Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito...

26
Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Transcript of Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito...

Page 1: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY

S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito

J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Page 2: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Majorana   fermion

fermion + gravity

Motivations

Boulatov &Kazakov

Page 3: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Fractal Structure of 2D Quantum Gravity

N.K. & Yotsuji

N.K. & Watabiki

Q state Potts model on random surface

(c: central charge matter )

Page 4: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

success of lattice QCD

success of 2-dim. lattice quantum gravity

gauge theory + matter fermion + gravity on random lattice

Page 5: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Lattice FermionsFree Dirac

Naïve Staggered

Kogut-Susskind

Dirac-Kaehler

(N.K. & J.Smit)

(N.K. & I.Kanamori)

(Kluberg-Stern et.al.& Gliozzi)

y 2x

Ivanenko&Landau ‘28

i : flavour ?

Staggered phase

Page 6: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Dirac Kaehler Fermion

Page 7: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

staggered phase

species doublers

Puzzle 1

Is the staggered phase or species doublers or the “flavour” degrees of freedom physical ?

dual

Dirac-Kaehler fermion

Page 8: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Quantization and Twisted SUSY

(Two dimensional Abelian BF)

Nilpotency of BRS   charge s

Auxiliary fieldOff-shell invariance

Kato,N.K.&Uchida

Continuum

N=D=2 Twisted SUSY

Tsukioka, N.K., Kato, Miyake, Uchida

Page 9: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

9

N=2 SUSY in two dimensions

Dirac-Kaehler Twist (N=2)

Cont:

Latt:

Gauged Latt:

Twisted N=2 SUSY

Page 10: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Compatibility of Shifts

We need a modified Leibniz rule for too !

Page 11: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Symm. Choice

Asymm. Choice

Twisted N=D=2 Lattice SUSY Algebra

Cond. for Twisted N=D=2

Solutions

Equivalent to orbifold construction: by Kaplan et.al.

Page 12: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

N=D=2 SUSY

Dirac-Kaehler Twist

Dirac-Kaehler fermion

i : flavour ? Extended SUSY suffix

y 2x

2-dim. N=2 3-dim. N=44-dim. N=4

#boson = #fermion

super charges in d-dim.

Dirac-Kaehler twisting

Answer to the Puzzle 1

Page 13: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Jacobi Identities

Define fermionic link components

Auxiliary Field

Page 14: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Twisted N=2 Super Yang-Mills Action

Action has twisted SUSY exact form. Off-shell SUSY invariancefor all twisted super charges.

Page 15: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Bosonic part of the Action

Page 16: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Fermionic part of the Action

(1)

(2)

(1) (2)

Page 17: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Higer dimensional extension is possible:

3-dim. N=4 super Yang-Mills

Page 18: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

“inconsistency”When

BruckmannKok

but if we introduce the following “mild non-commutativity”:

then

In general

Two Problems

Page 19: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Modified Leibniz rule +Mild non-commutativity

Hopf algebraicField Theory

Concrete representation of this non-commutativity

Lattice version of Moyal product

Orbifold condition

Page 20: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

A possible solution

We claim: if there is covariantly constant super parameter which has opposite shift of and commutes with all the super covariant derivatives:

compensates the link holes.

lattice SUSY and gauge invariant !

operation makes link holes and thus loses gauge invariance.

gets coordinate dependence super gravity

Page 21: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Gauge Theory on the Random Lattice

・・

・・ ・

Form Simplex

1 3 0 2

Gauge Theory + Gravity ?

SUSY ?

Boson     Fermion ?

Page 22: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Generalized Gauge Theories in arbitrary dimensions

gauge field

gauge parameter

derivative

curvature

gauge trans.

Chern-Simons

Topological Yang-Mills

Yang-Mills

N.K. & Watabiki  ‘91

Page 23: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Puzzle 2

What is the role of “quaternion” in generalized gauge theory ?

Page 24: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Single lattice translation as SUSY transformation

Super parameter

SUSY algebra

Page 25: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Matrix Representation

are diagonal.

Two step translation as SUSY transformation

Page 26: Two Fundamental Puzzles And Lattice SUSY S.Arianos, A.D’Adda, A.Feo, I.Kanamori, K.Nagata, J.Saito J.Kato, A.Miyake, T.Tsukioka, Y.Uchida,

Partial answer to Puzzle 2

Quaternion may be fundamentally related to the lattice SUSY transformation. Chirality may play an important role in the transformation.

Differential form structure for Dirac-Kaeher mechanism should be essentially introduced to accommodate super gravity nature.