1

SST Webinar

SLDS Webinar 6-26-13

The presentation will begin at approximately 12:00 p.m. ET

Information on joining the teleconference can be found on the “Info” tab in the upper left of this screen. Be sure to use the “Attendee ID” number on the Info tab when dialing in to associate your name with your phone.

In order to cut down on background noise, please mute your phone by dialing *6 upon entry into the meeting.

During the question and answer portion of this presentation:• You can re-enter *6 to unmute your phone and ask a

question; or• Type your question into the Q&A panel below the participant

list and clicking “Send”.

A copy of this presentation and a link to the recording will be shared with the IES Grantees and EIMAC listservs.

IRB Webinar

2

SST Webinar

PanelistsKate Akers and Linda Borkosky (KY)Steve Snow and Mick Pytlik (ND)Andy Mehl (ID)Susan Murray (MT)

Agenda• Background of each state’s IRB process

• About the process• Process for review and approval of a data request• Use of an outside entity

• Best practices and lessons learned• Questions from participants

SLDS Webinar 6-26-13

IRB Process

SLDS Webinar 6-26-13 3

SST Webinar

Kentucky

SLDS Webinar 6-26-13 4

SST Webinar

Information Review Process• Requests are processed by priority

• End product may be de-identified data or an aggregate report

• Data owning agencies must provide approval via MOU for release of de-identified data and are given 5 days to review reports prior to publication

SLDS Webinar 6-26-13 5

SST Webinar

IRB Process• Initial IRB review was granted exemption

• Currently pursuing additional full IRB review with another institution per request from USDOE

• Some difficulty in filling out IRB form due to many responses as “N/A”

SLDS Webinar 6-26-13 6

SST Webinar

IRB Current Status• Currently finalizing IRB with Northern Kentucky

University

• Finalizing process for data/information requests from researchers (to include IRB approval from home institution)

• Reviewing security process and information request process with outside researchers

SLDS Webinar 6-26-13 7

SST Webinar

North Dakota

SLDS Webinar 6-26-13 8

SST Webinar

North Dakota has an SLDS committee appointed in legislation• Representation from several state agencies

The SLDS committee contacted several of the entities with existing IRB processes• Those entities felt conflict of interest because some of

the request will not originate with them• The IRB process should fall to the entity conducting the

research• The IRB should have some type of governance or control

over the entity conducting the research

SLDS Webinar 6-26-13 9

SST Webinar

Contacted Western IRB (WIRB)Broke it into two pieces• Establish an IRB protocol

A ‘checklist’ used to help determine if an IRB is necessary

• Perform the IRB if necessarySeparate engagement with WIRB to perform the IRB

If the requesting entity has established IRB, they will follow that

SST Webinar

SLDS Webinar 6-26-13 11

SST Webinar

Idaho

SLDS Webinar 6-26-13 12

SST Webinar

Environment• Idaho is pursuing a federated model for connecting our

K-12 SLDS, Postsecondary SLDS, and Labor LDS.• We started pursuing creating a new IRB, couldn’t find a

volunteer to chair it, decided we were better off leveraging an Idaho Institution.

• Designed our data exchange to limit exposure of PII including name, DOB, and SSN.

• Contacted several Idaho Postsecondary Institutions• Selected one to work with• Investigating requirements

SLDS Webinar 6-26-13 13

SST Webinar

Next Steps• Enter into an agreement with the institution• Prepare presentation• Resolve questions • Can we get an exemption?• Is this for the project or ongoing?• Can we do one time approval for where we

know we will be dealing with PII?• How does this apply?

SLDS Webinar 6-26-13 14

SST Webinar

Montana

SLDS Webinar 6-26-13 15

SST Webinar

• 2012 SLDS Grant project – K-20 Data Project• IES referred our project to USED Office of the Chief

Financial Officer for human subjects protections clearance

• Needed to go through the IRB process for our state’s own research• We are linking student transcript data for K-12 and

postsecondary sources using personally identifiable data• Had to be completed before any work with identifiable

data is initiated or data is exchanged with Montana University System (MUS)

SLDS Webinar 6-26-13 16

SST Webinar

• No MT OPI project has gone through IRB process before

• Finding IRB to review our project• Since the Montana University System partners

with us in K-20 Data Project, Montana State University IRB agreed to take on this review for free

SLDS Webinar 6-26-13 17

SST Webinar

Application Process• Applied for expedited IRB review in May 2013• Complicated by fact that Research Analyst hadn’t

started• Application reflects fact that most IRB research is

medical (drugs, coercion, etc.)• NIH/CITI Training for all “investigators”

• Ruled exempt in June 2013 – submitted to USED for ED IRB clearance

SLDS Webinar 6-26-13 18

SST Webinar

Questions

19

SST Webinar

Contact Info and Resources:Requests from State Support Team or SLDS Team:

Maddie Fromell, maddie.fromell@ed.govRobin Taylor, (302) 236-2651 Robin.Taylor@sst-slds.org

Panelists:Kate Akers, Linda BorkoskyKate.Akers@ky.gov, Linda.Borkosky@ky.gov

Steve Snow, Mick PytlikFsnow@nd.gov, mick.pytlik@ndus.edu

Andy MehlAndy.Mehl@osbe.idaho.gov

Susan Murraysmurray@mt.gov

SLDS Webinar 6-26-13

IRB Webinar