UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio +...

34
FACILITIES SERVICES BERKELEY, CALIFORNIA 94720-1380 September 27, 2011 TO: City of Berkeley Planning and Landmarks Preservation Commissions FR: Jennifer McDougall, Principal Planner, UC Berkeley RE: New University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive (BAM/PFA) Background: Among the largest university art museums in the United States in both size and patronage, the number of visitors to BAM/PFA averages 52,000 per year, and another 48,000 attend showings at the film archive (SMCP, January 2011). The existing BAM/PFA building, completed in 1970, was rated seismically very poor in 1997; in 1999 the physical locations of the program were split and the film component placed in a temporary building, addressing significant seismic risk at the theater. In 2001 a partial retrofit of the existing building addressed a few of the major vulnerabilities; however, in order to fully retrofit the existing building, the introduction of shear walls would reduce the functionality of exhibit space. In 2008, UC Berkeley presented a design for a new University of California Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive (BAM/PFA) building in downtown Berkeley, to the community and City commissions. The new building would have replaced the existing printing plant building at 2120 Oxford Street, a City of Berkeley landmark, and the existing 250space parking structure on Addison Street. Although that design was admired, in 2009, economic uncertainty stemming from the international recession led the museum to explore design alternatives that included maintaining the existing printing plant building if it could result in cost savings. UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current project. Although the project is a reuse and not an historic renovation of the existing printing plant building, Page & Turnbull Architects have assessed conditions of the historic fabric at 2120 Oxford, recommended rehabilitation treatments, and as preservation specialists are working with the team to review design concepts. Please see attached press release, and the Q&A including responses to many questions from the Community Open house held September 14, 2011. Please also see attached Table of Significant Features, explaining how important historic features are treated in the new design. Project Overview: The current proposal is comprised of four architecturally distinct elements: the existing production shed of the printing plant; the existing printing plant office block; a new element housing the BAM/PFA cinema and other programs; and a new services (or “back of house”) element housing the BAM/PFA loading facility and other support spaces. The existing office and production building at 2120 Oxford is approximately 45,500 GSF. A significant challenge is accommodating sufficient gallery space in the existing production shed envelope, while UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY BERKELEY DAVIS IRVINE LOS ANGELES MERCED RIVERSIDE SAN DIEGO SAN FRANCISCO SANTA BARBARA SANTA CRUZ

Transcript of UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio +...

Page 1: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

FACILITIES SERVICES BERKELEY, CALIFORNIA 94720-1380

September 27, 2011 

 

TO:  City of Berkeley Planning and Landmarks Preservation Commissions 

FR:  Jennifer McDougall, Principal Planner, UC Berkeley 

RE:  New University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive (BAM/PFA) 

 

Background:  Among the largest university art museums in the United States in both size and patronage, 

the number of visitors to BAM/PFA averages 52,000 per year, and another 48,000 attend showings at the 

film  archive  (SMCP,  January  2011).    The  existing  BAM/PFA  building,  completed  in  1970,  was  rated 

seismically  very  poor  in  1997;  in  1999  the  physical  locations  of  the  program were  split  and  the  film 

component placed  in a  temporary building, addressing  significant  seismic  risk at  the  theater.    In 2001 a 

partial retrofit of the existing building addressed a few of the major vulnerabilities; however,  in order to 

fully retrofit the existing building, the introduction of shear walls would reduce the functionality of exhibit 

space. 

 

In  2008, UC Berkeley presented  a design  for  a new University of California Berkeley Art Museum  and 

Pacific  Film  Archive  (BAM/PFA)  building  in  downtown  Berkeley,  to  the  community  and  City 

commissions.  The new building would have replaced the existing printing plant building at 2120 Oxford 

Street,  a  City  of  Berkeley  landmark,  and  the  existing  250‐space  parking  structure  on  Addison  Street.  

Although  that  design  was  admired,  in  2009,  economic  uncertainty  stemming  from  the  international 

recession  led  the museum  to explore design alternatives  that  included maintaining  the existing printing 

plant building if it could result in cost savings.    

 

UC Berkeley  is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect 

EHDD, on the current project. Although the project is a reuse and not an historic renovation of the existing 

printing plant building, Page & Turnbull Architects have assessed conditions of the historic fabric at 2120 

Oxford, recommended rehabilitation treatments, and as preservation specialists are working with the team 

to review design concepts.    

 

Please  see  attached  press  release,  and  the  Q&A  including  responses  to  many  questions  from  the 

Community Open house held September 14, 2011.   Please also see attached Table of Significant Features, 

explaining how important historic features are treated in the new design. 

 

Project Overview:   The current proposal is comprised of four architecturally distinct elements:  the existing 

production shed of the printing plant; the existing printing plant office block; a new element housing the 

BAM/PFA  cinema  and  other  programs;  and  a  new  services  (or  “back  of  house”)  element  housing  the 

BAM/PFA loading facility and other support spaces.   

 

The  existing office  and production building  at 2120 Oxford  is  approximately  45,500 GSF.   A  significant 

challenge  is  accommodating  sufficient  gallery  space  in  the  existing  production  shed  envelope,  while 

UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY

BERKELEY DAVIS IRVINE LOS ANGELES MERCED RIVERSIDE SAN DIEGO SAN FRANCISCO SANTA BARBARA SANTA CRUZ

Page 2: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY ART MUSEUM AND PACIFIC FILM ARCHIVE

Page 2

minimizing costly new construction.  The current design proposal would augment the building space with 

the  construction  of  a  new  element  of  some  30,000  GSF,  adjoining  the  office  block  and  anchoring  the 

southwest corner of Addison and Oxford Streets.   This new element would house  the BAM/PFA cinema 

and most of BAM/PFA’s research and teaching programs. 

 

The parking structure would be removed, and the remainder of the site would be striped for parking.  This 

is expected to accommodate approximately 40 spaces. 

 

CEQA Review:   The proposed project  is consistent with the UC Berkeley 2020 Long Range Development 

Plan and the campus expects to complete an addendum to the 2020 LRDP EIR for the project. 

 

Preliminary schedule:  We anticipate construction to begin at the beginning of 2013; occupancy may occur 

in late 2015. 

 

Further questions:  Please contact Jennifer with any questions or concerns at (510)642‐7720 or 

[email protected]

 

Attachments: 

Q&A 

Press Release  

Graphics 

Table of Significant Elements and BAM/PFA 

 

 

Page 3: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

September 27, 2011 

BAM/PFA BUILDING PROJECT  

Questions and Answers 

 BUILDING 

 

Where will the new BAM/PFA building be located? 

The museum’s entrance will be on Center Street, with additional frontages 

on Addison and Oxford streets. The new downtown site will anchor 

Berkeley’s Arts District and link the west campus entrance and the active 

downtown arts and commerce districts. Just a block from the Downtown 

Berkeley BART station, BAM/PFA will count as its neighbors the Berkeley 

Repertory Theater, Aurora Theater, Freight and Salvage Coffeehouse, and 

the Bancroft Library’s Magnes Collection of Jewish Art and Life. 

 

How will the new building relate to the former UCB printing plant?  

The Streamline Moderne‐style former printing plant—unoccupied since 

2004—will be repurposed to serve as gallery, education, and office space, 

including some areas created by excavating a basement level. This 

building will be integrated with an approximately new structure that will 

include the PFA Theater, Library and Film Study Center, collection study 

area, special‐event space, café, and back‐of‐house operations.  The existing 

printing plant building is approximately 45,000 gross square feet, and in 

total the new BAM/PFA will be approximately 82,000 square feet. 

 

The new building is smaller than the current one. How does this improve 

BAM/PFA?  

Despite its smaller size, the new building will be more efficient and will 

provide more programmatic space than does the current building. The 

galleries in the current facility are irregular in shape, and most have only 

three walls, which limits the number of linear feet available for hanging 

art. Further, the current building’s largest gallery, the 7,000‐square‐foot 

Gallery B, is of limited use for exhibitions because of its extraordinarily 

high ceiling, extensive windows, and irregular, concrete walls. The new 

building, on the other hand, will include versatile gallery spaces that can 

accommodate works of art in diverse media. So, while there will be fewer 

square feet of gallery space, the new building will contain 30 percent more 

linear feet for exhibition. The efficient design of the new building will also 

Page 4: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

 

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive Q&A September 2011 

2

provide 100 percent more space dedicated to education and collections 

access than the current building contains. 

 

Where will the back‐of‐house functions be located? 

Back‐of‐house functions will be located on‐site, in close proximity to the 

galleries and study areas. Frequently exhibited and studied works will be 

stored on‐site and works on paper will be accessible in an open storage 

and study area. The majority of the collection in other media will be 

housed in a university‐owned off‐site storage facility that is home to many 

of the University of California, Berkeley’s scholarly collections.  

 

Who is designing the new building?  

The new building is designed by the New York City‐based firm Diller 

Scofidio + Renfro (DS+R). Among DS+R’s recent architectural 

achievements are Boston’s Institute of Contemporary Art; the redesign of 

Alice Tully Hall, a concert and film facility at Lincoln Center for the 

Performing Arts, in New York City; a 95,000‐square‐foot expansion of The 

Juilliard School, which is also part of DS+R’s ongoing work for Lincoln 

Center; and the High Line, an urban park on a 1.5‐mile stretch of elevated 

railway in New York’s Chelsea District.  

 

What will the new BAM/PFA look like?  

The new BAM/PFA will unite the former printing plant with a bold new 

architectural form. The design preserves most of the historic features of 

the former printing plant, including the distinctive façades on Center and 

Oxford streets, the north‐facing skylights, and the elegant lobby. Through 

excavation, the printing plant will be greatly expanded, creating an 

additional floor of gallery and education spaces on a lower level. The 

ground level galleries are designed so that they appear to float like trays 

above this excavated space, with light extending from the skylights to the 

lower level through strategically sited light wells and a double‐height 

garden at the northwest corner of the building. The unique museum store 

will occupy a narrow slice of the ground floor along the Center Street 

façade. 

The new structure introduces an innovative formal and material 

vocabulary that echoes the streamlined curves of the Art Deco style, yet is 

updated for the 21st century. It will encompass a café that cantilevers 

above the museum’s Center Street entrance, offering views of the city and 

campus, and a mezzanine walkway that provides entry to the PFA 

Page 5: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

 

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive Q&A September 2011 

3

Theater. The external shape of the theater, which is also part of the new 

structure, echoes its own internal volume, so that from outside it appears 

as a rounded, almost vessel‐like form. The theater will appear to be 

suspended above the library and study areas beneath it. The perimeter of 

these areas comprises a glass curtain wall that creates a welcome 

transparency between the museumʹs educational program and the civic 

context. 

Embodying a thoughtful and creative amalgam of past and present, the 

new BAM/PFA will foreground the versatile, high‐quality presentation of 

art and film, while offering numerous moments of architectural wonder 

and surprise. 

 

How sustainable will the new BAM/PFA construction be? Will it earn LEED 

certification?  

The campus’s goal for the new building is a minimum of LEED‐Silver 

certification. 

 

Who is the architect of record?  

Architect of record for the new BAM/PFA is EHDD of San Francisco, a 

nationally recognized architecture firm with a long track record with the 

University of California, Berkeley, and with exceptional expertise in 

educational facilities, buildings for science, museums, and zoos.  

 

 Why does BAM/PFA need a new building?  

The impetus behind the creation of the new building is safety: A 1997 

survey found that the museum’s existing facility—a 102,800‐square‐foot 

reinforced concrete structure—does not meet current seismic standards. A 

seismic bracing of the building completed in 2001 elevated it from a “very 

poor” seismic standard to “poor.” This upgrade has enabled BAM/PFA to 

remain open while it plans and constructs a new facility. The campus has 

committed to elevating all campus buildings to at least “good” seismic 

standards. 

 

Will the new building enable BAM/PFA to expand or improve its programming? 

The new building will greatly enhance and expand the museum’s 

programmatic capacities. For the first time in its history BAM/PFA will be 

able to screen films and videos in a purpose‐built theater, designed 

specifically for the optimal experience of these media (the former theater 

Page 6: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

 

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive Q&A September 2011 

4

building was designed as a flat floor multipurpose performance gallery; 

the temporary location was designed as flexible lecture space). There will 

be 30 percent more linear feet of exhibition area, in a range of gallery types 

designed for the diverse needs of both contemporary and historical works 

of art in a variety of media. The new facility will also include a multi‐

purpose gallery intended for displays of both 2‐D and 3‐D works of art, as 

well as for performance in various modes, and a new 30‐seat multi‐

purpose screening room that will make possible a variety of screenings 

and education programs. The museum will additionally have double the 

amount of space for education and collections access, enabling it to 

expand its programs to serve the larger and more diverse audiences 

anticipated at the new downtown location.  

 

Can’t the Ciampi‐designed building be permanently seismically braced?  

Bracing the building for the long term would require the construction of 

interior shear walls, which are composed of braced panels. These would 

eliminate the open gallery space that the museum requires for its 

exhibition program. Thus, the building can be permanently braced, but 

only for another purpose. 

 

Will the museum close during construction of the new building? If so, at what 

points, and for how much time? 

 

The new building will be constructed on a new site, enabling BAM/PFA to 

continue programming at the current locations until it is determined that 

the staff must focus exclusively on preparing to open the new facility. The 

museum expects any closure period to be relatively brief. 

 

What will happen to the current Mario Ciampi‐designed art museum on 

Bancroft Way?  

The campus will determine the future use of the Ciampi building, which 

will likely provide academic and support space for campus units with 

space deficits. Reassignment of the building for these uses could become 

an impetus for the campus to install interior shear walls that would 

drastically improve the seismic safety of the building. However, such 

renovations would be incompatible with the open gallery space that is 

vital for the museum’s exhibition program.   

 

Page 7: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

 

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive Q&A September 2011 

5

Will the PFA Theater be part of the new building?  

Yes. One of the many benefits of the new facility is that the PFA Theater 

will once again be an integral part of the museum, alongside its galleries, 

education spaces, and administrative offices. Patrons will experience 

BAM/PFA’s film program in a structure designed specifically for film 

presentations. Both the current PFA Theater space at 2575 Bancroft Way 

and the previous film theater, housed downstairs in the current building, 

are classroom/lecture spaces that were modified for presenting film in a 

theater setting. 

 

When will construction begin, and when will the new BAM/PFA building open?  

The museum anticipates that it will begin construction in 2013. The new 

museum complex is targeted for completion by late 2015.  

 

Will there be parking at the new BAM/PFA? 

The new location is well served by public transit and has several public 

parking garages within close walking distances. The campus also allows 

parking in its lots on most weekends and evenings, which tends to be 

when attendance to the museum and PFA Theater is highest. Also, film 

programs are only presented during the weekday evenings and on the 

weekends, when those campus lots are available to the general public. 

 

 FUNDING 

 

How will the new BAM/PFA building be funded?   

The budget for the new downtown museum project is $100 million, all of 

which will come from private, non‐state sources. To date, $65 million has 

been committed, and BAM/PFA is working in partnership with the 

University to raise the remainder.  

 

 OTHER COMMUNITY CONCERNS 

 

How will the historic printing of the UN Charter at the printing plant be 

commemorated? 

 

Although the exact location is not yet determined, the commemorative 

plaque will be reused in the building. 

Page 8: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

 

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive Q&A September 2011 

6

 

The project would remove a 250‐car parking structure.  The project also would 

remove some street parking to accommodate wider sidewalks:   ten spaces at 

Oxford and perhaps additional spaces at Center Street and Addison.  What will 

be done to address loss of parking downtown? 

 

Visitors to the existing museum customarily arrive by alternative means; 

the existing museum does not provide parking, and the new museum 

would be better located to facilitate arrival by alternative modes. 

 

The project would maintain approximately 40 parking spaces at Addison 

Street; these would be below grade close to the current elevation of the 

basement level of the existing parking structure.  UC Berkeley is exploring 

possibly renting space in local garages, and development of parking 

spaces at Shattuck between Berkeley Way and Hearst Avenue, to address 

some of the day time commuter parking demand dislocated by the loss of 

the parking structure.   

 

How does the project support community aspirations for Center Street?  Could 

the café be on the street? 

The project does not preclude any future for Center Street.  There is no 

loading or service vehicle access planned along the Center Street façade of 

the proposed museum.  The narrow bookstore offers an active, windowed 

storefront use for Center Street.  Areas of the museum that can be accessed 

without a ticket will include the bookstore, the lobby, the café, and the 

Matrix gallery as well as library and learning spaces; all ticketed and 

unticketed spaces will be accessed from the Center Street entrance, 

maintaining lively pedestrian activity for a potential future plaza. 

Neither the initial Downtown Area Plan nor the UC Berkeley Long Range 

Development Plan anticipated reuse of the existing landmarked printing 

plant building; reuse of the existing building form places pressures on 

program spaces.  The café space is pushed to the second level as a narrow 

retail space fronts street‐level windows, and the essential building 

function as exhibit space occupies entry level spaces as well.   

Further, the design goal for the new element generally is to perform as a 

connector – an interface between city and campus, arts district and 

commercial center, art and film, old and new. The café cantilever is an 

extension of this link, expressing activity on the interior and creating a 

protected entry to the building. It not only reaches out to the city and 

Page 9: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

 

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive Q&A September 2011 

7

campus to provide views into the structure from downtown Berkeley and 

the campus, but also reflexively offers views back to each of these 

locations from its transparent café interior. The cantilevered café and the 

theater volumes are formally tied together to create a unified image for the 

new BAM/PFA. 

 

Did you consider closing Addison Street?  Could more be done for the Addison 

Street edge of the project?   

 

The project has been guided as fully as possible by the City of Berkeley 

Downtown Area Plan as that plan has been in development.  To our 

knowledge, there has not been an initiative to close Addison Street.  Even 

if Addison were to close, access for loading to the building, to allow art to 

arrive and be removed as exhibits change, would remain critical; the 

remaining surface parking would also be accessed by Addison Street. 

Any project struggles to address competing demands, and the desires for 

Addison Street are balanced against the desires to activate Center Street, 

and the operational cost savings in operating a single public entry point. 

 

How will BAM/PFA engage Berkeley City College/teens/families with the move 

downtown? 

In its current Strategic Planning process, BAM/PFA is looking at a number 

of ways to better engage these groups, and expects the new downtown 

site will offer tremendous opportunities for collaboration and 

engagement.  BAM/PFA especially hopes to be more welcoming to teen 

audiences, working with Berkeley High School, and reaching out beyond 

Berkeley to serve teens through programs and through spaces that are 

conducive to their needs.  BAM/PFA has piloted a number of programs 

serving families to begin to assess strengths, capacities, and potential 

community partners.  There are no specific plans to work with Berkeley 

City College currently, but BAM/PFA looks forward to reaching out to the 

BCC and other neighboring cultural and educational institutions.   

How programs will happen in the community gallery? 

The community gallery will function much like the existing theater 

gallery, with shows of works from the BAM/PFA collection and works 

related to special exhibitions.  It will not require an admission ticket for 

viewing. 

Page 10: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

 

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive Q&A September 2011 

8

Does there need to be a café in the building, given other coffee and food on Center 

Street? 

 

An essential aspect of BAM/PFA’s vision for the new building is that it 

accommodates multiple sites for student and community gatherings, both 

for informal relaxation and conversation as well as programmed events 

(music, lectures, etc.). In its current Strategic Planning process, an idea 

that as repeatedly been brought up is holding such gatherings around 

food, i.e. in the cafe. Indeed, the sharing of food in conjunction with 

conversation around art and culture is a growing phenomenon here in the 

Bay Area and elsewhere in the country, as in the work of the Bay Area 

collective OPENrestaurant, Portlandʹs literary salon ʺBackroom,ʺ etc. 

Thus, the cafe is envisioned as a place not only for the regular supply of 

ordinary light refreshment, but also as a place where audiences can gather 

to discuss films, and hold informal dialogs scheduled through, for 

example, the membership meetup.com page.  

Page 11: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

View from corner of Center and Oxford Streets. Image courtesy Diller Scofidio + Renfro.

BERKELEY ART MUSEUM AND PACIFIC FILM ARCHIVE ADVANCES PLANS FOR NEW FACILITY, PRESENTS DESIGN TO PUBLIC

New museum complex, designed by celebrated firm Diller Scofidio + Renfro, to be located in the Downtown Berkeley Arts District.

Berkeley, California, September 14, 2011 — The University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive (BAM/PFA) today held a community open house to present the schematic design for its new facility to the public. The project, designed by the renowned New York City-based firm of Diller Scofidio + Renfro (DS+R), will unite a repurposed former UC Berkeley printing plant at 2120 Oxford Street with a new structure. Located in Berkeley’s arts district, the new building will be bounded by Center, Oxford, and Addison Streets, and will count as its neighbors the Berkeley Repertory Theater; Aurora Theater; Freight and Salvage Coffeehouse, devoted to traditional music; and the Bancroft Library’s Magnes Collection of Jewish Art and Life. The new BAM/PFA is targeted for completion in late 2015. The architect-of-record for the new BAM/PFA building is the nationally recognized, San Francisco-based EHDD. “UC Berkeley is pleased to share with the campus and wider community its plans for a new building for BAM/PFA,” said UC Berkeley Chancellor Robert Birgeneau. “Diller Scofidio + Renfro’s design successfully integrates great architecture with Cal’s mission of public service and contemporary and civic life. The new museum will make BAM/PFA’s tremendous artistic and intellectual resources more publicly accessible to local, national, and international audiences. We congratulate BAM/PFA on the progress that it is making on this exciting project and look

Page 12: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

2

forward to opening the doors of this superb new facility to our students, faculty, staff, and the public.” BAM/PFA Director Lawrence Rinder added, “BAM/PFA’s dynamic exhibitions and programs will find an ideal home in the new facility designed by DS+R. The firm’s plan respects the grand interior of the existing printing plant, while adding to that building a bold new architectural form filled with sensuous colors, materials, and surfaces. DS+R’S commitment to the integration of cultural institutions into the life of cities is embodied in its embrace of transparency and openness as fundamental design principles. At once beautiful and accessible, the new BAM/PFA will be a destination for art and film lovers from throughout the Bay Area, the nation, and the world.” Project Background BAM/PFA began planning for a new facility in 1997, when an engineering survey determined that its current building, on Bancroft Way, does not meet present-day seismic standards and cannot be upgraded to meet those standards without eliminating the open space required for the museum’s exhibition program. In 2006, the museum engaged the Tokyo-based firm of Toyo Ito & Associates to design a new building on the University’s downtown site. However, in 2009, economic uncertainty stemming from the international recession led the museum to explore design alternatives. The museum subsequently convened an architect selection committee composed of campus faculty and administrators and representatives of the museum and community. The committee identified ten national firms and invited them to submit qualifications for the project. From this group, three were selected to make presentations and participate in interviews. The committee’s recommendation of Diller Scofidio + Renfro was endorsed by the BAM/PFA Board of Trustees.

Page 13: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

3

View from northwest. Image courtesy Diller Scofidio + Renfro

View of entry from Center Street. Image courtesy Diller Scofidio + Renfro.

Building Design Diller Scofidio + Renfro’s design for the new BAM/PFA combines the 1939 concrete Art Deco-style former printing plant, unoccupied since 2004, with a new metal-clad structure. The new design creates a cohesive and visually arresting space for art, film, education, civic interaction, and administration. Plans call for the industrial building—currently a single-story, skylighted structure with a three-story administrative wing at its east end—to house the museum’s collection and exhibition galleries, a thirty-two-seat screening room, museum store, learning center, K–12 education areas, community gallery, and offices. The new structure, extending between the corner of Oxford and Addison Streets and

the museum’s Center Street facade, includes the 230-seat PFA Theater, Library and Film Study Center, special event space, collection study area, café, and nonpublic areas. The facility is thus defined by two primary and integrated components: the imaginatively repurposed older building and a complementary, forward-thinking multipurpose structure.

The entrance to the new BAM/PFA will be on Center Street, on the south side of the former printing building, one block from the Downtown Berkeley BART station. On the north side of the building, an outdoor plaza will provide a welcoming public space. A large section of the new museum will be accessible to the public without an admission fee, including the lobby, multipurpose gallery, MATRIX gallery (devoted to exhibiting work by emerging artists), community gallery, special-event space, and café. The new BAM/PFA is anticipated to achieve LEED (Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design, given by the U.S. Green Building Council) certification of silver or higher. Former UC Printing Plant Plans for repurposing the former printing plant include preserving many essential aspects of the building

Page 14: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

4

envelope, including the sawtooth roof and distinctive facade. Work on the interior has been designed with great sensitivity to the original structure, and will include extensive excavation to allow for additional gallery and education spaces, as well as elevators and other required service elements. The building will also be seismically upgraded. Infused with natural light admitted by three large north-facing skylights, the ground-floor galleries provide 10,800 square feet of exhibition space ideally suited for viewing art. Other ground-floor amenities include the grand lobby; MATRIX Gallery, devoted to the work of emerging artists; and a distinctively designed museum store with large windows running along the Center Street frontage. DS+R’s plans call for the lower level to be excavated to obtain 12,500 square feet of additional gallery space, much of which is particularly suitable for light-sensitive work, as well as public study areas, a seminar room, a thirty-two-seat screening room, and spaces specially designed for K–12 visitors. The total number of linear feet of wall space for exhibitions will be approximately thirty percent greater than in the current building. New Structure The new structure will be most visible at the corner of Oxford and Addison Streets, across from the western entrance to the UC Berkeley campus, where it will appear to hover above the excavated lower level. Rinder says that “this minimally sculpted volume—a sensuous cipher—will instill a sense of curiosity about the PFA Theater within.” Below the PFA Theater, a lower level will contain the Film Library and Study Center, open collection storage and study areas, and other education-related spaces. Created to accommodate a range of programming, the theater itself will include a screen as large as fifteen-by-thirty-six feet and will be suited to a variety of media formats, including 35mm, 16mm, and both regular- and super 8mm film, as well as HDTV and SDTV. It will also accommodate lectures and performances with a stage area suitable for a small band, orchestra, or other musical accompaniment to film. The compelling forms and materials of the theater structure will appear to drape over the roof of the printing plant’s administration building and cut through the eastern end of the sawtooth skylights to create a dramatic connection to Center Street, where they resolve into a double-height atrium and a café that cantilevers

Page 15: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

5

over the museum’s main entrance. This striking intervention will serve as an architectural spine that unites the two buildings into a single composition. Funding The museum has received commitments for $65 million of its $100 million campaign. Diller Scofidio + Renfro Diller Scofidio + Renfro is widely celebrated for cultural projects that play an integral role in the life of the cities in which they are located. The studio is led by three partners—Elizabeth Diller, Ricardo Scofidio, and Charles Renfro—who collaborate with a staff of seventy-five architects, designers, artists, and administrators. Recent projects include ongoing design work for New York City’s Lincoln Center for the Performing Arts, including, to date, the redesign of Alice Tully Hall (opened 2009) and a 95,000-square-foot expansion of The Juilliard School (opened 2009). Also in New York City, the first portion of the High Line, an urban park on a 1.45-mile stretch of elevated railway in New York City’s Chelsea District, designed in collaboration with James Corner Field Operations, opened to the public in 2009; the second portion opened in 2011. In 2006, the firm completed Boston’s Institute of Contemporary Art, which combines civic and cultural experiences while providing a contemplative space that reveals shifting perspectives of the waterfront. DS+R’s current projects include The Broad, the new museum of The Broad Art Foundation, in Los Angeles, scheduled to open in 2013; “Bubble,” a seasonal expansion planned for the cylindrical courtyard of the Hirshhorn Museum and Sculpture Garden on Washington, D.C.’s National Mall; and the Museum of Image & Sound, in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, which is conceived as an extension of the Copacabana Beach promenade designed by Roberto Burle Marx. In 1999, the MacArthur Foundation presented Elizabeth Diller and Ricardo Scofidio with the “genius” award for their commitment to integrating architecture with issues of contemporary culture. They were recently made fellows of the Royal Institute of British Architects and were inducted into the American Academy of Arts and Sciences. Other prestigious awards and honors received by Diller Scofidio + Renfro include: the National Design Award from the Smithsonian; the Brunner Prize from the American Academy of the Arts and Letters; an Obie for an off-Broadway

Page 16: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

6

theater production; the AIA President’s Award; the AIA Medal of Honor; and AIA Design Awards for numerous projects. University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive Founded in 1963, the UC Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive (BAM/PFA) is UC Berkeley’s primary visual arts venue and among the largest university art museums in terms of size and audience in the United States. Internationally recognized for its art and film programming, BAM/PFA is a platform for cultural experiences that transform individuals, engage communities, and advance the local, national and global discourse on art and ideas. BAM/PFA’s mission is “to inspire the imagination and ignite critical dialogue through art and film.” BAM/PFA presents approximately fifteen art exhibitions and 380 film programs each year. The museum’s collection of over 16,000 works of art includes important holdings of Neolithic Chinese ceramics, Ming and Ching Dynasty Chinese painting, Old Master works on paper, Italian Baroque painting, early American painting, Abstract Expressionist painting, contemporary photography, and video art. Its film archive of over 14,000 films and videos includes the largest collection of Japanese cinema outside of Japan, Hollywood classics, and silent film, as well hundreds of thousands of articles, reviews, posters, and other ephemera related to the history of film, many of which are digitally scanned and accessible online.

* * *

Press Contacts For information on the BAM/PFA building project: Jeanne Collins or Libby Mark, Jeanne Collins & Associates, LLC, New York City, 646-486-7050 or [email protected] For the University of California, Berkeley: Kathleen Maclay, 510-643-5651 or [email protected]

Page 17: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive design proposal, September 2011

Page 18: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive design proposal, September 2011

Page 19: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive design proposal, September 2011

Page 20: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive design proposal, September 2011

Page 21: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive design proposal, September 2011

Page 22: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive design proposal, September 2011

Page 23: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive design proposal, September 2011

Page 24: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive design proposal, September 2011

Page 25: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive design proposal, September 2011

Page 26: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive design proposal, September 2011

Page 27: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive design proposal, September 2011

Page 28: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive design proposal, September 2011

Page 29: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive design proposal, September 2011

Page 30: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive design proposal, September 2011

Page 31: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive design proposal, September 2011

Page 32: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

University of California, Berkeley Art Museum and Pacific Film Archive design proposal, September 2011

Page 33: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

Table of Character Defining Features, BAM/PFA  September 2011 page 1 of 2   

CHARACTER‐DEFINING FEATURES OF 2120 OXFORD, STATUS IN PROPOSED PROJECT 

Item   Character Defining Feature  

(per Significance Diagrams, 

2010, Page & Turnbull)   

Where Feature 

Appears 

 

Status of Feature with implementation of 

BAM PFA project (preliminary) 

Location in downtown 

Berkeley, adjacent to UC 

campus 

n/a  Unchanged 

Overall form and 

organization of the building, 

divided into a three‐story 

administration building 

(originally used for editors’ 

offices) and a two‐story 

printing plant shed 

(originally housed physical 

printing functions) 

n/a 

Form altered to four parts:  three‐story office 

wing; two‐story printing plant shed; high 

volume theater addition with extension over 

printing plant;  three‐story back of house 

building. 

3 Profile of printing plant 

shed’s sawtooth roof 

Printing plant 

shed 

Altered in part by extension of theater 

addition and new cantilever over Center 

Street; maintained in part. 

Board‐formed concrete 

construction, including 

facades, floors, walls, and 

roofs 

Printing plant 

shed 

The original character of the shed building 

will be retained as fully as possible.  With the 

exception of the glass block windows, the 

façade will remain largely unaffected.  The 

design intent is for the interior surface of the 

roof to be retained, however for acoustical 

reasons, an acoustical plaster will be added 

within the sawtooth bays that will be colored 

to match the original concrete.  Insulation 

and a vapor barrier are required on the 

perimeter walls and so new wall finish will 

be added on top of the insulation and vapor 

barrier to match the character of the original 

walls. 

WPA Moderne‐style design 

and details, including tiered 

pilasters, fluted spandrel 

panels, and lighting fixtures 

Primarily 

apparent on 

administration 

building 

Largely intact and restored 

Multi‐light, steel sash awning 

windows with clear glass 

(still operable) 

Administration 

building 

The team is examining whether to retain or 

replace multi‐light windows, which may be a 

cost concern.  If replaced, the design would 

not replace the multi‐light style. 

Page 34: UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY...Sep 27, 2011  · UC Berkeley is working with Diller Scofidio + Renfro as design architects, and with Executive Architect EHDD, on the current

Table of Character Defining Features, BAM/PFA  September 2011 page 2 of 2   

Item   Character Defining Feature  

(per Significance Diagrams, 

2010, Page & Turnbull)   

Where Feature 

Appears 

 

Status of Feature with implementation of 

BAM PFA project (preliminary) 

7 Glass block wall sections on 

south facade of printing plant 

Printing plant 

shed 

Removed and replaced with windows that 

have greater transparency to street; 

considering opportunity for some reuse of 

glass block in landscape or in back of house 

building on Addison. 

Main entry with cantilevered 

canopy, original aluminum 

doors, original aluminum 

sconces, and bronze plaque 

Administration 

building 

Main entry moved to Center Street; staff 

entry at Oxford remains, most features 

restored.  New entry doors will likely be 

needed for accessibility and energy 

performance. 

First floor lobby with 

terrazzo floor, curving 

terrazzo stair with aluminum 

railing, plaster walls, and 

original light fixtures 

(interior) 

Administration 

building Retained, restored  

10 

Second floor stair lobby with 

terrazzo floor and aluminum 

railing (interior) 

Administration 

building Retained, restored 

11 

Second floor library with 

built‐in oak cabinets and 

shelving (interior) 

Administration 

building 

Library removed for more efficient open 

office layout 

12 

Production shed with two‐

story volume and industrial 

character, especially the 

sawtooth roof with north‐

facing skylights, steel‐and‐

glass partitions, and redwood 

block flooring (interior) 

Printing Plant 

Shed 

Steel and glass interior partitions removed; 

volume largely retained below the sawtooth 

roof with additional height at locations where 

first floor is open to basement; north‐facing 

skylights mostly retained and altered in part 

by cantilever over Center Street; wood block 

flooring to be replaced with new flooring that 

has a similar character to the existing. 

 

(The Historic Structure Report for the building at 2120 Oxford Street – the UC Printing Plant building ‐ is 

available on the web at http://www.cp.berkeley.edu/CP/PEP/History/planninghistory.html ‐‐ see under “off 

campus” buildings, UC Printing Plant)