Translation of Genetic Technologies into the Clinical ... · Comprehensive Assessment of DMET Phase...
Transcript of Translation of Genetic Technologies into the Clinical ... · Comprehensive Assessment of DMET Phase...
Translation of Genetic
Technologies into the Clinical
Space: DMET
Rick Hockett, MD
Chief Medical Officer
2Affymetrix Confidential
One size fits all
Goal: Improve individual patient outcomes and health outcome predictability through tailoring diagnosis, prognosis, treatment, and relevant information
assess spectrum of patient response to therapy; stratify patient populations; optimize benefit/risk.
“Providing meaningful improved health outcomes for patients by delivering the right diagnosis, right prognosis, or the right
drug at the right dose at the right time.”
Tailoring (e.g. oncology products
comprising drug and companion diagnostic)
Targeted Therapy
Tailoring is Broader Than Pharmacogenomics
Measure something in a patient to learn how to treat them better
Why Are Biomarkers So Important?
3Affymetrix Confidential
Pinpoint the ‘right’ biomarker
DNA----ACGTGGGCAGTAGACTCAT----
----TGCACCCGTCATCTGAGTA----
Protein----Thr Trp Ala Val Asp Ser ----
RNA----ACGUGGGCAGUAGACUCAU----
Large Scale ‘Fishing’
Whole Genome Scan
Medium Scale ‘Confirmation’Many Different
Groups
Small Scale ‘Validated’
Clinical TrialSupport
Large Scale Fishing
DNA – 100K to 2x106 SNPs
Chip Based
Electrophoresis
RNA – 30K+
Chip Based -oligos
Slide Based - cDNAs
Protein – 1K upward
Mass Spec
Med. Scale Confirm.
DNA –2K to 30K
Chip Based
Electrophoresis
PCR Based
RNA – 30 to 1K
Chip Based -oligos
Slide Based – cDNAs
RT-PCR Based
Protein – 50 to 500
Mass Spec
Luminex Type
Small Scale Valid.
DNA – 1 to 25
PCR Based
Electrophoresis
RNA – 1 to 25
RT-PCR Based
Protein – 1 to 30
ImmunoAssay
Clinically Utilized
PGx Tests
Shrinking Clinical PGx Funnel
Hercept Test
Ph Chromosome
VariationY
Resp
on
se
N
Y
N
VariationY
Resp
on
se
N
YNvs.
≥ 3
Predictive
Situation SpecificOnc vs. Neuroscience
c-kit
TPMTHLA
Disease vs.
ResponseInteresting Genetic Associations
Prospective
Clinical Proof
Genetic Polymorph
With Rel. Risk
Genetic
Variant
Freq
Genetic Polymorph
With Good
Sens. & Spec
Apo E, CETP
5 - LO
Variants in
Growth Genes
DMET
Needs Examples
OncotypeDxUGT1A1
EGFr
CYP2C9/VKORC1Tissue of Origin CYP2C19
k-RAS
5Affymetrix Confidential
Hurdles to applying -omics to medicine
Strategic Gearing the infrastructure
Technologic Information overload
Lack of biologic understanding
Platform challenges
Regulatory Understand how to apply technology
Implementation Clinician education, understanding, and acceptance
X
??
6Affymetrix Confidential
We Need to Develop Good Clinical Tools
Not all tools can be readily moved to the clinical
arena
Many technologies generate more data than
is clinically relevant
7Affymetrix Confidential
Discovery Experiments
• Hypothesis Generation
• Variant Identification
• Scientific Validation
Clinical Research
• Hypothesis Testing
• Study Design
• Clinical Validation
• Patient Selection
Clinical Diagnostic
• Patient Selection
• Drug Selection
• Dose Modification
• Prognosis
Changing Arenas of Importance
Biologic Relevance
Determined
Clinical Relevance
Determined
Regulatory Scrutiny
DMET PlusDrug
Metabolism
Enzymes &
Transporters
A Comprehensive Tool for Assessing
Drug Bioavailability
9Affymetrix Confidential
Rationale for pursuing DMET
Result of Early Phase strategy
Drug Activity Biomarkers Genetic Polymorphisms Predicting Drug Metabolism
DNA Variations Predicting Drug Response
DNA Variations Predicting Adverse Events
Main objectives of this strategy were to set out a plan to collect samples to enable genetic studies and to generate more information on metabolism
Benefits of a better understanding of the genetics behind metabolism :
Better ability to understand PK outliers in early phase trials
Build a database for selective recruitment of healthy volunteers with a defined genotype
Work with the FDA in an attempt to decrease the number of biopharm (DDI) trials needed for future NDAs
10Affymetrix Confidential
Comprehensive Assessment of DMET
Phase I Metabolism
Drug Phase I Metabolite Phase II Metabolite
Oxidation
Reduction
Hydrolysis
Conjugation with:Glucuronic acid Amino acids
Glutathione Sulfuric acid
Acetic acid
Cytochrome P450 Genes
CYP2D6 CYP2A6
CYP2C8/9 CYP2C19
CYP1A2 CYP3A4/5
CYP2E1
N-acetyl transferases
Glutathione-S transferases
Methyl transferases
Phase II Metabolism
Two Sets of Genes:
Validated set – known clinical correlation
~40 Genes – ~300 Variants
Additional genes – suspected clinical utility
~200 Genes – ~1,600 Variants
Transporter Genes
11Affymetrix Confidential
DME/T PLUS - Benefits
Fully validated system for core set
FDA accepts use in support of clinical trials
Analyze 99.9% of known functional variants
CYP enzymes
Non-CYP enzymes
Transporters
Common platform for all genes
Ability to be flexible and react to additional data
Add new variants and/or genes to list
Move variants on and off ‘must have’ list
12Affymetrix Confidential
DMET: the ‘right’ biomarker
Large Scale ‘Fishing’
Whole Genome Scan
Medium Scale ‘Confirmation’Many Different
Groups
Small Scale ‘Validated’
Clinical TrialSupport
Large Scale Fishing
DNA – 100K to 2x106 SNPs
RNA – 30K+
Med. Scale Confirm.
DNA –2K to 30K
DMET Plus
RNA – 30 to 1K
Small Scale Clinical Res.
DNA – 1 to 25
DMET Plus
RNA – 1 to 25
DMET Plus has only causative variants
Once causative variants are
known, ethnicity becomes
irrelevant.
DMET PlusDrug
Metabolism
Enzymes &
Transporters
Clinical relevance of a purpose-built
comprehensive targeted panel
14Affymetrix Confidential
S
N
Cl
O OCH3
S
N
Cl
O OCH3
O
HS
N
Cl
O OCH3
HOOC
Clopidogrel
CYP2C19
CYP1A2
CYP2B6
Esterases
~85%
Inactive
Metabolites
S
N
F
O
O
O
S
N
F
O
O
HS
N
F
O
HOOC
Esterases
Prasugrel
CYP3A4/5
CYP2C19
CYP2C9
CYP2B6
CYP3A4/5
CYP2B6
CYP2C19
CYP2C9
15Affymetrix Confidential
No Relationship between Genetics and PK/PD for Prasugrel, Significant Effect for Clopidogrel
Pharmacokinetics
Integrated Genetic Analyses in Healthy Subjects
Pharmacodynamics
16Affymetrix Confidential
CYP2C19 Null Variant Frequency
Those patients who have at least one copy of a
reduced-function variant of CYP2C19
Caucasians - 25 – 30%
Africans - 40%
Asians - 60%
17Affymetrix Confidential
Research Applications
Pre-clinical Research
Enzyme activity analysis for in vitro toxicology studies
Early Clinical Research
Enzyme activity analysis for ADME work
Early Understanding of PK outliers
Broad Based Clinical Research
Comprehensive metabolic profiles for long term clinical programs
(PGENI or PharmGKB)
Study Benefit/Risk Ratio
Building a Database of Known Genotypes
Support industry sponsored trials
Apply DMET for primary discovery of new metabolic associations and to validate involvement of metabolic pathways in current medicines.
Regulatory ChallengesHow to get a complex device
designation on a molecular device
19Affymetrix Confidential
Research Use
Only
Typical Technology Development Path - US
Laboratory
Derived Test
In vitro
Diagnostic
Regulations for LDTs Enforced by CLIA Guidelines for Labs Expert Groups
Involved Manufacturers
Cannot Promote
Regulations for IVDs Enforced by FDA Guidelines for
Manufacturers Safety is Paramount Label drives Marketing
20Affymetrix Confidential
FDA: The process and challenges
Complexity must be decided
Drives regulatory path
Class II – 510(k)
Class III – PMA
Number of Analytes Available is Increasing
IVDMIA
Intended Use Must be Stated
Can drive class designation
Sets clinical strategy
Will drive labeling of device
Clinical Validation
Sets the FDA process apart
Must define both safety and efficacy
To date, a diagnostic intended use has been linked to a specific clinical diagnosis
21Affymetrix Confidential
Working with the FDA
FDA at Their Computer
Contrary to some popular beliefs, the FDA is not
waiting to pounce
22Affymetrix Confidential
Genetic Biomarkers in Drug Labels
Drug Biomarker Drug Biomarker
Required Maraviroc CCR5 receptor Informational Imatinib c-Kit expression
Cetuximab - colon EGFr expression Voriconazole CYP2C19 variants
6 Trastuzumab Her2/neu overexpression Celecoxib CYP2C9 variants
Lenalidomide del(5)q Atomoxetine CYP2D6 variants
Panitumumab KRAS Variants Fluoxetine CYP2D6 Status
Dasatinib Ph1 chromosome Lenalidomide Chromosome 5q del
Recommended Warfarin CYP2C9 variants Capecitabine DPD variants
Warfarin Protein C deficiency Erlotinib EGFr expression
Warfarin VKORC1 variants 14 Cetuximab - Head EGFr expression
Atorvastatin LDL variants Primaquine G6PD variants
11 Rasburicase G6PD variants Rifampin/isoniazid NAT variants
Carbemazepine HLA-B1502 allele Busulfan Ph1 chromosome
Abacavir HLA-B5701 allele Nilotinib UGT1A1 vriants
Azathioprine TPMT variants Prasugrel CYP2C19 variants
Irinotecan UGT1A1 variants
Clopidogrel CYP2C19 variants
Valproic Acid Urea cycle disorder deficiency
Tretinoin PML/RAR a gene expression
FDA Current Drug Labels Containing Genetic Biomarkers
23Affymetrix Confidential
Summary
Utility of genetic tests in a clinical setting is to
define subgroups with a better risk:benefit profile
The translation of genetic technologies to clinical
problem solving is in its infancy
Device manufacturers, health care professionals,
and third party payers must partner with the
regulatory agencies to enable the best use of
genetic technologies