Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top...

47
1 Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March 11, 2015

Transcript of Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top...

Page 1: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

1

Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment

Western Regional Boiler Association

March 11, 2015

Page 2: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

2

Page 3: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

#11

Ultra Low Range Hardness Testing

3

Page 4: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

Continued Increase in Boiler Feedwater Hardness

275 PPB (0.275 PPM) Average hardness

Nexguard dosage recommendation: 9.5 PPM

Page 5: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

#10

Temperature Correction for “High Purity” pH Testing

5

Page 6: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

Condensate Testing

Dedicate IRON test glassware. False high iron. Expect <0.025 ppm

Do not adjust sample flow

Replace pH meter as required, once/6 months

Adjust for temperature

Page 7: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March
Page 8: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

# 9

Myron 6P – Reliable pH and Conductivity Measurement

8

Page 9: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

9

Replacement pH Probe

Page 10: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

#8

Know Your Boiler Mass Balance – Diagnostic Study

10

Page 11: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

11

Page 12: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March
Page 13: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

#7

Deposit Weight Differential - How Clean are your Boiler tubes?

13

Page 14: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March
Page 15: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March
Page 16: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

#6

Operator Procedures

16

Page 17: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March
Page 18: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

BOILER CONTROL

CONDENSATE

Amine 1820

* Consult your Program Administration Manual for further guidance *

IN

RANGE

OUT OF

RANGE

LOW HIGH

1. Leaking

blowdown valve

2. Manual

blowdowns are too

long/often

3. Decrease

surface blowdown

setting

4. Reduced steam

production

5. Change in

feedwater quality

1. Conduct manual

blowdown daily

2. Increase surface

blowdown setting

3. Change in

feedwater quality

4. Increased steam

production

CONDUCTIVITY 2500 - 3500 mmhos

IN

RANGE OUT OF

RANGE

HIGH

1. Regenerate

softener

2. Check brine

level

3. Check valve

setting

4. Have resin

analyzed

5. Run elution

study

SOFT WATER Hardness < 1.0 ppm

pH 8.2 - 9.0

IN

RANGE

OUT OF

RANGE

LOW HIGH

1. Chemical pump

malfunction or lost

prime

2. Feed tank

empty

3. Increase the

chemical pump

setting and record

on log sheet

4. Process

contamination

1. Boiler water

carryover

2. Chemical pump

malfunction

3. Decrease the

chemical pump

setting and record

on log sheet

4. Process

contamination

IN

RANGE

OUT OF

RANGE

Conductivity < 25 mmhos

HIGH

1. Boiler water

carryover

2. Process

contamination

Page 19: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

#5

Automated Amine Feed

19

Page 20: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

Start Auto Amine control

Before Auto

pH variation: 7.2-10.3

Page 21: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

#4

Continuous Feedwater Corrosion Monitoring

21

Page 22: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

Two New Technologies:

3D TRASAR Technology for Boilers™

Measures and controls scale inhibitor chemistry

Nalco Corrosion Stress Monitor™

Measures and controls pre-boiler corrosion environment

Page 23: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March
Page 24: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

Stimson Start-up

Feedwater (DA) Temp vs. ORP

2. Corrosive feedwater - High ORP

1. Low DA temp - Inadequate Pegging Steam

High O2 >100 ppb

3. Oxygen Scavenger INCREASED

4. DA Pegging Steam ON, Set Point

increased to 6 psi

5. At-Temp ORP in range, O2 <20 ppb

Page 25: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

New Boiler Automation Technology

Automatically responds

Maintain optimum treatment levels

Directly measures

ppm

22310

0

5

1 0

1 5

2 0

2 5

3 0

3 5

4 0

4 5

0 1/10 /9 9 0 1 /2 0/99 01 /3 0 /9 9 0 2/09 /9 9 0 2 /1 9/99 03 /0 1/99 0 3/11 /9 9 0 3/21 /9 9

Da te

Optimum Operation

Detect

System

Upsets

TRASAR Automation

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

01/10/99 01/20/99 01/30/99 02/09/99 02/19/99 03/01/99 03/11/99 03/21/99

D ate

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

10/11/1997 20/11/1997 30/11/1997 10/12/1997 20/12/1997 30/12/1997 09/01/1998 19/01/1998

Date

ppm

22310

TRASAR Automation

Direct control of scaleInhibitor chemistry

ppm

22310

0

5

1 0

1 5

2 0

2 5

3 0

3 5

4 0

4 5

0 1/10 /9 9 0 1 /2 0/99 01 /3 0 /9 9 0 2/09 /9 9 0 2 /1 9/99 03 /0 1/99 0 3/11 /9 9 0 3/21 /9 9

Da te

Optimum Operation

Detect

System

Upsets

TRASAR Automation

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

01/10/99 01/20/99 01/30/99 02/09/99 02/19/99 03/01/99 03/11/99 03/21/99

D ate

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

10/11/1997 20/11/1997 30/11/1997 10/12/1997 20/12/1997 30/12/1997 09/01/1998 19/01/1998

Date

ppm

22310

TRASAR Automation

ppm

22310

0

5

1 0

1 5

2 0

2 5

3 0

3 5

4 0

4 5

0 1/10 /9 9 0 1 /2 0/99 01 /3 0 /9 9 0 2/09 /9 9 0 2 /1 9/99 03 /0 1/99 0 3/11 /9 9 0 3/21 /9 9

Da te

Optimum Operation

Detect

System

Upsets

TRASAR Automation

ppm

22310

0

5

1 0

1 5

2 0

2 5

3 0

3 5

4 0

4 5

0 1/10 /9 9 0 1 /2 0/99 01 /3 0 /9 9 0 2/09 /9 9 0 2 /1 9/99 03 /0 1/99 0 3/11 /9 9 0 3/21 /9 9

Da te

Optimum Operation

Detect

System

Upsets

TRASAR Automation

ppm

22310

0

5

1 0

1 5

2 0

2 5

3 0

3 5

4 0

4 5

0 1/10 /9 9 0 1 /2 0/99 01 /3 0 /9 9 0 2/09 /9 9 0 2 /1 9/99 03 /0 1/99 0 3/11 /9 9 0 3/21 /9 9

Da te

Optimum Operation

Detect

System

Upsets

ppm

22310

0

5

1 0

1 5

2 0

2 5

3 0

3 5

4 0

4 5

0 1/10 /9 9 0 1 /2 0/99 01 /3 0 /9 9 0 2/09 /9 9 0 2 /1 9/99 03 /0 1/99 0 3/11 /9 9 0 3/21 /9 9

Da te

Optimum Operation

Detect

System

Upsets

TRASAR Automation

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

01/10/99 01/20/99 01/30/99 02/09/99 02/19/99 03/01/99 03/11/99 03/21/99

D ate

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

10/11/1997 20/11/1997 30/11/1997 10/12/1997 20/12/1997 30/12/1997 09/01/1998 19/01/1998

Date

ppm

22310

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

01/10/99 01/20/99 01/30/99 02/09/99 02/19/99 03/01/99 03/11/99 03/21/99

D ate

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

10/11/1997 20/11/1997 30/11/1997 10/12/1997 20/12/1997 30/12/1997 09/01/1998 19/01/1998

Date

ppm

22310

TRASAR Automation

Direct control of scaleInhibitor chemistry

-0.8

-0.6

-0.4

-0.2

0

0.2

1/2

3/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

2/2

/20

06

0:0

0:0

0

2/1

2/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

2/2

2/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

3/4

/20

06

0:0

0:0

0

3/1

4/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

3/2

4/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

4/3

/20

06

0:0

0:0

0

4/1

3/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

4/2

3/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

5/3

/20

06

0:0

0:0

0

5/1

3/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

5/2

3/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

6/2

/20

06

0:0

0:0

0

6/1

2/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

LP

#3 A

T-T

OR

P v

s E

PB

RE

(V

)

Phase 2: LP #3 AT-T ORP Controlled

Feed Of Eliminox

Phase 1: AEPCO Controlled Feed Of Eliminox

Baseline Monitoring LP #3 AT-T ORP

LP #3 AT-T ORP Set Point = -350 mV

Figure 1: LP #3 AT-T ORP Results During Phase 1 and 2 of AEPCO Trial

Direct control of preboiler corrosion

NCSM Automation-0.8

-0.6

-0.4

-0.2

0

0.2

1/2

3/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

2/2

/20

06

0:0

0:0

0

2/1

2/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

2/2

2/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

3/4

/20

06

0:0

0:0

0

3/1

4/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

3/2

4/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

4/3

/20

06

0:0

0:0

0

4/1

3/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

4/2

3/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

5/3

/20

06

0:0

0:0

0

5/1

3/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

5/2

3/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

6/2

/20

06

0:0

0:0

0

6/1

2/2

00

6 0

:00

:00

LP

#3 A

T-T

OR

P v

s E

PB

RE

(V

)

Phase 2: LP #3 AT-T ORP Controlled

Feed Of Eliminox

Phase 1: AEPCO Controlled Feed Of Eliminox

Baseline Monitoring LP #3 AT-T ORP

LP #3 AT-T ORP Set Point = -350 mV

Figure 1: LP #3 AT-T ORP Results During Phase 1 and 2 of AEPCO Trial

Direct control of preboiler corrosion

NCSM Automation

Page 26: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

#3

Automated Chemical Inventory

26

Page 27: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

Tank Level Monitoring

Page 28: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March
Page 29: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

#2

Blowdown Heat Recovery

29

Page 30: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

Blowdown/Condensate Heat Exchanger

Page 31: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March
Page 32: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

90%

Energy Saved!

Boiler Blowdown at 150 psig

1,000 lb/hr at 364° F

Hf = 336 BTU/lb

Heat Flow = 336M BTU/hr

Useable Heat Flow = 308M BTU/hr

To Sewer Waste at 86° F

Hfg = 58.2 BTU/lb

Heat Flow = 58.2M BTU/hr

Useable Heat Loss = 30.8M BTU/hr

Clean BD HX efficiency gives

90% removal of heat

Make-Up water picks up

Heat Flow = 278M BTU/hr

Make-Up at 60°F

27.4M BTU/lb

BD HX

150 psig boiler

Blowdown Heat Recovery

Page 33: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

#1

Managing your data

33

Page 34: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

3D Trasar – Stimson Forest Grove

Scale Control NexGuard Trasar

Corrosion control At-Temp ORP

BFW pH

BFW Conductivity

Boiler Blowdown

Turbidity

Temperature

Tank Level

Amine Conductivity

Softener Hardness

Page 35: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

35

Page 36: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

36

Page 37: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

Possible root cause: Low inventory, blocked feed

Description: Relay has been under failsafe condition for a while. But even with30% relay duty concentration

is still dropping. This indicates either the product container may be empty or a leak or blockage may exist in

the feed line. Prior to this during normal operation (auto) concentration decreased less in 1400 minutes

indicating reduced feed rate (conductivity is not dropping that much). Please check the above issues.

Graph attached

Nalco 360™

Page 38: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March
Page 39: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

39

Page 40: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

40

Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment

Western Regional Boiler Association

March 11, 2015

Page 41: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

LION CAM-3 SECURITY ALERT

ALERT LEVEL: 1A

ACTION: IMMEDIATE

THREAT LEVEL: HIGH

AUTOMATED REPORT SUMMARY

Page 42: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

42

LION SEC CAM 3A 17:21:56 03102105

Page 43: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

43

Page 44: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

44

LION CAM3

01:29:22

03112015

Page 45: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

45

LION CAM3

01:29:22

03112015

Page 46: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March

LION CAM-3 SECURITY ALERT

ALERT LEVEL: 1A

ACTION: IMMEDIATE

THREAT LEVEL: HIGH

AUTOMATED REPORT SUMMARY

Page 47: Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment - Western Regional ... Presentations/8-Nalco/WRBA 2015 - Top 10... · Top 10 for Boiler Water Treatment Western Regional Boiler Association March