Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

79
Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces Tiago Guerreiro Hugo Nicolau Joaquim Jorge Daniel Gonçalves

Transcript of Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Page 1: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Tiago Guerreiro Hugo Nicolau

Joaquim Jorge Daniel Gonçalves

Page 2: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Mobile evolution …

Page 3: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Touch Interfaces

Leading to …

Page 4: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

pleasant

Page 5: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Tactile feedback

loss of tactile feedback

Page 6: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Loss of physical stability

Page 7: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

hard to select targets

Page 8: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

it occurs to everyone

Page 9: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

… and motor impaired

Page 10: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

require less strength

Page 11: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Adapt to users’ needs

Page 12: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Provide the knowledge to build better touch interfaces

Page 13: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

We performed …

Page 14: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Tested several …

Interaction Techniques

Page 15: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Screen areas …

… corners

Page 16: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Screen areas …

… edges

Page 17: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

7 mm

… and target sizes

12 mm 17 mm

Page 18: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Tapping

Page 19: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Crossing

Page 20: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Exiting

Page 21: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Gesturing

Page 22: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

15 participants 28-64 years old

C4-C7 lesion level 6 left-handed

never used touchscreens

Page 23: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Results

Page 24: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Error Rate

X

Page 25: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Precision

Page 26: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Movement Error

Page 27: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Movement Time

t0 tn

Page 28: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Tapping

Page 29: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Target Size

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

7mm 12mm 17mm

Erro

r R

ate

(%

)

Target sizes (milimeters)

Page 30: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Corners and Edges precision

Page 31: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

7mm

Vertical error rate

45% 28% 27%

39% 28% 24%

43% 19% 12%

12mm 17mm

Page 32: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Distance error rate

28%

28%

20%

20%

12%

12%

11%

11% 6%

17mm

Page 33: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Crossing

Page 34: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Target Size

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

7mm 12mm 17mm

Erro

r R

ate

(%

)

Target size (milimeters)

Page 35: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Exiting

Page 36: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Target Size

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

7mm 12mm 17mm

Erro

r R

ate

(%

)

Target size (milimeters)

Page 37: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Gesturing

Page 38: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Edges

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

Center Edge

Mo

vem

en

t E

rro

r (p

ixels

)

Gesture

Page 39: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Directions

0

50

100

150

200

250 N

W

NE

SW

SE

SLef

t N

WU

pp

er S E W

SRig

ht

NR

igh

t

EUp

per

NLe

ft

WB

ott

om

EBo

tto

m

Mo

vem

en

t Er

ror

(pix

els

)

Gesture Direction

Page 40: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Mixing All Techniques

Page 41: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

7mm 12mm 17mm

Erro

r R

ate

(%

)

Target Size (milimeters)

Exiting Gestures Tapping Crossing

All Techniques

Page 42: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces
Page 43: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Interact with edge support

Page 44: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Interact with edge support

22%

36%

Page 45: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces
Page 46: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Acquiring edge targets

Page 47: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Acquiring edge targets

Page 48: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Edge or Middle

Page 49: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Edge or Middle

Page 50: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Interacting mid-screen

Page 51: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Interacting mid-screen

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%

45%

50%

7mm 12mm 17mm

Crossing GesturesM4Way Tapping Middle

Page 52: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Interacting mid-screen

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%

45%

50%

7mm 12mm 17mm

Crossing GesturesM4Way Tapping Middle

Page 53: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces
Page 54: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

0

1

2

3

4

5

Exiting Tapping Crossing Gesturing

Page 55: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Conclusions

Page 56: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

What is the best size for each interaction technique?

Page 57: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

12 mm

Page 58: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

However, error rates are still …

High

Page 59: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

What is the best screen area for each interaction technique?

Page 60: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces
Page 61: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces
Page 62: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces
Page 63: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Regarding target position …

Support

Page 64: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces
Page 65: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

What is the best interaction technique for motor-impaired people?

Page 66: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces
Page 67: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces
Page 68: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

What is the best interaction technique for each screen area?

Page 69: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces
Page 70: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces
Page 71: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces
Page 72: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces
Page 73: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces
Page 74: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces
Page 75: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

What is the best technique-size-area combination?

Page 76: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces
Page 77: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces
Page 78: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

Explore target size for the target population Differences between able-bodied and tetraplegics

Future Work

Page 79: Towards Accessible Touch Interfaces

The End Tiago Guerreiro [email protected]