Understanding Financial Restructuring · Successful turnarounds are based on addressing both...
Transcript of Understanding Financial Restructuring · Successful turnarounds are based on addressing both...
UnderstandingFinancial
Restructuring
December 2018
What is Distress?
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
• At its core: a “distressed” business is simply one with “unsustainable operations”• This can be defined as: “the inability to generate consistent, positive cash flow
over a period of time relative to the financial obligations of the business”• Usually, this is discovered by the firm’s lender following a covenant breach, which
can push a relatively healthy business into distress, because of the lender’s abilityto shut down liquidity and force a liquidation of the business
• Temporarily unsustainable operations can be restructured or funded via:• Junior Capital (typically equity)• Working capital run-down• Excess revolver/term debt availability/capacity• Capital restructuring
• So the definition of a distressed business becomes: “a business with temporarilyunsustainable operations, in combination with inadequate liquidity, relative to theworking capital and debt service needs of the firm”
Page 2
Causes of Distress
Page 3
Causes of Distress
Copyright 2014. All Rights Reserved.
External Internal
Capital Structure / Leverage
Changes in Market Demand
– Housing market– Coal industry
Competition– New competition– Change in relative
competitive position– Brick and mortar retail vs.
online
Change in Costs– Adverse change in
commodity prices– Disconnect with customer
contracts
Poor Management– Not necessarily
incompetence but poorteam dynamic
Inadequate Financial Control
– Failure to identify decliningperformance and takeaction
High Cost Structure– Fixed costs may have
increased as a result of anattempted growth push
Loss of Talent– Or mis-alignment of
resources due tomanagement changes
Poor Marketing– Lack of focus on selling and
marketing efforts
Big Projects / Acquisitions
– Poor integration– Distraction from core
competencies– Drain on financial
resources
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
The Distress Decline Curve
Page 4
83
Success Factors for Complex Restructuring
Then the most dangerous crisis will take effect, the liquidity crisis. In this respect,the scope of action is limited; ass early as 2005, the BGH (Federal Court of Justice– Bundesgerichtshof) decided: Anybody not being able to pay debts due is con-sidered to be insolvent. In such an event, the affected company has either torestore solvency within three weeks or to file for insolvency. Insolvency has to beproven by the cash and debt position.
The short deadlines already show how dangerous the situation is: it is gettingmore difficult for companies to settle loan claims, suppliers ask for advance payments, loan insurers cut the limits, the lessor threatens with termination,leasing contracts are in danger, etc. In such a situation, professional consultantsmay already contact individual contractual partners in parallel to the actual preparation of an appraisal report: Only somebody who is able to signal trust ina convincing manner may calm the situation so that there will be at least achance of completing the analysis and implementing the required measures. Insuch a situation, practitioners are needed who exactly know, based on manycases of restructuring, how to address the problem and which issues have to betaken into account.
Course of a company crisis Fig. 2Pr
obab
ility
of c
ontin
uanc
e
Stake-holder crisis
Source: bdp-aktuell.de
At the beginning of a company crisis there is a stakeholder crisis, or strategically wrong decisions were taken. However, measures areonly taken in case of a success or liquidity crisis.The probability of continuance decreases overthe course of the time.Strategy
crisis
Success crisis
Liquiditycrisis Insolvency
maturity
time
Usually Where an advisory is brought in
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Path of a Turnaround or Restructuring
Page 5
Paths of a Turnaround or Restructuring
Copyright 2014. All Rights Reserved.
Time
Non-Crisis
Crisis
Sustainable Recovery
Mere Survival
Short-Term Survival
Failed Turnaround
InsolvencyFinancial Position
Turnaroundstrategies adopted
The transition to a Crisis can take weeks, months or years depending on many factors, such as:– the industry– the degree of indebtedness– the availability of capital– the nature of the causes of poor performance
Source: Corporate Recovery: Managing Companies in Distress, by Stuart Slatter & David Lovett To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
The Impact of Distress on Valuation
Page 66
Overview – distress impacts asset valuation
Liquidation v. Enterprise Value
Enterprise ValuePartial Breakup Value
The short answer to reorganize or liquidate:• When the value of assets exceeds the cash generating capacity, the
assets should be liquidated.
• Consider a partial break-up as an alternative to outright liquidation to
maximize value.
AssetLiquidation
Value
AssetLiquidation
ValueCashFlowValue
PartialCashFlowValue
Liquidation Value
PartialLiquidation
Value CashFlowValueAsset
LiquidationValue
• The key is actual value versus expected value
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Four Key Objectives of Turnaround Process
Page 7
Turnaround Process - Four Key Objectives
Copyright 2014. All Rights Reserved.
Successful turnarounds are based on addressing both strategic and operational issues and by doing so, creating a new EBITDA engine. Only then can a new financial structure be put in place to match the new EBITDA engine.
4. Resolve Future Funding
2. Rebuild Stakeholder Support1. Take Control of the Situation
3. Fix the Business
• Financial restructuring• Strategic focus• Organizational change• Critical process improvements
• Crisis stabilization• Leadership
• Stakeholder management
Phases of the Turnaround Process
Four Key Objectives
Survival Phase Stability Phase Growth PhaseGrowth PhaseSurvival PhaseSurvival Phase Stability PhaseStability Phase Growth Phase
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Seven Essential Ingredients of Turnaround Process
Page 8
The Seven Essential Ingredients
Copyright 2014. All Rights Reserved.
To achieve the key objectives, there are seven essential ingredients.
Seven Key Ingredients Generic Turnaround Strategies
Crisis Stabilization • Take Control• Cash Management• Working Capital Reduction• Asset Reduction• Short-term Financing• First-step cost reduction
Leadership • “Critical Mass” of New Thinking• Potential Change of Senior Management
Stakeholder Support • Communications
Strategic Focus • Redefine Core Businesses• Divestment and Asset Reduction• Product-Market Refocusing• Downsizing• Outsourcing• Investment
Organizational Change • Structural Changes• Key People Changes• Improved Communications• Building Commitment and Capabilities• New Terms and Conditions of Employment
Critical Process Improvements • Improved Information and Control Systems (“Management Accounting”)• Improved Sales and Marketing• Cost Reduction• Quality Improvements• Improved Responsiveness
Financial Restructuring • Refinancing• Asset Reduction
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Page 9
Restructuring Framework
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Tools of the Trade
Page 10
• Situation Analysis – What is the initial understanding of the problem?
• Capital Structure Analysis – Who has the leverage?
• Liquidation Analysis – Again, who has the leverage?
• Viability Analysis – Is this a viable business?
• Strategic Alternatives – Status quo, Amendment, Refinance, Restructure and Sell
• Debt Capacity Analysis – How much new equity is needed?
• 13-Week Cash Flow Forecast – Can the Company keep operating?
• Financial Assessment – Projections – Is there value in the business?
• Liquidity Analysis – How do we get thru the next month?
• Covenant Analysis – What are the limitations in the credit agreement?
• Business Plan Review – Is there a valid recovery strategy?
• Operations Improvement – Is more needed than a financial restructuring?
• Bankruptcy as Strategy – Can we motivate creditors to cooperate?
• Restructuring Proposal – What is the plan?
• Feasibility Analysis – Will the plan work?To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.com
www.NTA-Riverbend.com
Analytical Framework For Cash Flow Evaluation
Page 11
©2002 ReeseMcMahon, L.L.C. 11
Analytical framework for cash flow evaluation
Historical Reconstruction Forward Projections Opportunities
RationalizationAdjustments
NormalizationAdjustments
SeparationAdjustments
Cash Flow Evaluation
RevenueEnhancement
Cost Reduction
Capital Redeployment
New customers existing productsNew products existing customersNew channelsNew pricingNew marketsNew product technologyChange focus of sales & marketing
New products existing methodsNew methods existing productsNew process technologyChange productionChange sourcingChange distributionChange sellingChange marketingChange administrationChange scale of operations
Reduce facilitiesReduce receivablesReduce inventoriesChange payables Reduce other assetsChange investment process
“Left Brain” “Right Brain”
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Rebuilding the Past
Page 12©2002 ReeseMcMahon, L.L.C. 20
Rebuilding the past
Reconstruct historical financials to reflect “left side” adjustments.
Unadjusted Historical
Rationalization Adjustments
Normalization Adjustments Separation
AdjustmentsValue added
Adjustment Layers
CashFlowValue
Observations:• Rationalization adjustments almost always add to value and can be very significant• Normalization adjustments usually add to value, but are often overestimated• Separation adjustments almost always subtract from value and are often underestimated
Change in value based on historical reconstruction
Value lost
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Projecting the Future
Page 13©2002 ReeseMcMahon, L.L.C. 27
Projecting the Future
Build on reconstructed historical to include “right side” adjustments.
ReconstructedHistorical
CostReduction
Value added
Adjustment Layers
CashFlowValue
Observations:• Cost reduction opportunities almost always add real value, but are often overestimated• Capital redeployment usually adds to value, but timing is usually underestimated• Revenue enhancements almost always are overestimated
Change in value over reconstructed historical
Capital Redeployment
Revenue Enhancements
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Crisis Stabilization – Mechanics of a 13-Week Cash Flow
Page 14
1) Crisis Stabilization – Mechanics of a 13-Week Cash Flow Projection
• Granular detail, “Direct” cash flow• Not GAAP cash flow statement (Indirect)• Not an “Excel model” but a comprehensive “process” that
must be used over an extended period of time– Must develop primary drivers of business and how to include in
model– Find historical data in accounting systems– Why . . . Why . . . Why . . .– Must be able to cost effectively pull actual results on a timely
basis from books for use in weekly variance analysis– Talk to management and staff not just at the top, but also
middle levels and “DOERS”
Copyright 2014. All Rights Reserved.To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.com
www.NTA-Riverbend.com
Crisis Stabilization – Example 13-Week Cash Flow
Page 15
1) Crisis Stabilization – Example 13-Week Forecast
Copyright 2014. All Rights Reserved.To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.com
www.NTA-Riverbend.com
Crisis Stabilization – Example 13-Week Cash Flow
Page 16
1) Crisis Stabilization – Example 13-Week Forecast
Copyright 2014. All Rights Reserved.To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.com
www.NTA-Riverbend.com
Page 17
Restructuring Alternatives
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Considerations of Constituents
Page 18
Objectives of Selected Constituents - Understanding various constituents’ behavior and reactions to the Company’s situation is critical to developing an effective alternative that achieves the Company’s goals
Constituency Objectives
Company / Board
▪ Preserve financial liquidity and business value
▪ Maximize value for all stakeholders
▪ Minimize cost, management distraction, process duration, and execution risk
Shareholders
▪ Create greatest likelihood for maximizing equity value
▪ Minimize dilution to equity
▪ Seek transaction with greatest market impact
Secured Lenders
▪ Preserve liquidity
▪ Monitor collateral
▪ Seek compensation for facilitating liquidity and taking a greater risk
Bondholders
▪ Gain influence over any restructuring process through coordination with other holders
▪ Maximize investment returns (short-term or long-term)
▪ Bondholders will otherwise seek to marginally improve and protect the value of their position, since mostholders mark to market; this allows broad solicitations to be effective when there is not significantconcentration among few holders
▪ Assess impact of subordination agreement on recoveries
Customers/Suppliers/Employees
▪ Minimize operational disruption to Company
▪ Avoid compromise of collective bargaining agreements or trade terms
▪ Often encourage de-levering transaction
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Definition of Insolvency
Page 19
Bankruptcy Code Defines Insolvency as a Balance Sheet test:
• When the value of liabilities is greater than fair value of all of the
assets (where “Fair Value” is undefined)
Outside of bankruptcy, a Capital Adequacy test covers:
• The inability to pay obligations as they come due
Both definitions are applicable and meaningful to distressed companies
Either form of insolvency typically leads to liquidation, unless the
company can be turned around, restructured or sold in a reasonable
amount of time
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.com
www.NTA-Riverbend.com
Restructuring Threshold Questions
Page 20To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.com
www.NTA-Riverbend.com
• Is the business worth saving?
• Is there a “Core” business to restructure around?
• Can the business be saved?
• Is the management team capable?
• Is the capital structure willing and able?
• Who is the “fulcrum security?”
• What level of new capital will be required to sustain thebusiness or finance a turnaround?
• Can a restructuring be accomplished out of bankruptcy court?
Understanding the Rules
Page 21
Claims and Absolute PriorityA company’s indentures and/or the bankruptcy code ranks a company’s claims to determine the order in which claims or a “class” of claims will be paid, if there is not enough money to pay all claims in full (the “absolute priority” rule)
• Administrative claims
• Expenses for lawyers, bankers, accountants, etc.
• Priority claims• Employee wages (earned but not paid for up to 180 days) up to $12,475 per employee
• Taxes owed to state or federal entities
• Secured claims
• Only to the extent of the value of the collateral
• Unsecured claims• Trade claims
• Deficiency claims (unsecured lenders)
• Bondholders
• Contingent claims (lawsuits, lease damage claims, etc.)
• Equity interests• Preferred stock
• Common stock
This is Traditional Bank Debt
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Negotiating With Creditors
Page 22To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.com
www.NTA-Riverbend.com15
Negotiations with creditors
• Understand Creditors’ Motives
Negotiate with insight…fluid and company-specific processes
• Reduce loan exposure via reducing advance rates, commitments or establishing reserves
• Reduce “downside” versus enhance “upside”
• Push for additional collateral, especially when making accommodations, loan waivers
• Call a loan default and negotiate a forbearance agreement
• Require company to hire a turnaround consultant and develop, execute turnaround plan
• Do not underestimate the importance of credibility
• Understanding Creditors’ Motives• Reduce loan exposure via reducing advance rates,
commitments or establishing reserves
• Reduce “downside” versus enhance “upside”
• Push for additional collateral, especially when makingaccommodations, loan waivers
• Call a loan default and negotiate a forbearance agreement
• Require company to hire a turnaround consultant anddevelop & execute a turnaround plan
• Credibility is critical
Find the Fulcrum Security
Page 23
• The fulcrum security is the highest-priority security in a capital structure to recover less than par value in a hypothetical restructuring
• Consequently, it is the one most likely to be converted into equity; and therefore, can be valued as an option on the equity of the restructured firm
• This is where “loan-to-own” investors look to invest in distressed companies• Knowing the fulcrum security often allows leverage to be applied to other constituents to get to
a successful restructuring
Liquidation Value of Assets 1st Lien Debt
Unsec. Debt
Equity
Fulcrum Security2nd Lien
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Potential Alternatives
Page 24
©2010 2
The typical scope of work will vary depending on the amount
of time available to complete the assessment and the amount
of detail/depth of analysis required to reach a conclusion. The
scope of work completed by the financial advisor in a strategic
assessment will typically include the following:
■ On-site visit and facility tour
■ Interviewing key management
■ Gathering information from company representatives
■ Utilizing projections created by management to analyze free cash fl ow (and developing upside and downside scenarios)
■ Identifying improvement opportunities to enhance value
■ Assessing the value of the company using various methodologies including:
i I precedent transactions ii I public company comparables iii I discounted cash fl ow iv I leveraged buyoutv I underlying asset value
Components of a Strategic Assessment ■ ■ ■
The analysis performed during a strategic assessment is generally
very detailed and meant to encompass all factors, both internal
and external, that influence the company’s future performance.
The crux of the advisor’s assessment will be an in-depth review
of internal/company-specific factors from both a qualitative and
quantitative perspective. Additionally, external factors will be
accounted for in terms of the overall economy, industry health,
financial markets, etc. Once all components have been analyzed,
conclusions and recommendations are derived as the various
available strategic alternatives and what the outcome will likely be
and how the various stakeholders are affected. Although strategic
assessments will vary depending on a company’s specific
situation, there are several key common areas of focus:
In terms of the quantitative analysis, facts are gathered relating
to the company’s financial performance that will illustrate if the
company is viable from a cash flow standpoint. Advisors will
spend a considerable amount of time concentrating in this area as
the conclusions drawn by the quantitative analysis will minimize
any subjectivity. On the qualitative front, one of the goals and
Pursue a Going Concern Sale
Invest Additional Capital
Refinance with Current / New
Lenders
File Bankruptcy and Pursue a Restructuring
LiquidateRestructure / Continue as a
Going Concern
Strategic Alternatives
Interference with Daily Operations HighLow
Distressed Middle Market Company
� Deep dive of historical and projected (pro forma) fi nancial performance
� Assessment of current and future booked business
� Cost structure / impact of restructuring efforts
� Asset base
� Valuation
� Operational strengths and weaknesses
� Product assessment
� Competitive advantages
� Assessment of key relationships with customers, vendors, and lenders
� Geographic presence
� Potential buyer universe
� Economic outlook
� Industry health
� Financial markets (equity, debt, and valuation trends)
� Raw material prices
� Geopolitical
Company Specifi c –
Quantitative
Company Specifi c –Qualitative
External
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Strategic
SaleNew Equity
Issuance
PIPE Investment
Exchange
OfferRights
Offering
CH. 11. 363 Sale
Reorganize in CH. 11
Borrow More Secured Debt
Potential Alternatives
Page 25
Illustrative Decision ProcessWhile enhancing financial liquidity is a key objective, it is also the means toward pursuing a more comprehensive solution. Having enough cash today does not preclude investigating alternatives such as those shown below, given the current situation and operating environment
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Page 26
Bankruptcy
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Bankruptcy Overview
Page 27
• Companies customarily seek protection under Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code for one or more of the following reasons• Company faces a serious liquidity problem and requires breathing room to operate its
business and reorganize its capital structure (considerations include unsecured and trade debt versus secured debt)
• Company has made a strategic determination to restructure its business and utilize benefits of various statutory provisions of Chapter 11 to implement its restructuring plan often through a prepackaged or pre-negotiated reorganization plan
• Company has recognized serious going-concern or stand-alone operational issues and will use the Chapter 11 process for business combination or divestiture purposes (including, in some instances, liquidation)
• A catastrophic event has occurred and is reasonably foreseeable (i.e., mass tort, fraud, serious environmental problems) and the Company must immediately seek protection from creditors
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Chapter 11 Alternatives
Page 28
Pre-Packaged Pre-Negotiated "Free Fall"
▪ Company and creditors agree to a planof reorganization to bankruptcy filing
- Plan is both negotiated andsolicited prior to filing
- Allows company to enter Chapter 11with a consensual plan that is notsubject to further negotiation
▪ Plan of reorganization can beconsummated on an expedited basisafter filing
▪ Avoids operational/legal risks andadministrative expenses of a longChapter 11 case
▪ Low risk of rejection of plan by court
▪ Debtor negotiates with creditors prior tobankruptcy but does not solicit creditorapproval until after filing
▪ Dissenting stakeholders in bankruptcymay delay confirmation or block plan
▪ Dissent may inhibit Company fromimplementing business plan
▪ Debtor follows normal Chapter 11procedures
▪ Debtor has no agreement with its creditorsfiling and negotiates with creditors while inChapter 11
- Plan filed during pendency of case
▪ Typically longer timetable and higheradministrative costs than prepacks / pre-
negotiated filings
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Bankruptcy Overview
Page 29
• Characteristics of U.S. Chapter 11 Bankruptcies (frequently referred to as a “reorganization” bankruptcy)
• The U.S. Bankruptcy Code is pro-debtor in its approach• Debtor remains in control of business under a Chapter 11 filing and operates as a going concern on a
“business as usual” basis (“debtor in possession” or “DIP”). Differs significantly from receivership-style
bankruptcies common in many European countries
• The U.S. bankruptcy code is designed to give the debtor the opportunity to reorganize in a manner that maximizes value to all stakeholders and preserves jobs• Debtor benefits from a “stay” of all claims and litigation
• Debtor often receives post-petition “DIP financing” to ensure continued operations of business
• Debtor has 120 days from date of bankruptcy filing to file a plan of reorganization. If the debtor
shows progress toward formulating a plan, this period is customarily extended by the court
• Code allows debtor to reject contracts and leases that have unfavorable economic terms. Liabilities
arising from the rejection of leases are limited by the bankruptcy code
• Code allows for orderly asset sales. The court employs several procedures designed to stimulate a
competitive bidding process
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.com
www.NTA-Riverbend.com
Bankruptcy Overview
Page 30
• Despite the benefits afforded a debtor by the bankruptcy process, bankruptcy can be expensive, litigious, and lengthy• Debtor pays for fees and expenses of all professionals subject to reasonableness standard
• Bankruptcy Code provides a forum for all stakeholders to be heard, resulting in potential for creditors to pursue litigation to extract “hold-up” value
• In contrast to a Chapter 11 “reorganization” Chapter 7 has as its primary end the liquidation of the estate• Business is shut down (not sold as a going concern as in a “Liquidating Chapter 11”)
• Trustee is appointed to locate and collect the property of the estate, to convert/reduce such property to cash and to make distributions to claimants in a prescribed order
• Debtor allowed to retain only “exempt” property
• Unpaid amounts on “dischargeable debts” are discharged
• In some instances, the Trustee may receive court authorization to operate the debtor’s business temporarily when doing so facilitates orderly liquidation
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Bankruptcy Overview
Page 31
Key Players in the Bankruptcy Process• Bankruptcy Judge
• U.S. Trustee
• The Debtor (in possession)
• Management
• Board of Directors
• Advisors
• Secured Lenders (if any) and their advisors
• Unsecured Creditors’ Committee and its advisors
• Equity Committee (to the extent there is a reasonable chance of recovery to thisclass of creditor)
• Unions
• Other parties-in-interest (landlords, taxing authorities, plaintiffs in litigation, etc.) and
their respective advisors
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Bankruptcy Overview – Plan of Reorganization
Page 32
PetitionAutomatic Stay
Continued Control by ManagementCommittees Form
Creditors’ MeetingPlan of ReorganizationDisclosure Statement
Voting and ConfirmationDischarge
Paying CreditorsDispute Resolution
Appeal
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Page 33
Overview of §363 Sales Process
• In addition to a plan of reorganization, Chapter 11 provides a forum for a
company to sell some or all assets free and clear of all liens and
encumbrances pursuant to a §363 sale process
• The filing of a “363” motion to sell assets places everyone on notice that the
Company’s assets are for sale and provides an opportunity for buyers to bid
and creditors to object; both are highly visible and objections are usually
resolved quickly
• To effect “363” sale, the Company only needs to substantiate a good
business reason for sale (e.g., that the business is deteriorating or that a
prompt sale is the best available means of preserving “going concern” value)
• In a sale of less than all assets, it is usually sufficient that the assets
are non-core
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.com
www.NTA-Riverbend.com
Page 34
Overview of §363 Sales Process
• Optimal vehicle to use when value of company is deteriorating rapidly
• Management can advance best interests of all stakeholders through the sale of
the debtor’s assets as a going concern
• The perception of the Debtor as having to sell assets may significantly depress price
that might be obtained for the business
• A “363” sale of all or substantially all of the Debtors’ assets requires support of
creditors whose money is at risk
• Makes it very difficult for those creditors who are “out of the money” to hold
up the process
• In general the court requires that:
• The Debtor has demonstrated good faith and the assets have has been
thoroughly shopped prior to filing
• Debtor’s assets are wasting or there are other compelling business reasons for
selling them
• “Fair” bidding process has occurred or is provided for in the proposed sale
process
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.com
www.NTA-Riverbend.com
Page 35
Overview of §363 Sales Process
Illustrative Timeline for Middle-Market 363 Process
Expedited Marketing
Process
Select Stalking Horse
Filing of Sale Motion
Bid Procedure
Competitive Bid
Deadline
Court Auction
Weeks 1-5 Weeks 6-7
Week 8 Week 11
Weeks 13-15
(competitive, but fast)
(typical)
(describes breakup fee, deposit
requirements and overbid amounts)
Closing
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Page 36
Overview of §363 Sales Process
• Marketing process is similar to that for non-distressed companies, though time pressure may be greater
• Limiting the initial buyer universe can accelerate the process, although fewer bidders may result in lower initial bids
• In some cases, there are relatively few easily identifiable potential purchasers
• Bids are solicited from parties showing the greatest interest and ability to move quickly
• Often, it is advantageous to sign up a "Stalking Horse" bid which represents the starting point for the auction process (required in mostbankruptcy sales)
• Stalking Horse bidders often receive a break-up fee in the event their bid is topped
• Typically, Courts approve break-up fees of approximately 3%, plus the reimbursement of expenses
• After parties conduct due diligence, the most attractive bid is selected, and an Asset Purchase Agreement is negotiated and signed
• An Asset Purchase Agreement is subject to Court approval, which will typically not be granted in the face of a better offer
• The Stalking Horse bid and procedures for the auction are submitted to the Court
• The Stalking Horse bidder often influences the bidding procedure terms
• The procedures lay out deadlines and the rules for bidding (such as the minimum bid above the Stalking Horse bid and the biddingincrements)
• They define what qualifies a bidder to participate in the auction process
• Often, a bidder is required to prove financial ability to execute a purchase by disclosing sources of funding and paying a deposit
•
• The auction takes place according to the bidding procedures established by the Court
• Typically, the auction takes place after an initial round of bidding limits the participants
• During the auction, bids are evaluated and the best bid is determined
• An Asset Purchase Agreement is signed and submitted to the Court for approval
• Following Court approval and fulfillment of closing conditions, the transaction closes
Market Assets
Select Stalking Horse Bidder
Establish Bidding Procedures and
Approve Breakup Fees
Conduct Auction
Receive Court Approval
Close Transaction
Sale
s Pr
oces
s
To learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.comwww.NTA-Riverbend.com
Page 37
Overview of §363 Sales Process
• Exclusivity periods
• No shop provisions (exclusivity)
• Termination provisions
• Bidding Procedures – creditors may participate in approving such procedures• Minimum overbids• Qualification of bidders (expression of interest, ability to perform, etc.)• Submission of initial bids (use of stalking horse’s form of APA, deposit often
required, bids irrevocable, firm offers)• Possible to condition commitment to proceed on court approval of bid
procedures• Break-up or topping fees, expense reimbursement
• Accelerated auction process
• Credit bid of claims
• Quick court approval of saleTo learn more please visit: www.DCF-LLC.com
www.NTA-Riverbend.com