UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work...
Transcript of UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work...
![Page 1: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
UNCLASSIFIED
AD 295. 094AD o
ARMED SERVICES TECHNICAL INFORMATION AGENCYARLINGTON HALL STATIONARLINGTON 12, VIRGINIA
UNCLASSIFIED
![Page 2: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
NOTICE: When government or other drawings, speci-fications or other data are used for any purposeother than in connection with a definitely relatedgovernment procurement operation, the U. S.Government thereby incurs no responsibility, nor anyobligation whatsoever; aad the fact that the Govern-ment may have formulated, furnished, or in any waysupplied the said drawings, specifications, or otherdata is not to be regarded by implication or other-wise as in any manner licensing the holder or anyother person or corporation, or conveying any rightsor permission to manufacture, use or sell anypatented invention that may in any way be relatedthereto.
![Page 3: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
1295 094,
I TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP2 AERIAL WAY 0 SYOSSET, NEW YORK
![Page 4: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
REPORT NO.
TRG0453-SR- 1
Submitted by:
TRG, Incorporated2 Aerial Way
Syosset, New York
LINEARIZED THEORY OF THE UNSTEADY NOTION
OF A PARTIALLY CAVITATED HYDROFOIL
Prepared under Contract Nonr 3434(00),pponsored under the Bureau of Ships
Fundamental Hydromechanics Research Program,Project S-4009 01 01,
technically administered bythe David Taylor Model Basin
Author: Approved: K-
Submitted to: AST"A
Commanding Officer and Direc nDavid Taylor Model Basin 3
Washington 7, D.C. 2.I
TtSIA A
Reproduction in whole or in part is permitted
for any purpose of the United States Goveruent.
March 1962
TICHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 5: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
List of Figures --------------------------------------------- ii
Acknowledgement --------------------------------------------- iii
Abstract ---eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeiv
INTRODUCT IONeeeeeeeee---- eee-------- ee------- eee------ e1
GENERAL STATEMENT OF PROBLEM -m ---- m -------- meeeee-eeeeeee4
STEADY STATE SOLUTION ---- m--------- Cc -------- e e e e e e e e e e9
UNSTEADY CASE ----------- m ------ M --- ft -- -- eeee eee eeee eee13
THE FORCE AND MOMEN ON THE HYDROFOIL-(UNSTEADY CASE) ------- 25
NUMERICAL ANALYSIS FOR UNSTEADY SOLUTION --- c---e--c ------ 30
APPENDIX ' * 30 03 * 40 04--m e -eeeeeeeeeeee- e eeeeee36
APPENDIX I I In 1 (a) , Jn (ax) c---e- e ee- en n ---- 64
APPENDIX III -Steady State Integrals --------------------- 67
APPENDIX IV -Condition (4) Integrals ----- e--- m ------ m---- 68
APPENDIX V -Force and Moment Terms -- ee-----------~ ec 75
~'k 'okAPPENDIX VI - *ko Ok' Ta 1 z- Tabulated --------- m ------ 94
B IBLIOGRAPHY e----- m ---eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeienc m - -100
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 6: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
LIST OF FIGURES
Page No.
FiLgure 1---------------------------------------------------------- 5Figure 2 --------------------- 26
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 7: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Acknowledgements are due to Professor Samuel Karp
for his assistance in clarifying the procedure for the
development of these results, to Messrs. Edward Grenning,
Edward Friedman, and Jacques Bresse for checking the calculations,
and to Mrs. Thelma Bourne for typing the report.
iii
TECHNICAL RESEARCH G.ROUP
![Page 8: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
ABS2&AC
A linearized theory for the unsteady motion of a
partially cavitated flat hydrofoil in two dimensions is carried
out. A second linearization procedure is ~sed, based on ideas
of Tiuunan and Guerat, to obtain the unsteady pressure distribu-
tion around the hydrofoil and the resulting force and moment,
as functions of the cavitation number and Strouhal number
for given pitch and/or heave.
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 9: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
NOMENCLATURE
normalized pressure (or acceleration potential) -
-a- , where p is the actual pressure and d is the density
a normalized cavity pressure. (cavitation number - al U2)
G Green's function for regular term for pressure
I one-half the length of the hydrofoil
c position of the rear end of the cavity (assuming hydrofoil
between -A and 1)
a velocity potential
U free strean velocity
v oscillation frequency
a ZA (reduced frequency)
M(t) slope of hydrofoil
B(t) y intercept of hydrofoil
f force perpendicular to hydrofoil
m moment on hydrofoil
v
TECHNICAL RESF.ARCH GROUP
![Page 10: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
HYDROELASTIC EFFECTS OF UNSTEADY MOTION"OF A HYDROFOIL
1. INTRODUCTION
In order to analyze the hydroelastic effects of
unsteady motion of a hydrofoil it is necessary to determine
the pressure distribution on the hydrofoil. The problem of
particular concern here is that of a partially cavitated hydro-
foil, experiencing simple harmonic oscillations in vertical
position (heaving) or angle of attack (pitching).
In order to solve this problem, it is first
necessary to determine the flow pattern around the oscillating
hydrofoil. Furthermore, in order to produce a solution rel'atively
quickly, it is desirable to make certain simplifying assumptionso
First a two-dimensional flow pattern will be assumed, i.e., the
hydrofoil will be assumed to have infinite Qpan. Secondly, the
fluid will be assumed infinite in all directions. Third, thickness
effects and initially, cauber effects will be neglected. Moreover,
the angle of attack will be assumed sufficiently small that
linearized theory may be used. Finally, the unsteady motion
will be assumed to consist of small oscillations around a steady
motion so that a 'second linearizatono may be made. Therefore,
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 11: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
2.
the flow pattern is assumed to fluctuate at the same frequency as
the hydrofoil oscillation, i.e., higher harmonics are neglected.
Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem.
In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the
problem have consequences which are physically unacceptable.
Guerst [l] has formulated the problem in such a way that this contra-
diction is resolved. However, he has not carried through the problem.
to any extent. In. our treatment, Timian's analytical machineii is
used throughout, but the physical assumptions used to determine
the unique solution are those of Guerst. Although Guerst's set
of conditions is not beyond question we felt it is the best
possible in the light of present knowledge.
To solve this problem, it was first necessary to obtain
a steady state solution by Timman's method. This was done, and
the result compared to that of Guerst (2]. Preliminary calculations
indicate complete agreement, except.. for discrepancies which can
be attributed to numerical inaccuracies (of less than 17) in
Gueratts calculations. Tiiuan's approach, as developed here,
gives much simpler closed-form expressions for the pressure and
velocity potentials than Guerst was able to obtain.
The next step in solving this problem was to develop
an explicit mathematical nepre'entation for the physical assumptions
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 12: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
3.
made. This was done, and resulted in six simultaneous linear
equations, involving six unknowns. The coefficients are functions
of reduced frequency and cavity length. Some of them are defined
by integrals which must be evaluated numerically. To do this a
program is being written for the IBM 7090, which will compute
these integrals as functions of the two parameters. The expressions
for pressure and velocity are simple combinations of these
coefficients and elementary functions.(see Section 4)
Finally the lift and moment of the hydrofoil were
calculated as linear functions of the above mentioned coefficients.
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 13: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
20 GENERAL STATEMENT OF PROBLEM
Timman has derived the general expression for the acceleration
potential t 1o be:
= - -i-f f(x',t)G(x',o,x,y)dx' + cl0I+c
2v wetted
surface
(see Figure 1).
In this expression c1 and c2 are functions of time which are
determined, together with the position of the rear end of the cavity,
by additional conditions given by the physical model used.
If h(x~t) profile of hydrofoil
then w(xt) ht +Uht x
and f(xt) wt+Uwx
For a flat plate, the above integration may be done explicitly. (See
Appendix I),
Let h - M(t)x+B(t) 0
Then w = M'x+B' +MU
and f = M"x+B"' +2M'U
Therefore
It -0 4- A 2 MF 2 - 1.(B 4 2M'U)F 1 + c 1 + c2 2
M". (B"'+2M'U), c 11 c2 are functions of t only. Fk' #k are harmonic
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 14: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
PlYSIC.L PLANE 5.
yflow
U =velocity
cavity c
hydrofoilz X'-Liy
IMAGE PLAN
image of end of cavity leading edge
cavity image
trailing edge imageimage
w /\2 2-a
r A-qt x axis image
4-i
ainJn
Figure 1
![Page 15: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
6.
functions of x and y in the plane slit along the hydrofoil.
Let ~-/f
where z - .x + iy
and - + .in
21 - length of hydrofoil
c - x-coordinate of rear end of cavity
Fk' *k (see Figure 1) are harmonic and rational functions of t and n
only, and are time dependent only through o.
The solution of the general problem requires specifying
three conditions to determine the three parameters Cl, c 2 , and a.
there are four conditions which may be used:
Boundary conditions (general)
(1) *(-) - 0
(2) 1y - w(x,t) on wetted surface, where I - the velocity potential.
(3) h(c,t) - h(-At) - f c 0I(X,O+,t - c dx' (closure)
(4) 1 y(X,0+t) + V y(X,0-,t), x > I (continuity of verticalcomponent of velocity)
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 16: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
7.
Conditions (1) and (2) seem quite satisfactory on physical
and mathematical grounds, so that the choice lies between (3) and (4).
For the steady state problem (4) is automatically satisfied so that
(3) is the only condition left. However in the unsteady problem,
the physics of the problem seem to us more reasonable if (4) is used
rather than (3). This is the view of Guerst, Wu and others, and this
approach is used here.
Using condition (1), and following Timman, we write
I=1 x 4u f + x Ck~ -x $~k k( )dx'
where
c4 = jt'2M", c3 -(B"+2M'U), $3 -F 1, *4 = F2
x 1 x 41 M,... dx, k f E dx'-k = kkky - k-l
But
4'k d*k 1 21k d ( t - - )
T4NICA R AC kc~~~ 4xk.l 'k)
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 17: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Therefore
f= c( k cst( -Y()dxj
y Ck(t)k(x,y,(t)k()k(X'
The harmonic functions are listed in Appendix VI, Table I
where those with subscripts 1 and 2 were derived by Timman and those
with subscripts 3 and 4 are calculated in Appendix I.
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 18: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
9.
3. STEADY STATE SOLUTION
Since c3 M C4 - 0, we have
- + c1 1 + c2#2
y-U (c,* + c2*2)
The boundary conditions become (1, 2, 3)
(1) ' CLA' - c2A +'a -0
(2) MU2 + + c2B - 0 ( - 0 on wetted surface)
(3) u2M(cj) c - (I - ,)da c2 + (-B)dz
where A and B are defined in Appendix VI.
If we substitute (2) in (3) we find
CC(3') c1 f - dx + c 2 ,f dx 0
Since x - £ 24)2
1+(t2 ) 2
and 1 - 0 on the cavity,
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 19: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
10.
(31) is replaced by
01 f dtd +c 2 o0 d -
ora* t2 + Q dt 2 U2 4242C, f 2 dt 2 22 dt 0
0 [l+(Q2 -) 21] 0 (1+ 240) 2
The integrals are evaluated in Appendix III and we obtain:
(3) (ja/+1+ 2) - + ( V/o'+l) C2 O
The solution of (1), (2), and (3*) is as follows:
Let p 2U2Ma
Consider the-.equation y3 .Y + p - 0
1T'hen a = (-y
C - y+
-p+i /4- P2 2
Let WT 2 0p2
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 20: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
11.
Then Y W AI/3 +
The only allowed roots are those which give positive y. In general
there are two solutions y1, Y2 where 1 ? yj > 0 and1
1 Y2 k r The only solution which is physically meanl gful
(see (2]) is given by yl.
Special Cases:
1) p2 4 y (apparently the maximu angle of attack for which
linearized theory will hold.)
y .. (2 positive roots identical)
I
c
.75 (cf. Geurst value of .7485)
2) p = 0 (no angle of attack)
S c
0 -s (no cavity, physically real solution)
1 0 A (cavity full length; anomalous)
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 21: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
12.
Since y is only an intermediate variable, it is of interest
to express everything in terms of a.
By solving a - - y), we obtain
Since p y y 3 we have
c 1 - -oB( +2) (. a+l - a)
C 2 M vB(q/0a21+1 + 1 - a2)
C 2 2
S-- -+ + )2
-u2 (v'r 5 + 2a +0
Therefore
C . U (a2 +1)(a+ 4o+1)
EcN C= E2CMB GU2+ P
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 22: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
13.
4. UNSTEADY CASE
The general expression for the velocity 1y is given by
= z cfk(t)*k(X'Y$Q(t))kf
1 d x xyxG t x )dxfU dt f :.Ck(t U ,)k ,yY(t-U"
Assume the time dependence is given by a small simple harmonicoscillation
around the steady state
= o + a 1 cos(vt-e0 )
ck = Cko + Ckl cos(vt'ek)
where a0, c10 , c20 are the steady state values.
Let M(t) = M° + M1 cos vt,
B(t) = B1 cos(1 t-OB)
where Mo Ml , Bl , 0B are all given quantities.
Then M'(t) = - vM1 sin vt
At M V- V 2M1 cosvt
-2B"(t) - B1 cos(Vt-0B)
c 3 -Vi(vB 1 cos (vt-8B) + 2MlU sin vt)
- vj(vBlcoseB cosvt + ( 2 M1U+vBl sin OB) sin vt)
1(vB)2.+ 4(M U)2+ 4vBM sin 0. coo(vt-tan'1 (tan + M1V 1VENU+ A E coSeRU))
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 23: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
14.
C3 0 -0
31 vsV(V3J ) +4(M1U) 2 +4VB U &in 9B
63 ta 1 (tan 0 + U
iB'Ecos %C4 -- 2 J2 M1 Cos vt
C40 0
a41 2 . 2Ml
94 .0
The problem is to find aI, C119 021, ell *20 ' *
We now carry out the second linearisationt
(Aover a symbol denotes the perturbation in that quantity Siven by the
symbol without the A)
Ck(t)#k(xzym(t)) - CkOk(yo) + CklCOs(vt-tk)#k(zLy .g.)
b k
ECHI RS(xyAC )ocoU(vt-9)
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 24: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
- *I 'P
15.
+ U Z k os (Vt-ek)*k(x'yt ) + kO yi Cost - )kni -0
V
x
U -jck sin - - ., ) k ('Y o)
+co# (xI s)a sin(v(t- dx']
The above integrations are carried out explicitly for the cases
where y - 0+ or y = 0", thus giving the vertical component of the pertur-
bation velocity along the hydrofoil. The steady state term has been
derived previously. Similarly the following equation gives the pertur-
bation term for the pressure distribution along the hydrofoil when y - 0+
or y =0":
A 4 k, (c ( kl co p (Vt -9 k)'k(x~'' o) + k0 -- al cos (Vt-ee)ak-l 0
6of lF@IP2 and are given in Appendix,7II, Table 1.0
of 03,l3p,4 and ?p are not needed since c3 0 -c 4 0 -0.
The boundary conditions (1), (2), (4) of Section 2 are explicitly given
as follows:
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 25: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
16.
Condition (1)
4z c k1COS{,vt-9k )4kc) + kO a k acos(vt-e a)) -O
k=1. 0
where the values at co of and, are given in Appendix V1, Table I..
Condition (2)
w M'x .+ BI' U(M-1M )
-xvMl 5 j0.- Bsair fVT-.) lJMc - .IyP B 1.
-xvM~ s -'r Vt + Um ±vB1 sin -,B) cosv-t -vB cose sin vt
~(X sL i-t -+/ t 4 o L -t I*
Therefore Condition (2) become~s
Uc,, sin + K o (vt-e3
4 x-XZ.3Cl1~ ~ Cl3~tk c~ Oa)sin(v(t- 'j)-V~dx 1
2 c)*k
+U -'k1 " U)ky-k, 0.
c -?k X',0,a )a Sin (.1"t- X.x)e)d0
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 26: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
17.
2 Xlie)x Ckl*k (OOOo) rcos(vt-e k-Cas(v(t---=)-8)
+ C kO ; (O,90o0)a, [Cos (It-%a)-cos'(t -24-4).9)
k c~ are constants along the wetted surface for kml,2].
This may be-simplified to
k 3 k kk + I sixiov t) UFU k)*k(x 0 )d)
2 Uk
Ick C- (x'O Czsin n.v(t dx
+ 7k-kO, U)O(~ kl±k 0) k
Uc1 -Cc
+= - aj- (j x in t + c~v~t) +.-x , sin (vtx1'k1'i
+Let (ks 0- PC ) Ckx o sinV (x'+9) - k t'
k1~ kU 0 U ko8 %)cos( 0(0 a Ocdz*'C *
-kc (As dein t usin Co t + ,sn v
TEHNCA AESEARC 3ROU
![Page 27: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
These integrals must be evaluated numerically.
The tanid -needed are listed in Appendix V1, Table V (in the form
6;k. 0 *
* ~ and the non-constant parts of anrd - defined in Appendix I)..0
Let
p - V(t - ),
x
W-f sin(p + - e3) ,(xo~l)dx
Ao~ + )(xe I+ Vdxtx
sV + 3) x'+ +71Uf cos(P + - 83
"+*-) -2 0U j~)csv- 3)+2 2 1
Then
x X
f sin(p +- X
= W *~3 (-2O_1 o)(C05(P + - 03)-O( - -3s
U -)cos (Vt-03)+ U ~.sin(t-9 3 -invt LU~~3j
+ UX+,SV*3 (-AIO-90 0)cos(v('t - j- 3)
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 28: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
xLet T =f sin(p + vx' )dx
2f sin(p + x'+A 2 __2
ucos(p + -w [(")2 L Xl~
v 229
+ 2 - COS(P + vlXJ
=1 U 21r x 2 2-A1
2 Cos (p + EX-j) -r
-+ 22Xlx
v I~ + ) -j sin Tp + T
T2xsn]+f i~ x dxl)]XI -2 -1
f x ws in(p + -)+ Asin (p -~ i + (csp-M) o~A v Co Up
Note that T -Cos (p + E-) *
Therefore
x
T -T )((AO Chos (p + 4x-csp!)
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 29: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
20.
U -_U 2 x U= - 4 (x,o ,%) cos vt + -- (_ sin vt + C7 Cos vt)
u 2 ) I+ -- (sin(p - Cos - cos-( + K (-Y,o- )%-c>v2A
Condition (2) then becomes
where s = t -U
0 Z Ckl [(Jks+*k(,o ao))COS(vSe k) + Jk, csin(vs-ek)]
+ aick0[(Js + k (-Io ,ao))cos(vs-e )+ Jksin(vs-9
-c -i(s9 +c Usnv) ( U) cos(vs))31 V 3 41 - n
Condition (4)
0= f cklin(v(s + U ) ek) [ k(x I,o+,%)-Pk( ' ,ao',1]k=l -1
x'in(v(s + .U+) ea 67P (x1 k +",oa)I dx'
Integration along the wetted surface in the z plane is equiva-
lent to integrating along the q axis ih the C plane. Similarly integrating
along the cavity surTace in the z plane is equivalent to integrating
along the g axis in the plane. Therefore (4) can be stated as follows:
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 30: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
21.
4 0 x'+ ( x+1. )*. Ixo
SCklsin(v(s + k ,)+ckoli7Jn(v(s + -'- d
1 0 X1 a~ '
+ c QklS.l(V(6+ +'),.a xto U0"
, Let k - non-constant part of *k' Since the above equation is
satisfied by the constant part, it is sufficient to consider only the
non-constant parts, which are given in Appendix VI, Tables III and IV, for the
wetted cavity surfaces respectively.
On inspection of these tables we see that along the wetted
surface # k and all equal 0 for k-l and 2. Furthermore for k-3 and 4,
*k on the wetted surface are both polynomials in x, while on the cavity
surface are equal to a quantity defined in Appendix I, plus the
same polynomials.
Therefore condition (4) can be simplified to the following:
0 = X f cc sin(vs )k lsin(vs 0 + (2 ) dj1 - kkPin-;Tck&ps. ] 2 "
where 1 = .(reduced. frequepcy)
P = + Q2 + a)2
and is replaced by * for k-3 and 4.
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 31: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
22.
LetIk,c ' f 0kCS) 2)( 2
Iks =00 ksin(2P) (Q2+a) d t
where is used instead of for k-3 and 4.
Let Ik s be the corresponding integrals involving 5--.
These integrals are reduced to infinite series in Appendix IV.
Then condition (4) can be stated
X ckl(Ikcsin(vs-9k) + Ik,scOS(vs-Ok))
* *+ lco(I* sin(vs-e) + I* cos(Vs-9 )). 01 °ikO( kc a k's. a
Since the conditions must hold for all time, each condition
is expressed as two linear equations, given by the coefficients of the
cosine and sine of vt or vs, respectively.
Let dk,c w cklcs Ok k - 1,4
dk s " CklSinA Qk
0 = 01co s ecs 1 sn Q
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 32: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
23.
Condition (1) becomes
4 C 1I d+Cko --1 Lk~c k~ o 0
4 (
x ssO~o + ckO (;? aJ -o0
Condition (2) becomes
x dk c +d ( + ?k(Io a )) + ck J* a~ ~ic dk~(k,s k ''0 k k,c c
+Ck c J + 'r (-I~o,a ))a]
4,
Jks k,c±+ dk,c(Jk,s + *k-~ ,ao))-CkO ik,c as
+ cko(Jk s + 0~-( A 0 % o)
+ 77d3 ,s - 77 c4,s + (V7 d4,c 0
Condition (4) becomes
4**
1 fdkcIk,c + dk,slk,s + CkOIkca + C~ks
x dk$6ik~ +d kclk,s -c kOikc 8 + C kOIksal
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 33: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
24.
After solving the above set of equations for dl,c, d1,89 d2 ,cs
d2 ,s' ac and a , we then can explicitly write the unsteady pressure
term as:
A 4kSZ dk'c'k + cCfko -a. ) j CosvtLkl 0C'
+ 4 C) 0 k
+ k: dk,sk + cas(ckO -) sinvtk-l 0
From this the unsteady lift and moment can be obtained.
These are explicitly developed in Section 5.
Since the closure condition was dropped from the calculation
it is of interest to obtain the cavity shape. To obtain the horizontal
component of velocity along the hydrofoil, needed for such a calculation,
we would have to evaluate certain integrals which are not otherwise
needed. Therefore the solution of this problem is postponed.
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 34: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
25.
5. THE FORCE AND MOMENT ON THE HYDROFOIL (UNSTEADY CASE)
Let g(xt) - *(x,Ot)- *(xO+,t). Since * - p)/d,
where d is the density, the pressure difference at each point x of
the hydrofoil at time t is given by -dg(xt). Thus She force f normal
to the foil and the moment m (around the leading edge) are given by
(see Figure 2):
f - -d f g(xt)dx
m - -d . (x +A)g(x,t)dx.
The lift - f cosP, where 1 is the angle of attack (given by cosp I ).
The moment m' around any other point x0 is given by:
m'(xo) - m (x0 +A)f.
ASince 4 = 4=0 + 0,
Aand since 0 can be expressed by
A* = *ccosA + i8sinvt
where 4 kc E dk ,c'k +O(CkO k
k-i '0
s '1ksk + as(ckO S-)
it follows that we can similarly resolve g(x,t) and the resultant f and m:
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 35: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
26.FORCE AND MOMENT
lif t
pivot aboutwhich themoment is taken
Force ()anid moment (in) are positive in direction of arrow.
Vigure 2
![Page 36: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
27.
g(xt) = go(x) + gC(x)cosvt + gs (x)sinvt
f - f0 + f cosvt + f sinvt
m - m° + mccosvt + msSinvt
For problems of heave alone or pitch alone, f is the magnitudeC
of the unsteady force in phase with the displacement (assume for heavealone, aB - 0), while -fs is the magnitude of the component of force in
phase with the velocity. Similarly mc and -m are the components of the
moment in phase with the displacement and velocity. We have
2go - k~l ckO(*k O)
k-l ck c -
9+ + ac - oo
a~~ dkS( 0+) +- s ckOk=l s'o 0
z+Let * = 2 k - *jk)dx
-2 f2 (x+1)(,0- - *j+)dx
and let R , S * be defined similarly using k instead of The integralsk k inta fk Teiterl
above can be considered as litte integrals (in the '(x,y) plane) ovek the
surface of the hydrofoil in a counter cl6ckwise direction. This is
equivalent to integrating (in the (4,n) plane - see Figure 1) from -aoto 0
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 37: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
283.
along the axis and then integrating from 0 to - along the 4 axis. Since
all k and ;a- are zero along the g axis, Rk. Sk, R and Sk can be
expressed by
R Rk 2 0f d k(O ld
0 3' (k0 ,T) i lk l
Ski (X+ t )*k( 0 ,9,n - diak d d-m
Rk and Sk are found by replacing *k by B0 in the above. Note that allI k dx-k' and d are odd, while x+ I is even as functions of T1. Forpurose o£ 0 neIpurposes Of integration:
1 '( -c 0) + 1
d cx. -8 1j(r1 -C ,1),01'2 " .. 00; . + 1) 2
The integratilons are carriLed out in Appendix V.2
+i. ' k-l
2
k-l
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP'
![Page 38: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
29.
Then -d2
fo = 2 F ckORkk=l
-d4
k=l
and m, mc, and ms defined similarly using Sk and Sa instead of
Rk and R . fI mo R , and S are calculated in Appendix V. The steadya 0a a
state terms are:
fo ="rdU2M (1 + F )
m = - 'd'A2UM (4+ 2 a( + a)2 )o ( 2+i3/2
J
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 39: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
30.
6. NUMERICAL ANALYSIS FOR UNSTEADY SOLUTION
The "I" integrals may be evaluated using the results of
Appendix IV, while the "J" integrals require direct numerical
integration, using Euler's methocd for increasing the rate of con-
vergence of alternating series. Given these integrals in terms of
a and 0, wne problem is reduced to solving the system:
Qv = q
where
Q Q1 Q2
and Q and Q2 are each 3 x 3 matrices:
40 (00) 0 2(W
Q= 1 *J1 (W) J 2 s- 2 () 0 *a(=)
lIs 12,s Ias
0 0 0
Q2 l ,c J2,c
I ,c 12,c IcaJ
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 40: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
where 31.
() - 1 2()a ckO adUMD0 1
() 1 2 Ok(00)=pa -= Z ckO ad
1 *ac = z c kOJk) c
Similarly J ' , and I are defined in terms of J I* The * * * k~ s kc'
and Ik,s* The vector v is (d15, d2 , as dlc, d2 ,.0 , aa) and the
vector q is given by:.
di, s~k(-)dkl k -
kc(Jk, c + a + k,s(Jk,s + -*k())
4 dkclkc + dk slksq- 2k-3 *,=()
3-k kc(ks + - k(.))-k: ,Jk c + I
THc ks Eks kRc
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 41: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
32.
where
UNM
d d ksk, sUNo
Since any solution to a problem of pitching and heaving can be
expressed as a combination (taking into account phase) of pitch
alone and heave alone, it is necessary to find only the solutions
for unit amplitude pitch alone and unit amplitude heave alone.
Let qp and qh be the unit pitch and heave vectors respectively,
given by M, - M° for pitch alone and BI = m° for heave alone.
For pitch alone:
c3 1 - - 2viM U - - 2n(Miit 2)
93 = r/2
c4 = - v 2I2 M1 . a 2(M1U2)
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 42: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
33.
Therefore (for MI - Mo)
+3 +- 0 3 ~c)
d * 023,cs
d 3) 2LB - - a2nU
d4,J c =_
d*3 - 0
d 0TS
n 2(j4, c + 1i) + 21l (J 3, s .3 3(0)
n 2 14, c + 2M 13, s
qP 02 04(')
n 2 (1 (c) - )~J4, s 77 *- 4( ) "2J3, c
a 214,s -2al3, c
For heave alorie:
=.V2 ..~ a 2( 1U2)c31 TB
9 3 -0
'41 -0
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 43: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
34.
Therefore (for BI= IM )
d* 23,c
d* = d* =d* =03 s 4,C 4,s
0
~20-. 2(J3,c
2- .l213, c
qh = 2
(J3, sa23,s
Let
vs = (dl s d2, a)
c = (d2, d2,ce)
and let vSIP V be the unit solutions for pitch alone andc,p
Vs,h, Vc,h the unit solutions .for heave alone. Let vs,h, vh
be the unit solutions for heave alone and e3 = r/2. Then
/ch = Vs,h and V, h = v c,h . The unit solution for heave alone
at an arbitrary phase 0B is given by
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 44: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
35.
Vs= VshCOSB + VchSin
vc , VC,hCOS B Vsh B
Therefore for unsteady pitch - MIcosvt and unsteady heave - Bicos(Vt-qB)
M1 BI
v rnv cos6 ins M 0 'sp + - (,h B + VhsOB
H1 BIO- + CO)
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 45: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
36.
APPENDIX I - 'P' 3) 40 04
Calculation of 4/31 031 44 04
A. General
0 f k--lk-2~dk 2rI - wettedsurface
Where G = Re(In(L. LUZ )
2-zcand - +Z - a
Along wetted surface C' is imaginary
and x = 21 2l+ (u 2-a)2
Therefore G =,I(u+C . ui-) since argument of In is apositive realu-ia c i
number. Ui
As a result, G = F(Q) + Q
-where F(Q) = In( )~tu-ic"
Since as a function of C~, the 0kare the imaginary parts of an analytic
function of C, where *kare the real parts, each *kcan be expressed as:
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 46: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
37.
k 21 (k " k)
Let Ht) 2iF(Q)
1Then G(Q) (HQ)
Therefore f - f xk 3 H(Q,iu) dxkri 2k wetted
surface
i x k-3 1n(U+iC)rlk-2 fu-ic"d
where f *k i~okbeing determined only up to an additive constant,
so that k -w 0
The wetted surface of the hydrofoil corresponds to the interval
f0,) of u,
-i 0 k-3 dx .uiTherefore f' f x k - x u i du
k ri 0
- (xk'2- ( )k'2) u+ 1(k-'2) ,rek'2 '--- j
i 00 k-2.+ i f°°xk'2 (_I)k- (u- 1 1-- du+(k-2)TrJk-7 0oTC U1
At u , x =-, in ("+- ) f 0u-ic
at u . x , a- 2 .n( u+i) ri
Sin ce is only known up to an additive constant, the first term for f
nvay be dropped.
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 47: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
38.
Let *k be the non-constant part of *k"1. 1 2ui+_
Since - - - , the integrand is even andUTiC u-ic
fk f f " above constant) can be represented by:
f __ r 2 k-2 _lk-2) 1 1 dk 2(k-2)r f +- 1) -(1 _ du
In particular:
3 f 1+(u 2 u2-_0) du
ff= f ( 2 2 2 2Ju.iu )du4 -L l+(U2 -2a)2 1+(u -a).2
Let t = A+Bi, A and B positive.
2where t = a + i
Then 1 + (u 2-) 2 = (u 2-t 2)(u 2-t )
Since C = +in, iC = -q+ie, where t > 0.
Therefore for purposes of determining residues to evaluate f3 and f4 by
contour integration, the upper half plane poles are t, -t, and iC.
Since 1 1 1 1(u2.t 2 ) (u2-t 2 t2.E2 (u2_t 2 u _
1- (_1 - 12 2 2_2 -T-- 2 )
T C Ou-t
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 48: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
39.
f4 3 2 f ( 2 2 +-2 duooQU -t u -t
f f - (. l ,1 -12 1d14 - ~ ~+ 2 2 2- I ici ~ d-. u'-t2 u2 (u -t )(u 2-t2 -
-i11 2 1 1.u u2.u 2 i
In addition to the general expressions, the following special
cases are desired
1) at x =-*(or f=B and T=i-A), * and ,
since the desired ?p is 0 at this point and the function must be adjusted
accordingly.
2) at = 0, (the wetted surface) * and
3) at i = 0, (the cavity surface), , and separated into odd and
even functions of e,
4) 12 2 +,(for Jk c and J integration)
B f3 Calculation
f11 l1 1(1 1 1 du3 2 2t ut u+t) 2E u-E u+t ui u-it
1 2 1 R -2 1 ]t~i~ i~t J~r
t F (t(-iC) ( t+r)
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 49: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
40.
t+ic 1 2 I A+Bi-Tn+it 2= (A-11) 2+ (B+t)2
t+i~t 12 .-iTli - (A+Tl) 2+ (B+t)2
t(t+i7C) -(A+Bi)(A+rn+i(B+4)) - AA,)BBt+(A+tBI
- al + A1I-Bt+i(l+At+BTI)
-(A-Bi) (A-Tj-i(B+t)) - 0 - A I-Bt-i(l+At-B1)
Therefore f 1= At- -i ! -B S+~(A-n)2 + (B+t)z (A+rT) + (B+t)
+ q-&T-BE _g______-___
(A-I) + B~t 2 (A+TI)2 + (B+t)2
Therefore ~- 1 1 +*3 (ATI)2 + B + 7t (A+YI) 2 + Bt2
22 2 221"- '1) + (B+t) (A+ij) + (B+t)
3 a-BE2 1 2- 'AT 21 2~ (A-TI + (B+t) 2 ( +Tj2 (B+t) 2 "
cl (+)1 (B+T)2 + (B (+t) 2
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 50: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
41.
Special cases
1) 3 + 1 +2) *3+ \4A+B2) 4B} 2 ~ 4(A 2+B 2 4B2
1 1
2(o2+1) 2 +( J'I -2 )2 c, + -1
= a 2
2(a2+1)( _ -a)
2 ''27
a, + + V,+
- +
21.7+1 4 f2+1(-
a 12 +
2(a +1)
V,;2
2(o 2+1)
1) (_____B1 q) 2 + -B2 22) +3 B2 + (A-r) 2 B (A+*q) 2i * B + (A-q) 2 B 2 (A*-n)
2(B 2+A 2+T2) - 4ABTI2.
lk,7 ((A2+B2+12) 2 - 4A2 2)
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 51: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
42.
273 2 2 1,4 _.2 2
2 x+j2 -a) +1
B +(A-n)+ 2 -2 A+ 1 7+- T-- B)+''
r 2- (2) 21) (4A, + 2A (P IOY + 11))
2AT-1(2a - . 21-T12)
1 2 2+1)
3) 2 (1-40 2
((B+) 2+A2)
2(1+At) ( 1 + e2 -2BQ)
= 2 " + t 2 +2B) ( + 2 -2B)
2 2A( 2 +1+ - -U+)
2 2 E
S(4 4-a 2 + I +2c 2 ) (( 2) 2 +1
C) 3
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 52: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
43.
where *• Q 2 +2 -h 3 [o a27+(1 + (e2 +c0),2
4 )Let D = ((A-TI) 2+ (B+t) 2) ((A+n) 2+(B+t) 2) (A2 -TI2 ) 2+(B+t ) 4+2 (B+ 2 (A2 + 2)
Substitute t 2 + 0 for j 2
D - (B+t) 4 + 2(B+ ) 2 (A 2+2 4a) + (A - - )
B4 +4B3 e +6B2 e2 +4B 3 +t 4 + 2(B 2 +2Bt+ 2 )( 2 + A2 )
+ A4 +2+ t4+ 2 jJ2.2A 2 A 2t2
c+l - +4Bt(o+ + (6B2+ 2o+ 2A2+2B2+2a-2A 2
+ 8BJ 2 + 4t4
=1 + 4BWcs Y+ 2 ~(4 clyJ) + Ut3+ 4t 4
2 ((I+At)( a2 +1 + 2t2 +a+2BE) - (e 2+a))
'(1+4(o + )2+i) + 4t2(10 +j) + 8B 3 +444)
2(2e2+ +1+ 2A,r1-ca)E +At(a +1+o +2 2 ))
T (1 + 4Bt (a + P2T++ + 422+ + 8B3 + 44
2(2t 2 + I7Y + At(3 4T1 - a) + 2A3)
TECHNICAL2 ESARt 3 t4O
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 53: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
44.
2 (k12 2 t-2-. 2 2f -
(1 + 4t2 T + 44)2 - 16B2 t2 (o + Z= + 2j2)2
2 = 4o2 4t4x+ 2
(1+4+2 0 + 4t (4+4 + 42. 1+4( - )+2 + 2)2
, (4t4 + 4t2 - 1)2 + 4(44+ 1 ( 1 )t2 + 1
+ 4(2( - )02 + 1)2
= (4+ 4c2 1)2 +4(2( 1 +1 _ cz02+ 1) (4t4 + .) 2)
= + 4i2 21)2+8 j2( 2-+1_-Q)( 2 a2+ +0) 2
2p I T-,-+ 2j ) 2 1+ 4e"...+46 --*3 2Ai + v
+ A((.3 a.-c+22 , )(1+4 l e2+44,- 4(FU -c)(o ct 2+t 2(2+22>
= 2 (x)2a2 +t2(2+4(o2+1) -2(3(o 2+1)-a 2 +2o/ ')
TECHNCAL +RSEA+R -OUP
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 54: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
45.
Co f Calculation2__ i "1 22
"- 1a2 -2 +- (u t2 t t u+
4 2 (u-) (u+t)2 6u
+ ( 1 _+ 1( + O + (
Le -1ir\ut) (u-t u+ \u-tY (uE
-7 +-)2 (-)u
FRC
TECH4 CA REEAC GROU
![Page 55: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
Let h* f 4ff* 46.
fi *)(~~(u-) 13 (4r-do 1uiv (4t. + it t-
-go (uE)45 2t t -t t+7t/
+(u-iC)(u+t) (4t t (t-
+ + . + L du
(4 (-t1\ (1i- 1+
= -- ++ ~ ~ +
=~ , 4 y Z3)i-i r4~ i itiy
1 4z t 1)
-M + n
+ E2 1_ ( -:.1 + 1 1z 1 d
+ 2(u+i) Ec i +C E+iC u+i "t d
Therefore - 1 ~1 + 1
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 56: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
47.
F t (ti) 2 t (tii
E-2 -i 2 t2 -ti)2
4(tt7 (t~ic(E~W 2 -im~iD 2
1 f[a-Arj-Ba-i(l+A-B~] ta+A~ -Be+i(l+A+Bi)1
4(a,21) L 9[ (A 2 + (B+) 2 + (A+TI)2 + (B+ .)21 2
1 _ rCaATI )2 -j1Ae-B)2 +_(____-_ E _- (1+AE+Bi) 2
4(a2 +) (A- q) 2+ (B+ )2)2 (A+T) 2+ (B+ )2)2
2(a2 +1) '.((A-ri)) + (B+ ) 2) 2 ((A+Tr') + (B+ ) 2)2
f 1 (a 2 _ +a(n 2 2 n, rE -2 E(A-iaB) +tifl (B -aA)
4(a 21) ((A-TI) 2 +(t 2 )2
(tT)2t(B4 ) 2) 2)
2_2i_(2a.+;2 (.A-B) E-2(aB*A)n-2a'E+'q a
4(az 2 + 1 ((A-TI) 2 4 (B+0 ) 2
-2a+2 (ciA-B) k+ a.A q2giE12
((~n 2+ (B+ t) 2 ) 2 2
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 57: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
48.
p t 7 +4(- 3 (tC
4(tE+) (ic(-i) + 17+~
-1 (ct21 /2 (A-i-n) + (B+e AT)2+(~ )2
4(a 2 +1) 3/2 (A-TI) 2 + (B+t) 2 + (A-i-r) 2 + (B+) 2
-i Afl+Be-2a-cS(AE-BTl) +Ari-Bk+2o-so(AM-,Bri
4(a 2+1) / 2 (A-ri) 2 + (B+t) 2 (A+r1) 2+ (B+V) 2
ti~e ((t~i) T-;t ) - JC (t_____
f 3 = 1 I ~ l-T1 + 1+AE+BI2 29+1 (A-l )2+ (Bt)2 (A+i)' + (B+t) 2
_____ a-ArI-BE ag+ATI-BE
2 +12i (Aq) 2 + (B+J) 2 (A+ri) 2+ (B+j)2
A =B( , 1+ a)
B =A( ]c21- a
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 58: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
49.
2 223/ 2 2 2
4 (a2 +1) 32(A-TI)2 + (B+ )2
2 2 - 12+1a
I(A+rl) 2+ (B+t)2
j-i (a+Ali(l1a 4ava +) + BEa j
4(a21) 3/2 N(A-TI) 2+ B 2
I-2c8-ATI(1-a a + Be (,_-a F j
(A+T )2 + (B+e)2
a 2 f a ( BTI+AE A -BT4 (a2+1) 34 (a 2+1) (A-Ti) 2+ (B+e) 2 (A+i) 2 + )
a + /a2 ~+1' B E+ An + fa24(a 2+1) \\(A-i) 2 + (B+t) 2 (A-Tlr) 2 + (B+ )2 /
Let r =q a 2 - f3((21jj 4( (a1))
* * a 2 -1 fIs + 2 34a +1)
Therefore f 4 = f + r + s
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 59: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
50.
Special Cases
1) Ref* o -1- (2 -1+22 + o -1+ 0 2 o 14 (o 2 +-)16 2+1 - .- 4( 2
. oT1 a ~2 ci
4(o2 +1) \4(o2i) 2
J 2 F2
1-0 * 0- a +1 +,+-16 (02+1) 8(o +1)
i. ______+___)
Re(s) or2 ~48(c2+1)
8(42 +1)
Re.,,/"- +) 7+1 21 r +2 )k4 (o +1) 2(c 2+1) 2 I T - ) /
2-t [- a 31 0)
2
3o (+1) / + " a
,22+1 028TE +1 )C HR
-22 2 2c( a ++ 0). 7o +1 -3o +1 -~ +
*4 4c 2 +1 (,2+1) 8(ci +1)3-4o+) 16(o +1)2 2
2 2_1
8(o 2 +1) 3284(o 2+1) 16(c *1)2
1(02 +____3/ + (21) 2+1)
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 60: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
51.
2~ + - 2 2 - t+a+aa4(a2 +1) 16,(ci 2+1)
2at + i - + a a a
! ~~4 8 (2+) a4.1 a 1~
8(o2+1) '7
41
IM(s)= - 204(a 2+1)/2
+21)4Fa2/r,+
82+1)2 r2
4 2 2 a- /8(a +1) 8(t+)4(0 +1)
* 1 (a2 1-i+.12 + 2q(B-oA) a 2 -1n22(B-)4(2)+1) \ ((A-) 2 +B) + 2nB,2
Re_,f) .2 2 2 2 + 2 2
M(-1) 2 + B2)(A.+T) 2 + B 2 ) B 4 + (A 2_-q2. 2 + 2B 2(A 2+1 2)
(a 2 + 1 + 4 . 22
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 61: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
2 2Re( *) a21+2n2 OTav+-l + q 22 +2 (L2+, +0)112 + 2"q(B'2A)4An( a'+1 * ,q2)
2 2 (+1) (602 +l+n1.0 2 2) 2.
2- 1+ 2) ( + 1 2(29+1+ +n+4n + A2)
o2~14012 2-___ 4___ 2__2-
2(0 +1)(M) 4 2_20n
2 222
* 1401
22
(o ) ( + 1) B (M+ ) +-
262l~2+l 42a+1) (+ ) + .20,m +1 )zc
2 2 2+ 2-(a+ .12)2 + " 2(~ a2+1 1) ( ++Ta 2 y
=4(o2+1)( (a+1+TI -2ot12 )
2
2- 2 2 2 4=c 22+10) a+l+ 2(o+2 ) o+ 2o
Re (a' ') , - 32+! 2 22 24(+1) ( (A-n) 2ta+ (+l
* ~ 2
2 4 214(a +1) 71 _240 +1
iTECHNICAL RESEARCH G;ROUP
![Page 62: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
53.
2 2*4 (a +1+,q 4_2ayi )2 a 2+1+rj4 -2cij2
1 x+2 2 x+j
Im (f) 1 2o - 2(A+Bo) i+Ti 2 2a+2 (A+Ba) TI+'l2 1
4(oc2+1) ((A-ri) 2+ B 2) 2 ((A+rh ) 2+ B22) 2
2 2 42 22(o +1) (T) -2al' +a 2+ 1)2
-(A+Bca)TI2 4 22
(ar t +1 ( 2Ia +1)r2?/i- (iBaiiYa)24 2 4+ 2
+ C(a +1) (TI -2ari + a02+1)2
= A( I02+1 + 2a)
lxn(f) = 2 22TI + 2ATI (ri 4 a c t47(2 +1) (TI 4_2ail 2 +0 +1) (a 2+1) (T 4 -2ol 2 -ta2 12
= 2 4 22 * +1 2 2*(o +1) (TI -124, (n-tal-a +) ~Yr2~i. 1)2
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 63: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
54.
Im(s) = l (0 +1 -A ;4(a2 1) \\ (A-n) 2+B 2 (AMn)2 + B 2
-- a (An y- 2)2T 0+
2 4 22
2 22
im~ (3~llAn( 2 Q1Ti n
~2(a +1) \ +(,_0T2 0 1
+4 2 ,1A, -2T(1 2o+ 2to +1
2_0 -o -- 7
2(oZ1+1/ (fI -20fl0 2+41)+1
2 22/24 22
2( +1)13/ (iio -2r 40o +1)1
a +,(T-4_20'12402+1
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 64: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
55.
3 1 a 2 -2 (AaB) )3 , \ (A2+(B+t)
r2 2 f2F2
= 2+1+4+ 2 2( 2 J"-) - 4B( l/' +2)
Rf*) (2-1.-2)422(2TYY+ -) , 02+1 ) +4 21 + 2)(-a vl- 2) .
2 4 22 2a(c +1 _ 2 ) 4 +1
+ 2(A-aB) (ci2+1+t +2t (2V - a1 + 1 2)
+ ~2a1 +a 2+ 2+1 2 -2
I= f 1 + O
2 + 1-o 2 2e2((22)2)( +- ( 2J)(.2-Ta+)fe2(o2+1) +2c,2.402+1) ( a+1) 4+2 a22+1)2
4 2 222( (2+) (4+2o~ 42.2+1) (c2+i)( +2cot 40+1)
2 2 2= 2 f4
( 2+ ( 2_2 2). L2+i (_4+) +,. o2+i)2
2(a +1)(t +2ot4 +1) +() Q2o +20+1)o+
a ( 2(+1 2 A2+(B+t)2 ,)at _ - 22
a( +1) t
T(-2 2 2
+2o 20 +21 Q +2t 0+)
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 65: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
56.
S* 28E 222
a(c +1) Q 4 +2a +0c +1)
S 3a 2 +1 2
) +2ot +a +1
2 -4a 2-4(pE +2ae 2 a 2+71) 2(02+j)(j 4+2aj2 402 +1)
(a +1)(Q +2a +0~ +1) 21
-1_a) (0o +(17+1 + 1- (-
_ ~(42-I) 2j~ _(1a 2+ ~) F2 2 +2 ( 2 1X2+1U)
(2+I) +21) e2+02+1)2+)
* A2s-2 4 22
s0 2 (a2+1)(e4 +2oe 2 +0 +1)
r* -(3o 2 1)o 4(a +1) *
2v F2 2 2 T 2 2 2fA7 (e4+2- a j) (oE -aia(1+2(~-a +1)) 3a +1)
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 66: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
57.
4) -4(o 2+1)f ((0 2_1-fa(TI 2~ 2 2t(A4oE))(D21q~)+D 2(-TI))
D1(Ti)D 1(-1)
2 2+ 2ij(Q+B-oA) (D 1(TI) -D1 (-TO))
where
D2() A 2 j2 (BO2 2)2
122 2 2 2 2 2+2-(A: + Y +(B+4) ) + 4A 11 +4ATI (A +1+(B+t))
-2(a +) f * 1 ((o_1 Ao)( ~ +
+ 2( 0 +1+ cl)(Q 4a)) + 8Q4)QB-A +-02+Bt
Di (71)D I(-TO) . (J2+ +o+2t 2 +2BW+AI) ( cl+1 ++2t+2Bt-24Tl)
- o (J~+ +22 +2Bt) 2 -2(I +1+)(t2+0)
- 8B +4m+ t2 +4(To'+G +)Bt+1
222o -1-2(B) 42
D 1 (TI)D 1 (-Yl) DI T)1(n
+ 2(t 0( +% 2tlo( + o)
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 67: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
58.
2 2 2_-1 -2t(A4clB) 4(tam 2 (12( GcB)-2(a +1)f - +2 2 o12(Pi+)tD T) () D 1 (tI)D 1 (- 1)
2o 2 1-2t(MB) + (2_o 2
D (nD (T)) D2 (r)D 1(2
4o2 #(CM 0 ) 43j+B~,Q-.-- ~ +--~ 24 2 a ( 4 o B)t+
22 1-2t(A4*B)+4+4( o Y1o)BE
D 1(TI)D 1 (-Yl)
432 22+ 2 (-6Bt +Bo-4+1 t +(G +L +AG 2o)Bt-o) l
D 1 (rI)D1 (-)
2o ~ TCHIA R2_AC 1-2GROUP44( + 0
![Page 68: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
59.
-2(a 2+1) f 2o12(-a)4 ++)E2~ioD 1 (71)D 1 (-11)
242(24 3_ cg2 20B+ 2D- (T) - &~-2B4
2 Iik21 (4B (vi.r a~ - +2I (1_) e2
+ (1+2o(c-fo2Y))EC-S'
-- 1-2o~o+ T+ 2 BE,
+ I.4 MtB +(2Y Y.)2+1-* a4 +-30)Bt- GQ~ja ))
Let D1 (TI)D 1(-q) - D(
2( jf = 2P+1(Be-ca)-l 2 (4Bg3+22~.LG~
D2 ") D 2()D 2(-g) -
+ 2(([1_0c) -2)Bt- Di 7 jza)lD 2(-_0
2Ji72T090)1 44D2 (-t) 2- 2 (2B4 -at-2cz)
2")2 2)4
D 2 (-4) -D 2 (4)- 16B 3 _8 ();+c,+) B
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 69: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
60.
-2(a2+1) f* 2,,- 2iiB.K) -1 i (B 2-- c
32B 2(2E2+~iI) 2+ -(2 9++)-(2Bt -cst-2oB)
D 4 2+B-e (9)DThu(2+~*) 42~
22 2"
= L
+ ~ (ovlo (4 (4C,-B(~i~c)
2 2
N 32t(2t + 0 1 TECH(NICAL_0 tE2AC GR~tOUPF1-
![Page 70: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
61.
N 1 + N 2 16( 0 10(2D2 )4t2
-~~ +6((_0-) t -Bt)D 2 ("))
-2(o +1)f __ ___
+ 4tK (2£-a£-2sB) -2(2i+-a) (4£2+2B-)+16 (;2Tia) £2_-a)
2- 2
Let Q .14t 4 +±o 2
-2( +1) f*Q 2 -Q(292TiB-2j 1i-t)+2 2Y(-4(foi-*) t4
-2 2 t34
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 71: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
62.
+ 4;+(m+ )t4(21
4o) *1 1 1 1
A( + D(T)+ B(1(T D
22 +1) At 0-102 2E+ 40
2AA +2g AT710 4
2(02+1)D*20
(U (A3 +2t 2+A(TM2+u) t~)18684
+ (8 (4*Y-u) -8((4GTY-. 0)) t4+(4A.-8A+..-SOB)t3
(44( ri-c)-2(a i40) 22t
+ (24faTY40l)-4Qx)Ag+2o
-(2M3+22 +A(lT+,i4) t4)Q-8t 6-8Be-16mt4 _8m~t3
+ (2-8a 2)t ~2+2(4s~l-)At+2o
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 72: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
63.
2 3 4 2 22(+)*2-(2A +(A4o14)-21-R44a)Q-8at _80 t +(29o +-a)A-2B)t+2oa
-(2.4 3+3-cTlA-
2(o 2+1) (f + s AQ 2 Mt3-(c-G+~A2121)t0 12(21
;Y-t 8 2 04~iI2a14)At+4(2+1)
(2Aot +(( +
4 4/1 g~)At+4(021)
2 (302 r O 1) 1(1 ---- (+~.)A)
2( ~ 2 O 2(21o3 2 0(3m 2 +1))A
+)3( +1) r ~
2( -)4 (2 (cs73I21 -± P_ At3+ H(72+) _,At
+ (0+) Q~~(243(~iG +)4(02+1)
TECHNICAL- RESEl(ARC GROUP)A
![Page 73: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
64.
APPENDIX II -I n(a), Jn(a)
Let duLet 1 ( 0) f m® -
u2 dLet () f du
where P(uo) - 1 + (u 2+a) 2
P= P1 = 4u(u2 +a)
Integrate by parts
I -nf -s-P' duIn = n p d
ca 2 2 + ) d4n f u2 (u +a) du- P pn+l
u2 (u 2 + a) =P- u2 _ 1 2
ThereforeIn I ,,(1 2)4'n In' an+I - (la n+l
or
(1- n~) =In , Jn+l+ (1+ )ln+l
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 74: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/74.jpg)
65.
FinallyS 3
Jn 3 f -n'_ ' du
Therefore
W J + 2 - 2 2 u2 (u2 0) du4n " n n (++l
Since
U 2(U2"40)du = n_ n+l 4n
and
(140 )I (1 - -
(ltt)n+1 = ( f -) n - tn+1
therefore3 CAI
(1 - fn)Jn ,, Jn+1 + 4
For recursion purposes
Jn+l = - 4 + (1 -n)Jn
11n+1 THC2 REn-A)n - Jn+G)
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 75: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/75.jpg)
66.
n - 1 Determination
P - (u-z) (u-) (u+z) (u)
Where z and - are in the upper half plane, and z2 -G+i
7 (u-z) u+ Q dz - 0f dzw
Therefore J " z zI = 0
i.e. J = 1 -I eO
f du
(u 2z 2)(u2-Z)
I 21. 1
Since z2 22 222
Ii 1
T(Z+Z)2 zi2za -z
Ii (,.a) - ira1
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 76: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/76.jpg)
67.
APPENDIX III - Steady State Integrals
Let L.k(0) - f* x2(k-1) x 2 ) dx
where P - P(xa) is defined in Appendix II.
We wish to evaluate L1 and L2 .
Using Appendix II and suppressing the argument a in Lk, Ik, Jk"
L1 = J 2 +a1 2
+ 3112 1J + -f (-- " aJ2 )
2 21fa 4(l+ 2 )
-aI J 3cI1
4(1+a 2 ) 4(1+a ) 4(1+t 2)
2a + V0+1
4(l+ ) 1
rB 2a
4- + 2r (1 24(lic )
IiL2 4
VB
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 77: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/77.jpg)
68.
APPENDIX IV - Condition (4) Intezrals
Let P( ,) be defined as in appendix II.
Let M Im "f -cos ( d
.o pmP1 (22) 2nf d
(_ 1)n(2.) 2n
0 (2n) ! i2n+m0
Let
N Co dNC m = Pm
0(_l)n(2a) 2n
= (2n)! J 2 n+m0
Let
M, =f - sin (2-) d
00(_. n (2,) 2n + l
= (2n+l) 2n+l+m0
Let~~22
N 8 , _ Lm sin ( dt
.1 n (2,.2n+10T (2n+1) : 2 n+l+m
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 78: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/78.jpg)
69.
1,c f Ef pd-v p
n22
(2n (J J o-0, (2 2n(2n+2- o2n+2)
n 2) n+- (+r (J 2n+3 "4GtI 2
n+3 )
= z ' (2 )OD 2 2.t
I2, t Q 40 C os 2n d
09(-Qln(20 2n 2 Q2 dt
0
Sii.lar ly E . 1n( ) 2 n+1 In+21 2 8 - Z (2nl)! 2n+2
0
1 00 2 2
Ii'c - ot 2"
M + Fi-rCos2ndt2 c22f2 Pt
TEP
m~Mc+ofdP~ d0d1 2fl1 dP dt
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 79: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/79.jpg)
70.
Since P - ( 2) + 2a(Q 2 ) + +1
dP 24 2 + 2o
d 1 2 2 +2f
P- PI- P- p -w -
Therefore
* Q 40)2" in) Cos 2n-c T 2+ 3 (a. o-) dt
PI
" Mc.2 + 40 [n(Ns,4 " M 9,4) ' Nc, 3 +°c,3)]
22S(-l)n(2) 2
2 0 (2n)! I2m+2
1 n(2n)2n+2 2n+2
+ 4a(P (2+l)! (J 2n+54I 2n+5)' 2n+20
0 42n)l ! (2n+3 + *I23- 2nI
S (2n) 2n+2 - 4o (n+l) (J2 n+3 +01
an+1 +m M2+l 0(1 ' n)In-I+1 n -2t,
I* . ( j')( 2m) 2f1 1,c o~ (2) ! (( 4n+4 )I 2 +3 - (4n+3)i2n+ 2)
TICHNICAL RIESARCH GROUP
![Page 80: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/80.jpg)
71.
40fs sin iT
=ll MS4 + . p
2ms,2 +0 f ( sin T)( *2a)dA
1 co (a2 4)( n 2d 21 m s,2 _ -- p3 cos - + sin
1 • . Ms,2 _ c,4 +cMc,4 ) +Ms, 3 + c 3
1 (-n+n(2, 2 n+ l
(2n+l)! I 2n+3
._ - 4a[ Z (23)' (J 2n 4. + 2n+4)" 2n+L0
n (2n+1
+ £ (2n+1) ! (J2n+4 + 012n-4)]0
0 1 2n+ 2n1 2n+3)I- ~ -4o(n + f(1~2n+4 + 4
. l)! 2n )4n+n n) 2n+l1 2n+3 3___1
(2n-) - 4(n + 1)(- 12 4(2n+3)212n+3 2+)0
(-) 21 2n+1 (4+)(2n+1)! 2n+4" (4n+5)12n+3)
112, c 2 - l,c
2, s = - l1,s
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 81: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/81.jpg)
72.
Let E - 2oc, +1
22(Q2"Q(2+E) cos 2 dI3,c -= " 2 22
2 A vp (.1) n(2n) 2n A.2 2 -1)(Q 2+E)E (2) ! 2+3 dt
2A a -1 2n W2+ El2~
z 2n! 4(2n+2 + 4(2n+2)
Q (2n) 2 n J2n+2 2 l 2n+2)
E - £ (2n) ! 2n+2
Similarly
A 1 (-1)(2n)2n+ l W3 2n+3 + (2a a-2+l)I 2n+ 3
3,s (2n+l) 2n+37 0
22Let F =a 2p+1- 2( 2+1)
= 2A 2 2 40 ) (12+E) 2n' (
I4,c 4 2A o d
A e Q22 to ) 2+
2 - Cs d 3M 2+1-3c2(a +1) _ P - 4(p +1)
- U1 + U2 + U3
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 82: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/82.jpg)
73.
2n 2 2 2U1 2A (-ln)", 2 n Q 2 40) (a2+E) dt0 o (2n) . 00 p 2n+4
2A (-1(2f) 2 (2n+3 EI 2 n+3
S(2n) 4(2n+3) + 4(2+3)- -
A 00 (_l)n(2,) 2 n o [2(
2 2(02+1) o 2n! _ 2n+3
A c(- 1 )2n(2fl) 2 n 3o2n+2 F12n+2S2(ct2+1) 2n! "4(2n+2) - 4(2n+2))
U3 2 "(! 2n+2 + 2n+2"
8(a +1) 3/a2U2 -U3 m +A 2 _, .)n(2 2 n .
A ~, 2nU2 +U) (2+2 (3(c 2s+1" (30 2+1))J 2 n+22 3 8( (2+1) 3 / 2 0o2)(n+)2+
- (Fi[i+ + (3m 2+1)E)12n+ 2 )
F 2C+i+ (3o 2 +1)E =a(12+1) - 2(o2+1)4a2+1 + (352+1) (2a-a2+)
2 2
=l (7d2+3) - a +1 (5c,2+ 3)
4,c 8 2 I 3 / 2 o (2n)! "2n+2 " 2 +
(5%2+,3g+l _ cl(7,m2+3)1
+ 2n+2 2n+2
4(02+1). 2+),23)
+ 2n+3 (W 2n+3 + (2c&
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 83: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/83.jpg)
74.
Similarly
A (-in(2,)2n+l 3(o (302+1))s 3/(2n+). .2n+3 2n+314s 8 (c2!+.) 3 / ..
+ 502 +3) 12 +1- 0(7m2+3)+ 2n+3 I2n+3
4(o2 +1) a 2n++)T N2n+4 R C2n+4 GROUP
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 84: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/84.jpg)
75.
APPENDIX V - Force and Mmnent Terms
Part 1.
LdxLet Rk a f 0 k 2- dT
Rk -kSdx,a Tdil
S dx d
sk - (x+1 ,k d d-0
* sk dxSk - - + ) 77-
Let P . P(Ti,-o) - 1 + (2a)2 (See Appendix II)
-81 f nL 20 d~j1 00 P 2
1 81 (J2(-a)-aI2(-))
Henceforth we will suppress -o in in and In
311
2 l +ci
14EO
R- 21 2o 2-
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 85: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/85.jpg)
76.
* r TI2"-41 1 d OT
2m T -P, 11 I P
fTIP TIP.2 -2 .T
--8 2 !I0 dTj
- -8(J 3-1 3 )
R- -41(12 + 8o(J 3 - GI3))
013 - -i (aj 3 + 8 12)
3 ] 52 +012
R - -41 (12 + c' (5J 2 - 6a12))
6o2, .1-5a 2 31T 1- -(1- 6+-Q0 - 2 (1 o2 2 2+4
1-a2 %J60 01(5 + + - (1 +.2 1.2 "2 (.2)2 + -)
i4CL 140o (i14o )
R 2*3a 1-3m2
R1 2-J ((.23/2 2 (.22 1
(14Go) (140O)
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 86: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/86.jpg)
77.
R 2 =-88 f ,L2(, 2. dj- .e P2
= -21I
. 1R - R,
= 2a 40l0 R2 2
.. ~~~~ 3 . _A ,f 2(.q2-G) (,q2-E)
~09
where E -29 _-O+
16AJ 3
E - G + I8(10: 2)
(3 CE 3(' 2 "GE C&I i1~-)J (T.. + -i-)
8(14a2) 8(1.40
2) 4
AR 2 2 2R.3 -7 ((3(1a)"- E)J1 + (3c(1-*a2)-(2+3)E)I1 )
2(1lto2)
(01J1+ (c 2+ 3)11)E - Toh+ / + a+2+ 3)(2- PM+l)Ii
- (2( 2+3),-(a2 ) (23))I1
- ((2 +5)+ (2-3))I1
2 2)[213(14a (J1 1 I1) - 3(1i t a2 ) l
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 87: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/87.jpg)
78.
All 1 ( 2 f7R 3 (2m -2) + /C,+1 (202+6))
UIL~I~2) 2 W 1) +/i (i+3))2(14o )" r 2.a22 2 2 2 T
2(1403)2 (a 2(21) + (a 2+')(a2+3) + a 1 a+ 1 ( 20 2 +2))
A , 2, 2m+ 3m2 2o(a2+1)3/2)2(142)
' 16AJ 20) -n 2- d
4A1
+ R+
(c,2+i) -t p3 4(c +1)
where F -a 7,+- 2(14a2)
16 J 3 El 3 4AI 3oJ2 Fl 2 o12+I2it+++ '+ " -"+" ( -"T/ + ("i-- +-5:--<-,T-+.,W) + 1 4 8 (c,2+1)
- 1 + T2 + T3
El 3 E 7
- 12(1-2 ) 3 8 ( '2)
12 (14 12(1 )
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 88: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/88.jpg)
79.
2__3/_ 2 2 2 )T1 6(1+ct2)3/2 (5(3(1+cB2)- cE)J 2 + (3cs(1+a 2 ) - E~co2+7))12)
A6 ((1 -i
T +T A - ((9(O+I+3 5(3(1+a2 -E))a12 6(14o ) /
+03(A -. F+ o(1+o2)) - E(ok2+7))12 )
-22
9 + +5(3(1+ -2OE) 14oq + 5(o 2 +3)
3(J7l I .(11)) - +(2 +7)=3(2,(1+ 2 ) - 2(1+a2)3/2)+( 2 )(2+7)
2o (22-4) + I+ (1-5o 2)
2_2 cf 2 311VT3 1
(2o(2a 4)+ cl +(1_50a2)),I2 - 2+ vj(1i ( 2 +o +1
2,2( 2_ (152))
(14afa+1 + 5(a 2+3) + 4 22 +1 2
9 + 12a 2 + 15 + T T+(9 0 2+ 15) (T +1
- a2+i
+T (04 21 2((235/ + 4a~t + 5 + a +1 (302+5))J1- 8(140 )5/2
+ (a(3a4 + 8c 2 -3) + f (3a 4 + 1)),1)AJI 1 4 2f2
- 1 (60 + 16a2 + 2) + C2+1 (64 +402 +6))8(.Z)5/2
8(1+0)
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 89: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/89.jpg)
80,
-(3a2 +1)AI 1 2 2) + (22+-" 3 ( 5/ 2" +
.8 .t25/2 (a(6 4 - 2) "AmI .12 (2 +) 2 + )
-All 1 4 2 (64+2+)(o7~ ((6cs _4a - 2) + T+ 6 0 )
Alil1 2 2R4 2 5/2 (o(20a + 4) - 16oa2 +1)
8(14+0)
. S c, +,) (16,2(,. , ii+) + r,(2+1))
16(14o2 )3
n-i 222 3 (00 ct+l)(c +1 + ot) -' 4 2 )
4(1-ta2)
2 .R - Z kRk
*3iaBI 1 2 2- ---- (2(o 0+1) + 1 3 )'F+1 a)
a 1
c 3RoBI1 ((5-2+1) + [o+ (1 - 2))
20 23
aBl l 2 2c2R = (2a - 3o ( + + 1 -30 2 )
N +1
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 90: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/90.jpg)
81.
R aBlI 1 2 2 2R= 2 (a(12a +4) + a +1 (2- 12a))
2 3/2 (a (6a2+2) + a (1- 62))(a +1)
2- -U27r (J 2 +) 2 (1- 2)( 2-i) + 3a )
-u Mir 2(-6aaa (a2+1) 3/2 (a +1+a)
2-U M2r (fa2+ + aii) a2+3 F 1a(a 2+1) 3/2
a (a2 +) 3/2a j
S1 = 1612 f 2 3a d I
= 162 (J 3 - a13 )
_e3 = -a( 73 2 (8 2 + aJ3 )
222 2
a5 J21--8-2(i- 2+ )3 -° 2 8 + -
SI -+0 (2 2 - 6a12 )
32 212J22 R 1- 2
2(1ra2 ) l+a
3= 32 1 2a \ I 2 (2+1 + c) 1i322 1 2a 22 2 4_j )
= 2 1 a 3 6a
2 + - 2(+ 2 ) (+2)3/2 + 22
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 91: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/91.jpg)
82.
SI = -8 f d2 3d
=8 82(1 -a f~ .4l3)-3 23 P
f ]-3 3 -i-0 1 P -l 0- TIP
=-12 f (12-_)di
P 4
* 2SI = -812 (13 + l2ct(J4 - 044))
-a4 _ -a 11
4 +a2 (2 13 + aJ4)
:2 1 a 3
* + 2 a Z2(-
S= -82 2 (1 + -l 2 (9J - lomi))2 4 3 3
-98 2 s . .. 1 32(1-a2 140 3
1 1 713 i 2 (t712 + aj 3)
1 (7+021-2 2 + 8 J2)
S+a2 3(7-ia)12 _ 2 (t 1 + aJ 2)
17IA
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 92: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/92.jpg)
83.
(5+7-Fa2 a2 a J
a J(5 + 7=2aJ 6(1 2)+(4 +"--
1. 2 2l2 2
3 1 2( 2 (6(2+a2 )aJ 1 + (3(7+a) + 6a 2(2+a2))l)32(1--c )
-3 2 7- 2 4
32(1-+ac (2(22+a2 ) a\a+1 + 7+5 + 2a
S* 121 [ 92 + 1 3 6a)- 2(1-a 2 2 1i2-2 2(1i+a2) (1+a2) 3 / 2 (1+a 2)
32 (2(2+a 2 )a Va+1 + 7 + 5a2 +4(1i c)
3i (3 (1 - 2 ) 3 /2+3 2(1i- 22) '18 a l 2 2" 2 3/2" Fi - ,2
4 1a2 43 1a+6 _2 1a2
-7 - 5a 2 - 2a 4)
- 2)1 (a (lgaa 2 )3 / 2 - 20 TI 2 - 7 + 34a2 + a 4 )
4(1iac2 )3
S2 -16 2 f OD 23 dq2 - p
- 21 1
-2 31I-2 + aJ2)
S= 2
2(i1+ac2) ((3+a 2 )1 + aJ, )
= _ 2 22i (3 + + a + )Ii
2 C( I+ H
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 93: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/93.jpg)
84.
* i 's 2 -- " s
2 1 3 6a2 ( + 3 / 2 +22 2 /i 2(-) ('-*) "("1+oi) 2
2 +a- 2rj
= 32A.2 2-a) (T2_E) dS3 fa 2V+1 . p 4
32AA2 J 3 El 332A 1 (. -4)
= 2T 1 (See R4 )
A12 3/2 (5(3(1+2 )-aE)J 2 + (3a(l-a )-E(a 2+7))12)
(3a(l-a 2 ) -E (a +7))1 2 (3a E(a 2 + 7))(._1._ €j2E = 2 42+2
(15(15+a 2)-5aE+3a 2 Ee+)J 2 = (15+ 18a 2 + 4i) 1
A +1 2 1 1+1 -
s= -, (3a+(5+6a2) (a+ +j) E (c&2+7+2a(c 2+2) (cc+ [a2+)))4(ia) 3 / 2 a 2+1
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 94: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/94.jpg)
85.
E (a2+7+2a (a2+2) (o+[+l))) =c (c,2+7)2 a2+2) (a+c X+)+(02+7) (a-Fa )
-2o(o 2+2)
- 2a(2+7)+2o(o 2+2)(a 2-1)+ /2+(2a2(22) 2
C, +2 __a-7)
2o(o4+2a2 +5) +fa (2a 4+302 -7)
2
Al .1 1 2 +)a2 +)a4 _22_5S3 (2ci((3a2+4)(ci2+)-a= 2a2 -5)4(1. 2)5/2 ".
+ a +f((62 +5)(l 2) - 204 - 3&2 + 7))
2r ( /~io 2 4a(2(2 4 + 5a -) + 1 (4o2+84 + 12))
22- (2(2a4 + 5a 2 -1) + (a2 +1) (2a 4 + 4 2 +6)4(1"t2)
+o Y2c4 52_ 1+ 2a 4 42+6))
• j: = .23 (4c 6+lla4+9a2+6+a 2 1 (4+ 4 9c2+ 5))4(1-t2)
4 2B co 2 3+1 p (a +1) p. P 4(a +1)
32- A 3"M4 EI4 8At2 l3 FI3 32+('T-2 ) 2 (__ + ( 2+1) $2+1+ 4(a2+)
=X 1 + X2 + X3
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 95: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/95.jpg)
86.
-EI = -E 114 = 13 + OJ 4 )
2)J4 E 7) +3( +- - c 1+0j -- "-
x At 2 (93- oE 7J "+ (3o - (1+0 2) )- 3 2 31-g -fa 4
At 2
x+X = A 2 ((12a + 9 o2+i,(3 - aE))J126 (i-2+) o2 3
+ (4F + a (3a - (1I+c.2 )E)) 1 )232
l 2a + 9[2+1 (-E 2=1+ +9a
9+2 +227= i21a+92+2 7V~ &
2
= 2Lx + c +27
-_____2 (11-ct2- 8l )(10 2 224F +ia +(303 (140)E = aVZi81 - a 2 2 +11+-
2a 21
= 0 - (5 2 - 15)- 7a2+ 3
25a (2.3) 3-7a 2 712
( ( 23)- 7a +3)13 =( 2 +.aj3
TECH ICA+1) a + 1
TECH.NICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 96: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/96.jpg)
87.
(21a+ 9 (+3 .+ 5a 2(a23) +(3"7a2))j( 2 +1 ) 3 / 2 a 2+ 1 3
4 l 2 5J 2
a (14 +24) + 14a 4+21a 2+27('1 2 _.J 2a2 +1 ( 2+ i)3/2 8 +8
+ X At 2 ((5a(14a 2 +24 + 5(14a 4 +21a2+27)48 (2 1)2 +)
4 2a 4 2
+ (14a 4 - 25a 2+ 21+ a (14a 4+ 56a 2 - 78))12)
a +1
121= ', 2 1 + aJ)1+a
a+ a +2 4 11
2 12 (3 + a 2 + aV2+)I I4(1a)
1+AI 1 '(Fa + a )
2 F+
x x r,92(+1+a) (52(14a2+24)+ 5 (14a 4 + 21a 2 + 27)1 2 384(a2+1) 5/2
+ (5(a +1)(14a 2+24) + 5 (14a 4+21a 2+27))
+ 2-t (.14a4.25a2 +. 2 (!4a 4 +56a 2 -78)
+ 2 3/2 ((a 2+1)(14a 4-25a 2+21)+ (a 2+3)(14a 4+56a 2-78)))
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 97: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/97.jpg)
88.
S2 ( a2+1+0) 2(168256a2+78+ l4o4-1062+120384(02+) / 2 a 2+1
+ 0 (168a 4 +326a 2 +198 + 2 84+112oJ -1 56
aa +1
71 a~hii 4 2422402 512 (168a +270m -4 240384(o +1) a +1
+ t (16804+354a 2+282 -. 240F2- a 2 +1
r( 2 4 +624a 2 + 240)
2 5 24 2
384(o2+1) 5 /
+ 1 ((o 2 +1)(168o4+ 270 2 42)
+ 240+a (168a + 354o + 282 240)))a +1
r'i2 (48o(7a 4 + 13m 2 + 5)384(2 +1)5/2
+ 1 (336I6+ 792d4+ 510o2_ 42 2.40))S2/+1 a +1
3x 2 (3c 2 +I) (36k -l 2 4 6 +ay+1 (404+902+ 5))
16 (c2+1)4 .4
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 98: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/98.jpg)
89.
38(c2 .& (-24(3a 2+1)(4a 6 +Il4 +9a 2+6) + 240$4 = 384(a 2 +11/
+ ( a2+1) (336a 6+792a, 4+510a 2-42)
+aVa +1 (-24(3 2+1)(4ct+9a2+5). + 48(a2+1)(7q4+13a2+5)))
ff 2 48 a8+.40a 6 + 65,4-30. 2+ 964(a2 +1)
4
+ 4a +1 (2 6+9934+12a2 +5))
S = S + c2S'
3aB2 1 Va+ a(a 4 +341 2 - 7 + - 2 (422 -19))c10 S1 4(22+)2
-3al 2 2 2 4 2 TT4 2 2 2-25/2 (a((a +1)(a -19)-a -34a2+7)+c t+1(a4+34a -7-a (a -19)))
8(a2 +1)
_____2_7 2_ 72 2-21 5/ (a(-52a -12) + a +1 (53a -7))
.BA 211(ay a2+1+ i- 2 2)c20S 2 = 4(2+1) (a( 2 +13) + V§'I (a 2 --5))
at2 2 22 2= 8(a2. 5/ (a+213)(1-a2)+(a 2+1)(a2_5))+ 2+((a2_5. a 2)+a 2(as2+13)))
atw 2 2 2228(c2+i)5/2 )c*(+2))
-it (ca(-16a 2 +8) + a2+1 (19a 2 -5))I_8(a 2 +1)5/2 +
II TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 99: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/99.jpg)
900
a 2 +": 5/2 (a(140cs2+44) + 4 (-140a 2 16))
_ -uM 2 (i 2 ) r 2 2 (2-)+1 +2a( 2+1)5/2 y+a (35a (a - lla 4 +1)
-U2M12 r (2-i+c) 2+ 4+ 15ca) 2+i)2a (a2 +) 5 / 2 +4+15
22r ((-5a + 19) + a (-5a2 +4))2a (a2+1) 5/2+
IIII
![Page 100: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/100.jpg)
91.
Part 2: (Steady Force and Moment)
-d 2
I c10 R1 = -2acBI 1 ( a2+i.-0)( /a2+1-2af= 2- 2 0R
i -2X2aI(32 + 1 - 3aV +l)
20R2 = -2 laBII( a+1+ i-a 2)
Ifo = d 2a2
f 0 = B1 (2ca +2 -2~
I = dair(f/i+1- a)
I -U 2Mdir(1 + )I m -m -d (
0 2 (C10 S1 + c 2 0 S 2)
C0S1 a 2 (2)
I 2(c*o 2 +1) ((
+1) 2 2(a +1 - 6 (a +1) - 12a + 18a Ul)
- r37 (-17a 2 - 5+ l8a \2+1)f 4(a 2+1) 3 / 2
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 101: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/101.jpg)
92.
2 V2c 20S -2-aBl 11 (a 2+1-) (3a aa l
-C T 2 2J 2 2 -21
4(a ) (+2 (a2+1)+ (1- a2)(3+2) + 4a a +i)
42 3/2 (-a 2 + 3 + 4a
4(a21)3/ 34 1
m 8da23 (16 2 8- 14a \2/+1)
- 8e2+i)3/2 2 2 2
-2Md 2 ( +1 +) (7Va2+1 ( 2+1 -a) +a 3)4e-U 2 +) 2 " + -a+4 2++aa
4a (a +1)-3)
-2 d2 2 2 22 2 .2= -(a2M 2 (F-2+e)((a +4) a ++a( - 3))
-u 4 2 2 2 2 2= -O2d3/2 ((a 2+4) (a2+) a (a2 3 ) (2a2+1) a~a +1
U 2Mdl 2 r (2a4+ 2a2+ 4 22+i -)= 4a (a2 +i) 3/2 +4+( a +) a j
2 2- -U2Mdl2r + 1 ( 2+1+24c(a 2+1) 3/2 (4 + a )
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 102: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/102.jpg)
93.
Table I
Index R S
-2+2 2 ( 2 +l) 2
.22(3+ 2+ 2+)(.cs)2) -2ei(-) 22a+1 2 (a +1)
a +3+2+ (a12 +l) 3 /2)2( 2+1)2 4( 2+1)( +
+ (2+ (4a 4 + 9a 2 +5))
4) 72 ((e2+j)(fe2+l+€,)4 2) 72 4 ( 8c 8 + 40 6 + 65e-30Z+4 (2 +1) 64(a2 +1)
+ 4a2t+1( 246+ 94+12a2 +5 ))2i 22 -2-- 2 i 4 2d
a) "U27 (4ct+Vc2a+l) UM 2 7r 2(CS,2, - CSe+
2 3/2
(4a ++1) f 2 (c2+)5/
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 103: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/103.jpg)
4k Ok 94.APPENDIX VI - 7k' 7k' - Tabulated
Notes for Tables
B -
*k -k *
;)*k airk ak
![Page 104: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/104.jpg)
+ N+
+i
M UP ~ N N
w +N .44
m+ + ~C14I C1 +1.0 N T N +
+ +3tis Nc* + "f+
gop +1 N4 + Nl
N1 0 6 N +Kw 04 NN +
04- N, 1 L46+ 5r
1 N4
IIti~l+4-04
+- N4I.+ N
u~ N
cq +1 + -w1 A +
N= Ni Nq +*n W W + N+Nq % +N c
+ Nr+
NNN N 4I + AN+
N* N W. N ALP NI N+ + N
N N .CI + 6 -
+ up
r-4N
+ ++C+
4 %.04W4.CA i
TECNICL RSEACH ROU
![Page 105: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/105.jpg)
96.
ci c
+ ".4
+
r-4 i-4 M I-
+
04 N.N
N
r-4
-:-
+w+ N C
0~~ +N-,-,4 + 04HH N1C4 1
H- 0 d
0)
r-4
0 r
I..H
P4 +C.N
:104
-~ - 0
H N C -4 -"
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 106: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/106.jpg)
97.
0 0
~00
C'wc
r-4 U
"4
r-4 rZ44
.5.4 04
s -4 e4
N 0 +
I ~ ~ -C' HtC-4
+%+1 + N
10 i-INM I
TC NA RESARC GUP
![Page 107: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/107.jpg)
98.
r4
+ +'-V4
0 c
U. ,.J+
4-4
N 04
-- rJ ,-*
,.-4 0 I.I€
-,
-4 + 0
cc 04 qq-0
-'-4J
j r
004
+ + N
+ N4
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 108: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/108.jpg)
99.
+cne4
ci +,+ .l
0 04!
N N
I'
0 cn
'-44
r14
0 C4
-e-4
+I +
04 N
0 ci
rCoE NCLREERH RU
u Co
.1-4
r. ++0 0*
C)*
04 Ic.1P4 1
-l +oC~r~ r- -
/111
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 109: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/109.jpg)
1000
Bibliography
1. Guerst, J. A. A Lineaxi~zed Theory for the Unsteady Motion
of a Supercavitating Hydrofoil, Instituut voor
Toegepaste Wiskunde, Technische Hogeschool te Delft,
Nederland, Rapport Nr. 22
2. Guerst, J. A. Linearized Theory for Partially Cavitated
Hydrofoils, International Shipbuilding Progress,
Vol. 6, No. 60, Aug. 1959
3. Timman, R. A General Linearized Theory for Cavitating
Hydrofoils in Nonsteady Flow, Second Symposium on
Naval Hydrodynamics, Washington, D.C., 1958
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 110: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/110.jpg)
DISTRIBUTION LIST
Contract Nonr-3434(00)
Chief of Naval Research ChiefDepartment of the Navy Bureau of ShipsWashington 25, D.C. Department of the NavyAttn: Code 438 (3) Washington 25, D.C.
Code 461 (1) Attn: Code 3451Code 3201
Commanding Officer Code 335Office of Naval Research Code 420Branch Office Code 421 (3495 Summer Street Code 440 1Boston 10, Massachusetts (1) Code 442
Code 449Commanding OfficerOffice of Naval Research ChiefBranch Office Bureau of Yards & Docks346 Broadway Department of the NavyNew York 13, New York (1) Washington 25, D.C.
Attn: Code D-400 (1)Commanding OfficerOffice of Naval Research Commanding Officer and DirectorBranch Office David Taylor Model Basin1030 East Green Street Washington 7 D.C.Pasadena, California (1) Attn: Code l3 (75)
Commanding Officer CommanderOffice of Naval. Research U.S. Naval Ordnance Test Station.Branch Office China Lake, California1000 Geary Street Attn- Code 753 (1)San Francisco 9, California (1)
CommanderCommanding Officer U.S. Naval Ordnance Test StationOffice of Naval Research Pasadena AnnexBranch Office 3202 E. Foothill Blvd.Navy No. 100 Pasadena 8. California (1)Fleet Post OfficeNew York, New York (15) Commander
Planning DepartmentDirector Portsmouth Naval ShipyardNaval Research Laboratory Portsmouth, New Hampshire (1)Washington 25- D C.Attn: Code 2627 (6) Commander
Planning DepartmentChief Boston Naval ShipyardBureau of Naval Weapons Boston 29, Massachusetts (1)Department of the NavyWashington 25, D.C. CommanderAttn: Code RUAW-4 (l) Planning Department
Code RRRE 1 Pearl Harbor Naval ShipyardCode RAAD 1 Navy No. 128Code DIS-42 Fleet Post Office
San Francisco, California (1)-1-
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 111: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/111.jpg)
Commander SuperintendentPlanning Department U.S. Naval AcademySan Francisco Naval Shipyard Annapolis MarylandSan Francisco 24, California (1) Attn: Library (1)
Commander SuperintendentPlanning Department U.S. Naval Postgraduate SchoolMare Island Naval Shipyard Monterey, CaliforniaVallejo, Callifornia ( )
CommandantCommander U.S. Coast GuardPlanning Department 1300 E. Street, N.W.
New York Naval Shipyard Washington, D.C. (1)Secretary Ship Structure Committee
Commander U.S. Coast Guard HeadquartersPlanning Department 1300 E. Street, N.W.Puget Sound Naval Shipyard Washington, D.C.Bremerton, Washington (1) WsigoDC 1
t WU.S. Maritime AdministrationCommander GAO BuildingPlanning Department 441 G. Street, N.W.
Philadelphia Naval Shipyard Washington, D.C.U.S. Naval Base Attn: Div. of Ship DesignPhiladelphia 12, Pennsylvania (1) Div. of Research
I C omnmander SuperintendentPlanning Department U.S. Merchant Marine AcademyNorfolk Naval Shipyard Kings Point, L.I., New YorkPortsmouth, Virginia (1) Attn: Capt. L.S. McCreadyC Dept. of Engineering (1)CommanderPlanning Department U.S. Army Transportation ResearchCharleston Naval Shipyard and Development CommandU.S. Naval Base Fort Eustis, VirginiaCharleston, South Carolina (1) Attn: Marine Transport Division (1)
I Commander Director of ResearchPlanning Department National Aeronautics & SpaceI Long Beach Naval Shipyard AdministrationLong Beach 2, California (1) 1512 H Street, N.W.
Washington 25, D.C. (1)CommanderPlanning Department DirectorU.S. Naval Weapons Laboratory Engineering Sciences DivisionDahlgren, Virginia (1) National Science Foundation
1951 Constitution Avenue, N.W.Dr. A.V. Hershey Washington 25, D.C. (1)Computation and ExteriorBallistics Laboratory
U.S. Naval Weapons LaboratoryDahlgren, Virginia (1)
-2-
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 112: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/112.jpg)
Director State University of IowaNational Bureau of Standards Iowa Institute of Hydraulic ResearchWashington 25, D.C. Iowa City, Iowa (3)Attn: Fluid Mechanics Div.
Dr. G.B. Schubauer (1) Harvard UniversityDr. G.H. Keulegan (1) 2 Divinity Street
Cambridge 38, MassachusettsArmed Services Technical Attn: Prof. G. BirkhoffInformation Agency Dept. of Mathematics (1)
Arlington Hall Station Prof. G.F. CarrierArlington 12, Virginia (10) Dept. of Mathematics (1)
Office of Technical Services Massachusetts Institute of TechnologyDepartment of Commerce Cambridge 39, MassachusettsWashington 25, D.C. (1) Attn: Dept. of Naval Architecture
and Marine Engineering (iCalifornia Institute of Prof. A.T. IppenTechnology
Pasadena 4, California University of MichiganAttn: Prof. M.S. Plesset (1) Ann Arbor, Michigan
Prof. T.Y. Wu 1 Attn: Prof. R.B. CouchProf. A.J. Acosta 1 Dept of Naval architecture (2)
Prof. W.W. WillmarthUniversity of California Aero. Engrg. Dept. (1)Berkeley 4, California Prof. M.S. UberoiAttn: Div. of Engineering (3) Aero Engrg. Dept. (1)
University of California Dr. L.G. StraubDepartment of Engineering DirectorLos Angeles 24, California St. ANthony Falls Hydraulic Lab.Attn: Dr. A. Powell (1) University of Minnesota
Minneapolis 14, MinnesotaDirector Attn: Prof. B. SilbermanScripps Institute of I.A. J.N. Wetzel 1OceanographyUniversity of California Professor J.J. FoodyLa Jolla, California (1) Engineering Department
New York State UniversityProfessor M.L. Albertson Maritime CollegeDepartment of Civil Engrg. Fort Schulyer, New York (1)Colorado A & M CollegeFort Collins, Colorado (1) New York University
Institute of MathematicalProfessor J.E. Cermak SciencesDepartment of Civil Engrg. 25 Waverly PlaceColorado State University New York 3, New YorkFort Collins, Colorado (1) Attn: Prof. J. Keller (l
Prof. J.J. Stoker1Professor W.R. Sears Prof. R. KraichnanGraduate School of AeronauticalEngineering Dynamic Developments Inc.
Cornell University Midway AvenueIthaoca, New York (1) Babylon, New York
Attn: Mr. W.P. Carl (1)
-3-
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 113: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/113.jpg)
The Johns Hopkins University Hydronautics, Incorporated
Department of Mechanical 200 Monroe StreetEngineering Rockville, Maryland
Bal-timore 18, Maryland Attn: Mr. Phillip Eisenberg (1)Attn- Prof. S. Corrsin ()
Prof. O.M.Phillips (2) Rand Development Corporation13600 Deise Avenue
Massachusetts Institute of Cleveland 10, OhioTechnology Attn: Dr. A. S. Iberall (i)
Department of Naval Architectureand Marine Engineering U. S. Rubber Company
Cambridge 39, Massachusetts Research and Development Dept.Attn: Prof. M.S. Abkowitz, Head (1) Wayne, New Jersey
Attn: Mr. L. M. White (1)Dr. G. F. WislicenusOrdnance Research Laboratory AVCO CorporationPennsylvania State University Lycoming DivisionUniversity Park, Pennsylvania (1) 1701 K Street, N.W.Also. Dr. M. Sevik (1) Apt. No. 904
Washington, D. C.Professor R. C. DiPrima Attn. Mr. T.A. Duncan (1)Department of MathematicsRensselaer Polytechnic Institute Mr. J. G. BakerTroy, New York (1) Baker Manufacturing Company
Evansville, Wisconsin (1)Stevens Institute of TechnologyDavidson Laboratory Curtiss-Wright CorporationCastle Point Station Research DivisionHoboken, New Jersey Turbomachinery DivisionAttn- Dr. J. Breslin (1) Quehanna, Pennsylvania
Dr. D. Savitsky (1) Attn: Mr. George H. Pederson (1)Mr. C. J. Henry (1)Dr. S. Tsakonas () Hughes Tool Company
Aircraft DivisionWebb Institute of Naval Culver City, California
Architecture Attn: Mr. M. S. Harned (1)Crescent Beach RoadGlen Cove, New York Lockheed Aircraft CorporationAttn. Technical Library (1) California Division
Hydrodynamics ResearchDirector Burbank, CaliforniaWoods Hole Oceanographic Attn: Mr. Kenneth E. Hidge (1)
iistituteWoods Hole, Massachusetts (1) The Rand Corporation
1700 Main StreetCONVAIR Santa Monica, CaliforniaA Division of General Dynamics Attn: Mr. Blaine Parkin (1)San Diego, CaliforniaAttn: Mr. R.H. Oversmith (1) Stanford University
Mr. R. Peller (1) Department of Civil EngineeringMr. C.E. Jones, Jr. () Stanford, CaliforniaMr. H.T. Brooke (1) Attn: Dr. Byrne Perry (1)
Dr. S. F. Hoerner Waste King Corporation148 Busteed Drive 5550 Harbor StreetMidland Park, New Jersey (1) Los Angeles 22, California
Attn: Dr. A. Schneider (1)
-4-
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP
![Page 114: UNCLASSIFIED AD 295. 094 · Timman [3-], has made an attempt at solving this problem. In his work the assumptions made to complete the definition of the problem have consequences](https://reader034.fdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042114/5e9052ca8ee3c2049e054b71/html5/thumbnails/114.jpg)
Commander General Applied ScienceU. S. Naval Ordnance Laboratory Laboratories, Inc.White Oak, Maryland (1) Merrick and Stewart Avenues
Westbury, L.I., New YorkDirector Attn: Dr. F. Lane (1)Langley Research CenterLangley Field, Virginia Grumman Aircraft EngineeringAttn: Mr. I. E. Garrick (1) Corp.
Mr. D. J. Martin (1) Bethpage, L.I., New YorkAttn: Mr. E. Baird (1)
Air Force Office of Scientific Mr. C. Squires (1)Research
Temporary Building D Lockheed Aircraft Corp.Washington 25, D. C. (1) Missiles and Space Division
Palo Alto, CaliforniaCommander Attn: Mr. R. W. Kermeen (1)Wright Air Development DivisionAircraft Laboratory Massachusetts Institute ofWright-Patterson Air Force Technology
Base, Ohio Fluid Dynamics ResearchAttn: Mr. W. Mykytow (1) Laboratory
Dynamics Branch Cambridge 39, MassachusettsAttn: Prof. H. Ashley (I
Boeing Airplane Company Prof. M. Landahl (1)Seattle Division Prof. J. Dugundji (1)Seattle, WashingtonAttn: Mr. M. J. Turner (1) Midwest Research Institute
425 Volker BoulevardCornell Aeronautical Laboratory Kansas City 10, Missouri4455 Genesee Street Attn: Mr. Zeydel (1)Buffalo, New YorkAttn: Dr. I. Statler (1) Director
Mr. R. White(1) Department of Mechanical SciencesSouthwest Research Institute
Electric Boat Division 8500 Culebra RoadGeneral Dynamics Corporation San Antonio 6, TexasGroton, Connecticut Attn: Dr. H. N. Abramson (1)Attn: Mr. R. McCandliss (1) Mr. G. Ransleben (1)
Editor, AppliedGibbs and Cox, Inc. Mechanics Review (1)21 West StreetNew York, New York (1) Oceanics, Incorporated
114 East 40th StreetNew York 16, New YorkAttn: Dr. P. Kaplan (1)
-5-
TECHNICAL RESEARCH GROUP