The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system...
Transcript of The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system...
![Page 1: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Experiences on the French Transmission grid
The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC
and FACTS schemes
1
![Page 2: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
IntroductionSeveral power electronic devices (HVDC and FACTS projects) are currently planned or constructed by RTE
Considerable impact on the grid performance and reliability
HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections
Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices
Requiring skills and tools dedicated to this technology
2
![Page 3: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Introduction
2011
2017
Creation of the real-time simulation laboratory : SMARTE in Paris La Défense
Control system replicas are acquired and installed in this laboratory for each new power electronics project on the French grid.
3
![Page 4: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
HV power electronic Projects
IFA 2000 réglage f/p - 2015
FABFrance Aldernay
Britain1400 MW - 2022
France SpainGolfe de Gascogne2*1000 MW - 2022
Piémont Savoie2*600MW 2019
Midi Provence1000 MW - 2020
France Spain2*1000MW - 2015
Eleclink1000 MW –2018
Celtic Interconnector700 MW - 2025
IFA 21000 MW - 2020
Existing
Decided
Studied
Private
SVC
Decided Offshore Wind farm
4
![Page 5: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Design & engineering studies
• Offline EMT model
• Preliminarycontrol system
FPT/DPT
• Offline EMT model (final version)
• Real-time simulation withphysical controls
On site commissionning
• Software may beupdated
• Measurementscompared to DPT
Commercial operation
• Black box EMT models deliveredto customer
Model may be differentto the software on site
Typical life cycle of EMT models
5
![Page 6: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Specific issues for EMT models
Validity• Difficult to follow
software version
Long term
studies
• Shall be available in 10/15 years ?
• How to maintain it?
Functions
• Limited functions to speed up the model
• Simplified controls because of CPU performance
EMT offline models are mandatory to perform accurate studies
RT simulation can provide validation and update on a long term of the offline models
6
![Page 7: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Issues with offline modelsReal event occurred on an LCC scheme after refurbishment : control system disoperation, followed by protective valve bypass and finally main CB failure due to current zero crossing delay.
First attempt: analysis with the offline model provided by the manufacturer virtually impossible to recreate the event even with the manufacturer support
Second attempt: analysis with replicas with the same software on site event successfully recreated
Software on site was different than in the model
Engineers initially involved in the model development left the manufacturer company
The offline model only ran on old OS
3ph current in main AC CB
7
![Page 8: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Replica overviewA replica is an exact copy of the actual control and protection system installed on site
8
![Page 9: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Replicas for HVDC/FACTSReplicas scopes :
Develop skills and knowledge on HVDC and FACTS systems
Investigate interactions phenomena related to HVDC and FACTS devices
Training engineers and support maintenance activities
Improve specification and optimize system performance
Validate future software update
Network studies and improve offline models
Studying and testing multi-vendors and multi-infeed schemes
9
![Page 10: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Real-time lab with HVDC/FACTS replicasLocated in Paris with every HVDC/FACTS control systems connected to the French Transmission System (including controls for wind generation)
Replicas connected to real-time simulators (Hypersim and RTDS)
Hardware installed in the RTE lab from 2013:
5 SVC replicas from ALSTOM Grid (Merlatière and Domloup project) and SIEMENS (NANTERRE project)
1 HVDC LCC replica from ALSTOM Grid (IFA2000)
2 HVDC SVC replicas from SIEMENS (INELFE project)
6 real-time simulators (170 CPU) and IO cabinets
Staff : ~10 engineers
10
![Page 11: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Replica typeA. Study replica
The study replica is dedicated for functional verification, dynamic performance and protection studies.
Only relevant equipment for network studies are provided.
B. Maintenance replica
The Maintenance replica is intended to help the preparation of on-site maintenance operations and operator trainings. It includes testing and validation of the upgraded system version before field implementation.
Maintenance replica includes identical cubicles to the on-site cubicles : same interfaces, redundant equipment, etc.
11
![Page 12: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Real Time lab
12
![Page 13: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Typical event study using Replicas
13
![Page 14: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Interaction studies with SVC controls
14
![Page 15: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Interaction studies with SVC controlsWest 225kV grid modeling in Hypersim.
West grid: lack of production, antenna structure Weak part of the French grid
24 substations
31 lines
3 SVC replicas
4 machines and controls
11 cores
15
![Page 16: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Interaction studies with SVC controlsEvent: 400kV line fault seen by the 3 SVCs
Observation of SVC regulation during the fault to support the voltage and after the fault to keep voltage stability during oscillation of Cordemais power
16
![Page 17: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Tools for maintenance and training
Operator and engineer training
Test hardware
modification
Develop skills and
knowledge on HVDC
Network events
analysis
Test software update
Integration of new
development
17
![Page 18: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Real-time model validation Before connecting the replica, real-time model is validated against offline model
In order to validate the power system component, the exact generic control system implemented in EMTP-RV and Hypersim is used
18
![Page 19: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Hypersim model validationActive/reactive power
19
![Page 20: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Hypersim model validationDC voltage/current and SPR current
20
![Page 21: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
IFA2000 Replicas validationPole-to-ground fault event on the IFA2000 link (November 2016)
Incident reproduction using Hypersimsimulator and replicas
21
![Page 22: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Example of studies with INELFE replicasResonance interactions between VSC controls and AC grids
• Network configurations can lead to harmonic interactions between AC grid and HVDC controls
• Accurate representation of AC grids and exact behavior of controls is needed
22
![Page 23: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Parametric studies using replicasParametric studies using replicas :
Parameters Values # of config
P/Q setpints± 500 / ±150MW
± 1000 / ±300MW8
Fault type 3LT, 1LT, 2L et 2LT 4
Short-circuit Level
(PCC)Pcc_max, Pcc_mean, Pcc_min 3
Fault impedance 10, 1 et 0.001 ohm 3
Fault duration 150 et 280 ms 2
Fault instant (relative
to AC voltage phase A)0 à 17.5 ms par pas de 2.5 ms 8
GAUDIERE
BAIXAS
VIC
RIUDARENES
BESCANO
SANTA LLOGAIA
RAMIS
FRANCESPAIN
HV
DC
LIN
K1
HV
DC
LIN
K2
• Total number of simulated test cases 8*4*3*3*2*8 = 4,608 tests !
• Parametric simulations are conducted automatically using Testview software 23
![Page 24: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Parametric studies using replicasParametric studies using replicas : Results are automatically generated
Test fault_type PCC fault_impedance fault_duration fault_instant Conv_BLK Conv_Trip BLK_duree_ms Vpos_max_peak Ipos_max_peak Vdc_max_peak Idc_max_peakINELFE_Fault-1 2LT PCCmax 0.001ohm 150ms 0 ms 0 0 0 1.0119 1.4264 1.1554 924.92e-003INELFE_Fault-1 2LT PCCmax 0.001ohm 150ms 2.5 ms 1 0 81.882 0.994 1.3999 1.2034 928.49e-003INELFE_Fault-1 2LT PCCmax 0.001ohm 150ms 5 ms 1 0 161.86 993.96e-003 1.4139 1.2854 924.51e-003INELFE_Fault-1 2LT PCCmax 0.001ohm 150ms 7.5 ms 1 0 80.471 1.0092 1.3955 1.3194 924.18e-003INELFE_Fault-1 2LT PCCmax 0.001ohm 150ms 10 ms 0 0 01.0138 1.4339 1.1396 924.74e-003INELFE_Fault-1 2LT PCCmax 0.001ohm 150ms 12.5 ms 1 0 81.554 994.59e-003 1.4002 1.2786 927.93e-003INELFE_Fault-1 2LT PCCmax 0.001ohm 150ms 15 ms 1 0 162.18 993.94e-003 1.4152 1.3067 928.04e-003INELFE_Fault-1 2LT PCCmax 0.001ohm 150ms 17.5 ms 1 0 80.764 1.0102 1.3955 1.3146 926.62e-003INELFE_Fault-2 2LT PCCmax 0.001ohm 580ms 0 ms 1 0 163.48 993.97e-003 1.3937 1.2454 1.001INELFE_Fault-2 2LT PCCmax 0.001ohm 580ms 2.5 ms 1 0 80.497 995.53e-003 1.4001 1.2536 925.93e-003INELFE_Fault-2 2LT PCCmax 0.001ohm 580ms 5 ms 1 0 81.324 995.07e-003 1.4148 1.302 1.3222INELFE_Fault-2 2LT PCCmax 0.001ohm 580ms 7.5 ms 0 0 0 1.0099 1.3955 1.2223 925.44e-003INELFE_Fault-2 2LT PCCmax 0.001ohm 580ms 10 ms 1 0 162.37 997.64e-003 1.3947 1.2168 923.34e-003INELFE_Fault-2 2LT PCCmax 0.001ohm 580ms 12.5 ms 1 0 79.925 995.58e-003 1.3997 1.2487 931.81e-003INELFE_Fault-2 2LT PCCmax 0.001ohm 580ms 15 ms 1 0 80.774 995.06e-003 1.416 1.3033 1.3329INELFE_Fault-2 2LT PCCmax 0.001ohm 580ms 17.5 ms 0 0 0 1.0099 1.3952 1.2121 925.16e-003INELFE_Fault-3 2LT PCCmax 1ohm 150ms 0 ms 1 0 162.89 994.53e-003 1.4282 1.2529 926.04e-003INELFE_Fault-3 2LT PCCmax 1ohm 150ms 2.5 ms 1 0 82.106 1.0103 1.3957 1.3461 1.3653INELFE_Fault-3 2LT PCCmax 1ohm 150ms 5 ms 1 0 161.93 994.06e-003 1.4291 1.2648 933.45e-003INELFE_Fault-3 2LT PCCmax 1ohm 150ms 7.5 ms 1 0 161.28 994.27e-003 1.4218 1.2586 925.85e-003INELFE_Fault-3 2LT PCCmax 1ohm 150ms 10 ms 1 0 161.38 994.5e-003 1.4276 1.2543 930.88e-003INELFE_Fault-3 2LT PCCmax 1ohm 150ms 12.5 ms 1 0 80.69 1.0106 1.3974 1.3455 1.3522INELFE_Fault-3 2LT PCCmax 1ohm 150ms 15 ms 1 0 162.21 994.04e-003 1.4286 1.2634 934.28e-003INELFE_Fault-3 2LT PCCmax 1ohm 150ms 17.5 ms 1 0 161.58 994.49e-003 1.425 1.2599 930.44e-003INELFE_Fault-4 2LT PCCmax 1ohm 580ms 0 ms 0 0 0 1.0146 1.3963 1.1915 923.41e-003INELFE_Fault-4 2LT PCCmax 1ohm 580ms 2.5 ms 1 0 81.588 994.77e-003 1.3962 1.2717 1.0639INELFE_Fault-4 2LT PCCmax 1ohm 580ms 5 ms 1 0 162.42 993.93e-003 1.4087 1.1933 940.52e-003INELFE_Fault-4 2LT PCCmax 1ohm 580ms 7.5 ms 1 0 162.44 993.91e-003 1.3903 1.1975 926.4e-003INELFE_Fault-4 2LT PCCmax 1ohm 580ms 10 ms 0 0 0 1.0147 1.3991 1.1621 922.48e-003INELFE_Fault-4 2LT PCCmax 1ohm 580ms 12.5 ms 1 0 81.61 994.86e-003 1.3968 1.2763 1.0618INELFE_Fault-4 2LT PCCmax 1ohm 580ms 15 ms 1 0 161.65 993.94e-003 1.4064 1.1869 925.75e-003INELFE_Fault-4 2LT PCCmax 1ohm 580ms 17.5 ms 1 0 163.26 993.9e-003 1.3896 1.2006 924.41e-003
24
![Page 25: The use of real time simulation to de-risk and manage HVDC ...HVDC and FACTS include control system and protections Dynamic behaviour much more complex compared to standard AC devices](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022081616/600c55358414d05a09318b58/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
THANK YOU
Questions ?
25