Theistic proofs for god

11
Concepts of a Higher Being Arguments for God Ontological, Cosmological and Teleological

Transcript of Theistic proofs for god

Page 1: Theistic proofs for god

Concepts of a Higher Being

Arguments for God

Ontological, Cosmological and Teleological

Page 2: Theistic proofs for god

The philosophy of religion examines the nature of religion, explores rational arguments for and against various religious views, analyses the nature of religious language and explores the variety of human religious experience. This theme allows students to explore philosophically such questions as:

Page 3: Theistic proofs for god

In short

Ontological: God is defined as the perfect being. Existence is more perfect than non-existence. Therefore, God exists. (St. Anselm, Descartes)

Cosmological: Every even has a cause. The universe is

an event. Therefore the universe has a cause, God. (St. Thomas Aquinas)

Teleological: All complex things have a designer. The

universe is complex. Therefore it has a designer, God. (Willam Paley).

Page 4: Theistic proofs for god

The Ontological Argument

St. Anselm argued that we can deduce the existence of God from the idea of God. Just from thinking that about what God is, we can conclude that God exists. Therefore the ability to conceive the idea of God, supports the fact that God exists.

Page 5: Theistic proofs for god

The argument

Anselm’s argument relies on conceivability 1. By definition, God is a being greater than

which cannot be conceived. 2. I can conceive of such a being. 3. It is greater to exist than to not exist. 4. Therefore God must exist.

Page 6: Theistic proofs for god

Key points

The ontological argument is a priori; it works from the analysis of the idea of God, not from any fact or experience. Also called rational thinking. Anselm’s argument takes for granted the idea that God is the greatest conceivable Being. Our capacity to conceive the idea of God makes God’s existence logical. The conclusion of the ontological argument is that God necessarily exists.

Page 7: Theistic proofs for god

The cosmological argument

A medieval Christian thinker called Thomas Aquinas wrote:

‘In the cosmos is it obvious that some things change. Now, whatever changes must have been changed by something

else. And if that something else in turn changes then it must have been changed by another. But this cannot go on to

infinity… you eventually have to arrive at something that is unchanging. This is God!’

The cosmological argument is an argument from natural theology; the view that we can understand the nature and

existence of God through his work in creation. Which is accessible to all humans, through experience, rather than

through reason.

Page 8: Theistic proofs for god

The argument

1.  Nothing can happen by itself 2.  Everything that happens must be caused

by something else. 3.  The universe could not have just ‘happened’ by itself.

4.  A very powerful force must have caused it into being.

5.  This cause must have been God. 6.  This means that God must exist!

Page 9: Theistic proofs for god

The teleological argument

The teleological theory is often called the argument for design. It is based on observation of the apparent order in the universe and the natural world, to conclude that it is not the result of mere chance, but of design. The argument makes the basic assumption that there is order and design in the universe, and that all things function to fulfill a specific purpose.

Page 10: Theistic proofs for god

The argument

1.  The world is so well ordered and everything is balanced to sustain life. The world is so beautiful and complex, with interdependent parts making a whole.

2.  This complex world must therefore have been designed.

3.  If it is designed, it must have a designer. 4.  The only being powerful enough to

design the universe is God. 5.  So God must therefore exist.

Page 11: Theistic proofs for god

Task

1.  Read the material for ONE of the arguments for God (including criticisms)

2.  In groups discuss what you have read. 3.  Answer the following question:

Define the argument for the existence of God and discuss its strengths and

weaknesses.