tVPN White Paper Virtual Items & Public Policy 2011 V1

8/7/2019 tVPN White Paper Virtual Items & Public Policy 2011 V1

1/11

!!!!!

!!!!!!!

"#$%&'(!)%*+,-!"#$%&'(!.&$$*/01!'/2!3&4(#0!35(#01!!

!!

!

!!!!!!!6!78#%*!3'9*$!41!%8*!"#$%&'(!35(#01!:*%;5$

!%8*!"#$%&'(!35(#01!:*%;5$??!

!!!!

"#$%&'(!)%*+,!'/2!3&4(#0!35(#01!

!%8*!"#$%&'(!35(#01!:*%;5$

! U#,*!#/!F#$%&'(!#%*+!$*('%*2!0$#+*-!*J@J!%8*A%!! K,*!5A!F#$%&'(!0&$$*/0#*,!',!'/!'(%*$/'%#F*!%5!8'$2!0&$$*/0#*,!

!6!05+9(#0'%#/@!A'0%5$!;#%8!F#$%&'(!#%*+,!#,!%8'%!%8*#$!(*@'(!,%'%&,!#,!5A%*/!F'@&*-!05/%*/2*2!Q4*%;**/!9&4(#,8*$-!&,*$-!'/2!,%'%*R-!'/2!F'$#*,!A$5+!P&$#,2#0%#5/!%5!P&$#,2#0%#5/J!O8*!95(#01!$*,95/,*,!%5!#+9(#0'%#5/,!5A!F#$%&'(!#%*+,!#,!F'$#*2!'/2!#/0(&2*,!'((!5A!%8*!A5((5;#/@T!!!

! O$*'%!',!+*$*!05/%*/%!'/2!#@/5$*!5%8*$!#,,&*,!!! 699(1!*E#,%#/@!(';,!!

o V#%8*$!%5!$*('%*2!'0%,!,&08!',!8'0


2/11


3/11

"#$%&'(!)%*+,!'/2!3&4(#0!35(#01!

!%8*!"#$%&'(!35(#01!:*%;5$

5&%!5A!%8*!%$'2#%#5/'(!+'$

! )%*+,!`*'$/*2I!%8$5&@8!9('1\!!! )%*+,!9&$08',*2\!! .&$$*/01\!'/2!! 6005&/%,J!!

!

)1

![5;*F*$-!F#$%&'(!;5$(2!9&4(#,8*$,!%*/2!%5!8'F*!'!2#AA*$*/%!(*@'(!F#*;!5A!%8*!,#%&'%#5/J!O8#,!2#,,5/'/0*!@#F*,!$#,*!%5!'!/&+4*$!5A!#,,&*,!;8#08!;*!;#((!*E9(5$*!4*(5;J!!!

)1= "5>9(.?(6@9(45&6#%7(869$(A%&,96((O8*$*!'$*!/5!*E'0%!A#@&$*,!A5$!%8*!,#H*!5A!%8*!F#$%&'(!#%*+,!+'$R-!$#,#/@!%5!KLM?Z4/!41!=>?=J!O8#,!*,%#+'%*!9&%,!%8*!'F*$'@*!$*F*/&*!9*$!0&,%5+*$!'%!'45&%!KLMNJ!e%8*$!,5&$0*,!9&%!%8*!=>>]!F#$%&'(!#%*+,!$*F*/&*,!A5$!%8*!6,#'/!+'$>]!KLM^N+!$*9$*,*/%#/@!P&,%!5F*$!?>j!5A!'//&'(!$*F*/&*!0'+*!A$5+!F#$%&'(!#%*+,J!!78#(,%!+'/1!`+#0$5G%$'/,'0%#5/,I!+'1!4*!&/2*$!KLM?-!'22#/@!&9!%5!'$5&/2!KLMN!

9*$!&,*$-!%8*$*!'$*!*E0*9%#5/,!;8*$*!,#/@(*!#%*+,!0'/!05,%!,#@/#A#0'/%!'+5&/%,J!d(#HH'$2!$*0*/%(1!0$*'%*2!'!75$(2!5A!7'$0$'A%!#%*+!9$#0*2!'%!KLM=NJ!6!75$(2!5A!7'$0$'A%!'005&/%!8',!$*95$%*2(1!08'/@*2!8'/2,!A5$!k^->>>\!,5+*!@'+*,-!9'$%#0&('$(1!#/!%8*!U&,,#'/!+'$X>SX>=XA'0*455


4/11

"#$%&'(!)%*+,!'/2!3&4(#0!35(#01!

!%8*!"#$%&'(!35(#01!:*%;5$

)1B1>!'/2!#/F5(F*2!9'$%#0#9'/%,!A$5+!5F*$!S>!05&/%$#*,J!!!!

!!!

"#$%&'(!)%*+,!'/2!3&4(#0!35(#01!

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


5/11

"#$%&'(!)%*+,!'/2!3&4(#0!35(#01!

!%8*!"#$%&'(!35(#01!:*%;5$

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

"#$%&'(!)%*+,!'/2!3&4(#0!35(#01!

!%8*!"#$%&'(!35(#01!:*%;5$

!L5+*!,*$F#0*!9$5F#2*$,!+'#/%'#/!'!8'(A;'1!95,#%#5/J!)/!%8*,*!0',*,!9$5F#2*$,!@$'/%!%8'%!&,*$,!8'F*!$#@8%,!%5!F#$%&'(!#%*+,!%8'%!#/0(&2*!%8*!$#@8%!%5!`,*((I!%85,*!

#%*+,J!78'%!#,!@5#/@!5/!&/2*$!%8*!(*@'(!05F*$,!#,!%8'%!%8*!F'$#5&,!%*$+,!'/2!05/2#%#5/,!,%'%*!%8'%!%8*!&,*$,!'$*!+*$*(1!,*((#/@!(#+#%*2!(#0*/,*,!%5!&,*!%8*!F#$%&'(!#%*+,!_!%8*!(#0*/,*,-!5A!05&$,*-!0'/!4*!;#%82$';/!'%!'/1!%#+*-!8'F*!/5!#/%$#/,#0!F'(&*-!'/2!05/A*$!/5!5;/*$,8#9!5A!%8*!&/2*$(1#/@!9$59*$%1!$#@8%,J!)/!%8#,!;'1!9$5F#2*$,!0'/!'((5;!;8'%!(55>S!d*#P#/@t,!.8'51'/@!W#,%$#0%!3*59(*t,!.5&$%!$&(*2!%8'%!H%2),2!I2$!8'2!%5!$*,%5$*!%8*!#%*+,!',!%8*1!;*$*!(#'4(*!A5$!%8*!(5,,!2&*!%5!;*'


6/11

"#$%&'(!)%*+,!'/2!3&4(#0!35(#01!

!%8*!"#$%&'(!35(#01!:*%;5$

%*$+,J!)/!$*'(#%1!9$5F#2*$,!%*/2!%5!(*@'((1!+#E!,5+*!5A!%8*,*!0'%*@5$#*,J!78'%I,!+5$*-!#/!,5+*!P&$#,2#0%#5/,!%8*!(';!#,!/5%!0(*'$!5$!05/,#,%*/%!;8*/!'99(#*2!%5!F#$%&'(!#%*+,J!78'%!#,!05++5/!#,!%8'%!F#$%&'(!#%*+,!%*/2!%5!4*!2*A#/*2!#/!%8*!O*$+,!5A!L*$F#0*!5$!V/2!K,*$!c#0*/0*!6@$**+*/%J!O8*1!'$*!2*A#/*2!',!4*#/@!9'$%!5A!%8*!@'+*!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Z!!ps6T!LeV-!c#F*!o'+*$!U*F*'(!tc#F*!o'+*$!VE08'/@*t!L*$F#0*!8%%9TXX;;;J@'+',&%$'J05+X989G4#/X/*;,u#/2*EJ989l,%5$1m?^=fi!Q'00*,,*2!=N!L*9%*+4*$!=>?>!R!N!8%%9TXX;;;J'+'H5/J05+X%'@X>N!L5/1!('&/08*2!`L5/1!L%'%#5/!VE08'/@*I!;8#08!*/'4(*2!9('1*$,!5/!%8*#$!"#$%&'$()!II!@'+*!5/!`L%'%#5/!VE08'/@*I!,*$F*$,!%5!4&1!'/2!,*((!F#$%&'(!#%*+,!'/2!'005&/%,J!O8#,!,*$F#0*!+'2*!5AA#0#'(!'!!9$'0%#0*!%8'%!8'2!4**/!500&$$#/@!5/!@$*1G+'$>i!',!9'$%!5A!'!2*'(!;#%8!c#F*!o'+*$!VE08'/@*-!'/!#/2*9*/2*/%!5/(#/*!F#$%&'(!#%*+!+'$

$#@8%,!5A!#/2#F#2&'(,!%5!%8*!#/G;5$(2!0&$$*/01!c#/2*/!W5(('$,-!(*@'((1!c#/2*/!+'#/%'#/,!%8*!,%'/2'$2!(*@'(!95,#%#5/!%8'%!%8*#$!`0&$$*/01I!#,!+*$*(1!'!(#+#%*2!(#0*/0*!#/!,5A%;'$*!'/2!8',!/5!F'(&*!#/!'/2!5A!#%,*(AJ!78'%I,!+5$*-!;8#(*!+'#/%'#/#/@!'!4$5'2(1!05++5/!0'$$#*$!'99$5'08!%5!05/%*/%-!c#/2*/!'0%#F*(1!9$*F*/%,!&,*$,!A$5+!*/@'@#/@!#/!@'+4(#/@!'/2!,5G0'((*2!4'/

&/A'#$!+*'/,!%5!9&$08',*!%8*!('/2!'%!%8*!9$#0*!%8'%!8*!2#2!4(50


7/11

"#$%&'(!)%*+,!'/2!3&4(#0!35(#01!

!%8*!"#$%&'(!35(#01!:*%;5$

! V$$5$\!!! 6005&/%!0(5,&$*!2&*!%5!4$*'08!5A!05/%$'0%\!! B$'&2&(*/%!59*$'%5$\!! C*$0&$#'(!'0%!41!9$5F#2*$\!5$!! 3$5F#2*$!@5#/@!5&%!5A!4&,#/*,,J!

!)/!'22#%#5/-!%8#$2G9'$%1!'0%,!%8'%!'$*!,5+*%#+*,!',,50#'%*2!;#%8!#%*+!(5,,!'$*T!!

! c5,,!5A!8'$2!0&$$*/01-!*J@J!%8$5&@8!0$*2#%!0'$2!A$'&2!5$!3'13'(!08'$@*!4'0

! V$$5$!!! 6005&/%!0(5,&$*!2&*!%5!4$*'08!5A!05/%$'0%!! C*$0&$#'(!'0%!41!9$5F#2*$!! 3$5F#2*$!@5#/@!5&%!5A!4&,#/*,,!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!f!8%%9TXX;*4;*$*(2J/(X/#*&;,XNS=SZXF#$%&*(*G2#*A,%'(GF55$%''/G,%$'A4''$J8%+(!

!(&%-'B/1$*(;'C$%D&'E"FF%1,'')/f!=>>^!#/!O8*!:*%8*$('/2,!'!?S!1*'$G5(2!9('1*$!5A!%8*!5/(#/*!@'+*!G'0$R2.=$!QS.


8/11

"#$%&'(!)%*+,!'/2!3&4(#0!35(#01!

!%8*!"#$%&'(!35(#01!:*%;5$

O8#,!$*'08!5A!5;/*$,8#9!8',!95%*/%#'(!#+9'0%,!5/!$#@8%,!,&08!',!,9**08J!)%!'(,5!

8',!#+9'0%,!5/!45%8!9*$,5/'(!'/2!9&4(#0!'$08#F#/@!5A!F#$%&'(!,9'0*,J!!


9/11

"#$%&'(!)%*+,!'/2!3&4(#0!35(#01!

!%8*!"#$%&'(!35(#01!:*%;5$

['445![5%*(-!'/2!%8*!.5/,&+*$!e+4&2,+'/-!,*%%#/@!'!,9*/2#/@!0'9!5A!k^!9*$!;**

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!^!8%%9TXX*/@(#,8J+5A05+J@5FJ0/X''$%#0(*X/*;,$*(*',*X05++5//*;,X=>>]>fX=>>]>f>fSfZ=>iJ8%+(!i!.8#/'!o5F*$/+*/%!d'/,!e/(#/*!"#$%&'(G.&$$*/01!W*'(#/@!3('%A5$+,!A5$!C#/5$,!8%%9TXX;;;J4(55+4*$@J05+X/*;,X=>?>G>fG==X%*/0*/%G,8'$*,GA'((G'A%*$G08#/'G'//5&/0*,GF#$%&'(G0&$$*/01G4'/GA5$G+#/5$,J8%+(!!

"#$%&'(!)%*+,!'/2!3&4(#0!35(#01!

!%8*!"#$%&'(!35(#01!:*%;5$

'$*!'99(#0'4(*!%5!%8*+!#/!'%!(*',%!,5+*!0',*,J!!!O8*!(';,!%8'%!8'F*!4**/!A5&/2!%5!'99(1!,5!A'$!'$*T!!

! "5(&/%'$1!0'9!5/!9&$08',*!5A!F#$%&'(!#%*+,!5A!k^!9*$!;**>^!'/2!%8*/!A&$%8*$!0('$#A#*2!41!%8*!L&9$*+*!.5&$%!5A!b5$*'!%8$5&@8!'!0',*!#/!=>>]J!d$*'08!5A!%8*!'0%!0'$$#*,!'!95%*/%#'(!A#/*!QN>!+#((#5/!;5/!X!kS=->>>R!5$!'!9$#,5/!%*+!&9!5A!%5!A#F*!1*'$,J!!!O8*!0&$$*/%!,#%&'%#5/!#,T!!

! .&$$*/01!*E08'/@*,!'$*!#((*@'(\!! )%!#,!(*@'(!A5$!#/2#F#2&'(,!%5!,*((!F#$%&'(!#%*+,!A$5+!@'+*,!5A!,>^!'+*/2+*/%!%5!%8*!o'+*!)/2&,%$1!3$5+5%#5/!'0%!+'2*!#%!#((*@'(!%5!4&1!'/2!,*((!`9'1!+5/*1I!A5$!4&,#/*,,!9&$95,*,-!#J*J!59*$'%*!'!F#$%&'(!0&$$*/01!*E08'/@*J!O8#,!'+*/2+*/%!(*A%!5$2#/'$1!&,*$,!%5!A$**!%5!4&1!'/2!,*((!#%*+,J!!!


10/11

"#$%&'(!)%*+,!'/2!3&4(#0!35(#01!

!%8*!"#$%&'(!35(#01!:*%;5$>^!'+*/2+*/%!%5!%8*!o'+*!)/2&,%$1!3$5+5%#5/!'0%!'(,5!2*A#/*2!%8*!

/5%#5/!5A!`'4/5$+'(I!9('1-!'/2!%8&,!41!#+9(#0'%#5/!2*A#/*2!'!,*/,*!5A!`A'#$!9('1IJ!64/5$+'(!9('1!$&(*2!5&%!'0%#5/,!,&08!',!*E9(5#%,!Q*$$5$,!#/!@'+*!052*!%8'%!'((5;!'!9('1*$!%5!@'#/!&/A'#$!'2F'/%'@*R!'/2!45%,!Q8'F#/@!'!05+9&%*$!9('1!'!08'$'0%*$!#/!9('0*!5A!'!8&+'/!9('1*$RJ!!

!3.3.3.1 Taxation (VAT)e/!h&(1!?!=>>^!b5$*'!#/%$52&0*2!'!$&(#/@!%8'%!'99(#*2!"'(&*!622*2!O'E!%5!,'(*,!5A!F#$%&'(!#%*+,!A5$!8'$2!0&$$*/01J!6!$'%*!5A!?>j!#,!'99(#*2!%5!#/2#F#2&'(,!;85!*'$/!4*%;**/!f!G!?=!+#((#5/!;5/!QMf->>>!G!!M?S->>>R!#/!,#E!+5/%8,J!O85,*!;85!*'$/!'45F*!%8#,!'+5&/%!+&,%!'99(1!A5$!'!4&,#/*,,!(#0*/,*J!!

=1B [@9(O96@9&7%/0:(!

=1B1) [@9?6((O8*!:*%8*$('/2,!8',!/5!,9*0#A#0!(';,!A5$!F#$%&'(!#%*+,\!85;*F*$!#/!'%!(*',%!5/*!

0',*!%8#,!$*,&(%*2!#/!'!P&2@+*/%!;8#08!A5&/2!%8'%!%8*!%8*A%!5A!F#$%&'(!#%*+,!%8$5&@8!%8$*'%,!5A!A5$0*!05&/%*2!',!$544*$1J!O8*!'99(#0'4(*!(';!#/!%8#,!0',*!;',T!!

! W&%08!.$#+#/'(!.52*!Q6$%#0(*!S?=R!!

=1S Q/5690("6%69:(.?(J$9&5+%(O8*$*!8'F*!4**/!/5!8#@8!9$5A#(*!05&$%!0',*,!5A!F#$%&'(!0$#+*,!5A!%8*!%19*!,**/!#/!5%8*$!05&/%$#*,J!O8*!%;5!+'#/!0',*,!%8'%!8'F*!4**/!4$5&@8%!8'F*!45%8!#/F5(F*2!

)*61%D%'!"*1$'"2':"1%(')/!h'/&'$1!=>?>!%8*!L&9$*+*!.5&$%!5A!L5&%8!b5$*'!'0a%%*2!%;5!9('1*$,!5A!%8*!CCe!c#/*'@*!5A!,#@/#A#0'/%!A#/*,!#+95,*2!41!(5;*$!05&$%,J!b#+!'/2!c**!9('1*2!VW(34)I,!X,0$.>]!%8*!2*0#,#5/!;',!5F*$%&$/*2-!;#%8!%8#,!'99*'(!2*0#,#5/!4*#/@!&98*(2!41!%8*!L&9$*+*!.5&$%J!!O8*!A50&,!5A!%8*!2*4'%*!4*%;**/!%8*!(5;*$!'/2!'99*'(!05&$%,!;',!;8*%8*$!X,0$.

F#$%&'(!;5$(2,-!#/!9'$%#0&('$!%8'%!%$'2*+'$

=1S1


11/11

"#$%&'(!)%*+,!'/2!3&4(#0!35(#01!

!%8*!"#$%&'(!35(#01!:*%;5$>^!'!`4'/!+#((#5/!c#/2*/!25(('$,!G!%8*!*aF'(*/%!5A!'99$5E#+'%*(1!k^N>->>>J!)/!=>>i-!9'$%(1!#/!$*,95/,*!%5!%8#,-!c#/2*/!c'4!4'//*2!L*05/2!c#A*!`4'/

tVPN White Paper Virtual Items & Public Policy 2011 V1

Documents

Transcript of tVPN White Paper Virtual Items & Public Policy 2011 V1