THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN …minisites.ieep.eu/assets/2370/DBlandford_trade.pdfTHE ROLE OF...
Transcript of THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN …minisites.ieep.eu/assets/2370/DBlandford_trade.pdfTHE ROLE OF...
![Page 1: THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN …minisites.ieep.eu/assets/2370/DBlandford_trade.pdfTHE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN REDUCING THE CARBON FOOTPRINT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE David](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042312/5eda88f6febf237c0c3b758f/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN REDUCING THE CARBON FOOTPRINT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE
David Blandford
Professor Emeritus/Pennsylvania State University/USA
Katowice Climate Change Conference (COP24)
7 December 2018
1
![Page 2: THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN …minisites.ieep.eu/assets/2370/DBlandford_trade.pdfTHE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN REDUCING THE CARBON FOOTPRINT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE David](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042312/5eda88f6febf237c0c3b758f/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
• Agriculture and associated changes in land use
are a major source of GHG emissions
• Agriculture accounted for 3.8% of world GDP in
2015 but 24% of global GHG emissions (World
Bank)
• Developing countries accounted for 92% of
global emissions from AFOLU in 2012-14
(FAOStat)
THE CONTEXT FOR ADDRESSING THE
CHALLENGE
2
![Page 3: THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN …minisites.ieep.eu/assets/2370/DBlandford_trade.pdfTHE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN REDUCING THE CARBON FOOTPRINT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE David](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042312/5eda88f6febf237c0c3b758f/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
• As a facilitator of shifts in the pattern of global
production to low-carbon food sources
• Through the expansion of market opportunities
(improved livelihoods) for low-carbon suppliers
of food
• As a facilitator for global adaptation in the
location of production in response to climate
change
• As a stabilizer for food prices in the face of
climate-induced disruptions in supply
TRADE’S POTENTIAL CONTRIBUTION
3
![Page 4: THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN …minisites.ieep.eu/assets/2370/DBlandford_trade.pdfTHE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN REDUCING THE CARBON FOOTPRINT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE David](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042312/5eda88f6febf237c0c3b758f/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
1. Policies to address emissions costs and
international trade
2. Government financial support for
mitigation/adaptation – trade implications
3. Domestic adaptation policies and border
measures
An important issue is whether domestic climate
change policies for agriculture can be consistent
with existing GATT/WTO disciplines on trade
policies
PRESENTATION COVERAGE
4
![Page 5: THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN …minisites.ieep.eu/assets/2370/DBlandford_trade.pdfTHE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN REDUCING THE CARBON FOOTPRINT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE David](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042312/5eda88f6febf237c0c3b758f/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
• Internalization of emissions costs in
production/consumption through taxation, regulation
or a mixed approach (cap-and-trade)
• Financial support for adaptation or for adoption of
low-emission practices/consumption of low-emission
products (includes support for development/adoption
of low-carbon technologies)
• Behavioral change inducements for producers and
consumers through information, education,
knowledge transfer
MITIGATION/ADAPTATION
POLICIES – MAJOR OPTIONS
5
![Page 6: THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN …minisites.ieep.eu/assets/2370/DBlandford_trade.pdfTHE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN REDUCING THE CARBON FOOTPRINT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE David](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042312/5eda88f6febf237c0c3b758f/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
• Non-discrimination principle of the GATT –
application of internal measures or border
measures affecting imports
• Government support – the “boxes” in the
Agreement on Agriculture (as well as disciplines
under the Subsidies Agreement)
• Inadequately disciplined measures – export taxes
and restrictions
WTO TRADE DISCIPLINES –
SOME KEY ISSUES
6
![Page 7: THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN …minisites.ieep.eu/assets/2370/DBlandford_trade.pdfTHE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN REDUCING THE CARBON FOOTPRINT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE David](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042312/5eda88f6febf237c0c3b758f/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
• Internalization of emissions costs (explicit or implicit)
• Changes in imports as carbon leakage from a domestic perspective
• Carbon reallocation versus misallocation from a global perspective
Internalization and Imports
7
![Page 8: THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN …minisites.ieep.eu/assets/2370/DBlandford_trade.pdfTHE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN REDUCING THE CARBON FOOTPRINT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE David](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042312/5eda88f6febf237c0c3b758f/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
• Differential taxes on imports based on carbon “content”?
• How to deal with partial or complete internalization of emissions costs in imported products?
Preventing carbon misallocation through border tax adjustments
8
![Page 9: THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN …minisites.ieep.eu/assets/2370/DBlandford_trade.pdfTHE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN REDUCING THE CARBON FOOTPRINT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE David](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042312/5eda88f6febf237c0c3b758f/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
• Lack of a global carbon price (“bottom-up” approach of
the Paris Agreement) poses great challenges, nationally
and internationally
• Border measures (tariffs, import restrictions, BTAs)
cannot be used to discriminate between “like products”
with differing carbon footprints and be WTO legal
• But products with differing carbon footprints are not
“like products” in terms of their implications for global
mitigation
• Without specific exemptions (e.g., GATT Article XX)
difficult to address “unlikeness” legally through border
measures
TRADE POLICY ISSUES IN
MITIGATION
9
![Page 10: THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN …minisites.ieep.eu/assets/2370/DBlandford_trade.pdfTHE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN REDUCING THE CARBON FOOTPRINT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE David](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042312/5eda88f6febf237c0c3b758f/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
• Carbon footprint labeling through an internationally
agreed approach (ISO?) to Life Cycle Analysis (LCA)
• Effectiveness depends on consumer response to low-
carbon options, but could intensify global effort if
choices are not based solely on price
• Regional trade agreements could play a supporting role
by fostering cooperation (e.g., labeling) and preferential
access for low-carbon products
• Special and differential treatment (SDT) could focus on
promotion of trade in low-carbon products by least-
developed countries
MITIGATION POLICIES – A way
forward?
10
![Page 11: THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN …minisites.ieep.eu/assets/2370/DBlandford_trade.pdfTHE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN REDUCING THE CARBON FOOTPRINT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE David](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042312/5eda88f6febf237c0c3b758f/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
• Government support is not always needed because of
private incentives for adoption of mitigation/adaptation
options
• Is government financial support amber box or green box
under WTO rules?
• Are current green box categories and restrictions in the
Agreement on Agriculture (AoA) appropriate (e.g. on
environmental programs)?
• Do SDT exemptions under Article 6.2 of the AoA need
to be “tightened up” to avoid mal-adaptation?
FINANCIAL SUPPORT FOR
ADAPTATION/MITIGATION –
SOME ISSUES
11
![Page 12: THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN …minisites.ieep.eu/assets/2370/DBlandford_trade.pdfTHE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN REDUCING THE CARBON FOOTPRINT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE David](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042312/5eda88f6febf237c0c3b758f/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
• Increased international price variability as a key policy issue
• Domestic and border measures can affect transmission of
domestic variability to international markets and absorption of
international variability in domestic markets
• International consistency of domestic measures (e.g.
stockholding)
• International disciplines on some border measures are
relatively weak (e.g. export restrictions and taxes)
• SDT role through expansion of food aid for least-developed
countries (LDCs)
ADAPTATION AND BORDER
MEASURES
12
![Page 13: THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN …minisites.ieep.eu/assets/2370/DBlandford_trade.pdfTHE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN REDUCING THE CARBON FOOTPRINT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE David](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042312/5eda88f6febf237c0c3b758f/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
• Climate policies that seem to make sense from a
national perspective may not make sense from an
international perspective when trade is in the picture
• Technical and legal issues make it complicated to
reconcile climate policy and trade policy – the potential
for conflict between them is high
• SDT needs to be used in a more targeted way if
developing countries are to contribute effectively to
global mitigation and adaptation in agriculture
• In general, global mitigation and adaptation can be
supported through trade, but national policies need to
be consistent with that role
FINAL TAKE-AWAY
13
![Page 14: THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN …minisites.ieep.eu/assets/2370/DBlandford_trade.pdfTHE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN REDUCING THE CARBON FOOTPRINT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE David](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042312/5eda88f6febf237c0c3b758f/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
THANK YOU
For further information please contact [email protected]
or visit www.researchgate.net for many of my publications on
climate change policies and trade policies
14
![Page 15: THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN …minisites.ieep.eu/assets/2370/DBlandford_trade.pdfTHE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN REDUCING THE CARBON FOOTPRINT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE David](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022042312/5eda88f6febf237c0c3b758f/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN REDUCING THE CARBON FOOTPRINT OF FOOD AND AGRICULTUREDavid Blandford
Professor Emeritus/Pennsylvania State University
Katowice Climate Change Conference (COP24)
7 December 2018
15