The Scope of Free Inquiry

7/31/2019 The Scope of Free Inquiry

1/14

e ee o e preen ricle i e cope o ree inqir ro e perpec

ive o e Vmk- o e Pli Mjjm-k n i conerpr in e Mm-gm, preerve in Cinee rnlion. Inee wo pecien ro e corp o erl Bi icore, propecive iciple i encore o inveie weer e B clio bein ll wkene ecer i jife. preenion i beon n nnoe rnlion o e Mm-gm icore, wici ollowe b coprive o e wo verion n n evliono e inifcnce o eir preenion. re o reerence in e preen ricle i o e oworl o e erl Bi icore

eelve, wic or e o pr cn be coniere repreenive oBi in i preecrin e. Ti oworl or poin oeprre in n ep o illre e ee ee wo prllel icore conve on e ee o ree inqir in relion o one own ecer.

Introduction

Eainations o uddhist thouht Kl xmp p x pp , xpg - pgm . Y, m-p w Kl Vk g- m pg mkb . T p w w-kw

* m b Bk, G M, K S J w

mm pp.

1. N 3. N I.18813, w p M 1 I.438b43. F

xm . E (2007).

E SCOPE OF FEE NqUY

CCODNG O E VASAKA-

SuA ND S ADAA-GAA PLLEL*

Anlayo

Rivista di studi sudasiatici, 09, .


2/14

8 riss 4, 2010 articoli

p bg w b . g Vk p, w, B m bg wk - b m bj m g p .

T Vk, - jjinik Terv , p --g-x C w p bGm Sg, b w pp b Pk g- m w Srviv .

ranslation o the Madhyamagama iscourse

T gg [ k ] g.

. T . m B w wg K, Kmmmm, w K.

. m B O mk: b [b] w m, kw m , kw B O g

2. T m r g wkg m b k,

g p p pp Cbbion, MN 112

MN III.237 p M 187 I.732734, g; mp

. (2008).

3. MN 47 MN I.317320.

4. M 18 I.731b732.

. O gg mp . Bp (1: ), Em

(18: 20) b (182: 20); . Em (184), L

(13: 242), M (18: 8), M C (11: 27) Wm (180: 13).. mp bw M 18 MN 47, p pgp

mbg m (1/200: 41418). F m , mp P

mg, xp g m k Dm, w b g k

p g gg .

7. MN 47 MN I.317.20 J G, Sv.

8. M 18 I.731b3:, p bv

. N (2003: 232) mm mg bw m

mm [] p kw-


3/14

anlayo he coe o ree Inuiry

wk. w [ ] g [ k ] g ?.

. T mk p B O: T B O Dm, B O m Dm,Dmm m B O. W w w [ BO] xp [ ], g w w g x kw-g mg [ B O m].

T B : Mk, p , g xp. T mk [ ] g.

. T B O : b [ b ] w m,

kw m , -g w w [ k ] g . F[ g ] m kw b , [ g ] b . [O g k ]:

C kwb g b b ? Spp m gg m kw kwb g b . [ ], g:

5. C mx kwb g b b ? Spp m gg m kw mx kwb g b . [ mx ], - g:

6. C p kwb g b b ? Spp m gg m

g m p mp m w p

mg .

. M 18 xp b

B g . T m xp

P w, . .g. MN 47 MN I.318.23: . p b

, w, P pk , .

MN 47 MN I.318.: vijjni v e no v, . bw.


4/14


kw p kwb g b . [ p ], g:

. b b pg Dm g m, pg [] mp? Spp m -gg m kw b b pg Dm g m, [j] pg mp. b pg [k g m], g :

. D b m k m g, m k m g? Spp m gg m kw

b m m b mg[ w ] m [ bg m g].

9. [ g ] pk k : T b g p, . Bg m gg , g .

. T [m] mg k [ g]: Vb , w

p, w pw, w kwg, b b g m mk : Tb g p, . Bg m - gg , g ?

10. M 18 I.731b1: , . MN 47 MN I.318.23

wm Dm g m g , r

pnno i kl irpnno, w P

II.382. xp m cirklo p [] [] io g m[] [] .

11. g m p, MN 47 MN I.318.2 -

b m w mbg g m bm-

g m.

12. MN 47 MN I.31.2, p b w -

b m . T p bg

g w b pg , w M 18

m mw xp.


5/14

anlayo he coe o ree Inuiry 11

[T g ] g w: Vb , kw m , kwg g [b w p pw]. Y, b , w , mg [m] mm, [pb] m-b; [m] pgg w; [] bm [w] pgg w; [ ] m g; [ ] [ ] b .

[M, g] m kw [] m [b ppw], m b , [] kg [m] , [w ]: g p, m . Bg m gg , g .

Vb , p, pw,

kwg, w g m mk -: T b g p, . Bg m gg , g - .

. , [ g] k [- g ] , w kwbg , [ ] [] -m w . [T g

13. T MN 47.

14. M 18 I.7311: , , , . M -

g p pg . T p pg MN 47 MN I.31.12

: e c e c e c nni, e c i

ekcce ie nini, e c i ekcce ien npli, n en

vjni w pg w, w pg b, w gp,

m w w m g, m w b m

g b p [ ] m . M 18, w pg b w b m g

. , M 18 bg g /, w b g b-

g m g b , .. B,

p. F, xp kw m b

mkg vj p + j kw.

1. T p m b pg b g Si

Sk p, w b g wkg B

w pb pmg p g p


6/14


k] mx kwb g , [ ] [] m w -. [ k] p kwb g , [ ] [] mw .

. T w m p g kw-b g , [ ] [] w g ; mx kwb g , [ ] [] w g , [g]:

. g kwb g ,

mp m p m, w g. mx kwb g mp p m, w g. p , k m p, k m bj, k [m] p, k m mp g p.

. p w [ w g m] pp m. p w

Dm m . T m Dm [] g g, bm mbm, k g bk w.

[W] m Dm [] g g, bm m bm, k -g bk w, g x k [ p] m kw g g pm

m kw , . DN 33 DN III.217.8 Sk gm S- (18: 7). m w

MN 47.

1. MN 47 xp pg b

g.

17. MN 47 MN I.31.31 w p, no c en

o.

18. MN 47 MN I.31.34 pk Dm bg kkkppib

w k bg p.


7/14


pm, [b g ] B O:T B O g wk!

5. g, [m] mg k [ p]: Vb , w p, w pw, w kwg, w

b m kw g g p-m pm, [b g ] B O: T B O g wk!?

[T p ] g w: Vb , kw m B O, kwg

1. M 18 I.73120:,, w k xp b -

g Pprijni pri. Spp b g m

xp M I.8413, w p kn pri

p g p p MN 13 MN I.84.10.

T mm P II.4.21 xp kn pri mp kn

pn p. T

b b m g mp pri. T p-

g pg MN 47 MN I.31.37 : o i e bi i ekcc

e ni cci; b B m (1/200: 417)

: g kwg g Dmm m - b g; . Cm (12: 22), w pg :

g , b g , p-

m ; (17: 382), w : g b

pkwg p p mm m m mm.

20. MN 47 MN I.320.2 Dm mm. Ew

(2008: 23) k m Dm g

Bm m g. Y, p p pg

m w m m- (. m-

m g P II.388.: ekcc pive bi en bienpiveen ene ni cci, w k bmm x-

pgpive bi p jniv), m--

w kw w g m m b wk (

b mp g m p g wkg).

T pp m g m-

mm m bg wk,

b p g p , w

w g m- z.


8/14


9/14


mk. T xp b b xp w bg g p - w b bg k .

S xp B , b bg , m pbb p p g. pp w g B w p b xp g m P , pp -, w g pp w b mpbb.

m f P gxm w B wm g m g . g -

, p g w w b pg wm w g m mp. T p k C m b w g g B wkg, b w .

, w B wk w b b g w g g w m b wkg. T B p p b g m S-nik,g w C Sk p. T f

p w B xp Kg P z g mk g bm. T

24. C. b 10.

2. T M 18 m b j

pnn pg P pg,

b pjji p pp pnn jjinik

p p, . MN 43 MN I.2.12:pnno M 210 I.7811:; MN 0 MN I.333.24: pnn M 131

I.2022:; MN 7 MN II.37.2: pjji M 208 I.781:; MN 10

MN II.22.1: pjji M 7 I.42b22:; MN 13 MN III.207.14: pnno

M 171 I.70b22:. T gg g w M

18 w b f b p xp. kw (17: 1043)

b g pb , w , w, mp p.

2. SN 3.1 SN I..; S 122 II.332; S 3 II.3117; pg

m Sbev G (177: 182, 17).


10/14


p , f p P j xp b b B m b wk, B g g m w mgk p. T w B wkg w, m pp , pp b g z.

p B m m g, . T m-p m C . P f p, g w B - . T p k pp b Bb xp p, bgpw b m m g p.

T P b bg b p , w p w b b-. T pg mw p P g, w w g, pg pg C b.

valuation

w, mp w p g g -m g m w m mw pzzg w m. T , , g kg mp bw p- P Nik C (, b, p Sk b). D b g m , pg m m bm b . p C, m, w

pb m . B pg p- b , b .Pp m mp mp , w-

, g -

27. M I.731b27:.

28. MN 47 MN I.31.2: bpro , n bpro.

2. C. b 14.


11/14


m f . T p f p , xmp, m b g, pp b p gm b B m . , pp b mp k m p g p b m.

p , mp Vk p m b mg g w xp Bg m . T mg b m pb m bg wk . b , g b p- g m g.

Sercin or ipriie b epiricl obervion

Pp p w p pw b gg m p k p w m b wk w. S kg b -k b bg bwg w g w g m.

Scrin o e ie o e ecer

O b g p w b b w, x p w p bg . Lg gm bw w p (w p z g m g -), b w m g

b g. T , m p w .

30. Jk (13/180: 32), mmg Vk, xp

b b m g m, b p

p w b p g

b ( ).


12/14


Direc qer o e ecer

F m g p, g -g w, kg mp. T gg m pp m mkb p p .

Peronl verifcion

g k mp g g , m m p g . T g- g (), bgwg g . Y, m m-

p w g p p - . p, p b g b m p xp kb.

T g g p w B g pp w w -mkb mp. m, B g w p P Nik C

p m bm bj g p xm b pp p.

31. T w z w m Dp 7, w b porio pm p w g b

, o, . T m pp p ,

. ro [] ve iporo Pn Drp 333 C (18:

11) (180: 127); r[] vi pr un(-vr)

2.23 B (1: 377); C p 212

I.704 213 I.73b1; b Wm (178: 132 [2.22]) w

[] m; b p p e cin[] i

ni ke b p in, 2.23 Bk (111: 107) Zg (10: 310).


13/14


Areviations

N Arnik P Ppcn(mm. MN)Dp Dp S Sk ( 99)DN Dnik S () Sk ( )M ( 6) SN SnikMN jjinik

Reerences

. . T Sx P , g Cbb- P.Jornl o Bi Eic 5: .

Bp, P. V. 969. C Mmgm Lgg B x.

Dr. Skri ookerji Feliciion Vole, . B. P. S, 6. V:Cwkmb Pb.

Bk, m. 9. unvr, Eine Sln Biicer Sprce inibeicer Sprce. B: m.

B, Fz. 965. unvr. Gg: Vk & p.Cm, b. 96. Frer Diloe o e B, rnle ro e Pli

o e jji Nik. L: Ox U P.C, Mg. 99. P Dmp. Jornl o e Pli ex Socie :

.

Ew, C. . Lb B. Bi Sie Review5.: .

Em, Fm. 9. T Fm Dpm SSp. Proceein o e TirFir Inernionl Conre o nScience in Ai n Nor Aric, okoKoo 31st A 7t Sepeber 1983,. . Ymm, 99. k: Gkk.

. 96. O Fm Og x C gm.Bi Sie Review : 9.

E, Sp . . Dbg Km-S: Epmg, E

S. Bi Sie Review .: 9.G, . 9. Te Gili ncrip o e Sbev, Bein e17t n L Secion o e Vin o e lrvivin. m: p M Em O.

kw, k. 99. Bi CineeSnkri Dicionr. k: k., . B. 96. Te Collecion o e ile Len Sin (jjiNik).

L: P x S.Jk, K. N. 96/9. Erl Bi Teor o Knowlee. D: M

B.


14/14


L, Cg. 96. gm. Encclopei o Bi, . G. P. Mk,. ., . S Lk: Dpm B f.

M [=M], Egk. 95. Jp S S Cgm. Zr Sclzerikei von Werken er nnLierr, . .B, . , 9. Gg: Vk & p.

M C, T. 99. Te Cinee n e Pli jjiNik. D: M B.

m, Bkk. 995/5. Te ile Len Dicore o e B, .Bkk B. B: Wm.

N, J. . T Ep B Zq.Annl Repor o e Inernionl Reerc Inie or AvnceBolo Sok univeri 6: 5.

, G. . 9. x P Dmp. Te Lne o e

Erlie Bi riion, .. B, 95. Gg: Vk& p.

S-, V. 96. Doice Berireien i leren Bi.II. D Sir n ein Koenr Sipr. B: kmVg.

b, Ok. 9. Up V Mjjmk M-mgm. Inoloicl n Bi Sie, Vole in onor o Proeor

J. W. e Jon on i 60t bir, . L. . , 5. Cb: F S.

Wm, E. 9. C S Fgm C gm. Te Lne o e Erlie Bi riion, .. B, 6. Gg: Vk & p.

Wm, C. 9. Te Cinee unvr, A Collecion o Iporn Oeo e Lw, F Ci o Sn Cin, rnle n Annoe. Bx: Bg C.

Zg, Cmp Tp. 99. unvr. III. Der ibeice ex, nerirbei von Siline Diez ereeben von Cp Tpen Zone.Gg: Vk & p.

The Scope of Free Inquiry

Documents

Transcript of The Scope of Free Inquiry