4057-07



Well 4057-10

The proposed use of potable water for aquacul ture should be questioned until applicant shows evidence of the infeasability of using alternative non-potable water sources.


Well 4100-02

The proposed use of potable water for aquaculture should be questioned until applicant shows evidence of the infeasability of using alternative non-potable water sources.

The apparent proximity of the well to a perennial Kawela stream t~ibutary may indicate- a potential restriction on use not iaentified in the application, including possible effects on interim instream flow standards, existing legal uses of the stream, and inchoate legal uses of the stream as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition.

Well 4157-04

The well site appears to be upgradient from and close to the Kili National wildlife Refuge. Potential restrictions on the proposed

o .0.

water use not identified in the application include possible effects on interim instream flow standards for any springs within the refuge, existing legal uses of all refuge waters, and inchoate legal uses of these waters as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition.

Well 4157-05 to -07

Potential restrictions on the proposed water use not idehtified in the application include possible effects on existing legal uses of all refuge waters and inchoate legal uses of these waters as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition.

Well 4157-09

While we have no specific objections to the extraction of salt water for aquacultural use, we are concerned about the potentia~ impacts of wastewater effluent discharge upon water sources and water uses in the area. These water quality concerns should be listed in the applications as potential restrictions on use.

Wells 4158-01 through -11

The well sites appear to be upgradient from and close to the Kili National wildlife Refuge, Punamano spring, and Punamano National Wildlife Refuge. Potential restrictions on the proposed water use not identified in the application include possible effects on interim instream flow standards for any springs within the refuges and for Punamano spring, existing legal uses of all refuge and spring waters, and inchoate legal uses of these waters as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition.

Well 4158-14

The well site appears to be upgradient from and close to Punahoolapa springs and Punamano National wildlife Refuge. Potential restrictions on the proposed water use not identified in the application include possible effects on interim instream flow standards for any springs within the refuge and for Punahoolapa springs, existing legal uses of all refuge and spring waters, and inchoate legal uses of these waters as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition.

Well 4159-01

The well site appears to be upgradient from and close to Punahoolapa springs and Punamano National wildlife Refuge. Potential restrictions OR the proposed water use not identified in ~ application include possible effects on interim instream flow standards for any springs within the refuge and for Punahoolapa springs, existing legal uses of all refuge and spring waters, and inchoate legal usea of these· waters as authorized by Native Hawaiian cus~cmand tradition.

o .0 Well 4159-02-

While the public notice lists domestic service as an existing water use, the application shows that only water of non-potable quality is being requested for irrigation and military uses only, not for domestic uses. Which is correct? Note that the application for adjacent Well 4159-01 is for irrigation use of non-potable water.

The well site appears to be upgradient from and close to Punahoolapa springs and Punamano National Wildlife Refuge. Potential restrictions on the proposed water use not identified in the application include possible effects on interim instream flow standards for any springs wi thin the refuge and for Punahoolapa springs, existing legal uses of all refuge and spring waters, and inchoate legal uses of these waters as authorized by Native Hawaiian'custom and tradition.

~.

Well 4258-04

The well site appears to be upgradient from and close to Punahoolapa and Punamano springs and Punamano National Wildlife Refuge. Potential restrictions on the proposed water use not identified in the application include possible effects on interim instream flow standards for any springs within the refuge and for punahoolapa and Punamano springs, existing legal uses of all refuge and spring waters, and inchoate legal uses of these waters as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition.

Mahalo,

David L. Martin, Water Claims Manager

pc: Campbell Estate Kuilima Resort Co.

+

WATER USE PERMIT APPLICATION NOTICE STATUS REPORT 10/05/93 .. WPA .. PUBLIC 1 PUBLIC 2 NO APPLICANT WelL NO WEll NAME

OBJECTION DAYS IAJPA EXIST PROPOSED RECEIVED ACKNOWGD ACCEPTED NOTICE NOTICE DEADLINE SUSPENSE LEfT AGENDA mgd

ISLAND OF OAHU

Aquifer System: KOOLAULOA WALT KAMALOLO KAMAI.OLO Y 07113/93 08/30/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 0.015 HELEN ALVARADO 07/14/93 08/13/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 0.000 ALBERTINA K. ROBERTS 1111-11 UNNAMED SPRINGS Y 07115/93 09/29/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 0.000 WAIAHOLE IRRIG co., LfD. 3154-01 KAHANA DEVELOP TUN Y 06/22193 07/08/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 3.840 KUALOA RANCH, INC. 3351-04 YAMAMOTO Y 07/06/93 09/29/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 0.004 GENTARO OTA 3453-03 OTA Y 06/04/93 06/14/93 06/04/93 07109/93 07/16/93 07/30/93 09/02193 89 09/01/93 0.006 0 HONOlULU BloIS 3453-06 PUNALUU WELLS III Y 07/06/93 08/30/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 1.250 HONOlULU BWS 3453-07 PUNALUU WELLS III Y 07106/93 08/30/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 0.000 GALE L. , KATHLEEN WARD 3453-08 WAIONO-PUNALUU Y 07114/93 08/30/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 0.030 BILLY' KANANI CASEY 3453-08. WAIONO-PUNALUU Y 07/15/93 08/13/93 07/15/93 09/15/93 09122193 10/06/93 10/13/93 9 10/13/93 0.003 HANOtIANO ENTERPRISES, INC 3553-01 HANOHANO Y 09/20/93 09/21/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 2.667 HONOlULU BloIS 3553-'02 PUNALUU WELL I Y 07/06/93 08/30/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 0.350 HONOlULU BloIS 3553-03 PUNALUU WELLS II Y 07106/93 08/30/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 6.000

m HONOlUlU BWS 3553-04 PUNALUU WELLS II Y 07106/93 08/30/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 0.000 HONOlULU BUS 3553-06 PUNALUU WELLS II Y 07/06/93 08/30/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 0.000

X HONOlULU BloIS 3553-07 PUNALUU WELLS II Y 07/06/93 08/30/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 0.000 HONOlULU BWS 3553-08 PUNALUU WELLS II Y 07/06/93 08/30/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 0.000

:::T ZiONS SEC4RITIES CORP. 3554-01 KAPAKA FARM 1 Y 06/23/93 08/30/93 06/23/93 09/15/93 09/22193 10/06/93 09121/93 -14 10/13/93 0.108 ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3554-02 KAPAKA FARM 2 Y 06/23/93 08/30/93 06/23/93 09/15/93 09122193 10/06/93 09/21/93 -14 10/13/93 0.108 -. HONOlULU BWS 3554-03 PUNALUU WELLS II Y 07/06/93 08/30/93 / / / / / /. / / / / 0 / / 0.000

C'" HONOlULU BWS 3554-04 KALUANUI WELLS Y 07/06/93 08/30/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 1.500 HONOLULU BWS 3554-05 KALUANUI WELLS Y 07/06/93 08/30/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 0.000 -. LEMON W. HOLT 3654-02 LW HOLT Y 06/08/93 06/14/93 06/14/93 07109/93 07/16/93 07/30/93 09/12/93 79 09101/93 0.002

r-fa ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3654-03 KAPAKA FARM 3 Y 06/23/93 08/30/93 06/23/93 09/15/93 09/22193 10/06/93 09/21/93 -14 10/13/93 0.000 HONOLULU BloIS 3655-01 HAUULA WELL Y 07/06/93 08/30/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 0.250 HONOlULU BloIS 3655-03 KAIPAPAU Y 07129/92 09/30/92 07/29/92 09121/92 09128/92 10/12192 10127/92 -342 / / 1.000

~ WARREN SOH 3054 -~s.3655 &it SOH WEll Y 07/14/93 08123/93 07/14/93 09/15/93 09122193 10/06/93 10/12193 8 10/13/93 0.500 ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3155-04 LAIE NALDO Y 06/23/93 08/30/93 06/23/93 09/15/93 09122193 10/06/93 09/21/93 -13 10/13/93 0.005 ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3155-06 TRUCK FARM Y 06123/93 08/30/93 06/23/93 09/15/93 09122193 10/06/93 09/21/93 -14 10/13/93 0.167

0 ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3855-04 WELFARE FARM Y 06123/93 08/30/93 06/23/93 09/15/93 09/22193 10/06/93 09121/93 -13 10/13/93 0.128 R.E • .,HITE JR. 3855-05 WHITE WELL Y 05/10/93 06122193 06128/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/26/93 -8 10/13/93 0.087 LAIE WATER co., INC. 3855-06 CAMPUS WelL Y 06/23/93 07/14/93 06123/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09121/93 -13 10/13/93 1.461 LAIE WATER co., INC. 3855-07 CERAMICS WELL Y 06123/93 07114/93 06/23/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09121/93 -13 10/13/93 0.000 LAIE .,ATER CO., INC. 3855-08 'LIBRARY WELL Y 06123/93 07114/93 06/23/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09121193 -13 10/13/93 0.000 POlYNESIAN CULTURAl CEN. 3855-09 PCC LAGOON WELL Y 06123/93 07115/93 06/23/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09121/93 -14 10/13/93 0.691 RAYMOND CALDEIRA 3855-11 CALDEIRA Y 07/09/93 08/30/93 07/09/93 09/15/93 09122193 10/06/93 10/07/93 3 10/13/93 0.058 GEORGE N. NIHIPALI, JR. 3855-12 NIHIPAlI Y 07/12193 08/30/93 09/29/93 10/13/93 10120/93 11/03/93 12/28/93 85 12/08/93 0.230 ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3856-04 QUARRY WELL D Y 06/23/93 08/30/93 06/23/93 09/15/93 09122193 10/06/93 09/21/93 -14 10/13/93 0.334 ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3856-07 PRAW FARM Y 06/23/93 08/30/93 06/23/93 09/15/93 09122/93 10/06/93 09/21/93 '-34 10/13/93 0.475 PUU PAlMA RANCH 3956-01 PUMP 6 Y 09/14/92 09129192 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 0.003 CAMPBELL ESTATE 3956-01 MALAEKAHANA Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 0.100 LAIE WATER CO., INC. 3956-03 TEMPLE WelL Y 06123/93 07114/93 06/23/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/21/93 -13 10/13/93 0.000 ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3956-05 EGG FARM Y 06/23/93 08/30/93 06/23/93 09/15/93 09/22/93 10/06/93 09121/93 -14 10/13/93 0.062 JACOB I. KAIO, SR. 3956-07 KAla ARTESIAN WELL Y 07/15/93 08/30/93 08/17/93 09/15/93 09/22/93 10/06/93 11/15/93 42 11/17/93 0.020

CAMPBELL ESTATE 3957-01 PUMP 3 Y 06/16/93 07108/93 06/16/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 1.000

CAMPBEll ESTATE 3957-02 PUMP 3 Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 08/06/93 08/13/96 08/27/96 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 0.000

CAMPBEll ESTATE 3957-03 PUMP 3A Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 2.000

CAMPBELL ESTATE 3957-04 PUMP 3 y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 -08/30/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 0.000

CAMPBELL ESTATE 3957-05 PUMP 3 Y 06116/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 0.000

Page No.

~ATER USE PERMIT APPLICATION NOTICE STATUS REPORT 10/05/93

I1J WPA • NO APPLICANT ~Ll NO ~ELl NAME

PUBLIC 1 PUBLIC 2 OBJECTION DAYS WPA EXIST PROPOSED RECEIVED ACKNOI.IGO ACCEPTED NOTICE NOTICE DEADLINE SUSPENSE LEFT AGENDA mgd

ISLAND OF OAHU

Aquifer System: KOOLAULOA CAMPBELL ESTATE 3157.06 PUMP 3 Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 08/(,0/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBElL ESTATE H57-07 PUMP 6 Y 06/17/93 07/08/93 06/17/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.100 CAMPBEll ESTATE 41)56-01 KAI.IANANAKOA Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/14/93 -21 .10/13/93 1.000 CAMPBElL ESTATE 4157-01 PUMP 1 Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/19/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/17/93 -17 10/13/93 1.500 CAMPBElL ESTATE 4057-04 SUGAR MILL PUMP Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29193 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 0.500 0 CAMPBEll ESTATE 4057-06 PUMP 8 Y 06/17/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 0.500 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4057-07 PUMP 12 Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 2.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4057-10 PUMP 12-A Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 1.500 1tOII000ULU B~ 4057-15 KAHUKU ~llS Y 07/06/93 08/30/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 1.000 1tOII00UlU BWS 4 )57-16 KAHUKU IoIELLS Y 07/06/93 08/30/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 0.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4100-01 PAlMER G.C. Y 06/17/93 07/08/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -20 10/13/93 0.800 CAMPBElL ESTATE 4100-02 KA~LA Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29193 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 1.000

m ItOIIOLUlU B~S 4;01-07 ~AIALEE I Y 07/06/93 08/30/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 0.500 1tOII0LULU B~S 4101-08 I.IAIALEE II Y 07/06/93 08/30/93 / / / / / / / / / / 0 / / 0.750

X CAMPBElL ESTATE 4157-04 PUMP 15 (ARMy) Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29193 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBElL ESTATE 4157-04 PUMP 15 Y 07/16/93 07/08/93 07/16/93 09/15/93 09/22/93 10/06/93 10/14/93 9 10/13/93 1.530

-::r CAMPBEll ESTATE 4157-05 USF~ 1 Y 06/17/93 07/08/93 06/17/93 09108/93 09/15/93 09/29193 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.082 CAMPBElL ESTATE 4157-06 USF~ 2 Y 06/17/93 07/08/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.106

-- CAMPBELL ESTATE 4157-07 USF~ 3 Y 06/17/93 07/08/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.107

C"" CAMPBElL ESTATE 4157-08 HAI.I MAR ENT OGO Y 06/23/93 08/31/93 06/23/93 09/21193 09/28/93 10/12/93 09/21193 -13 10/13/93 3.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4157-09 AMOR I KKO SALT Y 06/23/93 08/17/93 06/23/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/21193 -13 10/13/93 7.000

-- CAMPBEll ESTATE 4157-10 HAI.I MAR ENT CLAM Y 06/23/93 08/31/93 06/23/93 09/21/93 09/28/93 10/12/93 09/21193 -13 10/13/93 3.000 ,..... CAMPBELL ESTATE 4157-11 PACIFIC SEA 1 Y 06/23/93 08/31/93 06/23/93 09/21/93 09/28/93 10/12/93 09/21193 -13 10/13/93 3.700 CAMPBEll ESTATE 4158-01 PUMP 5 Y 06/17/93 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 1.500 CAMPBElL ESTATE 4158-02 PUMP 5 Y 06/17/93 06/28/91 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 . 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000

~ CAMPBEll ESTATE 4158-03 PUMP 5 Y 06/17/93 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-04 PUMP 5 Y 06/17/93 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBEll ESTATE 4158-05 PUMP 5 Y 06/17/93 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBElL ESTATE 4158-06 PUMPS Y 06/17/93 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000 0 CAMPBEll ESTATE 4158-07 PUMPS Y 06/17/93 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-08 PUMP 5 Y 06/17/93 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-09 PUMP 5 Y 06/17/93 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000

CAMPBEll ESTATE 4158-10 PUMP 5 Y 06/17/93 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000

CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-11 PUMP 5- Y 06/17/93 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000

CAMPBEll ESTATE 4158-12 KAHUKU AIRBASE PUH Y 06/16/93 06/28/93 07/16/93 10/08/93 10/15/93 10/29/93 10/14/93 10 12/08/93 0.500

CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-13 KAHUKU AIRBASE PUM Y 06/16/93 06/28/93 08/18/93 10/08/93 10/15/93 10/29/93 11/16/93 43 12/08/93 0.000

WlliNA RESORT co. 4158-14 WlliNA 1 Y 07/12/93 07/15/93 07/12/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 10/10/93 6 10/13/93 0.800

CAMPBELL ESTATE 4159-01 PUMP 2 Y 06/17/93 07/08/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 1Q/13/93 3.000

CAMPBELL ESTATE 4159-02 PUNAHANO (ARMY) Y 06/17/93 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/-13/93 1.500

CAMPBELL ESTATE 4257-01 PACIFIC SEA 2 Y 06/23/93 08/31/93 06/23/93 09/21/93 09/28/93 10/12/93 09/21/93 -13 10/13/93 5.200

CAMPBELL ESTATE 4257-02 PACIFIC SEA 3 Y 06/23/93 08/31/93 06/23/93 09/21/93 09/28/93 10/12/93 09/21/93 -13 10/13/93 3.700

CAMPBEll ESTATE 4258-04 AHOR RCA FRESH Y 06/17/93 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.300

CAMPBELL ESTATE 4258-05 T. ASTRO SALT Y 06/23/93 09/24/93 06/23/93 10/08/93 10/15/93 10/29/93 09/21/93 -13 12/08/93 5.000

CAMPBELL ESTATE 4258-06 HI AQUACULTURE 1 Y 06/23/93 09/24/93 06/23/93 10/08/93 10/15/93 10/29/93 09/21/93 -13 12/08/93 3.000

CAMPBELL ESTATE 4258-07 HI AQUACULTURE 2 Y 06/23/93 09/24/93 06/23/93 10/08/93 10/15/93 10/29/93 09/21193 -13 12/08/93 3.000

CAMPBElL ESTATE 4258-08 AMOR RCA SALT 1 Y 06/23/93 09/24/93 06/23/93 10/08/93 10/15/93 10/29/93 09/21193 -13 12/08/93 0.300

CAMPBEll ESTATE 4258-09 PACIFIC SEA FARM 4 Y 06/23/93 08/30/93 06/23/93 09/15/93 09/22/93 10/06/~3 09/21193 -13 10/13/93 2.000

CAMPBElL ESTATE 4258-10 PAC SEA FARMS 5 Y 06/23/93 09/24/93 06/23/93 10/08/93 10/15/93 10/29/93 09/21193 -13 12/08/93 5.000

CAMPBElL ESTATE 4258-12 AMOR PACT SALT 1 Y 06/23/93 09/24/93 06/23/93 10/08/93 10/15/93 10/29/93 09/21/93 -13 12/08/93 3.000

Page No. 2

m X ::T --C---r-+ ~

IoAJPA NO APPLICANT

ISLAND OF OAHU

Aquifer System:

CAMPBelL ESTATE CAMPBelL ESTATE CAMPBELL ESTATE CAMPBEll ESTATE CAMPBELL ESTATE

.. 4

~ELL NO ~ElL NAME

KOOLAULOA 4258-13 AMOR PACT SALT 2 4258-14 AMOR RCA SALT 3 4258-15 PACT OFF I CE 3 4258-16 AMOR PACT SALT 4 4258-17 AMOR PACT SALT 5

~ATER USE PERMIT APPLICATION NOTICE STATUS REPORT 10/05/93

PUBLIC 1 PUBLIC 2 OBJECTION DAYS IAJPA EXIST PROPOSED RECEIVED ACKN~GD ACCEPTED NOTICE NOTICE DEADLINE SUSPENSE LEFT AGENDA mgd

Y 06/23/93 09/24/93 06/23/93 10/08/93 10/15/93 10/29/93 09/21/93 -14 12/08/93 3.000 Y 06/23/93 09/24/93 06/23/93 10/08/93 10/15/93 10/29/93 09/21/93 -13 12/08/93 0.300 Y 06/23/93 09/24/93 06/23/93 10/08/93 10/15/93 10/7.9/93 09/21/93 -14 12/08/93 0.720 Y 06/23/93 09/24/93 06/23/93 10/08/93 10/15/93 10/29/93 09/21/93 -13 12/08/93 0.720 Y 06/23/93 09/24/93 06/23/93 10/08/93 10/15/93 10/29/93 09/21/93 -13 12/08/93 1.440 0

103 Applications Totaling 98.109

o

•

Page No. 3

+

TENTATIVE C~RM MEETING SCHEDULE FOR ~PAs 10/05/93 .. ~PA .. NO APPLICANT IoIEll NO IoIEll NAME

PUBLIC 1 PUBLIC 2 OBJECTION DAYS IAJPA EXIST PROPOSED RECEIVED ACKNOI./GD ACCEPTED NOTICE NOTICE DEADLINE SUSPENSE lEFT AGENDA mgd

CWRM Meeting of 10/13/93 I BillY & KANANI CASEY 3453-08 ~AIONO-PUNAlUU Y 07/15/93 08/13/93 07/15/93 09/15/93 09/22/93 10/06/93 10/13/93 9 10/13/93 0.003 CAMPBEll ESTATE 3956-01 MAlAEKAHANA ~ 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 0.100 CAMPBEll ESTATE 3957-01 PUMP 3 Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 1.000 CAMPBEll ESTATE 3957-02 PUMP 3 Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 08/06/93 08/13/96 08/27/96 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBEll ESTATE 1957-03 PlJoIp 3A Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 2.000 CAMPBEll ESTATE 3957-04 PUMP 3 Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 0.000 0 CAMPBEll ESTATE 3957-05 PUMP 3 Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBElL ESTATE 3957-06 PUMP 3 Y 06116/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBElL ESTATE 3957-07 PUMP 6 Y 06117/93 07/08/93 06/17/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09115/93 -19 10/13/93 0.100 CAMPBElL ESTATE 4056-01 KAIoIANANAKOA Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09114/93 -21 10/13/93 1.000 CAMPBElL ESTATE 4057-01 P'-"P 1 Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/19/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09117/93 -17 10/13/93 1.500 CAMPBElL ESTATE 4057-04 SlJ.,GAR MfLL PUMP Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 0.500 CAMPBElL ESTATE 4057-06 PUMP 8 Y 06/17193 07/08/93 06/16/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 0.500 CAMPBElL ESTATE 4057-07 FUtP 12 Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 2.000 CAMPBElL ESTATE 4057-10 PUMP 12-A Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 1.500 CAMPBElL ESTATE >.100-01 PALMER G.C_ Y 06117/93 07/08/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -20 10/13/93 0.800 CAMPBElL ESTATE .. 100-02 KAloIElA Y 06/16/93 07/08/93 06/16/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/14/93 -20 10/13/93 1.000

m CAMPBElL ESTATE 4157-04 PUMP 15 Y 07/16/93 07/08/93 07/16/93 09/15/93 09/22/93 10/06/93 10/14/93 9 10/13/93 1.530 CAMPBElL ESTATE .. 157-04 PUMP 15 (ARMY) Y 06116/93 07108/93 06/16/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09114/93 -20 10113/93 0.000

X CAMPBElL ESTATE 4157-05 USFIoI 1 Y 06117/93 07/08/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.082 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4157-06 USFIoI 2 Y 06117/93 07/08/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.106

::r CAMPBELL ESTATE 4157-07 USFIoI 3 Y 06/17193 07/08/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.107 CAMPBElL ESTATE 4157-08 HAIoI MAR ENT OGO Y 06/23/93 08/31/93 06/23/93 09/21/93 09/28/93 10/12193 09/21/93 -13 10113/93 3.000 -- CAMPBElL ESTATE 4157-09 AMOR IKKO SALT Y 06/23/93 08/17193 06/23/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/21/93 -13 10/13/93 7.000

C- CAMPBElL ESTATE , 157-10 HAIoI MAR ENT CLAM Y 06/23/93 08/31/93 06/23/93 09/21/93 09/28/93 10112193 09/21/93 -13 10/13/93 3.000 CAMPBElL ESTATE 4157-11 PACIFIC SEA 1 Y 06/23/93 08/31/93 06/23/93 09/21/93 09/28/93 10/12193 09/21/93 -13 10/13/93 3.700 -- CAMPBELL ESTATE ~158-01 FUtP5 Y 06/17/93 06/28/93 06117193 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 1.500 ,..... CAMPBELL ESTATE (158-02 P'-"P 5 Y 06/17193 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09115/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-03 FUtP5 Y 06/17193 06/28/93 06/17193 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000

I'V CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-04 FUtP5 Y 06/17/93 06/28/93 06117/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000 0 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-05 PUMPS Y 06117193 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000 CMPBELL ESTATE 4158-06 FUtP5 Y 06117193 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-07 FUtP5 Y 06117/93 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-08 P'-"P 5 Y 06117193 06/28/93 06117193 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000

CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-09 FUtP5 Y 06/17/93 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000

CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-10 FUtP5 Y 06/17/93 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000

CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-11 P'-"P 5 Y 06/17/93 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.000

CAMPBELL ESTATE 4159-01 FUtP2 Y 06/17/93 07108/93 06/17193 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 3.000

CAMPBELL ESTATE 4159-02 PUNAMANO (ARMY) Y 06/17193 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 lD/13/93 1.500

CAMPBELL ESTATE 4257-01 PACIFIC SEA 2 Y 06/23/93 08/31/93 06/23/93 09/21/93 09/28/93 10/12193 09/21/93 -13 10113/93 5.200

CAMPBELL ESTATE 4257-02 PACifiC SEA 3 Y 06/23/93 08/31/93 06/23/93 09/21/93 09/28/93 10/12193 09121/93 -13 10/13/93 3.700

CAMPBELL ESTATE 4258·04 AMOR RCA FRESH Y 06/17193 06/28/93 06/17/93 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 09/15/93 -19 10/13/93 0.300

CAMPBELL ESTATE 4258-09 PACifiC SEA FARM Y 06/23/93 08/30/93 06/23/93 09/15/93 09/22193 10/06/93 09/21/93 -13 10/13/93 2.000

KUILIMA RESORT CO. 4158-14 KUILIMA 1 Y 07112193 07115/93 07/12193 09/08/93 09/15/93 09/29/93 10/10/93 6 10/13/93 0.800

LAIE IoIATER CO., INC. 3855-06 CAMPUS ~ElL Y 06/23/93 07/14/93 06/23/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/21/93 -13 10/13/93 1.461

LAIE \.lATER CO., INC. 3855-07 CERAMICS IoIEll Y 06/23/93 07114/93 06/23/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/21/93 -13 10/13/93 0.000 3855·08 LIBRARY "'Ell Y 06/23/93 07/14/93 06/23/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/21/93 -13 10/13/93 0.000

LAIE \.lATER CO., INC. 3956·03 TEMPLE ~ElL Y 06/23/93 07114/93 06/23/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30pjl3 09/21/93 -13 10/13/93 0.000

LAIE \.lATER CO., INC. POlYNESIAN CULTURAL CE~. 3855·09 PCC LAGOON "'ElL Y 06/23/93 07115/93 06/23/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/21/93 -14 10/13/93 0.691

R.E. \.IHITE JR. 3855·05 "'HITE "'ELL Y 05110/93 06/22193 06/28/93 08/06/93 08/13/93 08/30/93 09/26/93 -8 10/13/93 0.087

Page No.

m X ::T --CT --r-+

N

... ~PA ~

NO APPLICANT WELL NO ~ELL NAME

CWRM Meeting of 10/13/93 I RAYMOND CALDEIRA 3855-11 CALDEIRA WARRfN SOH 3(;,54 -0" J'~i G4 SOH ~ElL ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3554·01 KAPAKA FARM 1 ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3554-02 KAPAKA FARM 2 ZIONS SECURITIES CORP •. 3654-03 KAPAKA FARM 3 ZleNS SECURITIES CORP. 3755-04 LAIE MALOO ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3755-06 TRUCK FARM ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3855-04 ~LFARE FARM ZIONS SECURITIES COR~. 3856-04 QUARRY WEll D ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3856-07 PRAWN FARM ZIONS SECURITIES COIlP. 3956-05 EGG FARM

TENTATIVE C~RM MEETING SCHEDULE FOR ~PAs 10/05/93

PUBLIC 1 PUBLIC 2 OBJECTION DAYS EXIST PROPOSED RECEIVED ACKN~GD ACCEPTED NOTICE NOTICE DEADLINE SUSPENSE LEFT AGENDA

~PA mgd

Y 07/09/93 08/30/93 07109/93 09/15/93 09122193 10/06/93 10/07/93 3 10/13/93 0.058 Y 07/14/93 08/23/93 07/14/93 09/15/93 09/22193 10/06/93 10/12193 8 10/13/93 0.500 Y 06/23/93 08/30/93 06123/93 09/1~/93 09/22193 10/06/93 09121193 -14 10/13/93 0.108 Y 06123/93 08/30/93 06/23/93 09/15/93 09122193 10/06/93 09/21193 -14 10/13/93 0.108 Y 06123/93 08/30/93 06/23/93 09/15/93 09/22193 10/06/93 09121193 -14 10/13/93 0.000 Y 06/23/93 08/30/93 06/23/93 09/15/93 09/22193 10/06/93 09121/93 -13 10/13/93 0.005 Y 06/23/93 08/30/93 06123/93 09/15/93 09/22193 10/06/93 09/21/93 -14 10/13/93 0.167 Y 06/23/93 08/30/93 06/23/93 09/15/93 09122193 10/06/93 09121193 -13 10/13/93 0.128 Y 06/23/93 08/30/93 06/23/93 09/15/93 09122193 10/06/93 09/21193 -14 10/13/93 0.334 Y 06123/93 08/30/93 06/23/93 09/15/93 09122193 10/06/93 09/21193 -14 10/13/93 0.475 Y 06/23/93 08/30/93 06/23/93 09/15/93 09122193 10/06/93 09121193 -14 10/13/93 0.062

There are 61 ~PA scehduled for action on 10/13/93

STATE~IDE THERE ARE 61 APPLICATIONS SCHEDULED FOR ACTION

•

Page No. 2

0

o

+

~ATER USE PERMIT APPLICATION USE STATUS REPORT 10/05/93 I!

WPA .. USE IS NO APPLICANT WelL NO EXIST PROPOSED DESCRIPTION OF USE WPA

TMK ZONING SUSPENSE AGENDA mgd

ISLAND OF OAHU

Aquifer System: KOOLAULOA BILLY & KJI.NANI CASEY 3453-08 Y SUPPLY 1 HOME IRRIGATE 1 ACRE BANANA, PAPAYA 5-3-5:11 AG-Z 10/13/93 10/13/93 0.003 CAMPBelL ESTATE 3956-01 Y DOMESTIC SERVICE TO 31 HOMES & MALAEKAHANA PARK 5-6-6: 1 R-5 09/14/93 10/13/93 0.100 CAMPBelL ESTATE 3957-01 Y DOMESTIC & IRRIGATION FOR 80 ACRES OF VARIOUS CROP 5-6-6: 18 AG-1 09/14/93 10/13/93 1.000 CAMPBelL ESTATE 3957-02 Y ~OMESTIC & IRRIGATION FOR 80 ACRES OF VARIOUS CROP 5-6-6: 18 AG-l 09/14/93 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBelL ESTATE 3957-03 Y AQUACUL TURE FOR 60 ACRES OF PRAWNS 5-6-6: 18 AG-l 09/14/93 10/13/93 2.000 0 CAMPBelL ESTATE 3957-04 Y DOMESTIC' IRRIGATION fOR 80 ACRES Of VARIOUS CROP 5-6-6: 18 AG-l 09/14/93 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBelL ESTATE 3957-05 Y DOMESTIC & IRRIGATION fOR 80 ACRES OF VARIOUS CROP 5'6-6: 18 AG-l 09/14/93 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBelL ESTATE 3957-06 Y DOMESTIC' IRRIGATION fOR 80 ACRES OF VARIOUS CROP 5-6-6: 18 AG-l 09/14/93 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBelL ESTATE 3957-07 Y IRRIGATION fOR 150 ACRES PASTURE AND CATTLE 5-6-6:6 AG-2 09/15/93 10/13/93 0.100 CAMPBelL ESTATE 4056-01 Y DOMESTIC' IRR FOR 135 ACRES Of RANCHLAND & CATTLE 5-6-6:6 AG-2 09/14/93 10/13/93 1.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4057-01 Y. DOMESTIC' IRR Of 218 AC Of VARIOUS CROPS 5-6-6: 19 AG-l 09/17/93 10/13/93 1.500 CAMPBelL ESTATE 4057-04 Y DOMESTIC' IRR OF 40 AC VARIOUS CROPS 5-6-2:0 AG-2 09/14/93 10/13/93 0.500 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4057-06 Y SERVICE TO'KAHUKU HIGH SCH AND TURf FARM (10 AC) 5'6-6: 18 AG-1 09/14/93 10/13/93 0.500 CAMPBelL ESTATE 4057-07 Y DOMESTIC & IRRIGATION FOR 120 ACRES OF VAR CROP 5-6-6: 18 AG-l 09/14/93 10/13/93 2.000 CAMPBelL ESTATE 4057-10 Y AQUACULTURE FOR 48 ACRES PRA~NS 5-6-6:6 AG-2 09/14/93 10/13/93 1.500 CAMPBelL ESTATE 4100-01 Y IRRIGATION fOR 160 ACRES Of A.PALMER GOLf COURSE 5-7-1:22 P-2 09/15/93 10/13/93 0.800 CAMPBelL ESTATE 4100-02 Y DOMESTIC & IRRIGATION FOR 40 ACRES OF VARIOUS CROP 5-7-1:21 AG-l 09/14/93 10/13/93 1.000 ..... CAMPBELL ESTATE 4157-04 Y 6 MILITARY OFFICES, IRRIGATE 23 ACRES AQUACULTURE 5-6-2:0 AG·2 10/14/95 10/13/93 1.530 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4157-04 Y DOMESTIC SERVICE TO 6 MILITARY ADMIN fACILITIES 5'6-8:2 AG-1 09/14/93 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBelL ESTATE 4157-05 Y MAINTENANCE OF HABITAT FOR ENDANGERED WATER BIROS 5-6-2:0 P-2 09/15/93 10/13/93 0.082 CAMPBelL ESTATE 4157-06 Y MAINTENANCE OF HABITAT FOR ENDANGERED WATER BIROS 5-6-2:0 P-2 09/15/93 10/13/93 0.106 CAMPBelL ESTATE 4157-07 Y MAINTENANCE OF HABITAT FOR ENDANGERED WATER BIRDS 5-6-2:0 P-2 09/15/93 10/13/93 0.107 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4157-08 Y IRRIGATION NEEDS fOR XX ACRES OF OGO AQUACULTURE 5-6-2:9 AG-2 09121193 10/13/93 3.000 CAMPBelL ESTATE 4157-09 Y IRRIGATION NEEDS OF 300 ACRES OF SHRIMP AQUACULTUR 5'6-2: 1 AG-2 09121193 10/13/93 7.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4157-10 Y IRRIGATION NEEDS FOR XX ACRES OF OGO AQUACULTURE 5-6-2:9 AG-2 09121/93 10/13/93 3.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4157-11 Y IRRIGATION NEEDS fOR XX ACRES OF SHRIMP AQUACULTUR 5-6-2:9 AG-2 09121193 10/13/93 3.700 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-01 Y IRR OF 688 AC OF VARIOUS C~OPS fOR STATE AG PARK 5-6-5:7 AG-l 09/15/93 10/13/93 1.500 CAMPBELL ESTATE 410;8-02 Y IRR OF 688 AC OF VARIOUS CROPS FOR STATE AG PARK 5-6-5: 7 AG-l 09/15/93 10/13/93 0.000

0 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4';8-03 Y IRR OF 688 AC OF VARIOUS CROPS FOR STATE AG PARK 5-6-5: 7 AG-l 09/15/93 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-04 Y IRR OF 688 AC OF VARIOUS CROPS FOR STATE AG PARK 5-6-5:7 AG-1 09/15/93 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 41'i8-05 Y IRR OF 688 AC OF VARIOUS CROPS FOR STATE AG PARK 5-6-5:7 AG-1 09/15/93 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 41.l8-06 Y IRR OF 688 AC OF VARIOUS CROPS FOR STATE AG PARK 5-6-5:7 AG-l 09/15/93 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-07 Y IRR OF 688 AC OF VARIOUS CROPS FOR STATE AG PARK 5-6-5:7 AG-1. 09/1,5/93 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-08 Y IRR OF 688 AC OF VARIOUS CROPS FOR STATE AG PARK 5-6-5:7 AG-1 09/15/93 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-09 Y IRR OF 688 AC Of VARIOUS CROPS FOR STATE AG PARK 5-6-5: 7 AG-l 09/15/93 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-10 Y IRR Of 688 AC OF VARIOUS CROPS FOR STATE AG PARK 5-6-5:7 AG-1 09/15/93 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4158-11 Y IRR Of 688 AC Of VARIOUS CROPS FOR STATE AG PARK 5-6-5:7 AG-1 09/15/93 10/13/93 0.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4\59-01 Y IRRIGATION fOR VARIOUS CROPS OVER 250 ACRES 5-7-1:21 AG-1 09/15/93 • 10/13/93 3.000 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4159-02 Y TWO MILITARY ADMIN fACILITIES:IRR Of 75 AC PASTURE 5-6-5:0 AG-1 09/15/93 • 10/13/93 1.500 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4251-01 Y IRRIGATION NEED FOR XX ACRES Of SHRIMP AQUACULTURE 5-6-2:9 AG-2 09121193 10/13/93 5.200 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4a7-02 Y IRRIGATION NEEDS FOR XX ACRES Of SHRIMP AQUACULTUR 5'6-2:9 AG-2 09121193 10/13/93 3.700 CAMPBELJ. ESTATE 4258-04 Y IRRIGATION NEEDS fOR XX ACRES Of HATCHERY 5-6-3:32 AG-2 09/15/93 10/13/93 0.300 CAMPBELL ESTATE 4258-09 Y IRRIGATION NEEDS FOR XX ACRES Of SHRIMP AQUACULTUR 5-6-3:0 AG-2 09121193 10/13/93 2.000 KUllIMA RESORT CO. 4158-14 Y IRRIGATION FOR 160 ACRES OF GOLF COURSE 5-6-3:40 P-2 10/10/93 10/13/93 0.800 LAIE WATER COo, INC_ 3855-06 Y MUNICIPAL fOR 607 RES,BYUH,COMHERCIAL,LAIE SCHOOL 5-5-6:0 R-5, SEE MEMO 09121/93 10/13/93 1.461

3855-07 Y MUNICIPAL FOR 607 RES,BYUH,COMHERCIAL,LAIE SCHOOL 5-5-6:0 R-5, SEE MEMO 09/21193 10/13/93 0.000 LAIE WATER CO., INC. 38~5-08 Y MUNICIPAL FOR 607 RES,BYUH,COMHERCIAL,LAIE SCHOOL 5-5-6:0 R-5, SiE MEMO 09121193 10/13/93 0.000 LAIE WATER CO., INC. 3956-03 MUNICIPAL FOR 607 RES,BYUH,COMHERCIAL,LAIE SCHOOL 5-5-6:5 R-5, SEE MEMO 09121193 10/13/93 0.000 LAIE WATER CO., INC. 3855-09 Y SUPPLY LAGOON'S AQUATIC LIFE, PROVIDE CIRCULATION 5-5-6:28 B-2 09121193 10/13/93 0.691 POlYNESIAN CULTURAL CEN.

Page No.

m x =r --CT --,.....

WPA " USE IS NO APPlIC4NT WELL NO EXIST PROPOSED

ISLAND OF OAHU

Aquifer System: KOOLAULOA R.E. ~HITE JR. 3855-05 Y RAYMOND CALDEIRA 3855-11 Y ~ARREN SOH 3<;.,,,, -o$;w.§§ Q4 Y ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. ?S54-01 Y ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3554-02 Y ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3654-03 Y ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3755-04 ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3755-06 Y ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3855-04 Y ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3856-04 Y ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3856-07 Y ZIONS SECURITIES CORP. 3956-05 Y

~ATER USE PERMIT APPLICATION USE STATUS REPORT 10/05/93

DESCRIPTION OF USE TMK

IRRIGATION OF 9 ACRES OF BANANA 0-0-0:0 IRRIGATION FOR 1.2 ACRES OF VARIOUS CROP & LIVESTO 5-5-1:60 FISH, IRRIGATE MANGO, TARO, BANANA 5-3-15:18 IRRIGATE 33 ACRES BANANAS, PAPAYAS, GARDEN CRm 3 5-3-12:1 IRRIGATE 33 ACRES BANANAS, PAPAYAS, GARDEN CRO?S 5-3-12:1 IRRIGATE 33 ACRES BANANAS, PAPAYAS, GARDEN CROPS 5-3-12:1 SUPPLY FOR LIVESTOCK 5-5-6:11 IRRIGATE 51 ACRES OF GRASS 5-5-6: 1 IRRIGATE 39 ACRES BANANAS, PAPAYAS, GRASS 5-5-6: 1 IRRIGATION FOR 51 ACRES BANANAS, PAPAYAS, GRASS 5-5-6: 1 SUPPLY 103 ACRES OF PRAWNS 5-5-5:1 SUPPLY CHICKEN AND EGG FARM NEEDS 5-5-8:51

ZONING

COUNTRY 56 COUNTRY DIST COUNTRY AG-l AG-l AG-l AG-2 AG-2 AG-2 AG-2 AG-l AND AG-2 AG-2

61

SUSPENSE

09/26/93 10/07193 10/12/93 09/21/93 09/21/93 09/21/93 09/21/93 09/21/93 09/21/93 09/21/93 09/21/93 09/21/93

AGENDA

10/13/93 10/13/93 10/13/93 10/13/93 10/13/93 10/13/93 10/13/93 10/13/93 10/13/93 10/13/93 10/13/93 10/13/93

WPA mgd

0.087 0.058 0.500 0_108 0.108 0.000 0.005 0.167 0.128 0.334 0.475 0.062

Applications Totaling 52.712

Page No. 2

0

o

m >< :::r --tT --r-+

~

~ATER USE DECLARATIONS FOR ~ELlS IN THE KAHUKU AREA OWNED BY CAMPBELL ESTATE

WEll , REPORT DONE

\oIEll NAME OTHER NAMES

i.e., PUMP' & WElL~PERATORS(USERS IS WELL IN USE? DATE INSPECTED

3956-01 YES 3957-01-06 YES 3957-07 YES 4056-01 prev 4057-01.2,8,13,

14 353 A-E prey 4057-03* 4057-04,09,11,12* 4057-06 YES 4057-07 4057-10 4100-01 YES 4100-02 YES 4157-01 4157-02 4157-03 4157-04 YES

-04A YES

4157-05,06,07 YES

4157-08 YES 4157-09 YES 4157-10 YES 4157-11 YES 4158-01-11 YES 4158-12,13 YES-4158-14 YES 4159-01 YES 4159-02 YES 4257-01 YES 4257-02 YES 4258-04 YES 4258-05 YES 4258-06 YES 4258-07 YES 4258-08 YES 4258-09 YES 4258-10 YES 4258-12 YES 4258-13 YES 4258-15 YES 4258-16 YES 4258-17 YES

9/22/93 SS

Kalaek.ahama 0001 Sys pump 3,17 Battery Pump 6 KAWANANAKOA WELL

KAHUKU FARM ASSOC

363, Pump 7 Campbell Est. is opr of MALAEKAHANA DOMESTIC WATER SYS (fresh) Campbell extended the casings to ground level, no pumps installed Max Smith and another rancher A.KAWANANAKOA RANCH 142 ACRES, ONLY IRRIGATE 30-50 ACRES, 65 HEAD LIVESTOCK

354 Kahuku Mill Campbell Estate not able to locate caSing KAHUKU HILL WELL 355-A KAHUKU MilL Campbell Estate/truck. farmers, Xayaphat & Huong 20 acres each Pump B Southern Turf Nurseries Pump 12 361-a, Campbell Estate/Various subleases to truck farmers Pump 12-A KAHUKU PRAWN WELL KAHUKU PRAWN CO (Bruce Smith) anticipates using pump 3 later A PALMER GOLF (at KUILIMA RES)--well owned by Campbel1- (clarify -160 fir 2aa acres-} ,.r ~. "Unused wpll on Opana Road, overgrown 346 Sealed in 1948

Sealed in 1964 Hote: Amorient reports caSing buried under roadway. Pump 15 AMORIENT (fresh water well pumped 24 hours/day for 35 prawn ponds, several bldgs) Pumpage estimated by Campbell Estate - Meter broken for years-ARMY operates for Air Force in use for 6 buildings-

Fish & Wild 1,2,3

Haw'" Mar Ent 1 AIoor IKKO salt Haw'n Mar Ent 2 Pac Sea Fanns 3 PUMP , 5 Kahuku Airbase 0001 Kuilima Resort owns P~ 2 PUHAHANO WELL Pac Sea Farms 1 Pac Sea Farms 2 Amor RCA fresh Aurea Ma.-i ne HI Aquaculture 1 HI Aquilcul ture 2 Amor RCA salt 1 Pac Su Fanns 4 Polc Sea Fanns 5 Amor PACT 1 Amor PACT 2 "mar PACT 3 Amor PACT 4 Amor PACT 5

US FISH & WILDLIFE Three artesian wells, used as necessary to maintain water levels in wildlife refuge to promote good feeding and nesting environments for endangered birds., No meters, no pumps, flow controlled by valves HAWAIIAN MARINE ENTERPRISES AHORIENT SALT WATER WELL (aka "IKKO WELL") HAWAIIAN MARINE ENTERPRISES PACIFIC SEA FARMS battery Site overgrown and unused--owner believes the State wants this well KAHUKU AIRBASE WEll DOMESTIC SYSTEM, 15 service connections, 75 people Irrigate new 18 hole golf course mixed w/treated effluent .• C • - /. "'-.

Campbell Estate is operater/truck. farmers are users US ARMY operates for Air Force - current users only 2 Kuleana Houses PAC SEA FARMS PAC SEA FARMS AHORIENT Aurea Marine (Terry Astra) Well in use Recently leased to HI Aquaculture Inc. Facilities not built yet. Recently leased to HI Aquaculture Inc. Facilities not built yet. AHORIENT PAC. SEA FARMS PAC SEA FARMS AMORIENT AHORIENT AMORIENT AMORIENT AMORIENT

YES NO-no pumps YES (fresh) YES (fresh)

YES

5/21/93 5/28/93 5/21/93 10/8/90

10/8/90

YES, well YES

"04" in use 5/21/93

YES updated users YES (fresh)

5/28/93 5/21/93 5/21/93

YES NO NO NO NO YES

YES

YES

4/91 photographed 5/21/93

inspected 4/91 & 5/21/93

8/30/93

YES (salt) 5/28/93 YES (salt) 5/28/93 YES (salt) 5/28/93 NO ( salt) 6/8/93 NO-no pumps 5/28/93 YES (fresh) 5/21/93 YES 5/92 YES updated use 5/93 & 4/17/91 YES 9/1/93 YES (salt) 6/8/93 YES as backup (salt) 6/8/93 NO (fresh) 5/28 & 6/8/93 YES 6/4/93

,NO- 5/28 & 6/4/993 ,NO 5/28 & 6/4/93

YES (salt) 5/28 & 6/8/~3 NO (salt) 5/28 & 6/4/93 NO (salt) 5/28 & 6/4/93 YES (salt) 5/28 & 6/8/93 YES as backup (salt) 5/28 & 6/8/93 NO (salt)' 5/28 & 6/8/93 NO (salt) 5/28 & 6/8/93 NO (salt) 5/28 & 6/8/93

o

o

'.

01

"

_____ .J--

, ,

, (

~'

I,

\ '0\ ' '\

\ , \ 'I

') \ J

"

/ .'

-;.; \ "'r,\ '(" I '1\,1

I

jl

/

o

, I _

l ... ·".AIC\A.I--' . .;:.. W..,I""'" ~ .. e;:

L ....... ",. ,

p c

1" o

,",

c

Well No. 4158-14 'IT

}'U,j'("'fI1H,"':

.'-'I"·n,,, I

~ . \ "'~', '

jI 1

\ I

"

h ,_ .

A.''::'"'' ,,"

----~---,._- ""M,,,W" 11 w::

"------I(OOLAU-OKO 4) .;:

~- ---~~ """'~: -----,,--- ........ lO.

.. ,' I': ,'. '~ ,', ,',' -"

L ... · I~'{:" 41"'. r~~", ... '...t.,' 7-

I (I ... ' ..... \,.'

',,~.,;.

'~' ...

:-:.' -:w " ~ •• 1 ..... .,( .. .,;:

, :::::::-\I:',~ II J 'j I I ~ --• 7 / f I ' r--w't ; I ' ""'-- ' .... 01.0 ~ w"

'C)'!'('i I LLooAIANUI.IICO \ 'I 'f' , \ I OAL" , _GO

I ""\ \' L: GO " \ I~... '/ \ - 1iIO .... L.UA .. .. [/

# I j ........ LU ., "'= , ," 1 .. (__ I

" " y '-;"';;" ... =i"'i'=:"';,..-F"I"'="':'ft .... -~ ..... 'I'i!',..'"";-;;'~ ....... ·rr ;--'r""":~!"""=;-~~~ .... ""';-;---;?:>-uu7.,~"

, \ I' '/

I~_.-t /( ,

II '\:""'1' ,\ .. " I ,(. ~'I' It' ~.".( ". I ( , . . I', 'J ,. .' ,,:'1 ,.,). . I .J \ I ~ ' .............. \ J ,.i' '

:' (.I),l,'\/CO • .1 ','~" "1\ S;, -.l;.-L~i~-··i-'·~"~:7-i·+--,-·,· Exhibit 5A "

'0

•

Kahul

..... ;

11 ( 'I

I,

---_ .. -

~ ....... .. '"; '.

W.")~ . (.

'~<.

I ~YA""" YGO _~ I LKt£AU ... CD J

20 YCD C.A-c1.NA

I.'" \, \. .JO", (,

! ,l

I j, " /~

\ \ ., \

I ,

I o

", r le",oku Rock 1 Blfd n'IU~tJ

a;,

l

HYDROLOGIC UNITS

PROJECT AREA

\ -\

\

~ \

•

160000 FEE'

1I-~-i~~~--~---4ii ~o ,~ . .;; z .. . , , . • l , .

~

'" l o '" l • ,

UNITED STATES

tm~~~r11'mtt'~~tt7tJ7~~~~-_-L Well No. 3654 -0 ~

, .... ", .

...,\--,.;Z.-0~---r-'t---I---I-

ISLAND OF OAHU HYOROt.CC:: UNlrs

-,..----- ICQOL4lA.OA !) .;:

C3: -PROJECT AREA .' ,-

" ~\---'-, - 'A .. .,.A " .. ;:

-----~~~_7-.A~ .... J1 .. ~

" _____ .000 ..... O .) w::

~~-~)1~ ~~

1,-"4 ........ 0 t .. ;:

. .. ',-'\ -' ..

..:.. \tJ\' -..... " , •• , - ," .' ~ •• 'ALAe f .... , ~ .~/ , ; - d:' ..1- L.J'

I l''::::::'' --'I ~ :::.. ... ,~~;~ ~C: I -..&,'" MGO -MO ...... LV ... till!::

- .... 6&,u., we:

··.-P-~·""""· .,-_---

I

Ii

., , , , , " ,

, , 'r'

•

I

\ \J K~U~.\lla

c, ',. ,

.--... .....

,)

FROM: ____ ~ ______________ __

Review & Comment ' Take Action Investigate & Report Draft Reply Acknowledge Receipt

;'_':_' _ ,Type Draft :'_' '_' _' Type Final '

Xexox __ _ . \,",'

.. ' .

~, Approval

" l/Signature , ,Information

03/93

" ,"'

10/05/93 15:33 CAMPBELL ESTATE

THE ESTATE OF JAMES CAMPBELL

September 22, 1993

Mr. Neal Fujii State of Hawaii Department of Land and Natural Resources Commission on Water Resource Management

Dear Mr. Fujii;

Water Use Pc:nnit Applications For Wells Listed Below and status

I. Well 3957-03, Pump 3A

~·ZJ 0011003

o

This well is one of six wells located at the old plantAtion Battery No.3. Well has not been in use for YeaJ'$, bot will be rehabilitated for aquaculture operation to commence in next three to six months.

2. Well 41()()'02, Kawela

Thl.'~ well has not opemted for a number of years. This weD is in tbe W wee Aquifer. We plan to rehabilitate this well sometime in 1994 for agriculture operdtions.

3. Well 41S7-Q4. Pump IS

This well setVices the Air Force and Amorient Aquaculture prawn ponds. Water use is 1,100,000 gallons per day. Amorlent may not have filid reports for last 12 months.

4. Well 4157-05, USFW 1 Well 4157-Q6, U5FW 2 Well 4157-07; USFW 3

'These wells are operated by U. S. Fisb &. Wr.ldlife Service fOt" the wildlife refuge at Kahuku. We undcrstandtbey we~ tiling monthly water use reports.

Mr, Neal Fujii Sep~ber22, 1993 Page 2

•

j, Well 4157--09, IKKO (Lot J)

C.~lIlPBELL ESTll.TE

o

TIlis well is the primary source for salt water for all of Arnonent Aquafanns shrimp ponds m.alcai of Kamehameha llighwEly at Kahuku. Daily production is 5,000,000 gallons per chty. We uodentoGd Amorient was filing monthly water use reports on this well.

6. Well 4157~11. Pacific Sea Fanns

~ 00Z/003

This well is not in use due to the fmanc.w difficulties of Pacific Sea Panns. The well may be rehabilil.:ated if a new aquaculture tenant takes over (his operation.

7. Wells 4158--OJ to 11, Pump 5

Thi& old plantation pump station hlJ.3 been abandoned fur yean). The state is taking over this area as part of a CI,;'ndemnatlon procedure.

8. Well 4159-02) Punamano Pump 2

1'1tis i~ the Air Force ope-rolted well using about 1,250 gallon per d4y. We understood the Air FOl'Ce was m~ monthly water usc repons.

9. Well 4257-01, Pacific Sea Farms VleU 4257-02, Pacific Sea Farms

l'he~ are the main supply weIl~ for what wu the Pacific; Sea Parms shrimp operation. Well 42!)7-Ql supplied about 5,000,000 gallons per day and Well 4257-02 is a back-up well. We uuderstood Pacific Sea. Fanns was makini monthly water use reports. -

10. Well 4258-04, llCA Building

This well supplies salt water to tile Amorient hatchery at the RCA Building at K~ku. Well is used only when hatchery is in operation and supplies about 130,000 gallons pel' day at those times. Again we understaud monthly water use reports were being made.

, ... - '

•

10/05/03 15: H

:Mr. Neal Fujii September 22. 1993 Page 3

o

11. Well 4258..Q9, Pacific Sea Fanns

CAMPBELL ESTATE

o

Thil> well hai not been in use by Pacific Sea Fanns. A new aquaculture tenant may want to rehabilitate this well for future aquaculture operations.

Please give me a call if you have any questions at .

cdi»S:O 1045100\1(10066

Sincerely,

~- ~A'; / . __ . . . :- .; ~ ...... ,.. .• ' {~1-l.-('~·

.. James E. Menor Administntor,

Natural Resources

~ 003/003 !

1639.90 29 9

JOHN WAIHEE GOVERNOR

STATE OF HAWAII

o o

STATE OF HAWAII DEPARTMENT OF HAWAIIAN HOME LANDS

October 4, 1993

The Honorable Keith W. Ahue, Chairperson Commission on water Resource Management Department of Land and Natural Resources

Dear Mr. Ahue: water Use Permits

HOALIKU L. DRAKE CHAIRMAN . _ ;'

HAWAIIAN HOMES COMMISSIO'Y , ' I"~ (

, .,~ .:~\~,. ... ~\~

,",

i~~~ \'.:~'.\ " .....

"

(J'\

. .

OJl)It.'1 } I

:() ,'r\

.. ")

,\\ \ '''j , ......

Thank you for the opportunity to respond to applications for water use at the following Kahuku-Campbell Wells:

4056-01 4056-01,04,06,07,10 4100-01 4157-04,05,06,07,09 4158 01 thru 11 4159-01,02 4258-04

and the Kahuku-Kui1ima Well (4158-14).

We have no objections to these applications.

o o NATIVE HAWAIIAN ADVISORY COUNCIL

A NoNPRoRr Cc:lRPoRAllON

1993 September 29

~ . ..,,' ( ;) ~ state of Hawaii ~/:\

.,'.'

commission on water Resource Management

.,,'"

"":\ t~,;) (.~.,

"0 v'

OBJECTIONS AND COMMENTS ON APPLICATIONS FOR WATER USE PB~TS ." Public Rotice dated Auqust 30, 1993 ,,:::, 0 Send written objections by September 29, 1993,~ c::>

NHAC represents water source registrants, water use declarants, water use permit applicants, and others with property interest inland within the hydrologic unit of the source of water supply, as well as persons with non-property interests, all of who would be directly and immediately affected by the proposed water use.

GENERAL OBJECTIONS

We reiterate our general objections to current COWRM water use permit application processing and decisionmaking practices as previously submitted on numerous occasions (10/12/92, 10/21/92, 12/1/92, 6/22/93, & 7/8/93).

Campbell Estate proposes to continue a total of 23.225 mgd of existing uses, 7.0 of which involve seawater. This leaves 16.225 mgd of use from the basal aquifer, yet the May 1992 review draft of the Oahu water Management Plan (p. 14) reports 1990 groundwater use of only 13.6 mgd. The 16.225 mgd of proposed use is about 46% of the 1992 revised sustainable yield of 35 mgd for the Koolauloa aquifer. Without better knowledge of existing, foreseeable, and potential competing applications for this yield, it is difficult to assess the propriety of allocating almost 50% of aquifer yield to a single applicant. -

Many of the applications are for combined domestic and agricultural use. Quantification of the breakdown between these uses is essential at this stage of the permit review process so that existing acreage under cultivation, existing agricultural water use, crop water requirements, and future water allocations can be coherently analyzed.

'i \~

o o SPECIPIC OBJBCTIONS

W.ll 4057-01


The proposed use of potable water for pasture irrigation should be questioned until applicant shows evidence of the infeasibility of using alternative non-potable water sources.

Well 4057-01

While the public notice only lists Well 4057-01 as the well source, the application identifies 4 other wells that serve as sources for the Pump 1 battery. In order to preserve due process of all parties, the public notice for this application should be revised and re-published with a new deadline for written objections to clearly indicate that Wells 4057-02, -08, -13, and -14 are also part of the application.

The well site appears to be upgradient from and close to the Kili National Wildlife Refuge. Potential restrictions on the proposed water use not identified in the application include possible effects on interim instream flow standards for any springs within the refuge, existing legal uses of all refuge waters, and inchoate legal uses of these waters as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition.

The proposed use of potable water for agricul tural irrigation should be questioned until applicant shows evidence of the infeasibility of using alternative non-potable water sources.

Well 4057-04

While the public notice only lists Well 4057-04 as the well source, the application identifies 3 other wells that serve as sources for the Sugar Mill Pump battery. In order to preserve due process of all parties, the public notice for this application should be revised and re-published with a new deadline for written objections to clearly indicate that Wells 4057-09, -11, and -12 are also part of the application. .

The well site appears to be upgradient from and close to the Kili National Wildlife Refuge. Potential restrictions on the proposed water use not identified in the application include possible effects on interim instream flow standards for any springs within the refuge, existing legal uses of all refuge waters, and inchoate legal uses of these waters as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition.

o o The proposed use of potable water for agricultural irrigation should be questioned until applicant shows evidence of the infeasability of using alternative non-potable water sources.

Well 4057-06

While the public notice lists domestic service as an existing water use, the application shows that only water of non-potable quality is being requested for irrigation and other uses only, not for domestic uses. Which is correct?

Well 4057-07



Well 4057-10

The proposed use of potable water for aquaculture should be questioned until applicant shows evidence of the infeasability of using alternative non-potable water sources.


Well 4100-02

The proposed use of potable water for aquacul ture should be questioned until applicant shows evidence of the infeasability of using alternative non-potable water sources.

The apparent proximity of the well to a perennial Kawela stream tributary may indicate a potential restriction on use not identified in the application, includinq possible effects on interim instream flow standards, existing legal uses of the stream, and inchoate legal uses of the stream as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition.

W.ll 4157-04

The well site appears to be upgradient from and close to the Ki'i National Wildlife Refuge. Potential restrictions on the proposed

o ()

water use not identified in the application include possible effects on interim instream flow standards for any springs within the refuge, existing legal uses of all refuge waters, and inchoate legal uses of these waters as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition.

Well 4157-05 to -07

Potential restrictions on the proposed water use not identified in the application include possible effects on existing legal uses of all refuge waters and inchoate legal uses of these waters as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition.

Well 4157-09

While we have no specific obj ections to the extraction of salt water for aquacultural use, we are concerned about the potential impacts of wastewater effluent discharge upon water sources and water uses in the area. These water quality concerns should be listed in the applications as potential restrictions on use.

Wella 4158-01 throuqh -11

The well sites appear to be upgradient from and close to the Ki' i .. National Wildlife Refuge, PUnamano spring, and PUnamano National Wildlife Refuge. Potential restrictions on the proposed water use not identified in the application include possible effects on interim instream flow standards for any springs within the refuges and for PUnamano spring, existing legal uses of all refuge and spring waters, and inchoate legal uses of these waters as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition.

Well 4158-14

The well site ~ppears to be upgradient from and close to PUnahoolapa spr1ngs and PUnamano National Wildlife Refuge. Potential restrictions on the proposed water use not identified in the application include possible effects on interim instream flow standards for any springs within the refuge and for PUnahoolapa springs, existing legal uses of all refuge and spring waters, and inchoate legal uses of these waters as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition.

Well 4159-01

The well site appears to be upgradient from and close to PUnahoolapa springs and PUnamano National wildlife Refuge. Potential restrictions on the proposed water use not identified in the application include possible effects on interim instream flow standards for any springs within the refuge and for PUnahoolapa springs, existing legal uses of all refuge and spring waters, and inchoate legal uses of these waters as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition.

o o •• 11 4159-02

While the public notice lists domestic service as an existing water use, the application shows that only water of non-potable quality is being requested for irrigation and military uses only, not for domestic uses. Which is correct? Note that the application for adjacent Well 4159-01 is for irrigation use of non-potable water.

The well site appears to be upgradient from and close to Punahoolapa springs and Punamano National wildlife Refuge. Potential restrictions on the proposed water use not identified in the application include possible effects on interim instream flow standards for any springs within the refuge and for Punahoolapa springs, existing legal uses of all refuge and spring waters, and inchoate legal uses of these waters as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition •

•• 11 4258-04

The well site appears to be upgradient from and close to Punahoolapa and Punamano springs and Punamano National wildlife Refuge. Potential restrictions on the proposed water use not identified in the application include possible effects on interim instream flow standards for any springs within the refuge and forPunahoolapa and Punamano springs, existing legal uses of all refuge· and spring waters, and inchoate legal uses of these waters as authorized by Native Hawaiian custom and tradition.

Mahalo,

David L. Martin, water Claims Manager

pc: Campbell Estate Kuilima Resort Co.

; ,

o

1992 October 12

o NATIVE HAWAIIAN ADVISORY coUNCiL

A NoNrnom CorY>orv..l"lOtl

."; \ { ',)'

, . '1' "

.. Hand-OeliY~red\. i ~ , sta.te of Ifa.waii Commission 011 Water Resource Management,.,

' "'

~~. . . COMMENTS ON APPLICATIONS FOR WATER USE c~ 1. IIl\HAIIAN ELECTRIC COMPl\NY HAIAU TUNNEL -2. 1(AIPAPAU WELL 3. ALL SUBSEQUENT WATER USE APPLICATIO~S ~dR PEARL HARBOR WATER

MANl\GEMENT AREl\, HINOhTl\IW Ol\lIU WATER MANAGEMENT AREA, AND MOLOK1\I WATER HANAGEMENT AREA

Native Hawaiian Advisory council, Inc. (NHAC) represents persons wi th property interests in lands wi thin the hydrologic units of the sources of water supply and/or who will be directly and immediately affected by the proposed water use. Furthermore, NHAC advocates the enforcement of consti tutional, statUtory, and common laws whi<;::h require consideration and accommodation of various appurtenant, riparian, correlative, and Hawaiian water righ~s, as well as other Hawaiian rights, in the Water commission's (COWRM) allocation process.

NHAC strongly objects to the Wording of the legal notices you have published with respect to who may file written objections or comments. One does not have to prove they will be 11 immediately affected" by a potentially adverse action in order to meet standing requirements. Therefore, the language of the legal notices is misleading and will have an unwarranted chilling effect on public response and participation in the wat~r Use permitting proceedings.

Neither the Water Code nor its rules specifically address the question of standing for filing writteh obj~c~ibns or co~ments on applications for water use. Under the Administrative ProcedUre Ac~ CHAPA) standing has been interpreted very broadly. ,Furthe~~dt~, COWRM has not yet finalized its procedures for processing water USe permits in newly design<lted water management areas. NHAC is quite concerned that COWRM appears to be establishin~~narrow parameters for standing, as evidenced by these legai hotice~. This arguably consti tutes rulemal<ing which has not been duly undertaken according to procedures required under ilRS 91.

Because water resources have been defined as being owned by the people of the State of Hawai'i in Mc~tyde and RepbUh all people have property interests in the water supply and may be admitted to any and all proceedings involving its disposition, tegulation, and management. NHAC requests that you modify all future legal notices

. "

J ,. ',.: rr·

"0 on water use permit applications ~o reflec~ ~his cohce~n.

NHl\C obj ects to COWIU1' s apparent plan to process water use permits applications on a first-come, first.-serve basis. In order to ful f ill the leg is I a t i ve in tent of wa ter mariaqemen t. a rea designation, a comprehensive view of existihg, planned, ana proposed water Uses and water rights in e~ch hydrdlogic unit is required. COWRM should merely collect applications during the oneyear post-designation application period. Then after the application period is closed, and surveys of water riqhts aha. reserved water uses are completed, COWRM can assess and evaluate each application with regard to competing applicatiohs, reservea water uses, water rights, and the overall water situation in each hydrologic unit. without such a process, COWRM will not be able to meet Water Code requirements for evaluating competin~ uses within the framework of the "roasonable and beheficial" standard ahd ol::.her legally-imposed constraints.

In the case of PI?-arl lIarbor Water l1anagement 1\rea, COWRM has identified a new cushion of wat~r which can be allocated. Staff has received over 80 applications for these approximately 10 mgd of allocations. There is no way that ~he current first-come, first serve processing of applications can equitable resolve this si tua tion. 1\ f ini te applica tion period. for these allocations should be established, after which all applications received can ~e comprehensively processed.

We, therefore, s ta te our overall obj~ction to current COWRH procedures and policies regarding water use permit application processiw;1, in a large part because they do not yet exist. ,We reserve the right to submit specific objections to proposed permits at later dates, since at present there is inSUfficient information about the overall context of stich permits to allow a fair and informed assessment.

NHAC requests that COWRM postpone decision-making on ali water Use permit applications for the above-discussed Water Management Areas until after the application period h~~ closed and theheciessary assessments of water righ~s and reserved water Use,s have been completed.

David L. Martin, Vice-President

1992 October 21

state of IIawaii

d\ NATIVE HAWAIIAN AbViSORY COUNCIL·

A NoNl'OOi=1r ~TlOti

Hand-belivered

Commission on Water Resource Managemen~

COMMENTS ON l\PPLICl\TIONS FOR Wl\TER USE--Wl\ltIl\Wl\. Wl\TER MANAGEMENT l\REl\

1. DPW, USl\SCH Well Nos. 2901-02 ahd/or 04 2. l\11 (Future/Subsequent) }\pplicat.io·hs for wahiawa GWMJ\

Dear Commissioners:

Na ti ve Hawa iian l\dvisory Council, Inc. (NHl\C) represents persons with property interests in lands wit.111h th~hydtologic uhits of the sources of water supply and/or who will b~ directlY ~hd immediately affected by the proposed water use. Furt:hermor.e i NU1\C advocates the enforcement of constitutional;· statutory, and; commoh laws which require consideration and accommodatioh of v~:tloUs a~purtehaht, riparian, correlative, and Hawaiian ~ater ri~htsr ~s we11 as othet Hawaiian righ ts, in the Water commission I S (COWRM) alloca t:ioh process.

NI!fo..C requests clarif ication of COWRM I s tefetencln<j the app1ications listed above as bein~ within the Wahl~~d GtbUhd ~~tet Hah~<je~eht fo..rea, Oahu. This is the first time We H~ve seen sUch a refereHce. Has there been a decision to btedk th~ ~eatl "a~bot W~tet Management area into sectors? This wtiii have broad implications which merit public discussion and which mu~t ~eet bth~±- tui~-~~kiH~ requirement.s.

NHl\C obj eets to COWRM I S apparent plan to ptoces,Ei water Use pertn:lJ,s appl ica t ions on a firs t-come, firs t-ser-vec1 b~sis. ttl order to fu1 f i 11 the leg isla ti ve intellt bf water hlclhaqeri1eht area designation, a comprehensive view of existihg, tJ1~hhed; ahd proposed water uses and water righ~s ih each hydtd1b~ic tlnit i~ required. COWRM should merely collect applications dutln~ finite application periods. Then after each applicatibh period i~ cldsed, and surveys of water rights and reserved water uses a~e,co~pleted, COWRM can assess and evaluate each application w:i.~h tegard to competing applications, reserved water uses, ~atet ri~hts, ahd th~ overall water situation in each hydroi09ic uhit. without ~ueh a

o '. O·

'::;:,'·J

commission on Water Resource Mgmt. RE: Comments on Applications for Wa~er Use

october 21, 1992 Page 2

process, COWRM will not be able to meet water Code requirements for evaluating competing uses within the fra~ework or ~he j'reasonable' and beneficial" standard and other 1e~~l1y-impo~ed cons~taihts.

In the case of Pearl Harbor ~-1atet Management 1\rea, tOWRM has identified a new cushion of water which c~n be ~llocated. S~aff has received over 80 appl lca tions for these approxima~ely io mgc1 of allocations. There is no way that the curreh~ first-come, tirstserved processing of applications can equitably resolve this si tua tion. 1\ f ini te application period for these alloca tioh5 should be established, after which all applications received cah be comprehensively processed.

We, therefore, state our overall objection to current cowRM procedures and policies regarding water Use permi~ application processing, ina large part, ,because they do hot ye~ exist~W~ reserve the right to submit specific objections ~d proposed permits at later dates, since at present thete is irisUfficii~ht information about the overall context of such permits to allow a tail:' and informed assessment.

NlIAC requests that coWRM postpone decision making 011 a11 water use permit applications for the above-discus~ed Wa~er Management AreaS until after the application period has'-close&~ahd thehecessary assessments of water rights al1d'. res~rved wa~er uses have beert

completed.

Mahalo,

~(W{C~ :K. ~1!JA--f,\ David L. Martin, vice-President

DLM/DCP:tr

"'0 "

1992 December 1

':A, "w NATIVE HAWAIIAN AbvISORY·CoUNCIL.

,A ~rr Cof:PoRo.TlON

'

state of Hawaii Commission on Water Resou~ce Management

,

Attn: Rae M. Loui Deputy Director

Re: OBJECTIONS TO WATER USE PERMIT APPLICATIONS ALL GROUND WATER HANAGEMENT AREAS STATEWIDE AND RESPONSE TO PUBLIC NOTICES AND TO COWRM LETTER OF NOVEMBER 17, 1992

Dear 11s. Loui:

In studying Hawaii Administrative Rules (BAR) Title 13, Chapter 171, we find no explicit or implicit: language supporting your, contention that processing water use permits as NHl\C previously suggested is inconsistent with theser.tiles .or would require ru1emaking. We would appreciate some cla~ific~tionon this point as it seems inconsistent with the fact the Pearl Harbor WM1\ is noVl being handled in a manner ~imi1ar to our suggestions.

Two distinct classes of WMAsVlill emerge if you proceed on a, firstcome, first-served basis in some WMAs and with a comprehensive management revieVl of all uses and applications in othe~ WMAs. ,Then the determination of Vlhether competingWuPAs exceed the available supply becomes a second tier of the designation process. NItAC believes such a management regime reqUites rulemaking. Granting I'TUPAs on a first-come, first-served. basis will citcumvent a humber of the conditions for a Water Use Permit: particularly if specific reserva tions for HaVlaiian Homelands beneficiarieE:: are hot previously implemented and allocations ~b county boards of watet supply for municipal purposes are not established.

COy-IRM appears not to be in compliance Vlitli HAR tJ..:..171-i1(b) , which implies that COWRH will determine water supply allocated to the county boards of water supply in each w~b~r ~anag~ment area. These gross allocations to the counties, as well as gross reservations to Hawaiian Home Lands (required under Act 325), mUE::t be defined prior to any new water use permitting to other parties.

While NHAC recognizes there is a rule that COWRM act upon permit. appl ica tions within 90 or 180 days (BAA 13 -171-19 (c) J we do not see this as a constraint to the approach we are suggesting. COWRM

records over the last 5.5 deferral of decision making well as categorization of decision making.

years shows that:. It action 11 inc 1 udes until information needs are met, as applications to facilitate future

While COHRM, staff, and the public have participated in discussions about wate-r use permit application processing, there have been no formal declarations of COWRM permit application processing policy. It appears that COWRM staff and NH1\.C are advocating different:. interpretations of the Administrative Ruies governirt~ the water tise permitting process, and that perha~s pctblic h~arih~~ are needed to help the Commissioners decide what kind of int.erpretation. best serves the purposes of the Water code and the pctblic interest.

Native Hawaiian Advisory Council (NHAC) requestg COWRMdefet decision making on water use permit applications until t.he following issues are resolved:

1. Allocation of water to Hawa iian Home~:.tands. , ,

2. Allocation of water to county mUhicipal purposes.

3. Implementation of water use permit application processing methodologies that avoid the cont.intiatioh of firs~-come, firstserve permi tt ing. iT irst-come, first-s~rve YJ'a.tet Use permit processing contradicts the very heart of t.he iht~ht of ~at:et management area designation. We canhot. have cornpr~hehsive ~at.et resource management without comprehensive ev~1Uation of ~ater Use scenarios.

Sincerely,

/5f

David L. Martin

DLM:cln pc: Water Commissioners

Department of Hawaiian Home Lands County Boards of Water Supply Office of Hawaiian Affairs Ka Lahui Hawai'i Native Hawaiian Legal Corp.

"f ~ ,',. ,,. ,I'! " .• I ';'. ''..

, , i !

: ... ' .. '~M

o

1993 June 22

state of Hawaii

o~ NATIVE HAWAtiAN ADViSORY coUNciL

A~~rdl

commission on water Resource Management 1

OBJECTIONS TO AND COMMENTS ON WATER USE PERMIT APPLrCATIONS RESPONSE TO PUBLIC NOTICES DATED MAY 24 AND JUNE 27; 1993

These objections incorporate our previously submitted generai objections to water use permit application processihg (ietters of October 12 & 21 and December 1, 1992).

We would like to ask if all water use declarants, water source registrants, and water use permit applicants in the affected areas have been served direct notice of the pending applications and the deadline for filing objections? without such hotice, the~e persons cannot be expected to have timely~" knowledge of pending applications, much less file ~imely objectiohs. The Water Commission, through its Nakata Subcommittee, has ackhowledged this reality and recommended implementation of a process for direct notification of affected parties.

NHAC specifically objects to the permit applic~ti6n tiled by Grace Pacific corp. We contend that Use of 170, 000 qpd of potable water for industrial washing and dust cohtrol, is hot a teasohable ~hd beneficial use of water, and expect that the applicant will provide further information about the availability or honaVciilability bf nonpotab1e water and/or further detaii!:: about the hecessit:.y of potable water Use. We fUrther request that this availabie Water resource be placed in reserve for Hawaiian Home Land~ since no water from this aquifer was allocated to DHHL in the Water Commission's June 2 reservation decisibn~

Mahalo,

David L. Martin, Water Claims Manager

' .. c state of Hawaii commission on Water Resource Management 1993 June 22 Page 2

pc w/enc: Mahealani Ranch Ellen M. osborne Thomas N. Matayoshi Honolulu Board of Water Supply The Oceanic Institute Kamehameha Schools Grace-Pacific, Inc. chairperson Hoaliku Drake, DHHL

enc: Letters of october 12 & 21 and December 1, 1992 from

NHl\.C to COWRM

__________ ~_........:...., .• ....&n.. ••• "'/~ •. ·.~/ .•.• ~ ••. ...• '. -- .' . ~:. . .'

. " :V;t ..

1993 July 8

/ .-,.)

NATIVE HAWAIQ ADVISORY COUNCIL A NoNPROf1T CoFPoIv.l1ON

TO: state of Hawaii commission on Water Resource Management

SUBJECT: Comments on Water Use Permit Applications Kawela Plantation Wells (various numbers) Honolulu Board of Water Supply Kuou III Well No.

2348-06 DLNR DOWALD Waiawa 1-6 Wells (various numbers)

and any other water use permit applications with comments due July 8 and 9, 1993.

GENERAL OBJECTIONS

We reiterate our general objections to current COWRM water' use. permit application processing and decisionmaking practices as previously submitted on numerous occasions' t 10/12/92, 10/21/92, 12/1/92, & 6/22/93).

In addition, we are increasingly concerned about the lack of ciear guidelines for timing, sequencing, and. coordinating coWRM permitting processes with environmental review processes conducted under other authorities (including tms 343, .13t.NR Conservation District Use permitting, DOH 401 and NPDES, and County grading and drainage ordinances). This is discussed. more fUliy wlJ:hin the context of specific objections to the KuoU Well III application below.

SPECIFIC OBJECTIONS

1. Kawela Plantation Wells (All)

The permit application information d.istributec1 by coW"kM for comment should also include the results of Cow-rut I ~ field verificcd:ion of declared water uses and should surntnarize t.he monthiy- water Use reports submitted over the last six years for comparison of, existing uses with quantities of ~ater teqtlested.

2. Kawela Plantation Breadfruit Weil Ncl. 0456-04 Kawela Plantation Ag Well No. 0457-04

NHAC obj ects to the proposed use of potabie water for, landscape irrigation. Applicant should provide assessmen~s of alternative water source availability and piahs for minimizing landscape irrigation requirements before permit application processing proceeds. The "reasonable and beneficial" nature of the proposed

..• e., '. I ,\ ! •. ' •. J

I· .!

o water uses is suspect until these assessments and plans are reviewed and until the proposed water uses are evaluated within the context of all other existing, planned, ,proposed, and reserved water uses.

The Ag Well (No. 0457-04) is not listed in the JUly 14, 1992 COWRM Ground Hater Index and Summary, but does appear to be a declared use in COHRM Circular C-123 of September 1992 (listing 5 wells for Kawela Plantation).

When was the declaration of water use filed for Well No. 0457-04? If the declared use began after the implementation of the State Water Code, when were well construction and pump installation permits issued?

3. Honolulu Board of Water Supply Kueu Well j NO'. 2348-06

NHAC obj ects to further processing of this' permit application until the Environmental Assessment (EA) precess for the proposed project is completed. Today is the deadline for submitting comments on the Draft EA (DEA) for the exploratory weli, after which the Final EA must be published with a subsequent waiting period of thirty days during which the Final EA may be centested.

BWS states in that DEl\. that "Production well development will 'be subj ect to the environmental review process as stipulated 'in Chaptere 343, Hawaii Revised Statutes, amd Chapter 200 of the STate Department ef Health Regulatiens." In respense to this, we wrote:

Does BWS intend to prepare anothe~tA for its Production Well at Kuou Well site III? Will this EA address a broaa range of environmental impacts stemming from both the general allocation of water to BWS from the Koolaupoko Ground Water Management Area and the specifics of extracting that allecation frem the aquifer at the proposed site? since ~WS already applied to' the cemmission ert Water Reseurce Management (COWRM) for a Water Use Pe~iE;, ~e ebJected ,to' that application on the greunds that the envirehmehtal review precess for the allocation has not been cempieted. We ebJec~ to' this DEA because it fails to' ~ddres~ 'th~ alioc~~i6h ~hd extractien impacts in the cemprehensive manher reqUl.:ted to' inferm COWRM water use permit decisiohmaklng. Also ne~e tha~ COWRM has recently taken a pesitieH th~t permit applicatieHs are net cemplete and cannet be taken up fer decisl.ehmakihg until envirenmental review precesses are cempleted.

There is huge cenfusien and preblems with the current Eimihg, sequence, and ceerdinatien ef envirenmehtal revie~ precesses fer beth expleratery and preductien wells (ihcluding HRs j43 precesses, censervatien disttict Use permitting, and DOH processes) and COWRM permitting processes (~ater use, ~ell censtruction, and pump installatieh) ~ The DEA,sheuld expiaih the BWS view and these ef ether agencies cencerning the timing, sequence, and ceordinatl.en of these precesses. This

o would provide a starting point for wcirking ~i~h all parlies ~o integrate the processes for the greatest mutUal benefit.

Similarly, we now ask COHRM to explain . its view and how it perceives that of other agencies with regard to these same issues.

NIIAC also objects to further processing of this applica~ion until water reservations to Hawaiian Home Lands from the designa~ed windward aquifers are completed. We recommend ~ha~ this application be consolidated with other BWS applications so ~hat the bulk allocation requested by BWS from Koolaupoko and BWS p1ans for distributing that allocation are more clearly understood.

4. DLNR DOHALD Haiawa Wells 1-6 (All)

NHAC requests additional information and extended review for these proposed uses. He have not yet received the petrnil applications and other supporting documentation needed tci sort out the fol1o~ing issues:

a. COWRM minutes of June 2, 1993 meeting are confusing, and the presently remaining availabl~ allocation in the ~aipahti-Waiawa system is unclear. Allocation of 2.0127 mgd to BWS on behalf of HFDC was approved (page 9). Was the 5.093 mgd alloca~ion to .BWS recommended in the staff submittal (page 4 humber 4.) alsQ approved? If so, does the 5.093 mgd allocation ihclude the 2.0127 for HFDC?

b. He need more information and mol"e time to research the land ownership and water rights issues raised by the Federal transfer to the State of the Wa'iawa lands where the proposed sources are located.

c. We need assurances that DLNR plans to operate these systems as state water systems and does ho~ plan to dedicate them to BWS.

d. We need to know how DOWALD has responded to COWRM concerns about the specifications for the proposed wells and their potential impact upon aquifer dynamics and existing groundwater Uses.

e. we need to know how COWRM plans to integrate environmental review processes under other authorities ~ith its own perrnit~ing processes (see above discussion of Kuou Well III applica~ion).

Based on the inforrnation·now available, "NHAC raises the following specific objections to the applications; ahd reserves the right to file additional specific objections as information becomes available:

a. Many of the State projects listed (Exhibit 6 of COWRM submittal of 6/2/92) propose using po~able water for landscape irrigation of public facilities. Appiicant should provide assessments of alternative wa~er source availability and plans for

o minimizing landscape irrigation requirements before permit application processing proceeds. The "reasonable ahd beneficial" nature of the proposed water Uses is ,suspect until these assessments and plans are reviewed and until the proposed water uses are evaluated within the context of all other existing, planned, proposed, and reserved water Uses.

b. There may be insufficient available allocation to meet DOWALD's quantity of use requested.

c. DOWALD's requested uses compete with other reqUested uses; thus it seems that public hearings are reqUired.

d. Most of the state projects listed in the previous COWRM submittal are not listed in the current version of the state Water Projects Plan.

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION/EXTENDED REVIEW REQUESTED

NHAC has not yet received copies of the permit applications filed for DLNR DOWALD Waiawa 1-6 Wells. We reqUest that this information be sent and the review period extended so that we cah more closely analyze these extremely significant applications.

In our review of the Star-Bulletin for June 18; 1993, we did not find public notice of the Honolulu Board of Water Supply watet use permit application for Kuou III in the" legal notice section or elsewhere. Thus weare unable to asbe~tain whether or not any other water use permit applicati~ns were publicly noticed at that time. If so, we request that you transmit copies of these applications and extend the associated review period.

Ma~ifo _ A

/YM1AX?~ David L. Martin, Water Claims Manager

pc: Kawela Plantation Homeowner's Association Molokai Working Group for COWRM Honolulu Board of Water Supply DLNR DOWALD Water commissioners Water Code Review commission and Commissioners Ka Lahui Hawai'i Hawaiian Homes Commission Office of Hawaiian Affairs Native Hawaiian Legal Corp.

~~1'\' ~ 0 ~ BOARO OF WATER SUPPLY

~ "(57

FRANK F. FASI, Mayor ~J\'\ CITY AND COUNTY OF HONOLULU

WALTER O. WATSON, JR .. Chairman \ MAURICE H. YAMASATO, Vice Chairman ' SISTER M. DAVILYN AH CHICK, O.S.F.

JOHN W. ANDERSON, JR. REX D. JOHNSON

MELISSA YJ LUM C. MICHAEL STREET

September 22, 1993 KAZU HAYASHIDA Manager and Chief Engineer

Mr. Keith Ahue, Chairperson Commission on Water Resource Management Department of Land and Natural Resources State of Hawaii

~, ,.~,

_.''t' ,1'

. l'

Dear Mr. Ahue: \', * • ,;,:\',\ . ,J(

, .. ' '," ~ Subject: Your Letters of September 9, 1993 on Water Use Permits for Campbell~~t~te in tffe

Koolauloa Groundwater Management Area, Windward Oahu: Well No. --4056-01; Well No. 4057-01; Well No. 4057-04; Well No. 4057-06; Well No. 4057-07; Well No. 4057-10; Well No. 4100-01; Well No. 4100-02; Well No. 4157-04; Well No. 4157-05; Well No. 4157-06; Well No. 4157-07; Well No. 4157-09; Well No. 4158-01 through 11; Well No. 4158-14; Well No. 4159-01; and Well No. 4159-02

Thank you for the opportunity to comment on these water use permits for Campbell Estate in the Kahuku area. We have no objections to issuance of permits for these existing uses. We feel, however, that the requested amounts of water for some wells are overstated and should be adjusted based on the actual amounts used and in accordance with the sustainable yield, especially when other well owners such as the Board of Water Supply are considered. The requested sum of 14.7+ mgd already exceeds the sustainable yield from the basal aquifer.

In the interests of preserving the best quality water for domestic consumption, however, the operators of the golf course using Well No. 4100-01 should use an alternative source of lesser quality water for irrigation. This action would be in accordance with the Board of Water Supply Rules and Regulations requiring golf courses to use nonpotable sources for irrigation where possible.

We return for your i!1formation the completed forms.

Very truly yours,

KAZU HAYASHIDA Manager and Chief Engineer

Attachment

[Jure Water . .. man's greatest need - llse it wisely

;'\' .. ~",

·n '1.-,). I." •

')

r f D C /,':~~-~-: '- .

JOHN WAIHEE

GOVERNOR OF HAWAII Sf? 10

o o



REF:WRM-KO

SEP - 9 1993

MEMORANDUM

TO:

FROM:

SUBJECT:

Mrs. Hoaliku L. Drake, Director Department of Hawaiian Home Lands

Dr. John C. Lewin, M.D., Director Department of Health

Mr. Clayton H. W. Hee, Chairperson Office of Hawaiian Mairs

y' Mr. Kazu Hayashida, Manager & Chief Engineer Honolulu Board of Water SU~IY

Keith W. Ahue, Chairperson Commission on Water Reso e agement

Water Use Permit Application Koolauloa Ground Water Management Area. Oahu

932603

KEITH W. AHUE CHAIRPERSON

JOHN C. LEWIN. M.D. ROBERT S. NAKATA

RICHARD H. COX. P.E, GUY K. FUJIMURA

J. DOUGLAS ING. ESQ.

RAE M, LOUI. P,E.

DEPUTY


We would appreciate your review of the attached application and please return this form by September 29. 1993.


Attachment(s)

Memorandum to: Mrs. Hoaliku L. Drake Dr. John C. Lewin Mr. Clayton H.W. Hee Mr. Kazu Hayashida

Page 2

o

Response: Contact person: Herbert H. Minakami

( ) We have no comments ( ) We have no objections (X) Comments attached ( ) Additional information requested ( ) Extended review period re uested

Manager Engineer

o

SEP - 9 1993

Phone:

o o State of Hawaii

DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MLANAGEMENT

Honolulu, Hawaii

SEP - 2 1993 MEMORANDUM

TO:

SUBJECT:

Aquatic Resources Forestry and Wildlife Historic Preservation Land Management ~Natural·Area"'ReselVe~Syst~ni."l Office of ConserVation and Environmental Mairs State Parks Water and Land Development Other Interested Parties



-Co:)

' .. '. Transmitted for your review and comment is a copy of a water use permit

application for Ca!npbell Estate for Well Nos. 4158-01 through -11. Public notice of this application will be published in the Honolulu Star Bulletin issues of September 8, 1993 and September 15, 1993.



LN:ko Attachment(s)

::::n f11 (J

rn -< m o

Response: Contact person: Siate, Ta:~A Phone::;o

( ) We have no comments ~ VWe have no objections CVJ Comments attached

J4, 5~d wei! >/!e 15aa11oC4-~ M/1/n A:: I~~ ,a~d;

( ) Additional information requested

( .) Ext~ ~eriOd requested

Slgned:~~~ _____ ~~ __________________________ __ Date: '1[so (u

o OFFICE OF THE MAYOR

CITY AND COUNTY OF HONOLULU

FRANK F_ FASI

MAyOR

September 23, 1993

Mr. Keith Ahue, Chairperson Commission on Water Resource Management Department of Land and Natural Resources State of Hawaii

"'~II' ...•..• '

c.,;:;) (..,.".)

ell ("1

"'"J t.

I""ol .J'," ..

··~~ :P

::0 in ",,-)

'i1 ':; .,"., .....

Dear Mr ~~ ',I' '\ ~~ ~ • ':'~. ~,. c.,.)

Subject: our Letter of September 9, 1993 on Water Use Permits for ca~~~;ll Estate in the Koolauloa Groundwater Management Area, Windward Oahu: Well No. 4056-01; Well Nc. 4057-01; Well No. 4057-04; Well No. 4057-06; Well No. 4057-07; Well No. 4057-10; Well No. 4100-01; Well No. 4100-02; Well No. 4157-04; Well No. 4157-05; Well No. 4157-06; Well No. ~157-07; Well No. 4157-09; Well No. 4158-01 through 11; Well No. 4158~Well No. 4159-01; Well No. 4159-02; Well No. 4258-04 V"?,

Thank you for the opportunity to comment on these water use permits. We have no objections to issuance of permits for these existing uses. However, the amounts of water requested, for some wells, are overstated and should be adjusted based on the actual amounts used and the applicable sustainable yields.

In the interest of preserving the best quality water for potable use, the operators of the golf course using Well No. 4100-01 should investigate the use of nonpotable water for irrigation. This action would be in accordance with the Board of Water Supply Rules and Regulations requiring golf courses to use nonpotable sources for irrigation where possible.

Warm personal regards.

~ - . FFF:js cc: Jeremy Harri:>, Managing Director

JOHNWAIHEE GOVERNOR OF HAWAII

o a

STATE OF HAWAII

DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES

STATE HISTORIC PRESERVAnON DIVISION

September 17, 1993

Oml .unJB. CllADPBII80N BOARD OF LAND AHO NATURAL REBOURCE

DEPUTIES

JOHN P. KEPPELER H DONA L HANAIKE

AQUACULTURE DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

AQUATIC RESOURCES CONSERVATION AHO

ENVIfIONMENTAJ.. AFFAIRS CONSERVATION AHO

RESOURCES ENFORCEMENT CONVEYANCES

FORESTRY AND WILDLIFE HISTORIC PRESERVATION

DIVISION LAND MANAGEMENT STATE PAAKS WATER AND LAND DEVELOPMENT

MEMORANDUM

TO:

FROM:

SUBJECT:

LOG NO: 9224 DOC NO: .. ~,309EJ24

Rae M. Loui, Deputy Director :(::I:':! s;~: ~! , " ' rr1 "0 Commission on Wate'r Resource Management " : :::;.~ -0 ':~:r'f

Don Hibbard, Administrator ~ ,,:1 :':":1 ~ ':';~ Historic Preservation Division "" > :,,2

I :i:;\ a ,"tl! Application for Water Use Permit, 0' olaulo~'I;:~~pund .wate~,:f Management Area, 0' ahu ::,~: ~::,r CJ Campbell Estate for Well No. 4158 through-''!.!l ct Kahuku, KO'olauloa, O'ahu TMK 5-6-05:007

Thank you for the opportunity to review this project. The applicant proposes to use water from existing sources. Since an approved permit will not authorize any ground disturbing activities we believe that there will be "no effect" on historic sites.

EJ: jt

o o State of Hawaii


Honolulu, Hawaii


TO: Aquatic Resources Forestry and Wildlife Historic Preservation Land Management

FROM:

SUBJECT:

"'Narural-Area-Reserve·Systeml Office of Conservation and Environmental Mfairs State Parks Water and Land Development Other Interested Parties


Request for Comments \ () Water Use Permit Application Koolauloa Ground Water Management Area. Oahu


We would appreciate your review of the attached application and please return this form by September 29, 1993.

If you have any questions regarding this application, please contact Roy Hardy at .

LN:ko Attachment(s)


( ) We have no comments ( ) We have no objections ( ) Comments attached ( ) Additional information requested ( ) Extended review period requested

Signed: __________________________________ __

Phone: __________ __

Date:

JOHN WAIHEE

GOVERNOR OF HAWAII

REF:WRM-KO

o o

STATE OF HAWAII OEP,Q.RTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES


SEP - 9 1993

MEMORANDUM

TO:

FROM:

SUBJECT:

Mrs. Hoaliku L. Drake, Director D~_'partment of Hawaiian Home Lands

Dr. John C. Lewin, M.D., Director Department of Health

Mr. Clayton H. W. Hee, Chairperson Office of Hawaiian Affairs

Mr. Kazu Hayashida, Manager & Chief Engineer Honolulu Board of Water S~UlY

Keith W. Ahue, Chairperson Commission on Water Reso e agement

Water Use Permit Application Koolauloa Ground Water Management Area. Oahu

KEITH W. AHUE CHAIRPERSON


RICHARD H. COX. P.E. GUY K. FUJIMURA


RAE M. LOUI. P.E.

DEPUTY




Attachment(s)

· . o Memorandum to:

Mrs. Hoaliku L. Drake Dr. Jolm C. Lewin Mr. Clayton H.W. Hee Mr. Kazu Hayashida

Page 2


( ) We have no comments ( ) We have no objections ( ) Comments attached ( ) Additional infonnation requested ( ) Extended review period requested

Signed: __________________________________ __

SEP - 9 1993

Phone: ------------

Date:

. . , . o o JOHN WAIHEE

GOVEA NO A OF HAWAII KEITH W. AHUE

CHAIRPERSON



REF:WRM-KO

Honorable Frank F. Fasi, Mayor City & County of Honolulu City Hall

Attn: Mr. Jeremy Harris

Dear Mayor Fasi:

SEP .. 9 199~

Notice of an Application for a Water Use Permit Koolauloa Ground Water Management Area. Oahu



J.DOUGLASING,ESa.

RAE M. LOUI. P.E.

DEPUTY

In accordance with the Department of Land and Natural Resources Administrative Rules, Section 13-171-17(a), we are sending you a copy of the public notice for the water use permit application for the Campbell Estate for Well Nos. 4158-01 through -11, which will be published in the Honolulu Star Bulletin.

In addition, Section 13-171-13(b) of our Administrative Rules states:

"Within sixty days after receipt of notice of a permit application, the county shall inform the commission if the proposed use is inconsistent with the county land use plans and policies."

We have attached a copy of the application for your review and would appreciate receiving your comments, within the next sixty (60) days, on whether this water use is consistent with county plans and policies.

Very truly yours,

Attach.

o PUBUC NOTICE

Applications for Water Use Pennits Ground Water Management Areas

o

Applications for the following water use pennits have been received and are hereby made public in accordance with Department of Land and Natural Resources Administrative Rules 13-171, "Designation and Regulation of Water Management Areas."

Well 4056-01 (Well No. 4056-01) Applicant: Campbell Estate

Date Completed Application Received: June 16, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu Well Source: Well 4056-01, Kahuku, Oahu at Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:6 Quantity Requested: 1,000,000 gallons per day Existing Water Use: Domestic service and irrigation of 135 acres of ranch lands for cattle Place of Water Use: Kahuku at Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:6

Pump 1 (Well No. 4057-01) Applicant: Campbell Estate

Date Completed Application Received: June 19, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu Well Source: Pump 1, Well No. 4057-01, Kahuku, Oahu at Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:19 Quantity Requested: 1,500,000 gallons per day Existing Water Use: Domestic service and irrigation of 218 acres of various crops place of Water Use: Kahuku at Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:19

Sugar Mill Pump (Well No. 4057-04) Applicant: Campbell Estate

Date Completed Application Received: JW1e 16, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu Well Source: Sugar Mill Pump, Well No. 4057-04, Kahuku Sugar Mill, Oahu at

Tax Map Key: 5-6-2:17 Quantity Requested: 500,000 gallons per day Existing Water Use: Domestic service and irrigation of 40 acres various crops Place of Water Use: Kahuku at Tax Map Key: 5-6-2:0

(more)

..., I~


Date Completed Application Received: June 16, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu

o

Well Source: Pump 8, Well No. 4057-06, Kahuku, Oahu at Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:18 Quantity Requested: 500,000 gallons per day Existing Water Use: Domestic service to Kahuku High School and 10-acre turf farm Place of Water Use: Kahuku at Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:18


Date Completed Application Received: June 16, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu Well Source: Pump 12, Well No. 4057-07, Kahuku, Oahu at Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:18 Quantity Requeste<l: 2,000,000 gallons per day Existing Water Use: Domestic service and irrigation of 120 acres various crops place of Water Use: Kahuku at Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:18

Pump 12-A (Well No. 4057-10) Applicant: Campbell Estate

Date Completed Application Received: June 16, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu Well Source: Pump 12-A, Well No. 4057-10, Kahuku, Oahu at Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:18 Quantity Requested: 1,500,000 gallons per day Existing Water Use: Aquaculture for 48 acres of prawns place of Water Use: Kahuku at Tax Map Key: 5-6-6:6

well No. 338 rnell No. 4100-01) Applicant: Campbell Estate

Date Completed Application Received: June 17, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu Well Source: Well No. 338, Well No. 4100-01, Kahuku, Oahu at Tax Map Key: 5-7-1:21 Quantity Requested: 800,000 gallons per day Existing Water Use: Serves 160-acre golf course place of Water Use: Kahuku at Tax Map Key: 5-7-1:22

(more)

o Kawela Well (We!! No. 4100-02) Applicant: CamVbell Estate

Date Completed Application Received: JWle 16, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauba System, Windward Sector, Oahu

o

Well Source: Kawela Well, Well No. 4100-02, Kawela, Oahu at Tax Map Key: 5-7-1:21 Quantity Requested: 1,000,000 gallons per day Existing Water Use: Domestic service and irrigation of 40 acres of various crops Place of Water Use: Kawela at Tax Map Key: 5-7-1:21


Date Completed Application Received: June 16, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu Well Source: Pump 15, Well No. 4157-04, Kahuku Aquafarm - Kamehameha Hwy, Oahu at Tax Map Key: 5-6-2:1 Quantity Requested: 30,000 gallons per day Existing Water Use: Domestic service to 6 military administrative facilities place of Water Use: Kahuku Army training area at Tax Map Key: 5-6-8:2

Well No. 4157-05 Applicant: Campbell Estate

Date Completed Application Received: June 17, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu Well Source: Well No. 4157-05, Kahuku, Oahu at Tax Map Key: 5-6-2:1 Quantity Requested: 82,410 gallons per day Existing Water Use: Maintenance of habitat for endangered water birds Place of Water Use: James C. Campbell NWR - Kii unit at Tax Map Key: 5-6-2:0


7

Date Completed Application Received: June 17, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu Well Source: well No. 4157-06, Kahuku, Oahu at Tax Map Key: 5-6-2:1 Quantity Requested:' 105,572 gallons per day Existing Water Use: Maintenance of habitat for endangered water birds Place of Water Use: James C. Campbell NWR - Kii unit at Tax Map Key: 5-6-2:0

(more)

o well No. 4157-07 Applicant: Campbell Estate


o

Well Source: Well No. 4157-07, Kahuku, Oahu at Tax Map Key: 5-6-2:1 Quantity Requested: 106,791 gallons per day Existing Water Use: Maintenance of habitat for endangered water birds Place of Water Use: James C. Campbell NWR - Kii Unit at Tax Map Key: 5-6-2:0


Date Completed Application Received: June 23,1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu Well Source: Well No. 4157-09, Kahuku, Oahu at Tax Map Key: 5-6-2:7 Quantity Requested: 7,000,000 gallons per day Existing Water Use: Aquaculture for 300 acres of sluimp Place of Water Use: Kahuku at Tax Map Key: 5-6-2:1

Pump 5 (Well Nos. 4158-01 through -11) Applicant: Campbell Estate

7

Date Completed Application Received: June 17, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu Well Source: Pump 5, Well Nos. 4158-01 through -11, Kahuku, Oahu at Tax Map Key: 5-6-5:7 Quantity Requested: 1,500,000 gallons per day Existing Water Use: Inigation of 688 acres of various crops in State Agricultural Park Place of Water Use: Kahuku at Tax Map Key: 5-6-5:7

well No. 4158-14 Applicant: Kuilirna Resort Co.

Date Completed Application Received: July 12, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu Well Source: well No. 4158-14, Kahuku, Oahu at Tax Map Key: 5-6-3:44 Quantity Requested: 800,000 gallons per day Existing Water Use: Service to 160-acre golf course Place of Water Use: Kahuku at Tax Map Key: 5-6-3:40

(more)

o Pump 2 (Well No. 4159-01) Applicant: Campbell Estate


o

Well Source: Pump 2, Well No. 4159-01, Kahuku, Oahu at Tax Map Key: 5-6-3:43 Quantity Requested: 3,000,000 gallons per day Existing Water Use: Irrigation for over 250 acres of various crops Place of Water Us,,=: Kahuku at Tax Map Key: 5-7-1:21

Punamano Pump 2 (Well No. 4159-02) Applicant: Campbell Estate

Date Completed Application Received: June 17, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu Well Source: Punamano Pump 2, Well No. 4159-02, Kahuku, Oahu at Tax Map Key: 5-6-3:43 Quantity Requested: 1,500,000 gallons per day Existing Water Use: Domestic service to two military administrative facilities and irrigation of 75-acre pasture place of Water Use: Punamano Air Force Station and pasture at Tax Map Key: 5-6-5:0

well No. 4258-04 Applicant: Campbell Estate

Date Completed Application Received: June 17, 1993 Aquifer: Koolauloa System, Windward Sector, Oahu Well Source: Well No. 4258...()4, Kahuku-RCA Building, Oahu at Tax Map Key: 5-6-3:32 Quantity Requested: 300,000 gallons per day Existing Water Use: Fish hatchery place of Water Use: Kahuku-RCA Building at Tax Map Key: 5-6-3:32

(more)

. . o • Written objections or corrunents on the applications for water use permits may be

filed by any person who has property interest in any land within the hydrologic unit of the source of water supply, any person who will be directly and immediately affected by the . proposed water use, or any other interested person. Written objections shall: (1) state property or other interest in the matter; (2) set forth questions of procedure, fact, law, or policy, to which objections are taken; and (3) state all grounds for objections to the proposed permits. Send written objections by September 29, 1993 to 1) the Commission on Water Resource Management, , and 2) a copy of the objection letter(s) to the applicant at the above address.


Chairperson

Dated: AUG 30 1993

Publish in: Honolulu Star Bulletin issues of September 8, 1993 and September 15, 1993

o State o~ Ra~iv·~ 0

DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES

COMMISSION ON ~~~11f~~cro ~IffAGEMENT R E C F f V E [1

I "

MEMORANDUM Stt,.~ fd!9~;,.~, ;\jt,:; '93 S£P -9 P2 :28

TO:

FROM:

SUBJECT:

Aquatic Resources Forestry and Wildlife Historic Preservation Land Management 'Natural-Area"Re~~rv~::SysteIIl"l

... t;-.-:"'

i\ ~

Office of Conservation and Environmental Affairs State Parks Water and Land Development Other Interested Parties



FOf~LSTi\ Y i ',,', ": " ~;( I j ,t I) L I) ,

STATE OF h)\)~;\}; ,




LN:ko Attachment(s)


( ) We have no comments ( ) We have no objections ( ) Comments attached ( ) Additional information requested ( ) Extended review period requested

Signed: &&: J ~£-

Phone: _____ _

DOFAW HAS NO COMMENlS OR OBJECTIONS TO 1Hi PROPOSED REQUESt '

Date:

o o State of Hawaii


Honolulu, Hawaii


FltOM!'1 0 f

SUBJECT:

Aquatic Resources Forestry and Wildlife Historic Preservation Land Management !!Natura1-Area"'Reserve~ysrem'\ Office of ConserVation and Environmental Mairs State Parks Water and Land Development Ot.~er Interested Parties



TO: __ M'tW~ISTR~TOR _,~ i :'; i ::':'MIN.

"; ',' t'?

___ ') ': '!(;T gR. ___ :,u:IlmOl ___ ~' i-;:C PLAN.

. 1,41. STAFF ____,:- .':, ASS'T. __ .... • :"';\EOLOGISTS FOR _____ .. rl'?~t!lATE/POST

___ i;,ir1ENTS & REO. _.. 'HAFT REPLY

-'I.E "'UQW UP

'0. iSH (DUE )

-" r!.E 0':;~\ C(1PYTO' ___ _




LN:ko Attachment(s)

Response: Cont~ct person:

~, We have no comments ( r We have no objections ( ) Commen attached ( ) Additiona information requested ( ) Extended r view period requ d

Signed: ____ ~+_~--------------------------- Date:

I

· \~ o /;,

r~ .9~ J',l" C .t/ y

State of Hawaii (-,I' D ~ <:) DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES "u ~

COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MLANAG~&T I . Honolulu, Hawaii ~JaCf' ~ · .;,

SEP - 2 1993 ~~'4lf-1f> O,oAtc,t. MEMORANDUM

TO:

FROM:

SUBJECT:

Aquatic Resources Forestry and Wildlife Historic Preservation Land Management

I!N atural-Area~ReselVe"'System'\ Offi:e of Conservation and Environmental Affairs State Parks Water and Land Development Other Interested Parties






LN:ko Attachment(s)


( )

~~ ( ) ( )

We have no comments We have no objections Comments attached Additional information requested Extended review period requested

Signed: __________________________________ ___

Phone:

Date:

. # ."

TO:

FROM:

SUBJECT:

o " o STATE OF HAWAII

DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES Division of Water and Land Development

Honolulu, Hawaii

Ms. Rae M. Loui, Deputy Director Commission on Water Resource Managem

Manabu Tagomori, Manager-Chief Engin

Koolauloa Ground Water Management Area, 0

Since the State Agricultural Park is included for water consumption, we have no comments to offer.

GA:lc

~-c .. ,':::')

•... ; ('"'''' p"'\

r .t .... f<l ::0 t. ... ,,')

• "T,j I :1 \ ....., J } w \',' .;'L·'

."." ... "J"

;p .1. .... -1

':;:;,:' c..o eq , , " . . (:,:J . ,." :J:', :"'\ :'i'i i 'I '\ Con .:~:~ ':.oJ -.J -.-, .. ~

o o RECE:;~f[:

~) ; '; f ~ I ,., x it .' \ • - " State of Hawaii '. : ~D ~AJihfJi! ':r!)

DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES' - N ,

COMMISSION ON WATER RESOU~~E ~».9~li1H iJ~· I 0 Honolulu, Hawan ;; J ... Lot ZJ •


TO:

FROM:

SUBJECT:

Aquatic Resources Forestry and Wildlife Historic Preservation Land Management

"Natural-Area-Reserve-System'l Office of Conservation and Environmental Affairs State Parks Water and Land Development Other Interested Parties






LN:ko Attachment (s)


( ) We have no comments ( ) We have no objections ~ Comments attached ( ) Additional infonnation requested

( ) Extended revi.",.. periOd0~'

Signed:~~

Phone: ____________ ___

Date:

o Oahu District Office has no objection provided that the applicant obtain the

required Federal, state and County permits if required. Should you have any questions, please call John Doooling at

.-- --------------o Q

g/

~ State of Hawaii STAF;' svcs 0 DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOUR~::Ev"___+__I~!:.!£!.:~_O

COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MLANAGE~ss Return to: "'---Honolulu, Hawaii f:::'''C _ ,Cf1l~ie~-,-,,-'1:_


TO: Aquatic Resources Forestry and Wildlife Historic Preservation Land Management

FROM:

SUBJECT:

":Natural"Area-Reserve-Systemt Office of Conservation and Environmental Mairs State Parks Water and Land Development Other Interested Parties



~:;)~.!C A 1~f)N I ! RpI'I'r"'rk"

iG-;]f;_~:~::-=:l'~"""~=' ~="''----

~'::~::~.:.:~~:~=~~:-~-··t-----=

Transmitted for your review and comment is a copy of a water use permit application for Campbell Estate for Well Nos. 4158-01 through -11. Public notice of this application will be published in the Honolulu Star Bulletin issues of September 8. 1993 and September 15. 1993.



LN:ko AttachmentCs)


C ) We have no comments C·) We have no objections C~Comments attached

Wi 11 i am Deyi ck

C ) Additional information requested C ) Extended review period requested

Signed: ::2< 2t?rr' II WILLIAM DEVICK, Acting Administrator Division of Aquatic Resources

Phone:

Date: 9/17/93

o o State of Hawaii

Department of Land and Natural Resources DIVISION OF AQUATIC RESOURCES

September 17, 1993

MEMORANDUM

TO

FROM:

SUBJECT:

Rae M. Loui, Deputy Director Commission on Water Resource Management

Henry Sakuda, Administrator Division of Aquatic Resources

Comments on water use permit application for Campbell Estate for Well No. 4158-01 through -11 in the Koolauloa Ground Water Management Area, Oahu

The application is for existing wells at low elevation above Kamehameha Highway in the vicinity of the Kahuku National Wildlife Refuge. Approximately 1,500,000 gallons of nonpotable caprock water will be pumped daily for irrigation in the State Agricultural Park. Given the location of the well and the water source, there is little likelihood that it will reduce surface water habitat for native aquatic species. We have no objections from the aquatic biological resources standpoint.

• 10 o JOHN WAIHEE

GOVERNOR OF HAWAII

KEITH W. AHUE

Ms. Donna Goth Campbell Estate

Dear Ms. Goth:

STATE OF HAWAII DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL. RESOURCES


JUl 8 1993

Applications for a Water Use Permit Koolauloa Ground Water Management Area, Oahu

CHAIRPERSON




RAE M. LOUI. P.E.

DEPUTY

We acknowledge receipt, on June 17, 1993, of your completed water use permit applications for the following wells:

Pump 2 Punamano Pump 2 Pump 5 Pump 6 Pump 8 Well No. 338 Well No. 4158-14 Well No. 4258-04 Well No. 4157-05 Well No. 4157-06 Well No. 4157-07 Malaekahana Well Pump 3 Pump 12 Pump 15 Pump 1 Pump 12A Pump 3A Sugar Mill Pump Pump 15 Well 4056-01 Kawela Well

(Well No. 4159-01) (Well No. 4159-02) (Well No. 4158-01 to 11) (Well No. 3957-07) (Well No. 4057-06) (Well No. 4100-01)

(Well No. 3956-01) (Well No. 3957-01) (Well No. 4057-07) (Well No. 4157-04) (Well No. 4057-01) (Well No. 4057-10) (Well No. 3957-03) (Well No. 4057-04) (Well No. 4157-04) (Well No. 4056-01) (Well No. 4100-02)

We also acknowledge receipt of your water use permit application for Air Base Pump (Well Nos. 4158-12 & 13). However, this application is incomplete. Please specify the Tax Map Key portiones) at which the water is to be used. In addition, please provide an estimate of the number of acres that will be used for aquacultural operations.

Ms. Donna Goth Page 2

10 o JUL 8 1993

The applications for Well Nos. 3957-01, 4057-07, 4157-04, 4057-01, 4057-10, 4158-12 & 13, 3957-03, 4057-04, 4157-04, 4056-01, and 4100-02 indicate that some water will be used for domestic purposes; please provide an estimate of the number of units to be served by each well. Also, potable water is being requested for irrigation and aquaculture. Would brackish and/or fresh/non-potable water, respectively, suffice for these uses?

Lastly, two separate applications were submitted for Pump 15 (Well No. 4157-04). We recommend that the applications be combined because, even though the end-uses may differ, Campbell Estates is the applicant for both. Also, your reporting of monthly water use would be facilitated by not having to individually meter each end-user if you combine the applications.

Upon receipt of the requested information for the Air Base Pump (Well Nos. 4158-12 & 13), we will continue to process the application. We will send you a copy of the public notices and any further information regarding your applications' status. In addition, we may need to visit and verify your proposed water sources and use sites if we have not done so already under our registration program.

LN:ko Enc!.

If you have any questions, please contact Roy Hardy at .

Sincerely,

Deputy Director

~"O UD!fAlH02 ~IOOUOOO

01000000 RPPl. fE£ "ftTER 0$£ P£Rnrr

THE ESTATE OF JAMES CAMPBELL HONOLULU, HAWAII

!.UES~ .~ , ,

June 10, 1993

THE MA~rm JAMES CAMPBELL JAMES CAMPBELL BUILDING. SUITE 500

DATE

.tl!H 10 a', 7,.

, . " ',' ~ 6/07i9l r .. ' " t ,'}'

r ,-,

f.", 1,-' .

• < . ' ,

~~ '" " .....

T,OTftlS

CHECK NO.

M~"'AA ... t'Wt1:I\"'~>'Wrlr~iw<*.~<tt~~*-IIri,~'JuC;tiltv f.i~~ DUllMS TO THE ORDER OF

. . "

DfR:~~~~~;S of lilnd R Ha~,~~ai ' ' Cut!l1issi(m on NatE'r Rftsoortt th"llaQenellt ' " P,O. -nox

nolulu

VOID AFTER 90 DAYS

. "!: ,: ~ .

~ "

~:" . :.~ ~. ..... "

.". ~.

SflIB# ~ ~ 91 j ,,' , I:HEtKI 9124'1 ,,' '0 ," " ,', ; . · "" '. .' . ,,' 'I " i < .... • ......... ,,~.,... .' ....

. ", ,,' '''', "'5 0""" '--' n, :"'1'" 25 00- " t ' ,

-... t...'}.,-J' .~: ,", '~.'" '! .. ~.~(f~ ..... '.. ::','/1.".:. ~.~ .......... r~; ~ { ,"" ./ , .. ,,;~,t;: ~( :~n;1~~~~"tPt,:'/~t~f:'~-"~\ -,' :L

~ , .' .. ., t~'~ ::::~ _: ,~, ~,./~.~~

I '~ .• ~~~':;.~:;~.;;.~.( .~:,; ~~~/:~.;r~. ~f '" . , ,~ .• f..... .~.~ ,". ~, "' •• i

. ~: .... ; -.. :~ ,r~.; ,.'"1 f ,'> .,,; J"~ :,'

f '.J'

'l.; _,' ,.,'

.... 1. ".~'" ~J "').~ ' •• -'~ •• , •• r' ~ f ,.., C. • • • <', ~. r t ,",

.~,:>.~; ~ ;~. ,~.~; :: ~ ,.:;.;" .~.;~)~ .. ~ -:: " ,"," • ( '''l.- ... (" - ~ t ., • ".

." , , ')

, ,

'\ ::' .. ..,.: :.' .,,~; .. :.' .'"\

f"~', • '-~":~:~'/~'(";·::?~""1 .. ~,1 .. "~

. : j! :;:. ~; ~H~Ha'i~~r;" :':> .' "2' oo~' ";~~';'~'~25 00 ,:;~ ,;., ' . :. • . .;" .~ :' ::.: ~:<' . .; .• ".' :;-.. ..;' ~ /

PLEASE DETACH BEFORE DEPOSITING CHECK

MAIN OFFICE BANK OF HAWAII HONOLULU, HAWAII

•• , .~ t ~ ..

,., "fI~?UNT

~; 0

~ p. ./ ; , ,

.~ ~ ,": ...

~~~Z'oOO*' ," (".: ... L'?, .:.~ ", ":'I"';.~.'I¥'\

';';Wt.~~~;w<ft"fl*1riff.~.*,*lWc~"'-k4,.,...,..,rt,~ '",::.\ .::~ '';: .. ':' ;:.;~." " . ",' '. ~. ' ,

"::';.: ~ , " . ," . ~:; ~ :: "

.. ,:"! ..... , . ,.. ,- n.-t-~ .... :...:.;.i.~~d.~~:=, '" • ; t;:--:;on .':"{j..:J;"-'~.;1-:., ~ \\."~.:'.\~

""'11 •• • .... ·'J. ...... t~a ~ ~- ~ .~h.\;.;..('~ .. '.i .... \! i;.::~;~i~ ;.v: ""vrl.~ .: .... :~ ....... ~ '.. '" .... ,. ........ ~':., IJ·.~ :, .;..~:."i.-<l.~. ro • .... 'c'. '''. ,J , "Y"). 'h ... 1 .... )I>.,~ , ~.~';':'!t ';.. • " _ ..

; , ~ .... ~ , ... ~~ .. : .. ,:~~:> ... ~ . '- '

," ,~"

f1~A- k~ ~ (';'/2A I v\.?:,

f

\, o THE ES1ATE OFJAA1ES CM1PBELL

June 15, 1993 RFCFfVEO

Mr. Roy Hardy State of Hawaii Commission on Water Resource Management Department of Land and Natural Resources

Dear Mr. Hardy:

93JUNI7 All: 24

cc;~<;~ 7~J :-... ~' ·~V ~~, ~~E

RESD~.;:~C~ ~~. < (:.~~~i~~FJ~ r

Application for Water Use Permits - Non-Potable Water

Enclosed are 11 applications for water use permits for the following wells, along with a $25 filing fee for each application.

Pump 2 - 4159-01 Pump 2 - 4159-02 Pump 5 Pump 6 Pump 8

Well 338 Well 4158-14 RCA 4258-04 Well 4157-05 Well 4157-06 Well 4157-07

If you need additional information, please give me a call at

sdhg:Ol045100\KlO048

Enclosures

Sincerely,

Q- V!Cf~P~ ~:~>~: ~enor -

Administrator, Natural Resources

D o State of HawaII COMMISSION ON WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT Department of Land and Natural Resource.

APPUCATION FOR W,A TER USE PERMIT

SJ Ground Water or C Surface Water

1. (a) APPUCANT (b) LANDOWNER FI INasnt The Estate of James Campbell FInn/Name The Estate of James Campbell c: tiel PttIon DOnna GOth ph. Con_ ~ Donna Goth Ph'

2. WATER MANAGEMENT AREA: -:.W1,;.;;n~dw;;.;;;ar;..;d:...;.;Oa;,;.;h.;;,:,u/.;.;Ko,;;..;o..;.;l a;.;;u.;.;lo;.;a ________ ISLAND:_.;.;;Oa;;.;,;hu ___ _

3. (a) EXISTING SOURCE NAME AND STATE NUMBER: Pump 5, We]] Nos. 4158-01 to 11 (weU ot Itteam dlvtrtlon namt/number,

(b) PROPOSED (NEW) SOURCE NAME: _..:;N:.;,:on.:.:,e _______________ _

4. SOURCE LOCATION: Address Kahuku Tax Map Kay 5-6-05:7

(Attach I USGS rNP, ICIie ,".2000', and I proS*1Y til( mIP IhoWing IOUrc» Ioc&1Ion rlf ... tnCId 10 ~ property boundlriet.)

5. SOURCE TYPE (chedc one): 0 sr.am

6. METHOD OF TAKING WATER(checJ( one): CNtIeIIn flow tlw .. , Pun1)

7. LOCATION OF PROPOSED WATER USE: (If po.", Ihow on MInI rNP' .1OUrct 1OeiIOn. ~ 1ItICh5 6-m'~rNP') (I) Addr... Kahuku Tax Map KIV - - • (b) Land U .. DiIII1ct(chedc one): 0 Urban AG-1 III AgI1cuJIutt C Co...vllion C Rulli (c:) COuMy Zoning (OtectIbt) ___ -..;.;~ ____________________ _

8. QUANTITY OF WATER REQUESTED: __ 1,_50_0_,0_00 ____ _ galiON per day

9. METHOD OF MEASUREMENT: l!l Flowme..... COpen-pipe 0 Ww C Ortl'lce 0 Other (expilln)

10. QUAUTY OF WATER REQUESTED: C Freeh o BracKllh

1 1. PROPOSED USE: C Municipal Qnc:ludlng ho\el8, stor .. , 81c:.) C 00meI1Ic Qndlvldual, nol'lOOl111Wcial, •• ) ~lnigdon

C IndulVtll C MIIItIry C 01her(expllln)

12. NUMBER AND TYPE OF UNITS TO BE SERVED (explain): _S_t_at_e_A..;.,9 _Par_k _________ _

13. TOTAL ACRES PROPOSED FOR IRRIGATION ANO TYPE OF CROP: ___ 6'l""'88......,. __ v_ar_io..,.u~S ~ __ (1Cf .. , (crop)

14. PROPOSED TIME OF WATER WITHDRAWAL OR DIVERSION: ___ --.;;.2..;..4 ~ho~lr~S~p~er~da_!lY~~~--(ii\diC&iI houI1 of op«llion)

1 5. APPUCAHT MUST BRIEFLY DESCRIBE FOLLOWING POTENTlAJ. RESTRIC110NS ON USE: (a) Impact on Sustainable yield (1): ~U~n~kn~own::.::... ______________ _

(b) Permenant or Interim None lnatream Flow Standards affected (1):

. (c). Hawaiian Home Land usee affected (1): _o:i-No .. ne _____________ ~----

. (d) Other exlstlng legal USN affected (1): None (9) ~~: _______________________ N .. on .. e ______ -----------------------------

16. REMARKS, EXPLANATIONS: ______________________ _

NOTe: $I~ ~"ow ~.1\It IN '"*""' ~ IIIC. •• ..., 1M 1*l1li11 ~ III co. .. 1IOft '" WfMi ..... ct """"'''' .... 1*l1li1. "*Jt~ 10 PIiQ( tIIllun; I*IIIIlttct "" .. CI\UI; .. III lUI ..... ~ .......... low ttlndllcII, ,. ""' II ...,. _~ III ColI ...... HlWIIIM Ho",.1.ItIIaI MI¥. ~.... In IOOIIIon, IIIIIIICInC .... cancat file. IoICIOI'II*IIIII ~oWl. • WIttr IIIONtIIIIM I'IIUIC ~. MIIIIIhcIII'IOIA4II1t COIIUIIIIIIOII ,..."e one. A~~~ ~e Estate of James Campbell ~~~ The Estate of James Campbell

Slgnat~dI~ Slgnatur ~. Date lp(ql'lh: Oal. __ ~

Fot 0tfdII U .. Only: 0 .. RIOIIYtd Olle Acctpted------

Nob Olill: Pubic __ _ Mlyor __ _

HydrOlogic Un/I No. ___ __ DivtfIIOn WW No. _____ _ SlIM Wei No. _____ _

BWS __ _ MIiIUII __ _ "Un __ _

::::::::

~p.:;~"

..... , ..

.. I:, .

;

.. -

,,' t~

. :' ~:

~ ;'.

; re,

I .. ~

'" T "

-..

tMlIU

tIll

il' l-

. tt

~ if

_._.---

._.--

; '--,

f J'7

Ii

' 0

' ~~

~~."

rJ

" "

----

',

' --

".1

--"

" .,.

\ ..

\

o \,

I I

~ \ I

" I

... :..

I

'1

.. I

,. I

~ \

.. 1 I

~

I

~

I "

,.r'"

I ~,

I *

.---+_ .

.. I

• \

*

.. '" '- ... ;;. ... q l ... '. -.

'~'.

,,,

" .

I I

• •

I}' or)nooo APPl. HE "AnR lISf fI£RlU r

THE ESTATE OF JAMES CAMPBELL HONOLULU, HAWAII

·JunE' 10, 1993

THE isfArE~CiF JAMES CAMPBELL JAMES CAMPBELL BUILDING. SUITE 500

TO THE ORDER OF

DATE

lUff 10 9J

Il~p:;lr·tnent I" lMd I "i\tut~-l R~sottn>.s

CQfltti<rsicn 01\ U",ter R~$()lJft:~ hlliHJ~tt'!n t r .0.

VOID AFTER 90 DA YS

61 07 i 'f!t

lOJftlS

CHECK NO.

25.00

STUBft '1%1. ,"rtD 21%1'

25.00

, ' 25.00

PLEASE DETACH BEFORE DEPOSITING CHECK

MAIN OFFICE BANK OF HAWAII HONOLULU. HAWAII

AMOUNT

University of Hawaii · .. JOHNWAIHEE ~OF_ REF:WRM-KO Q STATE OF HAWAII DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND...

Documents

Transcript of University of Hawaii · .. JOHNWAIHEE ~OF_ REF:WRM-KO Q STATE OF HAWAII DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND...