8/3/2019 The Viability of the Peasant Economy

1/16

6

Dkacl` Afdlq

Wnq}hyfm|f}l Mkw`ndf kj Mlrl`nwdlj} Q}|mklq

Y|yf` Mlrl`nwdlj}

\jkrlyqk}{ nb @llmq

Lqqf{ $ Qldlq}ly 6

6;;

8/3/2019 The Viability of the Peasant Economy

2/16

9

]cl{ f`` xfj} andwl}k}knj xk}cn|} }cl `l}cf` lbbla}q nb andwl}k}knj

#Ek}ackjh, 6;3;, v|n}kjh Dfys+* ]ckq ak}f}knj i{ Dfys, xck`l ylblyykjh }n

Wklyyl Onqlwc Wyn|mcnj kq fj fj}kakwf}knj nb }cl ljm|ykjh mlif}l il}xllj

}cnql xcn fqqly} }cf} }cl }yfjqbnydf}knj nb }cl fhyfykfj qnakl}{jlalqqk}f}lq }cl mlrl`nwdlj} nb `fyhl$qaf`l |jk}q nb wynm|a}knj fjm }cnql

xcn }ckje }cf} }ckq }yfjqbnydf}knj afj il ifqlm nj qdf``$qaf`l wlfqfj}

bfdk`{ bfydq* ]cl mlif}l xckac cfq wyla|yqnyq ylfackjh ifae kj}n wyl$

kjm|q}ykf` }kdlq nykhkjf}lq kj jkjl}llj}c alj}|y{ Y|qqkf fjm cfq lrly cfm

ylwlya|qqknjq qkjal, lqwlakf``{ kj }cl mlrl`nwkjh xny`m* Faanymkjh }n

Ek}ackjh, }clyl xfq f qacnn` nb }cn|hc} kj Y|qqkf xkqckjh }cf} qndl n}cly

bnyd }cfj afwk}f`kq}ka mlrl`nwdlj} an|`m il lq}fi`kqclm frnkmkjh }cl

cnyynyq fjm q|bblykjh xckac k} cfm iyn|hc} }n }cl Xlq} f`ylfm{, frnkmkjh

}cl qnakf` fjm c|dfj anq}q nb wyn`l}fykfjkzf}knj fjm }cl qelxlm kjandl

mkq}yki|}knj afwk}f`kqd kdw`klm* ]cl{ xlyl ljhfhlm kj b|ykn|q kj}l``la}|f`

if}}`lq xk}c Dfys xcn fyh|lm }cf} Y|qqkf cfm }n wfqq }cyn|hc f wynalqq nb

afwk}f`kq}ka kjm|q}ykf`kzf}knj kb qnakf`kqd xfq }n il f}}fkjlm* Fq Dkecfk`nrqe{

yl}ny}lm }n Dfys?

F`` }ckq dfkdkjh nb xndlj fjm ack`mylj xl q}k`` cfrl ilbnyl |q, fjm, bynd

}cl wnkj} nb rklx nb Dfys(q ckq}nykaf` }clny{, xl qcn|`m jn} wyn}lq} fhfkjq}

}cld ilaf|ql k} xn|`m dlfj fa}kjh }n n|y nxj ml}ykdlj}5 nj }cl anj}yfy{,

xl qcn|`m xl`andl }cld fq }cl q}llw i|} jlalqqfy{ q}lwq }n }cl }ldw`l nb

cfwwkjlqq #Ek}ackjh, 6;3;, w =1b, K v|n}kjh Dkecfk`nrqe{, 6388+*

Fq Ek}ackjh anj}kj|lq, }ckq ayk}kv|l nb afwk}f`kq} kjm|q}ykf`kzf}knj, }lydlm fqwnw|`kqd fjm ylblyylm }n i{ Dfys fq wl}}{$in|yhlnkq xfq dfkj`{ ifqlm

nj qnakf` fjm l}ckaf` hyn|jmq* K} yla|yq kj xyk}kjhq nb ylalj} mlrl`nwkjh

an|j}yklq `lfmlyq `kel J{lylyl fjm lrnelq l`k}l h|k`} fq }cl ifqkq nb fj l}cka

nb qlyrkal }n }cl wnny, i|} bfk`q }n q|hhlq} anclylj} q}yf}lhklq }n bfal }cl

mk`lddf*

Bny `lfmlyq fjm wn`ka{$dfelyq xk}c }cl jllm ny mlqkyl }n acfjhl qnakl}{

dfml |w nrlyxcl`dkjh`{ nb wlfqfj}q fjm n}cly qdf``$qaf`l wynm|alyq,

}clyl xk`` f`xf{q il f aly}fkj f}}yfa}knj kj f }yfmk}knj nb }cn|hc} xckac

8/3/2019 The Viability of the Peasant Economy

3/16

1

q|hhlq}q in}c }cf} acfjhl fjm mlrl`nwdlj} kq wnqqki`l fjm }cf} f`` }cf} kq

anjalkrlm fq ilq} kj lskq}kjh kjq}k}|}knjq fjm wyfa}kalq df{ il dfkj}fkjlm,

fjm }cf} }ckq mn|i`l niola}krl afj il b|`bk``lm xk}cn|} aylf}kjh dfqqkrl

ls}yldlq nb xlf`}c fjm wnrly}{ #Ek}ackjh, 6;3;, w 21+*

]ckq fjskl}{ fin|} kjm|q}ykf`kzf}knj cfq lrlj illj xnyy{kjh xlq}lyj

afwk}f`kq}q xcn nxlm }clky b|}|yl }n kjm|q}ykf`kzf}knj* ]cl bn|` myfkj fq Ml

]nav|lrk``l acykq}ljlm }cl qn|yal nb Iyk}fkj(q xlf`}c, Dfjaclq}ly, cfq }c|q

`lm kjm|q}ykf` rkqknjfyklq `kel Ynily} Nxlj }n i|k`m andwfj{ }nxjq kj }cl

bnyd nb mlalj}yf`kzlm hfymlj ak}klq kj xckac wlnw`l xn|`m il y|yf` ljn|hc

}n ellw kj }n|ac xk}c }cl `fjm fjm }n lqafwl }cl |jxcn`lqndljlqq nb }cl

ak}{ `kbl* ]cl dfkj mykrl }n anjalkrl }clql |yifj |}nwkfq xfq cnxlrly

dlyl`{ }n wynrkml }cl k``|qknj nb }yfmk}knj fjm qla|yk}{ kj f xny`m nb b`|s

#]cl Lanjndkq}, Mlaldily 91ym, 6;;

8/3/2019 The Viability of the Peasant Economy

4/16

=

xnyekjh fjn}cly cn|y, i|} }cl }n}f` n|}w|} xckac hkrlq ckd fjm ckq bfdk`{

}clky dkjkd|d q|iqkq}ljal, lrlj kb }cl dfyhkjf` wynm|a} nb }clky ls}yf

`fin|y kq jlhf}krl* ]ckq kq f`qn }y|l nb `fjm* Lrlj kb }cl ylj} nb `fjm kq kj

lsalqq nb k}q dfyhkjf` wynm|a}, }cl wlfqfj}(q nj`{ anjqkmlyf}knj kq }n cfrlljn|hc `fjm }n wynrkml }cl q|iqkq}ljal `lrl` bny ckq bfdk`{ #Ek}ackjh, 6;3;+*

Mo|ybl`m} jn}lq }cf} lrlj }cn|hc Acf{fjnr mkm jlrly ayk}kakzl @ljkj

mkyla}`{, ckq mldnhyfwcka mkbblylj}kf}knj anjalw} nb }cl `fin|y$anjq|dly

if`fjal afj il `nnelm |wnj fq f wn`ldka fhfkjq} @ljkj(q |jk`kjlfy

mkbblylj}kf}knj }clny{* Acf{fjnr a`fkdq }cf} }cl mkbblylj}kf}knj an|`m il

lsw`fkjlm i{ fjm `fyhl }n }cl lswfjqknj fjm anj}yfa}knj xk}c }cl

mlrl`nwdlj} nb }cl wlfqfj}(q bfdk`{ a{a`l#Mo|ybl`m} kj Cfyykqq, 6;36+* ]cl

kdwny}fj} wnkj}, fq Ek}ackjh a`fkdq, kq }cf} Acf{fjnr(q }clny{ wynrkmlq }cl

faan|j} xc{ }cl wlfqfj} lanjnd{ kq fi`l }n andwl}l xk}c `fyhl `fyhl$qaf`l

afwk}f`kq} lj}lywykqlq* K} kq }cl wlfqfj}q xk``kjhjlqq }n xnye `njh cn|yq kj

nymly }n ljq|yl ckq ifqka q|iqkq}ljal #Ek}ackjh, 6;3;+* Nj`{ }ckq ay|ml ql`b$

lsw`nk}f}knj qfrlq ckd bynd ilkjh f`kljf}lm bynd ckqdlfjq nb wynm|a}knj

fjm ilkjh kj}lhyf}lm kj}n }cl afwk}f`kq} dnml nb wynm|a}knj*

Mo|ybl`m} wnkj}q f} f }|yjkjh wnkj} fyn|jm 638< xclj kj}lyjf}knjf` afwk}f`

ilhfj }n iylfe mnxj afwk}f`kq} fhyka|`}|yl i{ f qckb} kj }cl }lydq nb }yfml*

I{ }clj }cl kdwny} nb hyfkj bynd jnj$L|ynwlfj an|j}yklq cfm kjaylfqlm

myfdf}kaf``{ fjm q}ykwwlm }ckq lanjndka bnyd nb k}q anjmk}knj nb

ylwynm|a}knj* ]cl q}fy}kjh wnkj} kj }ckq lrn`|}knj xfq }cl ylwlf` nb }cl

Ljh`kqc Anyj @fxq kj 63=2, xckac xfq }cl lbbla} nb }cl q}yljh}c nb }clkjm|q}ykf` afwk}f` kj }cl a`fqq q}y|hh`l xk}c }cl `fjmlm kj}lylq}q*

]cl afwk}f`kq} wljl}yf}knj kj fhyka|`}|yl, xckac jlrly}cl`lqq lskq}q, ilhkjq

cnxlrly, faanymkjh }n Acf{fjnr, jn} nj }cl bfyd fq q|ac, i|} i{ qw`k}}kjh

nbb bynd }cl wlfqfj} bfyd kjmkrkm|f` qla}nyq, kj hljlyf`, }cnql anjjla}lm

xk}c dlacfjkaf` wynalqqlq* ]cl ylfqnj bny }ckq kq }cf} afwk}f`kq} lsw`nk}f}knj

kq dnyl lbbla}krl kj }cl rly}kaf` }cfj kj }cl cnykznj}f` anjalj}yf}knj

#Mo|ybl`m} kj Cfyykqq, 6;36+*

8/3/2019 The Viability of the Peasant Economy

5/16