Tool Vendor Day 2 Session 2 - MODAF Development · Developing the MOD Architectural Framework MODAF...
Transcript of Tool Vendor Day 2 Session 2 - MODAF Development · Developing the MOD Architectural Framework MODAF...
IAECC – InformationSuperiority
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Session 2
MODAF Development
THIS DOCUMENT IS THE PROPERTY OF HER BRITANNIC MAJESTY’S GOVERNMENT, and is issued for the information of such persons only as need to know its contents in the course of their official duties. Any person finding this document should hand it to a British Forces unit or to a Police Station for its safe return to the SECURITY OFFICE, DEFENCE PROCUREMENT AGENCY, ABBEY WOOD,
BRISTOL, BS34 8JH, with details of how and when found. THE UNAUTHORISED RETENTION OR DESTRUCTION OF THIS DOCUMENT MAY BE AN OFFENCE UNDER THE UNITED KINGDOM OFFICIAL SECRETS ACT OF 1911-89.
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
AgendaAgenda
• Aims and Objectives• MODAF progress update• MODAF development• Enterprise Reference Model• Facilitated discussion
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
MODAF ViewsMODAF Views• MODAF is based upon DoDAF but with
tailoring to MoD lifecycle / processes and as a result of US and UK lessons learned
• Most DoDAF views will be incorporated largely as-is with tailoring to MoD terminology, ERM, etc
• Some DoDAF views may be modified to incorporate lessons learned
• Two new viewpoints included:– Strategic Views – mainly support capability
management– Acquisition Views – support the acquisition
lifecycle
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
MODAF DevelopmentMODAF Development• Will utilise existing DoDAF products where
possible• Similar documentation approach to DoDAF –
executive summary, handbook, desk book• Will develop progressively with multi-stage
stakeholder reviews to minimise surprises and volume of new material at each stage
• Using white papers as discussion documents prior to integrating the full MODAF product set
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
COI COI
DeskbookDeskbookCOI COI
DeskbookDeskbookCOI COI
DeskbookDeskbookCOI COI
DeskbookDeskbook
MODAFMODAF
COICOI
DeskbookDeskbook
(x 5)(x 5)
MODAFMODAF
Volume 2Volume 2
HandbookHandbook
MODAFMODAF
Volume 1Volume 1
ExecutiveExecutive
SummarySummary
MODAF Products
DODAFDODAF
Volume 1Volume 1
DODAFDODAF
Volume 2Volume 2
DODAFDODAF
Desk bookDesk bookDODAF Products
Overall StrategyOverall Strategy
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
DODAFDODAF
Volume 2Volume 2
MODAFMODAF
OutlineOutline
PapersPapers
((StVStV, , AcVAcV))
NowNow
= Review= Review
Volume 2 Volume 2 -- HandbookHandbook
MODAFMODAFSuggestedSuggestedChangesChanges
WhiteWhitePaperPaper RevisedRevised
DODAFDODAFViewsViewsWhiteWhite
PapersPapers
MODAFMODAF
New ViewsNew Views
WhiteWhite
PapersPapers
Jan 05Jan 05
DraftDraft
MODAFMODAF
Volume 2Volume 2
HandbookHandbook
May 05May 05
UpdateView
UpdateView
Σ
MODify MODify Existing Existing DODAF DODAF ViewsViews
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
DoDAFDoDAF
Desk bookDesk book
MoDMoD
ProcessesProcesses
MODAFMODAF
COICOI
WorkshopsWorkshops
MODAFMODAF
ConceptConcept
Of UseOf Use
= Workshop= Workshop
NowNow
= Review= Review
DeskbookDeskbook
PilotPilot
AFAF
ExamplesExamples
MODAFMODAF
New ViewsNew Views
WhiteWhite
PapersPapers
MODAFMODAF
ViewsViews
To MODTo MOD
ProcessesProcesses
Jan 05Jan 05
COICOI
AFAF
ExamplesExamples
May 05May 05
COICOI
DeskbooksDeskbooks
(x 5)(x 5)
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
View OutlineView Outline
DoDAFDoDAF
Volume 2Volume 2
MODAF ViewMODAF ViewUML Representation
Data object definition
ERM Support
Mandation by COI
View Description
Roles and Responsibilities
x33
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Changes from DoDAFChanges from DoDAF• Introduction of Strategic Views (x5)• Introduction of Acquisition Views (x2)• Modification to OVs, SVs, TVs (~x6)• Mandate ~ 15 key views – to be
specified in COI deskbooks• All other views will be optional, but if
produced should be in accordance with the MODAF handbook to ensure architecture model interchange
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
StV-1 Capability Vision• Provides an outline of the
strategic vision for a capability area over a particular time frame
• Informs the long term capability planning process
• Generated largely through operational concepts and research work
• Probably a textual format
New
THE DEFENCE LOGISTIC VISION
Defence Logistics will be a highly effective, agile and networked component that underpins the operational commander’s ability to
execute his mission successfully. It will be joint, integrated and interoperable, tested and developed to provide the military commander
with confidence in his ability to deliver effect at the required tempo. Success will be built on balanced, adaptable systems and force elements
combined with converged logistic processes and procedures.
A number of logistic capability goals to be achieved across Defence have been drawn from the Vision:
Capability Goal 1. A truly joint logistic posture and culture, developed to support Effects Based Operations. A joint approach to the planning of future operations will continue to be fundamental and will increasingly include coalition partners, with tight co-ordination of logistic elements across Services. There will be a move towards role specialisation within deployed components and lead Services in the Base. Consistency and coherence of logistic information will be key to building the required trust.
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
StV-2 Capability FunctionsCommand Battlespace Management
Decision Support Information Management &Acquisition
Effects
1. Operational Planning:• Initiation• Mission Analysis• CCIR & planningguidance• Estimate
- COA - W argaming• Decision• CONOPS• SoM• Assemble/review Plan• Orders
2. Operational Analysis3. Mission Rehearsal4. Situational Awareness:
• Physical Env• Mission Env• Blue Env• Red Env• W hite Env• APNLRS• CID
5. Intelligence:• CCIRM• Int Direction• Collection mgt• Collation mgt• All-source fusion• Dissemination
1. Targeting:Target selectionTarget List managementAttack Guidance MatrixTargeting Cycle:
• Detect• Recognise• Identify• Track• Decide• Engage• Assess
2. Plan Engagement:• Effects selection• Resource allocation• Synchronisation
6. Functional PlanningSupport:• Arty Fire planning• Engr Obs planning• Engr Sp planning• EOD planning• AD planning• EW planning• Air planning• Avn planning• CIS planning• Info ops planning• Log planning• Sup• ES• Tpt• Med• Personnel planning
1. Information Management• Information Analysis• Information Fusion• Information Quality
Assurance• Information Dissemination
2. STAR• STAR Asset
Management/Tasking:− STAR asset status
monitoring− Mission planning− Mission control− Sensor cueing
• STAR Product Management:− Product analysis− Collation and fusion− Product Dissemination
3. Conduct Engagement:• Decision• Fires/Mission
Control• BDA• Reporting
Information and Communications Infrastructure
• Structured list of capability functions that are required during a certain epoch
• Should be traceable to StV-1
• Will probably relate to the Defence Capability Framework
• Provides taxonomy for capability audit and management
• Probably textual format
New
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
StV-2 Capability Functions• Likely to include the
quantification of attributes and metrics as additional fields associated with each capability function
• Example:– Concept = manoeuvre– Capability function =
ground manoeuvre– Attributes = range,
speed– Metrics = X km, Y kph
New
US DoD JCIDS Capabilities, Attributes and Metrics
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
StV-3 Capability Phasing• Analysis of the planned availability of military capability
at different points in time (epochs)• Only maps the primary systems that deliver a capability
function (eg sensors, weapon systems, …) not all the enabling systems (eg communications, networks, …)
• Should be traceable to StV-2 capability functions• Additional fields should be provided to capture the
attributes and metrics as to how well the capability in each epoch satisfies the capability function targets
• Supports the analysis of capability gaps and overlaps• Typically a tabular format
New
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
StV-3 Capability FunctionsNew
Systems within category
Capability by Capability Function
& Requirements
Phasing of individual systems
Capability gaps
Capability shortfalls
EpochsCapability CategoryEpoch 1Now-2008
Epoch 22004-2007
Epoch 32006-2011
Epoch 42008-2012
Epoch 52010-2017
Command SupportDecision Support
Decision Support Interoperability
Functional PlanningSupport
Functional Planning Support Interoperability
IS Infrastructure
Communications Infrastructure
STARAsset Management/TaskingSTAR ProductManagement
STAR Interoperability
STAR Sensors
EFFECTSTargetingPlan EngagementConduct Engagement
Effects Interoperability
Effectors
Enabling Projects
Epochs defined by key infrastructure
insertion points
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
StV-4 Capability Clusters• Provides a means of
analysing the main dependencies between capability functions
• Identifies logical grouping of capabilities – ie for CRDs
• Should relate to StV-2 capability functions
• Likely to be enduring across epochs
New
command battlespace management
decision support
operationalplanning
operationalanalysis
missionrehearsal
situationalawareness
intelligence
informationmanagement& acquisition
informationmanagementSTAR
effects
targeting planengagement
conductengagement
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
StV-4 Capability Clusters
• May also be presented as UML Use Case
New
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
StV-5 Capability to Systems Deployment Mapping
• Shows the planned capability deployment and interconnection by echelon / epoch
• Developed through a synthesis of information including: capability functions, system connectivity, echelons, epochs and programme data
• Develops upon the StV-3 – one StV-5 per epoch• Provides more detailed dependency analyses
than available with StV-3
New
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
StV-5 Capability to Systems Deployment Mapping
• Can be used for a variety of capability analyses, including:– Capability overlap/gap analysis– Deployment level shortfalls– Identifying connectivity issues– System interoperability by echelon– Identifying legacy issues
New
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
StV-5 Capability to Systems Deployment Mapping
New
System deploymentby echelon level
Overlap of systemsbetween epochs
PJHQ
LCC
Plt
Div
Bde
BG
Coy
Corp
JTF
Capability 1 Capability 2 Capability 3 Capability 4
System deploymentby operational capability
category
System connectivity and systems involved
EPOCH 1
EPOCH 2
EPOCH 3
EPOCH 4
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
AcV-1 Acquisition Clusters• Provides a means of
analysing the main dependencies between acquisition elements
• Likely to change through the epochs as systems come and go
• Strong linkage with StV-4 Capability Clusters
New
Beyond Line of Site ISTAR & Effects
Information
Specialist Comms
Surveillance
Land Comms
Watchkeeper
Phoenix
Bowman
Cormorant
Specialist Comms (SPCICR)
ElectronicWarfare
Soothsayer
Effects
Imagery
Canberra
ELINT
Jaguar
Nimrod R
Strike
Tomahawk Missile
Artillery
Comms
Sat Comms
Skynet 5
Special Projects
HUMINT Equipment
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
AcV-2 SoS Acquisition Programmes• Provides an overview of either the complete
acquisition programme or a subset of projects• Includes dependencies between elements,
acquisition lifecycle stage and maturity of lines of development
• Can be used to determine the impact of either planned or unplanned programmatic changes, and highlight opportunities for optimisation across the delivery profile
• Can be used to highlight areas of concern that may not be directly within an IPT's control, but would need addressing in order to successfully deliver the integrated capability
New
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
AcV-2 SoS Acquisition ProgrammesNew
FOC 01/01/06
People
Organisation
Sustainment
Equipment Training
Doctrine
LoDs
Pre-IG
IG to MG
MG to IOC
IOC to FOC
In Service
Disposal
Key to View
Project Phase
No outstanding issues
Manageable issues
Critical issues
LoD 'Hexagon'
2004 2005
System A
FOC 01/08/05IOC 01/04/05MG 01/10/04
System C
IOC 01/10/06IG 01/06/04 MG 01/01/05
System B
MG 01/11/04IG 01/05/04 IOC 01/06/04
System D
IOC 01/05/05MG 01/10/04
System E
2006
DISPOSAL 01/11/04 OUT OF SERVICE 01/06/05
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
OV-1 Extensions• Proposed that there are a
linked set of OV-1s that more fully define the operational scenario / use case:– High level operational
concept graphic– Concept of operations– Operational
performance attributes
Modified
FRES Deployment ConceptFigure 3
FRES
APOD
SPOD
FRES
Rapid Rapid Intervention Intervention
(Sea)(Sea)
2000 nm+
Rapid Intervention (Air) Rapid Intervention (Air)
FRES
Littoral Littoral ManoeuvreManoeuvre
<500 nm
Area of Ops
Self-Deploy500km
Rail
Operational Deployment Options 1-3
1
3
2
1
2
3
Objective
4
Strategic Deployment Options 1-4
ARG
OV-1 High Level Operational Concept
Graphic
OV-1b Concept of Operations
Operational Tempo
Attribute
TargetEpoch 3Epoch 2As-Is
100 km / day60 km / day40 km / day20 km / dayRate of advance for Armoured Brigade against light resistance
ValueMeasure
Operational Tempo
Attribute
TargetEpoch 3Epoch 2As-Is
100 km / day60 km / day40 km / day20 km / dayRate of advance for Armoured Brigade against light resistance
ValueMeasure OV-1c Operational Performance
Attributes
Described in
Required performance Perf
orm
ance
At
trib
utes
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
OV-1 Extensions• OV-1b Concept of Operations would
be textual description of the scenario / use case
• OV-1c Operational Performance Attributes:
Modified
Operational Tempo
Attribute
TargetEpoch 3Epoch 2As-Is
100 km / day60 km / day40 km / day20 km / dayRate of advance for Armoured Brigade against light resistance
ValueMeasure
Operational Tempo
Attribute
TargetEpoch 3Epoch 2As-Is
100 km / day60 km / day40 km / day20 km / dayRate of advance for Armoured Brigade against light resistance
ValueMeasure
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Modified View – OV-2• Possible extension
to OV-2 to show the relationship of operational nodes with platforms or geographic locations
• May use swim lanes or graphical overlays
Modified
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Modified View – SV-1
• Proposed extension of SV-1 to of adding extra information to show the relationship of system nodes with operational roles, platforms and/or geographic locations
• May use swim lanes or graphical overlays
Modified
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Modified View – SV-1Modified
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Modified View – SV-2
• As everybody moves away from point to point communications the traditional SV-2 becomes obsolete
• However, system interoperability remains a key concern
• Therefore, MODAF may extend SV-2 to include more information relating to system interoperability:– Port specifications– Protocol stack
Modified
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
SV-2a – System Port Specification• Each port specifies a protocol
or hardware interface specification
• Each protocol/spec is just shown by name- its full specification is defined in TV-1
• Wherever possible, data models or schemas should also be quoted (e.g. NATO ADAT-P3)
• There may be more than one possible protocol per port and these are shown as horizontal boxes
System 3Port: 3a
PLCS DEX 7
HTTP
TCP/IP
Bowman
Port: 3b
NATO ADAT-P3
WAP
GPRS
Port: 3c
LDAP
TCP/IP
Ethernet
RJ-45 Socket
GSM 900MHz
HTTP FTP SMTP
SMS
FTP
Modified
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
System 5
SV-2b – System to System Protocol Stack
• Port to port connectivity can only be assured when all of the protocols for the ports in question fully match
• When a port allows more than one protocol (e.g. port 3c), only one route through the protocol stack is shown per diagram
System 3
Port: 3c Port: 5f
TCP/IP
Ethernet
CAT 5 Cable
SMTP
3-5 e-mail
System 3System 1
Port: 1a Port: 3b1-3 Operational Feedback
PLCS DEX 7
HTTP
TCP/IP
Bowman
Modified
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Summary of Proposed Changes
View Ref View Title Source of Baseline View Changes? Description of Changes
AV-1 Overview and Summary Information
DODAF Handbook Volume II None N/A
AV-2 Integrated Dictionary DODAF Handbook Volume II None N/A
StV-1 Strategic Capability Vision
MODAF-M04-001 New View Document a new MODAF view as per outline Strategic Views.
StV-2 Capability Functions MODAF-M04-001 New View Document a new MODAF view as per outline Strategic Views. Add target capability attributes / metrics as per JCIDS. Likely mandated view on the ECC COI.
StV-3 Capability Phasing MODAF-M04-001 New View Document a new MODAF view as per outline Strategic Views. Add epoch-specific capability attributes / metrics as per JCIDS. Likely mandated view on the ECC COI.
StV-4 SoS Clusters MODAF-M04-001 New View Document a new MODAF view as per outline Strategic Views.
StV-5 Capability to Systems Deployment Mapping
MODAF-M04-001 New View Document a new MODAF view as per outline Strategic Views. Likely mandated view on the ECC COI.
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Summary of Proposed ChangesOV-1 High-Level Operational
Concept Graphic DODAF Handbook Volume II None Likely mandated view.
OV-1b Concept of Operations MODAF-M04-005 New View Document a new MODAF view as per suggested changes.
OV-1c Operational Performance Parameters
MODAF-M04-005 New View Document a new MODAF view as per suggested changes.
OV-2 Operational Node Connectivity Description
DODAF Handbook Volume II and MODAF-M04-005
Modify Suggested change to include overlay of platform / location of operational nodes. Likely mandated view.
OV-3 Operational Information Exchange Matrix
DODAF Handbook Volume II None Likely mandated view.
OV-4 Organizational Relationships Chart
DODAF Handbook Volume II None Likely mandated view.
OV-5 Operational Activity Model
DODAF Handbook Volume II None Likely mandated view.
OV-6a Operational Rules Model DODAF Handbook Volume II None N/A
OV-6b Operational State Transition Description
DODAF Handbook Volume II None N/A
OV-6c Operational Event-Trace Description
DODAF Handbook Volume II None N/A
OV-7 Logical Data Model DODAF Handbook Volume II None N/A
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Summary of Proposed ChangesSV-1 Systems Interface
Description DODAF Handbook Volume II and MODAF-M04-005
Modify Suggested change to include overlay of operational node and platform / location for system nodes. Likely mandated view.
SV-2 Systems Communications Description
DODAF Handbook Volume II None May be combined with SV-1.
SV-3 Systems-Systems Matrix DODAF Handbook Volume II None Likely mandated view.
SV-4 Systems Functionality Description
DODAF Handbook Volume II None Likely mandated view.
SV-5 Operational Activity to Systems Function Traceability Matrix
DODAF Handbook Volume II None Likely mandated view.
SV-6 Systems Data Exchange Matrix
DODAF Handbook Volume II None N/A
SV-7 Systems Performance Parameters Matrix
DODAF Handbook Volume II None N/A
SV-8 Systems Evolution Description
DODAF Handbook Volume II None N/A
SV-9 Systems Technology Forecast
DODAF Handbook Volume II None N/A
SV-10a Systems Rules Model DODAF Handbook Volume II None N/A
SV-10b Systems State Transition Description
DODAF Handbook Volume II None N/A
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Summary of Proposed Changes
SV-10c Systems Event-Trace Description
DODAF Handbook Volume II None N/A
SV-11 Physical Schema DODAF Handbook Volume II None N/A
TV-1 Technical Standards Profile
DODAF Handbook Volume II None Restructuring to show design principles driving standards and policy. Likely mandated view.
TV-2 Technical Standards Forecast
DODAF Handbook Volume II None N/A
AcV-1 SoS Acquisition Clusters MODAF-M04-002 New View N//A
AcV-2 SoS Acquisition Programmes
MODAF-M04-002 New View Likely mandated view.
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
MODAF Development – Next Steps
MODAF Development – Next Steps
• A MODAF internet website is under development and will go live shortly –you will need to register with us to gain access
• A number of draft white papers are being provided to you today
• Comments on these are welcome to:Andy North - [email protected]
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Questions?Questions?
THIS DOCUMENT IS THE PROPERTY OF HER BRITANNIC MAJESTY’S GOVERNMENT, and is issued for the information of such persons only as need to know its contents in the course of their official duties. Any person finding this document should hand it to a British Forces unit or to a Police Station for its safe return to the SECURITY OFFICE, DEFENCE PROCUREMENT AGENCY, ABBEY WOOD, BRISTOL, BS34 8JH, with details of how and when found. THE UNAUTHORISED RETENTION OR DESTRUCTION OF THIS DOCUMENT MAY BE AN OFFENCE UNDER THE UNITED KINGDOM OFFICIAL SECRETS ACT OF 1911-89.
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Outline MODAF Concept of UseOutline MODAF Concept of Use
DoctrineDoctrineOVOV-1OV-2OV-3… Doctrine
TTPs
Missions/ Tasks
TVTV-1TV-2
SVSV-1SV-2SV-3…SV-8SV-9
HLOC, FLOC …
OV
Concepts / Scenarios
OV-1OV-2OV-3…
Future ConceptsFuture Concepts
AcquisitionAcquisitionAcquisition
Documented in
CapabilityCapabilityManagementManagement
StVStV-2StV-3StV-4…
Gap
Disposal
Operational Planning (eg
J6)
Operations
OperateOperate
Sustain
SupportSupport
FieldedFieldedCapabilityCapability
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Outline MODAF Concept of UseOutline MODAF Concept of Use
CRD
StVStV-2StV-3StV-4…
AssuranceAssuranceTV
TV-1TV-2
GapNEC Use CasesSAG ScenariosIERs…
OV
UseCases
OV-1OV-2OV-3… URD
UserUserRequirementsRequirements
ARP
TDPsResearch &Research &TechnologyTechnology
CIP
FieldingFielding
AcV
AcV-2
SRD
SVSV-1SV-2SV-3…SV-8SV-9
AcquisitionAcquisition
CapabilityCapabilityManagementManagement
JSPDEF STAN
STANAGISO
…
StandardsStandards
ArchitectureRepository
ArchitectureArchitectureCoordinationCoordination
(AcquisitionProcesses)
(AcquisitionProcesses)
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Architecting for a PurposeArchitecting for a PurposeQuestions / Questions /
IssuesIssues
Real WorldReal World
ArchitecturesArchitecturesArchitectures
OV-2
: NMJIC
: JFC(JOC/JIC) : JFACC(AOC, 609AIS)
: DJFLCC(DOCC, 513ACE)
: MAW
: WOC
6: Target Nominations
1: BDA Reports8: Recommend Restrike
2: Munitions Effects Assessment5: Target Nominations
4: Target Nominations
9: Recommend Restrike
3: Target Nominations
10: Recommend Restrike
7: Target Nominations
11: Recommend Restrike
CAPABILITY FUNCTION
Decision SupportSituat ional Awareness
CCIRM JOCS (IPM only)/GP3(HQ ARRC only)Op Planning JOCS (IPM only)/GP3(HQ ARRC only)Intelligence JOCS (IPM only)/GP3(HQ ARRC only)
InteroperabilityJoint Strategic Intelligence LOCE MIDB/LOCEOperational Intelligence INT-C INTELWEB?Joint Logisitcs JCS LogNATO C2 & Int NIUTS/NSWANNATO CommsAllied Interoperability MIP Messaging/US-GCCSMaritime RNCSS/LPD(R)/T22/T23/T42/CVS/T45Air C2/Coord RAFCCIS/JFAC
Functional Planning SupportCSS AP3Medical SGISNBC BRACIS/BATESBRACIS NT NBC BISA/BATES NBC BISAGBAD AD BriC IGBAD IOCFi re Support FCAAviation C2Aviation Logis tics Support ACCESSEngineer/EODComms Management BCMS/CORMORANT CMSIS Management II IOC/II FOC DBL II FOC
InteroperabilityNATO ADAllied Fire Support AFATDS AFATDS II
JTF/ARRC IS JOCS/E-IARRCIS MLI/RNCSSFmn IS BOWMAN IOC/ATacCS/II EOCBG & below IS Platform BISA IOC/FOC/BGTIIn barracks IS DIIUnit IS DIIIndividual IS BOWMAN PUDT, BRAD FIST/BOWMAN PUDT, BRAD
FALCON CMS/BCMS/CORMORANT
CWAN (IPM only?)
JFAC (IPM only)RNCSS/LPD(R)/T22/T23/T42/CVSUS-GCCS (IPM only)
AP3/QP24
IS INFRASTRUCTUREJOCS/E-IARRCIS/RNCSS
Epoch 2 (2004-2007)
JCS Log
JOCS/G2 BISA/GP3 (HQ ARRC only
JOCS/E-IARRCIS MLI/RNCSS
ACCS LOC1
Epoch 3 (2006-2011)
AM BISA?
Log C4I?/G1 BISA?
DBL II IOC/DBL II FOC/BOWMAN FO
Bi-SCAIS
UNICOM/EMS
COMMAND BATTLESPACE MANAGEMENT
CASH (SLI/RLI)/EMS
ADCISFCBISA/ IFPA
ASH
BATES
MAKEFAST/EOD BISA
ATacCSATacCS
ACCESSWAH-64 GSS
Epoch 1 (Now - 2008)
CRONOS (IPM only)
JOCS/ComBAT/GP3 (HQ ARRC onlyJOCS/ComBAT/GP3 (HQ ARRC only
BMETS/JOCS/GP3(HQ ARRC only)/RNCSS
ComBAT/GP3 (HQ ARRC only)/JOCS/RNCSS/HVM SIFF/GBA
BMETS/JOCS/BSAM/GP3(HQ ARRC only)/RNCSS/HVM SIFF
ATacCS
StV-3
T R M ’s In te rfac e s V iew
Ap p lica tio n S o ftw a re M IS S IO N AR E A AP P L IC AT IO N S
S E R V IC E A R E A S E R V IC E S T AN D AR D A ll W e b Ap p lic a tio n s In te rfa c e 4 D : (A p p lica tio n to W e b S e rv e r) C o m m o n G a te w a y In te rfa c e
(C G I) 1 .1 , N C S A S o ftw a re D e v elo p m e n t
S U P P O R T AP P L IC A T IO N S S E R V IC E A R E A S E R V IC E S T AN D AR D
In te rfa c e 4 L : H T M L 4 .0 S p e cifica tio n , W 3 C R e c o m m en d atio n (H yp e rte x t M a rk u p L a n g u a g e )
P e rs o n a l M e ss a g in g In te rfa c e 4 D : (E -M a il C lien t to E -M ail S e rve r) IE T F S ta n d a rd 10 /R F C -8 2 1 /R F C -1 86 9 /R F C -1 8 70 S im p le M a il T ra n sfe r P ro to co l (S M T P ) S e rv ice E x te n s io n s , N o v em b e r 1 9 9 5
TV-1 SV-1
,2& )2&
:DWFKN HH SHU
2FW ' H F51&66
% /' &6 6,)/3'5
)D OFRQ,QFUH PHQW$
0D LQ*DWH,QF$,QLWLDO*D WH ,QF%,QF$'0&WW/H W
) LHOG7U LD OV' HOLYHU 7UD QFKH 'H OLYH U7U DQFKH ' HOLYHU 7U DQFKH,QF$,6'
,QF$,6'0DLQ*D WH ,QF%
'H OL YH U7 UD QFKH
' HOLYHU 7U DQFKH' HOLYHU 7UD QFKH
)D OFRQ,QFUH PHQW%
'0&WW/H W
)D OFRQ,QFUH PHQW&
,QLWLD O* D WH ,QF&
)LH OG7ULD OV,QF%' HOLYHU 7UD QFKH' HOLYHU 7UD QFKH' HOLYHU 7UD QFKH' HOLYHU 7U DQFKH' HOLYHU 7UD QFKH'H OLYH U 7UD QFKH
'H OLYH U57768 SJU D GH'H OLYH U 7UD QFKH 'H OLYH U 7UD QFKH
'H OLYH U7U D QFKH
7HFKQR ORJ\UH IU H VKH V
&R U PR U DQW
0 D\,6'
0D \)2&
2FW) 2&
' H F,6'
0D\06$0
- DQ06$0
2FW ' HF0D U9H UVLR Q
'H F9H UVLR Q
0HU JHG&66-2&6"-2&6
&R PPR Q2SH UD WLR QD O&R PPDQG6XSSRU W6\VWHP"
6H S,QF% $VVH VV3 KD VH&WW/H W
$6725
2S7ULD OVDF*6 2S7ULD OVD F*6 %$786WU LD O,6' /LP&5
,2&) XOO&5&WWRU LQWH J WU LDOV
- &6 /R J
3 KD VH,QF3KD VH,QF,2&
)2&) 2&
',,
0D LQ* DWH ,6' ) 2&
%2:0$1
&,3
5$) &&,6
,6' /LWWR UD O25'$025'
( &,32)7 ,&,3WR ',/ )&,3WR' ,/)&%,6$,2&
6WDJH 6WD JH
"
) XOO)&%,6$
/DQG25'%R ZPD Q,2& % RZPD Q,6'&D SD ELOLW\25'&D SDELOLW\% GH 2)7
,2& )2&
:DWFKN HH SHU
2FW ' H F51&66
,2& )2&
:DWFKN HH SHU
2FW ' H F51&66
% /' &6 6,)/3'5
)D OFRQ,QFUH PHQW$
0D LQ*DWH,QF$,QLWLDO*D WH ,QF%,QF$'0&WW/H W
) LHOG7U LD OV' HOLYHU 7UD QFKH 'H OLYH U7U DQFKH ' HOLYHU 7U DQFKH,QF$,6'
,QF$,6'0DLQ*D WH ,QF%
'H OL YH U7 UD QFKH
' HOLYHU 7U DQFKH' HOLYHU 7UD QFKH
% /' &6 6,)/3'5
)D OFRQ,QFUH PHQW$
0D LQ*DWH,QF$,QLWLDO*D WH ,QF%,QF$'0&WW/H W
) LHOG7U LD OV' HOLYHU 7UD QFKH 'H OLYH U7U DQFKH ' HOLYHU 7U DQFKH,QF$,6'
,QF$,6'0DLQ*D WH ,QF%
'H OL YH U7 UD QFKH
' HOLYHU 7U DQFKH' HOLYHU 7UD QFKH
)D OFRQ,QFUH PHQW%
'0&WW/H W
)D OFRQ,QFUH PHQW&
,QLWLD O* D WH ,QF&
)LH OG7ULD OV,QF%' HOLYHU 7UD QFKH' HOLYHU 7UD QFKH' HOLYHU 7UD QFKH' HOLYHU 7U DQFKH' HOLYHU 7UD QFKH'H OLYH U 7UD QFKH
'H OLYH U57768 SJU D GH'H OLYH U 7UD QFKH 'H OLYH U 7UD QFKH
'H OLYH U7U D QFKH
)D OFRQ,QFUH PHQW%
'0&WW/H W
)D OFRQ,QFUH PHQW&
,QLWLD O* D WH ,QF&
)LH OG7ULD OV,QF%' HOLYHU 7UD QFKH' HOLYHU 7UD QFKH' HOLYHU 7UD QFKH' HOLYHU 7U DQFKH' HOLYHU 7UD QFKH'H OLYH U 7UD QFKH
'H OLYH U57768 SJU D GH'H OLYH U 7UD QFKH 'H OLYH U 7UD QFKH
'H OLYH U7U D QFKH
7HFKQR ORJ\UH IU H VKH V
&R U PR U DQW
0 D\,6'
0D \)2&
2FW) 2&
' H F,6'
0D\06$0
- DQ06$0
2FW ' HF0D U9H UVLR Q
'H F9H UVLR Q
0HU JHG&66-2&6"-2&6
&R PPR Q2SH UD WLR QD O&R PPDQG6XSSRU W6\VWHP"
6H S,QF% $VVH VV3 KD VH&WW/H W
7HFKQR ORJ\UH IU H VKH V
&R U PR U DQW
0 D\,6'
0D \)2&
2FW) 2&
' H F,6'
0D\06$0
- DQ06$0
2FW ' HF0D U9H UVLR Q
'H F9H UVLR Q
0HU JHG&66-2&6"-2&6
&R PPR Q2SH UD WLR QD O&R PPDQG6XSSRU W6\VWHP"
6H S,QF% $VVH VV3 KD VH&WW/H W
$6725
2S7ULD OVDF*6 2S7ULD OVD F*6 %$786WU LD O,6' /LP&5
,2&) XOO&5&WWRU LQWH J WU LDOV
- &6 /R J
3 KD VH,QF3KD VH,QF,2&
)2&
$6725
2S7ULD OVDF*6 2S7ULD OVD F*6 %$786WU LD O,6' /LP&5
,2&) XOO&5&WWRU LQWH J WU LDOV
- &6 /R J
3 KD VH,QF3KD VH,QF,2&
)2&) 2&
',,
0D LQ* DWH ,6' ) 2&
%2:0$1
) 2&
',,
0D LQ* DWH ,6' ) 2&
%2:0$1
&,3
5$) &&,6
,6' /LWWR UD O25'$025'
( &,32)7 ,&,3WR ',/ )&,3WR' ,/)&%,6$,2&
6WDJH 6WD JH
"
) XOO)&%,6$
/DQG25'%R ZPD Q,2& % RZPD Q,6'&D SD ELOLW\25'&D SDELOLW\
&,3
5$) &&,6
,6' /LWWR UD O25'$025'
( &,32)7 ,&,3WR ',/ )&,3WR' ,/)&%,6$,2&
6WDJH 6WD JH
"
) XOO)&%,6$
/DQG25'%R ZPD Q,2& % RZPD Q,6'&D SD ELOLW\25'&D SDELOLW\% GH 2)7
AcV-2
Abstraction
AnalysisAnalysisAnalysis
Static AnalysisStatic Analysis Dynamic AnalysisDynamic Analysis ExperimentationExperimentation TrialsTrials
Informs
Validation
Refines
AnswersAnswers
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Example - Capability ManagementExample - Capability Management
StV-2 Capability Functions StV-3 Capability Phasing StV-5 Capability-System Mapping
Define Capability Functions
Inform
Define relationships
Command Battlespace Management
Decision Support Information Management &Acquisition
Effects
1. Operational Planning:• Initiation• Mission Analysis• CCIR & planningguidance• Estimate
- COA - Wargaming• Decision• CONOPS• SoM• Assemble/review Plan• Orders
2. Operational Analysis3. Mission Rehearsal4. Situational Awareness:
• Physical Env• Mission Env• Blue Env• Red Env• White Env• APNLRS• CID
5. Intelligence:• CCIRM• Int Direction• Collection mgt• Collation mgt• All-source fusion• Dissemination
1. Targeting:Target selectionTarget List managementAttack Guidance MatrixTargeting Cycle:
• Detect• Recognise• Identify• Track• Decide• Engage• Assess
2. Plan Engagement:• Effects selection• Resource allocation• Synchronisation
6. Functional PlanningSupport:• Arty Fire planning• Engr Obs planning• Engr Sp planning• EOD planning• AD planning• EW planning• Air planning• Avn planning• CIS planning• Info ops planning• Log planning• Sup• ES• Tpt• Med• Personnel planning
1. Information Management• Information Analysis• Information Fusion• Information Quality
Assurance• Information Dissemination
2. STAR• STAR Asset
Management/Tasking:− STAR asset status
monitoring− Mission planning− Mission control− Sensor cueing
• STAR Product Management:− Product analysis− Collation and fusion− Product Dissemination
3. Conduct Engagement:• Decision• Fires/Mission
Control• BDA• Reporting
Information and Communications Infrastructure
Command Battlespace Management
Decision Support Information Management &Acquisition
Effects
1. Operational Planning:• Initiation• Mission Analysis• CCIR & planningguidance• Estimate
- COA - Wargaming• Decision• CONOPS• SoM• Assemble/review Plan• Orders
2. Operational Analysis3. Mission Rehearsal4. Situational Awareness:
• Physical Env• Mission Env• Blue Env• Red Env• White Env• APNLRS• CID
5. Intelligence:• CCIRM• Int Direction• Collection mgt• Collation mgt• All-source fusion• Dissemination
1. Targeting:Target selectionTarget List managementAttack Guidance MatrixTargeting Cycle:
• Detect• Recognise• Identify• Track• Decide• Engage• Assess
2. Plan Engagement:• Effects selection• Resource allocation• Synchronisation
6. Functional PlanningSupport:• Arty Fire planning• Engr Obs planning• Engr Sp planning• EOD planning• AD planning• EW planning• Air planning• Avn planning• CIS planning• Info ops planning• Log planning• Sup• ES• Tpt• Med• Personnel planning
1. Information Management• Information Analysis• Information Fusion• Information Quality
Assurance• Information Dissemination
2. STAR• STAR Asset
Management/Tasking:− STAR asset status
monitoring− Mission planning− Mission control− Sensor cueing
• STAR Product Management:− Product analysis− Collation and fusion− Product Dissemination
3. Conduct Engagement:• Decision• Fires/Mission
Control• BDA• Reporting
Information and Communications Infrastructure
CAPABILITY FUNCTION
Decision SupportSituational Awareness
CCIRM JOCS (IPM only)/GP3(HQ ARRC only)Op Planning JOCS (IPM only)/GP3(HQ ARRC only)Intelligence JOCS (IPM only)/GP3(HQ ARRC only)
InteroperabilityJoint Strategic Intelligence LOCE MIDB/LOCEOperational Intelligence INT-C INTELWEB?Joint Logisitcs JCS LogNATO C2 & Int NIUTS/NSWANNATO CommsAllied Interoperability MIP Messaging/US-GCCSMaritime RNCSS/LPD(R)/T22/T23/T42/CVS/T45Air C2/Coord RAFCCIS/JFAC
Functional Planning SupportCSS AP3Medical SGISNBC BRACIS/BATESBRACIS NT NBC BISA/BATES NBC BISAGBAD AD BriC IGBAD IOCFire Support FCAAviation C2Aviation Logistics Support ACCESSEngineer/EODComms Management BCMS/CORMORANT CMSIS Management II IOC/II FOC DBL II FOC
InteroperabilityNATO ADAllied Fire Support AFATDS AFATDS II
JTF/ARRC IS JOCS/E-IARRCIS MLI/RNCSSFmn IS BOWMAN IOC/ATacCS/II EOCBG & below IS Platform BISA IOC/FOC/BGTIIn barracks IS DIIUnit IS DIIIndividual IS BOWMAN PUDT, BRAD FIST/BOWMAN PUDT, BRAD
FALCON CMS/BCMS/CORMORANT
CWAN (IPM only?)
JFAC (IPM only)RNCSS/LPD(R)/T22/T23/T42/CVSUS-GCCS (IPM only)
AP3/QP24
IS INFRASTRUCTUREJOCS/E-IARRCIS/RNCSS
Epoch 2 (2004-2007)
JCS Log
JOCS/G2 BISA/GP3 (HQ ARRC only
JOCS/E-IARRCIS MLI/RNCSS
ACCS LOC1
Epoch 3 (2006-2011)
AM BISA?
Log C4I?/G1 BISA?
DBL II IOC/DBL II FOC/BOWMAN FO
Bi-SCAIS
UNICOM/EMS
COMMAND BATTLESPACE MANAGEMENT
CASH (SLI/RLI)/EMS
ADCISFCBISA/IFPA
ASH
BATES
MAKEFAST/EOD BISA
ATacCSATacCS
ACCESSWAH-64 GSS
Epoch 1 (Now - 2008)
CRONOS (IPM only)
JOCS/ComBAT/GP3 (HQ ARRC onlyJOCS/ComBAT/GP3 (HQ ARRC only
BMETS/JOCS/GP3(HQ ARRC only)/RNCSS
ComBAT/GP3 (HQ ARRC only)/JOCS/RNCSS/HVM SIFF/GBA
BMETS/JOCS/BSAM/GP3(HQ ARRC only)/RNCSS/HVM SIFF
ATacCS
→ů₧űΓαźźφź‼
ⁿττ₧Γⁿů↔ź‼Θτű
ůⁿ₧τ‼φŇ
��$%
��$
��%
�$
��&
��$ ���r$#
���$$#��#$
��$$
��$$
���$$#
���$$#
���#&
���$&
�# ��"
Ptarmigan
BOWMAN
Skynet5
���n%%#!���%$"
���n%%#!���%$"
���n%%#!���%$"
���%%
τ
��S&&
'%P�ی�� #%
τ
τ
τ
Ї
��S%&
τ
����$%% ��%
�� $
��%
��S%'
��S%&
��%
��%
��%
��%
��%
����$$&
��S%&
����$%$!
φ├┴║╖ŹŰⁿ
��&
��&
��$&
τ
τ
ŻůδűτσΘŇ
ЌКМύχ
χϊЌϊЄ
�� $
'%$/��ک���#
������%%$% $% $ $��چ�گچ����,&# %
�����&#&%$
������%%$% $% $ $��چ�گچ����,&# %
�����&#&%$
������&$%% $% $ %��چ�گچ����,%# %
�����$$&%$
������&%$% %$!$ %��چ�گچ����,&#!$
�����%#&$%
ЏЁЋЁύЇЌώώό
όχЄωЇІЁΰς
ϋ����%%
ЁЁЁЧПЫКЬЭЫЮМЭЮЫО
ЁЧПЫКЬЭЫЮМЭЮЫО
ϋЁχЊЊωЁЋЁЧ�!�
���� # ��% �� % $%ټ��
��%#
��##
��&"��&&
���% %��#(
��#%%%#��ی�
%#&��چ�
��$&���%%
���%%
��##
$$&��چ�
E3D
RAPTOR
CORMORANT
����(#$
����$ #
��%
��%
����$%$
����#%%
��&$
��&$
��&$
��#%%%#��ی�
��#%$%#��ی�
������� $!##
ЂЇωЋЁЧ� ���%
����$ #
����$ #
ŻůδűτσΘ═┐╔⌠
����#!$
����#!$
����#!$
����#!$
�� #
�� $
�� $
��%
���%%!
���% %��#(
���% %��#(
ژ�� ���ی��������� �� ��)%$&%% #! #$&% %$' %%%$' $%
CRD
Note: example views only – not definitive
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Use Case i – Defensive Ops
CRD
URDs
Inform
Elements described by OVs
Val
idat
ed a
gain
st
OV-2
: NMJIC
: JFC(JOC/JIC) : JFACC(AOC, 609AIS)
: DJFLCC(DOCC, 513ACE)
: MAW
: WOC
6: Target Nominations
1: BDA Reports8: Recommend Restrike
2: Munitions Effects Assessment5: Target Nominations
4: Target Nominations
9: Recommend Restrike
3: Target Nominations
10: Recommend Restrike
7: Target Nominations
11: Recommend Restrike
Needline Identifier
Information Exchange Identifier
Info
rmat
ion
Elem
ent N
ame
And
Iden
tifie
r
Cont
ent D
escr
iptio
n
Mis
sion
/ Sc
enar
io U
JTL
or
MET
L
Lang
uage
Accu
racy
Tran
sact
ion
Type
Trig
gerin
g Ev
ent
Inte
rope
rabi
lity
Leve
l
Send
ing
Op
Node
Nam
e An
d Id
entif
ier
Send
ing
Op
Activ
ity N
ame
And
Iden
tifie
r
Rece
ivin
g O
p No
de N
ame
And
Iden
tifie
r
Rece
ivin
g O
p Ac
tivity
Nam
e An
d Id
entif
ier
1 W OC-AOC BDA Report Report on Battle Damage
Combat Assessment English 1 Day collaborate
Air Strike 072200, 0615am
2A W OCConduct Battle Damage Assessment
AOC Conduct Munitions Effects Asessment
1 W OC-AOC Target Nominations
Report on possible tragets
Combat Assessment English 2 hours direct AitTO XX,
072300 1B W OC Recommend Restrike AOC External Activity
2…
11 MAW-AOC BDA Report Report on Battle Damage
Combat Assessment English 1 Day collaborate
Air Strike 072200, 0615am
2A MAWConduct Battle Damage Assessment
AOC Conduct Munitions Effects Asessment
Nature of TransactionInformation Description Producer Consumer
OV-3ConductSR
Send SR Da ta
Send Ta rget Nominations
Produce/Send BDA Reoprts
Conduct Battle Damage Assessmen t
Assess Enemy Force Effecti veness
Conduct Muni tions Effec ts Assessm en t
Send Co llection Requ i rements
Obtain New Col lections
Start Ac ti vi tie s
Receive BDA Repo rts
A na ly si sR ec omme n d Re s tr ik eMu n iti on s Eff ec ts A s s es s men tB at tle D a mag e As se s s men t
OV-5
: DIA : MAW : WOC : JFACC(AOC, 609AIS)
: JFC(JOC/JIC) : DCCC : JFSOCC : DJFLCC(D...
: F2C2 : JFMCC : NMJIC
Imagery, MISREPs, WSV, Combat Reports
Imagery, MISREPs, WSV, Combat Reports
Target Materials Analysis
Target Materials Analysis
Target Materials Analys is
Collection Requirements
Collection Requirements
OV-6c
Example - Developing User RequirementsExample - Developing User Requirements
Note: example views only – not definitive
OV-1
TV-1 Standards ProfileTRM ’s Interfaces View
Ap plication So ftw are
M ISSIO N ARE A AP PLIC ATIO NS
SERVICE ARE A SERVICE ST AN D ARD
All W eb App licatio ns Interface 4D: (Ap plication to W eb S erver) Com m on G atew ay Interface (CG I) 1.1, NCS A S oftw are Developm ent
S UPPO RT APPL ICAT IO NS SERVICE ARE A SERVICE ST AN D ARD
Interface 4L: HTM L 4.0 Specification, W 3C Recom m endation (Hyp ertext M arkup Lang uage)
Person al M essaging Interface 4D: (E -M ail C lient to E-M ail S erver) IETF Stand ard 10/RF C-821/RF C-1869/RFC-1870 S im ple M ail Transfer Protocol (SM TP ) Service Exten sions, Novem ber 1995
Constrain
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Example - MODAF in Systems AcquisitionExample - MODAF in Systems Acquisition
Operational Activities Assess
Col
lect
Exp
loit
Dec
ide
TCT
Neg
atio
n - P
air
Wea
pon/
Pltf
m/S
nsr t
o Ta
rget
Strike
Rem
ove
from
Tar
get L
ist
Col
lect
Exp
loit
Dec
ide
TCT
Neg
atio
n - P
air
Wea
pon/
Pltf
m/S
nsr t
o Ta
rget
SF#System Functions - 3.0 (Act)
2.2.
1
2.2.
3
2.2.
3.1
2.2.
3.4
2.3
2.4
2.4.
1
2.4.
2
2.4.
3
2.4.
4.4
2.4.
5.5
2.4.
6
3.1.
1
3.1.
5
5.1.
1.1
5.3
3.1 Engagement Execution3.1.1 Direct Attack/Evasive Maneuvers X X3.1.2 Determine Engageability X X3.1.2.1 Develop Intercept Prediction X X3.2 Target Development3.2.1 Employ Targeting Assets X X3.2.1.1 Task/ Re-task Target ing Assets X X3.2.1.1.1 Transmit Tasking and Target Data to Targeting Assets X X X X3.2.2 Designate Target X X3.2.4.1 Determine Target Location X X X X X XHA# Human Activities - 3.0 (Act)
3.1 Assess ISR Cue3.1.1 Determine if cue qualifies as TCT X3.1.2 Determine time latency of cueing X X3.1.3 Compare IMINT cue characteristics against known IMINT data X3.3.4 Compare SIGINT cue characteristics against known SIGINT data X
URDs
SV-5
Map through
SV-1
Define System
Functions
SRDs
Inform
Val
idat
ed
agai
nst
SV-8 System Evolution PlanSV-9 Tech
Forecast
Option Performance Analyses
Trade-Off & COEIA
Input to
,2& )2&
:DWFKNHHSHU
2FW 'HF51&66
%/'&66,)/3'5
)DOFRQ,QFUHPHQW$
0DLQ*DWH,QF$,QLWLDO*D WH,QF%,QF$'0&WW/H W
)LHOG7ULDOV'HOLYHU7UDQFKH 'HOLYHU7UDQFKH 'HOLYHU7UDQFKH,QF$,6'
,QF$,6'0DLQ*DWH,QF%
'HOLYHU7UDQFKH
'HOLYHU7UDQFKH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH
)DOFRQ,QFUHPHQW%
'0&WW/H W
)DOFRQ,QFUHPHQW&
,QLWLDO*D WH,QF&
)LHOG7ULDOV,QF%'HOLYHU7UDQFKH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH
'HOLYHU57768SJUDGH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH 'HOLYHU7UDQFKH
'HOLYHU7UDQFKH
7HFKQRORJ\UHIUHVKHV
&RUPRUDQW
0D\,6'
0D\)2&
2FW)2&
'HF,6'
0D\06$0
-DQ06$0
2FW 'HF0DU9HUVLRQ
'HF9HUVLRQ
0HUJHG&66-2&6"-2&6
&RPPRQ2SHUDWLRQDO&RPPDQG6XSSRU W6\VWHP"
6HS,QF%$VVHVV3KDVH&WW/H W
$6725
2S7ULDOVDF*6 2S7ULDOVDF*6 %$786WULDO,6'/LP&5
,2&)XOO&5&WWRULQ WHJ WULDOV
-&6/RJ
3KDVH,QF3KDVH,QF,2&
)2&)2&
',,
0DLQ*DWH ,6' )2&
%2:0$1
&,3
5$)&&,6
,6' /LWWRUDO25'$025'
(&,32)7 ,&,3WR',/ )&,3WR',/)&%,6$,2&
6WDJH 6WDJH
"
)XOO)&%,6$
/DQG25'%RZPDQ,2& %RZPDQ,6'&DSDELOLW\25'&DSDELOLW\%GH2)7
,2& )2&
:DWFKNHHSHU
2FW 'HF51&66
,2& )2&
:DWFKNHHSHU
2FW 'HF51&66
%/'&66,)/3'5
)DOFRQ,QFUHPHQW$
0DLQ*DWH,QF$,QLWLDO*D WH,QF%,QF$'0&WW/H W
)LHOG7ULDOV'HOLYHU7UDQFKH 'HOLYHU7UDQFKH 'HOLYHU7UDQFKH,QF$,6'
,QF$,6'0DLQ*DWH,QF%
'HOLYHU7UDQFKH
'HOLYHU7UDQFKH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH
%/'&66,)/3'5
)DOFRQ,QFUHPHQW$
0DLQ*DWH,QF$,QLWLDO*D WH,QF%,QF$'0&WW/H W
)LHOG7ULDOV'HOLYHU7UDQFKH 'HOLYHU7UDQFKH 'HOLYHU7UDQFKH,QF$,6'
,QF$,6'0DLQ*DWH,QF%
'HOLYHU7UDQFKH
'HOLYHU7UDQFKH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH
)DOFRQ,QFUHPHQW%
'0&WW/H W
)DOFRQ,QFUHPHQW&
,QLWLDO*D WH,QF&
)LHOG7ULDOV,QF%'HOLYHU7UDQFKH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH
'HOLYHU57768SJUDGH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH 'HOLYHU7UDQFKH
'HOLYHU7UDQFKH
)DOFRQ,QFUHPHQW%
'0&WW/H W
)DOFRQ,QFUHPHQW&
,QLWLDO*D WH,QF&
)LHOG7ULDOV,QF%'HOLYHU7UDQFKH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH
'HOLYHU57768SJUDGH'HOLYHU7UDQFKH 'HOLYHU7UDQFKH
'HOLYHU7UDQFKH
7HFKQRORJ\UHIUHVKHV
&RUPRUDQW
0D\,6'
0D\)2&
2FW)2&
'HF,6'
0D\06$0
-DQ06$0
2FW 'HF0DU9HUVLRQ
'HF9HUVLRQ
0HUJHG&66-2&6"-2&6
&RPPRQ2SHUDWLRQDO&RPPDQG6XSSRU W6\VWHP"
6HS,QF%$VVHVV3KDVH&WW/H W
7HFKQRORJ\UHIUHVKHV
&RUPRUDQW
0D\,6'
0D\)2&
2FW)2&
'HF,6'
0D\06$0
-DQ06$0
2FW 'HF0DU9HUVLRQ
'HF9HUVLRQ
0HUJHG&66-2&6"-2&6
&RPPRQ2SHUDWLRQDO&RPPDQG6XSSRU W6\VWHP"
6HS,QF%$VVHVV3KDVH&WW/H W
$6725
2S7ULDOVDF*6 2S7ULDOVDF*6 %$786WULDO,6'/LP&5
,2&)XOO&5&WWRULQ WHJ WULDOV
-&6/RJ
3KDVH,QF3KDVH,QF,2&
)2&
$6725
2S7ULDOVDF*6 2S7ULDOVDF*6 %$786WULDO,6'/LP&5
,2&)XOO&5&WWRULQ WHJ WULDOV
-&6/RJ
3KDVH,QF3KDVH,QF,2&
)2&)2&
',,
0DLQ*DWH ,6' )2&
%2:0$1
)2&
',,
0DLQ*DWH ,6' )2&
%2:0$1
&,3
5$)&&,6
,6' /LWWRUDO25'$025'
(&,32)7 ,&,3WR',/ )&,3WR',/)&%,6$,2&
6WDJH 6WDJH
"
)XOO)&%,6$
/DQG25'%RZPDQ,2& %RZPDQ,6'&DSDELOLW\25'&DSDELOLW\
&,3
5$)&&,6
,6' /LWWRUDO25'$025'
(&,32)7 ,&,3WR',/ )&,3WR',/)&%,6$,2&
6WDJH 6WDJH
"
)XOO)&%,6$
/DQG25'%RZPDQ,2& %RZPDQ,6'&DSDELOLW\25'&DSDELOLW\%GH2)7
AcV-2 Programme Plan & Technology Route map
TV-1 Tech Standards Profile
Con
stra
ins
Basis for
Constrains
Basis for
+ 1 yr + 3 yrs + 5 yrs + 7 yrs + 10 yrs
V 0.1 V 0.2 V 1.0 V 1.5 V 2.0
RobustAdaptive DistributedSystem
StovepipeLegacySystems
Block II Upgrades
Phase I, Version 2
Block I Upgrades
Phase I Integration
Phase II Integration
TECHNOLOGY FORECASTS TRM
TECHNOLOGY
CATEGORY
SHORT TERM
(1 year)
MID TERM
(3 years)
LONG TERM
(5 years)
Application Software
Support Applications Microsoft Office 2000 available (for Windows 2000)
Microsoft Office 2000 stable enough for full scale implementation
Microsoft Office available for Linux
E-mail on wireless PDAs commonplace
Application Platform
Data Management Oracle 9i available
MySQL (Open Source DBMS) available
Operating System Next MS Windows desktop upgrade expected
Next Red Hat Linux major release expected
Next MS Windows server upgrade expected
Physical Environment Intel IA-64 becomes standard processor for desktops
Initial use of quantum computing technologies
SV-6
P ta rm ig an
FALCON
BOWMAN
CORMORANT
SKYNET5
C IP
MIP
FCB ISA
NBCB ISA
ADBR IC
MAKFAS T
DS1(AP3 )
DS 1(GP 3)
DS1(QP2 4)
TACYS IS
RNCS S
RAFCC IS
J OCS
ARRCC 2IS
DII
DS 1(AT acCS )
WAH6 4
J CSL og
SOOTHSAYER
ASTOR
WATCHKE EP ER
COBRA
MAMBA
GRAP(L in kS ys t em s)
CAST
T ES
OGD
NGO s
C iv i lia n
C o m m s S y s te m s P t a r m i g a n Y Y ? Y Y Y Y Y ? ? ? ? Y ?F A L C O N Y Y Y Y Y ? ? ? Y Y Y ? ? Y ? ? ? ? ? ? ?B O W M A N Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ? Y Y Y Y ? Y Y Y Y YC O R M O R A N T Y Y Y Y Y ? Y Y Y Y Y ? ? ? Y Y ?S K Y N E T 5 ? Y Y Y ? ? Y Y Y Y Y ? ?
In f r a s t r u c tu re C I P Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ? Y ? Y Y Y Y ? ? Y Y YM I P Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
B IS A s F C B I S A Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ? ? Y Y YN B C B I S A Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ? ? ? ? ?A D B R I C Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?M A K F A S T Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ? ? ? ?D S 1 ( A P 3 ) Y Y Y YD S 1 ( G P 3 ) Y Y Y YD S 1 ( Q P 2 4 ) Y Y Y YT A C Y S I S ? Y Y Y Y Y Y Y
C o m m a n d S u p p o rtS y s t e m s
R N C S S Y Y Y Y Y ? Y ? ? ? Y Y ? Y ?
R A F C C IS Y Y Y Y Y ? ? ? ? Y Y ? Y ? ? ?J O C S ? Y Y Y Y ? ? ? ? Y Y ? YA R R C C 2 I S ? ? Y Y Y Y ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? Y ? ?D I I ? ? Y Y Y Y Y Y Y ?D S 1 ( A T a c C S ) Y Y ? Y Y Y YW A H 6 4J C S L o g ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
S e n s o r s S O O T H S A Y E R ? Y ? Y Y ? ? ? ? ?A S T O R ? Y Y ? Y Y ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?W A T C H K E E P E R ? Y Y Y Y ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?C O B R A ? ? Y Y ? ? ? ? ?M A M B A ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?G R A P (L in k S y st e m s ) ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
T ra in in g S y s te m s C A S T Y YT E S Y Y
O t h e r s O G D Y Y YN G O s Y Y YC i l i l ia n Y Y Y
SV-3
SV-7
T R M ’s In terfaces V iew Ap p lica tio n S o ftw are
M IS S IO N AR E A AP P L IC AT IO N S
S E R V IC E AR E A S E R V IC E S T AN D AR D All W eb Ap p lica tio n s In terface 4D : (Ap p lica tio n to W eb S erver) C o m m o n G a tew ay In terface
(C G I) 1 .1 , N C S A S o ftw are D eve lo p m en t S U P P O R T AP P L IC AT IO N S
S E R V IC E AR E A S E R V IC E S T AN D AR D
In terface 4L: H T M L 4 .0 S p ec ifica tio n , W 3C R ecom m en d ation (H yp ertex t M arku p L an g u ag e)
P erso n a l M essag in g In terface 4D : (E -M ail C lien t to E -M ail S erver) IE T F S tan d ard 10 /R F C -821 /R F C -1 869 /R F C -1870 S im p le M ail T ran sfer P ro to co l (S M TP ) S erv ice E xten s io n s , N o v em b er 1995
OVs
Provides requirements for
Note: example views only – not definitive
SV-4
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
OV-5
P2 Establish Solution
Specification
P1 Manage the Defence Logistics Enterprise
External Context
O/P 1
O/P 2
O/P 3
Through Life
Logistics Processes
Example - Logistics ProcessExample - Logistics Process
P3 Materiel Provision
Traditional Logistics Processes
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Broader Logistics ContextBroader Logistics Context
P2 Establish Solution
Specification
P1 Manage the Defence Logistics Enterprise
External Context
O/P 1
O/P 2
O/P 3P3 Materiel Provision
OV-5
What
Who
SCOTS DG 2 RTR 1 RRF 1 BW
7 Armd Bde
HQ 1 (UK) Armd Div
SCOTS DG 2 RTR 1 RRF 1 BW
7 Armd Bde
HQ 1 (UK) Armd Div
OV-4
Needline Identifier
Information Exchange Identifier
Info
rmat
ion
Elem
ent N
ame
And
Iden
tifie
r
Cont
ent D
escr
iptio
n
Mis
sion
/ Sc
enar
io U
JTL
or
MET
L
Lang
uage
Accu
racy
Tran
sact
ion
Type
Trig
gerin
g Ev
ent
Inte
rope
rabi
lity
Leve
l
Send
ing
Op
Node
Nam
e An
d Id
entif
ier
Send
ing
Op
Activ
ity N
ame
And
Iden
tifie
r
Rece
ivin
g O
p No
de N
ame
And
Iden
tifie
r
Rece
ivin
g O
p Ac
tivity
Nam
e An
d Id
entif
ier
1 W OC-AOC BDA Report Report on Battle Damage
Combat Assessment English 1 Day collaborate
Air Strike 072200, 0615am
2A W OCConduct Battle Damage Assessment
AOC Conduct Munitions Effects Asessment
1 W OC-AOC Target Nominations
Report on possible tragets
Combat Assessment English 2 hours direct AitTO XX,
072300 1B W OC Recommend Restrike AOC External Activity
2…
11 MAW-AOC BDA Report Report on Battle Damage
Combat Assessment English 1 Day collaborate
Air Strike 072200, 0615am
2A MAWConduct Battle Damage Assessment
AOC Conduct Munitions Effects Asessment
Nature of TransactionInformation Description Producer Consumer
OV-3
InformationOV-2 : NMJIC
: JFC(JOC/JIC) : JFACC(AOC, 609AIS)
: DJFLCC(DOCC, 513ACE)
: MAW
: WOC
6: Target Nominations
1: BDA Reports8: Recommend Restrike
2: Munitions Effects Assessment5: Target Nominations
4: Target Nominations
9: Recommend Restrike
3: Target Nominations
10: Recommend Restrike
7: Target Nominations
11: Recommend Restrike
How
TV-1
Constraints
• DEF STAN 00-60• SCOR• ISO data standards• JSP 400 series• JSP 600 series• …
OV-1
Where
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Broader Architectural ContextBroader Architectural ContextNew Mil
CapabilityLogistics Fight
BMSProcess
ApplicationsLA Architecture BISA Arch.
Network & Comms
DFN Sat BII
PlatformsT45PJHQ FRES
InfrastructureDII Architecture Bowman Arch.
Logistics Operational Architecture
P2 Establish Solution
Specification
P1 Manage the Defence Logistics Enterprise
External Context
O/P 1
O/P 2
O/P 3P3 Materiel Provision
OV-5What
Who
SCOTS DG 2 RTR 1 RRF 1 BW
7 Armd Bde
HQ 1 (UK) Armd Div
SCOTS DG 2 RTR 1 RRF 1 BW
7 Armd Bde
HQ 1 (UK) Armd Div
OV-4Who
SCOTS DG 2 RTR 1 RRF 1 BW
7 Armd Bde
HQ 1 (UK) Armd Div
SCOTS DG 2 RTR 1 RRF 1 BW
7 Armd Bde
HQ 1 (UK) Armd Div
OV-4Needline Ident ifier
Informat ion Exchange Identifier
Info
rmat
ion
Elem
ent N
ame
And
Iden
tifie
r
Con
tent
Des
crip
tion
Mis
sion
/ Sc
enar
io U
JTL
or
MET
L
Lang
uage
Accu
racy
Tran
sact
ion
Type
Trig
gerin
g Ev
ent
Inte
rope
rabi
lity
Leve
l
Send
ing
Op
Node
Nam
e An
d Id
entif
ier
Sen
ding
Op
Act
ivity
Nam
e A
nd Id
entif
ier
Rece
ivin
g O
p N
ode
Nam
e A
nd Id
entif
ier
Rece
ivin
g O
p Ac
tivity
Nam
e A
nd Id
entif
ier
1 WOC-A OC BDA Repor t Report on Battle Damage
Com bat Assessmen t English 1 Day collaborate
Air Str ike 07 2200, 06 15am
2A W OCConduct B attle Dam age Assessment
AOC Conduct Munitions E ffects A sessmen t
1 WOC-A OC Target Nom ination s
Report on possible tragets
Com bat Assessmen t English 2 hours direct AitTO X X,
07 2300 1B W OC Recom men d Restrike AOC E xternal Activity
2…
11 MA W -A OC BDA Repor t Report on Battle Damage
Com bat Assessmen t English 1 Day collaborate
Air Str ike 07 2200, 06 15am
2A M AWConduct B attle Dam age Assessment
AOC Conduct Munitions E ffects A sessmen t
Nature of Tr ansactionInform ation Descr ipt ion Producer Consumer
OV-3Information
Needline Ident ifier
Informat ion Exchange Identifier
Info
rmat
ion
Elem
ent N
ame
And
Iden
tifie
r
Con
tent
Des
crip
tion
Mis
sion
/ Sc
enar
io U
JTL
or
MET
L
Lang
uage
Accu
racy
Tran
sact
ion
Type
Trig
gerin
g Ev
ent
Inte
rope
rabi
lity
Leve
l
Send
ing
Op
Node
Nam
e An
d Id
entif
ier
Sen
ding
Op
Act
ivity
Nam
e A
nd Id
entif
ier
Rece
ivin
g O
p N
ode
Nam
e A
nd Id
entif
ier
Rece
ivin
g O
p Ac
tivity
Nam
e A
nd Id
entif
ier
1 WOC-A OC BDA Repor t Report on Battle Damage
Com bat Assessmen t English 1 Day collaborate
Air Str ike 07 2200, 06 15am
2A W OCConduct B attle Dam age Assessment
AOC Conduct Munitions E ffects A sessmen t
1 WOC-A OC Target Nom ination s
Report on possible tragets
Com bat Assessmen t English 2 hours direct AitTO X X,
07 2300 1B W OC Recom men d Restrike AOC E xternal Activity
2…
11 MA W -A OC BDA Repor t Report on Battle Damage
Com bat Assessmen t English 1 Day collaborate
Air Str ike 07 2200, 06 15am
2A M AWConduct B attle Dam age Assessment
AOC Conduct Munitions E ffects A sessmen t
Nature of Tr ansactionInform ation Descr ipt ion Producer Consumer
OV-3Information
OV-2 : NMJIC
: JFC(JOC/JIC) : JFACC(AOC, 609AIS)
: DJFLCC(DOCC, 513ACE)
: MAW
: WOC
6: Target Nominations
1: BDA Reports8: Recommend Restrike
2: Munitions Effects Assessment5: Target Nominations
4: Target Nominations
9: Recommend Restrike
3: Target Nominations
10: Recommend Restrike
7: Target Nominations
11: Recommend Restrike
HowOV-2 : NMJIC
: JFC(JOC/JIC) : JFACC(AOC, 609AIS)
: DJFLCC(DOCC, 513ACE)
: MAW
: WOC
6: Target Nominations
1: BDA Reports8: Recommend Restrike
2: Munitions Effects Assessment5: Target Nominations
4: Target Nominations
9: Recommend Restrike
3: Target Nominations
10: Recommend Restrike
7: Target Nominations
11: Recommend Restrike
How
TV-1Constraints
• DEF STAN 00-60• SCOR• ISO data standards• JSP 400 series• JSP 600 series• …
TV-1Constraints
• DEF STAN 00-60• SCOR• ISO data standards• JSP 400 series• JSP 600 series• …
OV-1Where
OV-1Where
Enterprise Architecture
Developing the MOD Architectural Framework
Architecture Development ProcessArchitecture Development Process
OrganisationType
Environment
could becomposed of
Cadre Role
Ta skMissionType
Proces s
Activity
InformationService
Run TimeApplication
Softwa reComponent
Run-TimeEnvironment
SoftwareCompone nt
RTEStorageService
RTEProce ssing
Service
RTECommunication
ServiceRTE I/OService
Run-time Environment Service
HardwareS tora ge
Ca pa bility
Hardwa reProcessingCapabil ity
HardwareCommunications
Capa bility
Hardwa re I/OCapabil ity
Hardware Capability
HardwareComponent
CommunicationsMedium
NetworkCompone nt
Pla tform
wo uld dependon completion
o f
couldcontain
individualswho be long
to a
could becomposed of
could requireindividuals to
perfo rm
could bea chieved bycarrying out
could beco mposed of
co uldconsist of
co uld berequired toperform an
could use
would bequalified to
carry out/use
could need toma ke use of
co uld beco mposed of
would bequal ified
toperform
could invoke
co ulddepen d on
could be used to allowcommun ication over
could becompose d of
could becomposed of
couldinvoke co uld be
hosted on
could beprovided b y
cou ld beprovided by
could beprovided
by
could becarried on
could beuse d in
could providecommu nications in
couldp rovide aninterf ace to
could be usedto providehardware
connectivity to
cou ld makeuse of
could becomposed of
could ha veuse of
could haveuse of
cou ldopera te in
could becarried on
could becomp ose d of
InformationSystem
may contain
may contain
may contain
Information
may require
Location
Has an
could bedep loyed at a
Policy Standards
Constra in ts
MoD Ente rp rise
constrain theope rat ion of
Stak eholder
Needs Requirements
Project Team Activitiy Changes acros srelevant LODs
Funding
Refer to
hasexpressed as
appoin ts a
se cures p rovid esresource for
works to the
condu cts to delive r
sat isfied by
Change Delivery
constrain t heoperation of
d eliverch anges
to
MoD Enterprise ReferenceModelDra ft 0.2
30 th March 2004
MODAF
• Methodology• Views
• Arch objects• Lexicon
Ent. Ref ModelObject Taxonomy
ConstructionConstructionPrinciplesPrinciples
Architectural Framework
MoD ArchitecturalRepository
Query / Query / PublishPublish
Architecture
New MilCapability
Logistics Fight
BMSProcess
ApplicationsLA Architecture BISA Arch.
ApplicationsLA Architecture BISA Arch.
Network & CommsDFN Sat BII
Network & CommsDFN Sat BII
PlatformsT45PJHQ FRES
PlatformsT45PJHQ FRES
InfrastructureDII Architecture Bowman Arch.
InfrastructureDII Architecture Bowman Arch.
Logistics Operational Architecture
P2 Establish Solution
Specification
P1 Manage the Defence Logistics Enterprise
External Context
O/P 1
O/P 2
O/P 3P3 Materiel Provision
OV-5What
Who
SCOTS DG 2 RTR 1 RRF 1 BW
7 Armd Bde
HQ 1 (UK) Armd Div
SCOTS DG 2 RTR 1 RRF 1 BW
7 Armd Bde
HQ 1 (UK) Armd Div
OV-4Who
SCOTS DG 2 RTR 1 RRF 1 BW
7 Armd Bde
HQ 1 (UK) Armd Div
SCOTS DG 2 RTR 1 RRF 1 BW
7 Armd Bde
HQ 1 (UK) Armd Div
OV-4Needlin e Ident ifier
Info rm ation Exch ange Identifier
Info
rmati
on E
lem
ent N
ame
And
Iden
tifier
Cont
ent D
escr
iptio
n
Mis
sion
/ Sc
enar
io U
JTL
or
METL
Lang
uage
Accu
racy
Tran
sact
ion T
ype
Trig
gerin
g Eve
nt
Inte
rope
rabi
lity L
evel
Send
ing
Op N
ode
Name
And
Id
entif
ier
Send
ing
Op
Activ
ity N
ame
And
Iden
tifie
r
Rece
iving
Op N
ode
Nam
e An
d Ide
ntifi
er
Rece
iving
Op
Activ
ity N
ame
And
Iden
tifie
r
1 W OC-A OC BDA Repor tReport on B attle Dam age
Com bat A ss ess m en t E ng lish 1 Day c ol labora te
A ir Str ik e 072200, 0615am
2A W O CConduct B attle Dam age A ss ess m ent
AO CConduct M un itions E ffects A sess m ent
1 W OC-A OC Tar get Nom inations
Report on pos sib le tragets
Com bat A ss ess m en t
E ng lish 2 hour s d i rect A itTO X X, 072300
1B W O C Recom m end Restr ik e
AO C E xterna l A ctivi ty
2…
11 MA W -A OC BDA Repor tReport on B attle Dam age
Com bat A ss ess m en t E ng lish 1 Day c ol labora te
A ir Str ik e 072200, 0615am
2A M A WConduct B attle Dam age A ss ess m ent
AO CConduct M un itions E ffects A sess m ent
Nature of T ransactionInfo rm ation Descr iption Prod ucer Consum er
OV-3Information
Needlin e Ident ifier
Info rm ation Exch ange Identifier
Info
rmati
on E
lem
ent N
ame
And
Iden
tifier
Cont
ent D
escr
iptio
n
Mis
sion
/ Sc
enar
io U
JTL
or
METL
Lang
uage
Accu
racy
Tran
sact
ion T
ype
Trig
gerin
g Eve
nt
Inte
rope
rabi
lity L
evel
Send
ing
Op N
ode
Name
And
Id
entif
ier
Send
ing
Op
Activ
ity N
ame
And
Iden
tifie
r
Rece
iving
Op N
ode
Nam
e An
d Ide
ntifi
er
Rece
iving
Op
Activ
ity N
ame
And
Iden
tifie
r
1 W OC-A OC BDA Repor tReport on B attle Dam age
Com bat A ss ess m en t E ng lish 1 Day c ol labora te
A ir Str ik e 072200, 0615am
2A W O CConduct B attle Dam age A ss ess m ent
AO CConduct M un itions E ffects A sess m ent
1 W OC-A OC Tar get Nom inations
Report on pos sib le tragets
Com bat A ss ess m en t
E ng lish 2 hour s d i rect A itTO X X, 072300
1B W O C Recom m end Restr ik e
AO C E xterna l A ctivi ty
2…
11 MA W -A OC BDA Repor tReport on B attle Dam age
Com bat A ss ess m en t E ng lish 1 Day c ol labora te
A ir Str ik e 072200, 0615am
2A M A WConduct B attle Dam age A ss ess m ent
AO CConduct M un itions E ffects A sess m ent
Nature of T ransactionInfo rm ation Descr iption Prod ucer Consum er
OV-3Information
OV-2 : NMJIC
: JFC(JOC/JIC) : JFACC(AOC, 609AIS)
: DJFLCC(DOCC, 513ACE)
: MAW
: WOC
6: Target Nominations
1: BDA Reports8: Recommend Restrike
2: Munitions Effects Assessment5: Target Nominations
4: Target Nominations
9: Recommend Restr ike
3: Target Nominations
10: Recommend Restrike
7: Target Nominations
11: Recommend Restrike
HowOV-2 : NMJIC
: JFC(JOC/JIC) : JFACC(AOC, 609AIS)
: DJFLCC(DOCC, 513ACE)
: MAW
: WOC
6: Target Nominations
1: BDA Reports8: Recommend Restrike
2: Munitions Effects Assessment5: Target Nominations
4: Target Nominations
9: Recommend Restr ike
3: Target Nominations
10: Recommend Restrike
7: Target Nominations
11: Recommend Restrike
How
TV-1Constraints
• DEF STAN 00-60• SCOR• ISO data standards• JSP 400 series• JSP 600 series• …
TV-1Constraints
• DEF STAN 00-60• SCOR• ISO data standards• JSP 400 series• JSP 600 series• …
OV-1Where
OV-1Where
Logistics Operational Architecture
P2 Establish Solution
Specification
P1 Manage the Defence Logistics Enterprise
External Context
O/P 1
O/P 2
O/P 3P3 Materiel Provision
OV-5What
Who
SCOTS DG 2 RTR 1 RRF 1 BW
7 Armd Bde
HQ 1 (UK) Armd Div
SCOTS DG 2 RTR 1 RRF 1 BW
7 Armd Bde
HQ 1 (UK) Armd Div
OV-4Who
SCOTS DG 2 RTR 1 RRF 1 BW
7 Armd Bde
HQ 1 (UK) Armd Div
SCOTS DG 2 RTR 1 RRF 1 BW
7 Armd Bde
HQ 1 (UK) Armd Div
OV-4Needlin e Ident ifier
Info rm ation Exch ange Identifier
Info
rmati
on E
lem
ent N
ame
And
Iden
tifier
Cont
ent D
escr
iptio
n
Mis
sion
/ Sc
enar
io U
JTL
or
METL
Lang
uage
Accu
racy
Tran
sact
ion T
ype
Trig
gerin
g Eve
nt
Inte
rope
rabi
lity L
evel
Send
ing
Op N
ode
Name
And
Id
entif
ier
Send
ing
Op
Activ
ity N
ame
And
Iden
tifie
r
Rece
iving
Op N
ode
Nam
e An
d Ide
ntifi
er
Rece
iving
Op
Activ
ity N
ame
And
Iden
tifie
r
1 W OC-A OC BDA Repor tReport on B attle Dam age
Com bat A ss ess m en t E ng lish 1 Day c ol labora te
A ir Str ik e 072200, 0615am
2A W O CConduct B attle Dam age A ss ess m ent
AO CConduct M un itions E ffects A sess m ent
1 W OC-A OC Tar get Nom inations
Report on pos sib le tragets
Com bat A ss ess m en t
E ng lish 2 hour s d i rect A itTO X X, 072300
1B W O C Recom m end Restr ik e
AO C E xterna l A ctivi ty
2…
11 MA W -A OC BDA Repor tReport on B attle Dam age
Com bat A ss ess m en t E ng lish 1 Day c ol labora te
A ir Str ik e 072200, 0615am
2A M A WConduct B attle Dam age A ss ess m ent
AO CConduct M un itions E ffects A sess m ent
Nature of T ransactionInfo rm ation Descr iption Prod ucer Consum er
OV-3Information
Needlin e Ident ifier
Info rm ation Exch ange Identifier
Info
rmati
on E
lem
ent N
ame
And
Iden
tifier
Cont
ent D
escr
iptio
n
Mis
sion
/ Sc
enar
io U
JTL
or
METL
Lang
uage
Accu
racy
Tran
sact
ion T
ype
Trig
gerin
g Eve
nt
Inte
rope
rabi
lity L
evel
Send
ing
Op N
ode
Name
And
Id
entif
ier
Send
ing
Op
Activ
ity N
ame
And
Iden
tifie
r
Rece
iving
Op N
ode
Nam
e An
d Ide
ntifi
er
Rece
iving
Op
Activ
ity N
ame
And
Iden
tifie
r
1 W OC-A OC BDA Repor tReport on B attle Dam age
Com bat A ss ess m en t E ng lish 1 Day c ol labora te
A ir Str ik e 072200, 0615am
2A W O CConduct B attle Dam age A ss ess m ent
AO CConduct M un itions E ffects A sess m ent
1 W OC-A OC Tar get Nom inations
Report on pos sib le tragets
Com bat A ss ess m en t
E ng lish 2 hour s d i rect A itTO X X, 072300
1B W O C Recom m end Restr ik e
AO C E xterna l A ctivi ty
2…
11 MA W -A OC BDA Repor tReport on B attle Dam age
Com bat A ss ess m en t E ng lish 1 Day c ol labora te
A ir Str ik e 072200, 0615am
2A M A WConduct B attle Dam age A ss ess m ent
AO CConduct M un itions E ffects A sess m ent
Nature of T ransactionInfo rm ation Descr iption Prod ucer Consum er
OV-3Information
OV-2 : NMJIC
: JFC(JOC/JIC) : JFACC(AOC, 609AIS)
: DJFLCC(DOCC, 513ACE)
: MAW
: WOC
6: Target Nominations
1: BDA Reports8: Recommend Restrike
2: Munitions Effects Assessment5: Target Nominations
4: Target Nominations
9: Recommend Restr ike
3: Target Nominations
10: Recommend Restrike
7: Target Nominations
11: Recommend Restrike
HowOV-2 : NMJIC
: JFC(JOC/JIC) : JFACC(AOC, 609AIS)
: DJFLCC(DOCC, 513ACE)
: MAW
: WOC
6: Target Nominations
1: BDA Reports8: Recommend Restrike
2: Munitions Effects Assessment5: Target Nominations
4: Target Nominations
9: Recommend Restr ike
3: Target Nominations
10: Recommend Restrike
7: Target Nominations
11: Recommend Restrike
How
TV-1Constraints
• DEF STAN 00-60• SCOR• ISO data standards• JSP 400 series• JSP 600 series• …
TV-1Constraints
• DEF STAN 00-60• SCOR• ISO data standards• JSP 400 series• JSP 600 series• …
OV-1Where
OV-1Where