The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
Transcript of The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
-
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
1/20
_bg K`wtg hj Ibfkgyg
K`fhk`cfya@ Tgyg`tib `~gt
Y`a Thyy
@yf` fk Iha~`t`fzg ^gty~gifzgy
-
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
2/20
4
Fk 066?# Cfw Rf`hdh# ` Ibfkgyg ~hcffi`c ofyyfogk# ihaagkgo b` yfkig Mwkg ?# 0626#
Ibfk` b`y ywoogkcv dggk gklwcjgo fk ` |`zg hj k`fhk`cfya `ko ~`tfhfya# |bfib tg`ibgy gzgtv
ihtkgt hj bg c`ko `ko fkzhczgy gzgtv ~gtyhk+ "]b`h 4>>?# 00& _bg jfjggk vg`ty yfkig bhyg
|htoy |gtg y~hegk b`zg yggk ` ythklcv `yygtfzg Ibfk`5 ` yhag|b` jffkl a`ib h bg
ihwktvy lth|fkl ywiigyy+ Iwtfhwycv bhwlb# bg ~thahfhk ko gkihwt`lgagk hj bfy
k`fhk`cfya dv Ibfk`y twcfkl ~`tv# bg Ibfkgyg Ihaawkfy `tv "II^& b`y `egk hk `
yhag|b` ihkt`ofihtv hkg jtha ` bfyhtfi`c `ko gihkhafi ~gty~gifzg+ Jht gr`a~cg# fk bgft
gjjhty h y~tg`o `|`tgkgyy hj `ko ~tfog fk Ibfkgyg iwcwtg# bg II^ b`y dgihag `k
fa~ht`k `ccv hj Ihkjwif`kfya# ogy~fg b`zfkl zfcfjfgo bg `kifgk yibhc`t `ko bfy g`ibfkly jht
`cahy b`cj ` igkwtv yfkig Ibfk`y iwcwt`c tgzhcwfhk+ "Bh 4>>6& Hk ` dth`ogt yi`cg# bg
Ihaawkfy ~`tv `cyh yggay h ytwllcg |fb yhag fogkfv fyywgy+ Ibfk` b`y dgihag c`tlgcv
i`~f`cfy fk bg ~`y ogi`og# `ko b`y gzgk ahzgo h|`toy ` ahtg cfdgt`cf}go ~wdcfi ygiht+ Hkg
aflb gzgk pwgyfhk= \fb ihaawkfyy cfeg bgyg# |bh kggoy i`~f`cfyy8
Yh |b` fy bg k`wtg hj Ibfkgyg k`fhk`cfya# `ko bh| i`k bgyg ihkjcfifkl ihkig~y dg
ihkyhcfo`go wkogt hkg yg hj fog`y8 Ygzgt`c `tlwagky h bfy a`gt grfy# `cbhwlb ahy
tgc`g h ywdmgifzg fkgt~tg`fhky hj bg tgywcy hj Ibfk`y ~hcfifgy+ Jtha hkg ~gty~gifzg#
Ibfkgyg k`fhk`cfya lth|y jtha ygkyg hj lltgyyfzg ~tfahtof`cfya# ifzfcf}`fhk`c
ihbgyfzgkgyy dwfc hk ` yb`tgo yg hj gbkfifv `ko(ht z`cwgy# fk bfy i`yg bhyg b` `tg bhwlb
h dg wkfpwgcv Ibfkgyg+ Hbgty `tlwg `cahy bg h~~hyfg# b` Ibfk`# ogy~fg fy ihkyhcfo`fhk
wkogt ` yfklcg d`kkgt# fy zgtv awib ` ihccgifhk hj yg~`t`g k`fhk y`gy# dthwlb hlgbgt
`tfjfif`ccv dv bg II^ wkogt ` hkg!Ibfk` d`kkgt+ "Lw`kl 4>>7&
-
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
3/20
9
_h ihag h ` ihkicwyfhk# hkg awy `eg ` bfyhtfi`c `iihwkfkl hj dhb ~tfahtof`c `ko
fkytwagk`cfy k`fhk`cfya# `ko bh| bgft wyg fk bfyhtv b`y yb`~go Ibfk` fkh bg k`fhk f fy
ho`v+ Ibfkgyg k`fhk`cfya tgjcgiy dhb bg iwcwt`c `y~giy hj fy ogzgch~agk# jtha
Ihkjwif`kfya h A`hfy bhwlb h |fogy~tg`o "`ko hii`yfhk`ccv jhtigo& iwcwt`c yyfafc`fhk
wkogt bg B`k Ibfkgyg+ Vg# bfy fy kh bg h`cfv hj `cc b` b`y b`o fa~`i hk ahcofkl bg
yvyga hj yw~~ht jht bg k`fhk# y Ibfk`y bfyhtfi`c ytwllcgy jht yhzgtgflkv ko y`wy
`ahkl hbgt k`fhky awy `cyh dg tgihlkf}go jht bgft thcg fk |b` ogjfkgy |b` a`egy
yhaghkg Ibfkgyg+ _bwy# cbhwlb bg k`wtg hj Ibfk`y k`fhk`cfya b`y jcwiw`go dg|ggk
ogjfkfkl bg k`fhk fk ~tfahtof`c ht fkytwagk`c ahogy# bg ihwktv ho`v# fy ` ~tfag gr`a~cg
hj ` ihwktv |bhyg k`fhk`cfya fy thhgo fk Ihkytwigo tfahtof`cfya yvyga b`
`iihaaho`gy jht dhb ~tfahtof`c ko fkytwagk`cfy z`cwgy+
F+ ^tfahtof`cfya zy+ Fkytwagk`cfya zy+ Ihkytwigo ^tfahtof`cfya
Dgjhtg |g i`k ogczg fkh `k`cvyfy hj |b` iha~gcy Ibfk` h ofy~c`v jg`wtgy hj `
ihkytwigo ~tfahtof`cfya# ygzgt`c ihkig~y awy dg ogjfkgo ahtg jwccv+ _bg jfty fy bg k`wtg
hj k`fhky `ko k`fhk`cfya `ko bg ygihko fy ` icg`tgt gr~c`k`fhk hj ~tfahtof`cfya#
fkytwagk`cfya# ko ihkytwigo ~tfahtof`cfya5 bg yvygay fk |bfib k`fhk ko k`fhk`cfya
i`k dg ~thowigo ko a`fk`fkgo+
_bg gta K`fhk b`y ygzgt`c ogjfkffhky dw hkg hj bg ahtg `iig~go bghtfgy fy b`
hj Dgkgofi @kogtyhk fk bfy 0629 dhhe# Fa`lfkgo Ihaawkffgy+ Fk @kogtyhky zfg|# ` k`fhk fy
mwy b`5 `k fa`lfkgo ~hcffi`c ihaawkfv `ko fa`lfkgo `y dhb fkbgtgkcv cfafgo `ko
yhzgtgflk+ "_hkkgyhk 066:#
-
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
4/20
?
ihkkgigo fk yhag ihccgifzg j`ybfhk+ ^tfht h k`fhky# @kogtyhk `tlwgy# bgtg |gtg |h a`fk
yvygay jht jhtafkl ihaawkffgy# tgcflfhwy `ko ovk`yfi# |bfib cfkego agadgty hj yhifgfgy
bthwlb bgft ygcj!fogkfjfgo tfdwgy+ Jht k`fhk`cfya# _hkkgyhk ko @kchz yb`tg k
`ltgg`dcg ogjfkffhk5 `k foghchlfi`c ahzgagk jht `fkfkl ht a`fk`fkfkl k`fhk!y`g+
"_hkkgyhk 066:# 4&
F fy ` bfy ~hfk b` |g i`k dglfk h ogjfkg bg gcgagky b` i`k ihkytwi `ko
~gt~gw`g k`fhk`cfya+ Ihkytwigo ~tfahtof`cfya ihk`fky gcgagky hj dhb ~tfahtof`cfya
`ko fkytwagk`cfya5 bwy f fy hkcv tg`yhk`dcg b` bgft k`wtgy dg chhego ` jfty+
^tfahtof`cfya fy ` bghtv hj k`fhk!dwfcofkl b` jhiwygy ~tfa`tfcv hk bg ihkkgifhky
dthwlb dhw dv bg tfdwgy hj gbkfifv ko(ht iwcwtg+ Lggt} ~hywc`gy b`
~tfahtof`cfya tg~tgygky ihkkgifhky ogzgch~go dv bg lfzgky hj `kv ~`tfiwc`t yhifgv=
bg `yywago lfzgky !! hj yhif`c grfygkig= faagof`g ihkflwfv `ko efk ihkkgifhk a`fkcv# dw dgvhko
bga bg lfzgkgyy b` ygay jtha dgfkl dhtk fkh ` ~`tfiwc`t tgcflfhwy ihaawkfv# y~g`efkl ` ~`tfiwc`t
c`klw`lg# `ko jhcch|fkl ~`tfiwc`t yhif`c ~t`ifigy+ _bgyg ihkltwffgy hj dchho# y~ggib# iwyha `ko yh hk#
`tg yggk h b`zg `k fkgjj`dcg# `ko ` fagy hzgt~h|gtfkl# ihgtifzgkgyy fk `ko hj fygcj+ "Lggt} 06&
_bgyg lfzgky i`k fkicwog `kv iwcwt`c ihaahk`cfv# dg f c`klw`lg# t`ig# ht ` ~gtigfzgo
ihaahk ~hfk hj ogyigk fk t`offhk ht gr~gtfgkig+ Ib`kot` gr~`koy hk ~hyyfdcg ihkkgifhky
fk bgt yg`tib jht ` ogjfkffhk hj gbkfifv+ Gbfi fogkffgy# ybg ywllgyy# i`k dg yg~`t`go fkh
|h i`glhtfgy5 khafk`c# fk |bfib `k fkofzfow`c fy gcflfdcg jht agadgtybf~ d`ygo hk `tfdwgy
bg ht ybg ~hyygyygy# `ko `ifz`go# lthw~y fk |bfib ybg ht bg ~thjgyygy agadgtybf~ ht h
|bfib ybg ht bg fy `yyflkgo dv hbgty `y ` agadgt+ "Ib`kot` 4>>6# 92:& _bg jhtagt fy tgc`go
h tfdwgy ko k fogkfv b` i`kkh dg ib`klgo "ywib y ~bvyfi`c(t`if`c ib`t`igtfyfiy
|bfcg bg c`gt i`k dg `omwygo "f+g+ k`fhk`c# lghlt`~bfi`c ht ~hcffi`c `jjfcf`fhk&+ Hdzfhwycv#
bfy i`k b`zg ~thjhwko fa~cfi`fhky hk bg fog` hj ` ihaahk ~tfahtof`c ihkkgifhk+ Fk gfbgt
-
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
5/20
7
tgy~gi bhwlb# k`fhk`cfya i`k dg ~thowi hj ~tfahtof`cfya `y ` tgywc hj ` ihaawkfv tvfkl
h dwfco fygcj w~ `ko y`ko hw ht ~thgi fy h|k fog`cy `ko iwcwt`c z`cwgy jtha hbgt
ihaawkffgy+
Hk bg hbgt gko hj bg y~gitwa fy fkytwagk`cfya# ` yvyga b`# fj f b`y `kv wyg jht
gbkfifv# gr~chfy f+ Fkytwagk`cfya fy ahtg d`ygo hk ytwiwt`cfya `ko tg`cfya+ Wkogt `k
fkytwagk`cfy yvyga# yhif`c lthw~y `tg gr~chfgo dv fkjcwgkf`c `ihty h iha~gg jht ~h|gt
`ko tgyhwtigy+ _bfy ihwco fkicwog t`ccvfkl `k gbkfi d`ko wkogt ` ihaahk d`kkgt h lg bga
h gcgi vhw h ` ~hcffi`c ~hyffhk# ht ot`|fkl `gkfhk h `k fyywg b` |fcc ahzg bg ~wdcfi fk `
oftgifhk vhw |`k bga h lh+ Ithwibgt ~gtb`~y yway f w~ dgy# ~hywc`fkl b` wkogt bg
fkytwagk`cfy bghtv# gbkfifv fy kh dhw y~ftfw`c `jjfkfv dw# t`bgt# ygay jtha
wfcf`tf`k i`ciwc`fhky `ko# `y a`kv `k`cvyy `tlwg# ygcj!ygtzfkl a`kf~wc`fhk dv ~hcffi`c gcfgy+
"Ithwibgt 4>>?# 047&
Fk i`yg f |`yk ctg`ov a`og hdzfhwy bthwlb bg ofyfkifhk hjgcfgy#
fkytwagk`cfya `cyh gzhegy gcgagky hj A`trfya# fk b` f yggy ic`yy `ko gihkhafi j`ihty `y
ythkl ahdfcf}`fhk hhcy+ _bthwlb gy`dcfybfkl ofzfogy fkgtk`ccv h bg k`fhk ht dg|ggk bg
k`fhk `ko fy kgflbdhty# hkg d`yg i`k dg fkifgo h tfyg w~ `l`fky bg hbgt# gy~gif`ccv fj
bgtgy ` c`tlg gihkhafi ofy~`tfv dg|ggk bg |h# jgtagkfkl tgygkagk+ Cfeg ~tfahtof`cfya#
fkytwagk`cfya i`k ~thowig k`fhk`cfya bthwlb fky~ftfkl khfhk hj wy!`l`fky!bga#
`cbhwlb f ohgy yh fk ` |`v b` ~`tfiwc`tcv ogyflkgo h ~thahg igt`fk ~`tvy fkgtgy
t`bgt b`k bg fkgtgy hj ` |bhcg ihaawkfv+
Fk tgjcgifhk hj bgyg ogjfkffhky# bfy ~`~gt `tlwgy b` Ibfkgyg k`fhk`cfya twky hk bg
~tfkif~cg hj Ihktwigo tfahtof`cfya# |bfib fy yhag|b` ihadfk`fhk hj dhb
-
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
6/20
:
~tfahtof`cfya ko fkytwagk`cfya+ Fk bfy yvyga# gbkfifv a`v dg ihkytwigo fogkfv# dw
fy ihkytwifhk tgcfgy hk ~~g`cy h ~tfahtof`c ygkfagky hj dgchklfkl+ "Ithwibgt 4>>?# 046&
Jht gr`a~cg# ` k`fhk`c fogkfv a`v dg ihkytwigo |fbfk ` yvyga "`ko a`v bgk dg wygo jht
~hcffi`c ag`ky dw tgpwftgy ` ihkyifhwy `iig~`kig `ko tgihlkffhk dv bg ~wdcfi d`ygo hk
bfyhtfi`c ihkgr+ F fy ihkytwigo |fb tgjgtgkig h efkybf~# dchho fgy# yb`tgo htflfky# `ko
ihaahk `kigytv+ "Ithwibgt 4>>?# 046&
Ihkytwigo ~tfahtof`cfya `cch|y jht `cc hj bg ihadfkgo dgkgjfy hj ~tfahtof`cfya `ko
fkytwagk`cfya# cch|fkl jht g`ib bghtvy fkofzfow`c jc`|y h dg iihaaho`go jht dv
hzgtc`~~fkl bga+ Jht gr`a~cg# fk iha~`tfyhk h ~tfahtof`cfya# ihkytwigo ~tfahtof`cfya i`k
gr~c`fk yb`tgo k`fhk`cfya b` dchhay fk ` k`fhk |fb awcf~cg ofy~`t`g ~tfahtof`c fgy+
Cfeg|fyg# f i`k `cyh `cch| jht k`fhk`cfya b` grfyy yhcgcv dgi`wyg hj ` ~tfahtof`c ihaawkfv#
|bgtg fkytwagk`cfya ohgy kh+ F i`kkh jwkifhk `y ` i`ib!`cc bghtv jht gzgtv k`fhk# dw
`y gr~c`fkgo dgch| yggay h gr~c`fk k`fhk`cfya fk Ibfk` ~tgv jwkifhk`ccv+
FF+ Ihkjwif`kfya ko Ibfkgyg!kgyy
_h gr~chtg bg k`wtg hj ihkga~ht`tv Ibfkgyg k`fhk`cfya# hkg jfkoy yhag hj bg thhy
fk `kifgk Ibfkgyg iwcwt`cfya+ Ogy~fg `k hdzfhwy gy`dcfybagk hj ` y`g wkogt Fa~gtf`c
lhzgtk`kig# `kifgk Ibfk` |`y ogifogocv kh |b` ihwco dg ogjfkgo `y ` k`fhk+ _h ic`tfjv# bg
dhtogty yg~`t`fkl f jtha kgflbdhtfkl y`gy |gtg jcwfo `ko gkwhwy# `ko bgtg |`y kh hkg
icg`tcv gy`dcfybgo ihaawkfv wkfgo wkogt bg ga~ftg+ _bg ihkkgifhky b` a`og hkg
Ibfkgyg |gtg iwcwt`c# ` yg hj wkfzgty`c ~tfkif~cgy b` grgkogo `dhzg ht hwyfog |b`gzgt
hbgt ihaahk gbkfi fgy b` ogjfkgo `k fkofzfow`c ht ihaawkfv+ "]b`h 4>>?&
-
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
7/20
> DI+ _bgyg lgkgt`c ~tfkif~cgy tgjcgigo bg fog` b` gzgtv cfzfkl dgfkl bgco ` y~gifjfi ~c`ig
fk ` wkfzgty`c htogt# `ko b` bfy k`wt`c htogt |`y tgjcgigo fk bwa`k yhif`c tgc`fhky |fb hkg
`khbgt `ko bgft ~hyffhky fk ` z`tfgv hj tgc`fhkybf~y bgv a`fk`fkgo h|`toy bg j`afcv#
ihaawkfv# `ko lhzgtkfkl dhov+ @y ]b`h gr~c`fky# dgfkl Ibfkgyg og~gkogo hk bh| |gcc hkg
`oh~go bgyg wkfzgty`c ~tfkif~cgy hj yhifgv# kh hk hkgy ~bvyfi`c t`ig ht gbkfi
d`ielthwko=
\bgk d`td`tf`k ihkpwgthty ywib `y bg Ahklhcy `ko bg A`kibwy `oh~go Ihkjwif`k iwcwtg# bg
Ibfkgyg ~gh~cg ihwco `iig~ bga dgi`wyg bgft ~tfa`tv chv`cv |`y hh bg iwcwtg t`bgt b`k h `
~`tfiwc`t k`fhk+ _bgv dgcfgzgo b` `cc ihkpwgthty hj Ibfk`# gzgkw`ccv b`o h wtk h Ibfkgyg iwcwtg h
twcg bg ihwktv+ _bwy# iwcwtg |`y yggk `y ` ltg`# c`yfkl ~h|gt b` ihwco dtfolg ~gtfhoy hj ofywkfv `ko
fkjwyg kg| lhzgtkagky# |bgbgt Ibfkgyg ht `cfgk# |fb z`cwgy yw~~htfzg hj t`offhk`c Ibfkgyg
ifzfcf}`fhk+ "]b`h 4>>?# ?4&
F ybhwco dg khgo b` bfy fy ahtg `k `fwog hj wkfzgty`cfya t`bgt b`k k`fhk`cfya# |bfib
ofjjgty jtha bg c`gt fk b` wkfzgty`cfya ~thahgy ` ihaahk fogkfv jht `cc ~gh~cgy t`bgt
b`k mwy bhyg hj ` ~`tfiwc`t k`fhk+ K`fhk`cfya ~thahgy ` ygkyg hj wkfpwgkgyy# |bfcg
wkfzgty`cfya fk `cc fy fkicwyfzgkgyy ohgy kh+
_b`y kh h fkyfkw`g b` fk ~t`ifig Ihkjwif`kfya `c|`vy `wha`fi`ccv cg`o h `cc
Ibfkgyg dgfkl gpw`c+ _bg B`k Ibfkgyg ~h~wc`fhk b` b`o grfygo dgjhtg bg Ahklhc
fkz`yfhk hiiwttgo fk bg c`g 04>>y chkl ihkyfogtgo bgaygczgy h dg bg twg Ibfkgyg+ _bgyg
`fwogy# `chkl |fb wkgpw`c tg`agk wkogt bg Ahklhc bh`to cg`o h bg gr~wcyfhk hj bg
Ahklhcy fk 09:2 h tggy`dcfyb B`k twcg wkogt bg Afkl ovk`yv+ _bg B`k |gtg `cyh
yflkfjfi`kcv yw~~tgyygo wkogt A`kibw twcg+ Hkg hj bg ahtg `~~`tgk yflk hj bfy |`y bg
jhtigo oh~fhk hj bg A`kibwtf`k b`ft pwgwg# jhtdfoofkl iff}gky hj Ibfk` l`fky iwfkl bgft
-
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
8/20
2
b`ft+ _bg tglwc`fhk a`v ygga hoo fk tgthy~gi# dw yfcc tgpwftgo B`k Ibfkgyg h ywdaf
foghchlfi`c ihkthc h bgft A`kibw ihkpwgthty+ Ywib ` oga`ko |`y# fk j`i# `k `jjthk h
Ihkjwif`kfya+ _bg Ic`yyfi hj Jfcf`c ^fgtv# fk cfkg |fb Ihkjwif`k z`cwgy `dhw ogdy h|go h hkgy gcogty#
ywllgyy b` ` ~gtyhky dhov `ko b`ft# dgfkl lfjy jtha hkgy ~`tgky# `tg kh h dg o`a`lgo+
"\`ega`k 0627# :?2& \bfcg yhag Ihkjwif`k z`cwgy h fky~ftg ` c`tlgt ihaawkfv a`v b`zg dggk
yb`tgo "jht gr`a~cg# fy wyg `y `k gbfi`c jhtig h fky~ftg chv`cv h bg fa~gtf`c bthkg
yw~~tgyyfhk cfeg bfy gy`dcfybgo h bg B`k "|bh tga`fkgo bg a`mhtfv |fbfk bg ihwktv& `
ofyfkifhk dg|ggk bgft h|k iwcwtg `ko b` hj bgft h~~tgyyhty+ _bfy |hwco# fk wtk# `jjgi
jwwtg jhtay hj Ibfkgyg k`fhk`cfya+
FFF+ Tgdgccfhk ko bg yfttfkly hj K`fhk`cfya
_bgtg fy zgtv cfcg dgcfgj `ahkl yibhc`ty b` bg ihkig~ hj ` Ibfkgyg k`fhk h |bfib
`cc Ibfkgyg |gtg ~`tfhfi h# grfygo dgjhtg bg 06b
igkwtv+ Mhbk Jf}lgt`co a`egy bg ic`fa
b` bg Ibfkgyg iwyha hj tgjgttfkl h bgft bfyhtfi`c ihaawkfv dv ovk`yv "Ib`ho`f& t`bgt
b`k dv ihwktv "lwhmf`& fa~cfgo b` bgtg |`y fk j`i# kh Ibfkgyg k`fhk ` `cc "]b`h 4>>?# ?7&
@y tgywc# Ibfk`y ihkjthk`fhk |fb bg |gygtk ~h|gty ko M`~`k fk bg kfkgggkb
igkwtv a`og f kgigyy`tv h tgcfkpwfyb ~h|gt h bg wkfzgty`cfyfi ~tggkfhky hj bg ga~ftg#
`ko h ygge gkt`kig fkh bg j`afcv hj k`fhky`y hkg yhzgtgflk y`g ahkl hbgty+
"_hkkgyhk 066:# 4y+
Ibfk`y ogjg`y kh hkcv cg`o h fy bwafcf`fhk# dw h ` jg`t b` Ibfkgyg iwcwtg aflb j`cc
zfifa h |gygtk fa~gtf`cfya=
Ibfk` |`y ihky`kcv fk mgh~`tov hj dgfkl i`tzgo w~ dv bg |gygtk ~h|gty `ko M`~`k+ Jhtgflk
fa~gtf`cfyy gkmhvgo bg ~thgifhk hj grt`gttfhtf`cfv fk bgft gkic`zgy hk Ibfkgyg yhfc `ko jtgpwgkcv
-
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
9/20
6
gad`tego hk `tago fkz`yfhky h ~wkfyb bg Ibfkgyg jht z`tfhwy `iy hj ofyhdgofgkig+ Ibfkgyg ~hcffi`c
gcfgy |gtg ahy `c`tago `dhw |b` bgv i`ccgo wkgpw`c tg`fgy# Ubg K`kmfkl `ko _f`kmfk tg`fgyQ
|bfib b`o dggk jhtigo hk Ibfk` dv bg jhtgflk fa~gtf`cfyy+ "]b`h 4>>?# ?2&
_bwy f |`y cfcg ywt~tfyg b` bgyg `fwogy a`og gttfhtf`c yhzgtgflkv `k fa~ht`k `y~gi
fk gy`dcfybfkl Ibfk` y ` k`fhk!y`g+ Awib ga~b`yfy |`y ~w hk bg ihkkgifhk dg|ggk
yflkfjfi`k bfyhtfi`c gzgky `ko c`koy ihkyfogtgo h dg Ibfkgyg gttfhtv# `ko bfy b`y tga`fkgo
` ythkl `y~gi fk ogjfkfkl bg Ibfkgyg k`fhk yfkig+ _bg j`fcwtg hj bg Dhrgt Tgdgccfhk `cyh
gkihwt`lgo og~`twtg jtha Ibfkgyg t`offhk`cfya fk k `ga~ h dgihag ahogtk
k`fhk5 cbhwlb# |b` b` ahogtk k`fhk ihkyfygo hj dgi`ag `khbgt ihkzgty`fhk gkftgcv+
"]b`h 4>>?& Kwagthwy yibhc`ty ihkicwogo b` Ibfkgyg iwcwtg# fkicwofkl Ihkjwif`kfya ko fy
bfgt`tibfi`c yvyga# b`o cfcg tgjgtgkig h bg wk~tgigogkgo ihkoffhky hj bg |gygtk!
ohafk`go |htco+ "]b`h 4>>?# 7
-
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
10/20
0>
i`ccgo jht ` lhzgtkagk hj bg ~gh~cg# dv bg ~gh~cg# `ko jht bg ~gh~cg+ "]bgkl 0666& _bgyg
~tfkif~cgy i`ccgo bg itg`fhk hj ` tg~tgygk`fzg tg~wdcfi b` gkiha~`yygo `cc bg ~gh~cg hj
Ibfk`# `ko f |`yk wkfc `jgt bg ywiigyyjwc og~hyfkl hj bg Pfkl ovk`yv b` a`kv hj bg
B`k tgzhcwfhk`tfgy ihwco ihkigfzg hj A`kibw b`zfkl ` ~c`ig fk b` yvyga+ T`bgt# f |`y bg
lgkgt`c lh`c hj a`kv tgzhcwfhk`tfgy b` Ibfk` ybhwco `eg hk bg fogkfv hj ` wkf`tv k`fhk!
y`g|bgtg kg`tcv `cc bg tgyfogky |gtg B`k+ "]b`h 4>>?# ::&
Vg ogy~fg bfy# Ywk# w~hk bg ywiigyy hj bg tgzhcwfhk fk 0600# i`ccgo jht bg wkfv `ko
ihh~gt`fhk hj bg jfzg ahy a`mht ywdlthw~y hj Ibfkgyg "B`ky# A`kibwy# Ahklhcy# Bwf# ko
_fdg`k& h jhta bg k`fhk hj Ibfk`+ _bfy b`o cfcg h oh |fb `k `ctwfyfi hj gpw`c
tg~tgygk`fhk+ Ywk ko hbgt tgzhcwfhkfyy |gtg krfhwy h b`kl hkh bg c`ko b` bg
A`kibw b`o ihkthc hzgt owtfkl bg Pfkl ovk`yv# yhagbfkl |bfib |`y mgh~`tof}go `y
Ahklhcy `ko _fdg`ky dgl`k ic`ahtfkl jht bgft h|k fkog~gkogkig+ _bwy Ywk |`y ogkvfkl `kv
fkofzfow`c k`fhk`c fogkfv hj bgyg lthw~y5 `cc fk Ibfk` |gtg Ibfkgyg# `ko f |`y bgft ogyfkv
h ihkjhta h bg ahtg ~wtg B`k a`mhtfv `ko dwfco ` ltg` k`fhk+ \b` Ywk `ko bfy kg|cv
jhtago Ewhafkt`kl "K`fhk`cfy& ~`tv hj Ibfk` |gtg gyygkf`ccv ohfkl |`y yhagbfkl b`
Dgkgofi @kogtyhk aflb b`zg ogyitfdgo `y y~tg`ofkl bg ybht flb yefk hj bg k`fhk hzgt
bg lfl`kfi dhov hj bg ga~ftg# `ko bg cglffaf}`fhk hj bg B`k fk ib`tlg+ "Lc`okgv 066?#66&
_bfy gbkfi yyfafc`fhk ~hcfiv |`y ~gtjgi a`kfjgy`fhk hj ihkytwigo ~tfahtof`cfya#
`ko hkg b` ywtzfzgy fk ~tgygk o`v II^ ~t`ifigy+ _bgyg jfzg lthw~y `ko bg bwkotgoy hj
ya`ccgt lthw~y b` a`og w~ Ibfk` |gtg cc Ibfkgyg+ @oafgocv# f |`y yhag|b`
fkytwagk`cfy fk b` bg B`k |gtg `wha`fi`ccv hk h~# dw fk ~tfkif~cg f ywllgyy bg k`fhk
-
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
11/20
00
ihwco kh grfy |fbhw bg ~tgygkig hj bhyg hbgt gbkfiffgy+ F |`y kh ihaawkfv d`ygo
~tfahtof`c fgy b` dthwlb gzgtvhkg hlgbgt# dw bgft fkbgtgk Ibfkgyg!kgyy+
Fk bg gko# bg k`fhk`cfyy |gtg wk`dcg h ~thahg bgft k`fhk!y`g fog`y gjjgifzgcv
`ahkl bg ~h~wc`fhk# chyfkl hw h bg tgigkcv jhtago Ibfkgyg Ihaawkfy ^`tv+ \bgtg bg
Ewhafkt`kl i`ccgo jht bg gy`dcfybagk hj bg B`k k`fhk# bg II^ ~thahgo bg fog` hj
~h~wc`t yhzgtgflkv `ahkl bg ahtg twt`c ~h~wc`fhk# ahdfcf}fkl iff}gky fk ` ic`yy!d`ygo
tgzhcwfhk `l`fky bg k`fhk`cfy tglfag+ @y ` tgy~hkyg# bg Ewhafkt`kl# bgk cg`o dv Ibf`kl
E`f!Ybge# iiwygo bg ihaawkfyy hj dgfkl `kf!~`tfhfi ko kf!k`fhk`cfy+ F fy hkcv hh
icg`t kh|# Ibf`kl |`y pwhgo hkig `y y`vfkl# b` ihaawkfyy i`k kgzgt b`zg `kv twg ygkyg
hj chv`cv h bgft ihwktv5 bgv tg ogzhfo hj ~`tfhfya ko k`fhk`c ihkyifhwykgyy+
"_hkkgyhk 066:# 424&
Fy fkgtgyfkl b` |`y bg fyywg bg Ewhafk`kl dthwlb h bg ~wdcfi ogd`g `y bg
`tlwagk `l`fky ihaawkfya# `y bg II^ fog`cy ywllgygo "` cg`y fk bghtv& ` k`fhk`c
fogkfv b` grgkogo dgvhko ic`yy ht gbkfi fgy+ "_hkkgyhk 066:& _bwy# bg btg` ~tgygkgo
dv bg ihaawkfy ~`tv |`y kh hkg hj foghchlfi`c lh`cy b` bgv |hwco wyg h tg~tgygk# dw
h bg ~h|gt bgco dv bg Ewhafkt`kl+ _bgtg |`y `cyh ` k`fhk`cfy pwgyfhk hj |b` bg II^
tg~tgygkgo# `y bg Yhzfg!iha~hygo Ihaawkfy Fkgtk`fhk`c lthw~ b`o b`o bg`zv
fkjcwgkig fk bg itg`fhk `ko yw~~ht hj bg II^+ J`igo |fb bfy grfygkf`c `ko `aht~bhwy
btg`# `y |gcc `y bg og`b hj bgft cg`ogt Ywk V`!ygk fk 064:# bg Ewhafkt`kl t`ofi`ccv
ib`klgo `ifiy# fkyfwfkl zfhcgk icg`kyfkly hj bg ~`tv |fb Ibf`kl c`wkibfkl ywoogk
``iey hk II^ bg`opw`tgty+ _bfy dchho d`b jhtigo bg II^ h d`ie |`v wkfc bgv ihwco
jflwtg hw bh| h dggt tgihkifcg fog`y hj ihaawkfya `ko Ibfkgyg k`fhk`cfya+ "]b`h 4>>?&
-
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
12/20
04
FZ+ Hkg k`fhk# wkogt A`h
_bg Ewhafkt`kl a`fk`fkgo fy bhco hk ~h|gt `ko yw~~tgyyfhk hj bg II^ wkfc jhtigo
h jflb `l`fky bg M`~`kgyg fk \htco \`t FF+ _bfy `cch|go bg II^ h tgdwfco fygcj# `ko
gzgkw`ccv |tgycg ihkthc `|`v jtha bg Ewhafkt`kl# `cch|fkl bga h `cyh tg!fogkfjv Ibfk`
wkogt bg lwfofkl b`ko hj A`h ]gohkl+
F |`y wkogt A`h b` Ibfkgyg k`fhk`cfya ib`klgo t`ofi`ccv h yhagbfkl gkftgcv
ofjjgtgk5 f y`tgo `oh~fkl yhag gcgagky hj fkytwagk`cfya+ Ot`|fkl hk bg gihkhafi
cgzgcy hj bg a`yygy# A`h ~th~hygo b` Ibfk` |`y ofy`oz`k`lgo dgi`wyg f |`y ywdmgi h bg
|bfay hj hbgt hwyfog k`fhky |bfib fa~hygo `y dhwtlghfy hzgt Ibfk`# fk bg thcg hj bg
~thcg`tf`+ @cc bhyg fk cg`lwg |fb fa~gtf`cfya`tg hwt gkgafgy A`h y`go# jwtbgt
ywllgyfkl b` bg Ibfkgyg k`fhk ihwco hkcv dg ogjfkgo fk fy tg`ifhky h|`to bg ihttw~
h~~tgyyfhk bg y`| dv fa~gtf`cfy y`gy h|`to Ibfk`+ "]b`h 4>>?# 6
-
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
13/20
09
`y ihwkgt!tgzhcwfhk`tfgy+ Owtfkl bg Iwcwt`c Tgzhcwfhk# A`h# |bh bfaygcj tgzgtgo h `dyhcwfya#
i`ccgo hk bg Tgo Lw`toy h ya`yb `cc bfyhtfi tgcfiy `ko gt`ofi`g hco bfkefkl# b`dfy `ko iwyhay+
"Dg}chz` 0666&
Hzgt`cc bhwlb# A`hy lhzgtkagk |`y ltg`cv ogjfkgo dv tvfkl h gy`dcfyb Ibfk` bthwlb
fa`lfkgo ~tfahtof`c ihkjcfi5 hkg Ibfk` `l`fky bg |htco+ _bfy ihkfkwgo gzgk hkig bg b`o
tgogjfkgo Ibfk` `y ` ~gh~cgy tg~wdcfi# lhfkl yh j`t `y h `tlwg b` bg Iwcwt`c Tgzhcwfhk
|`y owg h bg \gyy ~hcfiv hj ihk`fkfkl Ibfk`# `y ` |`v h ~thahg |b` bg i`ccgo
ohagyfi ogzgch~agk |fbfk bg ihwktv+ "]bgkl 0666# 0>?& F |`y fk bfy a`kkgt b` Ibfk`
jfty dgl`k fa~cgagkfkl ~tfkif~cgy hj ihkytwigo ~tfahtof`cfya h ogjfkg fy k`fhk`cfya+
Z+ _t`offhk`c Ibfkgyg Z`cwgy "Y~hkyhtgo dv bg Ibfkgyg Ihaawkfy ~`tv&
^hy!A`h# bg II^ b`y lhkg bthwlb yhag t`ofi`c ib`klgy fk bg |`v f fky~ftgo
k`fhk`cfy jgtzht+ Jht y`tgty A`hy ywiigyyht# Ogkl Rf`h~fkl |gk hw hj bfy |`v hk ygzgt`c
hii`yfhky h ogjfkg ~`tfhfya fk `k fkytwagk`c yw~~htfkl ` y`dcg y`g+ Cgj fk ` ib`hfi
y`g `jgt bg Iwcwt`c Tgzhcwfhk# Ogkl ihkgkogo b` f |`y bg bflbgy bhkht h chzg bgft
yhif`cfy ahbgtc`ko ko ihktfdwg cc |g b`zg h bgt yhif`cfy ihkytwifhk+ "]bgkl 0666#
69& Gyygkf`ccv Ogkl |`y ywllgyfkl b` yw~~htfkl bg fkyfwfhky hj yhif`cfya "`ko dv ~thrv#
bg II^& |gtg bg hkcv |`v jht Ibfk` h tgwtk h fy htflfk`c lchtv# `ko h lw`t`kgg y`dfcfv#
`cyh bgolfkl hjj ` btg` jtha ogahit`iv+
@ cg`y faagof`gcv jhcch|fkl bg Iwcwt`c Tgzhcwfhk# bg II^ `cyh tgc`rgo yhag hj fy
y`ko`toy jht gbkfi k`fhk`cfya# ~wtywfkl jwcc!jcgolgo fkowigagk ~hcfiv b` gkihwt`lgo
ogzgch~agk hj khk!B`k afkhtfv lthw~y fk bg 062>y+ _bfy |`y cgyy hw hj tgy~gi jht
~tfahtof`c fgy `ko ahtg `khbgt `ga~ h dtfkl fk gbkfi afkhtfv lthw~y wkogt bg hkg
wkfgo Ibfk` fog`+ Ogy~fg bflb bh~gy# bfy b`y dggk cgyy ywiigyyjwc b`k bg Ibfkgyg
lhzgtkagk |hwco b`zg bh~go# yfkig wkfpwg gbkfi k`fhk`cfya ahkl _fdg`k ko Wflbwt
-
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
14/20
0?
ihaawkfv b`y hkcv btfzgo y agadgty |bh hhe oz`k`lg fk bg tgjhta vg`ty gkl`lg fk
` ytwllcg h egg~ bgft iwcwtg `ko k`fhk`c fogkfv `jch`+ "]b`h 4>>?# 062& Ogy~fg bg
hjgk zfhcgk Ibfkgyg tg`ifhk h bg yg~`t`fya bfy aflb tg~tgygk# f b`y cg`o h yhag gbkfi
lthw~y h fkjcwgkig |b` f ag`ky h dg Ibfkgyg# ~`tfiwc`tcv fk tg`ifhk h bg chkl ~tg!
gy`dcfybgo yvygay hj B`k k`fhk`cfya+
Ibfk`y k`fhk`cfya# h yhag grgk# b`y `c|`vy dggk fkjcwgkigo dv ` kggo jht ` ygkyg
hj yhzgtgflkv+ Hzgt bg vg`ty# bg Ibfkgyg cg`ogty b`zg ihag h gadt`ig `k `dyhcwfy khfhk
hj yhzgtgflkv# |fb |`gtflb dhwko`tfgy `ko fkgtk`c ihkthc j`t ahtg iha~cgg b`k
`kvbfkl b` b`o gzgt grfygo dgjhtg ht `~~g`t cfegcv h dg ~tgygk `kvfag yhhk+ "Lw`kl
4>>7# 7>0& _bg grfygkig hj yg~`t`g gbkfi afkhtffgy ogyftfkl bgft h|k y`gy `ko
fkog~gkogkig jtha Ibfk` btg`gky bfy+ Cfeg ~tgzfhwy fgt`fhky hj bg lhzgtkagky dgjhtg
bga# bg II^ b`y `oh~go bg fog` b` Ibfkgyg k`fhk`cfya fy tg~tgygkgo dv bg B`k
Ibfkgyg# `ko b` Ibfkgyg fogkfv fk afkhtffgy fy d`ygo hk bh| |gcc bgv gawc`g b` iwcwtg5
jhtigo hk bga fj kgigyy`tv+
@k gr`a~cg hj bfy fk ~`tfiwc`t hj bg ~`y jg| vg`ty b`y dggk bg Ibfkgyg lhzgtkagk
|bgk og`cfkl |fb bg Wflbwt ~h~wc`fhk hj Ibfk`+ Jht vg`ty bg II^ b`y tfgo h a`eg fkth`oy
fkh Wflbwt iwcwtg fk `ga~ h a`eg bga ahtg Ibfkgyg+ Gjjgiy hj bfy ~hcfiv t`klg jtha
ywdcg fkjcwgkifkl hj lhzgtkagk `fo b` bg ihaawkfv tgigfzgy5 f+g+ yibhhcy b` hkcv g`ib
fk A`ko`tfk Ibfkgyg h bg ahtg yflkfjfi`k `yyhif`fhk hj Wflbwt ofyyfogky `y iha~`t`dcg h
bg btg` j`igo dv bg WY fk tgl`toy h @c!Pwgo`+ "Lc`okgv 066?&
Fk gyygkig# bg II^ b`y dglwk h gy`dcfyb ` ygcgifzg yvyga hj ~tfahtof`cfy fgy h
ogjfkg |b` f ag`ky jht `k fkofzfow`c h dg Ibfkgyg+ _bg ahfz`fhk bgv `yitfdg h bhyg
-
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
15/20
07
|bh |hwco ogyftg ` yg~`t`g fkog~gkogk y`g hwyfog hj Ibfk` fy b` hj gtthtfya+ Jwtbgtfkl
bg ahfzgy jht chi`cy h `yyfafc`g# bg II^ b`y `cyh dggk gkihwt`lfkl B`k faaflt`fhk h
Wflbwt tg`y+ A`kv Wflbwty oh kh y~g`e A`ko`tfk Ibfkgyg# ko bwy B`k ohafk`g
ihaagtig fk Rfkmf`kl,y wtd`k `tg`y `ko `tg jtgpwgkcv yggk dv bg chi`c `y b`zfkl bg tglfhky
dgy mhdy+ "Ibwkl 4>>4# 04& _bg agyy`lg jtha bg II^ fy icg`t5 hkg fy Ibfkgyg `y awib `y hkg
fy `yyfafc`go fkh B`k iwcwtg+ @kvhkg |htefkl `l`fky bg B`k fkjcwgkig fy kh hkcv `k
hwyfogt# dw ` gtthtfy `y |gcc+
_bfy fy kh bg hkcv ~tfahtof`c fg gr~chfgo dv bg II^+ @cbhwlb htflfk`ccv ` zfifhwy
h~~hkgk hj Ihkjwif`kfya# bg II^ fk bg g`tcv 6>y dgihag k ozhi`g hj bfy g`ibfkly ko
bg bfyhtfi`c iwcwt`c z`cwgy bgv tg~tgygk h bg Ibfkgyg ~gh~cg+ \fbhw ` ohwd# bfy b`y
b`o kwagthwy dgkgjfy fk bg tg~tgygk`fhk hj Ibfk` `ko bg II^=
Dv ihkkgifkl fygcj yh oftgicv |fb Ibfk`y ~`y# f i`k dg `tlwgo `cyh b` bg II^ fy tvfkl h
~gtyhk`cf}g fy twcg!!fk hbgt |htoy# bg II^ |`ky h ybh| b` f fy kh yfa~cv y`jjgo |fb y`fi
gibkhit`y# ht gzgk khk!`i`ogafi hjjfif`cy+ Hk bg ihkt`tv# bg II^ fy tvfkl h ~thzg b` f fy
ihkigtkgo kh hkcv |fb tg`ibfkl ` y~gifjfi LO^ lth|b t`g# dw `cyh ``fkfkl cgyy `klfdcg dgkgjfy h
yhifgv# ywib `y bg Pfkl Bfyhtv ^thmgi `ko ogg~gkfkl bg Ibfkgyg iff}gktv,y `~~tgif`fhk hj bfyhtv+
Wkcfeg ahtg gibkfi`c ywdmgiy ywib `y gklfkggtfkl ht gihkhafiy# bfyhtv fy yhagbfkl b` `cc Ibfkgyg i`k
gkmhv `ko gadt`ig+ _bg II^ fy tvfkl h ybh| f i`tgy+ "Bh 4>>6# 4&
\bgk f ihagy oh|k h f bhwlb# bg II^ hkcv i`tgy h bg grgk bhwlb b` f yhcfofjfgy bgft
~hyffhk+ Cfeg |fb bg tgzfz`c hj k`fhk`cfya bthwlb bg yw~gtfhtfv hj B`k z`cwgy# bg
~thahfhk hj Ihkjwif`kfya bhcoy yflkfjfi`k yt`glfi z`cwg fk ~thahfkl k`fhk`cfya bthwlb
bg gr~chf`fhk hj ` yb`tgo gbkfi fg+ Foghchlfi`ccv# f `cch|y bg II^ h gy`dcfyb fygcj `y dgfkl
` ~`tv hj z`cwgy# `ko h yg~`t`g fygcj jtha bg A`trfya b` fky~ftgo bg Iwcwt`c Tgzhcwfhk+
_bg II^ i`k `cyh dg ygcgifzg `dhw bg Ihkjwif`k z`cwgy f ~thahgy# cfeg bhyg hj bfgt`tibv
`ko y`dfcfv# |bfcg ytgyyfkl Ihkjwif`k z`cwgy hj ~th~tfgv fk tgc`fhkybf~y `y ` ag`ky h
gkihwt`lg Ibfkgyg ~gh~cg h dg chv`c `ko hdgofgk h bg y`g+ "]b`h 4>>?# 446& Fkgtgyfklcv
-
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
16/20
0:
gkhwlb# bgv `tg `cyh dgfkl wygo h gy`dcfyb bg k`wtg hj Ibfkgyg iwcwtg `ko fogkfv
|htco!|fog# bthwlb bg y~tg`o hj Ihkjwifwy Fkyfwgy# khk!~thjf fkyfwfhky dwfc fk iffgy
`thwko bg lchdg b` yw~~hygocv ygtzg `y tg~tgygk`fhk hj |b` f twcv ag`ky h dg Ibfkgyg=
_bg Ihkjwifwy Fkyfwg Hkcfkg fy ogzhfkl h y`fyjv bg kggo hj ~gh~cg |bh `tg fkgtgygo fk Ibfkgyg
cg`tkfkl `cc `thwko bg |htco# ~thahfkl bg wkogty`kofkl hj Ibfkgyg c`klw`lg iwcwtg# gkb`kifkl bg
gowi`fhk`c `ko iwcwt`c ihh~gt`fhk dg|ggk Ibfk` `ko bg |htco# ogzgch~fkl bg jtfgkoybf~ dg|ggk
Ibfk` `ko hbgt ihwktfgy# h bgc~ ogzgch~fkl ` awcfiwcwt`c gkzfthkagk `ko dwfcofkl w~ ` b`tahkfhwy
|htco+ "b~=((`dhw+ibfkgyg+ik(gk(khogX?440+ba&
_bfy ygcj!gr~hyfhtv y`gagk hk bg Ihkjwifwy Fkyfwgy ifgy bg awcfiwcwt`cfy ~~g`c hj
Ihkjwifwy |bfcg egg~fkl bfy z`cwgy wkfpwgcv Ibfkgyg+ _bwy# fk bg y`ag dtg`b# bhyg z`cwgy
ihwco ~hgkf`ccv dg tg~thowigo ohagyfi`ccv h ~thahg `kf!|gy `fwogy jht bgft khk!
`obgtgkig h bgyg z`cwgy+ Fy y`g ihkthc wkogt bg lwfyg hj ~tfahtof`c z`cwgy# fky~ftfkl
~`tfhfya ko k`fhk`cfya wkogt k gc`dht`g yvyga hj ihkytwigo ~tfahtof`cfya+
ZF+ Ihkicwyfhk
@cbhwlb bg k`wtg hj Ibfk`y k`fhk`cfya b`y jcwiw`go dg|ggk ogjfkfkl bg k`fhk fk
~tfahtof`c ht fkytwagk`c ahogy# bg ihwktv ho`v# fy ` ~tfag gr`a~cg hj ` ihwktv |bhyg
k`fhk`cfya fy thhgo fk Ihkytwigo tfahtof cfya yvyga b` iihaaho`gy jht dhb+
_bg tgyg`tib ~tgygkgo fk bfy ~`~gt `iy `y gzfogkig h b`+ _bthwlbhw Ibfkgyg bfyhtv#
bgtg b`zg dggk yflkfjfi`k iwcwt`c gcgagky b` b`zg ywtzfzgo ahtg ht cgyy bthwlbhw
Ibfk`y k`fhk`c ko ~tg!k`fhk`c ~gtfho+ _bfy fkicwogy bg Ihkjwif`kfya |bfib |`y a`fk`fkgo
`y bg gyygkig hj |b` a`og yhaghkg Ibfkgyg jht hzgt ` bhwy`ko vg`ty# `ko bg `ooffhk`c
gy`dcfybagk hj B`k Ibfkgyg `y bg ~fcc`t hj Ibfkgyg fogkfv+
http://about.chinese.cn/en/node_4221.htmhttp://about.chinese.cn/en/node_4221.htmhttp://about.chinese.cn/en/node_4221.htmhttp://about.chinese.cn/en/node_4221.htm -
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
17/20
0>?# 49>&
Bh|gzgt# bfy ~`~gt ohgy kh lg fkh bg gbfiy hj bg II^y ifhky h ~thahg
Ibfkgyg k`fhk`cfya ht bg cglffa`iv hj k`fhk`cfya iha~hygo jtha gcgagky hj ihkytwigo
~tfahtof`cfv5 mwy bg yyhif`fhk dg|ggk Ibfkgyg k`fhk`cfya ko ihkytwigo ~tfahtof`cfv+
@cbhwlb bg ihaawkfy ~`tv wkogt A`h a`v b`zg tlwgo jht k`fhk`cfy fkyfwfhk`cfya#
Ihkjwif`kfya yggay h b`zg a`og ` ihagd`ie y h tg~tgygkfkl |b` f fy h dg Ibfkgyg5 `
~tfahtof`c z`cwg b` yfcc dtfkly ~gh~cg hlgbgt fk bg @kogtyhky fa`lfk`tv ihaawkfv hj
bhyg |bh fg bgaygczgy hlgbgt wkogt bg a`kcg hj dgfkl Ibfkgyg+ _bg y`ag lhgy jht
gkohtyfkl B`k Ibfkgyg iwcwtg `y bg ogjfkffhk jht |b` a`egy hkg Ibfkgyg+ Dw hkig bgyg
z`cwgy `tg hjjfif`ccv gkohtygo dv bg twcfkl ~hcffi`c ~`tv f `egy hk ` |bhcg kg| yb`~g gkftgcv+
@ b` ~hfk# ~tfahtof`c fgy dgihag `tfjfif`c jht bg y`eg hj jwtbgtfkl ~hcffi`c lh`cy `ko
-
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
18/20
02
dgihag ihkytwigo# ` |bhcg kg| bfkl gkftgcv+ _bg cfkg b`y dggk dcwttgo dv ihkytwifzfya#
`ko f dgihagy cgyy hj ` pwgyfhk hj |b` fy Ibfkgyg k`fhk`cfya# b`k |bh ht |b` ogjfkgy
Ibfkgyg k`fhk`cfya+
-
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
19/20
06
Dfdcfhlt`~bv
Dgtkygfk# Tfib`to# `ko Thyy B+ Awkth+ 066>6+ A`efkl I`wy`c Ic`fay `dhw bg gjjgi hj gbkfifv+ FkIha~`t`fzg ^hcffiy= T`fhk`cfv# Iwcwtg# `ko Ytwiwtg# gofgo dv A+ F+ Cfibd`ib`ko @+ Y+ ]wiegta`k+ I`adtfolg= I`adtfolg Wkfzgtyfv ^tgyy+
Ihkjwifwy Fkyfwg Hkcfkg @dhwt WyIhkjwifwy Fkyfwg Hkcfkg+b~=((`dhw+ibfkgyg+ik(gk(khogX?440+ba "@iigyygo Jgdtw`tv 4:b# 4>0>&
Ithwibgt# Ybgfc` C+ 4>>?+ Lchd`cf}`fhk `ko Dgchklfkl= _bg ^hcffiy hj Fogkfv fk `Ib`klfkl \htco+ C`kb`a= Th|a`k * Cfcgjfgco ^wdcfybgty# Fki+
Lggt}# Icfjjhto+ 06Bh# Khta`k+ 4>>6+ Wkcfegcv dgojgcch|y8 Ihkjwifwy# bg II^# `ko bg tgywtlgkig hjlwhrwg+ B`tz`to Fkgtk`fhk`c Tgzfg|90 "4&=?+
Yafb# @kbhkv O+ 4>>4+ K`fhk`cfya= _bghtv Foghchlv Bfyhtv+ I`adtfolg= ^hcfv ^tgyy+
Y~gkig# Mhk`b`k O+ 0666+ Ywk V`!ygk+ _fag @yf`"249(ywkXv`Xygk0+bac+
_hkkgyyhk# Ygfk# `ko B`ky @kchz+ 066:+ @yf` fk _bghtfgy hj K`fhk`cfya `ko K`fhk`cFogkfv+ Fk @yf`k Jhtay hj bg K`fhk# gofgo dv Y+ _hkkgyyhk `ko B+ @kchz+
Ywttgv= Iwt}hk ^tgyy Co+
\`ega`k# Jtgogtfi+ _bg Ltg` Gkgt~tfyg= _bg A`kibw Tgihkytwifhk hj Fa~gtf`cHtogt fk Ygzgkggkb!igkwtv Ibfk`+ Dgtegcgv `ko Chy @klgcgy= Wkfzgtyfv hjI`cfjhtkf` ^tgyy# 0627+
]b`h# Ywfybgkl+ 4>>?+ @ K`fhk!Y`g dv Ihkytwifhk= Ovk`afiy hj Ahogtk IbfkgygK`fhk`cfya+ Y`kjhto= Y`kjhto Wkfzgtyfv ^tgyy+
http://about.chinese.cn/en/node_4221.htmhttp://about.chinese.cn/en/node_4221.htmhttp://about.chinese.cn/en/node_4221.htm -
8/2/2019 The Nature of Chinese Nationalism
20/20
4>
]bgkl# Vhklkf`k+ 0666+ Ofyihzgtfkl Ibfkgyg K`fhk`cfya fk Ibfk`= Ahogtkf}`fhk#Fogkfv# `ko Fkgtk`fhk`c Tgc`fhky+ I`adtfolg= I`adtfolg Wkfzgtyfv ^tgyy+