The Skeptic's Handbook II

8/9/2019 The Skeptic's Handbook II

1/20 Dilooe Oiwl 2>>: Pme Vke~pjfv Mlo`biik JJ >> pjhev hire pmlo Bja(ijc/ Cel`joa fcjhlpe vfjeopjvpv qiop èblpe jo ~ubcjf

lo` qiop ~riwjè pmejr `lpl/ Qmlp ì pmez mjè9 Qmeo glfe` qjpm cealc re|uevpvpmez vlz pmezwe civp pme irjajolc aciblc peh~erlpure refir`v/ Pmiuvlo`v ig

vfjeopjvpv lre rjvjoa jo ~ripevp laljovp pme vflre flh~ljao/ Heloqmjce $>= lo` blokerv aep vep pi hlke bjccjiov/


2/202 Pme Vke~pjfv Mlo`biik JJ dilooeoiwl/fih/lu

9OIPE4 Flrbio# flrbio ji}jè# lo` FI2 lre lccuve` joperfmloaelbcz mere gir pme vlke ig vjh~cjfjpz#LAQ4 Lopmri~iaeojf Aciblc Qlrhjoa# pme pmeirz pmlp

muhlo FI2 ehjvvjiov lre pme hljo fluve ig aciblc

qlrhjoa/

J^FF4 Joperaiweroheoplc ^loec io Fcjhlpe Fmloae/

JVBO4 :1=(>(:5=

Ziu lre oip bejoa pic` pme qmice vpirz

Miq qiuc` ziu koiq9

Qmlp jg aiweroheopv vlfke` lo` buccje` vfjeopjvpvqmi `jvlaree`9 Jg igfjlcv uve` vcloèr lo` cjbec

jo irèr pi vu~~revv vfjeopjf i~jojiov9 Qmlp jg~ubcjf laeofjev mj` pmejr `lpl# reguve` pi vu~~cz jp#ir eweo civp jp; jg blvecevv arl~mv qere ~ubcjfjve`lo` oip firrefpe`9 Qmi jogirhv pme ~ubcjf lo`qmi eogirfev pme rucev ig vfjeofe# ig vfjeofe

diurolcv# ig Lrjvpipce9

Qmlp jg pmiuvlo`v ig vfjeopjvpv rive u~ jo ~ripevp#bup jp qeop uore~irpe`9

Qmlp jg hucpjolpjiolc olofjlc miuvev |ujepcz vep

pmehvecwev u~ pi hlke bjccjiov9

Pme qirc` jv fiovjèrjoa l oeq olofjlc hlrkepclraer pmlo loz fihhi`jpz hlrkep/ Qere pic` jpvlcc blve` io vfjeofe# bup jg ziu lvk gir ewjèofeziu lre flcce` olhev èojer,

Glhiuv arl~mv vmiq pme e}lfp rewerve ig qmlp lfecebrjpz e}(~icjpjfjlo vlj`# bup jovpel` ig bejoavmlhe`# me aepv l Oibec/ Rifk Vplr vfjeopjvpv

brelk blvjf rucev ig ciajf# bup vfjeofe(qrjperv pmjok

pmlpv ik/ ^R qeb vjpev lre guoè` v~efjflccz pivhelr revelrfmerv# lo` @lwj` Vutukj# vu~~ive`czl vfjeopjvp# clu`v pme vhelr vjpev# lo` pme UO ajwevpmeh igfjlc ~lvvev/ Qlcc Vp mlv hiwe` jo io pme

bjaaevp ~iqer arlb jo mjvpirz/ Bup relccz# blokvqlop pi vlwe pme eowjrioheop/ @jòp ziu koiq9

Qecfihe pi pme blrkjoa hl` pree

flcce` fcjhlpe fmloae/

Jg ziu lre io pme pelh qmjfm mlv vilke` u~ bjccjiovziu hjamp flcc pme uoguoè` wicuopeerv ijc vmjccv#

qmjce ziu lo` #>>> grjeo`v z io pqi qeeke}ipjf duokepv ewerz zelr/ Ziu fiuc` kjfk u~ lvpjok lbiup $26 hjccjio ìcclrv pmlp `jòp fiheziur qlz# qmjce pme $1: bjccjio ìcclrv pmlp `j`#aiev uooipjfe`/ Ziu flcc ziurvecg vu~~revve`lgper ìjoa ziur >pm pecewjve` joperwjeq# qmjceariuo` brelkjoa revelrfm jv cifke` iup ig diurolcv/Heloqmjce l uojwervjpz ~upv pmerhiheperv vj}geep lbiwe ~lweheopv# -cufkz mip ljr ìevop rjveigg fiofrepe em9* lo` l $0 bjccjio ìcclr laeofzaepv fih~cjlofe lu`jpv bz l pelh ig muo`re`v ig

wicuopeerv/ Vihemiq# pme he`jl ìevop pmjok pme~ubcjf qiuc` cjke pi koiq/

Jo pme mel`(v~joojoa fivhiv ig fcjhlpe fmloae#ewerz`lz muo`re`v ig ~ei~ce fcljh pmere lrepmiuvlo`v ig ~l~erv jo vu~~irp ig l pmeirz# zepoi ioe flo lfpulccz olhe ioe vjoace ~l~erqjpmeh~jrjflc ewjèofe pmlp vmiqv flrbio `ji}jèehjvvjiov lre pme hljo fluve ig aciblc qlrhjoa/Vjofere jowevpjalpjwe ~rjte(qjoojoa diurolcjvpvìop veeh pi oipjfe/

Pme arlwz prljo mjp gucc v~ee` begire pmee}~erjheopv qere ìoe# lo` qmeo pme revucpvpuroe` # pme prljo rlo igg pme prlfkv/

Mic` iopi ziur mlp/ Vprl~ ziurvecg jo/

Oipmjoa jv lv jp veehv/

6

[vke~pjf4 ~erviojo`jv~ive` pi

lffe~p ~i~uclrjpz irlupmirjpz lv ~riwjoa

pme prupm ig i~jojiov/X

Qmlp jg aiweroheopv ~iure` bjccjiov ig hioi~icjvpjf guo`joajopi ioe pmeirz bup mlr`cz lozpmjoa jopi pme lcperolpjwev4 l

pmeirz pmlp vujpe` ~erviolc lhbjpjiov# ~ripv ig hldir ~clzerv#

flreerv ig vfjeopjvpv# lo` pme ljhv ig olwe areeov9

Wervjio >:

U~`lpev# CJOKV pi viurfev# e}prl oipev# GL\#fihheopv# prlovclpjiov lo` qlzv pi irèr

fi~jev lre ~ivpe` io dilooeoiwl/fih/lu


3/20 Dilooe Oiwl 2>>: Pme Vke~pjfv Mlo`biik JJ 6

Qmz qiuc` loz vfjeopjvp qlop pi rljve ìubpv

laljovp qecc guoè`# qecc iralojve` lupifrlpv qjpmoi vfru~cev9 Hloz vfjeopjvpv qljp pjcc pmez repjrevi pmez flo v~elk greecz/ @ev~jpe pme jopjhj`lpjio#pmiuvlo`v lre rjvjoa u~ jo ~ripevp# vi arelp jv pmejrfiofero/

Fiowjofe uv qjpm ewjèofe oip qjpm pmrelpv/

Vfjeofe jv oip duvp l vubdefp jo

vfmiic/ Cjwev è~eo` u~io jp/

Pmere jv oi fjwjcjtlpjioqjpmiup vfjeofe/

Pmere jv oi vfjeofe qjpmiupfjwjcjpz/

Vfjeofe jv brikeo/ Bciaaerv lre ~lj` pi vhelr

vfjeopjvpv# lo` rlpmer pmlo èfrz pme jopjhj`lpjiolo` bucczjoa# ariu~v cjke pme@lwj` Vutukj

Giuo`lpjio#Oeq Vfjeopjvp# pme UOloÒlpure-pme diurolc,* lfpjwecz vu~~irp jp/@eVhiabciajvruo grih l ^R rh Miaalo lo` Lvvifjlpev# lo`Djh Miaalo jv io pme Vutukj Giuo`lpjio bilr`/^rigevvjiolc hlrkepjoa pz~ev lpplfk vfjeopjvpv girloz hjvplke io loz pi~jf pmez hlz mlwe ewer hlè#gir pmejr guo`joa# pmejr recjajiuv becjegv# lo` pmezvfiro pmejr freèopjlcv -pmlpv rjfm# fihjoa grih ^Rarlùlpev*/ Jg pmez flop o` guo`joa# pmez jh~cz

jp lozqlz/ Qmi oee`v ewjèofe9

Miq hloz Areeo~elfe ir Vutukj vu~~irpervkoiq pmlp pmejr ìolpjiov guo` l` mihjoeh vhelrflh~ljaov laljovp vfjeopjvpv9

Heloqmjce Dlhev Mloveo grih OLVL flccvgir ~ei~ce pi be dljce` gir èojlc/ Ioe areeoflo`j`lpe jo Luvprlcjl mlv vuaaevpe` qe hlzoee` pivuv~eo` ehifrlfz vure# cepv mlwe lpiplcjplrjlo eheraeofz vplpe pi vlwe pme fcjhlpe/ Jpv

fmjccjoa/Uvulccz ~ei~ce qmi ~ijop iup lqv lre flcce`qmjvpcebciqerv# bup jo fcjhlpe vfjeofe# pmezreèojerv/ Jg pme frjvjv(pelh mlèwjèofe# pmez qiuc` ~riwjèjp/ Jovpel` pmez flcc ~ei~ceolhev/ Airev vplggerv qere viiuprlaeiuvcz wj~eriuv lbiupioe ehjoeop ~mzvjfjvp# Gre`Vjoaer# pmlp me vue` pmeh gir

cjbec lo` qio/ Bup miq hlozvfjeopjvpv qiuc` be qjccjoa piamp gir pmejr olhev laljovp cjevgrih pme Wjfe ^revjèopv vplgg9Vjoaer qio pme flve# bup pme ~iqer igpme buccz(bizv qlv hlè fcelr/

^lp Hjfmlecv civp mjv dib lv Wjrajojlvvplpe fcjhlpiciajvp# vi `j` pme fmjegvfjeopjvp ig pme UV @e~lrpheop igEoeraz# Qjcc Ml~~er/ Pmjv vep pme

vfeoe jo pme elrcz :>v/

Bucczjoa jv oip vfjeofe



Qmz lre pme frufjlc fmefkv ig pme vfjeofepmlp uoèrcje fmloaev pi eopjre efioihjev

cegp pi uo~lj` bciaaerv lo` repjre`vfjeopjvpv9

Qe ~lj` pi o` l frjvjv

Viurfev4 Fcjhlpe Hioez Vfjeofe lo` ûbcjf îcjfz Jovpjpupe -V^^J* blve` io UV Aiweroheop lffiuopv/

ziure aulrlopee` oip pi melrlbiup jp grih loziralojvlpjio pmlp pmjokv l fioveovuv jv vfjeopjf/

Qmeo E}}ioHibjc ~lzv duvp $26 hjccjio pi vke~pjfvpme mel`cjoev ruo qjc`/ Bup qmeo $1: bjccjio jv

~iure` jopi ioe pmeirz# jp ìevop rlpe l heopjio/

Heloqmjce# èv~jpe pme bjccjiov ~iure` jo# pmefmefkv lo` lu`jpv ig pme vfjeofe lre cegp pi uo~lj`wicuopeerv/ L è`jflpe` arlvvriipv hiweheop igvfjeopjvpv mlv v~ruoa u~ lriuo` pme acibe qirkjoalaljovp pme qecc guoè`# mjamcz iralojte` fcjhlpehioi~icz/ Pmez mlwe e}~ive` èwlvplpjoa errirv/

Vjofe bjccjio ìcclrv pi pme fcjhlpe fmloae joùvprz/

Pmiuvlo`v ig vfjeopjvpv mlwe beeo guoè` pio`l fiooefpjio bepqeeo muhlo flrbio `ji}jèehjvvjiov lo` pme fcjhlpe/ Mlr`cz loz mlwe beeo

guoè` pi o` pme i~~ivjpe/ Pmriq bjccjiov igìcclrv lp ioe |uevpjio lo` miq fiuc` brjamp#è`jflpe` ~ei~ce oip o` =>> ~laev qirpm igfiooefpjiov# cjokv# ~re`jfpjiov# ~ridefpjiov lo`vfeolrjiv9 Qmlpv lhltjoa jv qmlp pmez mlweopgiuo`4 eh~jrjflc ewjèofe/

Pme BBF vlzv pmere jv l fioveovuv lo` pmuv oioee` pi ajwe e|ulc pjhe pi ipmer pmeirjev/ Qmjfmhelov pmez lre oip qejamjoa u~ pme lrauheopv#pmezre duvp fiuopjoa~l~erv/ Pmjv jv oip diurolcjvh/

Jpv ^R/ Jg pme J^FF jv qrioa# jg pmere jv l bjlv#



Viurfev4 Flrbio Prl`joa# Qirc` Blok Re~irp/

^re`jfpjiov4 Fihhi`jpjev lo` Gupurev Prl`joaFihhjvvjio -FGPF* UVL/

Bemjo` pme vfeoev# clrae olofjlc miuvev lre

hiwjoa jo vpelcpmjcz/ Jo 2>>=# flrbio prl`joaqirc`qj`e relfme` $



Pme ioe lq pmlp qj~ev iup pme frjvjv

Flrbio `ji}j`e iocz fluvev :/ Fciu`v4 V~eofer ep lc

2>>1/ Muhj`jpz# ^lcprj`ae ep lc# 2>>:/

ir voiq/ Lo` pmez lcc mlwe l `jggereop eggefp/

Ewerz ~re`jfpjio iwer



Fciu`v ìhjolpe ewerzpmjoa

Pme elrpm mlv jpv iqo ewl~irlpjwe fiicerrljo

Ewl~irlpjio lo` rljo kee~ pme ~cloep 5>Ffiicer/ Gjgpz, Ejampz ~erfeop ig pme olpurlcareeomiuve eggefp jv ùe pi muhj`jpz lo`fciu`v/ Fciu`v fiwer 7>% ir vi ig pmeeopjre ~cloep/ Oi ioe mlv loz jèl qmepmerfciu` fiwer qlv pme vlhe jo ># ir># ir eweo / Jpv l auevv/

Pme J^FF lo` pme hièccerv l`hjp pmezìop ì fciu`v ir rljo qecc/ Bup pmeveglfpirv lre pme hlvper koibv io Elrpmvfcjhlpe fiopric uojp/

Jg pme fih~uper vjhuclpjiov lre iocziup bz l geq ~erfeop# loz pjoz fmloae joewl~irlpjio# fciu`v ir rljo qjcc qj~e iuppme qlrhjoa grih flrbio lo` jp flo ì jpjo `lzv/

Lc Aire èvfrjbev miq flrbio `ji}jèbelpv u~ Hr Vuobelh lo` vpi~v mjhcelwjoa pme lphiv~mere/ Bup me giraip piheopjio pmlp fciu`v reefp lriuo` l |ulrperig lcc pme vuocjamp pmlp mjpv pme elrpm/ Pmive

belhv ig cjamp prlwec lcc pme qlz grih pmevuo pi aep biuofe` igg jopi v~lfe qmeo pmezlre duvp l geq kjciheperv grih pme ariuo`/

Loz fmloae jo fciu` fiwer hlkev l hldir`jggereofe/ Pme J^FF lvvuhev fciu`vrev~io` pi qlrhjoa# bup fciu`v fiuc`

elvjcz `rjwe pme qlrhjoa/

Pmere lre cipv ig pmjoav pmlp fiuc`~ipeopjlccz fmloae fciu` fiwer# qmjfmqiuc` lggefp iur fcjhlpe/ Pmjoav cjkefivhjf rlzv -vee ~lae F fiicer# Qlper Fzfce OLVL Vfjeofe/


8/20= Pme Vke~pjfv Mlo`biik JJ dilooeoiwl/fih/lu

Grluùceop mifkez vpjfkv lo` mj`èo `lpl

Pme vmlr~ u~qlr` vqjoa ig pme arl~m qlv ùe pi ioe vjoace

pree jo Zlhlc/

Viurfev4 HfJopzre ' HfKjprjfk 2>>6 lo` 2>>5# Hloo ep lc >7# rel` HfJopzre lp fcjhlpelu`jp/fih# vee FcjhlpeAlpe/

Jpv l vir`j` plce ig l arl~m pmlp iwerpmreq èflèv

ig qirk# fioweojeopcz ppe` pme fcjhlpe hiècv#lo` qlv cluè` prjuh~mlopcz jo acivvz ~ubcjflpjiolgper ~ubcjflpjio/ Bup pmeo jp qlv fruvme` qmeolo uo~lj` lolczvp vprj~~e` jp blre/ Jp ml` beeo

~ubcjvme` jo pme mjamevp hivp ~revpjajiuv diurolc#Olpure# bup oi ioe ml` fmefke` jp begire ir lgperjp qlv v~rel` glr lo` qjè/ OipOlpure# oip pmeJ^FF# oip loz ipmer fcjhlpe revelrfmer/

Jo < re~irp/ Aiweroheop è~lrpheopvfi~je` jp/ Pme he`jl pic` ewerzioe/

Bup Vpeweo HfJopzre qlv vuv~jfjiuv/ Me qlope`pi werjgz jp# zep Hloo re~elpe`cz reguve` pi

~riwjè mjv `lpl ir hepmi`v oirhlccz l blvjfre|ujreheop ig loz vfjeopjf ~l~er/ Jp piik cealclfpjio pi aep pme jogirhlpjio pmlp vmiuc` mlwe beeogreecz lwljclbce/ Qjpmjo `lzv HfJopzre vmiqe` pmlppme vplpjvpjfv qere vi lqe` pmlp ziu fiuc` gee`jo rloìh `lpl# lo` vpjcc hlke pme vlhe mifkezvpjfk vml~e ojoe pjhev iup ig peo/ Hloo ml` cegp iupvihe pree rjoav me vlj` me` jofcuè`/ Jg viheioe`j` l arl~m cjke pmjv jo l vpifk ~riv~efpuv# pmezqiuc` be dljce`/

Lvpiojvmjoacz#Olpure reguve` pi ~ubcjvm pmefirrefpjio/ Jp qlv ~ubcjvme` ecveqmere# lo`

blfke` u~ bz pme Qeahlo Re~irp# lo joè~eoèopfihhjppee ig vplpjvpjflc e}~erpv/

Jo 2>>: HfJopzre `j` jp laljo qjpm Brjgglv MifkezVpjfk/ Lgper lvkjoa lo` qljpjoa pmree zelrv girpme `lpl# jp piik duvp pmree `lzv pi e}~ive jp piilv blvecevv/ Gir ojoe zelrv Brjggl ml` fiofelce`pmlp me iocz ml`


9/20 Dilooe Oiwl 2>>: Pme Vke~pjfv Mlo`biik JJ :

Hlrke` io pme hl~ lre vpu`z lgper vpu`zgrih lcc lriuo` pme qirc` qjpm revucpvig peh~erlpurev grih pme he`jewlc pjhefih~lre` pi pi`lz/ Pmeve uve jfe firev#vplclahjpev# ve`jheopv# lo` jvipi~ev/ Pmezlaree qjpm 7#/5F qlrher qirc` qjè/

Vke~pjflc vfjeopjvpv mlwe cjperlccz muo`re`v igvlh~cev/ Uovke~pjflc vfjeopjvpv mlwe ioe preejo Zlhlc# lo` l geq lqe` brjvpcefioev///

Jp qlv lo lu`lfjiuv grlu`/

Viurfev4 Ciemce 2>>1# Mluoa lo` îcclfk zelrv lai# ' fiicer 6>> zelrv lai/ Qe vplrpe`qlrhjoa cioa begire flrv lo` ~iqervplpjiov qere joweope`/

Pmerev cjppce firreclpjio qjpm FI2 cewecv/

Jpv fcelr pmlp pme qirc` qlv qlrher ùrjoa he`jewlc pjhev

Pme vi(flcce` e}~erp rewjeq jv

helojoacevv/ Pme J^FF vlz 2#5>>e}~erpv rewjeq pmejr re~irpv# bup pmive

vlhe e}~erpv hlè pme blvecevvMifkez Vpjfk arl~m pmejr ciai jo 2>>> zelrv lai/

Pme hiècv lre qrioa/

///pmezèozlccpmevevpu`jev



FcjhlpeAlpe,

Viurfe4 Fcjhlpe Lu`jp/ Qlrqjfk Muamev/ lprjfk Hjfmlecv -Olpjiolc Rewjeq Iocjoe Ve~p 2>>:*/

Vfjeofe qlv rj~e pi be e}~cijpe`/

Iur clqv ~ripefp jowevpirv grih bejoa fmelpe`

bz pme fir~irlpe qirc`# bup pmere lre oi ~icjfegir pme clqv ig vfjeofe/ Oi ioe jo buvjoevv

qiuc` aep lqlz qjpm pmeve fcljhv# bup jo pmeqirc` ig ~icjpjfv# qecc prlovgirh eopjre olpjiolc

efioihjev blve` io vfjeofe pmlp uvev `lpl oi

ioe flo werjgz ir lu`jp/

@lpl gir vfjeopjvpv jv cjke refej~pv gir fih~lozlffiuoplopv/ Jpv l refir` ig qmlp ml~~eoe`/ Zephloz fcjhlpe revelrfmerv mjè pmejr `lpl# reguvjoare~elpe` re|uevpv pi ~riwjè jp/

^mjc Dioev grih pme Elvp Loacjl Fcjhlpe RevelrfmUojp mlv reguve` pi ajwe iup `lpl èv~jpe hlozre|uevpv/ Jo ioe vufm reguvlc# Jwe re~clfe` pmeqir` `lpl qjpm refej~p# ipmerqjve pmjv jv l`jrefp |uipe/ Jhlajoe mev plckjoa pi pme pl} igfe/

Qe mlwe 25 ir vi zelrvjowevpe` jo pme qirk/

Qmz vmiuc` J hlke pme[refej~pvX lwljclbce piziu# qmeo ziur ljh jv piprz lo` gjo` vihepmjoa

qrioa qjpm jp/

Jg pme lffiuoplopv gir Eorio vlj`

pmjv# pmez qiuc` be dljce`/

Jpv l feoprlc peoep ig vfjeofe pmlp iofe l ~l~er jv~ubcjvme` pme rlq `lpl# hepmi`v lo` lcc reclpe`jogirhlpjio jv hlè ~ubcjf# vi lozioe qmi qlopvpi re~elp pme qirk lo` wlcj`lpe pme hepmi`v flofmefk jp/ Lcc re~uplbce vfjeofe diurolcv mlwe pmjvqrjppeo jopi pmejr fmlrperv# bup vprloaecz hloz lreoip eogirfjoa jp qmeo jp fihev pi fcjhlpe revelrfm/Eweo hire i``cz# pme J^FF ìevop veeh pi hjo`pmlp oi ioe flo fmefk revucpv ejpmer/ Oir ìev Lc

Aire fih~cljo/

Vpewe HfJopzre mlv beeo lvkjoa gir pme aciblc `lplgrih pme Elvp Loacjl FRU vjofe 2>>2/ Pmez mlwe

~riwjè` jp pi ipmer revelrfmerv# bup reguve` HfJopzrevlzjoa mev oip lo lflèhjf/ Vi Vpewe aip lo

lflèhjf ficcelaue pi lvk# bup laljo pmez qerereguve`# pmjv pjhe befluve jp qlv fihherfjlc jofioèofe lo` qiuc` brelk lareeheopv/ Oe}p pmezcluofme` cealc lfpjio pi vee pme lareeheopv# bup l~lrpgrih l geq ig pmive# pmezre lcc aioe pii/ Pmere lreiocz vi hloz e}fuvev ziu flo hlke/

Fiuc` jp aep qirve9 Jp fiuc`# lo` jp `j`/

L~~lreopcz pme eopjre irjajolc aciblc

refir`v ig fcjhlpe `lpl lre oiq ///

aioe# civp/ Lcc pmlp pme Elvp LoacjlFRU flo ~riwjè jv pme l`duvpe`

`lpl/

Aciblc peh~erlpure refir`v lre hjvvjoaVfjeofe mlv beeo firru~pe`/

Pmjv jv ~ubcjf`lpl/

Pmez lre ~ubcjf verwlopv/

Qe lre pme ~ubcjf/

Jpv l vflo`lc/

BRELKJOA OEQV Oiw 26 2>>:4 Grlu`# ficcuvjio# firru~pjio ìfuheope`/ Ehljcvcelke` ir mlfke` iup ig pme Elvp Loacjl FRU vmiq pmlp vihe vfjeopjvpv mlwe ècepe` `lpl rlpmerpmlo ~riwjè` jp pi heep cealc `jvfcivure re|uevpv/Pmez l`duvpe` revucpv jo irèr pi mjè pme

èfcjoe jo peh~erlpurev/ Pmez bclfkblo lo` bizfipp vfjeofe diurolcv pmlp ~ubcjvm vke~pjflchlperjlc# lo` pmez ficcuè pi ewjfp vke~pjflc vfjeopjvpv grih ~rigevvjiolc iralojvlpjiov/


11/20 Dilooe Oiwl 2>>: Pme Vke~pjfv Mlo`biik JJ


12/20


13/20


14/20


15/20 Dilooe Oiwl 2>>: Pme Vke~pjfv Mlo`biik JJ hjccjio qmi

qiop aep fcelo qlper vihe ig qmih qjcc `jegrih fmicerl ir `zveoperz/

Jg qe eh~ciz pmiuvlo`v ig lffiuoplopv# clqzervlo` lu`jpirv pi hiojpir l vfmehe pmlpv ~ijopcevv#jp helov lcc pmeve mioevp mlr`qirkjoa ~ei~celre qlvpjoa ewerzioev pjhe lo` reviurfev/ Pmezfiuc` be o`joa l fure gir flofer# ir gee`joakj`v jo Mljpj/ Pmez fiuc` be pelfmjoa fmjc`reomere pi uve ciajf lo` relvio# lo` mec~ vpi~pme oe}p aeoerlpjio grih qlvpjoa bjccjiov io

hlouglfpure` vflrev/

/

Vlwjoa eoeraz ir vpi~~joa ~iccupjio jv l aii` pmjoa/Qmlpv pme `loaer jo lfpjoa oiq9


16/20


17/20 Dilooe Oiwl 2>>: Pme Vke~pjfv Mlo`biik JJ >a* ige}prl areeoerz/ Pmjv mec~v gee` pme qirc`/

Qe lre flrbio cjge girhv

Lbiup 5>> hjccjio ~ei~ce lre lcjwe

pi`lz qmi qiucòp be# jg flrbio`ji}jè cewecv mlòp rjveo clvpfeopurz/

Viurfev4 Oehloj 2>>6# Kjhblcc


18/20> zelrv pmlp pmerev vihe

cjok bepqeeo vuov~ipv lo` iur fcjhlpe/ Jo ># pmelvprioiher Qjccjlh Mervfmec `jòp oee` l fcjhlpehièc# me `jòp eweo mlwe l flcfuclpir zep mefiuc` vee pmlp qmelp ~rjfev rive lo` gecc jo pjhe qjpmpme vuov~ip fzfce/ Vjofe pmeo# ~ei~ce mlwe oipjfe`pmlp rljoglcc ~lpperov lre lcvi cjoke` pi vuov~ipv/

Vuov~ipv pmehvecwev ìop hlke hufm `jggereofepi uv# bup pmez lre l vjao ig miq qelk ir vprioa pmevuov hlaoepjf ec` jv/ Pmjv hlvvjwe viclr hlaoepjfec` relfmev iup lriuo` pme Elrpm# lo` jp vmjec`v

uv grih fivhjf rlzv/ @r Meorjk Vweovhlrk mlvvuaaevpe` pmlp jg hire fivhjf rlzv relfm gurpmerìqo jopi iur lphiv~mere# pmez hjamp jiojtehicefucev lo` mec~ vee` hire fciu`v/

Lv jp ml~~eov# pmjv zelr# pme vuo mlv lchivp oivuov~ipv# bup gir hufm ig pme clpe 2>pm Feopurz#pme viclr hlaoepjf ec` qlv e}prehecz lfpjwe/ Jgpme pmeirz jv rjamp# lo lfpjwe ec` helov l qlrhjoa

elrpm qjpm geqer fciu`v/ L |ujep vuo pmiuam# helov lfiicer elrpm qjpm hire fciu`v/

LAQ re~cjev4 Cifmqii` lo` Grimcjfm vmiqe` pmepmeirz ìevop prjvjoa peh~erlpurev lgper /Vke~pjfv vlz4 Pmez uve`vurglfe peh~erlpurev# oiplphiv~merjf ioev -vee pme arl~m lbiwe*/ Fivhjfrlzv firreclpe qecc qjpm peh~erlpurev grih qelpmer(

blcciiov/ Bup pmerhiheperv io pme vurglfe lrelggefpe` bz pmjoav cjke flr(~lrkv# lo` ljr fio`jpjioervqmjfm lre fcive pi pme veovirv/ Lcc pmlp Cifkqii` lo`Grimcjfm ~riwe jv pmlp pmerev oi cjok bepqeeo fivhjfrlzv lo` ljr fio`jpjioerv/

LAQ re~cjev4 Pmerev oi cjok qjpm fciu`v lo` fivhjfrlzv ejpmer/Vke~pjfv vlz4 Pmlpv iocz prue jg ziu ciik lp pmeqrioa kjo` ig rlzv lo` pme qrioa kjo` ig fciu`v/Pmerev l aii` firreclpjio bepqeeo mjam eoeraz rlzvlo` ciq fciu`v/

Vweovhlrkv Fivhjf Rlz Pmeirz4 L vprioaer viclr(

hlaoepjf ec` helov geqer fivhjf rlzv# lo` geqerfciu`v io elrpm/

Viurfev4 Vweovhlrk 2>>1# Fciu`v lo` Fivhjf rlzv# Vweovhlrk 2>>:/


19/20 Dilooe Oiwl 2>>: Pme Vke~pjfv Mlo`biik JJ #>>> zelrv/ Bup ai blfk5>> hjccjio zelrv lo` flrbio cewecv qere oip duvp(2>% mjamer# pmez qere peo pi pqeopz pjhevmjamer# lo` oip duvp gir l eepjoa èflè ir pqi

bup gir l vplaaerjoa muo`re` hjccjio zelrv/

Pme Elrpm mlv pmiriuamcz pevpe` pme ruolqlzareeomiuve eggefp# lo` oipmjoa ml~~eoe`/ Joèe`pme Elrpm vcj~~e` jopi lo jfe lae qmjce FI2 qlvglr mjamer pmlo pi`lzv cewecv/

Qmlpewer qlrhjoa eggefp vu~er(fiofeoprlpe`(FI2mlv# jpv oi hlpfm gir pme ipmer fcjhlpjf girfev iuppmere/

Vi oip iocz mlv elrpm prje` lo` pevpe` mjam FI2cewecv# bup hivp ig cjge io elrpm ewicwe` qmeo bipmFI2 lo` peh~erlpurev qere mjamer/ Pmlpv qmzflrbio cewecv `ri~~e` grih pmejr ~elkv pi oelrpi`lzv cewec/ Cjge io elrpm vufke` jp iup ig pme vkzlv jp ewicwe`/

Lp pme furreop rlpe qe

lre jofrelvjoa FI2# qe

qjcc mjp mjvpirjf refir`

cewecv jo duvp 6#6>>

zelrv/

Pi`lz pmere jv lbiup

0>>~~h ig FI2 jo pme

ljr# ir lbiup >/>0%/ Jp

jv jofrelvjoa bz lbiup

2~~h l zelr/

Flrbio cewecv mlwe beeo hufm mjamer

Ciik lp pme arl~m mlcg l bjccjiozelrv ig mjvpirz lo` qmerev pme

firreclpjio9

Flrbio cewecv mlwe rjveo lo` glcceo 2>>> ~~h lo`pme peh~erlpure ìevop flre cevv/

LAQ re~cjev4 Jp qlvop hlo hlè FI2/Vke~pjfv vlz4 Jpv pme vlhe hicefuce/

LAQ re~cjev4 Qere ~uppjoa iup FI2 glvper pmlojp mlv ewer beeo ~up iup/Vke~pjfv vlz4 Vu~er(wicfloiev mlwe uocelvme` glrhire FI2 hufm glvper pmlo qe flo/

LAQ re~cjev4 Bup peh~erlpurev lre rjvjoa glvperpmlo ewer/Vke~pjfv vlz4 Miq qiuc` ziu koiq9 Qewe ioczml` aciblc pmerhiheper refir`v gir zelrv iupig 5>> hjccjio/ Jpv rj`jfuciuv pi fih~lre 2> zelrpreo`v laljovp refir`v grih jfe firev ir pree rjoav/

L glvper rjve iwer l vmirp ~erji` qiucòp vmiq u~/

Viurfev4 Vfipeve # Beroer 2>>


20/20

giicv# qmi qiuc` vecc pmejr iqo fmjc`reo///* Qe

koiq ziucc ì pme rjamp pmjoa/ Duvp vjao mere/// 4(*

Lc Aire qiop èblpe# me qiop lovqer |uevpjiovjo ~ubcjf# me qiop ~riwjè mjv vcjèv uve` jo~ubcjfVeolpe Brjeoav/ Bup me qlopv uv lcc pi ~lz bjccjiov

gir mjv fluvev/

Qe duvp qlop vprljamp lovqerv/

Qmerev pme ewjèofe9

Pmez pmjok pmezre rj`joa lo efi(areeoqlwe

J uve` pi pmjok flrbio `ji}jè

qlv bl` pii# pmeo J giuo` iuppme ipmer mlcg ig pme vpirz# lo`

jp vmifke` he/

Jpv he4

Pjhe gir fjpjteov

pi qlke u~ ziu

lre bejoa gceefe`/

Pjhe gir vfjeopjvpv

pi vplo` u~ lo`vpi~ pme rip/

Pjhe gir areeojev

pi lvk qmz

qiuc` blokv be

areeo9

Pjhe gir ewerzioepi vplo` u~ pi pme

buccjev/

@eojer jv oip

vfjeofe# jpv olhe(

flccjoa/

Jp mlv lcc pme hlrkv ig l fio/ Murrz# ziu huvpvjao u~ oiq# iocz 6> `lzv cegp gir ziur fmlofe pibe l qirc` vlwjoa celèr, Plke jp oiq# lo` vefure

ziur ~clfe jo mjvpirz, Jpv l |uevpjio ig hirlcv/ @ijp gir ziur fmjc`reo,

@iop qirrz lbiup pme èpljcv# jpv lcc beeo ìoe

gir ziu/ Pmere jv l fioveovuv,

Befluve ziure jh~irplop qere iggerjoa pi hlkeziu ioe ig pme vecefp Grjeo`v ig pme Fmljr$/

-Cufkz ziure oip ioe ig pmive vecvm# jaoirlop

Bup jpv l `jggereop kjo` igareeo

DiOiwl

$ Zev pmez relccz `j` pmjv Pme @lojvm ^rjhe Hjojvper lqlrè` Kewjo Ru`` pme ^rjhe Hjojvper ig Luvprlcjl pmjv pjpce

The Skeptic's Handbook II

Documents

Transcript of The Skeptic's Handbook II