THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA...

45
THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS (Formerly the Excavations at Sepphoris Manual for Area Supervisors) James F. Strange Thomas R. W. Longstaff Dennis E. Groh James Riley Strange Copyright 2017, The Shikhin Excavation Project, Israel

Transcript of THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA...

Page 1: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

THESHIKHINEXCAVATIONPROJECT MANUALFORAREASUPERVISORS

(FormerlytheExcavationsatSepphorisManualforAreaSupervisors)

JamesF.Strange ThomasR.W.Longstaff DennisE.Groh

JamesRileyStrange Copyright2017,TheShikhinExcavationProject,Israel

Page 2: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

i

TABLEOFCONTENTS

IntroductionObjectivesPeculiaritiesofaRuinBibliography

ExcavationMethodsThe"RulesofExcavation"StartingaNewSquare

TheProbeTrenchDatumPointsLineLevelElevationsSurveyor'sElevationsLocationoftheDump

ExcavatingSpecificFeaturesWalls

Floors Pits Fills Dumps FoundationTrenches Burials ChoiceofTools Strategy Objectives Priorities

LayingOutaBuildingforExcavation:TheGridFieldsinourExcavations

TheRecordingSystemTheTopPlan

Definition Conventions

HeadingDrawingstonesElevationsLocusnumbers The"PointOne"Locus

Boundaries Potterybucketnumbers

Mini-balkdrawings

FieldNotesBoxingNumbersPageOrganizationText

What Why Where

1122

2244555555666667777778

888888888999

9999999

Page 3: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

ii

ColorCompactionParticleSize

WallsTheLocusSheetPotteryTagsArtifactTagsCoinEnvelopesBiologicalMaterials

StratificationandStratigraphyDefinitionsColor

HueValueChroma

TextureComposition

ConditionofmaterialsConcentrationofmaterials

RecognitionofMethodsofDepositionWater-laidlayersWind-laidmaterialMan-madelayers

FillMake-upandlevelingoperationsAccumulationonfloorsCourtyardsFloors,pavedFloors,beatenearthPits

BalksTrimmingandMaintainingBalksNoThoroughfareTemporaryCrossBalksBalkTagsBalkDrawing

ScaleDatumlineDrawingthebalkCaller

BalkRemoval

WeeklyReportsWeeklyTopPlanTextIndices

Photographs

999

101011111111

121212121212121212121213131313131313131313

1414141515151515151616

16161616

16

Page 4: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

iii

PrinciplesofFieldPhotographyRecordPhotosPublicationPhotosPhotographIndex

ArtifactAnalysisinCampPotteryReadingCrudeWaresFineWaresPotteryRegistrationPotteryRestorationArtifactRegistryComputerRegistryCoinReadingsPresupposedArchaeologicalPeriodsArchitecturalFragmentsArchitecturalFragmentListFillingOuttheLocusSheet

FinalCommentsandInterpretationsSketchofLocusStratigraphicRelationshipsAveragePhysicalDimensionsContentsParticleSizeRecordingPotteryReadingsTheMentionIndex

SampleLocusSheetSampleLocusSheetforWalls

GlossaryAppendix1:TheIdentificationofCharcoalAppendix2:SampleDailyNotesAppendix3:SampleDailyTopPlanAppendix4:SampleFilledinLocusSheetAppendix5:SampleFilledinLocusSheetforWallsAppen-dix6:SampleFinalTopPlanAppendix7:SampleBalkDrawingAppendix8:SampleweeklyreportAnnotatedBibliography:ExcavationMethodsin

PalestinianArchaeology

17171

717171717171717181819191919202020202020202121212224

26

3031323335363738

39

Page 5: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

1

PREFACE

(Adaptedfrom“TheAmericanArchaeologicalFieldSchoolinGalilee:PedagogicalGoals,EducationalOutcomesandParticipantImpact,”byPennyLongMarlerandJamesRileyStrange)Tothebestofourknowledge,themodelfortheShikhinExcavationProject(SEP)fieldschoolbegantotakeshapeintheearly1960s.In1963,YigaelYa-dinbeganusingbothIsraeliandforeignvolunteersatMasada.Probablyoneyearearlierin’62,DavidNoelFreedmanbeganasimilarpracticeattheAsh-dodExcavationProject.Bothexcavationstrainedvolunteersinmethod.AtAshdod,Freedmanmadethedig’seducationalgoalsandtraininginmethodexplicit,andheofferedlecturestovolunteers.In1964,HebrewUnionCollegeJerusalemandtheUni-versityofNorthCarolinaChapelHillofferedasum-merseminarinIsraelthatincludedsometimeexca-vatingatTellArad.Intothemid1970s,BernardBoydofUNCChapelHillcontinuedtoofferlectures,pre-sumablytobothstudentandnon-studentvolunteersatdigshehelpedtoorganizeatBeersheba,Lachish,andArad.In1964,WilliamG.Dever,astudentofG.ErnestWrightandveteranoftheDrew-McCormickExpedi-tionatShechem,beganusingstudentsandnon-studentparticipantsratherthanhiredworkersasthebasefortheexcavationcrewoftheHebrewUnionCollege/HarvardSemiticMuseumExcavationsatTellGezer.Devergivestworationalesformakingthischange:thefirstwastoassignthediggingtopeoplewhowereeducatedinarchaeologicalreasoningandexcavationmethods;thesecondwastopopularizeandspreadAmericanarchaeologicalmethods.H.DarrellLancewroteanExcavationManualforAreaSupervisorsforGezerin1967followedbyDever’sandLance’sAManualofFieldExcavationin1978.ArchaeologistswithtiestoGezerexportedandadaptedthismodeltoothersiteexcavations:nota-blyJoeD.SegeratTellel-ḤesiandEricM.Meyers,A.ThomasKraabel,JamesF.Strange,andCarolMeyersattheMeironExcavationProject(MEP).RobertJ.Bull,alsoaveteranofShechem,setupasimilarschoolatCaesarea.J.F.StrangewrotethemanualsforbothCaesareaandMeiron,andtheMEPin-creasedthenumberofeveninglectureswhileaddingafternoonandweekendsitetours.TheMEPgavetwocoursesforcredit(sixhours),andbeginningin1970placedan“EducationalDirector”onitsseniorstaff.

TheUSFExcavationsatSepphorisadaptedthemethodtotheircityexcavation,andtheShikhinex-cavationprojectalsomadeappropriateadjustmentsbutkepttheprovenpracticesintact.TheaimsoftheSEPfieldschool,therefore,aretocollectdataandtoeducatethepeoplewhocollectthedata.ThisMan-ualexplainshowandwhytoachievethefirstgoal.Itspurposeisthesecond.

INTRODUCTIONAtthesiteofShikhin,AreaSupervisorscontroltheexcavation,recovery,andrecordingofdatathathelpthedirectorsformapictureofdailylifeatancientShikhin.Accordingly,notaskismoreimportant.TheworkrequiresthatAreaSupervisorssomewhatin-geniouslymaintainbothscientificcontrolandSquaremorale,andthattheythinkbeyondthemomenttoanimaginedfuturewhendigdirectorscombthroughtheirfieldnotes,seekingtounderstandhowexcava-tionsproceededonaparticularday,grasponesoillayer’srelationshiptoanother,orevencorrectanerrorinaregistry.Itisessential,therefore,thatAreaSupervisorsknowthedetailsofthediggingandre-cordingmethod,andthattheyappreciatewhythesedetailsareimportant.Objectives:Beforesinkingaspadeintotheground,itisabsolutelyimperativethatAreaSupervisorshaveaclearideaof(l)whattheyaredoingand(2)whytheyaredoingit.Themorebasicquestionisthesecond.Iftheyhaveformedaclearanswertothisquestion,theyareinabetterpositiontoanswerthefirst.Ifthethrillandromanceofdiscoveryistheaim,thenmethodologycansimplybediggingholesforpots.Ifsomemoreglobalaimcontrolstheprocess,suchastheelucidationandreconstructionofhistoryandculture,orthediscoveryofthelawsofprocessinhumanculture,thenamuchmorecarefulapproachisinorder.Morethansixtyyearsago,W.Taylornotedthatthegatheringofdatafromanarchaeologicalsitere-allyfollowedfromthedesiretorecoverwhathecalledthe“humanenvironment”(1948).Twentyyearslater,R.A.HeizerandJ.A.A.Grahamcalleditthedesire“tolearnasmuchaspossibleabouttheformofcultureandwayoflifeof(ancient)people.”Sincethen,othershaveofferedthegoalofunder-standingculturethroughanexplicitlyscientificap-proach,throughsystemstheory,orthrougheco-logicalmodels.Othersseektodisclosepastwaysofthinkingaboutthingsasdeducedfromarchaeologi-calremains(cognitivearchaeology).Thenthereare

Page 6: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

2

concernsforgender,history,evolution,post-modernconcerns,andquestionsofvalueandreligion(orrit-ual).Allofthesehavefollowers,butwefindourconceptualhometobeclosesttothegoalsofsocialarchaeology,i.e.,thereconstructionofpastsocialsystemsandrelations(Renfrew1984).Archaeologymakesavailablethephysicalevidenceforpasthu-manactivityandvaluesandthusprovidesim-portantlydifferentinformationthanthatfoundinliterarytexts.Literarytextstendtofocusonunusualoratypicalindividuals,thosewhomakehistory.Ar-chaeologyprovidesabroaderrangeofinformation,oftenfromtheactivitiesofthosepeopleandgroupswhogounmentionedinliterarytexts.Broadlyspeaking,archaeologicalmethodisde-signedtorecoverandrecorddatainsuchawaythatthearchaeologistscaninferamodelofanevolvingsocialworld.Theinferenceisultimatelymadethroughverbaldescriptions(fieldnotes),top-plans,sections,andphotographs.Earliergenerationsofarchaeologistsconcentratedeitherontheverticaldimensionofdiggingdowntolivingsurfacesoruponarchitectureasdefinedexclusivelybywallsandroomsofagivenbuilding.TheSepphorisandShikhinmethodincorporatesbothoftheseformerconcernsandemphasizestheinterrelationshipofthelociandstrata(seebelow)andthestructures.Archaeologistsdigvertically,butancientpeoplelivedhorizontally:thatis,withinagivenspatialandtemporalperiod.Hence,stratigraphicarchaeologymaybesaidtobeamethodbywhichdepositsinspaceareturnedfirstintorecordsofinferredsequences(whichdepositscamefirstandwhichcamelater),andthenintocomplextechnologies,socialstructures,beliefs,andvaluesthatchangedovertime(thehistoricalandhumandimension).Inanycase,thepotentialarchaeologistneedstoknowthatarchaeologicalexcavationisadestructivescience.Intheprocessofexaminingtheevidencethearchaeologistdestroysit.Materialswillneveragainlieastheydobeforetheyareexposedbyanexcavation.Inotherwords,fieldworkbyitsveryna-turedismantlestheoriginalrecordinsoilandstone.Therefore,itmustfollowthattheresponsibilityoftheAreaSupervisororvolunteerasarchaeologistincludeskeepingascompletearecordasisreasona-blypossible.Itisevennecessarytorecordthingsthatmayappeartobetrivialorofnospecialsignifi-cancetotheneophyte.Oneneverknowswhatwillbeimportantlater. Consequently,justastheaimofarchaeologymaybeunderstoodintermsofthereconstructionofpast

socialsystemsandrelations,soitsmethodincludes(l)diggingwithmaximumcontroland(2)recordingformaximuminformationretrieval.Thepersonreadingthismanualshouldkeepinmind,then,thattheexcavationandrecordingsys-tempresentedhereisintendedtoreflectthistwo-foldconsideration.Itsusefulnesswillbejudgedbyitsabilitytoenabletheexcavatortofulfilltheneedforcontrolandtherecoveryofdata.PeculiaritiesofaRuin:Thereisanothercon-sideration,however,andthatisthenatureofthesiteitself.Aruin,suchasancientSepphorisorShikhin,makespeculiardemandsonthearchaeolo-gistthatatelldoesnot:namely,unlikeatell,inaru-in,lateroccupantsoftendugintoorevenclearedawaythedebrisofearlieroccupants.TellsarethemoretraditionalsitesofinterestinancientNearEasternarchaeology.InthecasesofSepphorisandShikhin,wehavematerial,sometimesdeep,some-timesshallow,depositedastheresultofnaturalpro-cessessuchaserosion,orasaresultofhumanactivi-ty.Wehaveoccasionaltracesofwallsatthesurface,undergroundchambers,re-usedbuildingstones,stonefall,andothercharacteristicsuniquetoaruin.Excavatinginthiscontextrequiresauniqueresponsefromtheexcavator.Thismanualistheresultofmanyyears’digginginruinsandinafewtells.Ithasbenefitedfromcriticismsfromstudents,AreaSuper-visors,FieldSupervisors,andothers.Itistothemthatitisdedicated.ShortBibliographyBell,JamesA.(2009)ReconstructingPrehistory:Sci-

entificMethodinArchaeology.Philadelphia:TempleUniversityPress.

Dever,WilliamG.andLance,eds.,1978.AManualof

FieldExcavation:HandbookforFieldAr-chaeologists.Jerusalem:HebrewUnionCol-lege.

Groh,Dennis(2014)“TheAmericanFieldSchooland

theFutureofBiblicalArchaeology.”InACitySetonaHill:EssaysinHonorofJamesF.Strange,ed.DanielA.WarnerandDonaldD.Binder.MountainHome,Arkansas:BorderStonePress,128–160.

Hodder,Ian.(1991)“PostprocessualArchaeology

andtheCurrentDebate.”InProcessualandPost-ProcessualArchaeologies:MultipleWaysofKnowingthePast,EditedbyR.Preucel,pp.30–

Page 7: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

3

41.CAISouthernIllinoisUniversityatCarbon-dale,OccasionalPaperNo.10.

EricM.Meyers,Editor.(1997)TheOxfordEncyclo-

pediaofArchaeologyintheNearEast.AmericanSchoolsofOrientalResearch,Oxford:OxfordUniversityPress.

Praetzellis,A.(2000)DeathbyTheory:ATaleofMys-

teryandArchaeologicalTheory.AltaMiraPress.BruceTrigger(1989).AHistoryofArchaeological

Thought.CambridgeUniversityPress.

EXCAVATIONMETHODSBeforelaunchingintoadiscussionofexcavationmethods,afewwordsaboutsurveyingwillbehelp-ful.MostexcavationslikethoseatSepphorisandShikhinbeginwithanarchaeologicalsurvey,con-ductedeitherbythearchaeologistswhodigthesiteorbyaseparateteam.Forourpurposes,“survey”referstotwoactivities.Thefirstistowalkthesiteandsimplytolookatit.Volunteersspreadoutinalineandwalkslowly,witheyestotheground,watch-ingforanythingthatinterruptstheorganicjumbleofnature:concentrationsofpotterysherds,architec-turalfragments,threeormorestonesinastraightline,cuttingsinbedrock,cisternopenings,tombs,andsoon.Suchindicatorsofhumanactivityallowarchaeologiststomakeeducatedinferencesaboutwheretosinktheirfirstprobes.Also,althoughtheywillnotbetiedtoparticularloci(seebelow),thetypesofpotterysherdsandtheirrelativefrequencyenablearchaeologiststoformhypothesesaboutthelifeofasettlement(foundingdate,periodsofgrowthanddecline,andabandonment),whetherpotterywasmadelocallyorimported,wheredo-mesticspacesprobablystoodindistinctiontoindus-trialandothertypesofspace,andmanyotherthings,allofwhichcanbetestedbyexcavating.Theseconduseof“survey”matchesmorecloselywhatmanythinkof:inthe“olddays,”theuseofsurveyor’stransit,chains,andrangepoles;andmorerecently,theuseoftotalstationorextremelypower-fulGPS(globalpositioningsatellite)orGNSS(globalnavigationsatellitesystems)receiverstocreateacontourmapofthesiteanditsfeaturesofarchaeo-logicalinterest.Aswithothertechnologiesthathavetransformedwhatusedtobedoneonpaperalone,themapiscreateddigitallybeforeeverbeingprint-ed.Indeed,itmayneverseepaper.Also,itcanbecombinedwithaerialphotographyofthesitetocre-ateaGIS(geographicimagingsystem)database,

whichitselfcancontainastartlingamountofdata,includinginformationfromremotesensing(satellitephotos,LIDAR,andothertechnologiesthat“seethrough”vegetationandeventhesoil)aswellasrawdatacollectedinthefieldintheformofdrawings,photographs,andevenhand-writtenfieldnotes.Thedatabasecanthenbemadeavailableon-lineandininteractiveform,anditcanbecontinuallyeditedandupdatedasmoredatacomeoutofadig,towhichsubjectwenowturn.The“rulesofexcavation”arederivedfromtworeadilyunderstandableprinciples:(1)Onedigseachlocus(orthree-dimensionalfeature,includingsoillayers—seeGlossary)separatelyfromallotherloci,andonedoessowithmaximumcontrol.(2)Theaimofstratigraphicdiggingistoseparatetheartifacts,pottery,biologicalsamples,etc.fromeachlocusascleanlyaspossible,aseachlayerisunderstoodbyitsownuniquecontentsanddatedbythelatestartifactwithinit.InAmericanexcavationsintheMiddleEast,oneormorecontemporarylocimakeupa“phase,”asetofphasesconstitutesa“stratum,”andthevarious“strata”formthematerialhistoryofthesite.Forex-ample,allofthelocithatdatetoadiscreetsub-historicalperiodconstitutea“phase,”suchastheEarlyRomanphase.Allthephasesthatdatetoahis-toricalperiodconstituteastratum—i.e.,onemayhypothesizethattheERstratumiscomprisedofEar-lyRomanphases1and2.Butourunderstandingofthecharacteristicsofstrata,phases,andlociintermsofrelativeorabsolutedate,typeofoccupation,andsoforthrestsuponourknowledgeofthedistri-butionsoftheartifactsandpotteryinthelocithem-selves.Thedistributionscanonlyberecoverediftheyhavebeenexcavatedandrecordedseparately,withminimumcontamination,locusbylocus.Ourstudyoftheseparatedartifacts,layerbylayer,distributionpatternbydistributionpattern,enablesusasarchaeologiststoinferatypologicalhistoryoftools,weapons,pottery,etc.Wecanalsoinferthedevelopmentoftechnologyforasite.Inaddition,wewillreconstructthesocialsystemsandrelationsofthepeopleofSepphorisandShikhin.Wewillevenforgeamodeloftheirreligions,values,politics,andaesthetics.Eventually,wewilldeducethedevelop-mentoftheeconomicsandreligionorothersocialrelationsofthepeopleforanentireregion.Butwithoutthepriorseparationofartifactualmaterialbylociandthecarefulrecordingofposition,thetaskisrenderedvirtuallyimpossible.

Page 8: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

4

Consequently,contaminationofonelocusfromanother,ortheintrusionoflaterartifactsintoearliercontexts,isagrievouserrorinexcavation,foritcompletelyskewsthedatauponwhichwebaseourinterpretations.Eachlayermustberemovedinsuchawaythatnolatermaterialiscarelesslymixedwithearlier.Therefore,(l)digonelocusatatime.Ifyoumustdigtwolociatonce,makeprovisiontodigthemfarapartsothatyouminimizethedangerofcontamina-tion.(2)Digthelatestlocusfirst.Forexample,pitsarealwaysexcavatedbeforediggingthelayer(s)intowhichtheyarecut.(3)Digthelocusatthehighestelevationfirst.(4)Selecttoolswiththetypeofearthremovalinmind:pickandhoeformajordirtmoving,hand-heldpick(“patish”)andtrowelforsmallareas,andknittingneedle,spoon,ordentaltoolsandbrushfordelicatework.(5)Digatoneelevation,i.e.,exca-vatetheentirelayeratoncesothatstructuresemergeallatthesametime,ifpossible(called“dig-ginginphase,”seebelow).Itisgenerallypreferabletofinishdiggingonelocusentirelybeforestartinganother.Inpractice,howev-er,itisnotalwayspossibletofollowthisdictum,asitmaynotbefeasibletokeepanentirecrewbusyononelocus.Ifso,thenanotherlocusmaybeduginaremovedpartofthesquareifproperprecautionsaretaken.Potterybucketsaretobefarapart(oneforeachlocus)andevenofdifferentcolors,ifpossible.Tagsmustbepredominatelydisplayedandveryclearlymarked.Objectboxesandbonebagsneedtoremainbytheirrespectivepotterybuckets.Gufas(rubberbaskets)ofsoilaretobetaggedtoavoidcontaminationatthesifter.Allpossiblecorrectivesneedtobebuiltin,foroncecontaminationtakesplace,onecanneverbesureofsuccessful“decon-tamination.”Ifonedigsthelatestlocifirst,onereducesthepos-sibilityofcontaminatingearlierloci.Diggingtwolociorareasofdistinctdateiscalled“diggingoutofphase”andistobeavoidedforthereasonmen-tioned.Inpractice,thismeansthatallpits,burials,andfoundationtrenchesmustberemovedbeforeprobingtheearlierlayersintowhichtheseintrusionspenetrate.Onemayevenhaveto“overdig”afoun-dationtrenchorpittobesurethatallofitisgonebeforecontinuing.Thismeansdiggingintothelociintowhichthefoundationorpitwasduginantiqui-ty.Diggingslightlyintoanearlierlocusdoesnotdis-tortthedating,asanyearliermaterialthatcomesupwiththelaterlocuscannotalterthedatingofthatlaterlocus.Ontheotherhand,leavingevenafew

sherdsoflaterpotteryinanearlierlocuswilldefi-nitelychangetheestimateddateoftheearlierlocus,asitmustbedatedbyitslatestcontents.Therefore,removethelaterlayersfirst,diginphase,anddigcleanlyatonelevel.Justafinalnote:ifinthecourseofdiggingyouthinkyoumaybecomingontoanewlocus,butyouarenotsure,thencleanup,changebuckets,andtakenewelevations.Thisisawayofprotectingyourselfincaseofdoubt,asthenewbucketcanal-waysbeassignedtothenextlocus.Butifthereisanypossibilitythatitcontainspotteryorotherarti-factualmaterialfromtheoldlocus,thenassignittotheold.Rememberthatthedateoftheupperlayercannotchangebyhavingearlierpotteryinit.StartingaNewSquareItiswelltorememberthatyou,theexcavator,willalwaysdigblindly,evenifyouhavesomeideaofwhatliesbeneathyourfeet.Therefore,itbehoovesyoutomovecautiouslyatfirst,carefullyselectingyourareaoffirstearthremoval.Thismeansinprac-ticethatyoumustremoveallgrassandothervege-tationfromtheentiresquare(includingbalks)be-foreyoucanlayoutthefirstprobe.Vegetationandotherorganicmattercanconcealagreatmanyim-portantdetails.Afterclearingvegetation,yourfirsttask,ifitisnotdoneforyoualready,istostringupyoursquare.Thismeansstretchingstringsfromthefourcornersofyoursquaresothatyoucanisolateyourplotfromalltheothersaround.Thisalsoensuresthattheareayouexcavateisasquarethatcanbepreciselylocat-edonthemastergridforthesiteandlaterincorpo-ratedintoamasterplanfortheexcavation.Thesurveyorshouldhavesurveyedinbyopticalinstrumentatleasttwo,ifnotallfour,cornersofyour5x5m.square.Ifthesurveyorhaslocatedtwocornersongrid,e.g.theNWandNEcorners,thenyoucanstretchonetapefivemetersfromtheNWcornerandstretchasecondtape7.07metersonthediagonalofthe5x5m.squaretofindthefourthcorner.Usestringandlinelevelstoassurethatthemeasuringtapesarelevel.Checktheplacementbymeasuringfromtwootherknownpoints.

Page 9: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

5

Fig.1:5x5and4x4metersquarestriangulated.

Thefigureshowsthetriangulatedcornersofthe4x4meterdiggingplotwithinthe5x5metersquare.Youwillusebalkstringfortheprocess,whichislikeancientEgyptianorGreekgeometry(stringstretch-ing).Rememberthatyouwillleaveyournorthandeastbalksunexcavated.The4x4meterdiggingar-ea,then,islocatedwhollyinthesouthwestpartofthesquare.Anoteonsafety:toavoidcreatingtriphazardswithstring,stringuponlytheareatobeexcavated(the4x4squareoraprobewithinit),andstringon-lywhenyoumustusethestringstodelineatetheexcavationareawhenyoubegin,totrimbalk,todrawtopplan,orforsomeotherpurpose.Therestofthetime,coilthebalkstringsneatlynearthecor-nernailssothattheyarereadytobere-strungasneeded. AtSepphorisandShikhinweusetheprobetrenchmethodoftrialexcavation,whichisarefinementoftheWheeler-KenyonmethodusedwithsuccessatTellGezerandotherdigs.Thismeansthatasmallarea,perhaps2x4m.or1x2m.inoursquares,islaidoutalongamajorbalkanddugratherrapidly,butwithseparationoftheloci.Thisexposesasam-pleofthestratificationsothattherestofthedigginginthesquareisnotentirelyblind.Itsmaindisad-vantageisthatsomestratificationmaybemissedintheprobetrenchbecauseofthespeedwithwhichitisdug,thoughthiscanusuallyberecoveredintherestofthesquare.Layoutyourprobetrenchacrossthehighpointofyoursquare.Wegenerallylayitoutagainstamajorbalk(northoreast,seebelow)sothatamajorsec-tionisexposedfirst.Itisthemajorsectioncom-posedofseveralbalksthatcontainsthemajorstra-tigraphyofthesite.InFig.2,forexample,weshowthefirstprobesetupagainsttheeastbalk,forthatisoneofyourtwopermanentbalks.Theotherperma-

nentbalkisthenorthbalk.Yourfirstprobethenliesagainstthenorthbalkandeastbalk,yourtwoper-manentbalks(seeFig.2).

1 m.

2 m.

Fig.2:1x2m.ProbelaidoutinNE

Beforeyouremoveanysoil,however,youmustknowatwhatelevationyouarestarting.ThismeansthatyouasAreaSupervisorhavealreadyascertainedwhereyourrelativedatumpointsare(indicatedprominentlyinyoursquare)sothatyoucancalcu-laterelativeelevationabovemeanMediterraneanSealeveloffeaturesinyoursquare.Eachdatumpointissurveyedbythesurveyororbysomeonewiththenecessaryskills.Oftenthisisthetopofoneofthestakesthatmarktheintersectionofthe5x5gridlines.MARKYOURDATUMPOINTORDATAPOINTSPREDOMINANTLY.

THE TOP OF THE STAKEIS THE DATUM.

SUBTRACT DISTANCE

TAUTSTRING

LINELEVEL

Fig.3:Takinglevelsfromaknowndatum.

Normally"linelevels"aremeasuredoffaper-manentdatumpointwithastring,linelevel,andmetertape,thoughattimesyoumayaskforasur-veyor'selevation(seebelow).Thisbitofinformationisenteredonyourtopplan,inthenotes,andontheappropriateplaceinyourlocussheets.Themechanicalprocessoftakinglevelsissimpleenough:onepersonholdsastringtautatthedatum

YOU MUST RECORD THEELEVATION OF EVERYBUCKETOFPOTTERY

Page 10: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

6

pointwhilesomeoneelseholdstheotherendoverthepointwheretheelevationisdesired.Thesecondpersonholdsametertapeverticallyfromhorizontalstringtoground.Ithelpstoholdthetapewithaplumbbobtokeepitvertical.Thelinelevelisat-tachedinthemiddleofthestringtoinsurethatitisheldlevel.(Thehorizontalstringactuallyformsaca-tenarycurvebecauseofgravity,sothelinelevelmustbeinthemiddleofthestring.)Whenallislev-el,thedistancefromstringtopointismeasured.Thismeasureissubtractedfromthefigureforthedatumpointtoyieldtheelevationofthelocusinquestion.(Thisoperationisbetterseenthande-scribed.)Youmayhaveuseofa“dumpy”(optical)levelinthefield.Thislevelshouldbesetupbysomeonewhohasbeentrained,andthesetupshouldbecheckedbeforeeveryelevationtakentomakesurethatthemachineremainslevel.Ifthelevellingbub-bleisnotcentered,theentiresetupproceduremustberepeated.Thesetupprocedureisasfollows.First,setupthetripodlegsforthedumpylevelsomeplaceinthefieldawayfromregulartraffic,thenscrewtheleveltothetopofthelegs,tighteningonlytofingertight-ness.Usingtheadjustablelegs,raiseorlowerlegsuntilthelevelingbubbleisroughlywithinthecircle,thenusethelevelingknobsatthebaseoftheleveltopreciselyalignthebubble.Theprocedureforusingthelevelisasfollows.Onepersonholdsthe“rod”(polewithcentimetergradu-ations,adjustableinlength)onadatumpointwitharecordedelevation.Thepersonatthedumpylevelusestheverticalcrosshairtotelltherodpersonwhenheorsheisholdingtherodlevel,thentellstherodpersontorocktherodbackandforth,awayfromandtowardthedumpy.Thepersonatthedumpyreadsthelowestnumberindicatedbythehorizontalcrosshair.Uponeachsetup,allAreaSu-pervisorsusingthedumpyshouldrecordthesetupforthatday.Hereishowthatisdone.Placetherodonadatumpointinthefieldthatishigherthanthepointstobemeasuredinthesquares,recordthenumber,andaddittotheelevationofthedatumpoint.Thisistheelevationofthedumpylevelfromwhichalleleva-tionswillbesubtracted.WhenyoutakeBDorEDelevations,elevationsforpotterybuckets,oreleva-tionsonartifacts,subtractthenumberreadviadumpyfromthedumpyelevation.Forexample,iftheelevationofthedatumpointis186.385m.and

therodmeasurementabovethatdatumis1.299m.,thedumpyelevationis187.684m.Iftherodmeas-urementoverthepointinthesquareis1.478m.,theelevationofthatpointis186.206m.(Thisoperationisalsobetterseenthandescribed.)Surveyor’selevationsonthevariouslociarealsoindispensable.Whenallofonelocusisexposed,forexample,itisagoodideatocallinthesurveyorsothatyouhaveinstrumentelevationsonthatfeature.Thisisparticularlyimportantinthecaseofbeginningandendingelevationsonmajorlociortopandfoundingelevationsonwallsandfloors.Italsopro-videsagoodcorrectiveonwhatevercumulativeer-rormayhavecreptintoline-levelordumpyeleva-tions.Note:onalltopplans,indicateline-levelanddumpyelevationswith“+”or“x.”Indicateallsur-veyedelevationswith“⊕”or“⊗.”Onecannotoverestimatetheimportanceofele-vations,or“levels”astheyareoftencalled.“Begin-ningoftheDay”(“BD”)elevationsareyesterday’s“EndoftheDay”(“ED”)elevations.Thesebracketyourexcavationdaybothinyournotesandonyourtopplans.Topandbottomelevationsoneachandeverylocusmustbetaken.Topelevationsandfoundingelevationsonwallsareabsolutelyindis-pensable.Everyfeatureinasquare,andthereforeeverylocus,hasabeginningandendelevation,andseveralmore,ifthelayerorfeatureinquestionslopesorisotherwiseirregular.Nothingismorefrustratingthantryingtointerpret“cold”archaeo-logicaldatawithoutelevations.Beforedigging,therefore,cleanthevegetationfromyoursquare,layouttheprobetrench,andtakeelevations.Youmustalsodecideontwootherthings;wheretodumpandwheretoputthesifter.Locationofthedumpismorecriticalthanyoumightthink.Morethanonearchaeologisthashadtodighisorherowndumpbecauseofpoorplacement.(Thisiscalled“Wooley'sLaw”inarchaeology,be-causeSirLawrenceWooleydughisowndumpsoof-tenatUr.)Therefore,locateyourdumpfarenoughawayfrominterestingfeaturesthatitisnotindan-gerofbeingexcavated,butcloseenoughtobecon-venient.Ideallyitwillbenexttoyoursharedsifter,forobviouslythesifteddirthastobedumped.Loca-tionofsifteranddumpisnormallyamatterofcon-sultationwithotherAreaSupervisorsandyourFieldSupervisor.TheRegionalArchaeologistoftheIsraelNatureandParksAuthoritywillwishtoseegood

Page 11: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

7

placementofthedump.ExcavatingSpecificFeaturesWallsareallowedtoemerge,sotospeak,assoillayersaredugaway.Soillayersagainstawallpre-servetherecordoftheusageofthewallafterthefloororsurfacefirstassociatedwithitwentoutofuse,includingtheusecalled“abandonment”.Thatis,donotfollowthetopofawalltoseewhereitgoes,asthisprocedurewillseparateawallfromitscontext.Rather,takedownthelayersabovethewallallatonce,asusual.Youmaywanttoleaveasmall,temporarybalkacrossthewallsothatyoucaneasilyseethestratificationagainstit.Innocasewilltrenchingalongthefaceofawallenableyoutore-coverstratification!Itisalsoimportanttoseparatematerialononesideofthewallfrommaterialontheothersideofthewall.Sincewallsdefinetheuseofspace,itmaybepresumedthattwodifferentlociareidentifiable,especiallywhenseparatedbythewall.Ifthesoillayersarefillmaterialwhichhasbeenlaidinorhaserodedinoverthewall,thetwolocicanlaterbecombined.Itiseasiertocombinetwolociintoonethantotrytoseparateonelocusintotwo. Floorsmayeitherbepavedorofbeatenearth.Pavingishardtomiss,butbeatenearthfloorsmaynotbesoeasytofind.Whenexcavatingwater-washedorwind-blownlayers,itisimportanttore-memberthattheselayerswerelaidontosomething,andthisislikelytobeafloor.Thereforeexcavatesuchlayersatonelevel,carefully,sothatmaximumexposureofafloororotherlevelfeatureisdetected.Theflooritselfwillusuallyrevealitselfaboveallbyitscompaction,thoughthereareafewotherindica-tors:(l)small,flatstones,sherds,coins,andcom-pactedearthlayingflat.(2)Accumulateddebrisabovebutnotembeddedintothesurface,thisin-cludespotteryandartifacts,dung,charcoal,bone,andcoins.(3)Ahighpercentageofclay,plaster,orotherhardermaterialinthesuspectedfloor.Pitsaretheperfectexampleofthearchaeologist’snightmare,fortheyaretheprimereasonsforcon-tamination.Pitsaresometimesdifficulttodetectinsoillayers,butmustbealwayssuspected,expected,anddetected.Pitsusuallydeclaretheirpresenceinthesamewayasotherloci:bychangesincolor,contents(ortex-ture),andcomposition.Generallytheyarerathercircularinplan.Thereforearoughlycircularchangeincolor(theyareoftennoticeablydarkerfromashorlighterfromlime),compaction(theyareusuallysofter),orcontents(lotsofkitchenmiddens)isim-

mediatelysuspect.Fortunately,somepitsareclayorstone-linedandthussimpletodetect.(Forfurtherinformationondetectingpitsseep.15below.)Fills.Ancientworkmenoftenneededtolevelanirregularsurfaceinordertobuilduponit.Soiladdedinthiswayisoftenrecognizablebyitssoftcom-paction,itsvaryingsoiltypeandcolor,andthewidevarietyofitscontents(stonesandpotteryofwidelydifferingsizesandconditions),andbythefactthatthesoillinesinthebalkrunhorizontally(therefore,humanshaveleveledthefill).Dumps.Likemodernpeople,ancientsoftendumpedsurplussoil,gravel,pottery,plaster,andothermaterials.Adumpmaybedifferentiatedfromafillbytherandomtiplinesinthebalk.Workerstippedcontainersofdumpmaterialsoverawallorstructure.Aseachloadofmaterialwastippedovertheedge,itleftdiagonaltracesofitsdeposit,call“tip-lines.”Humansoftenwalkedonthetopsofdumpsinan-tiquity,andtheircompactedtopscanbemistakenforalivingsurfacesuchasafloor.However,inanordinarydump,sherdsareoftenembeddedinthetopatrandomanglesratherthanintheflat-lyingpo-sitioncharacteristicofafloororlivingsurface.Mate-rialsindumpstendtobegravity-sorted,theheaviestmaterialsbeingatthebottomofthedump,thelightestbeingatthetop.Whetherexcavatingapit,afill,oradumpthebestprocedureistoremoveonlyhalfthematerialatfirst,untiloneissurehowthematerialwaslaid.Foundationtrenchesarenormallypartofeverywallthatisnotbuiltonbedrock.Theyareanecessi-ty,asawallwithnofoundationisvulnerabletowa-tererosion.Therefore,whenawallisconstructed,thebuilderdigsatrenchasdeepashefeelsisneces-sary,laysinseveralroughcoursesofstoneforthefoundation(ordinarilylargerstonesthanthoseinhiswall),thenlaysintheupper,visiblecourses.Hefillsthefoundationtrenchwithfillbroughtinforthepurpose,soitoftenhasthecharacteristicsofpitfill.Hemaythanleveltheinsideofthebuildingwithmorefill,andabovethishewillconstructhisbeatenearthorpavedfloor.Thelayersofleveling(“makeup”)andbeatenearthorpavingsealthefoundationtrench,whichisquiteimportantfromthearchaeologicalpointofview.Inotherwords,thefoundationtrenchis"sealed"beneathapurposefullylaidmake-upforafloorandbytheflooritself,sothefoundationtrenchremainsuncontaminatedbylater

Page 12: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

8

debris.Ittakesabitofexperiencetofindafoundationtrench,sinceonoursitesoilwillsiltdownthefaceofawallpreservedtoaheightofseveralcourses.Gen-erally,afoundationtrenchisspottedbyapatchofloosefill-soilwiderthan.01-.03cm.fromthewall.Afoundationtrenchisusuallyassociatedwithacom-pactedsurfaceonwhichtheworkmanstoodtodigthetrenchandfoundthewall.Inremovingafoundationtrench'sfill,theassociat-edsurfaceonwhichtheworkmanstoodmustalsoberemovedfirst,asitisnormallythelastfeaturebuilt.Itisincludedwiththebuildingphase.Ifitisnecessarytoremoveawallinordertopro-ceedtothenextcoherentphaseinyoursquare,youwillneedtodismantleinreverseordertotheabovesequence.Thatis,removeseparatelythepaving,themake-up,thewall,thefillinthetrench,andthefoundingcourses,inthatorder.PLEASENOTETHATALLTHESEFEATURESRECEIVESEPARATELOCUSNUMBERS.Fromthepointofviewofchronology,thefoun-dationtrencheffectivelydatesthefoundingofthewall.Thematerialsealedbeneathafloordatesthatfloor,and,ifitismadeuptothewall,providesadateforoneuseofthewall.Sometimestheintervalbetweenfoundingandlastuseofawallissurprising-lylong.WehavewallsatSepphoristhathavelasted350years.Burialsarealsoasub-categoryofpits,thoughspe-ciallycharacterizedbytheircontents.Theymustbeexcavatedbothasintrusionsandaspotentiallyvalu-ablebearersofhistoricalandculturaldata.Excava-tionofnecessityproceedswithhandtools,evendel-icatetools,particularlywhendigginginandaroundbones.Yourfirstobjectiveistoexposetheskeletonandburialgoodswithoutdisturbingthem.Then,af-terrecordingindiarynotes,sketches,andphoto-graphs,allcontentsareremoved,boxed,labeled,andthepitiscleanedup.Choiceoftools,asyoumayhavegathered,isgen-erallydictatedbythetypeoflocusthatyouareabouttodig.Ifitisasurfacelocus,thenpickandhoeareinorder,atleastpartiallybecauseofthegreatcompactionyouwillencounter.Ifitisathinneroc-cupationlayer,itmaybenecessarytousepatish(handpick)andtrowel.Ifitisamatterofanex-tremelydelicatelayer,orofsoilinandaroundpot-terysmashedinsitu,thenuseaknittingneedle,

spoon,ordentaltoolsandbrush.(Weknowwesaidthisearlier.)Inanycase,itisuptotheAreaSupervi-sortodecidewithoneeyeontheskillofhisorherteammembersandtheotheronthesoiltobere-moved.Erronthesideofcaution,aslesswillbelostifsoilismovedtooslowlyratherthantooquickly.StrategyNormallystrategyisdecidedbyweighingover-allstratigraphicobjectivesagainstparticularexcavationpriorities.Yourstratigraphicgoalistoexposethecoherentoccupationalphaseswithinyoursquareoneatatime.Diggingprioritiesarethenasfollows:(l)Afterfinishingaprobe,exposeallofagivenlayerwithitsassociatedwallsorotherfeatures(hearths,artifactsinsitu,tabuns,columnbasesandotherar-chitecture,etc.).(2)Locateandexcavateallpits,bur-ials,drainsandwaterchannels,anderosionchan-nels.(3)IftheDirectorsandtheFieldSupervisoragreethatyouaretoproceedtothenextphase,thendismantlethewallsifyouhavebeentoldtodothat.Thenexcavatefoundationtrenches.(4)Checktoseethateverythinghasbeenrecorded(drawingsandphotographs),thenlayoutyourprobeforthenextadvance.Layingoutabuildingforexcavation:TheGridThetwomainobjectivesofarchitecturalarchaeol-ogyaswepracticeitare(l)toexposeanentirestruc-tureincontextand(2)tolearneverythingpossibleofitsfounding,use,andabandonment.Thesetwoaimsrequireexposureandbalks,thoughthebalkswilleventuallycomedowninthefinalfewdays.Theseaimsaremetbyfollowingtheclassicvaria-tionsontheideaofagrid.AtSepphorisweusetheHebrewUniversityGrid,setupbyEhudNetzerandassociatesin1985beforeourseconddiggingseason.AtShikhinweuseagridthatweestablishedthefirstseasonofexcavationin2012.Thisgriduses100x100meterplotswithinwhichwelayoutour5x5m.“squares”or“areas.”WedesignateasaFieldaco-herentexcavationunit,usuallyofassociatedarchi-tecture.ThesearedesignatedwithRomannumeralstodistinguishthemfromtheareas,whicharedesig-natedbyArabicnumerals.Thistypegridhasnobuilt-inregardforarchitecture,whichmayruninanydirection,butalwaysaccordingtosomeoverallpat-tern.However,the5x5m.gridcanbeadjustedwherenecessarytoallowforpeculiaritiesofthesite.Forexample,atSepphoriswehavedug5x7.5m.squares,andatShikhin5x10m.squares,even

Page 13: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

9

thoughwearetherebydiggingtwodifferent5x5m.gridsquares,wherethearchitecturewarrantedit.AtSepphoris,squaresaroundthefoundationofthe“citadel”werealignedwiththewalls.Thereislittlepointinstickingtothe5x5m.gridsquaresifviolat-ingitmeansyouwillgainabetterunderstandingofthedata.Anysizeororientationofsquarecanbeused,provideditcanbedrawneasilyonmillimeterpaper(withrespecttothesizeofthesquare,amul-tipleof25cm.isdesirable).FieldsinourExcavationsatSepphoris:FieldI:probesonthetopofthesiteagainsttheRo-manTower(“TheCitadel”),inWaterman’strench,andinthecommonbath.FieldII:TheRomanTheaterFieldIII:AProbeonthesouthsideofSepphoristhatyieldednoancientoccupation.FieldIV:TwosquaresonthenorthsideofSepphorisandeastoftheFranciscanproperty.FieldV:Thecivilbasilicadownthehilltotheeast.FieldVI:AmodernhouseattheNEcornerofthecivilbasilicainFieldV.FieldsinourExcavationsatShikhinFieldI:Associatedbuildingsonthecrownofthenorthernmosthill(A1).FieldII:InstallationslocatedduringagradiometersurveynorthofFieldI.FieldIII:ThenecropolisonthewesternslopeofJebelQat(D)totheeast.FieldIV:ThemiqvehsouthofFieldI.

THERECORDINGSYSTEMTherecordingsystemisadirectdescendentofthatusedbytheJointExpeditiontoTellBalatah(ancientShechem)inthe1960s,bytheJointExpeditiontoTellGezerinthe1960sand1970s,andbytheMeironExcavationProjecttotheendofthe1970s.Itmakesuseofafieldnotebookineachareathatcon-tainsalocuslist,coinlist,photolist,bucketlist,ar-chitecturalfragmentlists,balkdrawings,photosheets,alternatingsheetsoftopplanpaperandnotebookpaper,andasheafoflocussheets.Thetopplanpaperisfortopplans,thenotebookpaperisfor

notes,andthelocussheetsareforrecordingloci.Thesheetsforlistsareforrecordingthosepiecesofinformationthattheirnameimplies.AninnovationinPalestinianfieldarchaeologywasthetopplan,introducedbyPaulLappinthe1960s.Itsusehasbeenthoroughlytestedandvindicatedinthefield.Thetopplanisadaily,stone-for-stone,scalerec-ordofeveryfeatureinyoursquare.Itshowsallthelociwithlocusnumbers,elevations,andpotterybuckets(seesampleplan).Alltopplansaredrawnatascaleof1:25ontopplanpaperespeciallyprintedfortheexpedition.Traceyourtopplansforthenextdayfromonemasterplaninordertoavoidcumula-tiveerror,orpersuadesomeonetodosoaspartofhisorherarchaeologicaltraining.FollowthefollowingTOPPLANCONVEN-TIONS:1.PrinttheheadinginLARGELETTERSwithsite,date,FieldandAreadesignations,andscale.Includeanortharrow(northshouldbeattop).Thismustallbereadilyreadable.2.Stonesshouldbedrawnwith"characteristics"sothattheyresemblerealstonesratherthanjellybeansorflatirregularities.Duringthecourseoftheday,markallstonesthatyouremovewithan"X"ontheplan.Donotcopyremovedstonesonthenextday’stopplan.3.Enterlinelevelelevationsontheplanwitha"+"or"x"andsurveyor'selevationswitha"+"or"x"withinasmallcircle.Putthismarkontheplanpre-ciselywheretheelevationwastakeninthesquare.Thisincludesendofthedayelevationsorbeginningofthedayelevations,whicharemarked"E.D."or"B.D."Writetopelevationsforwallsonthestonewheretaken.Writefoundingelevationsbesidethepointunderneaththewallwheretheyweretakenandfurnishthemwithan"S"-shapedarrow.4.Labeleverythingwithlocusnumbers,precededbyacapitalL.Allthelocusnumbersforyoursquareconsistofthreedigitsaddedtothesquarenumber.Thus,forexample,ifyouarediggingSquareV.31,yourmodernsurface(wherethegrassgrows)isL31000.ThenextdiscernablelayerthatyouexcavateisdesignatedL31001,andsoforthtoL31999,whichisourconventionforbedrock.NOTE:Locusnumbersbetween100and199(e.g.L31100,L31123,etc.)arereservedfortheexcava-tionofundergroundchambers.

Page 14: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

10

The“pointonelocusnumber”designatesthefirstfivecentimetersofathick,dirtfloor.Forexample,ifthefloorisL1022,thenthepotteryandotherarti-factsimpressedintothefirst5cm.areremovedseparatelyasL1022.1.Thispotteryisimportantevi-dencefordatingthelastuseofthefloor.Write"POINTONELOCUS"onthepotterytagtoalertusinpotteryreading.Boththefloorlocusandthepointonelocusare,naturally,critical.5.Indicatetheboundariesofprobetrenchesandotherlimitedareasofexcavationwithdashedlines(-----).Allprobesshouldbeimmediatelyidentifiablebythisconvention.6.Aroundthemarginsofyourdrawing,enterpot-terybucketnumberswitharrowstotheplacesfromwhichtheyaredug.7.Ifyoudraftadrawingofamini-balk,drawitonthebottomofthetopplan,ifitfits,otherwiseonaproperlylabeled,separatepieceofbalkdrawingpa-per.Indicateonthedrawingwhichtemporarybalkitis.Forexample,labelthemini-balkdrawing"SectionA-B",thenshowpoints"A"and"B"onyourplan.In-dicatethescaleofthisminibalkdrawingdirectlyonthedrawing.

FIELDNOTESAnywhereinyourtextthatyouhappentomentionalocus,besuretodrawarectanglearoundthenumber(tomakeitstandout)afteryouhaveen-teredthedateonthebackofthelocussheetforthatlocus.ThisistheMENTIONINDEXandisveryim-portantfortheFieldSupervisororDirectorsorwho-everhastomakefinalsenseofthatlocus.Itshowseverypageinyournotebookwherethatlocusismentioned.Youaretoorganizefieldnotesaroundpotterybucketnumberswiththeirlociandelevationsneartheleftmargin(seesamplepage).Thatis,theleftmarginwillhavetheField.Square.Buck-etnumberfollowedbytheboxedlocusnumber,andbeneaththattheelevationforthisspecificbucket.Forexam-ple:I.33.75L33002

207.22THELINEUNDERNEATHTHEBUCKETNUMBERMEANSTHATTHISBUCKETNUMBERHASBEENENTEREDONTHELOCUSSHEETINTHESPACEPROVIDED.Underlinethenumberafterenteringthebucketonthelocussheetasawayofcheckingtobesurethatitisdone.Inthelinestotherightofthemarginentryillus-tratedabovewritewhatyouaredoingandwhy.Inyourveryfirstsentence,notethenumbersofthesquarestothenorth,east,south,andwest.Writeanyhypotheses,observations,speculations,ortheo-riesaboutthearchaeologyofyoursquarethatyouwish.Youmayspeculateabouttherelationoflocitooneanother.Itisalsovaluabletotheorizeabouttherelationshipsbetweenthelociofyoursquareandthoseofneighboringsquares.Inotherwords,whichlayersthatyouarediggingarealsotobefoundinthesquaresaroundyours?IfyourDirectorsorFieldSupervisorsinterpretsomething,recordtheinter-pretation,butyourowninformedopinionandtheevidenceyouadduceisalsoworthrecording.Includeabriefdescriptionofwhereinthelocusthediggingisgoingonandalsowherethelocusliesinthesquare.Yourdiscussionwillalsoencompasscol-or,compaction,andcontents(“theThreeCs”).Men-tionrelationshipstootherloci(abovewhat,underwhat,nexttowhat,identicalwithwhat?),itstiporslope,andothervariableslistedonthelocussheet.ItscolorwillbegiveninMunsellnotation,andwillbeanaveragecolor,butyoushouldnoteifyourunintopatchesofyelloworblackorwhatever.Compactionisarelativemeasure:veryhard,hard,ratherhard,somewhatsoft,soft,verysoft,loose.Water-washedmaterialisratherhard,unlessitisgravel.Air-laidparticlestendtoberathersoftunlesswalkedon.Dirtfloorsareveryhard,evenwhenex-posedtowindandwatererosion.Suchfloorswerepoundedwhilewetduringtheirmake-up,thenthor-oughlytroddendown.Besides,theyoftencontainafairamountofclayorlimeorboth.Alwaysrefertoparticlesizequantitatively,i.e.,givearangeofparticlesizeincentimetersormillimeters.Itismorehelpfultosaythatyourgravelis2-3cm.(indiameter)than"cherrysized."Ifitislessthan1mm.,sayso.Itmaybesilt-sized,sosayso.Youwillalsoneedtomentionhowyouthinkthislayerwaslaid

Page 15: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

11

down,asthisisacorrelationofcompactionandpar-ticlesize(texture).Wasthislayerwashedin,blownin,orbroughtinbyhumansoranimals?Water-washedlayerstendtobecompactedandtheparticlesaresortedinsize:thesiltisonthebottomandthegravelremainsontop.Ontheotherhand,wind-blown(air-laid)parti-clestendtobeuniforminsizeandrathersoft.Silt-sizedparticleswilldominate.Therewillalsobemuchlesshorizontalstriationsorlayeringinair-laidmate-rial.WALLSrequireratherextensivediscussion,butwitharchitecturalvariablesalsoinmind.Eachwallisaseparatelocusandshouldbenumberedinsequencewithotherloci.Thenumber,however,isprecededbyacapitalWratherthananL,andonlythenumberitselfisboxed(example:W33014).Filloutthespe-ciallocussheetforwalls(seebelow).Besuretorec-ordthefollowingdescriptorsasyoudiscoverthem:1.Preservedlengthinmeters.2.Preservedwidth(probablyarange,as61-72cm.).3.Preservedmaximumheightabovefoundation.4.Topelevations(selecttwoormorehighspots).5.Foundingelevations(selecttwoormorelow

spots).6.Isitfoundedinatrench?Whatisitsnumber?7.Isitfoundedonbedrock?8.Bondswithwhichwalls?(See“Bondjoint”inGlos-

sary)9.Buttswithwhichwalls?(See“Buttjoint”inGlos-

sary)10.Associatedfloors,includingfloorsuponwhichit

sitsandfloorsmadeuptoit.11.Associatedfeatures,suchasdoors,windows,

niches,bins,orotherdomesticfeaturesbuiltagainstit.

12.Wind-blownheapsorrefusepilesagainstit.13.Isitrobbedout(robbertrenchnumber?)orcut

byapit(itslocusnumber?)orotherwisedis-turbed?bywhichloci?

14.Thiswallcutsintowhichotherloci?15.Numberofrowswide.16.Isthererubblebetweenatwo-rowwidewall?17.Numberofcourseshigh.18.Averagesizeofstones.19.Aretheyfieldstones(undressed)?20.Aretheyhammerdressedonly?Thatis,noone

cutthem.21.Arethemarginsdraftedwithaboss(seeGlossa-

ry)leftontheface?22.Arethemarginsdraftedandisthefacecutlike

Herodianstones?

23.Mortaredwithwhat?24.Arethestoneskeyed(pecked)foralayerofplas-

ter?25.Numberofcourseslaidinthefoundationtrench.26.Numberoffinishedfaces.Ifthereisonlyonefin-

ishedface,whichisit?(Thefinishedfaceordinari-lyisintendedtobeseen,soitfacesoutside.)

27.Areanyofthefacesplastered?Ifonlyone,whichone?(Oftentheplasteredfacefacesinside.)

28.Arethestones"drylaid"(nomortar)?29.Doesthewallbetrayarepairorrebuildfromdif-

ferentsizeordressingofthestones?where?30.Whereisitfoundinthesquare?31.Directionitruns(approximatecompassorienta-

tion).32.Whatisitsevidentfunction?(Northwallofroom

terracewall,outsidewall,screenwall)DON’TFORGETTOINCLUDEASKETCHOFTHEWALLINTHEGRIDPROVIDEDONTHEWALLLOCUSSHEET.FILLOUTTHEBACKOFTHEWALLLOCUSSHEETASYOUWOULDTHEBACKOFASTANDARDLOCUSSHEET.Whenyoudismantlethewall,theremaybepot-teryandotherartifactsbetweenthestonesormixedintheplasterormortar.Thispotteryistobetaggedandsentinasisanypottery,andthebucketnum-ber,date,reading,andassociatedartifactsaretobeenteredonthelocussheet.TheLOCUSSHEETistobekeptuptodate,whichusuallymeansfillingintheblanksfromyourfieldnoteseitheronthesiteorintheeveningsatcamp.Itisimperativetoenteronthelocussheetallthedes-criptorsastheybecomeknown,particularlypotterybucketnumbers,dates,andreadings.Alsoenterarti-factcategoriesonthelocussheetastheyarefoundwitheachpotterybucketnumber.Itisimpossibletooverestimatetheimportanceofthelocussheet,asitgivesinbriefalltheessentialinformationaboutanygiventhreedimensionalfea-tureinthesquare.OneofthesurestmeasuresoftheseriousnessthatanygivenAreaSupervisorgivestoherorhisnotebookcanbefoundinthecarewithwhichsheorhedoesthelocussheets,astheyab-stractalltheinformationrecordedelsewhereontopplansandinthefieldnotes.Sometimesthishasbeenreferredtoasthe"cursedpaperwork,"butthisismainlywhatwehavewhenwegetbackhome.Thepointofthecontinuousrepetitionofinformationonthevariousformsistoprovidea"fail-safe"systemofrecording,sothaterrorsmadeon(e.g.)apotterytagorinthefieldnotescanbecaughtandcorrectedinthe(e.g.)locussheets.

Page 16: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

12

POTTERYTAGSgiveallnecessaryinformationforagivenbucketofpottery.Fillthemoutwithsite,date,Field.Square.Bucketnumber(writethesethreewithperiodsbetweenthem),andlocusnumber(initsrectangularbox).Ifthebucketisfromacriticallocus,markthetag“CRITICAL.”Insituationswhereyouthinkthepotterycanberestored,markthetag"RESTORE."Ifitispossiblycontaminated,markthetag"POSSIBLECONTAMINATION."Inthefirstin-stanceitispassedontotheFormator,inthesecondinstanceitwillbeprobablythrownoutafterbeinggivenitsdueinFieldPotteryReading.

Figure4:PotteryTagArtifacttags.Artifacts(exceptforbonesandcoins)arelabeledontheartifactboxesinpencil(sothattheboxcanbereused)withthepotterybucketin-formation,exactlylikethepotterytag,writtenonthelid.Inaddition,aoneortwoworddescriptionofthecontentsoftheboxiswrittenbelowthepotterytaginformation(nail,lamp,lampfragment,glass,ring,etc.).Thisoneortwoworddescriptionalsoap-pearsonyourlocussheet.TheRegistrarwillbemoreexhaustive.Inyournotes,describewherethearti-factwasfound.Takeanelevationonfindspotsforallcoins,lampmolds,wholevessels,orothersignif-icantartifacts(theelevationofthepotterybucketwillserveforotherartifacts).Includeasketchincaseofmix-uplater.Onyourtopplan,putasmall"x"wheretheartifactwasfound,drawanarrowtoit,andindicateinthemargintheword"nail"orwhateveritwas.Onthelocussheet,onthebackwherepotterybucketsandpotteryreadingsgo,writethesamewordtotherightofpotteryreadings.Coinsaretobeplacedincoinenvelopesuponwhichiswrittenthesamepotterytaginformationtogetherwithyourown"Cnumber."Thisisaserialnumberyouassigntocoinsfromyoursquare.Thatis,yourfirstcoinisC-l,yoursecondisC-2,andsoon.Youshouldalsoenteronyourcoinpagetherecordofthiscoin:

C-No. DateBucketLocus CommentsorI.D.C-l 6/172330010 Probus.C-2 6/17433002Foundinsitubetween

stonesofwall33004

Biologicalmaterials.Therecoveryofbiologicalma-terialsneednotbeadifficultprocedure,andtheev-idencefromsuchremainscanprovidevaluablein-formationwhichisaccessibleinnootherway.Fromplantandanimalresiduesitisoftenpossibletore-constructanancientecosystem,understanddetailsofapeople'sdietandhealth,anddrawconclusionsabouttheirmethodsofmanagingbothflocksandfields.Itmaybeusefultothinkofbiologicalsamplesintermsoffourgeneralcategories:[l]microflora(in-cludingsuchmaterialsaspollens,spores,andphyto-liths);[2]microfauna(primarilytheremainsofin-sectsandothersmallanimals,includingfishscales);[3]flora(includingseeds,grain,nuts,wood,char-coal,fabrics,oranyotherplantresidue);and[4]fauna(usuallylimitedtohardtissue:bones,teeth,horncores,andshells).TheDirectorsmayaskyoutoobtainsoilsamplesfromthelociwhichyouexcavate.Takethesecare-fullytoavoidcontamination(aparticularlygreatdangerwhenoneisdealingwithmaterialsofmicro-scopicsize).Athinlayerofearthshouldbecarefullyremovedwithatrowel(usuallybyscrapinggently).Auniformquantityofearththengathered,placedintoa"zip-lock"plasticbagandsealedatoncethentaggedlikeanartifact.Therecoveryofmicrofloraandmicrofaunaisnotafieldprocedure,butrequirescarefulworkinabiologicallaboratory.Largerbiologicalmaterialsmaybeobtainedusingmethodsemployedtorecoverotherartifacts.Care-fulobservationandscreening(sometimessup-plementedbyflotation)willenableonetopickoutthebones,teeth,shells,fishscales,charcoal,andotherbiologicalmaterials.Thesematerialsareoftenparticularlyfragileandsusceptibletodamagebe-causeofthechangesintemperature,humidity,acid-ity,etc.towhichtheyareexposedbyexcavation.Placethesematerialsintoapaperbagorcardboardbox(thelatterisparticularlyusefulifthesampleap-pearstobeparticularlyfragile).Donotsealtheminaplasticbag,asthiswillacceleratethedeteriorationofthesample.Thebagsorboxesshouldbemarkedwiththesameinformationasthepotterybucketwithwhichtheyareassociatedandturnedinalongwithotherartifactualmaterialattheendofthe

Sh13 6/15

I.5.75

L5002

CRITICAL

Page 17: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

13

workday.Biologicalmaterialswill,ofcourse,berec-ordedinthefieldnotesandonthelocussheets.

STRATIFICATIONANDSTRATIGRAPHYItisimportanttoobserveanelementarydis-tinctionhere.Thelayersastheyarefoundarestrati-fication;theinterpretationofthemisstratigraphy.Inotherwords,wedonottakethelayershomethemselves,butourrecordsofthem.Recognitionofstratificationisalearnedskill,buttheprinciplesofthisskillcanbesetdown.Itissimp-lyamatterofrecognizingdifferencesin“thethreeCs”:Color,Compaction,andContents.Thehumaneyecanrecognizemoredifferencesincolorthanyoumightbelieve.Youwillneedtotrainyourowneyetonoticesignificantdifferencesalmostunconsciously,althoughaperusaloftheMunsellSoilColorChartwouldhelpyoutodiscoverwhetheryoutendtonoticedifferencesinhue,darkness/lightnessofhue,orstrengthofhue.Huereferstothepointonthespectrumthatacol-oroccurs,itswavelength,ifyouplease.IntheMun-sellsystem,colorsofsoilsadvancefromred(R)toyellow-red(YR)toyellow(Y),eachonadifferentiat-edscalefromonetoten.Thatis,theoretically,“red”rangesfrom1to10,inwhich5Risthemiddleofthescale.At10Rwestartwith1YR(Yellow-Red)onitsscaleof1-10,andat10YRwemeetwith1Y(yellow),untilwereach10Y,thelastsoilcolorinthechart.Itisobviousthat10Risidenticalwith1YR,and10YRisidenticalwith1Y,butthesesheetsdonotoc-curinthesoilcolorchart.Hueslightenonaverticalscale("value")from2-8(1and9-10aretoodifficulttomanufactureasyet).Huesalsovaryinintensity(theamountofpigment,called"chroma")onahorizontalscalefrom2-8,orsometimes2-10.Thusalmostanysoilcolorcanbecloselymatchedwithacolorchipinthesoilcolorchart,whichlocatesthecolorinthreedimensions.Practicewiththechartincreasesaccuracy,andsomevolunteersalreadytrainedincolordiscriminationareavaluableasset.Inanycaseyouneedtobethor-oughlyfamiliarwiththeMunsellnotationsystem,asitisastandardinmanyexcavations.IthaslongbeeninuseinAmericanandEuropeananthropologicalarchaeology.Note:AmoredetailedexplanationoftheMunsellsystemisfoundintheJapanesesoilcolorchart;in-troduction.SeealsoA.H.Munsell,AColorNotation,

1946,pp.14-16.NOTE:NEVERDUMPSOILDIRECTLYONTHECOLORCHIPS.Texture,whichincludescompactionandparticlesize,hasalreadybeendiscussedonpage10.Itisveryimportantthatyoudevelopadiscriminatorysenseinthismatterandthatyouworkon"quanti-fying"it.Thatis,youneedtofamiliarizeyourselfwithparticlescalesthatusemeasuresinsteadofanalogiesasameansofstandardizingnotation.Themetricsystemshouldbecomefamiliarenoughtoyouthatyoucanlookatarockandgaugeitsdiame-ter(withinarange,as10-12cm.)incentimeters,withoutmentalconversion.Estimatingdegreeofcompactionisstillrelative,butcanbedonesystem-atically.TheContentsasasoilvariablereallyreferstothecontents.Forexample,agivenlocusmaycontainlargequantities(relativetootherloci)ofpotterysherds,plasterchunks,ash(blackissmotheredash;whiteisburned-outash),charcoal,slag,glass,water-washedgravel,sand,silt,organicfibers,animalbonefragments,snailshells,etc.Ineachcaseanexpla-nationofthepresenceofsuchmaterialsiscalledfor.Furthermore,theconditionofthesematerialsisim-portant,asthatisacluetotheirprovenanceanduse.Aretheywaterworn,burned,crushed,sub-angular(withsharpedges),patinated(fromoxida-tion),heavilycorroded,lightlycorroded,decom-posed,sun-bleached,orwhat?Alsotheirconcentra-tionordistributioninalocusisimportant.Thatis,dotheyalloccurtogethernexttoawall,oraretheyspreadoutratherregularly?Allsuchgroupingsortheirconversecallforexplanationandhelpusun-derstandthenatureofthelocusinquestion.Whenexcavatingalocus,whentwoofthethreekeycharacteristicsoflocusdescription(color,com-paction,andcontents)change,itisusuallybesttochangelocusnumbers.RecognitionofMethodsofDepositionAllthelayersthatyouwillfindwerelaideitherbynaturalforces(generally,“erosion”)orbyhumanbeings(“fill”or“dump”).Asidefromanimalburrows,thetwoagentsofnaturaldepositionareeitherwa-terorair.Earlierwementionedsomecriteriaforrecognizinghowlayersaredeposited,butitiswellherebothtoreviewandexpandthatdiscussion.Water-laidlayersusuallyarenotlevelexceptin

Page 18: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

14

thebottomofcisterns,sumps,andpits.Suchlayerswherewaterstoodforalengthoftimeoftencontainpredominantlysilt-sizedparticles,arerathercom-pacttoveryhard(dependingonwhethertheywereeversunbaked),andhomogeneous.Butthoselayersthataredepositedfrommovingwater,eitherinanerosionchannelorinarapidwashacrossanaban-donedfloororcourtyard,areusuallysortedbyparti-clesize(gravelontop;siltonbottom,rathercom-pact,andheterogeneousincontents.Oftenthecon-tentsincludewater-washedandbattered(smoothed)stones,animalbones,pottery,andothermaterials.Theconditionofthecontentsisanexcel-lentcluetothemethodofdeposition.Wind-laidmaterialismostoftenrecognizablebyitssoftness,silttosandparticlesize,andbyitspilingupincorners.Oftenunderamagnifyingglassitwillcontainmaterialcharacteristicofoccupation:tinypiecesofpottery,animalbone,ash,charcoal(bone,wood,ordung),organicfibers(grass,weeds),shell,wood,andsoon.Ontheotherhand,itmaycontainrelatively"sterile"particlesofsand,silt,stone,andorganicfibers.Itisimportanttonotecompositionofwind-laidmaterialexactlythesameasanyotherlo-cusasacluetoitsprovenance.Human-madelayersdivideintofill,make-up,level-ingoperations,floors,courtyards,andaccu-mulations.Fillcanberecognizedmainlybytheran-domarrangementofitscontents(sherds,stones,wood,etc.)andbyitssoftness.Ifthefillhasbeendeliberatelythrownintoanabandonedcisternorotherholeofsomedepth,itisusuallygravity-sorted.Thatis,theheavierstonesrollfurthertowardthebottomasthedirtdescends,whilethesmaller,lighterparticlesslidelessfarandmoreslowly.Suchfillisoftenveryloose.Make-up(offloors)andotherlevelingoperations,ontheotherhand,areoftenidentifiablebyamoreorlesshorizontalorientationoftheircontents,aresultoftheirhavingbeenspreadaroundbythepeoplewhobroughtthemin.Theyaremuchmorecompactthansimplefill,thoughnotashardasbeatenearthfloors.Accumulationonfloorsisoftendifficulttodistin-guishfromtheflooritself,ifthefloorispoorlycon-structed.Accumulationisapttohaveahigherashandcharcoalcontentthanotherlayersandmuchmorepottery.Itwillbelesscompactthanthebeatenearthfloors.DirtCourtyards,iftheycannotbediscernedbytheirlocation,oftencanbedetectedbothbythedungashandwoodcharcoalintheircontentsandbythecastsofseedsthatappearinquantity(feed).An-

imalandhumanactivitychurnsuptheseareas,sothecontentsareoftenworn,broken,andbattered.Anothercharacteristicofdirtcourtyardsisthehighincidenceoferosionpatterns,perhapsbecauseof-tentheroofwasmadewithagutterthatemptiedintothecourtyard.Suchchannelshaveadifferenttextureandcolorfromthelayersthattheycut,par-tiallyfromparticlesize,butalsofromthewell-washedcontents.Floorshavealreadybeendiscussedbrieflyonp.6.Youwillneedtolookforthethreecharacteristicsmentionedthereifyoususpectthepresenceofabeatenearthfloor.Wefindearthenfloors,oreventransientsurfaces,onoursite,soyoumustbepreparedtodiscriminatebetweenothercompactlayersandfloors.Thelatterareusuallymuchmorecompactthanthelayersthatrestuponthem.Theyarefurtherdistinguishedbytheirowncompositionandbytheflatorientationofmaterialrestinguponthemorpressedintothem.Theyoftenexhibithorizontalstriationsinsection,thoughtheircolormaynotdifferdramaticallyfromthelayersabovethem.Ifyouarediggingacourtyardfloorinparticular,youmustbepreparedtolookforPITS.(Pitsarealsodiscussedonp.6.)Herearesomethingsyoucandoifyoususpectthepresenceofapitbutarenotsure:(l)Scrapelightlywithyourtrowelthelayerfromwhichthepresumedpitiscut.Achangeintextureorcompositionoftenresultsinadifferent"feel"orinthesoundofthetrowel.(2)Standawayfromthesuspectedareatogetadifferentperspective.Youmightalsotrydifferentlightingconditionsatdiffer-enttimesofday.(3)Asktheopinionofthosewhoaretrainedtodetecttinydifferencesincolor(artists,arthistorians,geologists,peoplewhoworkwithdyes,experiencedfieldpersonnel,etc.).Ifallelsefails,layoutasmallprobeacrossthesuspectedpitanddigoutaboutfivecentimeters.Cleanuptheprobeandexamineitsbottomandmini-balks.Eventhemoststubbornpitwillusuallyyieldtothis.Be-causepit-materialisusuallysofterincompactionordarkerthanthesurfaceorsoillayercutbythepit,thehorizontalextentofapitcanoftenbetracedfromthetopbycarefuluseofatrowel.Scrapethehardersurface,allowingthetrowelpointtopene-trategentlyintothesofterpit.Thisisausefulwaytooutlinetheintrusivepit.Balknailscanbeusedtomarkforsubsequentexcavationsthepointswherethetrowelhasgoneoffthehardsurfaceintothepit.

Page 19: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

15

BALKSThesinglemostindispensablestratigraphicrecordinthefieldisthebalkasaverticalsectionthroughthelayers.Sometimesacarefuldressingandreadingofthebalkhasclarifiedahostofstratigraphicprob-lems;therefore,youshouldunderstandthepurposeandpropercareofbalks.TrimmingandMaintainingBalksYouwilldigwithinfourverticalbalks,andtheymustbecutascleanlyandverticallyaspossible.Thepointincuttingbalksthiswayis1)topreserveastratigraphicrecordofyourexcavation,particularlyinrelationtothestructuresandinstallationsinyoursquare;and2)toremovematerialthatcancontami-natelowerandearlierloci.Thisproblemoccurswhensloppybalktrimmingleavesa“bathtubeffect”atthebottomofthebalk,whichisthenremovedwiththeearlierlocus.Asageneralrule,ifit’stimetochangelocus,it’stimetotrimbalk.Duringthecourseofdiggingyouwillhaveyourpickpersoncutasverticallyaspossible,remaining5–10centimetersawayfromwhatwillbethefin-ishedbalk.Allvolunteersmustunderstandthattheyaretoleavefinalbalkcuttingtowhoeverhasbeenproperlytrained.Theywillthengetinthehabitofexcavatingnocloserthan5cm.fromthebalk.NormallyallteammembersincludingtheAreaSu-pervisoraretrainedinbalkcuttingat"balkschool"inthefieldorinsomeotherway.Theywillthereforealwaysbeoncalltokeepyourbalkstrimmedandstraight,preferablydaily.Beforeyoucancutyourbalk,youmustbesurethatthebalkstringsareaccuratelylaidoutandtaut.Youwilltrimstraightdownwiththepatishfromthebalkstring,usingaplumbbobtoinsurethatyoure-mainvertical.First,cutaverticaltrackinthebalk5–10cm.wide,checkingfrequentlywiththeplumbbobandtapemeasuretomakesureyouarenotun-dercuttingthebalk.Undercuttingisaseriouserror,aswhatisremovedcannotbeputback.Aneffectivewayofcheckingthatyoucutverticallyistohangaplumbbobfromapickorhoehandlethathasbeenlaidacrossthetopofthebalk,butthatisnotlyingonthebalkstring.Measurehorizontallyfromtheundisturbedbalkstringtotheplumbbobstring.Thatmeasureshouldremainconstantallthewaydownthetrackasyoucut,measuringfromtheplumbbobstringtothebalk.Inotherwords,ifthemeasurefrombalkstringtoplumbbobstringatthetopofthebalkis15cm.,thentheplumbbobstringshouldal-

waysbe15cm.fromtheinsideofthetrack.Contin-uetocutverticaltracks,spacedaround10cm.apart,andthencutoutthesoilbetweenthem.Youcancutthebalkfacefairlyaccuratelywithapatish,butthefinalcarefultrimmingistobedonewithatrowel.Stonesarenottobepulledout,asalargepieceofbalkmaycomewiththem.Neitherarestonestoechiseledthrough.Trimsoilaroundstonesinthebalkflushwiththeverticalfaceofthebalkandleavethestoneinplace,unlessthereisobviousdan-gerfromalarge,loosestone.NEVERATTEMPTTOSECTIONTHROUGHAHARDSTONE.Keepyourbalkstrimmedtowithinabout5-10cm.ofthebottomasyoudig.Ifyougettoofarbehindinfinaltrimmingitwilltaketoolongtocatchup.Itisalsoimportanttocutbalksinanotherpartofthesquareawayfromyourmajorexcavationwork,asallmaterialfrombalkcuttingortrimmingisprimecon-taminatingmaterial.Rememberthatbalktrimmingscomefrommuchhigher,thereforeearlierloci,andwillconsequentlycontaminatewhatyouareremov-ingbelow.Also,balkmaterialismixedfromseveralloci,thereforeitistobethrownout,unlessitisasignifi-cantfind,suchasacoin,lampmold,orotherim-portantartifact.Furthermore,youoryourregularbalktrimmermustcleanupthisdebrisconstantlysoasnottotreadcontaminatingmaterialintolowerlayers.Tomaintainabalkinitscleanest,mostreadablecondition,itmaybenecessarytoavoidusingitasacatwalk.OftenalineofstonesorsandbagsislaidacrossabalktoerectasmallbarriertoindicateNOTHOROUGHFARE.Butsometimesonemustwarndistractedarchaeologistsandvolunteersseveraltimes,andperhapsforcefully,DON'TWALKONTHEBALK!TemporaryCrossBalksareavaluabletoolforkeepingtrackofthestratigraphyofafeaturethatdoesnottouchanyofyourfourmainbalks.Forin-stance,youmaydiscoverthestubofawallinthemiddleofthesquarethatdoesnotintersectanyofyourbalks.Youmaythenfinditusefultoleaveatemporarycrossbalkextendingfromamainbalk,runningacrossthewall.Inthisway,youpreserveclearproofofitsstratigraphicrelationshipstootherwallsandfloors.Ifaredearthlayerrunsoverthiswallandovertheothermainwallsinyoursquare,thenallthewallsareearlierthantheredlayer.If,ontheotherhand,youdiscoverafoundationtrenchin

Page 20: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

16

theredlayerfortheisolatedwall,thenitislaterthanboththeredlayerandtheotherwalls,eventhoughitmaybeatthesamefoundinglevel.Thesetemporarycrossbalksaretobedrawnlikeamainbalk,butthedrawingisenteredonthebottomofthetopplanforthatday.Itistreatedasallbalkdrawings(seebelow).BalkTagsarepartofeverysquare.Suchtagsareverysimpletoreadandextremelyusefulforkeepingtrackofstratification,especiallyifyouspendlocusnumbersfreely.Everylayerorotherfeatureinthebalkistobetaggedassoonasyouhavenumberedit.ThetagreadsL1008,forexample,andispinnedtothecen-terofthatlocuswithanail.Ifthereismuchwindorthatparticularlocusissoft,youmayhavetousetwonails.Butinanycasetagyourbalks.Youmayhaveaninerrantmemory,butyourDirectorandcol-leaguesdonot.BalkDrawingTheconventionatSepphorisandShikhinistodrawthenorthandeastbalks.TheDirectorwillinformyouifitisnecessarytodrawanother.Balkdrawingsarethefinalpermanentvisualrec-ordofthestratificationofyoursquare.Inprincipletheyaretobedrawnbytheonewhodidthedigging,or,ifheorshedoesnothaveanydraftingskill,bysomeoneunderhisorhersupervision.AreaSuper-visorsareresponsibleforthebalkdrawingsinyoursquare.Intermsoftimespentonbalkdrawing,youwillprobablyfindthatyoucanstayaheadifyoudrawexposedfeaturesregularly,thatiseitherweeklyordaily.Whateverintervalyouchoosetokeepyourbalkdrawingsuptodateisnotasimportantasmak-ingsurethattheyareaccurateandclear.Balksaredrawnatascaleof1:25onspecialbalkdrawingpaper,whichisfourcentimeterstotheme-ter.Onetinysquareonbalkdrawingpaperrepre-sentstwocentimeters.Atthisscale,youraccuracyis±1cm,whichiswellwithinatolerablemarginofer-ror.Beforeabalkcanbedrawn,however,itmustbetrimmed,andthenprovidedwithaDatumLine,whichismerelyastringstretchedbetweentwoironrodsdrivenintothebalkatthesameelevationneartwocorners.Surveyor'selevationsaretakenonthe-

sedatapointsandthisreadingisthenattachedtotherod.Thatis,writeitonapotterytagwithamarkingpenandtieittothedatumpoint.Alsomarkitonthebalkdrawingpaper.Consultthesamplebalkdrawingintheappendix.Noticethatnothingisdrawnschematically,butthateverythingisdraftedstone-for-stonetothenearest1cm.Thereisareasonforthis:namely,sothatthemaximuminformationmayberetrievedfromthebalkdrawing.Awell-executedbalkdrawingismannafromheavenforthearchaeologistporingoverfieldnotesanddrawinginthewinter,oradecadelater.Heorshemaydiscover,forinstance,thatalayerclearlyappearstobegravity-sortedinthedrawing,butthatthenotesimplythatthelayerisdeliberatelycompacted.Thiscallsforexplanation.Therefore,drawonlywhatisthere,butdoitfullyandaccu-rately.Theactualmechanicalprocessofbalkdrawingissimpleenough.Youmustfirststretchametertapealongyourdatumline,fasteningittothedatapointswithclothespinsorpaperclamps.ThisestablishesanX-axisandtellsyouwhereyouarehorizontallywithreferencetothecornersofyoursquare(thistapemustbesetupaccuratelysothatthe1m.mea-sureisinfact1m.fromthecornerstake).Markyourhorizontallineonthepapertorepresentyourdatumlineandlabelitwithitselevation(seebalkdrawing).Nearthetopofyourbalkdrawingpaper,printaleg-endwithFieldandArea,balkdesignation,date,andyourname.Whenthesepreliminariesaredone,youarereadytolocatethesurfaceonyourpaper.Yourcallerwillcallheightofsurfaceabovedatumforyouevery25-50cm.alongthedatumline(youdecideonthein-terval).PlaceaLIGHTpencildotonthepaperatthe-sepoints,andthendrawinthislineasinadot-to-dotgame.Dotsshouldbelightenoughthatasyouconnectthem,theydisappearintothepencilline.Addtheconventionforgrass:

Figure5:ConventionforGrass

Page 21: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

17

Drawthebottomofthebalkinthesameway.Yourcallerwillnowcallpointsonthestonesforyou,andyouwilldraftinthestoneonthepaper.Thiswillin-cludewallsthatintersectthebalk.Finally,drawinthelinesthatindicatetheseparationbetweenlay-ers,havingyourcallercallthepointsthemexactlyasshecalledthesurface.Labeleverylocusonyourdrawingandincludetherectanglearoundthenumber.Checkthatyouhavenotmislabeledanythingorleftanythingout.Payat-tentiontodetails,suchastextureofalocus,i.e.,in-cludegravelorspecksofcharcoalconcentratedsomewhere.Artistictouchesneednotbeincluded,asaestheticsarenotasimportantasaccuracy.Thedrawingsofanytwobalksthatintersectoneanoth-er,forexample,shouldmatchattheiredges,justasthebalksdo.BalkRemovalRemovalofabalkinthesenseofcatwalkisaspe-ciesofanysoilremoval.Youhavethedistinctad-vantageofknowingwhatisthere,foryouandyournorthandeastneighborshavelabeledthebalkonbothsides.Youhavetheusualtask,then,ofcarefulstrati-graphicremovalofthelayersinoppositesequencetotheirdeposition.Thesinglecomplicationisthatyouaretorecordthenumbersthatyournorthernandeasterncolleagueslaveassignedtothelocusintheirsquare.Youarealsotorecordanydiscrepan-cies.Thesedatabelongbothonthelocussheetun-der"remarks"(e.g.thisL1035=L2019inthenextsquareeast)andinyournotes.Note:Rememberthatthenorthandeastbalksareyours.Yourneighborswilldealwiththesouthandwestbalks.

WEEKLYREPORTSWeeklyreportsarepreparedbytheAreaSuper-visortoenablethedirectorstohaveapermanentbriefaccountofactivitiesintheareas.Itisalsouse-fulfortheAreaSupervisor(whogetsonetypedcopy)towritedowninbriefcompasshergoalsandhowsheisachievingthem.Shefulfillsthisrecordingrequirementinathreepartreportcontainingtheminiatureschematictopplan,atext,andtheindices.TheWEEKLYTOPPLANispreparedatascaleof1:25asusual.Itsimplyrepresentsthemainfeatures

inyoursquare,thougheverythingislabeledwithitslocusnumber.Itisaninvaluablevisualreferenceforthepersonreadingyourweeklyreport.Thetextisaboutapageofdescriptionofyourgoalsthatweek,howyouachievedthem,didanyproblemsthatremainoutstanding.Thisisahighlycondensedversionofyourweek'snotes.Theindicesaremerelylistsfortheweekofnewitemsineachofthefollowingcategories:1.Potterybucketswithlocusnumbersandelevations2.glass3.coins4.bone5.tesserae6.metal7.plaster8.architecturalfragments9.newloci10.photos11.drawings12.organicsamples13.soilsamples14.miscellaneousIfnotesseraewerefoundthatweek,thenwrite"none"foritem5.Ifyouturnedintoregistryfivemetalartifacts,thenlistwhatpotterybucketsandlocitheyareassociatedwith.Turninanelectronic,typedcopybySundayeven-ing.

PHOTOGRAPHSPhotographsareoneofthemostimportantmeansofrecordinginformationthatwehave.Thereforeithelpstoknowsomeoftheprinciplesoffieldpho-tography.l)Photographsaresupposedtostoreinformation,thereforetheymustbeclear,distinct,andwellcom-posed.Thisalsoimpliesthatthesubjectmustbeclean.Nooneknowshowdeepdirtisfromthepho-tographalone,thereforeitisimpossibletoguesshowmuchhasbeenconcealedbywhatyouasexca-vatorknowtobeonlyonemillimeterdeep.2)Photographsrecordnotonlytheappearanceofthesubjectsuchastheconstructionofawall,butalsoitsrelationshiptootherfeatures(suchastherelationofthewallstofloorsandothersurfaces).

Page 22: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

18

3)Photographsmayalsobedesignedtorevealdaybydayexposureofsomeimportantfeature.Forex-ample,aseriesofend-of-the-dayphotographsmayrevealhowalocuswascoveredinthefirstplace,animportantpointinfinalinterpretation.TheAreaSupervisormakessurethateverythingisabsolutelycleanforthephotographer.Thelastoneoutofthesquaremustactuallybrushawayhisorherfootprints.Thisismostimportant,asanyoneknowswhohasbeenfacedwiththeproblemofin-terpretingphotographsofimproperlycleanedwallsandfloors.(Isthepotterysmashedwithinthefilloruponthefill,astheexcavatorsuggests?)Basically,therearetwokindsofarchaeologicalphotographs:(l)Informalphotos,and(2)publicationphotos.Eachhasitsownjustification.Theinformalphotoor“recordshot”isintendedtobeaspotrecordforyouofwhatisgoingoninyoursquare.Itisnotasubstituteforapublicationpho-tograph.Therefore,youorthedigphotographerwilltakedigitalphotosonlytoclarifysomethingforyourownuse,notforapermanentrecordofwhatisthereorwhathashappenedstratigraphically.Goaheadandmounttheminyourbook.Thinkofthemasoflimitedandtransientuse,butessentialtoun-derstandingwhatgoeson.Onetypenotebookphotographistheso-called“end-of-the-weekshot.”ThisissimplyarecordofhowfaryourexcavationhasproceededbyFridayofeachweek.Youcleanupforthisphotoinexactlythesamewayasforanyotherrecordshot.Recordphotosareproperlymountedandanno-tatedonanotebookpageandinsertedwithinthenotepagesinyournotebook.PublicationphotographsarecalledforbyyourDi-rectorswhohaveconferredwithyouandaresatis-fiedthatthisfeatureisnowcompletelyexposed.Of-tenseveralsuchphotosofvariouswidthanddepthofframemayberequiredtorecordalltheinfor-mationdesirable(thewholesquare;aparticularwall;therebuildinthewall;asinglestonewithgraf-fito).Consultthephotographer,bytheway,forhisorherprofessionaljudgmentasphotographer.ConsultyourDirectorsfortheirprofessionaljudgmentasar-chaeologists.Inanycase,youshouldknowthatallphotos

shouldbetakenwithoutshadows,ifpossible,forshadowscreateahostofproblems.Thismeansthatthebestpublicationshotsaretakeneitherveryearlyorverylate,whenthesunisbelowthehorizon,buttheskyisstillbright.Itmaybenecessarytocleanupat1:00andcomebackbeforesunset.Theuseofa“Joshuacloth”enablesphotostobetakenafterthesunhasrisenorbeforeithassetPhotographsaretobemountedinthenotebook.Besuretorecordthephotographnumber(whichthephotographerwillgiveyou),theorientation(com-passdirection),locusorfeaturebeingphoto-graphed,andanyotherexplanatorycommentsyoufeelarenecessary.YoualsoneedtokeepaPhotographIndexinthefrontofyournotebook.Thisissimplyarunninglistbydateofnumberedphotographsinyoursquare.Suchalistwillbearrangedneatlyasfollows:DatePhotoNo.Subject(locusNo.)

ARTIFACTANALYSISINCAMPThepurposeofthissectionissimplytointroduceyoutoourartifactprocessing.Perhapsifyouhaveagoodunderstandingofthisprocessyoucanaidinitsexpedition,particularlyinthecareyouexerciseinpreparingartifactandpotterylabelsinthefield.Potteryisprocessedinaregularunvaryingprocess.Thefirstdecisionaboutimportanceorsignificanceismadeinpotteryreading.Thisistheprocessofsepa-ratingpotteryintocategoriesaccordingtoitschro-nologyandsometimestypologyforthepurposeoffindingoutwhatarchaeologicalperiodsarebeingdug.Butthepointisthatthedecisiontokeepordis-cardpotteryisreservedforthepotteryreadingta-ble.Attendanceatthedailypotteryreadingisman-datoryforexcavatorsintraining.Potteryrepresentsthequickestandbestindica-tionofthechronologicalhorizonsofalocusunderexcavationandacquaintancewiththemainformsfoundonoursiteconstitutesanessentialpartoftheexcavator’scompetency.Rims,bases,andhandlesare“indicator”sherdsthatmosteasilydesignatethetypeofvesselanditschronologicalhorizon.WeclassifythepotteryfoundatSepphorisandShikhinintocrudewaresandfinewares.CrudewareswerelocallymanufacturedinPales-tineand,inthecaseofoursite,weremadevery

Page 23: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

19

nearSepphoris.Seventy-fivepercentofcrudewaresatSepphorisaremanufacturedatnearbyKefarḤan-aniahandanothertenpercent(includingsomeofourmostdistinctiveforms,liketheSepphoreanBowlorLid)weremadeatancientShikhin(the“Asochis”ofJosephus).AtShikhinwehaveuncoveredexten-siveevidenceofpotterymanufacturing.Crudewaresincludethecoarsely-madepotteryusedincookinganddailylife—plates,bowls,cookingpots,jugsandjuglets—andlargerstoragejarsandamphorae.FinewaresintheGalileeareallimportedfromotherregionsoftheEasternMediterranean.Themorefinelylevigatedclayandtheredwash(“slip”)thatcoatstheirsurfacedifferentiatesthemeasilyfromthecrudewares.ThethreewidelyusedwaretypesoflateAntiq-uity—CypriotRedSlipWare,AfricanRedSlipWare,andPhocaeanRedSlip(LateRoman“C”)Ware—arerepresentedatSepphoris.WehaverecoveredverylittlefinewareatShikhin.Crudewareformstendtochangeslowly,sincethesamegeneraltypeofcookingandcommercialvesselsarepreferredbyseveralgenerations,buttheydoevolve(withinonehundredtoonehundredandfiftyyears),andtherecognitionofthisevolutionhelpsinourchronologicalidentificationoftheloci.Finewares—fancierandmoreexpensiveves-sels—aremoreresponsivetochangesinhumantasteandpreferenceand,hence,providetheexca-vatorwithgreaterchronologicalprecision(withinfiftytoonehundredyearsusually,withsub-typesrevealingevenshorterchronologicalhorizons).Fieldrecognitionofsuchformsgreatlyaidstheexcavator.Afterpotteryiswashed,dried,andread,itgoestoPotteryRegistry.Thesherdshavebeenbaggeddur-ingReading,andinsomeinstancesthebagismarked“RESTORE.”AllbagsofsherdsthengotoPotteryRegistrytoberegistered.Thisistheprocessofmarkingonthesherdwithwaterproofinkitssite,field,andsquaredesignationwiththeserialnumberfrom1toNforthatspecificbucket.Thatis,ifthebucketcontains22sherds,thenthesherdsaremarkedasabovewithaserialnumberfrom1to22.Thelicensenumberalsoappearsoneachsherd.RegisteredpotteryisthensenttotheRestoratororFormator,ifitismarked“RESTORE.”Otherwise,itgoesdirectlytodraftingtobedrawnandthentobe

photographed.Notallpotteryisdrawn,andnotallthatisdrawnisphotographed.Butallpotterythatistobepublishedmustbedescribed.Thedescriptionofpotteryusuallyinvolvesrecordingcolorinside,outside,andofthecore,colorofsliporwash,typeandcoloroftemper(quartz,sand,calcite,“grog,”organicfibers,etc.),andsizeandpercentdistribu-tionoftemper.Thesevariablesareimportantfordistinguishingimportedfromlocallymadepottery,forexample.Potterythathasbeendesignated“draw”istakentodrafting.Thereitisdrawninoutlineinaspecialcomputerizedprocessthatwillproducetheinkeddrawingfromthedigitizedpenciledoutline.Thedig-itizeddrawingsarestoredinthecomputerwiththedescriptionsofeachsherdforproductionofthepot-teryplatesforpublication.Artifactsareprocessedinmuchthesameway,ex-ceptthateachseparateartifactisassignedaregis-trationnumber,called“R-number”forshort.ThisisaserialnumberfromR-1toR-N,dependingwhatthenumberofthelastartifactfromShikhinwillbe.ThefirsttwodigitsoftheR-numberarethelasttwodig-itsoftheyearexcavated.Forexample,R133252tellsustheartifactwasexcavatedin2013andwasthe252ndrecordedthatyear.Inthisprocess,Registrymustdecidewhicharti-factsaresignificantandthereforetobekeptandregistered.Inanygivendayseveralhundredtinyfragmentsofglassmaybesentin,forexample,butperhapsonlyadozencanbesuccessfullydrawnandphotographed,thoughonsomedaysfully90%ofallglassisretainedassignificant.AgainthisisadecisionforRegistryandnotforthefield.Artifactsthatarekeptareeachplacedinseparateboxes,aredrawn,photographed,anddescribed.Thedescriptionwillincludematerial,extentofpreserva-tion,color,manufacturingtechnique(s),form,andothersignificantvariables.Artifactsareenteredontospreadsheets,bothincampandbackintheStates.Thecategoriesthatweuseareasfollows:Site “S”(forSepphoris) 1letter “Sh”(forShikhin) 2lettersYr Year 2digitsNo. RegistryNumber 2digitsF. Field 2digitsSq. Square 2digitsLoc. Locus last3digits

Page 24: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

20

Pail BucketNumber 3digitsPart Rim,handle,etc. Artifact Itsidentification Technique Howitwasmade Color Munsellnotation Decoration (orthedate) Material Stone,ceramic,etc. Coinsundergoaratherspecialprocessingaftertheyareregistered(asartifacts),forthentheymustbecleanedand“read”byanumismatist.Coinread-ingthenbecomesasignificantaidindeterminingwhicharchaeologicalperiodsarebeingexcavatedinthesquareaspreliminarycoinreadingsareenteredonthecoinsheetunder“comments.”Ofcourse,duringthewinterthepottery,artifacts,andcoinsundergodetailedstudy.Thismayrequirecorrectingearlierfieldreadings.Potteryreading,artifactanalysis,andcoinreadingspresupposeasetofARCHAEOLOGICALPERIODS.Thefieldpotteryreadings,forexample,arerecordedas“LR”or“EB”,anditishelpfulifyouareawarewhatthisrefersto.Hereisthechronologyofar-chaeologicalperiodspresupposedatShikhintogeth-erwiththeirabbreviations:IronI I1 1200–1000B.C.E.IronII I2 1000–586B.C.E.Persian P 586–333B.C.E.Hellenistic H1 333–152B.C.E.Hellenistic H2 152–37B.C.E.EarlyRoman ER 37B.C.E.–135C.E.(phase1 37–)(phase2 70–135)MiddleRoman MR 135–250C.E.LateRoman LR 250–363C.E.EarlyByzantine EB 363–451C.E.LateByzantine LB 451–640C.E.EarlyIslamic EI 640–950C.E.LateIslamic LI 950–1291C.E.Note:ThedatingoftheMRandLRperiodsdiffersfromthecurrentchronologyinuseinPalestinianar-chaeology,butbestrepresentswhatwecurrentlyseeemergingatoursite.ThedividingofERintotwophasesfollowsthatoftheSepphorisRegionalPro-ject.Ofcourse,youmayalreadyknowthatattellswithearlieroccupation,EB,MB,andLBrefertoEarly,Middle,andLateBronzerespectively.Wedonotan-ticipateanyconfusionhere,however,asouroccupa-

tionstartswithIronIIpottery.TreatArchitecturalFragmentsratherlikeartifacts,buttheyarehandledinthefieldratherthanbytheRegistrar.Youwillneedtoassigneveryarchitecturalfragmentthatyouunearthan“AFnumber,”whichisaserialnumberforyoursquare.Thatis,thefirst“Arch.Frag.”youfindwillbe“AF-1,”thesecond"AF-2,"andsoon.YoushouldmarkonthepieceofstoneinquestionyourField.AreadesignationanditsAFnumber.AlsopaintontheArchitecturalFragmentourlicensenumber.Thiswilldistinguishitfromoth-erarchfragsfromothersquaresandfromthoseex-cavatedbyanotherexpedition.KeepyourArchitecturalFragmentListuptodate.Fillitinaccordingtothesamplebelow:No.DateLocusDescriptionAF-16/1833088Columndrum.51cm.dia.,5.12m.

long,uniformdiameter,brokenatoneend.

AF-26/1833089 Pieceofmolding,9x2x

11cm.Aroughsketchinyournoteswillalsobenecessaryanduseful,aswilladigitalphotograph.Itshouldap-pearonthenotepageforthedayitwasfound.Therefore,yourarch.frag.listiscross-referencedtothatsketchbydate.Ofcourse,onyournotepagewillappearacompletedescriptionofdimensions,orientation(whereitfell),decoration,dressing,sur-face,treatment(plastered,painted,polished,etc.),andsoforth.TheLocusSheetcontainsasummaryofallthein-formationgleanedfromthecourseoftheexcavationseason.Thelocussheetsareoftenthefirstthingthatthedirectorsturntoafterthedigseasonisover,andtheinformationonthemisformattedtogivequickaccesstotheinformationtheywant.Keepyourlocussheetsuptodateandinpencil.Theyaretobetreat-edlikelaboratorynotebooks,astheyrecordtheprimarydatabytheAreaSupervisoronthedaysofdiscovery.Alterationsafterthefactareverytrouble-someandneedtobeinredinktoshowthattheyarecorrections.Hereisaline-by-lineexplanationoftheLocusSheet:FinalCommentsandInterpretationservesasasummaryofthelocussheet.Althoughitisoneofthe

Page 25: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

21

firstthingslistedonthesheet,itusuallywillbethelastthingyoufillout.Itallowsyoutosayintheendexactlywhatyouthinkthelocusis.IftheDirectorsthinkdifferentlylater,theywillnotewithgratitudethatyoutookthetroubletotrytointerpretitany-way.YoumayaswellconferwiththeDirectorsonthisoneifyouhaveanyquestions.Besuretoincludethearchaeologicalperiodofthelocus,derivedfrompotteryreadings.Ifthelocusiscriticalfordatingfeaturesinyoursquare(especiallyifitisasealedlocus),indicatethatbycircling“critical?”.SketchofLocusisarelativelynewfeatureofthelocussheet.Itgivesthereaderabasicvisualimageofthelocustocorrelatewiththefinalcommentsandinterpretationswithouthavingtoflipbacktodailytopplans.StratigraphicRelationshipsreferstohowthislayerorfeatureisrelatedtoothersaroundit.Listthefirstlocusaboveit,thenextlocusbelowit,andthoselociaroundit(“adjoining”).ConferwiththeareaSupervi-sor(s)inthenextsquare(s)toseeifthislocusistobefoundthereaswell.Recordwhatyouthinkitis.Lo-cussheetsfrompreviousseasonsusedtohaveaplaceforyour“Tentativeexplanation”:yourinfer-enceofwhatthestratigraphicrelationsaddupto.Youmightconcludethatthisfeatureisaheapofashuponfloor3029andunderwind-blownsolid3022againstwall3010intheeastofyoursquare.TheseinferencesarenowincorporatedintotheFinalComments.Averagephysicaldimensionsisfairlystraightfor-ward.Iftheheightordepthofthislayerisnotcon-stant,thenyouhavetosayso.Youmustalsosaywhereitisthatitis10cm.thickandwhereitis15cm.thick.Ifitslopesdowntotheeast,thensayso.Ifitappearsinabalk,indicatewhichone.Ifitappearsinnoneofyourbalks,thenenter“none.”Contentssummarizeswhatisinthesoillayer,ifitisasoillayer.EntertheMunsellcolorreadingandthenameofthecolor.Refertothespecialsheetonparticlescaletofillinthesizeofparticles.For“com-paction”itisonlynecessarytouserelativelanguage,like“soft”and“rathersoft”or“hard,”anditisveryhelpfultonotetheexcavationtool:pick,patish,trowel,ordentaltool.Besuretolistcontentssuchasashorbones,asthisiscriticaltotheinterpreta-tion.“Explanationofcontents”isanopportunitytoexplainhowthestuffyoulistedjustabovegotthere.Youmaydecidethatallthisblackashimpliesthat

thissoilisnearafirethatwasneverallowedtoburnoutcompletely.Isitahearth?Sayso.ParticleSize:Thefollowingparticlescaleispre-sentedintheinterestofquantifyingouridentifica-tionofparticlesize.ItisessentiallyasimplifiedandsomewhatexpandedversionoftheWentworthscale,whichisastandardusedbygeologistsforanalysisofsedimentandrockparticlesize.Obvious-ly,youwillnotbeabletoidentifyclayandsiltparti-clesexactlywithouttheaidofsomeopticalmeasur-ingdevice,butthisidentificationisofferedhereforyourunderstandinganduse.Clay lessthan0.002mm.indiameter.Silt 0.002–.06mm.Sand 0.06–2mm.Pebbles 2–4mm.Gravel 0.4–6.4cm.Cobbles 6.4–10cm.Flagstones 10–25cm.Boulders largerthan25cm.Recordingonthebackofthesheetcontainscross-referencestothefieldnotesandothersourceswhereoneshouldlookforphotographs,drawings,andotherrecordsofthelocus.“Photography”in-cludesrecordshotsandpublicationphotographs.“Architect'sDrawings”meansthosecompletedbytheexpedition'sarchitectorbythearchitect’sstaff.Theyarenumberedand/ordated.Enterboththenumberandthedateofthedrawing,wherethatisknown.Indicatewhenthesurveyorshotinofficialelevations.Indicateotherreportsthatyoumayhavereceived,suchasreportsonorganicremains,onsoil,oranythingelseyoufeelispertinent.Potteryreadingsarefilledinatthepotterytable.Addalistofobjects(coins,architecturalfragments,lampfragments,andotherartifacts)later.Thementionindexallowspeopletolocateeverypageofyournotebookonwhichyoumentionthelocus.Keeptheindexuptodate,asitisanarduoustasktocompletementionindicesattheendofthedigseason.Theindexisacriticaltoolforthosewhoreaddignotebooks.Oftensupervisorsdonotappre-ciatetheimportanceoftheindexuntiltheyareread-inglocussheetsfromsomeoneelse’sbook.Followingaresamplesofthelocussheetandwalllocussheetusedatoursite:

Page 26: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

LOCUSSHEET,EXCAVATIONSATSHIKHIN,20_____22

DATEOPENED:_______________LOCUSIDENTIFICATION:FINALCOMMENTSANDINTERPRETATION:

LOCUSNO.:____________IDENTICALLOCIINADJOININGAREAS:CRITICAL?(circle)

STRATIGRAPHIC RELATIONSHIPS:Lociabove:Lociadjoining:Locibeneath:Topelevations+datesexcavated(potterybucketelevations):Meansofdeposition:Appearsinwhichbalks?

SKETCHOFLOCUS:

AVERAGEPHYSICALDEMINSIONS:HeightorDepth:Width:Length:Tiplineorslopedowntothe:

CONTENTS,etc.:Munsellcolorreading:Particlesize:Compaction:Contents,suchasash,charcoal,gravel,pottery,bone,etc.:

Page 27: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

23

Date BucketNo. Reading Objects,etc.

RECORDINGPhotographydatesandnos.Architect’sdrawing(e.g.finaltopplan),Dateandname:Bestsketchtoscale(e.g.dailytopplan),Dateandname:Appearsinwhichbalkdrawings?Othersamplesandreports(e.g.biological)

MENTIONINDEXDate Page

Page 28: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

LOCUSSHEETFORWALLS,EXCAVATIONSATSHIKHIN,20____ 24

Page 29: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

LOCUSSHEETFORWALLS,EXCAVATIONSATSHIKHIN,20____ 25

Date BucketNo. Reading Objects,etc.

RECORDINGPhotographydatesandnos.Architect’sdrawing(e.g.finaltopplan),Dateandname:Bestsketchtoscale(e.g.dailytopplan),Dateandname:Appearsinwhichbalkdrawings?Othersamplesandreports(e.g.biological)

MENTIONINDEXDate Page

Page 30: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

26

GLOSSARYarchitecturalfragment:Atechnicaltermforabuild-

ingfragment,suchasacolumndrum,capi-tal,columnbase,cornice,lintel,etc.,foundoutofplace.Theyareassignedar-chitecturalfragmentnumbers("A.F.num-bers"),thenumberispaintedonthem,andtheyaremovedtotheirstorageareas.

area:Atechnicaltermforthe5x5m.orlargerplot

withinaField(q.v.).Alsoknownasa“square.”

artifact:Anymaterialobjectthatisalteredbyaper-

sonforsomepurpose,suchasastoneormetalknife,acoin,clayfiredintoafigurineorvase,etc.

balk:(l)Theverticalfaceofthewallofsoilleft

aroundatrench,cut,orsquare,i.e.,thetwo-dimensionalface;or(2)the1meterwidecatwalkleftaroundfoursidesofasquare.Allsquaresinageometricgridleavetheirnorthandeastbalks,whicheffectivelyleavesfourcatwalks.

bondjoint:Ajointbetweentwowallsinwhichthe

stonesinthecoursesoverlapacrossthejoint.Inthistypeofjoint,thetwowallsarebuiltatthesametime.Onewallcannotbedismantledwithoutdisturbingtheother.

boss:Theuntrimmed,projectingfaceofastonewith

draftedorsquaredmargins.PopularintheLateHellenisticandEarlyRomanperiods.

buttjoint:Ajointbetweentwowallsinwhichthe

laterwallsimplyrunsupagainsttheearlier.Thesewallscanbedismantledseparately.

caller:Theonewhoassiststheonedrawingbalks.

Thecaller’sjobistocallthex-ycoordinates,referringtothedatumlineandasteeltapeheldatrightangles,foranyfeatureinthebalkthatthedraftsmanmayrequest.Allcallsaregiventothenearestcentimeter.

cameo:Areliefportrait,usuallyformedbycutting

awayathinlayerofonematerialsothattheresultingportraitisaccentedagainstadarkermaterial,suchasacameobonepor-traitonstone.

chroma:IntheMunsellcolornotationsystem,

“chroma”referstotheintensityorstrengthofcolor

core:Thethin,darkerlineofless-wellfiredpottery

insideasherd.Thatis,thecrosssectionofasherdmaylooklikethreelayers,inwhichthecenterlayeristhe"core."

course:Eachlineofbricksorstonesatoponeanoth-

erisa“course”ofmasonry.crudeware:coarselymadepottery,kitchen,

transport,andstoragepurposes,charac-terizedbygrittycores(See“core”)androughdullslips(See“slip”).

datumline:Thestringacrossthefaceofa balkat

somespecificelevation.This lineisstretchedbetweentwodatum points(q.v.).

datumpoint:l)Anypermanentfeatureuponwhich

ispainteditssurveyedelevationabovesealevel.Thisisthereferencepointforderiv-ingreducedelevations(q.v.).

2)Astakeinthefaceofabalkatsomespecificelevation,usedforthedatumline(q.v.).

description:Inpotteryanalysis,thisisatechnical

termforrecordingsurfacetreatment,tem-per,color,andhardness.Byanalogyitisatechnicaltermforobservationandrecord-ingofallstandardvariablesinanalysisofanyartifact.

dump:Theareawhereexcavated,siftedsoilisdis-

carded.Also,discardedmixedmaterialsfromearlieroccupationsusuallytippedoverthesideofawallorotherstructureinordertoclearanancientareaforbuildingorre-building.

elevation:l)Asurveyor’smeasureofheightabove

orbelowmeanMediterraneansealevel.Itisnormallymeasuredbytotalstationfromafixedpoint,suchasoneoftheBritishOr-dinanceSurveytriangulationpoints,oroneestablishedbytheSurveyofIsrael.

2)Areducedelevationismeasuredfromadatumpoint(q.v.)besideasquare.Theverticaldistancefromthedatumpointto

Page 31: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

27

thefeatureissubtractedfromthedatumtoyieldthereducedelevation,popularlycalledthe“level.”

erosion:Soil,gravel,sand,etc.,broughtinbynatural

processes,suchaswindorwater.Contrastwith“fill.”

fall:Stoneorbrickremainsfromthecollapseofa

wallorotherarchitecture.field:Oneofthelargeplotsmadeupofmany

"squares"(q.v.).fill:Soil,gravel,sand,etc.,broughtinspecificallyto

levelupunderneathaplannedfloororoth-erstructureinantiquity.I.e.,itistheresultofhumanactivity.Contrastwith“erosion.”Oftenoccupationdebris(q.v.)isused,inwhichcasethefillwillcontainartifactsandpotteryfromallearlieroccupationonthesite.

fineware,see“redware.”Formator:Alsoknownas“Restorator.”Theperson

chargedwithreconstructingpotteryfromsherds.Alsoreferstoanyonewhorecon-structsancientwalls.

foundingelevation:Thelowestpointofawall's

foundation,i.e.,beneaththefoundationstones.

foundationtrench:Thelong,narrowtrenchdugin

antiquityforthefoundingcoursesofawall.Oftensuchatrenchisquitewidesothatthemasoncanstandinthetrenchwhileas-semblingthefoundation.Ontheotherhandsomearenarrow,whichrequiredthemasontokneeloutside.Onoccasionatrenchmayexhibitfeaturesofbothtypes.(C.F.Kenyon,Beginning,p.81)

gastropod:Technicaltermfor“snail.”graffito,pl.graffiti:Anycasualwritingonplaster,

pottery,stone,andsoforthinantiquity.grog:Atempermaterialinpotterymadefrom

groundandcrushed,firedpottery.Usuallyappearsred,yellow,oralmostblackunderastereo,50xmicroscope.

gufa:(Arabicqufa)Arubberbasketformovingexca-vatedsoil.

header:Inmasonryabrickorstonewithitsnarrow

faceor"head"endinthefaceofawall.Usuallytheyextendallthewaythroughthewallformingakindofbinderorstrengthen-er.Theoppositeof“stretcher”(q.v.).

hue:Thetechnicaltermforcolor;thewavelengthof

reflectedlight.hammerdressed:Amethodofremovingthemost

prominentirregularitiesfromwallstonesbymerelyknockingthemoffroughly.

indicatorsherd:thepartsofabrokenvesselwhich

mostsurelyindicatethatvessel'stypeanddate:usuallyahandle,rim,orbasefrag-ment.

insitu:Pronounced“insee-too”means“inplace”

andreferringtoundisturbedartifactsandarchitecturalfragments.

intaglio:Theoppositeofcameo.Anengravedpat-

tern,usuallyonagem.locus,pl.loci(pronounced“low-cuss,low-sigh”:Any

threedimensionalfeatureinasquare,suchasalayerofearth,awall,pit,bin,etc.

make-up:Oftensynonymouswith“fill,”but"make-

up"isreservedforthelevelingoperationunderneathfloors.

MentionIndex:Thelistkeptonthebackofthelocus

sheetbydateofeachmentionofalocusinthenotes.

NS:“NotSaved,”referstopotterysherdsthatare

thrownoutinthepotteryreading(q.v.)be-causethebucketiscontaminatedorthesherdsarenotdistinguishableinperiod,or"UD"(q.v.).

occupationdebris:Soilmixedwithothermaterials

characteristicofhumanoccupation:tinyparticlesofbone,pottery,charcoal,ash,seeds,andorganicmatter.

Page 32: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

28

patish:Hebrewfor“hammer,”butonAmericanar-chaeologicalexcavationsinIsraelreferstoasmallhandpick.

patina:l)Onchert(“flint”)referstothesurfacelay-

erthatisoftenstainedyellow,brown,orred.Alsosometimesusedfortheglossycut-tingedge,whichhasbeenpolishedfromcuttinggrain.

2)Withreferencetocopperorbronzein-dicatesthegreenishlayerofcorrosionandcompacteddirtonthesurfaceofthearti-fact.

3)Withreferencetoglass,theopalescentcoatingcausedbyweatheringorchemicalinteractionwiththesoil.

phase:l)Asub-divisionof“stratum”(q.v.) 2)Arebuildorre-useofsomestructureor

smallerfeature,suchasarebuildorrepairofawallorre-surfacingofafloor.

phytolith:Asiliconcastofanindividualcellfroma

plantformedwhenwaterevaporatesthroughthecellwallsleavinganincreasingconcentrationofsilica.Aftertheplantdiesandtheouterwallofthecelldecaystheresidumisasmallsilicastoneintheexactshapeofasinglecellfromtheplant.

pithos,pl.pithoi:Anylargestoragevesselintended

tostayinoneplace.pointonelocus:Aspecialtypeoflocusnumberused

toindicatethefirstfivecentimetersofma-terialinafloor.Forexample,ifthefloorisdesignatedL1088,thenthepotteryandotherartifactswithinthefirstfivecentime-terscomefromL1088.1.

potteryreading:Theprocessofidentifyingtheperi-

odsrepresentedinabucketofpotterysherds.

probetrench:Sometimesmerely"probe."Thesmall,

rapidlydugtrenchthatisexcavatedsoastoclarifythenatureoftheunderlyingloci.Thisenablestheexcavatortoproceednotentirelyblindly.

relief:Atypeofcarvinginwhichthedecoratedele-

mentisraisedabovethebackground,which

iscutaway.Theoppositeof“intaglio”or“engraving.”

redware:Aspecifictypeof4thto6thcenturyByzan-

tinepotterycharacterizedbyrepeateddec-orationandred,oxidationfiring.Sometimesslippedwiththesameclay.See“terrasigil-lata.”

restorator,seeFormator.robbertrench:Thelong,narrowtrenchthatremains

afterrobbingoutawallinantiquity.row:Thelinesofstonesthatformthethicknessofa

wall.screenwall:Looselyusedtoindicateawallthat

buttsatbothendsonearlierwallsandisonerowwide.Perhapstobeassociatedwithanimalenclosures.

section:l)Thetwo-dimensionalfaceofabalk.2)Thebalkdrawing.slag:Theglassy,wastematerialthatisformedasa

by-productinironorcoppersmelting.slip:Theclaycoatingonpotteryformedbydipping

thepotintoclay+waterofpeasoupcon-sistency,thenfiringit.

square,seeareastratification:Thelayersandotherfeaturesina

squareastheyareuncovered.stratigraphy:Theprocessofobservation,inter-

pretation,andrecordingofstratification.stratum,pl.strata:Ahistoricalandculturalperiodof

habitationofasite,asthe"RomanStratum.Strataaredistinguishedfromoneanotherbydifferencesinartifacts,pottery,andoth-erarchitecturalorientation.

stretcher:Inmasonryconstructionastonewhose

longsideisinthefaceofawall.Cornersofwallsareoftenmadeofheaders(q.v.)andstretchers.

surface:l)Themoderntopsoil. 2)Theancienttopsoil.

Page 33: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

29

3)Afloor,courtyardorotherplaneuponwhichpeopleoranimalswalkedinantiqui-ty.

tabun:Abeehive-shapedovenmadeofclay,firedin

place,andoftenwithlargesherdsim-pressedintoitsoutsidesurface.

TBD:“Tobedrawn,”adesignationforpotteryorar-

tifactstobereservedfromtheregistry(af-tertheircompletedregistration)andsenttotheartist.

temper:Anarchaeologist'stermforthematerial

addedtoclaytoreduceitsplasticity.Pot-tersmoreoftensay"filler."Thismaterialiscommonlygrog(q.v.),calcite,sand,quartz,ororganicmatter,thoughothermaterialsareused.

tessera,pl.tesserae:Thesmall,cubicstonesof

whichmosaicsaremade.terrasigillata:l)AnEarlyRomanpotterycharacter-

izedbywhiteclayandthin,redglossyslip.Oftenitissignedorstamped(sealed)onthebottombythepotter,whichaccountsforitsname.

2)Popularlyusedinageneralsenseforred-slippotteryofvariouswaresfromthesecondcenturyB.C.tothefifthcenturyC.E.moreproperlycalled“redware”or“fineware”(q.v.).

tipline:Slopinglinesinthebalkthatindicatethatthelayerinquestionwasthrownout.Suchmaterialisoftengravitysorted,evidencedbythegradualincreaseinparticlesizeasonefollowstiplinedown.

topplan:Thedailyscaleplanofagivenarea

(square).typology:Classificationofartifactsaccordingtode-

velopmentofafeatureorfeatures(form,decoration,surfacetechnique,manufactur-ingtechnique,etc.)overtime.

ud:“undistinguished,”usuallyreferringtobody

sherdsofpotterythatdonotmanifestiden-tifiablecharacteristics,i.e.,theyarenotun-ambiguouslyclassifiabletoanyperiod.

unk:“unknown,”usuallyreferringtoanunfamiliar

potteryform.value:Thedarknessorlightnessofacolorinthe

MunsellColornotation.wash:Anunfiredcoatingonpottery,usuallythinand

easilywornoff.whiteware:AspecifictypeofByzantinepotteryon

theonehandand13thcenturyArabpot-teryontheothercharacterizedbywhiteclayandnoglazes.TheArabvarietyhasin-cised,geometricdecoration.

Page 34: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

30

APPENDIX1:THEIDENTIFICATIONOFCHARCOALCharcoalcanbeidentifiedashardwood,softwood,orbonebysimplybreakingit.Ifawoodgrainshowsinthebreak,itisobviouslywood.Hardwoodexhibitsafinegrainandsoftwoodalargegrain.If,ontheotherhand,thesampletendstobreakinonlyonedirection,namelylongitudinally,thenitisprobablybone.Ifthereisnodiscernibledirectionofbreakorofgrain,thenitisdoubtlessdungcharcoal.Theremaybetimesthatyoumaymistakebonecharcoalforhardwoodcharcoal,butbyandlargeitisrathersim-pletoidentifythesamplecorrectlybycarefulexaminationafterfracturingit.

Page 35: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

31

0

Page 36: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

32APPENDIX2:SAMPLEDAILYNOTES

Page 37: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

33APPENDIX3:SAMPLEDAILYTOPPLAN

Page 38: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

34APPENDIX4:SAMPLELOCUSSHEETFILLEDOUT

Page 39: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.
Page 40: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

APPENDIX5:SAMPLELOCUSSHEETFORWALLS,FILLEDOUT

Page 41: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

APPENDIX6:SAMPLEFINALTOPPLAN

Note:Nofinaltopelevationswereenteredonthisplan.Yourswilldefinitelyhaveelevations.

Page 42: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

38APPENDIX7:SAMPLEBALKDRAWING

Page 43: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

39APPENDIX8:SAMPLEWEEKLYREPORTSepphoris1994V.90WeeklyReport7/4-7/8AreaSupervisor:AlysiaFischer Thisweekweexcavatedtwomainareas,andforsimplicity'ssakeI’llexplainthingsbyarea. Thefirstareaisthecircularworkspace,whichisdefinedbyaringofmortaredstoneswhichincludesreusedcolumndrums.Webeganbyexca-vatingthecentralloosesoil(90013)whichdatedtotheByzantineIIperiod.Inthislocuswefoundpigbones. Surroundingthecentralloosesoilandbor-deredbytheringofstoneswasamuchharderverycompactedlayerofsoilinwhichwefound3coins,glass,alampfragment,asandalnail,anail,andpig,chicken,andsheep/goatbones.Thishardpackedlayer(90014)appearstohavebeenlaidduringtheByzantineIperiod. Underneaththehardpackedlayerween-counteredanewlocus(90018)definedatthetopbyalayerofbrokenpottery,anddefinedatthebottombybedrock.Inthislocuswefoundglassandthepot-terydatedtotheLateRomanperiod. Intheeasternsectionoftheworkspace,underneath90014,weencounteredanashylocus(90022)whichappearstobemortarlaidonbedrocktocreateasmoothworksurface.Inthislocuswefoundmanyburnedolivepits,whichsuggestthatacrudeoliveoilmayhavebeenproducedhere.ThepotterywasLateRoman. Wealsoexcavatedbetweenthestonesring-ingtheworksurface(90017),andtothewestofthestones(90020).Bothoftheselociyieldedonlyun-distinguishableshardsandnootherinformation. So,stratigraphicallyspeaking,thisareasawitsfirstuseintheLateRomanperiodasamortarfloorlaiduponbedrockusedforsomesortofoliveindustrythatinvolvedburning.DuringtheByzantineIperiodaringofstoneswasfoundedwithahardcompactedsurfacetocreateaworkspace.Thisworkspacewasstillinuse,orreusedduringtheByz-antineIIperiod.Theonlyinformationwehavecon-cerningthisworkspaceisthegoldjewelryfounddi-rectlyoverit(whichcreatesmorequestionsthananswers),andthefactthatduringtheByzIIperiodtheceilingoftheworkspaceburnedandfellin,pre-sumablyendingtheuseofthisspace. Theotherareaweexcavatedthisweekwasassociatedwithatrenchtothewestofthework-space.Thistrenchappearstoberoughlyinlinewiththeprojectedwallofthebuilding.Aswebegantoexcavatethetrenchweencounteredalargenumberofartifactsassociatedwiththetoplocus(90016):

glass,4nails,lampfragments,aglassbead,3glasstesserae,sheep/goatandchickenbones,andafishstampedpotteryfragment.ThislocusdatedtotheByzantineIIperiod.Afterthislocusthetrenchwasdividedintotwosections.Inthenorthwestcorner(90024)wefoundacoinandcowbones.OneofthreepotterybucketshasbeenreadanditdatestotheRomanperiod(BSonly).Thislocusendsonbed-rock.Thesoutheastsectionofthetrenchendsinanashylayerwhichcontainsburnedolivepitsandprobablyrelatestotheoliveindustryin90022.Thepotteryforthislocushasnotyetbeenread. NortheastofthetrenchwasaseparateareawhichwasatfirstdefinedbyalocusfullofcobbleswhichdatedtotheByzantineperiod.Directlybe-neaththecobbleswasanotherlocuswhichdatedtotheByzIperiod.Bothlociwereprettydry,artifac-tuallyspeaking.Thelastsoillayerpriortothetrenchandthisnortheastcornerjoiningin90023,containedlampfragmentsandcowandchickenbones.Thepotteryonthislocushasnotyetbeenread. Asforthisweek,wephotograph,drawbalksanddrawtopplans.Oursquarehasshownlit-tletonoinformationconcerningtheoriginalbuild-ing.Infact,insomewaysitarguesagainstthebuild-inghavingextendedthisfar.TheLateRomanoliveindustryisfoundedonbedrock,notonsomeearlierstructure.Wedidfindatrenchwhichmaylineupwiththebuilding(andIunderstandsomestonesemergedlateFriday,andtheymaybefoundationstones--unfortunatelyIwassick,andsoIamonlyhypothesizing).Anyway,lookforwardtomoreofthistypeofargumentinmyforthcomingfinalre-port...Wasthereanextensionoftheoriginalbuildinginthissquare,ifso,whendiditgooutofuse?

Page 44: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

40BIBLIOGRAPHY:EXCAVATIONMETHODSIN

PALESTINIANARCHAEOLOGYSeealsotheshortbibliographyonpage2.Aharoni,Yohanan."Remarksonthe'Israeli'Method

ofExcavation,"(1973)Eretz-Israel,vol.11.I.DunayevskyMemorialVolume.Jerusalem:Isra-elExplorationSociety,48-53(InHebrew),Eng-lishsummaryp.43.Apresentationoftheuse-fulnessoffollowingarchitectureandrestoringpotteryonancientfloorsasoneofthemainob-jectivesoftellarchaeology.

Albright,W.F.(1972)TheArchaeologyofPalestine.

Baltimore:Penguion.Anindispensablesynthe-sisofarchaeologicalandhistoricalinformation,withausefuldiscussionoffieldprinciplesinthefirstchapter,includingaclearexplanationoftheworkingsofageometricgrid.

Archer,StevenN.andKevinM.Bartoy,Editors.

(2006)BetweenDirtandDiscussion:Methods,Methodology,andInterpretationinHistoricalArchaeology.NewYork:Springer,.Arecentcon-tributiontoourunderstandingof“HistoricalAr-chaeology”,whichmustrelatetotextsmuchaswedointheMiddleEast.

Dever,WilliamG."TwoApproachestoArchaeologi-

calMethod--TheArchitecturalandtheStrati-graphic,"Eretz-Israel,vol.11.I.DunayevskyMemorialVolume.Jerusalem:IsraelExplorationSociety,1973:1*-8*(EnglishSection).Anar-ticulatestatementofthepositivefeaturesofre-lianceonstratigraphicinvestigationviastandingbalks--ourmethod.

Dever,WilliamG.andH.DarrellLance,eds.(1978)A

ManualofFieldExcavation:HandbookforFieldArchaeologists.Jerusalem:HebrewUnionCol-lege—JewishInstituteofReligion,NelsonGlueckSchoolofBiblicalArchaeology.

Drinkard,JoelF.,etal.,Editors.(1988)Benchmarks

inTimeandCulture:AnIntroductiontoPales-tinianArchaeology.ASOR/SBL,ArchaeologyandBiblicalStudies,PhilJ.King,ed.Atlanta:ScholarsPress.

Jeske,RobertJ.andDouglasK.Charles,Editors

(2003)Theory,Method,andTechniqueinModernArchaeology.Westport,Conn:Praeger.AlltheirexamplesarefromtheUSAorSouthAmerica,butingreatdetail.

Kenyon,Kathleen.(1970)ArchaeologyintheHoly

Land.NewYork:Praeger.SimilartoAlbright'svolume,butmoredetailedandwithanannotat-edlistofexcavationswithbriefbibliographies.Presupposesthemethodspresentedinmoredetailinthenextbookbutdoesnottreatmeth-odology.

Kenyon,Kathleen.BeginninginArchaeology,(1970).

NewYork:Praeger.Particularlychapters5and6on"Excavating"and"Recording."Wellillus-tratedwithanin-depthtreatmentofmanyofthetopicsmentionedinthismanual.Discussionofstratificationisespeciallyhelpful.

Lance,H.D.(1967)ExcavationManualforAreaSu-

pervisors.PreparedforTellGezer,andthere-forepresupposesexcavatingaTell.Neverthe-lessquiteusefulandcomplete,particularlychapter1,"Digging."(pp.1-10).Usesthesameexcavationandrecordingsysteminmainoutlinethatwedo.

Meyers,E.M.,A.T.Kraabel,J.F.Strange,"Ar-

chaeologyandRabbinicTraditionatKhirbetShema',1970and1971Campaigns,"BA35/1(1972),especiallypp.5-8,"ExcavationMeth-ods."ThesepagessummarizethemethodthatweuseincludinganexplanationofthegridatKhirbetShema'.

Meyers,E.M.Strange,J.F.,andMeyers,C.L.(1981)

ExcavationsatancientMeiron,UpperGalilee,Is-rael1971-72,1974-75,1977.MeironExcavationProject,Vol,III.Cambridge:AmericanSchoolsofOrientalResearch,:xvi,"KeytotheExcavation."Apresentationofthegridexcavationmethods,andrecordingSystemwithdefinitionofalocusasevolvedfortheMeironExcavationProject.

Renfrew,ColinandPaulBahn(2008)Archaeology:

Theories,Methods,andPractice.5thed.NewYork,NY:ThamesandHudson.Astandardworkfromthepointofviewof“socialarchaeology”.

Strange,JamesF.,etal.(2006)ExcavationsatSep-

phoris.VolumeOne:UniversityofSouthFloridaProbesintheCitadelandVilla.TheBrillRefer-enceLibraryofJudaism,Vol.22.LeidenandBos-ton:Brill.ThefirstvolumeoftheUSFExcava-tionsatSepphoris.Chapter1containsanab-breviateddiscussionofourexcavationmethods.Chapter2discussesthementionofthesitein

Page 45: THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA …THE SHIKHIN EXCAVATION PROJECT MANUAL FOR AREA SUPERVISORS ... Noel Freedman began a similar practice at the Ash-dod Excavation Project.

41ancienttextsandthehistoryofinvestigationsintoSepphoris.

Strange,JamesRiley.“ShikhinSurvey:Preliminary

Report.”HA-ESI124(2012).Availableon-lineathttp://www.hadashot-esi.org.il/report_detail_eng.asp?id=2195&mag_id=119.

Wright,G.E.Shechem,theBiographyofaBiblical

City(1964)Appendix1,"PrinciplesofFieldTechnique''byL.E.Toombs,pp.185-190.Thisvolumepresupposesessentiallythesamemeth-odswehaveseendevelopedatGezer.Toombsspellsoutthesupervisor'sneedforcontrol,sharpobservation,andaccuraterecording.Wellillustratedwithmanyplatesofsectiondrawings.

Wright,G.E."ArchaeologicalFillsandStrata"BA25

(1962),34-40.Ahelpfuldiscussionofthespe-cialarchaeologicalproblemsassociatedwithfills,particularlytheproblemsofdatingfromimportedfill.Alsoexplainstherationaleofthe

Shechemrecordingsystem.Wright,G.E.H."AMethodofExcavationCommonin

Palestine,"ZeitschriftdesDeutschenPalestina-Vereins82(1966),113-124.Adiscussionofthe"Americanstyleofexcavation"inPalestine,spe-cificallythe"Reisner-Fisher"method,whichistheancestorofthe"Wheeler-Kenyon"method.Theauthorcallsattentiontosomeambiguitiesofthe"locustostratum"approach.