Transfer Pricing Documentation Guidelines in Bulgaria Overview 13 April 2010.

Transfer Pricing Documentation Guidelines in BulgariaOverview

13 April 2010

13 April 2010 Transfer Pricing Documentation Guidelines in Bulgaria

Table of contents

► What is Transfer pricing (“TP”)?► International background and developments► Bulgarian TP developments► Transfer pricing documentation guidelines ► TP documentation files – contents and methodology► Closing remarks. EY recommendations


What is Transfer pricing (“TP”)?

► Transfer pricing definition► Pricing of related party transactions

► Transfer pricing issues► Integrated business processes► Comparable transactions► Different national rules and practice


property

physical movement

services

Board of Directors

purchasingraw-material transportation

trans

porta

tion

sales services after-sales service

sale of end product

management services adm

inis

trat

ive

serv

ices

Supplier

Shared Services

Sales

Central Company

Customer

distribution services

R&D

Warehouse

Transfer pricing issues

Manufacture

man

ufac

turin

g

6


Applicable common standard

► The Arm’s length principle

► International standard advocated by OECD► Refers to the price at which third parties would transact under

similar terms and conditions


International background and developments

► Response of OECD, EC and tax authorities► 1995 OECD Guidelines – www.oecd.org

► The “Arm’s Length Principle”► EU Joint Transfer Pricing Forum

► Code of Conduct for effective implementation of the "Arbitration Convention " and proposal for September 2009 revision

http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:C:2006:176:0008:0012:EN:PDF

http://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/resources/documents/taxation/company_tax/transfer_pricing/COM(2009)472_en.pdf

► Code of Conduct on transfer pricing documentation for 2006 EU associated enterprises

http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:C:2006:176:0001:0007:EN:PDF

► Guidelines for Advance Pricing Agreements (APAs) within the EUhttp://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/resources/documents/taxation/company_tax/

transfer_pricing/COM(2007)71_en.pdf


Countries with effective TP documentation rules


Ernst & Young’s TP Survey

► Published on 29 September 2009► www.ey.com/tpsurvey

► Main messages:

► Transfer pricing – under the scrutiny of tax authorities worldwide► China, Slovakia and Greece - other countries introducing detailed

requirements for maintaining theTransfer pricing documentation file with information and analysis

► Tax authorities dedicate more resources to TP investigations setting transfer pricing examination teams


Industries, countries and transactions in the spotlight

► The main targeted industries are automotive, consumer products, financial services, oil and gas, and pharmaceuticals.

► Focus on transactions with perceived tax havens and ‘blacklisted’ countries

► TP investigation could be triggered by unusually big losses in a group company; corporate restructurings involving closures or reductions in operations; significant inter-company management fees

Ernst & Young’s TP Survey, cont.


Bulgarian developments in a nutshell

► Arm’s length principle introduced in 1993 (Decree 56 on Business Activity)

► TP methods introduced in the Corporate Income Tax Act of 1998► Ordinance 5/1999 on the methods used to establish market prices► Ordinance N-9/2006 on the TP methods based on the OECD TP

Guidelines► Transfer Pricing Manual of NRA of 2008► Transfer pricing documentation chapter included in the Manual,

published on 8 February on NRA’s official website http://portal.nap.bg/


Internal legislation in force



► Burden of proof on the taxpayer

► Art. 116 of the Tax Code : For transfer pricing matters, the burden of proof that prices are at arm’s length is on the taxpayer



► Accounting standards/principles

► The notes to the financial statements should include information on transactions with related parties

► Definition of related party for accounting purposes: where common control exists


Related parties

For accounting purposes: For tax purposes:

Where common control exists 5 % shareholding

relationship is sufficient (§ 1, item 3 from the Tax Code)


Status of the Guidelines

► The Guidelines are part of the NRA’s TP audit manual, approved by NRA Executive Director order

► Technically, they are not part of the law► It is in the interest of taxpayers to comply with the

Guidelines since they define what the NRA requires ► Compliance with the Guidelines will greatly reduce the

scope for disputes about transfer pricing


Effect of the Guidelines

► TP documentation based on the Guidelines may be required for any open tax year and for tax obligations not covered by the statute of limitations period


Lack of TP documentation

► There is only insignificant penalty if no TP documentation is available

► The burden of proof is on the taxpayer to demonstrate that the transfer prices applied are at arm’s length

► Without a documentation prepared according to the Guidelines, the NRA may reassess the tax liabilities based upon any publicly available information


Structure of the Guidelines

► Two parts ► methodology on how to audit transfer prices, ► TP documentation requirements

► Notes of the financial statements► Focus on the differences in related party definitions► TPD documentation can be required after reviewing the

notes ► Our conclusion: it is time-consuming to prepare a

documentation according to the requirements of the Guidelines. Therefore, the time set by the NRA is likely to be insufficient.


Aggregation of similar transactions

► TP documentation should support each related party transaction

► Similar transactions may be aggregated in one TP documentation file:► Contracts of long duration, i.e. above 12 months► Where the objects of the transactions are similar

► Periodic supplies of one and the same product or product groups

► Complex price for supply of equipment and guarantee service► Compound transactions, e.g. franchise agreements


Exception for micro business

► Micro business will not be expected to prepare TP documentation

► Exception: when the operating profit margin is 20 % lower than the industry average for each of the last three preceding years, simplified TP documentation file should be prepared► NSI and other publicly available sources to be used► Summary of the operating profit margin for the last three years► List of competitors


Documenting restructuring of functions and risks

► Comparability analysis should be carried out before and after restructuring

► What shall be documented?► The actual changes which have occurred as a result of this

process► The economic reasons underlying the restructuring and expected

benefits ► Realistic options that would have been available to the parties in

the event of independent market relations► The way restructuring compensations (if any) are affected by the

compensation paid to the company


Simplified TP documentation

► May be prepared for lower value transactions based upon annual thresholds:► BGN200,000, where the object of the transaction is supply of goods► BGN200,000, where the object of the transaction is supply of services► BGN400,000, where the object of the transaction is supply of

intangible articles► BGN400,000, where the object of the transaction is granting of a loan

(the threshold relates to the amount of interest)

► Combination of aggregation and the above thresholds:► The above thresholds apply to the aggregated amount► The above thresholds apply to the transaction with the greatest value

among the aggregated transactions, e.g. franchise


► Offshore zone definition: Art. 116(3) from the Tax Code► Presumption for related parties► Shifted burden of proof► Requirement for simplified TP documentation► Detailed version may be required

TP documentation for offshore business


Obligation for presentation

► TP documentation should be presented upon the request of the tax authority, e.g. during a tax audit or DTT clearance

► No obligation to be submitted to NRA on a regular basis► In case of non-compliance:

► EUR250 fine ► Reassessment, based on any publicly available pricing information


Keeping TP documentation up-to-date

► TP documentation should be prepared for each tax year and should be kept up-to-date if changes occur in relevant factors

► No changes are also documented


Retention of TP documentation

► TP documentation should be retained for a period of five years after the expiry of the statute of limitations for the relevant tax year.


Language of documentation

► The country-specific file should be prepared in Bulgarian► The master file may contain documentation in other

languages but the NRA may require certified translations of all or any part of it


► TP documentation should consist of two parts:

► Group information – Master file

► Information on the local entity and the transfer methodology applied – Country-specific file

TP documentation files


Contents of master file

► Legal, functional, financial and management organization of the Group: description/chart

► Economic role of each member of the Group – functions and risks assumed;

► Allocation and financing of the intellectual property► Explanation of the transfer pricing policy of the Group► Description of the controlled transactions► A list of any agreements for allocation of expenses, advance

pricing agreements (APAs), decisions of courts, etc.


Contents of country-specific file

► Description of the functions, assets and risks of the local company

► Description of the controlled transactions in view of their nature and scope

► Excerpts of the financial statements of the taxpayer in relation to its related party transactions

► The transfer pricing methodology of the Bulgarian company► Description of the method selected and reasons underlying the

selection► Internal and/or external comparable transactions► Description of the information sources► Explanation of the adjustments to the comparable transactions applied

with the aim to eliminate the differences► Any other information evidencing the compliance with the arm’s length

principle


Contents vs. methodology in drafting a TP documentation file

Company Analysis

Transaction Description

Functional Analysis

Industry Analysis

Economic Analysis

► Description of the functions, assets and risks of the local company

► Description of the controlled transactions► Excerpts of the financial statements of the

taxpayer in relation to its related party transactions

► Transfer pricing methodology of the Bulgarian company


Final conclusions

► The TP documentation file is not just a comparables search or a mechanical comparison of financial ratios. It should involve business analysis.

► There is not one proper price or margin BUT a range of prices and margins that are compatible with the arm’s length principle that the Company can use, provided that they are documented properly.

► The TP documentation file will lead to a better understanding of the value drivers in the business concerned.


Closing remarks

► Wide range of international rules► TP rules have been in BG legislation since 1993► However, they have not been forced by the NRA as the

expectations as to how to document transfer prices were not set

► TP Guidelines remove uncertainties but create expectations► The Guidelines are not technically part of the law. However, it

is in the interest of the taxpayers to follow them.► We do not see any reason why the NRA will not require TP

documentation according to the Guidelines and for any open tax years.


Closing remarks

► Increase in the number of TP audits/reviews should be expected. Therefore, Ernst & Young recommends:

► Health checks to identify and analyze exposures and planning opportunities

► Review of group TP policies in view of their compatibility with the Bulgarian rules

► Preparation/review of local TP documentation file


Your key contacts

► Laszlo Szakal

[email protected]► Trevor Link

[email protected]► Evguenia Tzenova

[email protected]► Mitko Stoykov

[email protected]

Main tel: +359 2 81 77 100

Fax: +359 2 81 77 111


Thank you for your attention!

Transfer Pricing Documentation Guidelines in Bulgaria Overview 13 April 2010.

Documents

Transcript of Transfer Pricing Documentation Guidelines in Bulgaria Overview 13 April 2010.