8/11/2019 Ucd Tla 0040

1/18

UCD TEACHING AND LEARNING/ RESOURCES

www.ucd.ie/teaching

ASSESSMENT

The Use of Concept Maps forAssessment

Author: David Jennings

Email: david.jennings@ucd.ie

Date: 17 th May 2012

8/11/2019 Ucd Tla 0040

2/18

"

#$%&'$$&

()* +,- $. /),0 1$%&'$$& ,0 /$ 2%$3,4* + 0*%,*0 $. %*0$5%6*0 ,7 /)* %*+8- $. +00*00-*7/ +74 /)*50* $. 6$76*2/ -+20 /$ 0522$%/ /),09

()* 1$%&'$$& ,0 7$/ *:)+50/,3*; '5/ +//*-2/0 /$ .$650 $7 + 75-'*% $. 6$%* ,005*0 +74 7**409

- ()* ?=06)$8$@= $. A*+%7,7@- B00*00-*7/ ?%,76,28*0- B7 C7/%$456/,$7 /$ D$76*2/ E+20- B00*00,7@ D$76*2/ E+20

F$5 +%* .%** /$ *4,/; +4+2/ +74 6$2= /),0 1$%&'$$& +74 2%*0*7/ ,/ /$ =$5% 0/54*7/0 +746$88*+@5*0; )$1*3*% +//%,'5/,$7 -50/ '* @,3*7 /$ /)* $%,@,7+8 +5/)$%G0 H/),0 1$%& ,0 8,6*76*4574*% /)* D%*+/,3* D$--$70 B//%,'5/,$7 I78= A,6*76*; 0**)//2>GG6%*+/,3*6$--$709$%@GJ

K*77,7@0; L9 "MN"9!"#$%&' )*&+ ,"- .++%++/%#'0ODL (*+6),7@ +74 A*+%7,7@; ODL;C%*8+749

12-'3%- 4"-56""5+ *-% *7*89*69%: ,"- 8#,"-/*'8"# $"#'*$' ;*78+?2$

8/11/2019 Ucd Tla 0040

3/18

P

(+'8* $. D$7/*7/0

"#$ %&$ '( )'*)$+" ,-+& ('. -&&$&&,$*" # IQ

8/11/2019 Ucd Tla 0040

4/18

X

W$1 1* 8*+%7

A*+%7,7@ 0/=8*0 )+0 '*6$-* + 0$-*1)+/ 6$7/*7/,$50 /*%- 50*4 /$ 4*06%,'* /)* +//,/54*0 +74'*)+3,$5%0; 1),6) `-+=a 4*/*%-,7* +7 ,74,3,45+8b0 2%*.*%%*4 1+= $. 8*+%7,7@9 C/ ,0 /)* `-+=a /)+/4%+10 +//*7/,$7 +0 ,/ ,0 $./*7 $-,//*4 +74 )*76* /)* 6$76*2/ '*6$-*0 + 4*/*%-,7,0/,6 +22%$+6)/$ 6+/+@$%,0,7@ )$1 8*+%7*%0 *7@+@* 1,/) ,7.$%-+/,$7; /)*,% 2**%0; *456+/$%0 +74 $22$%/57,/,*0/$ 8*+%79 V5..,6* /$ 0+= ,/ ,0 +80$ +7 +%*+ 1)*%* 0$ -+7= 8*+%7,7@ 0/=8*0 G 2%*.*%*76* -$4*80 *:,0/;/)+/ /)* -+%&*/28+6* ,0 /%58= $3*%c6%$14*4 H+ 6,/+/,$7 0*+%6) %*3*+8*4 $3*% N_M +%/,68*0*02$50,7@ -$4*80J; 0$ 1)*%* 4$*0 $7* 8$$& /$]d B74 )$1 -+= 1* 50* /)*- /$ $5% '*7*.,/d

C. 1* -*%*8= /+&* 7$/* $. /)* %+7@* $. 0/=8*0 +74G$% 2%*.*%*76*0 +3+,8+'8*; 1* -+= '*@,7 /$+44%*00 + 75-'*% $. &*= ,005*0 /)+/ ,-2+6/ 0/54*7/ ,7/*%+6/,$79 ()* ,4*+ $. 8*+%7*% -+8+,0*; 8+6&$. -$/,3+/,$7; -,0,7/*%2%*/+/,$7 ,0 7$/ 4$17 /$ %*6+86,/%+7/ ,74,3,45+80 +8$7*9 R= +4+2/,7@ /)*1+= ,7 1),6) 1* /*+6) +74 2%$3,4* 8*+%7,7@ $22$%/57,/,*0 /$ %*.8*6/ /)* 2$/*7/,+8 `8*+%7,7@0/=8*0a +22+%*7/ ,7 +7= 6$)$%/; 1* -+= '*@,7 /$ $..*% +7 $2*7 +74 *7@+@,7@ 2%$6*00 /)+/ ,04,%*6/*4 /$ /)*,% H/)* 8*+%7*%0J 2%*.*%%*4 0/=8* G -*/)$4 $. ,7/*%+6/,$7 +74 *7@+@*-*7/9

()* .$88$1,7@ /)%** /+'8*0 *8+'$%+/* /)* 4*/+,80 $. /)*,% %*02*6/,3* -$4*80 HQ$0*; W$7*= e

E5-.$%4 +74 Z+%4*7*%J +74 /)* ,7/*%2%*/+/+/,$7 $. /)* ,-28,*4 8*+%7,7@ 0/=8*0 $7 /)*,74,3,45+89

Q$0* N^[_/01234 ! A*+%7*%0 2%*.*% /$ 8*+%7 1,/) 3,05+8 %*,7.$%6*-*7/ 056) +0 6)+%/0 +74 4,+@%+-0 -2506789 @ A*+%7*%0 2%*.*% /$ 8*+%7 '= 8,0/*7,7@:0;3

8/11/2019 Ucd Tla 0040

5/18

_

Z+%4*7*% N^^P/01234 A &C36034 D;6GG1119)5-+7-*/%,6096$-G6@,c1,7GK(=2*0"9+02

- L+3,4 GG&*,%0*=96$- - V$8$-+7 e T*84*% I78,7* /*0/

)//2>GG1119*7@%976059*45G8*+%7,7@0/=8*0G,801*'9)/-8

8/11/2019 Ucd Tla 0040

6/18

Y

- Q$0*a0 \BQ< I78,7* /*0/

)//2>GG11193+%&c8*+%796$-G*7@8,0)G2+@*9+02d2ih5*0/,$77+,%*

- W$7*= +74 E5-.$%4a0 [M ,/*- h5*0/,$77+,%*

)//2>GG11192*/*%)$7*=96$-G

B7 C7/%$456/,$7 /$ B00*00-*7/

V$-* $. /)* &*= 25%2$0*0 $. +00*00-*7/ +%*j /$ *7+'8* /)* 6$--57,6+/,$7 $. /)*

+6),*3*-*7/ +74 05'0*h5*7/ 0/+/50 $. 0/54*7/0 45%,7@ /)*,% 2%$@%+--* $. 8*+%7,7@j/$ 2%$3,4* + -*+70 $. 0*8.c*3+85+/,$7 +74 ,7.$%-+/,$7 2*%/+,7,7@ /$ 056)j /$ ,4*7/,.=0/54*7/ 28+6*-*7/ 1,/),7 *456+/,$7+8 2+/)0 +74G$% 2%$@%+--*0j /$ +44%*00 /)**3+85+/,$7 +74 *..*6/,3*7*00 $. ,70/%56/,$7+8 2%$@%+--*0j +74 /$ 0,-28= -$/,3+/* /)*8*+%7*%9

&625 ()%** ?5%2$0*0 $. B00*00-*7/ N

"56% #), >#*2()#0%T$%-+/,3* B00*00-*7/ c -11

8/11/2019 Ucd Tla 0040

7/18

k

C0 /)* +00*00-*7/ 1),6) 2%$3,4*0 $3*%+88 +74 .,7,/* *3,4*76* $. /)* +6),*3*-*7/ $.0/54*7/0 +74 $. 1)+/ /)*= &7$1; 574*%0/+74 +74 6+7 4$; '= +00,@7,7@ + 3+85* H$./*7h5+7/,/+/,3*J /$ 1)+/ /)* 0/54*7/ +6),*3*0

(%*740 ,7 B00*00-*7/

#%,//*7 *:+-0 +%* '*,7@ %*28+6*4 '= -$%* 6$7/,75$50 +00*00-*7/ +74 6$5%0*1$%&9 ()*%* ,0 +-$3* /$1+%40 -$%* 0/54*7/ ,73$83*-*7/ +74 6)$,6* ,7 +00*00-*7/9 D$5%0* $5/8,7*0 )+3*'*6$-* -$%* *:28,6,/ +'$5/ /)* *:2*6/+/,$70 ,7 +00*00-*7/9

Z%$52 +00*00-*7/ ,0 -$%* .%*h5*7/8= 50*4 H,7 8,7* 1,/) /)* 0),./ ,7 *-2)+0,0 1,/),7 /)*65%%,6585- .%$- 6$-2*/,/,$7 '*/1**7 0/54*7/0 /$1+%40 6$88+'$%+/,3* 8*+%7,7@ '*/1**7

0/54*7/09J B7 574*%0/+74,7@ $. 2%$6*00 ,0 7$1 0**7 +0; +/ 8*+0/; *h5+88= ,-2$%/+7/ /$ +&7$18*4@* $. .+6/09 HC7 8,7* 1,/) /)* @*7*%+8 0),./ /$1+%40 + 2%$6*00c'+0*4; %+/)*% /)+7 2%$456/c'+0*4 65%%,6585-9J V/54*7/ .$650*4 b8*+%7,7@ $5/6$-*0b )+3* '*@57 /$ %*28+6* -$%* /*+6)*%$%,*7/+/*4 b$'g*6/,3*0b9 ()* .$650 ,0 -$%* $7 1)+/ /)* 0/54*7/ 1,88 8*+%7 %+/)*% /)+7 1)+/ /)*/*+6)*% 28+70 /$ /*+6)9 H(),0 ,0 ,7 8,7* 1,/) -$%* 0/54*7/ 8*4 +22%$+6)*0 ,7 /)* 65%%,6585-@*7*%+88=J9"

(87@ "7J3851 #%,//*7 S:+- D$5%0*1$%&(5/$% 8*4 V/54*7/ A*4C-28,6,/ D%,/*%,+ S:28,6,/ 6%,/*%,+D$-2*/,/,$7 D$88+'$%+/,$7?%$456/ +00*00-*7/ ?%$6*00I'g*6/,3*0 I5/6$-*0D$7/*7/ D$-2*/*76,*0

T,@5%* "> (%*740 ,7 B00*00-*7/

1 *+,-. /4) *$?? @4) A9.=?9B$+C # 0"DDE3 !""#""*%7 (&01#%& 8#4)%*%7 *% 3*79#) :10;4&*,%4 8,.=,.7F,$%?9=

8/11/2019 Ucd Tla 0040

8/18

[

E+/6),7@ A*+%7,7@ I5/6$-*0 ($ B00*00-*7/ (=2*0

L,..*%*7/ +00*00-*7/0 4%,3* 4,..*%*7/ /=2*0 $. 8*+%7,7@; /),0 /+'8* $..*%0 + 0*8*6/,$7 $. +8/*%7+/,3*-$4*0 $. +00*00-*7/ *7+'8,7@ 0/54*7/0 /$ 1$%& /$ /)*,% 0/%*7@/)0; /)50 2%$3,4,7@ +7 ,76850,3*+22%$+6) /$ /)* +00*00-*7/ %*@,-*9

"9C

8/11/2019 Ucd Tla 0040

9/18

^

HB4+2/*4 .%$- U,@)/,7@+8* */ +89;N^^YJ

B*+5 @?*%.$%- + 02$/ 6)*6& $7 /)* -$4*0 $. +00*00-*7/ +'$3*j

- W$1 -+7= 4$ =$5 50*d- B%* =$5 $3*% +00*00,7@d- #)+/ *80* ,0 50*4 +/ + 2%$@%+--* 8*3*8 H,0 /)*%* + '%$+4 %+7@* $. -$4*0; ,0 ,/ 4,0/%,'5/*4

%*+0$7+'8=Jd

- L$ =$5 $..*% + %+7@* $. +00*00-*7/ /$ +66$57/ .$% 0/54*7/ 2%*.*%*76* H8*+%7,7@ 0/=8*Jd

- T,7+88= %*3,*1 =$5% +00*00-*7/ 2%$/$6$8 l1)+/ 4$ 0/54*7/0 +3$,4; .%$- 1)+/ 4$ /)*= 8*+%7H*7@+@* 1,/)J -$0/; 1)+/ 6$76*2/0 +%* 0/,88 2%$'8*-+/,6d

S7+'8,7@ S..*6/,3* T**4'+6& W H,7 /)%**V/*20] XJ

+8

8/11/2019 Ucd Tla 0040

10/18

NM

S76$5%+@*0 2$0,/,3* -$/,3+/,$7+8 '*8,*.0 +74 0*8.c*0/**-

S:28,6,/; 1%,//*7 .**4'+6& ,0 ,-2$%/+7/; )$1*3*%] #%,//*7 .**4'+6& %+%*8= 6$--57,6+/*0 /+6,/ 574*%0/+74,7@0 V/54*7/ *7@+@*-*7/ ,0 *7)+76*4 ,. 1%,//*7 .**4'+6& ,0 05228*-*7/*4 1,/) 4,+8$@5*

+87B05< "0@

8/11/2019 Ucd Tla 0040

11/18

NN

L*0,@7,7@ B00*00-*7/0 X

V*3*7 h5*0/,$70 /)+/ 8*6/5%*%0 -,@)/ +0& 1)*7 4*0,@7,7@ +7 +00,@7-*7/ +%*>

N9 #)+/ +%* /)* $5/6$-*0 /$ '* +00*00*4d

"9 #)+/ +%* /)* 6+2+',8,/,*0G0&,880 H,-28,6,/ $% *:28,6,/J ,7 /)* $5/6$-*0d

P9 C0 /)* -*/)$4 $. +00*00-*7/ 6)$0*7 6$70$7+7/ 1,/) /)* $5/6$-*0 +74 0&,880d

X9 C0 /)* -*/)$4 %*8+/,3*8= *..,6,*7/ ,7 /*%-0 $. 0/54*7/ /,-* +74 0/+.. /,-*d

_9 #)+/ +8/*%7+/,3*0 +%* /)*%*d #)+/ +%* /)*,% +43+7/+@*0 +74 4,0+43+7/+@*0d

Y9 L$*0 /)* 02*6,.,6 +00*00-*7/ /+0& -+/6) /)* $5/6$-*0 +74 0&,880d

k9 B%* /)* -+%&,7@ 06)*-*0 $% 6%,/*%,+ +22%$2%,+/*d

)7@@7; J

8/11/2019 Ucd Tla 0040

12/18

N"

C-2+6/ $. D$76*2/ E+20G

8/11/2019 Ucd Tla 0040

13/18

NP

B00*00,7@ D$76*2/ E+20

B 6$76*2/ -+2 ,0 + 3,05+8 %*2%*0*7/+/,$7 $. &7$18*4@*9 ()* 2%$6*00 *7+'8*0 $7* /$ $%@+7,f* +740/%56/5%* ,7.$%-+/,$7 +74 /)* %*8+/,$70),20 '*/1**7 /)*-9 (),0 -+= '* 4$7* ,7 + 1)$88=@%+2),6+8 -+77*% ,9*9 50,7@ ,-+@*0; 2)$/$0; 6$8$5% */69 /$ ),@)8,@)/ 4,..*%,7@ 6$76*2/0 +74 /)*,%8,7&+@*0 $% '= ,4*7/,.=,7@ &*= /)* 6$76*2/0 '= 7+-* $% /,/8* +74 *768$0,7@ /)*- ,7 + 3,05+8 '$:/)*7 2%$3,4,7@ 6$77*6/,7@ 7+3,@+/,$7 /$ 8*00*% 6$76*2/09 B /%+4,/,$7+8 6$76*2/ 2%$3,4*0 +),*%+%6),6+8 %*2%*0*7/+/,$7 $. /)* ,7.$%-+/,$7 .%$- /$2 4$17; 1)*%*+0 + -,74 -+2 -+= %+4,+/*.%$- + 6*7/%+8 0,7@8* 6$76*2/ $78=9 V5..,6* /$ 0+=; 1)*7 6%*+/,7@ + 02,4*% -+2; 0=0/*-0 -+2;6$76*2/ -+2; -,74 -+2; .8$1 6)+%/; 3,05+8 28+7 */6 *+6) 2*%.$%-0 + /+0& /)+/ 7$ $%4,7+%=6$88*6/,$7 $. 7$/*0 -+= *76$-2+00 ,7 + 0,7@8* 0)**/ m + 2*%0$7+8 3,05+8,f+/,$7 $. &7$18*4@* m

+74 .$% $5% +74 /)* 0/54*7/0 2*%02*6/,3* /)*,% &*= `8*+%7,7@ @+20a ,9*9 1)+/ ,/ ,0 /)*= -+= 1,0) /$.$650 $7; %*.8*6/; %*3,*1 +74 4*3*8$29 C7 /),0 1+= /)*= -+= '* 50*4 .$% +0 + /$$8 /$ 0522$%/ +74*7)+76* 8*+%7,7@9

B -*/)$4 $. +00*00,7@ D$76*2/ E+20 2%$2$0*4 '= U$3+& +74 Z$1,7 ,7 N^[X ,0 '+0*4 $7 /)*6$-2$7*7/0 +74 0/%56/5%* $. /)* -+29 (),0 0=0/*- +1+%40 2$,7/0 .$%>

\+8,4 ?%$2$0,/,$70 HN ?$,7/ S+6)J; A*3*80 I. W,*%+%6)= H_ ?$,7/0 T$% S+6) A*3*8J; U5-'*% I. R%+76),7@0 HN ?$,7/ T$% S+6) R%+76)J; D%$008,7&0 HNM ?$,7/0 T$% S+6) \+8,4 D%$00cA,7&J; B74 V2*6,.,6 S:+-28*0 HN ?$,7/ T$% S+6) S:+-28*J9

B 8*00 .$%-+8+22%$+6) /$ @%+4,7@D$76*2/ E+20 ,0 /$50* +74 2%$3,4* +0*/ $. +00*00-*7/6%,/*%,+ 1,/),7 +

%5'%,6 056) +0 /)*.$88$1,7@>

$O>>

8/11/2019 Ucd Tla 0040

14/18

NX

6$76*2/0

%1< 7A 580C60BGG6/*951+/*%8$$96+G/*+6),7@p%*0$5%6*0G/,20G%5'%,6q"M.$%q"M6$76*2/q"M-+209)/-8

8/11/2019 Ucd Tla 0040

15/18

N_

?%$456/0(),0 /+'8* 2%$3,4*0 + '%,*. 6$88*6/,$7 $. /)* -$0/ 6$--$78= 50*4 2%$@%+-0 .$% 6%*+/,7@ 6$76*2/-+20; /)*%* +%* 4,3,4*4 '= /)$0* /)+/ $7* -,@)/ $2/ /$ 25%6)+0* +74 /)$0* /)+/ %* .%** /$ 50*9

)7@C3;9 +87?83@ +436A78@ LGG1119,-,74-+296$-

CUV?CQB(CIU C702,%+/,$7 ?D; E+6 )//2>GG1119,702,%+/,$796$-

VEBQ( (*6)7$8$@,*0 VEBQ( C4*+0 ?D; E+6 )//2>GG0-+%//*6)96$-

E,74 (*6)7$8$@,*0 \,05+8 E,74 ?D )//2>GG11193,05+8c-,7496$-

CWED D-+2($$80 ?D; E+6 )//2>GG6-+29,)-6950

D$76*2/L%+1 ECULEB? ?D; E+6 )//2>GG11196$76*2/4%+196$-

D$D$ V=0/*-0 A/49 \,0,E+2 ?D )//2>GG11193,0,-+296$-

E,74 Z*7,50 E,74Z*7,50 ?D )//2>GG1119-,74@*7,5096$-G

C4*+0$7D+73+0 E,747$4* E+6 )//2>GG1119-,747$4*96$-G

(8GG1119@8,..=96$-G

r-,74 r-,74 ?D )//2>GG1119:-,7497*/G

(OT(V \OS ?D; E+6 )//2>GG35*9/5./09*45G+'$5/G

D$-2*74,5- C70/,/5/* D$-2*74,5- ?D; E+6 )//2>GG6$-2*74,5-9$2*79+695&G,70/,/5/*G

8/11/2019 Ucd Tla 0040

16/18

NY

V*8*6/ R,'8,$@%+2)=HOQA0 +66*00*4 MP9N"J

- 74*%0$7 */ +8 H"MMNJ B (+:$7$-= .$% A*+%7,7@; (*+6),7@ +74 B00*00,7@> B Q*3,0,$7 $. R8$$-a0(+:$7$-= $. S456+/,$7+8 I'g*6/,3*09 A$7@-+7; A$74$7

B/)*%/$7 K9V9; "MM"9C%*-#8#> *#< B%*$38#>@ C%*-#8#> D#GG11190/+..94-59+695&Gsg+-*0+G8*+%7,7@

B505'*8; L9 ? HN^YPJ B3% F+G$3"9">G ", )%*#8#>,29 H%-6*9 C%*-#8#> HU*1 F$%&> Z%57* +74 V/%+//$79

H,@@0; K9 HN^[kJI'2 ?85-*J9

R%$17 Z9; R588 K9; ?*748*'5%= E HN^^kJ B00*00,7@ V/54*7/ A*+%7,7@ ,7 W,@)*% S456+/,$79 A$74$7>Q$5/8*4@*9

) +77$7 Q9; U*1'8* L9 H "MM"J B W+74'$$& .$% (*+6)*%0 ,7 O7,3*%0,/,*0 +74 D$88*@*0> B Z5,4* /$C-2%$3,7@ (*+6),7@ E*/)$409 A$74$7> D#'%-#*'8"#*9 ; X_ HXJ; Pk_cP[k9

D$88,0; R +74 E$$7*7; K "MMN9 T8*:,'8* A*+%7,7@ ,7 + L,@,/+8 #$%84> *:2*%,*76*0 +74 *:2*6/+/,$709 * C%$'2-%@ 1-"/ F-%+%#'8#> '" B%*$38#>Q$5/8*4@*9

( *84*% Q9E9 +74 V,83*%-+7 A9

8/11/2019 Ucd Tla 0040

17/18

Nk

Z$08,7@ L; E$$7 K H"MMNJ W$1 /$ 50* 8*+%7,7@ $5/6$-*0 +74 +00*00-*7/ 6%,/*%,+9 A$74$7> VSSD9

Z%,..,/)0 V9; ?+%/,7@/$7 ? HN^^"J S7+'8,7@ B6/,3* A*+%7,7@ ,7 V-+88 Z%$5209 V)*..,*84>D\D? O7,3*%0,/,*0b V/+.. L*3*8$2-*7/ +74 (%+,7,7@ O7,/9Z%$78574; U9 S9; +74 A,77; Q9)%*+2-%/%#' *#< J7*92*'8"# 8# B%*$38#>0 HY/) *49J U*1 F$%&> E+6-,88+7;N^^M9# $7*=; ?9 e E5-.$%4; B9 HN^["J E+75+8 $. A*+%7,7@ V/=8*0 A$74$7> ?9 W$7*=

E6D85%*;K9Q9; V$7+&;R9; V5*7; W9Q*8,+',8,/=;\+8,4,/=; +74 A$@,0/,6+8 ?%+6/,6+8,/= 9 ="2-#*9 K, R%+%*-$3 D# I$8%#$% B%*$38#>\$89 PY; UI9 X; ??9 Xk_mX^"9

, +%/$7 T; W$570*88 L +74 S7/1,0/8* U H*409J HN^^kJ ()* S:2*%,*76* $. A*+%7,7@ H"74 *4,/,$7J S4,7'5%@)>V6$//,0) B6+4*-,6 ?%*00

E+%0)+88; A +74 Q$18+74; T HN^^[J B Z5,4* /$ 8*+%7,7@ ,74*2*74*7/8= I2*7 O7,3*%0,/= ?%*00;

R56&,7@)+-9

* $3+&; K9L9 e D+w+0; B9K9B3% B3%"-G Q# !"#$%&' )*&+ *#< M"4 '" !"#+'-2$' *#< Q+% B3%/ 9 T8$%,4+C70/,/5/* .$% W5-+7 +74 E+6),7* D$@7,/,$7; ?*70+6$8+; TA9 (*6)7,6+8 Q*2$%/ CWED D-+2($$809 B3+,8+'8*>)//2>GG6-+29,)-6950G?5'8,6+/,$70GQ*0*+%6)?+2*%0G ()*$%=O74*%8=,7@D$76*2/E+20924. 'Y* *,88; Z9; W57/8*=cE$$%*; V9; Q+6*; ?9 S40 9H"MMkJ D+0* V/54,*0 $. Z$$4 ?%+6/,6*0 ,7 B00*00-*7/ $.V/54*7/ A*+%7,7@ ,7 W,@)*% S456+/,$79 L5'8,7> BCVWS9+*/%,88,; E9K9 "MM^9 vA,7&= A$3*; V7+%& B//+6&0; +74 T,*%6* L*'+/*0 +'$5/ (*+6)*% t5+8,/=d vB 2**& ,70,4*/)* *456+/,$7 '8$@$02)*%*;v S456+/,$7 U*:/ ^HNJ; #,7/*%)//2>GG1119)$$3*%9$%@G25'8,6+/,$70G*47*:/GPXY[k[YX9)/-8

. +6*; ?9; H"MMNJ ()* A*6/5%*%b0 ($$8&,/> B ?%+6/,6+8 Z5,4* /$ A*+%7,7@; (*+6),7@ +74B00*00-*7/9 A$74$7> !"#$%&' )*&+ *+ *# .++%++/%#' B""9 9 ?%$69 $. /)* T,%0/ C7/9 D$7.*%*76*$7 D$76*2/ E+22,7@; ?+-28$7+; V2+,79 B3+,8+'8*> )//2>GG6-69,)-6950G2+2*%0G6-6"MMXcMPY924.

#+8&*% +74 D$%4%+= H"MNMJ!"#$%&' )*&&8#> *+ * 1"-/ ", I'2

8/11/2019 Ucd Tla 0040

18/18

N[

U$/*0>

S74 $. #$%&'$$&