THINK ARMENIAN CLAIMS ARE TRUE? THINK AGAIN….

4
A COMPLEX, POLITICAL WITCH HUNT… The first claim of an “Armenian Genocide” surfaced in 1965, 50 years after the alleged event, when Soviet Union instigated Armenia to hurt the Republic of Turkey, a member of NATO and a staunch ally of the US during Cold War? (1) Armenian sources note that the Russian army forcibly relocated about 300,000 Armenians during WW I, half of whom perished during the process. Why haven’t Armenians accused Russia of ethnic cleansing? (2) At the end of WW I, Britain gained full control of major Turkish cities, including Istanbul, the capital of the Ottoman Empire, and conducted an exhaustive investigation of Ottoman archives to substantiate the Armenians’ claim; the 2-year search yielded no evidence that could withstand the scrutiny of a court room, resulting in the release of all 144 Turkish detainees on the island of Malta without trial; hence the Malta Tribunal of 1919-1921 was abandoned before it could start (3) The main piece of evidence for the genocide claim – the Blue Book – was found to be a compilation of notes from Armenian revolutionaries and crusaders. (4) …WHERE DEBATE IS STILL NOT PERMITTED In 2003, the Viennese Armenian Turkish (VAT) Platform - was created to be an independent, mediated review committee, but the Armenian side inexplicably left the table immediately after the first 100 documents were exchanged between parties. (6) As of 2015, Turkish archives are open to global research & scrutiny but the Republic of Armenia, as well as the ARF, refuse to open their archives, one of which is located in Massachusetts. (7) Reports are being freely circulated in the United States that the Turks massacred thousands of Armenians in the Caucasus. Such reports are repeated so many times it makes my blood boil. The Near East Relief have the reports from Yarrow and our own American people which show that such Armenian reports are absolutely false. The circulation of such false reports in the United States, without refutation, is an outrage and is certainly doing the Armenians more harm than good. … Why not tell the truth about the Armenians in every way? Admiral Mark L. Bristol, U.S. Ambassador to the Rep. of Turkey 1920 – 1926, March 28, 1921 letter to the post It would seem as if an Armenian insurrection to help the Russians had broken out at Van. Thus a former deputy here, one Pastormadjian who had assisted our proposed railway concessions some years ago, is now supposed to be fighting the Turks with a legion of Armenian volunteers. These insurgents are said to be in possession of a part of Van and to be conducting guerilla warfare…. Their [Armenian insurgents’] numbers have been variously estimated but none puts them at less than ten thousand and twenty-five thousand is probably close to the truth US Ambassador to the Ottoman Empire, Henry Morgenthau, Sr., to the US Secretary of State, May 25, 1915. VIOLENT ARMENIAN UPRISING “It is a well- known fact that even in the last war the native Christians [mostly Armenians], despite the Turkish cautions, armed themselves and fought on the side of the Allies. In these conflicts, they were not idle, but they were well supplied with artillery, machine guns and inflicted heavy losses on their enemies….” George Lamsa, missionary (10) “...When Turkey had not yet entered the war...Armenian volunteer groups began to be organized in Trans Caucasia… the Dashnagtzoutune actively helped the organization of the aforementioned [Armenian rebel] groups, and especially arming them, against Turkey. In the Fall of 1914, Armenian volunteer groups were formed and fought against the Turks...Hovhannes Katchaznouni, First Prime Minister of the Independent Armenian Republic (11) During the Van rebellion conducted by the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (ARF) members and affiliates between April 18-May 19, 1915, 194,000 Muslims, mostly Turks, were killed or perished (62% of Van’s Muslim population) (12) In 1914 alone, Armenians killed approximately 120,000 Turks in Eastern Anatolia (which equated to 0.8% of the Ottoman Turkish population at the time). What would the US Gov’t do if 2.5 million of its citizens were killed by an internal threat? (13) (Photo source: Houshamatyan of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, Centennial, Album-Atlas, Vol. I, Epic Battles, 1890-1914, pg. 185 and 231) THINK ARMENIAN CLAIMS ARE TRUE? THINK AGAIN…. PAST QUOTES FROM THE FIELD DON’T LIE HARMONIOUS HISTORY, NOT HATRED Turks and Armenians lived in harmonious cohabitation for a millennium. (Yes, that is 1,000 years!) (16) Armenians held critical positions in the Ottoman Government throughout its history including WW I. For example, between 1908 and 1913, Gabriel Noradunkian, an Armenian, served as the Minister of Commerce and Foreign Affairs of the Ottoman Empire. (17) 350-400 thousand Armenians in Western Anatolia – including the vast majority of the 160,000 Armenians who lived in Istanbul- remained in their homes during WW I. (18) In 1915-1916, the Ottoman Government courts martial prosecuted & convicted many Turks- some of whom received the death penalty- for individual mistreatment of Armenians. (19) “The Court also agrees with [Perincek] that ‘genocide’ is a clearly defined legal concept… Genocide is therefore a very narrow legal con- cept which, moreover, is difficult to prove. The Court is not satisfied that the ‘general consen- sus’ to which the Swiss courts referred as a ba- sis for the applicant’s conviction can be relied on in relation to these very specific points of law. The Court therefore considers that the method used by the domestic courts to secure the applicant’s conviction was questionable” – European Court of Human Rights Judgment, Case of Perincek v. Switzerland ref. conviction ONLY THE COURTS CAN DETERMINE GENOCIDE NOT PUBLIC OPINION of Dogu Perincek for having stated publicly that the Armenian genocide was an inter- national lie. (8) The International Court of Justice (which the US, Armenia and Turkey are party to per Article 9 of the UN Genocide Convention) - in its verdict for the Bosnia v. Serbia case - concluded that the crime of genocide must be proven with conclusive evidence and “dolus specialis” that offers high level of certainty appropriate to the seriousness of the allegation, yet no such document exists to prove the Armenian claim. (9) April 2015 69 expert scholars came together to publish an ad on NY Times addressed to the US Congress stressing that the term “Armenian Genocide” is not ac- curate, and the events were rather “inter-communal warfare between Chris- tian and Muslim irregulars. (5) Armenian Military Academy Armenian Weapon Smuggling Routes

Transcript of THINK ARMENIAN CLAIMS ARE TRUE? THINK AGAIN….

Page 1: THINK ARMENIAN CLAIMS ARE TRUE? THINK AGAIN….

A COMPLEX, POLITICAL WITCH HUNT…� The �rst claim of an “Armenian Genocide”

surfaced in 1965, 50 years after the alleged event, when Soviet Union instigated Armenia to hurt the Republic of Turkey, a member of NATO and a staunch ally of the US during Cold War? (1)

� Armenian sources note that the Russian army forcibly relocated about 300,000 Armenians during WW I, half of whom perished during the process. Why haven’t Armenians accused Russia of ethnic cleansing? (2)

� At the end of WW I, Britain gained full control of major Turkish cities, including Istanbul, the capital of the Ottoman Empire, and conducted an exhaustive investigation of Ottoman archives to substantiate the Armenians’ claim; the 2-year search yielded no evidence that could withstand the scrutiny of a court room, resulting in the release of all 144 Turkish detainees on the island of Malta without trial; hence the Malta Tribunal of 1919-1921 was abandoned before it could start (3)

� The main piece of evidence for the genocide claim – the Blue Book – was found to be a compilation of notes from Armenian revolutionaries and crusaders. (4)

…WHERE DEBATE IS STILL NOT PERMITTED� In 2003, the Viennese Armenian Turkish

(VAT) Platform - was created to be an independent, mediated review committee, but the Armenian side inexplicably left the table immediately after the �rst 100 documents were exchanged between

parties. (6)

� As of 2015, Turkish archives are open to global research & scrutiny but the Republic of Armenia, as well as the ARF, refuse to open their archives, one of which is located in Massachusetts. (7)

Reports are being freely circulated in the United States that the Turks massacred thousands of Armenians in the Caucasus. Such reports are repeated so many times it makes my blood boil. The Near East Relief have the reports from Yarrow and our own

American people which show that such Armenian reports are absolutely false. The circulation of such false reports in the United States, without refutation, is an outrage and is certainly doing the Armenians more harm than good. … Why not tell the truth about the Armenians in every way?

—Admiral Mark L. Bristol, U.S. Ambassador to the Rep. of Turkey 1920 – 1926, March 28, 1921 letter to the post

It would seem as if an Armenian insurrection to help the Russians had broken out at Van. Thus a former deputy here, one Pastormadjian who had assisted our proposed railway concessions some years ago, is now supposed to be �ghting the Turks

with a legion of Armenian volunteers. These insurgents are said to be in possession of a part of Van and to be conducting guerilla warfare…. Their [Armenian insurgents’] numbers have been variously estimated but none puts them at less than ten thousand and twenty-�ve thousand is probably close to the truth—US Ambassador to the Ottoman Empire, Henry Morgenthau, Sr., to the US Secretary of State, May 25, 1915.

VIOLENT ARMENIAN UPRISING“It is a well- known fact that even in the last war the native Christians [mostly Armenians], despite the Turkish cautions, armed themselves and fought on the side of the Allies. In these con�icts, they were not idle, but they were well supplied with artillery, machine guns and in�icted heavy losses on their enemies….” — George Lamsa, missionary (10)

“...When Turkey had not yet entered the war...Armenian volunteer groups began to be organized in Trans Caucasia…the Dashnagtzoutune actively helped the organization of the aforementioned [Armenian rebel] groups, and especially arming them, against Turkey. In the Fall of 1914, Armenian volunteer groups were formed and fought against the Turks...” —Hovhannes Katchaznouni, First Prime Minister of the Independent Armenian Republic (11)

During the Van rebellion conducted by the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (ARF) members and a�liates between April 18-May 19, 1915, 194,000 Muslims, mostly Turks, were killed or perished (62% of Van’s Muslim population) (12)

In 1914 alone, Armenians killed approximately 120,000 Turks in Eastern Anatolia (which equated to 0.8% of the Ottoman Turkish population at the time). What would the US Gov’t do if 2.5 million of its citizens were killed by an internal threat? (13)

(Photo source: Houshamatyan of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, Centennial, Album-Atlas, Vol. I, Epic Battles, 1890-1914, pg. 185 and 231)

THINK ARMENIAN CLAIMS ARE TRUE? THINK AGAIN….

themselves and fought on the side of the Allies. In these con�icts, they were not idle, but they were well supplied with artillery, they were not idle, but they were well supplied with artillery, machine guns and in�icted heavy losses on their enemies….” machine guns and in�icted heavy losses on their enemies….” machine guns and in�icted heavy losses on their enemies….” machine guns and in�icted heavy losses on their enemies….”

“...When Turkey had not yet entered the war...Armenian “...When Turkey had not yet entered the war...Armenian “...When Turkey had not yet entered the war...Armenian volunteer groups began to be organized in Trans Caucasia…the Dashnagtzoutune actively helped the organization of the aforementioned [Armenian rebel] groups, and especially arming

In the Fall of 1914, Armenian volunteer

“...When Turkey had not yet entered the war...Armenian “...When Turkey had not yet entered the war...Armenian “...When Turkey had not yet entered the war...Armenian “...When Turkey had not yet entered the war...Armenian volunteer groups began to be organized in Trans Caucasia…“...When Turkey had not yet entered the war...Armenian “...When Turkey had not yet entered the war...Armenian volunteer groups began to be organized in Trans Caucasia…volunteer groups began to be organized in Trans Caucasia…volunteer groups began to be organized in Trans Caucasia…volunteer groups began to be organized in Trans Caucasia…the Dashnagtzoutune actively helped the organization of the aforementioned [Armenian rebel] groups, and especially arming the Dashnagtzoutune actively helped the organization of the the Dashnagtzoutune actively helped the organization of the the Dashnagtzoutune actively helped the organization of the aforementioned [Armenian rebel] groups, and especially arming

In the Fall of 1914, Armenian volunteer

the Dashnagtzoutune actively helped the organization of the aforementioned [Armenian rebel] groups, and especially arming

In the Fall of 1914, Armenian volunteer aforementioned [Armenian rebel] groups, and especially arming

In the Fall of 1914, Armenian volunteer groups were formed and fought against the Turks...

aforementioned [Armenian rebel] groups, and especially arming aforementioned [Armenian rebel] groups, and especially arming In the Fall of 1914, Armenian volunteer In the Fall of 1914, Armenian volunteer In the Fall of 1914, Armenian volunteer In the Fall of 1914, Armenian volunteer In the Fall of 1914, Armenian volunteer In the Fall of 1914, Armenian volunteer

” In the Fall of 1914, Armenian volunteer

groups were formed and fought against the Turks...groups were formed and fought against the Turks...” groups were formed and fought against the Turks...groups were formed and fought against the Turks...groups were formed and fought against the Turks...groups were formed and fought against the Turks...groups were formed and fought against the Turks...groups were formed and fought against the Turks...groups were formed and fought against the Turks...groups were formed and fought against the Turks...Hovhannes Katchaznouni, First Prime Minister of the Independent Hovhannes Katchaznouni, First Prime Minister of the Independent Hovhannes Katchaznouni, First Prime Minister of the Independent Hovhannes Katchaznouni, First Prime Minister of the Independent Hovhannes Katchaznouni, First Prime Minister of the Independent Hovhannes Katchaznouni, First Prime Minister of the Independent Hovhannes Katchaznouni, First Prime Minister of the Independent Hovhannes Katchaznouni, First Prime Minister of the Independent Hovhannes Katchaznouni, First Prime Minister of the Independent

During the Van rebellion conducted by the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (ARF) members and a�liates between

Hovhannes Katchaznouni, First Prime Minister of the Independent Hovhannes Katchaznouni, First Prime Minister of the Independent

During the Van rebellion conducted by the Armenian During the Van rebellion conducted by the Armenian During the Van rebellion conducted by the Armenian During the Van rebellion conducted by the Armenian During the Van rebellion conducted by the Armenian During the Van rebellion conducted by the Armenian During the Van rebellion conducted by the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (ARF) members and a�liates between Revolutionary Federation (ARF) members and a�liates between Revolutionary Federation (ARF) members and a�liates between Revolutionary Federation (ARF) members and a�liates between Revolutionary Federation (ARF) members and a�liates between April 18-May 19, 1915, 194,000 Muslims, mostly Turks, were killed or Revolutionary Federation (ARF) members and a�liates between Revolutionary Federation (ARF) members and a�liates between Revolutionary Federation (ARF) members and a�liates between April 18-May 19, 1915, 194,000 Muslims, mostly Turks, were killed or April 18-May 19, 1915, 194,000 Muslims, mostly Turks, were killed or April 18-May 19, 1915, 194,000 Muslims, mostly Turks, were killed or April 18-May 19, 1915, 194,000 Muslims, mostly Turks, were killed or April 18-May 19, 1915, 194,000 Muslims, mostly Turks, were killed or April 18-May 19, 1915, 194,000 Muslims, mostly Turks, were killed or April 18-May 19, 1915, 194,000 Muslims, mostly Turks, were killed or April 18-May 19, 1915, 194,000 Muslims, mostly Turks, were killed or April 18-May 19, 1915, 194,000 Muslims, mostly Turks, were killed or April 18-May 19, 1915, 194,000 Muslims, mostly Turks, were killed or April 18-May 19, 1915, 194,000 Muslims, mostly Turks, were killed or perished (62% of Van’s Muslim population) (12) perished (62% of Van’s Muslim population) perished (62% of Van’s Muslim population) perished (62% of Van’s Muslim population) perished (62% of Van’s Muslim population) perished (62% of Van’s Muslim population) perished (62% of Van’s Muslim population) In 1914 alone, Armenians killed approximately 120,000 Turks in In 1914 alone, Armenians killed approximately 120,000 Turks in Eastern Anatolia (which equated to 0.8% of the Ottoman Turkish population at the time). What would the US Gov’t do if 2.5 million

In 1914 alone, Armenians killed approximately 120,000 Turks in In 1914 alone, Armenians killed approximately 120,000 Turks in Eastern Anatolia (which equated to 0.8% of the Ottoman Turkish In 1914 alone, Armenians killed approximately 120,000 Turks in Eastern Anatolia (which equated to 0.8% of the Ottoman Turkish Eastern Anatolia (which equated to 0.8% of the Ottoman Turkish Eastern Anatolia (which equated to 0.8% of the Ottoman Turkish population at the time). What would the US Gov’t do if 2.5 million Eastern Anatolia (which equated to 0.8% of the Ottoman Turkish Eastern Anatolia (which equated to 0.8% of the Ottoman Turkish Eastern Anatolia (which equated to 0.8% of the Ottoman Turkish Eastern Anatolia (which equated to 0.8% of the Ottoman Turkish Eastern Anatolia (which equated to 0.8% of the Ottoman Turkish population at the time). What would the US Gov’t do if 2.5 million population at the time). What would the US Gov’t do if 2.5 million population at the time). What would the US Gov’t do if 2.5 million population at the time). What would the US Gov’t do if 2.5 million of its citizens were killed by an internal threat?population at the time). What would the US Gov’t do if 2.5 million population at the time). What would the US Gov’t do if 2.5 million of its citizens were killed by an internal threat?of its citizens were killed by an internal threat?of its citizens were killed by an internal threat?of its citizens were killed by an internal threat?of its citizens were killed by an internal threat?

(Photo source: Houshamatyan of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, Centennial, Album-Atlas, Vol. I, Epic Battles, 1890-1914, pg. 185 and 231)(Photo source: Houshamatyan of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, Centennial, (Photo source: Houshamatyan of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, Centennial, (Photo source: Houshamatyan of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, Centennial, (Photo source: Houshamatyan of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, Centennial, (Photo source: Houshamatyan of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, Centennial, (Photo source: Houshamatyan of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, Centennial, (Photo source: Houshamatyan of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, Centennial, (Photo source: Houshamatyan of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, Centennial, (Photo source: Houshamatyan of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, Centennial, (Photo source: Houshamatyan of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, Centennial, (Photo source: Houshamatyan of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, Centennial, Album-Atlas, Vol. I, Epic Battles, 1890-1914, pg. 185 and 231Album-Atlas, Vol. I, Epic Battles, 1890-1914, pg. 185 and 231Album-Atlas, Vol. I, Epic Battles, 1890-1914, pg. 185 and 231

“PAST QUOTES FROM THE FIELD DON’T LIE

““ “

HARMONIOUS HISTORY, NOT HATRED� Turks and Armenians lived in

harmonious cohabitation for a millennium. (Yes, that is 1,000 years!) (16)

� Armenians held critical positions in the Ottoman Government throughout its history including WW I. For example, between 1908 and 1913, Gabriel Noradunkian, an Armenian, served as the Minister of Commerce and Foreign A�airs of the Ottoman Empire. (17)

� 350-400 thousand Armenians in Western Anatolia – including the vast majority of the 160,000 Armenians who lived in Istanbul- remained in their homes during WW I. (18)

� In 1915-1916, the Ottoman Government courts martial prosecuted & convicted many Turks- some of whom received the death penalty- for individual mistreatment of Armenians. (19)

“The Court also agrees with [Perincek] that ‘genocide’ is a clearly de�ned legal concept…Genocide is therefore a very narrow legal con-cept which, moreover, is di�cult to prove. The Court is not satis�ed that the ‘general consen-sus’ to which the Swiss courts referred as a ba-sis for the applicant’s conviction can be relied on in relation to these very speci�c points of law. The Court therefore considers that the method used by the domestic courts to secure the applicant’s conviction was questionable” – European Court of Human Rights Judgment, Case of Perincek v. Switzerland ref. conviction

ONLY THE COURTS

CAN DETERMINE GENOCIDE

NOT PUBLIC

OPINION

of Dogu Perincek for having stated publicly that the Armenian genocide was an inter-national lie. (8) The International Court of Justice (which the US, Armenia and Turkey are party to per Article 9 of the UN Genocide Convention) - in its verdict for the Bosnia v. Serbia case - concluded that the crime of genocide must be proven with conclusive evidence and “dolus specialis” that o�ers high level of certainty appropriate to the seriousness of the allegation, yet no such document exists to prove the Armenian claim. (9)

April 2015

69 expert scholars came together to publish an ad on NY Times addressed to the US Congress stressing that the term “Armenian Genocide” is not ac-curate, and the events were rather “inter-communal warfare between Chris-tian and Muslim irregulars. (5)

Armenian Military Academy

Armenian Weapon

Smuggling Routes

Page 2: THINK ARMENIAN CLAIMS ARE TRUE? THINK AGAIN….

M E D I T E R R A N E A N S E A

B L A C K S E A

CASPI A

NSEA

Baku

Tiflis

Trabzon

Erzurum

Diyarbakır

Van

Tabriz

Mosul

Aleppo

Adana

Konya

AnkaraBursa

İzmir

Edirne

Sofia

Manastır

Athens

Vienna

Budapest

Sarajevo

Salonica

Bucharest

Sivas

Erivan

1800 Border

1830 Border

1912 Border

1912 BalkanStates Borders

1914 Border

NumbersUnknown*

ChristiansMuslims

R U S S I AA U S T R I A

O T T O M A NE M P I R E

I R A N

1922-3: Turks 480,000

1860s: Crimean Tatars 300,000

1860s: Nogay Tatars *

1770s: Crimean Tatars 100,000

1918

-9:

Turk

s *

1921: Arm

enian

s 30,000

1877-9: Turks 520,000

1912

-3:

Alb

ania

ns *

1919-22: Turks *

1875-80: Bosnians

120,000

1877-8: Tata

rs150,0

00

1878: Bulgarians 190,000

1877

-81:

Tu

rks

40,

000

1877-8: Turks 70,000

1877-8: Armenians 20,000

1915: Armenians 300,000

1806

-7: A

zeri

Tu

rks

*

1827-9: Turks 20,000

1919-22: Turks 1.2 mil.1915-6: Turks Kurds 1 mil.

1860

s:C

irca

ssia

nsAbhazians 1.2 mil.

1915-6: Armenians440,0 00

1890s: Armenians *

1915: Armenians *1915-6: Ku

rds *

1915-6: Kurds *

1878-82: Laz 40,000

1918-9: Azeri Turks 40,000

1918-9: Armenians *

1918-20: Turks 220,000

1914-23: Greeks 850,000

1918-9: Armenians *

1821

-30:

Tu

rks

*

1878-80: Turks 1

00,000

1912-3: Greeks 20,000

1912-3: Bulgarians 50,000

1912-4: Turks 410,000

1913: Bulg

arians 50,000

1896-8: Cretan M

uslims Turks *

FORCED DISPLACEMENTS OF 5 MILLION MUSLIMSAND 1.9 MILLION CHRISTIANS, 1770-1923

Muslim Muslim Christian MuslimEast

Armenian MuslimWest

Greek

40

30

20

10

0

%

*

Christian

Wartime Mortality, Mainly Civilian

1877-1878 WarEurope (%)

Balkan WarsEurope (%) Anatolian Wars, 1914-1922 (%)*

4

3

2

1

0Muslim Christian

Deaths (millions)1864-1922

including Caucasians, 1864-7By Region. Due to migration, Greek and Armenian lossesby individual regions of Anatolia are not precisely known,

Mainly East Mainly West

4

3

2

1

0Muslim Christian

Forced Migration1770-1923 (millions)

unknowns not included

5

Istanbul

E. Anatolia

N. Anatolia

Cilicia

C. AnatoliaW. Anatolia

OttomanEurope

MU

SLIM

GRE

EKA

RMEN

IAN

BULG

ARI

AN

OTH

ER

Population of Ottoman Balkans and Anatolia by Religion, 1912

CITATIONS

01. http://bit.ly/1aSyo9E , pdf , pp 3-5) 02. Source: Richard G. Hovannisian, Armenia on the Road to Independence. 1918, Berkeley-Los

Angeles-London: University of California Press, 1967, p. 67. 03. http://bit.ly/1b1ZjQO and http://on.fb.me/1EDyPk3 04. http://bit.ly/1CMaOkP and http://bit.ly/1CZiQao 05. On February 25-26, 1992, Armenian armed forces of the ARF brutally murdered 613 civilians,

including 106 women and 83 children, during a raid in Khojaly, Azerbaijan. The incident was chronicled by the Memorial Human Rights Center and Human Rights Watch as well as many other international entities such as the Gov’t of Israel.

06. www.tetedeturc.com/home/IMG/pdf/VAT.pdf 07. www.meforum.org/2114/ottoman-archives-reshape-armenian-debate 08. 12/17/2013 http://echrblog.blogspot.com/2014/01/perincek-judgment-on-genocide-denial.html 09. Source: International Court of Justice, Application of the Convention on the Prevention and

Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, Bosnia and Herzegovina v. Serbia and Montenegro, Summary of the Judgment of 26 February 2007, para. 209, 210, 430

10. Lamsa, George M., a missionary well known for his research on Christianity, The Secret of the Near East, The Ideal Press, Philadelphia 1923, p 133

11. Katchaznouni, Hovhannes. The Manifesto of Hovhannes Katchaznouni, 1923. (The Armenian Revolutionary Federation Has Nothing to Do Any More, New York, Armenian Information Service, 1955, p. 5.)

12. McCarthy, J., Arslan, E., Taşkıran, C., and Turan, Ö., The Armenian Rebellion at Van., University of Utah, 2006, p 246.)

13. Stephen Pope & Elizabeth-Anne Wheal, Dictionary of the First World War, pg. 34-35) 14. Map Source: Justin McCarthy, Uni. of Louisville, Forced Migration and Mortailty in the Ottoman

Empire. 15. www.amazon.com/Death-Exile-Justin-McCarthy/dp/0878501150, pp 161, 220-1, 223, 229, 305, 339.)16. www.amazon.com/The-Armenians-history-Armenian-question/dp/9757555002 pp 293-294.) 17. Source: Yücel Güçlü, The Holocaust and the Armenian Case in Comparative Perspective, Lanham-

Boulder-New York-Plymouth: University Press of America, 2012, pp. 85-8618. Source: Guenter Lewy, The Armenian Massacres, pp. 158, 165, 180, 186-187, 191, 203-20519. Y. Halaçoğlu, Facts on the Relocation of Armenians. 1914–1918(2002), at 84–86; H. Özdemir and Y.

Sarınay (eds), Turkish–Armenian Con�ict Documents (2007), at 294

THE ARMENIAN SIDE KNOWS ITS CLAIM HAS NO MERIT.

THIS IS WHY THEY HAVE NEVER ATTEMPTED NOR AGREED

TO FOLLOW DUE PROCESS REQUIRED BY THE 1948 UN

CONVENTION ON GENOCIDE (THE RIGHTEOUS PATH

FOLLOWED BY CLAIMANTS OF HOLOCAUST, RWANDA AND

SREBRENICA). RATHER, THEY CONVENIENTLY LEVERAGE

PUBLIC BIAS AND LACK OF KNOWLEDGE ON THIS 100-YEAR

OLD ISSUE. PUNISHMENT WITHOUT DUE PROCESS AMOUNTS

TO PUBLIC LYNCHING AS OUTLINED BY THE UN UNIVERSAL

DECLARATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS OF 1948 AND THE 5TH AND

14TH AMENDMENTS OF THE US CONSTITUTION.

ARE YOU A PART OF THE LYNCH MOB?

TURKISH SUFFERING YOU WERE NEVER TAUGHT IN CALIFORNIA SCHOOLS:Nearly 5 million non-combatant Muslims (mostly Turks) were killed between 1864 and 1922 as the Ottoman Empire fell apart (14)

Hundreds of thousands of Turkish refugees - men, women and children - perished as they were forced out of the Caucuses, Crimea and Balkans in 1914 alone(15)

M E D I T E R R A N E A N S E A

B L A C K S E A

CASPI A

NSEA

Baku

Tiflis

Trabzon

Erzurum

Diyarbakır

Van

Tabriz

Mosul

Aleppo

Adana

Konya

AnkaraBursa

İzmir

Edirne

Sofia

Manastır

Athens

Vienna

Budapest

Sarajevo

Salonica

Bucharest

Sivas

Erivan

1800 Border

1830 Border

1912 Border

1912 BalkanStates Borders

1914 Border

NumbersUnknown*

ChristiansMuslims

R U S S I AA U S T R I A

O T T O M A NE M P I R E

I R A N

1922-3: Turks 480,000

1860s: Crimean Tatars 300,000

1860s: Nogay Tatars *

1770s: Crimean Tatars 100,000

1918

-9:

Turk

s *

1921: Arm

enian

s 30,000

1877-9: Turks 520,000

1912

-3:

Alb

ania

ns *

1919-22: Turks *

1875-80: Bosnians

120,000

1877-8: Tata

rs150,0

00

1878: Bulgarians 190,000

1877

-81:

Tu

rks

40,

000

1877-8: Turks 70,000

1877-8: Armenians 20,000

1915: Armenians 300,000

1806

-7: A

zeri

Tu

rks

*

1827-9: Turks 20,000

1919-22: Turks 1.2 mil.1915-6: Turks Kurds 1 mil.

1860

s:C

irca

ssia

nsAbhazians 1.2 mil.

1915-6: Armenians440,0 00

1890s: Armenians *

1915: Armenians *1915-6: Ku

rds *

1915-6: Kurds *

1878-82: Laz 40,000

1918-9: Azeri Turks 40,000

1918-9: Armenians *

1918-20: Turks 220,000

1914-23: Greeks 850,000

1918-9: Armenians *

1821

-30:

Tu

rks

*

1878-80: Turks 1

00,000

1912-3: Greeks 20,000

1912-3: Bulgarians 50,000

1912-4: Turks 410,000

1913: Bulg

arians 50,000

1896-8: Cretan M

uslims Turks *

FORCED DISPLACEMENTS OF 5 MILLION MUSLIMSAND 1.9 MILLION CHRISTIANS, 1770-1923

Muslim Muslim Christian MuslimEast

Armenian MuslimWest

Greek

40

30

20

10

0

%

*

Christian

Wartime Mortality, Mainly Civilian

1877-1878 WarEurope (%)

Balkan WarsEurope (%) Anatolian Wars, 1914-1922 (%)*

4

3

2

1

0Muslim Christian

Deaths (millions)1864-1922

including Caucasians, 1864-7By Region. Due to migration, Greek and Armenian lossesby individual regions of Anatolia are not precisely known,

Mainly East Mainly West

4

3

2

1

0Muslim Christian

Forced Migration1770-1923 (millions)

unknowns not included

5

Istanbul

E. Anatolia

N. Anatolia

Cilicia

C. AnatoliaW. Anatolia

OttomanEurope

MU

SLIM

GRE

EKA

RMEN

IAN

BULG

ARI

AN

OTH

ER

Population of Ottoman Balkans and Anatolia by Religion, 1912

M E D I T E R R A N E A N S E A

B L A C K S E A

CASPI A

NSEA

Baku

Tiflis

Trabzon

Erzurum

Diyarbakır

Van

Tabriz

Mosul

Aleppo

Adana

Konya

AnkaraBursa

İzmir

Edirne

Sofia

Manastır

Athens

Vienna

Budapest

Sarajevo

Salonica

Bucharest

Sivas

Erivan

1800 Border

1830 Border

1912 Border

1912 BalkanStates Borders

1914 Border

NumbersUnknown*

ChristiansMuslims

R U S S I AA U S T R I A

O T T O M A NE M P I R E

I R A N

1922-3: Turks 480,000

1860s: Crimean Tatars 300,000

1860s: Nogay Tatars *

1770s: Crimean Tatars 100,000

1918

-9:

Turk

s *

1921: Arm

enian

s 30,000

1877-9: Turks 520,000

1912

-3:

Alb

ania

ns *

1919-22: Turks *

1875-80: Bosnians

120,000

1877-8: Tata

rs150,0

00

1878: Bulgarians 190,000

1877

-81:

Tu

rks

40,

000

1877-8: Turks 70,000

1877-8: Armenians 20,000

1915: Armenians 300,000

1806

-7: A

zeri

Tu

rks

*

1827-9: Turks 20,000

1919-22: Turks 1.2 mil.1915-6: Turks Kurds 1 mil.

1860

s:C

irca

ssia

nsAbhazians 1.2 mil.

1915-6: Armenians440,0 00

1890s: Armenians *

1915: Armenians *1915-6: Ku

rds *

1915-6: Kurds *

1878-82: Laz 40,000

1918-9: Azeri Turks 40,000

1918-9: Armenians *

1918-20: Turks 220,000

1914-23: Greeks 850,000

1918-9: Armenians *

1821

-30:

Tu

rks

*

1878-80: Turks 1

00,000

1912-3: Greeks 20,000

1912-3: Bulgarians 50,000

1912-4: Turks 410,000

1913: Bulg

arians 50,000

1896-8: Cretan M

uslims Turks *

FORCED DISPLACEMENTS OF 5 MILLION MUSLIMSAND 1.9 MILLION CHRISTIANS, 1770-1923

Muslim Muslim Christian MuslimEast

Armenian MuslimWest

Greek

40

30

20

10

0

%

*

Christian

Wartime Mortality, Mainly Civilian

1877-1878 WarEurope (%)

Balkan WarsEurope (%) Anatolian Wars, 1914-1922 (%)*

4

3

2

1

0Muslim Christian

Deaths (millions)1864-1922

including Caucasians, 1864-7By Region. Due to migration, Greek and Armenian lossesby individual regions of Anatolia are not precisely known,

Mainly East Mainly West

4

3

2

1

0Muslim Christian

Forced Migration1770-1923 (millions)

unknowns not included

5

Istanbul

E. Anatolia

N. Anatolia

Cilicia

C. AnatoliaW. Anatolia

OttomanEurope

MU

SLIM

GRE

EKA

RMEN

IAN

BULG

ARI

AN

OTH

ER

Population of Ottoman Balkans and Anatolia by Religion, 1912

M E D I T E R R A N E A N S E A

B L A C K S E A

CASPI A

NSEA

Baku

Tiflis

Trabzon

Erzurum

Diyarbakır

Van

Tabriz

Mosul

Aleppo

Adana

Konya

AnkaraBursa

İzmir

Edirne

Sofia

Manastır

Athens

Vienna

Budapest

Sarajevo

Salonica

Bucharest

Sivas

Erivan

1800 Border

1830 Border

1912 Border

1912 BalkanStates Borders

1914 Border

NumbersUnknown*

ChristiansMuslims

R U S S I AA U S T R I A

O T T O M A NE M P I R E

I R A N

1922-3: Turks 480,000

1860s: Crimean Tatars 300,000

1860s: Nogay Tatars *

1770s: Crimean Tatars 100,000

1918

-9:

Turk

s *

1921: Arm

enian

s 30,000

1877-9: Turks 520,000

1912

-3:

Alb

ania

ns *

1919-22: Turks *

1875-80: Bosnians

120,000

1877-8: Tata

rs150,0

00

1878: Bulgarians 190,000

1877

-81:

Tu

rks

40,

000

1877-8: Turks 70,000

1877-8: Armenians 20,000

1915: Armenians 300,000

1806

-7: A

zeri

Tu

rks

*

1827-9: Turks 20,000

1919-22: Turks 1.2 mil.1915-6: Turks Kurds 1 mil.

1860

s:C

irca

ssia

nsAbhazians 1.2 mil.

1915-6: Armenians440,0 00

1890s: Armenians *

1915: Armenians *1915-6: Ku

rds *

1915-6: Kurds *

1878-82: Laz 40,000

1918-9: Azeri Turks 40,000

1918-9: Armenians *

1918-20: Turks 220,000

1914-23: Greeks 850,000

1918-9: Armenians *

1821

-30:

Tu

rks

*

1878-80: Turks 1

00,000

1912-3: Greeks 20,000

1912-3: Bulgarians 50,000

1912-4: Turks 410,000

1913: Bulg

arians 50,000

1896-8: Cretan M

uslims Turks *

FORCED DISPLACEMENTS OF 5 MILLION MUSLIMSAND 1.9 MILLION CHRISTIANS, 1770-1923

Muslim Muslim Christian MuslimEast

Armenian MuslimWest

Greek

40

30

20

10

0

%

*

Christian

Wartime Mortality, Mainly Civilian

1877-1878 WarEurope (%)

Balkan WarsEurope (%) Anatolian Wars, 1914-1922 (%)*

4

3

2

1

0Muslim Christian

Deaths (millions)1864-1922

including Caucasians, 1864-7By Region. Due to migration, Greek and Armenian lossesby individual regions of Anatolia are not precisely known,

Mainly East Mainly West

4

3

2

1

0Muslim Christian

Forced Migration1770-1923 (millions)

unknowns not included

5

Istanbul

E. Anatolia

N. Anatolia

Cilicia

C. AnatoliaW. Anatolia

OttomanEurope

MU

SLIM

GRE

EKA

RMEN

IAN

BULG

ARI

AN

OTH

ER

Population of Ottoman Balkans and Anatolia by Religion, 1912

1830 Border

1912 Border

1830 Border

1912 Border

1830 Border

1912 Border1912 Border

Page 3: THINK ARMENIAN CLAIMS ARE TRUE? THINK AGAIN….

TURKISH AMERICANS IN CALIFORNIA FEEL DISCRIMINATEDAccording to a 2015 poll conducted of Turkish Americans in California:

73% HAVE LIVED in CA over 10 years (27% have lived in CA for 1-9 years)

68% REPORT having Armenian-American friends

ONLY 25% CLASSIFY their interactions with Armenian-Americans as “generally or mostly positive”-

Overwhelmingly, negative interactions were reported.

63% REPORT having been bullied because of their Turkish American heritage/ ethnicity

60% WORRY about their child being bullied because he/she is Turkish American.

THOSE WHO SPEAK OUT AGAINST THE GENOCIDE CLAIM HAVE BEEN SILENCED, THREATENED, BULLIED OR MURDERED BY ARMENIAN AGRESSORS FOR 50 YEARS RIGHT IN YOUR BACK YARD.

STAND UP AND SAY “ENOUGH IS ENOUGH”.

WELCOME TO THE UNITED STATES OF ARMENIA!

Their Absolute Power is Corrupt, Absolutely…� On February 18, 2009, Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW) �led a complaint with the US Dept. of Justice, the IRS, the State Dept. and the House of Representatives with evidence indicating that the Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA) and the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (ARF) were engaged in acts that violated the Internal Revenue Code (IRC), the Foreign Agents Registration Act and the Lobbying Disclosure Act. On March 16, 2009, the US Dept. of Justice announced an investigation into the matter. (6)

� In 2010, the FBI arrested more than 50 Armenians who were involved in a nationwide gang responsible for the largest Medicaid Fraud ever (~$163 million). The FBI said the group used, “….violence and threats of violence to ensure respect for and payments to its leadership”. (7)

� In 2001, Mourad Topalian, former chairman of the Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA) was sentenced to 37 months in prison for possession & storage of weapons and explosives that were believed to be linked to an attack on the Turkish Consulate in New York. (11)

� In February 2011, US Law Enforcement o�cials arrested and charged 100 members and associates of the Armenian Power crime group, based in East Hollywood. The group was engaged in narcotics tra�cking, extortion, and kidnapping among other things. (8)

Their Absolute Power is Corrupt, Absolutely…Their Absolute Power is Corrupt, Absolutely…

No One is Safe from the Wrath of Armenian Americans… Anything “Turkish” Is A Target…Starbucks CorporationFebruary 2015: Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA) launched a campaign against Starbucks for placing photographs of Turkish dancers in Turkish costumes under a Turkish �ag, taken by Tim Rose at a festival in Turkey. ANCA claimed these photos were of Armenian origin, despite the evidence at hand, and bullied Starbucks into issuing an apology for the photos.

Kobe Bryant & Turkish AirlinesDecember 2010: Kobe Bryant of the LA Lakers, one of the most popular athletes in the world, announced that he agreed to become a global ambassador of Turkish Airlines. Armenian diaspora groups immediately launched a barrage of attacks through social media and other platforms against Kobe. He proceeded with his plan despite intense bullying and protests.

City of Carson, CAMarch 4, 2015: A garden sculpture project promoting intercultural tolerance featuring Mustafa Kemal Ataturk - the founder of the Republic of Turkey - was abandoned by the City Council of Carson after a barrage of negative media attacks and protests by Armenians.

CALPERS and CALSTRSOngoing (1990s-2000s): Armenian-American California State Assembly members introduce countless bills against the interests of Californians. The latest, AB 1410, introduced by Assemblyman Nazarian & Achadjian, proposed to prevent CALPERS and CALSTRS from investing in securities, vehicles and businesses associated with the Republic of Turkey, the 17th largest economy in the world. This bill- nonsensical and practically impossible to implement – is the latest in a string of attempts to demonize all things Turkish.

No One is Safe from the Wrath of Armenian Americans… No One is Safe from the Wrath of Armenian Americans… No One is Safe from the Wrath of Armenian Americans… No One is Safe from the Wrath of Armenian Americans… No One is Safe from the Wrath of Armenian Americans… Anything “Turkish” Is A Target…

ARMENIAN TERRORISM� Worldwide Armenian Terror = 239 violent acts, across 21 countries resulting in over 70 deaths (mainly Turkish diplomats & their families)� January 1973. Armenian emigrant Gurgen Yanikyan killed 2 Consuls of Turkey (Hon. Mehmet Baydar and Bahadir Demir) in Santa Barbara.� October 3, 1977, a bomb exploded at the doorsteps of the home of Dr. Stanford Shaw of UCLA, a proli�c Jewish- American historian of the

Ottoman Empire widely known for his views against the Armenian claims. � November 1981, destruction of a building of the Turkish consulate in Beverly Hills, CA� January 1982, Consul General of Turkey Hon. Kemal Arikan was killed in Los Angeles on his way to work and Hon. Orhan Gunduz in Boston was

killed. � Armenian terrorists were responsible for the 1981 bomb attack at the Anaheim Convention Center area of Disneyland (10). � May 1982, three ASALA members put a bomb in cargo department area of Air Canada at LAX.� Armenian terrorists are embraced by the Armenian community in California. Vicken Yacoubian, Viken Hovsepian and Steven Dadaian, who were

convicted of transporting dynamite on an airliner with the intent to blow up a building in Philadelphia, PA, were later granted US citizenship and are now seen as the pillars of the Armenian community. Armenian-Americans raised hundreds of thousands of dollars for Hampig Sassounian, the convicted murderer of Hon. Kemal Arikan, and continued to assert his innocence despite his own admission that he committed the assassination (14).

Today, Turkish diplomats serving in the US continue to receive intensive armed protection by the FBI due to the ongoing threats; and any Turkish American cultural and heritage celebrations continue to be done in the shadow of tight security. (13)

April 2015

Page 4: THINK ARMENIAN CLAIMS ARE TRUE? THINK AGAIN….

Graphic is of the Turkish diplomats slain at the hands of Armenian terrorists. (9)

Many in the leadership of ASALA and JCAG were reported to be highly educated, multilingual individuals. The most notorious was the shadowy �gure of Hagop Hagopian, presumed an alias, who led ASALA during most of its active phase.

—Historical Dictionary of Armenia, by Rouben Paul Adalian, 2010 - p. 170

CITATIONS

01. http://bit.ly/1HqkhVD 02. www.tallarmeniantale.com/nyt-bias.htm 03. http://bit.ly/1NGQuxb , see also the propaganda documentary here04. http://bit.ly/1CI11gZ , p 74 )05. http://bit.ly/1Hqkus306. http://bit.ly/1cuExK1, http://cbsn.ws/1IbU5fSn07. http://1.usa.gov/1PKXPtW08. www.nytimes.com/2011/02/17/us/17armenian.html?_r=009. Source: http://bit.ly/1FIt6FG10. Source: The Daytona Beach News Journal, “5 Armenians Held in Bombing Series”, October 23, 1982 (Google News)11. www.laweekly.com/news/the-�lthiest-48-hours-214390012. Hyland, Francis (1991). Armenian Terrorism: the past, the present, the prospects. Westview Press. 13. http://regionplus.az/en/articles/view/136614. http://bit.ly/1OcLETb15. Dr. Alexander Murinson, Begin-Sadat Center for Strategic Studies, Bar-Ilan University, Baltimore Jewish Times, 3/19/2015

WATCH THE DOCUMENTARY “ARMENIAN REVOLT” ON YOUTUBE, LISTEN TO THE EXPERTS AND DECIDE FOR YOURSELF….

http://bit.ly/1DKahVPPLEASE VISIT THIS SITE FOR IMPORTANT QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS

www.factcheckarmenia.com

“ “During WW 2, Armenians formed a battalion of 20,000 soldiers called “the 812th Armenian Batallion of Wehrmacht” under the command of Drastamat Kanayan and this legion was later trained and led by the SS as a part of the Nazi Einsatzgruppen (extermination squad) during the invasion of the Crimea and North Caucasus. Is it not twisted logic that the enthusiastic supporters of the Nazi regime are asking you to support claims of Armenian victimhood? (15)

Even one dead is one too many and each death is tragic. But what’s equally tragic are these obvious and deliberate falsi�cations designed to dupe the unsuspecting public in California, escalate polarization and incite hatred for political gain. Systematic Armenian attacks on anyone who dared to speak the truth against this claim has emboldened the Armenian side to operate free of historic facts.

ESTIMATED ARMENIAN LOSSES: #FUZZYMATH

“… more than

200,000 dead…” (1)

800,000

dead (2)

1,500,000

dead (3)

2,500,000

dead (4)

Paris Peace Conference,

Sub-Commission Report of 3/29/1919

NY Times, October 1919

50th Anniversary Monument in Yerevan, 1965

Then the number jumps to

200,000