ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241...

43
ULUSLARARASI iMAM SEMPOZYUMU INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON AL-IMAM AL-SHAFII 7-9 Mayu;/May/y.\..o 2010 EDiTOR MEHMET BiLEN KENT

Transcript of ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241...

Page 1: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

ULUSLARARASI

iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMU

INTERNATIONAL

SYMPOSIUM ON AL-IMAM AL-SHAFII

7-9 Mayu;/May/y.\..o 2010

EDiTOR

MEHMET BiLEN

~ KENT l~lkl.ARI

Page 2: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

Kent l§Iklar 46

Uluslara.ras1 imam ~affi Sempozyumu

Intemahonal Sympos1um on al-Imam al-Shafll

Editor

Mehmet Bilen

i~diizen - Kapak

Ridwan Xelil

JJ..UI ~WI ~\.o')l ~j.o

Birinci Baskl: 2012

Baskl-Cilt

Artus Basrm

i:kitelli Organize Sanayi Bolgesi

Eskoop Sanayi Sitesi B1 Blok No: 63

Ba~~ehir/istanbul Tel: +90 0212 671 70 92

Fax: +90 0212 671 70 93

ISBN: 978-605-5402-40-2

Yayui Sertifika No: 16919

Kent I~lklan

Pak Ajans Yaymcillk Ltd. $ti

Biiyiik Re~itp~a Cd.

Yiimni i~ Merkezi No: 22/29

Vezneciler-istanbul

Tel & Fax: 0 212 519 00 09

Page 3: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

4JJ-o"';il v-$.::.J1 ~J.l.o J ~\..!J I ~~~~ Jf i~am ~afii'nin Usiili Kelam Ekoliine Etkisi

D~ Dr. Haythem Khaznaho

~II

~!:'!, ~\.!.11 rt•)l4 J"'"}l ._A,.;o:)l { ~ ~_,....,\11 ~ ~J.l..o rj ~\.!.11 rl..~l )i ~~ I..U. J_,~.:;

.~_,..,\II~~~_, ~_,....\II

..:..~~}! ~ '-i)..i.• ~l,}l <S_rl ~ ~I ~;.l..o_, ~\.!.11 rt..~l ~ 4t;WI ..!.ll~ ""-! ~I J_,t:; f ,:,I J! ~1.,!1 ~-',~_,..,\II~~ rj ;~~~ ~_,...,\11 ..:..~>-"}l-' ~\.!.11 rt..~l ~ rj ;~~~ ~_,....\11

.~\.!.11 rl..~l4a-.D_, ~ J_,....,\11 ~-....~....\II ..,~~..:..~1 ~ ~;.~..o

,:,1 J! '+-t ~-' ~-' ~\.!.11 rt..'ll .:/ JS' ~~_,...,\II ~~l ._roll...A>:- ~ '-i}.O.. ~l,}I <S_ri I...S'

· '-11 -...11 .·• \..i.b:-1 " ·1 I · _,'"I" ..U :.•~ 1-11 -r-~ ..r-:' '-! ~'-""'~ ~ '-! ..... ~ '"'"..I'""

~ Jl ~ I...S' ,~_,..,)II -..~i p rj ~\.!.11 !,ii~ ~ ,:,! J! '+-t ~ ~~ ~~.) ~l,li <S_r~

.j._¢.1 rj ~ j_,....( ~.~WI ~.i.JJ f:)i '"~I

~ & ~ ~ ~ J! a!P- J_,....,\1, JJWI lJ ~\.!.11 r~..~~. & ,:,1 ~t.l,<Sh ~~ rb- ()-' ~y ~\.!.11 rl..~l .J~ ..;:l!Ltli<Sy.) ~ '!/ ..!.ll~ .Jf '!/! a!f:JII..i.J. ~.JJ 'YJu.ll rj ~ J~l ~ ~~-'

.~_,....\tl~l ~;.l..o

Abstract

The Impact of Imam Shafii In Speakers Fundamentalism School

This is research addressed the impact of Imam Shafi'i in speakers fundamen­talism school, where the definition summary Imam Shafi:i and Imam Shafi'i effects of fundamentalism and its radical fundamentalist school speakers.

This research effected the Imam Shafi.'i in speakers fundamentalist school were short definition Imam Shafi'i and Imam Shafi'i effects of fundamentalism and its radical speakers fundamentalist school.

He then discussed the search after the relationship between the Imam Shafi'i and speakers scliool, where the researcher compared among the subjects fun­damentalism contained in the books of Imam Shafi'i and themes of fundamen-

. 0 Esmeriye Universitesi, Libya

Page 4: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu

talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the researcher that the school speakers adopted the basic themes for the information of the assets developed by the Imam Shafi'i.

The researcher· also compared the characteristics . of writing at each of the fundamentalist Imam Shafi'i and speakers, which concluded that the parties have a consensus in some of the.cha_ractefistics and differed in others.

The researcher and the study also concluded that the speakers agreed Shafei in more fundamentalist views, and concluded that the health of anabolism branches of the Shafi'i destine of the assets of speakers in all. ·

At the conclusion of research the researcher felt that the approach of Imam Shafi in authoring fundamentalist largely consistent with the approach of the speakers and their way with them in different walks of life, despite this compa­tibility, but this does not correct the case of those who say that Imam Shafi'i, founder of speakers fundam.entalism School._

4.-.lA.JI

. ...w.., ··l'~ if-'~-' .JT Js-_, ,,1, ~ .:r. ..I.J. ,.,1, Jb:- ....;_;.i Js- r)U~ o')\...a)~ ,.1 J......J-1

r#' c:..;\5' <>u •($.)~)'' JW'.J.~<.; ~ 1ii I.AJS"~ lit>:.. ~r-~ y)L.'J' 0w, J>.f .:/ .w11 J;-.1 ~ <>~

~ ;.;..l.,-J~ ~ J"y11 Js- h.)u ...:kt..;. .)JJ if .}' ._r-l_, ....... ~, -....t:.:. ~ WJ1 J;....i ~ 0~ ...... ~, ~ ~.rJ'

.) l'! 0§; )' 4::! ~_,A:l~ L,.._,..,.,.,.~.p 4.¥1.!1 ~~1..!.1.1; -.6-)\.._, ,L!._,.....~ t..JrAII..h..J -.;? ~u..1 0~ v_r_, JP. · JW .11 .W.... ......llll .·• .; L..i · ,•. ~ ..w.ll -.!.- )' U.l u ... 1·-: :_ • •• •• ,.!.lJ.ll ~<lll JW .11 .~1 I) . .. 1../J.., • <.?!"-'--. . 7 • • _,~'-I<?'

.&A:.. .:/ JS' ._r::1; '~I ~ ~ .11 '-:-"'~j .Ji ~ l~l ~ <~ ~ ~J o.)Y,. .:/ ~~ .:/ y_,li

.~lkll ~-' i...}.'JI ~}I.:/~)\_; ,.)t.p.. )II Js-1.)\; J_,.....\11 .....;_,_, t..JrAI~ .wll JL.... ~ PJ J"_,...dl

J_,.J y ,.;..~ J_,! .:/ "! ~l=)'l 015' y)L.'jl r#l .:/ y.UI <;\5:.U oJ;. ~ Wll J_,.....i ~ 015' ll_,

~ .:r~ 1 ~~ ,..s_,.!.j J>!T-_, ~~i -.;..r- ~~ l.i4 ~t=l'l ...,._;~ ;_, . .)t.p.. l'l ~ .-u..11_, ,litl.l.:.o_, rtS::.. \11

Js- r..>? \.. ~ r..S?J i.l.:l_, l!.; liiJ ~4-WI .:/ ~ ~ )'_, .:/)1 .:/ ~ ~ ~ ~ t-' ~L. ..y_, Wll J_,....i

·?ll-1 li_r= Jl ~L.)I_r= if ..Jci ,-.;\5'y.)L.'JI r#l

rt..'JI .Y"J .J.~~ $-l...WI ~i .:/J ,J-':"')1~ Wll wi j;.i J.>.~ ~ .k;.,t c)l ~II.U JW .11 Jj; .u_, ~ ~~ .s:J..._, J_,.o..ll ~ ~ c)\s' 0i ~ ,.)_,..._,1! ~~ ~I lli 0_,.) .:/ J_,i c)\) ..W ,~L!.ll · ..r~! .:;. ~

.jl ~4-;IJ .:/~.....A:! J\:.:.~ ~I l..k ._:..\:.!.! ~L!.ll ~ '.J.J\;&.J ~Lc--~ ._ra. )'_, .)-'~ ~ ')U c..t'_,A;ll

~_,..!1 ....u1 ~ ..;:;.) ~ .:/ .J} ~ ~~ ,_u r WI e:-"-'~ el:.l.l r--J H~ )11 ~lf..o ~ ~ ~.£_,.)_, ~ ~ ~\)

.~UI J_,.aJ~ ~ ~ ~4-UJI ._:..ti)\:.:.1 Js- t_')\1.~ Wl~ ......_~ akb.IJ ~~~ -.;..r"J

,<,J..,...,\11 ~8.1_, dAI_;IJ ~-' ~L..W~ ~.J\11.:/ _#' ~ ..,_.;Sj ~L!.ll rt..'JI ~ ~IIJ;. ~~I (:}I;; {

Page 5: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

imam $afii'nin UsUli Kelam Ekoliine Etkisi 1425

,J_,....\11 ~ .J_,.) if J_,i ~I..!JI .JIS' ~ t._,. .... $0- J_,...,\rl ~ tJ ~I..!JI rL-~1 ;i .Jl: ~~~.i.e> if ~w~

JJ~ ..;..o.lJ..U .J.iJ ,~\..!JI ~.ill J! 4.A)_;. pi ...,_.:il ..:.....>- '<..1"~1 ~J Js- ~--....,)11 ~I --._r. tj o)~

:~,/:11 1.!...>-\.,ll t) ~~

,~_,...,\11 -.."U:....:a..o_, ,~\..!JI (1..~4 4 ci_r !r.Y i~ 4 .:_,;,JJi ~ ,J,...,'JI ~-' ~I..!JI :J_,':/1 ~I

-~ t) ~_,....\ll.:ty:ll y~~ ,~_,....)rl.:ty:ll [) ~~

j;.\1 c}W~ ~:.~l:ll ...f'_,JI j')b:. if --.J-111 ~~ cif- ..:.....>- ,4_,...,'.i1 ~I a....JJ.e :<iWI ~I

. 4-.all..a>:-_, lii.Al_;.. _, --. rJ.1 ~.u. .:r..,-.::.U LJJ.J_,..., \r1

:~"":/1 ylhl.l J! ~..:.......,...; .J.i_, ,4_,...,'.i1 ~I a....,;.~.e J ~I..!JI .J'"i :~~~ ~~ ~ t) ·~~~~_,...,\II ..;..o\.$0-,....,_,l.l ~ ..:.,..;}; ~ '~" ~I..!JI J:S. 4_,...,'.i1 ~\.:JI :J_,'JI ~I

._.!;.> ~~~ { ,~ __ ....,)11 ~<:ll ~ t) ·~~~ -<J_,...,)rl ..;...1$-_,...,_,LIJ -~L-)1 y\5' 4-J'i ifF ~_,....\II ~\..!JI rL-~1

.~_,...,\ll..;..ol>')tb..,)l~ ..;..o\.$0-,..,_,u _J.:l ~

~l:SJI cJ>ll..a>:- ~ ~\AJJ <.:-.!_,>.-j ~ '~" ~I.!JI J:S.. 4_,...,':/1 ~16:11 ~~ :<i~l ~I

.~_,...,)II~ --._r. cJ>ll..a>:-J ~l.!JI rL-)'1 ..l:.$0- ~~)11

._,J..~,.. :.~1 t,S..I..o .:J::i ._.!,:. <.:-.!_,>.-j ~ ,4_,...,':/1 ~I.!JI s.I,)'J ~I .)~\ t,SJ.e :~~\ ~~

.~'.....-•lltJI ~\.of~~ ,~l.!Ji~ ~WI t.S..I..oJ ,"-:,J_,....\11 ~l.!JirL.~I ~~'J ~_,...,\JI.J.,.J.-<:!.1

~~if J:i_,;.i .:_r-- if ~ . .JIS' Lo_, 'Y~~ ..l!-)1 ~ .J~ f_?:)l ....,.}_l..J6:. .;..s- .Jy-<t .Ji J~i JW ~~

.~WI YJ ~ J.J.~ 'f./4 ,..U) ~~ l.li) (.j~ ..!.lJ.) .rf .JlS"'L.J 'J--J f

4i_r~~~~ . .)

J_,'~l ~I

J_,...,':/1 ~-' ~I.!JI

~ .:ty; tJ -~t..:JI r~..~~ ~i J')b:. .:/' ~!)1 ~..i.A ~_, ,w_, U.!.,i) ~w1 _rL-~4 J_,...,\11 ~ J.;)

,~_,....\fl.:t_,.cll t) J,-]1 s.~ .y c...<.. ~I ~\..!JI rl.o~l ~ t) ~ ..,_;t,J:I ~\.i.e> t) J>.l'~ ,J_,...,)rl

,4J ._;....,11 ~j\.:..J .:t_,..cJI ~j ~L,. t) ..!.lJ.) ~ .Ji>~ ,~L-)1 y\5' 1.&---~ Js-J <,J_,...,\JI -.,"tA.:..,..l. J>.ri I..S

.~_,...,\l,.:t_,.cll ~w1 rL-~1 ..:..s-:. J' y~\11 ~ik-:-~

Page 6: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

426 1 IDuslararast Imam ~afii Sempo~mu

~I..!J' r~,.tu ~~~J~.#I

~ c!l:. .:.;. w\...!$> .:.;. ._,-l,JI .:.;. ..rA .:.;. ~ ..1!1 -Y' y.i J~ ,~\..!.11 rt. ')4 ;r-y ~~ .y '..yJI ~ 'J

•!Jf!J ~..1.1.4J l6. ~J ~ G ~ 204 c.. ~ Jt.u ..t1 ...,..J .YJ ~tso c.. ~ cj ~u. ~ .uJ ,~_;~1

L-.}:11 ~~ ...,....,.l.lll wl ...~,:..! Y'J ~~ ci~ ~ .r'-' JJ { ·~J I*'~ J!,-]1 y.i .:r ..i.>~ ~_,.. .)1~ r-U_, 04#- ~'j....'JI-...':/1..;.6; <.:.J,)\5"" ~I

WJI cj r..lil' t-'~ :.Y_,t _,..; .~_,:.:.- J,)t..a.. .y rW' 4,ll.J .J~>-; ofi cj ~~ ~1..!.!1 rt.'JI ~ ~~<;

~) . . ._,a. ..UJ , . .!lJ.) .lA! .wll ...,..J1 { ,y,)':/1, y~l (It~ ~I ~~I ~~I cj o)\S"" ~\..!.11 rt.'JI .J\f.!lJ.)J ~~~~

..i.>J! .:r ~1..!.!1" :.J~T JuJ ,"WJI cj ..,_ ~1..!.!1 Jj'' :~ -J Ju ~ ,4.0..u trJ ~ Wll y.t rJ' _#' ·

(2) "y~l.y ~4 ~ LS'l6. ~ o.~,>.- -..J ~t.!.ll .J!" :~""""~ JuJ "Wll ~

cj .Jl. LS' ~~.:.;. o)~ ~ cj ~~I Jl$" .:f' o..i.>i <!...::>- ~..1).1 ~ .Jl.O.:.!.l.!lJ.). J! ~\..!.11 JW.~

.J..:...-,.o) .cj ~1!..11' ..;...r. ..uJ ,~..1).1 o~ .y .;IS:i .~J t1._,1.1 ~o:s ..i.>i ..w •..rii .:.;. .!lit.. ~~ Jb rt.! rJ' ~..lil

• : • o. (3) cj .iJ4 J.),) cji\..!.11 (t.jU o)\S"" <!...::>- ~!VI J.Aj Jj.!lJ.) u..W J . ,~.lJ.I ~~ ~ ..r' \II .:...U! tJ , . o_f-J (~I..!JI

(4) : • • 0 ~J 4!L..)I ~\:5'" j')l.:.:. .y ~ ~ cj .Jy .y JJI ~\..!.11 rt.'JI ~I~ ..UJ '~J ~..1).1 rJs-

~ •c!lt:..? Y'J u_,:.ill ~ ~ ~.lliJ ~ ~4-.i.i .:/ o..i.>i <!...::>- .wll ..,..n. ~..1).1 ..,..n. c: ~\..!JI c:-J

cj ~... .!l~.')fJ'j.:.:. .:/ 4:-:! b.y .;IS"" J ,.w~~, ~:.~:~-' ~ e .)_r; _,.':/, ~ h ·~..1,:.-J ~Jl" ~ .w 0\1 .

.:.;. .v-I rt.'JI ~ Ju ~ ,~..1)." ...u11 ~ r:}l cj 1..u~ .;IS:i ,..:..'J':J.~.;...l, ..:..U.lF-1, ~~....._, .w rJ' ~,)~>-~'

(5) j_,! ~($.ill (~..1).1 J')b:.l) yt:S'" ~~J ..p cj r:}llh ~J , "~..1).1 .W wf t. ~1..!.!1 ':/}" :J.:>

(6) 0 ~_,~..1).\~~cj......A;..,a..o

24/1 y.i.f.JI cT ~I •<:?»"1 :Jail (l)

202/11 ~I •<:?»"1 :IA~J .:.r'JjiJI o.iA }ail (2)

Jl.t"J'J ~,)~':il rJ" ~\.!.11 ~l.to'j/1 ~ J..~;...ol \.to~ ~It:::.--~ (Jil~'J .r-JI ~.J"") ~\:) .j ~I~ \.to If.:.. (3)

olf.,IJ ... h .... ~ ~\.!.11 r"'';ll ~

060 ~~~ rP J J.i:JI ~ <.;t..lll JJi ,.) •P 011 fo ~~ J'.-114-.s.i> ,4!t...)l ,~l.!JI :Jail (4)

.4 .}'~.:> ..w-14-o.s.i> ,4Jt... )1 ,~\.!.11 (5)

~\.!.11 "':-",;.. J! .f"..\.JI •r.fl o.) '<r""'J.ill 0284 ~J 4.0p ~~I J,...t ~~~ ........,. 0.) ,~1 :Jail (6)

0252

Page 7: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

im.am 1Jafii'nin Usiill Kelam Ekoliine Etkisi 1427

J. .J....i. o.i.,....l; if otA.l; ~ ~ <Jf w \..,.,r"""-J J~l <) <?~I J>f w ~ ~I <) ~\..!.JI .)!f:.-1 f (7)

"! ~~ ~~I w ~_,:...\,; ' II~ }) .:r-:ll J. ..l..S-~ if ..:..!r" :..!.ll~ <) ~L.;JI J~ <1)~1 .:r-:ll

(8) • ;P-') rl.!.ll ...o e- ..w ..!.ll~ J~ -.;w.! . ~~~ <Ji ~ J~ .w11 <) c./'1.:11" :J~; ..r

~) <) ....;_,..JJ ~L.;J1" :Jw ~L.;J1 rl..o)'l ~ <)~.rill ~1..:t_,s::J1 u,. J.>.:;. ...Lri rl..o)'l ............,_, ..u_, .

~-' ,.w~~ ~~~ WJI ris-e ..u ~L.;JI rl..o/'1 .Ji ...li. ~~.., ,<9)".w~~ '\}WJ_, .~~....;~~ ,WJI <) :~~~ ,..tA:.o ~151_, yl! _fJ_, ..UI.i ~ ~ Q"J <?~I J>f ~J ~..IJ-1 J>i ~ .J ~I ~ <o.)..U.:. YJW.... if v}s­

~ •_;; ~ 4)~.) dSJ ,4.;.}AI <?} .1~ ~I M.) .r¥1 .l;t; ~ .J\5"' ~ ~ ~ ifi.; ¥ ..!.ll~ ~ij

.4!_,.) .Jj\; _,i '~ c)\hL. ~~ .Jlpi-if lh L:..J! J! ~p~ ~.1.. J\..!..;;1

yi:S' ~_;; ,.wll J_,...,i ~ J_,'JI .;.,~I ~J <) l.ll~ .J~ .J'J ~y JW~ ~1.:t_,s::J11~ ~\..!.JI.J\5"'

.~!J'-==>~ .o_,...,f ~L.;J1 rl..o)'ll# .J_,.) ~ .w11 J_,...,i <) ...;.~_;.. J_,i y1.:5:lll.i:. ~_, ,4lt....)l

J¥'~1 ~ J ~uJI ..:;J\.oi:...Aa

~~ ,._:.,IA:..,all .oh e-f if~ 4JL...)I y\:S' .J( ':/) ,J_,...,'JI ~ <) ..:.>~y.Oy <) o~ {$ ~\..!.JI rl..o)'l .j..:..,p

:411 ~.., Jl ~-""''11 ~l.!.ll rl..o)'l ..:.>lA:...al. !;:.._,.. tl.! .)J-'~ ,J-""''1" ~~if _,s-~ <.>~

' AlL..)! y\£ :~_,1

..W '-.(.u.lll..oi ,4~..\:lol a.JL...)~ ~.u.ll a.IL...)I :.J41:S' ~} <) ~ ..!.lill '~/alL...)! yi:S' ~\..!.JI rl..o)'l.j..:..,p

u~ <.l1AJ4 J~...~;... ~~ -._,i ~ .J ~ 41:S' .J ~ .Ji .JL ~ <<?-4-- .:.r. .f'}..Y. ..,...U. ~ ~~ .)1~ <) ~

..!.lJ.il ~ ~~ 4L.J~ y1.:5:JI ~\..!.JI .J ~_;; 'u"~~ rrJI ... , .... ;~_, (rd~J t---1.:11 01.!) c.l'~~ t,lr.)'~

. . (10) <Ji ~1" :<?})1 0!..\ll _rj J~ ,'-.(.u.ll a.IL...)I ._o.;.....; ~ .)~i ~ ';P-' <) ~ o~..\hl \...~ , 4lt....)4

(11) . . • . . . "_#' ~ ~ ...1>-~ Js' <)J a.IL...)I yi:S' ._o.;.....; .)\s>l ;P-' J! (:;'J ll_, <.)~<)alL... )I yi:S' .j..:..,p ~\..!.JI

•0~..\J.,I 4!~)1 ~ J_,l..d.l \...( ,tc,.uul 4!~)1 if ~~ ~ t-'

.142 ~lfiill.;,\.i,i> •Js' <J.I"""'I;!! •cijtr.JI (?)

.403/6 ~'j..:JI r~' r. •.,r.o.U1 <s> .41/2 ~\.!.11..,._;\.;.t ,~1 (9

)

25/1 ~I •ci_v.:ll :pi (10

)

157 ~\.!.II rl.ojll ..,._;~..;.. •.;r..UI ,# •ci)l)l (11)

Page 8: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

428 I Uluslararas1 imam ~afii Sempozyumu '

12 ( ) ,...{ • • • • • t •

.,)~ l..il , 4f..ill -..;S' r I ~ (I .,)1 ~ 4Jt... )I ~ .)~1 ~L!.JI r~ 'JI .JI _,s'\..!. ..v-1 .)\:..,. yl ~JJ

.~ _;;...1 ~J ~~~ ~t;J1 r~'il ~ )l......t;J IJ.,o.A; ~ -.lt...)l ._,..\5

(13) ~ ·~ jJI........j. -.it...) ..:..!,;" :lp-- <J}l Jt;J ' 4>-f- .? ~l;.ll ..,s., , -.!I.... )I ylS' ._,.t;ll ~I ..liJ

':/! ~ 4J ..:..):; 1,)1 r-1"1 ~ ,-.:..... ~..,.. -.lt...)ll) jt;ll.il :Jli ~ ~"-' cJJ .•~..~>.- o..uu 4;.. ..:..J.A.:...., ':/! ~..,..

(14) • II Q f .}1 t l;.!- ._:....lA::.....,

;~ AJ ~t;J1 r~)'l & J ...,..~llh ._,a:~_, -.lt...)l ._,..lS' cJ ·~~~ 4J_,. ..... ~~ ..:..~p}l cJ r')IS:JI J->-~

. ..:...1\:ll ~ J! ·~ .:rJ -.it... )I y\5

IJ~";/1 J~! yloS" :!.:;IS

~~ -.lt...)l ...,..lS' cJ .)JJ t1 ~-' ~ 0§.) 1-......b:- l.JL....:..:...':/1 t:].PY cJ ...,..~~~~ ~t;J1 rt..)'I....A;.....

(15) ' . t,r-6 Y'J ,.,:,L...:..:.,. ':/1 .)) ~~ ~

~~ tl.-. ~\.s" :i!JIS

.Jl:!J ,..1>~1,.. ~ :<./'J 4)_,..,~1 ..:..~_,.P_,IJ ~ J&- )\...;.!... 0\Sj ,~1 &- ._,..lS' ~t;JI rt..)'l ....A;.....

~~ . . -Y'J . -.11....)1 J&- ..:..':/b-1 .y ~ ll ·~~~ -.11....)1 ~ ~ ..liJ .c...J')\;l-1 ~ $ ~J 'tl.i:-)'., <iJ!;ll WI

(17) . tr-b

~.bel l ....;~, y\oS" :~1)

lh_, .~t... ..:.._r-1 1...5" ~~~ Jl$. r-1" cJ ..._t.:....:a,. JJI .,:,\5:.; .~~~ ._j~' ...,..lS' ~t;JI rt..)'l ....A;.....

<}:"'-~I <h! ~_jll i~~J ,-.1.)~1 ~ ~~., J>Jt-:11 -lPI_,i <./'J J_,.....~l ..:..~;..._,. c.S-1>! c.) o~.>.-!Yl ~ y~l

-~J ~)51~ ..:..~k-l6i ':/! -.lt...)l ...,..lS' cJ wJ_,h.,..,~l cJ ~t;J1 rt..)'l ~;. ~~..:.>~_,.P_,l.IJ

10 4ll...o)l J:,i>oJ 4-.l.i. ( 12)

i.j_MI t~IJI u}JI ~~ Jl.r.JJ;:JI.J" .wll J_,..,l ~ •"'-I . .) •c,r"'-'.J-l:lol' ,12 jU. "'-I 4-.l.i. :4ll...o)l o.r!' p i (13)

.} ~"JI l,:.(J1.} t .)y.-y <i"~l cr .J" ~_,lo..:... 47.-J ul ~I foJ ' i:)_r.ll o.l,o. ,j" ~.r ~ tt'J ,327/1

.245 ~\.!JI rl.o~ll..,....l.. Jl J.o".WI '.r"IJill :)2;1 ._;""JII.l.o> .......... r~ ; lf!Oll <./J <<.J""'..JI!

25/1 ~· •f$~1 ( 14)

-~ &> t..S"' ,.;,,_- .;t.UI J.l.f ""-( • .) J:,i>.JJ ~ ~\.!JI rl.o~l Is-_,.._,.~&> ( 15)

.248 ~\.!JI ..,....l.. J ! J.o".WI '.r"IJill :p i (16)

.~\.!J ' r~..~, As-_,.._,.~&> t..S"' .~ &> <17>

Page 9: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

imam $afii'nin UsUU Kelam Ekoliine Etkisi 1429

~~ ~ 4A.,p yl:S' :L..~:»

J! ~ yl.:t::ll o~L.J •AAI,-<ll J! 4.:.,) o_,.aj f L. f_r:ll ~~I.;( ~UJI rL.)'I 4:i ~ ·~ ~L.J t,/'

~~ . . . tJ,b .Y>J .~L.)I y\5' y!y.l .y ~~ -0_,....,;:.!.1 ~ .:r ~ ..1.>

J.t-P~I ~ ~.J.U J ~l.!JI ~~ ~.r:JI f::.;t tj ~ .y jSI ~ ._,..; L. l..i.:>J ,j_,....\11 ~ tj ~ .y JJI .d ~L!JI rL.)'I .y- ,F-1

~ ,~ .dL.J ~ J.oi, ~UJI (.wll j_,..,i ~) ~ ~ .y JJI .;I)'' :o..l..i.o () .JJ..\6:. 0!1 Ju v"j._.)'l

(19) J~l ~,)t; ~UJI ~ ~~ ..UJ. "._Aill.y ~ c.J"_,......:.IJ ..WI ~J _,..;1-~ .Jt.:l~ t,/'~~ .A'JI l; 4:i

.r~ y ~UJI\.:...L.jw\5)" :1.?~)'1 J~ ,~ ~ .y JJI ..,;{ Js- ...1.iA:..o tlr.)'l 0~ Jy\11 ~ ~UJI rL.)'I

(20)11 . J ' . 1. \ : I . t_lr. )'~ .., ...;..:...... .:r ~~ •& ~ rll ....... l..i.:> ..:..l:.!.i t:::' J •of.:.-:. fJ ~I lh t~ f ~I..!J\j 'J~\11 '-~.)1 L.f '~ ~ tSy..lll oh 0i tSJb

f WI ~J!, ~l.:l.l r-') ''-!r-';1 ~lj..o ~ () I..Sj~J ~ () ..:...iiS" ~I ~l.:l.l .y ~ "--".:.! ) .. :.>!, ~~

..:,\j')\.::.:.1 Js- t~l, ~~ ~ -.!.~!_, ~...lJ_~ o_,-..J ~~~ WJI \) J:i,) ~ .y I)Ji ~~I I.U

.~L.Ji J.,......J'J 0~ \) "4-W'

~ ~~ J,....i ~ Jl ~1..!..11 ~ .;i ~1" :Jw ,-.JLl.l o.lA tj Jyillt?j!}l .:r...lll ~ ~~ ..UJ

.:,}~_,h..) j.i ~IS" <.1'\..:JI.J~ .!.il~J 'vO.vJI ~ J! ..~.ri .:r. J.l!l-14,-:..Sj ,Jbil ~ J! ~I _,h..)

.!l.J.lS) ... .J:At.r.J!,) ~J...lJ-1 ~} W' tj ~ 0jli r-"~ .JIS" L. .:}J ,t..,UI ~~ ,)~ 0,.P~J

J-_,.)1 ~ JJ:l-1 ~\,; •e:;kl' y;..? r-",)~1 .:>IS) JL...!.\11 0~ ..uo-1 J. J:6:- J.i ~IS""~' (21)

.Jy~ "4-WI .;IS"~ \.:..<> jl:l-1 .!l.l.lS) , · "oJ....,l.UJ r!-11 tl..,a... u_,... tj 6\¥ b_,;u .!l.J) .;15:..;

.~L!JI rL.)'I "l>... c.S"" ~~ ~~ tj J,.....\11 oh ..~.>! 0J~ ( .:}J ,~ tJ_,AJI 0,HJ J,....'JI ~

JJ~J ~~) 4Jl..11 ~L!.ll ..f'fi ~ 4JL.)I yi.:S' l; ~" J~l y_,Li .!l.J.)..? J~ l.t)

J.i ~ J')b:.~t, 14 "4-"11 J~.J.:..-1, J,.....\11 ,)>""J,? c......P'J 4.1~,) J~ ~.t w~ ~J ~L ~J y1~

.~1.!.!' r,.il, ~_,....,.. ~ ~ l..s" ,~1 t'--' ...,15 ~ ~ <1s>

.455 4.t.I.WI ,.;,J,W. .J!I t) .45 J,..,~, Js t).}!l ~..;N J ~' •<$?1' /0)

156 ~\.!JI fl.ojll ...,_:;~.:,o •<$j!)1 t)

Page 10: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

430 1 UluslararasJ imam ~am Sempoz.yumu

,)l+>-~' J~ '1_, 'r~~~ Js- ~'-' J_,.....\11 0~ \~L:JI r~..o~1 ~ 0i J..i J. ,~L:JI r~..o~1li_,-4 .:>i

.~L!.ll rl.o)'l ~ JtJ.Iy> L.$"4# Wk...a_. ~ ( 0!, ,~~ ~~J J_,.....i ~ r~\11 c)

~~ j.J...UI ,)-"""-" .0')6.:. ~~J J}WI .ly.-_,1 ~~ c:--' ~ ,~L!JI rLo)'l 4,.J_,i ~ t_l.r.-)'1 ~\$..)\ Lo~

~u~ .:1-J..dl c) ~\1 Y-:---\11 ~I Juu.J y\...)'1 ~I ~.)1 .iA; ,'j rl '-! J'j~'j~ j.J...UI ~~

'C:"} 0!, J.:-11 4:-lt...::..l "'~-' t_l.r.-)'1 t}J ~ ll1~~ ul>._, ~.)~ ~~ J_,; c) <.S;~ ,~_,; ~ Jl'.)

.J:..a.i:ll .y ~'..f-! ~_,All ..;. /'~ ,~L:JI r~..o )'I Y-:-i

yl.o~l ··:.It I.Sj&'~ ~l>.J <.:r--4WI .:r-j Js' ..:;. }~1 ~ ~ y.i rl.o)'l Wll J_,...,! 0J.l .y J_,l 0! yLo)'l ~I ~.)1

4l:L...o ~J Wll J_,.....! ,r-i .y J_,i 0i ~1" : ;..l....<oll .;r>- J.,.-..JI J~ ,_J.ll..all ~ .11 ~ y.i ~I o~

.y 'F-' .~~ W.l>...,..l ~ t.J..i -li_, ,..;.)L.aJI 1»1 ~ y.i rLo)'l ·~ { r)l..JI ~ ;~1 ~ y.i rLo)'l

(22) ".lL)'! a..:..~~ o..t:....... ..:..4tv. y ~~ ~; ~ 0..1f""hlll+,;; JL...o ..!..ll.l

o...!J\.:.. w.s:J1 o.i.A c) ..}Jhl ~I .!.Jj.) ._?G li!J" :o_,Aj y.f ~ ~u Lo ~1$-.)'jl l.i.A ~ ~l>.! .19'-J

~ ,~u Lo ._?G li!J ,~ .11 ..?; ~I ~Lo)'l J! ~!,ill o.i.A a.,.....; J-.-1 c) -..!JG 'jJ ,~~.)\A

o..U l..t>. ~I=S' .))i ..;i tJJ ~~ c) .Y' li! ~L!.ll Y-:-i c) r)l5:)1 .:>!, ,~ W! :~ (J ,lJ,.I :J~

o.i.A "-:-i 0} :J_,Ai 01 ~ .!.Jj.) ~J 'ol:;:S' _,1 ol.J,..I.!.JJ.; c) ~\=S' b}l WI ~I ~I t_J.. (J ,~l:ll

~i ..}Jhl..l,-.11 Ju ..w_, .. _.J_,.....~I c) .;J-1 ~.ill w\1 )r~i ~_,.....!c)~~~ ~Lo)'l Jl ~~~

c) ~L!JI L4..,. W! :jJ 0~ ,...,_s_,... pi; "'')l.o! ..C .J!, ,~Lo;\J J::.:...aj 41 ~ ( ..;4 ;..l....<oll.;r->- J.,.-..JI iil1

WI Js- ..:..?-_, r'~ .YJ ~l:l~ ~b...all.y .:r-~1 J~ c) ~t,; ~ ..:,..;lS' ~l:..l.10i li.J) ..w ;}:.All

~jl4 ·~ .y ._,!_,~;;_,~b....,..~~ ~1-li ~ y.l rLo)'t 0lS' 1.;~ ,~La# rl.i:...~ ~

~li Jl a.i.J..I c)~ }~I~ rL<)'I 4.~ ~ 1»1 ~~:AI rLo~l ~c) .o..lS' .y)l0ts' ..W 1-:-:!r.J~

~.,... ~ ~ r .J')I..Ll:.l 0\...Lo)'l 0\S' % ,~\.:.. c) ._;:.11 ,_r;~..u1 ..:..:,:1 .!.ll.ll_, ,~l:..\.1 -.b.~

(23) "- 1:.·-11 . 1\:J\.. "L!JI u....., 1 ."•.)1 I . - ~ { I·. r--~ ~ . ~ . - (" ............ '-=-'

.310 r-;.....'1' r# ~,..,.......~; ·~ .1,-J1 'J~' <22> .15 .wl1 J_,...l ,~ <i;'j y.l (23

)

Page 11: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

imam $afii'nin Usiill Kelam Ekoliine Etkisi 1431

. ~I ,jAAJ. ~j$'~

J_,....f yi.:5:J ~ ._..li.. c) -~L.....:ll JJWI ~t,:.-'i .,...WI ~I ...,-}r I)~Ai~l u_,JI y.f ~I Jl.i

..!...:>- <.JL.....:ll ~ y.i .... ~~ c'rJ w~1 rv! _,.; -~ l....:'- J_,....)rl ~ c.J ....;.;..... .:.r J_,i 1...~" :~.r-11

·rv'i~ <.j} . .,..;)rl r.~! .:.r. y~ ...._o....y. y.i rv'il ~UII ol:>-\..P o';J..:iJ ..J <.j!}l yi.:S' c.J J:,~)'l cJ):> c.J!.!

(24)..__, ~ ' .t • ~ ' • I • j_ . I •.:A .. J ....;.;..... Alll v-J ~~I t.r.J~l 0! ~ ('\... 'il { Alll ~J 1)~1 .:,--1 .:.r. ~ l)l..oJ'I

~ JJI,bll ._;..i~.:t _,._, y..L. J! w~ C:""' u:1 J_,....)rl c.J ~~~ t~t.....~ 4:)_,1.;" :<.?J.,s:JI rv'il J~_,

yi.:S' ~ t..}.t..;_, ..l:i.i\.J-1 W1 o.?:> w- ~~ ...._o....y. t.}.t..;_, J_,....)rl c.J yi.:S' .J.....): r lA_, 'r~l c.J J_,....t..;l c.J

(25), ! I • (.$~1

(27) (26) . ~ ~~ )'!, <.?J§JI p ~... ~ ..J yi.:S' c.J ri_,All t..}.t .:.r.ll.Afo ~ t..}.~ <.?~~ yi.:S' ~ <.J!J

.:.r. W1 Jl o...l.:.-.! (.$~1~1 ~I I.S..1J ..ili ,...._o....y. t.}.f ,y- <.$..1J \... vi -~f l...:'- opi;- o_A ~J ~ ei

J f. ""'I . J 'I ~~·I ··'I -· 'I '. " J•~ (28) '•'I . • .. >"" cJ ...,...::>V t:"'-' if -'~ · · .o_r:s- ..r UJ" ~ t..}. ...,-..... r : u ...u.""'""' ~ .:.r. ............

<.Jf ~l.:.r.l foJ /29

)"._;.-')rl.>lhii c)~ t..}.i ~ ~J l.A_r.;_, Jl~l u1-~ ~ t..}.j ....,......l.. Js- ...WI

c30> • . . . • . (JI..,a..)'l ._,')\:>.I yi.:S')J ("-! ~_,>til <.j!}I)J (t..J"l:.ll d)b-1) ...._o....y. t..}.l ~if

yi.:S')_, (<.j!}l ~4:>--1 ·yi.:S') ..J <.Ji r~~ 011 ~.~_,r ...w ~~· ,j. JJ. '-!~1 J_,....~~ ~ ~...~

. (31) ~I 01 .J.....): J,J{; ~Y'"J ~ ~~ ~l..!.j ,Y _;:,>-)'1 l...u._, , (...WI j_,....f yi.:S')J (<.J~)'I

,J_,....)rl ~ cJ 1)~1

.3/ 1 ~_;-J1 J_,...f ,j,W i..e.li. t~J'W~1\jjl1 y.f (24)

.67 .;1.,.!J1 .;;-:>' .r. .4>u r~.o';l1 o.r J IJ'I.o~l tJl! ,J.Alj .w... •<!)~, <:Q> .r.l :pi ,~ ~~ ._,J\:.e y\5 <II <A405 ~_,:.11 t!.IA...II r1Jo11 ~~ .r.l! ...;_,F, ~~ 4- .r. .w... .r. .4:>-1 JA (26)

.47 ~!J:ll ~,. .w.,u.; . 181J'I.o~l tJl! •1!)~1 ("].

7)

•t!~l.u,ll ..,..,s...:J1 :p1 t~l..lA! OW~ y\5 oiJ oA380 ~_,:.11!""""\.ill y.f J.Al.!JI j-. tJ. ,W...,)! ~ _,:> {28)

.139/ 1 ~I ~lj .j 4,-AJI ~\y.J1 t~_}J1 ;~\.ill .J+ ,351/ 9 ~1..lA! C;!;1i

.246-245/ 14 ~l..lA! f:!!.;1i •t!~l.u,ll ..,..,s...:JI (29)

.253 .:.....ft-&11 •J>'-'J.;,! .W... ,~J.:JI .r.l (30)

.254 ..:...... _HI I ·~J.:ll .;r.l(31)

Page 12: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

4321 Uluslararast imam $afU Sempozyumu

ej ~u.ll rt...'jl ~~ ~.) ej C:"'"!)l .:,! Y! ~~ ~~ ,;;y ej ~I 4-iL. Jl 41~\JI oh rSJJ

:c.}4 ~ ~141~1 .:r ..... ~_, '<J-J..I.:ll

c.J"l:.ll J'::)b:-1 yi.:Sj "~ .ly=-UI <$!)1 yi:S' .:.r- ._a....y. <.}.\JJ <$!)1 yi:S' .:.r-~ <J.\1 ._,.......; \... .Jl :~Ji

~ ..;..~ r..W .~1 .~ w\11 ~YY, ~\11 ..;..y! ~ ')U •~.,.w·..,.£ l$!)1 ~4->-1 ._,.,\S" .:.r- ~j

..? ~ ~ JL....o .Jfo .ili ,.:-_5 ~ <$1 <JJ ~.,.......... <$.JJ.j ')U ~ L:..P;til 01J ·~! ~

...WI<} JL....o <} yi:S' <~il.l! .:r-J-1 c)!~ y_,.....:l.l .)~)II ._,.,t.;S:J W4 JIJ-1 y W' <$!,!4 ~4-:>--)11

t...i ,.1_,_,.1.4 J_vJ.~ .:r-J-1 cJ! ~ j.o\11 yl:S" -..lr. .:.r' ~ YJ ,4,)_,...,\JI .J~)II 41l.... ,j ._,..,)j

. :~ ~~ y .~ .:.r- u.~, ci;l; J_,...,\11 ~,:; ~ <J.\1 <$!)1 ._,.,\:S" .:,4 ~t;.;\JI u_,ll <Ji r..r:-

<J ..,.£ ~II.<{ ~ .:r-J-1 .:r. ..l...S-J ._a....y. <J.\1 .u.All J_,...,f <} ..,.£ ~.»-Y. ..,__,.all ..;.,4~1 .J! :\:;U

._,..:S') ~ o\J <4J "!b....:>i ".JJL!... ~ liy~ rt...'jl JL!.f Jl ~ <Ji rt...'jl ,:r ~.J.I ~I j:WI

0! ..J...S. rt...)'l ,y- ~JJ Jl ~I if'J ·~~~ _,.,.U; ._,.£ ~~ ~J ~I ~ ,;~ ~ (Jy\JI

~'v. ~J..r" c./'J ,~ ~ ~_,}1 J:WI ,j ._a....y. <.}.~ ~ <.}.! ~ ~!JT_, ..:!_,T .:.r' ~ l..,.J .:r--J--1

t:'lJ:.~ ,.:..b4)~ <(j.o\11) .1_,_.,.1.1 :..,.£ ~ <./'-' •".J~ _,! OJ~ t...! .:r-J-1 .:r. ..J...S. ,:r q~_, .:..I.A!ll

~~ -J>f' <} p:ll .:r.l ~ ~ J!JWI lh ._? J~J , p$J1 p-l~ ,~1 p-l~ ,~1 t:'lJ:.~ ,~1

~_, ... olS)I ..,.,L:Sj o')L....II ._,.,\S" Jt...\1~ J_,...,\11 ,:; ~~ .:.r- ._a....y. <J.\1_," :J_,At ~ ~L.all ..,.£

(33) " ... olS)I yi.:Sj o')L....II ._,.,\:S" J_,...,\11 ,:; ~~ ,y ·

,o.JL.)I "'l:S" ,:; ~u.Jt rL.'jl J_,...,\1, ~ ,:; ._c..... .:.r- J_,l .:,4 .)~~ J.; C:"'"!)l ..,~ ,.us- .!11.) ~_,

Ji \... ?J •.JJI ~ ..l>.\.; L:..:S:l ·~ ~ .:..4~1 o.U .:..~_,t:JI ofo 0~ b.J~ ~ ·~ Jt...::..l .:,! Y!

IJ.>.i cJI .:,\11 Jl ~ ( ~~ Js- _,; ~ ( ~~ <~u..11 rt...)'l) y_," :~j y.l ..J...S. Jj ~.) ,:;

(34) II •

u.-

J.J-P~I tJ'.JJ3 y~f

<.J"I.Al~ t.U:-'j~ w~ .JT,Al4 J)l..~;:...)ll ~_,;-..,} ~ ~I;S' ..J ~ .:,! crl.!Jt r\...)'1 if<$~ 0! tJ"'}-¥ ..,_.u,

.4.JL.)I y\;S' crl.!JI r\...)'1 ~j 'J'~~ r_,......ll ._,..,:,.._, triliJ t;--l:ll .Jt.!_,

.16/1 .;..!~~ .J!I J'l..o; ~~ ~ ~lt"'""J ~_,.i.o! iil......JI ~fo:.JI cr ~l..o; <.;..!~~ .J!I (32)

.254-253 ..:,.... .Jfoill '!"!..t..:ll .J!' c33)

.16 ...WI J,..,l ,ii~j y.l (:H)

Page 13: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

imam !7afii'nin Usiili Kelam Ekoliine Etkisi 1433

rt..'J' ..:,..$o::. ~t,... pJ;- c.>?l ~1.:--i !.I~.:.> .;! )I! .~L...)I ._,..\:S' ~~~ ri:.'JI JJ-'=lf-t,... ~ ...,.Jkll 1.,;..._,

1}::; ...,..u.· pJ;- ,y &JJ u-l ~~~ rt..'J'.:r _,.~, 1J.... t?--4-- cJ! .:,r)I...~.,J> ~ t _,l.i ,J_,..,cyl JJ-'=1 ~L!J'

~ ..r=i- </~ ~) ,J_,..,!yl ~ ..;14 ':1 to~ c,r~::. ta;.....i ,..:;.r.)..I,.;J ..J!J-'=11 ~~::. ..:,..$o_,-.; ..u_, .'..J!J-'=11 </~ )_,:I

.J_,..,~I

~ ,i,.:.~ ~::.jl ~ <$pAl <.?\!JI 0_;!1 cJ "-"Jo J.!.t ~~ ~Is- y')L... ")I r_,WI ..J!J-I.i .;! ~ ~WI ~~I t..f

.!..:~1 cJ!r cJ _,-lll..i...> cJ r"j..... ")I ~~ tf' 4:\...J ~.J~ .::..':}.! ~ cJ :~1 Jt;" <~:... <.?\!JI ~I cJ ~W:I

I. , ,,.... (35),_. . . _I. II . 'I _ ,I;,.;_ ·. te'. • ,t,l · ,,.... --Ill ' I: . '·'I · " 11 ..l.A t..loJ. -.,._,. y ~ .:f r U.ll;! J r-- ,Y t.J~ ._.l t.Jo _r- ..l.A <J"'J •. -~~ .......,~

.J_,..,!yl ~ ..J!r .!.1.1~ 4..lr. ,YJ .(9 :.r-J-1] "0~\i ~ d13 j1J1 ¢ ~ df o.Js._,l ~ ~J.I JW .1!1 .lW. ,y

=<J~ I...J lAir.! J-...J ,J_,.....fyl ~ ..J!.J-'=1 ~I.:L-1 ~~It..!

I_(...,~~ WJ1 cJ .:rli' !~_, ~~ ..::.r_r::;u r-:J.-'JI cJ ~_,:All ::.')1-:-11 ~~ y::. ~ ~J.rll .;LJJI .....;......;. •

,\i;':J':J::._, ._,.,_,..dl ~ cJ ..::.r':/L...;:..':Jt, ..::.rU.~':/1.;# Jl c_>::.l

t:!'.i .;! c.r::.f .;15:; •4-:::1 &JI ::.1.1::..!.~ •<$!.,11 ~~ ..... .)..Lo) ~..\).1 ~~ ..... .;..Lo ~ ~J..Lo .;# •

. J':/..1:..-':/~ j.JJ.II ~J C;:"".fll J)>_, J')I.:L-1 ~ ~ j_,.....i

r~l Jl ..:;....,.b-1 .::..::.~) e:luJ ..::.r~ •'-".;_,!:,;) ¥l...=':/l ..::.r~l J)b:.~ y":J.-")1 ~_,J.II a.d.; t_Wi e

.¥..,.:. ~~) ~ J,...l J-r.~~

~ ~ ':1 .;I.S:i ·~'.11~ cJ e:-P}~ J,...aJI .;,# J! .. !.m c..>::.i ~ u.::.L:....! ::.l.l.;.o~ ~-l.:ll ~'.JI •?. . . ~'.1)114 .}.At \t_,..,i ~ .;I

,a:....)~ J':J..~;...':JI ~ t...pi:-_, <..b-),!1.?: J':J..~;...':JI.f;; w'\k <Jb ,~_, '-!.}- ~~~ ~-' ::.4>.':/1 ~J ,_;,~ ~·

(36) • • • ~ ~ ~ ::.j..b- e:-"'J ,y ~':I .;IS:; ,~_r. ~ ..,-) ~ ~ u.~_, •t_lr.'JI.fs c.>?!>

~\!11~1

4:1-""'~' ~' L.)J.o

~~~ rt..'JI C::» ,j_,..,~l ~ J. ~ j_,i ..14 ~IS"~~&~_, j_,..,~l ~ J_,fyl ~I ~~I rt..'JI e:-"'J "s-\1.) ._,..IS" J!:.o ....t:w .}>A! J. .:.241 Jpl J.> cJ. J..io-l rt...'JI....,..:S .w ,._,..'-:lith·~ ,y J~ .;~ ~~ y'-:11

. . (37) <...,4]1 J~!) yl:S' .~>270 <,)_,:1.1 <$.1'\l:ll ::._,1::. ,_;.)( .!.U..i.SJ , {jWI yl:S')J ~J t;--l:ll yiS")J (Jy)l

.261 ~\.olLIJI t;.JU •Jo_,_ll (JS)

.167 .-!,..,~ Wll.,...Jii ~~ ·~ ,.) •.:f"J' .36 .j::>JtJJ-"'il.fJ.ll # ·~ ,.) ,iiy :pi (6) .281 .;.....HJI ,~J.:IIIJ!I (37

)

Page 14: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

434 1 Uluslararast imam ~afai Sempo~u

..,.;SJ I (38) ~~ _,-A!J) ..,.,l:SJ <r.,..J~ ..,..~'> ..,.,l:SJ (~I> ..,.,l:SJ (.b-~1 .r.>) ..,.,t.:sJ <..lJA.:l' J~!) ..,.,!:SJ (39) .

~220 J.fl\.J4i .:t. ~ ..,.;SJ . &'l' ~ ~ c.Jb (..:.....<:JI) ..,.,t:S" .A221 0.,.:11 rlla.:.ll J'--!.:;. ~!r.! 40 .

1( \f$!}1 .)4:>-1) y\:Sj (~I ~I) y\:Sj (~I ~,J..I) y\:Sj (..rl.AJI ..:..t,.1) yl:SJ (-1>-~1 ;.>) y\5

• • . . l . (41) ~ . 233 .-,ly)ll ..:,L4:..,.ul ,y ~YJ I ...WI J_,....l cj ~ J.,ili ~.:;. ~ ~

,Jl) ~~J .!..ll~ cj ~IS' ~<J ~~~~ ~~T ..:..l,>'\! ~i:JI cj ~w.ll rt..')l .;~ ~~~ ._,..l:ll.;i ..1.>...:i

~~T ,y ~t...)l cj l.. I..I"J) Jl)J 1..!-!.JJ.I J:>i ~J ~w.JI r-"'J .....-..i.. ,:.r <::_bJ-1 cj ~~li ~~ ~L..)I cj t.. ..i>:.i

<)! ~ t?'J J-lJ .~ J:>f ~J o~ 4J.l~ t.. t?'} ~~ ....;.llil: ll4.:.- .r'JI .)JJ ~ J,A.i 1-,J_,....i J~~

~ ..:..ils' ~ ~~ ._,..,illl cj a..,w Jyl ~ ..::.J.i; ,y JJI .J4i .:t.' ~ ~~ ·~I lli ,y .;~ J_,...,~ .;4i

42 . ( ) .. =· · · · J I I w ·· ·'I '-~ lr.' '· • • · • ...~ c.J !r" .y ·~ _ ~~ rt..11 ...r ~~ -,J_,....)It.;41 .:t.l..:..~

.;I ~ ~ J}JI 41--!r- cj J!j t.. ..:..,;IS' ~L!JI rt.. ~~ ~ ..:J; Jl Op.Oll cj cJ_,.,,/~1 ~I .;! )lj

t? JJ.j ~Jt;,.; 1_rull ~ cj ..,_..l.il!J ~4A"!I ~ 4-o_,........,.J tJ J\!.. ..:..,;IS'~~ <,:,r:- d.~_,.;._,.. cj .;IS' ~I

~ ·-. ( )l.-_r. Ji ~l; Jf LA; -,lyl..:..~.;._,..;._,.. ,y ~L..)I cj ~J l,. J,... JJ~ ~_;s1.;i w-l.!il~

~ IO)~J ~ -,!_,....! I..I"Ju... ~ ( \.... d~J •;L.:l~ ~4 -,!_,....~1 ~\.:l.l d~ c$..r:-ll C:!!)l .J_;.JI cJJ .

<J~ (..>321..:..) J~l ~\..> <Jr "-=!~ (~03...:..) J~l ~ <J~ J,....~, wi ~ .:r ~pi -,!_,....~1 .,~'JI.;i ~­

c$~1 ..3l1 ~ <J~ (~340..:..) if"_f.JI ~I <J~ (~33...:..) f$..lijll1 ~ <J~ (.A330..:..) C$_r.!.:YI .:,-J-1

~ <JY j_,....yl cj J~l yi:S" ..14 w- 1~\.dl -,J_,...,:Yt ~l:l.l • ..1.... .)J>.'J ~ ~ 11'""';}-J (A369..;...)

J,:...a-o J} y~l l..i.> ~J ~~I .!11; cj -,J_,....\11 ~l:l.l • ..1.... )_J>.J ...:..~! Jl ..,.£.11 .:.r' (~370..:..) ._,..l.,d,.l

44) · . . < _~_,....)!, ~ ..:.._,A.:...I Jl Jy~l C->t,.. y;y J-L!. -l:Jj J..:>r cJ_,...,I

~~~ r:?'Ji J.~ Lrlw ~1_, ~liJ 1.# jSi-,J_,...,\11 ~l:l.l ~~ C$..r:-l1 u-"l.:l.l .J_;.ll Jb! l.lJ t.S>-

:~ ,L~.!:J_,....i .;?_).J ~ J;- _,A.:...I t$>' ~ .J_;.lll..l.... .)\)l,.J

.159{ 1 v,J,...l.Jl ..:.o\4,1> J ~I c-All·~~~ (38)

.143/1 ~I c-All •c/~l (39)

.140/1 ~·c-Al'·~~~ (40)

.255 .:-..JEA!I '(O!J.:ll .;r.l (41)

.118 '} .. h; ~ ~..1\1 4...1_;.) .,P<Jt .;_,...~l.}:all,ah; c4ly :)a;l (42)

.23 Ui"J ~ ~ ;if')..,.~t.wll J_,...f <_j.l?.- .U. .) •.jl#l .42 .,PJI .,.~_,...~l.}:aJt,ahi ,4Jy :)a;l (43)

.IA.I.A! I..J 133 .,P<Jt .;,...~I j:Al1 ,ahi ,4;/'" ;clJ.) ~ )a;l ( 44)

Page 15: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

imam ~afii'nin Usilli Kelam Ekoliine Etkisi (435

c!'J .:,15:; ,'-:)_,..,~1 ..1.1'~~ ~U.4 ~ wi .y- ~J}.I ~~ t.,;ll ..b.J U.J.ll o.iA ._,..L..~ :~1 ~)'

.~lt-WI ~_P. ~~ ~ I.U_, ,~ '-:)_, .... ~1 JWI d~~ ~~ o.iA ~')I.. .y-~ ~ J_,..,)\1 ~~ t)_,..,i

t:f'l,. J\.;s-1 _,;. .:/' ~J la<)~J ~~.ill ?::,1_,:;.;....~ ..1.1'~1 j....l; ~ 14b.....>f ~I .l.iJ :·~1 ~_,b

~ -.bJJ ¥b:J.~ ~I if't:.IJJ ~~I J>_,;ll ~ l.iA 'J _;5' 1.1!_, ,_,JI; <$f.y- !¥- ..1.1'~1 ~.>ji .!11~ ~ I...S" ~I ~JoJ a,uJI ~J:" C: ~4 <lij .)j ~\.!.~~ -.l.rJ.I ~~ ,:y ~I ~I~ 1-iA ~.>fr--1 .l.i_, ·i~1

o.iA ..:...:-a ,o~l...;.i J. J..lJ:.~ ~1 Jls; if ~J~ ,Y ~1 .:/' ~ ~~ ~U.~I t~'J )lls; .Y ~J

~ ......<;.....> .:/' pl <.h ~~L!JI U.~ ~~ ~J ,~QI ~_P. ..:..;_r_, ,W:,:.ll 14b.....>i ..:...U.~4 ~~ ~)=ll

.~t.:Ji r

J_,All ~J~ ..1.1'~1 ..!,ll; ~J (.u.oll J_,..,i ~) ,Y ~I "4-U <-4"' :~J.ll ..:.r.,.1A .J\: J. .J,..U:.:. .:r-1 Jfi

JlL.ll ~l:.J ~}-!J~ ~ ~~I ~ ~~4 ..;.!~ .u.ol4 ,ri ~ ~4AAJI ~\5" .Ji ~j.!.ll..i.S' ~~ .:,_,...IS:;U ~ ,~

~_,a ...,J~ .;~ !~i \... t}AJI J~.l;..~l J! .J_,I:c, .u.oll.y- J'WI..!.lli .Jy.fi .:,_,...IS:;U_, ,~..:-<.:!I~~

(45) . "r=-""Jo ~J

~ d_,..,~l jj.~ J=b-:1~ ~.}:ll J>rJI J)l.>. if '-:)_,...~1 ~ '-J~ ........ .,-.:11 ~Il-iA.:/' ~1.0.1~

o.il ..roll..4-~ tWI j,!~ t.P'1 J ,JoWl y~~l J>~ll.iA .:/' ~~ ~J ,1;-.al\...a..:.J \6\Al_;..J <-J..lll o.U

.J.4=.--- p$' ._Aljl ?£_~ f ~I .Jj I...S" .!.ll.il ~ -=-.J L!J-lll o.iA .Jj .)j <-J.l!J

~J ~~ 4..1J~ 0~

r~l Jooi rli ..!:....:>- ,J_,...'J~ r~' ~ 0:!! ..bJI ~ t ~1 o.fA.II Jl '-:)_,..,'JI ~ <-J..~,.o,ol!.; J...f .:.~ ~)o ~ 1.1!_, ,'-:)_,..,'JI..1.1'~4 ~.,ZJ y~l ~~';1 ~..lj .!11.) .:/' ~~(; ,~_,..,f ..l.l'!,i ~ y~l ~~i ~~

Jw ,~4AAJI U.Jo .y- r-P'Jo ~}iJ ~4 ~J ~ .J_,..lb:. .:r-1 .!11~ rl.c:-- if J_,f JJJ '~ ~_P. ." ... .J_,.l-<::!.1 ~ ... ~1 ~4-U <-4"' :o_?.:o .Y.WI._r.ll J.

?::,~4 y~l J_,ill d . .~.t 0?- t!!)l .J_;ll ~i.l.t J! ~ ..I.:S- J_,..,'J~ i')\SJI ~ 0:!! ..b)l l.lo. .:.~_,

.y- -.J_,.al '-:J;...'J1 ~~';u ,'-:)_,..,)!, ~ ._.~ •G ~ll.t ..;.;IS'~ .:/'J 'c.J!f"';1 ~ .:.)~ ~')ISJ14J~'; 1)_,..,)11

~ o-"'-V '-:J., ... ~ ~<:1.1 L,rl- J_# j} .:,j ~~ ,<46)\J:.,. ..bJII.iA p .J_,.tl11.ic. J. i')L<:JI ~ Wi ~

I).;J.I ~u.JI },J.I .J...r ~l.OI~ '(~403..:...) <$r!')rl ~")1;\.,ll .r~ J!f :IJ' 'i')\SJI ~~ .:/' 0!-J'I ~ Js- .:,IS'

.455 4-.IA.JI ,,:,_,..u,. ,;r.l t 5)

.)~~~ .f.AJI _ul:.i y\:S" .j t!l)l .J}JI ~1.1! .j r~'J J~"JI ~.;,.! .»t.,;J'iii.IA )y."J .)s- i,;$ Jl'i) .;..,ll (46)

' ' •• ' I I • ~ ..:.. 11 ' ·I ' •·- II . .....,...~ .......... ..) -~·~-

Page 16: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

4361 Uluslararas1 imam ~am Sempozyumu

~}1 Jfi ·~~ .,!JJ;, ~ lr- _,>~1 ~J ~ rYJ j:Wilro J--J ~I :.}_,.,~1 UIAl_;...t •(-A415)

.. ~.,. ~ .~_r.J ~J !f-PJ~ ~_,::.,; ,(~L!.ll rt.)'l) ·~.:; .. ~.,.J" :J_,.,~Il) ~L!.ll rt.)'rJY J! Ju.i .;i ~

~..!} ,JI.r.)'l 1.::) ,..::..~U.)'II.S:.tJ ,..::..~l,JI ~_,; ,},.:1:1 -¥-~ ~uJ ~~ .J. ~ y,i WI ~u :.Jl:,;:>LO.II

J-~ ~J ,s:.!f.l P'- iul ~"""'~ ·~"""'J ,!1JJ ~ •r-"J\.j ~~ ~ ~\.....J •r-"J~\ u-\:11 ~,_, ,JIS:..!-)'1

(47) . "s:.I.:.AJ~

.>y.-J ~JJ ,~u.~1 ..::..~J aJpl! ..::..~ Ll> ~ ~ ..;....u :y_,.,~, ~ ....._J.l..o .;l ...li. ..!.U.i...J

..::.>~ . .:fJ ,.__r!J o.i.c. ._,.1.....! -.:;..;~ ~L!.~l, aJpl! ..::.>~ .;l ~~ ~<::!J w_J. ~ ~J I"""'~ ..::..lA:...a..o

J>.A ,...,....\:!., .:>_,&11 ~ .y Is:.-!! ..!.U>J ....._r!J o.i.c. l) J_,bJI .J.,ll ~ -.:;..;~ ~ ~.rJ.I ..::..~ • .: ... m ~u.\11

.J,-0:11 0" .. ~ ..!.lJ;,

~ p.Jl j:l _,.,!

Jl,.:l:l ~I.A y,~ •(-A303..::..) Jl,.:l:l Js- y,i :~"""'-' ~~ J~ .y w) ~ ~_;J.I .l.:.P w.11 J_,...,l ..;....u

aJpl! .l.:.P w.ll J_,...,f ..,..£J ~J <(.A369..::..) ~_,...,11 iu1 -¥- y,~ <(-A340..::..) t./.fJI .:,-J-1 y,~.!_(.A321..::..)

tJj J~i 'L,ya:o'-J '(WI ..,JWI l) ~ .y J~~~ C;!"}J ~~i ..~....:or ~ <alpl! .)_,...,! t7' I"""' s:. ~.Y' cJi ~

~ .:r~ ~ w.J~l s:.'J_y> .Ji 'Jj ,U.,.W. J_,...,~ ~~ _?''Jl, ~ _?''Ji U~ ~c$_,...,11 iu1 ~ tJ~ ._r.fJI.:r-J-1

. . (48) - . -..;S' l) ttyJ aJpl! J_,...,l..:..;t; ..1-\J:.Io¥- c.s-"'LO.Ii .,.b,. ~ , I.Ajy .y ~ <J ~ ....,..._.;; s:.~l.}. :.j_,...,l..::..IAl_;..

. ..,._.,..i.J.J4}..S"',_, 4-'J l.i'..L<._, JlWI ~-'

~~ <s:.if' ~ ~ ( ~~ o.i.c.J <..lf..!i ,.J....JI :1-A~f.y J_,...,~I - <J ~ o~ Jl,J:lo¥- ~LOll e;:PJ .UJ

,)l,J:io¥- ~LOll ~.:f) ,~ ~~ <~.:... ~ ~ <!.?;- ..;i ~~ JJL\:.. ~ Y'J ~_,...,)1 ~I tJl o..i,..l:l...l..Ji if .JJL\:.. u:b Y'J ~ yi.:S' .y .,....,_ Y'J ..::..~.rJI yi.:S' J_,...,\rll) ~i

aJpl! .l.:.P Wll J_,...,i .;:..._;;...u ,~ J...s-~ Jl,.:l:lo¥- ..,...LOll ~.(A36..::..) ~_,...,11 ~~ y,ls:.b {

c: ~ yi.:S' ~ w_; ·~ w J_,...,i J.)~ r-"10" y\.:5J1 !.i.e. -'-"!J .~ :y_,...,\11 -..;S' ~~.:f) ·~~ t? .:.}_,...,~1 ~~ ....._J.l..o .J~ ~ rtA:....I Jl w.J ~I ..,..£Ji.y Jl,J:l -¥- ..,...LOll ~ ..lf..!i yl:S'

. 6/1 .~1 _,....!1 •,rs".Jil1 t) ..}! i.l...;-JI J_,..,l Jl ~ ~ ':1 ~ .j ,;>J ,~p1 v-J',./'J J_,..,~~.j ~~ ii~ iJ~..oJ clJ.) v-~ <48

)

-.,..A.WI L-UJ -.1! ~~ ~ o~ .j ~~ r"'! .JIS" ~p1 .:r-J1 1.!1 .;,1 rl-ll ~ •t+"J..J ~~ J_,..,l J! ..,_.:i

<(426/15 s:.'M1 i'~l.r--') "J~':/I.j t..~ .J\S"" :<F'.UI ~ \.oS" _,.; olil.oj .j i.l...;-JI ~ ~ \.oS" ,J~I .j .}:>JI

..;_,..,~, _j.AJ1 JJlo1 ,ii? :cll.) ~ pi -~" i.l..,;-!1 V' JS' J.;S. J\.,$1 ~ .,s_,..,~l Os:.'.JT ..:.;IS" .w cll~ ~-' .U..IA/ l.oJ 143 ._p..l1

Page 17: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

imam ~afii'nin Usiili Kelam Ekoliine Etkisi 1437

~ J_,...,lyl Cr W ... \6" 0\5"' .!).).) 0i )I! t?__,..,.,ll ~~ !.}.j ~ ~ L:.J~~ ~ a,J_,...,lyl ~~'YI ~ ~JJ

, ... ~;11~ ~w.ly1 ~.i.. .J.-~) Jw..:;, JtA.. cJ .r~;~..' 0}JI cJ e!rl~ }J'l! cJ r~ J~'l' ~ 01.)1 ,4l.rl' J~'ll,y- y.:J-1 eY w; '!.?~' t!!)~ ...:JI!l10}J1 cJ l..._,...a.> ~~~.ill t_t,.-1 ~ ~ J~)ll 0\5"' .::....r

~....;......;. '<f"\;1..1 ;)}JI ... \6" cj ~.llllh ~ y.:J-1 J,ki tS>' t!!)l 0}JI cj 1.?~)111 ~.ill~ Jl.~ ~j~J

~..1>-f t?JJI fii:.ll .!).).) 'l!.!JJ.) ~ a,J_,...,lyl .;;..1-<.:11 ..__J..v cj _,...U;. >..f""J J~)\! >IJ> W ,~hUt ~~ 4l_r.J.I

~~ ~ .r\;1..1 0}JI ... \6" cj a,J_,...,lyl .:_,;..L<:JJ ..__J..v ..:..._;:....u 'l.?__,..,.,ll ~I y.i ·~J Jyi:-1 -¥- t?lill

Jw..:;~ o_,; <S~ ~ t t.s-i 'llo.l'w.lyt pi> .;r- .;;..1-<.:11 ~_). ~ ~ a,J_,...,i ..::..~ >-"""J ,.S.JJ ~~;; t?_r::.lyt

.a,J_,...,ly, ~L;.lyl ..::..1.4~

o_rl!.~l _,.,JJ-Pi

cj j.aAJI ~ <~,)), ,J_,...,lyl Jll.....o if k:s' t;PJ .)1 ~\.;.~I~ J_,...,lyl Wi if tJ:>U~I ~ y.i ~lA.II ~

.... -w_;... J'.>\>- ;y wU>> <S}J ~ ~ ..w ,<.?_r-::.~1 ~.ill>..u;J ..;...;;~ ~ J ,~w.~l ~ .wll J_,...,i ~...u

.a,J_,...,~~ ~')15:11

.Y"J J:,_,Jly1 .>W.J~~ ...,_.,.,;:!~ ,_r-$JI .>W.J'i~ o..,-,!}:11 yl:S' U.~f if j_,...,lyl cj ~ o~ t,?)li~l t;PJ ..UJ

..,_.,_,p1 ._,.,1.::)': '1! o>fo a,1_,...,~1 tJ)Ii~l ~ 0i )I! ,LJ~ J~....a:>1 .Y"J ~~ >W.J'i~ ...,..,;:1~ ,p$JJ J~....a:>1 ' '

(49) . ~)I!~ f .::....r L.I"'_,A.:.. -.;...(J ,~I.>W.J'i~

~J ~w' ~J ,a,J_,...,\11 ~<:ii ..... J..tJ. 0~ U!JJ' !f-W-)11 cJ' J_,..,.,:~, wi cJ' .iS' ())u~' rv)'l ~ ~l>.-J :~ 'ly. ~i if) ,.JI,:.,ll

·ell~ ,.w}l J_,...,i cJ WI :-..;5' if) (.A476..:..) t?j~l ..;:--1 y.i .1

.J_,...,~~ r~f cJ J_,......;Jt r~! :-..;5" if) (.A474> <..?'"~'..IJ}I y.i .2

J_,...,i ~...uJ f:::'J cJ r.$' JJ> ~ .:,\5"' ..w ,.:_,;..L<.:ll ...._~ r)U>i if rJ (.A478) ~_,l-,1 0.l-'}-l rvl .3 4.:.. ofi5' ..:..Loil_;... i~' ~ cJ !!; ..u) ,J_,...,lyl ~ cJ r..I.Oll t:-"~ 0\5"' w- r)IS:ll cJ r..I.Oll t:""~ <tii .!).).) , ..... JJ.l.l oh

Loi ~~~~ C,\A:.,a.l.l if L:.pi>) ,~ll::.ll -~~ '0!..1.11 J_,....,i cJ J-1..!..1~ (.)~'11 J_;.,i cJ al.>lyl ~~ Jl>W.J'il

J_,...,i cJ ~ 0'-' Y'J ..:..l:tJ_,ll 'tJ:>U\,ll .>W.J'i~ o..,-,!):11 yi.:S' .._.; ~ .::....r ._,a.>J:ll :~ J_,...,~l ~ cJ -.;5'

.w. 0\5"' ..u) 'L.I"'_,..,..;I-1 <1.>.-J ~ ~~ ..... ~ ~ r-"'i·ifJ r.,-ll ~ J_,...,lyl ~ r-"'i if rJ .:,t.:._pl~ ,.w11

.a,J_,...,~I .... 1.A.:...v cJ b..;,~ i~' ~

Page 18: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

438 1 Uluslararas1 imam ~am Sempozyumu '

ks" ~I; 0\S"" UJJ '<.?~1 ~-y,; .:/' Y'J ,~ ~.r'-' r~l .:/' Y'J •(~SOS..:.o) <.}!;JI ...l.ob- J!i . 4

Jk:l.IJ r')\SJI ~ wi .:/' ~~ <J!;JI ~J ,J)U.)'I ~ J>-"'\11 ~~ j;.i rJ' <J!;JI ~J <JJ\fl .J.:..y cj ~

cJ •R" ~ <~.~_, ,v..#'_, .,t.a-~1 cJ .:ll...:oal'~ ,o...')lill ..:..iii_, •rW'.)~ :~ .~ c.:.o~.A:....v 4:-t <~.~.:...;IS'~

·~>""\II ~I ~.J...l.o ~ ~~.:/' ..1!"""\fll.,i..,j ,~ ,J~ :~..WI J>""'i

~ •r ..... '>'' r ~>""\I' .l;J> ~ ~ ~-' .~, '-'J...l.o r~i rJ' rJ •<~606) <,?jl}l _c)!..u' .r:J .5

~ c:? ...,"U:.,a.. .:rJ •R" c.:.o~.A:....v 4-:t ~I...# t~~ J>-"'\1~ r')\SJ' ~ <h! e.'~>"""~' rJ' r')\SJ' ~~ rL.1

t.A~i 0i ~~ .:l..WI •R" ~ J.,...,~, ~ c:? ...,"U:.,a.. L.i ,v..#'J '0!..1.11 J .... ...,..i c:? ~.)~' •..r-..LO:l' ~~ :r')\S:Jt

~~ -.,~_,...,\1, ~ ...... ~ ~ rJ' ._,.,IS" ri ...,.,~,,.,1.., 0~ ,:)~_, ,J>-"'\1' ~ rJ' J~' ...,.,IS" ~IS:. u.~!,

0\..l.pl~ ·<.?~'~~I.}.~ ..l.o..:Jtll_, '.JI.,:lol ~ ~WJ .lf-)1 y\S" c,/'J ~ .:.....,:5' ~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ 4i1

'· r)l...<ll ~ c:? t.L.! 0\S"" ..u_, .~ '-'.J...l.o r~i .:r ~~ rJ •<~631c.:.o) <,?...l.o'YI ·c)!..u' J:.. .6 ri rJ' rJ J>""'~' ~ c:? ...;:: ~~ rJ' r~ ~~ J>""'i c:? r~ )'I ~IS" 0i ~~ ·~..!.>- ~~ c:? .... -w_;...) ,J>-"'\1~

.•..~.:&- c.:.ouW>b c.:.o~ c: 0.,..;U1 -..;S"L. v':lt>- ~.:.\... ..lojJ '~>-"'\11 ~ ~

cJ if~~~~ 0i ~~.Oft)($' J>-"'\11 ~ cJ !,:S) ~>""\II~ ~r~. 'r--=i' R J.>. ~~JA .l.A! ~6,. f .:/' y ..,_.:SJ1 J'..J 0i ~~ ,J>-"'~1 ~ cj ~ ~W>! r..lii ~J 'C.~)'~ ... ~~ cr=J~ .Jl..=:-~~ ~l,f ~I (.:.646) ~\.J-1 .:.;.~ J_,...JI uP~ ~loh r:.t'J <J>-"'~1 o.!->1.,-oJ JL.... J.:AiJ ~}J J:i..IJJ e.~ _ ~~ <,?.r'"b ..,..s- '~j .:/' r .J!"""\fllh_, M.Jf-J (.:.685) <,?Jw..,IJ ~4:J.I ,:;..._, ,...,_,.\.J-1 .:.;.1 ~~I

J! l.A.:l..i.>- J.->J c$>" '->-y c.:.,o.)..lojJ ks" ~~=' ~t...WI ~ t?' ~ Ll¢-1 u.;si rJ'J J')l.k)'l ~ ~>"""~' ~

.c__,rjl .!.lJ; ~ c.:.o~~ c,?~l J! ~W>! orJI c.:.o~

~~ ,~U.\11.#' rJ' tp.J. ~ ~ J ,~U.~I ~ _ra::A; ~ 4,1>-"'\fl ~ ._.,rl-' 0! ~~I~ LC_,

lii.A:...cv ~{; <~'":M: .!.11~ .!lfi ._y.!J •+" ..:..0~ e;=1' 0b ~~y.!J oh cj J_,kll ..1,11 rA .:..,;\5"" ~U.\11 0i

.o~l cj·<,?_,...;.\11 ~ ~ LL!.:i~ ~>.-~ u.~~

4:)_,...,'.1, ~' 4...j.l.t ~~

~ '~JJ.ll oh c.:.oi.Al_;... cj o...b-~ ~J.:l ~ ._r>JL.d-1 oh J.; ~J '~>""\II~~ ~J...l.o ._r>Jl..=:- c.:.,o.)..loj

c.:.o~l.h ;s1 cJ o,).,.-y ._r>JL.d-1 .h 01 :J_,.oll ~§J ,u..#' .:r ;si._;..JL.d-1._;-.... <.>..f'"\ll.;r .:rJ .:/'

:c)~ I...J ~>""~I~ ~.,rl-' .._,..:L.=:- J~! §.sJ <..f'"'YI,:r ~ J5"" cJ ~ ~y ..:...A.b:-101_,

Page 19: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

imam !?afii'nin Usiili Kelam Ekoliine Etkisi 1439

~ Jt;,; ~_rlJ o.l.<. .;..~.A;......~ J--~ .J} .§>" ~_,...~I .:,..Liljll <J ~)15:!1 ..:.oi.A\.i.~l _p(; ~ .1 f 4ii ~~ ~_,...~1 ..:..LC..aU ~ <J ~I <J ~_,; .J\5"' .J!J _p\;111.1.<. .§J ,J_,...~I ~ <J ~ 1")15:!1 ~ <J ~ t~:>i

j=>-x ~)15:!1 ~l,ll..;..;\5"' ~ •k-J b..,;.~ ~_,...~1 -!..>l:).~ .b)I.J\5" J .. ;1:>~1 ;s1 q L.i. ~.) .:r~

<J o.l>-~ ~.) J-- §; ·t ~ & J-- ~_,...~1 ..:..\.A;.,all .:,! ~~ ,~ 41.,.. ..:....b:-J L.JS' J_,...~l ~~ t? ~.,...~I ..:..LC..aU ~ i.i)I.Al.J .:,! ~! ·~I ~ .b)~ 1$')15:!1 I#: t.S...I..o <J ~ ..;..;~$"' J ,~)15:!1 ~l,ll &! .h..J~ \1~~ WJ _p1 ~IS"' .;_v-t:l.u ,~_,...~, ~ ~)..l.A <J .:.r'} r..u; L.JS' ;,~ ~)15:!1 ~l,ll cl;.l! .:,i _,.1;.;

.;..~.A;...... .:.r' I.A~ .:.r' r)I.S:JI ~ \llA::.I _?i ..;..;~$"' -.,.;I..!JI t)_,...f ..:..~.A;...... .;i .!ll~ J! ....A..l>i ,.#..IA:IJ .:.r' 1$')15:!1

..:...:..,lJ y)i ~_,...~1 Jll-11 ~ c)\5"' ~ ~~~ ~1.\l.:r' ~_,...~1 ~ ~_rll -=-:--:il ~I t.Sj"'-~1'-:-"l.il.l

p~ll"""' ~\S' -.,.;I..!JI .Jl-9 ~J ,..,_JWI <J ~)15:!1 ..:,..~1;.)'1 ~ .:.r' ~_,...~I ~t..- yi t .J!J .)fil ~~

.~~.A;...... <J ~_,...~1 o.!.>l,ll <J 4>.-~.)!J ..b.J ~ .:.r' r)I.S:JI ~\..~....:AI

y.lll t:)}l4 r_?; ~~I ~)2.:ll ~~..r:-.:JI ~!rill J--~ J..:$. ~_,...~1 ~~I~~ & r_,At .2 \.:~ ~~I o..i:A .fo r.;). lij {" : ~_,A! ~\:1..1 o.l.<. if t,j!_,,:-1 y ..l.iJ ~~~~ ~}' <J 4:1! ~ ~ •14'-=-~

i.i.fl2!J JlL.ll <J t...~ ~ r~ ~J t:Jr"ll ...,.,'-=-1 ..,_..u.. J! ~ ~~ J.,...~~ ..;:-..i ~!J •4J i..uxJ J.ff'~

tjlu ,.wll JlL... J!..::....i:J.; ~ j_,...)rt .!l!L... <J lii J--" :~! J_,.GtJ , (51

),:JJI ili <J oli~i \.. ~~ 1.4t •¥.rJI

• • (52). ' to ..l.iJ • .JI:>~I ~ <J .)~~~ j!..:!l ~ J-- ~~~I ~I~.))! r», tjll Js- ~ j..o:JI J--~ ,~ t~:>i ~~ \&¥; ;:r J-IS:l4 ~_,...~1 o~l.ill .;J.y; ~1.?-~ 1.1.<. <J ~ ~_,...~1.:/ _#' JjS

u. i..-:u 'Y -.,~_,...I o.!.->1.:-t ~Ji .ill .!JJ) Jl ;.sw.l ,.)~~~ J;....:!l ~ Js- _,!_, 4iQ!t t_J)ll.:.r' \;.:. 0_,.).1)! ')\j

·~ ~ _,! J- ~~ u...,...! ~_,...! o.!.>t,... ..;..;15:.; •r~ ~l.l.t,:::...~ .w~~

,~l.A:..,a.. l) o.l>-~ ...... ) .) t? §; f l.&i ~! ~.,...~1 ~ ~.rll ~ r~ l) ~\:1..1 o.l.<. )L!.::il ~.»

OJAtll )!$: ~ .;\5" ~ ,..,.._,..4-1 "->--J t?...,.....;.... 4$'..2)!., rr-JI "->--J J--~ r:-"~ .1't ~ .;\5" ~

~4 ~ .__rl. 4,.-::ll ~_,...~I ..:..\.A;...all ~ ~u ,..,_,..ill tJ} .j!; ..;..;~$"' \.. 1~1 4:-JO!J ~J-~I

i~ ~I .lot,::...~ .wl~ .k;j ~ Jl ~_,...~1 JW~ t*'I....:AI .:,! I...S" ,~4-UJI U.J. .:.r' .Jy..} 1.1.<. l) ~ 1~1

yL>. ~ 4U}I t.~4 t*'I.....:AI .;15:.; ,~_,...~1 ~~~ -J Lb.JJ 1")15:!1 ~· t..t....:AI Jif JI.Al.ll) ~IS"' ..u_, ,.)_,~

~ ~~ ~.,...~, ~~~..JJ ,~I..!JI..y..ll ~ _,....:;1 ~ w1 ~~ l) <$j~l ~~ y.i ~~.Y' .:r'J ,r)I.S:JI ~

. ...,....;....t.J)

l) b...;.~ .!ll~ .:,15:.; ~ .l>- J! ~ \.Vh ~ ,~_,...~I ..:..L...!J..UI l) ~li_,.ll ..;ldJ ~ .J~ J>-.)f .3 ~ ~_,...~I..:..L...~..1ll L,_,....,.._, ~ ~~ ~~ l)-= ~ ~J •\..a.IS' oWl ill~ .;l:z;ll .;i ~.» ,~_,...~I ~L...~ ·

.534/ 2 viA_r.ll ·.r~' <51>

.892/2 viA_r.ll ·.r~' <52>

Page 20: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

440 I Uluslararas1 imam $afli Sempo~umu

~~ ~ Jp ~ J':/..~:...':1~ ·~~ ~~J t7' l; ~..;!}iJ ~ ..,..J~ l; ~YJJ J-'"'"'~1 ~ ~ ~) .)l$'"

-='-'""'~1 ~ rJ ~ ~ ~ ~ .J.>- J! ~l>.,-,.11 .._u.J~ ~i;J ~ ~lO:.!.I .._Ud\ ~ ~I~ .Ji ':/1

~ J.,...~~ Jlw.:; ykll ..;..~~ J':J..~:,...':J~ ._AAJI,:; ~t....~ ~t>_,..l ~ ~ ..:.ei~ ~_#'.iii~

.;~_r.ll ~IS ..;..L...~,i. rJ ~ ~ ,~_,J,-1 y:. j_,...~l Js- ~IliA J:--~1 .y .)J( JJJ <<1!:>-l,..- JS' rJ ~~ ~ ..:..~

.l.o~ y.i o~ ~\>... f ,J_,...~I ~ rJ ~l;_,..l Jk:l.l rbd!oJ~ o.l.A ...:..i\5' ~ (~l..l...J (_,J.JI rJ J_,All) .J~ a.,...~A,.

~ rJ Jk:l.l ~ j:--.)f.y JJi y> J!;JI .Ji t\..!. ..UJ ~~ ~t:5:J ._1.:,:. a.,...~A,. rJ .._Udl ~ ts~l,..o ~.)t; Jy.ll

'I ~ <53)"JI·~·t 1 1 '1 . I II J f ·1· II • · "" _ • ;\. .• I I • J '1 11 • • 1 J • J ;_,, ~ _r.:... {' , _&" .l.o~ y. ~ """''! (uuJ:' ........,-"") ~ ~ .y "" :"='"'=' cJ. ~ < r" ~

.:FJi:U ~_,....~1 ~ )S1.y <,?j~l ~J ~~ ~ ..;;...LU <,.1_,....~1 ..;..L..!J.l.ll rJ ~t;_,..I.._Udl ~ Ji:ll .!.11.:.

f. ~~ \'j <,.1_,....~1 ..;:,....L<:!.I L.J.l.o rJ ......,\;1..1 oh .J\.!.:;1 ~.JJ ,J_,.$1 ~IS 41.:: JS' rJ ~)~ lh ~J .._Udl ~

~ ;~~, ~~ ~ Ji:liL>.l.o Jb:.l.ili ,._._rll .~ ~~ <,.~_,....~, ..;..l.O.:.a!J.:; o...b-~ ~.>.-7 Js- .:.r<.;

.:>IS' y')L<II <!->-l,il_,i j.ll.:>\5' L..L(; •l..o-UJ Js- J_, ... ~l.t_;;J •.-e-"•11 U.A .... ~, ~::u:, r~~ ~ ~ ~ Ji:ll .Jl$'" ~}J Jsi_,All ;;; rJ ~.)~~ ~~ t_v.ll J! J.ll .;IS' l.$" JlAll rJJ </! ~ ~ Ji:ll

.Ji r)\SJ~ .._.b.:.\.1

wl.>.-~ ..,..Jy; rJ u.~J ~.)J..,b. .:>_,...L<:!.ll.& <!..,> ·4-i>~J <,.~_,....~, ..;..Wk.ail ~ ~Ji .4 a.....\U rJ ....r\.:.:. J.a.t ~~ Jl ~ _#' ..~,;s. ......,\.:1-1 oh ..:J.)i ..UJ •\.eJ ~~ J~..pJi Jy:-.) .y wl.. 4$\...,.J':}

..;..~__,d~ .>yJ-1 ...J>fi ._sU tr='_,.IJ ~ rJ ._\.:.:. ..;..I.A.:....v .)Y.J J! .,;w,l <.)J..IJ.I y~ ~ ... ~ -='_,....~1 ~lAl_r

·cj"'"l.,ll ..1,.1_,11 J.~ .f""l_, ,.!l.J_,; cJ. ~ <..}.~ (Jr"~l rJ .)J.l.J.I) yiS~ J_,....~l ~ ._1;1..1 ~)\h..,':/1 ~1......11

.!::...;. j>--~ .!.lJ;,J ,\2}1}1~ ~ L. \..p~J 1.¢>-1.:--J ~_,JI Wll L!J~ <,.1_,....~1 ~~ L.J.l.o r~l .5 f .:>[, ~ o.iAJ I C.. rl5:,.. ~I .14=--~ ._rll ~ rJ .)4=:-.-\11 .h.<; ~ ~ .)l..f-! j)\.:.:. .y ~) ..1:2A.lll 01-! ~")WI

.Ji ':11 •4-A\..:.. J')b:.l Js- -='_,....~, ..;..l.O.:.a!J_, ..;..L..!J.lll JS' ~~.;...;IS' J -='.,....~, ~<:u ...... ~ ....... \.:,:. J.; u c,.;~ t C->-1.:-- 4:1! ~w.t; C::"J~ y-r_ 4.; ~ .;IS' ..w 'r~ if j:-'; ...:..i\5' ~_,illl ._:..,..t,....~~ ~ ._.!.~.>

r.,...JIS' WJ~ ... ~ -='_,....! <!->-t,... if~.,....~, r.rs- « t.. J! oW.)'t.,;. •L>.f"-~1 -='.,....~, i!:"'l.:.l.l ...,..~..-...oi if r..r.P

U.A f L>.f""i <!..>-'-:-- .:>_,..JS:.:I.I .)t ,o,.~_,....~l <!->-l,il if u.~J jlA~ ¥~ .;r..,!JJ J..A~ ~~ J'~~ ...,.._,.,...;t~

~.r~ .!.lJ;, ~.r--\1 ~1$. .:.r c.....,11 c?J -.JU.)'I ~ \'}J ,.J;lAJ~I ..;..~ ~) WJI C:!'J ~ r..r.P

·r~ u cJ~ f ~yl <!->-t,... L!J~ ..;;...L<:!.l :rJ L>.l.o ~ ~).._.

..I.:S- ._\.:,:. 4.ilS:. Jbll.:>j <!..,> ~~~l;)i) -='_,....~1 <!->-1.,1.~ JL.l.l L!J.) ,_) c}WI J\1..~:..\'~ ~bJI .6 ~\1':/..~:...1 cJ):> ~.fJ ..u_, ·~t,... olS"" Js-~ ~~ ~ .,u..ll ..;..':/':/..~:..':/l.y .:>»-<.;, ,~, ~_,....\11 _,i rj)\;.1~ J\'J.:....\11 ,~\.;; ..;..L,.~ 4,k- J,.l..l:l~ ..;..L...illl .)!;!! :o':/':/..~:..\11 oh r'i ifJ ,\2}11......:...1 tf=l a,l.WI

Page 21: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

imam ~afii'nin UsUli Kelam Ekoliine Etldsi 1441

<.I' V.~J ,~yl ~~ J':/ .. 1: •. :~1 •J-L:l~ JJJ.l~ J':/...~:.J)II •J=WI ~ ...bWI J~...>':/~ J':/...~:.J':/1 ,~j)\11

J_,...i ~<.I'~ Jt!.oJ J':/...~:.JI J-<l l.._r. .;.J:>JJY olA:,.o.:.? ~~l::._JT"J i.llk~l ~ ':/}J ,4J_WI.;.J)i':/...~:.J':/I

-~

.;.Jl..~:. ..:,..j\5:; ,~~T r;:>"}J ~ ~ ,a)_,...YI ~~J~J ~!):>l:.. cj J~l y_,L.i .J_,...L<:tl j>-:.i .7 a,J_,...~, ~L.~:; c:; J~~ ~<.:1.1 r~...:.<.l ~ t:".J.J 'l::...k.J.~ ~l:.JJ ..,...!L.~ J~' ~ 0).;~>- a,1_,...~~ ~<.:1.1

t"ol.i:. ~~ cj ~I ._,...!L.i ..t.i. l.il ty)~l .;.J!»I.¢~ ..:..!):>l:.JJ Js- •_,:.t .!..:>- (")L<JI ~ cj J~~ (""')\; JJ

.!JJ~ ~ :.»! { M J':/...~:.J':/1 :.;J ~ t.S>' ~14bi Js- J_,...YI·~j!. ($.ill.j>~':/l Js- J_,...~l J~l r~J

~ .!.I)L..,. ..:...:;.W ~J .~1 r'%' .h.O..,; <:>J~I o.U .:/ ~ ~J d . ..P~':/1 o.l.A Js- ~I :.J~ J_,...~l ~ ':/ ~ '~ j:WI J~l :~ '":b~ ~~ ~~i Js- \i):;Jj!. .jl .;.J\...P~)il "->--Jj cJ ~_,...~1

~J. j:WI jk,! ':/\.:.A_,..; ,J.I...U~ J':/...~:.J':/1 J~J J_,...YI J~I..!..UL.... .:.r'J ,1,.. ~y. "! l::..,b,.:,..':/1 ~J. J.I...U~

.jl:dl JAJI J':/...~:.J':/1 ..,...!L.i .:.r- ~y..,.i ~~..!,.ll... .!..:>- •rj)l:ll Ji ~j')lll c/' 4:.-J ,~,.. ~y. "! J':/...~:.J':/1.._.,

~~ Js- Jhll...,_l; 4:.-J ~~~ Js- .O~!J rj)l:ll ~ J_,...:y, r# ••l4 ..:..,;~0!) .:t.:! rj)l:ll .;.Jt,.i ~J

~L.i <.I' ..!..ll~ ~J •"! ~~ J':/...~:.JI J~!J 41 "! J':/i:... ":/1 J_,...) ~t.:.. ~J J.I...Ui" ~P J.,...~~ r~ 4-

~ J~l y _,L4 r+'l..:AI o:.t!. .:.r'J •l&J ~~ 4.c" .;.JJ.i. t.S>' a,l.roYI ~~ ~ ~ .;.J) l:..l Jl J_,...~l J~l

cJ. ~~I) y\? ~_,J,.I ~}-1 rt..i ...,_-<; ,J_,....~~ 4.UJI cJ J~l ~ ~ -~~ ~lA:...,a..o cj ~....;,j ,~ -J

.d.O.: ... oll <.I' V.~J •(~I cj <.iyll) "!I.:S" ($j\p.!JI ~~ y.f ~ •(J.!hl

~V, J_,...~l ~ cj ~ & 4..-~ 0lJ •4--aJl...a.>J ~ .... -\11 ~<:1.1 LJJ.l. ~.}:ll f WJ ~ t./' o.l.A

rt..~l )i .JI.! ~J ol:.:,.o ~ ~ t... ~I l.k J ~ ~i li! •4-:!~ JS" JJI.::; ~ ~l>. •. :A ... ~~ Jj

.a,)_,...YI ~<:ti4..-J.J..o cJ ~L!.ll

1!.-JI:ll ~I

4¥"~1 ~I 4....JJ..o t) ~\..!J I )I

~_,...yl .:>~ ~~_,bll .~ ~ <.I' JJi <l.i~ J_,...YI ~ cj ~<:!.1 & t.J""""Y ~\.!.JI rt..)'l ~~ ~

:0\..J... y.i yV.}I ~ .:. J~ ,;JL.)I "!I.:S" cj ~L!.ll rt..~l w)o t./' w>Jio-4i ,.!JJ~ cj ~ Js- ~L.. ~

~4-U o\b:. \b:. ,~1 ~ c:-"~ ,.w.11 J_,...i ~ cJ ~ u,. t.J""""Y ~L!.ll ..r.;:.! .:.r. ..l..S rt..~l ..l4"

~J ,~L!.ll ..._.J.J..o ~ ~t.>i ~ lli. ~ { ~ •Y~)'~ ~~j~ yt..~~ ~~ ~LJ.~ ~\lJJ ~L!.ll 54

".w.ll J_,...l cj ~L!.ll rt..)'l ~~)<.I' ~IS' lS..f"'i ~~J ,~l.il.l • .l.A t_t,.-i rr- J_,...yl cj ~

Page 22: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

442 I Uluslararas1 imam ~afii Sempozypmu

':IISyoUll~.? Pll.:l ~ .§>") '\!~! _,i ~ ~PI JJ lr.i ~~ ~ J! ISy..UI .~ ~ld_,

:-.,~1 JJ~I!) ~~ J')b:.. ..,- /''JI ili ~J ,<:J_,..,\11 ~.__,.,...!)~WI rt..)'l ;i .J ~1..,-l:l-~.!

~ ~ c:) ·~~~ <:J_,..,\11 ..:..ls-y.<>_,lJJ -.IL..jl y\S" cJ ·~~~ <:J_,..,\11 ..:..ls-y.<>_,lJ ~ ~~ ~!f.-1 :JJ"JI

<J_,..,'JI ~1+1 t?.-.JL.)I ~~_,.:>-~ 1<:1_,..,'J1 ~WI rt..)'l ..::•l.C..a.o ..,- U.~ .:,_,.:. -.IL.)I .J ~I .,..U~ ,<:J_,..,\11

• ..:..\..t:...a.!J J4 cJ ·~~~

.<:~_,...\II~ ._J..l.o ~t.....>J ~t:!..ll rt..)'l ~<:~_,...\II ~~1..,-.lt.....>- ~ ~J~ ~!f.-1 :~1!.11

,~WI_~ ~WI15..LoJ ,-.J_,..,\11 ~WI rt..)'l ~~'J -.J_,..,\11 ~<8.1 .__,.,... .:o~lf.S..Lo ._~ :\!.JI!JI

.~.wl ~I ~1.? lft~!>

:.!J.I~ .)l: I)~ l..JJ

~lj ~l.!JI ~ 4,l_t-P'JI ~~j-P_,.ll :JJ'JI ~I '·

.:._,.,._, .b-)' ...!...:>- ,~ .J ~.U.I Joo~ f$~1 Jool ~ & J\!.. ..:,..j\5"' ..:..ls-_,.P_,.. ~WI rt..)'l )>6:- .J Jb,.

;# Jl~i .J ~L!.ll GJ" :f$_,L>.lll .&1 J_, J~ ,.....,;.;,;! .t.. ~ 4.t y~l .:,t: .:.~t; ~ ~ ( J_,..,i

.J 0V.I,:.r .;~:J> ~ L.,..i ~ .~.:>.-} y~\11 ~ .J ~ ~_v_, w_,..,i '-dJJ <~.u.~ I$~~ J-"i) ~ 55

(WI~~ ..,.J~ .J ~..u r~\11 Jot,::....l J.,..,t..b..;. J; ~L!.ll rt..)'l /')II ili ~ ,< ) " .. -~.P ~L!.ll ...sbl\1 La .)Y!J ,ili l,.J! Jl ~ ~J ·~..,. ~ ..:..b..lh....-o cJ ~'!, J_,..,)ll.:,_,..u ,~\.:ll i.>...-!J

~WI cJ ~WI -.IL.)I ~ ...!...:>- ~yl UJ .)Wll cJ ~\....aj Jl -..;~,.;,! ,r-WI cJ ......... ~ ~J ~ ~ .:/' -'-'~::$';" ;1.;- ..• <1 • .J.i"-1 J . '.WI~~ 0 I..JI ,I. .)WI\~ w. I. L': ,.:,U\ OS.')lll ..• i..lWI u 11 • ~ "11""""") ~ .r ,_ ~ (} !.) ~ • ........ • • '+."""' •. !.) • ~ • -~~

fJ ~ ~ ( ~L!.ll .:,f ..!.ll~ J.,..,~ .w ~ .:,§.; .:,! J,i -..;tZ_, ail_, y.:oi ~ ~~ ~L!.ll ~ J. -.IL.)I 56

( ) . ' . • II~ J\ 8.-~ J:.ii (J ~ .;L.J J; J>'-..U

o..U.~..:.A J>.r~ ,~ ~ t..._,.....,.,.J .;.r.t:u ~ ..:.._;:.,.1 Jl J_,..,\ll..:..ls-_,.P_,.. r-"1 ~L!.ll rt..)'l J_,l:i ..u_,

c::"'J .J ~L!.ll rt..)'l ;t ~ ,~_,bll ~ ~J~ .!J.I~ ~ c.s~ ~~J ~L!.ll rt..)'l..,- JS"' ~ ..:..ls-y.P}I

-~~<:~_,...\II j:LJJ_, ~~+~

.272/1 AAJt,ll ~~ tO~.!. ..._,, .!11 .)J <1$_,l.to.IJ1 (55)

11 ~l.. }I JPU i...l.i.< (56)

Page 23: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

imam $afii'nin Us ill Kelam Ekoliine Etkisi (443

4J~~I 4!\...)1 .;.,~_,...;.:._,..

~~ y1.:5JI .Ji d ~J W ._rl;}l Jb._, (d') ~~I ~ ~~ 4J ~ ~ ~1.....)14!\:S" ~L!.ll ~~

.:>f J! ~J ,J.t,::..-'11 ~~ c:!'J ,,!.ll.i! ~ '..,-:!l.OIJ e>p...~ .:>!J' c:!'J ~....<( 0~ ..r.JI J)l>. o>~ l...->.J 1~1..,.

-~~ ~J _,.!.,JI e>li~ ~ (~~ .:>!;JI) ~~I ~I ~r ~ d'_ra;ll P l.S" ~~_,All o..i.A

:Jw "J_,i ...0..~ i..y (~0~1 J$' Y4) .J~ .J 0_,:-j 0~1 y4 Y"J J_,....~l <.!..>-t,.. J_,4 ~WI (~'Jif~ { .

(58) • (57)

: o..~.a> t,/'J ,.J~I (WI.,!.lb ~ fo {, "Wll ~ J_,....~l ~ cJW.C:"t.,. r10~~·

~.,....~, ._;-,. ..\.a> J_r ~ l.l.A_, .I.A~_, 0~~ 4')\..dl .:f JzS!rill ~ u J!.-J Lu Wj. ..3ll 0'-!i ~ .1 ·J~'110~4

0'= l..i.A_, .~ 0'= o>~ ~I e>~\..,..; ~ o>~ _,( (.S.r'"f A>rJI ~ & ~~ ~ ~ 0YJI <J >JJ ~ .2 . .J.lf'"t:l.l ~~I <?.ill ;):11

..~.a> J_r \.. l.i:._, ~~~ o~~ 4')\..dl e>~ ~ ..!.l}.iJ J!.-J ~I <J '"'-= ~J { o0YJI <J ...._(:._ >JJ ~ .3 .j..AI.J'= _,i ~I 0\,t, ~~~~

..3l1 .ri r~ <J J>~ t..i.A .:>i ~ ~L!.ll -.,;_, ,..3ll ...,...I:S" t) ..,....1 1.t r~l .y (d') J_,..-)l.:_r >JJ ~ .4

~ ;)J .!...\!~ ~WI (~'jl ~.;!J ,JW ..3l1 ~ Ji ..ili (.r) J_,..-)1 ~ Ji .y 0~ (d') .J_,...J ~~ JW

·if'j_; ~~~~I ~~~I ~ ._?) .;~ >lf:>. '11 ;)J ..!.1}~ ~\.!JI >~~ ~~ ~ <J >~ '11 o>~ ~ JW ..3ll ._?) ~ .5

59 ( )

1..1"1.-ill J_r { ' II ••• J-WI ~ ~ .,;~ 1..1"1.-ill c.S"-' y\,JII..i.A c.S"-'J" :JI.i ..!...,>- J'I.A)I ~_,i r-"'i .:f 0i ~J 60

.< >,~1 i .... A:S::JI • ...lA.:l.l :1.1 wl ,.,. I!"..I.JL " ~ 1 :11" .·.J­J . .:.r ( .}'r !>"' <..r tJ ~ . ....,....... J'':"'!> ~

"J_,ff..y '(l....J~I o..i.A ...1>-f ~ j>.u 4.15" ~1.....)1 e>~_,..Py ..:,..;lS:; ~1.....)1 4!\:S" 46.>- (W~I o..i.A ..:,..;IS"' .u_, ~ ....,......_, l.iJ_, ~~..,JI Wll ~ j.,.,. 0~ ~ ~ '1 ~ l}/ 0YJI .Ji ~ ~ ,..,~'1>J -.il.!J f.f.JI y\.:S::J4

<J d'~~ r_,......ll.y. ~..l,..;:i lo5'1'1>J .:>YJI .!;\All .:_r ~..JJ-4 ..!.1}.) ')\; { ~~ _ _, ~ ~ j.,.,. ~_,s::J ~_tJI

:1)4 I...J o..l.a> ..:,..;lS:; yiy.f ~L.A.. 4J ~..\J-1 J-.-J •0YJI

111 ~~...)I (57)

136-111 ~1...)1 :}ill (58)

126 ~~...)I (59)

126 ~~...)I (60)

Page 24: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

444 1 Uluslarar:m imam $alii Sempo~mu

, . ,..., oJ;;. ~~ 41>-~ ( ...,u, L.:>,...,V foJ 'c...f'~l ...6:.~; iWI ~ .)~ \...U> y\;Svl ,:r Jj \... .Jl,: y~ .1

:J~.U ...1_,; 4:i\.:JI.:.r-J ,[6 :.)rJ "4i..v .11..? ~~ ._;.}Jt cJ ~b .:.r- t..J" :J~.U ..lj J}JI.rJ ·~' 41>-.) \...._,.....;_, 61

. ( ) [77 : · -s:J~ "l.l> · · ,:,i 1 I.; u . j t-.b:....t -. - I ~1 Li Gl - " ~ ~ ~ . ~ - b'r.r - .<?

~ ,:,lS" ~ •.#' <.1!.4 ..!.ll.il J:-_, '<.I"~~ rWI ~ rJ _~>l.l:ilt rY> ...,t.:S:J1 .:.r- J;i t.. ,:,~.,; .._,4 .2 62

( ) -. <.I"~' J,... ..? ? ~~ r.,..J' J,... ..? ._,dl

Ji] "c.f'UI_ ~ J~.t <)!.ill" :Jt.u .u_,.as- •..r_,....:!.t ~ "-! .)!t _,.,.lkl, rY> ..,..t.:S:Jt .:.r- J; t.. ,:,~.,; ..,..~ .3

(63)

. [173 :c)~

.4

.5

.1wi. cJ <.I"~~ r.,..JI.:_r .q..b- .:.r- ? ~~ ~~ J= ~~ ut ~ cJ .. !J.l.) -'--! ~L!.lt rt.. 'JI ..!J.J.i. i y~.) ru~ 4-=J.rJ WI ~ ~ •.#' ~L,.o ..!.11->-'--! ~t.:Jt rt..'il ._;.~ •t,rP}' 1J... cJ <::f_,ll_...,..~A.- .:>I,A!t

66

~ ~ ~ ,:,tsj ,J~.U .11 .._,IS' cJ :.; ( t.~f tl' (<.I") ~~ .;i ..!.11-> J~ .:.r- £~ , < ) ..!.11-> . ..? •..r.%'

c:!'J ..!.lJ.) .:.r- ..L..;! ~\A>~ t)t Jt uU>_,.;._,JJ .:_r i)L(lt ~ (t...P)I t.h. c) G..b- r=- { ,~_,;;t Wt ~

:t)YI ~~..? ...:...ilS" J.i_, W4 .:>I,Alt ._,~ 4.; c.k! ..!...$; 46:.

yi:S:Jt ~ y\:S:JI wf J! ) . .!.1.; •t:-Jt i~f ~~ ,Y .M (~J t:---1..:.11 ~1~1) ole- t:-Jt c) 4~ ~ .1 67

• ( ) • ,..., . ',..., f ..!.11.> -'--! .)JJI { , ..lj ..? j:~J.!I iu~ ,WI ~ ~ yi:S...it t.iSJ y~:NI ~ ~ WI 0~ ,WI~ W!,

.t:-JI r~l cJ ~ 4)!i

.)Y"J' 4J...aAi (\5:;.,. \II~ .Jf 4J .M ~ {t..,.; .1t J) Jt Jolyll Y4) ole- 44 ..!.lJ.)-'--! ~I..!Jt (t..'jt ..l.4P 2 ·. 68

( ) . ut 0\:! .:.r ~u ,JI.; .»t y\S' t,) .

137 411....)1 (61)

139 iJI....)I (62

)

141411....)1 (63)

144 411....)1 (64)

146 iJI....)I (65

)

lA~ I..J 153 iJI....)I :)all (66

)

181 iJI.... )I (67

)

Page 25: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

imam $afii'nin Usfill Kelam Ekoliine Etkisi 1445

L$'li 0~ 1.. ~.r- ,:,i ~ ,u~ .J!,il' -.,--:J.s. c) J_,All 4J J.=ai y~i .~ ..!..1!~ ~ ~L!.l' rt..'l' ~ .3 69

( )_, 1 ' ' • C . ' - . t..' . C i :1 '' • ~~ J:.W)I.I~.:,... ,:,~ L.l.f.:..-J •r_,...,.l' J:.Lill ~ J!r. s,.. 0~ t..l.f.:..-J ,,:,~'c) "'

01 ~ 0~ u1 ,__;~, ,J' I# & 1.. ,:,I ~ ,~;~t:.-~~ ....;~, ~Y c) L.~..:. ~~ ~L!.l' rt.. 'I' ..w. t 70 ( ) I · . c · · -0" ..!..1!~ ~J , ..b.WI yl,.. ~ flJ ~;~\.:.-')II jA; cj ..b.WI ~ o)~ 01 Jl <t.,r:-' ..?'-')I~ t:-"t; ~

.J!-.:!1 (;: 4:,j J_,All J.aiJ l,.~Ji Jl ~;~6-~I J~l yt,..f

J.iJ ~)!_, ?':JI ~ ~ ~;~6-~1 .Ji .;.,.J ,~ Ul 01::/ Y'J ..!..1!~ ~ ~y cj ~L!.ll ..!JJJ.J

71 < ) I . . .

. ~~ 41 foJ o~ ~~I 41 ~_, ~_,IJI..I.A cj ~L!.ll.j>l.O=..I

73

· ( ) ~~~ ..!.lJjj J!.-J ~;~l..,a...J ~!_,;b 4\.. .:f" ~ ..!JJJ. (rl-ll Y4) ..!..1!~ ~ ..lAs- {

74

..t>I,JI p.'-~ cj ~ { < ( ) 4! 4ALdJ r\5:;... ~~ ;~6-':JI p.'- J_,; J._,r. ~J ~_ri ( ..t>~l p.'- Y4) ..lAs- {

-~4::i .j>l.O=..~ 75

~J ,;~tp..')ll tfr. o.Js.J ··~ ,_,.\,All~ { ,< ) ~ Js- ~;~~I ;~JJb .v~i ~ ~ t!.r.)'l cj 4~ ..lAs- {

76

. < ) ~ Js- Jl'Y..lll rub .vw~ .v\5:;...1 ~ ')I ~I 0i J! }..!.b <4::"_,.!..- Js- jl'Y..lll ru~ <~~ ~ .;§ .:f" ~ ..!JJJ. (;~l.p. ')II Y4) ..!..1!~ ~ ;~JJi {

77 ( )

..;:L-1 tfr. ~I..>! ~

213 ~1...)1 (68)

~.lA! l.oJ 224 ~1...)1 t> ~.lA! l.oJ 268 ~1...)1 :jill (70

)

~.lA! l.oJ 341 ~1...)1 :jill t> 371 ~1...)1 (72

)

382 ~1...)1 (73)

391 ~1...)1 (14)

469 ~1...)1 (75)

473 ~1...)1 (16)

481 ~1...)1 (n)

Page 26: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

446 1 Uluslararas• imam ~affi Sempo~u

78 ( )

~~~ r.;::- .)J)t; "-! ..i:>-~1 f~ ~ r')L<JI ~~II) Gr'-' (0l-;....\ll y~) ..!.l)~ .~.A! ~L!JI rt.)'l ~ (

.$}It._,~ ._,..l:AJI jy.: \..o J! Jt.;.l; t._,..t.AJI r\5:;....i ~ r:_r ~J.:I-1 J! rif ( ,~1._,..'-:AJI ~J ~ ~_;;1~ 79

{, . 1 ' ' • /f .. • ( ) • • . ..1; t? ~ 1~ j:\l.ul ru~ ,$ \1 t._, ~ $ ~..o_, ,.u>~~ <...J';}.::>. \II r~S-.>- ":' ~ (<...J';}.::>. \II ...,.,~) ~ r 80

• ( ) ~ J_,AJI ~~ "-'\5:;....~ .d~i p_, ~b....all J_,; I) ~~ ~ (~b....all Julil) y~ .)J_,I (

a.IG:-1) Ju ~ ~_, o_r<J I) ~y-.o~l JL..ll_, ..!..>-~I...,...;;~ r:.r ~ .;~! YY. .dt...J ~L!JI r> { ~ 1.1!. J_,.ta ,~ J';}.::>.l \1 ~.ill 4.)s. ~~ ~~ yi:5J~ ~~~ :(._,..t.il~ &)'1 ? y~) ~L...)I y~i

J.i .;~.] ~..I'Uilll) ~~ t.:.....<=.. :J_,.ta ~ ._,..t:ll ~ \1.)!_,.0;\11 ~P. ~J) J.i ~~ r-~-' tJ:ol,l~ ..I'Uilll) ~~

_p.~ ._,..t.AJI J:<; \1 .;I.J !~ ~.r- 4;..<.1_, u.... if~~ rJ ._,..t.AJI ( &'>'~ p_, ,~J.:I-1 t.SJJ ~ .hWI ~ 81

..!...>-l,!J .~ ~ ~ ( ~L!JI rt.)'l wi ..li. ~), ( ),.~1 if _#I I~!.....,._ ~I ..~.A! \..o '0~ ..!.lJ.iSj ... .)~y .~_, t? ~ (WI.._.,~~_,~ & JiJ \1! .,ty-.o~l JWI_,

~..:ui ~~~, ,J..,...,I.JI ..!...>-y r-"'i if~~ ..li. l:i!J ,~t...)l "!IS" 1)·-~L!..II rt..)'l 4iJ. J' ...::J~_,..;.}I J....; <~" .~

:~ ,J..,...,I.JI ~ J_,~S. r-"'i if~ I)~ ~L!..II rt.)'l .;i'Ji. ~ )2.:!1

~) u..l.:$. o.r.:J-1 ~.)1.]1 <./"-' <u-l:AJ~_tl.r.)'~ ~~ yi:5JI r:_r o.!J~ ,u,.)..IJ l...!._,i -._,~ 4::::-_, ~.)1.]1 :JJ~I .

. .Jl-;.... }I~ ~b....all J_,A$'~1 ~.)1.)1 ~ .y-

t--'l:.l~ ,...,..~~ r_;....JI r\5:;....~ ~-'~ wiJI _.?.J:, ,4-:-- r\5:;....1.)1 J.l,.::..-1 ~~-' ........ ~~ ...::J\1\1.) -._,i :~w1

.~1 ~}1.)_, 'tr-d~

...!...>-~~ ...::J~_,.,;,_,1.1 wY. I) 0'11 ti'~ ,~L:.J' rt.)'l ..1.:$. '-:}_,...,I.JI ..!...>-~~ ...::J~_,.,;,_,l.l 01:! if~~ ..!.ll~_,

.~..1.:$.-.J_,...,I.JI

~I J.;S. 4J-P~I .;.,~_,..,_,JI

if .l>-~.;...; t? .:.f.; r.li t..!...>-1.,1.1 ~) ...,...;; ~ if ~ I.....; ..:....Q.l:,.:.~ ..;..s._,:;_, ~ ...::J\.A:..:v ..::.>.)...W

~~~ ..:....Q.l:,.:.l LS' ,.,t_,...,I.JI ..!...>-1.,1.1_, ...::J~_;.;._,l.l.!,l.l; t? ~II) ~1 01, .,t_,...,~l JL..ll_, ..!...>-1.,1.1 ..)>_r ~\.i

if~ JS' .;IS' ..W ,J_,..I.JI ..IJ.A:l~ ~~ r:_r ..u.,ll_, y~l )2.:!1 if"-! '.2)\.:.olll !P; ~~ .,t_,...,I.JI JWII) r-"'jb~

494 i!l...)l (78

}

536 il\...)1 (7\

564 il\...)1 :}Ill (80

)

566 ill..o)l (81)

Page 27: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

<,8) ,cf.if'· I~ L

1i(j,..,.., 7! ·~r ~ f>~ r:r-2 ~ r ~·11)!"11,..,.., If-/·~, ~r:

; M(' ~~r .sn ~~2 ..;~ 11\"'"'"r .m (! ~· IJ\!"11,..,.., If{~ T"r-: .. rTif' ~r 1"'"'"r ~~ ~ 4"' 'i~ •<>'?"In . ,--·. - "( )

zs ~~ 1(i~: (! ~ ·~ ~~ 1rrsi ~ ~· '"'!l'r' rmr 1rrsi '(.-. 1-'i~' ~ if -;-'f., rmr

'if..f-"tl~' •(""~ "~ 1"!"!'r <l[f,..n)·

I~ lr.\;.'1: (! c(if' lf..--::;-o·{' (~ (""'"• <"/\,~II)<"~' C./"> f~: <"/\,~ 1)-p.fJ• (<"/\.~ 'lv.t'"J' (<"/\.~ '!~'!

~~ 1r.1~"'= (Ill)<"~' r.? 1(71,..,.., 'in 'i,\~""J, ·~ 1P- ic: r.r lrfi1.P. .....-:~1M 1\.!..-J .r. ....r~ l"lf'"·

~~ ~~lr: (Ill\ -<;S\J· Grn~! ~ !'"r ~)?liM 1'f!f~· ~C:! ~ ll)"'"'"r rrCr 4"' (~ )!"11,..:-,:

o 'i~ ~ 1rr' •r:.. rr .r. ~~ "'1'\-"' C-;-'f-p 'i-<;S~...,.

M"'1 C--rt'"-+)·"~~ ·~.9\ !'" ~Yl (rv:"\"'11~ .-:+j (C~ I)~# l(!i..r>)· . . 0 f<f' 1/i.~( ./"> (""'"• _cf..~ 1/={~ C./I (~' ic: ll)flr i-1 j(' rrr 4"' lr."'~ ~ Cr:rf-+j' f 0 Cj~ ,/1 IJ\c~' (./"> ~"! 1(7'1,..:-, 'ir. Cj~~""J !!<f"

Gric(~"'1·

o 'i~!.? 11\-<;S~J' !R If""'",.,., Gfi 'ir-r,..,.., Gr:s'i~ 'i~"'<t G-r-0 'i~ 'i~~ .fi,~i~~ 'i~

("""!"n (! ~V (Yl ~' (~ •;;zr, Cc(if' (!If..--:;•-{:

(! ffi 1r.Y"' II) ""::S\J .P.1~c~' f (! <>"?)r:" IF l(fsi !"' !(' ~ 11) -<;SIJ' ~011) ""::S\J {lr:-~ (! ~ ""Tf

1!7'""~ f ~ ~ j0 fF-"""c ,.,.r~ ffi lr-1-'"' II) ...::51J .P.Ii)C~' f".,...:.... 1P-f (Ill) -<;S\J' t (! li)C~ 'j!l-+)' f C{.t=f) ¥r- (! "!l"~ _s::)ilo ~: .. ~ J!lf' iC:I ~ j0 !"( lt')"'"'"fl (! (""'"• <"f..~ li)C~ ~ 4"' II) -<;S\J

•!1" •.:crr:- 10 -# .r. ~ rf.;'"~r:- II\.,..~~ ~~r •r.~ 1Mr !!'"""' !!"!" •-r rn~ 11).,..~ -s:r•

1r".f' ~~· •rn M., ~ _-F- -E.f' ..;..-.-- 1rf.ir 1\flr. ... r:.. ""!1 'lf<:'"~r:- •rn..-.-- -s:r ~~.,J 1m~·

lr-)"1""011)"'"'"f0 "'£""'"0-F- ~·~f"'"~r:-· 5"11~ ~~01Mr (!If-,:-:., 1t.~r IM-<7 'i01.,.::r,'i ..... (!

·~ ~~_,J ~~r· (,..:...:... l""='fsi r- ~ E~ n<?lf),.,..r "(~ "'"~-' ..s=1;,. "f\"'! (l~rr.~ GP-r'• ..5"1 10 ~J

·~~~1\.r ~ (!..,;!"! .r. (si• tc: r. 1-E.f" f~~r:- rr->T'011\.,..f0' ~ 1c1r:-. 10 1~f 1...cr..-J

•rn-<711\.,..~..51'-' -=""l"! (l1rJ 'i01~ (! ,p.tJ 'ifr 'irE.f'·

~~J rr->""Y""'=' ll\"'"'"f0 9 (! ~ ~~.,...r " ~ ?• (! ·~ ~~~r ·~· cr~ "n..>r- If.. 10 rf~~r:-

Lvt I !SPfl3. 3\1TIJO'f3. Ull!J3)1 !ftlSfi lJ!U,ffil!S UMUIJ

Page 28: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

4481 Uluslararas• imam ~afii Sempozyumu

,._a.<J.I rJ ~ rP~ •tl.!.l' r; ~4 ..;Lu ~_, ·rw.;~ ~ <J ~ rw_, :~1 JA J.,~, ~~

:4W~ ~~ .Y'J ~ ~~...J ,....Ai$l, Jd .Y'J ~ rP4J

& ":J; .:r> ":J_, .}All \A....:>;~-' tr'' y\.b:. .:.r ~~ <lii ~ ~ <J r<:L1 ~ .:.r ~~.Ji o .t;;JI _,..W ._}.:; ~ ":JJ ~ JWl j:-:-..v ":JJ

_,w~ 4>...,aJ~ ~,_,~~ ~w~ ._,fl.~ cW.~ YJJ.:.l.~ #~ ~~~..I.> ~ pt rwf .:.r ~~<J_, o -r~ ~~ rwf V" .!lb ~J ~)~ 4-c~~

J>- J_f4 ":J; ~I~ .l,-11 ":J; J_,.-)l ~ ":J oli~ .33 ":Jj ~ ":J .Jf ~ ~l.:_r ~I lJJ 0

.• _.:AI~ ":J ~-» JW .1!1 r<> ..!11~ y J. ,Jp

ylk>-_, ,trJI VA ;1s:J1 ylb:-_, .~~ 0J.!_, 1$""\.:ll y\.b:. ~ ~ rPt .:.r ~~ ,J; o -$ ":J ,j"J ~ $ l/'J u)~l

.li~ l) JW)\1 l.i..:>; ~<lib ,.:>~~4 ":J JW~4 ~ yl.Y-1.:>1 ~ ~ rPI'J. ~~ !); 0

.4-)W~ ~~ .h_r.!~ 4W~ ~~ ~ ~ r<:l-1 ~ .:.r ~I<J; o ~~~ 4-i. ":J; ..,_.\.;:; ":} ~ t:-"ly I) o.lJ..,-o .J_,.I_,....~IIA~~Jj j_,....~l J.,...U <J!Ju; .:/' Ur. ...,_.l..iJII.i:. JJI.::J

• ...ull J.,....4 ~% ~.p_,.... J! ...... \.:!.1 <~>--_» IA.I..,.,I,i. Jl ~lkll <.?X-fr. )\.;

:e_l-.iJ~ W~ y~l JAJ _r.WI J ~WI~~ ,.hii .11.fll oli~ yi.:SJI ..:.tl-:'l <J!J.J ,~ ~ Lo; ~ y> LoJ tyi.:SJI ..I.> 08 y\.:SJI j..>f .:_r ~I lJJ 0

-~J a:.r; j\?.J ~ .:/' yl:S:ll ~ p .;! $ Lo .Jl:!J

.:/' 4:!!2.1 J)o; ,_,b-i_, .11J .:/' li_,: J_).J J_,.-)1 .:/' JW~~ J~~l r<> .:8 WI ,y- ~I lJJ 0

·Jt,>:-~1 yl:S'rt.e J! ;Y-Js:;_, ~~~ V" li!2J ..:.tU...._, •J.-.I"J .J..:.....,. . (83)

.4)j ~I J~ Jt; t_lr.)fl Lo~ .~ ":Jl_,.t ":J oli~ ~I yl:S'W~ y\.:SJ4 ~J 0

~ Jl r~ .:/' t_lr.!J ~b....:JI t_lr.!J .._.w~ ,J,.bJ ci,..>- c.k:i t_lr.)fl j..>f .:_r ~I <JJ 0

.e_l.r.)fl Jll.-o

~J~ ..;.'j'j.ill ~1.- J •.Po! J. ~b~l yl! J ~~ ~ J-. J c}lj"ll .;,::1_,...,~1 ~I filtPly. ~ {83)

.J'j~";;l

Page 29: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

imam $afii'nin Usuli Kelam Ekoliine Etkisi 1 449

:~) if'J :.)~~~ J> J ..:..l\!11 ~~

j.dl • ..:>\.ldl .... .....::3-t. >.......!1. ··lt . ... ~I~.-~ ldi ,&L..:. ~· .~ ...:....- ..... ..b..:lll '-.l)l.).:j}JI 0 'J.,IJ-' ..,,,,r..., ..,,..., J...p-J., .. "":"r-- -- ·J - - '-' './

.~_,;Jll ~I~ .j p ._r_,..d-~ (~~ ._r~.:J~ /~'J1 .,.,IS' .j ):=!~ ,._r~~

....... ~I ll.)a > • ;II .....,\S' ...J.;. L· • o ~ . :It• 0 .-i)l...:.,.- ._. -.J)'..UI t..i. 0 . ...P' J \~ . - ~ \~J "" - \J J

,~:.s- .!l...l,$- ..._=i :jlL:.ll J ... ..:s" J;W~I ..;...~~~ ;_r Ui:-~ ojl.:::!'J ..b..:llt ~J? ~ ;_r ~)I..Ut \..~ 0

•• l....::ci,.) ~~ ~J? .J' ...:..<.!.., ~ tJ u--=WJ .!..ll.\.1 J.:-=-~ ..;~ ,..:..Gi :J_,.a S.J

I ( ) .

,..:\hi lc. u..lo -.iu , .J~ .,.., . ...;,WI _:,.<, ) 1 :; -") ~..:) ..;i ..b..:lll j..W ~ ._. '-.I)I..UI \..1. 0 \.... ~ .. • • .., J ~ ~--- \u- J ..,... "" • u .J

85 ( ) . ,- . . . .....w~ J'~~ r~~ cr. ,:,~ J! ~J ....... ~~ ~ ...:..) •• ~ J~ ji.J.~ J:><).~

t.$fi f.$.ill c"'PJ .ililt ...:..ot.W>J ¥.1 ...:..oLW .:,~ ~J ,.ilil' ~~ .:;J ¥.1 Y'J : ~~ J ~1)1 ~~

. .)t.p..'il r~i 4.l.i:-J .J!~~ ~.r='.:; J~~ ~ .)4-:>--)ll Jl$; '1 f.$.ill ,:,J.) .)4:>--l'l ~ 86 ( >... '-11 d •:..11 • I ,1 • 'I • • ..... ' • J :..., _ \<:. ' ~ I •I • • '

• <WJJ yUO!~ OoU.:f"'!l,A..;..,J 'Y':'..=....f-..1.!) ~~ r.J ..r'.)'-"~ o..l,j.!

'r-<s. c...;,~ J~i & _;;) 4JS' J .... ~'l~ -!...>-l:l ~ ,_;.,.,s- Js- .JL. .. :.::.'J·.J ... .k rS-J J!;JI {>\$" ..:....<..... ..l.i)

. o..».:JI: ._.;·It~ .W :.:.....r.." :jl.i ~ ..,\5' jl·:lt ~ J-:>• \.. t.l,.. • . ...,kll • ._.;.;JI ;-1_;_,1 j ·._,IS- .W .11.: 11 .)\$" -· J • • '.]V .... • • .. • • '.? . J J \ - J ... ., ..._ ... - .. - ""':''..~""'

~ Js- a..J JJi .:; _,.J;l:ll·~ ,~....,. --AJd ~.fo. ..;. ~~ ci....a.! ,1)\!11 .y- v~ '1 <.>.~ )u .JW' r-e-"1 87

. ( ),. y ).:JI (!t_. ~ Js- ~~.:;....)I I ·~) ~I l.iA ..u~ ..;..o~l.:r....L<:!J ..l:s- <J~'JI -!...>-l:il .J! j~l.:;-~ l>\4 r-+dJJ ~<:!J ..L:s- J..r'\11 ~l:i .)>_,JII.iA ~)

Js- o_,:>-1 ~\..!JI rt..j\l '-.IL-.)1 y\5 .;i ...:..o~ ..W ,J_,...:,\11 .j JlL....J o.!.->-1.,-- .:.t' ~\..!JI ..._.j \.. J! p$' ~ J!

:J.J..,~ .j '-'.r=- .:r~J~'ll .j o.!.->-1.,--

,.:,~ ~J ~ _,1 ...... WI ~ ~ ...,...~ ·~Jb;.,)l ~ ·.:,~ ~J ,:..,.:.'1 ,jl. ~ ~ 'J ' :~ ~Jb;.,ll • IJJ (8-1)

~J ...... \.ill ,\..<:l 'i.A~ ...,...~ ,~ ~ ".J~ JAJ ~I .J:! ~i ~ 'J " :~ ~ o"_v .6739 ~) ~~

.1717 ~) ~~ ·"~ .;~ ~ ~ 4! ;.:.._ Jh ~J.:s. ~ .}. ,~'J..IJI ...,...~ ,J' IJ"!Jll j-. .) ._Jij"ll .;,.,J,..,~I ~I _;S'i Ji'J! ~ (85

)

-~.r; J.l..<:.o

8 ~I •.}\jll (86

)

4 ~I •J\jll t)

Page 30: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

450 1 Uluslararas1 imam ~am Sempozyumu

;U.)\fl<.f'J vi:Al'J tt..?.-'i'J WI_} ._,.,~1 J ~L!JI t\...'il 0Ji. ~ ,~.)J) IJ.J.,> "->.-)~ 4:::>--->J ;U};ll :JJ~I

. .JL..:,.:...':J!_, o.J~I J_,;s'~l 4.1.)\11 ~ J r-1-<-J , • ..~.:; ofr"ll

r~l t~~ ~)~ <JL,.,ll ~L!JI r\...'11 _?~ ,~ r~\11 .1~1 ..:r.,;~J U"'.roJI .. ::N'y.) ...,.} :~WI

.~1 ;U':J.)) •t,.......:l'J t---l:l'J 'U"'~'J

;U':J.) "->.-)~ ,;U.)\11 :~) -J~I ~ ...l> J>-- ~.;\II ._,.,U:..;\11 )j JJ...,\11 .:;\5) 0" ~c))~ .:>~1'1 01~

a,')~~) ~L!JI t\...?IJ ~ ,~_,...,.\1 1 ~I.,!J ~ .)Lp,.':JI ~ ~L!JI r\...'il ~) ...W .!).b JJ-.;L.;,J ,;U.)~I

-~.J\11 JJ...,\11 c:>\5} 0" .:;15}

o.i.A cj L_,..-. ~'J \..J...s ~_,...,.)II~ ..:.._,4;...1 Jl ~I ~_,...,.)II ~I.,!J .y '!P 0~ .!).).) J! ...;....;,!

W'J y~l :c,/'J ;U.)i -.,.,.J4 ~)11 ;U.))il ~J]. .!).).) .r-' ,JL?.-)'1 cj ~~ }.;.~ ~L!JI t\...'11 4.,Js. di..!! JJ~I

0!, ~L!JI t\...'il ~) Jl .Jlo,JI ~y .)>- oj}i t.S' ,~ ..:.._,4;...1 t.>JJI _,...:)1 .)>-led}) •fl'J t_l.?.-)''J

~I t-JI ~y .)>- oj}~ ,w~ 0"!;JI a,~ cj ~) Jl c..r"\11.)>- ojji'W" ,4-_,;,~b-)\k...,.l ~ o.::...A.b:-1

fi""J WI ._,.,~ cj ~) Jl ~I ~I.,!J .y _iS' .)>- oj)i t.S' ,..:..o)\,..aA:ll ~ cj ._;....,II .....:.;1.; 0!, ~.).;)i

1..5'-i..li ~_,...,.\11 ~t,l.l.y •.r.PJ l.i.A J-.<; ,4-_,; ~~~ .:.r ~411 r\...'ii·~Ji \.....? ..:..ot..;,trl.:t.f""w 0\S"" 0!J ,.)~>-'11

.J_,...,.\fl r-1' .y ~_,;J..:; )j ~)~ .:;i .)).) ~t,\.1 o.i.A cj <(j_,);.~ ·~ .y ~b) ~~I (\...)'1 ~

- .:t.f""i:l.l ~~I j_,...,.\11 ~y ~ \.¥ ..:..o~l..li ~L!JI t\...'il ~) Jl ~_,...,.\II ~I.,!J .J~ ~)

t\...'11 c..r:--i; <.;->" .)>- J~ <(j~ ~;_r .)>- lh J.) 0~ •~<./" ~ ~ (J -IJ. o!WI Ji w~.J.I J )dl ~

.~.)>--~_vi J .dL.J cj j_,...,.\11 ~y ~ ~L!JI t\...'il ·~Ji ~ ~ ( ~ r-W11.i! ~I.!JI

, .... Ill I AA:ll J~l 0- - ·-11 ~ 0 ° . I~ ~\..,.. ;UL. II ~\..,.. 0 • <' • ~II 01 : l~ij J • ..!! • ...r-- !} 'r-- . if ~ . :} '.J' • v;! fro' ur . <.J' ~

...L> J! ~ ( ..:_.,..t,!.l ~ cj )LW ~b \...) ,._,.,4 .}' cj JlWI V'JlJ ~ .)>- ':J! ..;.>h ( 4.1L.)I ..:_.,..t.,....;

.0Jj"-i:l.l ~ _,.<;...i t.>JJI ~I

.y ts~ 0i ~ ~~ .:r~ ':JJ ,~_,...,.)II '-!~1 ~~~~ c,l' 4.!L.)I .)j '.)>- ~~ # JJ 'C..,.,.._ l.i.A :J_,;i

Jt..;,i jS) ,~t;;J ~~'YI ~")t;; ,~)\::1.1 j_,...,.\11 ~L..k. .)~ ~I..UJ ~WI J-\5:; J <0J?-i:l.l .Y! ~ ~

~ -.IL.)I yi..U )\.! ,.:;)f"-'YI.Y! ..l::...'J .:.>}JYI ~J t.>JJI.:@I V'L.YI J! _A ~l.:r<J ,0~U1 ~J \... J!

.~1 ~_,...,.\11 ..:_.,..t,!.I._;.....,!Ll.~! .)>- ':J) '.:t.i""i:J.I ~ ..:.....~>.-) Jl ~..1.11 ..:_.,..t,\.1 J~~

~},..,_l:l,.:.r J-IS"" ~ ..:..o~l ~L!.l' r\...)'1 ~;. J' ~_,...,.\ll..:_.,..t,!.'J ..:..ot.-_,..;:._,1.10~ .!.ll->..? ~~)

;y \...i .~t,~.' ~) ..,_\,; .:.r lh) ·•..f-S' ..:..ouL.;,1 4-_,; ~ ..::..;l5J 'r-1.:; 4-_,; Jd'-' ~~ ~ij ,~<.:11 .J.:>.

J)~ <.) ~ ~<.:11 0i J! .)Y! _,.. \11 JJJ ,.!).).> <.) ~ ~<:u) ~L!.l' r\... ~~ ~ J)~=:>. ':JI .:;i <.S); led; ..,_~.;

1.U 015:; •ifrJI r-0.1 ~ .!.ll-> .:.rJ ,~L!.ll r\...'i' ~~ ( ~.)) ~~ ..:_.,..t..,. J_,...,.'J, ~ <.) '-'.)!; yW>!

Page 31: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

imam ~afi.i'nin Usilli Kelam Ekoliine Etki.si 1451

..!..>.,lt ~_, ~~~ ~b)\l ~l..!.lt r~'i' ~; ,:,i ~~ <ii l'! ,~L!Jt r~'l' ~; .)~~ r.J.S. tj p$' JJ.) .f'~'

.Jlr.'JI t) ~ ~w r~-' .J_,...l<:l..l <..:....>.:...1 ~; r ._,..loAll { tLr.'JI { u1 { ...,..l::SJ~

~IJ ~L!.ll ~ 4J,rP"ll ~~~ ~~ :~WI ~~

C:: ,~L!JI rV'JI ~ Y.,"-"~1 '-!l:S:JI ._rJL=:- b. .lJJ~ <.J!Lll ~~ tj ~<.:11 '-'J..V ._rJl..a.,:. .)~ ._;,....

...rJL.a.,:. ~~ ,~L!JI r~'l~ y_,....,~~ ~<:.u ._.J..v ;h 4.>.-_,i ~ w ~ .~, '-'p ...rl~ 4=iJ!i.o

: .J ~ ~ U.Lr.! .:.r<.....J ~L!JI rt.. 'JI ~ <.~ ... """ ~~ ~l::SJ1 if~ t) 1.i.> ~ ~L!JI r~)fl )-· ..u_, .~ .;-,;.1 Ji tr"_,...u <.!Lr.! &:. t:;4Y- ~L!Jt r~'l' :r-i .1 .:r~ tj ~<.oll 0 ..;.._, ~ l.i.> J~_, ,y_,....,~I-.!L-)1 ...:..~_,...,_,.. Jo.r ~ J ..:..1!,.._, -!.lb J! ...:..pl..!i_, J_,....,~l C->t,..

~ ~.i.>_, ,._,; .;-,;.1 ~; c?.il' J_,....,~~ ~w~ J:-:>Ld .C!J.l!J ~ J..~ Y,..,~~ ..!..>-l,.-ll ~-' ~w r~)fl

~ ~;._, ,<.~_,....,~~ ..:..~.r<>_,l.l .;..r ~ J~' r'%' if <ci.... w ,~:u. ~~ .;Y_,....,~, ~ ~ O.l.J>--"'

~~ ~,;11 tj W· Jo!S::.. J_,....,i ~~ ._¥_, -.IJL.... JS' J..-!-'J J_, ... .,~l <!.>I.,.- JS' ~ &:. t;4J ~ •..!..>-l,.-ll

.._i!L.. c$~ ~ .)~! tj ~L!JI rt..)'l ~J ~I~ U.):JI ~ ~L. ~<:.IJ ,:,i ~ ._,; ._,-,! ':/ J..~ ·J~

.<J.,....,\11 ~l,IJ_, ...:..U:...ail ~~~ tj ..__..~ &:. tj ~~ Jo.r { ,<J_,....,\!t ..!..>-l,IJ t:4-' ~

,u~ . ...,..t:S:J; if ~?' ...,.)~~ ~..~-_, 4:Js. Jl..l.:l~ <.~,....,~, .J.S.t,All .;..r ~ ~L!JI r~'>'~ ~ .2 JS' tj s.")~ ~~ t.>.li. ~lo.i.>J M ..!.J-;)1 ~ 4-J U>l:.v ..\S.:tJ .tr-JI._r>~ ~ \..>~.,<:! ~~ j_,....,\11 Jo,H

...:..':J':J..~;;...':JI yl->- J>- ~_r.JI._r>~l .}>- j.l..dl tj :r(;..t ~L!Jt r~'JI .)\5" l.il_, ,.j")\1)'1 .}>- -.!L.)I ..!..>-1.,.­

j.>i if -1A J_;:; ...:.-,l.i" :Ju ~ ..,:J':J..~;;...I tj ~~ ol.>. ._.<.._i J! ~L!JI r~'JI J~;i ..li_, ,~ ( .J[, y.AJI 88

. lc" .. lo ...<'t • ( ) • • ~ ...:.>.k-J .)~ ~ _;., I ~ w.:; ':J ~ • .l..>_, . . II~ t.>..u\.1 j:.,.... ~ j.l.tll .:ill yi:S" t)J ':/! aljli .:ill <)!.)

yl:S:JI ._r>~ 4# J':J..~;;...':}I if _pi ~I ~!r.)~ '-).WI ...:,.':J':J..~;;...':J~ ~~ .;,..;\5" ~ ,,b:.(.\.1 ~

.c....J~

,W~ .J!;JI._r>_,....,.; ~ .!J.b tj ~J 4J.,.....,\JI.J.S.t,AJI ~ " .. v.i<ll ..;...lA:,k:JI.l~! if ~L!JI (~)'I~ .3 o.J.S.lAlt t;_,A! iu~_, ,Wt_, ...,..t:S:J1...r>~ if 4# y.....J1..u.~1 Jofi <.~_,....,\11 o.J.S.WI ~ J.l..l.:ll ~ r_,A! ~

~~ ~ o)J • .l..>_, . ..w~ y_,....,\11 C->l,IJ ~ ~L!JI rt..)'l ~ i,k. ..b)I.J\5" .!.ll.il_, ,i; __ k_, 4;.; ~_, tj .:.r~ ~ ,y_,....,\11 .J.S.~..W c$_,1o;ll ...,_.;lJ,-1 ~~I ("+'~I j>. .J~ IY.r"'~l ~<:.IJ '-'p ....,_5 tj .l.J>-}~

Fl 4-u[, ~ j.l..d~ o.J.S.WI J:-h tj .)!):o:--':}I .li. ,.} <.J.S.t,All o.i! .;WI .j.:l:dl ...,_.;lh~ rl...;.o.l ~

. .):WI ':J! y_,....,\11 o.J.S.WI o.l..> ~ 4..).$' c!'>.}! ~ t) _,i 4:.... _,! yi:S" if jl!. l).li ~if 4:}s- ~!r.)~

Page 32: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

4521 Uluslararast imam 1>afii Sempowumu

,tJS' ~_,1.1 ~~ .... .j.f-:1 '~J-"'ll ..IJ>~~~ JlLli,_~J ~:; ~ ~.1.11 ~l..!JI ~~~~ tS~ .4 Jb ,.y ~~ ..b-~' ..:....1>-~ r)\5JJ 4:! ~L!.ll./.r Jl' 41:L.._, ....,..~~ ....,..~'!i ,:,)" :JL!. ..v-i .!.11~.:; JJ~

j_,...,i cj ~l...WI y:S" ~ J&-~ J~i t_?~ jlLllo~ .. ·~) j--}l ~~ ~JJ ,;~.h <.II~J ..:.....~.;LI ~ .k_.V

~ ~ ~_, .!.11~ ~ ..;~ .~ <.~~_, ,-.;... f:)} _,;. 111 •-'-"! ~ ~ .Ji ~ ~..1.;L1 r_,ls. .:; ...u:1.1 .J! J ,--:..:..lJ-1

89 • • I { o • t(" '' _r .. ' • /" ..,-'( • •·I • ( ), ' ~ J li! ..,_,..,)'I~~ ~;.V ~ if r. ~ .)1 ~ L:;! J t.;;;...l'-.:!.1 r 1 ~ --'="' ·~c>lo..l.>j. oy.l <» t.j!l... \!,.

.;;;...L<:!J y:S" cj ._;..0:..:.. /~I I~J ,.:,\5' ~ t_?i cj ._,.,\S' t_?i ) ~\j.\ .~ .J! .:....r ,~\j.l .~ j>-'J .)\5'

~~ c.}.'J ...I....:J.I J\!1.1 j:,--~ l.;.;.. fo~ ,~1 .~ ;:' Jo~ .1>-i ~\j.l .~ ..:....i\5' ..W ,;_,r.!ll 4J)-"~1

JJ_, ,~.;.~_, t.?JW:Jl cl.r!J, •t.?.v)ll r~~~ •c.S})l J~~ ·J~ ~-' '..j!_,.,.JJ ,:,~.;.}.~ ,c.S_,...,.~,

.J~' ·~~~I ~\j.' .~ ~:J ?''Y' r ~

~ .))"! { 4J ~' ~~i .)))!) rL..:ll ~ ~1,ii ./.I'!~ oy;J~ ~)t_, J~.!-:y ~L!J' r~'i'v#fl .5 - "'·. \.r.-=S1 ~p ._<J..._, ~~ ..,.._,.. J ~ 'Y) ,_Al..c(; ~if~ J..\hl ._,.,_,Li eft I~ ~L!JI (~'JI .)~ ,J~)I~ J>A:l~

'.r(:, y ..;! ..!...,>if .JL...i)\l ~if Jl ~I r._,WI ~~~~ :.J_,.u,.:. .y.l..!.lJ~ .J Jfi t}o~j ;)IS: j~ .r(A_, .)\......j~ ~

,J\5' .L .JW'JI tfl cj o~y:-y if'J ,~[,.._, ~l..l.o .) .J..if--tJ •r-¥ Jill J>i J! 4:! )>.:.~ ---~ J ,~ ~ ~ ~ 90 -

.< >" · · .Jid.l ~ :J_,:y, 'iys. ~) ~ <l...;.!.. if-' ,...._<w_, u....J..i) r~ r_,l.-.\ ~ ~' ·~1 ,:,~ c.SL J~'J W:.:.:.il J..lk'J ;~.J.i ... , ... ::ll...4 ~~ Jt.u .t1 ._,.,t:..<; •r-}JI .Ji_;JI .J ~y:--y ....,.._,L~I ~~_,

}_;.1.1 c./' ..:;...;\5:.i ,,:,i_;JI../~ .)t.,;...:.;.....'YI if o}!S'! -!.l)~ J:l~J \o~ '1 .Ji_;IJ C:f' 1~ cj ~l.!..l~ '(~\

..... /)\All J..~>.- ....,.._,Lt, i;b .~ t ~l.!..ll .)~ ~, ,~1.11_, J..lhl .:; ~l.!..ll ....,.._,Li cj -jlll ~- .

~fl) ~ ~) ~ ~ ....,_. .i:>.{,i t.J.........JI <.r' ..:..All ~ c,S.ill l:.~_-ll }\; --~ ~ }t .J!) ••~ .j Ub\.:.l~

~ ~ J~ to~ .j i..t:L. ,J\5' t_?.iJI .?d' j..lJ:I ._,.,J.L.i, ~l.:JI rV')1 }\; ,f~ ~I .:;-<J ,.~

t; ~J.L.i :(<.IL..)I.J ~~ p-<.o:J' _rlh.. :r c.Si> ~..r--," :~l.!..l' rt..~l ..l:J> J..lkl ....,.._,Li ~_,.:; J.JI)'

J.r=JI .:r>"J r+<JI ._Ahl) ~I o; :.r'.,; ll.-~ .)15::1 .$- ,._,;t...._, ._ik.:.ll Jr"-! ~~ _J..lJ:I ;~I • .

..~~~_, ,...;:..l.il~, \l_,i J<.:l' Js- d~' ~J Js- .w L~:>- -~' rth:.ll ·~~_, ~~ J'1..~.:....'11 .J 91

( )

,~L..~ <.t.rJ.' r-:lt.u ~ wu ~l.!J' ~.:; r)t.s::.ll ~ ,:,\5' '~b" :-!.ll~ .Jl:! .:; •.rj y.i J..S. JJ~J

~ ~.il ,<J_rl.l .j t;.i_; .,::JI ;J_:-dl '1! ....,_. ~ '1 ~~ \~ J~.i:.;.'11 .r~'J r-LJI .!.11~ ~l.!..ll ~ ~

11 ~t...)t (89)

.478 4o.u..ll ,.:,_,~ .J.' (90

)

.245 y'j.,.,'jl u.....lAJI t:'.JI:) ~ ,~ ,Jjl)l J.,t- {91)

Page 33: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

imam $afii'nin Usilli Kelam Ekoliine Etkisi (453

lJ .._<J_. ~ ..).~)II •}\; if) <'-:>-1..; if~~!_, ~L; if W- .JIS" ~L!JI ._,..A; cJ <.l_rl.l Ji .J! :J_,.o; .)l

...!,.WJ~ <~)\ ~ <.l_rl.l .!,.lL .j \y>.-J.>l .:f 9!,)1 '-4-Q.i ~ j.>~ .JIS" ..1.0.i <4>.-l>..;.>-1 ojJ ~I J..IJ:.I

.j _,.-lu Jl>- <$j Js-.1 ,~I ..j~ ~ ,J..IJ:.I .j ~I)> c./J.> .U ~L!JI j..1i .-_,.:.<;~ JJJ:.4 1,_. _j JJ

92 ( )

"cl>..;.>-'-' J..l>.- rs .:>IS"...,...~..; a.~.r.

._,\.>. ..:.-,) J..IJ:.I ~L.i .JY !->J~ J\; * J\; .:>!J .!.ll~ )~ t ~L!JI rL..)II .;i <.>) ~j ~~

~_,; .u ...U.\.J.I .;~if r)! )u ·~1) ..,...,J.....i _,..,., ,__,...L..;S"i J! cl;j. ~ >)o.Al4 ~ 0.Js. .,r J. ,018.4

~' ..Li:.o '"~' C:""~ ~ if .JJ; U; ~L.!Ju 'r-4 ..:r-Jl:.. ._,..L:ll .Jr~ .:,! ._..~>- ~~_,! .:; .~_, .Y

.pAll if '-"L..:S""I Ji 4,...kl <.>.-l>- .:,_,_, r}JI o.il 9~1 yl-.:S"\11 Js- J.UYI r 'fr<JI .;1_;]1 ~L.~

~~_,.ill ..!.l.J; Js- r_,\....;$.~ .y .r-1 ~ c.-"'-' ~~ JJJ:.I ..,..._,1...~ rJt; .J\i .:>_,.!_,...,'11 .;_:-L<.:ll vi

~<.:11 ._.)_,_. ._,.,.:~...=:- c:; ~~~ ..t;s. ~ ..:.£, .!.ll~ ~ .u_, <\;.:i .;.,u.:......l.l (:!>JJ ~4! r-r-1..~,:;,.:....1_,

W' ~YJ-> ~ ,~L!JI '"~I~~ ~..;IS" .:>!J '-" ~ .U ~ ••}5:.i! .:.;-<s_ ~ .r"i I~ ,4)_,...,YI

.U-.Lt_, J..l>.-, .._il:z.:.. of .JL;_,.ll rP'r-J->

_;j ~~ ,;)>l:.l.l_, JJJ:.I ~L.i ~ll.....r-- )\5' _;j ..l4 -~<.:1'-' ~L!JI (l...'/1- .:&}JI ~ ~}Al4J

.;_:-L<.:ll L..i. <<$_,kll J.W' ;:.~'-' ~1_;11 .k...:.ll .? i...l...::A..o ~,.!. ·~ ~ ..:..;IS" ~L!Jl ~)·

.~ y} . .:J.I .:,i ~~ ...,.;U:.. ~L.~'I .;, ... <; ..u, ,.;t;_,.ll U...)u .:/ ...t...=....ll.;rAll ~~ ...b....:.ll ~J.......:...u

..!..>-l,l.l .j ~ ~ .:...\J~ i..._rL. :r<. t -.:..<! <\.o.k,jUJ ..;_,Wk....J,I ~.l/. y_,l....i ~L!JI (lo'/1 ~I .6 W"' r..l'yJ~ 0\,Jl .w,_,.; ~m Jt:._, ,~.;.\.:..... -'-!~ ~J.r" <->L Jl .;.,bJh..al,l ~ ~L!.ll rV'JI J_r ..w ,;_,)_, .... ")''

.J~ c}}'-' .;.,\:.J.h..d.t __..,,;U y_,J.....i .JY !...-'<.,...; _rj- if ..::..\:.J.h..d.t if ifrS' J.W.t .j .!l; ...:...<:! ,~L. t,;So .;.,.>JJ;

~I o.i.:.o , .·,\;..JI , old.~ ._,.1 t ~i:JI ~...:; _.yl l.i.:. .)IS" .,U, <4J1.) ..1.>- J -..IS- ~j ::.>- ,i.,.:.k,. .1~ \.;>.>•..1.>-J y ..I- - • ~ • ..1 - .J J - - '-" \...> J .• lft.P J

J ·~ ~ ..!J.I.) i.A .:r<. r-U ~\...:..!1 rt..)'lt..i ,~t..=:. .:; ~_,; w- 4,1>-"'11 ~<:!J --4' oiS" c:; ,_,.f"'Y

. .Jio:ll ~\.J-1 ..:,~ ._.:;;, ;_,_,~ if')\k..,~l ~.,..:J~ ....,t..,:;.\ ..Ji, 1.11 ·~.:; ..:,u.:..d,l JS' c:; ~ t;..f" l..i.:. .:.r<. ( 9i) 4-:--" :Jt; ..!..,:>- ,<.L}I.j \.,.,.+' v!,::l'-' if')\k..,~l ~.k>.:l4 ~L!JI rt..:..>l ._r->11....::=-- J_,.ill cJ ~4 ~l.:.r<J

j;.:!l C:: ~~ cJ .b:.YI { ,\')i .j.:-.~t..:l'-' _,,..~J-1 (:!>J J! .jldl·li.~l U... :(-.!L.)I·c:; ~~ ;:.S::...:II_rlk. of

~.;! l,.. _# J! ~~ "'< ._r.1 l,;..:: .J).-') ~~ ._:..~.,..:JI .>~ ~L!JIJ>fi ..U_, .~ j-<J .)~)!~

Page 34: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

454 1 Uluslararast imam ~afii Sempozyumu

93

)I ~ ,~_,..!.? u~ ,y l.!f- L. .Jj J ,..;..La.~~ 4 ~L!JI .:.r~ ~ ,4A)l_,.. J_,A]tt,i.,. <) .Ji )lj , ( ) "le-:-o 94

( ) . U!.r'\.JJ ,y ..1.:>-~ .r):- o.JS1L. l..i.;._, ,4.1L..)I <) 4,1\&-~ l&j :J_,All .:.r~

c)' rJ rJ>\;11 j:b t~ yl.fi ~ j:l..l:l~ ..:~i u~) rJ OJ-WI ..;..)1':/~':/1 c.riL!JI (L.)'I ~ t .7 c.....ll lilt JyJ .:/" Jj! ':1_, 01AJ~ ...::..., ~ { lilt j_,.....J .:r ...li :J~ .:.>i jb _,]_," :Ju ..:...,:.. y\.:S:J~ WI t:-'

V-' c:-'' lilt .rr~ ~ J..r. .Ji J.i ~.r- .Jh. .Ji ~ ...li :\#"" tJ::ll,:;. .tt J.,....J r.r- ~....,; :J~ .Ji jb 4>....-l:.ll

..~.:>-~ y t,ku ~~~ ~~1" :lilt J_,d ~>_,....:..- r"'")t .J_,..~ .Ji ~ ...li :ot;jt ..,.. r"'"J ~-' ,[275 :WI] "t.Jt

..,.. J;. jJL.. .:/" iA. ':1 :J~ .Ji jb_, ,~, ~ .... ...;:.}1 ~~ ..:...>.-.i :~t ~ ~~ rJ_, ,[2 :J_,:lt] "o..U... -.:t.. ~

'-'.r..,.. r:fi <i_,..Jt r' .J:Y ![28 :o..ulit] "4~i ~u <iJLJ~ JJUt" .1!1 J_,Al J~> ~,)..,.. yi ci.r_, j_r- .r:'­

>J jk-J •J.rl1 .? ·~ t 1~1 ~ t ;J~ ,)~ ..3,, J_,.....J d" ~..!.:>- JS' ;;J ji.:I,.J <.if .ri- ..,.._, j_r- .YJ ·~ )I.J.i ~ . /.. . .. -

j.-.>1 1:,1 ,.J w~ ':/! t~l .J_,..'V ':1 if'-' <wY .Jt ...::..., Jd ~ yi:S"" 1.r-o ~ JS' ~fl ·~}I U!~ .:r-JI

.JIS' .J!) •J;=ll t; Mt <J 1.t j51 ~ .Yt J. .J_,..<. .Ji ~~ _,i ,..,.y. J?l <J Ml J'.>l> .;.p '.?JJ 1....,; .l2.allt 95

" I - -" ( > ..... "I --·1 JL:III" .... L. ·-. ,~ J- I - ~, ...... • ... ~ ·"I -~ ..;_,':/':/X....~I ;;.....;...u. ..:u '-" <AJy•J ,- ~ '-'~ ~ .x; "'YJ ..:...._, ..» y~;;>J .-._,..,.. ~.;.. .;1 )\....::.-

4~1 4l:.:Yt ~ 4-:,ls-. (J.S. :J_,YI 'J.., .... i ._,~ r-'1 ..!JJ:, §.J ,4JL..)t ..!....>-y J. b...;.~.~ ~~\112..~'! rJ ~~

:~1!11 •j;.:Yt -........11 ~b.._,;:. ~-j.o.:J~ J':lx....':/1 ...,JP ...s>- w~ .:.>1AJt '-"'_,.....;..,.. 4l:.:YI ~ >~':/' .JIS' ~

.Jj O.:..OJ .J1AJI l) :._,..y )\!.. (j'.>\=l\ j:l...li .}WI J':/..t.:....':/1 J. .:.>1AJI y_,L~ u':/':/x....':/1 ,y (.,.;)\I~ c.rtL!.lt _)\;

~ ~ t./f' oli.l r c.rtL!.lt rt..'/1 ~ .}Wt .~':/u ,[22 :~1,,81] "t..L.-il..i,t ':1! ~~ ~ .JIS' ,!" :JW

}>- .b-J; ..:...,:.. ._s-ll cr"'-'-' -~\.,.JI 4.1-*' ~ u':/':/X....':/1 o.l;. ._;>_r J. o>~l :..!...11!11 .W~ 01AJI ,y J_,...,i .

. ~ 4.-L ~ v_r .J~ ,yk.;i~ y.....J..oll ul~t ,y 4.1L)

~_," :.!.ll.> J. ~...bL!.lt J .... ~ ,...a...Jt wi ~ & rWt ~~ r ~~ Jl'x.... ':It J. c.rtL!.lt y_,Li .JIS' -li_,

~ y.L<.:II i~ :Y1 u~'! ~ ~ ':/x..-1. J. )2; ..,.._, ,--..A]b:JJ_, --..Al~ 4.u__rll ~ <J tL.:Jt ._a....!t / ~I t.h

~ r'>IS:l~ 0_,...;! y\S' J ,--..AJ_;... ~ ':1_, .....;JS:::.. ~; .rJ:- ..,.. §.J ~lkll J~ J! ~Jb J)Jt r-1 ~..L.ai ~~

~ J. .:e-o-l!YI ~ J! \...>.-~ .J\S' .J!_, l.i.> ~ ~ .i>ilt ...,._,j .JIS' 1:,1 ..,;; J. c!J ....;..$" .J}l:! ':/_, -=!Y

pi- } w uL..y ~ 1.,;/ ~)JI .JIS' l~lt..b r-o--..~Z ,y .. li:.-1 ..:...,:.. ,y ':/ ;;_,...,..Ail Jla.!! .)~ y\S' ..:...,:.. .:r--!

.245 a.,_.")l...'jl 4i..J.ill ~.J\:1 ~ ,Jjl)l J.,S- (93)

.106 41_,..,1_, ...w• J ~l..!.l • ..r.J>! .:r. ~ r~.o'j • ~ .y~A.f• J.:S- .> ,.,~...,~..... y.i <94>

185 i.lt....)l (9~)

Page 35: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

imam ~afii'nin Usiill Kelam Ekoliine Etkisi I4SS

i'%!.) ':1_, WI !.) ':IJ 01"Jil) o..li. ':/_, if~ ~}JII~ ._,...l.t j.WJ..;..;_,:II ~ y_,lk!J J! lA~! cJ .;,i ':/! ~ . 96

.( )"j.WJUI:.o ~> 0~ tLaJI._AUI

.Js-~ L.S' •.jb ~ y_,L~ .l;Ul~l ..y.u_, ,~\,JI cJ JL<::JI ~ ~ .W 0_,.1_,.....~1 0.,...L<:l.i t..i

rt..~t.; ,-.!WI o.iA cJ ~ cJ_,b ,js- ~) ~J ~WJI (Lo~l 0i ..li. W. .:/'J ,~1 ,;.J':/':J4"JI ~~\..:..

1.} 4>-l...aj C: ~~ r.~ J':/..1.:... ':/4 c.}4 015"" ._;j L.S' '~ ( 0!J j.WI ,js- JA;l4 J':/..~.:... ':/I ..,_i\.:.,. .ys. ~ ~\.!JI

,:; ;;~ .~jll ;;..u..... ~~~ ..:...;15' L.S' ,~1 .;..':/':Jx...,.''ll 0_,.1-<:1.1 ~ ~ JlAll cJJ ,.;,1).1 cJ ;;_,;_, 0Ull

.~~I ~1-:..,W 'Y! ..!.1.1> Lo_, •lf:i\... .!l!r!

._:.,\...i:.a... .:/' u.~ c; ':1_, -.IL.JI c; ..li. )'.; •r)L<ll ~ ft"' ~~if..:....~..-. J ,y)L<ll.!->-l.,l.l if <L) ..:....~..-. .8 ~ ...;i 'Y! ,~ ~J~~ ~\:1.1 ~ .;_,..u_, ~ 4;...(1 ~} '(')\SJI ~ Jt..... .:/' 4JL ":i _,i y)L<ll ~1 ~L!..I1 rt..~l .

~~ .:/' r~-' -.!;J-1 ~ ~L:.J1 rV"JI ._:.,~\.;... .:r .)» t.._, ,-$ r~ c; ..t:t..... .:/' -.~L -.1 Jl ...;~ r.li A.LC ..!.1.1>

.;...;ts:' ..w...:. !?'"" :.}.>- ..:r. ..u--i rt..~1 ¥ Ji.i ...u_, •J:I-1 ._:..l,Jb .))1 J:i if _,1_, ... ~ c; ~L!..II rt..~1lR ( r)L<ll . ~

:.Oj -:s- .)JJ ..ili ,._.fiJ r-LJ11h c) ~1..}:>A: 015' ~L!..I~ rL-~10! J ,< \.WI .;.to li!J r')IS:JI ~ .:.r~-( ¥

~!;>-- ili :~ ($.)~-' Jl,.il~ •)1..:....11 ~ J~_, JW:1 ,js- ~-' ...1;!}:4 ~~ .;i r')I.S:II yb.....oi c) ¢l'J t.;tL" 98

~ ._:..L<k. § .:/' <;:ll> ~L!.l' rt..~1 ~ J_,....\11 .!..>-'-:-- .;~ w. 0"-' ,< \')ls:!l c; .i>.~ i.:.....l~ ...,..~1.!l; .:/' .J!UI..:...:..,IJ cJ ._:.._,.:.i L.S' e!Y10_;ll «J 'Y! ~ ( ~~ ~ .11.,;;':/I.J! J •r')I.S:II

cJ~' ~~ .l'u... .;r ~I) tr-/ :Jw ..!.1.1> J-:AA r:r' ..;_;y1 ~ ~ 0i "1!-.IL.ll .~ rY-' ~JJ cJ lb. .!lw. .;~ ·~' c; ~15' •r)IS:ll ~ _,; ._:..'-:).~' Js-~ .)~ J_,....~, ~if..!..>-'-:-- J! ~l(~' :(4!L..)1

'(~':/\ JU'J ,i.:.....l~ 01"JI ~ J_;l~ <_,_,.h..~ _,f ~ ~~.;~ <.j>\,110_,.) .1'\.WI cJ lb._, •.J>\,1~ .1'\.WI

~ J! .JL>>\r1 ..:..AJj ,J_,....\rl.:/' 1.6"y Lo_, WI~ ,js- ~\.!J\ J..~.:...I...U_, '~J l6j ~ j_,....\rl ~}J . 99

. ( )"~ ..:..tA Jt....,;':/1 u;_, -.!L c./'-' ,"-"i 01"JI

0i 'Y! •r)IS:ll ~lb. "1 ..:...h.J ..!..>-'-:-- ..:...;15' 0!J c.s+' •r')IS:J1 ~ ..b.J ~~ 4.! ..lf- ':1 ·ts)AJ' 01 J •r)\SJI ~ Js­!,-"! ~~.:f.J ,J_,....\rl ~ .;..\Ak.. if til J~..,:>-1 Js- 4:1! Jdl015' ~ ,J.r"' J_,....i..:....; u. ~t..:JI rt..~l..:....;

.59/1 .;.ol,i;~l <~! y.l ,._J>\..!..11 (96)

.81 ~'"-J ~1.!.11 yl.)i 'I'"'~ ~~..J! ..!....- y.l•c$j~l (97)

.116/9 ~l,l.,~l ~ ,...111 ~ ..J! ~1 • ..;,.,...~1 (98)

.245 y')l...~lll...J.ill t;>..>l.:.l ~ •Jj~l ~ (99)

Page 36: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

456 I Uluslararas1 imam Sam Sempo~·umu

Jj ~W~1 p. ')U ,~15 ifj t: ...,.....~ ~? ;f~ ._r-:]1 ;f~ .:.r ~ '1 w- 'JJ-..dl ~ 1.7<J ..::..~Jl'.:.r ;.)~'

·i')\S:JI ~ y .:>_).1 _J.r"\JI ~ jlL...l.lo.U .J ~ ~\.!.)1 iv'JI .;i !1;..~; ~.i; 1.;..._;)1 l~y <l;.:l)I.:>J ~h...

~~~~ .J! W' <y)'SJI ~1.,14(::~ ~Li:....:.,. ..:..i\5' .!...:>- ,\...li ~~ .y ~I~ 4JLJ.\i ._:.~<:!J ~ t..i 100

< > ~ .:>i .:r ?i ~~ ~ <b\1" 'if')\S:JI...;..;...d.l ~ w_, l.b~.,;;~ ..~:.,;; ..,T""\1'

~l.,l.u ,...,.,~~ .:r r~~~.k~l _,i .;-.s. .w 4.1s- .... , .. ;_; .. '1 ~~ <JT"'~~ ~1.,11 if -.Jt...)l..;..k:. .9 ~L!.ll rv)'l .!J.-C ~ .!..l.b 0t5J ,.k~'1'.:; J.r"\11 4:>--t:.: ~~ 4JS' ~L!.l' rv'JI ~;.U_, J' <JT""\1'

fiWJ ·.:>..G._, ~ <.b~l lr.i .:.& ~..IJ.r'o ~~ ~) .:>i "-'--' .)\.S:; ·J----1' ...ul4 <J.r"\11 ~1.,11 ..b .... .:; ~

( J_,. .... \11 ~.:; Jw ~_.._, ..:....._,.... ~~ .:r ~~ ~ ~.;\S' ..w .:>_,...1-<.:ll vi .<.b~l ..!.1J; .:r .k~')\J ~~

~ .:>fi(,?}>.:JI..:..-,li.J \Jt..._r-.1 ~ 0\5j ,y')\S' ¥. ..::..1.) JlUI o.U .j:u.! .:>IS"..:....._,....,~ ...,_.;1>.-lk 0-~

.1.,..)1 ..U_, ,J,~)II .J lA j>-..1..< )l._sll ~_,ill\ ~1.,11 ._}u.! J! ~.) <5-AAj W' ,yk:ll ~I ..:,.)II...;;... )II ...,...._!.:l . '

~I <Ji ~ t)\S" <.S_y.lll o..i.t ;# J_,i JJJ .~l.,l.lo.U ~ J! ~ ~..U ,~<:!J .y ftS' .r~l lli 101

< \_;; ~.i; r.A ( ..;irS; ..L..:..ll ~~S"._....LO... .:; •J.rl1 l?~1 ,4:-- y ~ J.r"\11 .$:" J! y u.1 • .u.:; J>~'.:; .J:o.L<:!.I_, ~L!.l' rv'JI .:r y ...J')\;,.r.::;:.,.... .)~-'

.:>_,...1-<.:ll vi .~1.,11 .:r ~~ J! J}:>:! ')l.i ,~, • • ..p•11 ..::..~>.-~,:>-)ll._;i_, ._,J...,~' ~1.,11 ~ ~L!.l1 rt..)'ti

J_;ll I.U J! ~jl ~ ..U_, ,J_,..;.\J" i')\S:JI ~ ~ .1.1.,;;'11 ~..p_, '-:iW.! <.S.f"-j ..::..b:-l,:>-1 ._;;_, JJ-\JI t)J.- .a.}

~ J-OJI j~to..~L..:; ~L!.l' rt..l''l?h .1.~1 .J:o.L<:!.I .J:u.! J_,~>-t..:.,.> ,J:o.L<:!J_, ~L!.l' rt..'JI ~ ~

.Ji <~>.-_,!1 I.U ~ j..o\.J.."" ;Ju .!...:>- ,~.) tbl J! y ,.;1<J" 4.:..-ll ~ ~I tjJ (~ .J_,i .y .J1<J4 4.:.-ll

,.;j ,Jm ~ .:>~i 0! ..;~ !~ J_,.<il ""'"J )1_, ,•~ .J '1) ~_,.1.1 I.U .J '1 <;,II ~ r-1-~ t J ,J-OJI j~l <::'-t ~WJI 102

· ( ) ... .. !•·" ., •II J J · · ·· · · 1: ... 11 · '1 I '1 ·I 11..1 : J' .!.1 · ' •. 1. ~i .1>...:! • ~ ....... if ~..t .r...;..;~ , -~ J~ ~ ~ ~ ..r- .., .:>:; ..,~ ,._,.....,. ~ "-r if (f.

• .u.:; ..;.~' ~ 'J ~L!.l' rv)'t ~ .:>i ~ i~ ~L!.lt rt..i'' J! J~~'.:r .~_, J_,..oltlh ...,..._.._;.;~}I

.\.r.i ..;.~'I/~ l?..il' ,J:o.L<:!J & .:.r ._s:1.1 .!...:>- .:r ~ & rJ .yw .J:u.! .:; .J:o.L<:!.I ._.)..)... ..,..:L:»- c: ..:...ii!f ~.&i ~-' ,~L!.l' rv)'t ~ ._,T"'~' ~t:Q, ..,..:L.=:- J.J.. ..r • .u

. o.frS' ...,_.;~ .J ....AI:.> I 1;.:.-<.J ,..,_.;~I

.j~"JI ~I#.~}"- . .;r...IJ1 J~i_, WI! J~i t.Jo! iS'_r.W1 j'\......411 .~ . .) '<r'-'_,.11 =~~ Js- ~"11 _,12;1 ( 100)

J.:.INJ ~1 ~1J ~1 ~L .) ~')l.SJ1 ~J Wl1 J~i t.Jo! a.d1 ·~ ..w-i •Yr .UI..I.o.! l.oJ 293 .}=J1

. .)w.&1Jwi

.3/1 J..o.:o.J1 <.;,.-:-J1 _j!i <c,?~l :_,12;1 (101)

114/4 .l:.,:-.11 .r-J1 •._r.sjjl (102)

Page 37: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

imam ~afii'nin Usiili Kelam Ekoliine Etkisi 1457

4J--P~I ~\..:JI ~I}J ~I .)~1 :~WI ~I

,a).J-"'~1 ~l.:JI j'+'Lo! ~~'J -~ ~l.:JI <..1"'~1 ...,._, ~_,- 0:.J.J-"''11 ~<:1.1 .)\...#1 ~...v <) ~ ~~

\:&. ...::...-.1 ~\.:.:. ~y J! \.;.)_,A! _,..~ll..i.;._, ,~l.:JI ~~I ()}!1 ~ ~ 6.J_, .... '11 ~~)11 ~'-=!1 c.S-VJ

J.J-"''11 <.!->-1.,-o ....... ~.) ~ ('_,~ .:M.J-"'~1 ~<:1.1 c.:.. .:,i if-'-~ if pili'-!!'-'.,.._,_ '-:l.J-"'~1 ~<:l.l ...... _r..

J_,...,~l wi if 0;-'l..o!o£1 Lo l..i.;._, ,J.J-"'~1 .J..}J <) 4:1! .J~~ )\; ,~1 t_J}ll ~ o¥ ~_)2; ._.~.) .U:L-o_,

'"'._; :ib ,I.e.! ~)..u_, J_,....,)u ~..ii -..1!..~1 • ..i.;. .fo l?) 1.;1 {" :<P'_;..1 Jli ~ ,J!f!~ <P'j1 ~ ,~1 if

<) ot;.)_;j Lo ~\.$;.I~ ,~_r.JI '-i_,.:h\.1 JlL..l.l <) L,~ ~ r_rl: )1_, t__,;ll ._,..,b...:.i ~I.L J!...:...A.:4 )fi J_,....,~l 103

c " ' 11 # " ( )II · ~;; J..>:il J>-c~ t}l'-' ,...u11 y~-o Jl .::...d.i ;; J.J-"';;1 ..!ll~-o <J \.;1 J>- =~~ J~_;_, , .:r<JI 1..i.;,

104

4,! J>fl. J ,JI:l.l._,..,_,.;, Jl)> J>- )1_, <JlL..l.l c.S~"/ t.o.,; J>fl. )\; JJ....,~I Lo~" :Ju ..W J!;JI Loi ,< )"tjll

_,i \.oliz..il O·eA" _,i ~ ~ if l..o! ~I \.o.;l:i.) •y.-} { 12~_, ~ .hl!r=J_, t_l.r."/~ -.:......l~ ._,..,\.:5JI j..>~ 105 .

( \ .... _v ...u11 J.J""'i J}..; 1-4,; --.,~,.:. o.JLI. 4.! J> fl. .:,i _,;:. if <.l"yll _y_, 4Ji...il J~ •.-¥<11 t_J}ll J~lr..Js. J>- <>-!r> J~ ~l.:.ll ~.ill J! ~ ~<:1.1 J.,.....~, wi if 0;-'l..o! \")~

~ J_,....,\11 s-l'-! ~l.:JI ...,_,...i...J.J ~I ~J-"~1 .;:.1.<:1.1 C.:.0 if 0-~ t l..il_, <'-JJ....,\JI ..li~l _j._}J <) ...,_,...i...J.J

...,..5 if.#" _,1>- .14 GLJ ,~1 ~~ G)lif 4.al~.> '-:1_,....,'11 r_;~i ..:,..j~ ,4-:-- 4:>--~~ Y..ill G)'

·c:">.:=JI o.)I,J ~~ .)~'lll J..-~ 4-:-- .:,\S'Lo :i! ~4!1 t_,;l' .)!,.!! oJ' ~<:1.1

:0!/j J!..!ll~ <) ._,..,...JI .)~J

~L.~.) if oy.....:..-1 el l..i.;._, ,'-J_,...,\11 ~L.~.) <) .)foll?_)i.JI e4 ~<:l.l0:.JJ...,{y\ ,J' _#" r!?l :JJ~I

l..i.;. ~ J>- J_,...,)U ~J .:,\$' l..il <¥ el\..i.;. ~I J_,....,~l ~ <) ~ .:,\$' ll_, '1")\5:1~ .._.o.h:l.l ~ <)

·--='.J-"'~1 ~.L rl..ol J~4r.P: ;;, y..ill G)4 ..b,;_j. 'i l¥ ,~.,...,..:" 6; '-:)_,....,'11 JL..l.l <) ~ .:,~ 'el

0~. ,~1 .)~)II ._,..,4 ..;JS-i .:,j ~ 4,! .)~)\lb.._,:.<.. ._,..,L,ll '-:)_,....,~1 uL.~..UI <) .:,_,..JS::l.l ..1.:>.-J :~\:11

~ .:,~ ~~ .:_,j ~~~ :~j y.i ..!1]~ <) JJ~ ,...ull <) oy)ll?..ill ~I .:f ~ 4>,.j J_,...,~l r-LJ ("'W"Y

J! ~ ~_,.<)1 JJ..WI u..I.:>.-J J J_,....,~l ~ ~ t ~ ~ J_,....,i ~ .)\.p. )I~ .._.ilkl.l .)tp,. )II ._,..,4 ~i

l?..ill ~~ ~ Lo J,lli I"~ I .1.~1 <) .kJ_,:; .:,i _,;:. .y ~ v~) ~4 ...ull J_,....,i <) ._.~~ ~~ ._,..,....;!1

.534/2 1)1.:>.;,11 'oi"~1 ( 103)

.892/2 1)1.:>.;,11 <.j-!y..l1 (104

)

5 ~1 <J~1 (105)

Page 38: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

458 I Uluslararast Imam Salli Semp~zyumu

106

~~~ ~l.i l..iJ_, ·~· ~l.p.)ll r-B Jb- .Ji ~ J_,..,\11 ~ lJ ~l.p.)ll .__o.#- ~~ ..:,..;15:.; _< >...,~, .J~ .y..il.t wWl Cf.r> .J ~ )I ...S>-~· t._,_;l'

•.+:;k Wl' ~ .:r~ ~ -~WJI ~ ~ J'_,....;l-1 ""'"J ~r- ~_,...,~1 ~<:!J & c)~ ~J

.J _,i -.,1_,...,~14.;S' lJ ·~~~ <:)_,....~1 ~L.!.JI r+'Loj J~i ~~I~ .y ~ ~ J ,-.,~_,...,~1--l&-~1 _t}U l) y..lil .

J~~l.y ~~ -.,~_,...,~, r-rL-! J~i .Jy;.,..; ,~..iii ~l.:f •¥- -.,~_,...,~1· ~L..~~ ..:,..;IS'~ ,~1 ..,s- 48

~ co;:;.~ r::-.tJ ~l.!JI vLoj J_,; ~..!:! )\:... J~l yo L;;j c.lfi t?P' ~ JSJ C;="'"jl~ }diJ ~ l.i~J

c:!>Y.) !lpl c)~ \~l.!..l~ ~l..dl u':)\...:. li~ ,Y ~_,....JI c.Sy~ .:r~ )I~~ !lpl r-')11 :~l...." :J..;~ 107

~Lo'/1 c::" ~J ojjk-l; ccJ"!,.iJ~ WI~ lJ ~WJI r+-LoJ ~\...:. ~ ~;:;.) f$jy~ ~_,hljd l.iSJ .< ) .. F 108

lJ ~l.!JI ~(:.. ~ ....WI <:)'::>\A.;... )II ~ J~ I~ ,..!.lJ.) ~ ..u~~ '.b ~I .y ..!.lJ.) .r.i-J , ( ) o~j ~L!.ll '·

.4,1_,...,\11 ~L..~~

j_,...,\ll.y ftS' ~~l.y ~WJI ~(:.. c:f- ~ ..!.lJ.) .Ji )lj -.,1_,...,~1 ~<.:1.1 '-'J..I..o .J ~t;l..l oh .))"'") ~J)

:.»"f -..')1; ..!.lJ.) J=l~J c~l.!..ll rLo'JI ~ ~ ~ ~~~~.y ftS' J~~

tJ}' w~ ..!..lJ; ...:,..;\$1 ,,.... ,~L;.ll ~..iii~ ~l.!JI ~<:!.-.,I_,... \II .;..!_,~)ll.y ftS' w!Y- :JiJI

-.,1_,...,\JI ._:..~~)11 s:.\...aA:....I li~) _,.!_, s:.'::>~ C;-"'~ /\11 lhJ ,-..\..i.:...a... l) ~L.!.JI rLo'JI .:f i.:,!\.1 J_,...,)U ri ._,....,..il.l

tj pi~ ,)I_;;.~ y_,.L.i .Ji )lj c~l J_,A;" ~li..l>.-_,.1 ~l.!JI ~..wJ 4=,..-> ~~I ~l.!JI ~9-

·~WJI ~I j_,...i .:f J..Ail) if )I ~I.J J..o.;..<.J ,.;..~~)II..!JI; lJ -.,1~1 .

J_,...,\11 ~J ..r.$" ..1>- Jj ~I tJ} ~ ~~I ..~...:.j ~<:!.1 ~_). ~ .,r"'i ._:..\.C..a.. .;....l>.J :JWI

~ <f$j~l.y......J <.}.i ~ .;..LO:...dJ oh .YJ cy'::>\..<.11 ..!..>-\J,I ~b.:i) ,,_,;;11 ~~ ~ ..:,..;lS:; ~~

.j' -.,~_,...,:.y, .. ~':.'' ;~~ ,~, tJ)I~ J_,...\11 .b..,~ ..l...:.j •eli' if-'~~ WIS"" -.,~_,...:.y, -..-u.:...... ..:..;IS'

t_PJI .. ~ lJ ~· :t.r-o ·~ d-.0.:~ .))"'".» ~L!.ll ~ lJ J;...\11 ~ t..,;l' ~_ji. OA.J. J*" :o.!.J\:11

~WJI ._,...,..iii tJ} .b,; ~ ~}:JI oh ..;.....\; ~ <l)lt.)l J_,...,\11 ~ tJ}'I ~.fJ <1$_,:...--)IJ J_,...\JI .? ._:..Li:...2..o _,b:- J! ..!.lJ.)...,........ .l~J c4,lj ~I O)l.l;J -.,I_,..., \II ~L!.ll ~(:.. ._:..LC..a...J ·~~14,1_,...,\fl..l&-~.Al'-!

J! j_,...)U f$~1 ~lJ.I t.ir'-1 J! ,)1_;;. ~.) Lc ~_v_, ~ J_,...,i ~ .b)llh .y -.,1_,...,\fl ~l.!JI ~(:..

17 w.h J_,...,i co_rj y.l ( 106)

240 ~I cJijAII (107

)

.851/2 c:lU>_,ll c._r.,.,:JI .340/3 J_,.-.JI c~jt)l :)all (108

)

Page 39: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

imam $afii'nin UsUii Kelam Ekoliine Etkisi 1459

109

~l...WI if i..b-i ji t .. ; ... ,,./ :<.}\i.}l Jfi I..U. .:)) , ( ) ~\...:.JI ...l:s- j..:o\;ll .!ll5:Ai\'l I..U. -.It[, ~I ...,._;\.:1.,1

u~ u)ll ~~_, ,;~_,AI J_,...,.\11 A j_,...,.\11 ~~ J.0.:--1 J '~ ... ~ I..U. ~1.). <.S..I...::>j ..;:.o...L0.:\.1 ~4-iOJ~ ..J:..'>\.1.1 r: ,_ _{ ,_ ,_ ,_ •

-.!W~ .. : . ..!..~,.< . •• ._~11$_,;, ....»:1 .JI ...::...,>-1 J.,...,\fl ..!.lJ.; J! ~~l;...l ~~~~if ,;~..l,.ll JL..l.l

t~l v~~J { (~~ ~\...:.JI) .:r.-,;\.:1.,1 if ~_,...,.\11 ~~ p 4z......;._, o~li j) .j tJr"ll le-J! :.j .,sJI ~_,...,.\11 110 .

I~ J..I.:....J ,< ), ... Q)ll ~~..ol \.....1>.- ,j_,...,.\11 ~~ 4_,t:.. '->..> ~ C: y~l J.;-d <le-J! l..p ~\.:JI ..:_.,.. ,;,_?I _)dl ~ ~ ~ o)\5"" .J)) ,~1 .j .,r'\...:.JI .....,..._...ill J! ....,_...::.; ~\...:.JI ~<(;.. J ... ....,i oJi f.>\S:JI

-'+-1! ~:.)_, Jra\JI..!.liJ .)>- if'L:.ll .....,..._....i....ll ~~~~ t~l ?!:!_}.if !$y )'~ <.?l.i).:;-<1

Q) ~~I <.Sy:> C.~-' tif'\...:.JI .....,..._....i lf.l;........i ~..1>.-_,i ~\...:.JI ~<(;.. j_,...,.i .Ji <.>) <i~ ._..,_. v ~ ~~)

j_,...,.i ~I .j ~j \'j ,...:JJ~ .._A.a.:;\' ...;:..l-<:!.1 ._:...~~~ ~) J..,....,\JI o..U. ~ ..::...;\5"" .J[, ,~ .,r'\...:.JI .....,..._...ill

·if'I...:JI.....,..._....i....ll

v~_,..;,_,l.l ..:k 4.i).All J'.>\..:. if ~_,..,.\II ...;:..1.<:1.1 .._.)oM .j .,r'\...:.J' rv)'l Ji .Jl:! .:) ~ J:>_,..JI 1..iA ~.,

('+'v) ~~'Y .:r.::J.r-\11 ~\...:.JI ~<(;.. :.~\ <.S.Lo .J~:!_, tl..<"...l.:s- ~_,...,.\11 ~l.:5JI ._rll..a.>-_, <4:--o j) ...l:s- ~_,...,.\11

oy-..1.11 .j J_,All ._~ :.y-i ,if'\...:.JI .....,..._....i....ll ~~ t~l ~ r...l:s- ~_,...,.\11 ~~'YI ~41 <.S.Lo) ,~_,...\11 if'\...:.JI

.w.)dl ·~ ._,5 if J_,~ ~_,....\JI...;:..L<:J.I ._.J.Lo u-'Y ~\...:.JI rv)'l ,:,i·:~:.U.._, ,~II..U. ~~~ .j I.S:.J_,i .,sJI

....... )~ .J! ":.! ,~-~~ ~ .:,~)~vi ,Jtr.)'~ r~l..:....,... if~~ ~y-..1.11 • ..u. .Jl :J_,:;\;

~ ~ 0-~ t /\JIIJ... .:;-<J_, ,J ... .....,\JI .j ..!..>-t,.. if .,r'\...:.JI rv)'l ..u._, lJ; ~ ..b- Jj ._:...)\;~ ....... \II j;.J_.<:J.I

~~ t) .... ...,;_, ~L;J1 rt..)'l ~if ~~U:..-1 ~!,b_, ~ .... ~.:... J'.>b:-1 ~ J_,....~, ~i ~ ,j;.J_.<:JJ

.J_,...\11 ~ .j ..;:_,\.:..)\.h.._,~ J:L. ... _, ..!..>-t,.. if ..u._, I..J ._,.:.;~_, ,J_,...,.\11

~_,....,\11 "-!~1 [.-+--' .j ~ Jjli.Ji \.:] .:r..,; ..w ~_,...,.\11 ~\.&11.__...:~ .... ~ w ?1...,._;1>.- if)...,._;~>.- if lh

if~ ...u.~l ~'tl J'.>\..:. if u)l~ J_,...,.\11 .k..J -~ ~t..:.JI ..~....:>-1..:....,... ,.:r.,..L<:!.I_, if'\...:.J' rv)'l if JS' ...l,;s.

,J_,...,.)u .. ,i .. b-11 ~I if .r--?" ..b- Jj ,.-ii.A.:........ -:...J.,:. ..::...._:- ...;:..l-<:!.1 ...l:s- v J)~ l.h_, ,'-:....!~ .J~I ._rr2'

r 1.1. J>!l:,. /i l.h_, ,~1._:...\'\'.J;....\'1 y... ( .J[, ~1-.J:.\11 ~ J\f..~;...\'1 .j if'\...:.JI rv)'l :.~1 J! -.;w.!

~ J_,....,\11 1.."" ( if'\...:.J' rv)'l ,:,i W"" ,~, ._:..\'\'x....\'1 J>- .r--? ~ J! ~~ ..:....,... ...;:..1.<:1.1 ...l:s- J\;ll

~;. .J! J ,~_,...,.\!, ,.-il4:....a.. ~ --.....!1 • ..u. ~ lS>" ...:.U~ ,.-i~IS" ._:...:r.f .:t..u1 .:r.,..1.<::!.1 Jt:.. J'.>~ 'r'.>IS:.h

.a:)_,... \II ,.-i~.A.:........ ~ y)\SJI ~14.,1J 1)2i ...:JJ~ ~

,._,JJ.\.1 o..U. u-'Y if'\...:.JI rv)'l ,:,i Jdl J! ~I~;, ll ~_pll ...l:s-~ <I!L!.; :._,.,.y. J_,All..:r~JL<l.l .jJ

.)_,.,._,11 .j ~\..... o.t:J:. ~\11 .J!..:....,... \:.fi !$P ~ uL..i .)>-,:,IS"" lij j_,...,.)\J if'\...:.JI rv)'l ~J .Ji :...:.U":. .J~:!_,

.53 U:!¥.,....~!J ~lf.llll ~ [~1 .. ...,.~ .J ·~411 :.)0;1 (109)

.34 J.J...>~I ~ E,!Jill 1::~ •cJ:!.lll '":'~ •v-i\.:-ijll (110)

Page 40: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

460 I Uluslararast imam ~afii Sempl!zyumu

J.,.....~~ JJ-'2>" .h! ~ J ,~ i..y.a; tpall ..i.,;.c~ '1 .... .ua... ~ rt..! ~L!.l' rt..'l' :h \..! ci t}l'J •ttl' J>­..r..,.....; ,J' ;J.)\11 J! ~J .j ...l.::..-: ..;i \'! .).r. t?P ~ ._;.;_, ..:;..~l,;>-1 <.,J_,...,\11 "'!Jl.;>-1 ..;...;\$' Ill_, <lo-:.- o:-<1_,

J..tJ.-1 J>i ...,.._,L~ ~~_, c;J:U J-~ t..&b:.l.' ~\.....; .... ~ .!.ll~.:; _,.._, ,4AJI..;..\f\f..~;.....\f~ ~-' w~ ._,..1.:S:11

.<.:ili_,JI 4A......l.<JI .J:.i~.i t..ti) t.,...L..:.! <::_\.;.>-1 _,j; ,J' ~I UJ-ll...?

.:; 4:= J)b.:.l e:: ...,...;1..:1:1 ~~.:; .Jri-<.:1.' ~ ~~ .).r. c;)>; ~-' _,.. J..,...,)u ~L!.l' rt..'l' ~_, .J\.i ~-'

.:,.:..L<.:l.l ~_rl. ~\..!JI rt..)'l..r--'i; I.Sy.) ~ u-"Ji .Ji ,:r~ )I ._,...;\.:1:1 I~ .j \.....;.:: ._;O~.:lii.,Y <<::_-rl'l~ YJL::...

~ ...,...;~ ~ ~;J.;_, ·~.ri- .)t.o:....l w- J_,...,\tl ~-'.:; ~L!.l' rt..'/1 if .Jrt-<.:1.1 .)t.o:....l :J..,..o; lib ,<.,~_,...,\tl

. .;:j)=JI ~

~·~if ~b.i ,J..,...,\11 ~ L~ ...,..1.,11 c..;j ~I..!JI rt..)'I.J\.i ,o.JL!J .~.:; J_,.all ~ .:,i u.)) '~b

~l; '~J ~..;!~ C:: ~ ._,..;~I ~ <.J!.i.,.:.i ~ ,J' <.)!¥---- ,<.,J_,....,\11 ..;..:..1..,1.~ JWI t::'J -~\.:...) r-+:"'1.1. j')\:,.:.1 c? ~~.A:..:... J..,...,\11 r-1>- .j ~;,:s_; <Jl')d~ ~\.:JJ r+-"'\1

WWI

.:; 4lw ~1 ~ J! ~i ~.r"\ti.:,.:..L<.:l.l ~~ ~L!.ll rt..'JI u;W J:i""=l~ ./-.JI:JI j,)11~ ~ ">--J c? .:,.:..L<.:l.l ...._J..v lJJ r,..JI ">--) c? J..,....,\tl r-1>- .j \.k_, \.-.;,~ lr'i ~L!.ll rt..)I.J ,:,i :t:..>wJ ,~1 4G

~~~ .j ~ ~L..:d-1 .j J}: LS ,j_,....\11 ~ ..:...:..1..,1. ~\..!JI rt..'/1 ~J .j fii:lll~ J}: ..u_, 'c..l"..,....a.J-1

.>~I J! 4JW.! ,'~.r")rl .:,.:..L<.:l.l ~~ .j ~~ .1'i <.,).r"\11 "'"\A:..a.. .j ~\..!JI rt..)'l ~ .J\S' ~ <.,J_,......\11

4UII t_,All ~~4 J..,..oJI .:r~ w- ,~ ..b- J! "-:J.., ..... \11 ~\..!JI rt.."JI ~~'J ~L!.ll ~.l..ll ~~ ~<.:1.1

.j-.AI .j ~\..!JI ~(:!. <.,)_,....\II u~l;>-)II c? ~\.!JI ~...i.....l.l

)1_, Jt.. eft )I(_:!~ .Jb "-!eft .Jb (:;-<JI ~_,! LJ~.> J-.JII~.~ .;.,i JW .11 JLi ~I Li..> (\:>. lJJ

·r-:1-~ .11 Ji ,J' \'! .J_:=.:

~'rl~ J.)\..a.JI w~

·(1981 t<.:il!ll ~I <uJp. ,;J\.....)1 ~y ,J.,..,~ I Js- t)_}ll r!j_;;r; J .y...oll <t?.i-'"JI.l

.... 1405 ,~1)1 ~I <uJp. <<J_rll yi.:..<JI ).) ,~I.JJ~I ~ ,_.tl_y. 0! ..l.l'-i '<?~\11 .2

..... 1414 <.}>4)1 ,.J...!,)I..,_<. ,~.,...,~'-' s;.~l ~ r!j.J:;..:ll ,...,..t:._,ll..y. ....,..~ . .) '~1.,.}1.3

·(1987- ... 1407 ,cJI.!ll ~I <uJp. <.rfi' .:.r.l ).) <1$Jb<.:ll ~ <ylc-!.:.t. ~ <t?J\;;.,)1.4

..... 1403 <JJ\tl ~I <uJp. ,~I...,_:..<JI ).) ,~1 ,~ly.i <t.;_r,l1.5

Page 41: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

imam !?afii'nin Usilli Kela.m Ekoliine Etkisi 1461

·r1971-..-1391 .>_rWI ,..!.Jijll .;~_, '+-<... ,~\.!J~ ~~.:.o ·~ .:r. ..v-i .r~ y.i ,~1 .6

.~\!!1 ~~ ,~ ..:r.l ...,_-(.. •I.SJI.::AI I ~ ,~1-¥ J. ..l..i'-i ,~ ..:r.l .7

. ..-1418 .,~1)1 ~~ ' r>-' , ~u_,ll ;b , I.A.QJ1 JJ-P( J c:ll.:l;o.J1 ,..!J.1.l.1-¥ JW.I y.i ,~_,hi .8

J.:ltuJ ~1 ~1J ~~ ~L. J r~l ~J I.A.QJI JJ-PI 1ft ll.4!1 ,~ ..v-i ,....,_,... .9

• .J_,J \11 ,~1 Ji a,...L,. ,~_,;l.ii'J ~I .. :.A ... !J..UI ys" <o;~-_,;. fr->.L> 3.!L...; ,JW .&1 Jwi

~~ ,.;w •1$j!)1 ;b ,•_a_.b; ~ ~Ju 4....1J.) ~1 ~J-P':ll j:AJ1 JfoJ ·~ _ _, .~? .10

·r2007-... 1428 .J_,\11

,;_r.WI <...,kll ,;_rl.ill ,..J;W.I }::> '~J 4.op ~.bJ1 JJ-"i 'i::.~ ~ . .) ,~1 .11

·r1988-..-1408

• ..:.-_,;::! 't?rJ' ..... ~1 )::. , .)1~ t;!.JI;; <.)s- .J! ..v-1 .r~ y.i <1$_,1J.A)I ~~ .12

·r 1984 ,~\J.I ~~ ,..:.-_,;::! ,~1 ;~_, ,4.o.liJ1 ,..I.J. .:.t. .:rJI ~ ,.;_,.u,.:. .:r.l .13

,~...;_,ill>..l>.:l.l O'_r.ll ,~ ..:;.,_# ~1 ..:;.,1.:1~':/'J .o_,...,IJ WU ~-->'; i...o'J.) ,~ . .) ,.:f-1 .14

·r1984 •J_,'JI ~I,.;.:...._,

. ..-1408 , ..:_.Jft. ,~1 ...,_:..<.JI )_, ,MJ~1 ~I,.\.!. ..l..i'-i .tt JJ · 'I$~..UI .15

. ..-1413 ·,~l:Jt .....,w1 • ..:.-_,;::! ,3.!L...)t <.........._;.. ·~~1 _r~i r. ,..v-i ..:r. ~,~.ill .16

• ..:.-Jf.-'< ,alL... )I <..........y ,~.A.QJI JJ-P( ~ J J~l 'V...Ut ~ <l$j~1 .17

-..-1406 'J-'"' Wd' ·•.rw' •'<.rj"l -=--~<.!1 '+-<... ,~\.!J1 r~.o~l ~~.:.o ,v-..u' ~ •1$j!)1 .18

·r1986

. ..:.-_,ft. ,~1 ...,_:..<.!t }::> , ~l.:.oJ ~\.!JI y l.)l •{'- c.).i .:r. ~ y.i <l$j!)1 .19

,~\!.11 <...,kll <...:..._,s::ll ,y')L...'jl .;_,~'J Ju_,"1 ~~-' , I.A.QJI JJ-Pi .) ..h::-J1 ~I ,~jt .20

·r1992-... 1413

.~l.ill 't?rJI .r<.Alt ;b , ~.A.QJ1 J~l ,~ <o_r>j y.i .21

.>_rl.ill •t?r-''.rc(;Jt )_, ·~J oj'JT O~J .u~ ~\.!J I ,~ <O_rj y.i .22

<...,kJt •-=--w, ,3JL...)t <.........._;... ,JJ-P'./1 ._)s- t:J}ll ~fo ,..v-i .J! ::>~ .:r...UI '"<"'4-!- <l)li.)t .23

·r1987-..-1407 .~lJ.I

~~ ;b .J_,'Jt ....,Wt '.Jw'J1 u_,ll y.i ._~ ,~_rl1 JJ-Pi ,..l..i'-i .:r. ~ .r~ y.i ,~.;-11 .24

·r1993 ,..:.-_,;::! ,~1

Page 42: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

462 I Uluslararas• imam l;;afil Sempozyumu

;....bJI ,;..\>.- ,J_,_rJI )~ ,~.Iii ~ ~}.i Ll;~ .)_,..,~I ~I ,._,.,U._,JI ¥ .~ ,j~ Jii .25

·i1983 <j_,~,

•r.r- .:r.l ;~~ ,.u_,...,iJ wh ~ ~1..:.!1 l.f""!J.)! ~J~ ..w... r~.o~~ ~ ,_...,..~..>}1 ¥ .~ ,,:,~ y.i .26

·r1999-~1420 <JJ~I ;,..bll IVJ_#

·r1952 ,J_,~~ ~~ '.J"""'-' ~•~u1 ~,~\AWl tJ;"U •.:r...l.ll J;~.>,. •t}.::-JI .27

.v)p. ,;.;_,JJ )~ ,..::JI.Q.;I_,.ll 'IS"".Y .:1- r-"~! c.."-! Jii,c..J:.L!JI .28

-~1426 ,~1.!11 ~~ <o.ri.AII ,..:,!fJI )~ -...,_<. ~~ ~ .u--1 ... -.,;i ,4!1.....}1 '..,-".;~! ..J. ~ ,~\.!.11 .29

·r2005

,;_,:; ;~~ ,,:,r-->- .:t·d ~ .u--i .~ .... ..,;.;._, (:!': '<r~~ y i.:S') ~1..!.11 r1.t~1 ~..,...._,. •..r.r! ..:r. ~ ,~L!.l' .3o

·r1996~J416 <JJ)il ~~ lvJ..t:!

.v_,p. •r-W' )~ ~~~~ ..:J~ •Js- .:r. ('":"~! •<,?j~l .31

·r1981 <v_w. <l)_,..li..U!)I ).) •r~~~ r# ~11)""!"""\r '<.;-> ..l,-)1 <;..L.dl .32

~'1):--1 ~;IJ L~ <,_S_Mll t!I)IIJ}ll ~~ J! .;r.,J.:JI .:/' ~~ J_,...,i ~ ,.11-¥- ..:r. .u--i .~ <.}.j:'JI .33

·r2006-~1427 ~~~~~ ,y";A..."J' ~yo- ..:r. ~ rt...'i' a...~>. ,w,.u

.JJ-1! '0!-'-!l&- ..:r.l JL..; ~~ ~ ,~1 \""") .)~ o\..o.....JI t._F.JI c_r. 41L..; •..:t-'-!l&o .:.r.l .34

.~1..;.,1..._:1...

~~ ;,:_(.. (:jj.f ,_,.!.:)1_, ~jll_, <...A.J\:lt 4.:J, ,y~\.....~1 U-lAJI C:'.}::l ~ ~~ ,Jj!)l ¥ .35

·r1966 ,<!)1!)1 ~~ •o.rWI ,~~~

·r1992-~1412 ,<.:Jwt ~~ ..... ~~ '.r<.o.J' ;~~ ,~..bJI r.Ys- ~ .li:h ~ ,.:r...u' ;i .~'is .36

,j_,~l ~~ <o..\>.- ,.lo..il> )~ '!ft.UI J_,...,iJ ...WI J_,...,i cJ.:! i.S'_r.WI JR •• ..JI ~~ .~ 'c,s"'"J..,.JI .37

·r1990

'if'":J.-.'jl .r<.ill .}WI -4-all '~r'J ~ ~ :<$"~~~ ...WI J_,...,i '.1.6.,. .J. .~ •<)~J.JI .38

·r1988-~1408 ,J_,\1, ~~ ,~,_,

1JJ~I <...,k)l <vJp. ~~~ ..,._:-<JI ).> ,J.,...,~I ~.:/'~I ~~ ..J. ..L..S ..V\.:.. .l•J~I .39

.~1413

'.J"""'-' ,_r.:Jt, ~l,h.U ~ ,-.,;l!ll ~~ ,~1 ~lj ~ ~~ _;:.ly.Jl <;~WI~ ,.,;._,All .4{)

·r1993

Page 43: ULUSLARARASI iMAM ~AFii SEMPOZYUMUisamveri.org/pdfdrg/D201675/2010/2012_KHAZNAHH.pdf · 4241 Uluslararas1 imam 1>afii Sempozyumu talism in the books speakers fundamentalism, and the

imam ~afii'nin Usilli Kelam Ekoliine Etkisi 1463

.~2003-~1423 <JJ:YI ~I ,.:_,w. ,._,..;WI)~ ,~\..!JI ~..i,. J! j.o'-..I.JI '(_?i .~ '../""'~1 .42

JJWI ~Y..! <.:.h ,Jt,..;jl ~ ~ ~ rl.o11 o..r--' J Jl.o~l t_,J.! ,..u~ ~ <1$)_,5:j1 .43

. .cll ,~l;i J~ ,a_,;L....:.II

;a_,;t:.ll ~I <..::..>Jfi ,~1 ...,._:...<.11 )~ ,~_,..,.~I ..::J\A,l:o J ~I ~I ,~ ..11 .y. 'J'~I .44

·r1974

. ..::..>Jfi <l}..,JI ..;.,ljll ~Y..! ;~~ 'rl-" ~ ·~'"'=- cJ. r-1--- (~ .45

·r1985 ,j_, :Y1 ~I ,o~l>.d cJ. l?_):.j )~ ,~fiAJI ,.._....._..! cJ. ...!...$. '{...l:ll .:.r.l .46

-~J;ll ~I ,y-4-JI c_.r. ~~ ,JJ..:. .:;. .:.r...UI ~ '1$J_,;ll .47